
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR’S REPORT ANNUAL REPORT
Our procedures in relation to revenue recognition and measurement
of expected sales returns included considering the Group’s accounting
policies for revenue recognition, including those related to measurement
of expected sales returns, and assessing compliance of policies with
applicable accounting standards. We identified and assessed internal
controls related to the timing of revenue recognition and measurement of
expected sales returns. We tested the effectiveness of the Group’s internal
controls in relation to calculation of expected sales returns and timing of
revenue recognition. On a sample basis, we tested sales transactions taking
place at either side of the balance sheet date as well as credit notes issued
after the balance sheet date to assess whether those transactions were
recognised in the correct period. We assessed the key assumptions applied
by Management regarding expected sales returns based on our knowledge
of the business and by reviewing the supporting documentation prepared
by Management. As part of our audit we have utilised data analytics, analys
-
ing the relationship between revenue, trade receivables and cash receipts.
Furthermore, we evaluated the disclosures provided by Management in
the consolidated financial statements and the Parent Company financial
statements to applicable accounting standards.
Revenue recognition and measurement
of expected sales returns
Revenue is recognised when control of the goods has been transferred
to the buyer and it is measured at fair value of the expected consid-
eration to be received, less rebates, discounts, sales taxes, duties and
expected sales returns. Revenue recognition and measurement of the
related expected sales returns was a matter of most significance in our
audit due to the inherent risk in the estimates and judgements which
Management makes in the normal course of business as to timing of
revenue and measurement of expected sales returns.
Details on revenue recognition and expected sales returns are provided
in notes 2.1 and 3.8 of the consolidated financial statements and in
notes 2.1 and 3.5 of the Parent Company financial statements, to which
we refer.
Income tax recognition and provisions
for uncertain tax positions
The Group has extensive international operations and con-
sequently, Management makes judgements and estimates in
determining the recognition of income taxes, deferred taxes and
provisions for uncertain tax positions. In Thailand, the Group is
subject to Board of Investment (BOI) agreements, where many,
but not all, types of net income are tax-exempt, and therefore,
changes in profit allocation could significantly impact the Group’s
consolidated tax expense. On this basis, income tax recognition
and provisions for uncertain tax positions were a matter of most
significance in our audit. Additional details on income taxes are
provided in note 2.5 of the consolidated financial statements, to
which we refer.
Our procedures in relation to recognition of income taxes, de-
ferred taxes and provisions for uncertain tax positions included
assessing the Group’s processes for recording and assessment of
provisions for uncertain tax positions. Our procedures also covered
evaluating the assumptions applied by Management in determining
the recognition and measurement of income taxes and deferred
taxes while taking into account relevant correspondence with
relevant tax authorities. Our own tax specialists performed an as-
sessment of the Group’s recognition of income taxes and deferred
taxes, including correspondence with relevant tax authorities to
consider the completeness of the tax provisions. In addition, we
assessed the assumptions applied, taking into consideration our
own tax specialists’ knowledge and experience. Further, we evalu-
ated the disclosures provided by Management in the consolidated
financial statements and the Parent Company financial statements
to applicable accounting standards.
Inventory valuation
Our procedures in relation to inventory valuation included assess-
ing the Group’s processes related to inventory valuation including
on a sample basis testing of direct costs related to raw materials,
labour costs and attributable overhead costs incurred in the
crafting process, recording of write-downs and understanding of
the process for internal gain elimination. We assessed the basis
for write-downs and performed analytical procedures to assess
slow-moving items. We assessed the key assumptions applied by
Management regarding items’ life-cycle status and expected value
of the reusable raw materials based on our knowledge of the busi-
ness, and on a sample basis tested the supporting documentation.
Further, on a sample basis we tested the calculation of elimination
of internal gain at Group level. Furthermore, we evaluated the
disclosures provided by Management in the consolidated financial
statements and the Parent Company financial statements to appli-
cable accounting standards.
DESCRIPTION OF
MATTER
CONSIDERATION OF THE
MATTER IN THE AUDIT
The Group carries inventory in the balance sheet at the lower of
cost and net realisable value. Significant management judgements
are required with regards to valuation of inventories due to the
uncertainty associated with the estimate of slow-moving items and
expected value of the reusable raw materials, as well as calcula
-
tions of elimination of internal gain. Given the level of management
judgements and estimates, inventory valuation was a matter of
most significance in our audit. Additional details on the valuation of
inventories are provided in note 3.5 of the consolidated financial
statements and in note 3.4 of the Parent Company financial state
-
ments, to which we refer.