WXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572023-01-012023-12-31iso4217:GBPWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572022-01-012022-12-31WXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572023-12-31WXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572022-12-31WXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572023-01-01ybs:GeneralReserveMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572023-01-01ifrs-full:ReserveOfCashFlowHedgesMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572023-01-01ifrs-full:ReserveOfGainsAndLossesOnFinancialAssetsMeasuredAtFairValueThroughOtherComprehensiveIncomeMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572023-01-01WXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572023-01-012023-12-31ybs:GeneralReserveMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfCashFlowHedgesMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfGainsAndLossesOnFinancialAssetsMeasuredAtFairValueThroughOtherComprehensiveIncomeMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572023-12-31ybs:GeneralReserveMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572023-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfCashFlowHedgesMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572023-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfGainsAndLossesOnFinancialAssetsMeasuredAtFairValueThroughOtherComprehensiveIncomeMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572022-01-01ybs:GeneralReserveMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572022-01-01ifrs-full:ReserveOfCashFlowHedgesMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572022-01-01ifrs-full:ReserveOfGainsAndLossesOnFinancialAssetsMeasuredAtFairValueThroughOtherComprehensiveIncomeMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572022-01-01WXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572022-01-012022-12-31ybs:GeneralReserveMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfCashFlowHedgesMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfGainsAndLossesOnFinancialAssetsMeasuredAtFairValueThroughOtherComprehensiveIncomeMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572022-12-31ybs:GeneralReserveMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572022-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfCashFlowHedgesMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572022-12-31ifrs-full:ReserveOfGainsAndLossesOnFinancialAssetsMeasuredAtFairValueThroughOtherComprehensiveIncomeMemberWXD0EHQRPI7HKN3I5T572021-12-31
here for
generations
Yorkshire Building Society
Annual Report and Accounts 2023
welcome
Introduction
2
Performance at a glance 2
Welcome from the Chair of the Board 4
Introduction from the Chief Executive 7
Financial statements
145
Income statements 146
Statements of comprehensive income 147
Balance sheets 148
Statements of changes in members’ interest and equity 149
Statements of cash flows 151
Notes to the financial statements 152
Other information
234
Annual business statement 235
Country-by-country report 237
Glossary 240
Contents
Strategic report
12
The external environment 12
Our purpose and strategy 16
Our ESG priorities 22
Engaging with our stakeholders 40
Our financial review 46
Risk overview 53
Governance
55
Our Board and Executive team 55
Corporate Governance report 64
Board Governance and Nominations Committee report 82
Audit Committee report 89
Risk Management report 97
Directors’ Remuneration report 109
Directors’ report 127
Independent auditors’ report to the members
of Yorkshire Building Society
135
performance at a glance
Statutory profit
before tax
Leverage
ratio
Core operating
profit1
Liquidity coverage
ratio
Cost to core
income ratio1
Average savings rate
differential2
Common equity
tier 1 ratio
Net Promoter
Score (NPS
®
)3
£
450.3
m
£502.5m in 2022
6.2
%
6.2% in 2022
£
449.9
m
£425.6m in 2022
156.4
%
164.0% in 2022
42
%
41% in 2022
1.01
pp
higher than market average
0.56pp higher in 2022
16.7
%
16.8% in 2022
+61
+54 in 2022
Member value
1 SeetheGlossarydefinitionsforalternativeperformancemeasures
2 YBSGroupaveragesavingsratecomparedtorestofmarketaveragerates.Source:CACI’sCurrentAccountandSavingsDatabase(CSDB),Stock.DataperiodJanuary–
December2023.
3 NetPromoterScoreandNPSaretrademarksofBain&Company,Inc.,FredReichheldandSatmetrixSystems,Inc.DataperiodJanuary–December2023,basedon
58,586responses.
4 BasedonBankofEnglandtotalindustrygrosslending.DataperiodJanuary–December2023.
5 Growthinmortgagebalancesexcludesfairvalueadjustmentsforhedgedriskonloansandadvancestocustomers.Prioryearcomparativerestatedonaconsistentbasis.
6 Source:YBSanalysisofBSAHouseholdsavings.DataperiodJanuary–December2023.
7 Carbonfootprintyearonyearmeasureonlyincludesdatawheredataisavailableforboth2022and2023.Theincreaseisduetoareturntobusinessasusualin2023
postthereductionintravelduetoCOVIDintheperiods2020-2022.TheSociety’soverallcarbonfootprintremainsbelowpre-COVIDlevels.Thefullbreakdownof
emissionsisavailableintheSECRpartoftheDirectorsreport.
Gross
lending
Gross mortgage lending
market share4
Growth in
mortgage balances5
New residential
mortgages provided
£
9.2
bn
£10.3bn in 2022
3.9
%
3.1% in 2022
3.6
%
7.2% in 2022
44,000
47,000 in 2022
Place to call home
Savings accounts
opened
Savings balance
market share6
Growth in shares
balances
Average savings
rate paid
693,000
537,000 in 2022
2.3
%
2.2% in 2022
12.0
%
18.3% in 2022
3.43
%
over 2023
1.20% over 2022
Financial wellbeing
Carbon
footprint7
Landfill
diversion
+34
%
-79% in 2022
98.7
%
of waste
97.4% in 2022
Climate-related disclosures
2 | Introduction 3
Welcome
from the
Chair of
the Board
Welcometothe2023
AnnualReportand
AccountsforYorkshire
BuildingSociety.
Iampleasedtobeabletoreportthatthe
Societyhasdeliveredastrongsetofresults
duringaperiodofsomeeconomicturmoil.
Thiswillbemyfinalreportonthe
performanceoftheSocietyasIshall
besteppingdownafternineyearsas
ChairoftheBoardattheconclusion
oftheAnnualGeneralMeetingon
23April2024inaccordancewith
goodcorporategovernance.
Whilstagreatdealhaschanged
duringmytimeasChair,agreat
manyimportantcharacteristicsof
theSocietyhaveremainedthesame.
Wecontinuetobeamember-owned
mutualbuildingsocietywiththe
sameprioritiesthathaveguidedus
throughour160-yearhistory;helping
peopletohaveaplacetocallhome,
supportingthedevelopmentof
financialwellbeing,anddelivering
lastingvalueforourmembers.These
prioritiessitattheheartofour
purposetoprovideRealHelpwith
RealLife.
Thethingsthathavechangedsince
mybecomingChairincludeoursize
andscale(havinggrownourbalance
sheetfrom£38.2bnin2015,to
£61.0bn),ourdigitalandtechnological
capabilities,and,ofcourse,someof
theincrediblytalentedandcaring
peoplewhoservedtheSocietysowell
havenowretiredormovedontonew
challenges.Iwouldliketotakethis
Manyprospectiveborrowersalsoface
challengesashigherrates,coupled
withthepressuresonhousehold
incomes,canresultindifficulties
savingenoughforadeposit,or
meetingaffordabilitycriteria.Wehave
continuedtofocusondeveloping
newpropositionstosupportthose
segmentsofthemarketmost
impacted,includingthosethatalign
stronglytoourpurposesuchasfirst-
timebuyers.
Our long-term sustainability
Oneofthekeyconsiderationswhen
makingappointmentstotheBoard
isensuringthatwehaveadiverse
rangeofthought,supportedby
theappropriatelevelsofskillsand
experience.TheSocietyaimsfor
thehigheststandardsofcorporate
governanceandouroverriding
responsibilityistoensurethatwe
operateafinanciallysecureand
sustainablebusinessintheinterests
ofourmembership.OurBoardremains
committedtomaintainingarobustand
effectivegovernanceframework,which
supportsthedeliveryofourpurpose.
Indeliveringourpurposeofproviding
RealHelpwithRealLife,weseekto
haveapositiveeffectnotjustonthe
livesofourmembersandcustomers,
butmorebroadlyonsociety.Astrong
senseofsocialpurposehaslong
beenadefiningcharacteristicofthe
Society,andtodaywecanseethis
reflectedinouractivecommunity
programmes.Supportingcauses
relatingtoemployabilityskillsand
buildingfinancialwellbeingisone
Creatingasolidfoundationandthe
carefuldeploymentofourresources
arefundamentaltoensuringthat
weareabletocontinuetomeetour
purposeintheyearsahead.Asthe
initialphaseofourtransformation
journeycomestoaclose,ourfocus
turnstothenextstageofourgrowth
asanorganisation.Akeyelement
ofsustainabilityisensuringthatwe
keeppacewithtechnologicalchange,
andunderstandwhatourcustomers
needaswellasthewaysinwhichthey
wanttointeractwithus.Customer
expectationsareevolvingatan
increasingrate,andourcontinued
prioritisingoftransformationalchange
ofthewayswecangivebacktoour
communities,andIamproudofall
ofthecontributionsmadebyour
volunteersandpartners.Ourjourney
todeepenourunderstandingofthe
impactthatouroperationshaveonthe
naturalenvironmentalsocontinues,
assessingthepotentialrisksweface,
andtherolewecanplayinbuildinga
greenersociety.
recognisestheneedtoadvanceinthe
samedirectiontoremaincompetitive.
Toensurethatwearewell-equipped
forthisjourney,weareundertaking
significantfurtherinvestmentin
ourriskandcontrolframeworkand
havefinalisedthenextstageofour
strategythatwilltakeusinto2024
andbeyond.Itisimportantthatwe
findtherightbalancesothatweserve
ourexistingmemberswellandinvest
forourgrowth,whileatthesametime
ensuringthatwemaintainourlong-
termfinancialstrengthandstability.
opportunitytothankthemallfortheir
dedication,skill,andcommitment.
Apersistentthemeoverthecourse
of2023hasbeentheincreasedcost
oflivingandtherelatedchallenges
facedbyourmembersandbythe
communitiesweserve.Thelevelof
priceinflationbeganrisingsharply
in2022,andhasremainedaprimary
concernsince.Thelongerthe
cost-of-livingpressuresgoon,the
morepronouncedandwidespread
theireffectsbecome,requiringthe
Government,regulators,andtheBank
ofEnglandtomonitordevelopments
closelyandeffectchangeswherethey
deemnecessary.
Formuchof2023,BankRatehas
continuedtoincrease,nowstandingat
5.25%-alevelnotseenforanumber
ofyears.Interestrates,havingrisen
atasignificantmagnitudeandpace,
havehadapronouncedimpactonthe
marketsforsavingsandmortgages.At
timesthroughouttheyear,thedegree
ofuncertaintyaroundlikelypolicy
decisionshasresultedinthemarket
beinghighlyresponsivetothereleases
ofkeymacroeconomicdata.Asa
result,expectationsshiftedfrequently,
andsometimesmaterially,inshort
spacesoftime.
Forsavers,increasestointerest
rateshavebroughtsomegoodnews.
Significantincreasesintheratesof
returnavailableacrossthemarkethave
beenobserved,andattheSociety
wewerepleasedtohavebeenable
towidenouraveragesavingsrate
differentialtothemarketwhilstat
thesametimecontinuingtogrowour
savingbalances.Takentogether,these
haveenabledustoreturnmorevalue
toourmembersthaneverbefore.
Higherratesofinterestalsomean
anincreaseinthecostofborrowing,
whichposeschallengestomortgage
customers.Thosewhocurrentlyhave
amortgagefacemuchhigherrates
whentheirfixedtermscometoanend,
afterwhichtheirmonthlyobligations
couldincreasesignificantly.Wealways
seektoworkwithanyofourborrowers
whoareexperiencingdifficulties,and
itwillremainourprioritytohelpthem
tonavigatethesedifficultperiods.
Alignedtothis,wesigneduptothe
MortgageCharterinJune,alongwith
manyotherlenders,whichexpanded
therangeofoptionsavailableto
borrowers.
Changes to our Board and Executive team
AmongmykeyresponsibilitiesisensuringthattheBoardcomprises
memberswhoholdanappropriatelydiversecombinationofskillsand
experiencetooperateeffectively.Wehavecontinuedtoplacesignificant
focusonsuccessionplanningthisyearinordertoensurecontinued
effectivenessoftheBoardasweprogresstowardourstrategicgoals.
AnumberofchangeshavebeenmadetotheBoardandourExecutive
teamthisyear.
AsImentionedabove,afternineyearsasChairoftheBoard,Iwillbe
handingovertheroletoAnnemarieDurbin,whojoinedourBoardas
ChairDesignateinDecember2023.Iamdelightedtobeabletowelcome
AnnemarietotheBoardandtotheSociety,andIhaveeveryfaithinher
considerableabilitytoleadourBoardinnavigatingthechallengesofthe
yearstocome.
TheSociety’sChiefExecutive,SusanAllen,commencedherroleinMarch
2023,takingoverfromAlasdairLenmanwhoheldtheroleonaninterim
basisbeforereturningtohisroleasChiefFinanceOfficer.AlasdairhasannouncedhisintentiontoretireinJune
thisyearandIwouldliketotakethisopportunitytothankhimforhisoutstandingcontributiontotheSociety.The
BoardandIwillbepleasedtowelcomeTomRangerwho,subjecttoregulatoryapproval,willjointheSocietyasChief
FinanceOfficerlaterintheyear.
WewerepleasedtowelcomeDebraDaviestoourBoardasNon-ExecutiveDirectorinJuly2023.Debrawillbea
valuedadditiontotheBoard,bringingherextensiveexperienceandknowledgeofthefinancialservicessector,witha
particularfocusonremunerationandrisk.
IwouldalsoliketoextendawelcometoFraserIngram,whojoinedtheSocietythisyearasChiefOperatingOfficer.
FraserhasawiderangeofexperienceincludingbusinesstransformationandITandchangemanagement,whichwill
supportourorganisationgreatlyaswecontinueourchangejourney.
Annemarie Durbin
4 | Introduction 5
Welcome from the Chair of the Board (continued)
Regulatory factors
Keyupdatesfromtheregulatoryenvironmentthis
yearinclude:
•
TheFinancialConductAuthority('FCA')ConsumerDuty
cameintoforceforallon-saleproductsinJulythisyear,
withaseconddeadlinerelatedto‘closed’productsinJuly
2024.TheimpactoftheDutyisfar-reaching,withfirms
expectedtoembeda‘consumerfirst’approachintohow
theyruntheirorganisationsincludinghowtheypriceand
serviceproducts,howtheycommunicatewithcustomers,
andhowtheyprovidecustomersupport.Inrecentmonths,
theFCAhasbeenpayingparticularattentiontowhether
firmsaregivingcustomersfairvaluewiththeproductsand
servicestheyoffergiventhecurrenteconomicclimate.We
areengagingwiththeFCAtosharewiththemtheprogress
madetowardtheimplementationoftheDutyinadvance
ofthekeydates.
•
June2023sawtheintroductionoftheMortgageCharter
withthesupportoftheUKGovernment,theFCA,andthe
majorityofUKmortgagelenders.TheCharteroutlineda
setofstandardsthatlenderswilladopttohelpborrowers
whoareconcernedabouthighermortgageratesandthe
risingcostofliving.TheMortgageCharterisdesignedto
offermoreoptionstopeoplewhoarestrugglingwiththeir
mortgagerepayments,orareuncertainabouttheimpact
oftheirexistingfixed-ratedealcomingtoanend.
Facing the years ahead
TheoutlookfortheUKeconomyisalwaysexposedtoa
degreeofuncertainty;manyfactors,whethernationalor
international,canexertaninfluence.Thecurrentconsensus
viewamongeconomiccommentatorssuggeststhatthe
neartermwillbecharacterisedbytheongoingeffectsof
therisingcostoflivingandlimitedeconomicgrowth.This
islikelytocontinuetoposeconstraintsonthesizeofthe
mortgagemarketduetolowerconsumerdemand,and
reinforcesourneedtolendinapurposefulway.
Weanticipateanelevatedlevelofcompetitioninthemarket
forsavingsdeposits,havingalreadyobservedsomeofthese
pressuresinthesecondhalfofthisyear.Therequirement
forfinancialinstitutionstorefinancegovernmentfunding
aheadofitscontractualmaturityin2025hasresultedin
attimesdisruptivepricingstrategiesbeingemployedby
marketparticipants.Thispatternappearslikelytocontinue
into2024.
Inthecontextofthesepotentiallychallengingmarket
environments,itisimportantthatweresponsiblymanage
ourcostsasweaddressmanyofthesamechallengesfaced
byourmembersandcustomers.Wewillinvestpurposefully
inourtransformationprogramme,whichwillbeessential
inensuringwecontinuetomeetcustomerneedsand
expectationsnow,andinthefuture.
TheSociety’sbusinessmodelhasonceagaindemonstrated
itsresilience.Weclosetheyearinastrongfinancialposition
andreadytomeetthechallengesthatlieahead.Our
strategy,recentlyrefreshed,willseetheSocietyworking
collaboratively,inacleardirectiontowardfurtherimproving
onwhatwecandeliverforourmembersandcustomers.
Ithasbeenagenuinepleasuretohaveservedour
membershipoverthelastnineyears,andtohavehadthe
opportunitytoengagewithsuchatalentedanddiverse
rangeofpeople.Iwouldliketoconcludewithanoteof
gratitudetobothourmembersanddedicatedcolleagues
fortheirlong-standingtrustandsupport,andexpress
myfirmbeliefthattheYorkshireBuildingSocietyiswell-
equippedtosucceedasamutualbuildingsocietyformany
yearstocome.
John Heaps
ChairoftheBoard
Introduction from
the Chief Executive
Itismypleasuretopresentthe2023
AnnualReportandAccountsforthe
YorkshireBuildingSociety.
Asamutual,YorkshireBuildingSocietyisownedbyandrunforthe
benefitofourmembers.Ourrichheritagespans160yearsandwe
havedemonstratedasuccessfultrackrecordofprovidingRealHelp
withRealLifeforourcustomersoverthattime.
TheSociety’scommitmenttodeliveringforourmembersisevidentinthepassionand
enthusiasmshownbyourcolleaguesandteams,andthroughaculturethatplacesour
customersatthecentreofallthatwedo.Thechallengingeconomicbackdropofrecent
yearshasonlyreinforcedtheimportanceofourapproachtosupportingcustomers.
ThisreportmarkstheconclusionofmyfirstyearasChiefExecutive.Iamdelightedtolead
suchastrongandsustainableorganisation.Thegreatrangeofcompetitiveproductsand
servicesweofferarevaluedhighlybyourcustomers,andthestrengthofthefeedback
wehavereceivedshowsthattheywouldmorestronglyrecommendtheSocietytotheir
familyandfriendscomparedtolastyear.In2023,wewerealsoproudtoberecognisedas
aWhich?RecommendedProviderformortgages.
6 | Introduction 7
Introduction from the Chief Executive (continued)
Overthelastfewyears,ourmembers,
customers,andmanyothersacross
theUKhavehadtoadapttoavolatile
externalenvironment.Priceinflation
becameaglobalconcerninthefirst
halfof2022andremainsakeytheme
anddriverofmonetarypolicy.The
BankofEnglandcontinuestomonitor
developmentsintheeconomyclosely,
aimingtoreduceinflationtowards
theirmedium-termtargetof2%.Over
2023,BankRaterosefrom3.50%to
5.25%.
Thisenvironmenthascreated
challengesforthosewhoarelooking
tobuyahomeandthosewantingto
buildtheirfinancialwellbeing.
We are here to support our
members and customers
Amongourcoreprioritiesissupporting
andpromotingFinancialWellbeing.
Savingsbalancesrepresentaprimary
sourceoffinancialwellbeingand,at
timeslikethese,thepeaceofmind
thatcomesfromhavingarainy-day
fundcanmakeallthedifference.
However,althoughsavingsratesare
muchhigherthantheywereoneor
twoyearsago,weknowthatsaving
isnoteasyforall,especiallywhen
thecostofday-to-dayessentialsis
increasing.
Ourownresearch,publishedwithin
ourSavingtheNationreport8,
illustratedthedynamicsofsavings
behaviourintheUKoverthelast
fiveyears.Thereporthighlightedthe
wideninggapbetweenthosewhoare
abletosaveonaregularbasisand
thosewhoarenot.Italsocalledout
theneedtoraiseawarenessofthe
benefitsofproductslikeIndividual
SavingsAccounts('ISAs')andpointed
tostrategiestoestablishgoodhabits,
andtheresourcesavailabletosupport
customers.
Asamutual,weareproudtoprovide
valuetoourmembersbypaying
higherinterestratesonoursavings.
Over2023,theratesweprovidedwere
onaverage1.01percentagepoints
higherthanthemarketaverage,which
equatestoc.£441.1madditional
interestpaidtooursavers9.
We are a strong and
sustainable organisation
Wehavedeliveredanotherstrong
setofresultsfortheSocietyin
2023,furthersupportingour
financialposition,andourlong-term
sustainability.
Ourtargetedgrowthinretailsavings
droveanincreaseof£5.1bninsavings
balancesyearonyear.Whilstpaying
aboveaveragesavingsratestoour
customers,wealsomadeastrategic
decisiontocontinuemakingearly
repaymentsofgovernmentfunding.
ThevastmajorityofourinitialTFSME12
fundinghasnowbeenrepaid,ofwhich
£2.2bnwasrepaidin2023.Carryinga
loweramountofthisfundinghelpsto
mitigatetheriskheldonourbalance
sheetasthefirstmarket-widematurity
drawscloser,andmanylenderswillbe
seekingtorefinance.
2023grosslendingvolumeswere
£9.2bn(2022:£10.3bn)andnet
lendingwas£1.6bn(2022:£3.0bn).
Thisisagoodlevelofgrowthinthe
contextofthedisruptionstothe
mortgagemarketinlate2022,the
largerpopulationofmaturities,anda
reducedmarketsizein2023.
Netinterestmarginincreasedto
1.31%over2023(2022:1.30%).
Therateofbalancesheetgrowth
achieved,coupledwiththe
impactsoftherisinginterestrate
environment,hassupportedhigher
levelsofprofitin2023.Thisisalso
inthecontextofhavingcontinually
increasedoursavingsrates,aswell
asthecostimpactsoftheinflationary
environmentandaccelerated
transformationactivity.Coreoperating
profitfor2023was£449.9m,an
increaseof£24.3montheprevious
year,andstatutoryprofitbeforetax
was£450.3m(2022:£502.5m).Our
capitalgenerationremainssufficient
tosupportourfinancialposition,both
nowandunderourgrowthaspirations.
OurproactivityinpassingonBank
Rateincreasestooursavers,aswell
asthefournewmemberloyalty
productswelaunchedthisyear,
supportsthemeaningfulwidening
ofthisdifferentialyearonyear(0.56
percentagepointshigherover2022;
£198.6minadditionalinterest).
Providingsupporttoourborrowers
isalsoimportanttous.Researchin
ourHomeTruths10reporthighlighted
howhomeownershipismoving
furtheroutofreachformany.
ProductinnovationunderourPlace
toCallHomepriorityisoneway
thatweseektosupportprospective
borrowers.Wehavelaunchedproducts
throughourintermediarylender,
AccordMortgagesLimited(‘Accord’),
whichallowfamilymembersto
supportyoungergenerationsandwe
continuetoexplorewaystomakeour
productsavailabletoawiderrangeof
customers.
Wearealsomindfulofthechallenges
facedbyourexistingmortgageholders
andourteamshaveworkedhardto
understand,andrespondto,individual
circumstances.Weproactivelyreached
outtocustomersmostimpactedby
interestrateincreasesandwesigned
uptothegovernment-ledMortgage
Chartertohelpcustomersnavigatethe
highercostofliving.
We are committed to our
communities
Positivelyimpactingthecommunities
inwhichweoperatereflectsour
commitmenttoservingabroader
socialpurposeandwillremainakey
partofourfuturestrategy.
Oursupportforbuildingfinancial
wellbeingextendsbeyondtherange
ofcompetitivesavingsproductswe
offerintoourcommunityactivities,like
ouraward-winningpartnershipwith
CitizensAdvice.Inselectedbranches
acrossthecountry,representatives
fromCitizensAdviceofferfree,
confidentialadviceonmatters
includingfinancialwellbeing.
We have built strong
foundations
In2020,wesetoutaplantotransform
ourcapabilitiesandenhanceour
customerexperiencebytheendof
2023.WecalledthisourStrategic
Blueprint.AstheBlueprintcomesto
aclose,wearepleasedthatwehave
accomplishedmuchofwhatwesetout
toachieve.
Wedevelopedandlaunchednew,
betterwaystosupportourPlace
toCallHomepriority.Supported
byenhancedcapabilitiesanddata
analytics,webroadenedourmortgage
offering,makingitaccessibleto
awiderrangeofcustomersand
expandingourproductrange.Adeeper
understandingofassociatedrisksand
theirmanagementmeansthatweare
abletoacceptmoreborrowersthan
everbefore.Wehavebeenableto
launchtargetedproductstosupport
thosesegmentsthatarelesswell
servedbythewidermarket,suchas
thosewithlowercreditscores.
Thisserviceisavailabletomembers
andnon-membersalikeandisagreat
exampleoftargetedsupportinaction.
Feedbackshowsthatitismakingareal
differenceinlocalcommunities.
TheSocietyiscommittedto
maintainingabranchpresence.
Manyofourmembersvaluethe
personaltouchtheyreceiveinaYBS
branch,especiallywhentheyrequire
supportinmorecomplexsituations.
Ourresearchshowsthatbothlocal
branchesandpassbooksremainin
demandwithmorethanaquarterof
peoplesurveyedvisitingabranchonce
amonth,andoverhalfamillionofour
membersusingpassbooks11.Branches
alsoprovideanimportantlinkwith
ourlocalcommunities,astheCitizens
Advicepartnershipdemonstrates.
Ourflagshipvolunteeringprogram,
MoneyMinds,continuestoprovide
valuableresourcesonfinancial
educationandtohelppeopleto
prepareforwork.Thisisjustoneof
ourvolunteeringprogrammeswhich
enableourcolleaguestomakeareal
impactintheircommunities.
Iampleasedtoannouncethatthe
Society’slatestcharitypartneris
FareShare.FareShareisanational
networkofcharitablefood
redistributorswho,alongsideproviding
mealsforvulnerablepeople,strive
toalleviatetheimpact,androot
causes,offoodpovertyintheUK.
Thispartnershipalignsstronglyto
ourpurposeandvalues,andoffers
excellentopportunitiesforour
colleaguestocontributetowardsour
commongoals.FromNovember2023
untilJune2026,fundraisingactivity
anddonationsfromtheSocietywill
fundFareShare’sBuildingSkillsfor
theFutureprogrammewhichwill
providevaluablesupportformatters
relatingtofinancialhardshipand
employability.Weaimtoliftover
2,500peopleoutoffinancialhardship.
Ilookforwardtothepositiveimpacts
thatthiscollaborationwillbring.
Ouronlinesavingsexperiencewas
alsoakeyfocus,includinglaunching
ourmobileappin2020.Thestep-
changeinthelevelofgrowthachieved
inoursavingsbalances,andthe
continuedincreaseinourcustomer
satisfactionscores,aretestament
totheprogressmade.TheSociety’s
overallNetPromoterScore('NPS'),
whichisameasureofhowwillingour
customersaretorecommendusto
othersincreasedto+61in2023.This
isanincreaseof+7onourscorein
2022,and+10onthescorein2021.
Wealsocontinuetoreceiveexcellent
feedbackfrombrokerswhopraise
Accord’sswiftandhelpfulservice.
Wemustalwaysremainfocusedon
achievingthestandardsofservicethat
ourcustomersdeserve.Ifeverwefall
short,weactquicklyanddecisively.
Aftersomecustomeroutcomesdidnot
meetourinternalstandardsearlierin
theyear,weincreasedourfocuson
complainthandlingprocesses.Asa
result,customeroutcomesimproved
overthesecondhalfoftheyear,and
weremainfocusedonensuringgood
outcomesareconsistentlydelivered
toourcustomers.Wewillcontinueto
tacklechallengeslikethisheadon.
8 SavingtheNationreportavailableonourwebsite
9 YBSGroupaveragesavingsratecomparedtorestofmarketaveragerates.Source:CACI’sCurrentAccountandSavingsDatabase(CSDB),Stock.DataperiodJanuary–
December2023
10 HomeTruthsreportavailableonourwebsite
11 YorkshireBuildingSocietySavingssurvey:TheresearchwascarriedoutonlinebyOpinium.Allsurveyswereconductedbetween24thand27thOctober2023andthe
samplecomprisedof2,000UKadults.550,000membersofYorkshireBuildingSocietyusedapassbooktotheendofSeptember2023.
12 TFSME:TermFundingSchemewithadditionalincentivesforsmall-andmedium-sizedenterprises.
8 | Introduction 9
Introduction from the Chief Executive (continued)
OurMemberValuepriorityrepresents
thedutywehavetoourmembers
tooperatearesponsiblebusiness,
resilienttowhattheyearsaheadmay
bring.Thiscoverseverythingfrom
theproductsweoffer,totheservice
weprovideandhowwestewardthe
resourcesatourdisposal.
Ourmutualstructureallowsusto
makedecisionsintheinterestsofour
membership.Ihaveenjoyedhaving
openandhonestconversationswith
ourmembersinourbranchesacross
theUKandateventslikeYourTimeto
Talk.Insightintowhatmattersmost
toourmembersisabsolutelyvitalto
ensurethatwecontinuetoinvestin
therightareas.
Ourcapacitytoachievethegoalswe
havesetinOurStrategywillonlybe
fulfilledthroughtheabilityofour
colleaguestoreachforbetter,for
themselves,foreachother,andfor
ourmembers.Iamthankfulforthe
hardworkandgenuinecareforour
customersthattheydemonstrate
everyday.
We are strongly positioned
for the future
Withworldeventsdrivingcontinued
economicvolatilityandincreasing
levelsofcompetitioncompressingnet
interestmarginacrosstheindustry,
continuedchallengeslieahead.A
gooddealremainsdependenton
howtheinterestrateenvironment
evolves,andthespeedandefficacy
atwhichmonetarypolicyactioncan
returninflationtothelevelstargeted
bytheBankofEngland.Atthetimeof
writing,thecurrentsentimentofthe
We are ambitious about
the future
TheSocietyhasevolvedoverthelast
threeyears.Ofcourse,itisnotjust
ourorganisationthathaschanged,the
outsideworldlooksmuchdifferent
too.SincetheBlueprintwasset,the
environmentweoperatewithinisnow
fasterpaced,farmorechallenging,
andcustomerexpectationshave
continuedtoaccelerate.Aftertaking
timetocarefullyreflectonwherewe
arenowandwherewewouldliketo
be,aswellasdrawingonthewealth
ofexperienceofourcolleaguesand
members,wehaverefreshedour
strategyfor2024andbeyond.
marketindicatesapossibilitythatwe
havereachedtheendofthecycleof
increasestoBankRatethough,asever,
thisviewissubjecttochange.
Thefutureofthemortgagemarketwill
continuetobestronglyinfluenced
bytheinterestrateenvironment
anditsconsequencesforborrower
affordability,andthesupplyand
demanddynamicsinthehousing
market.Intheretailsavingsmarket,the
upcomingmaturityofTFSMEfunding
mayprecipitateanevengreater
degreeofcompetitionforbalances
thanthatobservedoverthesecond
halfof2023.
Insuchacontextitbecomes
increasinglyimportantthatweinvest
ourresourcespurposefullyand
selectively,focusingonthethings
thatwillbringthemostbenefittoour
membershipinthelongterm.Both
2022and2023representperiods
OurStrategyremainsfirmlycentred
onourpurposeofprovidingRealHelp
withRealLife.Ourvisionforthefuture
ofYBSisambitiousanditwillseeus
buildanagileorganisationthatcan
respondtomarketconditionsquickly
andhelpuskeepbetterpacewith
changingcustomerneeds.Itwillsee
usextendourreachtomorecustomers
anddomoretosupportourexisting
customerswhotrustusandwould
likeustohelpthemmeetmoreof
theirneeds.Customerexperiencewill
remainapriority,aswillsimplifying
ourinternalprocesses.
Thisnextphaseinourjourneywill
seeusgrowevenfurther.Toensure
thatwearewellpreparedforthis,
wecommissionedareviewofour
governance,risk,andcontrolsin2023.
Thisworkbuildsonourinvestments
insecurityimprovements,data
protection,andITriskinthelastfew
years,andisgoodpracticetoensure
thatourcapabilitiesremainresilient.
wherethelevelsofprofitsmadewere
higherthanhistoricallevels.Thiswill
helptoprotectthelong-terminterests
ofourmembership,providingstability
forwhentheanticipatedchallenges
crystallise,andallowingustoreinvest
inourproductsandservices.
Ittrulyisaprivilegetobeleadingthe
YorkshireBuildingSocietyintoitsnext
phase.Ilookforwardtocollaborating
withourmembers,ourBoard,andour
colleaguesacrosstheorganisation
asweunitebehindourrefreshed
strategicvision,andworktoevolve
theYorkshireBuildingSocietyinto
afuture-readyorganisation,fitto
provideevenmore
RealHelpwithReal
Life
forgenerationstocome.Thank
youforyourcontinuedsupportforthe
Society.
Susan Allen, OBE
ChiefExecutive
10 | Introduction 11
strategic
report
The external environment
TheSociety’soperations,andtheextentto
whichwecandelivervaluetoourmembership
overthelongterm,canbeimpactedby
factorsbeyondourcontrol.Forthisreason,
theexternalenvironmentinwhichweoperate
ismonitoredcloselyandcontinuously.
Identifyingandunderstandingrisksand
opportunitiesastheyemergeishowwecan
bestpreparefor,andadaptto,thechanging
externalcontext.
Economic and political overview
ManyofthefeaturesoftheUKeconomicandpolitical
landscapehavecontinuedalongthethemesestablishedin
2022.Theimpactofincreasedenergycostsanddisruption
totheglobalsupplychainbegantofeedthroughtoinflation
inwagesandthecostofservices,withthepeak12-month
ConsumerPricesIndex('CPI')inflationstandingat10.4%in
February202313.Inresponse,theMonetaryPolicyCommittee
('MPC')electedtoincreaseBankRatefivetimesinsuccession
uptoandincludingitsAugustmeeting,increasingfrom
3.50%astheyearopened,to5.25%14.AttheSeptemberand
Novembermeetings,theMPCchosetomaintainBankRate
atitscurrentlevel,pausingthecycleofincreaseswhichwas
previouslyunbrokensinceearly2022.Thisdecisionfollowed
thereleaseofinflationdatawhichshowedheadlineand
servicesCPIinflationhadfallenbacktoalevellowerthanhad
beenexpected.
Overtheremainderoftheyear,12-monthCPIfellfurther
to4.0%bytheendoftheyear,withanexpectationfrom
theUKGovernmentthatitwillreducetobeinlinewiththe
2.0%targetin2024.Theimpactofinflationarypressures
onhouseholdincomeshasbeensevereformany,withthe
increasedcostofeverydaygoodsandservices,coupledwith
highermortgageorrentalpayments,forcingmanytousetheir
savingsorborrowtomeeteverydayrunningcosts.Therateof
inflationoutpacedwagegrowthformuchoftheyear,andonly
inthesecondhalfwasrealwagegrowthobserved.
Thebroadconsensusviewamongeconomists
isthattheUKissetforaperiodofminimal
economicgrowthduetothegreatercostof
investmentinahighrateenvironment,coupled
withissuesinthelabourmarketaroundkey
skillsandproductivity.Asaconsequence,the
marketexpectationnowincludesapossibility
ofratecutsonthehorizon,thoughhow
closelythepolicydecisionsmaderesemble
thisexpectationissubjecttoahighdegreeof
uncertainty.
InNovember2023,theChancellorofthe
ExchequerdeliveredtheAutumnStatement.
Thispackagesetoutanumberoftaxmeasures
designedtostrengtheneconomicgrowth
throughsupportingBritishbusinessesand
increasingthenumberofpeopleinwork.
Thestatementalsoannouncedarangeof
administrativechangeswhichmakethetax
systemsimplerandmoremodern,ensuring
businessescaninteractwithitmoreeasily.
Thepoliticallandscape,bothwithintheUK
andglobally,remainsuncertain.AUKgeneral
electionisexpectedtotakeplaceduring2024
andaUSelectionisdueinNovember,bothof
whichmayhavesomebearingonthelevelof
volatilityinthemarkets.Theongoingmilitary
activitiesinUkraineandGazacontinuetobe
asourceofglobalpoliticaltension,withthe
timingofacessationintheseconflictshighly
uncertain.
The wholesale funding market
Wholesalefundingmarketssawseveralperiods
ofvolatilityanddisruptionthroughoutthe
courseof2023.Thespringbankingcrisis
thatbeganintheUS,alongwithongoing
conflictsinbothUkraineandtheMiddleEast,
servedtodampeninvestorconfidence.These
events,alongsidebroadervolatilityinthe
macro-economicbackdropresultedinmultiple
periodswheretheconditionsforaccessing
wholesalefundingmarketswereunfavourable.
Despitethis,thevolumeofissuancein
securedfundingmarketsincreasedin2023
asinstitutionscontinuedtorefinanceTFSME
borrowingsaheadofcontractualmaturitiesin
2025.Thisplacedincreaseddemandonthe
CoveredBondmarketinparticular,thoughthe
higherlevelofsupplyhasbeengenerallywell
absorbed.Thistrendisexpectedtocontinue
in2024assignificantrefinancingactivityis
requiredacrossthemarket.
The UK mortgages market
Thedegreeofchangethehousingmarket
hasbeensubjecttoinrecentyearshasbeen
significant.Aperiodofstable,historicallylow
interestrateshasbeensucceededbyone
inwhichBankRatechangesaremuchmore
frequentandbringgreaterconsequences.With
theinflationaryandcost-of-livingpressures
havingledtoBankRatestandingover5.00
percentagepointshigherthanthatinDecember
2021,theimpactonmortgageaffordabilityand
itsconsequencesforthelevelofdemandinthe
markethasbeenconsiderable.
2023openedinthewakeoftheimpacts
oftheeconomicdisruptionexperienced
inlate-2022,resultingfromtheAutumn
budgetannouncements.Althoughthere
weresomepositivesignsofthemortgage
marketrecoveringinthefirsthalfoftheyear
–customerrateshadbeguntoreduce,and
lendersresumedtheirpresenceinhigher-LTV
segmentsfromJanuary–muchof2023has
remainedcharacterisedbyvolatility.
Asmarketsandlendersreactedtothechanging
externalenvironment,fundingcostswere
subjecttofrequent,andsometimesmaterial,
changes.Themarketcontinuallyrevisedits
expectationsofthefutureratepath,factoring
inthelatestmacroeconomicdataandlatest
monetarypolicyaction.Thesefluctuations
haveadirectbearingonthestabilityof
mortgagepricingand,assuch,repricingactivity
continuedatgreatpaceandregularity.
Mortgagecustomerratescontinuedtotrend
upwardinthefirsthalfof2023,before
beginningtograduallydeclineoversubsequent
months.Evenso,thecostoftakingout
mortgagesissignificantlyhigherthaninrecent
years,whichisapotentialcauseforconcern
forthoseseekinganewmortgageandthose
withanexistingmortgageapproachingtheend
itsfixedterm.Potentialforhigherrepayment
obligations,combinedwiththeincreasedcost
ofliving,ledtheGovernmenttoannouncethe
MortgageCharterinJune2023.Thecharterset
outtoreassureandsupportborrowerswhoare
facingdifficulties,settinganumberofuniversal
standardsforlenderstoimplement.Anumber
oflenderssigneduptotheMortgageCharter,
includingYBS,representingaround90%of
themarket15.
Comparedto2022,thesizeofthemarket
formortgageshasreduced,illustratingthe
pressuresthatnewborrowersarefacingasthey
eitherexercisegreatercaution,findthemselves
unabletosave,orhavedifficultymeeting
lendingcriteria.Amoreacuteimpacthasbeen
seeninthemarketforbuy-to-letmortgages,as
affordabilityconsiderationscandirectlylimit
theamountlandlordscanborrow.
13 https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/inflationandpriceindices/bulletins/
consumerpriceinflation/december2023
14 https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/monetary-policy-summary-and-
minutes/2023/september-2023 15 https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/mortgage-charter/mortgage-charter
12 | Strategic report 13
The external environment (continued)
Inturn,thislowerlevelofdemandhas
servedtosteadilyreducehouseprice
growthoverthecourseoftheyear.
AccordingtotheOfficeforNational
Statistics,averageUKhouseprice
annualinflationhasbeengenerally
slowingsinceJuly2022whenthe
rateofgrowthwasashighas13.8%;
thelatestdataavailableatthetime
ofwritingshowstherateforthe12
monthstoNovember2023asa2.1%
decrease16.
Theoutlookforthemortgagesmarket
heavilydependsonthefutureinterest
rateenvironment.Intheshortto
mediumterm,itislikelythatboth
existingandprospectiveborrowers
willcontinuetofacechallengesamid
thiscontextofuncertainty.Inaddition,
becauseofthelong-heldcustomer
preferenceforfixed-ratemortgages,
theimpactsofthehigherinterestrate
environmentwillbestaggeredover
time,withsomeofthisimpactyetto
beseen.
The UK savings market
Inthefirsthalfoftheyear,fixed-rate
productscontinuedtoincreasein
popularity,alignedtothehigher
interestrateenvironment.Thisledtoa
premiuminpricingforthosewiththe
abilitytolockmoneyawayforaperiod
oftime,anddroveashiftincustomer
preferences.Acrossthemarket,
depositbalanceswereobservedto
migrateawayfromcurrentaccountsor
variable-rate,easyaccessalternatives.
Therateandpaceatwhichthe
changestoBankRatehavebeen
passedthroughtovariablecustomer
rateshasdifferedacrossthemarket,
sometimessignificantlyso.Astheyear
progressed,agreaterproportionof
themorerecentBankRateincreases
wasobservedtobepassedthrough
tocustomersasthegenerallevelof
competitionforattractingdeposits
heightenedfurther.
Thedriversoftheincreasein
competitiveintensityarelikelymany,
thoughoneimportantfactoristhe
overallsizeofthesavingsmarket.
Despitethehigherinterestratesof
recentyearsleadingtogreaterinterest
capitalisation,overallgrowthappears
tohavebeenlimitedaspeoplefind
themselveslessabletosaveamidthe
tohelpborrowerswhoareworried
abouthighermortgageratesandthe
risingcostofliving.TheMortgage
Charterisdesignedtooffersome
consistentandclearoptionsto
peoplewhoarestrugglingwiththeir
mortgagerepaymentsoranxious
abouttheimpactoftheirexisting
fixed-ratedealcomingtoanend.YBS
areamongthelendersthatsigned
uptotheCharterandwebelievethis
providesavaluableadditiontothe
supportavailabletocustomerswho
arestrugglingwiththerisingcostof
mortgages.
Confirmation of Payee
YBSimplementeditsConfirmationof
Payeeservice.Thisallowscustomers
tocheckifthebankaccounttheyare
sendingfundstomatchesthename
theyareexpecting.YBSwaspartofthe
secondphaseofproviderswhowere
directedtoimplementthisservice
(thesixlargestbankinggroupsbeing
partofthefirstphase).Confirmationof
Payeeprovidescustomerswithmore
comfortwhentheyarepayingpeople
orbusinessestheyhavenottransacted
withbefore.Itallowsthecustomerto
checkthattheyhaveentereddetails
correctly,aimingtopreventthem
beingsubjecttofraud.
Economic Crime and
Corporate Transparency Act
TheEconomicCrimeandCorporate
TransparencyAct2023('theAct')
receivedRoyalAssentinOctober
2023.TheActintroducessignificant
powerswhichwillallowUKauthorities
toproactivelytargetorganised
criminalsandothersseekingtoabuse
theUK’sopeneconomy.Companies
Housewillreceiveenhancedabilities
toverifytheidentitiesofcompany
directors,removefraudulent
organisationsfromthecompany
register,andshareinformationwith
criminalinvestigationagencies.
TheActalsomakessignificantchanges
tothelawofcorporatecriminal
liabilitybymateriallyexpandingthe
scopeofpersonswhosecriminal
conductcanbeattributedtoa
companyandbyintroducinganew
offenceoffailingtopreventfraud.
Largecorporations,includingYBS,have
thepotentialtobeimpactedbythese
changesasprosecutorswillbebetter
abletoholdthemaccountableshould
malpracticeoccur.
broadercontextofinflationaryand
cost-of-livingpressures.
Savingsprovidersalsocameunder
greaterscrutinyfromboththemedia
andregulatorstodemonstratethat
thebenefitsofhigherratesare
beingpassedonatanappropriate
level,atatimewheretheinterest
rateenvironmentsupports
incomeperformanceacrossthe
bankingindustry.Alongsidethe
implementationofthefirststageof
theConsumerDuty,whichbrought
afocusonfirmsprovidingfairvalue
tocustomers,inJuly,theFCAalso
publishedareviewofthecash
savingsmarket.Thisreviewfurther
emphasisedfairvalue–bothinthe
differentialbetweennewandexisting
customerrates,aswellasthelevelof
benefitsaversreceivefromincreases
toBankRate.
Thebankingsectorisalsopreparing
forthematurityofTFSME,the
government-backedfundingscheme
whichprovidedsystemicliquidity
totheindustryattheonsetofthe
pandemic.Schemeparticipantsare
intheprocessofrefinancingtheir
drawings,throughacombinationof
retailsavingsandwholesalefunding.
Bythefourthquarter,themarkets
forbothfixed-andvariable-rate
savingsproductshadbecomehighly
competitive,withsomeinstitutions
takingpricingpositionssignificantly
aheadoftherestofthemarket.
Lookingforward,itappearsunlikely
thattheintensityofcompetitionfor
savingsbalanceswilllessenin2024.
Ifthecentralbankinginterventions
aresuccessful,inflationarypressures
willsubsidegradually.Ifandwhen
theinterestratepathstartsreducing,
thismaydrivedifferentdynamicsfor
bothcompetition,andforcustomer
behaviours.
Regulatory overview
Relevantupdatesfromtheregulatory
environment:
Financial Conduct Authority
('FCA') Consumer Duty
TheFCAConsumerDuty('theDuty')
cameintoforceforallon-sale,or
‘open’,productsinJuly2023.Asecond
deadlineisapproachingtoensureall
Diversity equity and
inclusion in the financial
sector
TheFinancialConductAuthority,
PrudentialRegulationAuthority,and
BankofEnglandjointlypublished
adiscussionpaper(DP2/21)on
DiversityandInclusion('D&I')inthe
financialsectorinJuly2021and
havesincefollowedthisupwitha
publicconsultationinSeptember
2023.Theregulatorssetoutpolicy
optionsincluding,amongothers,the
useoftargetsforrepresentation,
measurestomakeseniorleaders
directlyaccountableforD&Iintheir
firms,linkingremunerationtoD&I
metrics,andtheregulators’approach
toconsideringD&Iinnon-financial
misconduct.
TheregulatorsbelieveincreasedD&I
willadvancetheirstatutoryobjectives
byresultinginimprovedgovernance,
decisionmaking,andriskmanagement
infirms,inturnleadingtoamore
innovativeindustrythatprovides
productsandservicesbettersuitedto
thediverseneedsofcustomers.
Theproposalsincludethatfirmswill
berequiredtoreflectD&Iintheir
Board-levelstrategy,haveD&Itargets,
‘closed’productsarecompliantwith
theDuty,by31July2024.Thismeans
thatfirmsmustensurethesamehigher
standardsofconsumerprotection
areinplaceforallproductsthatare
nolongeronsalebutarestillbeing
serviced.
TheimpactoftheDutyisfar-reaching,
withfirmsexpectedtoembeda
‘consumerfirst’approachintohow
theyruntheirorganisationsacrosshow
theypriceandserviceproducts,how
theycommunicatewithcustomers,and
howtheyprovidecustomersupport.
Oneyearonfromtheinitial
implementationoftheDuty,firmswill
beexpectedtoprovidetheirBoard
withthefirstannualassessmentof
howthefirmismeetingtheDuty,
andreportonanyareasofpotential
harmtocustomers.Whereissues
areidentified,aplantoaddress
theseshouldbeincluded.TheFCA
recognisesthatlastingchangecan
onlytakeeffectwhenafirmchanges
itsculture,behaviour,andprocesses
usingatop-downapproachwithstrong
seniorchampioningandoversight.
Inrecentmonths,theFCAhasbeen
payingparticularattentiontowhether
firmsaregivingcustomersfairvalue
withtheproductsandservicesthey
offergiventhecurrenteconomic
climateandvolatilitywithinflationand
interestrates.Theregulatorintendsto
moveatpacetohighlightfirmswhere
weaknessesexistandholdtheirsenior
leaderstoaccountwheretheyarenot
deliveringgoodconsumeroutcomes
withintheirareasofresponsibility,
inlinewiththeSeniorManagersand
ConductRuleDutyofResponsibility
andtheConductRules.
YBShasengagedwiththeFCAtoshare
withthemtheprogressmadetoward
theimplementationoftheDutyin
advanceofbothofthekeydates.YBS
alsocommissionedanindependent
reviewofitsConsumerDutyMI(and
supportingframework)andtheoverall
positionofYBSConsumerDuty
project.
Mortgage Charter
June2023sawtheintroductionofthe
MortgageCharterwiththesupport
oftheUKGovernment,theFCA,and
lenders.TheCharteroutlinedaset
ofstandardsthatlenderswilladopt
reflectD&IinappropriateSenior
ManagementFunctionresponsibilities,
includenon-financialmisconductin
theirConductRulesconsiderations,
andsubmitanannualregulatory
return.
AtYBS,weareguidedbyaclearset
ofbehaviours.Akeypartofhowwe
seektodemonstratethesebehaviours
istoworktocreateafullyinclusive
environmentforallourcolleagues,
customers,andcommunities:onethat
istrulyrepresentativeofmodern-
daysociety.StrivingtoensureYBS
iswelcomingtoandrepresentative
ofthecommunitiesweserve,and
thatweattract,retain,anddevelop
ourtalent,willonlyleadtogreater
success.Wearesignatoriestothe
WomeninFinanceCharter,theRace
atWorkCharter,haveachievedLevel
2:DisabilityConfidentEmployerand
areworkingtowardLevel3:Disability
ConfidentLeader.
TherecommendationsmadeintheFCA
andPRAconsultationpapersbroadly
aligntotheSociety’sdirectionof
travelforDiversity,Equity,&Inclusion
('DE&I').Wewillfullyconsiderthe
recommendationsaspartofourDE&I
Strategyreviewandmeasures,which
waspresentedtoESGCommitteein
December2023.
16 https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/inflationandpriceindices/bulletins/housepriceindex/september2023
14 | Strategic report 15
Our Purpose and Strategy
The Yorkshire Building Society exists to provide our
members and customers Real Help with Real Life.
The actions we take are in service of
achieving this purpose. Our three core
priorities underpin this purpose, and are:
helping people to have a place to call home,
helping to support and build greater financial
wellbeing, and delivering value for our
members over the long term.
Our business model
TheSocietyoperatesasimplebusinessmodel.Asamember-
ownedmutualweexisttoprovidethosesavingwithus
asafeplacetokeep,andearnintereston,theirdeposits.
Thesesavingsbalancesarethenprimarilyusedtofund
mortgagelending,enablingcustomerstosecureaproperty
theycancallhome.Alongsidesavingsdepositsfromour
members,theSocietyaccessesthewholesalemarketsfor
additionalfundingandtoprovidediversityandstabilityto
ourbusiness.
Wealwaysactinthelong-terminterestsofourmembership.
Aswedonothaveexternalshareholders,thelevelof
profittheSocietygeneratesisrequiredtobesuchthatour
financialpositionremainssecure,thatsufficientcapitalis
generatedtosupportourgrowthplans,andthatwecan
continuedevelopingproductsandservicesthatfulfilthe
needsofourmembersandcustomers.
How our
business is
funded
•
Savingsbalancesfrommembers
andcustomersareheld,afterbeing
depositedthroughourbranchesor
online(c.79%).
•
Ourcapitalreserves,predominantly
comprisingprofitsgeneratedfrom
previousyears(c.5%).Capital
providesprotectionandflexibility
againstthepossibilityoflossesor
unforeseenevents.
•
Additionalfundingisraisedthrough
thewholesalemarketsbyissuing
bondsordebtsecurities(c.14%)as
wellasdrawingsfromGovernment
fundingschemeswhereapplicable
(c.2%).Thisprovidesdiversification
andpreventsoverrelianceonanyone
sourceoffunding.
How this
funding is
used
•
Providingresidentialmortgages
toowner-occupierandbuy-to-let
customers(c.75%)andproviding
commercialmortgagesthroughour
specialisedlendingchannel(c.3%).
•
Ourlendingstrategyistobalanceour
lendingacrosssegmentswhichservea
largeproportionofthemarketaswell
asspecificallytargetingthosesegments
whicharealignedtoourpurposeor
currentlyunderserved.Beingselective
aboutthesegmentsinwhichwechoose
tocompetecanbeasourceofvalue
generation–valuewhichcanthenbe
sustainablyreturnedtoourmembers.
•
TheSocietyholdscashandTreasury
Investments(c.22%).Thepurposeof
holdingsufficientHighQualityLiquid
Assets(HQLA)istoensurethatwecan
meetourobligationsastheyfalldue,
tocomfortablyexceedtheminimum
thresholdsprescribedbyregulators,and
tosupportfinancialstabilityasinvested
assetsalsoprovideincomeandrisk
diversification.
How our
income is
earned
•
Income,intheformofinterest,is
receivedfromourmortgagecustomers,
aswellasfromtheliquidasset
investmentsheld.
•
Theinterestreceivedisoffsetbythe
interestwhichisduetoourdepositors
andinvestorstoarriveatnetinterest
income.
•
Asmallproportionofourincome
(lessthan1%)isnon-interestincome,
generatedfromsecondarylinesof
businesssuchascommissionearnedin
relationtoinsuranceproducts.
How we
spend and
invest
•
Ourrewardandremunerationpolicies
aredesignedtoattractandretain
colleagueswhopossesstherequisite
skillsets.
•
Toremaincompetitivedisciplinedcost
managementisessential.Overthelong
termweaimtoreduceouroverallcosts
toimproveourefficiency,acceptingthat
additionalinvestmentswillbemadein
thepursuitofourstrategicobjectives.
How we
manage our
long-term
stability and
sustainability
•
Weprioritisetherobustnessofour
systemsandframeworkswhicharein
placeforthemonitoringofrisks.We
ensurethatourliquidityandcapital
positionsaresufficientandabove
regulatoryrequirements.
•
Weinvestinourstrategically
importantcapabilities,includingour
TransformationRoadmap.Strategic
investmentensuresthatweevolve
alongsidetheexpectationsofthe
marketanditscustomers.
•
Ahighstandardofcorporategovernance
ismaintained,asiscompliancewith
lawsandregulations.
•
Appropriateprovisioningisheldinthe
eventthatcreditlossesarerealised.
•
TheSocietyembracesoursocialand
environmentalresponsibilitiesand
regularlyengageswithourwider
stakeholdergroups.
Our business model
16 | Strategic report 17
Our purpose and strategy (continued)
Our purpose
Ourthreecorepurposepriorities
guidewhereourfocusisplaced,
includingwhendevelopingnew
productpropositionsandundertaking
transformationactivities.
Place to call home
Helpingpeopletohaveaplacetocall
homeisalong-standingaimofYBS.Asa
buildingsociety,weexisttobringhome
ownershipwithinreachofmorepeople
throughourresponsiblemortgage
lending.OurPlacetoCallHomepriority
coversexistinghomeownerswhoare
lookingtorefinancewithus,aswell
asfirst-timebuyerswhoareseeking
totakethatfirststepontheproperty
ladder–bothofwhicharegroupswho
havefacednewchallengesoflate.The
Societyalsolendstothebuy-to-let
sector,allowinglandlordstoprovide
rentalaccommodation.
Thoseremortgagingfacesubstantially
higherinterestratesandtherefore
increasedmonthlyrepayments.First-
timebuyersmayfindgreaterobstacles
intheirpaththanbefore–intheraising
ofdeposits,andindemonstratingthey
canmeetaffordabilitycriteria.
Ourpropositiondevelopmentcentres
aroundthreekeyconsiderations:
•
Our purpose-offeringproductsthat
provideRealHelpwithRealLifeand
helpmorepeoplehaveaplaceto
callhome,
•
Optimising our existing capabilities
-developingpropositionswhilst
ensuringthatweunderstandandwe
managetheassociatedrisks,
•
Offering propositions that enable
us to compete-allowingusto
differentiateourbusinessfromthe
restofthemarketandcompete
sustainably.
Financial wellbeing
FormanypeopleintheUK,building
andprotectingtheirfinancial
wellbeinghasbecomemoreimportant
thanever.Whethertheyaresaving
tocoverunexpectedbills,avoiding
potentiallyexpensiveformsofdebt,or
simplytofeelsecureintheirpersonal
finances.
AlongwiththeBuildingSocieties
Association,weplayedanactiverole
inchampioningUKSavingsWeekin
September2023.Thetargetaudience
forthisinitiativeisthe11.5million
adultsintheUKwhohavelessthan
£100ofsavingstofallbackoninan
emergency.Theinitiativeaimstohelp
peopleunderstandhowtodevelop
andbuildasavingshabit,something
thathasaclearalignmenttoour
purpose.
Werecognisetheneedtokeepup
withevolvingcustomerneeds,and
ourtransformationprogrammehas
deliveredtangiblecustomerbenefits
in2023,withtheintroductionof
amoreaccessible,user-friendly
experienceandaraftofnewfeatures
foroursavingsapp.Thisincludes
easierfeedbackoptionstogetin
touchorraiseconcerns,andproviding
customerswithwhattheyneedto
managetheiraccountonlineoron
theapp,throughagreaterrangeof
self-servicefunctionality.Wewill
continuetoexpandandenhance
thefunctionalityavailableto
customers.Ourprogresssofarhas
beenrecognisedbycustomersandis
reflectedintheNPSofourmobileapp
increasingfrom+48to+63.
Wehavesupported263,000peopletoward
greaterfinancialwellbeingthisyear,
comparedto248,000in2022.
Propositionsdeliveredduringtheyear
includeanexpansionoftheCascade
Scorerisk-basedpricingproducts
toinclude95%LTV,whichoffers
productstocustomerswhomeet
alowerscorecardcriteriathanour
standardlending.Alongsidethis,policy
enhancementshavebeenakeyfocus,
withimprovementsinlendingtypes
suchastheself-employed,interest
onlyandcontractors.TheSociety’snew
inter-generationalproposition,Joint
Borrower-SoleProprietor,waslaunched
in2023,andallowscustomerstoadd
afamilymembertotheirmortgage
toimprovetheiraffordability.Rising
housepricesandthegrowingcostof
livingmeanspeopleareincreasingly
reliantuponfamilymemberstoprovide
supporttomeettheirfinancialgoals,and
supportingtheseunderservedsegments
ofthemarketalignsstronglytoour
purpose.
Ourtransformationjourneyfor
mortgagesremainsafocus,withactivity
underwaytoutiliseourMortgageSales
Origination(MSO)platformfurther.YBS’s
directlendingarmwassupportedbythe
implementationoftheMSOsystemfor
telephoneapplications,aligningwith
theapplicationprocessusedbyAccord.
Thiswilldeliveranimprovedapplication
processandincreasedefficiency,
allowingadvisorstohavemorequality,
focusedconversationswithcustomers.
Inordertosupportourexistingmortgage
customers,weformedadedicated
workinggroupthatreviewedand
proactivelycommunicatedwiththose
borrowerswhomaybemostimpacted
byasignificantincreaseintheirmonthly
repayments,withaviewtohelping
themreachasustainableandaffordable
solution.TheMortgageCharterwas
implementedduringJuly2023,withthe
aimofprovidingadditionalsupportto
existingcustomersatproductmaturity.
Followingimplementation,thenew
processeshavebeenmonitoredto
developimprovedinsightinrelationto
customerbehaviourandexperience.
In2023,wehavehelped52,000people
tohaveaplacetocallhomethrough
ourresidentialmortgages,ourbuy-to-
letmortgagestolandlords,andsocial
housinglending17(2022:55,000).
Goodprogresshasbeenmadein
ourcustomerpaymentsprocesses,
althoughourworkinthisarea
alsohighlightedthecomplexityof
thechangesweneededtomake.
ConfirmationofPayeeisaname-
checkingserviceforUK-based
paymentsthatallowsuserstoverify
thattheaccountdetailsmatchthose
intendedwhenanewpayeeisset
up.Thiswillhelpcustomersavoid
accidentallymisdirectedpayments,
aswellasprovidinganotherlayerof
protectionagainstfraudandscams.
InJune,welaunchedournewvirtual
assistant.Thisassistscustomers
withISAjourneys,cards,FSCSand
fraudtopicssocustomershavethe
optiontoaskquestionsaboutthese
topicswithoutneedingtoverifytheir
identity.Ifthevirtualassistantcannot
answerthequestion,orthecustomer
decidestheywanttospeakwithus,
theyalsohavetheoptiontoconnect
withacolleagueviaournewlivechat
serviceduringCustomerServices
openinghours.
Ourcommunityactivitiesalsoalign
toourfinancialwellbeinggoals.
Moreinformationonourcommunity
activitiescanbefoundintheEngaging
withourstakeholderssection.Through
oursavingsproductsandcommunity
initiatives,wehavesupported263,000
peopletowardgreaterfinancial
wellbeingin2023,comparedto
248,000in2022.
Member value
Asabuildingsociety,weexisttoserve
ourmembership,aswedonothave
externalshareholders.Ourdecisions
haveanappropriatelong-termfocus,
andouraimistosustainablyreturn
value.Onewayweaccomplishthisis
throughofferingrewardingratesto
thosesavingwithus.Weachievethis
throughthedevelopmentofmember
loyaltypropositions,whichoffer
competitiverates,andthroughpassing
onincreasestoourvariable-rate
customerswhenBankRateincreases.
Thereisalwaysabalancetobestruck
whenconsideringthescaleand
timingoftheseincreasesasallofour
decisionsneedtosupportourlong-
termsustainability.Thisisimportantin
protectingthestrengthofourfinancial
positionandallowingustocontinue
investinginoursecurityandrisk
managementprocesses,andultimately
providegreatproductsandservices.
OuroverallNPScouldbeconsidered
aproof-pointofhowwellweare
balancingthesedecisionsandwe
haveimprovedourperformancewhen
comparedtolastyear,withparticularly
goodprogressbeingmadeintheareas
ofsavingsanddigital.
Wedohoweverknowthatwedonot
alwaysgetitrightandthatthereis
alwaysroomforimprovement.Our
intentionwillalwaysbetoprovide
thebeststandardofservicepossible,
butsometimeswefallshortofthe
qualitythatourcustomersexpectand
deserve.Wewillcontinuetomonitor
keymetricsforcustomersatisfaction
andevolveourapproachaccordingly.
17 Placetocallhomemeasurebasedonaverageresidentsinpropertiesagainstwhichloanshavebeenadvanced
intheperiod(excludingremortgagesandfurtheradvancesbutincludingbuy-to-letandsocialhousing).
18 | Strategic report 19
Our purpose and strategy (continued)
Our strategy
SincetheSociety’sfoundingover160yearsago,
ourfundamentalpurposehasnotchanged;we
existtoprovideRealHelpwithRealLife.Our
strategyontheotherhandisadaptedmoreclosely
toourcurrentenvironmentandcapabilities.
In2023,theBoardwerepleasedtoapprovethe
newOurStrategy,whichsetsthedirectionforthe
futureoftheSociety,2024andbeyond.
The end of the Strategic Blueprint
2023markedthefinalyearofourStrategic
Blueprint,whichwaslaunchedin2020.Having
investedourtimeandresourcesinachieving
ourstrategicprioritiesofSavingsSupercharged,
PurposefulAnalytics,andUnbelievablyEasyand
Efficient,theSocietyasitstandstodayismuch
differenttothatofthreeyearsago.
Ourdigitalcustomerexperienceismuchimproved,
ourdataandanalyticalcapabilitiesareadvancing
ournewproductdevelopment,andprogresshas
beenmadeinsimplifyingandharmonisingsomeof
ourprocesses.
Theexternalcontextwithinwhichweoperatehas
alsoevolvedoverthecourseoftheyearsunder
theBlueprint.Whilstitisnotpossibletopredict
thefutureorcontrolexternalfactors,wecanbuild
anorganisationthatrespondsquicklytochanging
marketconditions,andtoevolvingcustomer
expectations,allsupportedbyaculturethat
reachesforbetter.
Thisiswhy,in2023,wehaveundertakenarefresh
ofourstrategy,whichwillservetounderpinthe
ambitiousnextphaseoftheSociety’sgrowth.
The four strategic pillars
OurStrategyisarticulatedthroughfourpillars:
Thefirstwillseeusextend our customer reach and deepen the impactwehaveontheirlives,whetherthrough
rewardingloyalty,orthroughspecificmortgageandsavingspropositionsthatworkinharmony.
Thesecondpillarwillseeuscreate joyful experiencesforourcustomersthataresimpleandfreefromstress
whethertheyareinteractingwithusinperson,online,orbyphone.
Thethirdseekstopromoteanambitious culturewithintheSociety,onethatenablesustomovetogetheratpace.
Withinthispillarareourfourexistingbehaviours,whichreflecttheprinciplesthatguideouractionsonaday-to-day
basis,andwhichremainakeycomponentofhowwewillunlockourculturalpotential.
Lastly,thefourthpillarfocusesonbuilding a future-ready Society.Thisincludesimprovingourabilitytoscaleas
wellassimplifyingsomeoftheinternalprocessesandproceduresthatwehavenotyetbeenabletooptimise,and
improvingthematurityofourcontrolenvironmentinrespectofdisclosuresandregulatoryreporting.Ournextphase
willseeusgrowevenfurther,andthispillarseekstoensurethatwearewellpreparedforthisfutureandfittoserve
moregenerationstocome.
The beginning of Our Strategy
ProvidingRealHelpwithRealLifespeakstoourmutualvalues,and
remainsfirmlyatthecentreofallthatwedo.OurStrategywillsee
theSocietyaimhigher,andprovidesaNorthStartowhichallofthe
decisionswemakewillbealigned.
For2024,wehaveidentifiedthreeterritorieswhichrepresentareas
wheretheSocietycanstandoutfromtherestofthemarketandmake
arealdifferenceforourmembers,forourcustomers,andforsociety
morewidely.
Our three territories
We care
about people
We say it
straight
We reach
for better
We make it
happen
Thisisaboutfostering
humanconnection
bothwithintheSociety
andwithout.Itmeans
actingwithempathy
andbeingawareofthe
impactthataction,or
inaction,canhaveon
others.
Theabilitytohave
honest,straightforward
conversationsbuilds
trustandgetsresults.
Thismeansspeaking
upwithpositiveintent,
andbeingopenand
preparedforfeedback
whetherpositiveor
negative.
Weshouldaim
forcontinuous
improvement
acrossalllevelsof
theorganisation.
Reachingforbetter
invitescolleagues
tobeinnovativeand
empowersthemto
takeresponsibilityfor
theirownlearningand
development.
Thisisaboutmovingat
paceandwithpurpose,
focusingonremoving
anybarriersthatexist,
adaptingtochallenges,
andultimatelyfinding
solutions.
Standing with savers
Throughourproductsandpropositions,competitiverates,
andusingourplatformtosupportthenation’ssavers.
Helping first homes happen
Throughourlendingdecisionsandtargetedproduct
development,aswellasworkingtosupportthosefacing
challengesinfindingaplaceonthepropertyladder.
Financial education
Throughcommunityengagement,andprovidingaccessible
resourcestosupportgreatereducationinmattersofmoney
managementandpersonalfinances.
Double reach
and deepen impact
Create joyful
experiences
Cultivate an
ambitious culture
Build a future
ready Society
20 | Strategic report 21
Our ESG
priorities
Workinginharmony
alongsideourthreecore
purposeprioritiesare
ourthreeresponsible
businesspriorities,which
formourstrategyfor
Environmental,Social,
andGovernance('ESG')
matters.Theserepresent
thetopicsofthemost
materialrelevanceto
theSocietyandour
operations,having
beenidentifiedthrough
stakeholderengagement.
Ourresponsiblebusiness
prioritiesareInvesting
inourpeople;Operating
responsibly;andBuilding
agreenersociety.
Investing in our people
Ourpeopleareourgreatest
asset;withoutthem,wewould
notbeabletoprovidethelevel
ofservicethatourcustomersand
membersdeserve.Toensurewe
haveanengagedandmotivated
workforceweinvestinour
colleaguesallowingthemto
thriveinanenvironmentwhere
theycanbeattheirbest.
More detail on the topics
relating to our Investing
in our people priority
can be found in our 2023
ESG report, which will be
available on our website
mid-2024.
Wellbeing
Thehealthandwellbeingofour
colleaguesisasimportantto
usnowasiteverhasbeen.Our
approachtosupportingwellbeing
focusesonfourpillars:mental
health,physicalhealth,financial
health,andsocialhealth.This
year,wepublishedaseriesof
guidesbringingtogetherallof
theinformationandsupport
colleaguesneedtoimproveand
maintaintheirwellbeingacross
eachofthesepillars.
Theimportanceweplaceon
colleaguewellbeingisalso
reflectedinourbenefitandleave
policies.Arangeofbenefitscan
bepurchasedviamonthlysalary
deductionsovera12-month
period,andincludediscounted
accesstocriticalillnesscover,
privatemedicalinsurance,and
Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
TheSocietyhasevolvedourapproachfrom
Inclusion&Diversity('I&D')toonethat
encompassesDiversity,Equity,andInclusion
(DE&I).Thisisalignedtotherecognition
thatinordertofosteraninclusiveplaceof
work,thereexistsaneedtoofferinitiatives
orinterventionsaimedtowardensuring
allcolleaguescan,andwantto,fulfiltheir
careerpotentialwithus.Thesemayneedto
varydependingontheindividualneedsor
circumstancesinordertoensureafairoutcome
forall.
Governance, strategy, and DE&I
measures
In2023,wehavestrengthenedthegovernance
ofDE&Ibysplittingwhatwasonecommittee
intotheDE&IWorkingGroupandtheDE&I
Forum,withthelatterreportingintoourESG
Committee.Thesechangeswillbeformalised
aspartofathree-yearstrategyfrom2024,and
willempowertheWorkingGrouptodeliver
change,whiletheroleoftheForumwillbe
providingchallengeandmonitoringwider
strategicprogress.Wehavealsoenhanced
accountabilityacrossalllevels,integrating
aDE&IobjectiveintoourLeadingforValue
bonusplan.WesetoutDE&Imeasuresas
partofourstrategy,whicharereviewedeach
quarter,andpresentedtotheDE&IForumto
measureprogresstowardourplans.
Eachyear,weconductanannualDE&I
engagementsurveytogathercolleagueviews
onhowinclusiveanddiversetheenvironment
atYBSis.The2022surveyinformedourareas
offocusin2023:recruitment,opportunities,
anddata.Robustdataandreportingon
colleagueandapplicantdemographics
hasallowedustomeasuretheinclusivity
ofourcultureandbegintoaddressareas
ofunderrepresentation.Ourprocessesfor
attractionandrecruitmentthemselveswere
alsoafocus,ensuringhiringmanagersare
equippedtofacilitatereasonableadjustments
throughouttheinterviewandonboarding
process.Wealsowantedtoprovidebetter
visibilityofinternalcareeropportunitiesfor
colleaguesacrossthebreadthoftheSociety.
Together,theseimprovementshelpedusto
improvetheoverallcolleagueexperience,as
wellasinformingourrefreshedDE&Istrategy.
Wewereabletomeasureprogressagainst
ourareasoffocuswiththelatestDE&Isurvey,
whichwasconductedinNovember2023.We
maintainedourscoreof8.8andourplace
intheupperquartileoffinancialservices
organisations.72%ofcolleaguescompleted
thesurvey,upfrom62%in2022andwe
haveseenanincreaseincolleaguessharing
theircharacteristics,specificallythosewitha
hiddendisabilityandcaringresponsibilities.
Colleague engagement
Weplacegreatemphasison
ourcolleaguesfeelingvalued,
listenedto,andfairlyrewarded
forthecontributionstheymake.
Aworkplacethatsucceeds
inmeetingallofthesewill
demonstratehighlevelsof
contentment,productivity,and
engagement.
Anannualsurveyisourprimary
meansthroughwhichthelevels
ofengagementacrosstheSociety
aremeasured,whichislater
supplementedbyperiodic
check-ins.
In2023,90%ofcolleagues
completedtheannualsurvey,and
theSociety’soverallengagement
scorewas8.6(2022:8.6)which
maintainsourpositioninthetop
quartileforengagementamongst
financialorganisations18.Our
employeeNPS('eNPS')improved
to+68(2022:+66),which
keepsusfirmlyinthetop5%of
financialorganisations.
ahealthcashplan.Inaddition,
allcolleagueshaveaccessto
awellbeingplatformwhich
providesalibraryofcontent
includingsleeptools,emotional
resilienceguidance,and
educationalvideosontopics
likemenopause,nutrition,and
neurodiversity.
Asameansofgaugingwhether
ourcolleaguesarereceivingthe
rightlevelsofsupport,weclosely
monitorkeymetrics,including
thelevelsofabsence.The
sicknessratein2023was4.23%
(onarolling12-monthbasis)
comparedto4.43%in2022.We
willcontinuetomonitordata
foranyemergingtrends,andto
informourongoingcommitment
tocolleaguewellbeing.
Theresultsandcolleaguefeedbackhavebeen
usedtovalidateourrefreshedDE&Istrategyfor
2024.
Colleague networks
Wehavefivecolleaguenetworks:Accessibility,
Ethnicity,Parents&Carers,Proud,and
Women.Eachofthenetworksaresupported
byseniorleadersponsors,andtheco-Chairs
ofthenetworksregularlyinteractwiththe
DE&Iforum.ColleagueNetworkshavebeen
instrumentalineffectingpositivechangeand
advancingourinitiativesinpromotingdiversity,
equity,andinclusion.Notablecontributions,
amongothers,includetheAccessibility
Network'ssupportfortherefurbishmentof
ourBradfordoffice,theEthnicityNetwork's
improvementstocontemplationandprayer
facilities,andtheWomen'sNetwork's
contributiontoreshapingourabsencepolicy
andmenopauseguides.
Reporting & accreditations
Overthepast12monthswehaveretainedour
placewithintheTop10employersforWorking
Familiesforthethirdyearrunning,continued
toworktowardachievingDisabilityConfident
LeaderLevel3,andhavecontinuedourwork
inconnectionwiththeRaceatWorkCharter
commitments.
Our2023GenderPayGapreportshowed
23.4%and23.8%formeanandmedian
respectively(2022:25.7%and24.0%).We
haveseenareductioninourGenderPayGap
forthepastfiveyears,themaindriverofwhich
continuestobetheimbalanceofwomenand
menatdifferentlevelsoftheorganisation.
AlignedtoourcommitmenttotheWomen
inFinanceCharter,wearebuildingatalent
pipelineforseniormanageranddirectorroles,
andweregularlyreviewourtalentdatawith
seniorleaders.Wehavemadeprogressinthis
area,asevidencedinthereductionofour
GenderPayGapandtheachievementofour
WomeninFinancetargetofa50:50splitat
gradeEandabovelevel.
Learning and development
Allcolleagues,nomattertheircurrentlevel
intheSociety,areencouragedtoundertake
professionaldevelopmentandprogresstoward
theircareergoals.Inordertoreachthemost
people,throughthemostconvenientmeans,
weutiliseablendedapproachthatcombines
face-to-faceworkshops,virtualworkshops,
andonline-basedresources.Thisempowers
colleaguestoworkontheirindividual
developmentinawaythatsuitsthem.
In2023,akeyfocuswasimprovingour
understandingofbothcurrentandfutureskill
requirements.Wehavesupportedbusiness
areasthroughaskillsdiagnosticthataimedto
Topromoteanopenand
supportiveculture,weseekto
embraceandunderstandarange
ofperspectives,offeringvarious
platformsforcolleaguestoshare
theirthoughts.OurColleague
Forumwasestablishedin2019
andhostsregulardiscussions
betweencolleagues,senior
leadership,andmembersof
ourBoard.Theseconversations
ensurethatthevoicesof
everyonecanbeheard,and
provideanopportunityfor
actionstobetakenbasedon
theirinput.Twiceayear,we
alsoholdsessionstofacilitate
opencommunicationbetween
Non-ExecutiveDirectors,and
themembersofourteamswho
areintegraltotheday-to-day
operations.
Maintaininggoodlevelsof
engagementisanongoing
processandwecontinually
assess,anddeveloptoolsto
furtherenhance,howengaged
andvaluedourcolleaguesfeel.
18BenchmarksourcedfromPeakon.
22 | Strategic report 23
Our ESG priorities (continued)
identifycurrentskillproficiencylevels,
comparedtoourfutureneeds.
Skillsrelatingtodigitalliteracy
anddataanalytics&insightswere
identifiedasprioritiesforourroadmap,
whichwillbedevelopedthrough
bothself-ledandprogramme-based
learning,includingapprenticeships.
Ourapprenticeshipschemescontinue
toprovidecolleagueswithan
opportunitytogainaprofessional
qualificationwhilstlearningonthe
job.Weareproudthat60colleagues
areactivelystudyingthroughvarious
apprenticeships,whichincludes24
colleaguesdevelopingtheirdata
capabilitythroughbothLiteracyand
FellowshipProgrammes.
Ournewlylaunchedmentoring
platform,madeavailabletoallYBS
colleagues,alsorepresentsauseful
tooltobetterenablethesharingof
knowledgeandexpertiseacrossthe
business,aswellassupportingtalent
mobility,andourDE&Iagenda.
Ourpeopleleadershaveimportant
rolestoplayinsupportingour
teams,inmanagingpeoplerisks,and
supportingourbusinessthrough
changesofallkinds.In2024,wewill
focusontheintroductionofleader-
specificprogrammes,whichwill
complementourexistingframeworks
andguidesandcontinuedeveloping
ourtalentandtalentpipelines
asourorganisationcontinuesits
transformationjourney.
Reward & recognition
Itisimportantthatourcolleaguesare
fairlyrewardedfortheircontribution
totheSociety’sabilitytodeliver
exceptionalproductsandservicesfor
ourmembersandcustomers.In2023,
wemadesignificantinvestmentsin
basepay,providingeligiblecolleagues
witha6%increase,supplementedby
anadditional1%whichleaderswere
abletoallocateonadiscretionary
basiswherefurtheradjustmentswere
feltnecessary.Wealsoreinforcedour
supportforthosecolleagueswithin
thelowestpaybands,introducing
aSociety-wideminimumsalaryof
£22,000.Thissupportedcolleagues
amidstinflationaryandcost-of-living
pressures,aswellasaligningtoour
commitmenttomaintainwagesator
abovetheRealLivingWage.
TheRemunerationPolicyhasbeen
reviewedin2023forallcolleagues
andtheDirectorsRemunerationPolicy
issubjecttoanadvisoryvoteatthe
2024AnnualGeneralMeeting.
Further details of this review
are covered in the Directors
Remuneration report.
Ourcommitmenttocolleague
recognitioncontinuestoevolve.In
2023,weinitiatedapilotprogramme
foranewapproachtorecognitionled
bypeopleleaders.Theoutputofthis
pilothassupportedthedesigning
anddevelopingofanewrecognition
frameworkfor2024.Thenew
frameworkrecognisesthe‘how’-how
ourcolleaguesmakedecisions,how
theycollaborateandhowtheynurture
innovation.Thiswillenablemore
flexibleandtimelyrecognitionfocused
acrossalllevelsoftheorganisation.
Operating responsibly
Asamutual,wehaveadutytooperate
responsibly.Havingrobustgovernance
andproceduresinplaceallowsusto
meetregulatoryrequirements,and
protectcustomers,colleagues,andthe
Societyfrompotentialrisks.
Risk management
TheRiskManagementreportdetails
ourEnterpriseRiskManagement
Framework,aswellasarticulating
theprincipalriskstowhichweare
exposedandhowtheyaremitigated.
Human rights
InherentwithinourpurposeofReal
HelpwithRealLifeisacommitment
thatthewayweconductourbusiness
shouldnotnegativelyimpactthe
humanrightsofothers.Thisincludes
howweinteractwithourcustomers,
colleagues,andcommunitiesaswellas
thewaywemanageoursupplychain.
The Society’s Modern Slavery Act
Transparency Statement, which
describes the steps put in place
to prevent slavery and human
trafficking in our supply chain, or
any part of our business, can be
found on our website.
Anti-bribery and anti-
corruption
TheSocietyisboundbythelaws
oftheUK,includingtheBriberyAct
2010,andisregulatedbytheFinancial
ConductAuthority;bothofwhich
conveyresponsibilitiesforidentifying
andmanagingrisksinrespectoffraud,
bribery,andcorruption.TheSociety
takesazero-toleranceapproachto
suchrisksandenforcescompliance
viasystems,processes,andour
internalcontrolframework.These
includemandatoryannualcolleague
trainingandawarenessinitiatives,
awhistleblowingprocedure,and
regularreviewsofourFinancialCrime
Policy,whichincludesourAnti-Bribery
andAnti-CorruptionStandard,our
approachtothemanagementofrisks
undertheUKCorporateCriminal
OffenceofFailuretoPreventthe
FacilitationofTaxEvasionlegislation,
andotherrelatedpolicies.
Rating Provider Rating/Score Scale (best to worst)
MSCI* AAA AAA–CCC
MorningstarSustainalytics** 12.9 0–100
S&PCorporateSustainabilityAssessment(CSA) 51 100–0
CDP*** Submitted-NotScored AtoF
ISSESG C A+toD-
Moody’sAnalytics 67 0–100
* TheusebyYorkshireBuildingSocietyofanyMSCIESGRESEARCHLLCoritsaffiliates('MSCI')data,andtheuseofMSCIlogos,trademarks,servicemarksorindexnames
herein,donotconstituteasponsorship,endorsement,recommendation,orpromotionofYorkshireBuildingSocietybyMSCI.MSCIservicesanddataarethepropertyof
MSCIoritsinformationprovidersandareprovided‘as-is’andwithoutwarranty.MSCInamesandlogosaretrademarksorservicemarksofMSCI.
** Copyright©2023MorningstarSustainalytics.Allrightsreserved.ThissectioncontainsinformationdevelopedbySustainalytics(www.sustainalytics.com).Such
informationanddataareproprietaryofSustainalyticsand/oritsthird-partysuppliers(ThirdPartyData)andareprovidedforinformationalpurposesonly.Theydo
notconstituteanendorsementofanyproductorproject,noraninvestmentadviceandarenotwarrantedtobecomplete,timely,accurateorsuitableforaparticular
purpose.Theiruseissubjecttoconditionsavailableathttps://www.sustainalytics.com/legal-disclaimers.
***DuetothetransitiontothenewEnvironmentalSustainabilityTeam,theSocietywasnotabletocompletethesubmissionintimetoberated.However,afull
submissionwascompletedafterthedeadlineandisavailableonCDP’swebsite.
Non-financial reporting measures
PresentedbelowaretheSociety’smostrecentratingsfromnon-financialreportingagencies.
Weareproudthat60colleaguesareactivelystudyingthroughvarious
apprenticeships,whichincludes24colleaguesdevelopingtheirdata
capabilitythroughbothLiteracyandFellowshipProgrammes.
24 | Strategic report 25
Building a greener society
Aspartofour2023AnnualReportandAccounts,wepresentanupdateonourcommitmenttoBuildingagreenersociety,
developingonthefoundationlaidoutinour2022TaskforceonClimate-relatedFinancialDisclosure(‘TCFD’).
ThisreportisstructuredtoshowtheSociety’sunderstandingoftherisksassociatedwithclimatechange,andhowtheSociety
hascontinuedtoadheretotheFinancialStabilityBoard’sTCFDrecommendationsfordevelopingclimateandenvironmental
disclosures.TheSocietyremainscommittedtoprogressingfurtheronthepathtofullcomplianceinatransparentway.
ThetablebelowillustratestheintegrationofTCFDrecommendationsacrosstheAnnualReportandAccounts:
Contents
Disclosure pillar Recommendation Reference
Governance
•
DescribetheBoard’soversightofclimate-relatedrisksand
opportunities.
•
Describemanagement’sroleinassessingandmanaging
climate-relatedrisksandopportunities.
See Climate
governance in the
Building a greener
society report.
Disclosetheorganisation’s
governancearound
climate-relatedrisksand
opportunities.
Strategy
•
Describetheclimate-relatedrisksandopportunitiesthe
organisationhasidentifiedovertheshort-,medium-,and
long-term.
•
Describetheimpactofclimate-relatedrisksandopportunities
ontheorganisation’sbusinesses,strategies,andfinancial
planning.
•
Describetheresilienceoftheorganisation’sstrategy,takingin
toconsiderationdifferentclimaterelatedscenarios,including
a2°Corlowerscenario.
See Strategy in the
Building a greener
society report.
Disclosetheactualand
potentialimpactsof
climate-relatedrisksand
opportunitiesonthe
organisation’sbusinesses,
strategy,andfinancial
planningwheresuch
informationismaterial.
Risk Management
•
Describehowtheorganisation’sprocessesforidentifyingand
assessingclimate-relatedrisks.
•
Describetheorganisation’sprocessesforidentifying,
assessing,andmanagingclimate-relatedrisksareintegrated
intotheorganisation’soverallriskmanagement.
•
Describehowprocessesforidentifying,assessing,and
managingclimate-relatedrisksareintegratedintothe
organisation’sriskmanagement.
See Risk management
in the Building a
greener society report.
Disclosehowthe
organisationidentifies,
assesses,andmanages
climate-relatedrisks.
Metrics and Targets
•
Disclosethemetricsusedbytheorganisationtoassess
climate-relatedrisksandopportunitiesinlinewithitsstrategy
andriskmanagementprocess.
•
DiscloseScope1,Scope2and,ifappropriateScope3,
greenhousegas(GHG)emissionsandtherelatedrisks.
•
Describethetargetsusedbytheorganisationtomanage
climate-relatedrisksandopportunitiesandperformance
againsttargets.
See Metrics & targets
in the Building a
greener society
report, alongside the
SECR section of the
Directors report and
Renumeration report in
the Directors’ report.
Disclosethemetricsand
targetsusedtoassess
andmanagerelevant
climaterelatedrisksand
opportunitieswheresuch
informationismaterial.
Climate governance
Board and executive oversight
TheBoardassumesultimateaccountabilityforaddressingclimatechangerisksandopportunitiesandissupportedbythe
governancestructurelaidoutabove.RegularBoardmeetingsarecomplementedbytheexistinggovernanceframework,which
activelymanagesclimatechangerisksonaday-to-daybasis.ProgressagainsttheSociety’sclimatecommitmentsandinternal
plansaresharedwiththeBoardanditssub-committees.
In2023,theSocietycontinuedtoembedclimatechangeandenvironmentalgovernanceintothecorporatestructure.We
continuetoassignkeyaccountabilitiesinenvironmentalstewardshipandclimatechangerisks,inorderthataclearsenseof
ownershipandresponsibilityisdemonstratedacrosstheSociety.
Senior management accountability
TheaccountabilityfortheseniormanagementfunctionremainssharedbetweenourChiefFinanceOfficerandourChiefRisk
Officer.Thiscollaborativeapproachensuresthatallelementsofenvironmentalandclimate-relatedmattersarecaptured
withintheaccountabilitydocuments.
TheChiefPeopleOfficerisExecutiveCommitteesponsorforoverarchingESGreporting.
Group Risk
Committee
Executive Risk
Committee
Audit
Committee
YBS Board
Asset and Liability
Committee
Executive
Committee
Environment, Social and Governance
Committee
Providesclimateriskoversight
andsetsGroupriskappetite.
Managementofthegovernance
frameworkforclimaterisk.
Non-financialdisclosurein
relationtoenvironment,social
andgovernanceagenda.
Ultimateaccountabilityoffinancialrisksforclimatechangeandassociated
responsibilities.TheBoardissupportedbythebelowsub-committees:
Focusonfinancialrisksarising
fromclimatechange.
Oversightofimplementation
ofenvironmentalstrategyand
approvalofclimateriskmatters
forrecommendationtotheBoard.
Delegatedauthorityfrom
ExecutiveCommitteetosupport
theBoardinoverseeingthe
environmentalstrategy.
Our ESG priorities (continued)
26 | Strategic report 27
Operational working groups and forums
In2023,weenhancedtheapproachtogovernancebelowthelevelofcommitteestostrengthenouroverallclimate
governance.Twoworkinggroupswhichmeetonalternatemonths,andaforumthatmeetseverytwomonthssupportfocused
workonthekeyclimateandenvironmentalchallengesthattheSocietyfaces.
Strategy
The YBS team
Themostprominentmilestonefor
2023hasbeentheestablishment
ofadedicatedEnvironmental
Sustainabilityteam,comprisingone
SeniorManagerandthreeManagers,
whichwasfullyresourcedin2023Q4.
Aspartoftheembeddingofthisteam,
thefoundationshavebeenlaidto
integrateenvironmentalsustainability
throughouttheorganisation,which
wehaveconsideredfurtherwithinthis
report.
DuringQ4of2023,thenewteam
bolsteredexistingprocessesto
monitorourScope1andScope
2emissionsandimproveour
understandingofclimatechange
riskandopportunitiesacrossthe
breadthoftheSociety.Byexpanding
ourresources,wehavebeenableto
increaseourcapabilitiestomeasure,
monitor,andeffectivelymanage
themultifacetedimpactsofclimate
change.Thisincludesembeddingthe
ambitiontoreachNetZeroby2050
withinourFinancedEmissions.
The Society's interpretation of
Net Zero means a focused effort
to significantly reduce our carbon
footprint across all Scopes.
Identifying and assessing the
impacts of climate risks
On the Group
Climatechangeposesarisktothe
Society,bothintheshort-termas
economiesandindividualstransition
toalowcarboneconomy,andover
thelongertermasextremeweather
eventsareexpectedtobecomemore
frequent.Tounderstandthesizeof
thisrisk,wehavedevelopedinternal
climatemodels,whichaligntothe
BankofEngland’sClimateBiennial
ExploratoryScenarios(‘CBES’).
Ourmostrecentclimatescenario
exercisewasundertakenin2022
andweplantorefreshthemodels
during2024.Ourscenariomodel
isbuiltaroundexistingcreditrisk
stresstestingmodelswithamodular
designtoaddcomponentsspecifically
forassessingtheimpactofclimate-
relatedrisks.Theclimate-related
riskcomponentsofthemodelsare
integratedintotheProbabilityof
DefaultandtheLossGivenDefault
modelstoenabletheimpactofsuch
risksoncreditlossestobegenerated
overshort-,medium-,andlong-term
timehorizons19.Currentlyourclimate
scenariomodelisbuiltonanincurred
lossbasis,anddevelopmentis
underwaytoalignthistoIFRS9.
Ouranalysis,basedonastaticbalance
sheet,usedthird-partydatatomodel
theCBESscenariosovervarioustime
horizons,upto30years.Physical
risksconsideredincludedflooding,
subsidence,andcoastalerosion.
TransitionrisksusedEPCdatato
understandtheriskofretrofittingand
potentialstrandedassetassessments.
The2022scenarioanalysisincludes
assumptionsthatdonotaccountfor
theabilityoftheSocietytomanageits
balancesheeteffectivelyor,account
formortgageredemptionandnew
lending.Evenonthisbasis,theoutputs
showminimalexposuretopotential
lossesoverthemediumandlong-term.
ThisresultisreflectedintheSociety’s
decisiontonotchangeitsbusiness
planningactivitiesmateriallyin
responsetoclimatechange.Alongside
therefreshedscenarioanalysis,our
considerationofmateriallossesand
ourriskappetitewillbereviewed.
For further detail on the scenario
analysis undertaken in 2022
please see the Strategic report
of our 2022 Annual Report and
Accounts20.
Tobetterunderstandandmodel
theSociety’slong-termexposureto
climaterisk,adynamicversionofthe
modelwasdeveloped;thisallowedthe
modeltoapplyassumptionsforloan
redemptionsandnewlending.This
improvedthemodel’sabilitytoreflect
thegrowthplans,andisthereforea
moreaccuraterepresentationofthe
Society’sbalancesheetinthefuture,
thoughitisworthyofnotethatthe
modelsarestillintheirinfancyand
assuchhaveseverallimitations,
including:
•
Underestimation,asscenariosdonot
accountforpotentialclimatetipping
points,afterwhichclimatechangeis
likelytoaccelerate.
•
Thetimehorizonsusedaremuch
longerthantraditionalfinancial
models,exposingthemtoincreased
riskfromforecastassumptions.
•
Dataisbeingusedinwaysfor
whichitwasnotdesigned,an
examplebeingEPCdata(seeEnergy
PerformanceCertificates).
•
Theinabilitytoback-testclimate
scenariomodellinginordertogauge
theaccuracyofresults.
Allmodelrisks,includingdataand
assumptions,aremanagedinternally
throughtheSociety’sModelRisk
Framework,whichisembeddedinto
theEnterpriseRiskManagement
Framework.Themodelsaredeveloped
byanindependentteamallowingfor
challengearoundtheirlimitations
andoutputs.TheSociety’sability
tocontinuouslyevolvetheclimate
modelswillbenefitfromtheadditional
resourceofadedicatedclimate
modeller,whowillberecruitedat
thestartof2024.In2024,weaim
toupdatethemodeloutputs,review
thescenariosbeingutilised,and
identifyfurtherscenariosrelevant
totheSociety’sportfolio.The
modelswillcontinuetobeusedfor
theclimatesectionoftheInternal
CapitalAdequacyAssessmentProcess
(‘ICAAP’),whichmeasurestheamount
ofcapitalholdingsrequiredtoprotect
theSocietyfrompotentialriskwhilst
remainingfinanciallystable.
On our customers and
members
Wearecommittedtoassistingour
customersastheytransitiontoa
low-carbonsocietyandenhancethe
energyefficiencyoftheirhomes.
TheSocietycontinuestodevelopa
customerNetZerotransitionplan,
focusingonsupportingthosewiththe
highestexposuretotherisksstemming
fromthistransition.Webelievethat
thetransitiontoaNetZeroeconomy
shouldbefairandjustforall,andwe
recognisethepotentialchallengesthat
manywillfaceinreachingthatgoal.
BybalancingthepursuitofScience-
BasedTargetswithourcommitmentto
providing
RealHelpwithRealLife
,we
prioritiseavoidingactivitiesthatmay
harmthesocialandfinancialwellbeing
ofourcustomers.
BoththeEnvironmentalandClimateRiskworkinggroupsarechairedbytheManagerswithinEnvironmentalSustainability
andarecrucialinprioritisingrelatedworkstreams.
EachCommittee,Forum,andWorkingGroupisfocusedondeliveringchangealignedtoourClimateCommitments.Asthe
Society’sunderstandingofclimatechangerisksandopportunitiesdevelops,sotoowillourapproachtogovernance.A
primarywaythatwewillstrengthenourclimategovernanceduring2024isbyprovidinginformationandtrainingoncarbon
literacyacrosstheSociety.
Environmental Sustainability
Working Group
Climate Risk
Working Group
Environmental Sustainability Forum
TheEnvironmentalSustainabilityWorking
Groupconsistsofsubjectmatterexperts
fromacrosstheSocietytodelivertactical
andstrategicchangewithregardto
understandingandreducingouroperational
emissions.
TheClimateRiskWorkingGrouputilises
subjectmatterexpertsfromacrossthe
Societytodelivertacticalandstrategic
changewithregardstounderstanding
andreducingourFinancedEmissionsand
exposuretophysicalrisk.Itincludesafocus
onlendingpoliciesandnewproducts.
TheESGCommitteehasdelegatedauthorityfromtheExecutiveCommittee
toconsiderandprovideguidanceonmattersrelatingtotheenvironmentand
climatechange.ItmeetseveryothermonthandbringstogetherC-suitelevel
representationfromacrosstheSociety.In2023,theCommitteemet11times
andreceivedsixpapersrelatingtoenvironmentalmatters.TheCommitteeis
chairedbytheSociety’sChiefExecutive.
TheEnvironmentalSustainabilityForumbringstogetherdirectorsandseniorleadersfromacrossthe
Societytoprovideopportunitytochallengeandreviewtheapproachtakenindeliveringourclimate
strategy,priortopresentationatESGCommittee.TheforumischairedbytheSeniorManager–
EnvironmentalSustainability.
ESG Committee
Setting ESG strategy and direction
Delivering updates on progress and metrics
19Horizons:Short0-5years;Medium5-15years;Long15+years.
20AnnualReportsandAccounts2022(ybs.co.uk)
Our ESG priorities (continued)
Building a greener society(continued)
Climate governance(continued)
28 | Strategic report 29
Identifying and assessing climate
opportunities
For our organisation
TheSocietyrecognisesthatclimatechange
offersopportunitiesforthosethatcan
recogniseandactonthem.ForYBSthis
includesincreasedoperationalresilience
andcostsavingsastheSocietytransitions
tolow-carbontechnologyandsustainable
practices.Byconsideringclimatechange
inouroperationalplanningandrisk
management,theSocietycanbebetter
preparedforpotentialextremeweather
eventsandsupplychainvulnerabilities.
Climatechangealsoprovidesan
opportunityfortheSocietytobolsterour
reputationasanorganisationwithastrong
socialpurposebyaddressingourimpact,
beingtransparentaboutourprogress,and
supportingourcustomerswithtransitional
changes.Thiswouldenhancethepositive
relationshipswehavewithourcustomers,
members,andcolleagues.
For our colleagues
Ourcolleagueswillplayapivotalrolein
contributingtooursustainabilityjourney
andclimateinitiatives.Wehavemade
noteworthyprogressinfosteringcolleague
engagementacrossalldepartments,
includingourbranchnetwork.In2023,we
embarkedonajourneytoraiseawareness
onenvironmentalsustainabilitythrougha
seriesofeducationalblogs,insights,and
interactivepolls.
In2024,wewilllaunchtheClimate
Championnetwork,whichisdesignedto
workinharmonywiththenormalroles
andresponsibilitiesofourcolleagues.
Sustainabilityisnotastandaloneeffort,but
ratheranintegralpartofeveryrolewithin
ourorganisation.TheClimateChampions
willleadbyexample,inspiringothersto
adoptsustainablepracticesandhighlighting
potentialopportunitiesandchallengesthat
maynothavebeenconsidered.Thenetwork
willbekeytodeliveringcarbonliteracy
upskillingacrosstheSociety.Itisintended
thatthiswillsupportcolleaguestomake
informeddecisionsaroundenergyuseand
wastemanagement.
Risk management
Climate-related financial risks
Climate-relatedfinancialrisksarecharacterisedbytheiruncertainty,whichaddscomplexitytotheir
managementandmodelling.Riskismanagedonanongoingbasisthroughpolicies,governance,and
riskappetitestatements,whicharticulatethelevelthatisacceptabletotheSociety.Thefinancialrisks
associatedwithclimatechangecanbecategorisedaseitherphysicalortransition,withthetwobeing
stronglyinterrelated.TheSocietyseekstoidentifyandunderstandallkeyrisksunderthesecategories,
includingtheirimpactonourabilitytoserveourmembersandcustomers.Ourapproachtomanaging
theseriskswillmaturealongsideourunderstandingofthem.
Physical risk
Physicalrisksarisefromchangestotheenvironmentthatmaydamagetheintegrityofaproperty,
includingspecificweatherevents(acuterisks)andlong-termchangesintheclimate(chronicrisks).This
impactstheSocietybyalteringthevalueofassetsheldandincreasingthecreditriskofourcustomers.The
topthreephysicalriskswehaveidentifiedarenotedinthetablebelow.
TheSocietyquantifiesphysicalrisksthroughdataprovidedbyathird-partysupplier,Hometrack,which
coversallthreeoftherisksshownintheprecedingtable.Thedataincludesaviewofhowtheriskwill
changeunderseveralclimatescenariosandtimehorizonsandisprovidedonaregionalbasis,whichis
updatedquarterly.UsingthisdatatobenchmarkYBSagainsttheUKaverageshowstheSocietyhasa
slightlylowerthanaveragelevelofriskacrossallofthethreephysicalrisks.
Asthephysicalrisksmanifest,theycanimpactotherriskareas:
Credit riskisincreasedasdamagedhomesreduceinvalue,andownershavereducedabilitytopayorfind
challengesinsecuringinsurance.Thismayincreasethelikelihoodofdefault.
Operational riskisincreasedasweathereventsmaydamageourbranches,offices,orsupplychain.Our
employee’shomesmaybeimpacted,impactingtheirabilitytowork,andourcustomers’homesmaybe
impactedwhichwoulddriveupcallvolumes.
Capital riskincreasesasphysicaldamagetohomescandeterioratebalancesheetassets.
Workstreams to manage the risks and opportunities associated with flooding, subsidence and coastal
erosion are discussed and prioritised within the Climate Risk Working Group (see Climate governance).
For our customers and members
Thetransitiontolow-carbonhomes
requiresustosupportourcustomersand
membersinnewways.Wehavelaunched
ourfirstmortgagepropositiondedicatedto
improvingenergyefficiencywithinhomes
andcollaboratedwiththeEnergySavings
Trust(‘EST’)toprovidecustomerswithan
assessmenttoolonhowtheycanreduce
theirenergyconsumption.Sincethetool
waslaunchedinNovember2022,2,545
peoplehaveusedittoassesshowtheycan
makehomeenergyefficiencyimprovements.
OurpartnershipswiththeBuildingSocieties
AssociationandGreenFinanceInstitute
allowustotakepartinandbenefitfromthe
collectiveexperienceandlearningsofour
industry.Theseforumshavehighlightedto
theSocietythatthemarketforgreenretail
productsisstillemerging,withlowcustomer
demandatpresent.Thesettingofclear
strategyandpolicydirectionfromtheUK
Governmentwillenablethismarkettogain
tractionandprovidesimpleandaffordable
productsthathelpdecarbonisehomes.
Additionally,guidancefromregulators,
suchastheFinancialConductAuthority’s
anti-greenwashingguidance21,isvaluablein
helpingtheindustrytransitiontoagreener
economywithintegrity.
Throughout2024,weplantoincrease
theamountofinformationonthistopic
availabletoourcustomersthroughour
website,supportedbysocialmediaactivity
tounderstandwhatkindofinformationour
customersvaluemost.Wewillalsocontinue
toreviewourproducts,bothmortgages
andsavings,inlinewiththedemandin
themarkettoensurethatwesupportthe
reductionofemissions.
Coastalerosionis
exacerbatedbyextreme
weatherevents,andusually
resultsinthecomplete
lossofapropertyunless
government-funded
defencesareputinplace.
Localauthoritiesincoastal
areas,togetherwiththe
Government’sDepartment
forEnvironment,Foodand
RuralAffairs(‘DEFRA’),create
ShorelineManagementPlans,
whichsetoutastrategyand
actionplanforhowcoastal
riskswillbemanaged.These
canprovideinformation
abouthowcoastalerosion
willimpacthomesbutare
subjecttochange.
Subsidenceiscausedbythe
shrinkingofsoilbeneath
ahome,whichislikelyto
becomemorecommonin
droughtconditionsbrought
onbyclimatechange.It
resultsincrackedwallsand
foundations,damagingthe
integrityofthebuilding.
Bettertechnological
solutionsarenowinplace
torectifysubsidence,and
theissueiscurrentlytreated
byinsurersasaone-off
damagerepairwitha10-year
uncertaintyperiod.
Currentlynogovernment-
backedsupportexists
forhomesexperiencing
subsidence,andthereare
noknownproposalsto
introducesuchascheme.
Floodingisoneofthe
biggestclimatechangerisks
intheUK,andistherisk
mostcloselyassociatedwith
climatechangeinthepublic
perception.Itisexpected
tooccurwithincreasing
frequencyandseverityinthe
future.
FloodRecurrentlyprovide
government-backed
reinsuranceforfloodriskfor
mostproperties,butthisis
duetostopin2039.Thisis
anexampleofhowchanges
ingovernmentpolicy(a
transitionrisk)canalterthe
impactofaphysicalrisk;
sincemanyhomesinflood
zoneswouldlikelyface
unaffordablehomeinsurance
withoutasimilarscheme.
Flooding Subsidence Coastal erosion
21GC23/3:Guidanceontheanti-greenwashingrule|FCA
Our ESG priorities (continued)
Building a greener society(continued)
Strategy(continued)
30 | Strategic report 31
Transition risk
Transitionrisksarisefromchangesinthewidereconomyasitmovestowardalow-carbonstate,includingchangestoclimate
policyandregulation,technologydevelopments,andshiftingconsumerattitudes.TransitionriskimpactsYBSbypresenting
uncertaintyforthefuturestateoftheeconomic,regulatory,andmarketlandscapes,andresultsindifferentbusinessthreats
andopportunities.Thetoptransitionriskswe’veidentifiedarenotedinthetablebelow.
Climate risk exposure and risk appetite
TheSocietymanagestherisksarisingfromclimatechangethroughitsriskappetitestatements.TheSocietyisworkingto
evolvethesestatementsovertheshortterm;thecurrentstatementsaresetoutinthefollowingtable.
Impacts on Accord
TheSocietyconsidersclimateriskataGrouplevel,whichincorporatesallbrandsandsubsidiariesincludingAccordMortgages
anditscustomers.
Horizon scanning
Tokeepabreastofnewregulation,includingpolicychangesandlegislationthatrelatetoclimate-relatedfinancialdisclosures
orgovernmentpolicyrelatingtohousing,theSocietyundertakeshorizonscanningactivitiesonaregularbasis.
Metrics and targets
Addressingclimatechangeisnotonlyasocietalissueofgreatimportance,butisalsoessentialforourlong-term
organisationalsustainability.Therefore,wecontinuetodesignandembedmetricstomonitorprogressagainstclimatetargets.
Furthertothis,climateriskisamongseveralmeasureswithintheSociety’sLeadingforValuebonusscheme.
For further information on this scheme please refer to the Directors remuneration report.
Our carbon footprint
TheSociety’soperationalcarbonfootprintis4,206tonnesofcarbondioxideequivalent(‘tCO2e’)24.Thistotalfootprint
includesourScope1,Scope2,andScope3emissionsforthereportingperiodJanuary–December2023,asdetailedbelow25.
Transitionrisksmayberevealed
throughotherriskareas:
Credit riskcouldincreaseduring
theshifttoalowcarboneconomy,
forexample,duetojoblossesor
changestohouseholdincome.It
mayalsoimpactonthevalueofthe
propertyifnewlegislationaround
energyefficiencymakestheproperty
undesirable.
Operational riskmayoccurifsupply
chainsareimpactedbythechanges,
whichcouldresultincostincreases.
Transitioningtoalow-carboneconomy
couldalsoimpactotherfinancialrisks
suchasliquidityandmarketrisk.Shifts
intheeconomycanhaveabearingon
financialmarkets,potentiallycausing
interestratevolatilitywhichcould
impacttheSociety’sfinancialstability,
orourabilitytoaccessfunding
markets.
Astheindustryconsiderswaysto
protectagainstclimateriskand
encouragesustainablefinance,there
isariskthatcapitalregulationcould
change,increasingtheamountof
capitalitwouldbenecessaryto
hold.TheSocietyperformsanICAAP
annually.IntheICAAP,weconsider
thepotentialimpactofphysicaland
transitionalrisksofclimatechange.
Itisourintentiontointroducemore
quantitativedisclosuresintheshort-
termasourmodellingmethodologies
evolveovertime,includingpublication
ofourFinancedEmissionsinthe2023
ESGreport(expectedJune2024).
Workstreams to manage the risks
and opportunities associated with
economic and regulatory change
are discussed and prioritised
within the Climate Risk Working
Group (see Climate governance).
Climate risk and Enterprise
Risk Management Framework
(‘ERMF’)
Climatechangeisidentifiedasa
cross-cuttingriskinourERMF,which
istheoverarchingframeworkused
toidentify,assess,andmanagerisks
totheSociety.TheERMFsetsthe
expectationthatallriskcategory
ownersconsidertherisksarisingfrom
climatechangewhenconstructing
andrenewingtheirriskpolicies.
Inaddition,theEnvironmental
&ClimateChangeRiskPolicy22
(‘ECCRP’)wasdesignedtomanagethe
Society’senvironmentalandclimate
changestrategycommitments.All
riskpoliciesarereviewedatleast
annuallytoensurethatemerging
risksarecaptured.Maintainingthe
ECCRPillustratesanevolutioninour
approachtobetterintegrateclimate
considerationswithinouroperational
framework,andwehavedecided
todiscontinueourEnvironmental
ManagementManualasaresult.
Climateriskisincorporatedinthe
ERMFinlinewiththePRASupervisory
Statement(SS)3/19,includingthe
DearCEOandDearCFOletters
releasedbythePRA,whichprovide
furtherguidanceforfirms.TheECCRP
isownedbytheEnvironmental
Sustainabilityteam,withany
materialchangesand/orpolicy
renewalsapprovedbyExecutiveRisk
Committee.TheSocietyrecognises
thattheunderstandingofclimate
risks,andtheimplementationofany
mitigants,willdevelopovertimeas
weprogressthroughthisjourney
andenhanceourunderstandingand
approach.Throughout2024,the
EnvironmentalSustainabilityteam
willworkwithriskownerstofurther
developunderstandingofhowclimate
changewillimpactthemanagement
andmeasurementofeachrisk.
Climateriskhasbeenintegratedinto
thethreelinesofdefencemodel
employedbytheSociety,withboth
Second-andThird-Lineteamshaving
conductedreviewsoftheFirst-Line’s
approachtomanagingclimaterisk
in2023.
More detail can be found in the
Risk Management report.
Economic downturn Regulatory change
DependingontheroutetakenbytheUKtotransition
toalow-carboneconomy,thecountrymayexperience
economicgrowthorslowdown,includingchangestothe
unemploymentrateandpropertyprices.
TheUKcentralanddevolvedgovernmentscontinueto
alterthecourseoftheclimatepolicylandscape.This
impactstheobligationsplacedonlenders,landlords,and
homeownerstounderstandandreducetheemissions
associatedwithbuildings.
22Ourpolicies|CorporateGovernance|YourSociety|YBS
23 Automotive;powerutilities;landtransport;andlogistics;agriculture;construction;oilandgas;airlinesandaerospace;buildingmaterials;shipping;chemicals;
miningandmetals.
24 TheSocietyusesabothamarket-basedandlocation-basedmethodologytoreportitscarbonemissionshoweveryoucanfindourlocation-basedcarbon
footprintwithintheDirectors’report.
25 Thisfootprintwasproducedinaccordancewith‘GHGReportingProtocol-CorporateStandard’methodology.
Principal risk Risk appetite statement
Strategic risk NoneoftheSociety’sdirectlending,includingtoCommercialproperties,supports
developmentinsectorsoftheeconomywhichcarryheightenedrisk23.TheGroupdoes
notengageinprojectfinanceandwouldnotsupportaprojectthatdirectlyharmsthe
environment.However,theGroupisnotabletoruleoutindirectinvolvementthroughthird-
partyinvestment.
Retail & commercial
credit risk
TheSociety’slevelofexposuretotransitionandphysicalriskswillcontinuetobestress
testedincompliancewithPRASS3/19toensurethatitdoesnotknowinglythreatenthe
Society’sfinancialsustainability.ThisapproachissetoutintheEnvironmentalandClimate
ChangeRiskPolicy(seeEnterpriseRiskManagementFramework).
Compliance & conduct
risk
Wewillonlyofferproductsandservicesthatmeetcustomerneeds,andwherewecan
manageanyconductriskswhicharise,includingconsiderationofcustomervulnerabilityand
impactsonandofclimatechange.Iffailuresoccur,weproactivelyidentify,establishtheroot
causeof,andtakeremedialaction.
Operational risk Wewillseektolimit,understand,andmitigateexposuretoclimatechangerisk.TheSociety
iscommittedtoreducingitsimpactontheenvironmentandthisincludesensuringthatits
suppliersarealsoactivelytakingstepstoreducetheimpacttheyhaveontheenvironment.
Scope 1
5 tCO2e
Scope 2
0 tC02e
Scope 3
4,201 tC02e
Directemissionsfromourown
operationsandassetsthatwe
directlycontrolorown,suchas
gasusage.
Indirectemissionsassociatedwith
thepurchaseofelectricityinour
operations.
Indirectemissionsfromsources
notownedorcontrolledbyusbut
arepartofourvaluechain.This
includesemployeecommutingand
wastegeneration.
Our ESG priorities (continued)
Building a greener society(continued)
Risk management (continued)
32 | Strategic report 33
Progressing our Scope 3 disclosures
TheSocietycontinuestoimprovethequalityofourdisclosuresbyincreasingthecoveragerelatingtoScope3emissions,
withtheintentionthatmaterialremainingcategorieswillbecalculatedanddisclosedby2025,ifnotbefore.During2023,
theSocietyworkedincollaborationwithanexternalsustainabilityconsultanttocalculateourbaselineoperationalScope3
emissions,andwearepleasedtohaveexpandedourdisclosurestoincludeemissionsgeneratedfromouremployeesthrough
bothworkingfromhomeandtheircommutejourneys.
Werecalculatedour2022supplychainemissionsbasedonspendfactorstohighlightwhereweneedtofocusourattention
withinourprocurementprocess.Thissupplychainanalysisisinitsearlystages,andweareactivelypreparingtoengagewith
oursuppliers,aswellasexternalpartners,tofurtherourunderstandingofoursupplychainemissions.Intheinterim,wewill
beusingthesefiguresinternallytoidentifyareasforimprovementandserveasafoundationforemissionreductionplans.
In2023werecalculatedourFinancedEmissionsacrosstheresidentialmortgageportfolioandwillbepublishingtheminthe
ESGreportwhichisduemid-2024.
Carbon reduction plans
Scope 1 and 2
ThepathtoNetZerosetsouttherouteandtimingof
reducingtheSociety’scarbonemissionsasfaraspossible,
andonlythenconsideringcarbonremovals.TheSociety
remainscommittedtoitsNetZerotargetforScope1
andScope2operationalemissionsof2035orsooner.
Supportingthis,wehavecontinuedtoprocureelectricity
andgasbackedby100%RenewableEnergyGuarantees
ofOriginandRenewableGasGuaranteesofOrigin
certificates.In2023,theSocietycompletedseveralretrofit
improvements,includingupgrading31branchestofullyLED
lightingsystems,withafurther48branchestobecompleted
by2025.In2024,theSocietywillfinalisetheNetZeroplan
forthesescopesandwillbedisclosingshort-termtargets
andapproachesonceimplemented.
TheSocietytookthedecisiontonotrenewanycarbon
offsettingcontractsin2023toallowustoconsiderour
NetZeroapproachandprioritiseemissionreductions,prior
tooffsetting.ThisapproachwillalsodeepentheSociety’s
understandingofeffectiveandpurpose-drivenoffsetting
projects.
Scope 3
TheSocietymaintainsthe2050NetZeroambitionfor
allapplicableoperationalemissions,andisdeveloping
acomprehensivereductionstrategyinsupportofthis.
Thisroadmapisexpectedtobecompletebymid-
2024andisbeingdevelopedinconjunctionwithour
externalsustainabilityconsultants.Theresultwillyield
recommendationstoaddressoursustainabilitytargets,
ensuringthatourjourneytowardsNetZeroremainswell
informedandeffective.
During2023,wecontinuedtoresponsiblymanageour
operationalandcapitalprojectwaste,andweremain
committedtomakingsurethatatleast97%ofour
operationalwasteisdivertedfromlandfill.Only1.3%of
thewastegeneratedwasdirectedtolandfill,reflectingour
commitmenttominimisesuchdisposal.
Notably,asignificant98.7%ofourwastewasrecycled,
recovered,orreusedandthereforedivertedfromlandfill
sites.
ForCategory15FinancedEmissions,theSocietyis
committedtosupportingtheUKGovernment’sambitionto
beNetZeroby2050.In2024,wewillexploreopportunities
tosupportcustomerstodecarbonise,howeverourability
toreduceoverallFinancedEmissionswillonlybepossible
withstronggovernmentpolicy.RetrofittingtheUK’sentire
residentialpropertyrequireseffectiveleadershipthat
demonstratesthebenefitsofreducinghouseholdemissions.
Thisapproachneedstosupporthomeowners,construction
industrydevelopments,andthedecarbonisationof
electricitynetworks.Anapproachofthisnaturewillnot
onlyreducetheSociety’semissionsbutthatofthewhole
country.
Upstream emissions
Scope 3 Category26 Sub-Category Status Data Quality27 tCO
2
e
1. Purchased goods &
services
Procurementandsupply
chainofgoods
2022spendbased
emissionsfactors
calculated
Low Initial
understanding
2. Capital goods Procurementandsupply
chainofgoods
2022spendbased
emissionsfactors
calculated
Low Initial
understanding
3. Fuel & energy
related activities
Extraction,productionand
transportationoffuelsand
energypurchasedinthe
reportingperiod
Externallypublished High 240tCO
2
e
4. Upstream
transportation &
distribution
Supplierdelivery
emissions
Initialunderstandingof
theavailabledata
Low Notcalculated
5. Waste generated
in operations
Wastedisposaland
treatmentinoperations
Capitalproject
waste
Endoflifecustomer
communications
Externallypublished
data
Externallypublished
data
Initialunderstanding
Low 21tCO
2
e
Notcalculated
6. Business travel Businessrelatedtravel
activity
Externallypublished Medium 292tCO
2
e
7. Employee
commuting &
working from
home
Colleaguecommuting
Workfromhomeenergy
emissions
Externallypublished Medium 3,648tCO
2
e
8. Upstream leased
assets
Operationofassetsleased
duringreportingperiod
Initialunderstanding Medium Notcalculated
Downstream emissions
Scope 3 Category Sub-Category Status Data Quality tCO
2
e
9. Downstream
transportation and
distribution
Transportationand
distributionofproducts
andservicessoldduring
thereportingperiod
Initialunderstandingof
theavailabledata
Low Notcalculated
10 - 12. Processing/Useofsold/
Endoflifeofproducts
sold
Notapplicable Notapplicable Notapplicable
13. Downstream
leased assets
Operationofassetsowned Initialunderstandingof
theavailabledata
Low Notcalculated
14. Franchises Notapplicable Notapplicable Notapplicable Notapplicable
15. Investments Propertiesfinanced,and
otherapplicablesecurities
financed,throughthe
Society’soperations
Calculateddata
andgainedinitial
understanding
Medium TofollowinESG
report
26 Scope3figuresarecalculatedonamarket-basedemissionsbasis.AssuranceofallourcarbonfootprintcalculationsandmethodologydetailscanbefoundintheSECR
sectionoftheDirectorsreport
27 Dataqualityreflectstheavailabilityandcompletenessofdatausedtocalculateemissions(lowtohigh)
Our ESG priorities (continued)
Building a greener society(continued)
Metrics and targets (continued)
34 | Strategic report 35
Energy Performance Certificates
(‘EPCs’)
EPCscapturetheenergyefficiencyofa
propertyandactasaproxyforunderstanding
theemissionsthepropertygenerates.They
alsoprovideinsightonhow,throughretrofit,
theproperty’senergyefficiencycouldimprove.
Therefore,thedatacanbeusedtounderstand
thepotentialrisktheSocietyfacesshould
property-relatedregulationchangeand
theopportunitiesavailabletosupportour
customerstransitiontoamoreenergy
efficienthome.
ThereareseveralknownlimitationstoEPC
data,whichshouldbeconsideredwhen
gaininginsightormakinganydecisions
fromthem.Firstly,theratingreflectsthecost
toheatahome,ratherthantheemissions
generatedfromit.Therefore,alow-carbon
homedoesnotnecessarilyrelatetoabetter
EPCrating28.Additionally,aratingisonly
requiredwhenahomeissoldorlet,andis
onlyvalidfor10years,reducingthenumber
ofpropertieswithavalidrating.Finally,some
oftherecommendationsincludedonanEPC
canbeprohibitivelyexpensiveimprovement
measures,bringingintoquestionthefeasibility
ofthepotentialrating.
TheSocietyusesEPCdatatounderstandthe
exposuretotransitionriskandopportunity
withintheloanportfolio.EPC’sarethe
underlyingdatatoolthatcanhelpus
understandtheclimate-relatedopportunities
(seeStrategy).In2023,wehaveEPCdatafor
59%ofourresidentialmortgagebook(‘match
rate’),ofwhich42%areEPCCorabove.
Bothfigureshaveincreasedsince2022,and
throughout2024wewillseekopportunitiesto
improveourEPCcoverage.
Ofthepropertiesinourresidentialmortgage
bookwithavalidEPC,98%showpotential
toberatedCorabove.Thisdemonstratesthe
scaleofchangepossiblewithinresidential
property,butalsotheurgentneedforgood-
qualityandscaledretrofitsupplychains,to
enablenation-wideupgradestohomesto
meetNetZerotargets.Inmanyways
theretrofitmarketisstillemerging,and
thereforeitisvitalthatstrategy,direction,
andfundingaresetthroughgovernment
policiesandleadershiptoensurethatsupply
meetsdemand.
Retail EPC Coverage
Proportion of residential mortgage book
with a valid EPC
Outercircle:2023|Innercircle:2022
ValidEPC NoEPC
EPCCorabove EPCDorbelow
Proportion of properties with a valid
EPC that have EPC C or above
Outercircle:2023|Innercircle:2022
ValidEPC
59%
EPCCor
above
42%
NoEPC
43%
EPCDor
below
61%
ValidEPC
57%
EPCCor
above
39%
NoEPC
41%
EPCDor
below
58%
28WhyEPCsaren'treadyforlow-carbonheating-Which?News
2023 2022
Current EPC Potential EPC Current Potential
Total
Owner-
occupied BTL Total
Owner-
occupied BTL Total Total
A 418 397 21 16,413 14,922 1,491 331 14,409
B 20,946 18,415 2,531 95,171 71,800 23,371 18,689 92,906
C 46,256 32,127 14,129 47,041 35,157 11,884 41,126 44,592
D 69,014 52,611 16,403 3,268 2,507 761 68,693 3,198
E 21,325 17,040 4,285 308 258 50 22,150 265
F 3,516 3,371 145 44 41 3 3,648 40
G 778 731 47 8 7 1 784 11
Total with EPC 162,253 124,692 37,561 162,253 124,692 37,561 155,421 155,421
Properties without valid EPC 110,469 98,972 11,497 117,610
Our ESG priorities (continued)
Building a greener society(continued)
Metrics and targets (continued)
36 | Strategic report 37
Our top 10 climate commitments
AchieveNetZeroScope1andScope2
emissionsby2035,andNetZeroScope3
operationalemissionsby2050.
1
Maintaina100%renewableoperationalenergy
supplyinlinewithRE100requirements.YBS
willmovetowardsnon-burninggreenenergy
andinstallheatpumpsystemsinallproperties
wherethisisfeasible.
2
Addonlyhybridorelectricvehiclestoourfleet
from2025,workingtowardsafullelectricfleet
assoonasoperationallypossible.
3
Improveclimatechangeresilienceacross
allareas.
4
Targetandmaintainaminimumannual
landfilldiversionrateof97%.
5
Implementfurtherpoliciestoprevent
lendingorinvestingineconomicsectorsthat
haveaheightenedclimateriskand/orare
environmentallydamaging.
6
LaunchacustomerNetZerotransitionplan,
increaseunderstandingofourfinanced
emissions,andsupportourcustomerswiththeir
NetZerotransition.
7
Supportcustomerstomakebetterenvironmental
choicesbyhelpingthemunderstandclimate
changeandhowitimpactshousing.
8
Launchamember-focusedNetZero
transitionplan,whichwillincludegreen
savingsproductinitiatives.
9
Continuetomakeprogresstowards
alignmentonourTaskforceforClimate-
relatedFinancialDisclosureswithbest
practiceandcreateaplatformontheYBS
websitetoshowcaseourprogressandfuture
plansonclimatethinking.
10
NET ZERO
pathway
TheSocietyaimstoalignitscommitmentswithourtransition
plansandallshort-,medium-,andlong-termtargets.As
aresult,weanticipatestreamliningthesecommitments
graduallytomirrortheprogressmadeandtheactionsthatare
yettobetaken.
Environmental progress and achievements
2012-2020:
Inthisperiod,weinitiatedcarbonfootprintdisclosures,
supportedlocalcommunities,adoptedrenewableelectricity,
andintroducedvariousgreeninitiatives.Ourcommitmentto
sustainabilitywasformalisedthroughthelaunchofBuildinga
greenersociety.
2021-2022:
Inrecentyears29wehavedeepenedourcommitmentto
Buildingagreenersocietybycollaboratingwithlocalclimate
commissionsandtransitioningtomorerenewableenergy
sources.Participationinclimatescenariosandasignificant
carbonreductioninourdirectemissionshighlightedour
dedicationtomitigatingenvironmentalimpact.Weinitiated
ourunderstandingofoursupplychainemissionsandenacted
lendingrulesagainstsectorsknowntobeenvironmentally
harmful.Furthermore,wecommittedtoresponsiblebanking,
improvedourbranchinfrastructure,anddevelopedthe
capabilitytounderstandFinancedEmissions.
2023:
TheSocietycontinuestosupportwiderNetZeroambitions
throughongoingpartnershipswiththeBuildingSocieties
Association(‘BSA’)andtheYorkshire&HumberClimate
Commission(‘YHCC’).ThroughtheBSAwecanexert
governmentalinfluencethroughacollectiveindustryvoice,
whileYHCCallowsustoutiliseourskillsetstosupportlocal
climateaction.Aspartofthiscommitment,wehaverenewed
oursponsorshipofYHCCforafurther3years,to2026.
EstablishingtheEnvironmentalSustainabilityteamduring2023
underpinsourcommitmenttoenvironmentalsustainability.
Thisdedicatedresourcewillprovidetheexpertiseandfocus
requiredtoeffectivelymanageandmitigateenvironmental
risks,whilstalsoidentifyingopportunitiesfortheSocietyto
furtheralignYBSwithdisclosurerecommendationsandglobal
sustainabilityobjectives.
29 Youcanfindfurtherdetailsofourprogressupto2022intheBuilding
aGreenerSocietySectionofthe2022AnnualReportandAccounts
availableonourwebsite.
Our ESG priorities (continued)
Building a greener society(continued)
38 | Strategic report 39
Engaging with our
Stakeholders
TheSociety’skeystakeholdergroupsaresetoutinthetablebelow.Thesearegroupsthateitherhaveaninterestin,orare
impactedby,ouroperations.Weactivelyconsidertheneedsofthesegroupsinthecourseofourdecision-making,andwe
makeuseofavarietyofmeanstoensurethatwecontinuetomeetthechangingexpectationstheyhaveofus.
More information on our stakeholder engagement and Our ESG priorities will be made available in our 2023 ESG report.
Key
stakeholders
Who they are How we listen and
engage
What they expect from YBS Material ESG topics
identified
Members and
customers
•
Members
•
Mortgages
andsavings
customers
•
Commercial
lending
customers
•
Registered
providersof
SocialHousing.
•
Memberevents(Your
TimetoTalksessions,
in-branchevents).
•
AnnualGeneral
Meetings.
•
OurMemberPanel,
MyVoice,andregular
surveysoncustomer
experienceand
brand.
•
Directengagement
throughspecialist
teams(face-to-face,
onlinewebchat,
telephonecalls,
letters,emails,and
socialmedia).
•
Offergoodvalueand
flexiblesavingsaccounts
andmortgages
•
Deliverhelpful,effective,
approachable,friendly,and
efficientservice
•
Investintheproductsand
servicestheyneedtogain
betterfinancialwellbeingor
secureamortgage
•
Runastrong,secure,and
sustainablebusinessintheir
long-terminterests
•
Demonstrateactionto
supportawidersocietal
purpose
•
Provideadaptablesupport
tocustomersinvulnerable
situations
•
Investintransformingour
digitaloffering.
•
Sustainablehomes
•
Flexibleaccess
toproductsand
services
•
Homeownership
•
Businessresilience
•
Dataprivacyand
informationsecurity
•
Communityimpact
•
Financialresilience
•
Financialinclusion
•
Vulnerablemember
support
•
Responsiblelending
•
Alignmentto
purpose.
Colleagues
•
Allcolleagues
•
Contractors
•
Agency
colleagues.
•
ColleagueForum,
whichisattended
byaNon-
ExecutiveDirector
forWorkforce
Engagement
•
Focusgroupsand
surveys
•
ChatPackstrategy
updates
•
Colleagueeventsand
virtualconferences
•
Intranet(liveQ&As,
news,blogs)
•
PeopleExperience
Forum
•
Directengagement
throughleadership
teams
•
Colleaguelistening
groupswithNon-
ExecutiveDirectors
•
Colleaguenetworks.
•
Provideaforumwhereviews
areheardbothintermsof
theirexperienceatYBSand
alsobusinessstrategy
•
Treatpeoplewithempathy,
respect,andfairness
•
Encourageandsupporttheir
developmentandtraining
•
Providefairrewardand
remunerationpolicies
•
Supportagoodwork-life
balance
•
Careabouttheirphysical,
mental,andfinancial
wellbeing
•
Provideaninclusiveculture
wherediversityisvalued
andcelebrated.
•
Businessresilience
•
Responsible
operations
•
Alignmentto
purpose
•
Pathwaytonet-zero
•
Impactofclimate
change
•
Diversity,equity,
andinclusion
•
Colleaguehealth
andwellbeing
•
Talentattractionand
retention
•
Communityimpact
•
Dataprivacy
andinformation
security.
Key
stakeholders
Who they are How we listen and
engage
What they expect from YBS Material ESG topics
identified
Government
and Regulators
•
Central
andlocal
Governments
•
Financial
Conduct
Authority
•
Prudential
Regulation
Authority
•
Information
Commissioner’s
Office
•
Payment
Systems
Regulator.
•
Directengagement
throughspecialist
teams(face-to-face,
telephonecalls,
letters,emails)
•
Engagingwith
consultations,
includingthrough
industrybodies
•
Monitoring,engaging,
andcomplyingwith
regulatorychange
andreporting.
•
Actwithinthelawand
regulationandinthe
interestsofourcustomers
•
Operationalresilience
•
Swiftlyandproactively
resolvecustomerissues
•
Befinanciallystrongand
securebymaintaining
adequateresources
includingcapitaland
liquidity
•
Actwithintegrityand
transparency.
•
Businessresilience
•
Responsible
operations
•
Pathwaytonet-zero
•
Sustainablehomes
•
Diversity,equity,
andinclusion
•
Dataprivacyand
informationsecurity
•
Responsible
lending.
Investor
Relations
•
Wholesale
investors
•
Ratings
agencies.
•
Directengagement
throughface-to-face
meetingsandevents
•
AnnualReportand
Accounts
•
Regulatory
NewsService
announcements
•
Investorreporting.
•
Offerappropriatelypriced
debtsecuritiesinthe
wholesalemarketswhich
adequatelyrewardthemfor
thelevelofrisk
•
Operateinaprudent
manner,protectingour
financialsustainabilityand
abilitytoserviceourdebt
•
Actresponsiblyinwholesale
markets
•
Provideregularinformation
andupdatesonourstrategy,
financialperformance,and
principalrisks
•
Sharedetailsofourfunding
strategyandtheexpected
volumesofsecuritiesbeing
issued
•
DemonstrategoodESG
practices,validatedbyNon-
FinancialRatingsAgencies.
•
Businessresilience
•
Responsible
operations
•
Pathwaytonet-zero
•
Impactofclimate
change
•
Diversity,equity,
andinclusion
•
Sustainablehomes
•
Financialresilience
•
Financialinclusion
•
Responsible
lending.
Partners
•
Brokers
•
Agency
proprietors
•
Suppliers
•
Tradeunions
•
Industrybodies.
•
Directengagement
throughspecialist
relationship
management
teams(face-to-face
meetingsandevents,
telephonecalls,
letters,emails).
•
Besimpleand
straightforwardtodealwith
•
Collaborateastrusted
partnerstoachievemutual
success
•
Deliverhelpful,effective,
approachable,andefficient
service
•
Demonstrateactionto
supportawidersocietal
purpose.
•
Businessresilience
•
Responsible
operations
•
Supplychain
engagement
•
Dataprivacy
andinformation
security.
Communities
•
Thelocal,
regional,
andnational
communities
inwhichwe
operate
•
Charitiesand
community
groups.
•
Charitable
partnerships
•
Arangeofinitiatives
tosupportthe
Bradfordcommunity
atalocallevel
•
Financialeducation
initiativesincluding
MoneyMinds.
•
Investresourcesinsupport
ofthesocialeconomic
welfareofcommunities
•
Demonstrateactionto
supportawidersocietal
purpose
•
Provideaninclusiveculture
wherediversityisvalued
andcelebrated.
•
Sustainablehomes
•
Flexibleaccess
toproductsand
services
•
Homeownership
•
Communityimpact
•
Financialresilience
•
Financialinclusion
•
Talentattractionand
retention
•
Diversity,equity,&
inclusion.
40 | Strategic report 41
Engaging with our stakeholders (continued)
Our Communities
Throughourcommunity
programmes,weaimtohave
apositiveimpactacross
thenationasweprovide
peoplewithrealhelptoward
improvingtheirfinancial
wellbeing.
Tomaximisethereachofour
programmes,wecollaborate
withnationalpartners,provide
fundingforlocalcharitiesthrough
theYorkshireBuildingSociety
CharitableFoundation,andoffera
rangeofvolunteeringoptionsfor
ourcolleaguestoprovidepractical,
hands-onsupportwheretheyliveand
work.Financialwellbeingprogrammes
liketheoneswesupporthaveonly
becomemoreimportantandmore
necessaryinrecentyears,giventhe
financialandeconomicchallenges
facinghouseholds.Asaresultthe
numberofpeoplewesupportedin
2023increasedto105,000(2022:
96,000).
More detail on the topics relating
to our community activities can
be found in our 2023 ESG report,
which is available on our website
ybs.co.uk.
Purposeful partnerships
Workingalongsidecarefullyselectedpartnersallowsustodeliverexperthelpand
supporttothosewhoneedit,attherighttimeandintherightplace.
Citizens Advice
Ouraward-winningpartnershipwithCitizens
Advicecontinuedtogofromstrengthtostrength
in2023,withtheSocietyincreasingthefunding
tosustainthisvaluableservice.Representatives
fromCitizensAdvicehavebeenpositioned
withinselectbranchlocationstoofferfree,face-
to-face,independentadviceonawiderange
ofissues,withaparticularfocusonfinancial
wellbeing.Thisserviceisaccessibletotheentire
community,whethertheyareYBSmembersornot.
Duetothesuccessofthispartnershipin2022,andthegrowinglevels
ofdemand,wehaveexpandedtheprogramtoencompass46locations
acrossScotland,Yorkshire,theNorthwest,EastAnglia,andtheSouthwest.
Feedbackfrombranchcolleaguescontinuestohighlightthepositive
impacttheserviceishavingincommunities,andthankstotheSociety’s
increasedinvestmentintheservicein2023,thepartnershiphelped3,800
clients–morethandoublethenumberinthepreviousyear.
SincethestartofthepartnershipinMay2021,wehavehelpedto
unlockover£2.5mworthofestimatedadditionalincomeforclients,
whichrepresentsincometheycouldexpectiftheyactontheadvice
given,oftenrelatingtomissedbenefits,ortaxcreditsandgrants.
Free for everyone,
finding a way forward at
Age UK
Ourpartnershipwiththeleadingcharityforolderpeople,AgeUK,
concludedinJune2023,andwetakeimmenseprideinthecontributions
madeduringourtwo-and-a-half-yearcollaboration,whichreachedatotal
of£1.02million.Donationsfromourcustomers,andmembersofthe
public,combinedwiththelaunchofaninnovativesavingsaccountand
additionalfundingfromtheYorkshireBuildingSociety,helpedtofundAge
UK'sBuildingBetterLivesprogramme.
Thisserviceplayedavitalroleformanyduringchallengingtimes,
includingtheCOVID-19pandemicandtheongoingcost-of-livingcrisis.
Thisinitiativewasdesignedtoprovideone-to-onesupportsessionswith
trainedadvisors,focusingonaddressingfinancialhardshipresultingfrom
significantlifeeventssuchashealthdiagnoses,thelossofapartner,or
changingcareneeds.Inthecourseofthispartnership,weareproudtosay
thatover4,900olderindividualsreceivedsupport,andmorethan3,600
benefitclaimsweremade.
Good Things Foundation
In2023,wecontinuedtoworkwithGoodThings
Foundation,supportedbylocalcommunitypartners,
tohelpdeliveressentialdigitalskillstrainingtoBlack,
Asian,andethnicallydiversepeopleinBradford.The
projectaimstohelppeopleacquireandimprovetheir
digitalskillsandisspecificallytargetedtowardethnic
minoritycommunitieswherethesocialexclusionand
skillsgapsmaybemorepronounced.
Theprogrammesupported489peoplein2023(2022:
442),72%ofwhomsaidtheyfeelmoreconfidentusing
adigitaldeviceandtheinternet,and73%saidtheyfelt
thedigitalskillslearnedhaveenabledthemtoapplyfor
ajobortrainingthattheywouldnothavebeenableto
dopreviously.
FareShare
InNovember2023,welaunchedournewcharitypartnershipwithFareShare,the
UK’sbiggestcharityfightinghungerandfoodwaste.TheimportantworkFareShare
undertakeinvolvesredistributingsurplusfoodtoover8,500localcharitiesand
communitygroups,supportingthousandsofvulnerablepeopleeveryweek–not
justwithfood,butwithskillstohelpliftthemselvesoutoffinancialhardship.
Ourgoalistoraise£1milliontofundFareShare'sBuilding
SkillsfortheFutureprogramme.
Wekickedoffthepartnershipwitha£150,000donationtoFareSharein2023,
andaddedtofundraisingeffortsfromcolleaguesandmembers,wehavesofar
raised£184,670towardsourgoal.Thisinitiativewillsupport2,500peopleand
helptopreparethemforemployment.Throughcommunityoutreachprograms
andanintensiveemployabilityprogramspanningLondon,Bristol,MiltonKeynes,
Leeds,Barnsley,Edinburgh,andCardiff,weaimtohelpindividualsregaintheir
financialindependence.ThispartnershipwillrununtilJune2026,andwelook
forwardtowhatourcollaborationwillbeabletoaccomplish.
Engaging with
our stakeholders
(continued)
42 | Strategic report 43
Yorkshire Building Society
Charitable Foundation
TheCharitableFoundationisan
independent,registeredcharitywith
itsownBoardofTrustees,ofwhich
YorkshireBuildingSocietyfundsthe
runningcosts.
TheCharitableFoundationis
predominantlyfundedbymembers
optingintotheSmallChangeBig
Difference
®
Scheme,whichenables
themtodonatetotheFoundationthe
penniesfromtheinterestearnedon
theirsavingsaccounts,orrounding
uptheirmortgagepaymentstothe
nearestpound.Asattheendof2023,
923,000accountsweresignedup,
and£358,000wasraisedforthe
Foundation(2022:829,000accounts,
and£308,000raised).
In2023,inorderthatthefunding
isdirectedtoareaswhereitismost
needed,theBoardofTrusteesagreed
tofocustheFoundation’ssupporton
areasofdeprivationandcharitiesthat
supportmarginalisedgroups.Similarly,
smaller,grassrootscharitiesareoften
beneficiariesoftheFoundation’s
supporttoensurethatdonations
makethebiggestdifference.The
Boardalsoincreasedthemaximum
donationamountto£2,500andmade
applicationguidelineslessrestrictive
togivecharitiesgreaterfreedomto
spenddonationsflexibly.Asaresultof
thesechanges,in2023theFoundation
donated£285,000,distributedamong
257charities(2022:£283,000).
Eachyear,theSocietydonates
£100,000totheCharitable
Foundation’sRealHelpforRealLife
Fund.Thefundingdonatedin2022
wasdistributedtofourprojectsin
November,deliveringsupportforthose
experiencingfinancialhardshipand
supportingpeoplewithemployability
skills.Thecharitieshavebeencarefully
selectedtohelpreachunderserved
groups,suchasvulnerableyoung
peopleandthosefromethnicminority
communities.
•
AlbertKennedyTrustwasawarded
£29,000tosupporthomelessand
vulnerableLGBTQIA+individuals
inManchester,providingaccess
toemergencysupportand
accommodation.
•
BradfordFoodbankreceiveda
donationof£10,680tofundastaff
memberataJobClubandITHelp
Hubforthoseusingthefoodbank.To
date,thishassupported153people,
with10securingemploymentand8
intofurthereducationortraining.
•
TheFoundation’spartnershipwith
RefugeeActionlaunchedin2021
hascontinuedandwillnowrununtil
2024.Thecharityhasbenefited
from£60,000todatewhichhas
fundedanemployabilityskills
coursefor79refugeesandthose
seekingasylum-thePathwaysto
WorkProject.Societycolleagues
arealsomentoringrefugeestohelp
themintosecureemploymentafter
re-settlingintheUK,andtosupport
theirindependence.
•
Vulnerableindividualsinadeprived
areaofHullhavebeensupported
intoemploymentandtraining
opportunitiesthankstoa£28,000
donationtotheVulcanLearning
Centre–helping332peoplein2023.
Afurther£100,000wasdonatedto
theFoundationin2023whichwillgo
towardsprojectsin2024.
Colleagues in communities
Eachcolleagueemployedbythe
Societyisprovidedanallowanceof
upto31hoursperyeartovolunteer
acrossourcommunityprogrammes.
In2023,23%ofcolleagues
volunteered,collectivelycontributing
6,500hourswhichis19percentage
pointshigherthanin2022.The
Society'svolunteeringeffortsinitially
focusedonfinancialeducationand
employabilityskills,howeverinthe
autumnof2023,ourfocuswidened
toincludeaddressingfinancial
hardship.Thisbroaderapproach
allowedcolleaguestoutilisetheir
skillsandtimetomeetimmediate
needsinlocalcharitiesandcommunity
organisations.Colleaguescanalsouse
theirvolunteerallowancetosupport
theSociety’scharitypartner,FareShare,
andusetheirprofessionalskillsto
providepro-bonosupport,becomea
trustee,schoolgovernor,ormentor.
Ourflagshipvolunteeringprogram,
MoneyMinds,teachesyoungpeople
aboutmoney,andpreparesthemfor
work.In2023wecontinuedtodeliver
hundredsofsessions,reaching16,000
childrenandyoungpeopleagedfive
tonineteen(2022:16,000).UKSavings
WeektookplaceinSeptember2023,
andoverthecourseofthemonth
branchcolleaguesdeliveredover
200sessionstoover3,100people.
Therecentexpansiontoincludean
onlineplatformprovidededucators,
parents,andcaregiverswitharesource
forenhancingfinancialliteracy,both
withintheclassroomandwithout.
OurEmergingTalentprogram
representsaninnovativecollaboration
withtwocarefullyselectedschools
andcollegesinBradford,prioritising
institutionswithasignificantnumber
ofstudentsonapupilpremiumgrant,
orsituatedindiversecommunities.It
deliverstailorededucationalsessions
focusedonemployabilityskillsand
meaningfulworkplaceexperiences,
preparingstudentsfortheworldof
work.In2023,theprogramevolvedby
introducingatwo-dayemployability
programwithAQA-certifiedworkshops.
Thisdevelopmentenabledusto
support82studentsandtheoutcomes
wereresoundinglypositive,as
evidencedbythefeedbackreceived
frombothstudentsandtheteachers
involved.
Community contribution
Weusethefollowingmethodology
tocalculateourtotalcommunity
contribution,usingthreecategories:
•
YBSdonations–includescash
contributions(themonetary
amountdonatedtocharitiesand
goodcausesandthemoneyspent
tofundcommunityprojectswith
partners),employeetime(the
costofthetimethatanemployee
spendsonvolunteering)andin-kind
giving(contributionsofproducts,
equipmentandservicesandother
non-cashitemstocharitiesandgood
causes)directlypaidbyYBS.
•
Customerandcolleague
donations(leverage)–includes
cashcontributions(themonetary
amountdonatedtocharities
andgoodcauses)andin-kind
giving(contributionsofproducts,
equipmentandservicesandother
non-cashitemstocharitiesand
goodcauses)fromcolleaguesand
customers,facilitatedbyYBS.
•
YBScosts–includesthecosts
incurredbytheSocietytofacilitate
ourcommunityprogrammes,
includingstaffcostsandother
managementoverheads.
*CharitabledonationspaidtoGoodThingsFoundation(2022and2023)
Community
Contributions
£000
2023 2022
YBS Donations
Customer
Colleague
YBS
Costs Total
YBS Donations
Customer
Colleague
YBS
Costs TotalCharitable Community Charitable Community
AgeUK
175 - 119 26 320 272 - 139 18 429
TheFoundation
100 - 358 - 458 100 - 308 12 420
Othercharity
15 - 65 - 80 100 - 66 - 166
CitizensAdvice
521 - - 14 535 299 - - - 299
Employability/digitalskills*
90 - - 59 149 109 64 - 18 191
Inkinddonations
- 97 15 - 112 - 92 19 - 111
Volunteeringtime
- 141 - 4 145 - 110 - 1 111
Other
- 15 - 588 603 - - - 624 624
Total
901 253 557 691 2,402
880 266 532 673 2,351
Engaging with our stakeholders (continued)
Our Communities(continued)
44 | Strategic report 45
TheSociety’sstrategyforparticipating
inthemortgagesmarketisunchanged:
wecontinuetobalanceserving
largesectionsofthemarketthrough
high-qualitymortgages,atrelatively
lowloan-to-valuecategories,with
morespecificofferingsthattarget
underservedsegments.Thisallows
ustooperateresponsiblyandwithin
riskappetite,whilstworkingtoward
deliveringonourpurpose.
Inthecontextofareducedmarket
sizeaseconomicfactorsservedto
subduethelevelofactivity,strong
levelsofgrosslendingwereachieved
bytheSociety.Totalgrosslendingwas
£9.2bnin2023(2022:£10.3bn).The
disruptionstothelendingmarketin
Q42022ledtoalowernewbusiness
pipelinebeingcarriedintotheyear,
butstrongapplicationperformance
fromQ12023onwardcompensated
forthisinitialshortfall.
Mortgages performance
Theshareoftheresidentiallending
marketcapturedhasincreased0.8
percentagepointscomparedto2022,
andhascontinuedtobesupportedby
theperformanceofAccordbuy-to-let
whichwasrelaunchedearlyin2023.
TheAccordresidentialrangehasbeen
buoyedbyitsexcellentreputationfor
serviceandflexibility,alongwiththe
breadthofourpropositions,allowing
Accordtocontinuetoperformwellin
anincreasinglycompetitivemarket.
Theprofileofmaturitiesfromour
mortgagebookledtoalarger
populationcomingtotheendoftheir
fixed-ratetermscomparedto2022.
Inturn,thiscontributedtoalower
netlendingvolume,whichalignsto
expectations.Netlendingwas£1.6bn
in2023(2022:£3.0bn).
Wehaveobservedchangesin
mortgagecustomerbehaviourrelating
topricesensitivity;thisislikelyto
bepartlyaresultofhigherinterest
ratesmakingthechoiceofmortgage
providermoreconsequential,and
alsopartlytheintroductionofthe
MortgageCharterprecipitatingproduct
switchingactivity.Thesefactors,and
theirrelatedoperationalimplications,
continuetobetrackedandmonitored.
More information on the external
mortgages market can be found
in The External Environment
section, and more information on
our Place to Call Home priority
can be found in the Our Purpose
section.
Mortgages 2023 2022
Grosslending £9.2bn £10.3bn
Netlending £1.6bn £3.0bn
Growthinmortgagebalances* 3.6% 7.2%
Marketshareofresidentialgrosslending 3.9% 3.1%
OUR
FINANCIAL
REVIEW
TheSocietyhasdeliveredstrong
growthintheyear,withshares
balanceshavingincreased£5.1bn
(2022:£6.5bnincrease)representinga
growthrateof12.0%(2022:18.3%).
Sustainingahighrateofgrowthhas
allowedtheamountofvaluereturned
toourmembersthroughsavings
ratestoincreasemeaningfully.This
isdemonstratedthroughawidening
ofthedifferentialinouraverage
savingsratewhencomparedtothe
marketfrom0.56%to1.01%.This
equatestoc.£441.1mofadditional
valuereturnedtomembers(2022:
£198.6madditionalvalue).Providing
thissupporthasbeenparticularly
importantatatimewhenthe
increasedcostoflivingismakingit
difficultformoreand
morepeople.
Thesavingsmarketin2023continued
tobeheavilyinfluencedbytherising
BankRateenvironment.Sincethestart
oftheyear,wehaveincreasedour
variablesavingsratesinresponseto
BankRatefourtimes,increasingrates
acrossallsegmentstosupportboth
newandexistingmembers.
Inahighinterestrateenvironment
theutilityofIndividualSavings
Accounts(ISAs)isgreaterand,as
such,theperiodleadinguptowhen
subscriptionscanbemadeforthe
newtaxyear,usuallybetweenMarch
andMay,seesamarkedincreasein
Savings performance
activityfromsaversandfromsavings
providers.Inflowsofnewmoneyover
thisperiod,drivenbyourmarket-
leadingLoyaltySixAccessISA,aswell
asourcompetitivelypricedLimited
AccessISAandfixed-rateISArange,
contributedtothegrowthinthefirst
halfof2023.
Oursavingsrangeremainssupported
bypurpose-ledpropositions,with
atotalof8variationsonloyalty
productsbeinglaunchedintheyear
(4products,withvariationsacross
bothbranchandonlinechannels).
Aregularsaverthatwillformacore
partofourrangewasalsoaddedin
June,offeringahigherinterestrate
forthosewishingtostarttheirsavings
journey.Separately,oursmarter-tiered
products,whichpayahigherratefor
thelowestbalancetier,havebeen
well-receivedbycustomers.
Ashiftinthecompetitivedynamicsin
thesavingsmarketwasobservedwhen
comparinghalvesoneandtwoof
2023.Thegenerallevelofcompetition
forbalancesintensifiedsignificantlyas
theyearprogressed,withnewproducts
puttingupwardpressureonthetop-of-
the-marketratesacrossbothfixed-and
variable-ratesegments.Thisdrovean
increaseinoutflowandareductionin
newmoneyinflow,leadingtoamuch
slowerrateofgrowthinthesecond
halfoftheyear.
Wedonotexpectthedegreeof
competitionforsavingsdeposits
tolesseninthenearfuture,given
thesizeableTFSMEbalancesthat
themarketwillneedtorefinance
overtheshortandmediumterm.
Lookingahead,ourfocuswillbe
tosupportourlong-termmembers
withfurtherloyaltypropositions,and
maintainstableacquisitionpricingto
demonstratesustainablegrowth.
More information on the external
savings market can be found
in The External Environment
section, and more information on
our Financial Wellbeing priority
can be found in the Our Purpose
section.
Sincethestartoftheyear,wehaveincreasedtheratesonourvariable-rate
backbookinresponsetoBankRatefourtimes,increasingratesacrossall
segmentstosupportbothnewandexistingmembers.
Savings 2023 2022
Sharesbalancegrowth 12.0% 18.3%
Sharesbalancegrowth £5.1bn £6.5bn
Averagesavingsratedifferentialtothemarketaverage 1.01pp 0.56pp
Marketshareofretailsavingsbalances 2.3% 2.2%
*Growthinmortgagebalancesexcludesfairvalueadjustmentsforhedgedriskonloansandadvancestocustomers.Prioryearcomparativerestatedonaconsistentbasis.
46 | Strategic report 47
Our Financial Review (continued)
Financial performance
ThefiguresbelowareconsolidatedamountsinrespectofYorkshireBuildingSocietyanditscontrolledentities(‘theGroup’).
Thefinancialresultsachievedin2023demonstratesustainedgrowthandstronglevelsofprofitability,setinthecontextof
therisinginterestrateenvironmentandincreasinglychallengingmarketconditions.Wehavedeliveredtheseresultswhilst
continuingtorewardourmemberswithcompetitiveratesandmanagingtheinflationarypressuresonourcosts.Thestrong
growthinoursavingsbalanceshasenabledustorepayafurtherportionofgovernmentfundingatatimewhenthemarket
requirementtorefinanceiselevatingcompetitionforfunding.Theresultingstrengthofcapitalandliquiditypositionswill
supporttheSocietyinnavigatingthechallengesahead.
2023 2022
Statutoryprofitbeforetax £450.3m £502.5m
Coreoperatingprofit £449.9m £425.6m
Netinterestmargin 1.31% 1.30%
Costtocoreincomeratio 42% 41%
Managementexpenseratio 0.56% 0.54%
Liquiditycoverageratio('LCR') 156.4% 164.0%
Liquidityratio 23.3% 23.3%
Commonequitytier1capitalratio 16.7% 16.8%
Leverageratio(UK) 6.2% 6.2%
2023 2022
£m Statutory
Remove non-
core items Core Statutory
Remove non-
core items Core
Netinterestincome i 786.0 (2.3) 783.7 724.1 (2.4) 721.7
Fairvaluegainsandlosses ii (5.5) 2.2 (3.3) 75.6 (74.9) 0.7
Netrealisedgains 1.6 - 1.6 2.9 - 2.9
Otherincome 4.3 - 4.3 8.8 0.3 9.1
Total income/core income 786.4 (0.2) 786.2 811.4 (77.0) 734.4
Managementexpenses (332.7) - (332.7) (298.7) - (298.7)
Impairmentoffinancialassets (4.0) - (4.0) (6.0) - (6.0)
Movementinprovisions iii 0.6 (0.2) 0.4 (4.2) 0.1 (4.1)
Profit before tax/core operating profit 450.3 (0.4) 449.9 502.5 (76.9) 425.6
Thenotesbelowexplaintheadjustmentsmadetostatutoryprofitbeforetaxtoarriveatcoreoperatingprofit:
i) Historicalfairvaluecreditadjustmentsonacquiredloans.
ii) Removedfairvaluevolatilityi.e.gainsandlossesonderivativesnotqualifyingforhedgeaccounting,andonnon-coreequityinvestments.
iii) Non-coreelementsoftherestructuringprovision.
Summary Balance Sheet
Net interest income
Netinterestincomewas£786.0min
2023,increasing£61.9myearonyear
(2022:£724.1m),andrepresentsan
improvednetinterestmarginof1.31%
(2022:1.30%).Furtherincreasesto
BankRatealongwithgrowthinboth
mortgageandsavingsbookshave
servedtoincreasenetincome,despite
aseriesofrateincreasestothe
savingsbackbookandwideningour
differentialtotheaveragemarketrate.
Ourstructuralhedgingportfolio
contributed£215.7mofgrossinterest
incomein2023(2022:£67.6m).
Grossstructuralhedgecontributions
representtheincomeearnedfromthe
fixedreceiptsontheswapswithinthe
portfolios.
Fair value gains and losses
Afairvaluelossof£5.5mwasrecorded
in2023(2022:£75.6mgain).Themost
significantdriveroftheyear-on-year
changeinfairvaluegainsandlosses
relatestoderivativesnotinhedge
accountingrelationship,including
swapsenteredintotohedgethe
mortgagepipelineaswellasshorter-
termswapstohedgefixed-ratesavings
balances.Whilstswapsratesremained
volatilein2023,themovementacross
theyearhasbeenlesssignificant
thanin2022,inturnhavingalower
Core operating profit
OurfinancialperformanceisreviewedregularlybyourBoardusinganumberofmeasures,includingstatutoryprofitbefore
taxandcoreoperatingprofit.Coreoperatingprofitisanalternativeperformancemeasurewhichexcludesitemssuchasfair
valuevolatilityandmaterialone-timechargesthatdonotreflecttheGroup’sday-to-dayactivities.OurBoardconsiderscore
operatingprofittobeanappropriatemeasureoftheunderlyingperformanceofthebusiness.
Statutoryprofitbeforetaxin2023was£450.3m(2022:£502.5m)andcoreoperatingprofitwas£449.9m(2022:£425.6m).
Thedifferencebetweenstatutoryprofitbeforetaxandcoreoperatingprofitismuchlowerin2023thanthepreviousyear;
2022sawalargefairvaluegainrelatingtoswapsnotinhedgeaccountingrelationships.
Goodlevelsofsavingsbalancegrowthwereachievedagainintheyear,althoughheightenedmarketcompetitionsawthe
rateofgrowthslowinthesecondhalf.Mortgagegrowthwasmoresubduedthanlastyear,withalowerapplicationpipeline
carriedintotheyearasaresultofmarketdisruptiontowardtheendof2022.Inaddition,2023sawahigherlevelofmortgage
maturities,whichservedtosuppressnetlending.AsatDecember2023theSociety'sretailloantodepositratiostandsat
98.2%(2022:106.4%).
impactonthefairvalueoftheinterest
rateswapsnotdesignatedinthe
accountinghedge.Moredetailon
thefairvaluegainsandlossesinthe
periodisavailableinNote5.
Other income
Otherincomereceivedintheyearwas
£4.3m(2022:£8.8m)andincludes
incomefromoursecondarylinesof
business,includingcommissionfrom
insurancebrokering,whichareless
materialinnature.
Management expenses
Overallmanagementexpenseswere
£332.7min2023(2022:£298.7m).
Anumberoffactorshaveinfluenced
thisoutcome,includingthegrowthof
thebusiness,increasedpurposeful
investmentinchangeactivities,and
theeffectofinflationarypressureson
ourcostbase.
In2023,£63.8mwasinvestedin
changeactivitieswhichisamaterial
increasefrom£54.6min2022.This
aimstoacceleratethedeliveryof
futurebenefitsandenableusto
commencethesecondphaseof
ourprogramme.Themainactivities
acceleratedin2023relatedto
paymentsfunctionalityandjourney
andexperienceimprovementsfor
savingscustomers.
Giventheelevatedlevelsofprice
inflationobservedinthewider
economy,wemadethedecisionto
awardasalaryincreasewhichwas
higherthaninatypicalyeartohelp
ouremployeesdealwiththecost-
of-livingpressures,andtomaintain
acompetitivepositioninthelabour
market.Highinflationalsodroveup
someofourthird-partycostsata
greaterratethanusualasaresultof
contractualobligations.Thishasled
toanincreasedcosttocoreincome
ratioof42%,up1percentagepoint
on2022.
Impairment of financial
assets
Atotalnetimpairmentchargeof£4.0m
(2022:£6.0mcharge)wasrecordedin
theperiod.Moreinformationonthe
impairmentoffinancialassetscanbe
foundinNotes2and7tothefinancial
statements.
Provisions
Areleaseof£0.6mwasrecognisedin
theperiodrelatingtoprovisionswhich
includecustomerredress,restructuring
andotherspecificitems(2022:£4.2m
charge).
£bn
2023
2022
Liquidassets 12.8 12.5
Loansandadvancestocustomers 46.8 45.2
Fairvalueadjustmentforhedgedriskonloansandadvancestocustomers (0.6) (1.5)
Otherassets 2.0 2.6
Total assets 61.0 58.8
Shares 47.1 42.0
Wholesalefundingandotherdeposits 7.8 11.6
Subordinatedliabilities 1.6 1.0
Otherliabilities 0.8 0.8
Total liabilities 57.3 55.4
Members’interestandequity 3.7 3.4
Total members' interest, equity and liabilities 61.0 58.8
Summary Income Statement
48 | Strategic report 49
Liquidity
Liquiditylevelsremainstrong,witha
liquiditybalancesheetratiostanding
at23.3%(2022:23.3%),anda
LiquidityCoverageRatioat156.4%
(2022:164.0%).Strongsavings
inflowsintheyearhavehelpedto
facilitatefurtherrepaymentofTFSME
funding.Sufficientheadroomto
regulatoryrequirementsforliquidity
wasmaintainedthroughout2023.
Ourinvestmentportfoliowasfurther
diversifiedintheyear,inlinewithour
balancesheetstrategy.
High-qualityliquidassets('HQLA')
balancesstoodat£10.7bnasat31
December2023(2022:£11.0bn).44%
oftheHQLAportfolioisratedasAAA
(2022:38%),withtheremainderrated
betweenAA+andA.
Loans and advances to
customers
Therateofmortgagebookgrowth
achievedwas3.6%(2022:7.2%).
Thecreditqualityofourmortgage
bookismonitoredusinganumber
ofindicatorsonaregularmonthly
basis.Animportantindicatoristhe
percentageofoutstandingretail
mortgagebalancesinarrearsby
threemonthsormore(including
possessions).Thequalityofour
loanbookhasremainedstrong;the
proportionofloansmeetingthese
criterianowstandsat0.39%byvalue
(2022:0.31%).
Theindustryaverageformortgage
arrearsismeasuredasthenumberof
accountsinarrearsbythreemonths
ormore(includingpossessions).At
0.50%(2022:0.44%)ourperformance
continuestoremainbetterthanthe
industryaverageof0.87%(2022:
0.74%).Moreinformationonarrears
canbefoundintheDirectors’report
andinNote31tothefinancial
statements.
InadditiontotheICAAP,theSociety
regularlyoperatesadditionalinternal
stressteststoensurethatsufficient
capitalisavailablethroughout
theplanninghorizon.Reverse
stresstestingallowstheSocietyto
understandthepotentialscenarios
andriskdriversthatcouldcausethe
potentialfailureoftheSociety,andto
ensurethatsufficientmitigationsare
inplace.
Specific details on capital
management can be seen in the
Society’s Pillar 3 disclosures
available on the Society’s
website.
Capital ratios
TheSociety’sCET1ratioatyear-end
2023stoodat16.7%,showinga
marginaldecreasefromtheprior
year(2022:16.8%).TheSociety’sUK
leverageratiowasmaintainedat6.2%
(2022:6.2%).
Whilstnomaterialdeterioration
inthecreditperformanceofour
mortgagebookhasbeenobserved,
risksarepresent,andthelevelof
arrearswillcontinuetobemonitored
closelythroughourestablishedrisk
managementprocesses.Therealso
existsthepotentialforaffordability
andcost-of-livingchallengesto
influenceourmortgagebookthrough
futurehousepricemovements.Asof
December2023,theaverageindexed
loantovalueofourmortgagebookis
49.0%(December2022:46.8%).
Asaproportionofgrossmortgage
exposure,ECLcoverageis0.1%,
(December2022:0.1%).Costof
risk,ascalculatedbyexpressingthe
impairmentchargefortheyearover
theaveragebalanceintheperiodwas
0.01%(2022:0.01%).
Wholesale funding
Followingaperiodofdisruptionto
wholesalemarketstowardtheend
of2022,theSocietysuccessfully
issuedwithintheRMBS,coveredbond
andseniornon-preferredmarkets
in2023.Theseissuancesrepresent
acontinuationofthestrategyto
maintainapresenceinourkey
issuancemarketsandensureaccessto
adiverserangeoffunding.
In2023,werepaidafurther£2.2bn
inrespectofthegovernmentfunding
scheme,TFSME,adoptingaprudent
approachtorefinancinginanticipation
ofheightenedcompetitionforfundsas
market-widematuritiesdrawnearer.As
atDecember2023,Societyhasrepaid
82.5%ofthetotalamountdrawn
underthescheme.
Capital
Introduction to capital
TheSocietymaintainscapitalreserves
tosafeguardtheinterestsofits
membersthroughouttheeconomic
cycle.
TheSocietyissubjecttoregulatory
capitalrequirementsenforcedinthe
UnitedKingdom(UK)bythePrudential
RegulationAuthority(PRA).Regulatory
capitalresourcesincludegeneral
reserves,fairvaluethroughother
comprehensiveincomereserves,and
subordinatedliabilities;theseare
GrowthintheSociety’sCET1
resourcesof£0.3bnhasbeenoffset
byrisk-weightedasset(RWA)growth
of£1.9bn.TheRWAgrowthwas
aresultofnetmortgagelending,
diversificationoftheSociety’streasury
investments(whichattractahigher
risk-weight),andanincreaseinthe
operationalriskcomponentgiven
theinclusionofhigherprofitlevels
inthecalculationwhichisbasedon
athree-yearaverage.TheCET1ratio
remainscomfortablyaboveregulatory
requirementsandriskappetite.
MREL (Minimum requirement
for own funds and eligible
liabilities)
TheSociety’sMRELRWAratioat
year-endstoodat24.2%,compared
totheprioryear’spositionof21.9%.
ThisincreaserecognisesSeniorNon-
Preferred(‘SNP’)issuanceactivity
undertakenduring2023tostrengthen
theSociety’sMRELresources.
subjecttoregulatoryadjustmentsand
IFRS9transitionalarrangements.MREL
resourcessuchasSecondaryNon-
PreferentialLiabilities(‘SNP’)arenot
includedaspartofregulatorycapital,
buthavebeendisclosedtoshowthe
impactonresources.
The Society has complied with
the PRA’s regulatory capital
requirements during the year,
further details of the Society’s
capital position can be found in
the 2023 Pillar 3 Disclosures.
Theratios,deductions,anddefinitions
belowareinaccordancewithCRDIV
regulations.
Management of capital
CapitalriskismanagedviaBoard-
approvedCapitalPolicyandrisk
appetite.TheSociety’smanagement
ofcapitalencompassesadhering
toregulatoryrequirementsandrisk
appetitelevelswhilstsupportingthe
Society’sstrategicobjectivesthrough
sustainablegrowth.
TheAsset&LiabilityCommittee
(‘ALCO’)istheSociety’sgovernance
committeewithresponsibilityfor
capitalmanagement.Underits
delegatedBoardauthority,itretains
responsibilityformonitoringthe
Society’scapitaladequacyand
recommending/approvingactions,as
appropriate.
Currentandprojectedcapitalpositions
areregularlymonitoredandforma
pivotalpartoftheSociety’sapproach
tocapitalmanagement.
TheSocietyundertakesanInternal
CapitalAdequacyAssessmentProcess
(ICAAP)annually.UnderPillar2A,the
Societyconsidersextremestresses
onindividualrisksinisolation.Under
Pillar2BtheSocietyapplieseconomic
stressscenariosovertheplanning
horizon.Thisprocessallowsthe
Societytoassesstheimpactonits
capitalheadroomwerethesestresses
tomaterialise.
Capital outlook
WhilsttheSocietycurrentlymonitors
andreportsitsLeverage-basedcapital
position,Leveragerequirementswill
becomebindingwhentheSociety
surpasses£50bnofretaildeposits
andisclassifiedasLREQ.TheSociety
iswellcapitalisedtomeetthese
requirementsonbothaUKandMREL
Leveragebasis.
TheSocietycontinuestoprogress
towardsInternalRatingsBased(IRB)
accreditation,andpreparationsare
alsounderwaytoimplementBasel
3.1perthePRA’snear-finalpolicy
statement(PS17/23)on1July2025.
Our Financial Review (continued)
Financial performance(continued)
50 | Strategic report 51
£m 2023 2022
Common Equity Tier 1 ('CET1')
Generalreserve
30
3,702.9 3,379.2
Fairvaluethroughothercomprehensiveincomereserve (10.2) 1.9
Cashflowhedgereserve 0.4 9.9
Common Equity Tier 1 prior to regulatory adjustments 3,693.1 3,391.0
CommonEquityTier1regulatoryadjustments - -
IFRS9transitionalarrangements - -
Pensionfundadjustments (27.8) (23.3)
Intangiblefixedassets (18.4) (20.2)
Prudentvaluationadjustment (7.7) (7.3)
Cashflowhedgereserve (0.4) (9.9)
Total Common Equity Tier 1 capital 3,638.8 3,330.3
Tier 2
Subordinatedliabilities 267.9 278.7
Collectiveprovisionsforimpairment - -
Total Tier 2 Capital 267.9 278.7
Total capital (audited) 3,906.7 3,609.0
MREL Resources
SecondaryNon-PreferentialLiabilities 1,313.0 739.4
Tier2MRELEligible 37.1 16.9
Total MREL Resources (unaudited) 5,256.8 4,365.3
Riskweightedassets(unaudited) 21,756.1 19,846.6
CommonEquityTier1capitalratio 16.7% 16.8%
Tier1ratio 16.7% 16.8%
Totalcapitalratio 18.0% 18.2%
TotalMRELResourcesratio 24.2% 22.0%
CRRLeverageratio 5.8% 5.6%
UKLeverageratio(excludingclaimsoncentralbanks) 6.2% 6.2%
30 IncludesallentitiesintheYBSGroup,asdisclosedinNote8tothesefinancialstatements,withtheexceptionofthesubsidiaryYorkshireKeyServicesLimited(YKS).
YKSisanon-tradingsubsidiaryand,asitsoperationswerenon-financialinnature,itisoutsidethescopeofCRDIVforcapitalpurposes.
Risk overview
Theenvironmentinwhichweoperate,
andthenatureoftherisksthatweface,
arecontinuallyevolving.Effectiverisk
managementisfundamentaltoensure
thatwemaintainthetrustofourmembers,
customers,andregulators.
How we manage risk
Wecategorisetheemergingandevolvingrisksthatwe
faceintonineprincipalrisks,definedinourEnterpriseRisk
ManagementFramework(seetheRiskManagementreport).
Thisensuresthatweidentify,assess,andmanagetheserisks
carefullyandconsistently.
Themostsignificantemergingandevolvingrisksare
reviewedregularlythroughourseniorriskcommitteesand
areconsideredduringourbusinessplanningprocesses.
Wecontinuetomonitortheeffectivenessof,andinvest
in,ourriskmanagementcapabilitiestoensuretimelyand
appropriateactionistakentoprotecttheinterestsofthe
Groupanditsmembersandcustomers.
Ourrobustriskmanagementframework,strongcapital
position,diversefundingsources,andhighliquidity
levelsleadustobeconfidentintheGroup’sfinancialand
operationalresilience.
Our top emerging and evolving risks
Emerging or
evolving risk
Principal risk(s) Commentary
The political
and economic
environment
Retail and commercial
credit risk
Market risk
Funding and liquidity
risk
AtaUKlevel,persistentlyhighinflation,higherinterestratesandan
uncertaineconomicoutlookcontinuetoaddpressuretohousehold
incomes.
Thishasreducedaffordabilityforbothmortgageborrowersandtenants
ofbuy-to-letlandlords,contributingtoaslowdownintheUKresidential
market.
Weassessaffordabilityfornewlendingusingasophisticatedmodelwhich
usesastressedinterestrate,andisreviewedatleasteverysixmonths.Our
lendingcriteriaaimtobalancethelevelofpurposefulriskwetakewith
lendingresponsiblytodelivergoodcustomeroutcomes,minimisearrears,
andcomplywiththeConsumerDutyregulations.
Weensurethatourproductsarecarefullypriced,andwearedisciplined
inourapproachtohedging,sothatwedonotexceedtheBoard-approved
riskappetite.
Westresstestourliquiditypositionregularlyandourliquidityratios
continuetoremainsignificantlywithintheBoard-approvedriskappetite.
Theinternationalpoliticalandeconomicenvironmentaffectsustoo;we
haveseennervousnessinsomewholesalefundingmarketsarisingfrom
thefailuresofbanksintheUSandEurope.
Our Financial Review (continued)
Financial performance(continued)
52 | Strategic report 53
Emerging or
evolving risk
Principal risk(s) Commentary
Attracting and
retaining the right
people
Operational risk Employercompetitioncontinuesforin-demandskills,suchasthose
relatingtochange,cybersecurity,digital,andanalytics.Coupledwithlow
levelsofunemploymentandhigherwageinflation,attracting,andretaining
therightpeopletodeliverourstrategyisvitalandchallenging.
Effectiveresourceplanning,forecasting,andsuccessionplanningremain
priorities.Wehavealsostrengthenedourriskmanagementcapabilitiesfor
peopleriskandhaveimprovedourpeoplepolicies,particularlyforworking
families.
The use of
sophisticated
models
Model risk Weusesophisticatedmodelstohelpmanageourfinancialrisks.These
usehistoricaldataandassumptionsbasedonthepast,toprovidefuture
estimatestoassistwithrunningthebusinessandinunderstandingour
risks.Anyapproachthatseekstopredictthefuturecarriesinherentrisk.
OurModelRiskCommitteereviewsthespecificrisksassociatedwiththe
modelsregularly.Wealsoensurethatourmodelriskframeworkmeets
regulatoryrequirements.
The regulatory
environment
Compliance and
conduct risk
TheregulatoryenvironmentfortheUKfinancialservicessectorcontinues
toevolve,withtheFCA’sConsumerDutyrulesandtheGovernment’s
MortgageCharterbothstartingin2023.
Wecontinuetohaveopenandconstructivedialoguewithourregulators,
andworkwiththemandindustrybodiestocontributetotheregulatory
agenda.Monitoringandmaintainingouractualregulatorycompliance
positionsisofthehighestpriorityacrossmanagement.
Climate change Credit risk
Operational risk
ThemainrisksfromclimatechangefortheSocietyariseinthephysical
riskstoourcustomers’properties,suchasfromflooding,subsidence,
andcoastalerosion,andthoseposedbythetransitiontoalower-carbon
economy,suchaschangesinenergyefficiencyregulation.
Wecontinuetodevelopourenvironmentalandclimatechangerisk
managementcapabilities,toensurethatwealignwithindustrygood
practiceandmeetreportinganddisclosurerequirements.
Financial crime
threats
Compliance and
conduct risk
Financialcrimethreatsarisebothfromcustomersfallingvictimtofraud
attempts,particularlythroughdigitalchannels,aswellasfromindividuals
attemptingtousetheSocietyforunlawfulreasonssuchastolaunder
moneyorevadesanctions.Thesethreatsareheightenedintheuncertain
economicandgeopoliticalenvironment.
Ourcontinuedfocusonourfinancialcrimecapabilityremainsparamount,
andwecontinuetoinvesttodeliverproportionateandeffective
monitoring,andpreventioncontrols.
Cyber security
threats
Operational risk TheincreasinguseoftechnologyanddigitalservicesmeanstheUK
financialservicessectorisexposedtoincreasingcybersecurityrisks.
Theseareheightenedfurtherbecauseofgeopoliticaltensions,suchasthe
warinUkraine.
Resiliencetosuchthreats,andanabilitytorespondeffectivelyintheevent
ofanattack,remainsessentialtoprotecttheSocietyandourcustomers,
andtomaintaintheconfidenceofregulators.
Wehavesignificantlyenhancedourcyberthreatmonitoringandresponse
capabilityandwillcontinuetodoso.
IT resilience Operational risk AsITcomponentsage,theirhealthandvaluecandeteriorate.Thisposesa
risktoourcustomerswhoincreasinglyrelyonourdigitalchannels,andour
colleagueswhouseoursystemstodeliverservicestoourcustomers.
WearecontinuallymodernisingandsimplifyingourITestatetoimproveits
resiliencesowecandelivertheservicesourcustomersexpect.
DetailsofourBoardandExecutiveTeam
aresetoutinthefollowingsection.
For information regarding our Board and
any changes during 2023 see the Corporate
Governance report.
Our Board and
Executive Team
AuditCommittee
GroupRiskCommittee
AC
BGNC
GRC
RC
BoardGovernanceand
NominationsCommittee
RemunerationCommittee
Risk Overview (continued)
Our top emerging and evolving risks(continued)
5554 | Strategic report
Chair of the Board
Joined our Board in
2014 as Chairman
Designate, becoming
Chair of the Board
in 2015.
Chair of the Board Designate
Background and career
Guyworkedintheauditprofessionfor36yearswithKPMG,
including24yearsasapartner.Hewasalsoamemberof
KPMG’sUKBoardforsevenyearsanditsEuropeanBoardfor
fiveyears.HewastheLeadAuditPartnerforanumberof
bankingclientsincludingBarclays,INGandHSBC.
Skills and experience
Guyisabankingexpertandbringsrecentandrelevant
experienceoftheUKbankingsector.Hehascomprehensive
knowledgeoftheregulatoryenvironmentinwhichwe
operate.
Other roles
Non-ExecutiveDirectorandChairoftheAuditCommittee
atICEClearEuropeLtdandaNon-ExecutiveDirector,Chair
oftheAuditCommitteeandamemberoftheCorporate
Governance&NominatingCommitteeatManulifeFinancial
Corporation.
Background and career
AnnemarieDurbinhas35years'internationalbusiness
andbankingexperience,includingretail,commercial,
corporateandinstitutionalbanking.Shespentthemajority
ofherexecutivecareerwithStandardChartered,aFTSE
100internationalbank,culminatinginmembershipofthe
GroupExecutiveCommittee.Sheheldavarietyofglobaland
businessroles,includingbeingCEOandExecutiveDirector
ofStandardChartered’spubliclylistedentityinThailandand
CEOinthePhilippines.Annemariehasalsoheldarangeof
non-executivepositions,includingWHSmithPlc,Santander
UKplcandwasChairofCaterAllenLimited.Annemarieis
alsoanexecutivecoachandmentor.
Skills and experience
Annemarieisahighlyexperiencedexecutivewitha
strongbackgroundinbanking,leadershipandtalent,
transformation,andcorporategovernance.Shealsohas
significantexperienceinrelationtoremuneration,including
asaRemunerationCommitteeChair,andextensive
experienceinrespectofaudit,riskandresponsiblebanking
fromhermembershipoftherelevantCommitteesat
SantanderUKplc.
Other roles
Non-ExecutiveDirector,ChairofRemunerationCommittee
andmemberofNominationCommitteeatPersimmonPlc.
Non-ExecutiveDirector,ChairofRemunerationCommittee
andmemberofManagementEngagement,AuditandRisk
andNominationsCommitteesatPetershillPartnersLLC.
Annemarie Durbin
BComm LLB MSc
Chair of the Board
Designate
Background and career
AlisonstartedhercareeratIBM,progressingtotherole
ofGlobalDirectorofOnlineFinancialServices.She
joinedBarclaysBankin2000holdinganumberofsenior
managementpositions.Alisonmovedtospecialistmortgage
providerKensingtonGroupplcin2004asManagingDirector
andthenGroupChiefExecutive,leadingthesuccessfulsale
ofthebusinesstoInvestecin2008.SheleftInvestecin
2008andlaunchedThePenniesFoundation,aregistered
charitywhichsupportsdigitaldonationstogoodcauses.
ShehasbeentheChiefExecutiveofthePenniesFoundation
since2009.
Skills and experience
Alisonhasastrongbackgroundintechnology,retailand
charitysectorsaswellasextensiveexperienceinthe
retailfinancialservicessector.Shehasmorethan35years
ofmanagementandBoardlevelexperience.Alisonwas
awardedaCBEin2016forservicestotheeconomyand
charities.
Other roles
ChiefExecutiveofThePenniesFoundation,Senior
IndependentDirectorofDFSFurnitureplcandSenior
IndependentDirectorofForesightGroupHoldingsLtd.
Background and career
Aqualifiedlawyer,Johnworkedinthelegalprofessionfor40
yearsandjoinedtheseniormanagementteamofcorporate
lawfirmEvershedsin1999.HewasappointedChairmanof
Evershedsin2010forafour-yeartermandretiredin2015.
Skills and experience
Johnhasextensivecommercialandlegalexperienceinhis
leadershiproleinshapingEversheds’long-termstrategyasit
grewintoamajorinternationallawfirm.Inthelastfewyears
hehascontributedtothedevelopmentandsuccessofboth
theSociety,includingdrivingBoardsuccession,aswellas
thevariousfinancialbodiesofwhichhehadbeenamember.
Other roles
MemberoftheAuditandRiskCommitteeandConstitutional
andGovernanceCommitteeoftheInternationalBar
Association.MemberoftheAdvisoryBoardofthe
InternationalBusinessandDiplomaticExchange.
John will retire from his role as Chair of the Board in
April 2024.
Joined our Board
in 2023 as Chair
of the Board
Designate.
John Heaps
LLB
Chair of the Board
Chair
BGNC
Non-Executive Director
Joined our Board in
2015 and became
Vice Chair and Senior
Independent Director
in October 2020.
Alison Hutchinson
BSc, CBE
Senior Independent
Non-Executive Director
and Vice Chair
Non-executive Director for
Workforce Engagement
(to 31 December 2023)
Non-Executive Director
Joined our Board
in 2019.
Guy Bainbridge
MA (Cantab), ACA
Independent
Non-Executive Director
Whistleblowing
Champion
BGNC GRC RC
56 | Governance 57
Our Board and Executive Team (continued)
AC GRC
Chair
BGNC
Non-Executive Director Non-Executive Director Non-Executive Director Non-Executive Director
Joined our Board
in 2022.
Joined our Board
in 2023.
Joined our Board
in 2021.
Joined our Board
in 2020.
Background and career
Debrahasover25yearsofexperienceinfinancialservices.
AfterstartinginMarketResearch,shespenttheremainder
ofherexecutivecareerwithAmericanExpress,inavariety
ofseniorrolesincludingleadingtheUKConsumerBusiness,
leadingProductMarketinggloballyandrollingoutthe
AmericanExpressbusinessacross55Countries.She
representedtheCompany’sinterestsinmajorJointVentures
intheMiddleEast,BelgiumandSwitzerlandwhereshe
wastheChairofSwisscard.Shehasheldarangeofnon-
executiveandcommitteeChairroleswithAXAUKplcand
CreditSuisseinternational.
Skills and experience
Debrahasastrongbackgroundinprofitandlossleadership,
customerservice,marketing,technologytransformationand
digitalinnovation,aswellasPartnershipdevelopmentand
management.Herexperiencespansbusinesstoconsumer
andbusinesstobusinessacrossmanycountriesand
cultures.
Other roles
Non-ExecutiveDirectoratAXAUKplc,Chairofthe
RemunerationCommitteeandmemberoftheAuditandRisk
Committees.Non-ExecutiveDirectorofIntrumAB,member
oftheTransformationCommittee.
Background and career
Angelaspent20yearsworkingforAvivaPLCinavarietyof
seniorroles–culminatinginherservingasChiefExecutive
Officer(CEO)ofUKLifefollowingaperiodasInterimCEOof
UKInsurance,whereshewasresponsibleforleadingtheUK
InsurancebusinessandamemberoftheAvivaLeadership
Team.PriortoherCEOroles,AngelawastheGroupChief
RiskOfficerforAvivaPLCforfouryears,responsiblefor
leadingtheRiskFunctionatGrouplevel.
Skills and experience
Angelahassignificantexperienceofthefinancialservices
sectorwithadeeptechnicalexpertiseinrelationtoriskas
wellastheabilitytocontributetoawiderstrategicagenda.
Other roles
IndependentNon-ExecutiveDirectorofRothesayLifeand
MemberofCouncilfortheLondonSchoolofHygieneand
TropicalMedicine.
Our Board and Executive Team (continued)
Background and career
MarkwasChiefExecutiveofCoventryBuildingSocietyfrom
2014untilhisretirementinApril2020.Markhassignificant
experienceworkingwithinretailfinancialservicesincluding
rolesatBarclaysandAbbeyNational,aswellastimeat
PricewaterhouseCoopers.AtBarclayshewastheChief
FinancialOfficerforRetailandBusinessBankingandalso
servedastheDeputyChiefExecutiveofBarclaysUKRetail
Bank.
Skills and experience
Markhasover35years’experienceinfinancialservicesand
hasarangeofexecutiveexperienceacrossfinance,human
resources,product,retailmanagement,riskmanagementand
investorrelations.
Other roles
Non-ExecutiveDirectorofFairstoneCapitalGroupLtd.
Background and career
Dinabeganhercareerinstrategyandtechnology
consultingpriortojoiningHSBC/MidlandBankinLondon.
ShesubsequentlyworkedwithUBS,BritishTelecomand
INGBankinatransformationcapacitywithintheirretail,
corporateandwholesalebusinessdivisions.Morerecently,
DinajoinedtheEuropeanBankforReconstructionand
DevelopmentinOctober2021astheVicePresidentand
ChiefTransformationOfficeroverseeingtheBank’sdigital
transformationwithdirectresponsibilityfortheBank’s
datamanagement,technologyandadministrativeservice
departmentsaswellasthebankwidetransformationoffice.
Skills and experience
Dinaisanengineerandeconomistandhasover30years’
experienceintransformation,operationsandtechnological
innovationworkingacrossindustriesbothinEuropeand
theUS.
Other roles
VicePresidentandChiefTransformationOfficerforthe
EuropeanBankforReconstructionandDevelopment.
Angela Darlington
BSc, FIA
Independent
Non-Executive Director
Chair
ACGRC
Debra Davies
BA (Hons)
Independent
Non-Executive Director
Chair
GRCRC
Dina Matta
BSc, BA (Hons)
Independent
Non-Executive Director
RC
Mark Parsons
BA, FCMA
Independent
Non-Executive Director
Board Consumer Duty /
Member Champion
58 | Governance 59
AC
GRC
Executive Director
Joined the Society
in 2018 and our
Board in 2022.
Executive Director
Joined the Society
and our Board in
2017.
Non-Executive Director
Executive Director
Joined our Board
in 2021.
Joined the Society
and our Board in
2023.
Background and career
SusanwasmostrecentlyHeadofCustomerTransformation
atBarclayswhereshewasresponsibleforleadingand
supportingallcolleaguesinfrontlineteamstodelivera
differentiatedcustomerexperience.PriortothatSusanwas
responsibleforallofSantander'sUKRetailandBusiness
bankingbusinesses,supporting15millioncustomers
andwithanationwidenetworkofbranchesandcustomer
contactcentres,followingherroleasChiefTransformation
Officer.SusanisaformerBoardmemberofUKFinance.
Skills and experience
Susanhasmorethan25yearsofexperienceinfinancial
serviceshavingheldseniorexecutivepositionsatanumber
oflargeretailbanksintheUK.Susanhasbeenaproud
championofdiversityandinclusivitythroughouthercareer.
SheisalsoamemberoftheBuildingSocietiesAssociation
Council.
Other roles
MemberoftheBoardofTrusteesfortheAlzheimer’sSociety.
Background and career
Jennellespentover17yearsworkingforYum!Restaurants
Internationalinavarietyofseniormarketingroles–
culminatinginherservingastheGlobalChiefMarketing
OfficerforKFC,responsibleforthecompany’smarketing,
communications,innovation,digitalpresenceandreputation
inover125countries.JennelleistheFounderandChief
BrandStrategistatLondon-basedbrandconsultancy
MarketingwithInsight.
Skills and experience
Jennellehasover25years’consumermarketing,digitaland
innovationexperiencewithleadingglobalFMCGandfood
retailbrands.
Other roles
Non-ExecutiveDirectorofShaftesburyCapitalPlc,Senior
IndependentDirectorofCamelotUKLotteriesLtdand
TrusteeforTheGuideDogsfortheBlindAssociation.
Susan Allen
BA Hons (Econ), ACIB, ACT, OBE
Chief Executive
Officer
Our Board and Executive Team (continued)
Background and career
DavidbeganhiscareeratCitigroupandhassubsequently
workedatvariousFinancialServicesinstitutionsacross
theUKandinternationally.PriortojoiningYBSDavid
wastheHeadofProductsatCoventryBuildingSociety.
Heisresponsiblefortheinnovation,developmentand
on-goingmanagementoftheSociety’smortgagesand
savingsproducts,YBS’smarketinganditsdigitalchannels,
mortgagedistributionandtheSociety’sbranchnetwork.
DavidisalsoresponsibleforourCommercialLendingand
isChairofAccordMortgagesLimited.
Skills and experience
Davidhasover15yearsofexperienceinretailbanking
andhasastrongtrackrecordofdrivingcommercial
performanceinfinancialservicesorganisations,including
themutualsector.
Background and career
Alasdairbeganhiscareeronthemanagementtraining
programmeatMarsInc.wherehespentanumberofyears
workinginsales,beforemovingintofinance.Sincethen,
he’sgainedsignificantexperienceinthefinancialservices
sector,includingasFinanceDirectorofRetailProductsfor
LloydsBankingGroupandGroupChiefFinanceOfficerfor
BGLGroup.
Skills and experience
Over20yearsofexperienceinFinanceworkinginavariety
ofBoardlevelroles,bothnon-executiveandexecutive.
TheseincludeCFOandInterimCEOofYBS,AuditCommittee
ChairforbothSainsbury’sBankandCoventryBuilding
SocietyandanumberofrolesatLloydsBankingGroup.
Alasdair will retire from his role with the Society
in 2024.
Jennelle Tilling
B.Bus, BA
Independent
Non-Executive Director
RC
Alasdair Lenman
MA, ACMA
Chief Finance
Officer
David Morris
BA, MA
Chief Commercial
Officer
60 | Governance 61
Chief Officer
Joined the Society
in 2010.
Chief Officer
Joined the Society
in 2022.
Chief OfficerChief Officer
Joined the Society
in 2023.
Joined the Society
in 2019.
Background and career
FraserwasmostrecentlyChiefDigitalandInnovation
OfficeratVirginMoney.Priortothisheheldarangeofroles
includingGroupChiefOperatingOfficer,ChiefInformation
OfficerandInnovationandChangeDirector.Beforejoining
VirginMoneyhismostrecentrolesincludedChiefOperating
OfficeratKleinwortBensonandCIOofCitizensBankinthe
USA.
Skills and experience
Fraserhasawiderangeofexperienceacrossbusinesses,
functionsandgeographies–includingbusiness
transformation,ITandchangemanagement.
Background and career
Orlaghisanexperiencedhumanresourcesprofessional
whohasheldseniorrolesacrossarangeofindustries
includingfast-movingconsumergoodsandretail,aswellas
havingsignificantexperienceinfinancialservices.Orlagh
isresponsibleforthePeopleDivisionincludingreward,
recognition,traininganddevelopment,diversityand
inclusion,internalcommunicationsandsocialpurposeand
sustainability.
Skills and experience
OrlaghwaspreviouslyHeadofHumanResourcesfor
AXASunlife,GroupHumanResourcesDirectorforFTSE-
100insurerRoyalSunAllianceaswellasGroupHuman
ResourcesDirectorforAIBinDublin.
Our Board and Executive Team (continued)
Background and career
Richardhasheldanumberofseniorriskmanagementroles
atseveraloftheUK’smajorbanksandbuildingsocieties.
Heisresponsibleforensuringthatthereareappropriate
proceduresandcapabilityforthemanagementofallrisks
whetherplannedorunplanned.InadditiontoRisk,heis
alsoresponsiblefortheLegal,ComplianceandSecretariat
functionsaswellasregulatoryrelationships.
Skills and experience
Richardhasextensiveexperienceofriskmanagementwithin
thefinancialservicesindustryacrossawideenterpriseof
risksincluding,Prudential,OperationalandConductRisks.
HeisalsoadirectorofAccordMortgagesLimited.
Richard will retire from his role with the Society in
2024.
Background and career
KatewasmostrecentlyHeadofEuropeanGovernanceat
Vanguard,leadingacrossfunctionalprogrammeofworkto
improvetheirgovernance,riskandregulatoryframeworks.
PriortothisshewastheEuropeanHeadofAudit(SMF5)
fortheirUK,IrishandGermanRegulatedentitieshaving
previouslybeenaSeniorManageratErnstandYoung.
Skills and experience
Katehasabroadrangeofaudit,riskandfinancialexperience
withinthefinancialservicesindustry.Sheisresponsiblefor
our'thirdlineofdefence'intheSociety'sriskmanagement
model,includingevaluatinghowwemanageourcapital,
liquidity,credit,operationalandregulatoryrisks.
Kate will be leaving the Society in 2024 to take up a
new opportunity.
*Also known as Katherine Remington
Fraser Ingram
MBA FCB
Chief Operating
Officer
Orlagh Hunt
BA, FCIPD
Chief People
Officer
Kate Ireland*
BSc, FCA
Chief Internal
Audit Officer
Richard Wells
FCIB
Chief Risk
Officer
62 | Governance 63
A word from the
Chair of our Board
IampleasedtopresentourCorporate
Governancereportfor2023,whichsets
outtheroleoftheBoardanditskey
activitiesduringtheyear.
AsaBoardweremaincommittedto
maintainingarobustandeffective
governanceframeworkwhichsupportsthe
deliveryofourstrategyandpurposewhilst
remainingadaptabletothechallenges
broughtbyexternaleventsarisingintheUK
andaroundtheworld.
Our approach to Corporate
Governance
Weapproachcorporategovernanceasa
frameworkofrules,practicesandprocesses
weusetomanagetheSocietyandour
approachisbasedontheprinciplesand
provisionsoftheUKCorporateGovernance
Code(theCode)publishedbytheFinancial
ReportingCouncil('FRC').
Ourcommitmenttooperatetothisstandard
helpstoensurethelong-termsuccessand
asustainablefuturefortheSocietyand
forthebenefitofourcurrentandfuture
members,customers,colleaguesandall
otherstakeholders.
Changes to the Board
AsreportedintheAnnualReportand
Accounts2022,wewerepleasedto
announceinAugust2022thattheSociety
hadappointedSusanAllenOBEasournew
ChiefExecutive.SusanjoinedusinMarch
2023andbroughtmorethan25yearsof
experienceinfinancialservices.Herskills
andexpertisearealreadyprovingtobe
asignificantbenefittotheSocietyaswe
deliverourstrategy.
WeannouncedinJanuary2024thatAlasdair
Lenman,ourChiefFinanceOfficer,willbe
retiringfromhisrolewiththeSocietyand
fromtheBoardinJune2024.Iwouldlike
totaketheopportunitytothankhimforhis
outstandingcontributiontotheSocietynot
leastforhisroleasInterimChiefExecutive.
Therehascontinuedtobeasignificant
focusonNon-ExecutiveDirectorsuccession
planningforourBoardduring2023to
ensureitremainseffectivenowandin
thefuture,includingmanagingasmooth
transitionofkeyrolesontheBoard.
InJuly2023weannouncedthat,after
nineyearsasChairoftheBoard,Iwillbe
succeededbyAnnemarieDurbinwhojoined
ourBoardasChairoftheBoardDesignate
on18December2023.Annemariehasover
35years’experienceinretail,commercial,
corporateandinstitutionalbanking,she
isaqualifiedlawyerwithexpertiseacross
generalmanagement,operations,HR,
legalandcompliance,aswellasbeingan
executivecoachandmentor.Iwasdelighted
thatAnnemarieagreedtojointheSociety
andtobeabletowelcomeheronthe
Board.Movinginto2024wewillbeworking
togethertocompleteadetailedhandover
processtoensuretheongoingsmooth
runningandeffectivenessofourBoard.
WewerepleasedtowelcomeDebra
DaviestoourBoardinJuly2023who’s
experienceandknowledgeofthefinancial
servicessector,togetherwithherfocuson
remunerationandrisk,isaconsiderable
valueaswecontinuetogrowanddevelop.
DebrabecameChairofourRemuneration
CommitteeinSeptember2023.
Iwouldliketotakethisopportunitytothank
AlisonHutchinsonforundertakingtheChair
ofRemunerationCommitteeroleduringthe
interimperiod,ensuringongoingstability
duringaperiodoftransitionthroughher
significantexperiencebothwiththeSociety
andasaRemunerationCommitteeChair.
Further details can be found in the
Board Governance and Nominations
Committee report.
Strategy
During2024theBoardandExecutive
Teamhavebeenworkingtorefresh
andfinalisethenextstageofour
strategywhichwilltaketheSociety
into2024andbeyond.Thiswill
provideuswithacleardirectionand
ensurewebuildonourachievements
todateandcontinuetoimproveon
whatwedelivertoourmembersand
customers.
Engaging with our
stakeholders
TheBoardrecognisesthevalueof
insightgainedfromourstakeholders
andtheimportanceoftakinginto
accounttheirviewsaspartofdecision
making.
OurAnnualGeneralMeetingisalways
oneofthekeyeventsintheyearfor
ustomeetandobtaintheviewsof
ourmembersonhowtheSocietyis
run.ForourAnnualGeneralMeeting
in2023wewerepleasedtooffereven
morechoiceonhowtotakepart,as
wellasbeingabletovoteaheadof
themeetingorattendthemeeting
inperson,forthefirsttimethose
membersparticipatingonlinewere
alsoabletovoteandaskquestions.
Consumer Duty
TheConsumerDutyhasbeenakey
areaoffocusfortheBoardin2023and
thiswillcontinueinto2024aswehave
thesecondphaseofrequirements
tomeetforourclosedproductsand
services.Thiswillleadustothefirst
BoardattestationinJuly2024.
TosupporttheBoard’soversight
wehavecontinuedtohaveregular
updatesandtrainingduring2023
andwehaveourownConsumerDuty
ChampioninMarkParsonsoneofour
Non-ExecutiveDirectors.
Board evaluation
Thelastexternalevaluationofthe
Boardwascompletedin2020and,as
such,basedontherequirementsof
theCodeanexternalvaluationwas
duein2023.
TheBoardiscommittedtocomplying
withtheCoderequirementsforan
externalevaluationwhichprovides
theopportunityforanindependent
viewofprogress,effectivenessand
providesinsightsintopotentialnew
areasoffocus.Assuch,Linstockwere
appointedtosupportanexternal
reviewprocessin2023.
For2023andinto2024thereview
processalsoprovidesuswiththe
opportunitytosupportthetransition
oftheChairoftheBoardrole.
Further details on the external
review process can be found
in the Corporate Governance
report and Board Governance and
Nominations Committee report.
Board priorities in 2024
ThecompositionoftheBoardand
ongoingsuccessionplanningforkey
roleswillremainafocusin2024.The
BoardGovernanceandNominations
Committeewillcontinuetosupport
theBoardtoensurerobustplans
areinplacetomaintaintheongoing
effectivenessandstabilityofthe
Board.
IwillberetiringasChairoftheBoard
attheendofourAnnualGeneral
MeetinginApril2024andIlook
forwardtoworkingwithAnnemarie
untilshesucceedsmeastheChairof
theYBSBoard.Ithasbeenaprivilege
toservesucharesilientorganisation
withastrongsenseofpurposeover
thelastnineyears.
John Heaps
ChairoftheBoard
64 | Governance 65
Corporate Governance report
Corporate Governance report (continued)
UK Corporate Governance Code Compliance 2023
Forthe2023financialyearwehaveappliedtheprinciplesandcompliedwiththeprovisions
oftheCodepublishedinJuly2018(availableontheFinancialReportingCouncil’swebsite
frc.org.uk)asfarastheyapplytobuildingsocieties(assetoutintheBuildingSocieties
Association(BSA)Guidanceavailableatbsa.org.uk)subjecttothefollowing:
•
Asamutualorganisationwedo
nothavesharesorshareholders
thereforereferencestolong-
termshareholdingsinrelationto
remuneration(Provision36)do
notapply.Wedo,however,seekto
applytheprovisionsoftheCode
thatreferenceshareholdersas
appropriatetoourmembersandin
accordancewiththeBSA’sguidance.
•
Provision19oftheCodeexpectsthattheChairshouldnotremaininpost
beyondnineyearsfromthedateoftheirfirstappointmenttotheBoard.
However,tofacilitateeffectivesuccessionplanningtheperiodcanbeextended
foralimitedtime,particularlyinthosecaseswherethechairwasanexisting
Non-ExecutiveDirectoronappointment.JohnHeaps,ourcurrentChairofthe
BoardreachednineyearsofserviceinNovember2023havingjoinedtheBoard
asChairoftheBoardDesignateinNovember2014beforeformallybecoming
theChairoftheBoardattheAnnualGeneralMeetinginApril2015.Following
carefulconsideration,andontherecommendationoftheBoardGovernanceand
NominationsCommittee,theBoardagreedtoextendMrHeapstermofofficeto
theendoftheAnnualGeneralMeetingin2024.MrHeapsdidnottakepartin
thedecisionsinrelationtohistermofoffice.
ThedecisiontoextendMrHeaps’termofofficebeyondnineyears,forashort,
time-limitedperiod,wasspecificallytosupportthesuccessionoftheChairof
theBoardroleandallowforanappropriatehandoverperiodwithAnnemarie
DurbinaftershejoinedtheBoardasChairoftheBoardDesignateinDecember
2023.Thisapproachwillensuretheongoingcontinuityandstabilityofthe
Boardduringthisperiodandsupportitsongoingeffectiveness.
Board leadership and the Society’s purpose
Our Board and Committee structure
The Terms of Reference for the Board, Remuneration, Audit, Group Risk and Board Governance and Nominations
Committees are on our website.
InOctober2022theBoardestablishedanadditionalCommittee,calledtheChairoftheBoardSuccessionCommittee,to
leadtherecruitmentprocessforthesuccessionoftheChairoftheBoardonbehalfofitandtheBoardGovernanceand
NominationsCommittee.TheChairoftheBoardSuccessionCommitteewasformallydissolvedfromthegovernancestructure
in2023followingtheconclusionoftherecruitmentprocessandapprovaloftheappointmentoftheChairoftheBoard
Designate.
Details of the membership and role of the Committee are set out in the Board Governance and Nominations
Committee report.
Chair’s
Committee
Remuneration
Committee
Audit
Committee
Group Risk
Committee
Board Governance
and Nominations
Committee
Chair -
John Heaps
Considersadhoc
mattersspecifically
delegatedtoitbythe
Board.
Membersarethe
ChairoftheBoard,
ViceChairand
ChiefExecutiveor
anyotherDirector
appointedbythe
Board.
Chair -
Debra Davies
Overseesthe
developmentand
implementationof
theRemuneration
Policyforall
colleagues.
Chair -
Guy Bainbridge
ReportstotheBoard
onfinancialreporting,
internalcontrolsand
riskmanagement
systems,environment
socialandgovernance
reporting,Internal
AuditandExternal
Audit.
Chair -
Angela Darlington
OverseesPrudential
Risk,Operational
RiskandConduct
Risk,RiskStrategy,
Appetiteand
Oversight.
Chair -
John Heaps
OverseesBoard
governance,including
composition,
successionand
appointment
processesforthe
Board.
Chair – John Heaps
Collectivelyresponsibleforthelong-termsuccessoftheSociety.
TheBoarddelegatescertainmatterstoBoardCommitteessothattheycanbeconsideredinmoredetailbythosedirectors
whohavethemostrelevantskillsandexperiencetodoso.
Board
Board Committees
Executive Committee ('ExCo') Executive Risk Committee ('ERC')
Chair - Susan Allen, Chief Executive
Overseesanddirectsthemanagementofallaspectsof
theSocietywithdelegatedauthorityfromtheBoard.
AllChiefOfficersaremembers.
Chair - Richard Wells, Chief Risk Officer
Overseesdaytodayriskmanagementactivitywith
delegatedauthorityfromtheGroupRiskCommittee.
66 | Governance 67
Climate and environmental
governance
InlinewiththePrudentialRegulation
Authority('PRA')expectations(SS3/19)
andourcommitmenttoaligningour
operationstoTaskForceonClimate
RelatedFinancialDisclosures('TCFD')
principles,theSocietyhascreateda
robustgovernanceprocessfortherisks
associatedwithenvironmentaland
climatechange.
You can read more about our
climate governance in the
Strategic report.
Board’s responsibilities
TheBoardisaccountabletoour
membersforactingintheirbest
interests.Itsroleandresponsibilities
aresetoutinitsTermsofReference
andinclude:
•
Collectiveresponsibilityforthe
success,includinglong-termsuccess,
oftheSociety.
•
OverallmanagementofSociety
withinaframeworkofrisk
management(includingapprovalof
riskappetite).
•
Establishingthepurpose,valuesand
strategyoftheSociety.
•
Establishingasustainablebusiness
model.
•
Developingthedesiredcultureand
settingthe‘tonefromthetop’.
•
OversightoftheSociety’s
operations.
•
Reviewofperformanceinlightof
theStrategyandCorporatePlan.
TheBoardretainscertainkeymatters
foritsownapprovalwhichitdoesnot
delegatetoanyofitscommitteesor
anyindividual.
These are set out in a Schedule
of Matters Reserved which can
be found on our website at ybs.
co.uk/board.
Setting our purpose and generating long-term success
TheBoardiscommittedtodeliveringourpurposeofprovidingRealHelpwithReal
Lifeaswellascreatinglong-termvalueforourmembersandotherstakeholders
throughgoodgovernanceandkeepstheSociety’spurposeandlong-termsuccess
underreview.
SomeofthekeyelementsthatsupporttheBoardinitsroleinclude:
Further information on our priorities, purpose and behaviours can be found
in the Strategic report.
Strong and robust
corporate governance
framework
TheBoardandCommitteegovernancestructure
supportseffectivedecisionmakingensuringit
alignswiththeSociety’spurposeandstrategy.
Board composition EnsuringtheBoardanditsCommitteesremainfit
forpurpose,withtherightskillsandexperience,
enablesittocontinuetobeeffectiveandableto
workforthelong-termsuccessoftheSocietyfor
ourmembers.
Strategy EnsuringtheSocietyhasacleardirection
whichenablesittoaddresscurrentandfuture
opportunitiesandchallenges.
Risk management Ensuringcontinuousidentificationandreview
ofprincipalbusinessrisksandhowtherisks
couldaffecttheSociety’spurposeandlong-term
success,takingintoaccounttheagreedrisk
appetite.
Compliance Goodcorporategovernanceensuresthatwemeet
legalandregulatoryrequirementsandavoidany
consequencesofnotdoingso.
Culture Strongbehaviourswhichsupportthedeliveryof
ourpurposeandstrategy.
Stakeholder
engagement
Engagementwithandparticipationfromkey
stakeholderssuchasourmembersandcolleagues
supportsdecisionmakingandthelong-term
successoftheSocietyforourmembers.
Brand and reputation Aclearandeffectiveframeworkofcorporate
governanceprovidesconfidencetoour
stakeholders,supportingapositivebrand
reputation.
Environment Social
Governance (ESG)
strategy
OurESGcommitmentsandgoalssupportthe
deliveryofourpurpose.
Finance Ensuringstrongcapitalandliquiditymanagement.
People Ensuringpoliciesandproceduresareconsistent
withtheSociety’spurposeandbehaviours.
Board activities in 2023
OurBoard’sactivitiesduringtheyeararebasedaroundanannualcyclewhichisplannedonarolling12-monthbasisto
makesureitmeetsitsresponsibilitiesandoverseesoverallmanagementofouroperations.
TheBoardagendaalsoincludesadditionalitemsasrequiredduringtheyeartogetherwiththefollowingstandingitems
presentedtoeachmeeting:
•
ReportoftheChairoftheBoard
•
Member,MarketandCompetitorUpdate
•
ChiefExecutiveOfficerReport
•
BusinessReview
•
BoardandCommitteeupdatesandminutes
ExamplesofsomeofthetopicsdiscussedandprincipaldecisionsmadebytheBoardduringtheyeararesetoutbelow
togetherwithanykeystakeholderimplications:
Principal Decision Examples Key stakeholder implications
Approval of Annual Report
and Accounts and Interim
Financial Statements
C
M&C
G&R
I
P
CO
Approval of 2023
Internal Capital Adequacy
Assessment Process (ICAAP)
C
M&C
G&R
Approval of Internal
Liquidity Adequacy
Assessment Process (ILAAP)
C
M&C
G&R
Approval of key policies,
such as Whistleblowing
Policy
C
M&C
G&R
Approval of Operational
Resilience Self-Assessment
C
M&C
G&R
I
Approval of the Society’s
Modern Slavery
Transparency Statement
C
M&C
G&R
I
P
CO
Approval of appointment of
Non-Executive Directors
C
M&C
G&R
Key Topic Examples Key stakeholder implications
Strategic Context Review
C
M&C
G&R
I
Consumer Duty Updates
C
M&C
G&R
P
Colleague Engagement
Updates
C
Cyber Security Updates
C
M&C
G&R
Change Portfolio Updates
C
M&C
G&R
Environment Social
Governance Updates
C
M&C
I
P
CO
Balance Sheet Management
Strategy
C
M&C
G&R
I
Strategy sessions in 2023
TheBoardalsoholdsseparatestrategysessionseachyearandin2023twosessionswereheldtoreviewthestrategic
directionoftheSociety.Thesessionsconsideredthefuturestrategytoensureitcontinuedtobuildshort-termresilience
whilstdevelopinganapproachtobuildinglong-termprofitabilityandgrowthinlinewithourMemberValuepriorityandour
dutytoourmemberstooperatearesponsibleandresilientbusiness.
EachstrategysessionwasattendedbyallBoardmemberswithmembersoftheseniorleadershipteaminvitedtoattendto
presentrelevantitems,supportedbyexternaladvisorswhereappropriate.
During2023theBoardhasbeenfocusedontheevolutionanddeliveryoftheSociety’sStrategy,engagingwiththeExecutive
CommitteeandSeniorLeadershipTeam.
Keytopicsconsideredduring2023coveredmeetingcustomerneedsandconnectingwithourmembers,supportedby
discussionsonbrand,mortgageandsavingsmarketparticipation,futureoftheretailnetwork,futureofretailfinancial
services,inspiringandempoweringourpeople,changeandourCorporatePlan.
C
Colleagues
M&C
Members&Customers
G&R
GovernmentandRegulators
I
Investors
P
Partners
CO
Communities
Key
Corporate Governance report (continued)
Board leadership and the Society’s purpose (continued)
68 | Governance 69
Our Board’s engagement
with stakeholders
TheBoardrecognisestheimportanceof
maintainingastrongrelationshipwithits
stakeholdersincludingthecontributionit
makestoachievingtheSociety’spurpose
anddeliveringitsstrategy.Thisincludes
understandingtheviews,areasofinterest
and/orconcernsofourkeystakeholders
whenitcomestodecisionmaking.
EachreporttotheBoardincludes,whereappropriate,details
ofanyconsultationundertakenwithkeystakeholders
togetherwithanyimpact,orpotentialimpact,adecisionmay
haveonrelevantstakeholders.Theperformanceinformation
providedtotheBoardalsocoverskeyareasrelevanttothe
Society’sstakeholders.
DetailsofhowourBoardengageswithourmembersandour
colleaguesaresetoutinthesectionsbelow.
OurBoardalsoengageswithotherstakeholderssuchas
investors,regulators,partners(suchasbrokers,agency
proprietors,tradeunions),industrybodiesandcommunities
asrequired.
Examplesinclude:
•
Updatesinrelationtoregulatorymatters.
•
Responsetoconsultations.
•
Membershipofindustrybodiesandinvolvementin
industryconferencesandforums.
•
Regularupdatesinrelationtokeystakeholderactivities,
suchasinrelationtoourcommunityintereststrategyand
resilienceofkeysuppliers.
•
Feedbackfromtradeunions(throughtheRemuneration
Committee).
•
Visitstobrokers.
For more details on how the wider Society engages
with its key stakeholders see the stakeholder section
in the Strategic report.
Our members and customers
Asabuildingsocietywedonothaveexternalshareholdersandinsteadweareownedby,andarethereforthebenefitof,our
members.WearecommittedtoensuringtheSocietyisruneffectivelyontheirbehalfandthisincludesusingfeedbackonour
activitiestoinformtheBoard’sdecisions.
Examplesofhowwegetthisfeedbackfromourmembersandcustomersinclude:
Annual General
Meeting
OurAnnualGeneralMeeting('AGM')providestheBoardwiththeopportunitytopresentto
ourmembersdetailsofhowweperformedduringthepreviousyear,ourplansforthefuture
and,wherecircumstancesallow,togivethemanopportunitytoaskquestionsandprovide
feedback.
In2023forthefirsttimeourmembersjoiningusonlinewerealsoabletovoteandask
questions.ItisimportantthatourmembersareabletohavetheirsayatourAGMsoeven
iftheyareunabletoattendinpersonorjoinusonlinewestronglyencouragealleligible
memberstoexercisetheirrightstovote.Memberswerealsoabletocall,emailorwritewith
theirquestionsandresponseswereissuedinatimelymanner.
VotingattheAGMisoneoftheimportantwaysinwhichourmemberscangetinvolvedand
voteonimportantmatters,includingthedirectorswhorepresentthemontheBoard.TheUK
CorporateGovernanceCodeexpectsthatifthereisavoteof20percentormoreagainstany
resolutionputforwardbyourBoardattheAGM,weshouldgivedetailsofhowwewillconsult
ourmemberstounderstandthereasonwhy.TheSocietyhasaprocessinplaceifthishappens.
Therewere,however,novotesof20percentormoreagainstanyoftheresolutionsourBoard
putforwardatthe2023AGM.
Member Champion
/ Consumer Duty
Champion
TheBoardhasaNon-ExecutiveDirectorMemberChampionroletoensurethecontinued
prominenceofourmembersvoiceindiscussionsandsupportalldirectorsintheirdutytoact
inthebestinterestsofourmembersandcustomers.
OurcurrentMemberChampionisNon-ExecutiveDirectorMarkParsonswhoisalsotheBoard’s
ConsumerDutyChampion.
My Voice
(Online community)
OurMyVoicepanelisouronlinecommunitywherememberscaninteractwiththeSocietythrough
arangeofchannelsandcommentonabroadrangeofservicesandcustomerjourneyssowecan
continuetoimproveandmakesurewearegettingthingsright.ResearchthroughMyVoiceisdone
inavarietyofways,suchasquickpolls,surveysanddiscussionswithothermembers.
Aswellasaquarterly‘moodtracker’,topicscoveredin2023haveincludedtheuseofChatbots,
savingsratenotifications,attitudestowardISAsandfinancialplanningforlaterlife.
Your Time to Talk
(In branch events)
WeholdYourTimetoTalkEventstoenablememberstohearfirst-handhowwearelooking
aftertheirinterests.Eventsareheldacrossthecountryandprovidelocalmemberswiththe
opportunitytomeetourseniorteam,askquestionsandmeetourcolleagues.
InJune2023aneventwasheldattheRoyalArmouriesMuseuminLeedswheremembers
wereabletolistentoapresentationonMakingtheMostofYourSavings.
ThiswasfollowedbyaQuestionandAnswersessionwithsomeofourseniorteam;Susan
Allen,ChiefExecutive;DavidMorris,ChiefCommercialOfficer;andJennelleTilling,Non-
ExecutiveDirector.Thequestionscoveredtopicssuchasthefutureofbranches,housing
marketandthechallengesfortheyoungergeneration,artificialintelligenceandthepotential
foracashlesssociety.
Your Time to Talk
(Online events)
OurfirstonlineYourTimetoTalkeventwasheldon23November2023providingsomeofour
memberswiththeopportunitytojoinourpanelofexpertsforinsightintowhatishappening
inthemarketandwhatthismeansforthem.
Membersalsohadtheopportunitytoaskquestionsandgivetheirthoughtsthroughpollsand
wordclouds,sowecouldseeexactlywhatmatterstothem.
Operational visits OurBoardrecognisesthecontributionoperationalvisitstoareassuchasbranchesand
customerfacingteamsmaketothecontinuedunderstandingofwhatismostimportanttoour
membersandcustomers.
Other Otherareasoffeedbackinclude:
•
NetPromoterScore('NPS')tracking.
•
BrandTracker.
•
Membercasestudies.
•
AnalysisofprofileandbehaviourofYBScustomersegments.
•
Adhocresearchwithmembersthroughonlinesurveysorfocusgroups.
•
Adhocinsightsuchascommissionedresearch.
Corporate Governance report (continued)
70 | Governance 71
Our colleagues
OurBoardremainscommittedtoensuringthereiseffective
engagementwithourcolleagues.Animportantpartofour
engagementframeworkisthequarterlyColleagueForum,
thathascolleaguerepresentationfromacrosstheSociety
andtheNon-ExecutiveDirectorforWorkforceEngagement
attends.AlisonHutchinsonhasheldtheroleofNon-
ExecutiveDirectorforWorkforceEngagementsince2019,
withAngelaDarlingtontakingoverthispositioninJanuary
2024.
OneofthekeyrolesoftheColleagueForumistohelp
informbetterBoarddiscussionsanddecisions,ensuring
colleagues’viewsareheardandconsidered.TheColleague
Forumisdesignedtoexplorefeedbackfromcolleagueson
specificBoardtopicsandtoenableunstructureddiscussion
tocaptureanyotherconcernstoo.
FollowingamovetovirtualmeetingsduringtheCovid-19
pandemic,theColleagueForumhascontinuedtomature
andevolvewithtwoofthefoursessionsnowtakingplace
inpersontoallowcolleaguestonetworkmoreeasily.The
Forumcontinuestobewellattendedbycolleagueswhoare
thoroughlyprepared,passionateandbringqualityfeedback
toparticipatefullyindiscussions.
Colleaguecommunicationshavefocusedonbuildingwider
awarenessoftheForum’spurpose,tobuildbeliefandto
reinforcethatdiverseperspectivesareactivelywelcomedat
YBS.TheadditionofColleagueNetworkChairsasattendees
hasalsoensuredwehaveastrong,diverserepresentation.
IntermsofwhatisdiscussedatColleagueForum,wetook
adifferentapproachin2023toensurethetopicswere
timelierandmorealignedtotheExecutiveCommitteeand
Boardstrategicrunway.Thisledtousexploringthefollowing
areas:BusinessTransformation,CustomerCentricity,Career
ProgressionandUnderlyingSkillsandourEnvironmental,
SocialandGovernancepriorities.
Followingeachquarterlyforum,theNon-ExecutiveDirector
forWorkforceEngagementprovidesasummaryofcolleague
viewstoBoard.TheForumChair,TinaHugheswhoisDirector
ofMarketing&DigitalChannels,alsosharesoutputswith
theExecutiveCommitteeandanyactionsarefedbackatthe
nextColleagueForum.Theeffectivenessofthisfeedback
loopisanareathatcontinuestostrengthen,particularlyas
membersoftheSeniorLeadershipTeamarerotatingtheir
attendanceateachForumtodirectlyhearcolleagues’views.
AlongsidetheColleagueForumwealsohaveseveralother
channelsforcolleaguestoprovidefeedbackandsharetheir
viewsinconfidence:
•
Wehaveaflowofregularengagementtemperaturecheck
surveystosupplementafullengagementsurveyatthe
yearend.
•
Allcolleaguesarealsoencouragedtocompleteour
Diversity,EquityandInclusionsurveyannually.
•
Boardlisteningsessionscontinuebiannuallyfor
colleaguestoraiseanyquestionstheyhavedirectlywith
ourNon-ExecutiveDirectors.
•
ColleaguescanattendworkingluncheswithourExecutive
Committeeand‘AskMeAnything’sessionswithourChief
Executiveonaregularbasis.
•
WehaveadirectlinktoourChiefExecutiveviaour
‘StraighttoSusan’mailboxwitheachmessagereceivinga
personalresponse.
AllBoardandCommitteepapersarestructuredtoensure
thateachoneincludesdetailsofhowcolleagueviewshave
beentakenintoaccounttoinformanyrecommendations
togetherwithanypotentialimplicationsforcolleagues.The
Boardalsoreceivesanannualassessmentandupdateonthe
frameworkforcolleagueengagement.
Therearemanytangibleexamplesthatdemonstrate
theinfluenceofcolleagueviews,continuingtoshow
thatfeedbackisbeingheard.Theprogress,impactand
outcomesofourengagementframeworkshowsupthrougha
combinationofchangestopolicyorpracticeandthosemore
intangiblebenefitsthateffectiveengagementcanbring.
ExamplesofhowcolleaguefeedbackhasbeenkeytosupportingcolleaguesacrossYBSinclude:
Connecting colleagues to
their role in transforming
the business
DuringtheMarch2023Forum,
whichcoveredthetopicofBusiness
Transformation,werecognisedsome
colleagueswerenotclearonwhat
thismeansforthemandtheirpart
inhelpingtomakethishappen
toimprovetheexperienceofour
membersandcustomers.OurSenior
ManagerofBusinessTransformation
attendedthefeedbacksession
whichresultedinherwriting
anarticle“Thepathtoreal
transformationstartswithyou.”This
clearlylaidoutwhattransformation
reallymeans,whyitmatters,and
therolecolleaguesneedtoplayin
helpingourtransformationhappen.
Thiswaswellreceivedbycolleagues
andgeneratedpositivefeedback
fromacrossthebusiness.
Climate check-ins
ThesediscussionstakeplaceattheendofeachColleagueForumand
remainanessentialpartoftheagendatoprovideasafespacetoraise
itemsoutsideofthemaindiscussiontopic.Oneexampleofthiswas
ConsumerDutywherecolleaguesfelttheyneededmoreinformation.
Asaresult,weprovidedadditionalcommunicationstocolleagueswhich
includedadedicatedConsumerDutypageontheIntranet,aQuestionand
Answervideoandregularblogsandfeaturestokeepcolleaguesupdated
withprogress.
Improving our intranet
OurIntranethasbeenahottopicofconversationacrossall
forumsinthepast12monthsandtheirtenacityhasproved
invaluable.WiththehelpoftheForumChair,progressto
movetheIntranettotheCloudwasacceleratedwhichnow
allowsfornewfeatures,andthereisateaminplacelooking
atwhatourIntranetprovisionwilllooklikegoingforwards.
TheimprovementstoourIntranetwillassistourcolleaguesin
supportingourmembers.
Providing better cost
of living support
Followingadiscussionon
thetopicofcostoflivingin
December2022,acost-of-
livinghubwascreatedonour
Intranettoenablecolleagues
tofindinformationabout
helpandsupportquicklyand
easilybothforthemselves,
ourcustomersandour
communities.
Corporate Governance
report (continued)
Our Board’s engagement
with stakeholders
(continued)
72 | Governance 73
Our culture
TheBoardrecognisesthat‘how’we
workasanorganisationiscritical
andourbehavioursdrivetrue
differentiationsettingouttheculture
wewishtofoster.
Ourcultureandbehavioursare
promotedthroughouttheorganisation
byourBoardandSeniorLeadership
Team,throughlearningand
developmentaswellasthrougha
rangeofactivitiessuchasworkforce
engagement,performancereviews,
remunerationpolicies,recruitment,
successionplanningandinclusionand
diversity.
TheBoardiskeyinoverseeingand
monitoringcultureandhowour
behavioursareembeddedaspartof
theSociety’swiderstrategytakinginto
account:
•
ColleagueEngagementincluding
ColleagueListeningGroupsandour
ColleagueForum.
•
FeedbackfromtheNon-Executive
DirectorforWorkforceEngagement.
•
EmployeeSurveyResults.
•
PeopleUpdates.
•
HealthandSafetyUpdates.
•
WhistleblowingUpdates.
•
OperationalSiteVisits.
Whistleblowing
Wearecommittedtomakingsure
thatanyone,includingourcolleagues,
canbeconfidentthatanyconcerns
raisedwithuswillbetakenseriously
andtreatedasconfidential.Nobody
willbethesubjectofvictimisation,
subsequentdiscriminationor
disadvantageforreportingtheir
concerns,whatevertheoutcome.
Weadvocateacultureofopenness,
accountabilityandintegritywhereby
individualsfeelconfidenttoreportand
raisegenuineconcerns,withoutthe
riskofexperiencinganyretributionas
aresult,eveniftheconcernturnsout
tobemistaken.
TheSocietyhasaWhistleblowing
Policywhichsetsoutourapproachto
whistleblowing.Ourwhistleblowing
processesareintendedtoensurethat
theSocietyinvestigatesanddeals
withdisclosuresfairly,promptlyand
properly.ThisenablestheSocietyto
beinformedatanearlystageabout
fraudulent,immoralormalicious
activitiesormisconduct,inorder
toenableappropriateactionstobe
initiated.
OurBoardapprovesthe
WhistleblowingPolicyonanannual
basisandoverseesitsimplementation.
TheSocietyalsohasaWhistleblowing
Championwhoisakeypointof
contactforindividualswhowishto
reportconcerns.Asreportedinour
AnnualReportandAccountsfor2022,
GuyBainbridgewasappointedtothe
rolewitheffectfrom1January2023.
AllcolleaguesandourNon-Executive
Directorsalsocompleteanannual
whistleblowinge-learningcourse.
Directors’ duties
Section172oftheCompaniesAct
2006describesthedutiesofcompany
directorsinrespecttopromoting
thebusinessandconsideringother
stakeholders.Thisdoesnotapplyto
theSociety’sDirectorsaswearea
mutualbuildingsocietynotacompany,
buttheUKCorporateGovernance
Codeexpectsboardstoreportonhow
theyhaveconsideredthemattersset
outinSection172indecisionmaking.
Our Section 172 Statement is set
out in the Directors report.
Conflicts of interest
OurBoardhasaConflictsofInterest
PolicyforDirectorsandChiefOfficers
whichsetsouthowwewillreview
and,whereappropriate,approve
anyconflictsorpotentialconflictsof
interest.ThePolicyisreviewedonan
annualbasisbytheBoardGovernance
andNominationsCommitteeand
recommendedtotheBoardfor
approval.
Anyinterestsandassociatedconflicts
arerecordedinaRegisterofInterests
whichisreviewedandapprovedbyour
BoardGovernanceandNominations
Committeeateachquarterlymeeting.
Ifanydirectorwantstotakeona
newexternalpositionitmustfirstbe
approvedbyourBoard,whichwill
considerwhethertherecouldbeany
conflictsofinterestand/oranimpact
onthetimetheycommittotheirrole
withtheSociety.
Division of responsibilities
Board roles and division of responsibilities
Independence
AlltheNon-ExecutiveDirectorscontinuetobeconsideredindependentbasedontheguidancesetoutintheCode.TheChair
oftheBoardandtheChairoftheBoardDesignatewereconsideredtobeindependentonappointment.
Chair of
the Board
Chief Executive
Vice Chair / Senior
Independent Director
Non-Executive Directors
Executive Directors
Group Secretary
Non-Executive
Director
Executive Director
•
LeadershipoftheBoard.
•
EnsurestheBoardacts
effectively,promotinghigh
standardsofcorporate
governance.
•
Leadsannualreviewofthe
performanceoftheBoard,its
committeesanddirectors.
•
Identifiesongoingdevelopment
needsoftheBoard.
•
LeadstheBoardinthe
developmentoftheSociety’s
culture.
•
OverallresponsibilityformanagingtheSociety.
•
Implementsthestrategiesandpoliciesagreed
bytheBoard,supportedbytheExecutiveTeam,
throughanumberofmanagementandrisk
committees.
•
ResponsibleforadvisingtheChairoftheBoardandtheBoardasawholeonallcorporategovernancematters.
•
Responsiblefortheday-to-daymanagementof
specificareasofthebusinessincludingmaintaining
theSociety’sfinancialstrengthandsustainability.
•
Bringsassociatedskillsandknowledgetotheboard.
•
Deputisesforandprovides
supportandguidancetothe
ChairoftheBoard.
•
Actsasanintermediaryfor
otherdirectors.
•
Leadstheperformance
evaluationoftheChairofthe
Board.
•
Actsasthemainpointof
contactfortheSociety’s
membersshouldthenormal
channelsofcommunicationfail.
•
Responsibleforbringing
independentjudgementto
Boarddecisionsanddebate.
•
Usestheirownexperience
andskillstoconstructively
challengetheExecutiveTeam.
Corporate Governance report (continued)
Our Board’s engagement with stakeholders (continued)
74 | Governance 75
Attendance at Board and Committee meetings
ThetablebelowshowsourdirectorsandthescheduledBoardandCommitteemeetingstheyattendedduring2023(where
theywereamemberduringtheyear)followedbythenumberofmeetingsthedirectorwaseligibletoattend.
In2023thefollowingadhocmeetingswereheldat
shortnotice:
•
OnemeetingoftheBoardtodiscusstheoutcomesofthe
Governance,RiskandControlsReview.
•
TwomeetingsoftheBoardGovernanceandNominations
CommitteeinrelationtotherecruitmentofNon-Executive
DirectorsandBoardcompositionandsuccessionplanning.
•
ThreemeetingsoftheRemunerationCommitteeinrelation
totheappointmentoftheChiefOperatingOfficerandthe
reviewoftheRewardPolicy.
Ifadirectorcannotattendameetingtheywillreceivethe
papersandprovideanycommentstheyhavetotheChairof
themeetingbeforehand.
AnnemarieDurbinjoinedtheBoardon18December2023andassuchdidnotattendanyBoardmeetingsin2023.
TheChairoftheBoardandChiefExecutiveareinvitedto
attendallCommitteemeetingsandtheChiefRiskOfficeris
invitedtoattendallBoardmeetings.
IfanurgentdecisionisneededwhenthereisnotaBoard
meetingadecisioncanbetakeninwriting(knownasa
writtenresolution)ifthereisapprovalfromalldirectors(or
membersinthecaseofacommittee).OurRulessetoutthe
procedureforwrittenresolutionsandthiswasusedduring
theyear:
•
ThreetimesbytheBoard.
•
OnetimebytheBoardGovernanceandNominations
Committee.
•
OnetimebytheAuditCommittee.
•
OnetimebytheRemunerationCommittee.
Director Board
Board
Strategy
Board Committees
Chair's Audit
Board Governance
and Nominations Remuneration Group Risk
Non-Executive Directors
John Heaps 9/9 2/2 Nomeetings
requiredin2023
i
– 4/4 – –
Alison Hutchinson 9/9 2/2 Nomeetings
requiredin2023
i
– 4/4 5/5 4/4
Guy Bainbridge 9/9 2/2 – 4/4 4/4 – 4/4
Angela Darlington 9/9 2/2 – 4/4 – – 4/4
Debra Davies
ii
4/4 1/1 – – – 2/2 –
Dina Matta 9/9 2/2 – – – 5/5 –
Mark Parsons 9/9 2/2 – 4/4 – – 4/4
Jennelle Tilling 9/9 2/2 – – – 4/5 –
Executive Directors
Susan Allen
iii
7/7 2/2 Nomeetings
requiredin2023
1
– – – –
Alasdair Lenman 9/9 2/2 – – – – –
David Morris 9/9 2/2 – – – – –
i. MeetingsonlyheldwhenrequiredtoconsideradhocmattersspecificallydelegatedtoitbytheBoard.
ii. DebraDaviesjoinedtheBoardandtheRemunerationCommitteeon26July2023andtheGroupRiskCommitteeon18October2023(pendingapprovalof
theappointmenttoGroupRiskCommittee,DebraDavieswasanattendeeatthemeetingon16October2023priortobecomingaformalmember).
iii SusanAllenjoinedtheBoardon2March2023.
Directors’ time commitment and
other directorships
AllNon-ExecutiveDirectorshavetomakesurethat
theyhaveenoughtimefortheresponsibilitiesof
theirroleandtosupportthis:
•
Availabilityandothercommitmentsarereviewed
andtakenintoaccountwhenrecruitingnewNon-
ExecutiveDirectors.
•
EachNon-ExecutiveDirectorhasaletterof
appointmentwhichsetsouttheexpectedtime
commitmentfortherole.
•
IfaDirectorisintendingtotakeonanadditional
externalappointmentthisisreviewedand,if
appropriate,approvedbeforeitistakenup.Our
Boardwillconsidertheimpactanyadditionalrole
wouldhaveonthetimetheycouldcommitto
theirrolewiththeSociety.
•
Areviewoftimecommitmentisalsoincludedas
partoftheone-to-onesessionsheldeachyear
withindividualdirectors.
Priortoappointmentthesignificantcommitments,
includingthetimeinvolved,forNon-Executive
Directorsisdisclosedandreviewed.
For2023thisincluded:
•
DebraDavies,Non-ExecutiveDirector–joinedthe
SocietyinJuly2023
•
AnnemarieDurbin,ChairoftheBoardDesignate–
joinedtheSocietyinDecember2023.
Therewerenosignificantappointmentswhich
requiredapprovalforexistingNon-Executive
Directors,however,theBoardGovernanceand
NominationsCommitteecontinuedtomonitorall
commitmentsthroughouttheyearthroughthe
RegisterofInterests.
NoneoftheExecutiveDirectorshaveheldany
non-executivedirectorshipsinaFTSE100company
during2023.
Composition, succession and
evaluation
Election and re-election of directors
Allofourdirectorsaresubjecttoelectionon
appointmentandannualre-electionbyour
membersattheAGMbasedonthebestpracticeset
outintheCode(ourRulesrequirethere-electionof
ourdirectorstotakeplaceatleastonceeverythree
years).
Detailsofeachindividualdirector’scontribution
aresetoutinthebookletaccompanyingtheNotice
ofAGMsenttoallqualifyingmembers.Theprofiles
inthe
OurBoardandExecutiveTeamSection
,and
availableonourwebsite,alsosetouttheskillsand
experienceofindividualdirectors.
Further information in relation to Inclusion and
Diversity can be found in the Board Governance and
Nominations Committee report.
Board gender balance
(asat31December2023)
58%
female membership
Women
58%
Men
42%
Board ethnicity
(asat31December2023)
1 director
from an ethnic
minority
background
Board tenure
(asat31December2023)
3.2 years
average tenure
50%
25%
17%
8%
0-2Years 3-4Years 5-7Years 8-9Years
Board composition
Rolling four year female representation
2023
58%
2022
44%
2021
40%
2022
20%
White(including
anyotherwhite
background)
Minority
Ethnic
Background
11
1
Corporate Governance report (continued)
Division of responsibilities (continued)
76 | Governance 77
Tenure
AsummaryofthetenureofthecurrentBoardissetoutintheBoardCompositionsection.
TheChairoftheBoard,JohnHeaps,wasappointedasaNon-ExecutiveDirectorandChairDesignatein2014andbecame
ChairoftheBoardin2015.Assuch,hereachednineyearsofserviceinNovember2023,however,followingcareful
considerationontherecommendationoftheBoardGovernanceandNominationsCommittee,theBoardagreedtoextendhis
termofofficetotheendoftheAnnualGeneralMeetingin2024.Fulldetailsinrelationtotherationalefortheextensionin
termaresetoutintheUKCorporateGovernanceCodeCompliance2023sectionofthisreport.
For further details on Non-Executive Director tenure see the Terms of Office section of the Board Governance and
Nominations Committee report.
Annual review of Board performance 2022
AsreportedintheAnnualReportandAccountsfor2022,aninternalperformancereviewwascompletedfortheBoardandits
Committeesin2022.TheoutcomeswerediscussedbytheBoardatitsmeetinginJanuary2023andwereusedtoinformthe
BoardEffectivenessActionPlanfor2023.
Keythemesforthe2023ActionPlanincluded:
Theme Background Update
Board
composition
and succession
Maintainingthesuccession
planningprogrammeand
managingthetransitionto
anewChiefExecutiveand
ChairoftheBoard.
SuccessionplansaremanagedonanongoingbasisbytheBoard
GovernanceandNominationsCommittee.
Clearinductionplansandcomprehensivehandoverswereputin
placeforthetransitionforboththeChiefExecutiveandChairof
theBoardrole.
Further details can be found in the Board Governance and
Nomination Committee report.
Board
meetings
Reviewingtheapproachto
Boardagendastoensure
theyremainalignedto
theSociety’spurposeand
strategy.
AdetailedreviewoftheMattersReservedtotheBoardwas
completedin2023toensurethatBoardagendasremainfitfor
purposeandensuretheBoardcanfocusonappropriateareasof
oversight.
Oversight Continuetooversee
keytopicsarisingfrom
aregulatoryorexternal
perspective.
During2023theBoardhasmaintainedoversightofkeyareas,
includingConsumerDuty,ResolvabilityAssessmentFramework,
developmentsinrelationtotheGovernmentconsultationon
RestoringTrustinAuditandCorporateGovernance,costofliving
issuesandthedevelopmentofcryptoanddigitalcurrencies.
For further details on the process followed for the Board and Committee evaluations please see the Board Governance
and Nominations Committee report.
Appointment of external facilitator Evaluation approach
2023 Board and Committee evaluation process
Recommendations and Actions
Afteracomprehensiveprocurementprocess,Lintstock
wereappointedtoundertaketheexternalevaluation.
TheSocietyhasnootherconnectionwithLintstockat
thistime.
Areviewprocesswasundertakenincorporatinga
survey,interviewsandmeetingobservations.
Particularareasoffocusforthe2023reviewincluded
thetransitionoftheChairoftheBoardroleand
prioritiesforthenewChair;theBoard’srelationship
withthenewChiefExecutive;externaldevelopments
suchasthecompetitivelandscape;andsuccession
planningandtalentmanagement.
Basedontheoutcomesoftheevaluationprocess,LintstockproducedareportfortheBoardandCommittees.The
reportwasdiscussedattheBoardmeetinginJanuary2024.
Therewerenourgentorsignificantactionsarisingfromtheinitialdiscussions,however,theBoardhasidentifiedthe
followingthemesforfocusin2024:
•
Overseeingasuccessfultransitioninkeyroles
•
Reviewingthemanagementofmeetings
•
Increasingcohesionfollowingaperiodofchange
•
ContinuingthejourneytothepossibledesignationasacategoryonefirmbythePRA
•
Supportingmanagementindeliveringonthestrategy
TheoveralloutcomesandrecommendationswillbeusedtoinformanyBoardactionsrequiredin2024andanupdate
onprogresswillbeprovidedintheAnnualReportandAccountsfor2024.
Annual evaluation of Board performance 2023
ThelastexternalevaluationoftheBoardwascompletedin2020withinternalevaluationscompletedin2021and2022.In
accordancewiththeCoderequirementsforanexternalevaluationtobecompletedeverythreeyears,itwasagreedthatan
externalevaluationwouldbeundertakenin2023facilitatedbyLintstockinaccordancewiththeprocesssetoutbelow.
Corporate Governance report (continued)
Composition, succession and evaluation (continued)
78 | Governance 79
Board training and
development
TheBoardhasaformalTrainingPlan
toensurethatthereisanoverarching
planinplacefortheBoardasa
whole,settingoutthetrainingand
developmentrequirementsforthe
year.TheTrainingPlanisagreedand
overseenbytheBoardGovernance
andNominationsCommitteeonbehalf
oftheBoardandtakesaccountof
futurestrategy,keytopicswhichwould
benefitfromanexternalperspective,
annualBoardEffectivenessReview,
BoardSkillsMatrix,successionplans
andregulatoryandgovernance
expectations.
TheTrainingPlancoversthose
developmentareaswhicharerequired
fortheBoardasawhole,with
individualtraininganddevelopment
incorporatedintopersonal
developmentplans.
AspartoftheBoardTrainingPlan,
arangeoftopicsareidentifiedfor
externalspeakers/facilitatorsto
providetheBoardwithanexternal
perspectivetosupportstrategy
discussionsandBoarddecision
making.
During2023keyBoardtrainingand
developmenttopicsincluded:
•
CryptoandDigitalCurrency.
•
ExternalMarkets.
•
HedgeRiskManagementand
Accounting(AuditandGroupRisk
Committeetrainingavailabletoall
Boardmembers).
•
ResolvabilityAssessmentFramework.
•
Onlinelearningincluding
ConductRules,overviewof
SeniorManagementFunctionand
ConsumerDuty.
Non-Executive Director induction
AllNon-ExecutiveDirectorshaveafull,formalandtailored
inductionprogrammeonjoiningtheBoard,basedontheir
skillsandexperience,includingwhereappropriateaspecific
inductiontoanyCommitteestheywillbejoining.Role
specificinductionsarealsoarrangedwhereadirectortakes
onanewroleorcommitteemembership.
DebraDaviesjoinedtheBoardasaNon-ExecutiveDirector
inJuly2023andatailoredinductionprogrammewasput
inplacebasedonherexistingexperience,keyareasof
theSocietyandthoserelatingtoherareasofexpertise.A
comprehensivehandoverwasalsoputinplaceinrelation
totheRemunerationCommitteeandhersuccessiontothe
Chairrolefollowingregulatoryapproval.
MoreinformationonourBoardisavailableinothersections
ofthisdocument:
Acomprehensiveinductionprocesshasbeendeveloped
forourChairofBoardDesignate,AnnemarieDurbin,who
joinedtheSocietyon18December2023.Theinductionwill
assistinfacilitatingthehandoveroftheChairoftheBoard
roleandwillbemonitoredbytheBoardGovernanceand
NominationsCommittee.
TheBoardGovernanceandNominationsCommittee
monitorsthecompletionofallNon-ExecutiveDirector
inductions.
Chief Executive induction
AllExecutiveDirectorshaveafull,formalandtailored
inductionprogrammeonjoiningtheSociety,basedontheir
skillsandexperienceandtakingintoaccounttheirroleon
theBoard.SusanAllenjoinedtheSocietyasChiefExecutive
inMarch2023andatailoredinductionprogrammewasput
inplacebasedonherexperienceandtakingintoaccount
allkeyareasoftheSociety.Theinductionprogrammewas
monitoredbytheBoardGovernanceandNominations
CommitteeinaccordancewithitsTermsofReferenceand
wasfullycompletedin2023.
“Realhelpwithreallifeissucha
powerfulmantraandthispurpose
wasamajorpartofwhatattractedme
totheSociety.SincejoiningIhaven’t
beendisappointed.Inthecourseof
myinductionIhavemetteamsfullof
passionate,dedicatedandenergetic
peoplehelpingcustomerseveryday.
I’mlookingforwardtoplayingmy
partindeliveringvalueformembers
alongsidethem.”
Non-Executive Director induction – Debra Davies
Succession
planning for the
Board
See the Board Governance and
Nominations Committee report.
Skills and
experience of
our Board and
Committees
See Our Board and Executive
Team profiles.
Recruitment and
appointment of
Directors
See our Board Governance and
Nominations Committee report.
Board diversity
and inclusion
See our Board Governance and
Nominations Committee report.
Ensuring that
both internal
and external
audit are
effective
More information can be found in
the Audit Committee report.
Setting our risk
appetite
More information can be found in
the Risk Management report.
Our systems of
internal controls
More information on the internal
controls framework can be found
in the Audit Committee report.
Audit, risk and internal control
OurBoardhasoverallresponsibilityforaudit,riskand
internalcontrol,anddelegatesoversighttoitscommittees:
TheBoardreceivesquarterlyreportsfromtheChiefRisk
Officertoenableittomonitortheeffectivenessoftherisk
managementframeworkandinternalcontrolssystems.
TheAuditCommitteereviewstheeffectivenessofinternal
controlsatleastannuallywiththeoutcomesreportedtothe
BoardbytheAuditCommitteeChair.
Remuneration
OurBoardhasaRemunerationCommitteewhichhas
delegatedresponsibilityforsettingthepolicyonthe
remunerationofExecutiveDirectorsaswellassettingthe
remunerationfortheChairoftheBoard,andothermembers
oftheLeadershipTeam.
For further details please see the Directors’
Remuneration report.
TheremunerationofNon-ExecutiveDirectorsisadecision
reservedforourBoard’sapprovalandisreviewedbythe
ExecutiveDirectorsandtheChairoftheBoardonly.
John Heaps
ChairoftheBoard
28February2024
Corporate Governance report (continued)
Composition, succession and evaluation (continued)
80 | Governance 81
Board Governance
and Nominations
Committee Report
AwordfromtheChairofthe
BoardGovernanceand
NominationsCommittee.
Iampleasedtointroducetheannual
reportoftheBoardGovernance
andNominationsCommitteewhich
providesasummaryofthework
undertakenbytheCommitteeduring
2023.
Followingthesuccessfulcompletionofthe
recruitmentprocessforourChiefExecutivein2022,
wewerepleasedtowelcomeSusanAllentothe
BoardinMarch2023.During2023theCommittee
hasprovidedoversightfortheChiefExecutive’s
inductionprocesstoensureasmoothtransitionto
therole.
Thesuccessionplanningandrecruitmentprocess
forkeyNon-ExecutiveDirectorroleshasbeen
apriorityfortheCommitteeduring2023.This
includedtheappointmentprocessforanewChair
oftheBoard,supportedbytheChairoftheBoard
SuccessionCommitteeestablishedforthepurpose
(andchairedbytheViceChair),andournewChair
ofRemunerationCommittee.
TheCommitteehascontinuedtomonitorall
governancedevelopmentsincludingtheposition
inrelationtotheoutcomesoftheGovernment’s
consultationinrelationtoRestoringTrustinAudit
andCorporateGovernance.Theconsultationon
changestotheUKCorporateGovernanceCode
(Code)wasconsideredbytheCommitteein2023
and,followingthepublicationoftherevisedCode
inJanuary2024,itwillreviewtherequirementsas
itappliestoabuildingsociety.
Aswemoveinto2024,theCommitteewill
continuetokeepthemixofskillsandexperience
onourBoardunderreviewtoensuretheyremain
appropriateforthedeliveryofourStrategy,with
strongsuccessionplansinplacetosupportongoing
Boardeffectiveness.
John Heaps
ChairoftheBoardGovernanceand
NominationsCommittee
Board Governance and Nominations
Committee members and meetings
ThemembersoftheCommitteeare:
OnlymembersoftheBoardGovernanceand
NominationsCommitteeareentitledtoattendits
meetings,althoughothersmaybeaskedtoattend
allorpartofameeting.TheChiefExecutive,Chief
PeopleOfficerandGroupSecretaryareusually
invitedtoattendeachmeeting.
TheCommitteemetfourtimesin2023andheldtwo
additionalmeetingsinrelationtoNon-Executive
Directorrecruitmentandfuturesuccessionplanning.
Details of the number of scheduled Committee
meetings attended by each member is
available in the Corporate Governance report.
John Heaps
Chair of the Board and
Committee Chair
Alison Hutchinson
Senior Independent
Non-Executive Director /
Vice Chair
Guy Bainbridge
Independent
Non-Executive Director
Board Governance and Nominations Committee
responsibilities
TheresponsibilitiesoftheBoardGovernanceandNominations
Committeeinclude:
•
Reviewingthestructure,sizeandcompositionoftheBoardtakinginto
accountsuccessionplansandtheBoard’sDiversityStatement.
•
Overseeingsuccessionplanningfordirectorsandothersenior
executivesandthedevelopmentofdiversepipelines.
•
ReviewingtheapproachtotheannualevaluationprocessfortheBoard
anditsCommittees.
•
OverseeingtheappointmentprocessforNon-ExecutiveDirectorsand
ExecutiveDirectors.
•
ReviewingthetrainingplanfortheBoardonatleastanannualbasis.
•
Reviewinggovernancearrangementsandmonitoringcorporate
governancedevelopments,makingrecommendationstotheBoard
whereappropriate.
•
ReviewingandrecommendingtotheBoardtheDirectorsandChief
OfficersConflictsofInterestPolicyforapprovalandmonitoring
potentialconflicts.
•
ReviewingandrecommendingtotheBoardtheBoardDiversity
Statementforapproval.
Further detail on the role and responsibilities of the Committee can
be found in the terms of reference which are available on the Your
Society section of our website, at ybs.co.uk.
Corporate governance
TheCommitteeisresponsiblefortheoversightofBoardgovernanceand
ensuringweworkwithinastrongcorporategovernanceframework.During
2023thishasincluded:
•
AnnualreviewoftheSociety’scompliancewiththeUKCorporate
GovernanceCode(asitappliestoabuildingsociety).
•
ReviewoftheCorporateGovernancereportandtheBoardGovernance
andNominationsCommittee’sreportandrecommendationtotheAudit
CommitteeandtheBoardthattheybeincludedintheAnnualReport
andAccounts.
•
Oversightofcorporategovernancedevelopmentswithanychanges
requiredasaresultrecommendedtotheBoardtoensurethe
governanceframeworkisbasedonbestpractice.
Succession planning
TheBoardiscommittedtoensuringithastherightcompositionbothnow
andinthefuture,tosupportthedeliveryofourstrategyandensurethe
long-termsuccessoftheSociety.TheBoardGovernanceandNominations
CommitteesupportstheBoardbyensuringthatitkeepsunderreview
thestructure,sizeandcompositionoftheBoardanditsCommitteesand
ensuresthateffectivesuccessionplansaremaintainedtomanageperiods
oftransitionontheBoard.
TheCommitteecarriesoutadetailedreviewofsuccessionplanningfor
DirectorsatitsannualstrategysessioninMarcheachyearandkeepsthe
planunderreviewateachsubsequentmeetingduringtheyear.Italso
plansaheadforfuturerecruitmentofNon-ExecutiveDirectorstomake
surethattheBoardcontinuestohavetheskillsandexperienceitneeds
tooverseethedeliveryofthestrategyforthelong-termsuccessofthe
Society.
82 | Governance 83
TheBoardGovernanceandNominationsCommitteehas
accesstoarangeofinformationtosupportsuccession
planningincluding:
TheCommitteecontinuedtooverseesuccessionplanning
forNon-ExecutiveDirectorsin2023,takingintoaccount
tenure,currentandfutureskillsrequirementswhilst
balancingtheneedforcontinuityduringaperiodof
transitionforkeyroles.
TheCommittee’sroleiskeyinsupportingtheongoing
stabilityandeffectivenessoftheBoardnowandin
thefuture.
InadditiontoNon-ExecutiveDirectorsuccession,the
BoardGovernanceandNominationsCommitteealso
reviewsthesuccessionandtalentpipelineforsenior
rolesacrosstheSocietytounderstandtheskillsrequired
tomanagethebusinessandassessanyrisksorpotential
gaps.During2023thishasbeenkeyinsupportingthe
onboardingofanewChiefExecutiveandensuringrobust
successionplansareinplaceasaresultofchangesinthe
seniorleadershipteam.
Board Skills
Matrix and
Skills Map
Basedonanannualself-evaluation
byourdirectorsoftheirskillsand
experience.In2023theCommittee
undertookadetailedreviewofthe
approachtotheSkillsMatrixto
ensureitremainedfitforpurpose
andsupportedtheCommitteein
itssuccessionplanningandfuture
recruitmentexercises.Takinginto
accounttheBoard’scurrentand
futurerequirementstodeliverthe
Society’sstrategy,togetherwith
externalfeedback,arevisedSkills
Matrixapproachwasagreedby
theCommitteeandcompletedby
allNon-ExecutiveandExecutive
DirectorsinQuarter42023.
Non-
Executive
Director
Succession
Timeline
Settingoutappointmentdates,
termsofofficeandexpected
retirementdatesincludingkey
rolessuchastheBoardand
CommitteeChairs.
Board
Committee
Membership
and Key Non-
Executive
Director
Roles
SettingoutcurrentBoard
Committeemembership,
compositionandanyfuture
requirements,togetherwithother
keyrolesheldbyNon-Executive
Directors,suchastheNon-
ExecutiveDirectorforWorkforce
Engagement.
Board
Diversity
Statement
and
Information
SettingoutourBoard’s
commitmentstoinclusionand
diversityandunderstandingthe
compositionofourBoard.
Recruiting Non-Executive and
Executive Directors
TheCommitteeleadstherecruitmentofnewNon-
ExecutiveandExecutiveDirectorsonbehalfofthe
Board,basedonathoroughandinclusiveprocess:
Succession planning
TheCommitteemaintainsoversightoftheBoard’s
successionplansincludingplanningforfuture
recruitmentexercises(takingintoaccountexpected
termsofofficeforNon-ExecutiveDirectors).
Role requirements
Arolespecification,includingthekeyskillsand
experiencerequired,isagreedtakingintoaccount
successionplansandtheBoardSkillsMatrixas
appropriate.
External search agency
Anexternalsearchagencyisappointedtosupportthe
processusingourPreferredRecruitmentSupplierList.
OurPreferredRecruitmentSupplierListensuresthat
thereisclarityintermsofthestandardofserviceto
beprovidedbythesupplierandtherequirementsand
expectationsoftheSociety.Thepurposeofthelistis
toensurethattheCommitteehasaccesstoarange
ofsearchfirmstoprovidethewidestpossiblepoolof
diversepotentialcandidates.Allthesearchfirmsare
expectedtoadheretotheBoard’sDiversityStatement
andensureitispartoftheirsearchprocess.
Short listing
Ashortlistisdevelopedandagreedbasedon
objectivecriteria,withdueregardtothebenefitsof
diversityontheBoard,andtheskillsandexperience
candidatescouldbringtotherole.
Interviewing
Astructuredinterviewprocessisundertakenincluding
PanelinterviewswithmembersoftheCommittee(or
anyotherCommitteeestablishedbytheBoardforthe
purposeofrecruitment)andsubsequentinterview
sessionswithotherkeyBoardstakeholders.
Appointment
Followingarobustprocess,apreferredcandidateis
identifiedandtheBoardGovernanceandNominations
CommitteewillmakearecommendationtotheBoard
toappoint(subjecttoregulatoryapprovalinrelation
torolesundertheSeniorManagersandCertification
Regime).
Chair of Remuneration Committee succession
and recruitment
Succession planning
AsreportedintheAnnualReportandAccounts2022,theCommittee
agreedtocommencearecruitmentprocesstoidentifyapermanent
successorfortheChairofRemunerationCommitteerole.This
followedtheretirementofGuyParsonsinApril2022withthe
interimroleundertakenbyAlisonHutchinsontoensureconsistency
andcontinuity.
Role requirements
AcandidatespecificationwasapprovedbytheCommitteesetting
outthekeyrequirementsfortheroletakingintoaccountsuccession
plansandexistingBoardcomposition,includingskillsand
experience.
External search agency
RussellReynoldsAssociateswereengagedastheexternalsearch
agencytosupporttherecruitmentprocess.Theyhavepreviously
assistedtheSocietyintherecruitmentofGuyBainbridge,Chairof
AuditCommitteein2018.
Shortlisting and interview process
Theshortlistingprocessandpanelinterviewswereundertakenbyall
membersoftheCommitteeandinaddition,theChiefExecutiveand
ChairofGroupRiskCommittee.Thepreferredcandidatealsomet
withallotherNon-ExecutiveDirectors,ExecutiveDirectorsandthe
ChiefPeopleOfficer.
Appointment
DebraDavieswasidentifiedasthepreferredcandidatefortheroletakingintoaccountherexperienceand
knowledgeofthefinancialservicessectorandfocusonremunerationandrisk,togetherwithastronginterestin
socialpurposeandsustainability.
TheBoardapprovedMsDaviesappointmentontherecommendationoftheCommitteeandsheofficiallyjoinedthe
Boardon26July2023.FollowingregulatoryapprovaloftheSeniorManagementFunctionrole,MsDaviesbecame
ChairofRemunerationCommitteeinSeptember2023.
For more information about Ms Davies skills and experience see the Non-Executive Director profiles in the
Our Board and Executive Team section.
Recruitment and Succession in 2023
Non-Executive Directors
Aspartofongoingsuccessionplanning,theCommitteehasbeeninvolvedintherobustrecruitmentandappointment
processesforthefollowingkeyNon-ExecutiveDirectorRoles:
Board Governance and Nominations Committee report (continued)
Succession planning (continued)
84 | Governance 85
Chair of the Board succession and recruitment
Succession planning
AsreportedintheAnnualReportandAccounts2022the
Committeeagreedtocommencearecruitmentprocessfor
successiontotheChairoftheBoardrole.
Chair of the board succession committee
ToensurerobustgovernancetheBoardagreedtoestablish
aChairoftheBoardSuccessionCommitteeasaCommittee
oftheBoardtomanagetheprocessonbehalfofitandthe
BoardGovernanceandNominationsCommittee.Themembers
oftheCommitteewereAlisonHutchinson(ViceChairand
SeniorIndependentDirector)whochairedtheCommittee,Guy
Bainbridge(IndependentNon-ExecutiveDirector)andMark
Parsons(IndependentNon-ExecutiveDirector).
Role requirements
AcandidatespecificationwasapprovedbytheCommittee
settingoutthekeyrequirementsfortheroletakingintoaccount
successionplansandexistingBoardcomposition,includingskills
andexperience.
External search agency
RussellReynoldsAssociateswereengagedastheexternal
searchagencytosupporttherecruitmentprocess.Assetout
above,theypreviouslyassistedintherecruitmentofGuy
Bainbridge,ChairofAuditCommitteeandDebraDavies,Chairof
RemunerationCommittee.
Shortlisting and interview process
Theshortlistingprocessandpanelinterviewswerecompleted
byallmembersoftheChairoftheBoardSuccessionCommittee
andinaddition,interviewswereheldwiththeChiefExecutive,
ChairofGroupRiskCommitteeandChiefFinanceOfficer.The
preferredcandidatealsometwiththeChairoftheBoard,all
otherBoardmembersandtheChiefRiskOfficer.
Appointment
AnnemarieDurbinwasidentifiedasthepreferredcandidatefortheroletakingintoaccountherextensiveretail
bankingandbroaderretailfinancialservicesexperience,togetherwithherexperienceinotherNon-Executive
Directorroles.
TheChairoftheBoardSuccessionCommitteerecommendedthepreferredcandidatetotheBoardGovernanceand
NominationsCommitteeforapprovalandtheBoardapprovedMsDurbin'sappointmentontherecommendationof
theCommittee.ShejoinedtheBoardasChairoftheBoardDesignateon18December2023.
For more information about Ms Durbin's skills and experience see the Non-Executive Director profiles in the
Our Board and Executive Team section.
Executive Directors
TheCommitteeisresponsibleforsupportingtherecruitmentofanynewExecutiveDirector.AsreportedintheAnnualReport
andAccounts2022,asuccessfulrecruitmentprocesswasledbytheCommitteefortheChiefExecutiveroleandresultedin
theappointedofSusanAllen.SusanjoinedtheSocietyinMarch2023anddetailsofherinductionprocessaresetoutinthe
CorporateGovernancereport
.
Board diversity
WeplacegreatimportanceonhavinganinclusiveanddiverseBoardandworkforcegenerally.OurBoardhasagreeda
DiversityStatementtosupportthisambition,whichisreviewedbytheBoardGovernanceandNominationsCommitteeand
approvedbytheBoardeachyear.
AsummaryofprogressagainstthekeyaspectsoftheStatementissetoutbelow:
Use of specialist recruitment agencies that
have signed up to the Standard Voluntary
Code of Conduct of Executive Search firms
for the appointment of Directors, with
a preference for those signed up to the
Enhanced Code
i
RussellReynoldsAssociateswereappointedtosupportthesearchfor
apermanentChairofRemunerationCommitteeandanewChairofthe
BoardandaresigneduptotheEnhancedVoluntaryCodeofConductfor
ExecutiveSearchFirms.
At least 40% of Board Directors will be
women
ThepercentageofwomenontheBoardasat31December2023was
58%andexceededthetarget.
For prior years see the Board Composition section of the Corporate
Governance report.
Further increase Board diversity in order
to enhance effectiveness and embrace the
talents of people from all backgrounds
OurBoardplacesgreatemphasisonensuringitsmembershipreflects
diversityinitsbroadestsense.Considerationisgiventodemographics,
skills,experience,race,age,gender,disability,educationaland
professionalbackground,andotherrelevantpersonalattributes.In
ensuringanappropriatebalanceofallthesefactorstheBoardcan
providetherangeofperspectives,insightsandchallengeneededto
supportgooddecisionmaking.
TheCommitteeregularlyreviewsthecompositionoftheBoardto
ensurethatithasthebalanceofskills,experience,independenceand
knowledgethroughitsdiversecompositiontoremaineffective.
i. TheVoluntaryCodeofConductforExecutiveSearchfirmslaysoutstepsforsearchfirmstofollowacrossthesearchprocess,fromacceptingabriefthroughto
induction.TheEnhancedVoluntaryCodeofConductwascreatedbyexecutivesearchfirmsthemselveswiththeaimofraisingthestandardsofprofessionalism
andconductintherecruitmentofwomentotheboardsofFTSE350companies(thelargest350companieslistedontheLondonStockExchange).
Board Governance and Nominations Committee report (continued)
Succession planning (continued)
86 | Governance 87
Evaluation of the Board and its committees
TheBoardGovernanceandNominationsCommittee
agreesandrecommendstotheBoardtheprocessforthe
annualreviewoftheBoard’sperformanceandthatof
itsCommitteesinaccordancewiththeCode.TheCode
recommendstheevaluationoftheBoardbeexternally
facilitatedeverythreeyears.
Asanexternalreviewwaslastcompletedin2020,itwas
agreedthatanexternalreviewwouldbecompletedin2023.
Further details on the appointment of an external
facilitator and the approach to the review can be found
in the Corporate Governance report.
Chair of the Board
OurSeniorIndependentDirector,AlisonHutchinson,meets
withourChairtwiceayearonbehalfofourBoardtoreview
theChair’sperformanceincludingtheannualreviewwhich
tookplaceinJanuary2024,takingintoaccountfeedback
fromkeystakeholders.Theoutcomesofthereviewwere
discussedattheBoardmeetinginJanuary2024without
theChairpresent.AsChairhehascontinuedtoshowstrong
commitmentandloyaltyandthequalityofhisleadership
wasnotedtogetherwiththeexpertiseandinsighthehad
broughttoYBSoverthelastnineyears.
Non-Executive Directors
OurChairhastwiceyearlymeetingswitheachNon-
ExecutiveDirectortoreviewtheirperformance,discuss
anyareasfordevelopmentandreviewongoingtime
commitment.
Executive Directors
ExecutiveDirectorevaluationsarecarriedoutbyourChief
Executive,(ortheChairoftheBoardinthecaseoftheChief
Executive),againstagreedobjectives.
TheChairoftheBoardmeetswiththeNon-Executive
Directorsatleastannuallytoconsidertheperformanceof
managementandtheExecutiveDirectors.
Evaluation of the Board Governance and
Nominations Committee
TheBoardCommitteeevaluationswereincorporatedinthe
externalevaluationprocessfor2023.TheBoarddiscussed
thefindingsofthereviewinJanuary2024andmore
detailscanbefoundintheCorporateGovernancereport.
Therewerenourgentorsignificantactionsarisingforthe
Committee,however,itwillconsidertheoutcomesofthe
reviewwhichwerespecifictoitsroleatitsmeetingin
March2024.
John Heaps
ChairoftheBoardGovernance
andNominationsCommittee
28February2024
Diverse talent pipelines
AspartofitsroletheCommitteeoverseesseniorleadershipsuccessionplansandthediversityofthetalentpoolfor
futurevacancies.
WehavesignedtheHMTreasury’sWomeninFinanceCharterandarecommittedtoimprovinggenderbalance,
particularlyatseniorlevelsinourorganisation.Bywayoffurtherinformation,wehadthefollowingpercentagesof
womencolleaguesat31December2023(andforcomparison2022):
For more details on our colleagues and inclusion and diversity please see the Strategic report.
31 December 2023
%
31 December 2022
%
Executive Committee
TheLeadershipTeamimmediatelybelowourBoard(assetoutinthe
UKCorporateGovernanceCode)
43 33
Senior Managers
OurcolleaguesinrolesGradeEorabove(inaccordancewithour
commitmentsundertheWomeninFinanceCharter)
49 50
All Colleagues 61 63
Audit Committee Report
AwordfromtheChairoftheAuditCommittee
Iampleasedtopresentour2023
AuditCommitteereportwhich
setsouttheAuditCommittee’s
roleanditskeyactivitiesduring
theyear,includingitsreview
offinancialreportingmatters,
oversightoftheGroup’sinternal
controls,anditsinternaland
externalauditors.Iammost
gratefultomyfellowCommittee
membersforthediligence
withwhichtheycontributeto
theCommittee'swork,andto
managementforthetimeand
efforttheyputintoensurethe
Committeeremainseffective.
Duringtheyearwehavespentconsiderable
timeassessinganyimpactsupontheGroup's
controlenvironmentfromtheCovidandpost-
Covidreturntoofficeperiod,andthechanges
inseniormanagementoftheGroupoverthe
lasttwoyears.Wehavealsoconsideredthe
continuingdevelopmentsinourinternalaudit
function,includingthefiveyearlyexternal
qualityassessmentofthefunctioncompleted
inthelastquarterof2023.Wehaveremained
focusedontheimpactsoftheeconomic
environment,notablyincreasedinterestrates
andinflation,andregulatoryandlegislative
developmentsuponourcurrentandfuture
business.TheBoardhasrecentlydelegated
responsibilityfortheoversightoftheGroup's
annualEnvironmental,SocialandGovernance
(ESG)reporttotheCommitteeandwehave
beenpreparingforactivityonthe2023
reportinthefirsthalfof2024,includingthe
introductionofafifthregularCommittee
meetingtomeettheESGreporttimetable,
whichwillalsogiveustheopportunityto
rebalancemeetingworkloadsandaccelerate
certainreportstotheCommittee.
In2024,theAuditCommitteewillcontinue
itsworktoprotecttheinterestsofallofthe
Group'sstakeholders.
Guy Bainbridge
ChairoftheAuditCommittee
Audit Committee membership
ThemembersoftheAuditCommitteeare:
OnlymembersoftheAuditCommitteeareentitledtoattend
itsmeetings,althoughothersmaybeaskedtoattendallorpart
ofameeting.OurChairoftheBoard,ChiefExecutive,Chief
FinanceOfficer,ChiefInternalAuditOfficerandtheexternal
auditorwereinvitedtoattendallmeetingsin2023,alongwith
othermembersofourLeadershipTeamandSeniorManagers
wheretheAuditCommitteefeltitwasbeneficial.
WehadfourAuditCommitteemeetingsin2023.Themeetings
beganwithaprivatesessionbetweentheinvitedmembersof
theLeadershipTeamandtheAuditCommitteemembersand
generallyfinishedwithaprivatesessionbetweentheAudit
Committeemembersandourinternalandexternalauditors.
TheseprivatesessionsallowtheAuditCommitteetodiscuss
confidentialmatters,whichmaynotbeappropriatetodiscuss
inthemainAuditCommitteeitself.
Details on the number of meetings attended by each of
the Audit Committee members during 2023 are shown in
the Corporate Governance report.
Angela Darlington
Independent Non-Executive Director
Mark Parsons
Independent Non-Executive Director
Guy Bainbridge
Committee Chair
Independent Non-Executive Director
Board Governance and Nominations Committee report (continued)
Succession planning (continued)
88 | Governance 89
OurBoardappointsmembersto
theAuditCommitteeandtakesinto
accounttherequirementsoftheUK
CorporateGovernanceCode('the
Code'),asfarastheyapplytobuilding
societies,whenconsideringwho
shouldbeamember.Inlinewith
theCode,allmembershavetobe
independentNon-ExecutiveDirectors,
atleastonemembermusthave‘recent
andrelevantfinancialexperience’
andtheAuditCommitteeasawhole
shouldhaveexperienceinthefinancial
servicessector.
You can find out more about
the Code, and how it applies
to building societies, in the
Corporate Governance report.
In2023,allthemembersofthe
AuditCommitteewereindependent
Non-ExecutiveDirectors,andall
haverecentandrelevantfinancial
experiencegainedthroughthe
qualificationstheyholdandtheroles
theyhaveheldorcurrentlyhold
withotherorganisations.Therehave
beennochangestotheCommittee
membersduring2023.
TheAuditCommitteebenefitsfrom
adiverserangeofexpertiseinthe
areasofauditing,financeandrisk,
withparticularemphasisonthe
financialservicessector.Altogether,
thisensuresthattheAuditCommittee
hastherequiredcompetenceinthe
financialservicessector.
You can find out more about
the skills, qualifications
and experience of the Audit
Committee members in the
directors' biographies in the Our
Leadership Team section.
Therolesandresponsibilitiesofthe
AuditCommitteeareexplainedin
itsTermsofReference,whichset
outtheareasonwhichitprovides
oversightorguidancetotheBoard.
TheAuditCommitteereviewsits
TermsofReferenceeveryyearto
ensureitcontinuestomeetregulatory
requirementsandgoodpracticeand
boththeAuditCommitteeandBoard
approvetheTermsofReferenceeach
year.
You can find them on our
website ybs.co.uk/your-society/
inside-your-society/corporate-
governance/committees.
Key financial reporting
matters
Providingourstakeholderswith
complete,accurateandrelevant
financialinformationiscriticalto
ensuringthattheSocietymaintains
theirtrust.TheAuditCommitteeis
responsibleforensuringthatthekey
accountingpolicies,estimatesand
judgementsusedinourfinancial
statementsareappropriate.Tohelp
theAuditCommitteeachievethis,it
receivesreportsfrommanagement
andourexternalauditor,PwC.
Audit Committee report (continued)
Matters
Considered
Key Activities 2023
Expected credit
losses
Thecalculationofimpairmentforaportfolioofmortgageloansisinherentlyuncertain.Expected
creditlosses('ECL')arecalculatedusinghistoricaldefaultandlossexperiencebutrequire
judgementtobeappliedinpredictingfutureeconomicconditions(e.g.interestratesandhouse
prices)andcustomerbehaviour(e.g.defaultrates).UnderstandingtheGroup’sexposuretocredit
riskandensuringthattheassumptionsfeedingintoourECLmodelsareappropriate,arekey
prioritiesfortheAuditCommittee,allofwhosemembersserveontheGroupRiskCommittee.
TheAuditCommitteecontinuedtochallengemanagementontheselectionofeconomic
assumptions,andtherelativeweightingoftherangeofeconomicscenarios,giventheyhavea
materialimpactonECL,todemonstratethatthesedecisionsappropriatelyreflectedeconomic
conditionsandtheoutlookforunemployment,bankrateandhouseprices.Inflationaryrisks
remainedanincreasedfocusareawithhouseholdspendingbecomingthegreatestheadwind
in2023ashigherpricescontinuedtodragonrealincomesaswellasthepersistentincrease
ininterestratesreducingdisposableincomeandraisingtheriskofborrowersfailingtomeet
theircontractualrepayments.Managementevaluatedtheseuncertainties,withtheeconomic
assumptionsappliedtotheECLmodeladjustedtoreflectanymaterialchangesinviewofthe
macro-economicenvironment.Probabilityweightingswerereviewedduring2023andupdated
toreflecteconomicconditions.Thecorescenarioweightingdecreasedandthedownturnand
severedownturnscenarioweightingsincreasedtoreflecttherisksassociatedwithinflation
remaininghigherforlonger,mortgageaffordabilitypressureduetotheincreasesinBankRate
todateandtheongoinggeopoliticalandUKeconomicsituation.SMEjudgmentisapplied
inthefinalassessmentofweights,informedbothbyanassessmentofexternaldataand
statisticalmodelresults.Followingdetailedreviewanddiscussion,assumptionsforbasecase,
upsideanddownsidescenarios,aswellasforasevereeconomicdownturn,wereagreed.The
Committeeconcurredwithmanagementthatthescenariosusedreflectedanappropriaterange
ofassumptionsandtheupdatetoscenarioweightingswereappropriatetoreflectthechanging
economicoutlook.
Postmodeladjustments('PMA')areappliedwhenachangeincreditriskisidentifiedthatisnot
effectivelycapturedinthecoreECLmodels.PMAsarereviewedthroughouttheyeartodetermine
whethertheidentifiedrisksarestillapplicable.
TheSocietywillcontinuetorelyonPMAsgiventheenvironmentofincreaseduncertaintyto
offerasolutiontoECLcalculations,whilstmodelenhancementoptionsarecontinuallybeing
developed.Sincetheyareinherentlyjudgemental,PMAsrequirerobustprocessandgovernance,
supportedbytransparentandhigh-qualitydocumentation.
APMAworkinggroupwasestablishedinH22023withthepurposeofmonitoring,analysing
andenhancingthedocumentationofPMAs.ThisgroupretainsacentralroleintheECLcontrol
frameworkwiththeresponsibilityofactivelymanagingtheportfolioofPMAs,keepingthescope,
durationandconditionsforunwindingmanagementoverlaysunderregularreview.Furtherto
this,theywillcontinuetoinvestigatethescopeofplanstoreducerelianceonPMAsinfuture
wherepossible.TheultimateapprovalofourECLprovision,includingPMAswillcontinueto
followinternalscrutinypriortobeingsubmittedtoAuditCommitteeeachhalfyearandyearend.
Thecontinueduncertaintyintheeconomicoutlookandtheimpactsofincreasedinflationand
raisedinterestratesonaffordabilitycontinuedtobeafocusareafortheCommittee,withthe
Group'scost-of-livingandinflationPMAschallengedtoensuretheapproachremainedfitfor
purpose,particularlywhenconsideringthemodelperformancePMAsandthepotentialforthese
tooverlap.TheaffordabilityPMAmethodologywasrevisedtoreflectalowerstressbeingapplied
toaccountsidentifiedasmostvulnerabletoaffordabilitystresses,howeveritwasconsidered
appropriatetomaintainamoreprudentassessmentforaccountsclosetoproducttermexpiry.
Thesechangesresultedinalowerproportionofaccountsbeingidentifiedashigherriskand
decreasedthelevelofPMAinplace.TheBTLbookwasconsideredseparatelyandcontinuesto
berelativelyinsensitivetothestressesmentionedabove.Thecommitteedeemeditappropriate
tocontinuetoholdanadditionalprovisiontocoverthisunderestimation,althoughthePMA
hasreducedinmagnitudefrom2022.ECLcoveragehasnotexceeded0.04%ontheBTLbook
despitethechallengingeconomicclimateoverrecentyears.
Significant financial reporting matters considered by the Audit Committee since the
last Annual Report and Accounts
90 | Governance 91
Matters
Considered
Key Activities 2023
Expected
credit losses
(continued)
FourthgenerationIFRS9modelsandimpactswerepresentedtotheSociety’sModelRisk
Committeein2023andapprovedforuse.ThesehavebeenusedasthebasisforgeneratingCore
modelECLsforthisreportingperiod.BoththeMethodologyChangesandModelRecalibration
PMAshavebeenreleasedastheyarenolongerrequiredandthereductioninECLassociated
withthestage2movementoutweighedotheraspectsofthemigrationtothefourth-generation
modelsthatwouldhaveincreasedECLs,leadingtoanoverallreleaseoninitialimplementation.
However,twoadditionalPMAshavebeenraisedinrelationtothefourthgenerationPDmodel,
onereflectsthelimitedsensitivitytothedifferenteconomicscenariosovertheavailablehistory.
ThenarrowrangeinaveragePDestimatesacrossscenariosofdifferingseverityhighlightedthe
modelweakness.TheotherrelatestoPDunderpredictionwhich,wasalsoachallengewithin
thethird-generationmodelsbuiltonsimilardataperiods,andthetrendhascontinuedtobe
observedthroughmodelmonitoringsincethefourthgenerationmodelwasputintouseinMay.
AsthesearematerialtotheECLbalance,theAuditCommitteereviewedandchallengedthe
rationale,calculationmethodologyandgovernanceforeachofthesePMAs.
TheCommitteecontinuetoconsiderbothphysicalandtransitionrisksinrelationtotheGroup’s
mortgageportfolioandnotedthechallengeswithunderlyingdataandlong-termnatureof
expectedimpactsofclimateriskaspartoftheARAreviewandapprovalprocess.
Beingkeytotheaccurateprovisioning,theECLmodelperformanceisconstantlymonitoredand
theresultsofthismonitoringarecommunicatedtotheCommittee.
TheCommitteewassatisfiedthattheimpairmentprovisionandthedisclosuresprovidedinthe
financialstatementswereappropriate.
Matters
Considered
Key Activities 2023
Hedge
accounting
TheAuditCommitteecontinuedtoreviewthemethodologyandkeyassumptionsappliedto
thehedgeaccountingmodelsovertheperiod,includingconsiderationofnewhedgestrategies.
TheCommitteereviewedtheSociety’sapproachtohedgeaccountinginthecontextofthe
marketvolatilityseenintheyearandrequestedadditionaldisclosuresaroundfairvalue
volatilityinthehalfyearreportgiventhemagnitudeofthevolatilityexperiencedduetorate
volatilityinthewidereconomicenvironment.TheCommitteerequestedanalysisofthekey
driversofthevolatilitybetweentheprioryearend,halfyearandcurrentyearendgiventhe
magnitudecomparedtorecentyears,allofwhichwassharedwiththeCommitteeinboth
formalandinformalmeetings.Themostsignificantsourceoffairvaluegainsandlossesinthe
incomestatementcontinuestorelatetointerestrateswapsnotplacedintoahedgeaccounting
relationship.Payfixedinterestrateswapsaretransactionstohedgethemortgagepipelineand
cannotbeplacedintoahedgeaccountingrelationshipforashortamountoftimeaftertheyhave
beentransacted.Thesearepartiallyoffsetbytheswapsthathedgefixedratesavingswhichare
neverplacedintoahedgeaccountingrelationship.
TheCommitteetookpartinahedgeriskmanagementandhedgeaccountinginformationsession
inH2withtheFinanceleadershipteamwhichincludeddetailonhedgingandhedgeaccounting
activitiesandfuturechangesordevelopmentsthatarebeingexplored.TheCommitteeissatisfied
thattheamountsrecognisedinthefinancialstatementsareappropriatelystated.
Matters
Considered
Key Activities 2023
Retirement
benefit
obligations
TheGroupoperatesoneemployeebenefitscheme(theScheme)withbothdefinedbenefitand
definedcontributionsections.ThedefinedbenefitschemeisaccountedforbytheGroupunder
IAS19,withthekeyassumptionspresentedto,andapprovedby,theAuditCommittee.During
theperiodtheAuditCommitteereviewedtheassumptionsproposedbymanagementandthe
schemeadministrators(WillisTowersWatson),withchallengeonhowthepensionsurpluswillbe
impactedgiventhecontinuedvolatilityinthemarketthisyearandreviewedhowtheybenchmark
againsttherestoftheindustry.
Effective
interest rate
('EIR')
TheAuditCommitteeconsideredtheresultsofmanagement’sdetailedreviewsofthemethods
andassumptionsusedinthecalculationofinterestincomeundertheEffectiveInterestRate(EIR)
methodology,asrequiredunderIFRS,andconcludedthattheamountsrecognisedwerefairly
stated.
Acquisition
fair value
adjustment
run-off
TheAuditCommitteereviewedtherun-offprofileofthefairvalueadjustmentsmadeonthe
acquisitionoftheChelsea,Norwich&PeterboroughandEggportfoliosandapprovedchanges
wheretheactualrun-offexperienceiseitherquickerorslowerthanthatanticipatedoninitial
recognition.TheAuditCommitteeiscomfortablethatthecarryingamountsreflecttheremaining
expectedlifeoftheacquiredloansandsavingsbalances.
Tax Paperssettingoutthejudgementsappliedintherecognitionofdeferredtaxbalancesandthe
leveloftransferpricingadjustmentsappliedbetweenGroupentitieswerepresentedtothe
AuditCommitteeovertheperiod.TheAuditCommitteeissatisfiedthattherecognisedamounts
ofdeferredtaxarereasonablegiventhesubstantiveenactmentofscheduledchangesinUK
corporationtaxratesandthetransferpricingassumptionsarereasonable.
Provisions for
liabilities and
charges
TheAuditCommitteereviewedandconsideredtheprovisionsanddisclosuresforliabilitiesand
charges,beingthoserelatingtorestructuring,customerredressandpropertyrelatedcosts,and
agreedwiththeoverallamountheld.Moreinformationontheseprovisionscanbefoundinnote
23tothefinancialstatements.
Viability and
going concern
TheAuditCommitteereviewedpaperspreparedbymanagementandrecommendedtotheBoard
thatthefinancialstatementsshouldbepreparedonagoingconcernbasisi.e.12monthsfromthe
endofthereportingperiod.TheAuditCommitteeconfirmedthatthreeyearswasasuitableperiod
ofreviewfortheviabilitystatement,andthattheviabilitystatementcouldbeprovided.Whilst
thereisnoguarantee,thereisareasonableexpectationthattheSocietywillbeabletocontinueto
beviable,i.e.operateandmeetitsliabilitiesastheybecomedue,to31December2026.
More information can be found in our Directors’ report.
Disclosures TheAuditCommitteereviewedpaperspreparedbymanagementandagreedthatthedisclosures
includedwithinthisAnnualReportandAccountsmetallstatutoryrequirementsunderthe
BuildingSocietiesAct1986,thedisclosureandtransparencyrulesoftheFCAandapplicable
internationalfinancialreportingstandards.
TheAuditCommitteeconfirmedthatdisclosuresintheHalf-YearlyFinancialReportmetthe
requirementsofthedisclosureandtransparencyrulesoftheFCAandinternationalfinancial
reportingstandards.
TheAuditCommitteealsoreviewedtheGroup’sregulatoryPillar3quarterlydisclosuresincluded
infullontheSociety’swebsite.TheCommitteeapprovedthequarterone,twoandthreePillar
3disclosuresforpublicationandrecommendedthequarterfourdisclosurestotheBoardforits
approval.
ToenabletheBoardtoapprovetheLetterofRepresentationtotheexternalauditoratbothyearendandhalfyear,the
AuditCommitteereviewedthespecificrepresentationsandthebasisonwhichmembersoftheLeadershipteamhave
evidencedthem.
Audit Committee report (continued)
Key financial reporting matters (continued)
92 | Governance 93
Oversight of the external
auditor and external audit
process
TheAuditCommitteeoverseesthe
auditprocessandtherelationship
withourexternalauditor.TheAudit
Committeebeginseachannualaudit
cyclebyreviewingandapprovingthe
proposedauditplanpresentedbyour
externalauditor,PwC.Thisprocess
includesadiscussionbetweenthe
AuditCommitteeandourexternal
auditoraroundkeyriskareastoensure
thatthereisagreementonthefocus
oftheexternalauditor’sworkand
theirassessmentofmaterialityforthe
financialstatements.TheCommittee’s
discussionoftheexternalauditor’srisk
assessmentwasinformedthisyearby
theincreasesininterestratesaffecting
ECLsandhedging,andmanagement
changesinthehedgingandhedge
accountingteams.
For further information about
materiality and how it is
calculated, please refer to the
Independent Auditors’ report.
TheAuditCommitteehasassessed
PwC’sriskassessments,plannedwork,
resourcesandauditfeesthroughout
theyearandmonitoredtheprogressof
PwC’sauditworkthroughdiscussions
withPwCandmanagement.The
externalauditorprovidesregular
updatestotheAuditCommitteeon
theirworkontheHalf-YearlyFinancial
ReportandtheAnnualReportand
AccountsbeforetheAuditCommittee
approvesthem.
ThroughouttheyeartheAudit
Committeeassessestheeffectiveness
oftheexternalauditprocess,an
assessmentwhichisbasedon
guidancefromtheFinancialReporting
Council(FRC).TheAuditCommittee’s
assessmentincludesareview
undertakenbythefinancialreporting
managementteamwhichfocusedon
atargetedlistofbusinessareaswho
havesignificantinteraction,outside
ofthemainfinanceteams,withthe
auditprocesstoobtainfeedback.A
setofquestionswasconstructedasan
anchorfordiscussionsandtogenerate
someconsistencywhencollating
feedback,andwiderfeedbackwas
capturedalongsidethis.Inadditiona
surveywassentfollowingcompletion
oftheaudittomembersoftheAudit
Committeeandseniormanagersinthe
Society’sFinanceDivision.Adebrief
withtheauditfieldteamtookplace
toobtaintheirfeedbackandareas
forimprovementswereidentified.A
meetingtodiscussauditfeedback
washeldwiththeSeniorAuditteam
memberstosharetheconclusions
ofthereviewandobtaintheirviews
ontheeffectivenessoftheexternal
auditprocessandhowtheSociety
cancontributefurthertothis.The
outputfromallthesestepsisshared
withtheAuditCommitteeandhelps
itreviewthequalityoftheexternal
auditteamandprocess.TheAudit
Committeeconcludedthattheexternal
auditorwasperformingitsdutiesin
aneffectivemannerwithareasfor
improvementsharedwiththelead
auditpartnerforconsideration.
External auditor
independence
TheAuditCommitteemonitors
andannuallyassessestheexternal
auditor’sindependenceand
objectivity,takingintoaccount
relevantlaws,professionaland
regulatoryrequirementsandthe
relationshipwiththeexternalauditor
asawhole.Tofulfiltheresponsibilities
setoutinitsTermsofReference,
theAuditCommitteeconsiders,as
describedbelow,theexternalauditor’s
non-auditwork,thefeespaidin
respectofsuchnon-auditwork,the
employmentofformeremployeesof
theexternalauditor,andtheexternal
auditor’stenure.
TheGrouphasapolicyontheuse
oftheexternalauditorfornon-audit
work,andtheapplicationofthispolicy
isoverseenbytheAuditCommittee.
Thepolicyisdesignedtoensure
theexternalauditor’scontinued
independenceandobjectivity.
Feesforindividualassignmentsthat
exceedasetthresholdarereviewed
bytheAuditCommittee.Feesforthose
assignmentsunderthethresholdare
approvedbytheChiefFinanceOfficer
underdelegatedauthority.Allnon-
auditservicesareapprovedinadvance
oftheworkcommencing.Ourexternal
auditor’sfeeisreviewedregularly.The
AuditCommitteeissatisfiedthatthe
Grouphasoperatedinlinewiththe
policyduring2023.
Thetotalamountoffeespaidtoour
externalauditorforbothauditand
non-auditworkisdisclosedinnote6
tothefinancialstatements.
TheGroupalsohasapolicyon
theemploymentofemployeesof
theGroup’sexternalauditor,and
theAuditCommitteemonitorsthe
implementationofthispolicyannually.
InsummarythisrestrictstheSociety
fromofferingemploymenttonamed
individualsfromtheexternalauditfirm
forkeymanagementpositionswithin
atwo-yearperiodfromworkingon
theGroupstatutoryauditandensures
anysuchoffersofemploymentare
vettedbytheAuditCommitteeto
ensureon-goingindependenceofthe
externalauditor.TheAuditCommittee
alsoreviewedtheindependence
positionoftheCommitteemembers
andrelevantseniormembersof
theFinanceDivision,anditremains
satisfiedtherearenoconflictsor
independenceissues.
TheAuditCommitteetakesinto
accounttheperformanceofthe
externalauditorwhenconsidering
theirreappointmentaswellastheir
lengthoftenureandthedateof
rotationoftheauditpartner.PwC
wereappointedasexternalauditor
followingacompetitivetenderprocess
in2018andtheirappointmentwas
approvedbymembersatthe2019
AGM.HeatherVarley,theauditpartner
isrequiredtorotateofftheauditat
theendofthe2023audit,having
completedthemaximumtermof
fiveyears.Hersuccessorhasbeen
identifiedandhasmettheAudit
Committee.PwCwerereappointedas
theSociety’sexternalauditoratthe
2023AGMandtheAuditCommittee
hasrecommendedtotheBoardthat
theybeapprovedforreappointmentas
externalauditoratthe2024AGM.
Review of internal controls
OurBoardrecognisesthattomanage
riskseffectivelyweneedgoodinternal
controls.Thesehelpustoachieveour
purposeofprovidingRealHelpwith
RealLifebyprotectingourcustomers’
andotherstakeholders’interests
andlookingafterourGroup’sassets.
Theyalsoenableustobecomemore
efficientandeffectiveatwhatwe
do,producereliableinformationand
reports,andcomplywithlawsand
regulations.
Therisksthatwefacechangeovertime,sotheAuditCommitteeregularlyreviewshowourGroup’sinternalcontrolsare
workingandwhetherourGroupneedstostrengthenwhatitdoestomanagethenatureandextentofthoserisks,including
theriskoffraud(whatwecallourinternalcontrolframework).OurBoarddevelopsourpoliciesonriskandcontrol,butall
ofourSociety’scolleagueshavearesponsibilitytocarryoutthosepoliciesaspartofhelpingourorganisationachieveits
objectives.Sothattheycandothat,ourLeadershipTeamprovidestrainingandcoaching,andthenmonitorshowcolleagues
aremanagingrisks.
TosupporttheAuditCommittee’s
reviewofinternalcontrolsourInternal
Auditfunctionprovidesreportsto
everymeetingandourexternal
auditorprovidetheirownindependent
opinionstous.TheAuditCommittee
alsoreceivesreportsonsignificant
controlweaknessesfromthe
LeadershipTeam.TheAuditCommittee
workscloselywiththeGroupRisk
Committeetomakesurethattherisk
managementframeworkisoperating
effectivelyacrossourbusiness.
You can find further details of risk
management practices in the Risk
Management report.
Themaintypesofinformationthe
AuditCommitteeconsideredduring
2023were:
•
Internal Audit reports:TheAudit
Committeereviewedandapproved
theInternalAuditplanforthe
year,theproposedrevisionstothe
plan,andtheresourcesneededto
supportit.IndoingthistheAudit
Committeeconsideredtheongoing
appropriatenessofInternalAudit’s
coverageoftheGroup’srisks,
processes,systemsandcontrols
andthebalanceofassurance
betweentheGroup’stransformation
programmeandotherbusiness
activities.TheAuditCommitteealso
consideredreportsontheplan’s
progress,includingInternalAudit’s
findings,theirrootcausesandthe
LeadershipTeam’sresponses.Where
InternalAuditreportsareratedas
‘Unsatisfactory’theaccountable
membersoftheLeadershipTeamare
askedtoattendtheAuditCommittee
andexplainwhytheidentified
controlweaknesseshavearisen
andwhatactionsarebeingtakento
addressthem.In2023,InternalAudit
drewAuditCommittee’sattention
toarangeofareasthatrequired
improvement,includingcapital
reporting,responsiblelending,
peoplerisk,arrearsmanagement,
theSociety’schangeframeworkand
informationsecurity.
•
Updates on risk management
culture and ways of working:During
theyeartheCommitteediscussed
theSociety’sriskcultureandthe
impact,ifany,ofworkingfrom
homeoncontroleffectiveness,and
continuedtheirongoingmonitoring
ofprogressmadebymanagementin
improvingendtoendprocessand
controlsdocumentation.
•
External auditor reports:TheAudit
Committeereviewedreportsfrom
ourexternalauditors,PwC,about
recommendationsinrelationto
internalcontrolsforkeyfinancial
reportingprocessesandsystems.
Findingsthatwereraisedwere
prioritisedbymanagementaccording
toimpactandareasforimprovement
arebeingaddressed.TheAudit
Committeeconsideredregular
updatesonthestatusofcontrol
issuesidentifiedbybothInternal
AuditandPwC,andthevolumeand
ageprofileofthoseissuesremained
withintolerablelimits.Because
ourtotalassetsexceed£50bn,our
externalauditorprovidesthePRA
withaWrittenAuditorReporton
selectedaspectsoftheirauditand
this,too,wasconsideredbythe
AuditCommitteeduringtheyearin
relationtothe2022audit,together
withnon-firmspecificfeedbackfrom
thePRA.
•
Report on the adequacy of internal
controls in 2023:AuditCommittee
receivedareportfromallthree
linesofdefenceconcerningthe
effectivenessofinternalcontrols,
includingfocusonareasnotyetat
targetlevelsofmaturity.TheAudit
Committee’sattentionwasdrawn,in
particular,toimprovementsrequired
todataandregulatoryreporting
controls,controlssupporting
customeroutcomes,changeproject
controls,andcontrolstoprotectthe
securityofthefirm’ssystemsand
applications.
•
TheAuditCommitteeconsidered
whetheranyrecommendation
shouldbemadetotheRemuneration
Committeetoadjustthevariable
remunerationoftheLeadership
Team,inrespectofinternalcontrol
weaknesses.
Takentogether,theinformationthe
AuditCommitteereviewedprovided
assurancethat,whilstcontrol
improvementworkisongoing,the
Groupmaintainedanadequate
internalcontrolframeworkin2023
andtherewerenosignificantbreaches
ofcontrolorregulatorystandards.
Thissupportsouraimofcomplying
withtheprinciplesandprovisions
oftheCodewheretheyapplyto
buildingsocieties.TheLeadership
Teamproactivelytookactiontotackle
identifiedcontrolweaknesses,thereby
improvingthestrengthoftheinternal
controlenvironment,sothatourGroup
remainsfinanciallyandoperationally
resilient.
Audit Committee report (continued)
94 | Governance 95
OurInternalAuditfunctionis
governedbyacharter,whichtheAudit
Committeereviewsandapproves
annually.TheAuditCommittee
reapprovedthecharterinSeptember
2023andyoucanfindacopyofiton
ourwebsiteybs.co.uk/your-society/
inside-your-society/corporate-
governance/committees.
OurChiefInternalAuditOfficerreports
directlytotheChairoftheAudit
CommitteeandInternalAudithasfull
andunrestrictedaccesstoallofour
Group’sfunctions,systems,records
andcolleagues.TheChairoftheAudit
Committeemeetsregularlywiththe
ChiefInternalAuditOfficertoreview
theperformanceoftheInternalAudit
functionanddiscussanymatters
emergingfromInternalAuditactivities.
TheChairoftheAuditCommittee
alsoprovidesinputtotheappraisal
oftheChiefInternalAuditOfficer’s
performance.
Inadditiontoreceivingreportsonthe
outcomesofInternalAuditactivities,
asdescribedabove,theAudit
Committeereceivesregularreports
ontheperformanceofInternalAudit
againstanagreedsetofmeasures.
InternalAuditalsoreportstothe
AuditCommitteeannuallyonthe
strategyforthefunction,theskills
andresourcesithas,andwhatit
needstoeffectivelydischargeitsrole.
TheAuditCommitteereviewsand
approvesanyproposedchangestothe
strategyandresources.During2023,
thishasincludedconsiderationofthe
resourcestheInternalAuditfunction
mayneedoverthenextseveralyears,
andtheprogressmadeindeveloping
thefunction’sdataanalyticscapability.
TheAuditCommitteeissatisfiedthat
InternalAudithastheappropriate
resources,usingexternalthird-party
supportwherenecessary,tofulfilits
responsibilities.
InternalAuditcontinuestooperate
itsownqualityassuranceand
improvementprogramme.In2023,
thisprogrammeincludedanexternal
qualityassessmentofthefunction
againstrelevantprofessionalstandards
andcodesandindustrybestpractice.
Theassessmentwasperformedbyan
independentthird-party.TheAudit
Committeereceivedapresentation
fromthethirdpartyoftheresults,and
discussedtheassessmentandthe
recommendationsputforwardbythe
third-partytoenhancethefunction’s
approach,effectiveness,quality,skills
andexperiencewiththethirdparty
andtheChiefInternalAuditOfficer.
TheAuditCommitteewillcontinueto
overseeInternalAudit’sdevelopment,
includingthemonitoringofaction
plansresultingfromexternaland
internalassessments,tomakesurethe
functionremainsequippedfortherole
itplaysinhelpingourSocietyachieve
itspurpose.
Audit Committee
effectiveness
TheeffectivenessoftheAudit
Committeeisassessedannually.The
BoardCommitteeevaluationswere
incorporatedintheBoardexternal
evaluationprocessfor2023.The
Boarddiscussedthefindingsofthe
reviewinJanuary2024andfollowing
itsconsiderationofthefinalreport,
eachCommitteewillthenreview
anyoutcomesandrecommendations
relevanttoitsrole.Therewereno
urgentorsignificantactionsarising
fortheCommittee,however,further
informationonanyactionsidentified
asaresultofthereviewwillbe
presentedintheAnnualReportand
Accounts2024andwillbemonitored
bytheBoardandBoardCommittees
during2024.
Further details on the evaluation
process for 2023 can be found in
both the Board Governance and
Nominations Committee report
and the Corporate Governance
report.
TheAuditCommitteeundertakesa
detailedreviewannuallyofitsTerms
ofReferencetoensureitmeetsall
itsresponsibilitiesandconfirmed
thatin2023ithadmetallofits
responsibilities.TheCommittee’sTerm
ofReferencewereupdatedin2023to
reflecttheCommittee’soversightof
theGroup’sannualESGreport.
AuditCommitteemembersalsotake
partintrainingandreceivebriefings
onareasthatconcernnotonlytheir
rolesontheCommittee,butalsotheir
rolesontheBoard.In2023theAudit
Committeesetasideadditionaltime
tobebriefedonthedevelopmentsof
theCorporateSustainabilityReporting
Directive('CSRD')andhedgingand
hedgeaccounting,thelatteralongwith
membersoftheGroupRiskCommittee.
TheSocietyandtheAuditCommittee
willcontinuetomonitorthe
governancedevelopmentsarisingfrom
theGovernment’sconsultationon
RestoringTrustinAuditandCorporate
Governance,includingtherevisedUK
CorporateGovernanceCode,published
inJanuary2024,toensurethatany
requirementsorrelevantareasofgood
practiceidentifiedareimplemented
bytheSocietyasappropriatefora
buildingsociety.
TheFRC’s‘AuditCommitteesandthe
ExternalAudit:MinimumStandard’
('theStandard’),publishedinMay
2023,setstheminimumstandards
forauditcommitteesinrelationto
theiroversightresponsibilitiesforthe
externalauditandincludesguidance
onassessingtheeffectivenessofthe
auditprocessalongsidecoveringthe
auditcommittee’sresponsibilities
fortheexternalaudit,theexternal
audittender,oversightoftheexternal
auditorandauditandfinallythe
reportingofactivitiesundertakento
meettheStandard’srequirements.
TheStandardappliestoFTSE350
companiesandisvoluntary,subject
toanyfuturelegislationbeingpassed
toestablishtheAuditReporting
andGovernanceAuthority,however,
theStandardmaybeseenasgood
governanceandtheAuditCommittee
willconsideritinmoredetailin2024.
Our Chair of the Board oversees
the training and development
of the full Board and you can
find more information on this
in the Composition, Succession
and Evaluation section of the
Corporate Governance report.
Guy Bainbridge
ChairoftheAuditCommittee
28February2024
Risk
Management
Report
AwordfromtheChair
oftheGroupRisk
Committee.
IampleasedtopresentourRisk
Managementreportfor2023.This
reportexplainstheroleofthe
Boardriskcommittee,whichhere
iscalledtheGroupRiskCommittee
('theGRC'),describesthematters
thecommitteeconsideredduring
theyear,andgivesanoverview
ofhowtheGroupmanagesthe
risksitfaces.Ourattentionin
2023hasbeenbalancedbetween
prudentialrisk,operationalriskand
complianceandconductrisk.
Theyearhasonceagaindemonstratedthe
needforeffectiveriskmanagement.AsChairof
theGRC,IamsatisfiedtheGroup:
•
hasaclearriskappetitetoensureitcontains
theimpactofthoserisksithaschosento
take;
•
hasappropriatecontrolsinplacetoidentify
boththeriskofdeviationfromtherisk
appetiteandanyunplannedriskstheGroup
encounters;and
•
appropriatelybalancestherisksittakes
betweenbeingpurposefulforcurrent
andfuturecustomers,andprotectingthe
resilienceandsustainabilityoftheGroup.
MyGRCcolleaguesandIwillcontinueto
expectariskmanagementapproachthatis
purposeful,prudentandcustomer-focusedso
thatIcancontinuetoreportmysatisfaction
withtheGroup’sriskpositions.
Angela Darlington
ChairoftheGroupRiskCommittee
28February2024
About the Group Risk Committee
TheGRCcomprisesfivenon-executivedirectors:
Alison Hutchinson
Vice Chair and Senior Independent Non-
Executive Director
Debra Davies
Independent Non-Executive Director
Guy Bainbridge
Independent Non-Executive Director
Mark Parsons
Independent Non-Executive Director
Angela Darlington
GRC Chair and Independent Non-Executive
Director
Audit Committee report (continued)
Oversight of the Internal Audit function
96 | Governance 97
Matters considered
during 2023
TheGRCmetfourtimesin2023and
consideredallthemattersinrespect
ofitsresponsibilitiessummarisedin
itstermsofreference,coveringawide
rangeoftopics.
Ongeneralriskmanagementmatters,
theGRC:
•
ApprovedtheGroup’senterpriserisk
managementframework.
•
Reviewedandrecommendedthe
Boardapprovethe‘tier1’risk
appetiteexposurelimitsfor2024
andoversawcompliancewiththose
agreedpreviouslyfor2023.
•
ReceivedtheChiefRiskOfficer’s
quarterlyreportandviewofthe
Group’sprincipalrisks.
•
Approvedandmonitoredthe
progressofthesecondlineof
defence’soversightplanincluding
itskeyfindings.
Foritsoversightofprudentialrisk,the
GRC:
•
Reviewedandrecommendedthe
Boardapprovethescenariosand
resultsofthe2023internalliquidity
adequacyassessment('ILAAP')
andinternalcapitaladequacy
assessmentprocesses('ICAAP').
•
Reviewedthescenariosusedforthe
Group’sreversestresstests.
•
ReviewedandapprovedtheGroup’s
recoveryplan.
•
MonitoredtheGroup’scompliance
withtheresolvabilityassessment
framework.
•
Reviewedreportsfrom‘deepdives’
oftheGroup’smanagementofcredit
riskandcapitalrisk.
•
ReviewedandapprovedtheGroup’s
policyonregulatoryrisk,and
reviewedandrecommendedthe
BoardapprovetheGroup’spolicies
onfundingandliquidityrisk,capital
risk,marketrisk,treasuryriskand
retailandcommerciallending.
•
Reviewedthereportfroma‘deep
dive’oftheGroup’scommercial
lendingbusiness.
Andforitsoversightofoperationalrisk
andcomplianceandconductrisk,the
GRC:
•
Reviewedandrecommended
theBoardapprovetheGroup’s
annualoperationalresilienceself-
assessment,andmonitoredprogress
oftheworktocomplywiththe
operationalresiliencerules.
•
Reviewedtheannualreportfrom
theGroup’sMoneyLaundering
ReportingOfficer.
•
MonitoredprogressoftheGroup’s
worktostrengthenitscontrol
frameworkoverpeoplerisk,financial
crimeriskandclimaterisk.
•
Reviewedthereportfroma‘deep
dive’oftheeffectivenessofthe
Group’soperationalcontrols.
•
ReviewedandapprovedtheGroup’s
policiesoninformationandcyber
security,informationmanagement
andfinancialcrime,andreviewed
andrecommendedtheBoard
approvetheGroup’spolicyon
procurement,outsourcingandthird-
partyrisk.
Committee evaluation
TheeffectivenessoftheGRCis
assessedannually.TheBoard
Committeeevaluationswereincluded
intheBoardexternalevaluation
processfor2023.TheBoard
discussedthefindingsofthereview
inJanuary2024andfollowingits
considerationofthefinalreport,the
GRCwillthenreviewanyoutcomes
andrecommendationsrelevanttoits
role.Therewerenourgentactions
arisingfortheGRC,howeverfurther
informationonanyactionsidentified
inthereviewwillbepresentedinthe
AnnualReportandAccounts2024and
willbemonitoredbytheBoardandthe
GRCduring2024.Furtherdetailson
theevaluationprocessfor2023canbe
foundinboththeBoardGovernance
andNominationsCommitteereport
andtheCorporateGovernancereport.
Outlook
TheGRCwillcontinuein2024
toprovidebalancedoversightof
prudentialrisk,operationalriskand
complianceandconductrisk.Wewill
alsofocusontheGroup’sresponseto
anychangeinregulatoryapproachas
itgrowsitsbalancesheet.TheGroup
alwayswishestoproactivelyensure
thatriskmanagementcapabilityis
equaltooraheadofthatwhichis
necessarysofollowinganexternal
review,theGroupplanstostrengthen
itsgovernance,riskandcontrol
capabilitiesfurtherinanticipation
offuturegrowthandthepossibility
ofbeingdesignatedacategory
onefirmbythePRA.Theseplans
includeensuringtherightlevelof
subjectmatterexpertiseinkeyareas;
leveragingthelatesttechnology
anddatatodeliverautomationand
efficiencies;andfurtherencouraging
challengeandlearning.
TheGRCisalsoattendedbytheChairoftheBoardandmembersoftheexecutiveteamincludingtheChiefExecutive,the
ChiefFinanceOfficer,theChiefCommercialOfficer,theChiefOperatingOfficer,theChiefRiskOfficerandtheChiefInternal
AuditOfficer.
TheGRCisresponsibleforbringingtogetherandchallengingforsuitabilityallriskinformationonbehalfoftheBoard.This
coverstheapplicationofourenterpriseriskmanagementframeworkacrossallofourprincipalrisks.
The GRC’s terms of reference are available from our website at ybs.co.uk/your-society/inside-your-society/corporate-
governance/committees.
Our Enterprise Risk Management
Framework (‘ERMF’)
Werecognisethateffectiveriskmanagementis
essentialforourbusinesstogrowandachieve
itscommercialaspirations.OurERMFenables
robustyetefficientriskmanagement,whichhasan
importantandintegralrolein:
•
Deliveringourstrategywithinanappropriate
culture
•
Protectingagainstunplannedfinancialoutcomes
•
Beingresilienttooperationalrisks
•
Protectingcustomersfromunfairoutcomes
•
Demonstratingcredibilitytoexternal
stakeholders
TheERMFexplainshowseveralprocessesfit
togethertocreateaconsistentandeffectivewayof
managingriskacrosstheGroup.Thekeyelements
ofriskmanagementcovertheidentification,
assessment,control,monitoringandreportingof
risk.TheGRCreviewsandapprovesthisannually,
anditconsistsof:
•
The Governance, Risk and Control Strategy—
theSociety’sprioritiesforriskmanagementand
howtheyaligntotheSociety’sstrategy
•
Society culture—thevaluesandbehavioursthat
shapeourriskdecisions
•
Risk appetite—howmuchriskwecantaketo
deliverourstrategywhileensuringweprovide
faircustomeroutcomesandcontinuetooperate
asasafeandsecurebusiness
•
Policy and governance—howweorganise
ourselves,makedecisionsandtakeapproved
risks
•
Risk assessment and control—howweidentify,
assessandunderstandourrisksandlimit
undesirableoutcomes
•
Risk events —howwerespondwhenthingsgo
wrongandstopthesamethingshappeningagain
•
Monitoring and assurance—howwecheckthat
controlsareworkingandhighlightwhenrisks
requireattention
Three lines of defence
Weoperateathreelinesofdefenceapproachfor
managingrisk,whichseekstodifferentiatebetween
those:
•
Withdirectresponsibilityforthemanagementand
controlofrisk
•
WithresponsibilityfordefiningtheERMF,
communicatingrequirementsandindependently
monitoringadherencethroughoversightactivity,on
behalfoftheBoard
•
Providinganindependentandobjectiveopinionto
theBoardontheadequacyandfunctioningofthe
systemofinternalcontrol
Asummaryoftheseresponsibilitiesissetouton
page100.
T
H
I
R
D
L
I
N
E
O
F
D
E
F
E
N
C
E
S
E
C
O
N
D
L
I
N
E
O
F
D
E
F
E
N
C
E
F
I
R
S
T
L
I
N
E
O
F
D
E
F
E
N
C
E
Risk Management report (continued)
About the Group Risk Committee (continued)
98 | Governance 99
First line of defence
Thefirstlineofdefenceconsistsofallcolleagues,whoareresponsibleforensuringthatriskis
effectivelymanaged.Manycolleaguesalsohaveadditionalresponsibilitiesto:
•
Actasownersoftherisksrelevanttotheirbusinessfunction
•
Identifyandarticulatetheriskstheyareresponsibleforandputthemintoariskregister
•
Assessrisksandcontrolsanddetermineiffurtheractionsarerequired
•
Designandoperateapplicablekeycontrolsanddevelopandoperatesupplementarycontrolsas
necessary
•
Directpolicy,whichsetsoutwhatcolleaguescanandcannotdo
Third line of defence
ThethirdlineisfulfilledthroughtheInternalAuditfunction.Itindependentlyassesseswhether
risksareadequatelycontrolled,challengingtheexecutiveteamtoimprovetheeffectivenessof
governance,riskmanagementandinternalcontrols.InternalAuditreportsdirectlytotheAudit
Committee,whichisaseparateBoardcommittee.
Second line of defence
ThesecondlineisfulfilledbyourRiskdivisionwhichdefinesourapproachtowardriskmanagement
andsupports,coaches,facilitates,independentlymonitors,challenges,assessescompliance,reports,
andifnecessary,givesdirectinstructiontothefirstline.
Thisindependentsecondlineriskmanagementfunctionisresponsibleforensuringthatappropriate
riskmanagementandmeasurementtechniquesareusedthatarecommensuratewiththeGroup’s
strategicaims,itsappetiteforriskandtherisksitfacesatanytime.TheRiskdivisionensuresthatthe
GRCreceivesacomprehensiveprogrammeofdecisionpapersandreviewstoensureitisfullysighted
onsuchmatters.
TheChiefRiskOfficerprovidesaformalupdatetotheBoardandtotheGRC,viatheExecutiveRisk
Committee('ERC')onaquarterlybasis,coveringallareasofriskmanagement.Thisincludesroutine
reporting,emergingrisks,theresultsoftheRiskdivision’sindependentoversightandadditional
issuesthatmeritescalation.TheRiskdivisionisresponsibleformanagingourregulatoryrelationships
andforprovidingindependentbriefingsandinsightstotheBoard.
2
3
1
Governance
TheBoardisultimatelyresponsiblefor
theeffectivemanagementofrisk.The
approvalofriskappetiteandcertain
riskmanagementpoliciesareamongst
severalspecificareaswhichare
mattersreservedfortheBoard.
TheGRCisaBoardCommitteethat
oversees,onbehalfoftheBoard,the
keyrisksinherentinthebusiness
andthesystemofinternalcontrol
necessarytomanagesuchrisks,
presentingitsfindingstotheBoard.
TheERClookstoensurethatthe
Group’sbalancebetweenseeking
opportunityandmanagingriskis
appropriate.Itisresponsiblefor
themonitoringofday-to-dayrisk
managementactivityincluding,butnot
limitedto,reviewingtheeffectiveness
oftheGroup’sriskmanagement
frameworkandsystemofinternal
controls.Ithasauthoritytodirect
thebusinessinrelationtomitigating
actionsandtoapproveorendorserisk
acceptancewithindefinedlevels.
BelowtheBoardandsenior
managementcommitteestructureis
asetofdivisionalriskCommittees.
Thesemonitorriskmanagement
activityacrossthedivisions,acting
asapointofescalationformatters
ofGrouplevelsignificance.These
committeesalsohaveauthority
todirectmitigatingactionsandto
approveorendorseriskacceptancefor
riskswithinthedivision,inaccordance
withdefinedlevels.
TheGroup’sBoardandseniormanagementcommitteestructureisillustratedbelow,withthecommitteesmost
directlyinvolvedwithriskmanagementgovernancehighlightedinorange:
Board and related
Committees
Management and
Sub-committees
The Board
Chair's
Committee
Group Risk
Committee
Executive Risk
Committee
Audit
Committee
Remuneration
Committee
Executive
Committee
Board Governance
& Nominations
Committee
Model Risk
Committee
Commercial
Lending
Sanctioning
Committee
Retail &
Commercial
Credit Risk
Committee
Commercial
Division Risk
Committee
Customer
Services
Division Risk
Committee
Asset & Liability
Committee
Risk Management report (continued)
Three lines of defence (continued)
100 | Governance 101
Strategic risk
TherisktotheGroup’searningsorsustainabilityarisingfromchangesinthebusinessenvironmentorfromthe
effectivenessofdecisionsandactionsinourstrategicresponsetothosechanges.
Sources Approach Commentary
•
Thebusiness
environmentwe
operateincouldchange
unexpectedly.
•
Thedecisionswemake
andactionswetake
couldproveineffective.
•
Weperformregularhorizon
scanning,corporateplanning,
scenarioanalysis,competitor
analysisandbusiness
performancemonitoringto
mitigaterisksarisingfromthe
economicenvironmentandour
strategicchoices.
•
Wehavedefinedriskattitudes,
riskappetitesandriskmetrics
forallourotherprincipalrisks.
•
Ourbusinessmodelisrelatively
simple,butweoperateina
highlycompetitivemarket.Our
hedgingstrategytherefore
mitigatestherisksarisingfrom
ourfocusedrangeofproductsin
thismarket.
•
Wehavecontinuouslymonitoredtheexternal
environmentinwhichweoperate.
•
Thesizeoftheresidentialmortgagemarket
hasreduced,illustratingthepressuresthatnew
borrowersarefacingastheyeitherexercise
greatercaution,findthemselvesunabletosave,
orhavedifficultymeetinglendingcriteria.
•
Wehavealsoseenamoreacuteimpactinthe
buy-to-letmortgagemarket,asaffordability
considerationscandirectlylimittheability
landlordshavetoborrow.
•
Wehaveexperiencedmorecompetitionin
thesavingsmarket,withcustomersseeinga
premiuminpricingfortheabilitytolockmoney
awayforaperiodoftime.
•
Savingsprovidersalsocameundergreater
scrutinyfromboththemediaandregulatorsto
demonstratethatthebenefitsofhigherratesare
beingpassedonatanappropriatelevel.
Ourprincipalrisksanduncertaintiesandourriskprofileevolveaswemovethroughtheeconomiccycle.Wehaveanongoing
processforidentifying,evaluatingandmanagingtheprincipalrisksweface,andthisprocessisregularlyreviewedbytheGRC.
Capital risk
TheriskthattheGroupisnotabletomeetregulatorycapitalrequirementsordeliveronitsstrategicplansdueto
insufficientcapitalresources.
Sources Approach Commentary
•
Principalriskscould
crystallise,causinglosses
anddepletingcapital.
•
Regulatoryrequirements
forcapitalcould
increase.
•
Capitalriskisconstrainedbya
Board-approvedriskappetite
andtheBoard-approvedcapital
riskpolicy.
•
Currentandprojectedcapital
positionsareregularly
monitoredandconsidered
instressscenariosaspartof
theinternalcapitaladequacy
assessmentprocess.
•
Weconductinternaltests
toensuresufficientcapital
isavailablefortheGroupto
maintainitsminimumcapital
requirements,eveninastress
scenario.
•
Furtherinformationonour
capitalmanagementcanbe
foundintheGroup’spillar3
disclosuresonourwebsite.
•
Wemaintainedstrongcapitallevelsthroughout
2023,wellaboveregulatoryrequirementsand
internalriskappetite,andforecastthatthis
positionwillbemaintainedacrossourplanning
horizon.
•
Leveragerequirementswillbecomebinding
whenwesurpass£50bnofretaildepositsand
areclassifiedasLREQ.Wearewellcapitalisedto
meettheserequirements.
•
WecontinuetoprogresstowardsIRB
accreditation,andpreparationsarealso
underwaytoimplementBasel3.1perthePRA’s
near-finalpolicystatement(PS17/23)on1July
2025.
•
WearesubjecttoendstateMRELrequirements
(doublepillar1and2A)andcomfortablymet
theserequirementsthroughout2023.
Funding and liquidity risk
Theriskofhavinginadequatecashflowtomeetcurrentorfuturerequirementsandexpectations.
Sources Approach Commentary
•
Memberscanwithdraw
theirdepositsatshort-or
no-notice.
•
Wholesaleinvestorsmay
loseconfidenceinthe
Group.
•
Weareprimarilyfunded
throughretailsavingsbalances,
supportedbyastrongfranchise
inkeywholesalefunding
markets.
•
Fundingandliquidityrisk
isconstrainedbyaBoard-
approvedriskappetiteandthe
Board-approvedfundingand
liquidityriskpolicy.
•
TheBoardannuallyapproves
thekeyassumptionsand
controlsformanagingliquidity
riskaspartoftheinternal
liquidityadequacyassessment
process.
•
Weconductinternalteststo
ensuresufficientliquidityis
availabletomeetbusiness-
as-usualandstressed
requirements.
•
WemanagetotheLiquidity
CoverageRatio('LCR')and
theNetStableFundingRatio
('NSFR')externalregulatory
measures.
•
Ourliquiditylevelsremainedstrongand
materiallyaboveregulatoryrequirements
throughout2023.
•
WereportmonthlytothePRAthequantityof
high-qualityliquidassetsagainstnetliquidity
outflowsovera30-dayperiod,forboththe
Societyandonanunconsolidatedbasis.At
December2023,thelowerofthesetworeports
was156.36%.
•
Liquiditylevelsareforecasttoremainabove
regulatoryandinternallyderivedminimum
requirementsacross2024.
Risk Management report (continued)
Principal risks and uncertainties and how we mitigate them
102 | Governance 103
Market risk
TherisktotheGroup’searningsorthevalueofitsassetsandliabilitiesduetochangesinexternalmarketrates.
Sources Approach Commentary
•
Ourearningsorthe
valueofourassetsand
liabilitiesdeteriorate
becauseofadverse
changesinmarket
interestrates.
•
Marketriskisconstrainedbya
Board-approvedriskappetite
andthemarketriskpolicy.
•
Weadoptarisk-averseapproach
tointerestratemismatches,
althoughsomeposition-taking
isallowed,subjecttotherisk
appetite.
•
Weconductinternalteststo
ensuremarketriskiswithinan
acceptablerangeoveraseries
ofinterestratescenarios.
•
Ourlimitsforbasisrisk
includelimitsforsensitivities
aroundisolatedmovements
inunderlyingrates(SONIA),
foroverallmismatchratios,
andforensuringtheGroup
hassufficientlevelsofmargin
managementcapability.
•
Themarketriskinourbalancesheethas
reducedyear-on-year,drivenbycontinuous
activemanagementofourexposuretomarket
riskdrivers.In2023,additionaldriversofrisk
includetheprovisionsspecifiedintheMortgage
Charterandthesignificantincreaseininterest
rateenvironment.
•
Wecontinuetoproactivelymanageourinterest
rateriskexposurewithinapprovedriskappetite
limits.Allmarketriskappetitemetricswere
reviewedtoensuretheyremainedeffectivein
thecurrentinterestrateenvironmentandto
keeppacewiththeprojectedbalancesheet
growth.
•
Thereductioninmarketriskisevidencedby
areductioninourPresentValue(PV)metric.
PV100(marketvaluechangeontheSociety
balancesheetarisingfromaparallel100bps
increaseininterestrates)nowresultsinagain,
withayear-endvalueof£1.3min2023.This
positionstheSocietyfavourablyforarisein
rates,butunfavourablyshouldratesfall.
•
Our12-monthearningssensitivityhas
decreased(impacton1yearnetinterestincome
ofa2.5%parallelincrease/decreaseinrates).
ThelargestnegativesensitivityasatDecember
2023wasa£10.9mcostagainsttheparallel
downshock.
•
Astructuralhedgeisinplacetomitigatethe
interestrateriskonadministeredratesavings
balances.
Model risk
TheriskthattheSociety’smodelsthatareusedtomanagethebusinessareinaccurate,performinadequatelyorare
incorrectlyused.
Sources Approach Commentary
•
Modelsmaybe
incorrectlydesignedor
containcodingerrors.
•
Modelsmayuselogic
andassumptionsbased
onthepastwhichareno
longerrelevant.
•
Wemaintainaninventoryof
modelswhicharegovernedby
ourmodelriskpolicyandmodel
governanceframework.
•
Wehaveaprocesstoidentify
andmonitornewmodelsto
bringtheseintogovernance.
•
Compliancewiththepolicyis
monitoredbytheModelRisk
Committee('MRC'),whichis
chairedbytheChiefRiskOfficer.
•
Worktoassessourmodelriskmanagement
frameworkagainstthefinalregulatoryModel
RiskManagementPrincipleswillseeplansset
outtoclosegapsagreedbytheendofQ12024.
•
Giventhecurrentpoliticalandeconomic
climate,thereisanelevatedlevelofsystemic
modelperformanceriskinmodelswhichare
calibratedbasedonhistoricaleventsand/
orcustomerbehaviours,whichrequiresclose
monitoring.
•
Modelriskappetitetrackskeygovernance
andperformancemetrics.Measuresforthe
performanceofcriticalmodelsarepresentedto
theMRCtoensuremitigantsandremedialplans
areputinplacetomanageandaddressany
identifiedrisks.
Treasury risk
Theriskoflossesfollowingdefaultonexposuresarisingfrombalanceswithotherfinancialinstitutions,liquidasset
holdingsandtheuseofderivativeinstrumentstomanageinterestrateandforeignexchangerisk.
Sources Approach Commentary
•
Transactingwith
otherfinancialmarket
participantswhen
managingmarketrisk
whothenfailtofulfil
theirobligations.
•
Treasuryriskisconstrainedby
aBoard-approvedriskappetite
andthetreasuryriskpolicy.
•
Mostofourliquidassetbuffer
portfolioisinvestedinthe
highestqualityassets.
•
Mostofourderivativecontracts
aresubjecttocentralised
clearingtominimiserisk
exposureswithcounterparties.
Wherethisisnotpossible,
derivativeexposuresare
restrictedtohighquality
counterpartieswhichare
subjectedtoregularreview
bytheAssetandLiability
Committee('ALCO').
•
Werevieweachwholesalecounterpartylimitat
leastonanannualbasis,orsoonerifariskevent
occursintheinterim.
•
Thesizeofthecreditlimitweallocatetoeach
counterpartyisdrivenbytheircreditstatus
asdeterminedbyinternalanalysis,andis
calibratedtothesizeoftheGroup’scapital
positiontoensurethatthefinancialviabilityof
theSocietyisnotoverlyexposedtoanysingle
counterparty.
•
ExposuretoAA-orabovecounterparties
remainshigh,maintainingthelowriskprofilein
accordancewithBoardriskappetite.
•
Theriskhasnotmateriallychangedsince
lastyear;marketvolatilityisstillatrelatively
elevatedlevelsgenerallybutthecreditcontrols
wehaveinplaceremainappropriate.
Risk Management report (continued)
Principal risks and uncertainties and how we mitigate them (continued)
104 | Governance 105
Retail and commercial credit risk
Theriskofcreditlossesfromafailuretodesign,implementandmonitoranappropriatecreditriskappetite.
Sources Approach Commentary
•
Loanstoretailand
commercialcustomers
maynotbefullyrepaid.
•
Retailandcommercialcredit
riskisconstrainedbyaBoard-
approvedriskappetiteandthe
commerciallendingpolicy.
•
Ourrobustcreditriskframework
ensureslendingremains
withinlimitsandappropriate
remedialactionistakenifa
breachoccurs.Adherenceis
monitoredthroughgovernance
committees.
•
Weregularlyusestresstesting
toassesstheresilienceofour
portfolio.
•
Ourcreditriskmodelsare
overseenbythemodel
governanceframework(see
modelrisksection).
•
Wecontinuetoexhibitalow,albeitrisinglevelof
mortgagesinarrears.Attheyear-endour>=3m
arrearsrateforretailmortgageswas0.50%,an
increasefrom0.44%attheendof2022.This
comparesfavourablytothelatestUKfinance
marketaverageof0.87%.OurCommercial
Lending>=3marrearsrateis0.54%.
•
Inthecurrentenvironment,akeyriskfor
residentialcustomersmaturingfromlowfixed
rateproductsandeitherre-fixingatamuch
higherrateormovingtoavariablerate.Wehave
seenincreasedarrearsemergencefromthis
cohortcomparedtotherestofthestock,inline
withourinternalarrearsforecast.
•
Wehavepreparedforincreasedarrearsvolumes
andwillbemonitoringthiscloselyin2024.We
continuetoproactivelycontactthemostat-risk
customerstosupportthemthroughtheeconomic
environment.
•
TheYBSresidentialpossessionratewas0.01%at
theyear-end,comparedtothelatestUKfinance
marketvalueof0.02%.ForRetailBTLmortgages,
theYBSpossessionrateis0.07%,comparedto
theUKfinancemarketaverageof0.05%,whichis
drivenbyourlegacyretailbuy-to-letportfolios.
•
Ourretailmortgagebookhasremainedresilient
toHPImovementsin2023.4.11%oftheretail
portfoliohasanindexedLTV>85%,compared
to1.22%inDecember2022.Theincreaseis
drivenbydeclininghousepricemovementsin
2023offsetbyalowervolumeof>85%LTV
completionsthroughout2023(22%in2023
comparedto27%in2022).
•
Overall,theassetqualityofourportfoliosremains
strong.Alargeproportionoftheexpectedcredit
lossesheldagainstourmortgagesrelatestopre-
2009lendingandtheportfoliosacquiredthrough
theN&PandChelseamergers.Seenote31for
moredetails.
Operational risk
Theriskofdirectorindirectlossresultingfrominadequateorfailedinternalprocesses,peopleandsystems,orfrom
externalevents.
Sources Approach Commentary
•
Ourtechnologymayfail.
•
Oursuppliersmayfailto
meettheircontractual
obligations.
•
Wemaynotbeableto
recruitandretainthe
rightpeople.
•
Criminalsmayuse
theSocietyforillegal
activity.
•
Otherexternalevents.
•
Operationalriskisconstrained
byaBoard-approvedrisk
appetiteandanumberofrisk-
specificpolicies.
•
TheERMFdefineshow
colleaguesareexpected
toidentify,assess,monitor,
manageandreporttheir
operationalriskexposures.
•
Directorsmustregularlyattest
totheeffectivenessofthe
controlstheyareresponsible
forthroughtheriskandcontrol
self-assessmentprocess.
•
Therehasbeenanincreaseinthevalueof
operationallossesin2023to£2.6m(2022:
£1.0m)becauseofarangeofnon-systemic
incidents.
•
Oversightofourtransformationandsecurity
improvementprogrammeshasbeeninplace
throughout2023,withcontinuousmonitoring
activityandperiodicreportingtotheGroupRisk
Committee.
•
Wecontinuetodevelopthematurityofour
operationalriskcontrolenvironment,with
plansandsupportinginvestmentinplace
acrossourinformationtechnology,information
managementandinformationsecurityrisk
categoriesalongwithtargetedimprovements
andinvestmentinourfinancialcrimerisk
managementcapabilities.
•
Weengagedanexternalreviewofour
governance,riskandcontrolcapabilitiesand
plantostrengthentheminanticipationoffuture
growthandthepossibilityofbeingdesignateda
categoryonefirmbythePRA.
Compliance and conduct risk
Theriskofdirectorindirectlossfromafailuretocomplywithregulationortoensuregoodcustomeroutcomes.
Sources Approach Commentary
•
Developingnew
productsforour
customers.
•
Marketingourproducts.
•
Servingourcustomers.
•
Complianceandconductrisk
isconstrainedbyaBoard-
approvedriskappetiteanda
numberofrisk-specificpolicies.
•
Wemonitorconductriskmetrics
foranumberofareasincluding
sales,service,complaintsand
collections.
•
Thesecondlineofdefence
providescompliancesupport
onallregulatorymattersto
thefirstline,forbothday-to-
dayoperationsandchange
programmes.
•
TheFCA’snewConsumerDutyregulation
cameintoforceinJuly2023foropenproducts
andservices.Weundertookcomprehensive
programmeofworktomeetthoserequirements,
theoutcomesofwhichwereapprovedbyYBS’s
Board.WorkisunderwaytomeettheJuly2024
regulatorydeadlinesforclosedproductsand
servicesandtheannualBoardattestation.
•
Complaintsper1,000at2023H2were0.89for
savingsandshareplans,and5.68formortgages.
•
Acompliancemonitoringplan,approvedbythe
GRC,hasbeencompletedduring2023allowing
robustoversightofthekeyareasofconduct,
financialcrime,anddataprotectionrisk.All
oversightfindingsarethesubjectofaformal
actionplanoverseentoclosurebytheGRC.
Risk Management report (continued)
Principal risks and uncertainties and how we mitigate them (continued)
106 | Governance 107
Climate risk
Werecognisethephysicaland
transitionrisksarisingfromclimate
changecreateriskexposuresfor
theGroupinseveraloftheprincipal
riskcategoriesabove.Wetherefore
managetheserisksthroughtheERMF
toensuretheyareproperlyconsidered
alongsidetheotherrisksweface.
Further detail on how we manage
climate change risk can be found
in the ‘Building a greener society’
section.
Stress testing
Stresstestingisaproactiverisk
managementtoolusedthroughout
theGrouptobetterunderstand
thepotentialvulnerabilitiesin
ourbusinessmodelandtoderive
effectivemanagementactions.Stress
testingispresentedtoarangeof
forumsandCommitteesincludingthe
ALCO,theGRCandtheBoard.2023
demonstratedtheimportanceofstress
testingwithcontinuouseconomicand
marketvolatility.
Thekeyusesofstresstestingare:
•
Totesttherobustnessofour
financialplanandexposurelimitsto
adverseeconomicconditions
•
Scenarioanalysisofourrecovery
planandcontingencyfunding
options
•
Tosupporttheproductionof
theinternalcapitaladequacy
assessment('ICAAP')andinternal
liquidityadequacyassessment
('ILAAP')processes,whichinform
ourregulatorycapitalandliquidity
requirements
•
Keepinguptodatewithmarket
movementsthroughdailytesting
offundingandliquidityandmarket
risks
•
Toprovideperformance
managementinformationtosupport
mortgagetradingdecisions
•
Toassessnewproductsand
initiatives
•
Tounderstand,throughtheGroup’s
annualreversestresstests,howto
preventriskscrystallising.
Wehavealsomodelledtheimpact
oftheBankofEngland’sAnnual
ConcurrentStresstest('ACS').This
allowsustoevaluatehowtheGroup
performsunderthisscenarioand
relativetotheorganisationsthat
arepartofthisprocess.Thetest
showedthatwearewellpositionedto
withstandastresseventsuchasthat
definedintheACS.
Directors’
remuneration
report
Awordfrom
theChairofthe
Remuneration
Committee.
Iampleasedtosharethe
Directors’Remuneration
report,myfirstasChairofthe
RemunerationCommittee.Iwould
liketooffermysincerethanksto
AlisonHutchinsonforherservice
totheCommitteeandthesupport
shehasprovidedduringthe
handoverperiod.Alisonremainsa
valuedmemberoftheCommittee,
andIlookforwardtoworking
withallourCommitteemembers
throughout2024.
Alison Hutchinson
Senior Independent Non-Executive
Director and Vice Chair as well as
member of the Group Risk Committee
and Non-Executive Director for Workforce
Representative.
Jennelle Tilling
Independent Non-Executive Director
Dina Matta
Independent Non-Executive Director
About the Remuneration Committee
ThemembersoftheRemunerationCommitteeconsistof
Non-ExecutiveDirectorsandincludemembersoftheSociety’s
GroupRiskCommittee:
TheRemunerationCommitteeissupportedbytheChairofthe
Board,theChiefPeopleOfficerandtheDirectorofPeopleand
Culture.Whereitisfelttobeappropriate,theChiefExecutiveis
invitedtoattendtoprovidefurtherbackgroundandcontextto
assisttheCommitteeindischargingitsduties.
Debra Davies
Independent Non-Executive Director
and Committee Chair and member of the
Group Risk Committee.
Risk Management report (continued)
108 | Governance 109
Looking back at 2023
2023continuedtopresentgreat
challengesinrespectofthewider
politicalandeconomicenvironment
inwhichweoperate,fortheSociety,
ourmembers,andourcolleagues
alike.Despitethis,asoutlinedinthe
FinancialReview
section,theSociety
hasdeliveredanotherverystrong
setoffinancialresultsin2023.I’m
proudofthewayourcolleagues
havecontinuedtodeliverstrong
performanceagainstourCorporate
Plan,deliveringrealvalueand
improvingtheserviceweoffertoour
members.
Tosupportourcolleagueswiththe
continuedpressureseenonpersonal
financesweagreedtoawarda6%
corepayincreaseforalleligible
colleaguesaspartofthe2023annual
payreview,supplementedbyan
additional1%whichleaderswere
abletoallocateonadiscretionary
basiswherefurtheradjustmentswere
feltnecessary.TheCommitteealso
approvedtheintroductionofanew
minimum salary of £22,000 for all
colleagues,regardlessoftherole
theyperform(pro-ratedforparttime
colleagues).Thisfurthersupported
ourcommitmenttopayinlinewithor
abovetheRealLivingWage.
TheSocietyhasdeliveredstrong
financialperformancein2023with
CoreProfitBeforeTaxof£445.9m
againstatargetof£359.8m.In
addition,theSocietycontinuedto
provideexcellentservicetoour
membersasdemonstratedbya
NetPromoterScorefortheyear
of61againstatargetof55.This
combinedperformance,supported
byaneffectiveriskenvironmenthas
resultedinalleligiblecolleaguesbeing
awardedwitha10%bonuspayment,
themaximumavailableunderour
scheme.
InMarch2023wewelcomedour
ChiefExecutive,SusanAllen.Susan
hasmadearealimpactsincejoining
theorganisation,demonstratingher
tremendouspassionforprovidingthe
bestproductsandexcellentserviceto
ourmembers.Susanbringsawealth
ofbankingexperienceandsignificant
operationalandtechnicalknowledge
thatwillbeparamountastheSociety
deliversitspurposeofrealhelpwith
reallife,inachallengingexternal
environment.Theremuneration
packageforthenewCEOisinline
withourRemunerationPolicyand
wassettakingintoconsideration
marketlevelsofremuneration
aswellasherextensivefinancial
servicesexperience.Asnormalin
thesecircumstances,wehaveagreed
tocompensateSusanfortheloss
ofdeferredbonusforfeitedonher
resignationfromBarclays;these
replacementawardsarenomore
generousthantheoriginalawardsand
willbepaidinlinewithpriorvesting
schedule.Thefullremunerationdetails
forSusanareoutlinedinthisreport.
Directors' remuneration
outcomes for 2023
TheCommitteebelievestheExecutive
Directorshavecontinuedtodeliver
realbenefitsfortheSociety,including
improvementstocustomerjourneys
acrossmultiplechannelsandthe
streamliningofkeyprocesses
whichhavehelpedtoimprove
customerexperience.Thisisfurther
demonstratedbyensuringsignificant
investmentinmembervaluethrough
oursavingspropositions,thestrong
financialperformanceoftheSociety
andprogressagainstourcommunity
anddiversityobjectives.Itisonthis
basisthatwehavegrantedvariable
payawardstoourExecutiveDirectors
inrespectofthe2023performance
year.
TheSociety’sBuildingTogetherbonus
schemepaidoutatthemaximumlevel
of10%foralleligiblecolleagues,
includingExecutiveDirectors.
ExecutiveDirectorsareeligibleto
receiveanadditionalbonusawardas
partoftheSeniorLeadershipelement
oftheBuildingTogetherbonus
scheme.Thevalueofthisadditional
awardisdeterminedbytheirlevelof
performanceasmeasuredagainsttheir
individualscorecard.
ExecutiveDirectorsarealsoeligible
toparticipateintheLeadingfor
Valuebonusscheme.TheLeading
forValueschemeincludesinyear
performancetargetssetagainst
ourlonger-termobjectives,serving
toprotecttheSociety’sfinancial
strengthwhilstfocusingondelivering
longtermmembervalue.Allofthe
schemeunderpinsfor2023,which
includedupgradestoouroperational
riskcapabilityhavebeenmet,which
hasunlockedabonusawardonthis
scheme.Performanceagainstthe
scorecardareas-Transformation,
MemberValueandESGmetricshas
resultedinanoveralloutturnof
72%foreligibleparticipantsonthis
scheme.
ThismeanteligibleExecutiveDirectors
receivedanaveragetotalbonusof
88%oftheirsalarywhencombining
theawardsgrantedtothemas
partoftheBuildingTogetherand
LeadingforValuebonusschemes.
Wehaveincludedfulldetailsofhow
remunerationisawardedtoExecutive
Directorsandtheamountslaterin
thisreport.
In2023theCommitteecarriedouta
reviewofhowthemulti-yearLeading
forValueschemehadperformed
againstitsobjectivessinceits
introductionin2021.2023isthefinal
yearoftheLeadingforValuescheme
initscurrentconstruct.TheCommittee
lookedbackatperformanceoverthe
3-yearperiodandconcludedthatthe
schemehadmetitsintendedaimof
rewardingkeystrategicmilestones
anddeliveryoflong-termvalueto
members.Overthedurationofthe
scheme,membervaluehasbeen
createdthroughofferingrewarding
ratestothosesavingwithus.Thiswas
achievedthroughthedevelopment
ofmemberloyaltypropositions,
whichprovidedcompetitiverates,
andthroughpassingonincreasesto
ourvariable-ratecustomerswhen
theBankRateincreased.In2023the
ratesweprovidedwereonaverage
1.01percentagepointshigherthan
themarketaverage,whichequatesto
c.£441.1madditionalinterestpaidto
oursavers.
For more information, please see
the member value section of the
Strategic report.
AstheSocietyevolves,wecontinuetoreviewthewidermarket,
adjustingwhererequiredtoensuretheSocietyisabletoattractthe
talentandcapabilityrequiredatalllevelsintheorganisation.An
exampleofthisiswithintheCommercialLendingteam,whichsawthe
introductionofanewbonusschemein2023.ThisbringstheSociety
moreinlinewiththewidermarketremunerationofferingforthistype
ofbusinesswhichhashelpedtheSocietytoattractandretainthe
requiredcalibreofcolleaguetodeliverourambitiousplans.
2024 Remuneration Policy
TheRemunerationPolicyforourExecutiveDirectorswillbesubject
toanadvisorymembervoteatthe2024AGM,inlinewithour
commitmenttohaveaRemunerationPolicyvoteatleastevery
threeyears.
Asamutual,ourapproachtoremunerationreflectstheneedsofour
membersandisconsistentwithourpurposeandstrategy.During
2023theCommitteeundertookacomprehensivereviewofthe
RemunerationPolicy,applicabletoExecutiveDirectorsandthewider
colleaguepopulation,toensureitremainedalignedtotheSociety’s
purposeandstrategy.TheCommitteerefinedthepeergroupagainst
whichitconsidersmarketpaylevels,toensureremunerationis
positionedatalevelthatsupportstheattractionandretentionofthe
requiredtalentandcapability.
Followingthereview,anewvariablepayschemehasbeendeveloped
andtheallcolleagueschemehasbeenrefinedtosupportthe
Society’sobjectives.Theseincludedthecreationofanambitious
culture,andthefosteringofanenvironmentwherehighperformance
isrecognisedandrewarded.ForSeniorLeaders,theremuneration
approachhasbeensimplified,withvariablepaynowdelivered
throughasingleincentiveplan.WhilstSeniorLeaderswillnolonger
participateinBuildingTogether,keymeasuresofprofitandcustomer
satisfactionwillcontinuetobeassessedwithinthenewplan
alongsideothermeasuresfocusedonthedeliveryoftheSociety’s
purposeandstrategy.Thisapproachisintendedtoaidtransparency
formembersandparticipants,whilstalsorecognisingtheregulatory
expectationsofaProportionalityLevelOneFirm.Themaximum
opportunityforExecutiveDirectorswillremainunchangedwithinthe
newscheme.
Full details of the proposed changes can be found in the
Remuneration Policy section of this report.
Looking forward to the year ahead
TheCommitteehavereviewedtheSociety’splansforcontinued
transformationin2024andhaveproposedchangestothe
RemunerationPolicytoensurethatthestructureandperformance
measuresoftheremunerationcomponentscontinuetoprovidelong
termmembervalueandfinancialsustainabilityfortheSociety.
IftheproposedchangestotheRemunerationPolicyareapproved,
theCommitteewillcontinuetomonitorandreviewthesethroughout
2024toensuretheyareoperatingasintended(adjustingwhere
required).Wewillalsocontinuetoreviewourremunerationpolicies
toensuretheyarealignedtotheregulatoryexpectationsofa
ProportionalityLevelOnefirm.
OnbehalfoftheCommittee,Irecommendthatyouendorseandvote
infavouroftheproposedRemunerationPolicychangesandthe2023
DirectorsRemunerationreportattheforthcomingAGM.
Debra Davies
ChairoftheRemunerationCommittee
28February2024
Directors Remuneration report (continued)
A word from the Chair of the Remuneration Committee (continued)
110 | Governance 111
Basis of Preparation
Forthe2023financialyearwehaveappliedtheprinciplesandcompliedwiththeprovisionsoftheCodepublishedinJuly
2018(availableontheFinancialReportingCouncil’swebsitewww.frc.org.uk)asfarastheyapplytoBuildingSocieties(as
setoutintheBuildingSocietiesAssociation(BSA)Guidanceavailableatwww.bsa.org.uk)otherthanwherestatedinthe
CorporateGovernancereport.
Executive Directors remuneration for 2023
Allremunerationinthe2023performanceyearhasbeenawardedinlinewiththeSociety’sRemunerationPolicy.
Details of the full policy relevant for 2023 can be found at www.ybs.co.uk.
ThetablebelowshowsthesingletotalfiguretableofremunerationfortheExecutiveDirectorsoftheSocietyfortheyears
ended31December2023and31December2022.Thisinformationhasbeenauditedbyourindependentauditors,PwC.
Base salary
In2023AlasdairLenmanandDavidMorriswerebothawardedapayincreaseof5%,whichtookeffectfrom01May2023.
Theseupliftsarecommensuratewiththoseprovidedtoallcolleaguesandinlinewithouranalysisofthebroadermarket.
Uponhire,SusanAllenwasawardedanannualsalaryof£785,000andtherewasnofurtherbasesalaryincreaseduring2023.
Single total figure of remuneration for each Executive Director (audited)
* SusanAllenjoinedtheSocietyasChiefExecutiveon2March2023andwasawardedanannualbasesalaryof£785,000.Replacementawardsinclude£1,684,356
awardedtocompensatefordeferredawardsforfeitedonleavingherpreviousemployerandanawardof£832,000tocompensateforlostincentiveopportunityin
respectofthe2022PerformancePeriod.Inlinewithremunerationregulatoryexpectationsthesereplacementawardswillvestinlinewithpriorvestingschedule.
ThebonusawardedtoSusanforthe2023performanceperiodundertheBuildingTogetherandLeadingforValuebonusschemeshasbeencalculatedbasedonher
annualsalaryasat31December2023.
** AlasdairLenmantookontheroleofInterimChiefExecutivefrom17June2022,uponwhichhewasawardedanadditionalresponsibilityallowance.Followingthe
appointmentofSusanAllen,AlasdairsteppeddownasInterimChiefExecutiveon2March2023,afterwhichpaymentofhisadditionalresponsibilityallowance
ceased.Thevalueofthesepayments,£59,163.46in2022and£27,468.75in2023hasbeenincludedintheBaseSalarycolumn.
Fixed
Remuneration
Variable
Remuneration
Total
Remuneration
Excluding
Replacement
Awards
Total
Remuneration
Including
Replacement
Awards
2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022
Executive
Directors Role
Base
Salary
£000
Taxable
Benefits
£000
Pension
£000
Total
Fixed
£000
Bonus
£000
Replacement
Awards
£000
Total
Variable
£000 £000 £000
Susan
Allen*
Chief
Executive
Officer
655 N/A 26 N/A 72 N/A 753 N/A 777 N/A 2,516 N/A 3,293 N/A 1,530 N/A 4,046 N/A
Alasdair
Lenman**
Chief Finance
Officer /
Interim Chief
Executive
Officer
482 480 31 31 50 46 563 557 378 408 - - 378 408 941 965 941 965
David
Morris
Chief
Commercial
Officer
362 350 12 11 40 38 414 399 311 298 - - 311 298 725 697 725 697
Variable pay
ThissectionexplainstheunderpinsandmechanicsofthevariablepayschemesinoperationbytheSocietyin2023.The
underpinsusedfortheBuildingTogetherschemesarethesameforallcolleagues(includingExecutiveDirectors).
Financial performance
ThefirstperformancemeasureisProfitBeforeTax,whichisadjusted
forbonuspurposestoexcludeitems,bothpositiveandnegative,
wheretheydonotreflectunderlyingcommercialperformance–i.e.
timingdifferencesandoraccountingtreatment,thisisreferredtoas
theSociety’sCoreProfitBeforeTax(CorePBT).ForBuildingTogether
thisisusedtobothunlockanddeterminethevariablepaypool.For
LeadingforValueCorePBTisonlyusedtounlockthevariablepay
opportunity.
TheCommitteehasscopetoadjustthecalculationofprofitwithin
thevariablepayplan,forexampletoreflecttheneedtoincrease
ourcapital(intheeventofSocietygrowth)ortoreflectsignificant
deviationfromcostmanagementplans.
Thefollowingprinciplesareappliedwhenidentifyingpotential
adjustments:
•
Whereanunexpectedorunplanneditemarisesthatisnotpartof
thecore,businessasusual,runningoftheSociety.Forexample,
one-offinvestmentsorprojectsthatwerenotincludedintheplan
profitnumberagainstwhichactualperformanceisjudged.
•
Removalofbothpositiveandnegativeimpactsfromnon-core
actionsthatdonotreflectmanagementoftheSociety.Forexample,
anyunplannedprofits(orlosses)onthesaleofpropertywouldnot
beincludedintheCorePBTfigureusedtocalculatevariablepay
awardlevels.
Inlinewiththeprinciplesabove,theoverallCorePBTfigureachieved
in2023was£445.9magainstareportedstatutoryfigureof£450.3m.
Thisrepresentsaperformancelevelaboveboththetarget£359.8m
andstretch£414.6mmetricsfortheSociety’sbonusschemesand
setsthefinancialelementofthevariablepayearningpotential.The
Committeeweresatisfied,basedonanalysispresented,thatthe
businessoutperformedevenwhentheimpactoftheBankBaseRate
changesduringtheyearwereexcluded.
Customer experience
Thesecondperformancemeasureisthecustomer‘NetPromoter
Score’(‘NPS’)whichmeasureshowlikelyourmembersandcustomers
aretorecommendus.
NPSunlockstheBuildingTogethervariablepaypoolwhichisthen
moderatedupordownfromtargetbasedontheNPSoutcomes.
Our2023SocietyNPSconstructandtargetswere:
TheoverallNPSfigureachievedin2023was61,
whichrepresentsaperformancelevelaboveboth
thetargetof55andstretchmetricof60forthe
Society’s2023bonusschemes.
Financial sustainability review
Inadditiontotheabove,beforeanyvariable
payawardsaregranted,anumberofreviewsare
completedtoensurethelevelofcapitalheldby
theSocietyremainssustainableandcompliant
withregulationaswellasanassessmentwhich
determinesthattheSociety’scostmanagement
practicesarerobust.
Building Together
TheSociety’sperformanceagainsttheCorePBT
andNPStargetsdeterminesthecorevariable
payaward,whichisunderpinnedbyafinancial
sustainabilityreview.Allneedtobeachieved
beforeanyvariablepayawardwillbegranted.
ForExecutiveDirectors,aswellastheSenior
LeadershipTeam(‘SLT’),anadditionalpercentageof
variablepaymaybeawardedbasedonindividual
performance.Theassessmentofindividual
performanceismeasuredagainsttheachievement
oftheirindividualscorecard,whichcontainsboth
financialandnon-financialmeasures.
Leading for Value
2023isthefinalyearofthemulti-yearLeadingfor
Valuescheme.Theschemeoperatedinadditionto
theBuildingTogetherscheme,withperformance
assessedagainstthedeliveryofmeasurableand
targetedfinancialvalueformembers,achievement
ofkeystrategicmilestonesandESGperformance
againstcolleagueengagement,inclusionand
diversityandsocialimpacttargets.Targetsfor2023
weresetbyreferencetothelong-termstrategy,in
ordertosupportlong-termvaluecreationandto
alignwithremunerationregulatoryexpectations.
TheExecutiveCommitteeandtheChairofthe
Boardcarryoutapre-grantassessmentbefore
determiningindividualeligibilityforthisscheme
andconsiderbothpersonal(e.g.individual
performanceandcompensationlevelscompared
tothemarket)andtheSociety’sperformance(e.g.
Capital,Liquidityandriskplusfinancialmeasures).
Theoutcomeofthispre-grantassessment
determinesthemaximumopportunitythatwill
beavailabletotheindividual,subjecttothe
overallmaximumlevelsetwithinthescheme.The
RemunerationCommitteeoverseethisprocess
beforeagreeingtoanyproposals.
Weighting on
Society NPS 2023 target
Savings Customer 40% 46
Mortgage Customer 25% 51
Digital NPS 10% 41
Broker Residential 20% 82
Broker buy-to-let 5% 75
Society NPS Total 55
Directors Remuneration report (continued)
112 | Governance 113
PaymentisalsounderpinnedbygatewaymetricsincludingtheachievementofCoreOperatingProfitandNPSbeingata
levelinlinewiththresholdforBuildingTogether,andupgradestoouroperationalriskcapability.Followingtheyear-end,
theRemunerationCommitteeassessesperformanceagainsteachmetrictodeterminethevariablepayoutturn.Forthe
2023performanceyear,theRemunerationCommitteeagreeda72%outturnfortheplan,basedontheoverallachievement
oftargetoraboveagainsttheTransformation,MemberValueandESGmetrics.Allvariablepayawardsaresubjecttothe
operationofaBusinessControlsOverlay(BCO)Processasoutlinedinthe
RemunerationPolicy.
How variable pay is awarded for Executive Directors
Inlinewithrelevantremunerationregulations,variablepayawardsforExecutiveDirectorsaresubjecttodeferraloveramulti-
yearperiod.
Thistablebelowshowstheyearsinwhichthe2023performanceyearpaymentstoExecutiveDirectorsvest,with50%
deliveredincashand50%viaShareEquivalentInstrument(‘SEI’).PaymentsmadeviaSEIaresubjecttoaholdingperiod.
ForfurtherdetailsondeferralpleaserefertotheDeferralandShareEquivalentInstrument(‘SEI’)section.
How Leading for Value was calculated for Executive Directors
Measures Levels of achievement
Transformation
40%
•
Aligningaccountopeningtimesandavailabilityofdigital
serviceswithcustomerneeds
•
Improvedpaymentsserviceforsavingscustomers
•
Improvingaccesstomortgagelending
•
Improvedmortgagedecisions
•
SimplificationofservicesforSavingsaccounts
24%
Member value
30%
•
Improvingsavingsreturnsformembers
30%
ESG
30%
•
Financialeducationandincreaseawarenessinlocal
communities
•
Creatingamorediverseandinclusiveorganisation
•
Maintainhighlevelsofcolleagueengagement
18%
Total Award Deferral schedule
Executive
Director Role
% of
salary
2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031
Cash SEI Cash SEI Cash SEI Cash SEI Cash SEI Cash SEI Cash SEI Cash SEI Cash SEI
£000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
Susan
Allen*
CEO 99.00 388.5 388.5 155.4
155.4
-
-
-
-
46.6
46.6
46.6
46.6
46.6
46.6
46.6
46.6
46.6
46.6
Alasdair
Lenman
Interim
CEO/
CFO
78.42 189.0 189.0 75.5
75.5
-
-
-
-
22.7
22.7
22.7
22.7
22.7
22.7
22.7
22.7
22.7
22.7
David
Morris
CCO 86.00 155.6 155.6 62.2
62.2
-
-
-
-
18.7
18.7
18.7
18.7
18.7
18.7
18.7
18.7
18.7
18.7
*ThebonusawardedtoSusanAllenforthe2023performanceperiodundertheBuildingTogetherandLeadingforValuebonusschemeshasbeencalculatedbasedonher
annualsalaryasat31December2023.
Payments for loss of office
TherewerenopaymentstoDirectorsforlossofofficein2023.
Payments to past Directors
TherewerenopaymentsmadetopastDirectorsin2023thathavenotalreadybeendisclosedinpreviousreports.
Colleague considerations in relation to remuneration
OuraimistobuildaworkingenvironmentwherecolleaguesfeelengagedandcommittedtotheSociety’sjourney,ensuring
theyfeelvaluedandrespectedtogivetheirbest.Ourrewardofferingisintegraltothat,withanapproachfoundedinour
mutualityandvalues.OurRemunerationPolicyisinplacetosupportourcolleaguesinworkingtogetherforthebenefitofthe
Societyandourmembersandcustomers.Thishasbeenreviewedfor2024,withchangesmadetosupporttheSociety’snew
strategy,includingthecreationofanambitiousculture,andtofosteranenvironmentwherehighperformanceisrecognised
andrewarded.
Colleague listening
TheSocietyactivelyseeksviewsofcolleaguesthrough
avarietyofsources,includingthroughourrecognised
tradeunion,Aegis.OurColleagueForumandPerformance
andRewardCommitteeareotherexamplesofwherewe
gaindirectcolleagueinputintothedesignandongoing
developmentoftheSociety’sremunerationframework.
AlisonHutchinson,amemberoftheRemuneration
Committee,andtheCommitteeChairuntilSeptember2023
hasheldtheroleofNon-ExecutiveDirectorforWorkforce
Engagementsince2019,withAngelaDarlingtontaking
overthispositioninJanuary2024.Theviewsofcolleagues
havebeentakenintoconsiderationaspartoftheSociety's
RemunerationPolicy,howeverconsultationonspecific
policyamendmentshasnotbeenundertaken.
Supporting colleagues in 2023
Itisimportanttousthatourcolleaguesfeelrecognised,
valuedandfairlyrewardedforthecontributionstheymake
toprovidingessentialservicestoourcustomersandthe
effectiverunningofouroperations.
In2023wemadeasignificantinvestmentinbasepay,
providingeligiblecolleagueswitha6%salaryincrease
whichwasaccompaniedbyanadditional1%discretionary
allocationforleaderstoallocatewherefurtheradjustments
wereneededtoaddressareassuchascolleagueswho
hadsignificantlydevelopedintheirroleortosupport
marketalignment.Wealsorecognisedthecostofliving
andinflationarypressuresfeltbysomeofourlowestpaid
colleaguesandintroducedaSociety-wideminimumfull-
timeequivalentsalaryof£22,000.Wealsomaintainedour
commitmenttopayallcolleaguesandcontingentworkersat
orabovetheRealLivingWage.
CEO pay ratio reporting
WecontinuetopublishtheratiooftheChiefExecutive’spaytothewidercolleaguepopulation.Thisratiocomparesthetotal
remunerationoftheCEOagainstthetotalremunerationofthemediancolleagueandthosewhositatthe25thand75th
percentiles(lowerandupperquartiles).
ThisratioreflectsthenatureoftheSociety,inparticulartherangeofdifferentrolesandskillsetsrequiredtooperatewithin
financialservices;fromanumberofcustomer-facingcolleaguesinthebranchnetworkandcallcentres,throughto,for
example,heavilytechnicalspecialistrolesinourTreasurydepartment.
Thisyear’scalculationisbasedonacombinationofearningsfromAlasdairLenmanandSusanAllen,whohavebothheldthe
positionofChiefExecutive(orInterimChiefExecutive)in2023.ForAlasdairLenman,thisincludeshisfixedearningsupto
andincludingthe01March2023,aswellasaproportionofhisvariableearningsfor2023(pro-ratedtotheperiodinwhich
hewasperformingtheroleofInterimCEO).ForSusanAllenthisincludesherfixedandvariableearningsfrom02March2023
paidinrespectofthe2023performanceperiod,aswellasthevalueofthereplacementawardsgranteduponhire.
72%
Directors Remuneration report (continued)
Leading for Value (continued)
114 | Governance 115
RecentresignationsfromtheCEOandInterimCEOpositionoverthelastfewyearshavecontributedtoarelativereduction
betweenthelevelofpayawardedtotheCEOandthatofthewidercolleaguepopulation.Theappointmentofanew
permanentCEOnowprovidesamorerepresentativeviewofCEOpaycomparedtothewidercolleaguepopulation.
Thetotalremunerationvaluesandbasesalaryvaluesforthe25th,50thand75thpercentileemployeesfor2023are:
Wehaveusedthereportingmethodof‘OptionB’,whichinvolvesutilisingourexistinggenderpaygapreportingdataasthe
basisforidentifyingthecolleaguesateachoftherequiredquartiles.ThetotalRemunerationcalculationforthecolleagues
identifiedateachquartilewastakenasat31December2023.
Year 25th percentile 50th percentile 75th percentile
Total £28,461.93 £38,489.83 £61,687,04
Salary £23,444.30 £32,860.53 £50,571.34
* Thefollowingelementshavebeenutilisedtocalculatethetotalremunerationofeachcolleague;basesalary,pension(includingpensioncashallowance),car
allowance,privatemedicalinsuranceandvariablepay.
Non-Executive Directors
Chair of the Board and Non-Executive Directors
TheChairoftheBoardandNon-ExecutiveDirector(‘NED’)feesarereviewedannually.Followinganalysisofthemarketdata
available,andinlinewiththeawardprovidedtoallcolleagues,theNEDfeeswereincreasedin2023asoutlinedbelow.
Single total figure of remuneration for each Non-Executive Director
TheNon-ExecutiveDirectorsbasicandcommitteefeesearnedin2023areoutlinedbelow.Non-ExecutiveDirectorsdonot
receiveanybenefits,butarereimbursedforanyexpensesincurred,suchastravelandsubsistence.Thisinformationhasbeen
auditedbyourindependentauditors,PwC.
Non-Executive Director fees (annual equivalents) Annual fees as at 1 July 2023 Annual fees as at 1 July 2022
£000 £000
ChairoftheBoardbasicfee 216.2 202.0
ViceChairoftheBoardbasicfee 81.5 76.1
Non-ExecutiveDirectorbasicfee 57.5 53.7
Additional fee for:
AuditCommittee-Chair 23.4 21.8
AuditCommittee-Member 9.7 9.0
RemunerationCommittee–Chair 19.1 17.8
RemunerationCommittee–Member 7.0 6.5
GroupRiskCommittee-Chair 23.4 21.8
GroupRiskCommittee-Member 9.7 9.0
BoardGovernance&NominationsCommitteeMember
(N.B.AdditionalfeedoesnotapplytotheChairorViceChair)
7.0 6.5
2023 2022
Non-Executive Director Basic Fees Committee
Fees
Total Basic Fees Committee
Fees
Total
£000 £000 £000 £000 £000 £000
John Heaps (Chair) 209.1 - 209.1 201.5 - 201.5
Alison Hutchinson* 78.8 24.0 102.8 75.6 23.3 98.9
Guy Bainbridge 55.6 38.8 94.4 53.3 35.2 88.5
Mark Parsons 55.6 18.8 74.4 53.3 18.1 71.4
Dina Matta 55.6 6.8 62.4 53.3 6.5 59.8
Jennelle Tilling 55.6 6.8 62.4 53.3 6.5 59.8
Angela Darlington 55.6 32.0 87.6 35.7 18.8 54.5
Debra Davies** 24.8 10.3 35.1 - - -
Annemarie Durbin*** 8.3 - 8.3 - - -
* AlisonHutchinsonsteppeddownasChairoftheRemunerationCommitteeon18September2023
** DebraDaviesjoinedtheSocietyon26July2023andbecameChairoftheRemunerationCommitteeon19September2023
*** AnnemarieDurbinjoinedtheSocietyon18December2023asChairoftheBoardDesignate.ThefeepayabletoAnnemarieisinlinewiththeexistingfeestructure
fortheChairoftheBoard.
Directors Remuneration report (continued)
CEO pay ratio reporting (continued)
* TheCEOpayratiofor2023includesthereplacementawardswhichhavebeengrantedtoSusanAllenuponjoiningtheSociety.Ifthesereplacementawardswerenot
includedinthecalculations,themedianCEOpayratiowouldreducefrom110:1to44:1.
Year Defined Method 25th percentile 50th percentile 75th percentile
2023* Option B 148:1 110:1 68:1
2022 OptionB 28:1 21:1 14:1
2021 OptionB 29:1 21:1 14:1
2020 OptionB 39:1 28:1 20:1
2019 OptionB 40:1 35:1 22:1
116 | Governance 117
2024 Remuneration Policy
Thefollowingpagessetoutthe
proposedRemunerationPolicyforour
ExecutiveDirectorsandNon-Executive
Directors.Theproposedkeychanges
applicabletoExecutiveDirectorsare
highlightedwithinthefollowingtables,
withnochangesbeingproposedtothe
RemunerationPolicyforNon-Executive
Directors.Wewillseekmember
approvalforthepolicyattheAnnual
GeneralMeeting(‘AGM’)on23April
2024and,ifapproved,thepolicyis
intendedtoapplyforthreeyearsto
theAGMin2027.Itisintendedthat
nopaymentstoDirectorswillbemade
outsideofthispolicy,unlessrequired
asaresultofregulatorychange.
Review of Remuneration
Policy
During2023theCommitteeundertook
acomprehensivereviewofthe
RemunerationPolicy,consideringinput
fromanumberofcolleaguesinthe
Society,whileappropriatelymanaging
anyconflictsofinterestarising.This
includedtheBoard,theExecutive
Committee,PeopleLeaders,the
PerformanceandRewardCommittee
aswellasassessingfeedbackfrom
theColleagueForumandcolleague
engagementsurveys.Inaddition,to
supportthereview,theCommittee
engagedDeloitteLLPtoprovide
marketinsightandbestpractice.
Beingamutual,howwedeliverforour
membersisoftheupmostimportance;
thiswasakeyfocusthroughout
thereview.Simplicitywasalsoa
keythemetoensurethatthenew
remunerationframeworkistransparent
andwellunderstoodbyparticipants,
whilealsosupportingthedeliveryof
theSociety’sstrategyandcreationof
long-termvalueformembers.
Thestartingpointofthereviewwas
toconsiderourRewardPrinciples,to
ensuretheyremainedalignedtoand
supportedtheSociety’sstrategy;the
CommitteebelievetheexistingReward
Principlesremainfitforpurposeand
thereforedidnotproposeanychanges.
Our Reward Principles
Wefollowfivekeyprinciplestosupportusinachievingourlong-term
aspirationswhichapplytoallcolleagueswithintheSociety.Thesehelp
usknowwhenwearedoingtherightthingsandsetoutwhatwebelieve
goodrewardpracticeforallofourcolleagueslookslike.
Ourfiverewardprinciplesdevelopedwithourcolleaguesare:
Ourrewardprinciplesareappliedconsistentlyregardlessofgender,
ethnicity,age,disabilityoranyotherfactorunrelatedtoperformance
orexperience.
Attract and retain talent
Alignedtoourmutualvaluesandforwardthinkingtoensure
relevanceinachangingworld.
1
Focused on total reward
Recognisingthatrewardismorethanjustpay,itispartofa
broaderEmployeeValueProposition.
2
Reward decisions are clear and transparent for
colleagues
Deliveredthrougheffectiveandopencommunication.
3
Flexible within a framework
Toensureaconsistentapproachwhilstrespondingtodifferent
challenges,supportedbyeducationtohelpmanagersbalance
doingtherightthingforboththeSocietyandtheirpeople.
4
Recognising contribution
Ourrewardarrangementsarereflectiveofsociety,teamand
individualachievements,withtheabilitytorecognisethe
contributionallcolleagueshavemadetooursuccess.
5
AsoutlinedintheOurstrategysectionoftheStrategicreporttheSocietystarts
anewstrategiccyclein2024,andhasoutlinedambitiousplanstoscaleup
andchangeatpace,whileremaininganchoredtoitspurpose,toguidetowards
aSocietythatisfuture-readyandfittoservegenerationstocome.Following
thereviewoftheRewardPrinciplesandtheSociety’sstrategy,theCommittee
focussedtheirreviewonthevariablepayschemesinoperationforcolleagues
acrosstheSociety,includingExecutiveDirectors.
Anewvariablepayschemehasbeendevelopedandtheall-colleagueschemehas
beenrefinedtosupporttheSociety’sstrategyincreatinganambitiousculture,and
tofosteranenvironmentwherehighperformanceisrecognisedandrewarded,
notjustthrough‘what’isdelivered,butalso‘how’itisdelivered.Whilethereare
separatevariablepayschemesforSeniorLeaders,includingExecutiveDirectors,
andthebroadercolleaguepopulation,theCommitteedeemeditimportant
toretainadegreeofalignmentbetweenthetwoschemesthroughtheuseof
commonperformancemetricsandgateways.Thisalignmentsupportsacollective
culture,whereeveryoneworkstogethertoputourmembersneedsfirst,aswellas
beingabletorecognisehighperformance.
Thereviewalsoincludedamarketbenchmarkingexercise,andtheCommitteereviewedanddefinedanewcompetitor
peergroupforthispurpose.TherefinedpeergroupincludesBuildingSocietiesandCategoryOneUKBankstoensure
remunerationispositionedatalevelthatsupportstheattractionandretentionoftherequiredtalentandcapability.
Overview of changes to Variable Pay Schemes for 2024
All Colleague Scheme
Theexistingallcolleagueschemehasbeeninoperation
since2019.Itwasdesignedtosupportcollaborative
working,withallcolleaguesreceivingthesamepercentage
ofsalaryawardwhentheSocietyachieveditsperformance
goals.
Theallcolleagueschemewillcontinuetobeunderpinnedby
performanceagainstCoreProfitBeforeTaxandNetPromoter
Scoremetrics,retainingthecommitmenttolongterm
financialsustainabilityandexceptionalcustomerservice.
TheallcolleagueschemeisalsosubjecttotheSociety’s
BusinessControlsOverlayprocess,whichincludesafinancial
sustainabilityreview.Subjecttoperformancelevelsbeing
met,allcolleagues(excludingSeniorLeaders)willbeeligible
forthesamepercentageofsalaryaward.
InrecognitionofthechangesintheSociety’sstrategy,some
changeshavebeenmadetotheoperationoftheschemefor
2024tobetterrecognisethecontributionofcolleagueswho
haverolemodelledexceptionalbehaviours.Thescheme
willnowallowforadditionalindividualdiscretionaryawards
oncethecoremeasureshavebeenmet.
New Senior Leader Bonus Scheme
Tosupporttheaimofsimplicity,itisproposedthatfor2024
onwardsSeniorLeaders,includingExecutiveDirectors,will
nolongerparticipateinBuildingTogethernorLeadingfor
Value,andinsteadtheseschemeswillbereplacedbyanew
singlevariablepayscheme.
Theschemehasbeendesignedtoensurethatthe
remunerationofourSeniorLeaders,includingExecutive
Directors,hasadirectlinktothesuccessoftheSociety,
supportingdeliveryoflong-termstrategicobjectiveswhilst
protectingandenhancingmemberandcolleagueinterests
inlinewithourpurpose.However,participationinthisnew
schemerecognisestheroleandimpacttheSeniorLeaders
intheSocietyhaveonthedeliveryofthelong-termstrategy.
Therewillcontinuetobeastronglinkbetweentheall
colleagueschemeandtheseniorleaderschemewiththe
samefinancialandcustomerunderpinsinplaceacrossboth
schemes.Priortoanyawardoneitherscheme,existing
financialsustainabilitycheckswillremaintoensurethe
levelofcapitalheldbytheSocietyremainssustainableand
compliantwithregulationaswellasanassessmentwhich
determinesthattheSociety’scostmanagementpracticesare
robust.Theschemeswillalsocontinuetobesubjecttothe
Society’sBusinessControlsOverlayprocess.
MaximumopportunitylevelsforExecutiveDirectorsare
unchangedunderthenewschemewhencomparedto
previousopportunitylevelsacrossbothBuildingTogether
andLeadingforValue.
Performancewillbeassessedonanannualbasisbasedon
aSocietyscorecardconsistingofbothfinancialandnon-
financialmetrics,aswellasperformanceagainstindividual
personalobjectives.TheBusinessControlsOverlayand
riskadjustmentprocesseswillcontinuetoapplyasinprior
years.Thescorecardwillbereviewedandapprovedby
theCommitteeonanannualbasis,andclearlylinkedto
thelong-termStrategyoftheSociety.Anexampleofthe
proposed,simplifiedscorecardisoutlinedbelow.
Category Performance measures
Financial and strategic/
non-financial measures
Coreprofitbeforetax
Cost
Extendreachanddeepenourimpact
1.Membervalue
2.Mortgagepropositions
Createjoyfulexperiences
1.Customerexperience
2.NPS
Buildafuturereadysociety
1.Buildingagreenersociety
2.Growingsustainably
Cultivateanambitiousculture Organisationalhealth
Individual objectives
Directors Remuneration report (continued)
118 | Governance 119
Executive Director remuneration policy
Fixed remuneration – base salary
Change for
2024
Purpose and
link to strategy
ToenabletheattractionandretentionofhighperformingexperiencedExecutiveDirectorsbyensuring
thattheyareappropriatelyrewardedfortheirrole.
ThelevelofbasesalaryawardedservestoreflectthecontributionofExecutiveDirectorsintheirroleas
definedbythecombinationof:
•
Skills,knowledgeandexperience
•
On-goingperformance
•
DemonstrationoftheSociety’sbehavioursandvalues.
Nochange
In practice Basesalaryistypicallyreviewedannuallyanddeterminedwithreferenceto:
•
Roleandresponsibilities
•
Skills,experienceandindividualperformance&behaviours
•
Comparisontotheexternalmarket,supportedbyreferencetotheSociety’sgradingstructure,andthe
CareerFramework
•
Internalrelativitiesandwiderworkforcebasesalarylevels
•
Affordability–theeconomicenvironmentandoverallfinancialpositionoftheSociety.
Nochange
Opportunity Thereisno‘maximum’basesalaryopportunity.
Weseektotargetanappropriateexternalmarketpositioninrelationto‘totalremuneration’.Toensure
thatthisisachievedbasesalaryrangesaredevelopedwithreferencetothetotalpackageincluding
variablepay.
Nochange
Fixed remuneration – benefits
Change for
2024
Purpose and
link to strategy
ToprovideatotalremunerationpackagethatenablestheattractionandretentionofExecutiveDirectors
oftherequiredcalibre.
Nochange
In practice ExecutiveDirectorsareeligibletoreceiveanumberofbenefits,whichmayinclude:
•
Privatemedicalinsurance
•
AnnualHealthAssessment
•
Lifeassurance(6xsalary)
•
Insuredsickpay
•
Provisionofacompanycar,orcashequivalent
•
Travelallowances.
Nochange
Opportunity Thereisnomaximumvaluetothebenefitsprovided.Thelevelofbenefitisregularlyreviewedtoensure
theyremainappropriatefortheroleundertaken.
Nochange
Fixed remuneration – retirement benefits
Change for
2024
Purpose and
link to strategy
TheSociety’spensionarrangementssupporttheattractionandretentionofExecutiveDirectorsthrough
theprovisionofcompetitiveretirementbenefits.
Nochange
In practice TheSocietyoperatesasingledefinedcontributionpensionscheme,andallcolleagueshavethe
opportunitytoparticipate.Whereparticipationintheschemeistaxinefficient,ExecutiveDirectors,
inlinewiththeapproachforallcolleagues,maybepermittedtotakeacashallowanceinsteadof
contributionstotheplan.
Nochange
Opportunity AllExecutiveDirectorsreceiveamaximumpensioncontribution(orcashallowance)of11%ofbase
salary,thesameasthecontributionlevelsforallcolleagues.
Nochange
Variable pay – Senior Leaders Bonus Scheme
Change for
2024
Purpose and
link to strategy
ToensurethatanExecutiveDirector’sremunerationhasadirectlinktothesuccessoftheSocietyand
supportsdeliveryoflong-termstrategicobjectivesinlinewiththeSociety’spurposeandvalues.
Nochange
In practice AllExecutiveDirectorsareeligibletoparticipateinthisschemewhichaimstorewardtheachievement
ofstretchingannualSocietyandindividualtargetswhicharealignedtothelonger-termstrategy.Awards
willbebasedonaSocietyscorecardoffinancialandnon-financialmetricsalignedtotheStrategy
togetherwithindividualperformance.
Paymentsundertheplanaredeterminedinthefollowingway:
•
Forallmetricswithinthescorecardtherewouldnormallybespecifictargetssettoreflectminimum
threshold,targetandmaximumperformancelevels
•
Scorecardmetricsareweightedsuchthatfinancialmetricsandnon-financial/strategicmetrics(which
mayincludemetricsrelatingtomembervalue,customers,ESGandrisk)areweightedat80%ofthe
scorecardandindividualperformanceisweightedat20%
•
Followingtheendofthefinancialyear,theRemunerationCommitteewillassessperformanceacross
allperformancemetrics,includingindividualperformanceofeachExecutiveDirector,todeterminethe
scorecardoutcome
•
Organisationalfinancialperformance,customerexperienceandriskgatewaysapply.Failuretomeet
thesewouldnormallyresultinzerovariablepayawarded
•
Anindividualcompliancegateway,whichwouldincludeanassessmentofindividualconduct,would
alsounderpinthepaymentofanyaward.Failuretomeetthiswouldreduceanyaward(including
potentiallytozero).
Allawardsaresubjecttodeferral,paymentin'shareequivalentinstruments'andmalusandclawback
provisionsinlinewithregulatoryexpectations.
Replacement
ofexisting
Building
Together
andLeading
forValue
schemes
withone,
simplified
schemefor
allSenior
Leaders,
including
Executive
Directors.
Opportunity An‘ontarget’achievementagainstallperformancecriteriawouldresultinavariablepayawardof75%
ofeligiblepayfortheChiefExecutiveand50%ofeligiblepayforotherExecutiveDirectors.
Maximumachievementagainstallperformancecriteriawouldresultinavariablepayawardof125%of
eligiblepayfortheChiefExecutiveand100%ofeligiblepayforotherExecutiveDirectors.
Nochange
tomaximum
opportunity
levels.
Theon-target
opportunity
forExecutive
Directors,
excluding
theCEO,
hasbeen
reducedfrom
60%to50%
ofeligible
pay.
Deferral and Share Equivalent Instruments
Inlinewithrelevantremunerationregulations,including
theRemunerationsectionofthePRARulebookandthe
FCA’sDual-RegulatedFirmsRemunerationCode,allvariable
payawardsforExecutiveDirectorsaresubjecttodeferral.
DeferralensuresthattheSocietydeliversvariablepayover
amulti-yearperiod,inamannerthatmitigatesunnecessary
risktaking,whilstachievingalevelofsustainable
performance.
Alsorequiredbyregulation,isthat50%ofeachvariablepay
awardwillbedeliveredviaaShareEquivalentInstrument
(‘SEI’)whichissubjecttoafurtherholdingperiodfollowing
vesting.
Forthe2024performanceyear,anExecutiveDirectorwhose
remunerationexceedsthede-minimislimitwillreceive
20%oftheirtotalvariablepayin2025,withafurther20%
deliveredviaSEIin2026.Theremaining60%isdeferred
oversevenyears,witha12monthholdingperiodapplying
tothepaymentsmadeviaSEI.
Forexample:
•
Year 1–40%ofanyvariablepayearnedispaidoutin
theyearfollowingtherelevantperformanceyear.Halfof
thisamountispaidincash(in2025)andtheotherhalf
isdeliveredinaSEIandsubjecttoanadditionalholding
periodpriortorevaluationandpayment(in2026).
•
Deferral Years–theremaining60%isdeferredfor7
yearsandpaidequallyeachyearfrom3yearsafterthe
award.Eachyear,theawardissplitintwo,withhalfthe
amountpaidincashandthesecondhalfheldinaSEIand
subjecttoanadditionalholdingperiodpriortorevaluation
andpayment.SEIvaluationscontinueevery12months
untilthevariablepayscheduleiscomplete.
Directors Remuneration report (continued)
120 | Governance 121
£2,000
£1,800
£1,600
£1,400
£1,200
£1,000
£800
£600
£400
£200
£0
Minimum Target Maximum
Chief Executive Officer
Minimum MinimumTarget TargetMaximum Maximum
Chief Finance Officer Chief Commercial Officer
100%
100%
100%
57%
62%
62%
23%
23%
17%
£1,490
£900
26%
45%
50%
50%
30%
30%
22%
15%
15%
£540
£770
£1,010
£420
£600
£790
20%
20%
£1,890
33%
2024 Bonus Delivery 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033
Un-deferred:April Cash
Un-deferred:April SEI
DeferredYear3:April Cash
DeferredYear3:April SEI
DeferredYear4:April Cash
DeferredYear4:April SEI
DeferredYear5:April Cash
DeferredYear5:April SEI
DeferredYear6:April Cash
DeferredYear6:April SEI
DeferredYear7:April Cash
DeferredYear7:April SEI
Variable pay – control framework
Change for
2024
Business
controls overlay
process
VariablepayawardsaresubjecttotheoperationofaBusinessControlsOverlay(‘BCO’)assessment
thatconsiderscurrentandfuturerisksthrougharangeofkeymetricsprovidedbytheSociety’s
controlfunctionstoevidencetherobustmanagementoftheSocietiescontrolse.g.,auditactions
andothermetrics.Beforeanyvariablepayawardsaregranted,anumberoffinancialsustainability
reviewsarecompletedtoensurethelevelofcapitalheldbytheSocietyremainssustainable
andcompliantwithregulationaswellasanassessmentwhichdeterminesthattheSociety’scost
managementpracticesarerobust.Thisformalriskoverlayprocessensureskeyriskindicatorsare
consideredtoprovideassurancethatnoinappropriaterisk-takingbehaviourshavetakenplace.
IninstanceswhereissuesareidentifiedaspartoftheBCOassessment,theRemunerationCommittee
reservetherighttoreducethescorecardoutturn,applyamalusadjustment(reducevariablepay
awardorlapsedeferredelements)and/orapplyclawback(recovervariablepayawardsalready
made)asapplicable.Awardsaresubjecttoclawbackforuptoamaximumoftenyears.
Nochange
Remuneration
Committee
discretion
TheRemunerationCommitteeretainsthediscretiontoadjustvariablepayawardstoensurethatit
reflectsatrueviewoftheunderlyingperformanceoftheSocietyandholdssufficientcapitallevels
tosupportthepaymentofanyvariablepayaward.
Nochange
Key
Cashbonusdeferral SEIdeferral SEIholdingperiod
Length of time variable pay at risk
Remuneration scenarios in relation to the Remuneration Policy in 2024
Thechartbelowshowsanillustrationofthepotentialsplitofremunerationbetweenfixedremuneration(basesalary,benefits
andpension)andtotalvariablepayfortheCEOandotherExecutiveDirectorsalignedtothenewpolicy.Forthepurposesof
thisillustration,wehaveusedthedatapertainingtotheChiefExecutive,theChiefFinancialOfficerandtheChiefCommercial
Officerunderthefollowingscenarios:
•
Minimum–undercertainperformanceconditions,variablepaycanbezero.
•
Target-representsavariablepayaward(75%ofeligiblepayfortheChiefExecutiveand50%fortheremainingExecutive
Directors)thatwouldbepaidifSocietyandpersonalperformancemeasuresareachievedin2024.
•
Maximum–themaximumvariablepayaward(125%ofeligiblepayfortheChiefExecutiveand100%fortheremaining
ExecutiveDirectors)thatcouldbepaidassumingstretchobjectivesandoutcomesarefullyrealisedin2024.
Key .FixedPay.Undeferred.Deferred
Directors Remuneration report (continued)
Deferral and Share Equivalent Instruments (continued)
Figuresinthistablearerepresentedin£000’s.
122 | Governance 123
New hires Change for 2024
Remuneration
package
WhenagreeingthecomponentsofaremunerationpackagefortheappointmentofExecutive
Directors,theRemunerationCommitteewillapplythefollowingprinciples:
•
Thepackageswillbesufficienttorecruithighperformingindividuals,inahighlycompetitive
market,toleadthebusinessandeffectivelyexecutethestrategyformembers;
•
TheRemunerationCommitteewilllooktoaligntheremunerationpackageofferedwiththe
Society’sRemunerationPolicy;and,
•
TheRemunerationCommitteewillensurethatthelevelofpayisnecessarybutnotexcessive.
Indeterminingremunerationarrangements,theRemunerationCommitteewillconsidersimilar
positionsinthemarket,thestructureoftheremunerationpackageandtheexperienceofthe
candidate.ThisensuresthatarrangementsareinthebestinterestsofboththeSocietyandits
memberswithoutpayinginexcessofwhatisnecessarytorecruitanExecutiveDirectorofthe
requiredcalibre.
Therearenoproposed
changestothe
maximumopportunities
whichremain125%
forCEOand100%for
ExecutiveDirectors.
Theon-target
opportunityfor
ExecutiveDirectors,
excludingtheCEO,
hasbeenreduced
from60%to50%of
eligiblepay.
Replacement
awards
TheRemunerationCommitteemaymakeawardsonhiringanexternalcandidatetocompensate
themforanypreviouslyawardedvariableremunerationandanyotherremuneration
arrangementsforfeiteduponleavingthepreviousemployer.
Indeterminingwhethertoapproveanysuchreplacementawards,theRemunerationCommittee
willconsiderthestructureandformofthepreviousarrangementsandwillseektoensure
awardsaremadeonmateriallysimilartermstothearrangementsbeingforfeitedintermsof
value,timehorizonsandtheextenttowhichperformanceconditionsappliedtotheoriginal
awards.
AnyreplacementawardswillbesubjecttotheSociety’smalusandclawbackprovisions.The
awardswillbeforfeitedintheeventofearlydeparturefromtheSociety.
Nochange
Leaver arrangements and loss of office Change for 2024
The Remuneration Committee shall apply the policy in relation to leavers, considering performance, conduct and
commercial justifications, as summarised below:
Notice period Thestandardnoticeperiodis12monthsfromtheSocietyand12monthsfromtheExecutive
Director.
Innormalcircumstances,ExecutiveDirectorswillberequiredtoworktheirnoticeperiod.In
theeventExecutiveDirectorsarenotrequiredtofulfiltheirnoticeperiod,theymayreceivea
paymentinlieuofnotice,ortheymaybeplacedongardenleave.
Nochange
Termination
payment
Typically,terminationpaymentswillconsistofcontractualpaymentsforthenoticeperiod,the
emphasisbeingtonotrewardfailure.
Nochange
Annual variable
pay – leaver
provisions
Onterminationofoffice,theleaverprovisionsassetoutbelowwillapply.Thesearealso
outlinedintheSociety’svariablepayplanrules.
•
Intheeventofretirement,redundancy,ill-healthordisability,anyvariablepayawardwill
bepro-ratedtoreflectthetimeservedduringtheperformanceperiod,withanypayment
remainingsubjecttorelevantperformanceconditionsandtheSociety’sBCOassessment.
Paymentofanyvariablepayawardwouldbeatthenormaltimeanddeferralwillcontinue
toapply,inlinewithregulatoryrequirements.Therewouldtypicallybenoaccelerationof
paymentorthevestingofdeferredawards.Foranyunvesteddeferredawardswhichremain
outstanding,thesewouldtypicallyberetainedandwouldvestinlinewiththeoriginal
vestingschedule.Malusandclawbackprovisionswouldcontinuetoapply.
•
Inthecaseofdeath,anyvariablepayawardwillnormallybepro-ratedtoreflectthetime
servedduringtheperformanceperiod.TheRemunerationCommitteehasthediscretionto
acceleratethepaymentofdeferredvariablepayaheadofitsdefinedvestingschedulein
exceptionalcircumstances.
•
IntheeventoftheresignationofanExecutiveDirectorwhohasunvesteddeferredbonus
paymentsoutstanding,theywillnottypicallyremaineligibletoreceiveunvestedawards.The
RemunerationCommitteehasthediscretionincertaincircumstancestoallowthecolleague
toremaineligibletoreceivethedeferredbonuspaymentsearnedinpreviousyears,subject
totherulesofthescheme,includingbutnotlimitedtotheSociety’sBCOassessmentand
malusandclawbackprovisions.
NoChange
Remuneration Policy for Non-Executive Directors
Non-Executive Director Fees Change for 2024
Purpose and
link to strategy
Remunerationsetatalevelthatreflectsmarketconditionsandissufficienttoattractindividuals
withappropriateknowledgeandexperiencetoprovideameaningfulcontributiontothe
Society.
Nochange
In practice FeesarebasedontheleveloffeespaidtoNon-ExecutiveDirectorsandChairsservingon
boardsofcomparableorganisations,thetimecommitmentrequired,andcontributionexpected
fromtherole.
•
BoththeChairoftheBoardandNon-ExecutiveDirectorsfeesarereviewedperiodically,
normallyatleastannually.
•
TheChairoftheBoardispaidanall-inclusivefee.ForNon-ExecutiveDirectors,abasicfeeis
paid,withadditionalfeespayableforadditionalresponsibilities,forexample,thechairingor
membershipofaBoardCommittee.
•
TheChairoftheBoard’sfeesaredeterminedbytheRemunerationCommittee.
•
Non-ExecutiveDirectorfeesshallbeamatterfortheChairoftheBoard.
•
TheChairoftheBoardandNon-ExecutiveDirectorsfeesarenotsubjecttoanyspecific
performancemeasures;however,theiroverallperformanceisreviewedonaregularbasis.
•
Non-ExecutiveDirectorsdonotreceiveanybenefitsbutarere-imbursedforanyexpenses
incurred.
•
Non-ExecutiveDirectorswillnotbeinvolvedinanydecisionsastotheirownremuneration.
Nochange
Opportunity Thereisno‘maximum’feeopportunity.
FeesaresetwithreferencetotheleveloffeespaidtoNon-ExecutiveDirectorsandChairs
servingonboardsofcomparableorganisations,thetimecommitment,andcontribution
expectedfromtherole.
Non-ExecutiveDirectorsarenoteligibletoreceivevariablepayawards.
Nochange
Our committees
Toensureourrewardpoliciesandproceduresarerobustand
assuredwehavetwomaincommitteesinplacetosupport
this:theRemunerationCommitteeandthePerformanceand
RewardCommittee.Thesecommitteesplaydifferentrolesin
makingsureourapproachtorewardmeetsourrequiredlevels
ofcompliance,asexplainedbelow.
Remuneration Committee
TheRemunerationCommitteehasspecificresponsibility
formakingsurewehavetherightpoliciesandprocessesin
placeforChiefOfficers(includingthosethatareExecutive
Directors)oftheSociety,andindividualsidentifiedasMaterial
RiskTakers(MRTs–seniordecisionmakers),aswellasthe
overarchingRemunerationPolicyandpaypracticesthat
impactallcolleagueswithintheSociety.Thepurposeofthe
RemunerationCommitteeistooverseetheRemuneration
PolicyinplacefortheSociety,makingsurethisalignstoour
businessstrategyandanyregulatoryrequirements.Detailsin
relationtothecompositionandtheTermsofReferenceofthe
RemunerationCommitteecanbeaccessedontheSociety’s
website.
TheRemunerationCommitteeoverseesabroadrangeof
activitieswithintheSocietysuchas:
•
SettingoftheRemunerationPolicyforallcolleagueswithin
theSociety.
•
Reviewingandapprovingtheindividualremuneration
arrangementsforallChiefOfficers(includingthosethatare
ExecutiveDirectors)andChairoftheBoard.
•
RatifyingtheannualobjectivesoftheChiefOfficers
(includingthosethatareExecutiveDirectors).
•
DeterminingindividualvariablepayawardsforotherMRTs.
•
Overseeingandapprovingthevariablepayoutturnforall
bonusschemes
•
Theapplicationofmalusand/orclawbackforMRTsifany
evidenceofrisktakingorbehaviournotconducivewithour
principlesisidentified.
•
Overseeingremunerationprocessesandproceduresin
relationtoMRTs,includingensuringMRTsdonotundertake
hedgingstrategiesinrelationtotheirvariablepay
opportunities.
•
ResponsibilityfortheBusinessControlsOverlayprocess.
•
Howremunerationisconsideredforallcolleaguesinthe
organisation,andtherelativityoftheirremunerationtothe
Executives.
TheRemunerationCommitteeissupportedbytheChairofthe
Board,theChiefPeopleOfficerandtheDirectorofPeopleand
Culture.Whereitisfelttobeappropriate,theChiefExecutiveis
invitedtoattendtoprovidefurtherbackgroundandcontextto
assisttheCommitteeindischargingitsduties.
Directors Remuneration report (continued)
Remuneration scenarios in relation to the Remuneration Policy in 2024 (continued)
124 | Governance 125
Our committees
TheCommitteemeteighttimesduring
theyearandcoveredthefollowing
activities:
•
ReviewingtheSociety’sRemuneration
PolicyforExecutiveDirectorsand
allcolleagues,ensuringitisfitfor
purposeinrelationtoTier1firm
•
Ensuringremunerationpoliciesand
practicesremainappropriateandare
operatingasintended
•
Ongoingworkinrelationtothe
PrudentialRegulatoryAuthority’s(PRA)
RemunerationCodeandhowitapplies
totheSociety
•
ReviewingtheSociety’svariablepay
schemestructureandtargets
•
Overseeingperformanceand
remunerationoftheSociety’sMaterial
RiskTakers
•
Reviewingandmonitoringtherisk
measuresinplacerelatingtoDirector
performance
•
ReviewingtheSociety’sgenderpay
gapreporting
•
Reviewingandapprovingthe
remunerationarrangementsforMRTs
•
Additionalmeetingswereheldin
2023tosupportthereviewofthe
DirectorsRemunerationPolicy.
Details of the number of scheduled
meetings attended by each
Committee member during 2023
can be found in the Attendance at
Board and Committee meetings
section of the Corporate
Governance report.
Appendices
Appendix 1 – Statement of member voting
TheSocietyremainscommittedtoongoingmemberdialogueandtakesanactiveinterestinvotingoutcomes.Thepolicyhas
receivedstrongsupportfrommemberstodate.
Appendix 2 - Aggregate remuneration data (Pillar 3)
ForfulldetailsontheSociety’sfullPillar3disclosure,pleasevisit
www.ybs.co.uk/your-society/financial-results.
TheRemunerationCommitteedrawson
theadviceofanindependentexternal
consultanttosupportitinperformingits
duties.Duringtheyear,theCommittee
soughtadviceonExecutiveDirector
salaries,variablepaystructuresand
regulatorymattersfromEY.The
Committeeissatisfiedthattheadvice
receivedisobjectiveandindependent.
EY’sfeesforadviceprovidedtothe
RemunerationCommitteein2023were
£53,340(includingirrecoverableVAT).
FurthertotheadvicereceivedfromEY,
additionaladvicewasobtainedfrom
WillisTowersWatsonandDeloitteLLP,
whoprovidedsupportandguidanceon
thereviewoftheExecutiveDirectors
RemunerationPolicy.Thisincluded
marketbenchmarking,aswellassupport
andguidancerelatingtovariablepay
structures.
Performance & Reward
Committee
ThePerformance&RewardCommitteeis
inplacetoensureeffectivegovernance
andoversightofourRemuneration
Policywithafocusonconductand
alignmenttoourbusinessstrategy.
Thiscommitteealsoensuresthatany
variablepayarrangementsthatweoffer
colleaguesdrivetherightbehaviours
towardsrisktakingandsafeguardgood
customerandmemberoutcomes.The
Performance&RewardCommittee
comprisesseveralseniorleadership
teammemberswithintheorganisation
withrepresentationfromtheCustomer
Services,Commercial,People,Finance
andRiskfunctions.
Our approach to risk
management and
governance of reward
Ourrewardprovisionsmeetallthe
requirementsofbothourinternal
governanceprocessesandexternal
regulators.Ourprovisionofreward
andtheassociatedpolicies,processes,
proceduresandpracticesrelatingto
thesearecreatedinawaywhichensures
theappropriatelevelofgovernance
isinplacetomitigateanypotential
currentandfutureriskstotheSociety,
colleagues,membersandcustomers.
Thevariablepayschemeissubjecttoa
BusinessControlsOverlayProcess,under
whichtheRemunerationCommittee
mayadjustvariablepayoutcomesinthe
eventriskissuesareidentified.
Our regulators
Asafinancialservicesproviderwe
areregulatedbyboththeFinancial
ConductAuthority(FCA)andthe
PrudentialRegulationAuthority(‘PRA’).
Therelationshipwithourregulatorsis
importanttous,andbuildstrustboth
insideandoutsideoftheSociety.This
meansthatfromaperformance,reward
andbenefitsperspectiveweensure
thatourbasesalary,variablepayand
benefitsnotonlymeetanynecessary
obligationsofourregulatorsbutare
designedandprovidedinawaywhich
developsatrustedrelationshipwith
them.
Non-Executive Director 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
To approve the Directors’ Remuneration Report 89.67% 90.29% 91.86% 91.32% 92.45% 91.77% 93.15%
To approve the Directors’ Remuneration Policy n/a n/a 90.95% n/a 91.58% n/a n/a
Directors’
report
Our directors
ThenamesofthedirectorsofYorkshire
BuildingSociety(‘theSociety’)who
servedduringtheyearanduptothe
dateofthisreport,theirroles,previous
experienceandmembershipofboard
committeesaredescribedintheOur
BoardandExecutiveTeamareaof
theGovernancesection.Noneofthe
directorshadaninterestin,orshare
of,anyassociatedbodyoftheSociety
atanytimeduringthefinancialyear.
Atour2024AnnualGeneralMeeting
(‘AGM’)ourdirectorswillallretireand
standforelection/re-election,with
theexceptionofJohnHeapswhowill
retirefromhisroleasChairofthe
BoardinApril2024.
Our strategy, future
developments and Key
Performance Indicators
('KPIs')
Informationonthestrategyof
YorkshireBuildingSocietyandits
controlledentities(‘theGroup’)canbe
foundintheOurpurposeandstrategy
sectionoftheStrategicreport.Details
offuturedevelopmentsareincludedin
theLookingaheadsectionoftheChief
Executive’sSummaryandKPIsareset
outinthePerformanceataglance
section.
Details of our corporate governance
practices are included in our
Corporate Governance report.
Thisreportcontainsthestatutorydisclosures
requiredundertheBuildingSocietiesAct1986
(‘theAct’)andtheDisclosureGuidanceand
TransparencyRulesoftheFinancialConduct
Authority(‘theDTR’).Italsoincludesdetailsof
voluntarilyapplieddisclosurerequirements,
includingthoseinrespectoftheUKCorporate
GovernanceCode(‘theCode’),theCompanies
Act2006andthestreamlinedenergyand
carbonreporting(‘SECR’)rules.
How we manage risks
OurbusinessactivityexposestheGrouptoavarietyofrisks,includingretailand
commercialcredit,treasury,fundingandliquidity,market,operational,model,
capital,andcomplianceandconductrisk.Weseektomanagealltherisksthat
arisefromourbusinessactivitiesandwehaveanumberofcommitteesand
policiesinplacetodoso.
Details of these risks are included in the Risk overview section of the
Strategic report and the Risk Management report.
Our mortgage arrears
Detailsofthemortgageaccountsthatwere12monthsormoreinarrearsat31
Decemberareasfollows:
Further details of the arrears position are set out in the Our Financial
Review section of the Strategic report. Note 31 to the financial statements
also details the various forms of support offered to borrowers experiencing
difficulties in meeting their repayments.
2023 2022 2023 2022
% of mortgage account/balances
Number of
accounts
194 217 0.07% 0.08%
Balances outstanding
on accounts
£25.4m £30.2m 0.05% 0.07%
Amount of arrears
included in balances
£3.5m £3.7m 0.01% 0.01%
Directors Remuneration report (continued)
126 | Governance 127
Directors' report (continued)
Our charitable and political
donations
Charitabledonationsmadebythe
Groupduringtheyearwere£0.9
million(2022:£0.9million),more
detailsandfurtherinformation
onfundraisingbyourcolleagues,
membersandcustomers,including
thevalueofvolunteeringtimeofYBS
colleaguescanbefoundintheOur
communitiessectionofEngaging
withourstakeholdersintheStrategic
report.Nopoliticaldonationswere
madeintheyear(2022:nil).
Our colleagues
Wecontinuetolistenandrespondto
ourcolleagues’needs.Itisimportant
thatallourcolleaguesfeelconnected
totheSocietyandcancontribute
tooursuccess.Toachievethis,we
communicatebusinessinformationto
ourcolleaguesacrossourorganisation
inanappropriateandtimelyway.
Werecognisethatemployingpeople
fromdifferentbackgroundsandwith
arangeofexperienceenhances
thewayinwhichwework.Weare
buildingadiverseworkforceand
wemakeworkplaceadjustments
whereverwepossiblycantoprovide
aninclusiveworkingenvironmentfor
allcolleagues.
See the Engaging with our
stakeholders section of the
Strategic report for more details.
Our responsibilities in
respect of Accounting
Records and Internal Control
Weareresponsibleforensuringthat
theSociety:
•
keepsaccountingrecordsin
accordancewiththeBuilding
SocietiesAct1986('theAct');and
•
takesreasonablecaretoestablish,
maintain,documentandreview
suchsystemsandcontrolasare
appropriatetoitsbusinessin
accordancewiththerulesmadeby
thePrudentialRegulationAuthority
undertheFinancialServicesAct
2012.
Wehaveageneralresponsibilityfor
thesafeguardingoftheassetsofthe
Societyandfortakingreasonable
stepsforthepreventionanddetection
offraudandotherirregularities.
Directors’ responsibilities in
respect of the preparation
of the Annual Report and
Accounts
Thefollowingstatement,which
shouldbereadinconjunctionwith
theAuditors’responsibilitiesforthe
auditofthefinancialstatementsinthe
Independentauditors’reporttothe
membersofYorkshireBuildingSociety,
ismadebythedirectorstoexplain
theirresponsibilitiesinrelationtothe
preparationofthefinancialstatements.
WearerequiredbytheActtoprepare
financialstatements,forboththe
SocietyandtheGroup,thatgivea
trueandfairviewoftheincomeand
expenditureforthefinancialyear,
andthestateofaffairsattheend
ofthefinancialyear.Wearealso
requiredtoprovidedetailsofdirectors’
remunerationinaccordancewithpart
VIIIoftheActandregulationsmade
underit.
Inpreparingthefinancialstatements,
thedirectorsarerequiredto:
•
selectsuitableaccountingpolicies
andapplythemconsistently;
•
makejudgementsandaccounting
estimatesthatarereasonable;
•
statewhetherthefinancial
statementshavebeenprepared
inaccordancewithInternational
AccountingStandards;and
•
preparethefinancialstatementson
agoingconcernbasis,unlessitis
inappropriatetopresumethatthe
Groupwillcontinueinbusiness.
Thedisclosureandtransparencyrules
oftheFinancialConductAuthority('the
DTR')requireanannualfinancialreport
toinclude:
•
auditedfinancialstatementsforboth
theSocietyandGroup;
•
amanagementreportthatincludes
afairreviewofthebusinessand
adescriptionoftheprincipalrisks
anduncertainties(seetheStrategic
reportandtheRiskManagement
report);and
•
responsibilitystatements(see
ResponsibilityStatementsbelow).
Weareresponsibleforthe
maintenanceandintegrityof
statutoryandauditedinformationon
theSociety’swebsite.Information
publishedontheinternetisaccessible
inmanycountrieswithdifferentlegal
requirements.LawsintheUnited
Kingdomgoverningthepreparation
andcommunicationoffinancial
statementsmaybedifferentfromlaws
inotherjurisdictions.
Annual Business Statement
TheActalsorequiresthedirectorsto
prepare,foreachfinancialyear,an
annualbusinessstatementcontaining
prescribedinformationrelatingtothe
businessoftheGroup.
See pages 235 to 236 for the
2023 Annual Business Statement.
Non-financial and sustainability statement
TheSocietyaimstovoluntarilyapplytherequirementsofs414CBoftheCompaniesAct2006byincludingnon-financial
informationintendedtohelpstakeholdersunderstandourpositiononkeynon-financialmatters.Informationregardingthese
matterscanbefoundinthefollowingsectionsofthisdocument:
Directors’ duties
Section172oftheCompaniesAct2006(s172)describesthedutiesofcompanydirectorsinrespectofpromotingthe
businessandconsideringotherstakeholders.ThisdoesnotapplytotheSociety’sDirectorsasweareabuildingsocietynota
company,buttheCodeexpectsboardstoreportonhowtheyhaveconsideredthematterssetoutins172indecisionmaking.
Thetablebelowsummarisesthes172requirementsandcrossreferencestowherethisconsiderationiscoveredinother
sectionsofthisdocument.
Area Strategic report reference
Environment matters SeeBuildingagreenersocietysection
Employees SeetheInvestinginourpeoplesubsectionofOurESGprioritiessection
Social matters SeetheOurCommunitiessubsectionoftheEngagingwithourstakeholderssection
Respect for human
rights
SeetheOurCommunitiessubsectionoftheEngagingwithourstakeholderssection
Anti-corruption and
anti-bribery
SeetheAnti-briberyandanticorruptionsubsectionofOperatingresponsiblysection
Our business model SeeOurbusinessmodelsubsectionofOurpurposeandstrategysectionoftheStrategicreport
Principal risks SeetheRiskoverviewsectionoftheStrategicreport
Key performance
indicators
SeePerformanceataGlancesectionintheIntroductionandtheEngagingwithour
stakeholderssectionforadescriptionofemployeeengagementscores
Summary of s172
Requirements
Yorkshire Building Society Board Relevant disclosure
A director must act in a way
they consider, in good faith,
would most likely promote
the success of the business
for the benefit of its members
as a whole (i.e. the company’s
shareholders) and in doing so
have regard (amongst other
matters) to the:
AsamutualtheSocietydoesnothaveexternal
shareholders,weareownedbyourmembers.The
Boardiscommittedtopromotingthelong-term
successoftheSocietyforthebenefitofourcurrent
andfuturemembers.Buildingonourpurpose
toprovideRealHelpwithRealLifeourStrategic
Blueprintstrategyunderpinsourcommitmentto
thesuccessofthebusinessforourmembersboth
nowandinthefuture.
Our Business Model section
Our Purpose and Our Strategy
sections
•
likely consequences of any
decision in the long-term
OurBoardrecognisestheimportanceofensuring
thelikelyconsequencesofdecisionsinthelong
termareconsideredwhichisreflectedinour
StrategicBlueprintbuiltaroundourpurposeof
providingRealHelpwithRealLife.
Our Business Model section
Our Purpose and Our Strategy
sections
•
interests of employees TheBoardunderstandsthatourpeoplearethe
foundationofourbusinessandrecognisesthe
importanceofensuringthattheirvoiceisheard
intheboardroom.Eachpaperconsideredbythe
Boardsetsouttheimplicationsforouremployees
and,whererelevant,howtheyhavebeenconsulted
ontheproposals.
TheBoardhasalsoputinplaceaframeworkto
ensurecolleagueviewsinformitsdecision.
Our Communities subsection
of the Engaging with our
Stakeholders section
Corporate Governance report
colleague section
128 | Governance 129
Streamlined Energy and Carbon Reporting
('SECR')
UndertheStreamlinedEnergyandCarbonReporting(‘SECR’)
frameworkmandatedbytheUKgovernment,theSociety
maintainsongoingdisclosure.
TheSocietyhasimplementedthefollowingenergy
efficiencyactionsinthisreportingyear:
•
RolloutofLEDlightingupgradesto31Branches
•
LEDlightingreplacementsatYorkshireDrive–310light
fittingsreplaced
•
RolloutofAirConditioningReplacementsto8Branches
•
Acquiredone100%electricmaintenancevehicleto
replaceadieselmaintenancevehicle
Comprehensive insights into the Society’s
environmental accomplishments, commitments,
and approach to managing climate related risks are
available within the Building a greener society section
of the Strategic report.
Limited level assurance
RicardoEnergy&Environment,ourexternalcarbon
footprintverifiers,havecarriedoutalimitedlevel
assurancereviewofthesefigures.Thisreviewassessed
datacollectionandcalculationmethodologiesagainst
theapplicablerequirements.Basedontheprocessand
proceduresconducted,theyhaveconcludedthatthereis
noevidencethatthe2023GHGassertion:isnotmaterially
correctandisnotafairrepresentationofGHGdataand
information,hasnotbeenpreparedinaccordancewiththe
ISO14064-1
specificationwithguidanceforthevalidation
andverificationofgreenhousegasassertations
andthe
GHGProtocolCorporateStandard.Thisstatementisvalid
forthecarbonfootprintverificationreviewfortheperiods
from1January2023,to31December2023.
Summary of s172
requirements
Yorkshire Building Society Board Relevant disclosure
•
need to foster business
relationships with
suppliers, customers and
others
TheSociety’sBoardiscommittedtofosteringand
monitoringtheeffectivenessofourwiderbusiness
relationshipswithallourkeystakeholders.Thiswas
reflectedintheshapingofourStrategicBlueprint
whichwassupportedthroughdetailedstakeholder
engagementexercises.
Our Purpose and Our Strategy
sections
Our Communities subsection
of the Engaging with our
Stakeholders section
•
impact of the business’s
operations on the
community and the
environment
Theenvironment,socialandgovernanceimpactof
theSocietyunderpinstheStrategicBlueprintand
eachpaperconsideredbytheBoardsetsoutany
socialorenvironmentalimplicationsofadecision
ensuringthattheBoardhasregardtotheimpactof
theseaspartofitsoverallapproachtopromoting
thesuccessoftheSociety.
Our Communities subsection
of the Engaging with our
Stakeholders section
Building a Greener Society
section
•
desirability of maintaining
a reputation for high
standards of business
conduct
TheBoard’scommitmenttomaintaininghigh
standardsofbusinessconducthelpstoensurethe
long-termsuccessoftheSocietyforourcurrent
andfuturemembers,customers,colleaguesandall
otherstakeholders.TheSociety’sbehaviourshelp
drivethecultureandsupportsthedeliveryofthe
StrategicBlueprint.
Our Business Model section
Our Purpose and Our Strategy
sections
•
need to act fairly as
between members (i.e. the
company’s shareholders)
TheSocietydoesnothaveexternalshareholders,
insteadourmembersareourownersandatthe
heartofwhatwedo.TheBoardunderstandsthe
importanceofengagingwithourmembersandis
committedtoensuringtheirviewsinformfuture
decisionmakingtoensureitisfairandinthe
interestsofourmembershipasawhole.
Our Communities subsection
of the Engaging with our
Stakeholders section
Corporate Governance report
member’s section
Internal Energy Usage (kWh) 2023 2022
Heatingandemergencyfuelusage 3,982,219 5,165,030
Companyownedvehicletransport 7,706 3,509
Scope 1 3,989,925 5,168,539
NationalGridElectricityConsumption 8,400,778 8,183,123
OnsiteSolarElectricityGenerationConsumption 150,157 144,500
CompanyownedEVvehicleusage 200 -32
Scope 2 8,551,135 8,327,623
Leased/hiredbusinesstransport 520,637 382,648
Scope 3 520,637 382,648
Total 13,061,697 13,878,810
tCO2e tCO2e
Total emissions from internal energy usage 2,591 2,619
Energy use and emissions report
AspertheGreenhouseGasProtocolCorporateAccountingandReportingStandard(‘GHGProtocol’)31,energyusageand
emissionsfromourbusinessactivitiesareclassifiedasfollows:
31 Greenhousegas(GHG)emissionsdataiscalculatedinaccordancewiththeGreenhouseGasProtocol,awidelyrecognisedaccountingframeworkformeasuringand
managingemissions.OurmethodologyhasbeenpreparedusingguidancefromISO-14064-1standardspecifications.
32 During2022reportingperiod,YBSdidnotownanyEVsandthereforethereisnoreportingonthiscategoryduringthatperiod.
Directors' report (continued)
130 | Governance 131
Methodology
OurapproachtocalculatinggreenhousegasemissionsandenvironmentalimpactwithintheGroupalignswiththeGHG
Protocol.Emissionsarereportedinmetrictonnesofcarbondioxideequivalent(‘tCO2e’),whilstenergyusageisquantifiedin
kilowatthours(‘kWh’).TheSocietyusesthemostuptodateUKGovernmentGHGConversionFactorsforCompanyReporting
exceptfor'market-based'renewableelectricityandgastariffs.AllemissionsandenergyusageareUK-basedapartfroma
smallpercentageofGHGScope3businesstravel.TheintensitymetricthattheSocietyusestonormaliseemissionsforannual
comparisonistCO2eper£mincome,andpercolleague.ForcalendaryearendingDecember2023,theprinciplesprovidedby
theGHGProtocolScope2GuidancehavebeenappliedtocalculatetheSociety'sScope1'market-based'emissionsfromthe
consumptionofgassourcedfromthegrid.
Intensity ratios
2023 2022
Location
tCO
2
e
Market
tCO
2
e
Location
tCO
2
e
Market
tCO
2
e
Scope 1 Generationofheat(gasconsumption) 728 - 941 -
Back-upgeneratorfuel 0.11 0.11 0.04 0.04
VehiclesusedonSocietybusiness 2 2 1 1
Refrigerantgases 3 3 7 7
Total 733 5 949 8
Scope 2 Electricityconsumption 1,740 - 1,582 -
Electricityforownedvehicle 0.04 0.04 - -
Total 1,740 0 1,582 0
Scope 3 Well-to-tank–Electricity 419 33 413 35
Well-to-tank–Land,AirTravelandFuels 177 57 197 36
Transmissionanddistributionlosses-Electricityconsumption 150 150 145 145
Businesstravel–Transport 268 268 161 161
Businesstravel–Hotel 24 24 15 15
Homeworkingandcommuting33 3,648 3,648 - -
Watersupplyandtreatment 12 12 8 8
Wastedisposal 9 9 8 8
Total 4,707 4,201 947 408
Total Carbon Footprint 7,180 4,206 3,478 416
2023 2022
Income GHG Emissions Intensity ratio Income GHG Emissions Intensity ratio
Income intensity ratio £m tCO
2
e tCO
2
e/£m £m tCO
2
e tCO
2
e/£m
Location
787
7,180 9.1
811
3,479 4.3
Market 4,206 5.3 416 0.5
Colleague intensity ratio Colleagues tCO
2
e tCO
2
e/person Colleagues tCO
2
e tCO
2
e/person
Location
4,77334
7,180 1.5
4,530
3,479 0.8
Market 4,206 0.9 416 0.1
Scope 1
Scope1emissions‘Location-based’
emissionsencapsulatethosestemming
fromthegenerationofemissions
throughburninggasorfuelsfor
heatingourGroupoccupiedbuildings,
hydrotreatedvegetableoil(‘HVO’)use
withinourenergygenerators,Society
ownedvehicles(facilitymanagement
vans)andrefrigerant/airconditioning
gaseslosttotheatmospherethrough
pipeworkleakages.During2023,YBS
procured100%ofthegassourced
toheatourbuildingsfromthegrid
backedbyRenewableGasGuarantees
ofOrigin(‘RGGO’).RGGO’sarea
typeofEnergyAttributeCertificate
thatmeettheGHGProtocolScope2
qualitycriteriaandarereflectedinour
‘market-based’calculations.35
Scope 2
Theemissionscalculatedwithin
Scope236accountforalldirect
electricityusagewithinYBSGroup
ownedbuildingsandSocietyowned
electricvehicles.'Location-based'
calculationsareassociatedwiththe
generationofpurchasedelectricity
fromthegridandenableusto
trackandmanageourconsumption.
TheSocietyhaschosentosource
electricityfromasuppliersupported
by100%renewablesourcesas
evidencedbyRenewableEnergy
GuaranteesofOrigin(‘REGO’)
certificates.Emissionsassociated
withthischosentariffofelectricity
registeraszerounder'market-based'
calculations.
Scope 3
Scope3encompassesindirect
businessactivities.Wecalculatethese
emissionsbasedonavailabledata
andwewillcontinuetodevelopour
calculationsoftheseemissions.This
yearwehavecontinuedtoinclude
ourbusinesstravel37,well-to-tank
(‘WTT’)fuelandelectricity,our
operationalwasteandwater38.For
2023weaddedhomeworkingand
employeecommutingemissions.
Themethodologyforcalculating
ouremployeecommutingand
homeworkingemissionsisbelow.
Employee commuting
YBSconductedanemployeesurvey
whichcontainedinformationon
whatcommutingmethodsareused,
thedistanceofthecommute,how
frequentlyapersoncommutes,and
detailsabouttheenginesizeand
fuelsusedinacarifacarisused
tocommute.Thetotalmileageper
commutingtypeperyearwasthen
calculated39.Dataarrivedwith
stipulationsoftherespondent’spay
gradeandworkinglocation.After
theaforementionedprocesswas
completed,weextrapolatedthe
resultingenergyconsumptionbythe
gapfromhowmanyrespondentsare
atalocationandpaygrade,versusthe
overalltotal.
Homeworking and appliance
energy
TheSocietyconductedanemployee
surveywhichrequestedinformation
onemployeebuildingandheating
types,alongsidetheroomsizeworked
within,andemissionswerecalculated
usingtheseresponses40.Benchmarks,
sourcedfromTheCharteredInstitution
ofBuildingServicesEngineers(‘CIBSE’),
allowedforthecalculationofaverage
energyusedforheatingandelectrical
loadwithinthespecifiedhousingtype
andwithinthesquaremetresized
room.Theenergyconsumedwithinthe
roomwasthenmultipliedupbased
onhowmanydaysaweektheywork
fromhometocalculatetheenergy
consumedinayear.
Surveyresponsesalsocontained
informationonwhatappliances
areusedwhilstworkingfromhome
andthequantitiesofthoseused.
AssumptionsweremadeonthekW
ratingofthosetechnologiesandhow
manyhoursadaytheappliances
wouldbeinuse.
Going concern
Thedirectorsconfirmthatthey
considerthattheGroupandthe
Societyhasadequateresourcesto
continueinexistenceforatleast12
monthsfromthedateofthisreport.
Thisconfirmationismadeafter
havingreviewedassumptionsabout
futuretradingperformance,liquidity
requirements,capitalrequirements
andorganisationalsustainability,
aswellasplannedimprovements
todataandregulatoryreporting
controls.Thedirectorsalsoconsidered
potentialrisksanduncertaintiesinthe
business,credit,marketandliquidity
risks,includingtheavailabilityand
repaymentprofileoffundingfacilities.
Details of how the Board monitor
longer term risks are included in
the Risk Management report in
the Governance section.
Basedontheabove,togetherwith
availablemarketinformationandthe
directors’knowledgeandexperience
ofthebusinessandourmarkets,the
directorscontinuetoadoptthegoing
concernbasisinpreparingtheAnnual
ReportandAccountsfortheyear
ended31December2023.
35 Estimateshavebeenmadefor2023Q4naturalgasconsumptionforheatingduetounavailableactualactivitydata.Theseestimateswerebasedon2022usagedata
ormorerecentavailableusagedata.
36 Estimateshavebeenmadefor2023Q4electricityconsumptionwhereactualactivitydatawasunavailable.Theseestimateswerebasedon2022dataormorerecent
availableusagedata.
37 Mostbusinessdatawasprovidedinmileage,howeverwhereunavailable,costdatawasprovided.Thecostisconvertedtomileageusingthemostuptodatebusiness
travelconversionfactoravailableatExpensesandbenefits:businesstravelmileageforemployees'ownvehicles:Rulesfortax-GOV.UK(www.gov.uk)
38 Estimateshavebeenmadefor2023Q4waterandwasteconsumptionwhereactivitydatawasunavailableduetotheinvoicingperiod.Theseestimateswereused
basedon2022dataandmorerecentusagedataaverages.Watertreatmentisbasedonestimationthat95%ofwatersupplywouldbecometreatedwater.
39 Emissionsandconversionswerecalculatedusingtheappropriatefactorsfromthe2023UKGovernmentGHGConversionFactorsforCompanyReportingproducedby
DESNZandDEFRA.
40 Emissionsandconversionswerecalculatedusingtheappropriatefactorsfromthe2023UKGovernmentGHGConversionFactorsforCompanyReportingproducedby
DESNZandDEFRA.
33 Thisfigureincludeswell-to-tankandtransmissionanddistributionlosseswhichrelatetohomeworkingandcommuting.
34 Thisincludesallfull-andpart-timecolleaguesaswellasallcontractors,consultants,managedservicesandagencystafffortheperiod1January2023–31December2023.
Directors' report (continued)
Streamlined Energy and Carbon Reporting ('SECR') (continued)
Carbon footprint
132 | Governance 133
Viability
TheUKCorporateGovernanceCode('theCode'),whichthe
SocietyadoptstotheextentthatitappliestoaBuilding
Society,requiresthedirectorstoassesstheprospectsand
ongoingviabilityoftheGroupoveralongerperiodthanthe
12monthsrequiredforthegoingconcernassessment.
Forthepurposesofassessinglongertermviability,the
directorshavedeterminedthreeyearstobethemost
appropriateperiodasthiscoversthetypicaltermofmostof
ourfixedrateproductsandisthelongestperiodoverwhich
thedirectorsconsiderthattheycanformareasonablyfirm
viewoverthemacroeconomicenvironmentandassociated
keydriversofbusinessperformance.Thedirectorshave
thereforeassessedtheviabilityoftheGroupandthe
SocietyoverthethreeyearstoDecember2026,taking
accountofthecurrentpositionandthepotentialimpactof
therisksdocumentedintheStrategicreportandtheRisk
Managementreport.
Ourfinancialplanningprocessconsistsofanoperating
planforthenextfinancialyearandacorporateplanfor
thefollowingadditionalfourfinancialyears.Theone-year
operatingplanhasagreaterlevelofcertaintyandisused
tosetnear-termtargets.Thefive-yearcorporateplanisless
certainthantheoperatingplanbutprovidesalongerterm
outlookagainstwhichstrategicdecisionscanbemade.
ThefinancialplanningprocessforecaststheGroup’s
profitability,capitalposition,liquidityandotherkeyfinancial
metricsovertheperiod,includingregulatorymeasuressuch
asMREL(MinimumRequirementforEligibleLiabilities).
Thesemetricsaresubjecttosensitivityanalysisthroughthe
annualGroupICAAP(InternalCapitalAdequacyAssessment
Process)andILAAP(InternalLiquidityAdequacyAssessment)
processes.TheGroupstressesitscapitalandliquidityplans,
under‘severebutplausible’stresstestscenarios,inlinewith
PRArequirements.
TheICAAPstresstestensuresthattheplanprojectionsfor
capitalrequirementsandcapitalgenerationareresilientto
stressesshouldtheenvironmentdeterioratebeyondthe
levelscurrentlyenvisaged.TheGroupmaintainscapital
buffersthataresufficienttoabsorbthelevelofcapital
erosioninthestressscenariooverandaboveitsminimum
capitalrequirement,ensuringthattheGroupcancontinueto
meetitsminimumcapitalrequirementsthroughouta‘severe
butplausible’stress.TheILAAPstresstestensuresthatthe
Groupholdsadequateliquidassetsintermsofbothquality
andquantitysufficienttomeetbothitsbusiness-as-usual
liquidityneedsandincreasedrequirementsthatcouldoccur
asaresultoftheGroupenteringintoaperiodofstress.
PlannedliquiditylevelsmeettheGroup’skeyriskappetite
measuresoveraperiodofthreeyears.
TheBoardhasundertakenarobustassessmentofthe
principalrisksanduncertaintiesthatcouldthreatenthe
businessmodel,futureperformance,solvencyorliquidity
oftheGroupandtheSociety.Basedonthisassessment,
thedirectorshaveareasonableexpectationthattheGroup
andtheSocietywillbeabletocontinueinoperation
andmeetitsliabilitiesastheyfalldueovertheperiodto
December2026.
Responsibility statements
AsrequiredbytheDisclosureGuidanceandTransparency
RulesoftheFinancialConductAuthority,thedirectors
confirmthat,tothebestoftheirknowledge:
•
Thefinancialstatementsgiveatrueandfairviewofthe
assets,liabilities,financialpositionandprofitorlossofthe
SocietyandtheGroup;and
•
TheStrategicreportincludesafairreviewofthe
developmentandperformanceofthebusinessandthe
positionoftheSocietyandtheGroup,andtheStrategic
reportandtheRiskManagementreportcontaina
descriptionoftheprincipalrisksanduncertainties.
Fair, balanced and understandable
AsrequiredbytheUKCorporateGovernanceCode,which
theGroupadoptstotheextentthatitappliestoaBuilding
Society,thedirectorsaresatisfiedthattheAnnualReport
andAccounts,takenasawhole,arefair,balancedand
understandableandprovidetheinformationnecessaryto
assessourperformance,businessmodelandstrategy.
External auditor
ThereappointmentofPricewaterhouseCoopersLLPasthe
Group’sexternalauditoristobeproposedatthe2024AGM.
Thedirectorsinofficeatthedateofthisreportconfirm
that,sofarastheyareaware,thereisnorelevantaudit
informationofwhichtheexternalauditorisunaware.Each
directorhastakenallthestepsnecessaryinordertomake
themselvesawareofanyrelevantauditinformationandto
establishthattheexternalauditorsarealsoawareofthat
information.
John Heaps
ChairoftheBoard
28February2024
Directors' report (continued)
Report on the audit of the financial statements
Opinion
In our opinion, Yorkshire Building Society’s Group financial statements and Society financial statements (the “financial
statements”):
•
give a true and fair view of the state of the Group’s and Society’s affairs as at 31December 2023 and of the Group’s and
Society’s income and expenditure and the Group’s and Society’s cash flows for the year then ended;
•
have been properly prepared in accordance with UK‑adopted international accounting standards; and
•
have been prepared in accordance with the requirements of the Building Societies Act 1986.
We have audited the financial statements, included within the Annual Report and Accounts (the “Annual Report”), which
comprise: the Group and Society Balance Sheets as at 31December 2023; the Group and Society Income Statements,
Statements of Comprehensive Income, Statements of Cash Flows and Statements of Changes in Members’ Interest and Equity
for the year then ended; and the notes to the financial statements, which include a description of the significant accounting
policies.
Our opinion is consistent with our reporting to the Audit Committee.
Basis for opinion
We conducted our audit in accordance with International Standards on Auditing (UK) (“ISAs (UK)”) and applicable law. Our
responsibilities under ISAs (UK) are further described in the Auditors’ responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements
section of our report. We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for
our opinion.
Independence
We remained independent of the Group in accordance with the ethical requirements that are relevant to our audit of the
financial statements in the UK, which includes the FRC’s Ethical Standard applicable to public interest entities and we have
fulfilled our other ethical responsibilities in accordance with these requirements.
To the best of our knowledge and belief, we declare that non‑audit services prohibited by the FRC’s Ethical Standard were not
provided to the Group.
Other than those disclosed in the Note 6 to the financial statements, we have provided no non‑audit services to the Group in
the period from 1 January 2023 to 31December 2023.
Our audit approach
Overview
Materiality
Group financial statements
•
£22.8m (2022: £21.3m)
•
5% of the current year profit before tax adjusted to exclude net gains and losses arising from financial instruments held at
fair value
Society financial statements
•
£15.7m (2022: £17.6m)
•
5% of the average profit before tax of the last three years adjusted to exclude net gains and losses arising from financial
instruments held at fair value
Audit scope
•
The scope of our audit and the nature, timing and extent of audit procedures performed were determined by our risk
assessment, the financial significance of components and other qualitative factors.
•
We performed audit procedures over components considered financially significant in the context of the Group (full scope
audit) or in the context of individual primary statement account balances (audit of specific account balances). We also
performed analytical review procedures to mitigate the risk of material misstatement in the residual components.
Independent auditors’ report to the members of Yorkshire Building Society
134 | Governance 135
137
Report on the audit of the financial statements (continued)
Our audit approach (continued)
Overview (continued)
Key audit matters
•
The application of key judgements and assumptions in determining expected credit loss (‘ECL’) provisions on loans and
advances to customers (Group and Society);
•
Fair value hedge accounting in respect of foreign currency debt issuances (Group and Society); and
•
The appropriateness of estimates used within the valuation of the funded defined benefit pension obligation (Group and
Society).
The scope of our audit
As part of designing our audit, we determined materiality and assessed the risks of material misstatement in the financial
statements. In particular, we looked at where the directors made subjective judgements, for example in respect of significant
accounting estimates that involved making assumptions and considering future events that are inherently uncertain. As in all
of our audits we also addressed the risk of management override of internal controls, including evaluating whether there was
evidence of bias by the directors that represented a risk of material misstatement due to fraud.
Capability of the audit in detecting irregularities, including fraud
Irregularities, including fraud, are instances of non‑compliance with laws and regulations. We design procedures in line
with our responsibilities, outlined in the Auditors’ responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements section, to detect
material misstatements in respect of irregularities, including fraud. The extent to which our procedures are capable of detecting
irregularities, including fraud, is detailed below.
Based on our understanding of the Group and its industry, we identified that the principal risks of non‑compliance with laws and
regulations related to the Financial Conduct Authority’s (‘FCA’) and Prudential Regulation Authority’s (‘PRA’) regulations, and we
considered the extent to which non‑compliance might have a material effect on the financial statements. We also considered
those laws and regulations that have a direct impact on the financial statements such as the Building Societies Act 1986. We
evaluated management’s incentives and opportunities for fraudulent manipulation of the financial statements (including the
risk of override of controls), and determined that the principal risks were related to posting manual journal entries to manipulate
financial performance and the application of management bias in the assumptions underpinning significant accounting
estimates. Audit procedures performed included:
•
Enquiries of management, those charged with governance and the Group’s in‑house legal counsel throughout the year,
including consideration of known or suspected instances of non‑compliance with laws and regulations;
•
Assessment of matters reported on the Group’s whistleblowing helpline and the results of management’s investigation of
such matters;
•
Review of internal audit reports throughout the year, in so far as these related to the financial statements;
•
Review of correspondence with, and reports to, the PRA and FCA;
•
Incorporation of an element of unpredictability in our testing through altering the nature, timing and/or extent of work
performed;
•
Challenging estimates and judgements made by management in forming significant accounting estimates in particular
those relevant to the key audit matters below; and
•
Identifying and testing any higher risk manual journal entries.
There are inherent limitations in the audit procedures described above. We are less likely to become aware of instances of
non‑compliance with laws and regulations that are not closely related to events and transactions reflected in the financial
statements. Also, the risk of not detecting a material misstatement due to fraud is higher than the risk of not detecting one
resulting from error, as fraud may involve deliberate concealment by, for example, forgery or intentional misrepresentations
or through collusion.
Key audit matters
Key audit matters are those matters that, in the auditors’ professional judgement, were of most significance in the audit of the
financial statements of the current period and include the most significant assessed risks of material misstatement (whether
or not due to fraud) identified by the auditors, including those which had the greatest effect on: the overall audit strategy; the
allocation of resources in the audit; and directing the efforts of the engagement team. These matters, and any comments we
Independent auditors’ report to the members of Yorkshire Building Society
(continued)
make on the results of our procedures thereon, were addressed in the context of our audit of the financial statements as a
whole, and in forming our opinion thereon, and we do not provide a separate opinion on these matters.
This is not a complete list of all risks identified by our audit. The key audit matters below are consistent with last year.
Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter
The application of key judgements and assumptions in
determining expected credit loss (‘ECL’) provisions on loans
and advances to customers (Group and Society)
As at 31December 2023:
•
The Group has gross loans and advances to customers of
£46,876m, with ECL provisions of £60.0m held against them.
•
The Society has gross loans and advances to customers of
£10,951m, with ECL provisions of £30.7m held against them.
The determination of ECL provisions is inherently judgemental and
involves setting assumptions using forward looking information
reflecting the Group’s view of potential future economic events.
This can give rise to increased estimation uncertainty and the need
for post model adjustments (“PMAs”), which is compounded by the
inflationary and interest rate environment in the UK.
The Group holds an Affordability PMA of £7.1m, which is
determined by applying a lifetime loss calculation to those
customers identified as being at the greatest risk of going into
default due to the rising cost‑of‑living.
The Group holds two Model Performance PMAs totaling £10.0m,
primarily reflecting the model’s current underprediction of
probability of default.
We consider the following elements of the determination of ECL
for residential mortgages to be significant:
•
The determination of forward‑looking economic scenarios
used in the core models and the weightings assigned to those
scenarios, particularly in respect of assumptions relating to
future house prices and unemployment levels since these
have the largest impact on the provision, and
•
The appropriateness of post‑model adjustments that are
recorded to take into account latent economic risks and model
performance.
The relevant disclosures are given in Note31.
Management’s associated accounting policies are detailed in
Note1.
Management’s judgements in the application of accounting
policy and critical estimates are disclosed in Note 1 and the
considerations of the effect of the future economic environment
are given in Note31.
The Audit Committee’s consideration of the matter is described in
the Audit Committee Report.
With the support of our credit risk modelling specialists and
economics experts, we performed the following procedures.
We understood and critically assessed the appropriateness of
the ECL accounting policy and model methodologies used by
management.
Forward looking economic assumptions and weightings
assigned to them
We assessed the reasonableness of the forward looking
economic scenarios and weightings assigned to them, and
benchmarked them against market consensus data.
The severity of the scenarios were evaluated with reference
to external forecasts, including data from historical economic
downturns, to assess their reasonableness.
We critically assessed the assigned weightings, using our
independently developed model to analyse management’s
selected weights with reference to observed historical losses
and the current macroeconomic environment, including an
increased focus on the economic variables most relevant to the
determination of ECL.
Post model adjustments
Based on our knowledge and understanding of the limitations in
management’s models and emerging industry risks, we evaluated
the appropriateness of the relevant post model adjustments
proposed by management.
Our testing included reperforming the modelling of key
assumptions and their application in the determination of
modelled ECL.
We then independently reperformed a sample of management’s
model monitoring tests, which compare actual outcomes to those
predicted by the models.
Our testing of the related Model Performance PMAs included the
following:
•
understanding and evaluating management’s methodology,
and implementation thereof, including the use of
assumptions;
•
independently recalculating the under‑prediction factors
using the model monitoring testing, and testing their
implementation in the PMA calculation through code review;
and
•
testing the accuracy of other key data inputs used in the
calculation.
Our testing of the Affordability PMA included critically assessing
the key drivers and assumptions and obtaining supporting
evidence to evaluate conceptual soundness and appropriateness.
We substantively tested the implementation of these
assumptions in the calculation used to estimate the PMA.
From the evidence we obtained and our assessment of the
economic scenarios, associated weightings, and the model
performance and economic risk PMAs, we are satisfied with the
reasonableness of the ECL provision.
136 | Governance
139
Independent auditors’ report to the members of Yorkshire Building Society
(continued)
Report on the audit of the financial statements (continued)
Our audit approach (continued)
Key audit matters (continued)
Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter
Fair value hedge accounting in respect of foreign currency
debt issuances (Group and Society)
The business enters into derivative contracts in order to manage
and economically hedge interest and foreign exchange rate
risk on foreign currency debt issuances. These arrangements
create accounting mismatches which are addressed through
designating the debt instruments into fair value hedge accounting
relationships.
These hedge accounting relationships are maintained in
spreadsheets with associated reliance on manual processing,
which elevates the risk of operational errors and hence the risk
that financial reporting is not compliant with IFRS requirements.
The relevant disclosures are given in Note 17.
Management’s associated accounting policies are detailed in
Note1.
The Audit Committee’s consideration of the matter is described in
the Audit Committee Report.
We understood the nature of the hedge accounting relationships
designated by management in the context of the risk
management strategies that they are associated with.
For a sample of hedging relationships, we obtained and
evaluated the hedge accounting documentation to assess
whether each hedge was compliant with the requirements of
accounting standards.
For a sample of hedging relationships which are maintained in
manual spreadsheets, we:
•
revalued hedging derivatives and underlying hedged items;
•
re‑performed hedge effectiveness calculations, agreeing key
terms to underlying support; and
•
tested that the hedge accounting was appropriately
recorded.
Based on the evidence obtained, we determined the application
of hedge accounting to be appropriate.
The appropriateness of estimates used within the valuation
of the funded defined benefit pension obligation
(Group and Society)
The Group and Society operates funded and unfunded defined
benefit pension schemes for certain current and former members
of staff. The present value of the funded defined benefit obligation
at 31 December 2023 is £572.5m.
The critical assumptions in the measurement of the defined
benefit obligation are discount rate, inflation and mortality rates.
Changes in these assumptions can have significant impacts on the
valuation.
During the current year, the value of the scheme obligations has
reduced by £20.9m. The decrease is a result of fall in assumed
long‑term price inflation, reduction in life expectancies and
change in membership data following completion of the 2022
funding valuation. This is offset by reduction in the discount rate
and inflation experience in 2023 being higher than assumed. The
value of the obligation is based on a roll‑forward of projected
benefit cash flows from the 31 December 2022 triennial valuation.
The relevant disclosures are given in Note 17.
Management’s accounting policies are detailed in Note 1.
Management’s judgements in application of accounting policy and
critical estimates are disclosed in Note 1.
The Audit Committee’s consideration of the matter is described in
the Audit Committee Report.
We considered the independence, objectivity and competence
of the third‑party actuaries engaged by management to perform
their valuation.
We confirmed our understanding of the actuary’s roll‑forward
methodology used in determining the valuation of the defined
benefit obligation. We tested a sample of member data produced
as part of the triennial valuation back to source documents.
We have engaged our actuarial experts to evaluate the
judgements and estimates made by management in determining
the discount rate, inflation and mortality assumptions used in
calculating the defined benefit obligation.
We reviewed the third‑party actuaries’ report and enquired
of those actuaries to obtain an understanding of how key
assumptions are set and the methodologies adopted in
calculating the defined benefit obligation. We assessed the
reasonableness of the assumptions and methodologies adopted
using our knowledge of current market practice, PwC‑developed
benchmarks and external market data.
Based on the work performed and evidence obtained, we found
the methodology to be compliant with accounting standards and
key assumptions to be within our independent derived ranges.
How we tailored the audit scope
We tailored the scope of our audit to ensure that we performed enough work to be able to give an opinion on the financial
statements as a whole, taking into account the structure of the Group and the Society, the accounting processes and controls, and
the industry in which they operate.
The Group comprises the Society, its wholly owned subsidiaries and special purpose vehicles over which, under accounting
standards, the Society has control. Each entity is located in the UK and is considered to be a financial reporting component.
In establishing the overall approach to our audit of the financial statements, we determined the type of work that was required to
be performed over each component. The Society and Accord Mortgages Limited were considered individually financially significant
in the context of the Group’s consolidated financial statements and were hence full scope audit components.
We considered the individual financial significance of other components in relation to primary statement account balances. We
considered the presence of any significant audit risks and other qualitative factors (including history of misstatements through
fraud or error). Any component which was not already included as a full scope audit component but was identified as being
individually financially significant in respect of one or more account balances was subject to specific audit procedures over those
account balances.
All remaining components were subject to procedures which mitigated the risk of material misstatement, including Group level
analytical review procedures.
All audit work was performed in the UK and by the same engagement team.
The impact of climate risk on our audit
As part of our audit we made enquiries of management to understand the process management adopted to assess the extent of
the potential impact of climate risk on the Group and Society’s financial statements and support the disclosures made in relation to
climate change in the Annual Report. In addition to enquiries with management, we also:
•
Read the Group’s Environmental and Climate Change policies and framework to consider the impact on our audit risk
assessment;
•
Understood the exposure of the Group and Society’s mortgage portfolios to physical and transition risks by examining the
output of assessments performed by management during the year. Management considers the impact of climate risk does
not give rise to a material financial statement impact; and
•
We also considered the consistency of the disclosures in relation to climate change (including the disclosures in the Task
Force on Climate‑related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) section) within the Annual Report with the financial statements and
our knowledge obtained from our audit.
Our procedures did not identify any material impact in the context of our audit of the financial statements as a whole, or our key
audit matters for the year ended 31 December 2023.
138 | Governance
141
Independent auditors’ report to the members of Yorkshire Building Society
(continued)
Report on the audit of the financial statements (continued)
Our audit approach (continued)
Materiality
The scope of our audit was influenced by our application of materiality. We set certain quantitative thresholds for materiality.
These, together with qualitative considerations, helped us to determine the scope of our audit and the nature, timing and
extent of our audit procedures on the individual financial statement line items and disclosures and in evaluating the effect of
misstatements, both individually and in aggregate on the financial statements as a whole.
Based on our professional judgement, we determined materiality for the financial statements as a whole as follows:
Overall materiality Group financial statements
£22.8m (2022: £21.3m).
Society financial statements
£15.7m (2022: £17.6m).
How we
determined it
5% of the current year profit before tax adjusted to
exclude net gains and losses arising from financial
instruments held at fair value.
5% of the average profit before tax of the last three years
(2021 – 2023), each adjusted to exclude net gains and
losses arising from financial instruments held at fair value.
Rationale for
benchmark applied
Profit before tax is a primary measure used by
stakeholders in assessing the performance of the Group
and Society and is a generally accepted benchmark for
determining audit materiality.
Management assesses the performance of the business
using the “Core Operating Profit” measure, which itself
excludes net gains and losses on financial instruments
held at fair value through the income statement, as
these are not considered to reflect the underlying
performance of the business. The fair value movement
relates predominantly to derivatives which are not yet in
accounting hedging relationships, rather than underlying
business performance.
For the Society, we have used a three‑year average of the
adjusted profit measure (2021‑2023) to normalise for
volatility in underlying business performance over that
period.
For each component in the scope of our group audit, we allocated a materiality that is less than our overall Group materiality.
The range of materiality allocated across components was £15.2m to £21.7m.
We use performance materiality to reduce to an appropriately low level the probability that the aggregate of uncorrected and
undetected misstatements exceeds overall materiality. Specifically, we use performance materiality in determining the scope
of our audit and the nature and extent of our testing of account balances, classes of transactions and disclosures, for example
in determining sample sizes. Our performance materiality was 75% of overall materiality, amounting to £17.1m for the Group
financial statements and £11.8m for the Society financial statements.
In determining the performance materiality, we considered a number of factors – the history of misstatements, risk
assessment and aggregation risk and the effectiveness of controls – and concluded that an amount at the upper end of our
normal range was appropriate.
We agreed with the Audit Committee that we would report to them misstatements identified during our audit above £1.1m
(2022: £1.0m) in respect of the Group and £0.8m (2022: £0.8m) in respect of Society as well as misstatements below these
amounts that, in our view, warranted reporting for qualitative reasons.
Conclusions relating to going concern
Our evaluation of the directors’ assessment of the Group’s and the Society’s ability to continue to adopt the going concern
basis of accounting included:
•
A risk assessment to identify factors that could impact the going concern basis of accounting, including the current and
forecast financial performance;
•
Evaluation of management’s going concern assessment, including consideration of the impact of current economic
environment;
•
Evaluation of management’s forecasts, including liquidity and regulatory capital over the going concern period;
•
Review of regulatory correspondence and reports provided to governance forums; and
•
Evaluation of the appropriateness of the relevant disclosures in the financial statements.
Based on the work we have performed, we have not identified any material uncertainties relating to events or conditions that,
individually or collectively, may cast significant doubt on the Group’s and the Society’s ability to continue as a going concern
for a period of at least twelve months from the date on which the financial statements are authorised for issue.
In auditing the financial statements, we have concluded that the directors’ use of the going concern basis of accounting in the
preparation of the financial statements is appropriate.
However, because not all future events or conditions can be predicted, this conclusion is not a guarantee as to the Group’s
and Society’s ability to continue as a going concern.
In relation to the directors’ reporting on how they have applied the UK Corporate Governance Code, we have nothing material
to add or draw attention to in relation to the directors’ statement in the financial statements about whether the directors
considered it appropriate to adopt the going concern basis of accounting.
Our responsibilities and the responsibilities of the directors with respect to going concern are described in the relevant
sections of this report.
Reporting on other information
The other information comprises all of the information in the Annual Report other than the financial statements and our
auditors’ report thereon. The directors are responsible for the other information. Our opinion on the financial statements
does not cover the other information and, accordingly, we do not express an audit opinion or, except to the extent otherwise
explicitly stated in this report, any form of assurance thereon.
In connection with our audit of the financial statements, our responsibility is to read the other information and, in doing so,
consider whether the other information is materially inconsistent with the financial statements or our knowledge obtained
in the audit, or otherwise appears to be materially misstated. If we identify an apparent material inconsistency or material
misstatement, we are required to perform procedures to conclude whether there is a material misstatement of the financial
statements or a material misstatement of the other information. If, based on the work we have performed, we conclude that
there is a material misstatement of this other information, we are required to report that fact. We have nothing to report based
on these responsibilities.
With respect to the Annual Business Statement and Directors’ Report we also considered whether the disclosures required by
the Building Societies Act 1986 have been included.
Based on our work undertaken in the course of the audit, the Building Societies Act 1986 requires us also to report certain
opinions and matters as described below.
Annual Business Statement and Directors’ Report
In our opinion, based on our work undertaken in the course of the audit:
•
the Annual Business Statement and the Directors’ Report have been prepared in accordance with the requirements of the
Building Societies Act 1986;
•
the information given in the Directors’ Report for the year ended 31 December 2023 is consistent with the accounting
records and the financial statements; and
•
the information given in the Annual Business Statement (other than the information upon which we are not required to
report) gives a true representation of the matters in respect of which it is given.
In light of the knowledge and understanding of the Group and Society and their environment obtained in the course of the
audit, we did not identify any material misstatements in the Directors’ Report.
140 | Governance
143
Corporate governance statement
ISAs (UK) require us to review the directors’ statements in relation to going concern, longer‑term viability and that part of the
corporate governance statement relating to the Society’s compliance with the provisions of the UK Corporate Governance
Code, which the Listing Rules of the Financial Conduct Authority specify for review by auditors of premium listed companies.
Our additional responsibilities with respect to the corporate governance statement as other information are described in the
Reporting on other information section of this report.
Based on the work undertaken as part of our audit, we have concluded that each of the following elements of the corporate
governance statement is materially consistent with the financial statements and our knowledge obtained during the audit,
and we have nothing material to add or draw attention to in relation to:
•
The directors’ confirmation that they have carried out a robust assessment of the emerging and principal risks;
•
The disclosures in the Annual Report that describe those principal risks, what procedures are in place to identify emerging
risks and an explanation of how these are being managed or mitigated;
•
The directors’ statement in the financial statements about whether they considered it appropriate to adopt the going
concern basis of accounting in preparing them, and their identification of any material uncertainties to the Group’s and
Society’s ability to continue to do so over a period of at least twelve months from the date of approval of the financial
statements;
•
The directors’ explanation as to their assessment of the Group’s and Society’s prospects, the period this assessment covers
and why the period is appropriate; and
•
The directors’ statement as to whether they have a reasonable expectation that the Society will be able to continue in
operation and meet its liabilities as they fall due over the period of its assessment, including any related disclosures
drawing attention to any necessary qualifications or assumptions.
Our review of the directors’ statement regarding the longer‑term viability of the Group and Society was substantially less in
scope than an audit and only consisted of making inquiries and considering the directors’ process supporting their statement;
checking that the statement is in alignment with the relevant provisions of the UK Corporate Governance Code; and
considering whether the statement is consistent with the financial statements and our knowledge and understanding of the
Group and Society and their environment obtained in the course of the audit.
In addition, based on the work undertaken as part of our audit, we have concluded that each of the following elements of
the corporate governance statement is materially consistent with the financial statements and our knowledge obtained
during the audit:
•
The directors’ statement that they consider the Annual Report, taken as a whole, is fair, balanced and understandable, and
provides the information necessary for the members to assess the Group’s and Society’s position, performance, business
model and strategy;
•
The section of the Annual Report that describes the review of effectiveness of risk management and internal control
systems; and
•
The section of the Annual Report describing the work of the Audit Committee.
We have nothing to report in respect of our responsibility to report when the directors’ statement relating to the Society’s
compliance with the Code does not properly disclose a departure from a relevant provision of the Code specified under the Listing
Rules for review by the auditors.
Independent auditors’ report to the members of Yorkshire Building Society
(continued)
Report on the audit of the financial statements (continued)
Responsibilities for the financial statements and the audit
Responsibilities of the directors for the financial statements
As explained more fully in the Directors’ responsibilities in respect of the preparation of the Annual Report and Accounts,
the directors are responsible for the preparation of the financial statements in accordance with the applicable framework
and for being satisfied that they give a true and fair view. The directors are also responsible for such internal control as they
determine is necessary to enable the preparation of financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether
due to fraud or error.
In preparing the financial statements, the directors are responsible for assessing the Group’s and Society’s ability to continue
as a going concern, disclosing as applicable, matters related to going concern and using the going concern basis of accounting
unless the directors either intend to liquidate the Group and Society or to cease operations, or have no realistic alternative
but to do so.
Auditors’ responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements
Our objectives are to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are free from material
misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to issue an auditors’ report that includes our opinion. Reasonable assurance is a
high level of assurance, but is not a guarantee that an audit conducted in accordance with ISAs (UK) will always detect a material
misstatement when it exists. Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and are considered material if, individually or in the
aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions of users taken on the basis of these financial
statements.
Our audit testing might include testing complete populations of certain transactions and balances, possibly using data
auditing techniques. However, it typically involves selecting a limited number of items for testing, rather than testing complete
populations. We will often seek to target particular items for testing based on their size or risk characteristics. In other cases, we
will use audit sampling to enable us to draw a conclusion about the population from which the sample is selected.
A further description of our responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements is located on the Financial Reporting
Council’s website at: www.frc.org.uk/auditorsresponsibilities. This description forms part of our auditors’ report.
Use of this report
This report, including the opinions, has been prepared for and only for the Society’s members as a body in accordance with
Section 78 of the Building Societies Act 1986 and for no other purpose. We do not, in giving these opinions, accept or assume
responsibility for any other purpose or to any other person to whom this report is shown or into whose hands it may come
save where expressly agreed by our prior consent in writing.
142 | Governance
Financial Statements
Income statements 146
Statements of comprehensive income 147
Balance sheets 148
Statements of changes in
members’ interest and equity 149
Statements of cash flows 151
Notes to the financial statements 152
Independent auditors’ report to the members of Yorkshire Building Society
(continued)
Other required reporting
Building Societies Act 1986 exception reporting
Under the Building Societies Act 1986 we are required to report to you if, in our opinion:
•
adequate accounting records have not been kept by the Society; or
•
the Society financial statements are not in agreement with the accounting records; or
•
we have not received all the information and explanations and access to documents we require for our audit.
We have no exceptions to report arising from this responsibility.
Appointment
Following the recommendation of the Audit Committee, we were appointed by the members on 30 April 2019 to audit
the financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2019 and subsequent financial periods. The period of total
uninterrupted engagement is 5 years, covering the years ended 31 December 2019 to 31 December 2023.
Other Matter
In due course, as required by the Financial Conduct Authority Disclosure Guidance and Transparency Rule 4.1.14R, these
financial statements will form part of the ESEF‑prepared annual financial report filed on the National Storage Mechanism
of the Financial Conduct Authority in accordance with the ESEF Regulatory Technical Standard (‘ESEF RTS’). This auditors’
report provides no assurance over whether the annual financial report will be prepared using the single electronic format
specified in the ESEF RTS.
Heather Varley (Senior Statutory Auditor)
for and on behalf of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
Chartered Accountants and Statutory Auditors
Leeds
28 February 2024
145144 | Governance
Income Statements
For the year ended 31December 2023
Group
Society
Notes
£m
£m
£m
£m
Interest revenue calculated using the effective interest rate method
3
1,954.6
1,202.6
2,905.0
1,214.7*
Other interest revenue
3
1,011.7
234.4
1,011.5
234.2*
Interest revenue
3
2,966.3
1,437.0
3,916.5
1,448.9
Interest expense
4
(2,180.3)
(712.9)
(3,308.6)
(992.2)
Net interest income
786.0
724.1
607.9
456.7
Fee and commission revenue
20.0
21.6
7.6
8.7
Fee and commission expense
(16.6)
(16.3)
(7.4)
(6.6)
Net fee and commission income
3.4
5.3
0.2
2.1
Net (losses)/gains from financial instruments held at fair value
5
(5.5)
75.6
(9.7)
67.8
Income from investments
8
–
0.1
50.0
100.1
Net realised gains on disposal of financial instruments
1.6
2.9
1.6
2.9
Other operating income
0.9
3.4
99.1
93.8
Total income
786.4
811.4
749.1
723.4
Administrative expenses
6
(312.3)
(276.9)
(312.1)
(276.7)
Depreciation and amortisation
(20.4)
(21.8)
(20.4)
(21.8)
Impairment (charge)/release of financial assets
7
(4.0)
(6.0)
–
0.6
Provisions for liabilities and charges
23
0.6
(4.2)
0.8
(4.2)
Profit before tax
450.3
502.5
417.4
421.3
Tax expense
9
(118.6)
(123.2)
(101.0)
(91.1)
Profit for the year
331.7
379.3
316.4
330.2
All profit for the year arises from continuing operations and is attributable to members.
* Please refer to
Reclassification within Interest Revenue (Society only)
in Note 1 for details of the reclassification made between these lines.
The notes on pages 152 to 233 form part of these financial statements.
Statements of Comprehensive Income
For the year ended 31December 2023
Group
Society
2022
2022
Notes
£m
£m
£m
£m
Profit for the financial year
331.7
379.3
316.4
330.2
Items that may be subsequently reclassified through profit or loss
Cash flow hedges:
Fair value movements taken to equity
–
26.1
–
26.1
Amounts transferred to the income statement
(13.2)
(28.1)
(13.2)
(28.1)
Tax on amounts recognised in equity
9
3.7
0.5
3.7
0.5
Effect of change in corporation tax rate
9
–
0.8
–
0.8
Financial assets measured through other comprehensive income:
Fair value movements taken to equity
(18.0)
(27.0)
(18.0)
(27.0)
Amounts transferred to the income statement
1.2
(1.9)
1.2
(1.9)
Tax on amounts recognised in equity
9
4.7
7.8
4.7
7.8
Effect of change in corporation tax rate
9
–
1.9
–
1.9
Items that will not be reclassified through profit or loss
Remeasurement of retirement benefit obligations
(11.2)
(80.0)
(11.2)
(80.0)
Tax on remeasurement of retirement benefit obligations
9
3.1
21.6
3.1
21.6
Effect of change in corporation tax rate
9
–
6.9
–
6.9
Total other comprehensive expense
(29.7)
(71.4)
(29.7)
(71.4)
Total comprehensive income for the year
302.0
307.9
286.7
258.8
The notes on pages 152 to 233 form part of these financial statements.
146 | Financial Statements 147
Balance Sheets
As at 31December 2023
Group
Society
Notes
£m
£m
£m
£m
Assets
Cash and balances with the Bank of England
10
4,839.1
5,982.8
4,839.1
5,982.8
Loans and advances to credit institutions
397.4
814.7
208.6
568.8
Debt securities
11
7,561.9
5,684.8
19,354.3
19,233.0
Loans and advances to customers
12
46,815.9
45,203.7
10,920.6
11,238.9
Fair value adjustment for hedged risk on loans and advances to
customers
(615.5)
(1,508.3)
(615.5)
(1,508.3)
Derivative financial instruments
26
1,755.0
2,356.5
1,751.9
2,323.7
Investments
8
3.3
2.8
37,462.6
35,739.8
Intangible assets
13
18.3
20.2
18.3
20.2
Investment property
14
15.7
16.0
15.7
16.0
Property held for sale
0.6
0.9
0.6
0.9
Property, plant and equipment
15
99.5
101.1
99.5
101.1
Retirement benefit surplus
17
38.6
48.8
38.6
48.8
Other assets
18
38.9
30.1
130.6
95.2
Total assets
60,968.7
58,754.1
74,224.9
73,860.9
Liabilities
Shares
19
47,056.7
42,008.2
47,056.7
42,008.2
Amounts owed to credit institutions
1,886.3
5,160.9
1,886.3
5,160.9
Other deposits
20
983.6
1,138.1
14,080.2
15,836.3
Debt securities in issue
21
4,919.4
5,259.3
5,517.6
6,153.4
Derivative financial instruments
26
697.4
666.3
584.3
507.0
Current tax liabilities
–
0.7
–
0.6
Deferred tax liabilities
16
22.5
11.9
21.1
10.2
Other liabilities
22
70.5
64.0
119.2
97.0
Retirement benefit obligations
17
8.1
7.4
8.1
7.4
Provisions for liabilities and charges
23
4.0
5.7
3.9
5.7
Subordinated liabilities
24
1,621.7
1,035.1
1,621.7
1,035.1
Total liabilities
57,270.2
55,357.6
70,899.1
70,821.8
Members’ interests and equity
3,698.5
3,396.5
3,325.8
3,039.1
Total members’ interest, equity and liabilities
60,968.7
58,754.1
74,224.9
73,860.9
Approved by the Board of Directors on 28 February 2024 and signed on its behalf by:
Susan Allen OBE Alasdair Lenman John Heaps
Chief Executive Officer Chief Finance Officer Chair of the Board
The notes on pages 152 to 233 form part of these financial statements.
Statements of Changes in Members’ Interest and Equity
For the year ended 31December 2023
Group
General
Cash flow Fair value Total
reservehedge through other
reservecomprehensive
income
£m
£m
£m
£m
At 1 January 2023
3,384.7
9.9
1.9
3,396.5
Profit for the year
331.7
–
–
331.7
Net remeasurement of retirement benefit obligations
(8.1)
–
–
(8.1)
Net movement in cash flow hedges
–
(9.5)
–
(9.5)
Net movement in fair value through other comprehensive income
–
–
(12.1)
(12.1)
Total comprehensive income
323.6
(9.5)
(12.1)
302.0
At 31December 2023
3,708.3
0.4
(10.2)
3,698.5
At 1 January 2022
3,056.9
10.6
21.1
3,088.6
Profit for the year
379.3
–
–
379.3
Net remeasurement of retirement benefit obligations
(51.5)
–
–
(51.5)
Net movement in cash flow hedges
–
(0.7)
–
(0.7)
Net movement in fair value through other comprehensive income
–
–
(19.2)
(19.2)
Total comprehensive income
327.8
(0.7)
(19.2)
307.9
At 31December 2022
3,384.7
9.9
1.9
3,396.5
The notes on pages 152 to 233 form part of these financial statements.
148 | Financial Statements 149
Statements of Changes in Members’ Interest and Equity (continued)
For the year ended 31December 2023
Society General
reserve
Cash flow
hedge
reserve
Fair value
through other
comprehensive
income
Total
£m £m £m £m
At 1 January 2023 3,027.3 9.9 1.9 3,039.1
Profit for the year 316.4 – – 316.4
Net remeasurement of retirement benefit obligations (8.1) – – (8.1)
Net movement in cash flow hedges – (9.5) – (9.5)
Net movement in fair value through other comprehensive income – – (12.1) (12.1)
Total comprehensive income 308.3 (9.5) (12.1) 286.7
At 31 December 2023 3,335.6 0.4 (10.2) 3,325.8
At 1 January 2022 2,746.1 10.6 21.1 2,777.8
Profit for the year 330.2 – – 330.2
Net remeasurement of retirement benefit obligations (51.5) – – (51.5)
Net movement in cash flow hedges – (0.7) – (0.7)
Net movement in fair value through other comprehensive income – – (19.2) (19.2)
Total comprehensive income 278.7 (0.7) (19.2) 258.8
Capital contribution 2.5 – – 2.5
At 31 December 2022 3,027.3 9.9 1.9 3,039.1
The notes on pages 152 to 233 form part of these financial statements.
Statements of Cash Flows
For the year ended 31December 2023
Group
Society
Restated
Restated
20222022
Notes
£m
£m
£m
£m
Cash flows from operating activities
Profit before tax
450.3
502.5
417.4
421.3
Non‑cash items included in profit before tax
35
147.0
(62.2)*
143.0
(68.8)*
Net change in operating assets
35
(1,937.2)
(3,647.2)*
(1,781.3)
(2,823.0)*
Net change in operating liabilities
35
1,744.7
6,094.7*
143.4
6,197.1*
Tax paid
(101.0)
(125.5)
(83.0)
(93.2)
Net cash flow from operating activities
303.8
2,762.3
(1,160.5)
3,633.4
Cash flows from investing activities
Purchase of property, plant and equipment, and intangible assets
(15.0)
(12.8)
(15.0)
(12.8)
Proceeds from sale of property, plant and equipment
(0.2)
0.8
(0.2)
0.8
Purchase of debt securities
(3,412.9)
(2,952.2)
(3,412.9)
(8,787.6)
Redemption and other movements of debt securities
1,520.6
1,316.9
3,276.4
4,469.1
Net cash flow from investing activities
(1,907.5)
(1,647.3)
(151.7)
(4,330.5)
Cash flows from financing activities
Redemption of debt securities in issue
35
(1,423.7)
(1,225.2)
(1,165.4)
(773.4)
Debt securities in issue
35
999.2
711.5
506.5
1,911.5
Issue of subordinated liabilities
35
650.0
300.0
650.0
300.0
Redemption of subordinated liabilities
35
(136.4)
–
(136.4)
–
Interest paid on subordinated liabilities
(51.5)
(33.7)
(51.5)
(33.7)
Interest paid on lease liabilities
(0.6)
(0.7)
(0.6)
(0.7)
Capital repayments on lease liabilities
(3.6)
(2.3)
(3.6)
(2.3)
Net cash flow from financing activities
33.4
(250.4)
(201.0)
1,401.4
Net change in cash and cash equivalents
(1,570.3)
864.6
(1,513.2)
704.3
Opening balance
6,630.3
5,765.7
6,384.4
5,680.1
Closing cash and cash equivalents
5,060.0
6,630.3
4,871.2
6,384.4
Cash and cash equivalents
Cash and cash equivalents
10
4,839.1
5,982.8
4,839.1
5,982.8
Less Bank of England cash ratio deposit
10
(176.5)
(167.2)
(176.5)
(167.2)
Loans and advances to credit institutions
397.4
814.7
208.6
568.8
Closing cash and cash equivalents
5,060.0
6,630.3
4,871.2
6,384.4
* Please see Note 1
Basis of preparation
for details.
The notes on pages 152 to 233 form part of these financial statements.
150 | Financial Statements 151
Notes to the Financial Statements
1. Statement of accounting policies
Basis of preparation
These financial statements present the
results of Yorkshire Building Society
(‘YBS’ or ‘the Society’) and its controlled
entities (collectively ‘the Group’ or
‘the YBS Group’) for the year ended
31 December 2023.
The Group is required under the
Building Societies Act 1986 to apply
‘UK‑adopted international accounting
standards’ as endorsed by the UK
Endorsement Board (‘UKEB’). As a
result, these financial statements have
been prepared in accordance with
international accounting standards
– being International Accounting
Standards (IAS), International
Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS)
and interpretations (IFRICs) issued
by the International Accounting
Standards Board (IASB) endorsed by
the UKEB and effective from 1 January
2021 – and with those parts of the
Building Societies Act 1986 and the
Building Societies (Accounts and
Related Provisions) Regulations 1998
applicable to societies reporting under
international accounting standards.
The financial statements have been
prepared on the historical cost basis, as
modified by the revaluation of certain
financial instruments measured at
fair value. Pounds sterling is both the
functional currency of the YBS Group
and the presentation currency applied
to these financial statements. Except
where otherwise stated, all figures in
the financial statements are rounded to
the nearest hundreds of thousands of
pounds sterling (£0.0 million).
Accounting policies have been
consistently applied, except where a
new accounting standard has been
introduced.
The preparation of financial statements
under international accounting
standards requires the use of certain
critical accounting estimates and
judgements. The areas involving
a higher degree of judgements or
complexity, or areas where assumptions
and estimates are significant to the
financial statements are set out in
note 2.
Going concern
The YBS Board of Directors (the Board)
undertake regular assessments of
whether the Group is a going concern,
taking into account changing economic
and market conditions, and using all
available information about future risks
and uncertainties.
Given its strong capital position and
high liquidity levels, the Group is well
placed to cope with economic volatility.
As a result, the directors confirm that,
based on the latest formal review
undertaken in February 2024, and
stress tests performed throughout the
period, they consider the Group has
adequate resources to continue in
existence for the foreseeable future.
Accordingly, they continue to adopt the
going concern basis in preparing these
financial statements.
Basis of consolidation
The Group financial statements
consolidate the financial statements of
the Society and the entities it controls
as listed in note 8. Control is deemed
to exist when the Group has the power
to govern the financial and operating
policies of an entity so as to obtain
benefits from its activities. Upon
consolidation, intra‑group assets and
liabilities, equity, income, expenses
and cash flows relating to transactions
between members of the Group are
eliminated. Investments in controlled
entities are stated in the Society
accounts at cost less any provisions for
impairment.
Securitisation transactions
The Group securitises mortgage loans
by transferring them into special
purpose vehicles (SPVs) and issuing
debt securities to investors, using the
underlying loan assets as collateral. As
the Society is deemed to control these
SPVs, they are fully consolidated into
these financial statements.
Generally, the transfer of the mortgage
loans to the structured entities does
not meet the derecognition criteria
under IFRS 9 Financial Instruments
as the Society/Accord substantially
retains all the risks and rewards of
ownership through the receipt of the
residual profits or losses of the SPVs.
In this instance, the Society/Accord
continues to recognise the mortgage
loans on their own balance sheets
after the transfer, with the proceeds
received from the transfer accounted
for as a deemed loan from the SPVs.
For covered bonds, the Society issues
the covered bonds, not the structured
entity. The proceeds are then lent to
the structured entity on back‑to‑back
terms. These proceeds are used as
consideration for the loans transferred
from the Society. Neither the loan to the
structured entity nor the consideration
for the transfer of mortgage loans is
recognised separately as an additional
asset and liability in the accounts of the
Society.
To manage interest rate risk, the Society
enters into derivative transactions with
its structured entities, receiving a rate
of interest based on the securitised
mortgages and paying a rate inherent
in the debt issuances. These internal
derivatives are treated as part of
the deemed loan and not separately
measured at fair value because the
relevant mortgage loans are not
derecognised.
Change in presentation
A balance sheet line item has been
created in these financial statements
to present
Fair value adjustment for
hedged risk on loans and advances
to customers
as a separate item
on the balance sheet as permitted
under IAS 39. The balance of
Fair
value adjustment for hedged risk on
loans and advances to customers
was
previously reported within the loans
and advances to customers balance.
Notes to the financial statements have
been updated to reflect this change in
presentation (note 12, note 27, note 31,
note 32 and note 35).
Reclassification within Interest
Revenue (Society only)
The
Income Statement
and, accordingly,
Note 3 Interest revenue
for the Society
for the year ended 31 December 2022,
have been updated in these financial
statements to correct the classification
of interest earned by the Society on an
intercompany arrangement.
£79 million of interest previously
reported within
Other interest
revenue (Note 3: Derivatives not
included in hedge relationships)
has
been reclassified to
Interest revenue
calculated using the effective interest
rate method (Note 3: Loans secured
on connected undertakings)
. This
reclassification has no impact on the
previously reported total interest
revenue. This matter has no impact on
the Group financial statements.
Reclassification of cashflow
balances (Group and Society)
Note 35
Notes to the cashflow
statements
and, accordingly, the
Statement of Cashflows
for the year
ended 31 December 2022, have been
updated in these financial statements
to correct the classifications of the
line items within the
Net cash from
operating activities
sub total. Please
refer to Note 35 for details.
Accounting developments
Changes to Accounting Standards
Effective in the Period
IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts
IFRS 17
Insurance Contracts
is the
comprehensive standard establishing
recognition and measurement
requirements for insurance contracts.
This standard is effective for periods
beginning on or after 1 January 2023.
Only a small equity release portfolio
in run‑off falls under the scope of
IFRS 17 so the impact of applying
this revised standard is not deemed
material.
Standards issued but not yet
effective
The following standards or
amendments were in issue but were
either optional, or not yet effective,
and have not been adopted in these
financial statements.
IFRS 9 and hedge accounting
IFRS 9
Financial Instruments
was issued
in 2014 as a replacement of IAS 39
Financial Instruments: Recognition and
Measurement
and was mandatorily
effective for periods beginning on or
after 1 January 2018.
However, IFRS 9 did not replace the
requirements for portfolio fair value
hedge accounting for interest rate risk
since this phase of the project was
separated out due to its longer‑term
nature.
As a result, IFRS 9 included a
transitional relief allowing the
continued use of the hedge accounting
requirements of IAS 39, and the Group
continue to adopt this approach.
The development of requirements will
be closely monitored and the Group
will continue to assess the impacts
of full adoption of IFRS 9 for hedge
accounting.
Material accounting policies
Change in Accounting Policy
IAS 1 Presentation of financial
statements
The IASB issued amendments to IAS 1
Presentation of Financial Statements
.
IAS 1 now mandates disclosure of
material accounting policies rather
than significant accounting policies.
The accounting policies of the Group
have been reviewed in respect of
IAS 1 amendments with no significant
changes deemed necessary.
There are no other new accounting
standards applicable for this set of
financial statements expected in the
near future, and only a small number
of narrow amendments or some annual
improvements to existing standards,
none of which have an impact on these
financial statements.
Interest revenue and expense
calculated using the effective
interest rate method
The effective interest rate method
is used to calculate the revenue and
expense for financial instruments
held at amortised cost. The effective
interest rate is the rate that exactly
discounts estimated future cash flows
(excluding credit losses) over the
expected life of the instrument back to
the fair value on initial recognition.
For mortgage loans and advances to
customers this includes an estimate of
any early repayment income. Directly
attributable acquisition costs, such as
application and arrangement fees, are
also incorporated in the calculation.
This has the effect of spreading these
fees and costs over the expected
life of the mortgage. Expected lives
are estimated using historical data
and management judgement. The
calculation is adjusted when actual
experience differs from estimates, with
changes in deferred amounts being
recognised immediately in the income
statement.
Fees and commissions
Fees and commissions on referral
of customers to third party service
providers of financial products is
accounted for on an effective interest
rate basis, similar to interest revenue
and expense calculated using the
effective interest rate method. Other
fees and commissions are recognised
on an accruals basis as the relevant
service is provided or at a point in
time if the service or product provided
relates to a one‑off action.
Other operating income
Other operating income comprises
profits on disposal of fixed assets,
rental income from investment
property and software licensing
income. The Society also includes the
recharge of administrative expenses to
its subsidiaries.
Income from investments
This consists of dividend income and is
recognised when the rights to receive
the payment have been established.
Financial instruments
Classification and measurement of
financial assets and financial liabilities
The Group initially recognises
financial assets and liabilities at their
fair value (adjusted for any directly
attributable transaction costs for those
subsequently classified at amortised
cost) on the date that the Group
becomes a party to the contractual
provisions of the instrument.
Subsequent measurement of financial
assets and financial liabilities
depends on the contractual cash flow
characteristics of the instrument.
152 | Financial Statements 153
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
1. Statement of accounting policies (continued)
Material accounting policies (continued)
Financial instruments (continued)
Amortised cost: this measurement approach is applied to instruments that are held to collect interest and principal payments
over the life of the contract. Subsequent measurement is via the effective interest rate method (see
Interest revenue and
expense calculated using the effective interest rate method)
, subject to impairment (see
Impairment)
, plus any adjustment if
designated as part of an effective hedge arrangement (see
Hedging)
.
Fair value through other comprehensive income: this measurement approach is applied to financial assets whose business
objective is the collection of interest and principal payments but that are also bought and sold. Subsequent measurement is
at fair value with changes in fair value recognised in other comprehensive income. When the instrument is derecognised, the
cumulative gain or loss previously recognised in reserves is reclassified to the income statement.
Fair value through profit and loss: this method is applied to those instruments that are not classed as amortised cost or fair
value through other comprehensive income. Subsequent measurement is at fair value with any movements recognised in the
income statement in the period in which they arise.
The table below summarises the Group’s financial instruments and the treatment adopted in these financial statements:
Financial instrument
Description
Subsequent measurement
Cash and cash equivalents
Cash balances and statutory deposits
Amortised cost
Loans and advances to credit institutions
Fixed and variable interest rates
Amortised cost
Debt securities
Fixed, variable and indexed linked interest
Fair value through other comprehensive
rates income, amortised cost and fair value
through profit and loss
Loans and advances to customers
Primarily mortgage products offering a
Amortised cost
variety of fixed and variable interest rates
Derivative financial instruments*
Swaps and options to manage interest rate
Fair value through profit and loss (unless
and foreign exchange risk exposures designated as a cash flow hedge, see
‘Hedging’ section of note 1, then fair value
through other comprehensive income)
Investments in subsidiaries
Equity investments in controlled entities
Cost less accumulated impairment losses
Investment in equities
Equity investments in non‑controlled
Fair value through profit and loss
entities
Shares
Deposits made by members with a variety of
Amortised cost
fixed and variable interest rates
Amounts owed to credit institutions
Time Deposits at fixed and variable interest
Amortised cost
rates
Debt securities in issue, subordinated
Fixed and variable interest rates
Amortised cost
liabilities and other deposits
Derecognition of financial instruments
Financial assets are only derecognised when the contractual rights to receive cash flows from the financial assets have
expired, or when the Group has transferred substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership. As described in
Securitisation
transactions
, the Group has not derecognised the loans transferred to the SPVs to secure the issue of covered bonds and
mortgage backed securities because substantially all the risks and rewards are retained.
Financial liabilities are only derecognised when the obligation is discharged, cancelled, or has expired.
* The Society holds intra group derivatives to manage interest rate risk within the special purpose securitisation vehicles and these are measured at
amortised cost. These internal derivatives are treated as part of the deemed loan with the SPV.
Impairment of financial assets
At each reporting date the Group
assesses financial assets held at
amortised cost for impairment.
For
loans and advances to customers
the Group uses the expected credit
loss (ECL) staging model to assess any
impairment in the carrying value of
the mortgage assets. This model uses
forward looking assessments of overall
expected credit losses and recognises
impairment based on a three‑staged
approach as follows.
Stage 1: financial assets are
categorised into ‘stage 1’ on initial
recognition. Impairment is based on
expected credit losses resulting from
default events projected within the
next 12 months (12 month ECL).
Stage 2: financial assets move into
‘stage 2’ when they are deemed
to have experienced a significant
increase in credit risk (SICR), based
on quantitative and/or qualitative risk
grade thresholds. Impairment is then
based on expected losses over the full
lifetime of the contract (lifetime ECL).
The Group assesses a SICR to have
occurred when the accounts are more
than 30 days past due or there has
been a significant relative increase in
the lifetime probability of default (PD)
compared to that at initial recognition.
For retail accounts, PD is based on the
customer’s credit quality, including
analysis of their behaviour scores
and other account characteristics.
For non‑retail portfolios, the Group
assess a significant increase in credit
risk using a combination of individual
and collective information, including
monitoring through the watch list
process. For further information on the
watch list process see note 31.
Stage 3: financial assets are moved
into ‘stage 3’ when there is objective
evidence that the loan is credit
impaired, with expected credit losses
still calculated on a lifetime basis.
A loan is considered credit impaired
when it is 90 days past due, has been
renegotiated for credit risk reasons, or
otherwise considered to be in default
(including possession, insolvency and
assets beyond term expiry).
The Group’s use of forbearance tools,
including arrears arrangements,
payment deferrals, term extension,
transfers to interest only and interest
capitalisation, are factored into
the criteria for identifying stage 3
accounts. The impairment provision is
determined using the same calculation
as stage 2 accounts, but with the PD
set to 100%.
Loans that are either purchased or
originated credit impaired (POCI)
are classified as stage 3 at initial
recognition and cannot be transferred
to stage 1 or 2 even if the credit
quality of these assets improves. The
Group has a portfolio of loans acquired
as part of the Chelsea Building
Society and Norwich & Peterborough
acquisitions that meet this definition.
ECL calculations: these are assessed at
individual loan level using three main
components.
•
PD, being the probability, at the
point of assessment, that the
customer will default in the future.
The definition of default includes
accounts that are 90 days past
due, interest only accounts past
term end, those under certain
forbearance measures and others
exhibiting other unlikeliness to pay
indicators.
•
Exposure at default (EAD), being
the outstanding value of the loan,
taking into account the repayment
of principal and interest between
the date of assessment and
expected default date.
•
Loss given default (LGD), is the
net impact of the EAD after taking
into account the mitigating effect
of collateral and the time value of
money.
PD is a calculation based on current
conditions and adjusted to take into
account estimates of future conditions
that will impact PD. EAD is modelled
based on expected payments over the
term and is not floored at the current
balance.
LGD takes into account the expected
impact of future economic conditions,
such as changes in value of collateral,
and does not include any floors.
Only costs directly associated with
obtaining/selling collateral are
included. Discounting of the expected
cash flows is performed using the
effective interest rate of the loan.
The ECL is calculated using models
that build up separate estimates for
PD, EAD and LGD for every month that
a loan is due to be outstanding.
PD and LGD estimates are then
flexed under different scenarios to
capture the effects of changes to
the forward looking macroeconomic
variables (including interest rates,
unemployment, house prices and
inflation). The final ECL figure takes a
probability weighted average of these
different scenarios.
Loans are written off against this ECL
balance when there is no realistic
prospect of recovery. This is generally
after receipt of any proceeds from the
realisation of the collateral backing the
loan.
Other financial assets are considered
low credit risk at the reporting date as
they are investment grade instruments.
As a result, impairment is based on
12 month ECL as per stage 1 above.
If changes in an instruments’ rating
breaches the risk appetite then an
ECL assessment will take place on the
individual asset basis.
154 | Financial Statements 155
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
1. Statement of accounting policies (continued)
Material accounting policies (continued)
Financial instruments (continued)
Financial instruments acquired in
business combinations
Financial assets and liabilities
acquired in a business combination
are recognised at fair value upon
acquisition. To the extent that this
differs from the underlying amortised
cost carrying value assumed on
the transaction date, a fair value
adjustment is recognised on the
balance sheet.
This balance is then amortised
through the income statement over
the expected life of the acquired
portfolio in a manner that reflects
the consumption of the economic
benefits arising from the underlying
assets and liabilities. To the extent that
the fair value adjustment relates to
estimated credit losses on a portfolio
of mortgage assets, the
fair value credit
adjustment
is included in the overall
ECL balance.
The Group continues to run off
balances in relation to the Chelsea
Building Society and Norwich &
Peterborough acquisitions. In addition
to the
fair value credit adjustments
, it
also includes
interest rate fair value
adjustments
in the
loans and advances
to customers
and
shares
balances.
Hedging
As discussed, IFRS 9
Financial
Instruments
included a transitional
relief allowing the continued use of
the hedge accounting requirements
of IAS 39
Financial Instruments:
Recognition and Measurement
, and the
Group continue to adopt this approach.
The Group applies hedge accounting
when the specific rules and conditions
in IAS 39 are fulfilled. The Group
has designated the majority of its
derivatives as either fair value or
cash flow hedges in order to reduce
volatility in the income statement.
Fair value hedges
Where a derivative financial
instrument meets the requirements of
a fair value hedge, changes in the fair
value of the hedged item are taken to
the income statement offsetting the
effect of the related movements in the
fair value of the derivative.
Where the hedge no longer meets
the criteria, the adjustment to the
hedged item is released to the income
statement over the remaining life of
the original hedged relationship.
Cash flow hedges
Where a derivative financial instrument
is designated as a cash flow hedge,
the effective part of any gain or loss
on the derivative financial instrument
is recognised directly in other
comprehensive income and recycled to
the income statement. Any ineffective
portion of the gain or loss on the
hedging instrument is recognised in
the income statement immediately. If
a cash flow hedge is terminated, the
cumulative unrealised gain or loss
recognised in equity is then amortised
to profit and loss over the remaining
life of hedging instrument provided the
cash flows on hedged items are still
expected to occur.
Segmental reporting
The Executive Committee (EXCO) is
responsible for allocating resources
and assessing the performance of the
Group and is therefore identified as
the chief operating decision maker.
The Group has one reportable segment
that EXCO reviews performance and
makes decisions on for the Group as
a whole. As a result, no segmental
disclosure is provided.
Intangible assets
Intangible assets held by the Group
consist primarily of externally
acquired and internally developed
computer software. This is measured
at cost less accumulated amortisation
and impairment.
Costs incurred in the development of
computer software for internal use are
capitalised as intangible assets where
the expenditure leads to the creation
of an identifiable non‑monetary asset
and it is probable that the expected
future economic benefits that are
attributable to the asset will flow to
the Group.
Purchased software is classified
as an intangible asset where it is
not an integral part of the related
hardware. Computer software costs
are amortised using the straight line
method over their estimated useful
lives, which are generally three to five
years.
Intangible assets are reviewed for
impairment at each reporting date
or at any point in time where there
is an indication of impairment.
Impairment is assessed by estimating
the recoverable amount of the asset,
being the higher of: fair value less
costs of disposal; and value in use.
In assessing value in use, the
estimated future cash flows are
discounted to their present value. If
the recoverable amount of the asset is
estimated to be less than its carrying
amount, the carrying amount of the
asset is reduced to its recoverable
amount. Any impairment in the
value of these assets is recognised
immediately in the income statement.
Investment property
Investment property comprise
freehold properties, and parts of
freehold properties, that are not used
in the business and held for rental
income or capital appreciation. These
properties are generally flats and
offices ancillary to branch premises.
Investment properties are held at cost
less accumulated depreciation and
impairment.
Property, plant and equipment
Freehold properties used in the
business, major alterations to office
premises, fixtures and fittings,
equipment and other tangible
fixed assets are stated at cost less
accumulated depreciation and
impairment. Costs incurred after the
initial purchase of fixed assets are
expensed unless it directly results in
increased future economic benefits that
can be reliably measured. Repairs and
maintenance are treated as an expense.
Depreciation is a measure that
recognises the cost, less estimated
residual value, over the estimated
useful economic lives as follows:
•
Freehold/long leasehold buildings
(including investment properties) –
50 years
•
Short leasehold property and
right‑of‑use property assets – Life
of lease
•
Equipment, fixtures, fittings and
vehicles – 3 to 20 years
•
Freehold land is stated at cost less
accumulated impairment losses
and is not depreciated.
Property, plant and equipment and
investment properties are reviewed
for impairment annually and where
there is an indication that events or
circumstances may mean that the
carrying amount is not recoverable.
Where the recoverable amount of the
asset is estimated to be less than the
carrying amount, the carrying amount
is written down immediately to the
recoverable amount. Any impairment in
the value of assets is recognised in the
income statement as it arises.
Leases
Contracts are accounted for as leases
when the terms of the contract
transfer substantially all the risks and
rewards of ownership to the lessee.
For such arrangements a ‘right‑of‑use’
asset, included in property, plant and
equipment, and a corresponding lease
liability, included in other liabilities,
are recorded on the balance sheet
upon initial recognition.
The right‑of‑use asset is measured
at the lower of its fair value and the
present value of the minimum lease
payments at inception of the lease,
less accumulated depreciation and
impairment. The lease liability is
measured at the present value of the
minimum lease payments.
Depreciation is recorded by the
Group to write off the cost over the
estimated useful economic life of the
asset. Rent payable on finance leases
is apportioned between the finance
element, charged to the income
statement, and the reduction of the
lease obligation so as to achieve
a constant rate of interest on the
remaining balance of the liability.
Leases with a short life, or relating
to low value assets, are expensed to
the income statement on a straight
line basis over the period of the lease
agreement.
Retirement benefit obligations
The asset or liability is recognised in
respect of the Group’s defined benefit
pension scheme measured at the
present value of the defined benefit
obligation at the reporting date, less the
fair value of the plan assets, together
with adjustments for unrecognised past
service costs.
An asset is only recognised to the extent
that it is recoverable by the Group via
available refunds and reductions in
future contributions to the scheme.
The defined benefit obligation is
calculated annually by independent
actuaries using the projected unit credit
method. Gains or losses arising from
changes in assumptions are recognised
in other comprehensive income in the
period in which they occur.
Defined benefit obligations are
discounted to present value using the
rate of return available on high quality
corporate bonds of an equivalent term
to the obligations.
Past service costs are recognised
immediately in the income statement
to the extent that benefits are already
vested and otherwise are amortised on
a straight line basis over the average
period until the benefits become vested.
156 | Financial Statements 157
1. Statement of accounting policies (continued)
Material accounting policies (continued)
Taxation including deferred tax
Tax comprises current tax and deferred
tax. Tax is recognised in the income
statement except to the extent
that it relates to items recognised
directly in equity, in which case the
tax is recognised in the statement of
comprehensive income.
Current tax is the expected tax
payable on the taxable profits for
the year, using tax rates enacted or
substantively enacted at the reporting
date, and any adjustment to tax
payable in respect of previous years.
Deferred tax is recognised for
temporary differences arising between
the carrying amount of certain assets
and liabilities for accounting purposes
and for taxation purposes. Deferred tax
is provided using tax rates enacted or
substantively enacted at the reporting
date effective on the date at which
they are expected to reverse.
The following temporary differences
are not provided for:
•
The initial recognition of assets
or liabilities that affect neither
accounting nor taxable profit.
•
Differences relating to investments
in subsidiaries, to the extent that
the parent is able to control the
reversal of temporary differences,
and it is probable they will not
reverse in the foreseeable future.
Deferred tax assets are recognised
to the extent that it is probable that
future taxable profits will be available,
against which a temporary difference
can be utilised. The carrying amount
of the deferred tax asset is reviewed
at the reporting date and reduced to
the extent that it is no longer probable
that sufficient taxable profits will be
available to allow all or part of the
asset to be recovered.
Provisions
Provisions are recognised when: the
Group has a present obligation (legal
or constructive) as a result of a past
event; it is probable that the Group will
be required to settle that obligation;
and a reliable estimate can be made of
the amount of the obligation.
The amount recognised as a provision
is the best estimate of the net present
value of the consideration required
to settle the obligation, taking into
account the risks and uncertainties
surrounding the obligation.
A restructuring provision is recognised
when the Group has developed
a detailed formal plan for the
restructuring and raised a valid
expectation that it will carry out the
restructuring through announcing the
main features of the plan to those
affected by it.
Capital management
As at the 31 December 2023,
and throughout the year, the
Group complied with the capital
requirements that were in force.
Information on the Group’s capital
management can be found in the
Capital risk section of the Risk
Management Report.
Foreign currency
Assets and liabilities denominated in
foreign currencies are translated into
Sterling at the appropriate rates of
exchange prevailing at the reporting
date and exchange differences are
recognised in the income statement. All
income and expense is translated into
Sterling at the rate of exchange on the
day of receipt or payment.
Statements of cash flows
For the purposes of the statements of
cash flows, cash and cash equivalents
comprise cash and liquid financial
instruments maturing within 3 months.
The statement of cash flows has been
prepared using the indirect method.
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
2. Critical accounting judgements and key sources of estimation uncertainty
In applying its accounting policies, the
Group makes judgements that have
a significant impact on the amounts
recognised in the financial statements.
In addition, estimates and assumptions
are used that could affect the reported
amounts of assets and liabilities. The
estimates and underlying assumptions
are reviewed on an ongoing basis. As
explained in the
Audit Committee
Report
in the
Governance
section, the
Audit Committee has considered the
accounting judgements and estimates
applied in the financial statements.
The Audit Committee have confirmed
to the Board that they consider these
to be appropriate.
The key assumptions concerning
the future, and other key sources of
estimation uncertainty at the reporting
date that may have a significant risk
of causing a material adjustment to
the carrying amount of assets and
liabilities within the next financial year,
are discussed below.
Retirement benefit obligations
The Group’s accounting policy
states that a net defined benefit
pension scheme asset should only be
recognised to the extent that the Group
has the ability to access the pension
scheme surplus in the form of a refund
or reduction in future contributions.
The scheme trustees could act
unilaterally in order to restrict the
ability of the Group to seek a refund
or reduce future contributions, hence
a judgement on the likelihood of
this event is required. The Group has
received a legal opinion supporting
the judgement that any surplus of
the scheme can be recovered in full
and that pension scheme trustees are
unable to act to amend the scheme
rules, and ultimately prevent the
Society accessing the surplus, without
the Society’s support.
In addition, significant estimation
uncertainty in respect of areas such
as future interest rates and mortality
rates have to be applied in estimating
the value of the assets and liabilities of
the defined benefit scheme. These are
outlined in note 17.
The impact of a 0.5% increase in the
rate used to discount future liabilities
from 4.5% to 5.0% would result in
a decrease of liability of 7% (2022:
decrease of 7%). The impact of a 0.5%
increase in inflation would increase
liabilities by 4% (2022: increase of
4%). The impact of a one‑year increase
in life expectancy at age 60 would
be to increase liabilities by around
3% (2022: increase of 3%). Note that
these sensitivities have been modelled
independently as single variable
adjustments and have not anticipated
any correlation between movements
in the inputs. A summary of the impact
of these sensitivities on the scheme
liabilities is included in note 17.
Impairment of loans and
advances to customers
The impairment calculation of
expected credit losses (ECL) for
a portfolio of mortgage loans
is inherently uncertain. ECL are
calculated using historical default and
loss experience but require judgement
to be applied in predicting future
economic conditions (e.g. interest
rates and house prices) and customer
behaviour (e.g. default rates). The
most critical judgements that lead to
estimation uncertainty are as follows:
Economic scenarios and
weightings
A forum, supported by Finance, Credit
Risk, Balance Sheet Management
and economic experts considers the
forward‑looking macroeconomic
assumptions with the objective
of developing internally coherent
economic scenarios to propose
to the Group Asset and Liability
Committee (ALCO) for challenge and
approval. ALCO ensures that the ECL
meets the requirement for unbiased
and weighted amounts derived
by evaluating a range of possible
outcomes and assumptions, or
economic scenarios.
Judgements are made in arriving at
the level of each economic variable,
such as house price index (HPI)
and unemployment, applied in
each economic scenario to support
the estimate of ECL. ALCO applies
judgements to arrive at these
assumptions.
The UK Economy technically entered
recession at the end of 2023,
attributed to the ongoing cost of
living crisis and higher interest rate
environment. Growth will likely remain
weak by historical standards in the
medium term and there remains more
downside risk than upside. Headline
inflation continues to fall, although
there are re‑emerging risks around the
price of energy following the recent
geopolitical tensions. Core inflation,
services inflation and wage inflation
continue to provide headwind to the
inflation target being met consistently
throughout 2024.
Management evaluated these
uncertainties, with the economic
assumptions applied to the ECL
model adjusted to reflect any material
changes in view of the macro‑
economic environment. A post model
adjustment was raised in 2022 and
has been updated to reflect the risks
relating to affordability and the impact
of cost‑of‑living increases on our
mortgage customers (see note 31 for
more details).
The provision is calculated by applying
a range of economic scenarios that are
weighted.
The Group continue to apply four
economic scenarios, with a higher
weighting attributed to the downturn
and severe downturn scenarios
than in 2022, reflecting the ongoing
uncertainty around the health of
the UK economy. SME judgement is
applied in determining the relative
weighting of each economic scenario
in the ECL estimate, informed both by
an assessment of external data and
statistical model results.
The Group considered alternative sets
of weightings. The most severe shifted
a further 5% from core and downside
to severe downturn resulting in a
£4.1 million increase in ECL. The least
severe shifted 10% from downside
and severe downturn to core resulting
in a £7.9 million decrease in ECL.
These changes in weightings have
been fully modelled and been allowed
to impact staging but impact on post
model adjustments (PMA) has been
excluded.
158 | Financial Statements 159
3. Interest revenue
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Calculated using the effective interest rate method:
Loans secured on residential property
1,366.2
1,027.3
346.7
272.0
Loans secured on connected undertakings
–
–
1,349.0
554.8*
Other loans
44.7
26.7
44.7
26.7
Other interest income/(expense)**
(61.5)
(15.5)
(61.5)
(15.5)
Liquid assets
364.0
93.0
352.6
91.0
Debt securities
241.2
71.1
873.5
285.7
Interest revenue calculated using the effective interest rate method
1,954.6
1,202.6
2,905.0
1,214.7
Other:
Derivatives in hedge relationships
926.4
212.2
926.4
212.2
Derivatives not included in hedge relationships
82.7
20.4
82.5
20.2*
Investments held at fair value
2.6
1.8
2.6
1.8
Other interest revenue
1,011.7
234.4
1,011.5
234.2
Total interest revenue
2,966.3
1,437.0
3,916.5
1,448.9
4. Interest expense
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Shares held by individuals
1,509.6
442.7
1,509.6
442.7
Deposits from banks
126.8
76.1
126.8
76.1
Deposits from connected undertakings
–
–
1,182.1
231.4
Other deposits
24.2
9.3
24.2
9.3
Debt securities in issue
164.6
75.5
186.8
81.3
Subordinated liabilities
51.5
33.7
51.5
33.7
Other interest payable
0.2
0.1
0.2
0.1
Derivatives in hedge relationships
174.4
38.7
105.7
3.3
Derivatives not included in hedge relationships
128.4
36.1
121.1
113.6
Interest expense for leasing arrangements
0.6
0.7
0.6
0.7
Total interest expense
2,180.3
712.9
3,308.6
992.2
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
2. Critical accounting judgements and key sources of estimation uncertainty (continued)
Impairment of loans and advances to customers (continued)
Economic scenarios and weightings (continued)
In terms of sensitivity to changes in key economic variables within the model, the ECL model was run with a 100% weighting
applied to the Core scenario, in both Core and Non‑Core models. When the HPI forecast was replaced with the respective
forecasts from the Downturn and Severe Downturn scenarios ECL, excluding PMAs, increased by £5.3 million and £28.4
million (2022: £11.1 million and £15.9 million). Below is the percentage change in HPI forecast for both downturn scenarios
for the next 5 years in relation to the Core scenario. The downturn scenario in 2023 replaced the stagflation downturn
scenario applied in 2022.
Scenario (% change)
HPI
Downturn
(3.5)
(6.0)
(0.5)
(3.0)
(2.8)
Severe Downturn
(8.0)
(14.5)
(9.0)
(4.5)
(3.5)
Scenario (% change)
HPI
Stagflation Downturn
(6.7)
(3.0)
(1.3)
(0.5)
(0.3)
Severe Downturn
(7.5)
(9.8)
(8.1)
(2.0)
(1.5)
The key in‑year impact of changes to economic variables came from applying quarterly Office of National Statistics (ONS) HPI
updates, which accounted for £0.7 million of impairment charge over 2023 (2022: £12.5 million release).
Post model adjustments
The determination, application and calculation of PMAs also requires judgement to be applied. Further detail on economic
assumptions, weightings and PMAs can be found in note 31.
Core model assumptions
Significant increase in credit risk
A judgement is applied to determine the threshold at which a significant relative increase in credit risk is deemed to have
occurred. If 10% of the accounts in stage 1, on a proportional basis, were to be transferred to stage 2 and subject to a
calculation of full lifetime expected credit losses, this would result in a £2.2 million (2022: £1.9 million) increase in ECL. This
change in staging has not been allowed to impact PMAs.
Acquired interest-only mortgages
A judgement has been applied in determining which probability of default assumptions to apply to different cohorts of
customers for acquired interest‑only mortgages.
The existence of an appropriate repayment vehicle has only been substantiated for 26% (2022: 27%) of these customers and
so there is a risk that the full amount due at maturity (average maturity being 2028) will not be collected. A model is applied
to estimate the probability that accounts will reach the end of the term without being recovered, with the average probability
across these accounts being 8.1% (2022: 9.2%). This results in an ECL of £7.9 million (2022: £8.2 million).
Two alternative probability of default (PD) estimates are applied, one for those customers that we are unable to contact, and
another for those that have confirmed there is no appropriate repayment vehicle in place. If the ‘no vehicle’ PD is applied to
the ‘unable to contact’ customers, expected credit losses increase by £3.8 million (2022: £5.1 million).
* Please refer to Reclassification within Interest Revenue (Society only) in Note 1 for details of the reclassification made between these lines.
** Includes net interest income on clearing collateral agreements.
160 | Financial Statements 161
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
5. Net (losses)/gains from financial instruments held at fair value
Group
Society
£m
£m
£m
£m
Equity investments held at fair value
0.5
1.4
0.5
1.4
Hedge accounting ineffectiveness
(29.1)
(32.4)
(29.0)
(44.3)
Derivatives and debt securities not included in hedge relationships
23.1
106.6
18.8
110.7
Net (losses)/gains from financial instruments held at fair value
(5.5)
75.6
(9.7)
67.8
Derivatives and hedging
The Society enters into interest rate swaps to hedge their exposure to interest rate risk. All interest rate swaps are transacted
for economic hedging purposes, however not all are designated into accounting hedges. Those interest rate swaps not
designated into accounting hedges are recorded at fair value through profit and loss within derivatives and debt securities
not included in hedge relationships. This portfolio consists of interest rate swaps that receive fixed cash flows (receive fix) and
that pay fixed cash flows (pay fix).
2022 saw a significant increase in swap rates which in turn had a significant impact on the fair value of the interest rate swaps
not designated in the accounting hedge. In 2023, whilst swaps rates remained volatile, the movement across the year has
been much less significant with rates decreasing overall. The volume of receive fix swaps has grown considerably driven by an
increase in retail deposits, along with the volatile rate environment, this has generated an overall fair value gain in the year.
Hedge accounting ineffectiveness includes the ineffective portion of the accounting hedges and amortisation adjustments
relating to the inception and de‑designation of these hedges.
Investments held at fair value include the fair value gains and losses on equity shares investment.
6. Administrative expenses
Group
Society
£m
£m
£m
£m
Staff costs:
Salaries and wages
138.2
125.4
138.2
125.4
Social security costs
14.2
13.4
14.2
13.4
Pension costs – defined benefit plans
1.1
0.3
1.1
0.3
Pension costs – defined contribution plans
11.4
10.4
11.4
10.4
Contractor staff costs
30.4
26.9
30.4
26.9
Other staff costs
1.6
1.5
1.6
1.5
Professional consultancy costs
6.1
12.3
6.1
12.3
Regulatory fees
6.2
6.0
6.2
6.0
Premises costs
15.6
14.3
15.6
14.3
IT costs
47.8
33.4
47.8
33.4
Marketing
15.5
14.8
15.5
14.8
Other expenses
24.2
18.2
24.0
18.0
Total administrative expenses
312.3
276.9
312.1
276.7
The Society operates a salary sacrifice scheme whereby employees can opt to make pension contributions from their pre‑tax
salaries. The amount shown in the table above under salaries and wages includes the headline salary (i.e. before the salary
sacrifice deduction) and pension costs exclude the additional contributions made by the Society on employees’ behalf as a
result of the salary sacrifice scheme.
Full details of directors’ remuneration, including the number of directors, the total remuneration of directors, including that of
the highest paid director, bonuses and pensions are given in the
Directors’ Remuneration Report
within the
Governance
section.
Staff numbers
The average number of persons employed by the Group and Society during the year (including executive directors) was as
follows:
Full time
Part time
Full time
Part time
Central administration
2,145
428
1,969
425
Branches
383
344
357
366
Total staff numbers
2,528
772
2,326
791
Remuneration of the auditors
Group
Society
2022
2022
£000
£000
Audit fees for the Group and Society statutory audit
783.5
734.5
783.5
734.5
Audit fee for the statutory audit of controlled entities*
449.5
375.5
–
–
Audit related assurance services required by law or regulation
129.5
131.0
129.5
131.0
Total audit and audit related assurance services
1,362.5
1,241.0
913.0
865.5
Other permitted non‑audit services
232.5
257.6
232.5
215.1
Total remuneration of the auditors
1,595.0
1,498.6
1,145.5
1,080.6
The above figures, relating to auditor’s remuneration, exclude value added tax. Details of the Society’s policy on non‑audit
work is given in the
Audit Committee Report
.
The classifications of audit related assurance services required by law or regulation and other permitted non‑audit services
reflect the terminology included in updated guidance issued by the UK Financial Reporting Council.
Other permitted non‑audit services primarily consist of the half‑year review and profit verification as well as assurance work
in respect of our debt issuances.
7. Impairment charge/(release) of financial assets
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Impairment charge on loans and advances to customers
4.5
7.0
0.2
0.1
Recoveries relating to loans and advances previously written off
(0.8)
(0.9)
(0.5)
(0.6)
Impairment charge/(release) of other financial assets
0.3
(0.1)
0.3
(0.1)
Impairment charge/(release) on financial assets
4.0
6.0
–
(0.6)
* Includes £12k, related to the prior year audit of Norwich and Peterborough Insurance Brokers Limited.
162 | Financial Statements 163
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
8. Investments
Income from investments
Group
Society
£m
£m
£m
£m
Dividend income from subsidiaries
–
–
50.0
100.0
Dividend income from equity investments
–
0.1
–
0.1
Income from investments
–
0.1
50.0
100.1
During 2023, the Society received dividends from Accord Mortgages Limited of £50.0 million (2022: £100.0 million).
Investments
Group
Society
£m
£m
£m
£m
Equities
3.3
2.8
3.3
2.8
Equity in controlled entities
–
–
104.9
104.9
Loans with controlled entities
–
–
37,354.4
35,632.1
Total investments
3.3
2.8
37,462.6
35,739.8
All loans with controlled entities are charged interest with amounts recognised in interest revenue.
Investment in equities
The Group holds equity investments in a banking and credit card service provider due to our historic participation in their card
servicing operations. A tranche of these equity shares was sold for £4.1 million in December 2022, there has been no sale of
equity shares in 2023. The investments are held at fair value through profit or loss and the valuation technique is detailed in
note 32.
Subsidiaries
The Society holds 100% of the ordinary equity share capital for each of the following subsidiary entities, all of which are
audited and consolidated.
Subsidiary Principal activity
Accord Mortgages Limited .................................................................................................................................................................................................................. Mortgage lending
Norwich and Peterborough Insurance Brokers Limited ................................................................................................................................................................... Non‑trading
Norwich and Peterborough (LBS) Limited ....................................................................................................................................................................................Mortgage finance
The Group has taken advantage of the audit exemptions available for small and dormant subsidiaries under sections 479 and
480 of the
Companies Act 2006
for the following subsidiary entities, all of which are consolidated:
•
BCS Loans & Mortgages Limited
•
Chelsea Mortgage Services Limited
•
YBS Limited
•
Yorkshire Direct Limited
•
YBS Group Limited
•
YBS Pension Trustees Limited
•
Yorkshire Group Limited
•
Yorkshire Insurance Services Limited
•
Yorkshire Life Assurance Services Limited
•
Yorkshire Mortgage Services Limited
•
Yorkshire Personal Financial Services Limited
•
Yorkshire Property Services Limited
•
Yorkshire Services Limited
•
Yorkshire Key Services Limited
All subsidiaries have a 31 December accounting period end, are registered in England and have their registered office as
Yorkshire Drive, Bradford, BD5 8LJ.
Other controlled entities
The following entities are deemed to be controlled as, whilst the Group does not have a controlling equity shareholding, it has
the right to variable returns from its involvement in the entity. The Society’s interests in these entities are, in substance, no
different than if they were wholly‑owned subsidiary undertakings and, as a result, they are consolidated into the Group. The
carrying value of the equity holdings in these entities in the Society is £nil (2022: £nil).
•
Brass No.6 PLC*
•
Brass No.6 Mortgage Holdings Limited*
•
Brass No.7 PLC*
•
Brass No.7 Mortgage Holdings Limited*
•
Brass No.8 PLC
•
Brass No.8 Mortgage Holdings Limited
•
Brass No.9 PLC
•
Brass No.9 Mortgage Holdings Limited
•
Brass No.10 PLC
•
Brass No.10 Mortgage Holdings Limited
•
Brass No.11 PLC
•
Brass No.11 Mortgage Holdings Limited
•
Tombac No.2 PLC*
•
Tombac No.2 Mortgage Holdings Limited*
•
Tombac No.3 PLC
•
Tombac No.3 Mortgage Holdings Limited
•
Yorkshire Building Society Covered Bonds LLP
•
YBS Covered Bonds Finance (Holdings) Limited
•
YBS Covered Bonds Finance Limited
All these entities are subject to audit and have a 31 December year end, apart from those entities currently in liquidation.
Their registered office is Third Floor, 1 King’s Arms Yard, London, EC2R 7AF, with the exceptions of
Yorkshire Building Society
Covered Bonds LLP
whose registered address is Yorkshire Drive, Bradford, BD5 8LJ.
Joint ventures
The Society has a 22.2% joint venture investment in Arkose Funding Limited. The carrying value of the investment at
31 December 2023 is £nil (2022: £nil).
* in liquidation
164 | Financial Statements 165
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
9. Tax expense
Group
Society
£m
£m
£m
£m
Corporation tax – current year charge
95.9
120.9
78.0
88.4
Corporation tax – adjustment in respect of prior periods
0.6
1.3
0.6
1.4
Total current tax
96.5
122.2
78.6
89.8
Deferred tax – current year
22.5
0.9
22.8
1.2
Deferred tax – adjustment in respect of prior periods
(0.6)
(1.1)
(0.6)
(1.1)
Deferred tax – impact of rate change
0.2
1.2
0.2
1.2
Total tax expense in the income statement
118.6
123.2
101.0
91.1
On 1 April 2023 the UK corporation tax rate increased from 19% to 25%, giving an average corporation tax rate for the year
of 23.5% (2022: 19.0%). The Group has an effective tax rate of 26.3% (2022: 24.5%), which is higher than the average UK
statutory corporation tax rate of 23.5% for the year. This is mainly due to the effects of the banking surcharge on the taxable
profits of the Society. A full breakdown of the difference is provided below:
Group
Society
£m
£m
£m
£m
Profit before tax
450.3
502.5
417.4
421.3
Tax calculated at a tax rate of 23.5% (2022: 19%)
105.8
95.5
98.1
80.1
Effects of:
Income not subject to tax
(0.3)
(0.3)
(12.1)
(19.3)
Fair value movements on securitisation
(1.0)
0.8
–
–
Expenses not deductible for tax purposes
0.9
0.8
1.9
3.8
Banking surcharge
13.1
25.1
13.1
25.1
Adjustment to tax charge in respect of prior periods
–
0.2
–
0.3
Recognition and utilisation of capital losses
–
(0.1)
–
(0.1)
Change in tax rate
0.1
1.2
–
1.2
Total tax expense in income statement
118.6
123.2
101.0
91.1
Tax (credit)/expense recognised directly in equity:
Tax on financial instruments held at fair value through other comprehensive
income
(4.7)
(7.8)
(4.7)
(7.8)
Change in tax rate on financial instruments held at fair value through other
comprehensive income
–
(1.9)
–
(1.9)
Tax on remeasurement of net retirement benefit obligations
(3.1)
(21.6)
(3.1)
(21.6)
Change in tax rate on net retirement benefit obligations
–
(6.9)
–
(6.9)
Deferred tax on cash flow hedges
(3.7)
(0.5)
(3.7)
(0.5)
Change in tax rate on cash flow hedges
–
(0.8)
–
(0.8)
Total tax recognised directly in equity
(11.5)
(39.5)
(11.5)
(39.5)
On 1 April 2023 the UK corporation tax rate increased from 19% to 25%. This measure was substantively enacted on 24 May
2021 and deferred tax assets and liabilities at 31 December 2023 and at 31 December 2022 have been calculated based on
the 25% rate.
On 1 April 2023 the banking surcharge decreased from 8% (on taxable profits in excess of £25 million) to 3% (on taxable
profits in excess of £100 million). This change was substantively enacted on 2 February 2022. Deferred tax assets and
liabilities at 31 December 2023 and at 31 December 2022 have been calculated based on the 3% rate.
On 11 July 2023, the government enacted legislation to implement the G20‑OECD Inclusive Framework Pillar Two rules in the
UK. The intention of the legislation is to ensure that UK‑headquartered multinational enterprises pay a minimum tax rate of
15% on UK and overseas profits arising after 31 December 2023. The rules include a Qualified Domestic Minimum Top‑Up
Tax, which aims to ensure that large UK groups pay a minimum tax rate of 15% on their UK profits.
The Group’s operations are entirely based in the UK and are subject to UK corporation tax. The Group has carried out an
assessment of Pillar Two impact during the year, and based on this assessment, the Group is not currently expecting to be
materially impacted by Pillar Two rules. Work to further assess the Group’s exposure to the Pillar Two legislation will continue
during 2024, and full Pillar Two calculations will be carried out in 2024, which is when the legislation becomes effective.
Pillar Two legislation applies to profits arising after 31 December 2023. The tax expense arising from Pillar Two is £nil for the
years ended 31 December 2023 and 31 December 2022.
The IAS 12 exceptions from recognising and disclosing information about deferred tax assets and liabilities related to Pillar
Two income taxes have been applied.
10. Cash and balances with the Bank of England
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Cash in hand
9.9
10.6
9.9
10.6
Unencumbered deposits with the Bank of England
4,652.7
5,805.0
4,652.7
5,805.0
Cash in hand and unencumbered deposits
4,662.6
5,815.6
4,662.6
5,815.6
Cash ratio deposit with the Bank of England
176.5
167.2
176.5
167.2
Cash and balances with the Bank of England
4,839.1
5,982.8
4,839.1
5,982.8
Cash ratio deposits are mandatory requirements of the Bank of England. They are considered to be encumbered assets and
are non‑interest‑bearing.
11. Debt securities
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Debt securities issued by:
UK public bodies
852.4
582.4
852.4
582.4
Other public bodies
958.9
965.6
958.9
965.6
Other
5,750.6
4,136.8
5,750.6
4,136.8
Group companies
–
–
11,792.4
13,548.2
Total debt securities
7,561.9
5,684.8
19,354.3
19,233.0
Debt securities issued by Group companies comprise retained investments in the Group’s securitisation vehicles.
166 | Financial Statements 167
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
11. Debt securities (continued)
Group
Held at fair
Fair value Amortised Total
value through through Other cost
profit and loss Comprehensive
Income
£m
£m
£m
£m
Movements in debt securities during the year were:
At 1 January 2023
25.5
4,292.7
1,366.6
5,684.8
Additions
–
1,545.0
1,867.9
3,412.9
Disposals and repayments
–
(725.0)
(918.2)
(1,643.2)
Exchange translation
–
(25.9)
(21.2)
(47.1)
Other changes in value
1.8
108.9
43.8
154.5
At 31 December 2023
27.3
5,195.7
2,338.9
7,561.9
Movements in debt securities during the year were:
At 1 January 2022
28.6
3,255.4
791.5
4,075.5
Additions
–
2,097.6
854.6
2,952.2
Disposals and repayments
–
(734.1)
(261.4)
(995.5)
Exchange translation
–
11.6
10.2
21.8
Other changes in value
(3.1)
(337.8)
(28.3)
(369.2)
At 31 December 2022
25.5
4,292.7
1,366.6
5,684.8
Society
Held at fair
Fair value Amortised Total
value through through Other cost
profit and loss Comprehensive
Income
£m
£m
£m
£m
Movements in debt securities during the year were:
At 1 January 2023
25.5
4,292.7
14,914.8
19,233.0
Additions
–
1,545.0
1,867.9
3,412.9
Disposals and repayments
–
(725.0)
(2,693.6)
(3,418.6)
Exchange translation
–
(25.9)
(21.5)
(47.4)
Other changes in value
1.8
108.9
63.7
174.4
At 31 December 2023
27.3
5,195.7
14,131.3
19,354.3
Movements in debt securities during the year were:
At 1 January 2022
28.6
3,255.4
11,656.5
14,940.5
Additions
–
2,097.6
6,690.0
8,787.6
Disposals and repayments
–
(734.1)
(3,461.0)
(4,195.1)
Exchange translation
–
11.6
11.7
23.3
Other changes in value
(3.1)
(337.8)
17.6
(323.3)
At 31 December 2022
25.5
4,292.7
14,914.8
19,233.0
12. Loans and advances to customers
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Loans secured on residential property:
Loans fully secured on residential property
45,126.4
43,793.6
9,208.5
9,810.7
Other loans secured on residential property
6.1
7.2
–
–
Loans secured on commercial property
1,743.4
1,461.3
1,742.8
1,461.3
Gross loans and advances to customers
46,875.9
45,262.1
10,951.3
11,272.0
Impairment
(37.7)
(33.1)
(8.4)
(7.8)
Fair value credit adjustment
(22.3)
(25.3)
(22.3)
(25.3)
Expected credit losses (ECL)
(60.0)
(58.4)
(30.7)
(33.1)
Total loans and advances to customers
46,815.9
45,203.7
10,920.6
11,238.9
The following tables analyse the changes in ECL impairment and fair value credit adjustments.
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Opening impairment
33.1
26.1
7.8
7.3
Amounts written off in the period
(1.3)
(1.0)
(0.6)
(0.3)
Discounting recognised in net interest income
1.4
1.0
1.0
0.7
Charge for the year recognised in the income statement
4.5
7.0
0.2
0.1
Impairment
37.7
33.1
8.4
7.8
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Opening fair value credit adjustment
25.3
28.4
25.3
28.4
Release recognised in the income statement through net interest
(2.3)
(2.4)
(2.3)
(2.4)
Write‑offs
(0.7)
(0.7)
(0.7)
(0.7)
Fair value credit adjustment
22.3
25.3
22.3
25.3
168 | Financial Statements 169
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
13. Intangible assets
Group and Society
Development
Software
Internally
Other
Total
costs generated
assets
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
Cost:
At 1 January 2023
4.1
59.8
13.6
7.1
84.6
Additions
(4.1)
10.5
–
–
6.4
Disposals
–
(2.7)
(1.0)
–
(3.7)
Transfers
–
–
–
–
–
At 31 December 2023
–
67.6
12.6
7.1
87.3
Amortisation:
At 1 January 2023
–
44.0
13.3
7.1
64.4
Charged in year
–
8.2
0.2
–
8.4
Disposals
–
(2.8)
(1.0)
–
(3.8)
At 31 December 2023
–
49.4
12.5
7.1
69.0
Net book value at 31 December 2023
–
18.2
0.1
–
18.3
Cost:
At 1 January 2022
0.4
61.9
15.1
7.1
84.5
Additions
3.7
1.8
–
–
5.5
Disposals
–
(3.9)
(1.5)
–
(5.4)
Transfers
–
–
–
–
–
At 31 December 2022
4.1
59.8
13.6
7.1
84.6
Amortisation:
At 1 January 2022
–
39.5
14.4
7.1
61.0
Charged in year
–
8.3
0.3
–
8.6
Disposals
–
(3.8)
(1.4)
–
(5.2)
At 31 December 2022
–
44.0
13.3
7.1
64.4
Net book value at 31 December 2022
4.1
15.8
0.3
–
20.2
Other intangible assets primarily comprise the fair value of items acquired on mergers (retail savings and brands) and an
amount paid for the transfer of a number of employee sharesave schemes to the Society. Transfers relate to the reclassification
of assets from development costs to software and internally generated assets.
14. Investment property
Group and Society
£m
£m
Cost:
At 1 January
22.0
19.7
Additions
0.3
0.5
Disposals
(0.6)
(0.6)
Transfers from Property, Plant and Equipment
–
2.4
At 31 December
21.7
22.0
Depreciation:
At 1 January
6.0
5.2
Charged in year
0.4
0.2
Disposals
(0.4)
(0.1)
Transfers from Property, Plant and Equipment
–
0.7
At 31 December
6.0
6.0
Net book value at 31 December
15.7
16.0
Fair value
12.2
13.6
Investment properties are generally flats and offices ancillary to branch premises and not used by the Group. Rental income of
£1.1 million on investment properties has been included within other operating income (2022: £1.1 million).
Transfers relate to the reclassification of assets between investment properties and property, plant and equipment, usually
due to changes in occupancy.
The fair value of the Group’s investment properties at 31 December 2023 is based predominantly on external valuations.
170 | Financial Statements 171
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
15. Property, plant and equipment
Group and Society
Land and
Equipment, Right-of-use Right-of-use Total
buildings fixtures and property motor vehicles
fittings
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
Cost:
At 1 January 2023
101.0
67.3
24.5
1.3
194.1
Additions
4.5
3.8
1.4
0.1
9.8
Disposals
(3.6)
(11.9)
(3.3)
(0.1)
(18.9)
At 31 December 2023
101.9
59.2
22.6
1.3
185.0
Depreciation:
At 1 January 2023
34.5
49.1
8.4
1.0
93.0
Charged in year
3.4
5.0
2.7
0.2
11.3
Disposals
(4.0)
(11.9)
(3.1)
(0.1)
(19.1)
Impairment
0.3
–
–
–
0.3
At 31 December 2023
34.2
42.2
8.0
1.1
85.5
Net book value at 31 December 2023
67.7
17.0
14.6
0.2
99.5
Cost:
At 1 January 2022
102.5
68.4
42.2
1.2
214.3
Additions
3.2
3.6
1.9
0.1
8.8
Disposals
(0.9)
(4.7)
(1.2)
–
(6.8)
Lease modification
–
–
(18.4)
–
(18.4)
Assets transferred to held for sale
(1.4)
–
–
–
(1.4)
Transfers to investment property
(2.4)
–
–
–
(2.4)
At 31 December 2022
101.0
67.3
24.5
1.3
194.1
Depreciation:
At 1 January 2022
32.9
48.1
10.6
0.7
92.3
Charged in year
3.7
5.5
3.5
0.3
13.0
Disposals
(0.9)
(4.5)
(0.8)
–
(6.2)
Lease Modification
–
–
(4.9)
–
(4.9)
Assets transferred to held for sale
(0.5)
–
–
–
(0.5)
Transfers to investment property
(0.7)
–
–
–
(0.7)
At 31 December 2022
34.5
49.1
8.4
1.0
93.0
Net book value at 31 December 2022
66.5
18.2
16.1
0.3
101.1
16. Deferred tax
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
At 1 January
11.9
50.4
10.2
48.4
Income statement expense/(credit) – note 9
22.1
1.0
22.4
1.3
Tax (credit)/expense recognised directly in equity
(11.5)
(39.5)
(11.5)
(39.5)
At 31 December
22.5
11.9
21.1
10.2
Deferred tax assets and liabilities are attributable to the following items:
Deferred tax assets
Fair value movements on external swap on intercompany loan
–
(3.7)
–
(3.7)
Deferred remuneration
(3.6)
(2.3)
(3.6)
(2.3)
Transitional adjustment arising following implementation of IFRS 9
(0.7)
(0.9)
(0.7)
(0.9)
Transitional adjustment arising following change in accounting treatment
(0.4)
(0.5)
(0.4)
(0.5)
Pensions and other post‑retirement benefits
(2.3)
(2.1)
(2.3)
(2.1)
Financial instruments held at fair value through other comprehensive
income
(4.0)
–
(4.0)
–
Capital losses
(0.2)
(0.2)
(0.2)
(0.2)
Other temporary differences
(0.1)
(0.2)
(0.1)
(0.2)
Total deferred tax assets
(11.3)
(9.9)
(11.3)
(9.9)
Deferred tax liabilities
Pensions and other post‑retirement benefits
10.8
13.6
10.8
13.6
Capital allowances in excess of depreciation
1.2
0.9
1.2
0.9
Fair value movements on external swap on intercompany loan
19.2
–
19.2
–
Financial instruments held at fair value through profit and loss
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
Financial instruments held at fair value through other comprehensive
income
–
0.7
–
0.7
Cash flow hedging
0.1
3.9
0.1
3.9
Transitional adjustment arising following implementation of IFRS 9
1.1
1.3
–
–
Transitional adjustment arising following change in accounting treatment
0.3
0.3
–
–
Other temporary differences
0.7
0.7
0.7
0.6
Total deferred tax liabilities
33.8
21.8
32.4
20.1
Net deferred tax liabilities
22.5
11.9
21.1
10.2
172 | Financial Statements 173
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
16. Deferred tax (continued)
The deferred tax expense/(credit) in the income statement comprise the following temporary differences:
Group
Society
£m
£m
£m
£m
Pensions and other post‑retirement benefits
0.1
0.2
0.1
0.2
Capital allowances in excess of depreciation
0.3
–
0.3
–
Fair value movements on external swap on intercompany loan
22.9
0.8
22.9
0.8
Deferred remuneration
(1.4)
(0.6)
(1.4)
(0.6)
Financial instruments held at fair value through profit and loss
0.1
(0.5)
0.1
(0.5)
Transitional adjustment arising following implementation of IFRS 9
(0.1)
0.1
0.2
0.3
Transitional adjustment arising following change in accounting treatment
–
0.1
0.1
0.2
Capital losses
–
1.2
–
1.2
Other temporary differences
0.2
(0.3)
0.1
(0.3)
Total deferred tax expense/(credit) in the income statement
22.1
1.0
22.4
1.3
17. Retirement benefit obligations
The Group operates one main employee benefit scheme (the Scheme), the costs of which are borne by the Society, with both
defined benefit and defined contribution sections.
In addition, the Group operates unfunded defined benefit (DB) pension schemes for certain current and former members of
staff. The present value at 31 December 2023 of the defined benefit obligation in relation to these schemes was £8.1 million
(2022: £7.4 million) and the relevant disclosures have been separated from those of the main employee benefits scheme
where appropriate.
Net defined benefit asset
As at 31 December 2023 the defined benefit asset is £38.6 million, a decrease of £10.2 million from 31 December 2022.
Pensioner buy-in
In mid‑November 2018, the Scheme entered into a pensioner buy‑in with Pension Insurance Corporation (PIC). The premium
of c.£248 million was paid for out of the Scheme’s assets, with no additional funding required from the Society. The asset loss
from the buy‑in was approximately £25 million on an accounting basis. The transaction covered around £250 million of the
Scheme’s pensioner liabilities, based on the Technical Provisions basis. As such, some pensioners remain uninsured and not
covered by the buy‑in. At 31 December 2023, we have valued the YBS Scheme insurance contract with PIC to be equal to the
corresponding IAS 19 defined benefit obligation in respect of the insured members. The assessed value of £155.8 million was
calculated using a methodology consistent with the approach used to calculate the total pension benefit. Benefits paid over
2023 in respect of the buy‑in members totalled £9.4 million.
Defined contribution post-employment benefits
In addition to the defined benefit section (see below), the Group operates a defined contribution (DC) section of the main
scheme. This Scheme is used by the Society to fulfil its auto enrolment duties. In 2023, the total Society contribution into
the pension scheme in respect of DC benefits was c.£11.9 million (2022: c.£9.8 million). In addition to this YBS also paid
£1.0 million (2022: £0.9 million) into the pension scheme to cover the approximate cost of DC expenses, including the cost of
life assurance which is provided through the Scheme for all YBS colleagues.
Defined benefit post-employment benefits
The Group operates a funded defined benefit scheme for certain employees, providing benefits based on final salary. However,
benefits earned by members of the defined benefit section of the main scheme, with the exception of N&P Section members,
from 1 April 2010 are based on career average revalued earnings. N&P Section members’ benefits are based on their Final
Pensionable Salary (following the removal of the 31 March 2010 freeze). The defined benefit section was closed to new
employees in 2000 and to future accrual on 31 December 2015. The assets of the scheme are held in a separate trustee‑
administered fund. Contributions are assessed in accordance with the advice of an independent qualified actuary using the
projected unit method.
The defined benefit section of the Scheme has a weighted average maturity of around 14 years (2022: 15 years). This weighted
average duration of a pension scheme is the average discounted term until benefit payments are due, weighted by the size of
the payment. A breakdown of the scheme liabilities by members is included below.
Funded DB scheme
Unfunded DB scheme
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Deferred in service liability
36.5
64.2
–
–
Deferred liability
166.3
175.1
–
3.8
Pensioner liability
369.7
354.1
8.1
3.6
Total liabilities
572.5
593.4
8.1
7.4
GMP equalisation
On 26 October 2018, the High Court ruled that the Lloyds Bank schemes had to equalise pension scheme benefits between
males and females for the effects of Guaranteed Minimum Pension (GMP) and identified acceptable methods as to how this
can be achieved. The benefits provided under the Scheme are uncertain to the extent that the impact of GMP equalisation has
not yet been fully reflected in Scheme benefits. An allowance has been included in the liabilities to reflect the expected value
of these additional benefits in line with what was calculated at last year end, i.e. uplifting the DBO by 0.2%.
On 20 November 2020, the High Court ruled that individual transfer payments made since 17 May 1990 would need to be
equalised for the effects of GMP. No further allowance has been made for this judgment as the impact is not material.
Scheme specific risks
The ultimate cost of the Scheme to the Society will depend upon actual future events rather than the assumptions made.
Many of the assumptions made are unlikely to be borne out in practice and, as such, the cost of the schemes may be higher or
lower than disclosed. In general, the risk to the Society is that the assumptions underlying the disclosures, or the calculation
of contribution requirements, are not borne out in practice and the cost to the Society is higher than expected. This could
result in higher contributions being required from the Society and a higher deficit being disclosed. This may also impact the
Society’s ability to grant discretionary benefits or other enhancements to members.
The assumptions not being borne out in practice could include:
I. The investment return on the Scheme’s assets being lower than assumed, resulting in an unaffordable increase in the
contributions required from the Society. The level of bond returns will be a key determinant of overall investment return;
the investment portfolio is also subject to a range of other risks typical of the asset classes held, in particular equity
returns, credit risk on bonds and exposure to the property market.
II. Falls in asset values (particularly equities) not being matched by similar falls in the value of liabilities. This risk has been
mitigated to some degree by the implementation of an asset liability matching investment strategy which is designed to
match a proportion of the Scheme’s interest rate exposure.
III. Future levels of inflation being higher than assumed, resulting in higher than anticipated annual increases to benefits in
payment, revaluations of benefits prior to retirement and salary increases. This risk has been mitigated to some degree
by the implementation of an asset liability matching investment strategy which is designed to match a proportion of the
Scheme’s inflation exposure.
IV. Unanticipated improvements in the longevity of members leading to an increase in the Scheme’s liabilities.
174 | Financial Statements 175
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
17. Retirement benefit obligations (continued)
Assets
The Scheme’s investment strategy, with a significant proportion of the assets invested in liability driven investments
(consisting of index‑linked government and corporate bonds and swaps), is expected to reduce the volatility of the difference
between the market value of the assets and the IAS 19 liabilities.
Disaggregation of assets
Funded DB scheme
%
%
Equities
1
1
Index‑linked bonds
53
58
Corporate and other bonds
7
1
Cash and other
13
13
Swaps
1
–
Pensioner buy‑in insurance contract
25
27
100
100
Approximately 61% of the Scheme’s investments are in quoted assets, with the exception of the liability matching assets
classified as ‘Swaps’ and reinsurance assets included in ‘Cash and other’, where a proportion of these will be invested in
unquoted assets and ‘Buy in’.
Scheme investment strategy
The Trustees set the investment strategy for the Defined Benefit scheme taking into account considerations such as the
strength of the Society’s covenant, the long‑term liabilities of the DB scheme and the funding agreed with the Society.
The Scheme’s investment strategy is set in conjunction with the Scheme’s investment adviser, recognising and managing a
number of risks involved in the investment of the Scheme’s assets in order to achieve the Scheme’s investment objective.
The Trustees agreed that the investment objectives for the DB scheme should be:
•
To achieve a return on the Scheme’s assets that is consistent with the long‑term assumptions in determining the funding
of the Scheme, whilst at the same time balancing risk.
•
To aim for the assets to exceed the liabilities as determined in the event of the Scheme winding up on the basis of cash
equivalent transfer values.
•
To minimise the requirement for the Society to make further deficit recovery plan contributions.
The investment strategy is set out in its Statement of Investment Principles (SIP). The strategy is to hold:
•
A range of instruments that provide a better match both to changes in liability values and expected liability cash flows,
including (but not limited to) gilts, corporate bonds, derivatives, secure income assets and insurance policies.
•
A diversified range of return‑seeking assets, including (but not limited to) equities (implemented physically and/or through
equity futures), corporate bonds and secure income assets.
•
Passive and actively managed portfolios as appropriate, following consideration of efficiency, liquidity and level of
transaction costs likely to prevail within each market as well as the impact of the investment managers’ fees on future
expected returns.
Between the end of September and mid‑October 2022, the assets the Scheme invests in experienced large market
fluctuations following the UK government’s announcement of the mini‑budget, where bond yields increased in such a manner
that the Bank of England stepped in to stabilise the market.
The increase in bond yields reduced both the value of the Scheme’s Credit and Liability Matching portfolios and the Scheme’s
liabilities. Given the hedging properties of these mandates, the Scheme’s funding level only marginally reduced, however
the leveraged nature of the Liability Matching portfolio has forced the Scheme to fully disinvest from its Diversified Return
Seeking assets in order to increase collateral and maintain the hedging properties of this mandate. This action was crucial to
maintain the hedging properties of these mandates, but decreased the expected return on the Scheme’s assets and increased
the proportion of illiquid assets the Scheme holds in its portfolio.
As a result, during 2023, the Trustees have worked with its investment adviser to assess the investment strategy against
the journey plan and review the return and risk characteristics of the DB scheme. This assessment resulted in the Trustees
decision to re‑risk the investment strategy from the previously agreed gilts+0.7% pa return objective to gilts+1.0% pa. The
Trustees also decided to reduce the amount of illiquid assets within the Scheme back to the pre‑gilt crisis level of 5% by
partially disinvesting from the secure income assets, recognising that such decision will take time to implement.
In order to re‑risk the investment strategy and maintain the hedging properties of the Scheme’s Credit and Liability Matching
portfolios, the Trustees decided to invest in equities using derivatives, specifically equity futures.
31 December 2022 Actuarial valuation
The most recent actuarial valuation of the Scheme was carried out with an effective date of 31 December 2022 and was
completed in November 2023. The next actuarial valuation is expected at 31 December 2025. The value of the benefits
promised to members that fall within the DB section of the Scheme are referred to as the Technical Provisions and are valued
on a prudent basis as determined by the Trustee, having received advice from the Scheme Actuary.
The funding level (the ratio of assets to Technical Provisions) at 31 December 2022 was 102.0%. As the Scheme was in
surplus at 31 December 2022, no recovery plan was required, and therefore, currently the Society does not have to pay any
deficit reduction contributions.
War in Ukraine
The Trustees are monitoring the unfortunate events happening in Ukraine and our thoughts are very much with all those
impacted during these extremely difficult times. In line with the western sanctions, the Trustees reviewed the exposure of
the Scheme to Russian and Belarussian assets, to which the Scheme had minimal direct exposures for both the DB and DC
sections of the Scheme. These exposures were subsequently written down to zero price as they were removed from market
indices. The Trustees expects its Investment Managers to gradually divest from these exposures and will continue to monitor
their progress in this area.
The Trustees continue to actively monitor the Scheme’s investments as part of the Investment Sub Committee, which includes
analysis on future expected returns for the investments. Further, the Trustees have an integrated risk management framework
in place to monitor and challenge the Covenant, Investment and Funding risk linked to the Scheme.
176 | Financial Statements 177
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
17. Retirement benefit obligations (continued)
Summary of assumptions
% pa
% pa
Retail prices index (RPI) inflation
3.2
3.5
Consumer price index (CPI) inflation
2.5
2.8
Discount rate
4.5
4.8
Salary increases
3.8
4.0
Rate of increase of pensions in payment*:
In line with RPI, subject to a min of 3% and a max of 5% pa
3.7
3.8
In line with RPI, subject to a min of 0% and a max of 5% pa
3.1
3.3
In line with RPI, subject to a min of 0% and a max of 2.5% pa
2.1
2.2
In line with CPI, subject to a min of 0% and a max of 3% pa
2.2
2.4
The most significant non‑financial assumption is the assumed rate of longevity. The assumptions made are equivalent to the
following life expectancies for scheme member at age 60.
Years
Years
For a current 60 year old male
27.8
28.4
For a current 60 year old female
29.7
30.1
For a current 45 year old male
28.9
29.4
For a current 45 year old female
30.7
31.2
Defined benefit actual contributions paid wholly relate to contributions made by the Society.
Changes in market conditions generate an actuarial gain (decrease in liabilities) and a return on plan less than discount rate
(decrease in assets).
Reconciliation of funded status
Group and Society
2023
£m
£m
Present value of defined benefit obligation
(572.5)
(593.4)
Assets at fair value
611.1
642.2
Funded status/defined benefit asset
38.6
48.8
Reconciliation of unfunded status
Group and Society
2023
£m
£m
Present value of unfunded defined benefit scheme
(8.1)
(7.4)
Present value of unfunded defined benefit scheme
(8.1)
(7.4)
Statement of comprehensive income (SCI)
Group and Society
Funded DB scheme
Unfunded DB scheme
£m
£m
£m
£m
Cumulative actuarial (loss)/gains recognised at 1 January
(30.8)
53.7
16.4
11.9
(Loss)/gain due on change in financial assumptions
(4.0)
342.7
(0.1)
4.5
Gain due to demographic assumptions
12.2
0.6
0.1
–
Gain/(loss) due to experience
13.2
(39.3)
(0.8)
–
Loss due to investment return different from return implied by the discount
(31.8)
(388.5)
–
–
rate
Total actuarial (loss)/gain recognised in SCI
(10.4)
(84.5)
(0.8)
4.5
Cumulative actuarial (losses)/gains recognised at 31 December
(41.2)
(30.8)
15.6
16.4
Components of pension expense as shown in the income statement
Group and Society Funded DB scheme
Unfunded DB scheme
£m
£m
£m
£m
Administrative expenses
2.1
1.7
–
–
Interest on net defined benefit asset/liability
(2.3)
(2.5)
0.3
0.2
Total pension expense
(0.2)
(0.8)
0.3
0.2
Reconciliation of present value of defined benefit obligation
Group and Society Funded DB scheme
Unfunded DB scheme
£m
£m
£m
£m
Present value of defined benefit obligation at 1 January
593.4
916.3
7.4
11.9
Administrative expenses
2.1
1.7
–
–
Interest cost
27.8
16.6
0.3
0.2
Actuarial (gain)/loss
(21.4)
(303.8)
0.8
(4.5)
Defined benefit actual benefits and costs paid
(29.4)
(37.4)
–
–
Disbursements directly paid by the employer
–
–
(0.4)
(0.2)
Present value of defined benefit obligation at 31 December
572.5
593.4
8.1
7.4
* Term dependent inflationary increases have been adopted to reflect expected inflation in each future year. Illustrative inflationary assumptions have
been provided which have been calculated to reflect the broad profile of the Society’s pension obligations.
178 | Financial Statements 179
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
17. Retirement benefit obligations (continued)
Movement in defined benefit fair value of assets
Group and Society Funded DB scheme
£m
£m
Fair value of assets at 1 January
642.2
1,049.0
Interest income on scheme asset
30.1
19.1
Return on plan assets less than discount rates
(31.8)
(388.5)
Defined benefit actual benefits and costs paid
(29.4)
(37.4)
Fair value of plan assets at 31 December
611.1
642.2
The defined benefit obligation has reduced over the period, this is primarily driven by membership movements and
experience following the 31 December 2022 valuation, a decrease in the salary escalation and price inflation assumptions,
and changes to demographic assumptions. These were slightly offset by the reduction of the discount rate to 4.50% from
4.80%, and inflation experience over 2023 being higher than assumed.
Sensitivities
The IAS 19 liability measurement and the service cost are sensitive to the assumptions made about future inflation and salary
growth levels, as well as the assumptions made about life expectation. They are also sensitive to the discount rate, which
depends on market yields on Sterling‑denominated high quality corporate bonds. A decrease in corporate bond yields will
increase the liabilities although this will be partially offset by an increase in matching assets.
The table below shows the sensitivity of the defined benefit obligation combined and Scheme assets to changes in these
assumptions. The final assumptions are chosen by the Society.
Principal Sensitivity Illustrations
Defined benefit
Assets
Net effect
obligation
£m
£m
£m
Total as at 31 December 2023
580.6
611.1
30.5
Change in defined benefit obligation/assets given the following change in assumption:
Discount rate*: 1.00% decrease
86.6
85.9
(0.7)
Salary Escalation: 0.75% increase
1.2
–
(1.2)
Inflation**: 0.50% increase
21.0
24.4
3.4
Life expectancy: 1 year average increase
20.8
6.2
(14.6)
The asset liability matching strategy implemented for the Scheme means that a change in discount rate or inflation
assumption has a broadly similar impact on the liabilities and the assets, reducing the volatility of the net impact. It should be
noted that this strategy is based on liabilities on the self‑sufficiency basis, i.e. higher liabilities than on an accounting basis. As
such, on an accounting basis, for the sensitivities above, the liabilities increase by more than the assets, resulting in a decline
in the accounting balance sheet position.
18. Other assets
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Prepayments and accrued interest
23.0
19.0
23.0
17.9
Due from subsidiary undertakings
–
–
93.6
68.0
Current tax assets
3.8
–
3.8
–
Other assets
12.1
11.1
10.2
9.3
Total other assets
38.9
30.1
130.6
95.2
Included in the Group and Society’s other assets are finance lease receivables of £1.3 million (2022: £1.8 million). The Group
has entered into agency sublease arrangements as an intermediate lessor on former branch properties that are considered
to be finance leases. As substantially all risks and reward are passed over as the subleases match the payment terms and
duration of the headline leases they are classified as finance leases.
Finance income on net investment in the lease in 2023 has been £19k (2022: £17k).
19. Shares
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Shares comprising balances held by individuals
47,056.7
42,008.3
47,056.7
42,008.3
Acquisition fair value adjustments
–
(0.1)
–
(0.1)
Total shares
47,056.7
42,008.2
47,056.7
42,008.2
20. Other deposits
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Amounts owed to:
Subsidiary undertakings
–
–
13,679.0
15,141.2
Other customers
983.6
1,138.1
401.2
695.1
Total other deposits
983.6
1,138.1
14,080.2
15,836.3
* The change in the discount rate is assumed to be equivalent to a 1% decrease in gilt, swap and credit based interest rates.
** The sensitivity illustrations above are calculated changing each assumption in isolation, keeping all other assumptions constant. In practice this is
unrealistic as it ignores the impact from correlation between assumptions.
180 | Financial Statements 181
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
21. Debt securities in issue
Group
Society
£m
£m
£m
£m
Covered bonds
2,968.4
3,365.4
4,254.9
4,715.8
Medium‑term notes
1,262.7
1,358.3
1,262.7
1,358.3
Residential mortgage backed securities
688.3
456.3
–
–
Certificate of deposits
–
79.3
–
79.3
Total debt securities in issue
4,919.4
5,259.3
5,517.6
6,153.4
Debt securities in issue include amounts secured on certain loans and advances to customers in Group £3.7 billion (2022:
£3.8 billion) and Society £4.3 billion (2022: £4.7 billion).
22. Other liabilities
Group Group
Society
2023
£m
£m
£m
£m
Accruals and deferred income
43.3
38.1
43.3
38.1
Finance lease liabilities
17.3
19.0
17.3
19.0
Other
9.9
6.8
58.6
39.8
Total other liabilities
70.5
63.9
119.2
96.9
The lease liabilities are secured by the related underlying assets. The underlying maturity analysis of lease liabilities at
31 December 2023 for the Group is as follows:
Buildings Finance NPV
lease charges
payments
£m
£m
£m
Within 1 year
3.6
(0.4)
3.2
1‑2 years
2.9
(0.4)
2.5
2‑3 years
2.5
(0.3)
2.2
3‑4 years
2.3
(0.2)
2.1
4‑5 years
2.0
(0.2)
1.8
5‑10 years
4.5
(0.3)
4.2
10‑15 years
0.5
(0.1)
0.4
Over 15 years
1.0
(0.1)
0.9
Total at 31 December 2023
19.3
(2.0)
17.3
The Group has elected not to recognise a lease liability for short‑term leases and leases of low value assets which consist
entirely of printing equipment. Payments made under such leases are expensed on a straight‑line basis. At 31 December
2023 the Group had no short‑term lease commitments (2022: nil).
23. Provisions for liabilities and charges
Group
Customer
Restructuring
Property
Other
Total
redress related
provision
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
At 1 January 2023
1.0
0.5
4.1
0.1
5.7
Amounts utilised during the year
(0.2)
(0.1)
(0.8)
–
(1.1)
Provision charge/(release)
0.2
(0.2)
(0.6)
–
(0.6)
At 31 December 2023
1.0
0.2
2.7
0.1
4.0
At 1 January 2022
1.4
2.2
2.4
0.1
6.1
Amounts utilised during the year
(0.4)
(2.6)
(1.6)
–
(4.6)
Provision charge
–
0.9
3.3
–
4.2
At 31 December 2022
1.0
0.5
4.1
0.1
5.7
Society
Customer
Restructuring
Property
Other
Total
redress related
provision
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
At 1 January 2023
1.0
0.5
4.1
0.1
5.7
Amounts utilised during the year
(0.1)
(0.1)
(0.8)
–
(1.0)
Provision release
–
(0.2)
(0.6)
–
(0.8)
At 31 December 2023
0.9
0.2
2.7
0.1
3.9
At 1 January 2022
1.4
2.2
2.4
0.1
6.1
Amounts utilised during the year
(0.4)
(2.6)
(1.6)
–
(4.6)
Provision charge
–
0.9
3.3
–
4.2
At 31 December 2022
1.0
0.5
4.1
0.1
5.7
During the course of its business, the Society receives complaints in relation to past sales or ongoing administration, as well
as being subject to enquiries from and discussions with its regulators, governmental and other public bodies, on a range of
matters. No provision is made where it is concluded that it is not probable that a quantifiable payment will be made; this will
include circumstances where the facts are unclear or further time is required to reasonably quantify the expected payment.
At 31 December 2023 the Group holds customer redress provisions of £1.0 million (2022: £1.0 million) and the Society of
£0.9 million (2022: £1.0 million) in respect of various potential customer claims and represent management’s best estimate
of the likely costs.
Restructuring provisions of £0.2 million (2022: £0.5 million) are held in relation to business and organisational changes
announced during 2023 and earlier periods.
Property related provisions of £2.7 million (2022: £4.1 million) are held in respect of lease costs for branch premises that are
no longer in use. This will be utilised over the remaining term of the unoccupied leasehold branches.
182 | Financial Statements 183
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
24. Subordinated liabilities
Group and Society
Maturity date
2023
2022
£m
£m
Senior non‑preferred:
3% Senior non‑preferred bonds 2025
18 April 2025
141.4
280.6
1½% Senior non‑preferred bonds 2029
15 September 2029
249.2
248.8
3.511% Senior non‑preferred bonds 2030
11 October 2030
301.5
301.3
63/8% Senior non‑preferred bonds 2028
15 November 2028
351.8
–
73/8% Senior non‑preferred bonds 2027
12 September 2027
305.2
–
Subordinated notes:
63/8% Subordinated Bonds 2024
26 April 2024
4.1
4.1
33/8% Subordinated Bonds 2028
13 September 2028
301.9
301.5
13½% Convertible Tier 2 Capital Notes 2025
1 April 2025
26.5
26.5
Fair value hedging adjustments
(59.9)
(127.7)
Total subordinated liabilities
1,621.7
1,035.1
All senior non‑preferred bonds and subordinated bonds are denominated in Sterling. The following notes are repayable at the
dates stated or earlier at the option of the Society and with the prior consent of the PRA under the following conditions.
Senior non‑preferred:
•
Redemption of the 3% Notes at par on the optional call date of 18 April 2024 after fifteen to thirty days’ notice. In the
event the Society does not redeem the notes on this date the fixed rate of interest will become the sum of the yield on the
relevant 1‑year UK gilt‑edged reference bond plus 2.15%.
•
Redemption of the 1½% Notes at par on the optional call date of 15 September 2028 after fifteen to thirty days’ notice.
In the event the Society does not redeem the notes on 15 September 2028 the fixed rate of interest will become the sum
of the yield on the relevant 1‑year UK gilt‑edged reference bond plus 1.15%.
•
Redemption of the 3.511% Notes at par on the optional call date of 11 October 2029 after fifteen to thirty days’ notice to
the holders. In the event the Society does not redeem the notes on 11 October 2029 the fixed rate of interest will become
the sum of the yield on the relevant 1‑year UK gilt‑edged reference bond plus 2.05%.
•
Redemption of the 63/8% Notes at par on the optional call date of 15 November 2027 after giving fifteen to thirty days’
notice to the holders. In the event the Society does not redeem the notes on 15 November 2027 the fixed rate of interest
will become the sum of the yield on the relevant 1‑year UK gilt‑edged reference bond plus 2.65%.
•
Redemption of the 73/8% Notes at par on the optional call date of 12 September 2026 after giving fifteen to thirty days’
notice to the holders. In the event the Society does not redeem the notes on 12 September 2026 the fixed rate of interest
will become the sum of the yield on the relevant 1‑year UK gilt‑edged reference bond plus 2.65%.
Subordinated notes:
•
Redemption of the 33/8% Notes at par on the optional call date of 13 September 2027 after giving thirty to sixty days’
notice. In the event the Society does not redeem the notes on this date, please see Final Terms.
•
Redemption of the 13½% Convertible Tier 2 Capital Notes will occur on the optional call date of 1 April 2025 unless
the notes are converted to Profit Participating Deferred Shares (PPDS). The ‘Conversion Trigger’ shall occur if on any
Calculation Date the Society’s Common Equity Tier 1 Capital Ratio, as confirmed in a report of the auditor to the Society
and addressed to the Board of Directors of the Society, is less than 5%. Should the ‘Conversion Trigger’ occur and these
notes convert into PPDS, the PPDS will be perpetual in nature.
The rights of repayment of the holders of Subordinated notes are subordinated to the claims of all depositors and members
holding shares in the Society, as regards the principal of their shares and interest due on them.
25. Financial commitments
Group and Society
£m
£m
Committed undrawn standby facilities
136.1
139.2*
Other financial commitments
2.8
–
Total financial commitments
138.9
139.2*
The above amounts represent undrawn elements on credit facilities with customers. The amount has reduced over the year
due to further drawdowns against these facilities and the maturity of a number of agreements.
In addition, the Society has a contractual commitment of £2.8 million for ongoing consultancy services.
26. Derivative financial instruments
Derivative financial instruments (derivatives) used for the management of market risk are contracts or agreements whose
value is derived from one or more underlying price, rate or index inherent in the contract or agreement, such as interest rates,
exchange rates or stock market indices.
Derivatives are used by the Group in accordance with the
Building Societies Act 1986
. This means that such instruments are
not used in trading activity or for speculative purposes and are only used to reduce the risk of loss on core assets or liabilities
arising from changes in interest rates, currency rates or other factors of a prescribed description.
The principal derivatives used in balance sheet risk management are interest rate swaps, interest rate options, cross currency
interest rate swaps and foreign exchange contracts. These are used to hedge Group exposures arising from fixed rate
mortgage lending and savings products, funding and investment activities.
The following table describes the significant activities undertaken by the Group, the related risks associated with such
activities and the type of derivatives which are typically used in managing such risks after considering any offsetting risk from
other activities.
Activity
Risk
Type of derivative
Management of the investment of reserves and
Sensitivity to changes in interest rates
Interest rate swaps
non‑interest bearing liabilities
Fixed rate savings products and debt issuance
Sensitivity to changes in interest rates
Interest rate swaps
Fixed rate mortgage lending
Sensitivity to changes in interest rates
Interest rate swaps
Management of foreign currency risk arising
Sensitivity to changes in foreign exchange rates
Cross currency interest rate swaps and
from investment and funding foreign exchange contracts
Floating rate liabilities
Sensitivity to changes in interest rates
Capped interest rate options
The Group’s objective is to manage risk within its risk tolerance, irrespective of the accounting treatment.
Whilst all derivatives have been entered into for hedging purposes, only certain arrangements meet the conditions
necessary to be designated as such for accounting purposes. In some cases a natural offset can be achieved and applying
hedge accounting is not required. The Group only designates accounting hedges where a high degree of effectiveness can
be achieved.
* The 2022 prior year balance has been updated to reflect the correct position on committed undrawn standby facilities.
184 | Financial Statements 185
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
26. Derivative financial instruments (continued)
Hedging
The following table shows the balance sheet categories covered by hedge accounting relationships:
Hedge relationship
Balance sheet line item
Fair value hedge for interest rate risk
Fixed rate mortgages
Loans and advances to customers
Fixed rate debt securities held
Debt securities
Fixed rate debt securities issued
Debt securities in issue
Fair value hedge for interest rate and FX risk
Fixed rate debt securities issued
Debt securities in issue
Fixed rate debt securities held
Debt securities
Cash flow hedge for interest rate risk
Floating rate deposits
Amounts owed to credit institutions
Floating rate debt securities issued
Debt securities in issue
Interest rate risk on fixed rate mortgages and purchased debt securities (fair value)
The Group holds portfolios of long‑term fixed rate mortgages and debt securities. These instruments generate fixed rate
income whereas the Group liabilities are mostly floating rate. The Group manages this risk exposure by entering into pay
fixed/receive floating interest rate swaps. These swaps are then designated into a fair value hedge relationship along with the
issued mortgage.
Only the interest rate risk element is hedged and therefore other risks, such as credit risk, are managed but not hedged by
the Group. The interest rate risk component is determined as the change in fair value of the long‑term fixed rate mortgages
arising solely from changes in SONIA (the benchmark rate of interest). Such changes are usually the largest component of the
overall change in fair value. This strategy is designated as a fair value hedge and its effectiveness is assessed by comparing
changes in the fair value of the hedged item (the mortgage loan) attributable to changes in the benchmark rate of interest
with changes in the fair value of the hedging instrument (interest rate swap).
Possible sources of ineffectiveness are as follows:
•
differences between the expected and actual volume of prepayments for mortgage portfolios, as the Group hedges to the
expected repayment date taking into account expected prepayments based on past experience;
•
difference in timing of cash flows between the mortgage loans and the interest rate swaps;
•
difference in the designated coupon rate % of the hedged asset and the interest rate swaps; and
•
interest rate swaps with a non‑zero fair value at the date of initial designation.
The exposure from the mortgage portfolio frequently changes due to new loans being originated, contractual repayments and
early prepayments made by customers in each period. As a result, the Group adopts a portfolio hedging strategy to hedge the
exposure by closing and entering into new swap agreements. The Group uses the portfolio fair value hedge of interest rate
risk to recognise fair value changes related to changes in interest rate risk in the mortgage portfolio, and therefore reduce the
profit or loss volatility that would otherwise arise from changes in the fair value of the interest rate swaps alone. This hedge
relationship is updated on a monthly basis for changes in the portfolio.
Foreign exchange and interest rate risk on fixed rate debt issuance (fair value)
The Group accesses international markets in order to obtain effective sources of liquidity and funding. As part of this process
the Group issues fixed rate debt in both GBP and EUR and also purchases debt securities in other foreign currencies, such as
JPY and USD. The foreign currency and interest rate risk associated with these instruments is mitigated by the use of cross
currency swaps, which exchange fixed interest payments in the foreign currency for floating interest payments in GBP. The
interest rate risk associated with the GBP debt is mitigated by the use of interest rate swaps which exchange fixed interest
payments with variable payments. These instruments are entered into to match the maturity profile of the Group’s debt
instruments.
The foreign currency risk component is determined as the change in fair value of the foreign currency debt arising solely
from changes in the relevant foreign currency exchange rate. The interest rate risk component is determined as the change
in fair value of the debt arising solely from changes in the benchmark rate of interest. Such changes are usually the largest
component of the overall change in fair value. This strategy is designated as a fair value hedge and its effectiveness is
assessed by comparing changes in the fair value of the debt attributable to changes in the hedged risk(s) with changes in the
fair value of the swaps.
Possible sources of ineffectiveness are as follows:
•
differences in discounting approach between the hedged item and hedging instrument, including the cross currency basis
spread applied in the valuation of cross currency swaps;
•
swaps with a non‑zero fair value at the date of initial designation;
•
difference in the designated coupon rate % of the hedged liability and the swap; and
•
counterparty credit risk which impacts the value of uncollateralised cross currency swaps but not the hedged items.
Interest rate risk on floating rate liabilities (cash flow hedge)
The Group purchased some capped interest rate options (caps) to protect from the risk of increases in market interest rates
impacting the variable rate savings products. The caps were entered into a cash flow hedge relationship on the basis that the
pay outs on the caps will offset the increase in interest payable on these variable savings products. These caps have matured
in 2023 and the Group now has no cash flow hedge relationships.
Ineffectiveness
All ineffectiveness is recorded in the income statement in
Net (losses)/gains from financial instruments held at fair value
.
The following table shows the ineffectiveness in relation to the hedging relationships designated by the Group.
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Fair value hedges
Fixed rate mortgages
(27.3)
(55.4)
(27.3)
(55.4)
Fixed rate debt securities held
2.7
1.9
2.7
1.9
Fixed rate debt securities issued
(4.4)
21.2
(4.3)
9.3
Cash flow hedges
Floating rate debt securities issued
(0.1)
(0.1)
(0.1)
(0.1)
Total
(29.1)
(32.4)
(29.0)
(44.3)
Elevated ineffectiveness of fixed rate mortgage hedges is driven by the significant increase in fair values of hedging
derivatives and hedged items in 2023 caused by the volatility in market interest rates. Changes in fair values can result in
corresponding deterioration in the offset as well as higher amortisation of mortgage fair value balance sheet adjustments.
186 | Financial Statements 187
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
26. Derivative financial instruments (continued)
Ineffectiveness (continued)
The following tables summarise the notional and fair value of all derivative financial instruments and the hedging
designations in place at that date.
Contract/
Fair values
Change in fair
Notional
Assets
Liabilities
value used for
amount calculating
ineffectiveness
£m
£m
£m
£m
Group
At 31 December 2023
Interest rate risk
Interest rate swaps designated as fair value hedges
27,894.4
1,548.1
269.9
(824.6)
Interest rate caps designated as cash flow hedges
–
–
–
–
Interest rate and FX risk
Cross currency interest rate swaps designated as fair value hedges
3,091.3
68.4
235.9
(22.0)
Derivatives not designated as hedges:
Interest rate swaps
21,432.1
129.9
191.2
n/a
Foreign exchange
171.1
8.6
0.4
n/a
Total derivative financial instruments
52,588.9
1,755.0
697.4
(846.6)
Society
At 31 December 2023
Interest rate risk
Interest rate swaps designated as fair value hedges
27,894.4
1,548.1
269.9
(824.6)
Interest rate caps designated as cash flow hedges
–
–
–
–
Interest rate and FX risk
Cross currency interest rate swaps designated as fair value hedges
1,787.7
68.4
122.8
(91.9)
Derivatives not designated as hedges:
Interest rate swaps
31,215.6
129.9
191.2
n/a
Foreign exchange
104.5
5.5
0.4
n/a
Total derivative financial instruments
61,002.2
1,751.9
584.3
(916.5)
The expected future cash flows have been discounted using the Overnight Indexed Swap (OIS) curve (SONIA) for all
derivatives. Credit Valuation Adjustments (CVA) and Debit Valuation Adjustments (DVA) are incorporated into the fair value
of derivative valuations to reflect the impact of counterparty credit risk and the Group’s own credit quality respectively for
uncollateralised derivatives.
Credit risk on derivative exposures is significantly mitigated within the Group by the existence of a Credit Support Annex
(CSA) with the vast majority of our derivative counterparties. Under a CSA, cash is passed between parties to mitigate the
counterparty risk inherent in the outstanding positions. Where cash collateral is received, to mitigate the risk inherent in
amounts due to the Group, it is included as a liability within amounts owed to credit institutions. Where cash collateral is
given, it is included as an asset in loans and advances to credit institutions. Credit risk is also mitigated by the use of central
counterparties (CCPs) for eligible derivatives.
Contract/
Fair values
Change in fair
Notional
Assets
Liabilities
value used
amount for calculating
ineffectiveness
£m
£m
£m
£m
Group
At 31 December 2022
Interest rate risk
Interest rate swaps designated as fair value hedges
29,812.7
2,216.2
191.2
1,137.9
Interest rate caps designated as cash flow hedges
1,515.0
24.8
–
–
Interest rate and FX risk
Cross currency interest rate swaps designated as fair value hedges
3,621.4
57.6
306.3
(22.0)
Derivatives not designated as hedges:
Interest rate swaps
12,016.0
38.1
167.9
n/a
Foreign exchange
281.2
19.8
0.9
n/a
Total derivative financial instruments
47,246.3
2,356.5
666.3
1,115.9
Society
At 31 December 2022
Interest rate risk
Interest rate swaps designated as fair value hedges
29,812.7
2,216.2
191.2
1,137.9
Interest rate caps designated as cash flow hedges
1,515.0
24.8
–
–
Interest rate and FX risk
Cross currency interest rate swaps designated as fair value hedges
1,848.4
37.2
147.1
127.3
Derivatives not designated as hedges:
Interest rate swaps
24,535.6*
38.1
167.9
n/a
Foreign exchange
108.5
7.4
0.8
n/a
Total derivative financial instruments
57,820.2
2,323.7
507.0
1,265.2
* As a result of the reclassification highlighted in
Note 1 – Reclassification within Interest Revenue (Society only)
, there is an equivalent reduction in the
contract/notional amount of interest rate swaps not designated in a hedge for 2022 only.
188 | Financial Statements 189
The following table shows the average price/rate of the hedging instruments by maturity used in the Group’s hedging
strategies:
Group and Society
Repayable In more than Over Repayable In more than Over
up to three years five years up to three years five years
three but less than three but less than
years five years years five years
Average fixed interest rate – Fair value hedges
Interest rate swaps (pay fixed)
1.65
2.56
1.50
0.85
1.09
0.83
Interest rate swaps (receive fixed)
3.69
3.19
3.51
0.93
2.37
2.60
Cross currency interest rate swaps
0.70
0.44
0.86
0.53
0.56
0.32
Average EUR:GBP FX rate – Fair value hedges
Cross currency interest rate swaps
1.13
1.15
1.14
1.14
1.12
1.17
Average JPY:GBP FX rate – Fair value hedges
Cross currency interest rate swaps
156.41
–
–
157.31
154.80
–
Average USD:GBP FX rate – Fair value hedges
Cross currency interest rate swaps
–
1.19
–
–
1.23
–
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
26. Derivative financial instruments (continued)
Ineffectiveness (continued)
The following tables show the maturity profile, by notional amount, of the hedging instruments designated in hedge
relationships used in the Group’s hedging strategies:
Group and Society Repayable In more than Over Total
up to three years five years
three years but less than
five years
£m
£m
£m
£m
At 31 December 2023
Interest rate caps
–
–
–
–
Total cash flow hedges
–
–
–
–
At 31 December 2022
Interest rate caps
1,515.0
–
–
1,515.0
Total cash flow hedges
1,515.0
–
–
1,515.0
Group Repayable In more than Over Total
up to three years five years
three years but less than
five years
£m
£m
£m
£m
At 31 December 2023
Interest rate swaps (pay fixed)
16,253.8
8,561.4
1,035.0
25,850.2
Interest rate swaps (receive fixed)
844.2
900.0
300.0
2,044.2
Cross currency interest rate swaps
1,429.7
1,582.8
78.8
3,091.3
Total fair value hedges
18,527.7
11,044.2
1,413.8
30,985.7
At 31 December 2022
Interest rate swaps (pay fixed)
17,994.9
9,320.4
966.8
28,282.1
Interest rate swaps (receive fixed)
280.6
700.0
550.0
1,530.6
Cross currency interest rate swaps
1,766.7
741.2
1,113.5
3,621.4
Total fair value hedges
20,042.2
10,761.6
2,630.3
33,434.1
Society Repayable In more than Over Total
up to three years five years
three years but less than
five years
£m
£m
£m
£m
At 31 December 2023
Interest rate swaps (pay fixed)
16,253.8
8,561.4
1,035.0
25,850.2
Interest rate swaps (receive fixed)
844.2
900.0
300.0
2,044.2
Cross currency interest rate swaps
995.2
713.7
78.8
1,787.7
Total fair value hedges
18,093.2
10,175.1
1,413.8
29,682.1
At 31 December 2022
Interest rate swaps (pay fixed)
17,994.9
9,320.4
966.8
28,282.1
Interest rate swaps (receive fixed)
280.6
700.0
550.0
1,530.6
Cross currency interest rate swaps
880.2
298.0
670.2
1,848.4
Total fair value hedges
19,155.7
10,318.4
2,187.0
31,661.1
190 | Financial Statements 191
The accumulated amount of fair value hedge adjustments remaining on the balance sheet for hedged items that have ceased
to be adjusted for hedging gains and losses is a loss of £3.3 million (2022: £7.9 million loss).
The following tables show the cash flow hedge exposures (gross of tax) covered by the Group’s hedging strategies:
Group and Society
Assets
Liabilities
Change in fair
Cash flow hedge reserve
value of hedged Continuing Discontinued
item used for hedges hedges
calculating
ineffectiveness
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
At 31 December 2023
Floating rate debt securities issued
–
–
(5.7)
–
(0.5)
Floating rate liabilities
–
–
3.2
–
–
At 31 December 2022
Floating rate debt securities issued
–
425.0
5.1
(1.0)
(0.4)
Floating rate liabilities
–
1,090.0
(3.2)
(12.3)
–
The following table shows the movements in the cash flow hedge reserve during the year:
Group and Society
£m
£m
At 1 January
9.9
10.4
Effective portion of changes in fair value of interest rate swaps:
Floating rate debt securities issued
–
8.5
Floating rate liabilities
–
17.7
Amounts reclassified from reserves to income statement:
Floating rate debt securities issued
(0.9)
(13.5)
Floating rate liabilities
(12.3)
(14.5)
Taxation
3.7
1.3
At 31 December
0.4
9.9
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
26. Derivative financial instruments (continued)
The following tables show the fair value hedge exposures covered by the Group’s hedging strategies. The change in fair value
of the hedged item for calculating ineffectiveness is based on all hedge relationships designated during the year.
Carrying amount of Accumulated fair value Change in fair
hedged item adjustments on the value of the
hedged item hedged item
Assets
Liabilities
Assets
Liabilities
for calculating
ineffectiveness
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
Group
At 31 December 2023
Fixed rate mortgages (interest rate risk)
23,721.6
–
(615.5)
–
892.8
Fixed rate debt securities held (interest rate and FX risk)
2,693.2
–
(254.6)
–
104.6
Fixed rate debt securities issued (interest rate and FX risk)
–
4,338.9
–
255.0
(210.2)
Society*
At 31 December 2023
Fixed rate mortgages (interest rate risk)
23,721.6
–
(615.5)
–
892.8
Fixed rate debt securities held (interest rate and FX risk)
2,693.2
–
(254.6)
–
104.6
Fixed rate debt securities issued (interest rate and FX risk)
–
3,035.0
–
161.9
(140.2)
Group
At 31 December 2022
Fixed rate mortgages (interest rate risk)
26,363.6
–
(1,508.3)
–
(1,270.0)
Fixed rate debt securities held (interest rate risk and FX risk)
2,308.3
–
(384.7)
–
(327.6)
Fixed rate debt securities issued (interest rate and FX risk)
–
4,453.6
–
460.4
450.8
Society*
At 31 December 2022
Fixed rate mortgages (interest rate risk)
26,363.6
–
(1,508.3)
–
(1,270.0)
Fixed rate debt securities held (interest rate risk and FX risk)
2,308.3
–
(384.7)
–
(327.6)
Fixed rate debt securities issued (interest rate and FX risk)
–
2,679.0
–
297.2
289.6
* For Society the exposure to mortgages includes those within Accord Mortgages Limited as this exposure is transferred via an intercompany loan that
mirrors the underlying loans in this entity.
192 | Financial Statements 193
Pledged assets
The Society’s asset backed funding programmes, reported within debt securities in issue (see note 21) are secured against
certain loans and advances to customers.
In addition, as part of its liquidity management, the Society enters into sale and repurchase agreements whereby the Society
sells but agrees to repurchase assets at a future date. Typically this is for up to three months and for UK government securities
and listed transferable debt securities. Proceeds of these sale and repurchase agreements are included within amounts owed
to credit institutions.
Assets pledged are as follows:
Group
Carrying
Carrying Total
amount of amount of
encumbered unencumbered
assets assets
£m
£m
£m
2023
Liquid assets
1,688.3
11,110.1
12,798.4
Loans and advances to customers
7,307.1
39,508.8
46,815.9
Fair value adjustment for hedged risk on loans and advances to customers
–
(615.5)
(615.5)
Other assets
–
1,969.9
1,969.9
Total assets
8,995.4
51,973.3
60,968.7
2022
Liquid assets
2,138.8
10,343.5
12,482.3
Loans and advances to customers
10,635.8
34,567.9
45,203.7
Fair value adjustment for hedged risk on loans and advances to customers
–
(1,508.3)
(1,508.3)
Other assets
–
2,576.4
2,576.4
Total assets
12,774.6
45,979.5
58,754.1
All of the assets pledged as security are shown in the balance sheet, as the Society has retained substantially all the risk and
rewards of ownership.
The Society established Yorkshire Building Society Covered Bonds LLP in November 2006. The LLP provides security for
issues of covered bonds made by the Society to external counterparties. As at 31 December 2023, the Society had in issue
£2,950 million of Sterling denominated covered bonds, of which £1,200 million was retained, and €1,500 million of Euro
denominated covered bonds.
The Group established its first securitisation programme in 2011. This year, no new securitisation structures were established,
however the Group did issue £500 million Brass 11 notes publicly in Q1 2023. Brass 11 was established in 2022 and was
initially wholly retained. As at 31 December 2023, the Group had in issue £9,716 million of securitisation notes, of which
£9,028 million were retained.
Whole mortgage loan pools are pre‑positioned at the Bank of England under the Term Funding Scheme (TFSME). The whole
loan pool is pledged and drawings are made directly against the eligible collateral. However, values shown are the whole
mortgage loan pool balances.
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
27. Liquidity risk
Liquidity risk is an intrinsic part of the Society’s business as long‑term mortgages are funded by short‑term retail customer
balances. Most mortgages have a contractual maturity date of around 25 years but in practice are frequently repaid early;
currently the estimated average life of a mortgage is approximately five years. Conversely, experience shows that retail
deposits, nominally repayable on demand or with short notice periods, actually remain with the Society for relatively long
periods. It is this inherent mismatch in the maturity profiles of retail assets and liabilities that creates liquidity risk.
The Society’s liquidity management policy is designed to ensure the maintenance of adequate investments in liquid assets
to cover statutory, regulatory and operational requirements. The primary function of liquidity is the provision of sufficient
assets in realisable form to ensure that the Society is able to meet its liabilities as they arise and to absorb potential cash flow
requirements created by the maturity mismatches referred to above or by a liquidity stress scenario.
The Society’s liquidity management comprises the following key areas:
•
At the highest level, the Society manages its liquidity levels to ensure compliance with the Overall Liquidity Adequacy
Rule, as set out by the PRA in Chapter 2 of the Internal Liquidity Adequacy Assessment part of the PRA Rulebook
(ILAA rules).
•
Limits are established by the Board that govern the quantity, quality and marketability of and returns from the Society’s
portfolio of liquidity investments. The portfolio is managed by the Treasury function, monitored by the first and second
line risk functions and overseen by the Asset and Liability Committee (ALCO) under a series of delegated authorities.
•
The Society conducts a series of daily stress tests that are designed to ensure that its liquidity is sufficient to meet its cash
flow needs under any one of a number of adverse scenarios should they arise. The scenarios include ones caused by both
Society‑specific and general market events, and incorporate both severe retail savings outflows and the unavailability of
wholesale funding. They are constructed on various timescales as far out as three months. These scenarios are updated
and approved by the Board annually through the Internal Liquidity Adequacy Assessment Process (ILAAP).
•
The Society also manages liquidity in line with prevailing regulatory requirements, namely the Liquidity Coverage Ratio
(LCR), as prescribed under the PRA Rulebook, Liquidity Coverage Ratio (CRR) part. The LCR measures the quantity of High
Quality Liquid Assets (HQLA) against net liquidity outflows over a 30 day period. YBS currently reports to the PRA on a
monthly basis on a Society and unconsolidated basis, with the lower of the two being reported as 156.36% for December
2023 month end. For comparison, the lowest as at 31 December 2022 was 164.02%.
•
The Society monitors and reports its Net Stable Funding Ratio (NSFR), which is a longer term measure of the stability of the
Society’s funding sources relative to the assets being funded. The Society’s NSFR as at 31 December 2023 was 148.80%
(2022: 144.49%) and was therefore in excess of the regulatory minimum of 100%.
•
The Society has also implemented internal backstop limits for liquidity, to mitigate the potential risk of liquidity levels
under a risk‑based approach being able to be reduced to below what is considered a minimum appropriate level for the
Society. These backstop limits are linked to balance sheet size.
•
The liquidity position of the Society is forecast across the next two years and measured against forecasts of the liquidity
requirements on both a regulatory and internal basis. This is to ensure that the short‑term plans of the Society do not lead
to liquidity limits being breached and the financial sustainability of the organisation being threatened.
The above metrics are the key elements of the suite of measures by which the Society actively seeks to manage its liquidity
position, along with other complimentary metrics which are included within the Society’s risk appetite framework.
Liquidity risk in subsidiary companies, with the exception of other deposits, is mitigated by the use of appropriate
intercompany loans and deposits.
194 | Financial Statements 195
The table below analyses the Group’s financial assets and liabilities into relevant maturity groupings, based on the remaining
period between the balance sheet date and the contractual maturity date.
Group
Repayable
Less than In more In more Over five Total
on demand three than three than one years
months months but year but
not more not more
than one than five
year years
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
As at 31 December 2023
Financial assets
Cash in hand and balances with the Bank of England
4,839.1
–
–
–
–
4,839.1
Loans and advances to credit institutions
397.4
–
–
–
–
397.4
Debt securities
–
955.2
971.7
4,205.4
1,429.6
7,561.9
Loans and advances to customers
–
15.4
128.6
1,240.8
45,431.1
46,815.9
Fair value adjustment for hedged risk on loans and
advances to customers
–
(109.2)
(244.0)
(262.5)
0.2
(615.5)
Derivatives financial instruments
–
64.9
182.8
1,298.6
208.7
1,755.0
Total financial assets
5,236.5
926.3
1,039.1
6,482.3
47,069.6
60,753.8
Financial liabilities
Shares
26,276.7
4,005.6
10,704.9
6,066.1
3.4
47,056.7
Amounts owed to credit institutions
55.4
807.6
10.3
1,013.0
–
1,886.3
Other deposits
604.2
366.8
12.6
–
–
983.6
Debt securities in issue
–
–
1,189.7
3,041.4
688.3
4,919.4
Derivative financial instruments
–
28.1
54.8
543.8
70.7
697.4
Subordinated liabilities
–
–
4.1
1,126.8
490.8
1,621.7
Total financial liabilities
26,936.3
5,208.1
11,976.4
11,791.1
1,253.2
57,165.1
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
27. Liquidity risk (continued)
The tables below provide an analysis of gross contractual cashflows. The sum of the balances depicted in the analysis do not
reconcile with the carrying value of the liabilities, as disclosed in the consolidated balance sheet. This is because they include
estimated future interest payments calculated using balances outstanding at the balance sheet date. Amounts are allocated to
the relevant maturity band based on the timing of individual contractual cashflows.
Group
Repayable on
In more than In more than Over five Total
demand and three months one year but years
up to three but not more not more than
months than one year five years
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
As at 31 December 2023
Shares
30,281.9
10,704.9
6,066.1
3.4
47,056.3
Amounts owed to credit institutions
743.7
49.5
1,041.6
–
1,834.8
Other deposits:
Society
389.0
12.9
–
–
401.9
Subsidiaries
582.4
–
–
–
582.4
Debt securities in issue
34.3
1,364.1
4,124.1
–
5,522.5
Subordinated liabilities
–
92.8
1,409.9
574.8
2,077.5
Derivative financial liabilities
109.1
186.8
599.8
51.4
947.1
Total
32,140.4
12,411.0
13,241.5
629.6
58,422.5
As at 31 December 2022
Shares
26,664.2
9,485.5
5,858.5
–
42,008.2
Amounts owed to credit institutions
2,004.6
92.9
3,350.0
–
5,447.5
Other deposits:
Society
555.9
143.2
–
–
699.1
Subsidiaries
442.9
–
–
–
442.9
Debt securities in issue
236.4
1,002.6
3,557.7
977.8
5,774.5
Subordinated liabilities
–
36.4
424.1
899.2
1,359.7
Derivative financial liabilities
85.9
174.4
424.7
10.8
695.8
Total
29,989.9
10,935.0
13,615.0
1,887.8
56,427.7
196 | Financial Statements 197
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
28. Market risk
Market risk is the risk to earnings and capital arising from changes in interest rates, foreign currency exchange rates, structural
mismatches within the balance sheets and the price of financial instruments.
Value at Risk (VaR)
VaR is a risk management tool which evaluates the potential losses that may be incurred as a result of movements in market
conditions over a specified holding period and to a given level of confidence. The model used is based on a 10 day holding
period and a 99% confidence level.
The VaR model calculates potential movements in market prices by reference to market data from the last 63 days and
incorporates underlying risk factors based on historic interest rate volatilities and correlations.
VaR for the Treasury portfolios is calculated and reported on a daily basis. A back test of the VaR model is performed to test
the validity of the assumptions and parameters within the model.
A number of limitations should be considered in relation to the VaR model:
1. Historic data is not necessarily a good guide to future events.
2. The model, by definition, does not capture potential losses outside the 99% confidence level, i.e. those events that are
extreme in nature.
3. VaR is calculated on the basis of exposures outstanding at the close of business and, therefore, does not necessarily
reflect intra‑day exposures.
The VaR measures shown below are based upon Treasury positions.
Structural risk analysis (basis risk)
An analysis of interest bearing items by rate type is performed to illustrate key areas of structural mismatch. It identifies
mismatches between administered rates, fixed rates and other rates, including those linked to Bank Base Rate and SONIA. The
effect of SONIA mismatches within the Balance Sheet is measured as the impact on net interest income (for a 12 month rolling
period) of an isolated increase in SONIA of one basis point (0.01%). A one basis point sensitivity measure is an industry standard
approach to quantify the quantum and direction of the interest rate exposure within the Society.
Basis Point value (BP) sensitivity
These measures calculate the change in value of the assets and liabilities resulting from both a one basis point (PV01) and
100 basis points (PV100) parallel upward shift in interest rates. Within the Treasury portfolio, this is calculated separately for
each currency and reported on a daily basis and at the full balance sheet level on a monthly basis.
Repricing gap analysis
Repricing dates are analysed primarily to avoid repricing risk concentrations, i.e. the situation where too great a proportion
of the Group’s assets and liabilities see the interest rates earned or charged on them resetting within a given time period.
The aim is to prevent excessive volatility in the net interest margin that could arise if rates shifted adversely within a given
time period and, since the Society cannot dictate interest rate movements itself, the best approach is to limit the amount of
assets or liabilities that are exposed in this way. The analysis identifies the net asset/liability repricing position across a series
of time intervals. Positions are calculated using nominal amounts and exclude interest flows. General reserves, fixed assets
and other liabilities are classified as having ‘non‑specific’ repricing characteristics with a zero rate of interest. The measure is
calculated as a reverse cumulative gap.
Group Repayable Less than In more In more Over five Total
on demand three than three than one years
months months but year but
not more not more
than one than five
year years
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
As at 31 December 2022
Financial assets
Cash in hand and balances with the Bank of England
5,982.8
–
–
–
–
5,982.8
Loans and advances to credit institutions
814.7
–
–
–
–
814.7
Debt securities
–
596.0
280.5
3,529.2
1,279.1
5,684.8
Loans and advances to customers*
–
38.9
84.2
1,145.4
43,935.2
45,203.7
Fair value adjustment for hedged risk on loans and
advances to customers
–
(181.8)
(481.0)
(845.5)
–
(1,508.3)
Derivatives financial instruments
–
17.0
261.6
1,793.2
284.7
2,356.5
Total financial assets
6,797.5
470.1
145.3
5,622.3
45,499.0
58,534.2
Financial liabilities
Shares
24,393.4
2,270.8
9,485.5
5,858.5
–
42,008.2
Amounts owed to credit institutions
38.0
1,945.8
5.1
3,172.0
–
5,160.9
Other deposits
462.7
533.4
142.0
–
–
1,138.1
Debt securities in issue
–
222.0
948.0
2,744.2
1,345.1
5,259.3
Derivative financial liabilities
–
7.9
45.0
360.1
253.3
666.3
Subordinated liabilities
–
–
–
612.7
422.4
1,035.1
Total financial liabilities
24,894.1
4,979.9
10,625.6
12,747.5
2,020.8
55,267.9
* The
Loans and advances to customers
line has been updated to correct the classification of loans reported in the
less than three months
and the
in more
than one year but not more than five years
groupings.
27. Liquidity risk (continued)
198 | Financial Statements 199
28. Market risk (continued)
All market risk is managed in the Society on behalf of the Group, hence the tables below apply to the Group.
Year end
Average
Maximum
Minimum
£m
£m
£m
£m
2023
SONIA basis
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.2
PV01 sensitivity
–
0.1
0.2
–
PV100 sensitivity
1.3
10.6
28.3
(0.3)
Treasury VaR
1.5
3.2
5.7
1.3
2022
SONIA basis
1.6
1.9
2.0
1.6
PV01 sensitivity
0.2
0.2
0.3
0.1
PV100 sensitivity
21.9
27.6
36.3
13.0
Treasury VaR
7.0
5.3
9.3
1.6
Greater than Greater than Greater than
one year five years ten years
£m
£m
£m
2023
Repricing gap (Treasury)
289
(30)
–
2022
Repricing gap (Treasury)
362
69
–
29. Currency risk
Currency exchange risk is monitored daily and the Society seeks to minimise its net exposure to assets and liabilities
denominated in currencies other than Sterling. In particular the Society’s existing non‑Sterling Liquidity portfolio and
Wholesale Funding exposures are swapped back into Sterling. Maximum positions throughout the year represented less than
0.02% of total assets.
Actual exposures were:
Group and Society
2023
£m
£m
Year end
5.2
6.1
Maximum
5.2
6.1
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
30. Wholesale credit risk
The Group’s wholesale credit risk arises principally from assets held for liquidity purposes. The risk is that counterparties with
whom the Group invests liquid assets fail to repay those investments when they fall due. The Group, through the Treasury
function, undertakes its own internal rating of all its counterparties and sets individual limits accordingly. These limits are
regularly reviewed internally and against the external rating agencies, with revocation or suspension taking place where
considered appropriate.
Limits are in place governing the types of instrument in which the Group will invest, as well as geographic limits designed to
prevent over‑exposure to a given country.
The Group uses an internal credit ratings process to identify potential risks and wholesale related credit risks are reported and
discussed monthly at the Asset and Liability Committee.
Whilst recognising that exposures will be maintained across a spectrum of counterparties the Board has maintained a low
risk appetite for wholesale credit risk. A diversified range of counterparties is in place to meet business and regulatory
requirements in order to meet the Board approved strategies with no credit risk exposures being undertaken by Treasury to
counterparties that have not been through an internal approvals process including a formal second Line of Defence function.
The following tables break down Wholesale Group exposures by type using the composite external ratings*.
Aaa-Aa3
A1-A3
Baa1-Baa3
Ba1-B3
Caa1-C3
Unrated
Total
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
2023
Central Bank and Sovereigns
5,732.9
241.0
–
–
–
–
5,973.9
Financial Institutions
6,222.6
1,800.7
68.4
–
–
–
8,091.7
Supranationals
487.8
–
–
–
–
–
487.8
Total
12,443.3
2,041.7
68.4
–
–
–
14,553.4
2022
Central Bank and Sovereigns
6,605.4
271.9
–
–
–
–
6,877.3
Financial Institutions
6,177.9
857.4
425.2
–
–
–
7,460.5
Supranationals
501.0
–
–
–
–
–
501.0
Total
13,284.3
1,129.3
425.2
–
–
–
14,838.8
* The composite rating is derived from an average external rating
200 | Financial Statements 201
30. Wholesale credit risk (continued)
The Group has a low risk appetite to exposures outside the UK. This is reflected in the country exposures by type shown in the
tables below.
Central Banks Financial
Supranationals
Total
and Sovereigns institutions
£m
£m
£m
£m
2023
United Kingdom
5,691.5
5,357.0
–
11,048.5
Australia
–
442.5
–
442.5
Canada
–
1,409.7
–
1,409.7
France
41.4
34.6
–
76.0
Germany
–
240.6
–
240.6
Japan
241.0
9.3
–
250.3
Netherlands
–
85.7
–
85.7
Norway
–
104.0
–
104.0
Spain
–
63.0
–
63.0
Sweden
–
61.5
–
61.5
Switzerland
–
179.9
–
179.9
United States
–
103.9
–
103.9
International
–
–
487.8
487.8
Total
5,973.9
8,091.7
487.8
14,553.4
2022
United Kingdom
6,565.3
4,989.7
–
11,555.0
Australia
–
296.7
–
296.7
Canada
–
1,275.7
–
1,275.7
France
40.1
40.9
–
81.0
Germany
–
273.4
–
273.4
Japan
271.9
319.4
–
591.3
Netherlands
–
82.6
–
82.6
Norway
–
75.4
–
75.4
Spain
–
76.1
–
76.1
Sweden
–
29.1
–
29.1
United States
–
1.5
–
1.5
International
–
–
501.0
501.0
Total
6,877.3
7,460.5
501.0
14,838.8
The Group’s main Sovereign exposure is to the UK which had an average external rating of ‘AA‑’. At the year end, UK Sovereign
exposure was £4,839.1 million (2022: £5,982.8 million) to the Bank of England and £852.4 million (2022: £582.5 million) in
UK Government bonds.
None of the wholesale exposures is either past due or impaired and there are no assets that would otherwise be past due or
impaired whose terms have been renegotiated.
The key trigger events used to evaluate impairments are set out in note 1.
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
Wholesale credit risk is recorded in the following balance sheet items as below:
Group
2022
£m
£m
Cash in hand and balances with the Bank of England
4,839.1
5,982.8
Loans and advances to credit institutions
397.4
814.7
Debt securities
7,561.9
5,684.8
Derivative financial instruments
1,755.0
2,356.5
Total wholesale credit risk
14,553.4
14,838.8
31. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers
Gross contractual exposure
The table below splits the loans and advances to customers balance per the balance sheet into its constituent parts and
reconciles to the gross exposures used in the expected credit loss (ECL) model. Effective Interest Rate (EIR) and hedging
adjustments have been excluded from the ECL model as these do not form part of the contractual cash flows from the assets.
EIR is the measurement method used for financial assets held at amortised cost, including loans and advances to customers,
which spreads income and fees over the life of the asset. See note 1 for more details. Hedging is described in more detail
in note 26. The fair value rate adjustment reflects the market value adjustment on acquired portfolios of mortgage assets in
respect of interest rates on the underlying products. This is amortised over the expected life of the acquired portfolio. The fair
value credit adjustment is the fair value discount applied on purchased or originated credit impaired (POCI) mortgage assets
acquired as part of the Norwich & Peterborough Building Society (N&P) and Chelsea Building Society (CBS) acquisitions.
Impairment represents the difference between the total ECL and the fair value credit adjustment.
ECL is calculated using models that take historical default and loss experience and apply predictions of future economic
conditions (e.g. unemployment and house prices) and customer behaviour (e.g. default rates). In certain circumstances, the
core models may not accurately reflect factors that have resulted in an increase in credit risk. When this happens, post model
adjustments (PMAs) are overlaid to reflect the impact on ECL. The economic scenarios and the PMAs applied at 31 December
2023 are described below.
Group
Society
2022
2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Gross contractual exposures
46,868.6
45,252.1
11,001.1
11,327.8
EIR and other adjustments
39.4
49.7
(17.6)
(16.1)
Fair value rate adjustment
(32.2)
(39.7)
(32.2)
(39.7)
Gross loans and advances to customers
46,875.8
45,262.1
10,951.3
11,272.0
Impairment
(37.7)
(33.1)
(8.5)
(7.8)
Fair value credit adjustment
(22.3)
(25.3)
(22.3)
(25.3)
ECL
(60.0)
(58.4)
(30.8)
(33.1)
Loans and advances to customers
46,815.8
45,203.7
10,920.5
11,238.9
202 | Financial Statements 203
31. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers (continued)
Expected Credit Losses (ECL)
Economic scenarios
Accounting standards require ECL to be calculated by applying multiple economic scenarios. Each economic scenario is
provided a weighting, and these are combined to arrive at the total ECL.
These scenarios are generated internally using external data, statistical methodologies, and senior management judgement,
to span a range of plausible economic conditions. The Group continues to apply four scenarios: an upside scenario that
assumes more benign economic conditions; our core or central best estimate scenario; a more negative downturn scenario;
and a severe downturn scenario. The downturn scenario replaced the stagflation downturn scenario applied in 2022. A
higher weighting has been attributed to the downturn and severe downturn scenarios than in 2022, reflecting the ongoing
uncertainty around the health of the UK economy.
Scenarios are projected over a 5 year window, reverting to long‑term averages past that point. The Group allows all
macroeconomic scenarios to impact staging.
Current macroeconomic conditions
The UK Economy technically entered recession at the end of 2023, attributed to the ongoing cost‑of‑living crisis and higher
interest rate environment. Growth will likely remain weak by historical standards in the medium term and there remains
more downside risk than upside. Headline inflation continues to fall, although there are re‑emerging risks around the price
of energy following the recent geopolitical tensions. Core inflation, services inflation and wage inflation continue to provide
headwind to the inflation target being met consistently throughout 2024. Since 31 December 2022, the economic outlook
has improved slightly as energy prices fell and the labour market remained resilient. Rates are expected to remain higher for
longer, and downward pressure on house prices is increased in the short term.
Upside
UK avoids a recession and grows modestly. Inflation returns to the 2% target by the end of 2025. Unemployment remains
lows and house prices grow at a moderate rate.
Core
The core scenario is the Group’s best estimate of how the UK economy will evolve and is aligned with the central scenario
used in the Group’s financial planning processes.
It assumes the economy will avoid a technical recession, but growth will be suppressed until 2025. The ongoing wage
and inflation pressures result in the Bank of England keeping interest rates higher for longer. Unemployment rises slowly
throughout 2024. House prices are impacted modestly by the higher interest rate environment but recover from 2025.
Downturn
The downturn scenario can be characterised as high inflation and low growth. The economy enters a technical recession in the
first half of 2024 and growth remains low thereafter. Inflation is embedded in the economy and remains above the 2% target
throughout the scenario. Interest rates continue to rise despite the recessionary conditions. Unemployment rises to 6.5% as a
result, and house prices fall in both 2024 and 2025.
Severe downturn
Geopolitical tensions escalate, materially impacting energy prices and supply chains. Another wave of inflation ensues, forcing
the Bank of England to raise interest rates. Consequently, the economy falls into a deep recession, resulting in significant
unemployment and house price reductions.
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
Macroeconomic assumptions
The following table shows the year end values of the key economic variables used by each economic scenario for the period
until December 2028. The table includes the three key parameters used to predict probability of default (PD) – unemployment,
HPI and UK Bank of England base rate. GDP is also presented as it is the key input for determining the economic parameters used
and provides context to the nature of the overall scenario.
Scenario
2022
Scenario
2027
2024
HPI
Upside
2.0
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
–
1.5
2.2
3.2
3.2
Core
(4.0)
2.0
3.0
3.5
4.0
(6.0)
(2.0)
1.3
2.0
2.0
Downturn
(7.5)
(4.0)
2.5
0.5
1.2
(12.7)
(5.0)
–
1.5
1.7
Severe downturn
(12.0)
(12.5)
(6.0)
(1.0)
0.5
(13.5)
(11.8)
(6.8)
–
0.5
GDP
Upside
1.5
1.8
2.0
1.9
1.9
1.5
2.0
2.1
2.0
2.0
Core
0.3
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.3
(1.5)
0.8
1.6
1.8
1.8
Downturn
(0.1)
0.1
0.1
0.2
0.3
(6.3)
(5.3)
0.4
0.6
1.0
Severe downturn
(4.5)
(1.5)
–
0.5
1.0
(7.4)
(5.3)
(1.2)
–
0.2
Unemployment
Upside
4.0
4.0
4.0
4.0
4.0
3.5
3.6
3.6
3.8
3.8
Core
5.0
4.8
4.6
4.4
4.0
4.9
5.5
5.2
4.8
4.5
Downturn
6.5
6.0
5.8
5.5
5.0
6.5
7.0
6.7
6.5
6.0
Severe downturn
7.0
9.0
8.0
7.0
6.5
7.1
8.8
8.4
8.0
7.5
Bank base rate
Upside
4.8
4.0
3.5
3.5
3.3
2.0
2.0
1.5
1.5
1.5
Core
5.0
4.5
4.3
4.3
4.0
4.8
4.3
4.0
3.8
3.5
Downturn
6.0
5.5
5.5
4.0
3.5
6.3
5.5
5.0
4.8
4.5
Severe downturn
7.0
6.0
5.5
5.0
5.0
2.0
–
–
–
–
204 | Financial Statements 205
31. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers (continued)
Expected Credit Losses (ECL) (continued)
The values in the table below are calculated as either a simple average of the rate across the 5 year forecasting period or as
peak to trough.
Upside
Core
Downturn
Severe downturn
2023
2022
2022
2023
5 year average
GDP
1.8
2.1
1.0
1.2
0.2
(1.6)
(0.8)
(2.4)
HPI
3.4
2.0
1.7
(0.6)
(1.5)
(3.1)
(6.4)
(6.5)
Unemployment
4.0
3.6
4.6
4.9
5.8
6.4
7.6
7.8
Bank base rate
4.0
1.8
4.5
4.1
5.1
5.3
5.8
0.7
Peak to trough
GDP
–
–
(4.7)
(6.7)
(0.9)
(6.6)
(1.8)
(7.5)
HPI
–
–
(14.1)
(6.5)
(9.7)
(14.3)
(26.1)
(26.4)
Unemployment
4.2
3.8
5.0
5.5
6.5
7.0
9.0
8.8
Weightings
The following table shows the expected credit loss under each of our four economic scenarios along with the weightings that
have been applied to arrive at the weighted average ECL. PMAs are calculated using the weighted scenario results and so their
sensitivity in each of the individual scenarios cannot be accurately determined. For completeness they have been included as
a uniform adjustment across each scenario.
Group
Weighting
ECL
Weighting
ECL
Scenario
%
£m
%
£m
Upside
5
35.3
5
37.6
Core
40
38.7
50
40.7
Downturn
35
63.9
30
73.5
Severe downturn
20
102.1
15
94.2
Weighted scenario
100
60.0
100
58.4
A modelling approach using quantitative analysis is applied to assess the weightings which uses industry‑level write‑off
data to infer the Society’s loss rates over the period, as internal loss data isn’t available to establish a historical loss rate
distribution which reflects the nature of our losses (i.e. relatively low losses in ‘normal’ times but the potential to make more
substantial losses in recessionary conditions). An econometric model was developed which could be used to infer future loss
rates based on a range of different economic scenarios.
The loss rates were mapped under each of the IFRS 9 economic scenarios to the historical loss rate distribution and using the
distribution‑defined probabilities of each loss rate being realised to derive relative likelihoods of each scenario occurring.
SME judgment is applied in the final assessment of weights, informed by assessment of the quantitative analysis/model. The
core scenario weighting has decreased and the downturn and severe downturn scenario weightings have increased to reflect
the revisions made to Bank of England forecasts as well as the ongoing economic consequences of the conflict in Ukraine and
the Middle East.
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
Post model adjustments
Post model adjustments (‘PMA’) are applied when an increase in credit risk is identified that is not effectively captured in the
core expected credit loss models. A rigorous review of the PMAs has been performed to determine whether the identified risks
are still applicable, and if any additional risks have been identified. Adjustments were made to which PMAs were required and
to the magnitude of those that were maintained.
A PMA working group has been established in 2023 encompassing colleagues from Finance, Balance Sheet Management
and Credit Risk. This working group has been used to review the on‑going suitability of existing PMAs and discuss whether
additional PMAs are required in relation to emerging risks or issues.
The PMAs applied at 31 December 2023 are as follows:
2022
£m
£m
Affordability
7.1
10.8
Model Performance
10.0
6.6
Other
(1.5)
7.1
Total PMA
15.6
24.5
Affordability
Inflation is not a direct input into the underlying ECL models and, as such, does not have a direct influence on the output.
Although the lending undertaken by the Society is risk‑averse, with a significant amount of affordability assessment
undertaken as part of the decision to advance mortgage loans, there are several segments of the mortgage book that are likely
to be at greater risk of affordability stresses due to the cost‑of‑living pressures.
A post model adjustment was established to reflect the risks of rising inflation, and its impact on customers’ ability to meet
repayments on their mortgage, not captured in the underlying ECL models.
The PMA has been established by considering affordability levels of the mortgage book by applying a stress to the monthly
expenditure amounts to reflect external pressures such as increase in outgoings, interest rate changes, cost‑of‑living
challenges and income decreases. Both elements are used to identify accounts that would be most vulnerable to stresses and
find their mortgage unaffordable.
The PMA has been refined over 2023 as actual increases in credit risk in relation to affordability materialise and are being
captured within the ECL models.
PD estimates of the accounts identified as vulnerable to affordability stresses are uplifted to the equivalent of what they
would need to be for the model to assign them to stage 2 as a result of meeting the SICR criteria.
The level of uplifted PD applied varies depending on whether the customer has a fixed term end date in the next 12 months,
the current risk grade associated with the account and how close the account is to SICR thresholds with accounts that are
relatively close to meeting the SICR criteria will be higher risk.
New criteria for identifying accounts to be treated within this PMA has been established.
Further consideration has been given to segments of the book that have been under‑represented in this assessment and
the Group has considered whether the coverage in these areas is sufficient to cover the increased risk to the book given
the current macro‑economic climate. Relative insensitivity to the stresses provided above was found and so an additional
provision has been raised to cover this underestimation.
These specific segments are:
•
Commercial – The Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR) test is used for assessing affordability of accounts and compares
the rental income to the mortgage payment where rent needs to cover 100% or more of the payment on a capital and
interest basis. Stress has been applied to this test to assess the impact on affordability levels.
•
Buy‑to‑let (BTL) – This segment of the book has similar behaviours to a cohort of mortgages included in the main
affordability assessment and so an appropriate uplift factor has been applied to replicate a stressed environment.
206 | Financial Statements 207
31. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers (continued)
Expected Credit Losses (ECL) (continued)
Post model adjustments (continued)
Affordability (continued)
The decrease in this PMA is due to a combination of the increased credit risk as a result of the impact of the cost‑of‑living
crisis on mortgage repayments starting to emerge as either increased modelled ECLs or write offs leading to a more targeted
methodology resulting in a lower PMA required, as well as easing inflation and mortgage rates across the industry beginning
to reduce; this means the payment shock experienced by customers might reduce going forward. This PMA will be monitored
as we progress through the year and will be held until a sufficient reduction in inflation and cost‑of‑living pressures is
observed.
Model Performance
PD Underprediction
The Society’s fourth generation models were used as the basis of underpinning the Society’s ECLs in 2023 for the first time. A
level of underprediction, that was observed within the third generation models, is also present in the new fourth generation
models. A PMA has been established to account for this which adjusts the PD estimates used to establish ECLs. Accounts are
then re‑staged if their revised PD estimate exceeds the SICR threshold for the risk grade.
Predictive accuracy monitoring on a perfect foresight basis has been developed by the Society to support an evaluation of
the risk. This monitoring has been produced at a product level over a range of outcome periods. The results for each portfolio
were evaluated and the need for an adjustment was acknowledged. The under‑prediction factors for Prime and BTL have been
incorporated into PD estimates by directly uplifting each month’s PD estimate by the associated under‑prediction factor and
recalculating staging and ECLs using the adjusted PD value.
Sensitivity of Models to Economic Stresses
The fourth generation IFRS 9 PD model has displayed limited sensitivity to the different economic scenarios as a result of the
benign economic conditions in the data period used to develop the model. A narrow range in average PD estimates across the
four economic scenarios of differing severity highlighted the model weakness. A PMA has been established to mitigate against
the lack of sensitivity in IFRS 9 PDs to economic factors.
An internally developed Credit Cycle Index (CCI) model was used with its ability to perform well under a range of different
economic conditions making it a useful tool in informing this PMA. The results of the CCI model across the different IFRS 9
scenarios were established and outcomes from the Core scenario compared to the Upside, Downside and Stress scenarios.
Adjustments were then applied to these non‑Core scenarios to produce adjusted PD estimates for each individual scenario. As
this PMA is driven by a weakness that will be inherent within both initial and current PDs, it was not considered appropriate to
adjust stage allocation based on the adjusted results.
Methodology Changes and Model Recalibration
Fourth generation IFRS 9 models and impacts were presented to the Society’s Model Risk Committee in 2023 and approved
for use. These have been used as the basis for generating Core model ECLs for this reporting period. Both the Methodology
Changes and Model Recalibration PMAs related to the third generation IFRS 9 models have been released as they are no
longer required. The reduction in ECL associated with the stage 2 movement noted has outweighed other aspects of the
migration to the fourth generation models that would have increased ECLs, leading to an overall release in 2023 on initial
implementation.
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
Other
Whilst we incorporate a range of economic assumptions in the scenarios and probability weightings used to calculate ECL,
this approach still has certain limitations where several assumptions cannot be considered within the model or is restricted by
when external data is available. The PMAs detailed below aim to cover for these risks.
House Price Volatility
This PMA originally focused on house price volatility developed in response to extraordinary growth in house prices since the
easing of the first COVID‑19 lockdown with two elements of uncertainty being assessed.
The first element relates to changes in HPI at a regional level not being evenly distributed and the ECL impact of changes
in collateral values is non‑linear. Management have since evaluated the support for the £1.0 million PMA recognised and
concluded that it is not significantly different to warrant a specific PMA, hence the release of this element of the PMA for 2023
year end.
The remaining element of this PMA relates to the risk that the ONS (Office for National Statistics) indexation data that is
incorporated into the ECL model on a quarterly basis is not a true representative of the market conditions as at 31 December
2023. The latest indexation from ONS was for data collected in Q3 of 2023. This PMA aims to correct for the update in market
conditions by using an average of Nationwide and Halifax more recent indexations for Q4 of 2023.
The HPI assumptions applied in the underlying economic scenarios estimate the impacts of future HPI trends at a macro level
based on the current baseline.
Climate risk
We have assessed the risks associated with climate change, both physical and transitional, in the context of ECL and
concluded that the majority of these risks do not meet the requirements for recognition as:
There have been no observed climate related defaults and therefore no identifiable significant increase in credit risks (‘SICR’);
and the material transition risks identified are expected to occur over a timescale in excess of the current behavioural life of
our portfolio (i.e. the average term before a customer either moves onto an alternative deal or transfers to another provider)
and, as such, any potential impact would be against loans yet to be underwritten.
This PMA aims to identify properties which are or will in the near future be at most risk from a climate perspective and assess
the additional ECLs that we could expect to incur if material costs/reductions to the value of security arise from those risks.
The four main risks considered are Energy Performance Certificate (EPC) impacts, flood risk, subsidence risk and coastal
erosion risk.
A similar approach has been taken within each of these areas where the properties with the very highest risks associated
are identified, appropriate adjustments are applied to the valuation of the properties and the impacts of these changes then
quantified and held as a PMA. The total PMA held is £0.7 million (2022: £1.0 million).
Standard Variable Rate (SVR)
The December 2022 Base Rate increase was not being incorporated into YBS variable rates until February 2023, and so a PMA
of £0.4 million (2022: nil) was raised to account for the impact on ECL should it take effect immediately. This PMA has been
released as the updated SVR rate has now been applied at account level.
208 | Financial Statements 209
31. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers (continued)
Expected Credit Losses (ECL) (continued)
Staging and POCI
The tables below show the staging of loans and advances plus those classed as purchased or originated credit impaired (POCI)
recognised as part of the acquisitions of Norwich & Peterborough Building Society (N&P) and Chelsea Building Society (CBS).
The fair value discount applied on acquisition is recognised as the
fair value credit adjustment
.
The Group has £339.7 million of POCI loans (2022: £385.4 million). Of these, 85% (2022: 88%) are now considered
performing loans but are not permitted to be reclassified to stage 1 or 2.
Details of the movements in staging are explained in the
movement analysis
section of this note.
Gross exposure
PMA
Total ECL
Coverage
Average LTV
£m
%
£m
£m
%
%
2023
Stage 1
41,597.7
88.8
3.0
8.5
–
50.2
Stage 2
4,521.8
9.6
13.1
26.5
0.6
36.5
Stage 3
409.4
0.9
(0.5)
13.8
3.4
42.5
POCI
339.7
0.7
–
11.2
3.3
40.1
Total
46,868.6
100.0
15.6
60.0
0.1
49.0
2022
Stage 1
40,251.1
88.9
3.0
7.5
–
49.0
Stage 2
4,277.3
9.5
18.1
26.3
0.6
33.7
Stage 3
338.3
0.7
3.4
11.3
3.3
39.4
POCI
385.4
0.9
–
13.3
3.5
40.5
Total
45,252.1
100.0
24.5
58.4
0.1
46.8
The
cost of risk
measure has been calculated using the impairment charge for the year divided by the average balance over
the period of which is 0.01% for 2023.
Problem loans
represent the total of the Group’s stage 3 balances and the non‑
performing portion of our POCI loans.
2022
£m
%
£m
%
Gross exposures
Stage 1
41,597.7
88.8
40,251.1
88.9
Stage 2
4,521.8
9.6
4,277.3
9.5
Stage 3
409.4
0.9
338.3
0.7
POCI
339.7
0.7
385.4
0.9
Total gross exposures
46,868.6
100.0
45,252.1
100.0
Problem loans
458.9
1.0
384.7
0.9
Cost of risk
–
–
–
–
ECL and Coverage ratios
Stage 1
8.5
–
7.5
–
Stage 2
26.5
0.6
26.3
0.6
Stage 3
13.8
3.4
11.3
3.3
POCI
11.2
3.3
13.3
3.5
Total ECL
60.0
0.1
58.4
0.1
Of which impairment
37.7
62.8
33.1
56.7
Of which fair value credit adjustment
22.3
37.2
25.3
43.3
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
The following table shows expected credit losses, split by impairment and fair value credit adjustments, and a best estimate
of the collateral against these mortgages. The collateral is calculated as the lower of the value of the property and the
outstanding loan amount so does not represent the overall value of properties backing the loans.
Group
Gross exposure
Collateral
Impairment
Fair value credit
adjustment
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
Stage 1
41,597.7
40,251.1
41,596.3
40,249.7
8.5
7.5
–
–
Stage 2
4,521.8
4,277.3
4,521.4
4,277.0
25.3
23.4
1.2
2.9
Less than 30 days past due
4,331.4
4,156.1
4,331.1
4,155.8
22.6
22.0
0.9
2.7
More than 30 days past due
190.4
121.2
190.3
121.2
2.7
1.4
0.3
0.2
Stage 3
409.4
338.3
409.1
338.0
10.0
9.2
3.8
2.1
Less than 30 days past due
161.1
155.6
161.1
155.6
2.2
3.3
0.5
0.4
30‑90 days past due
83.8
64.9
83.8
64.9
1.1
1.1
0.5
0.3
More than 90 days past due
164.5
117.8
164.2
117.5
6.7
4.8
2.8
1.4
POCI
339.7
385.4
339.1
385.0
(6.1)
(7.0)
17.3
20.3
Less than 30 days past due
294.5
346.7
293.9
346.3
(6.1)
(6.4)
14.6
17.3
30‑90 days past due
29.4
20.8
29.4
20.8
0.3
(0.1)
1.2
0.9
More than 90 days past due
15.8
17.9
15.8
17.9
(0.3)
(0.5)
1.5
2.1
Total
46,868.6
45,252.1
46,865.9
45,249.7
37.7
33.1
22.3
25.3
Society
Gross exposure
Collateral
Impairment
Fair value credit
adjustment
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
Stage 1
9,233.4
8,942.6
9,232.0
8,941.3
2.8
4.0
–
–
Stage 2
1,294.3
1,889.1
1,294.0
1,889.0
10.1
9.3
1.3
3.0
Less than 30 days past due
1,236.5
1,845.8
1,236.2
1,845.7
9.1
8.9
1.0
2.8
More than 30 days past due
57.8
43.3
57.8
43.3
1.0
0.4
0.3
0.2
Stage 3
133.8
111.0
133.8
110.9
1.7
1.5
3.7
2.1
Less than 30 days past due
55.8
52.9
55.8
53.0
0.4
0.7
0.5
0.4
30‑90 days past due
24.2
22.9
24.2
22.8
0.2
0.3
0.5
0.3
More than 90 days past due
53.8
35.2
53.8
35.1
1.1
0.5
2.7
1.4
POCI
339.6
385.1
339.0
384.7
(6.1)
(7.0)
17.3
20.2
Less than 30 days past due
294.4
346.4
293.8
346.0
(6.1)
(6.4)
14.6
17.2
30‑90 days past due
29.4
20.8
29.4
20.8
0.3
(0.1)
1.2
0.9
More than 90 days past due
15.8
17.9
15.8
17.9
(0.3)
(0.5)
1.5
2.1
Total
11,001.1
11,327.8
10,998.8
11,325.9
8.5
7.8
22.3
25.3
All accounts in stage 1 are less than 30 days past due.
210 | Financial Statements 211
31. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers (continued)
Lending by type
Group
Percentage split of gross contractual exposure
%
%
Residential Prime
79.8
81.4
Residential Sub‑Prime/Self‑Cert
0.4
0.5
Retail Buy‑To‑Let
15.4
14.3
Social Housing
0.4
0.5
Commercial lending (exc. Social Housing)
4.0
3.3
100.0
100.0
Credit risk management
The
Retail and commercial credit risk
section of the
Risk management report
describes how the Group manages credit risk via a
robust risk appetite, credit risk framework, governance framework and through stress testing.
The Group’s exposure to mortgage related credit risk is monitored and reporting on risk exposures is provided regularly to the
Group’s risk committees, including analysis of mortgages in arrears and monitoring of the characteristics of the loan portfolios
(e.g. geographic location and loan‑to‑value).
Group 2023
Retail
Commercial
Retail
Commercial
Arrears
%
%
%
%
No arrears
97.6
98.7
98.3
96.8
Less than three months
2.1
0.8
1.3
3.2
Equal to or more than three months, less than six months
0.2
0.3
0.2
–
Equal to or more than six months, less than twelve months
0.1
0.1
0.1
–
Twelve months or more
–
0.1
0.1
–
Property in possession
–
–
–
–
Total gross exposure (contractual amounts)
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
Number of properties in possession at the year end
67
–
49
–
The percentage of retail mortgages with arrears of three months or more (as a % of outstanding balances, including
possessions) has increased during 2023 from 0.31% to 0.39%.
The UK Finance industry average ratio for mortgage arrears is measured using the number of accounts (including possessions).
On this basis, the Group’s retail mortgage arrears ratio of 0.50% (2022: 0.44%) is below the comparable UK Finance ratio
0.94% (2022: 0.74%). Arrears on more recent lending are minimal, reflecting the Group’s credit risk appetite.
Arrears for the buy‑to‑let portfolio is also lower than average with an arrears ratio of 0.23% (2022: 0.13%) with an average
LTV of 45.8 (2022: 43.1) for this cohort.
Society 2023
Arrears
%
%
No arrears
97.0
97.9
Less than three months
2.3
1.5
Equal to or more than three months, less than six months
0.3
0.3
Equal to or more than six months, less than twelve months
0.2
0.1
Twelve months or more
0.1
0.1
Property in possession
0.1
0.1
Total
100.0
100.0
Number of properties in possession at the year end
48
39
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
Retail mortgage lending
The Group’s retail mortgage exposure can be broken down by customer type and geographical region as follows:
Group Book
New lending
2022
2022
Retail Mortgage Customer Type
%
%
%
%
First‑time buyer
23.6
24.4
23.5
21.8
Other buyers e.g. movers
35.5
37.1
29.6
32.1
Re‑mortgage
24.8
23.5
32.5
21.3
Buy‑to‑let
16.1
15.0
14.4
24.8
Other
–
–
–
–
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
2023 2022
Retail Mortgage Geographical Distribution
%
%
Scotland
6.6
6.4
North East
3.2
3.2
Yorkshire & Humberside
8.4
8.5
North West
10.4
10.3
Midlands
13.2
13.0
East
10.8
10.7
South West
7.5
7.4
Greater London
18.1
18.7
South East
17.6
17.8
Wales & Northern Ireland
4.2
4.0
Non‑UK
–
–
100.0
100.0
The Group’s retail mortgages are secured on property. The value of these properties is updated on a quarterly basis using the
Office for National Statistics (ONS) regional property price indices which comprise relative house price movements across the
UK. These indexed valuations provide senior management with a view of the value and risk of the properties on which retail
mortgages are secured.
212 | Financial Statements 213
31. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers (continued)
Retail mortgage lending (continued)
Group
Book
New lending
2022
Loan-to-value distribution of retail mortgages
%
%
%
%
100% or greater
–
–
–
–
95 to 100%
0.3
–
–
–
90 to 95%
1.6
0.2
4.6
5.3
85 to 90%
4.2
1.6
17.2
18.7
80 to 85%
5.9
4.3
15.7
16.1
75 to 80%
7.4
6.8
9.4
10.8
70 to 75%
9.5
10.0
13.0
19.1
60 to 70%
21.0
23.4
12.3
12.2
Less than 60%
50.1
53.7
27.8
17.8
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
Average LTV (all retail)
49.0
46.8
67.2
71.7
Average LTV (buy‑to‑let)
54.8
53.4
58.9
68.6
Group 2023
Not impaired
Impaired
Not impaired
Impaired
Loan-to-value distribution of retail mortgages
%
%
%
%
100% or greater
–
–
–
–
95 to 100%
0.3
–
–
–
90 to 95%
1.6
–
0.3
–
85 to 90%
4.2
–
1.7
–
80 to 85%
5.9
–
4.3
–
75 to 80%
7.4
–
6.7
–
70 to 75%
9.4
0.1
9.9
–
60 to 70%
20.8
0.2
23.1
0.3
Less than 60%
48.9
1.2
52.4
1.3
98.5
1.5
98.4
1.6
The definition of default/impaired includes accounts that are 90 days past due, interest only accounts past term end,
those under certain forbearance measures and others exhibiting other unlikeliness to pay indicators. Accounting standards
require accounts considered to be credit impaired at the time of business combinations (POCI) to be classed as impaired
until derecognition.
Commercial lending
The Group offers commercial lending though the YBS brand, providing loans to commercial owner occupiers and corporate
entity landlords of commercial and residential property. The majority of loans are advanced against commercial properties
using a vacant possession valuation to mitigate against future losses. Loans against specialist properties are strictly limited
and no lending is given against land only.
The valuations of commercial properties are updated on a quarterly basis using MSCI’s commercial property price indices
based on region and property type. Residential valuations are indexed using the regional ONS house price indices. The
indexed valuations are used to assess the risk of loss on individual loans and to monitor whether loan‑to‑value covenants
are met. Where borrowers are more than two months in arrears, consideration is given to obtaining a professional valuation
of the property.
Group and Society
2022
Average loan‑to‑value (%)
55.8
48.4
Average loan size (£m)
0.7
0.6
Value of security held (£m)
3,213.0
3,018.6
Balance of loans >100% LTV (£m)
21.9
6.2
Largest exposure to a single counterparty (£m)
20.0
18.0
At the year end 0.54% (2022: 0.03%) of commercial balances (including repossessions) were more than three months in
arrears.
‘Watch list’ loans include those where there are circumstances which could impact on the quality and recoverability of the
loan. Examples include borrowers requesting forbearance or reporting trading losses. Loans on the watch list total increased
to £46.9 million in 2023 (2022: £31.4 million).
Corporate buy‑to‑let loans increased to £1,207.3 million (2022: £884.1 million) and these loans are mainly interest only. They
are continuously monitored to ensure that full repayment is made on the expiry of the loan term.
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
214 | Financial Statements 215
31. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers (continued)
Commercial lending
Group and Society
2023
2022
Commercial mortgage balances by geographical region
%
%
Scotland
–
–
North East
0.5
0.4
Yorkshire & Humberside
2.5
2.8
North West
4.2
4.8
Midlands
5.8
6.6
East
3.1
3.5
South West
7.1
6.6
Greater London
49.8
49.0
South East
25.8
25.3
Wales & Northern Ireland
1.2
1.0
100.0
100.0
Group and Society
2023
2022
Commercial mortgage balances by lending type
%
%
Commercial owner occupied
2.6
3.9
Commercial investment property*
29.7
32.4
Corporate buy‑to‑ let*
59.0
51.6
Social Housing
8.7
12.1
100.0
100.0
The Group has an active business lending to housing associations in England and Wales, via the Yorkshire Building
Society brand. This sector has particularly robust credit characteristics and the lending is low risk albeit at low margins. At
31 December 2023 this loan book was £177.9 million (2022: £202.0 million). The Group has written further undrawn Term
Loan/Revolving Credit facilities in the region of £136.1 million (2022: £164.2 million) and these are expected to draw down
over the next 5 years.
* Please note prior year figures for Commercial mortgage balances split by lending type have been restated due to transitioning to an alternative
data source.
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
Risk assessment
The following tables are included to give an overview of the Group’s credit risk. This includes analysis of exposures by
12 month probability of default (PD) bands and origination year.
The risk models cover the majority of loans underwritten by the Group, with exceptions for portfolios subject to bespoke
modelling requirements including Accord buy‑to‑let, commercial lending and POCI accounts. The Accord BTL population
currently has very strict underwriting criteria and limited behavioural history, with only a single possession to date.
Commercial lending has significantly different behavioural characteristics to the retail mortgages.
Lending by risk grade
Group
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
ECL
Total
ECL
exposure exposure
PD Band
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
0.00%–<0.15%
26,735.6
1,936.1
–
–
28,671.7
1.0
32,792.6
1.7
0.15%–<0.25%
3,581.6
338.1
–
–
3,919.7
0.5
1,888.6
0.7
0.25%–<0.50%
1,114.8
172.1
–
–
1,286.9
0.4
484.6
0.3
0.50%–<0.75%
692.3
199.2
–
–
891.5
0.3
583.6
0.7
0.75%–<1.00%
559.9
308.4
–
–
868.3
0.6
334.1
0.8
1.00%–<2.50%
327.5
910.0
–
–
1,237.5
3.2
698.2
3.4
2.50%–<10.0%
25.4
288.3
–
–
313.7
2.8
205.1
2.5
10.0%–<100%
14.5
161.0
–
–
175.5
2.5
116.4
2.3
Default
–
–
390.7
39.3
430.0
14.8
366.6
11.1
Accord buy‑to‑let
6,606.8
101.1
7.5
–
6,715.4
3.6
5,905.6
6.3
Commercial
1,771.5
74.4
11.2
10.2
1,867.3
9.3
1,510.6
4.5
Other
167.8
33.1
–
290.2
491.1
9.0
366.1
10.3
PMAs
–
–
–
–
–
12.0
–
13.8
Total
41,597.7
4,521.8
409.4
339.7
46,868.6
60.0
45,252.1
58.4
Society
2022
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
ECL
Total
ECL
exposure exposure
PD Band
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
0.00%–<0.15%
5,987.8
563.2
–
–
6,551.0
0.2
7,455.4
0.2
0.15%–<0.25%
674.3
98.3
–
–
772.6
0.2
710.1
0.2
0.25%–<0.50%
200.0
54.8
–
–
254.8
0.2
172.4
0.1
0.50%–<0.75%
144.3
58.7
–
–
203.0
0.1
264.1
0.4
0.75%–<1.00%
127.7
84.4
–
–
212.1
0.2
193.0
0.6
1.00%–<2.50%
131.9
203.8
–
–
335.7
0.9
362.1
2.5
2.50%–<10.0%
20.8
66.8
–
–
87.6
0.8
98.6
1.5
10.0%–<100%
9.0
55.7
–
–
64.7
0.9
52.9
1.2
Default
–
–
122.6
39.2
161.8
6.8
143.6
7.2
Commercial
1,771.0
74.4
11.2
10.2
1,866.8
9.3
1,509.7
4.5
Other
166.6
34.2
–
290.2
491.0
8.9
365.9
9.1
PMAs
–
–
–
–
–
2.3
–
5.6
Total
9,233.4
1,294.3
133.8
339.6
11,001.1
30.8
11,327.8
33.1
216 | Financial Statements 217
31. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers (continued)
Risk assessment (continued)
Lending by origination year
The table below shows exposures and expected credit losses by origination year for retail loans. The table shows that the
credit quality of newly written business is of significantly higher quality than that written before 2009 or acquired as part of
business combinations.
Group
2023
2022
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
ECL
Total
ECL
exposure exposure
Origination Year
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
2023
8,625.6
555.4
18.2
–
9,199.2
6.5
–
–
2022
8,873.1
673.9
23.7
–
9,570.7
8.2
10,184.5
7.6
2021
6,337.0
632.2
41.4
–
7,010.6
6.3
9,260.3
6.3
2020
3,930.3
409.6
29.0
–
4,368.9
3.0
4,914.3
3.6
2013 – 2019
11,620.1
1,245.8
113.7
–
12,979.6
11.2
16,452.8
11.9
2009 – 2012
781.7
94.3
8.1
–
884.1
0.4
1,056.3
0.6
Pre‑2009
650.9
580.0
104.7
–
1,335.6
5.8
1,560.7
6.4
Acquired loans
779.0
330.6
70.6
339.7
1,519.9
18.6
1,823.2
22.0
Total
41,597.7
4,521.8
409.4
339.7
46,868.6
60.0
45,252.1
58.4
For 2009 and post lending, the average indexed LTV is 53.0% and the 90 days plus arrears rate is 0.2%. For lending prior to
2009 the average indexed LTV is 25.6% and the 90 days arrears rate is 3.1%.
Movement analysis
The tables on pages 219 to 222 detail the movement in the gross exposures and ECL from the beginning to the end of the
reporting period split by stage. The Society has updated the definition of default and the probability of default rating scale
on the back of a comprehensive review as part of the transition to the fourth generation internal ratings based (Gen 4 IRB)
method of calculating regulatory capital. These model updates were approved for use in the core underlying models in the
first half of this year and all ECL outputs have been updated to reflect these changes.
There was a known misalignment between the initial recognition PDs and the current PDs compared within staging transfer
criteria for accounts that originated prior to the implementation of the third generation model recalibration which took place
in 2018. Enhancements have been made within the fourth generation developments to alleviate the impact of this, resulting
in a large reduction of stage 2 volumes and associated ECLs. This can be seen on the Transfers from stage 2 to 1 line of the
gross exposures movement table.
The level of PD underprediction, that was observed within the third generation models, is still present to an extent in the new
fourth generation models. A PMA has been established to account for this which adjusts the PD estimates used to establish
ECLs. Accounts are then re‑staged if their revised PD estimate exceeds the SICR threshold for the risk grade. This can be seen
on the Transfers from stage 1 to 2 line of the gross exposures movement table.
Separate to the fourth generation model update, we have reassessed the affordability PMA throughout the year. At half year
all balances in relation to the affordability PMA were recognised in stage 1 due to the accounts identified through the PMA
not moving into arrears or meeting any of the quantitative (i.e. SICR thresholds) or qualitative criteria for being assigned to
stage 2. The ECL related to the PMA had previously been recognised in stage 2, the movement from stage 2 to stage 1 to align
with balances can be seen on the PMA line of the ECL movement table below.
Following ongoing monitoring of actuals and the Gen 4 model the affordability PMA was re‑evaluated with a focus on the
most vulnerable accounts. Those accounts identified by the criteria disclosed on page 207 had their PD estimates uplifted to
the equivalent of what they would need to be for the model to assign them to stage 2 as a result of meeting the SICR criteria
allowing re‑staging from stage 1 to stage 2 to occur. This can be seen on the transfers from stage 1 to 2 line of the gross
exposures movement table.
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
The following tables detail the movement in the gross exposures and ECL from the beginning to the end of the reporting
period split by class of financial instrument.
Group
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
Gross exposure at 31 December 2022
40,251.1
4,277.3
338.3
385.4
45,252.1
Transfers from stage 1 to 2
(3,200.5)
3,200.5
–
–
–
Transfers from stage 1 to 3
(77.4)
–
77.4
–
–
Transfers from stage 2 to 1
2,428.8
(2,428.8)
–
–
–
Transfers from stage 2 to 3
–
(111.8)
111.8
–
–
Transfers from stage 3 to 1
26.9
–
(26.9)
–
–
Transfers from stage 3 to 2
–
57.7
(57.7)
–
–
Changes to carrying value
(1,397.6)
(45.7)
10.9
(9.1)
(1,441.5)
New financial assets originated or purchased
9,020.6
–
–
–
9,020.6
Financial assets derecognised during the year
(5,454.2)
(427.4)
(40.4)
(35.5)
(5,957.5)
Write‑offs
–
–
(4.0)
(1.1)
(5.1)
Gross exposure at 31 December 2023
41,597.7
4,521.8
409.4
339.7
46,868.6
ECL at 31 December 2022
7.5
26.3
11.3
13.3
58.4
Transfers from stage 1 to 2
(0.2)
6.0
–
–
5.8
Transfers from stage 1 to 3
–
–
2.6
–
2.6
Transfers from stage 2 to 1
0.9
(4.7)
–
–
(3.8)
Transfers from stage 2 to 3
–
(1.1)
3.4
–
2.3
Transfers from stage 3 to 1
–
–
(0.6)
–
(0.6)
Transfers from stage 3 to 2
–
0.3
(0.8)
–
(0.5)
Changes in PDs/LGDs/EADs
(1.8)
8.0
3.7
0.1
10.0
New financial assets originated or purchased
3.6
–
–
–
3.6
Changes to model assumptions and methodologies
(1.3)
(1.9)
(0.1)
(0.6)
(3.9)
Unwind of discount
–
–
0.4
0.3
0.7
Financial assets derecognised during the year
(0.2)
(1.5)
(1.2)
(1.4)
(4.3)
Write‑offs
–
–
(1.0)
(0.5)
(1.5)
PMA
–
(4.9)
(3.9)
–
(8.8)
ECL at 31 December 2023
8.5
26.5
13.8
11.2
60.0
218 | Financial Statements 219
31. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers (continued)
Movement analysis (continued)
Group
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
Gross exposure at 31 December 2021
37,614.0
3,791.2
366.2
440.1
42,211.5
Transfers from stage 1 to 2
(1,562.2)
1,562.2
–
–
–
Transfers from stage 1 to 3
(59.0)
–
59.0
–
–
Transfers from stage 2 to 1
830.1
(830.1)
–
–
–
Transfers from stage 2 to 3
–
(69.4)
69.4
–
–
Transfers from stage 3 to 1
25.2
–
(25.2)
–
–
Transfers from stage 3 to 2
–
71.1
(71.1)
–
–
Changes to carrying value
(1,850.4)
227.4
6.9
(8.7)
(1,624.8)
New financial assets originated or purchased
10,588.7
–
–
–
10,588.7
Financial assets derecognised during the year
(5,335.3)
(475.1)
(62.0)
(45.5)
(5,917.9)
Write‑offs
–
–
(4.9)
(0.5)
(5.4)
Gross exposure at 31 December 2022
40,251.1
4,277.3
338.3
385.4
45,252.1
ECL at 31 December 2021
5.6
17.5
15.4
16.0
54.5
Transfers from stage 1 to 2
(0.1)
3.1
–
–
3.0
Transfers from stage 1 to 3
–
–
1.4
–
1.4
Transfers from stage 2 to 1
0.3
(2.2)
–
–
(1.9)
Transfers from stage 2 to 3
–
(0.9)
1.7
–
0.8
Transfers from stage 3 to 1
–
–
(0.6)
–
(0.6)
Transfers from stage 3 to 2
–
0.8
(1.5)
–
(0.7)
Changes in PDs/LGDs/EADs
(1.0)
3.7
1.9
(0.9)
3.7
New financial assets originated or purchased
3.4
–
–
–
3.4
Changes to model assumptions and methodologies
(1.5)
(3.3)
(3.1)
(0.6)
(8.5)
Unwind of discount
–
–
0.5
0.6
1.1
Financial assets derecognised during the year
(0.2)
(2.2)
(2.2)
(1.7)
(6.3)
Write‑offs
–
–
(1.0)
(0.1)
(1.1)
PMA
1.0
9.8
(1.2)
–
9.6
ECL at 31 December 2022
7.5
26.3
11.3
13.3
58.4
Society
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
Gross exposure at 31 December 2022
8,942.6
1,889.1
111.0
385.1
11,327.8
Transfers from stage 1 to 2
(835.5)
835.5
–
–
–
Transfers from stage 1 to 3
(18.0)
–
18.0
–
–
Transfers from stage 2 to 1
1,102.8
(1,102.8)
–
–
–
Transfers from stage 2 to 3
–
(46.5)
46.5
–
–
Transfers from stage 3 to 1
9.4
–
(9.4)
–
–
Transfers from stage 3 to 2
–
13.6
(13.6)
–
–
Changes to carrying value
(495.5)
(87.5)
(1.2)
(9.2)
(593.4)
New financial assets originated or purchased
1,377.4
–
–
–
1,377.4
Financial assets derecognised during the year
(849.8)
(207.1)
(15.8)
(35.2)
(1,107.9)
Write‑offs
–
–
(1.7)
(1.1)
(2.8)
Gross exposure at 31 December 2023
9,233.4
1,294.3
133.8
339.6
11,001.1
ECL at 31 December 2022
4.0
12.3
3.6
13.2
33.1
Transfers from stage 1 to 2
(0.1)
2.5
–
–
2.4
Transfers from stage 1 to 3
–
–
0.7
–
0.7
Transfers from stage 2 to 1
0.3
(2.7)
–
–
(2.4)
Transfers from stage 2 to 3
–
(0.6)
1.7
–
1.1
Transfers from stage 3 to 1
–
–
(0.2)
–
(0.2)
Transfers from stage 3 to 2
–
0.1
(0.2)
–
(0.1)
Changes in PDs/LGDs/EADs
(0.6)
5.2
2.8
(0.2)
7.2
New financial assets originated or purchased
1.2
–
–
–
1.2
Changes to model assumptions and methodologies
(0.4)
(0.8)
–
(0.6)
(1.8)
Unwind of discount
–
–
0.3
0.7
1.0
Financial assets derecognised during the year
(0.1)
(1.1)
(0.5)
(1.4)
(3.1)
Write‑offs
–
–
(0.3)
(0.5)
(0.8)
PMA
(1.5)
(3.5)
(2.5)
–
(7.5)
ECL at 31 December 2023
2.8
11.4
5.4
11.2
30.8
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
220 | Financial Statements 221
31. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers (continued)
Movement analysis (continued)
Society
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
Gross exposure at 31 December 2021
9,395.6
1,816.8
140.9
439.5
11,792.8
Transfers from stage 1 to 2
(566.9)
566.9
–
–
–
Transfers from stage 1 to 3
(13.4)
–
13.4
–
–
Transfers from stage 2 to 1
209.0
(209.0)
–
–
–
Transfers from stage 2 to 3
–
(26.6)
26.6
–
–
Transfers from stage 3 to 1
9.3
–
(9.3)
–
–
Transfers from stage 3 to 2
–
28.0
(28.0)
–
–
Changes to carrying value
(480.6)
(45.6)
(1.9)
(8.6)
(536.7)
New financial assets originated or purchased
1,529.3
–
–
–
1,529.3
Financial assets derecognised during the year
(1,139.7)
(241.4)
(28.5)
(45.3)
(1,454.9)
Write‑offs
–
–
(2.2)
(0.5)
(2.7)
Gross exposure at 31 December 2022
8,942.6
1,889.1
111.0
385.1
11,327.8
ECL at 31 December 2021
2.6
11.4
5.7
16.0
35.7
Transfers from stage 1 to 2
–
1.6
–
–
1.6
Transfers from stage 1 to 3
–
–
0.2
–
0.2
Transfers from stage 2 to 1
0.2
(1.0)
–
–
(0.8)
Transfers from stage 2 to 3
–
(0.5)
0.8
–
0.3
Transfers from stage 3 to 1
–
–
(0.2)
–
(0.2)
Transfers from stage 3 to 2
–
0.4
(0.7)
–
(0.3)
Changes in PDs/LGDs/EADs
1.0
–
(0.2)
(1.0)
(0.2)
New financial assets originated or purchased
0.9
–
–
–
0.9
Changes to model assumptions and methodologies
(0.8)
(1.5)
(1.0)
(0.6)
(3.9)
Unwind of discount
–
–
0.2
0.6
0.8
Financial assets derecognised during the year
(0.1)
(1.8)
(1.2)
(1.7)
(4.8)
Write‑offs
–
–
(0.6)
(0.1)
(0.7)
PMA
0.2
3.7
0.6
–
4.5
ECL at 31 December 2022
4.0
12.3
3.6
13.2
33.1
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
Forbearance
Forbearance tools are used, in line with industry guidance, where they are deemed appropriate for an individual customer’s
circumstances. These include capitalisation, interest only concessions, arrears arrangements and term extensions. Forbearance
measures are incorporated into the calculation of ECLs.
The table below shows the retail accounts that are forborne. These accounts have been further classified as follows:
•
non‑performing – where an account meets the definition of default at the point it is granted a forbearance measure; and
•
probationary – for accounts that have exited forbearance measures and been re‑classed from non‑performing in the last
2 years.
The definition of non‑performing and stage 3 are aligned such that no accounts in stage 2 are classed as non‑performing.
Any accounts that were previously in default have a cure period of 12 months, after which they are able to move back into
stage 2 or 1.
Group
Arrangements
Other concessions
Term extension
Interest only
Exposure
ECL
Exposure
ECL
Exposure
ECL
Exposure
ECL
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
2023
Probation
47.2
0.3
5.9
–
39.3
–
9.7
–
Stage 1
8.8
–
2.9
–
25.3
–
4.0
–
Stage 2
38.4
0.3
3.0
–
14.0
–
5.7
–
Non-performing
193.1
6.6
13.3
1.0
52.5
0.7
11.4
0.7
Stage 3
167.9
5.3
10.8
0.7
42.5
0.7
9.0
0.1
POCI
25.2
1.3
2.5
0.3
10.0
–
2.4
0.6
Total
240.3
6.9
19.2
1.0
91.8
0.7
21.1
0.7
2022
Probation
46.0
0.4
2.5
–
1.8
–
2.5
–
Stage 1
12.5
–
–
–
0.5
–
0.3
–
Stage 2
33.5
0.4
2.5
–
1.3
–
2.2
–
Non-performing
157.1
5.1
8.3
0.7
7.5
0.1
4.5
–
Stage 3
130.8
3.7
5.3
0.3
5.1
0.1
4.2
–
POCI
26.3
1.4
3.0
0.4
2.4
–
0.3
–
Total
203.1
5.5
10.8
0.7
9.3
0.1
7.0
–
All requests for forbearance on commercial loans are subject to full credit risk appraisal and are predominantly for a period of
interest only, which allows the borrower to improve income from trading or rent receipts, pending the sale of the property. The
appraisal process considers the likelihood of a loss being substantiated from any borrower granted a concession and ensures
that the concession is in the interests of both the borrower and the Group. In 2023 there were 3 accounts (2022: 13) in the
commercial loans portfolio subject to forbearance with a total balance of £1.6 million (2022: £4.1 million). There has been no
underlying increase in the risk of the portfolio.
222 | Financial Statements 223
31. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers (continued)
Loans Purchased or Originated Credit Impaired (POCI)
The table below shows the status of the Group’s POCI loans and how they are distributed across loan‑to‑value (LTV) bands.
A substantial proportion of POCI balances, were they not required to be classified as stage 3 by accounting standards, would
transfer to other stages. The table below shows that 69.4% (2022: 71.9%) of balances have been fully up to date for the last
24 months and only 14.6% (2022: 12.0%) of balances would be classified as in default.
Group and Society
Up to date
Some arrears Meets Total
for the last in the last definition of
24 months 24 months default
£m
£m
£m
£m
2023
Gross exposure
235.9
54.3
49.5
339.7
ECL
6.1
2.7
2.4
11.2
2022
Gross exposure
277.1
61.9
46.4
385.4
ECL
7.6
3.3
2.4
13.3
2023
LTV Split
Less than 60%
211.6
46.0
37.3
294.9
From 60 to 70%
16.6
5.0
9.3
30.9
From 70 to 80%
3.8
2.2
2.0
8.0
From 80 to 90%
1.0
0.8
0.2
2.0
90% or greater
2.9
0.3
0.7
3.9
Total
235.9
54.3
49.5
339.7
2022
LTV Split
Less than 60%
238.4
50.6
33.6
322.6
From 60 to 70%
25.8
6.9
10.6
43.3
From 70 to 80%
6.9
2.6
1.4
10.9
From 80 to 90%
2.1
0.7
0.2
3.0
90% or greater
3.9
1.1
0.6
5.6
Total
277.1
61.9
46.4
385.4
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
32. Fair values
Fair value is the price that would be received to sell an asset or the price paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction
between market participants at the measurement date.
Where external market prices are available they have been used to determine fair value. Otherwise, internal pricing models
using external market data have been used. The Group measures fair value using the following fair value hierarchy:
Level 1: Quoted prices (unadjusted) in active markets for identical assets or liabilities.
Level 2: Inputs other than quoted prices included within Level 1 that are observable for the asset or liability, either directly
(i.e. as prices) or indirectly (i.e. derived from prices).
Level 3: Inputs for the asset or liability that are not based on observable market data (unobservable inputs).
The table below summarises the carrying value and fair value of financial assets and liabilities measured at amortised cost as
at the balance sheet date.
Notes
Carrying
Fair values
Total fair
value
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
value
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
Group
Assets
Loans and advances to credit institutions
1
397.4
–
397.4
–
397.4
Loans and advances to customers
2
46,815.9
–
–
45,298.5
45,298.5
Debt securities – amortised cost
2,339.0
2,332.2
–
–
2,332.2
Liabilities
Shares
3
47,056.7
–
46,976.7
–
46,976.7
Amounts due to credit institutions
1,886.3
–
1,886.3
–
1,886.3
Other deposits
983.6
–
983.6
–
983.6
Debt securities in issue
4,919.4
4,222.9
693.4
–
4,916.3
Subordinated liabilities
4
1,621.7
1,566.8
32.4
–
1,599.2
Society
Assets
Loans and advances to credit institutions
1
208.6
–
208.6
–
208.6
Loans and advances to customers
2
10,920.6
–
–
10,502.6
10,502.6
Debt securities – amortised cost
14,131.4
14,116.2
–
–
14,116.2
Liabilities
Shares
3
47,056.7
–
46,976.7
–
46,976.7
Amounts due to credit institutions
1,886.3
–
1,886.3
–
1,886.3
Other deposits
14,080.2
–
14,080.2
–
14,080.2
Debt securities in issue
5,517.6
5,435.0
–
–
5,435.0
Subordinated liabilities
4
1,621.7
1,566.8
32.4
–
1,599.2
224 | Financial Statements 225
32. Fair values (continued)
2022
Notes
Carrying
Fair values
Total fair
value
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
value
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
Group
Assets
Loans and advances to credit institutions
1
814.7
–
814.7
–
814.7
Loans and advances to customers
2
45,203.7
–
–
43,002.8
43,002.8
Debt securities – amortised cost
1,366.6
1,352.3
–
–
1,352.3
Liabilities
Shares
3
42,008.2
–
41,835.3
–
41,835.3
Amounts due to credit institutions
5,160.9
–
5,160.9
–
5,160.9
Other deposits
1,138.1
–
1,138.1
–
1,138.1
Debt securities in issue
5,259.3
4,807.9
453.8
–
5,261.7
Subordinated liabilities
4
1,035.1
975.7
34.0
–
1,009.7
Society
Assets
Loans and advances to credit institutions
1
568.8
–
568.8
–
568.8
Loans and advances to customers
2
11,238.9
–
–
10,678.9
10,678.9
Debt securities – amortised cost
14,914.8
14,798.4
–
–
14,798.4
Liabilities
Shares
3
42,008.2
–
41,835.3
–
41,835.3
Amounts due to credit institutions
5,160.9
–
5,160.9
–
5,160.9
Other deposits
15,836.3
–
15,836.3
–
15,836.3
Debt securities in issue
6,153.4
6,013.6
–
–
6,013.6
Subordinated liabilities
4
1,035.1
975.7
34.0
–
1,009.7
1. The fair values of all cash in hand, balances with the Bank of England and loans and advances to credit institutions have been
measured at par as they are all due in under one year.
2. The fair value of loans and advances to customers is assessed as the value of the expected future cash flows. Future cash flows
are projected using contractual interest payments, contractual repayments and the expected prepayment behaviour of borrowers.
The resulting expected future cash flows are discounted at current market rates to determine fair value.
For standard variable rate mortgage products, the interest rate on such products is equivalent to a current market product rate
and as such the Group considers the fair value of these mortgages to be equal to their carrying value. Fixed rate mortgages have
been discounted using current market product rates. The difference between book value and fair value results from market rate
volatility relative to the fixed rate at inception of the loan; in addition to assumptions applied in relation to redemption profiles,
which are regularly reviewed and updated where necessary.
As these redemption profiles are not considered to be observable by the market, then the fair value of loans and advances
to customers continues to be a Level 3 valuation technique. Overall the fair value is lower than the carrying value by
£1,517.4 million (2022: £2,200.9 million lower), which arises primarily due to the fair value losses being calculated on a lifetime
basis for all mortgage accounts.
3. All of the Group’s non‑derivative financial liabilities are initially recorded at fair value less directly attributable costs and are
subsequently measured at amortised cost, except where an adjustment is made to certain fixed rate shares balances that are in
hedging relationships. The fair value of shares and deposits that are available on demand approximates to the carrying value. The
fair value of fixed term shares and deposits is determined from the projected future cash flows from those deposits, discounted
at the current market rates. In 2023, the estimated fair value of share balances, using a Level 2 method, is lower than the carrying
value by £80.0 million (2022: £172.9 million lower).
4. The Society accounts include some subordinated liabilities classified as Level 2 as fair values are calculated using a method
based on observable market prices. The fair value of subordinated liabilities, which is a fixed rate product, is lower than the
carrying value due to the significant increases in market rates over the course of the year.
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
The table below classifies all financial instruments held at fair value on the face of the Group’s balance sheet according to the
method used to establish the fair value.
Group
Fair values
Total fair
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
value
£m
£m
£m
£m
2023
Assets
Debt securities
27.3
–
–
27.3
Debt securities – fair value through OCI
5,195.7
–
–
5,195.7
Derivative financial instruments
–
1,751.9
3.1
1,755.0
Investments
–
–
3.3
3.3
Liabilities
Derivative financial instruments
–
697.4
–
697.4
2022
Assets
Debt securities
25.5
–
–
25.5
Debt securities – fair value through OCI
4,292.7
–
–
4,292.7
Derivative financial instruments
–
2,344.0
12.5
2,356.5
Investments
–
–
2.8
2.8
Liabilities
Derivative financial instruments
–
666.3
–
666.3
The Group’s Level 1 portfolio of available for sale debt securities comprises liquid securities for which traded prices are
readily available.
Some derivative financial instruments are also included within Level 2 as fair values are derived from discounted cash flow
models using yield curves based on observable market data.
Level 3 instruments
Derivative financial instruments within Level 3 are interest rate swaps held in the SPVs. These are valued using similar
valuation technique as Level 2 derivatives, namely present value calculations using interest rate curves, but these are not
based on market observable data.
The interest rate swaps are balance tracking and the swap notional is projected, and changes over time to match the
balance of the underlying mortgage portfolio. The changes in the fair value of these instruments from movements in Level 3
parameters related to prepayment risk will largely offset across the interest rate swaps as the Group is hedged across these
positions. Sensitivity analysis to the individual Level 3 parameters has not been disclosed on the basis that the Group does
not have a significant exposure to these.
Investments classified in Level 3 relate to the Group’s holding in equity preference shares. These shares are convertible into
common equity shares at various intervals during the life of the instrument, based on a conversion factor set by the issuer.
The valuation method therefore uses the quoted share price of the unrestricted stock as a base, applies the current estimated
conversion factor as advised by the issuer and applies a discount.
This discount reflects the current illiquidity of the instrument and the risks to changes in the conversion factor between the
balance sheet date and the next conversion date. Whilst the valuation is primarily based on an observable market price, the
level and significance of the unobservable input relating to the calculation of the discount moves this asset into Level 3.
Changes in the carrying value of Level 3 financial instruments in the period relate to the redemption of a derivative financial
instrument and changes in fair value. There have been no changes in methodology, additions or transfers in or out of Level 3
in the year.
Fair value through other comprehensive income and hedging reserve
Amounts within the fair value through other comprehensive income reserve are transferred to the income statement upon the
disposal of debt securities. During the year a gain of £1.2 million (2022: £1.9 million loss) was recognised in net realised losses.
226 | Financial Statements 227
33. Offsetting
In accordance with IAS 32
‘Financial Instruments: Presentation’
the Society must offset in the financial statements financial
assets and liabilities where there is a legally enforceable right to offset the recognised amounts and there is the intention to
settle these amounts on a net basis.
The Group enters into derivative contracts to mitigate various risks, see note 26 for further details. These derivatives are
governed by International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA) master agreements, an agreement is in place with each
counterparty the Group transacts derivatives with. These agreements define the terms of how the Group will enter derivative
contracts with the counterparty, including any netting arrangements.
In addition to these ISDA agreements the Group has various Credit Support Annexes (CSAs) with counterparties which defines
how collateral will be exchanged with a counterparty to mitigate market risk.
The following table shows the impact on the financial statements of these arrangements:
2023
Gross Master netting Financial Net Gross Master netting Financial Net
amounts* arrangements collateral** amount amounts* arrangements collateral** amount
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
Group
Financial assets
Derivative financial
1,755.0
(479.7)
(1,254.5)
20.8
2,356.5
(393.5)
(1,928.5)
34.5
instruments
Total financial assets
1,755.0
(479.7)
(1,254.5)
20.8
2,356.5
(393.5)
(1,928.5)
34.5
Financial liabilities
Derivative financial
697.4
(479.7)
(103.5)
114.2
666.3
(393.5)
(113.0)
159.8
instruments
Total financial liabilities
697.4
(479.7)
(103.5)
114.2
666.3
(393.5)
(113.0)
159.8
Society
Financial assets
Derivative financial
1,751.9
(479.7)
(1,254.5)
17.7
2,323.7
(393.5)
(1,928.5)
1.7
instruments
Total financial assets
1,751.9
(479.7)
(1,254.5)
17.7
2,323.7
(393.5)
(1,928.5)
1.7
Financial liabilities
Derivative financial
584.3
(479.7)
(103.5)
1.1
507.0
(393.5)
(112.8)
0.7
instruments
Total financial liabilities
584.3
(479.7)
(103.5)
1.1
507.0
(393.5)
(112.8)
0.7
Collateral is received and paid in the form of cash. Where cash is received from counterparties it is included as a liability
in amounts owed to credit institutions. Where cash is paid to a counterparty it is recorded as loans and advances to credit
institutions. Cash collateral paid and received is not restricted and is returned at the end of the contract.
* As recognised in the balance sheet
** Collateral is restricted by the value of the related financial asset or liability
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
34. Related parties
Identity of related parties
The Society has related party relationships with its controlled entities, a joint venture, the pension schemes and key
management personnel. The Society considers its key management personnel to be its directors.
Contributions to the pension schemes
The Society paid contributions of £19.3 million to the pension schemes (2022: £16.3 million).
Remuneration of and transactions with directors
Full details of directors’ remuneration, including the highest paid director, bonuses and pensions are given in the
Directors’
Remuneration Report
. In addition, past directors’ pensions in respect of services as directors from the closed scheme
amounted to £24,345 (2022: £23,176).
None of the directors of the Society had any equity interest in, or loans to or from, any subsidiary of the Society at any time
during the financial year.
A register containing details of loans, transactions and arrangements between the Society and its directors and connected
persons is maintained at the head office of the Society. A statement containing the details of this register for 2023 will be
available for inspection at the head office by members for a period of 15 days up to and including the date of the annual
general meeting.
Key management personnel compensation
The directors of the Society are considered to be the key management personnel as defined by IAS 24
Related Party
Disclosures
. Total key management personnel compensations was as follows:
Short‑term employee benefits
6,286.5
2,667.6
Post‑employment benefits
162.0
118.0
Total key management personnel compensation
6,448.5
2,785.6
Key management compensation in 2023 includes amounts paid to key management personnel who both retired and joined the
Society during 2023. The number of key management personnel at 31 December 2023 totalled 12 (31 December 2022: 9).
228 | Financial Statements 229
34. Related parties (continued)
Transactions with key management personnel
Key management personnel and their close family members have undertaken the following transactions with the Society
under normal business terms.
2022
No. of key Amounts in No. of key Amounts in
management respect of key management respect of key
personnel management personnel management
personnel personnel
and their and their
close family close family
£000
Deposit accounts and investments
At 1 January
9
1,462.5
11
1,067.7
Net movements in the year
3
(325.9)
(2)
394.8*
At 31 December
12
1,136.6
9
1,462.5*
There were no mortgage loan transactions or balances key management personnel and their close family members in 2023
(2022: nil).
Amounts relating to directors who joined or left during the year are included in net movement in the year.
Mortgage loans made to key management personnel and their close family members were granted in the ordinary course of
business and are subject to repayment under normal lending terms. The maximum outstanding balances during the year were
£nil (2022: £nil).
Amounts deposited by key management personnel and their close family members earn interest at the same rates offered to
the public.
Key management personnel and their close family members paid interest totalling £nil (2022: £nil), received interest totalling
£27,054 (2022: £6,639), and paid no fees and commissions during the year. Interest paid includes amounts relating to ‘offset’
mortgages where savings balances are used to reduce the interest‑bearing balance of mortgage loans.
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
Transactions with controlled entities
The Society transacts with its controlled entities in the form of intra‑group loans and equity shareholdings in the normal
course of business. The value of related party transactions and outstanding balances at the year end for the financial year are
as follows:
Shares in Loans to Deposits from
subsidiaries controlled controlled
entities entities
£m
£m
£m
At 1 January 2023
104.9
35,632.1
(15,137.3)
Net movements
–
1,722.3
1,465.0
At 31 December 2023
104.9
37,354.4
(13,672.3)
At 1 January 2022
104.9
32,129.2
(15,075.2)
Net movements
–
3,502.9
(62.1)
At 31 December 2022
104.9
35,632.1
(15,137.3)
The value of related party transactions income and expense for the financial year is as follows:
2022
£m
£m
Interest revenue on loans
1,349.0
475.8
Interest expense on deposits
(1,182.1)
(231.4)
Fees and expenses revenue
87.6
79.9
Fees and expenses expense
–
–
Dividends received
50.0
100.0
Other
The Society has a joint‑venture investment in Arkose Funding Limited. In 2014, a loan of £4.0 million to Arkose Funding
Limited was fully impaired.
* The 2022 deposit account and investment amounts in respect of key management personnel and their close family have been updated in these
financial statements.
230 | Financial Statements 231
35. Notes to the cash flow statements
Group
Society
Restated*
Restated*
2022 2022
£m
£m
£m
£m
Depreciation and amortisation
20.4
21.8
20.4
21.8
Loss/(profit) on sale of assets
0.3
(2.4)
0.3
(2.4)
Interest on subordinated liabilities
51.5
33.7
51.5
33.7
Impairment charge/(release) for the year
4.0
6.0
–
(0.6)
Provision (release)/charge for the year
(0.6)
4.2
(0.6)
4.2
Non‑cash movements on subordinated liabilities
73.0
(122.6)
73.0
(122.6)
Gain on realisation of debt securities
(1.6)
(2.9)
(1.6)
(2.9)
Non-cash items included in profit before tax
147.0
(62.2)
143.0
(68.8)
(Increase)/decrease in operating assets:
Change in loans and advances to customers and related fair value
(2,509.0)
(1,779.0)
(574.5)
1,726.6
adjustments for hedged risk, excluding impairment
Investments
(0.5)
2.6
(1,722.8)
(2,603.8)
Derivative financial assets
588.3
(1,867.6)
558.6
(1,906.2)
Other assets
(16.0)
(3.2)*
(42.6)
(39.6)*
Net increase in operating assets
(1,937.2)
(3,647.2)
(1,781.3)
(2,823.0)
Increase/(decrease) in operating liabilities:
Shares
5,048.5
6,501.8
5,048.5
6,501.8
Amounts owed to credit institutions
(3,274.6)
(928.9)
(3,274.6)
(928.9)
Non cash movements on debt securities
84.6
(117.9)
23.1
21.6
Other deposits
(154.5)
264.6
(1,756.1)
274.2
Derivative financial liabilities
31.1
393.6
77.3
326.1
Other liabilities and provisions
9.6
(18.5)*
25.2
2.3*
Net increase in operating liabilities
1,744.7
6,094.7
143.4
6,197.1
* The classification of these two lines have been corrected in 2023, moving them to their current position. Both line items
were previously reported within the “Non‑cash items included in profit before tax” section.
This has had the following impacts on the sub‑totals in Note 35 and, accordingly, on the Statement of Cashflows. Both have
been restated as a result.
Group
•
Reduced the “Non‑cash items included in profit before tax” by £21.7 million, from (£83.9 million) to (£62.2 million)
•
Increased the “Net increase in operating assets” by £3.2 million, from (£3,644.0 million) to (£3,647.2 million)
•
Reduced the “Net increase in operating liabilities” by £18.5 million, from £6,113.2 million to £6,094.7 million
Society
•
Reduced the “Non‑cash items included in profit before tax” by £37.3 million, from (£106.1 million) to (£68.8 million)
•
Increased the “Net increase in operating assets” by £39.6 million, from (£2,783.4 million) to (£2,823.0 million)
•
Increased the “Net increase in operating liabilities” by £2.3 million, from £6,194.8 million to £6,197.1 million
In all cases, there is no impact on the “Net cash from operating activities” line in the Statement of Cashflows as the impacted
lines all form part of that sub‑total.
Notes to the Financial Statements (continued)
The following table reconciles liabilities arising from financing activities.
Liabilities from Brought
Cash flows
Non-cash changes caused by:
Carried
financing activities forward
Redemption
Issue
Foreign
Accrued Fair value forward
exchange interest and other
movements
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
£m
2023 – Group
Debt securities in issue
5,259.3
(1,423.7)
999.2
(58.6)
3.4
139.8
4,919.4
Subordinated liabilities
1,035.1
(136.4)
650.0
–
6.6
66.4
1,621.7
Total
6,294.4
(1,560.1)
1,649.2
(58.6)
10.0
206.2
6,541.1
2022 – Group
Debt securities in issue
5,890.9
(1,225.2)
711.5
198.6
6.9
(323.4)
5,259.3
Subordinated liabilities
857.7
–
300.0
–
2.3
(124.9)
1,035.1
Total
6,748.6
(1,225.2)
1,011.5
198.6
9.2
(448.3)
6,294.4
2023 – Society
Debt securities in issue
6,153.4
(1,165.4)
506.5
(52.1)
1.7
73.5
5,517.6
Subordinated liabilities
1,035.1
(136.4)
650.0
–
6.6
66.4
1,621.7
Total
7,188.5
(1,301.8)
1,156.5
(52.1)
8.3
139.9
7,139.3
2022 – Society
Debt securities in issue
4,993.7
(773.4)
1,911.5
168.8
8.0
(155.2)
6,153.4
Subordinated liabilities
857.7
–
300.0
–
2.3
(124.9)
1,035.1
Total
5,851.4
(773.4)
2,211.5
168.8
10.3
(280.1)
7,188.5
232 | Financial Statements 233
Other Information
Annual Business Statement 235
Country‑by‑Country Report 237
Glossary 240
1. Statutory percentages
2023 2022 Statutory
limit
% % %
Lending limit 6.4 5.3* 25.0
Funding limit 14.2 21.6 50.0
The above percentages have been calculated in accordance with the provisions of the
Building Societies Act 1986
.
The Lending limit measures the proportion of business assets not in the form of loans fully secured on residential property.
The Funding limit measures the proportion of shares and borrowings not in the form of shares.
The statutory limits are as laid down under the
Building Societies Act 198
6 and ensure that the principal purpose of a building
society is that of making loans which are secured on residential property and are funded substantially by its members.
2. Other percentages
2023 2022
% %
As a percentage of shares and borrowings:
Gross capital 9.70 8.27
Free capital 9.46 8.05
Liquid assets 23.34 23.30
Profit after taxation for the financial year as a percentage of mean total assets 0.55 0.68
Management expenses as a percentage of mean total assets 0.56 0.54
The above percentages have been prepared from the Group financial statements and further details on the above percentages
can be found in the
Glossary
.
Annual Business Statement
* The 2022 lending limit has been updated in these financial statements.
234 | Other Information 235
3. Information relating to the directors at 31December 2023
Director name and
date of birth
Business
occupation
Date of appointment Other
Directorships
J R Heaps, LLB
8 July 1953
Chair of the Board 20 November 2014 None
A V F Durbin, BComm LLB MSc
9 October 1963
Chair of the Board Designate 18 December 2023 Persimmon PLC
Petershill Partners plc
S M Allen, OBE, BA Hons (Econ)
ACIB ACT
1 September 1966
Chief Executive 2 March 2023 Alzheimer’s Society
G L T Bainbridge,
MA (Cantab), ACA
13 September 1960
Non‑Executive Director 1 January 2019 ICE Clear Europe Limited
Manulife Financial Corporation
The Manufacturers Life Insurance Company
A J Darlington, BSC FIA
7 May 1968
Non‑Executive Director 26 April 2022 Rothesay Life Plc
Rothesay Limited
D J Davies, BA (Hons)
8 February 1963
Non‑Executive Director 26 July 2023 AXA UK Plc
AXA PPP Healthcare Limited
AXA Insurance UK Plc
Intrum AB (Sweden)
A E Hutchinson, CBE, BSc
5 February 1967
Charity Chief Executive 4 February 2015 DFS Furniture plc
Foresight Group Holdings Limited
Your Penny Limited
A B Lenman, MA, ACMA
25 December 1969
Chief Finance Officer and
Executive Director
4 December 2017 YBS Pension Trustees Limited
Arkose Funding Limited
D Matta, BSc, BA
15 May 1962
Non‑Executive Director 27 April 2021 Fat Fractal Inc
D E T Morris, BA (Hons), MA
26 September 1983
Chief Commercial Officer and
Executive Director
1 January 2022 Accord Mortgages Limited
BCS Loans & Mortgages Limited
Chelsea Mortgage Services Limited
Norwich and Peterborough Insurance Brokers
Limited
M A Parsons, BA, FCMA
24 October 1961
Non‑Executive Director 20 October 2020 Fairstone Capital Group Limited
Fairstone Private Wealth Limited
J L Tilling, BBus, BA
19 June 1969
Non‑Executive Director 1 November 2021 Marketing with Insight Limited
Camelot UK Lotteries Limited
Shaftesbury Plc
Guide Dogs for the Blind Association (The)
Mr A.B. Lenman entered into a contract on 28 September 2017 and was appointed to the Board on 4 December 2017 – his
mutual contractual notice period is six months.
Mr Morris entered into a contract on 25 June 2018 and was appointed to the Board on 1 January 2022 – his mutual
contractual notice period is twelve months.
Ms Allen entered into a contract on 5 August 2022 and was appointed to the Board on 2 March 2023 – her mutual contractual
notice period is twelve months.
Documents may be served on the above named directors: Ref. ‘Yorkshire Building Society’ c/o PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP at
the following address: Central Square, 29 Wellington Street, Leeds, LS1 4DL.
4. Registered office
Yorkshire Building Society is a building society incorporated and domiciled in the United Kingdom. The address of the
principal office is Yorkshire House, Yorkshire Drive, Bradford, BD5 8LJ.
Disclosure requirements under CRD IV country-by-country reporting
We are required to disclose the following information in our Annual Report and Accounts to comply with the Regulations of
Article 89 of the Capital Requirements Directive IV (CRD IV) country‑by‑country reporting (CBCR).
This regulation requires us to disclose financial information by country. Yorkshire Building Society has a number of
subsidiaries; these can be found in note 8 to these financial statements.
All the activities of Yorkshire Building Society and its subsidiaries (together, ‘the Group’) are conducted in the United Kingdom.
Country Nature of activities Number of
employees
Turnover (note i) Profit before tax Corporation tax
paid
(average
full time
equivalent)
£m £m £m
United Kingdom Provision of financial services 3,058 786.0 450.3 101.0
i) Turnover represents ‘total income’ on the Group’s income statement as disclosed in the Group’s Annual Report and
Accounts.
No public subsidies were received by the Group in 2023.
Basis of preparation
The Group’s CBCR disclosure has been prepared to comply with the Regulations. The requirements place certain reporting
obligations on financial institutions that are within the scope of CRD IV. CBCR requires annual publication of certain statutory
information on a consolidated basis, by country, where an institution has a subsidiary or branch.
The CBCR disclosure has been prepared solely to comply with the requirements of the Regulations and may not be relied on
for any other purpose.
Full-time equivalent employees
The figures disclosed above represent the average number of FTE’s all of which were employed in the UK.
Turnover and Profit before tax
Turnover and profit before tax are compiled from the Yorkshire Building Society Group consolidated financial statements for
the year ended 31 December 2023, which are prepared in accordance with IFRS.
Corporation tax paid
Corporation tax paid represents the net cash taxes paid during 2023. Corporation tax paid is reported on a cash basis and will
normally differ from the tax expenses recorded for accounting purposes due to:
•
Timing differences in the accrual of the tax charge
•
Brought forward losses from previous years
•
Other differences between when income and expenses are accounted for under IFRS and when they become taxable.
Country-by-Country ReportAnnual Business Statement (continued)
236 | Other Information 237
Report on the audit of the country-by-country information
Opinion
In our opinion, Yorkshire Building
Society’s country‑by‑country
information for the year ended
31December 2023 has been properly
prepared, in all material respects, in
accordance with the requirements of
the Capital Requirements (Country‑by‑
Country Reporting) Regulations 2013.
We have audited the country‑by‑
country information for the year ended
31 December 2023 in the Country‑by‑
Country Report.
Basis for opinion
We conducted our audit in accordance
with International Standards on
Auditing (UK) (“ISAs (UK)”), including
ISA (UK) 800 and ISA (UK) 805, and
applicable law. Our responsibilities
under ISAs (UK) are further described
in the Auditors’ responsibilities for
the audit of the country‑by‑country
information section of our report.
We believe that the audit evidence
we have obtained is sufficient and
appropriate to provide a basis for our
opinion.
Independence
We remained independent of the
company in accordance with the
ethical requirements that are relevant
to our audit of the country‑by‑country
information in the UK, which includes
the FRC’s Ethical Standard, and
we have fulfilled our other ethical
responsibilities in accordance with
these requirements.
Emphasis of matter –
Basis of preparation
In forming our opinion on the country‑
by‑country information, which is
not modified, we draw attention to
the basis of preparation note of the
country‑by‑country information which
describes the basis of preparation.
The country‑by‑country information
is prepared for the directors for
the purpose of complying with
the requirements of the Capital
Requirements (Country‑by‑Country
Reporting) Regulations 2013. The
country‑by‑country information has
therefore been prepared in accordance
with a special purpose framework and,
as a result, the country‑by‑country
information may not be suitable for
another purpose.
Conclusions relating to
going concern
Our evaluation of the directors’
assessment of the company’s ability to
continue to adopt the going concern
basis of accounting included:
•
A risk assessment to identify
factors that could impact the
going concern basis of accounting,
including the current and forecast
financial performance;
•
Evaluation of management’s going
concern assessment;
•
Review of regulatory
correspondence and reports
provided to governance forums;
and
•
Evaluation of the appropriateness
of the relevant disclosures in the
financial statement.
Based on the work we have performed,
we have not identified any material
uncertainties relating to events
or conditions that, individually or
collectively, may cast significant doubt
on the company’s ability to continue as
a going concern for a period of at least
twelve months from the date on which
the country‑by‑country information is
authorised for issue.
In auditing the country‑by‑country
information, we have concluded that
the directors’ use of the going concern
basis of accounting in the preparation
of the country‑by‑country information
is appropriate.
However, because not all future events
or conditions can be predicted, this
conclusion is not a guarantee as to
the company’s ability to continue as a
going concern.
Our responsibilities and the
responsibilities of the directors with
respect to going concern are described
in the relevant sections of this report.
Responsibilities for
the country-by-country
information and the audit
Responsibilities of the directors
for the country-by-country
information
The directors are responsible for
the preparation of the country‑by‑
country information in accordance
with the requirements of the Capital
Requirements (Country‑by‑Country
Reporting) Regulations 2013 as
explained in the basis of preparation
in the basis of preparation note to
the country‑by‑country information
and accounting policies in the Group
and Society financial statements,
and for determining that the basis of
preparation and accounting policies
are acceptable in the circumstances.
The directors are also responsible for
such internal control as they determine
is necessary to enable the preparation
of country‑by‑country information that
is free from material misstatement,
whether due to fraud or error.
In preparing the country‑by‑
country information, the directors
are responsible for assessing the
company’s ability to continue as a
going concern, disclosing as applicable,
matters related to going concern
and using the going concern basis of
accounting unless the directors either
intend to liquidate the company or to
cease operations, or have no realistic
alternative but to do so.
Auditors’ responsibilities for the
audit of the country-by-country
information
It is our responsibility to report on
whether the country‑by‑country
information has been properly
prepared in accordance with the
relevant requirements of the Capital
Requirements (Country‑by‑Country
Reporting) Regulations 2013.
Our objectives are to obtain reasonable
assurance about whether the country‑
by‑country information as a whole
is free from material misstatement,
whether due to fraud or error, and to
issue an auditors’ report that includes
Independent auditors’ report
to the directors of Yorkshire Building Society
our opinion. Reasonable assurance is
a high level of assurance, but is not a
guarantee that an audit conducted in
accordance with ISAs (UK) will always
detect a material misstatement when
it exists. Misstatements can arise from
fraud or error and are considered
material if, individually or in the
aggregate, they could reasonably be
expected to influence the economic
decisions of users taken on the basis
of this country‑by‑country information.
Irregularities, including fraud, are
instances of non‑compliance with laws
and regulations. We design procedures
in line with our responsibilities,
outlined above, to detect material
misstatements in respect of
irregularities, including fraud. The
extent to which our procedures are
capable of detecting irregularities,
including fraud, is detailed below.
Based on our understanding of the
company/industry, we identified that
the principal risks of non‑compliance
with laws and regulations related to
breaches of UK regulatory principles,
such as those governed by the
Prudential Regulation Authority, and
we considered the extent to which
non‑compliance might have a material
effect on the country‑by‑country
information. We also considered
those laws and regulations that have
a direct impact on the country‑by‑
country information such as applicable
tax legislation and the Capital
Requirements (Country‑by‑Country
Reporting) Regulations 2013. We
evaluated management’s incentives
and opportunities for fraudulent
manipulation of the country‑by‑
country information (including the
risk of override of controls), and
determined that the principal risks
were related to determined that
the principal risks were related to
posting manual journal entries to
manipulate financial performance
and the application of management
bias in the assumptions underpinning
significant accounting estimates. Audit
procedures performed included:
•
Enquiries of management,
those charged with governance
and the Group’s in‑house legal
counsel throughout the year,
including consideration of
known or suspected instances of
non‑compliance with laws and
regulations;
•
Assessment of matters reported
on the Group’s whistleblowing
helpline and the results of
management’s investigation of
such matters;
•
Review of internal audit reports
throughout the year, in so far
as these related to the financial
statements;
•
Review of correspondence with,
and reports to, the PRA and FCA;
•
Incorporation of an element of
unpredictability in our testing
through altering the nature, timing
and/or extent of work performed;
•
Challenging estimates and
judgements made by management
in forming significant accounting
estimates in particular those
relevant to the key audit matters
below; and
•
Identifying and testing any higher
risk manual journal entries.
There are inherent limitations in the
audit procedures described above.
We are less likely to become aware of
instances of non‑compliance with laws
and regulations that are not closely
related to events and transactions
reflected in the country‑by‑country
information. Also, the risk of not
detecting a material misstatement
due to fraud is higher than the risk
of not detecting one resulting from
error, as fraud may involve deliberate
concealment by, for example, forgery
or intentional misrepresentations, or
through collusion.
A further description of our
responsibilities for the audit of the
country‑by‑country information is
located on the FRC’s website at:
www.frc.org.uk/
auditorsresponsibilities.
This description forms part of our
auditors’ report.
Use of this report
This report, including the opinion, has
been prepared for and only for the
company’s directors in accordance with
the Capital Requirements (Country‑by‑
Country Reporting) Regulations 2013
and for no other purpose. We do not, in
giving this opinion, accept or assume
responsibility for any other purpose or
to any other person to whom this report
is shown or into whose hands it may
come, save where expressly agreed by
our prior consent in writing.
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
Chartered Accountants and Statutory
Auditors
Leeds
28 February 2024
238 | Other Information 239
The following glossary defines terminology used within the Annual Report and Accounts:
Additional Tier 1 (AT1) capital Capital that meets certain criteria set out in CRD IV. In particular, the criteria require that upon
the occurrence of a trigger event, the AT1 capital instrument converts to a form of Common
Equity Tier 1 capital or the principal is written down on a permanent basis.
Arrears Amounts unpaid at their contractual date. A customer is in arrears when they fall behind in
meeting their obligations to pay their mortgage.
Buy-to-let (BTL) mortgages Lending on property that is rented out to individuals.
Capital Requirements Directive (CRD) &
Capital Requirements Regulation
European legislation that defines the regulatory capital framework in the UK. The latest
legislation – the Capital Requirements Regulation (CRR) and the Capital Requirements Directive
(CRD) (together commonly referred to as CRD IV) came into effect from 1 January 2014.
Collateral (for loans and advances to
customers)
Security (property) pledged for the repayment of a loan. Collateral is valued as the lower of the
value of the property or the outstanding loan amount.
Commercial lending Secured loans to a commercial borrower.
Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) capital The highest quality regulatory capital resources, comprising retained earnings less regulatory
adjustments, as defined under CRD IV. Equivalent to Core Tier 1 defined under previous CRD
legislation.
Contractual maturity The final payment date of a loan or financial instrument, at which all the outstanding loan and
interest is repayable.
Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML) A not‑for‑profit organisation and trade association for the mortgage lending industry.
Covered bonds A type of wholesale funding backed by cash flows from mortgages that are segregated from the
issuer’s other assets to be solely for the benefit of the holders of the covered bonds.
Credit Valuation Adjustment (CVA) The risk of financial loss arising from a failure of a customer or counterparty to settle their
financial and contractual obligations as they fall due.
These are adjustments applied to the fair values of derivatives to reflect the creditworthiness of
the counterparty.
Cross currency interest rate swap An arrangement in which two parties exchange equivalent principal amounts of different
currencies at inception and subsequently exchange interest payments on the principal amounts.
At the maturity of the swap, the principal amounts are re‑exchanged at the original rates.
Currency risk The exposure to risk from assets and liabilities denominated in currencies other than Sterling.
Debt securities in issue Transferable certificates of indebtedness including certificates of deposits and fixed and floating
rate notes.
Debit Valuation Adjustment (DVA) These are adjustments applied to the fair values of derivatives to reflect the entity’s own credit
risk.
Defined Benefit Obligation The present value of expected future benefit payments resulting from past service of employees
in the defined benefit pension plan.
Derivative financial instruments Contracts or agreements whose value is derived from one or more underlying prices, rates or
indices inherent in the contract or agreement, such as interest rates, exchange rates or stock
market indices. Examples of derivatives include interest rate swaps, forward rate agreements and
futures.
Effective interest rate The method used to calculate the amortised cost of financial instruments and to recognise
interest receivable or payable over the relevant period. The effective interest rate is the rate that
exactly discounts estimated cash flows (excluding credit losses) to zero, through the expected
life of the instrument.
Encumbered assets Assets on the balance sheet which are pledged in order to secure, collateralise or credit‑enhance
a financial transaction from which they cannot be freely withdrawn.
Glossary
Expected credit losses An estimate of the potential losses on current exposures due to potential defaults.
Exposure The maximum loss that a financial institution might suffer if a borrower or counterparty fails to
meet its obligations to the Group.
Exposure at default (EAD) An estimation of the amount of exposure that will be outstanding at the time of default.
Fair value The price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly
transaction between market participants at the measurement date in the principal or, in its
absence, the most advantageous market to which the Group has access at that date.
Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) The UK conduct regulator which is responsible for regulation of conduct in retail, as well as
wholesale, financial markets and the infrastructure that supports those markets. The FCA’s
objective is to protect consumers, promote competition and enhance market integrity.
Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) An independent service which provides a service for settling disputes between financial services
providers and their customers.
Forbearance The Group grants concessions to assist borrowers who experience difficulties in meeting their
obligations to pay their mortgage. Examples of forbearance tools are described in note 31.
Free capital The aggregate of gross capital and collective impairment provision less property, plant and
equipment, intangible assets and investment properties.
Gross capital The aggregate of general reserve, hedging reserve, available for sale reserve, subordinated
liabilities and subscribed capital.
Impaired loans Loans which have been assessed and there is evidence to suggest a measurable decrease in the
present value of cash flows expected from the loans that have occurred after initial recognition
of the asset, but before the balance sheet date.
Internal Liquidity Adequacy Assessment
Process (ILAAP)
The Group's internal assessment of the levels of liquidity that need to be held by the Society to
meet its regulatory liquidity requirements.
Interest rate swap An arrangement under which two counterparties agree to exchange periodic interest payments
based on a predetermined notional principal amount.
Internal Capital Adequacy Assessment
Process (ICAAP)
The Group's internal assessment of the levels of capital that need to be held by the Society to
meet its regulatory capital requirements.
International Financial Reporting Standards
(IFRS)
International Financial Reporting Standards issued by the International Accounting Standards
Board (IASB).
Level 1 High Quality Liquid Assets (HQLA) Assets which can be easily and immediately converted into cash at little or no loss of value.
Liquidity Coverage Ratio (LCR) A liquidity metric which aims to ensure that a firm maintains an adequate level of liquidity to
meet its needs for a 30 calendar day time horizon under a severe stress scenario.
LIBOR (London Interbank Offered Rate) A benchmark interest rate which banks can borrow funds from other banks in the London
interbank market. Due to the IBOR reform this has been phased out during 2021, with the
exception of USD LIBOR that will be phased out by cessation date of June 2023.
Liquid assets The total of cash in hand and balances with the Bank of England, loans and advances to credit
institutions, debt securities and other liquid assets.
Liquidity risk The risk that the Group does not hold sufficient liquidity, in terms of quantity and quality, to
meet its liabilities as they fall due.
Loan-to-value (LTV) A ratio showing outstanding loan balance as a percentage of the value of the security.
Loss given default (LGD) An estimate of the difference between exposure at default (EAD) and the net amount of the
expected recovery expressed as a percentage of EAD.
Loss given possession The loss that is expected to crystallise when a repossessed property is sold.
240 | Other Information 241
Management expenses The aggregate of administrative expenses, depreciation and amortisation.
Market Risk The risk that the value of, or income derived from, the Group’s assets and liabilities changes
unfavourably due to movements in interest rates or foreign currency rates.
Mean total assets The amount produced by halving the aggregate of total assets at the beginning and end of the
financial year.
Medium-term notes (MTN) Corporate notes continuously offered by a company to investors through a dealer. Investors can
choose from differing maturities.
Member A person who has a share account or a mortgage loan with the Society.
Minimum Requirement for Eligible Liabilities
(MREL)
The minimum requirements a financial institution must hold to meet the loss absorption and
recapitalisation components if an institution were to fail.
Net interest income The difference between the interest received on assets and the interest paid on liabilities.
Net interest margin The ratio of net interest income as a percentage of mean total assets.
Operational risk The risk of direct and indirect loss resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes, people
and systems or from external events.
Other income The income received from selling non‑mortgage and savings products (e.g. home and contents
insurance, investment products and other insurances).
PRA Remuneration Code Guidance provided by the PRA on directors’ remuneration.
Probability of default (PD) An estimate of the probability that a borrower will default on their credit obligations.
Probability of possession The likelihood of an account moving into possession. This is used when calculating loan loss
provisions.
Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) The UK prudential regulator, which is a part of the Bank of England and alongside the FCA has
responsibility for the oversight of building societies, banks and insurers. The PRA’s objective is to
promote the safety and soundness of regulated firms.
Repossessions Property taken into ownership by the Society as a result of the borrower’s failure to make
contractual loan repayments.
Residential Mortgage Backed Securities
(RMBS)
An asset backed security that represents a claim on the cash flows from residential mortgage
loans through a process known as securitisation.
Risk appetite The level of risk that the Group is willing to take (or not take) in order to safeguard the interests
of members whilst achieving business objectives.
Risk weighted assets A regulatory measure that adjusts the value of assets to reflect their level of risk when
calculating capital requirements.
Securitisation A process by which a group of assets, usually loans, are aggregated into a pool which is used
to back the issuance of debt securities in issue. A firm transfers these assets to a special
purpose vehicle which then issues securities backed by the assets. The Group has established
securitisation structures as part of its funding activities and uses residential mortgages as the
asset pool.
Shares Money deposited by members in a retail savings account with the Society and held as a liability
in the balance sheet.
Shares and borrowings The total of shares, amounts owed to credit institutions, amounts owed to other customers and
debt securities in issue.
SONIA (Sterling Overnight Interbank
Average)
An index that tracks actual market overnight funding rates calculated as a weighted average
overnight deposit rate for each business day.
Subordinated liabilities Tier 2 capital that is subordinated to the claims of all depositors, creditors and members holding
shares in the Society (other than holders of PIBS).
Term Funding Scheme with additional
incentives for small and medium sized
entities (TFSME)
A scheme launched by the Bank of England designed to boost lending to households and
businesses by providing term funding to banks and building societies participating in the
scheme at rates close to Bank Rate.
Tier 1 (T1) capital The sum total of Common Equity Tier 1 and Additional Tier 1 capital.
Tier 1 capital ratio The ratio of Tier 1 capital to risk weighted assets.
Tier 2 (T2) capital A measure of regulatory capital that includes subordinated liabilities and provisions for
collective impairment, less regulatory adjustments.
Total capital The total capital resources, including retained earnings, PIBS and subordinated liabilities, less
regulatory adjustments.
Total capital ratio The ratio of total capital to risk weighted assets.
UK Corporate Governance Code The UK code on corporate governance, published by the Financial Reporting Council in October
2012 which sets out standards of good practice in relation to Board leadership and effectiveness,
accountability and remuneration. Reporting in relation to these accounts is based on the version
of the Code published in July 2018 (with the most recent Code published in January 2024
beginning to apply from accounting years after 1 January 2025).
Value at Risk (VaR) A risk management tool which evaluates the potential losses that may be incurred as a result
of movements in market conditions over a specified holding period and to a given level of
confidence.
Watch list The watch list is used by the commercial lending team to flag those loans where there are
circumstances which could impact on the quality and safety of the loan.
Wholesale funding The funding that is available between banks and other financial or commercial institutions.
Examples of wholesale funding include covered bonds, deposits and government guarantees.
Glossary (continued)
242 | Other Information 243
The following glossary defines Alternative Performance Measures (APM) used within the Annual Report and Accounts:
APM Calculation of Measure Reconciling items to statutory measure Definition and purpose
Income Statement measures
Core operating profit Profit before tax adjusted
for one‑off items.
A full reconciliation between profit
before tax as shown in the income
statement and core operating profit is
shown in the
Strategic Report
.
Core operating profit excludes items such as fair
value volatility and material one‑time charges that
do not reflect the Group’s day‑to‑day activities. Our
Board considers core operating profit to be a more
appropriate measure of the underlying performance
of the business and this is how financial performance
is reported to and assessed by the Board.
Cost to core income
ratio
Management expenses
as a percentage of core
income.
Management expenses = administrative
expenses plus depreciation and
amortisation per the income statement.
Core income = total income less gains/
(losses) from financial instruments held
at fair value per the income statement.
This is a measure of the Group’s costs in relation to
its income excluding fair value volatility. This is used
by the Group to monitor and manage its overall cost
position and understand how efficient the Group is at
generating income on an underlying basis.
Cost to income ratio Management expenses
as a percentage of total
income.
Management expenses = administrative
expenses plus depreciation and
amortisation per the income statement.
Total income as per the income
statement.
This is an industry‑standard measure of the Group’s
costs in relation to its income. This is used by
the Group to monitor and manage its overall cost
position and understand how efficient the Group is at
generating income.
Management
expense ratio
Management expenses
(the aggregate of
administrative expenses,
depreciation and
amortisation) as a
percentage of mean total
assets.
Administrative expenses and
depreciation and amortisation
(management expenses) are as shown
in the income statements. Mean total
assets are calculated by taking the
average of the value of the opening
balance for the year and the value of
the closing balance, as shown in the
Statements of Financial Position.
This is an industry‑standard ratio of the Group’s costs
as a proportion of its mean assets during the year,
and is used to measure how efficient the Group is at
maintaining its asset base.
Net interest margin Net interest income as a
percentage of mean total
assets.
Net interest income is as shown in the
income statements. Mean total assets
are calculated by taking the average of
the value of the opening balance for
the year and the value of the closing
balance, as shown in the Statements of
Financial Position.
This is an industry‑standard measure of the
relationship between net interest income (the
difference between the interest received on assets
and the interest paid on liabilities) and assets. This is
a key measure used by the Board to monitor how the
Group manages income from its assets and interest
paid on funding.
Balance Sheet items
Asset growth Total assets at the end of
the year less total assets
at the start of the year.
Total assets are as shown in the
Statements of Financial Position.
Movement in total asset over the period.
Average savings rate
differential
None Not applicable Calculates the average savings rate applied to the
Group’s savings accounts during the period versus
the average UK savings interest rates for the rest
of the market, based on savings stock from CACI’s
Current Account and Savings Database (CSDB), based
on stock value. This is used to assess how much the
Group is paying out in interest in comparison to
peers.
Gross lending None Not applicable The total value of mortgage loans advanced by
the Group in the period, including loans for house
purchase, further advances, re‑mortgages etc.
Lending to first time
buyers
None Not applicable The total value of mortgage loans advanced by the
Group in the period to first time home buyers. This
measure displays how the Group is helping people
overcome the challenge of buying their first property.
APM Calculation of Measure Reconciling items to statutory measure Definition and purpose
Liquidity ratio Cash in hand and balances
with the Bank of England,
loans and advances to
credit institutions and
debt securities as a
percentage of shares and
borrowings.
Cash in hand, balances with the Bank of
England, loans and advances to credit
institutions, debt securities, and shares
are as shown in the Statements of
Financial Position. Borrowings comprise
amounts owed to credit institutions,
other deposits and debt securities in
issue, also as shown in the Statements
of Financial Position.
The liquidity ratio measures those assets available
to meet requests by savers to withdraw their money,
to fund mortgage advances and to fund general
business activities. It expresses cash and assets easily
converted into cash as a percentage of the Group’s
liabilities to investors.
Loan to deposit ratio Loans and advances to
customers as a percentage
of shares and other retail
customer deposits.
Not applicable This is an industry‑standard measure of the
relationship between Loans and advances to
customers and retail customer deposits.
Mortgages funded
by retail savings and
retained profits
Shares and total reserves
as a percentage of
loans and advances to
customers.
Shares, total reserves and loans and
advances to customers are as shown in
the Statements of Financial Position.
The retail savings and reserves to mortgages ratio
shows the extent to which the Group is dependent on
financing from the wholesale markets.
Mortgage balance
growth
Loans and advances to
customers at the end of
the year less loans and
advances to customers at
the start of the year.
Loans and advances to customers are
as shown in the Statements of Financial
Position.
Movement in mortgage balances including
impairment provisions and fair value accounting
adjustments over the period.
Net lending Loans and advances to
customers at the end of
the year less loans and
advances to customers
at the start of the year,
excluding movements in
provisions and accounting
adjustments detailed in
note 12.
Mortgage growth less movements in
provisions and accounting adjustments
detailed in note 12.
Net lending represents gross lending less repayment
of principal and redemptions and is a key measure to
monitor the Group’s overall lending performance. This
measures our effectiveness in both new mortgage
lending and in retaining borrowers.
Number of accounts
more than three
months in arrears
None Not applicable The number of mortgage accounts where the amount
of arrears is greater than three monthly payments, or
the account is in possession, as a proportion of the
total number of mortgage accounts.
The industry average for mortgage arrears is
measured as the number of accounts more than
three months in arrears (including possessions). We
produce this KPI to assess how our level of mortgage
arrears compares to the market.
Percentage of
outstanding retail
mortgage balances
in arrears by three
months or more
None Not applicable The percentage of mortgage account balances where
the amount of arrears is equal to or greater than three
monthly payments, or the account is in possession, as
a proportion of the entire mortgage book.
This measures the overall quality of our mortgage
book.
Retail Savings
balance growth
Shares at the end of the
year less shares at the
start of the year.
Shares are as shown in the Statements
of Financial Position.
Movement in overall savings balances over the
period, including capitalised interest and accounting
adjustments.
Savings inflow/
outflow
None Not applicable Displays the cash in/out of savings accounts held,
excluding capitalised interest. The Group uses this to
monitor its main funding source throughout the year.
Share of the gross
mortgage market
None Not applicable Displays the Group’s total gross lending as a
percentage of the gross lending in the UK housing
market by banks, building societies and other lenders
as measured by the Council of Mortgage Lenders
(CML), which represents 97% of the UK mortgage
market. From 1 July 2017 the Council of Mortgage
Lenders integrated into a new trade association, UK
Finance.
Glossary (continued)
244 | Other Information 245
APM Calculation of Measure Reconciling items to statutory measure Definition and purpose
Regulatory Measures
Common Equity Tier
1 (CET1) capital ratio
None Common equity tier 1 capital ratio
is defined as a percentage of risk
weighted assets.
This ratio represents the relationship between the
strongest form of capital (primarily accumulated profits
that have built up over time) and assets, weighted by
the level of risk they carry. It is a regulatory‑defined
ratio whose purpose is to ensure that institutions are
able to absorb unexpected losses. It is a key measure
of financial sustainability.
Leverage ratio Reserves as a percentage
of total assets.
Leverage ratio measures the Society’s
Tier 1 capital as a percentage of total
assets adjusted for certain off‑balance
sheet exposures. The CRR leverage
ratio is defined by the EU’s Capital
Requirements Regulation, while the
UK leverage ratio modifies this ratio to
exclude Central Bank reserves.
The leverage ratio is also a regulatory‑defined ratio
used to assess capital adequacy, but removes the
risk‑weighting element of assets. It is therefore a
more simplified measure of financial sustainability.
Total capital ratio None Total capital ratio is defined as a
percentage of risk weighted assets.
This measure is used to assess the total amount
of capital the Group retains compared to its risk
weighted assets, hence it includes externally
issued capital. It is also defined by the regulatory
authorities.
Non-financial measures
Absenteeism None Not applicable This indicator is for measuring the average
absenteeism rate, as a % of the total working days.
This KPI can be an indicator of colleague motivation
as a high absence rate may indicate poor motivation
and engagement.
Colleague
engagement score
None Not applicable Our annual colleague engagement survey is used
to calculate an engagement score which helps to
understand our people’s needs and what will lead to
their enjoyment and commitment in work.
Net Promoter Score
(NPS)
None Not applicable NPS is a measure of how willing customers are to
recommend the Group to others. It measures the
difference between the percentage of ‘promoters’
(those willing to recommend the Group to others)
and ‘detractors’ (those unwilling to recommend
the Group). The score can range from ‑100 if all
customers are ‘detractors’ to +100 if all customers are
‘promoters’. The Group uses this as a key measure of
customer satisfaction with our products and service.
Peakon survey result None Not applicable This is an external benchmarking exercise conducted
by Peakon, involving an employee survey and
a culture audit. The Group uses this measure to
understand how successful we are at delivering our
vision as a workplace where our people can give
their best and thrive. This is monitored annually and
reported to the Board as a colleague engagement
measure.
Forward-looking statements
This document contains certain forward‑looking statements, which are made in good faith based on the information
available up to the time of the approval of this report. Such statements should be treated with caution due to the inherent
uncertainties, including both economic and business risk factors, underlying any such forward‑looking information.
Glossary (continued)
246 | Other Information 247
References to ‘YBS Group’ or ‘Yorkshire Group’ refer to Yorkshire Building Society, the trading names under which it operates (Barnsley Building Society, Barnsley, Chelsea Building Society,
Chelsea, Norwich & Peterborough Building Society, N&P and Egg) and its subsidiary companies.
Accord Mortgages Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Accord Mortgages Limited is entered in the Financial Services Register under registration number
305936. Buy to Let mortgages for business purposes are not regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Accord Mortgages Limited is registered in England No: 02139881. Registered
Office: Yorkshire Drive, Bradford BD5 8LJ. Accord Mortgages is a registered Trade Mark of Accord Mortgages Limited.
YBS Share Plans is part of Yorkshire Building Society. Yorkshire Building Society provides share plan trustee and administration services, including deposit taking, all of which are subject to
English law, with deposit taking being regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. The provision of share plan trustee and administration services is not regulated by the Financial Conduct
Authority. We are not responsible for share plan deposits held by local savings carriers outside the UK. Head Office: YBS Share Plans, Yorkshire House, Yorkshire Drive, Bradford, BD5 8LJ.
ybsshareplans.co.uk
Yorkshire Building Society Charitable Foundation is a Registered Charity (No: 1069082) and a Registered Company (No: 03545437). It is an independent registered charity governed by a
board of trustees and its results are not included in the annual report and accounts of Yorkshire Building Society. Registered Office: Yorkshire House, Yorkshire Drive, Bradford, BD5 8LJ.
Age UK is a charitable company limited by guarantee and registered in England and Wales (registered charity number 1128267). Registered address: 7th Floor, One America Square, 17
Crosswall, London EC3N 2LB.
FareShare is a registered charity in England & Wales (1100051) and Scotland (SC052672).
Citizens Advice is an operating name of The National Association of Citizens Advice Bureaux. Registered charity number 279057.
Yorkshire Building Society is a member of the Building Societies Association and is authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and
the Prudential Regulation Authority. Yorkshire Building Society is entered in the Financial Services Register and its registration number is 106085. Head Office: Yorkshire House, Yorkshire
Drive, Bradford, BD5 8LJ.
ybs.co.uk
YBM 0019 29 02 24