4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2022-11-30 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-11-30 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-12-01 2022-11-30 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-12-01 2021-11-30 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-11-30 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-12-01 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-12-01 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:SharePremiumMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-12-01 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-12-01 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:ReserveOfExchangeDifferencesOnTranslationMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-12-01 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:ReserveOfCashFlowHedgesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-12-01 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-12-01 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:MiscellaneousOtherReservesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-12-01 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:MergerReserveMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-12-01 2021-11-30 ccl:OtherReserveMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-12-01 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-12-01 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:SharePremiumMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-12-01 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-12-01 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:ReserveOfExchangeDifferencesOnTranslationMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-12-01 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:ReserveOfCashFlowHedgesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-12-01 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-12-01 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:MiscellaneousOtherReservesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-12-01 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:MergerReserveMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-12-01 2022-11-30 ccl:OtherReserveMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-11-30 ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-11-30 ifrs-full:SharePremiumMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-11-30 ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-11-30 ifrs-full:ReserveOfExchangeDifferencesOnTranslationMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-11-30 ifrs-full:ReserveOfCashFlowHedgesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-11-30 ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-11-30 ifrs-full:MiscellaneousOtherReservesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-11-30 ifrs-full:MergerReserveMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2020-11-30 ccl:OtherReserveMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:SharePremiumMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:ReserveOfExchangeDifferencesOnTranslationMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:ReserveOfCashFlowHedgesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:MiscellaneousOtherReservesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-11-30 ifrs-full:MergerReserveMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2021-11-30 ccl:OtherReserveMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:SharePremiumMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:ReserveOfExchangeDifferencesOnTranslationMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:ReserveOfCashFlowHedgesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:MiscellaneousOtherReservesMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2022-11-30 ifrs-full:MergerReserveMember 4DR1VPDQMHD3N3QW8W95 2022-11-30 ccl:OtherReserveMember iso4217:USD iso4217:USD xbrli:shares
Annual Report
Year Ended November 30, 2022
The Carnival plc Annual Report comprises the Strategic Report, Carnival plc consolidated Group and
Company Financial Statements, the DLC Financial Statements and certain parts of the Proxy Statement,
including its Annexes (the “Proxy Statement”).
The Directors consider that, within the Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc dual listed company (
“
DLC
”
)
arrangement, the most appropriate presentation of Carnival plc’s results and financial position is by reference to
the Carnival Corporation & plc U.S. GAAP consolidated financial statements (
“
DLC Financial Statements
”
).
Accordingly, the DLC Financial Statements are included as part of the Carnival plc Annual Report.
Cautionary Note Concerning Factors That May Affect Future Results
Some of the statements, estimates or projections contained in this document are “forward-looking
statements”that involve risks, uncertainties and assumptions with respect to us, including some statements
concerning future results, operations, outlooks, plans, goals, reputation, cash flows, liquidity and other events
which have not yet occurred. These statements are intended to qualify for the safe harbors from liability
provided by Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933 and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of
1934, as amended. All statements other than statements of historical facts are statements that could be
deemed forward-looking. These statements are based on current expectations, estimates, forecasts and
projections about our business and the industry in which we operate and the beliefs and assumptions of our
management. We have tried, whenever possible, to identify these statements by using words like “will,”
“may,” “could,” “should,” “would,” “believe,” “depends,” “expect,” “goal,” “aspiration,” “anticipate,”
“forecast,” “project,” “future,” “intend,” “plan,” “estimate,” “target,” “indicate,” “outlook,” and similar
expressions of future intent or the negative of such terms.
Forward-looking statements include those statements that relate to our outlook and financial position
including, but not limited to, statements regarding:
• Pricing
• Liquidity and credit ratings
• Booking levels
• Adjusted earnings per share
• Occupancy
• Adjusted EBITDA
• Interest, tax and fuel expenses
• Adjusted Net Income (Loss)
• Currency exchange rates
• Goodwill, ship and trademark fair values
• Estimates of ship depreciable lives and
residual values
Because forward-looking statements involve risks and uncertainties, there are many factors that could cause
our actual results, performance or achievements to differ materially from those expressed or implied in this
Strategic Report. This Strategic Report contains important cautionary statements and a discussion of the
known factors that we consider could materially affect the accuracy of our forward-looking statements
and adversely affect our business, results of operations and financial position. Additionally, many of these
risks and uncertainties are currently, and in the future may continue to be, amplified by our substantial debt
balance as a result of the pause of our guest cruise operations. It is not possible to predict or identify all
such risks. There may be additional risks that we consider immaterial or which are unknown.
Forward-looking statements should not be relied upon as a prediction of actual results. Subject to any
continuing obligations under applicable law or any relevant stock exchange rules, we expressly disclaim any
obligation to disseminate, after the date of this document, any updates or revisions to any such forward-
looking statements to reflect any change in expectations or events, conditions or circumstances on which
any such statements are based. Forward-looking and other statements in this document may also address our
sustainability progress, plans, and goals (including climate change- and environmental-related matters). In
addition, historical, current, and forward-looking sustainability- and climate-related statements may be based
on standards and tools for measuring progress that are still developing, internal controls and processes
that continue to evolve, and assumptions and predictions that are subject to change in the future and may
not be generally shared.
Strategic Report
The Directors consider that within the DLC arrangement, the most appropriate presentation of Carnival
plc’s business strategy is by reference to the consolidated strategy of Carnival Corporation & plc. Accordingly,
this Strategic Report presents the required strategy and business review for Carnival Corporation & plc in
order to satisfy reporting requirements of the Companies Act 2006.
CARNIVAL PLC ANNUAL REPORT
PAGE NO.
Strategic Report
Executive Overview
.....................................................
1
1. Business
...........................................................
2
A. Overview
........................................................
2
I. Summary
.......................................................
2
II. Mission (Purpose), Vision, Values and Priorities
...........................
2
B. Global Cruise Industry
...............................................
4
I. Overview
.......................................................
4
II. Passenger Capacity by Ocean Going Vessels
..............................
4
C. Our Global Cruise Business
...........................................
5
I. Segment Information
...............................................
5
II. Passengers Carried
................................................
5
III. Ships Under Contract for Construction
.................................
6
IV. Cruise Brands
...................................................
7
V. Principal Source Geographic Areas
.....................................
9
VI. Cruise Programs
.................................................
9
VII. Cruise Pricing and Payment Terms
....................................
9
VIII. Seasonality
...................................................
10
IX. Onboard and Other Revenues
........................................
10
X. Marketing Activities
...............................................
10
XI. Sales Channels
..................................................
11
XII. Human Capital Management and Employees
............................
11
XIII. Port Destinations and Private Islands
.................................
13
XIV. Ethics and Compliance
...........................................
13
XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact
...............................
13
XVI. Information Technology
..........................................
29
XVII. Supply Chain
.................................................
30
XVIII. Insurance
...................................................
30
XIX. Governmental Regulations
........................................
31
XX. Taxation
......................................................
38
XXI. Trademarks and Other Intellectual Property
............................
39
XXII. Competition
..................................................
39
D. Website Access to Carnival Corporation & plc SEC Reports
.....................
39
E. Industry and Market Data
............................................
39
F. Properties
........................................................
40
G. Legal Proceedings
..................................................
40
H. Executive Officers and Corporate Governance
..............................
40
I. Dividends
........................................................
41
J. Repurchase Authorizations
............................................
41
2. Business Review
.....................................................
42
3. Internal Control and Risk Assessment
......................................
50
CARNIVAL PLC ANNUAL REPORT
PAGE NO.
4. Risk Management and/or Mitigation of Principal and Emerging Risks
...............
52
5. Going Concern Confirmation and Viability Statement
...........................
64
6. Non-Financial Information Statement
......................................
67
7. Section 172(1) Statement
...............................................
68
Carnival plc Financial Statements for the year ended November 30, 2022
Carnival plc Group Financial Statements
......................................
74
Carnival plc Parent Company Financial Statements
...............................
117
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP Independent Auditors’ Report
........................
132
DLC Financial Statements and Other Information
DLC Financial Statements
................................................
142
Common Stock and Ordinary Shares
........................................
186
Stock Performance Graphs
................................................
187
Shareholder Benefit
.....................................................
189
Corporate and Other Information
...........................................
190
Proxy
Statement
Page No.
Other Information from the Proxy Statement
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
..............................................
A-1
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report – Part I
..............................
39
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report – Part II
.............................
B-1
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
.....................................
C-1
The Carnival plc Annual Report has been submitted to the National Storage Mechanism in European
Single Electronic Format (“ESEF”) and is available for inspection at
data.fca.org.uk/#/nsm/nationalstoragemechanism and will be included in the Annual Meeting materials
available to the Carnival plc shareholders. Only the Carnival plc Annual Report in ESEF is the official version
for the purposes of the ESEF Regulation. The Form 10-K is not set forth within this document but is
available for viewing at www.carnivalcorp.com or www.carnivalplc.com.
2022 Executive Overview
During 2022, we completed a monumental 18-month journey marking our full return to guest cruise
operations. Over the past 18 months we have:
• Returned 90 ships to service
• Re-boarded over 100,000 team members to our ships
• Restarted our unmatched portfolio of eight private island and port destinations
• Restarted our unrivaled land-based footprint in Alaska and the Yukon
• Welcomed back nearly nine million guests
Throughout 2022, we progressed on an upward trajectory as we continued to close the gap to 2019, our
most recent full year of guest cruise operations, and believe we are gaining momentum on our return to
profitability.
• For our cruise segments, revenue per passenger cruise day (“PCD”) for the fourth quarter of 2022
increased 0.5% compared to a strong 2019, overcoming the dilutive impact of future cruise credits
(“FCCs”) and fluctuations in foreign currency. This was better than the third quarter of 2022 which
decreased 4.1% compared to 2019.
• Occupancy in the fourth quarter of 2022 was 19 percentage points below 2019 levels, this was better
than the first quarter of 2022 which was 50 percentage points below 2019 levels. We achieved this on
growing capacity as we returned another 35% of our fleet to service in 2022, reaching 99% of our
2019 capacity levels during the fourth quarter.
• Revenue in the fourth quarter of 2022 was $3.8 billion, which was 80% of 2019 levels. This was
better than the third quarter of 2022 which was 66% of 2019 levels, an improvement of 14 percentage
points.
The uneven reopening of cruise travel around the world following the effects of COVID-19 and the impact
the invasion of Ukraine has had on European countries have had a material impact on our results of
operations. While all of our brands are on an upward trajectory, the pace of the recovery has trailed for
those brands most heavily exposed to these factors as the impacts have weighed on consumer confidence in
those regions resulting in greater uncertainty and closer-in booking patterns. To mitigate these impacts, we
have made strategic deployment decisions to increase our closer-to-home and shorter duration itineraries
to help reduce the friction of air travel, lower the overall cost of our vacations and facilitate a closer-in
booking environment. We believe these decisions have positioned us well to attract more new-to-cruise guests
and make us even more of a value proposition compared to land-based alternatives. Additionally, based on
the evolving nature of COVID-19 and our ongoing collaboration with local and national public health
authorities, our brands responsibly relaxed their COVID-19 related protocols aligning towards land-based
vacation alternatives and strengthening our competitiveness.
To help support our growth, drive overall revenue generation, elevate awareness and consideration and
enhance demand for both the near- and long-term, we have significantly increased our advertising activities,
including a nearly 20% increase in our investment during the fourth quarter of 2022 compared to the
fourth quarter of 2019. Our brands are utilizing pricing philosophies to maximize revenue and are sharing
best practices across brands. Having been in pause status for nearly two years, we are also rebuilding demand
by providing our guests with extraordinary cruise vacations, which we believe will increase the likelihood
of our guests recommending our cruise vacations. In addition, we have a renewed focus on our travel agent
partner relationships and a growing sales force. While building back demand and enhancing our revenue
management tools and strategies, we are working to optimize the combination of occupancy levels with
ticket and onboard prices to deliver revenue growth in the near-term while maintaining price integrity for
the long-term. We are also not losing sight of our expense base as we have worked through our restart and
continue to absorb and mitigate the impacts of the high inflationary environment we have all been living in.
During 2022, we continued to focus on minimizing our environmental impact and achieved a 2% reduction
in carbon intensity compared to 2019 (11% reduction for ships in guest cruise operations), a 30% reduction in
food waste compared to 2019 and used 290 million fewer single use items compared to 2018. We announced
the rollout of Service Power Packages, global fleet upgrades which will improve energy and fuel efficiency
and support our sustainability goals and announced the expansion of Air Lubrication Systems, which are
expected to generate savings in fuel consumption and reductions in carbon emissions. Additionally, AIDA
Cruises and Holland America Line achieved milestones in their decarbonization strategies piloting the use
of a blend of marine biofuel. These investments, along with the company’s fleet optimization and itinerary
Strategic Report
1
reviews, are expected to drive a 15% reduction in fuel consumption per ALBD in 2023, along with a 15%
reduction in carbon emissions per ALBD on an annualized basis, both as compared to 2019.
Our fleet optimization efforts included welcoming stunning new flagships for six of our brands including
Carnival Celebration
,
AIDAcosma
,
Costa Toscana
,
Discovery Princess
and
Arvia
, as well as our first luxury
expedition ship,
Seabourn Venture
. All of these ships were purpose-built to generate higher returns. In addition,
we announced the removal of additional ships from our fleet, bringing the cumulative number of smaller-less
efficient ships to be removed from our fleet since the pause to 26. Once completed, these efforts will result
in nearly a quarter of our fleet consisting of newly delivered, larger-more efficient ships. We also announced
Carnival Fun Italian Style™, a new concept for Carnival Cruise Line’s North American guests which will
debut in the spring of 2023 with
Costa Venezia
followed by
Costa Firenze
in the spring of 2024. Additionally
during 2022,
Costa Luminosa
was transferred to Carnival Cruise Line and began guest operations as
Carnival Luminosa
.
During 2022, we reduced our capital expenditures by over $500 million as compared to our previous
guidance. We have re-prioritized our expected spend to reflect the current environment, while maintaining
our commitment to seek excellence in compliance, environmental protection, and in looking after the safety,
health and well-being of every life we touch. In addition, we broke ground on a new exclusive destination
in Grand Bahama Port for our Carnival Cruise Line brand, which will be an important addition to our current
existing private islands and unique port destinations which had 6 million visits from our guests in 2022.
Going forward, we are committed to using our expected cash provided by operating activities to strengthen
the balance sheet over time and expect to be disciplined and rigorous in making newbuild decisions. We
have just four larger ships on order through 2025, plus our second Seabourn luxury expedition ship to be
delivered in 2023. This is our lowest order book in decades.
Overall, we remain focused on driving revenue growth and accelerating our return to strong profitability. We
believe that over time, this revenue generation and our more focused capital expenditure profile will
support significant free cash flow, and propel us on the path to deleveraging, investment grade credit ratings
and higher return on invested capital. This has been a truly remarkable year and we have come a long way
in an incredibly short amount of time. We look forward to continuing to deliver unforgettable happiness to
our guests by providing extraordinary cruise vacations in 2023, while honoring the integrity of every ocean we
sail, place we visit and life we touch.
1.
Business.
A.
Overview
I.
Summary
Carnival Corporation was incorporated in Panama in 1974 and Carnival plc was incorporated in England
and Wales in 2000. Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc operate a dual listed company (“DLC”), whereby
the businesses of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are combined through a number of contracts and
through provisions in Carnival Corporation’s Articles of Incorporation and By-Laws and Carnival plc’s
Articles of Association. The two companies operate as if they are a single economic enterprise with a
single executive management team and identical Boards of Directors, but each has retained its separate
legal identity. Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are both public companies with separate stock exchange
listings and their own shareholders. Together with their consolidated subsidiaries, Carnival Corporation
and Carnival plc are referred to collectively in this Strategic Report as “Carnival Corporation & plc,”
“company,” “our,” “us” and “we.” We are the largest global cruise company and among the largest leisure
travel companies with a portfolio of world-class cruise lines. With operations in North America, Australia,
Europe and Asia, our portfolio features — AIDA Cruises, Carnival Cruise Line, Costa Cruises, Cunard,
Holland America Line, Princess Cruises, P&O Cruises (Australia), P&O Cruises (UK) and Seabourn.
II.
Mission (Purpose), Vision, Values and Priorities
Mission (Purpose)
To deliver unforgettable happiness to our guests by providing extraordinary cruise vacations, while honoring
the integrity of every ocean we sail, place we visit and life we touch.
2
Vision
As the global leader in the cruise industry, we will lead the way in innovative and sustainable cruising to
deliver memorable vacations and build borderless connections.
Culture Essentials (our Core Values)
•
Speak Up
— Our voice is our strength. Every one of us, regardless of level or role, speaks up when
we have questions, comments, concerns, or new ideas. If we see something wrong or that doesn’t seem
right, we say something and trust our voices will be heard without fear of retaliation.
•
Respect & Protect
— The health, safety and well-being of our people and the planet are vital. We
choose to take decisive actions to respect and protect every life we touch, the places we sail and the
laws that govern us.
•
Empower
— We and our team members have the time, tools and support we need to do our best
work. We’re empowered to take personal ownership and accountability to succeed, and we take pride
in our work.
•
Improve
— Our business is built on forward motion. We have the courage to dream big, driving
innovation and continuous improvement in guest and team member experiences, operations,
compliance, sustainability and beyond.
•
Listen & Learn
— We listen actively and seek to understand before responding, because the more
perspectives we have, the better decisions we make. We value and respect the words and ideas of others,
keeping an open mind, and learning from our successes and failures.
•
Communicate
— We openly share our knowledge, skills and information across brands, functions
and the entire company to further our collective success. Together we champion our mission, vision,
values and company priorities.
Priorities
Ensure each of our world-class brands owns its space in the vacation market by delivering extraordinary
experiences tailored to its guests.
We understand vacation expectations and preferences vary widely among our diverse audience of potential
guests. To fulfill our mission, and in the process achieve outstanding guest satisfaction levels, industry-leading
demand and greatly improved pricing, each of our brands must carve out a distinct identity for delivering
cruise experiences. Our brands must effectively market their uniqueness to existing and potential guests and
deliver on their promise across the entire guest journey.
Become travel and leisure’s employer of choice.
We celebrate our diverse team of over 160,000 team members representing approximately 150 countries and
are committed to providing a welcoming and inclusive environment where people from different
backgrounds, experiences and walks of life can succeed. We care deeply for our team members and must
always cultivate an atmosphere of openness, respect and trust. We know our team members are at the heart
of inspiring unforgettable happiness, so we strive to be the world’s number-one choice for hospitality,
travel and leisure careers.
Maintain our commitment to seek excellence in compliance, environmental protection and in looking after the
safety, health and well-being of every life we touch.
Achieving our mission depends on being good corporate citizens and stewards of the environment.
Safeguarding the planet we call home, our guests, the communities we serve, and our Carnival family, and
complying with the laws and regulations that govern our business, is vital to our success.
Set the pace with the industry’s smartest solutions that deliver on our sustainability roadmap to 2030.
Our earth, ecosystem and environment mean everything to us. Without the incredible communities and
scenic spaces we operate in, our mission of inspiring unforgettable happiness would be impossible. We’re
determined to lead the way in sustainable cruising by promoting positive climate action, contributing to a
circular economy, partnering with the communities we sail to and from and reducing our carbon footprint.
To do this, we are investing in technology upgrades and fleet improvements, piloting alternative fuel types,
Strategic Report
3
optimizing itineraries and cultivating a workforce that mirrors the diversity of the communities we encounter
along the way.
Strengthen our balance sheet and deliver long-term shareholder value.
In recent years, travel and leisure has endured volatility unlike anything seen in modern history, including
unique obstacles that disproportionally affected the cruise industry. With our operations now approaching
full strength and the continued support of our guests, team members, investors and other stakeholders, we are
focused on our financial fitness. We’re determined to drive revenue, operate effectively and efficiently at
scale, generate record levels of cash from operations and invest our capital wisely. We believe this will allow
us to responsibly reduce our debt over time and return to strong profitability and investment-grade credit
ratings.
B.
Global Cruise Industry
I.
Overview
In the face of the global impact of COVID-19, we paused our guest cruise operations in March 2020 and
began resuming guest cruise operations in 2021. As of November 30, 2022, 97% of our capacity is currently
serving guests.
We believe cruising offers a broad range of products and services to suit vacationing guests of many ages,
backgrounds and interests. Each brand in our portfolio meets the needs of a unique set of consumer
psychographics and vacation needs which allows us to penetrate large addressable customer segments. The
mobility of cruise ships enables us to move our vessels between regions in order to meet changing demand
across different geographic areas.
Cruise brands can be broadly classified as offering contemporary, premium and luxury cruise experiences.
The contemporary experience has a more casual ambiance and historically includes cruises that last seven
days or less. The premium experience emphasizes quality, comfort, style and more destination-focused
itineraries and appeals to those who are more affluent. The premium experience generally includes cruises
that last from seven to 14 days. The luxury experience is usually characterized by very high standards of
accommodation and service, smaller vessel size and exotic itineraries to ports that are inaccessible by larger
ships. We have product and service offerings in each of these three broad classifications.
II.
Passenger Capacity by Ocean Going Vessels
Passenger Capacity as of
December 31 (a) (b)
Calendar Year
Global Cruise
Industry (c)
Carnival
Corporation & plc
2019
..............................................
589,820
254,010
2020
..............................................
607,500
246,450
2021
..............................................
636,270
253,950
2022
..............................................
663,970
259,060
2023
..............................................
701,490
263,730
2024
..............................................
729,820
268,050
2025
..............................................
764,440
272,360
(a)
Includes ships which have resumed guest cruise operations and ships expected to resume guest cruise
operations. 2023-2025 excludes four ships which will be removed from our fleet. 2023-2025 data is
estimated based on announced newbuilds and ship retirements and does not include an estimate for
unannounced ship retirements.
(b)
In accordance with cruise industry practice, passenger capacity is calculated based on the assumption
of two passengers per cabin even though some cabins can accommodate three or more passengers.
(c)
Global cruise industry data was obtained from Cruise Industry News.
4
C.
Our Global Cruise Business
I.
Segment Information
Ships in Service or Expected to Return to Service as of
November 30, 2022 (a)
Passenger
Capacity
Percentage of
Total Capacity
Number of
Cruise Ships
North America and Australia (“NAA”) Segment
Carnival Cruise Line
.....................
75,530 (b)
30%
24
Princess Cruises
........................
46,280
18
15
Holland America Line
....................
22,920
9
11
P&O Cruises (Australia)
...................
7,230
3
3
Seabourn
.............................
2,840
1
6
154,800
61
59
Europe and Asia (“EA”) Segment
Costa Cruises (“Costa”)
...................
39,580 (b) (c)
16
11
AIDA Cruises (“AIDA”)
..................
33,540 (d)
13
12
P&O Cruises (UK)
......................
19,020
7
6
Cunard
..............................
6,820
3
3
98,960
39
32
253,760
100%
91
(a)
As of January 12, 2023, includes three Costa ships, with a passenger capacity of 10,880, which are not
in guest cruise operations and are expected to return to service.
(b)
Costa Venezia
with a passenger capacity of 4,200 and
Costa Firenze
with a passenger capacity of 4,240
will be transferred to Carnival Cruise Line in 2023 and 2024, respectively.
(c)
Excludes
Costa Magica,
with a passenger capacity of 2,700, which was previously expected to transfer
to Carnival Cruise Line and will not resume guest cruise operations. Includes
Costa Fortuna
, with a
passenger capacity of 2,700, which is expected to stop guest cruise operations in April 2023.
(d)
Excludes
AIDAvita
, with a passenger capacity of 1,270, which will not resume guest cruise operations.
Includes
AIDAaura
, with a passenger capacity of 1,270, which is expected to stop guest cruise operations
in September 2023.
We also have a Cruise Support segment that includes our portfolio of leading port destinations and other
services, all of which are operated for the benefit of our cruise brands.
In addition to our cruise operations, we own Holland America Princess Alaska Tours, the leading tour
company in Alaska and the Canadian Yukon, which complements our Alaska cruise operations. Our tour
company owns and operates hotels, lodges, glass-domed railcars and motorcoaches which comprise our Tour
and Other segment.
II.
Passengers Carried
In 2022, we carried 7.7 million passengers, consisting of 5.6 million carried by our NAA segment and
2.1 million carried by our EA segment, which was lower than our historical levels as a result of the pause
and subsequent resumption of our guest cruise operations. In 2019, our most recent full year of guest cruise
operations, our brands carried 12.9 million passengers, 8.6 million carried by our NAA segment and
4.2 million carried by our EA segment.
Strategic Report
5
III.
Ships Under Contract for Construction
As of November 30, 2022, we have a total of 6 cruise ships expected to be delivered through 2025. Our ship
construction contracts are with Fincantieri and MARIOTTI in Italy and Meyer Werft in Germany.
Expected
Delivery Date
Passenger Capacity
Lower Berth
Carnival Cruise Line
Carnival Jubilee
(a)
................................
December 2023
5,370
Princess Cruises
Sun Princess
(a)
..................................
January 2024
4,320
Newbuild (a)
....................................
July 2025
4,320
Seabourn
Seabourn Pursuit
.................................
July 2023
260
P&O Cruises (UK)
Arvia
(a)
.......................................
December 2022
5,290
Cunard
Queen Anne
.....................................
April 2024
3,000
(a)
Powered by LNG
6
IV.
Cruise Brands
Carnival Cruise Line is “The World’s Most Popular Cruise Line
®
” and has provided multi-generational
family entertainment at exceptional value to its guests for 50 years. Carnival Cruise Line creates an environment
where guests can be their most playful selves on ships that are designed to inspire the experience of bringing
people together, with limitless opportunities for guests to create their own fun. Carnival Cruise Line is
teaming up with Costa Cruises to create a new concept for Carnival’s North American guests when Carnival
Fun Italian Style™ debuts in the spring of 2023. Carnival Fun Italian Style™ will marry the great service,
food and entertainment that Carnival’s guests enjoy with Costa’s Italian design features.
For over 55 years, Princess has sailed the world connecting guests to what matters most — the people they
love, the people they meet and the destinations they visit. Princess delivers effortless, personalized cruising
thanks to the Princess Medallion, a revolutionary wearable that anticipates guests’needs, wants and
desires so guests can enjoy more of what they love.
Holland America Line has been exploring the world for 150 years and was the first cruise line to offer
adventures in Alaska and Yukon. Its fleet offers an ideal mid-sized ship experience. Holland America Line’s
ships feature a diverse range of enriching experiences focused on destination exploration and personalized
travel. Live music at sea fills each evening at Music Walk, and dining venues feature exclusive selections from
a Culinary Council of world-famous chefs.
For 90 years, P&O Cruises (Australia) has taken Australians & New Zealanders on dream holidays to the
most incredible destinations along the Australian coast as well as the idyllic South Pacific. The home-grown
cruise line delivers a holiday with great entertainment, world-class dining and unforgettable onboard
experiences. Delivered in the Aussie way, guests can choose to do everything, or nothing at all, with P&O
Cruises (Australia).
Strategic Report
7
Seabourn, the most modern luxury fleet at sea, sails to legendary cities and less-traveled ports. Its smaller,
more intimate ships allow guests to discover the unexpected — about the world and about themselves. Guests
enjoy ocean-front suites and epicurean dining is theirs on demand. With nearly one team member for every
guest, its guests make meaningful connections. With Seabourn, they go further, deeper and experience luxury
in action. On a voyage so seamless, so all-inclusive and so far beyond compare, guests never want it to end.
For more than 70 years, Costa’s ships have sailed the seas of the world, offering a diverse choice of cruise
holidays. Costa primarily serves guests from Continental Europe, enriching them through the exploration of
the most beautiful destinations on five continents. Costa brings a modern Italian lifestyle to its ships and
provides guests with a true European experience that embodies a uniquely Italian passion for life through
warm hospitality, entertainment and gastronomy, that makes Costa different from any other cruise experience.
AIDA is the leading and most recognized brand in the German cruise market. AIDA delivers unique travel
experiences with modern comfort, where guests of all ages feel at home and enjoy consistently excellent service
accompanied by the AIDA smile. Guests across generations enjoy the German-inspired modern premium
lifestyle cruise experience with a wide variety of culinary delights, first-class entertainment, unforgettable
shore excursions, numerous sports activities, and spacious wellness areas to relax.
P&O Cruises (UK) is Britain’s biggest cruise line, welcoming guests to extraordinary travel experiences
designed in a distinctively British way — through a blend of discovery, relaxation and exceptional service
catered towards British tastes. P&O Cruises (UK)’s fleet of premium ships deliver authentic travel experiences
around the globe, combining style, quality and innovation with a sense of occasion and attention to detail,
to create a truly memorable holiday.
For over 180 years, the iconic Cunard fleet has perfected the timeless art of luxury ocean travel. While
onboard, Cunard guests experience unique signature moments, from Cunard’s white gloved afternoon tea
service to spectacular gala evening balls to its renowned Insights Speaker program. Guest expectations are
exceeded through Cunard’s exemplary White Star Service
®
. From the moment a guest steps onboard, every
detail of their voyage is curated to ensure they feel special and are inspired by unique events. Onboard
Cunard, guests are free to do as much or as little as they please.
8
V.
Principal Source Geographic Areas
Carnival Corporation & plc
Cruise Guests Carried
(in thousands)
2022
2021
2019
Brands Mainly Serving
United States and Canada
..
5,140
660
7,170
Carnival Cruise Line, Princess Cruises,
Holland America Line, Seabourn and
Cunard
Continental Europe
.......
1,610
390
2,590
Costa and AIDA
United Kingdom
.........
660
170
780
P&O Cruises (UK) and Cunard
Australia and New Zealand . .
230
0
920
Carnival Cruise Line, Princess Cruises and
P&O Cruises (Australia)
Asia
..................
10
—
1,110
Princess Cruises and Costa
Other
.................
80
10
300
Total
.................
7,730
1,220
12,870
As a result of the resumption of guest cruise operations, data for 2022 and 2021 is not representative of a
full year of operations. Due to the pause of our guest cruise operations, data for 2020 is not meaningful and
is not included in the table. We have provided 2019 data as it is our most recent full year of guest cruise
operations.
VI.
Cruise Programs
Carnival Corporation & plc
Percentage of Passenger Capacity by Itinerary
2022
2021
2019
Caribbean
..............................
34%
32%
32%
Europe without Mediterranean
...............
20
23
14
Mediterranean
...........................
18
29
13
Alaska
................................
8
4
6
Australia and New Zealand
..................
3
—
7
China
.................................
—
—
4
Other
.................................
18
12
25
100%
100%
100%
Due to the resumption of guest cruise operations, data for 2022 and 2021 is not representative of a full year
of operations. Due to the pause of our guest cruise operations, data for 2020 is not meaningful and is not
included in the table. We have provided 2019 data as it is our most recent full year of guest cruise operations.
VII.
Cruise Pricing and Payment Terms
Each of our cruise brands publishes prices for the upcoming seasons primarily through the internet,
although published materials such as direct mailings are also used. Our brands have multiple pricing levels
that vary by source market, category of guest accommodation, ship, season, duration and itinerary. Cruise
prices frequently change in a dynamic pricing environment and are impacted by a number of factors,
including the number of available cabins for sale in the marketplace and the level of guest demand. We offer
a variety of special promotions, including early booking, past guest recognition and travel agent programs.
Our bookings are generally taken several months in advance of the cruise departure date. Generally, the longer
the cruise itinerary the further in advance the bookings are made. This lead time allows us to manage our
prices in relation to demand for available cabins through the use of advanced revenue management capabilities
and other initiatives.
Strategic Report
9
The cruise ticket price typically includes the following:
• Accommodations
• Most meals, including snacks at numerous venues
• Access to amenities such as swimming pools, water slides, water parks, whirlpools, a health club, and
sun decks
• Child care and supervised youth programs
• Entertainment, such as theatrical and comedy shows, live music and nightclubs
• Visits to multiple destinations
We offer value added packages to induce ticket sales to guests and groups and to encourage advance
purchase of certain onboard items. These packages are bundled with cruise tickets and sold to guests for a
single price rather than as a separate package and may include one or more of the following:
• Beverage packages
• Internet packages
• Shore excursions
• Photo packages
• Air packages
• Onboard spending credits
• Specialty restaurants
• Service charges
Our brands’payment terms generally require that a guest pay a deposit to confirm their reservation and
then pay the balance due before the departure date.
VIII.
Seasonality
Our passenger ticket revenues are seasonal. Historically, demand for cruises has been greatest during our
third quarter, which includes the Northern Hemisphere summer months. This higher demand during the third
quarter typically results in higher ticket prices and occupancy levels and, accordingly, the largest share of
our operating income is typically earned during this period. This historical trend was disrupted in 2020 by the
pause and in 2021 and 2022 by the subsequent resumption of our guest cruise operations. In addition,
substantially all of Holland America Princess Alaska Tours’revenue and net income (loss) is generated from
May through September in conjunction with Alaska’s cruise season.
IX.
Onboard and Other Revenues
Onboard and other activities are provided either directly by us or by independent concessionaires, from
which we receive either a percentage of their revenues or a fee. Concession revenues do not have direct
expenses because the costs and services incurred for concession revenues are borne by our concessionaires.
In 2022, we earned 42% of our cruise revenues from onboard and other revenue goods and services including:
• Beverage sales
• Internet and communication services
• Casino gaming
• Full service spas
• Shore excursions
• Specialty restaurants
• Retail sales
• Art sales
• Photo sales
• Laundry and dry cleaning services
In 2019, our most recent full year of guest cruise operations, we earned 30% of our cruise revenues from
onboard and other revenues.
X.
Marketing Activities
Guest feedback and research support the development of our overall marketing and business strategies to
drive demand for cruises and increase the number of first-time cruisers. Our goal has always been to increase
consumer awareness for cruise vacations and further grow our share of their vacation spend. We measure
and evaluate key drivers of guest loyalty and their satisfaction with our products and services that provide
valuable insights about guests’cruise experiences. We closely monitor our net promoter scores, which reflect
the likelihood that our guests will recommend our brands’ cruise products and services to friends and
family, including those new-to-cruise.
During 2022, in connection with the resumption of guest cruise operations, we increased our marketing and
advertising programs after significantly reducing both during 2020 and 2021. Our brands have comprehensive
marketing and advertising programs across diverse mediums to promote their products and services to
10
vacationers and our travel agent partners. Each brand’s marketing activities have generally been designed to
reach a local region in the local language. We are focused on driving further brand differentiation and
clarity around each of our brand’s optimal target segments, ensuring that our creative marketing speaks to
each brand’s target audience and launching more effective digital performance marketing and lead generation
approaches. Our marketing efforts historically have allowed us to attract new guests online by leveraging
the reach and impact of digital marketing and social media. Over time, we have invested in new marketing
technologies to deliver more engaging and personalized communications. This has helped us cultivate guests
as advocates of our brands, ships, itineraries and onboard products and services.
Substantially all of our cruise brands offer past guest recognition programs that reward repeat guests with
special incentives such as reduced fares, gifts, onboard activity discounts, complimentary laundry and internet
services, expedited ship embarkation and disembarkation and special onboard activities.
XI.
Sales Channels
We sell our cruises through travel agents, tour operators, company vacation planners and our websites. Our
individual cruise brands’relationships with their travel agent partners are generally independent of each of
our other brands. Our travel agents relationships are generally not exclusive and travel agents generally
receive a base commission, plus the potential of additional commissions, including discounts or
complimentary tour conductor cabins, based on the achievement of pre-defined sales volumes.
Travel agent partners are an integral part of our long-term cruise distribution network and are critical to
our success. We utilize local sales teams to motivate travel agents to support our products and services with
competitive pricing, promotional policies and joint marketing and advertising programs. During 2022, no
group of travel agencies under common control accounted for 10% or more of our revenues. We also
employ a wide variety of educational programs, including websites, seminars and videos, to train agents on
our cruise brands and their products and services. In 2022, we held a variety of virtual and in-person trainings
and educational programs to continue to support and develop our travel agent partners, including ship
visits to familiarize our travel agent partners with our enhanced health and safety protocols.
All of our brands have internet booking engines to allow travel agents to book our cruises. Additionally, all
of our cruise brands have their own consumer websites that provide access to information about their products
and services to users and enable their guests to quickly and easily book cruises and other products and
services online. These sites interface with our brands’social networks, blogs and other social media sites,
which allow them to develop greater contact and interaction with their guests before, during and after their
cruise. We also employ vacation planners who support our sales initiatives by offering our guests one-on-one
cruise planning expertise and other services.
XII.
Human Capital Management and Employees
Our shipboard and shoreside employees are sourced from approximately 150 countries. In connection with
our resumption of guest cruise operations in 2022, we increased the number of employees onboard our ships
from the reduced levels during 2021 and 2020. In 2022, we had an average of 75,000 employees onboard
our ships, excluding employees on leave. Our shoreside operations had an annual average of 10,000 full-time
and 2,000 part-time/seasonal employees. In 2019, our most recent full year of guest cruise operations, we
had an average of 92,000 employees on our ships, excluding employees on leave and our shoreside operations
had an annual average of 12,000 full-time and 2,000 part-time/seasonal employees. Holland America
Princess Alaska Tours significantly increases its work force during the late spring and summer months in
connection with Alaska’s cruise season.
Strategic Report
11
Gender Diversity
:
Approximate Average for 2022 (a)
Female
Male
Shoreside Employees
...................................
7,000
5,000
Shipboard Employees
..................................
13,000
62,000
Total Employees
......................................
20,000
67,000
As of November 30, 2022
Female
Male
Boards of Directors
....................................
4
9
Non-Director Senior Management and Company Secretary
........
6
7
Non-Director Senior Management and Company Secretary Direct
Reports
...........................................
27
57
(a)
These amounts are approximations and at times, fluctuate significantly due to the seasonality of our
business.
We have entered into agreements with unions covering certain employees on our ships and in our shoreside
hotel and transportation operations. The percentages of our shipboard and shoreside employees that are
represented by collective bargaining agreements are 55% and 24%, respectively. We consider our employee
and union relationships to be strong.
A team of highly motivated and engaged employees is key to providing extraordinary cruise vacations. To
facilitate the recruitment, development and retention of our valuable employees, we strive to make Carnival
Corporation & plc a diverse, inclusive and safe workplace, with opportunities for our employees to grow
and develop in their careers.
a.
Talent Development
We believe in the investment in our team members through the training and development of both shoreside
and shipboard employees. We leverage a combination of virtual and in-person training to ensure that our
teams are well-prepared to carry out their individual and collective responsibilities.
For our shipboard employees, our goal is to be a leader in delivering high quality professional maritime
training, as evidenced by the Arison Maritime Center. The Center is home to the Center for Simulator
Maritime Training (“CSMART”). The leading-edge CSMART Academy features the most advanced bridge
and engine room simulator technology and equipment available, with the capacity to provide annual
professional training for all our bridge, engineering and environmental officers. CSMART participants
receive a maritime training experience that fosters advanced knowledge and skills development, critical
thinking and problem solving; all in a professional learning environment where our corporate culture is
reinforced. CSMART also offers training related to liquefied natural gas (“LNG”) technology as well as an
environmental officer training program and additional environmental courses for bridge and engineering
officers to further enhance our training on environmental awareness and protection.
b.
Succession Planning
Our Boards of Directors believe that planning for succession is an important function. Our multi-brand
structure enhances our succession planning process. At the corporate level, a highly-skilled management team
oversees a collection of cruise brands. We continually strive to foster the professional development of
management and team members in other critical roles. As a result, we have developed a very experienced
and strong group of leaders, with their performance subject to ongoing monitoring and evaluation, as
potential successors to all of our executive positions, including our CEO.
In August 2022, Josh Weinstein, previously our Chief Operations Officer, was appointed President, CEO
and Chief Climate Officer. Josh Weinstein has a long history of success in critical senior-level roles for our
company. In his most recent assignment for the past two years as Chief Operations Officer he oversaw all
major operational functions including global maritime, global ports and destinations, global sourcing,
global IT and global auditing. During this time, he also oversaw Carnival UK, the operating company for
P&O Cruises (UK) and Cunard, which he previously managed directly for three years as president. Prior to
his role with Carnival UK, he was our company’s treasurer for 10 years.
12
XIII.
Port Destinations and Private Islands
We operate a portfolio of port destinations and private islands enabling us to offer exceptional guest
experiences by creating a wide variety of high quality destinations around the world that are uniquely tailored
to our guests’preferences. In addition, to secure preferential berth access to third-party ports, we enter
into berthing agreements and commitments.
In May 2022, Carnival Cruise Line broke ground on its new Carnival Grand Bahama cruise port destination,
expected to open in 2025 and located on the south side of Grand Bahama Island. The new cruise port
development will include a pier able to accommodate up to two of our largest ships simultaneously,
welcoming guests to a stunning beach and further expanding our experience offerings for our guests.
Additionally, our investment in this cruise port destination will support our efforts to design more energy
efficient itineraries based on its strategic location. Carnival Grand Bahama will be an important addition to
our current portfolio of six corporate operated ports and destinations in the Caribbean:
• Puerta Maya in Cozumel, Mexico
• Grand Turk Cruise Center in Turks & Caicos
• Mahogany Bay in Isla Roatan, Honduras
• Amber Cove in the Dominican Republic
• Half Moon Cay, a private island in The Bahamas
• Princess Cay, a private island in The Bahamas
XIV.
Ethics and Compliance
We believe a strong ethics and compliance culture is imperative for the success of any company. Our
compliance framework includes a Global Ethics and Compliance (“GE&C”) department, which is led by
our Chief Risk and Compliance Officer who leads the effort to promote and monitor a strong ethics and
compliance culture throughout the company. The main responsibilities of the GE&C department are to
collaboratively:
• Identify, assess, monitor, prevent, detect and report on compliance risk
• Ensure compliance accountabilities and responsibilities are clear across the company
• Promote a strong culture of ethics and compliance
• Drive ethics and compliance continuous improvements
To further heighten the focus on ethics and compliance, our Boards of Directors have Compliance
Committees, which oversee the GE&C department and maintain regular communications with our Chief
Risk and Compliance Officer. Refer to Item 3. Internal Control and Risk Assessment on page 50 for additional
details.
XV.
Sustainability and Environmental Impact
We strive to be a company that people want to work for and to be an exemplary global corporate citizen.
Our commitment and actions to keep our guests and crew members safe and well, protect the environment,
develop and provide opportunities for our workforce, strengthen stakeholder relations and enhance both
the communities where we work as well as the port communities that our ships visit, are reflective of our
brands’ core values and vital to our success.
In 2021, we established goals for 2030 which incorporate six key focus areas listed below that align with
elements of the United Nation’s Sustainable Development Goals and build on the momentum of our
successful achievement of our 2020 sustainability goals.
Strategic Report
13
Sustainability Goals Progress
The tables below represent our progress on each of our six key focus areas:
2030 Climate Action Goals
Status (a)
Our Progress
Achieve 20% carbon intensity reduction
relative to our 2019 baseline measured in
both grams of CO
2
e per ALB-km and
kilograms of CO
2
e per ALBD
On Track
Achieved 2% carbon intensity reduction on
an ALB-km basis and 4% on an ALBD
basis. For ships in guest cruise operations,
achieved 11% carbon intensity reduction on
an ALB-km basis and 13% on an ALBD
basis
Reduce absolute particulate matter air
emissions by 50% relative to our 2015
baseline
Achieved
Increase fleet shore power connection
capability to 60% of the fleet
On Track
57% of the fleet has shore power connection
capability
Expand our LNG program
On Track
Seven LNG ships across the fleet
Optimize the reach and performance of our
Advanced Air Quality System program
On Track
93% of the fleet has Advanced Air Quality
Systems installed (b)
Expand battery, fuel cell and biofuel
capabilities
Ongoing
Piloted the use of biofuels as a replacement
for fossil fuel on two ships
Reduce Scope 3 (indirect) emissions
associated with food procurement and waste
management
Ongoing
Completed an inventory of our Scope 3
emissions. Following the Greenhouse Gas
Protocol, we estimate that our Scope 3
emissions represent approximately half of
our total emissions
Identify carbon offset options only when
energy efficiency options have been
exhausted
Ongoing
Continuing to monitor the carbon offset
market and options, as well as exploring
carbon capture and storage opportunities
2030 Circular Economy Goals
Status (a)
Our Progress
Achieve 50% single-use plastic item
reduction in 2021
Achieved
Achieve 30% unit food waste reduction by
2022 and 50% unit food waste reduction by
2030
• 2022 goal
achieved
• 2030 goal
on track
• Established interim goal to achieve 40%
unit food waste reduction by 2025
Increase Advanced Waste Water Treatment
System coverage to >75% of our fleet
capacity
On Track
Achieved 64% coverage of fleet capacity
Send a larger percentage of waste to
waste-to-energy facilities where practical
Ongoing
Completed a baseline of our waste
programs in the U.S.
Partner with primary vendors to reduce
upstream packaging volumes
Ongoing
Completed a packaging reduction pilot
program with our primary engine supplier
and achieved a reduction of approximately
44%
14
2030 Good Health and Well-Being Goals
Status (a)
Our Progress
Committed to continued job creation
Ongoing
• Increased the number of employees on
board our ships from the reduced levels
during the pause in guest cruise
operations
• Opened and filled a significant number of
shoreside positions
Establish measurable Company Culture
metrics and set annual improvement targets
Ongoing
Established Company Culture metrics with
semi-annual Culture surveys and are in the
process of establishing improvement targets
Implement global well-being standards by
2023
Ongoing
• Continued to work with authorities to
arrange for COVID-19 vaccinations and
boosters for our crew members, many of
whom may not have had access to
vaccines
• Maintained and evolved onboard public
health protocols to reflect the changing
nature of the pandemic while protecting
our guests and crew members responsibly
Reduce the number of guest and crew
work-related injuries
Ongoing
Continued to implement initiatives to
prevent guest and crew injuries
2030 Sustainable Tourism Goals
Status (a)
Our Progress
Animal Welfare – responsible sourcing
• Achieve 100% cage free eggs by the end of
2025.
• Achieve 100% responsible chicken
sourcing by the end of 2025
• Achieve 100% gestation crate-free pork by
the end of 2025
On Track
Continued to work with our supply chain
and met our glidepath targets for FY2022 –
achieved 58% cage free eggs, 25%
responsible chicken and 29% gestation
crate-free pork purchases
Establish partnerships with destinations
focused on sustainable economic
development, preservation of local
traditions, and capacity management
Ongoing
• Broke ground on a new cruise port
destination on Grand Bahama Island,
which is expected to open in 2025. The
new port will provide business
opportunities for the residents of Grand
Bahama with an estimated 1,000 local
jobs
• Working with ports of Miami, Galveston,
Barcelona, Savona and Genoa to support
their shore power development efforts
• Joined the Alaska Green Corridor
partnership to explore methods to
accelerate the reduction of greenhouse gas
emissions
• Costa Cruises continued with the
“Traditions in the Future” project which
supports the preservation of traditional
arts and crafts to a new generation of
artisans
Strategic Report
15
2030 Sustainable Tourism Goals
Status (a)
Our Progress
Continue to support disaster resilience,
relief, and recovery efforts
Ongoing
• Provided temporary housing for 1,500
Ukrainian refugees on a Holland America
Line ship for five months
• Launched brand specific projects and
provided overall support to our Ukrainian
crew members and their families
Build stronger community relationships in
our employment bases and destinations via
employee volunteering programs
Ongoing
Conducted multiple costal cleanups
involving shipboard- and shoreside
employees and partners in various locations
around the world
2030 Biodiversity and Conservation Goals
Status (a)
Our Progress
Support biodiversity and conservation
initiatives through select NGO partnerships
Ongoing
Continued working with the Ocean 100
Dialogues to support ocean stewardship
with a focus on climate change and
biodiversity
Conduct audits and monitor animal
encounter excursions regularly
Ongoing
Published Animal Welfare Statement for
Excursions & Experiences on our website
2030 Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Goals
Status (a)
Our Progress
Ensure our overall shipboard and shoreside
employee base reflects the diversity of the
world
Ongoing
Continued to employ shipboard crew
members from approximately 150 countries
around the world
Expand shipboard and shoreside diversity,
equity, and inclusion across all ranks and
departments
Ongoing
• Half of the global direct reports to our
CEO are women
• Named as one of the World’s Top
Female-Friendly Companies by Forbes
• Named as one of the World’s Best
Employers by Forbes Recognized as one
of America’s Best Employers for Diversity
by Forbes Named among Best Companies
for Latinos to Work by Latino Leaders
Magazine
• Earned a perfect score of 100 from the
Human Rights Campaign (HRC) and
designation as one of the Best Places to
Work for LGBTQ+ equality
(a)
On Track — Quantifiable/numerical goals that are showing a positive trend towards achieving the goal.
Ongoing — Qualitative/non-numerical goals which are currently in progress.
(b)
Excluding LNG ships.
A key focus of our sustainability efforts is climate action, which includes our commitment to reduce carbon
emissions and our aspiration to achieve net carbon-neutral operations. We have made significant progress
towards our 2030 carbon intensity reduction goals of 40% from a 2008 baseline, measured in both grams of
CO
2
e per available lower berth kilometer (“ALB-km”) and kilograms of CO
2
e per available lower berth
day (“ALBD”). During 2022, we updated the baseline year for both goals to 2019 from 2008. Both 2030 goals
now require a 20% improvement from 2019. With the updated baseline year, we strengthened our 2030
goal measured in kilograms of CO
2
e per ALBD since the initial 2030 goal would only have required a further
15% reduction from 2019 levels. Our goal measured in grams of CO
2
e per ALB-km remains the same. In
addition, this new baseline year helps us better communicate recent progress against our climate goals to our
investors and stakeholders as well as modernize our disclosures in alignment with developing best practice
and reporting standards.
16
We plan to achieve our 2030 carbon intensity goals based on the following planned actions:
• The delivery of larger-more efficient ships, as part of our ongoing newbuild program, some of which
will replace existing ships in our fleet
• Designing more energy-efficient itineraries
• Investing in port and destination projects
• Continuing to invest in new technologies and energy efficiency projects for our existing fleet; since
2016, we have invested over $350 million
We have considered the above planned actions in connection with the preparation of our financial statements
and any estimates used in the preparation of our financial statements, include projections (where applicable)
consistent with the above planned actions.
In addition to our 2030 sustainability goals, we are committed to continuing our reduction of carbon
emissions and have aspirations to achieve net carbon-neutral operations by 2050, well ahead of current
International Maritime Organization (“IMO”) targets. While fossil fuels are currently the only viable option
for our industry, we are closely monitoring technology developments and partnering with key organizations
to help identify and scale new technologies not yet ready for the cruise industry. For example, we are piloting
maritime scale battery technology and methanol powered fuel cells and working with classification societies
and other stakeholders to assess lower carbon fuel options for cruise ships, which includes methanol,
bioLNG, eLNG, hydrogen, and biofuels. During 2022, we piloted the use of biofuel as a replacement for
fossil fuel on two of our ships.
AIDAprima
became the first larger-scale cruise ship to be powered with a blend
of marine biofuel, made from 100% sustainable raw materials, and marine gasoil (“MGO”). Additionally,
Holland America Line completed two pilots on
Volendam
, one using a blend of marine biofuel and another
using 100% biofuel, becoming the first larger-scale cruise ship to be powered 100% by biofuel. The certified
biofuels used in these pilots offer environmental benefits compared to using fossil fuels alone through their
lifecycle CO
2
reductions. These biofuels can be used in existing ship engines without modifications to the
engine or fuel infrastructure, including on ships already in service. While alternative fuels may provide a path
to decarbonization for the maritime industry, there are significant supply challenges that must be resolved
before viability is reached. We are working with suppliers to encourage investment in a reliable supply
infrastructure.
During 2022, we also announced the global rollout of Service Power Packages, a comprehensive set of
technology upgrades, which will be implemented over the next several years across a portion of the fleet.
These upgrades include the following elements designed to reduce both fuel usage and greenhouse gas
(“GHG”) emissions while also contributing to cost savings:
• Comprehensive upgrades to each ship’s hotel HVAC systems
• Technical systems upgrades on each ship
• State-of-the-art LED lighting systems
• Remote monitoring and optimization of energy usage and performance
The Service Power Package upgrades are part of our ongoing energy efficiency investment program and are
expected to further improve energy savings and reduce fuel consumption. Upon completion, these upgrades
are expected to deliver an average of 5-10% fuel savings per ship.
In addition, we have five Air Lubrication Systems (“ALS”) currently operating in our fleet, we are currently
installing ALS on six ships and we are planning at least eight more installations. ALS cushion the flat
bottom of a ship’s hull with air bubbles, which reduces the ship’s frictional resistance and the propulsive
power required to drive the ship through the water, which is expected to generate approximately 5% savings
in fuel consumption and reductions in carbon emissions on ALS equipped ships.
As part of our plan for carbon footprint reduction, we have 11 LNG powered cruise ships that are expected
to join the fleet through 2025, including seven ships already in operation as of November 30, 2022. In
total, these ships are expected to represent 20% of our total future capacity by summer 2025. All of our
LNG ships also have the capability to run on conventional fuels. The price of LNG in certain markets has
been unattractive compared to other alternatives, and as such, at times we use conventional fuels to power our
LNG ships.
LNG is a fossil fuel and generates carbon emissions. Its direct CO
2
emissions are lower than those of
conventional fuels and it emits effectively zero sulfur oxides (only the sulfur in the pilot fuel is present),
reducing nitrogen oxides by 85% and particulate matter by 95%-100%. The types of engines that we use are
subject to small amounts of methane slip (the passage of un-combusted methane through the engine).
Strategic Report
17
There are different views relating to the measurement of the environmental impact of LNG, including the
methane slip. Our disclosures report our emissions, including methane slip, as part of our total carbon
emissions (reported as CO
2
e) using the 100-year global warming potential time frame and measured on a
“tank to wake” basis. We are working closely with our engine manufacturers and other technology providers
to further mitigate methane slip, and have recently joined the Methane Abatement in Maritime (“MAM”)
Innovation Initiative, where we will partner with other major maritime players to seek solutions for this
challenge.
We pioneered the use of Advanced Air Quality Systems on board our ships to aid in the reduction of sulfur
and lifecycle GHG emissions and are promoting the use of shore power. Shore power enables our ships to
use shoreside electric power, where available, while in port rather than running their engines to power their
onboard services, resulting in reduced ship air emissions. We have continued our work with several local
port authorities to utilize cruise ship shore power connections.
As part of our sustainability strategy, we have voluntarily reported our carbon footprint via the CDP
(formerly, the Carbon Disclosure Project) each year since 2006. The CDP rates companies on the depth and
scope of their disclosures and the quality of their reporting. We developed a GHG inventory management
plan in 2010 in accordance with the requirements of International Organization for Standardization (“ISO”)
14064-1:2018(E) standard and The Greenhouse Gas Protocol. Our submission includes details of our
most recently compiled emissions data and reduction efforts, along with the results of an independent,
third-party verification of our GHG emissions inventory. We also disclose our water stewardship through
the CDP water program.
Carnival Corporation & plc’s environmental management system is certified in accordance with the
ISO 14001:2015 Environmental Management System standard.
We voluntarily publish Sustainability Reports that address governance, stakeholder engagement,
environmental, labor, human rights, society, product responsibility, economic and other sustainability-
related issues and performance indicators. These reports, which are not incorporated in this document but
can be viewed at www.carnivalcorp.com, www.carnivalplc.com and www.carnivalsustainability.com, were
developed in accordance with the Global Reporting Initiative (“GRI”) Standards, the global standard for
sustainability reporting.
18
a.
Summary of our Environmental Impact
Unit
Global
Emissions
2022 (a)
Global
Emissions
2021 (a)
Global
Emissions
2019
UK
Emissions
2022
UK
Emissions
2021
UK
Emissions
2019
GHG Emissions
(in thousands)
Scope 1 – Direct GHG
Emissions
..............
Metric Tons
CO
2
e
8,539
4,409
10,723
1,027
480
1,223
Scope 2 – Indirect GHG
Emissions – Location
based
.................
Metric Tons
CO
2
e
43
29
47
1
1
1
Total GHG Emissions
(Scope 1&2) – Location
based
.................
Metric Tons
CO
2
e
8,582
4,438
10,770
1,028
481
1,225
Energy Consumption
(in millions)
Scope 1 – Energy
Consumption
...........
Kwh
30,853
15,752
38,298
3,733
1,721
4,404
Scope 2 – Energy
Consumption
...........
Kwh
107
82
114
3
2
3
Total Energy Consumption
(Scope 1&2)
............
Kwh
30,960
15,834
38,412
3,736
1,723
4,408
Intensity Ratio
...........
Grams of
CO
2
e/
ALB-Km
241
330
246
267
385
284
Intensity Ratio
...........
Kilograms of
CO
2
e/
ALBD
115
(b)
120
123
(b)
140
(a)
The CO
2
e conversion factors were adjusted in May 2021 following a review of the latest studies from
outside sources. The 2022 and 2021 GHG emissions were calculated using the adjusted CO
2
e conversion
factors.
(b)
Intensity ratio measured in kilograms of CO
2
e per ALBD for 2021 is not meaningful due to the
resumption of guest cruise operations.
GHG emissions data collection and calculations were performed in accordance with our GHG inventory
management plan, the Greenhouse Gas Protocol, emission factors from the International Energy Agency,
IMO and ISO14064 — Part 3 standard. Ship fuel emissions represent over 97% of our total global emissions.
UK ship fuel emissions represent over 98% of their total emissions. Total emissions include both scope 1
and scope 2 combined.
Scope 1 emissions include direct emissions from the combustion of ship fuel, inadvertent release of
ship refrigerants, and other direct emissions generated by sources owned or controlled by Carnival
Corporation & plc (global number as per above table) as well as ships operated and facilities owned and
leased by our UK-based and marketed brands — P&O Cruises (UK number as per above table) and Cunard
(UK number as per above table).
Scope 2 emissions include emissions from the consumption of electricity for facilities and ships as well as
heat or steam purchased by sources owned or controlled by Carnival Corporation & plc (global number as
per above table) as well as ships operated and facilities owned and leased by our UK-based and marketed
brands — P&O Cruises (UK) and Cunard (UK number as per above table).
We measure and report the ship fuel GHG emission rate in terms of grams of CO
2
e per ALB-Km. This
indicator enables us to make meaningful GHG emission reduction comparisons that take into account
changes in fleet size, itineraries and passenger capacity during normal operations. As a result of the resumption
of guest cruise operations, data for 2022 and 2021 is not representative of a full year of operations. Due to
the pause of our guest cruise operations, data for 2020 is not meaningful and is not included in the table. We
have provided 2019 data as it is our most recent full year of guest cruise operations.
Strategic Report
19
(in thousands, except percentages)
Unit
2022
2021
2019
Water Consumption
...............................
Metric Tons
17,867
5,730
27,122
Wastewater
.....................................
Metric Tons
17,395
5,437
26,787
Waste Disposal
..................................
Metric Tons
231
122
371
Percent of Waste Recycled
..........................
Percent
30.2%
35.8%
27.6%
As a result of the resumption of guest cruise operations, data for 2022 and 2021 is not representative of a
full year of operations. Due to the pause of our guest cruise operations, data for 2020 is not meaningful and
is not included in the table. We have provided 2019 data as it is our most recent full year of guest cruise
operations.
b.
Climate-Related Financial Disclosures
Under the UK Listing Rule LR 9.8.6R, which is mandatory for Carnival plc for the year ended November 30,
2022, we set out below our climate-related financial disclosures fully consistent with 10 out of the 11 Task
Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (“TCFD”) Recommendations and Recommended
disclosures. For Metrics and Targets recommended disclosures b), we are partially consistent, as further
work is underway to fully measure and disclose our Scope 3 GHG emissions, which we expect to disclose in
our 2023 Strategic Report. Our consistency with the TCFD’s four pillars, Governance, Strategy, Risk
Management and Metrics and Targets, and the recommendations thereof, are represented in the table below.
TCFD Pillar
Recommended disclosures
Section Reference
Governance
a) Describe the Boards’ oversight
of climate-related risks and
opportunities.
Governance
b) Describe management’s role in
assessing and managing climate-
related risks and opportunities.
Strategy
a) Describe the climate-related
risks and opportunities the
organisation has identified over
the short, medium, and long
term.
Strategy: Qualitative scenario
analysis
b) Describe the impact of
climate-related risks and
opportunities on the
organisation’s businesses,
strategy, and financial planning.
Strategy: Quantitative Scenario
Analysis
c) Describe the resilience of the
organisation’s strategy, taking
into consideration different
climate-related scenarios,
including a 2°C or lower
scenario.
Risk Management
a) Describe the organisation’s
processes for identifying and
assessing climate-related risks.
Risk Management: Climate Risk
and Opportunity Identification,
Owner Assignment and
Assessment
b) Describe the organisation’s
processes for managing climate-
related risks.
Risk Management: Climate Risk
and Opportunity Monitoring,
Management and Reporting
c) Describe how processes for
identifying, assessing, and
managing climate-related risks
are integrated into the
organisation’s overall risk
management.
Risk Management: Integration
into our overall risk management
20
TCFD Pillar
Recommended disclosures
Section Reference
Metrics and Targets
a) Disclose the metrics used by
the organisation to assess
climate-related risks and
opportunities in line with its
strategy and risk management
process.
Metrics and Targets
b) Disclose Scope 1, Scope 2,
and, if appropriate, Scope 3
GHG emissions, and the related
risks.
c) Describe the targets used by
the organisation to manage
climate-related risks and
opportunities and performance
against targets.
Governance
The Chief Climate Officer (“CCO”) and the Boards of Directors are responsible for the oversight of
climate-related matters and are directly supported by members of executive management. In addition, the
CCO and the Boards of Directors set the tone at the top with regards to embedding a climate risk culture
through fulfilling their responsibilities as outlined in the climate risk management framework (see page 27).
In January 2022, the Boards of Directors appointed Arnold Donald, President and CEO at the time, to
the additional role of CCO. In August 2022, Josh Weinstein, our Chief Operations Officer assumed the roles
of President, CEO and CCO. The CCO leads the identification of climate-related risks and opportunities
and oversees how these are embedded in our strategic decision-making and risk management processes.
To further support our climate-related efforts, we created a Strategic Risk Evaluation (“SRE”) Committee.
The SRE Committee consists of members of executive management and an advisor and reports to the CEO,
who in turn, reports to the Boards of Directors. At its establishment in January 2022, the SRE Committee
was comprised of David Bernstein (Chief Financial Officer), Josh Weinstein (then Chief Operations Officer),
William Burke (Chief Maritime Officer), and Stein Kruse (Advisor to the CEO & Chair of the Boards).
Following the August 2022 changes in leadership, Richard Brilliant (Chief Risk and Compliance Officer)
was added to the SRE Committee, David Bernstein was appointed as Chair of the SRE Committee, and Josh
Weinstein, who remained on the SRE Committee, assumed the role of CCO. The primary responsibility of
the SRE Committee is to assist the CCO in fulfilling his responsibility to identify, monitor and review the
management of climate-related risks and opportunities. Common recurring activities of the SRE
Committee include:
• Discussing climate considerations in the planning processes to further support its focus on
decarbonization, such as the recently adopted Corporate Itinerary Decarbonization Reviews.
• Considering if any new climate risks or opportunities should be included in the list of identified
climate risks and opportunities.
• Ensuring appropriate assignment of identified climate risks and opportunities to risk owners, who
are responsible for their day-to-day evaluation and management.
• Obtaining at least annual reporting from the risk owners on the monitoring and management of
identified risks and opportunities and reviewing, scrutinizing and challenging management of climate
risks and opportunities.
• Reviewing and approving the climate risk management framework.
An SRE Committee Charter was adopted and 12 SRE Committee meetings have taken place between its
creation in January 2022 and November 2022. From these discussions, the SRE Committee has provided a
quarterly update to the Boards of Directors on climate-related matters such as:
• Resetting our GHG baseline year to 2019 from 2008 and a strengthening of our 2030 goals relative
to the new baseline.
• Establishment of a climate risk framework.
• Completion of the qualitative and quantitative scenario analysis assessments.
• Commissioning of the port analysis study (see page 27).
Strategic Report
21
Role
Boards of Directors
Compensation
Compliance
Health,
Environmental,
Safety & Security
Ultimate oversight of climate-related
risks and opportunities
Committees responsible for
oversight of relevant aspects
of risks and opportunities
which may include climate
related issues
Assist in identifying,
monitoring and reviewing
climate-related risks and
opportunities
Lead integration of
climate into key
business functions
Support integration of
climate-related oversight
and management
Audit
Nominating &
Governance
Strategic Risk Evaluation Committee (SRE)
Executive Management
Management
Climate Risk Owners
CEO and
CCO
Management
Boards
Climate-Related Function
Board Education Program
To enable the CCO and Boards of Directors to fulfil their responsibility to oversee climate-related risks and
opportunities, a Board Environmental, Social and Governance (“ESG”) and TCFD education program
has been established, with core education components and optional self-study courses. This ESG and TCFD
education program has been developed with support from external advisors and the Senior Independent
Director. The core education components of the program were completed in November 2022. An annual
refresher education program, including updates to ESG and TCFD considerations, has been established.
Strategy
During 2022, we performed a qualitative and quantitative scenario analysis to assess our climate-related
risks and opportunities over the short, medium and long term.
Qualitative scenario analysis
We qualitatively applied two (and quantitatively applied three) distinct plausible climate scenarios, global
warming limited to below 1.5
o
C above pre-industrial levels by 2100 “Steady Path to Sustainability” and global
warming of 2.8
o
C above pre-industrial levels by 2100 “Regional Rivalry.” The scenarios were used to
generate the climate-related risks and opportunities listed in the table below.
As part of our qualitative scenario analysis, a series of workshops with the SRE Committee and a cross-
section of management was conducted to identify material climate-related risks and opportunities, based on
likelihood and degree of potential financial impact, over the following time horizons:
• Present – 2025 (short-term) — consistent with the period we use for our Viability Statement
• 2025 – 2035 (medium-term) — aligns with our existing sustainability goals
• 2035 – 2050 (long-term) — consistent with the useful life of our ships
Following the workshops, the SRE Committee selected certain risks and opportunities for further assessment
and quantification. The process of selecting these risks and opportunities included an in-depth assessment
by each participant of the proposed risks and opportunities. The process incorporated the use of a feasibility
matrix and subsequent group discussion to arrive at consensus on which risks and opportunities were most
appropriate for quantification. Feasibility was evaluated on the availability of internal and external
climate-related data, the estimated number of assumptions required and the magnitude of impact and
likelihood of occurrence.
22
Climate-related risks identified through qualitative scenario analysis
Our initial selected risks and opportunities for quantification are in
bold
:
TCFD risk categories
Risk summary
Impact time horizon
Markets and Products / Shifting
Markets (1)
Cruising no longer aligns to
consumers’ climate values
Medium Term
Reduced availability and access to
fuel*
Long Term
Unable to meet climate-related
requirements reduces access to
capital / insurance
Medium Term
Policy and Legal (1)
Increased costs driven by
climate-related regulations*
Short-Medium Term
Risk is that cruising (as a
carbon-intensive industry) is
severely restricted or subject to
bans
Medium Term
Reputation (1)
Failure to attract and retain
talent due to climate credentials
Medium Term
Increased demand for reducing
carbon-intensive practices
Short Term
Technology (1)
Lack of viable low carbon
technology to replace fossil fuels
Medium Term
Physical
Chronic climate change impacting
supply chain availability and price
Medium Term with expected
increases in the Long Term
Itineraries are not viable due to
extreme weather and/or sea level
rise
Medium Term with expected
increases in the Long Term
(1)
Transition Risks
*
Due to the similar nature of these risks, we have combined them for the quantitative analysis into a
combined risk: “How does a low-carbon transition impact the price of the fuels needed to power our ship
engines?”
Strategic Report
23
Climate-related opportunities identified through qualitative scenario analysis
TCFD opportunity categories
Opportunity summary
Realisation time horizon
Energy Source
Support the adaptation of
sustainable technological
advances for the cruise industry
Medium Term
Market Access
Access to new financing options
available for organisations
working on decarbonisation
Short-Medium Term
Access to private destinations or
islands with infrastructure built
by us
Short-Medium Term
Attract and retain new customers
and improve reputation through
sustainable itineraries and
activities for changing climate-
induced preferences
Short-Medium Term
Positioning as a sustainability
leader
Short-Medium Term
Products & Services
Opportunities for the ship to be
the destination
Long Term
Resilience
Engage with more sustainable
and economically favourable
alternative suppliers
Short Term
Improve resilience to physical
climate risk through adaptation
of itinerary routes and
investment in port infrastructure
Short Term
Resource Efficiency
Improved operational efficiencies
arising from technological
advancements
Medium Term
Increased fuel efficiency through
alternative itinerary planning and
reduced energy use
Short-Medium Term
Increased resource efficiency
through reduced on-board energy
demand and consumption
Medium Term
We presently consider transition risks to be the most significant in terms of likelihood and impact. The
risks with the highest impact and likelihood of occurrence are associated with the transition to a low-carbon
emission future, in a scenario where low-carbon technologies do not exist, or where we have not been able
to access these technologies and where we have reduced availability and access to fuel.
The climate-related opportunities with the highest impact are a mix of mitigation and adaptation
opportunities. These include the positive impacts of supporting the adaptation of sustainable technological
advances for our business, improved operational efficiencies from technological advancements, and more
energy efficient itineraries from investing in port and destination projects.
Quantitative Scenario Analysis
We quantitatively applied three distinct plausible climate scenarios to determine the potential impacts of the
risks and opportunities assessed. Using transition scenario assumptions from the International Energy
Agency (“IEA”) and climate and transition scenarios from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
(“IPCC”), we utilised two interlocking types of pathways, the Representative Concentration Pathways
(“RCPs”) and Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (“SSPs”) to create three sets of scenarios to understand the
relative materiality and possible range of impacts to the business from the selected climate-related risks
and opportunities under different potential futures.
24
Scenario 1: Steady Path to Sustainability (average temperature increase limited to 1.5°C above pre-industrial
levels by 2100) SSP1 / RCP1.9
Under this scenario, the world takes the rapid and strong policy measures required to meet the ambition
of the 2015 Paris Agreement (keep mean annual temperature rise well below 2°C warming above
pre-industrial levels by 2100). Under this scenario, low carbon technologies take over from fossil-fuels,
and reduced economic growth is also important for reaching net zero emissions by 2050.
We selected this scenario, as it provides us insight into a low-carbon world that would benefit us and our
Climate Action Goals. Under this scenario, transition risks identified are material and our resilience is
dependent on our ability to effectively adopt low carbon technologies. This would help us adhere to increasing
decarbonization requirements, including existing and emerging regulations, consumer preferences, and
talent market expectations. Our most impactful opportunity is the enhancement of our reputation and
competitiveness, by supporting the adaptation of sustainable technological advances for the cruise industry.
This would also further help us to mitigate our transition risks.
Scenario 2: Regional Rivalry (average temperature increase limited to below 2.8°C above pre-industrial levels
by 2100) SSP3 / RCP7.0
This scenario explores a possible route in which the world is seeing an emergence of tribalism and
nationalism. Low international priority for addressing environmental concerns leads to strong
environmental degradation in some regions. The combination of impeded development and limited
environmental concern results in poor progress toward climate sustainability. Growing resource
intensity and fossil fuel dependency along with difficulty in achieving international cooperation and
slow technological change imply high challenges to mitigation.
We selected this scenario, as it provides an indication of the world we would operate in if we do not achieve
the Paris Agreement target. This scenario presents a higher emissions future where physical risks are
material. Business resilience under this scenario is dependent on our ability to adapt to extreme weather
events and chronic physical risks. Under this scenario we can remain resilient by taking advantage of the
mobility of our cruise ships, which enables us to move our vessels between regions and adapt itineraries in
cases of extreme weather events. Additionally, based on a study performed, we are well placed to respond to
increased physical risks at our new port development projects, see
Investment in Port and Destination
Projects
.
Scenario 3: Fossil-fueled growth (average temperature increase limited to below 4°C above pre-industrial levels
by 2100) SSP5 / RCP8.5
The 4°C scenario explores a possible route in which as countries emerge from the coronavirus
pandemic, governments around the world focus on restoring growth through direct support to fossil
fuels and reverting to the tried and tested methods of the past.
This scenario presents the highest emissions future where physical risks have the potential to be most
significant and would therefore allow us to model the impact of these extreme climate risks. Akin to
Scenario 2, business resilience under Scenario 3 will be dependent on our ability to adapt to extreme weather
events and chronic physical risks as well as the impacts to our supply chain across different geographical
areas. Our experience with the current supply chain crisis suggests that under this scenario, we would be
resilient to these supply chain risks given our ability to adapt to supply chain disruptions.
Key assumptions and limitations
The results of our quantitative scenario analysis have a high degree of uncertainty as there are assumptions
made for all modelling inputs. This means that results should be taken as an indicative “order of risk”.
Furthermore, the analysis assumes that the future conditions from climate change are shifted to today to
contextualize impacts in relation to the current business size. The analysis does not include:
• Forward-looking forecasting of our business operations; or
• Potential mitigation or adaptation measures that could be taken either by us, or by other parties over
the period considered (e.g., sustainable ship fuel development, governments building flood defenses).
Strategic Report
25
Estimations and projections
We completed several scenario analyses over three time horizons (2025, 2030, and 2050). Any assumption
made about fuel prices acknowledges the current energy crisis and assumes that by 2025, oil prices will
stabilize in line with IEA price projections. We have also projected physical and transition risks at a global level
due to the high mobility of our assets.
The degree of potential impact was determined on a linear scale range of “Low”, having no material impact
or “High”having a material impact on Carnival Corporation & plc’s financial statements. Refer to page 82
in our Group financial statements for our analysis of the impact of climate change on the Group financial
statements.
Results of the Quantitative Scenario Analysis: Potential Impact on Operating Income
2025
2030
2050
Scenario 1
(
TR
) How does a low-carbon transition impact the price of the
fuels needed to power our ship engines?
(
TR
) How would changing consumer sentiment drive changes
in demand for our offering?
(
PR
) How are our profits affected by an increase in food
commodity prices?
(O)
What are the future savings associated with operational
efficiency improvements?
(O)
How could providing a service geared towards changing
consumer sentiment drive long-term growth for us?
Scenario 2
(
TR
) How does a low-carbon transition impact the price of the
fuels needed to power our ship engines?
(
TR
) How would changing consumer sentiment drive changes
in demand for our offering?
(
PR
) How are our profits affected by an increase in food
commodity prices?
(O)
What are the future savings associated with operational
efficiency improvements?
(O)
How could providing a service geared towards changing
consumer sentiment drive long-term growth for us?
Scenario 3
(
TR
) How does a low-carbon transition impact the price of the
fuels needed to power our ship engines?
(
TR
) How would changing consumer sentiment drive changes
in demand for our offering?
(
PR
) How are our profits affected by an increase in food
commodity prices?
(O)
What are the future savings associated with operational
efficiency improvements?
(O)
How could providing a service geared towards changing
consumer sentiment drive long-term growth for us?
Key
Transition Risk (
TR
); Physical Risk (
PR
); Opportunity (
O
)
Risk Financial Impact:
Low
Medium
High
Opportunity Financial Impact:
Low
Medium
High
How does a low-carbon transition impact the price of the fuels needed to power our ship engines?
While fossil fuels are currently the only viable option for our industry at present, we are closely monitoring
technology developments and partnering with key organizations to help identify and scale new technologies
not yet ready for the cruise industry. Refer to XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact on pages 16 to
18.
26
How would changing consumer sentiments drive changes in demand for our offering?
To mitigate the impact of this risk, our short and medium-term decarbonization goals focus on reducing
carbon emissions per ALBD and carbon emissions per ALB-km. In addition, we are committed to our
reduction of carbon emissions and have aspirations to be net carbon-neutral ship operations by 2050. Refer
to XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact on pages 13 to 18.
How are our profits affected by an increase in commodity prices?
Under Scenarios 1 and 2, the impacts on food prices are indistinguishable from the historical commodity
market volatility. Under Scenario 3, we could face higher food costs which may impact our value chain and
operating profit. Our existing supply chain management strategies have remained resilient through the
more recent supply chain issues experienced globally, demonstrating our ability to mitigate global-scale
disruptions. In addition, our Circular Economy 2030 Goals include achieving a 30% food waste reduction
per person by 2022 and 50% by 2030. Refer to XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact on page 14 and
XVII. Supply Chain on page 30.
What are the future savings associated with operational efficiency improvements?
Under each scenario, the estimated total price of the fuel is the same, but the amount of fuel demanded
differs based on assumptions about operational efficiency improvements. To capture this potential upside,
we are investing in projects that improve the energy efficiency of our fleet. An Internal Decarbonization
Premium is being added to the cost of fuel during the itinerary, strategic and capital planning processes and is
used to evaluate the payback period and return on investment for capital projects. We are also ensuring
that our brands design more energy efficient itineraries through our Corporate Itinerary Decarbonization
Reviews. For further details of our strategies in place to capture this opportunity, refer to XV. Sustainability
and Environmental Impact on pages 16 to 18.
How could providing a service geared towards changing consumer sentiment drive long-term growth for us?
Under scenarios 2 and 3, an immaterial number of consumers would align to low-carbon services. Under
Scenario 1, from 2025 to 2050 across all countries, there is an increase in the expected price per Passenger
Cruise Days that we will be able to charge. By continuing to reduce our carbon emissions through our strategies
such as investing in energy efficiency projects, fleet changes, itinerary changes, and port developments, we
can remain resilient under Scenario 1. For further details of our strategies to capture this opportunity, refer
to XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact on pages 16 to 18.
Investment in Port and Destination Projects
Utilizing the latest IPCC 6 report, a climate study was undertaken, by a third party, for two of our port
development projects at Grand Port (Grand Bahama Island) and Half Moon Cay Pier Project (The Bahamas),
to enhance climate resilience. Based on the results of this study, we are well placed to respond to the
physical risks of climate change at the two planned port locations and that we will have a number of measures
in place to address physical climate impacts. These results were reviewed by the SRE Committee and
presented to the Boards of Directors for an investment decision. Furthermore, our investments in these
ports and destinations will support our efforts to design more energy efficient itineraries based on their
strategic locations.
Risk Management
We utilize a process for managing our climate risks and opportunities which begins with climate risk and
opportunity identification then follows with owner assignment, assessment, monitoring, management and
reporting. This process is ongoing and iterative.
Climate Risk and Opportunity Identification, Owner Assignment and Assessment
The qualitative scenario analysis is the foundation of our climate risk and opportunities identification and
assessment process and began with the evaluation of a long list of climate-related risks and opportunities we
may face, to generate an initial list of possible risks and opportunities. As discussed above, we considered a
high-carbon and a low-carbon scenario. Input from key stakeholders in the business was obtained through
facilitated workshops to identify additional climate risks and opportunities and refine the list before
prioritizing those identified. Assessment of these risks and opportunities was performed by the SRE
Committee and a cross section of management, who qualitatively evaluated the impact and likelihood of
these risks and opportunities. Certain financial, regulatory, reputational and physical risks and opportunities,
as described on pages 22 to 24, were then selected for more detailed quantitative scenario analysis.
Strategic Report
27
The SRE Committee reviews the selected risks and opportunities from our qualitative scenario analysis
quarterly and considers if any risks or opportunities no longer need monitoring, and if any new climate risks
or opportunities should be identified. Each climate risk has been assigned an owner who has responsibility
for the day-to-day evaluation and management of the risk. Following the climate risk identification process,
climate risks are assessed based on expected impact, likelihood, time horizon and speed of onset.
A
A
B
B
C
C
D
D
E
E
G
G
I
J
J
#
Risk summary (Ordered alphabetically)
Lack of viable low carbon technology to replace fossil fuels
Risk is that cruising (as a carbon-intensive industry) is severely restricted or subject to bans
Increased demand for reducing carbon-intensive practices
Chronic climate change impacting supply chain availability and price
Itineraries are not viable due to extreme weather and/or sea level rise
F
F
Cruising no longer aligns to consumers climate values
Unable to meet climate-related requirements reduces access to capital / insurance
H
H
Reduced availability and access to fuel
Increased demand for reducing carbon-intensive practices
Failure to attract and retain talent due to climate credentials
Risks or opportunities that were selected for quantification
Key
Higher
likelihood
Lower
likelihood
Lower
impact
Higher
impact
Scenario key
Likelihood
Impact
S1 – Steady Path to Sustainability
S2 – Regional Rivalry
I
A
A
B
C
D
B
C
D
E
E
F
G
G
H
I
J
K
I
J
K
#
Opportunity summary (Ordered alphabetically)
Positioning as a sustainability leader
Opportunities for the ship to be the destination
Improved operational efficiencies arising from technological advancements
Increased fuel efficiency through alternative itinerary planning and reduced energy use
Access to new financing options available for organisations working on decarbonisation
F
Attract and retain new customers and improve reputation through sustainable itineraries and activities for changing
climate-induced preferences
Support the adaptation of sustainable technological advances for the cruise industry
H
Increased resource efficiency through reduced on-board energy demand and consumption
Engage with more sustainable and economically favourable alternative suppliers
Improve resilience to physical climate risk through adaptation of itinerary routes and investment in port
infrasrtucture
Access to private destinations or islands with infrastructure built by us
Risks or opportunities that were selected for quantification
Key
Harder
Easier
Lower
impact
Higher
impact
Scenario key
Ease of realisation
Impact
S1 – Steady Path to Sustainability
S2 – Regional Rivalry
Climate Risk and Opportunity Monitoring, Management and Reporting
The primary method for review, scrutiny, and challenge of climate risks, involves the risk owners monitoring,
assessing and reporting how each risk and opportunity is changing over time based on climate risk indicators
and discussing options with the SRE Committee to reduce, accept, avoid or transfer risk.
Integration into our overall risk management
Overall, the Boards of Directors are responsible for determining the strategic direction of the company and
the nature and extent of the risk assumed by it. The Boards of Directors carry out a risk assessment to
ensure that principal and emerging risks, including those that would threaten our business model, future
performance, solvency or liquidity are effectively managed and/or mitigated. Within our risk management
framework, the Boards of Directors have ultimate oversight of climate-related risks, which have been identified
as a principal risk. Refer to the Governance pillar for a description of how climate-related risks are
overseen.
28
Metrics and Targets
Our most material risks quantified, are the transition risks
.
To mitigate the impact of these risks, we have
identified four strategic actions, including energy efficiency projects, fleet changes, itinerary changes, and port
developments, to reduce our reliance on fossil fuels. Refer to XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact
on pages 16 to 18. The metrics and Climate Action Goals associated with these risks and opportunities, are
outlined above within XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact on page 14. To demonstrate our
commitment to achieving our Climate Action Goals, we will be updating our executive compensation target
linked to our progress toward achieving certain of our 2030 Sustainability Goals.
Our Scope 1 and 2 emissions are disclosed on page 19. We quantify and report, using the GHG Protocol
and obtain third-party assurance (under ISO-14064-3:2006) of our GHG emissions, including our direct
(Scope 1) and indirect (Scope 2) emissions. During 2022, we performed an inventory of our Scope 3 GHG
emissions using a baseline year of 2019 (our last full year of guest cruise operations) and determined that
Scope 3 emissions were estimated to be approximately one half of our total emissions. We expect to
disclose our Scope 3 emissions in our 2023 Carnival plc Annual Report. We plan to review the cross-
industry metrics recommended by TCFD’s 2021 Implementation Guidance and will consider additional
relevant metrics in 2023.
We have made progress over the past 15 years reducing our carbon emission intensity and achieved our
2020 goal three years early (in 2017). We have also made progress towards our 2030 carbon intensity reduction
goals of 40% from a 2008 baseline, measured in both grams of CO
2
e per ALB-km and kilograms of CO
2
e
per ALBD. Through 2019, we reduced our carbon emission intensity on a lower berth distance basis by 25%
relative to 2008 all while growing our capacity by 48%. Furthermore, because of our efforts, we peaked our
absolute Scope 1 and 2 emissions in 2011.
During 2022, we updated the baseline year for both goals to 2019 from 2008. This new baseline year will
help us better communicate recent progress against our Climate Action Goals to our investors and stakeholders
and modernizes our disclosures in alignment with developing best practice and reporting standards. Both
2030 goals require a 20% decrease from 2019. With the updated baseline year, we have strengthened our goal
measured in kilograms of CO
2
e per ALBD since the initial 2030 goal would only have required a further
15% reduction from 2019 levels. Our goal measured in grams of CO
2
e per ALB-km remains the same.
Carnival Corporation & plc Carbon Intensity
(g CO2e / ALB-km)
350
175
150
125
100
75
50
25
0
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
327
2008
246
2019
196
2030 goal
170
2008
120
2019
29.4%
20%
44%
96
2030 goal
Carbon Intensity
(kg CO2e / ALBD)
24.9%
40%
20%
To support the mitigation of the climate-related risks identified relating to the restriction of carbon-
intensive industries and fossil fuels, we have set 2030 Climate Action Goals.
XVI.
Information Technology
With the increasing size and sophistication of cruise ships, the technologies employed to enhance guest
experiences and operate ships have grown ever more complex and integrated. We have a Chief Information
Officer (“CIO”) who is responsible for leading three critical global functions across our brands: information
technology, innovation, and cybersecurity/compliance. Our Boards of Directors have Audit Committees
whose responsibility includes oversight of risk management relating to information technology, cybersecurity
and data privacy. The CIO briefs the Audit Committees on these matters on a regular basis and generally
at least quarterly.
Our global information technology model is designed to contribute to exceeding expectations of our guests,
crew, shoreside team members and other stakeholders. All of our brands are actively collaborating to
maximize the business value of our information technology solutions, standards and processes to eliminate
redundancies and drive process efficiencies, while increasingly leveraging our scale and common technologies.
Strategic Report
29
In order to achieve our goals, we are focusing on several key factors including applications, compliance,
connectivity, cybersecurity, data privacy, infrastructure, modernization and innovation.
In response to the increasing threat of continuously evolving cybersecurity risks, we have continued to
invest in our information technology and operational technology cybersecurity programs, managing risk
and protecting our company’s business operations through targeted people, process and technology-focused
improvements. This includes the implementation of routine data privacy and security focused training for
our shoreside and certain shipboard team members. We have a Chief Information Security Officer who
reports to the CIO and is responsible for leading global cybersecurity risk reduction efforts and compliance.
In light of numerous jurisdictional data privacy and security laws/regulations, we have data privacy and
security standards across the corporation. We have a Chief Privacy Officer and Data Protection Officers who
oversee our focus on the proper processing of personal information in alignment with our Privacy Policy.
XVII.
Supply Chain
We incur expenses for goods and services to deliver exceptional cruise experiences to our guests. In addition,
we incur significant capital expenditures for materials to support the refurbishment and enhancements of
our vessels as well as to build new ships. We approach our spend strategically and look for suppliers who
demonstrate the ability to help us leverage our scale in terms of cost, quality, service, innovation and
sustainability. We are focused on the creation of strategic partnerships and will streamline our supplier base
where it is prudent and on a risk-based basis. Our largest capital investments are for the construction of
new ships.
Global supply markets and supply chains have been impacted by certain events, resulting in shortages,
extended lead times and increased inflation impacting our operations and profitability. We continue to apply
a number of different strategies to mitigate the impact of these challenges on our operations, including
extending our demand planning, placing purchase orders earlier, leveraging corporate contracts, utilizing
short-term or long-term contracts as needed, seeking alternative sources, utilizing substitute products and
leveraging our supplier relationships.
XVIII.
Insurance
a.
General
We maintain insurance to cover a number of risks associated with owning and operating our vessels and
other non-ship related risks. All such insurance policies are subject to coverage limits, exclusions and deductible
levels. Insurance premiums are dependent on our own loss experience and the general premium requirements
of our insurers. We maintain certain levels of deductibles for substantially all the below-mentioned
coverages. We may increase our deductibles to mitigate future premium increases. We do not carry coverage
related to loss of earnings or revenues from our ships or other operations.
b.
Protection and Indemnity (“P&I”) Coverages
Liabilities, costs and expenses for illness and injury to crew, guest injury, pollution and other third-party
claims in connection with our cruise activities are covered by our P&I clubs, which are mutual indemnity
associations owned by ship owners.
We are members of three P&I clubs, Gard, Steamship Mutual and UK Club, which are part of a worldwide
group of 13 P&I clubs, known as the International Group of P&I Clubs (the “IG”). The IG insures
directly, and through broad and established reinsurance markets, a large portion of the world’s shipping
fleets. Coverage is subject to the P&I clubs’rules and the limits of coverage are determined by the IG.
c.
Hull and Machinery Insurance
We maintain insurance on the hull and machinery of each of our ships for reasonable amounts as determined
by management. The coverage for hull and machinery is provided by large and well-established international
marine insurers. Insurers make it a condition for insurance coverage that a ship be certified as “in class”
by a classification society that is a member of the International Association of Classification Societies
(“IACS”). All of our ships are routinely inspected and certified to be in class by an IACS member.
d.
War Risk Insurance
We use a combination of insurance and self-insurance to cover war risk for legal liability to crew, guests and
other third parties as well as loss or damage to our vessels arising from war or war-like actions. Our
30
primary war risk insurance coverage is provided by international marine insurers and our excess war risk
insurance is provided by our three P&I clubs. Under the terms of our war risk insurance coverage, which are
typical for war risk policies in the marine industry, insurers can give us no less than three days’notice that
the insurance policies will be canceled. However, the policies may be reinstated at different premium rates.
e.
Other Insurance
We maintain property insurance covering our shoreside assets and casualty insurance covering liabilities to
third parties arising from our hotel and transportation business, shore excursion operations and shoreside
operations, including our port and related commercial facilities. We also maintain worker’s compensation,
director’s and officer’s liability and other insurance coverages.
XIX.
Governmental Regulations
a.
Maritime Regulations
1.
General
Our ships are regulated by numerous international, national, state and local laws, regulations, treaties and
other legal requirements, as well as voluntary agreements, which govern health, environmental, safety and
security matters in relation to our guests, crew and ships. These requirements change regularly, sometimes on
a daily basis, depending on the itineraries of our ships and the ports and countries visited. If we violate or
fail to comply with any of these laws, regulations, treaties and other requirements, we could be fined or
otherwise sanctioned by regulators. We are committed to complying with, or exceeding, all relevant
requirements.
The primary regulatory bodies that establish maritime laws and requirements applicable to our ships
include:
The IMO:
All of our ships, and the maritime industry as a whole, are subject to the maritime safety,
security and environmental regulations established by the IMO, a specialized agency of the United
Nations. The IMO’s principal sets of requirements are mandated through its International Convention
for the Safety of Life at Sea (“SOLAS”) and its International Convention for the Prevention of
Pollution from Ships (“MARPOL”).
Flag States:
Our ships are registered, or flagged, in The Bahamas, Bermuda, Italy, the Netherlands,
Panama and the UK, which are also referred to as Flag States. Our ships are regulated by these Flag
States through international conventions that govern, among other things, health, environmental, safety
and security matters in relation to our guests, crew and ships. Representatives of each Flag State
conduct periodic inspections, surveys and audits to verify compliance with these requirements.
Ship classification societies:
Class certification is one of the necessary documents required for our
cruise ships to be flagged in a specific country, obtain liability insurance and legally operate as passenger
cruise ships. Our ships are subject to periodic class surveys, including dry-dock inspections, by ship
classification societies to verify that our ships have been maintained in accordance with the rules of the
classification societies and that recommended repairs have been satisfactorily completed. Dry-dock
frequency is a statutory requirement mandated by SOLAS. Our ships dry-dock once or twice every
five years, depending on the age of the ship.
National, regional and other authorities:
We are subject to the decrees, directives, regulations and
requirements of the European Union (“EU”), the UK, the U.S., other countries and hundreds of other
authorities, including international ports that our ships visit every year.
Port regulatory authorities (Port State Control):
Our ships are also subject to inspection by the port
regulatory authorities, which are also referred to as Port State Control, in the various countries that they
visit. Such inspections include verification of compliance with the maritime safety, security,
environmental, customs, immigration, health and labor requirements applicable to each port, as well as
with regional, national and international requirements. Many countries have joined together to form
regional Port State Control authorities.
As members of the Cruise Lines International Association (“CLIA”), we helped to develop and have
implemented policies that are intended to enhance shipboard safety and environmental protection throughout
the cruise industry. In some cases, this calls for implementing best practices, which exceed existing legal
Strategic Report
31
requirements. Further details on these and other policies, which are not incorporated into this document,
can be found on www.cruising.org.
Our Boards of Directors have Health, Environment, Safety and Security (“HESS”) Committees, which
were comprised of six independent directors as of November 30, 2022. The principal function of the HESS
Committees is to assist the boards in fulfilling their responsibility to supervise and monitor our health,
environment, safety, security and sustainability related policies, programs and initiatives at sea and ashore
and compliance with related legal and regulatory requirements. The HESS Committees and our management
team review significant HESS relevant risks or exposures and associated mitigating actions.
We are committed to implementing appropriate measures to manage identified risks effectively. We have a
Chief Maritime Officer to oversee our global maritime operations, including maritime policy, maritime affairs,
maritime standards, training, shipbuilding, asset management, health operations, and research and
development. In addition, we have a Chief Risk and Compliance Officer who leads the effort to promote
and monitor a strong ethics and compliance culture throughout the company, including all areas of HESS.
To help ensure that we are compliant with legal and regulatory requirements and that these areas of our
business operate in an efficient and effective manner, we:
• Provide regular health, environmental, safety and security support, training, guidance and information
to guests, team members and others working on our behalf
• Develop and implement effective and verifiable management systems to fulfill our health,
environmental, safety, security and sustainability commitments
• Perform regular shoreside and shipboard audits and take appropriate action when deficiencies are
identified
• Report and investigate health, environmental, safety and security incidents and strive to take
appropriate action to prevent recurrence
• Identify those team members responsible for managing health, environment, safety, security and
sustainability programs and aim to establish clear lines of accountability
• Identify the aspects of our business with potential to impact the environment and continue to take
appropriate action to minimize that impact
• Monitor an anonymous hotline for any reported allegations or concerns and the related responses
• Review and work to improve policies and procedures designed to prevent, detect, respond and
correct various regulatory violations and other misconduct
2.
Maritime Safety Regulations
The IMO has adopted safety standards as part of SOLAS. To help ensure guest and crew safety, SOLAS
establishes requirements for the following:
• Vessel design and structural features
• Life-saving and other equipment
• Construction and materials
• Fire protection and detection
• Refurbishment standards
• Safe management and operation
• Radio communications
• Musters
All of our crew undergo regular safety training that meets or exceeds all international maritime regulations,
including SOLAS requirements, which are periodically revised.
SOLAS requires implementation of the International Safety Management Code (“ISM Code”), which
provides an international standard for the safe management and operation of ships and for pollution
prevention. The ISM Code is mandatory for passenger vessel operators. Under the ISM Code, vessel operators
are required to:
• Develop and implement a Safety Management System (“SMS”) that includes, among other things,
the adoption of safety and environmental protection policies setting forth instructions and procedures
for operating vessels safely and describing procedures for responding to emergencies and protecting
the environment. In addition, our SMS includes health and security procedures
• Obtain a Document of Compliance (“DOC”) for the vessel operator, as well as a Safety Management
Certificate (“SMC”) for each vessel they operate. These documents are issued by the vessel’s Flag
State and evidence compliance with the ISM Code and the SMS
• Verify or renew DOCs and SMCs periodically in accordance with the ISM Code
32
We have implemented and continue to develop policies and procedures that we believe enhance our
commitment to the safety of our guests and crew. These initiatives include the following:
• Training of our bridge, engineering and environmental officers in maritime related best practices
facilitated by our CSMART Academy, the Center for Simulator Maritime Training located within
our Arison Maritime Center in Almere, Netherlands
• Further standardization of our detailed bridge and engine resource management procedures on our
ships
• Expansion of our existing oversight function to monitor and assist operations through our state-of-
the-art fleet operations centers in Miami and Hamburg
• Identifying and promoting the use of international standards and best-practice policies and
procedures in health, environmental, safety and security disciplines across the organization including
on all our ships
• Further enhancement of our processes for auditing our HESS performance throughout our operations
3.
Maritime Security Regulations
Our ships are subject to numerous security requirements. These requirements include the International Ship
and Port Facility Security Code, which is part of SOLAS, the U.S. Maritime Transportation Security Act
of 2002, which addresses U.S. port and waterway security and the U.S. Cruise Vessel Security and Safety Act
of 2010, which applies to all of our ships that embark or disembark passengers in the U.S. These regulations
include requirements as to the following:
• Implementation of specific security measures, including onboard installation of a ship security alert
system
• Assessment of vessel security
• Efforts to identify and deter security threats
• Training, drills and exercises
• Security plans that may include guest, vehicle and baggage screening procedures, security patrols,
establishment of restricted areas, personnel identification procedures, access control measures and
installation of surveillance equipment
• Establishment of procedures and policies for reporting and managing allegations of crimes
4.
Maritime Environmental Regulations
We are subject to numerous international, multi-national, national, state and local environmental laws,
regulations and treaties that govern air emissions, waste management, and the storage, handling, use and
disposal of hazardous substances such as chemicals, solvents and paints.
As a means of managing and improving our environmental performance and compliance, we adhere to
standards set by the International Organization for Standardization (“ISO”), an international standard-
setting body, which produces worldwide industrial and commercial standards. The environmental management
system of our company and ships is certified in accordance with ISO 14001, the environmental management
standard that was developed to help organizations manage the environmental impacts of their processes,
products and services. ISO 14001 defines an approach to setting and achieving environmental objectives and
targets, within a structured management framework.
i.
International Regulations
The principal international convention governing marine pollution prevention and response is MARPOL.
a.
Preventing and Minimizing Pollution
MARPOL includes six annexes, four of which are applicable to our cruise ships, containing requirements
designed to prevent and minimize both accidental and operational pollution by oil, sewage, garbage and air
emissions and sets forth specific requirements related to vessel operations, equipment, recordkeeping and
reporting that are designed to prevent and minimize pollution. All of our ships must carry an International
Oil Pollution Prevention Certificate, an International Sewage Pollution Prevention Certificate, an
International Air Pollution Prevention Certificate and a Garbage Management Plan. The ship’s Flag State
issues these certificates, which evidence their compliance with the MARPOL regulations regarding prevention
Strategic Report
33
of pollution by oil, sewage, garbage and air emissions. Certain jurisdictions have not adopted all of these
MARPOL annexes but have established various national, regional or local laws and regulations that apply
to these areas.
As noted above, MARPOL governs the prevention of pollution by oil from operational measures, as well as
from accidental discharges. MARPOL requires that discharges of machinery space bilge water pass
through pollution prevention equipment that separates oil from the water and monitors the discharged
water to ensure that the effluent does not exceed 15 parts per million oil content. During 2019, we voluntarily
completed the upgrade of oily water separation equipment to the latest MARPOL standards as set forth
by the IMO onboard all of our ships. Our ships have oily water separators with oil content monitors installed
and maintain a record of certain engine room operations in an Oil Record Book. In addition, we have
voluntarily installed redundant systems on all of our ships that monitor processed bilge water a second time
prior to discharge to help ensure that it contains no more than 15 parts per million oil content. This
system also provides additional controls to prevent improper bilge water discharges. MARPOL also requires
that our ships have Shipboard Oil Pollution Emergency Plans.
MARPOL also governs the discharge of sewage from ships and contains regulations regarding the ships’
equipment and systems for the control of sewage discharge, the provision of facilities at ports and terminals
for the reception of sewage and requirements for survey and certification.
MARPOL also governs the discharge of garbage from ships and requires the implementation of Garbage
Management Plan and the maintenance of a Garbage Record Book.
Furthermore, MARPOL addresses air emissions from vessels, establishes requirements for the prevention of
air pollution from ships to reduce emissions of sulfur oxides (“SOx”), nitrogen oxides (“NOx”), particulate
matter and GHG emissions. It also contains restrictions on the use of ozone depleting substances (“ODS”)
and requires the recording of ODS use, equipment containing ODS and the emission of ODS.
b.
Sulfur Emissions
The IMO has adopted a global 0.5% sulfur cap for marine fuel which began in January 2020. The EU
Parliament and Council has also adopted 0.5% sulfur content fuel requirement (the “EU Sulfur Directive”).
The options to comply with both the global 0.5% sulfur cap and the EU Sulfur Directive include the
installation of Advanced Air Quality Systems, or the use of low sulfur or alternative fuels.
MARPOL addresses air emissions from both auxiliary and main propulsion diesel engines on ships and
further specifies requirements for Emission Control Areas (“ECAs”) with stricter limitations on sulfur
emissions content in these areas, requiring ships to use fuel with a sulfur content of no more than 0.1%, or
to use alternative emission reduction methods, such as Advanced Air Quality Systems.
We have Advanced Air Quality Systems on most of our ships, which are aiding in partially mitigating the
financial impact from the ECAs and global 0.5% sulfur requirements. We use Advanced Air Quality Systems
wherever possible subject to local laws and regulations. Additionally, Advanced Air Quality Systems used
with heavy fuel oil (“HFO”) results in as good or better SOx, NOx, and particulate emissions compared to
MGO while also resulting in a marginal reduction of well-to-wake carbon emissions. These refer to the
emissions generated throughout the entire process of fuel production, delivery and use onboard ships.
c.
Greenhouse Gas Emissions
In 2013, the IMO approved measures to improve energy efficiency and reduce emissions of GHGs from
international shipping by adopting technical and operational measures for all ships. The technical measures
apply to the design of new vessels, and the operational reduction measures apply to all vessels. Operational
reduction measures have been implemented through a variety of means, including a Ship Energy Efficiency
Management Plan, improved voyage planning and more frequent propeller and hull cleanings. We have
established objectives within the ISO 14001 environmental management system for each of our brands to
further reduce fuel consumption rates and the resulting GHG emissions.
In 2016, the IMO approved the implementation of a mandatory data collection system (“DCS”) for fuel oil
consumption. The DCS requires ships of 5,000 gross tons and above to provide fuel consumption data to
their respective Flag State at the end of each calendar year, beginning in 2019. Flag States validate the data
and transfer it to an IMO database. The IMO will produce a summary annual report with anonymous data. In
2018, the IMO also set aspirations to achieve several shipping industry GHG emission reduction goals
with 2030 and 2050 target dates. In November 2020, the IMO’s Marine Environment Protection Committee
34
approved further MARPOL changes in support of its GHG emission reduction goals, which have entered
into force on January 1, 2023 and include the Carbon Intensity Indicator (“CII”), an annual ship-level CO
2
intensity emissions performance measure, and the Energy Efficiency Existing Ship Index (“EEXI”), a one-
off measure similar to the Energy Efficiency Design Index (“EEDI”) for newbuilds, that confirms for a
specific condition that a ship meets a target CO
2
emission intensity. The EEXI is not expected to have a
material impact and the impact for CII is uncertain as the enforcement mechanism of the regulation is still
to be defined. In addition, the IMO is currently considering various other proposals which aim to reduce
GHG emissions within the global shipping industry. These proposals include a range of measures including
possible fuel standards and market-based measures, such as a carbon levy, that, if enacted, could result in
changes to itineraries or increased compliance related costs which may individually and collectively have a
material impact on our profitability.
d.
Ballast Water
Ballast water is water used to stabilize ships at sea and maintain safe operating conditions throughout a
voyage. Ballast water can carry a multitude of marine species. In 2017, the IMO’s Ballast Water Management
Convention entered into force, which governs the discharge of ballast water from ships. Subsequent
amendments effectively extended the implementation date for installation of ballast water management
systems for existing ships by about two years, though other requirements went into effect immediately,
including requirements for ballast water exchange, record keeping, and maintaining an approved Ballast
Water Management Plan. The Convention is designed to regulate the treatment of ballast water prior to
discharging overboard in order to avoid the transfer of marine species to new environments, as well as
establishing other ballast water management practices for monitoring and environmental protection.
ii.
U.S. Federal and State Regulations
The Act to Prevent Pollution from Ships implements several MARPOL Annexes in the U.S. and imposes
numerous requirements on our ships, as discussed above. Administrative, civil and criminal penalties may be
assessed for violations.
The Oil Pollution Act of 1990 (“OPA 90”) established a comprehensive federal liability regime, as well as
prevention and response requirements, relating to discharges of oil in U.S. waters. The major requirements
include demonstrating financial responsibility up to the liability limits set by OPA 90 and having oil spill
response plans in place. We have Certificates of Financial Responsibility (“COFR”) that demonstrate our
ability to meet the liability limits of OPA 90 based on the gross tonnage of our ships for removal costs and
damages, such as from an oil spill. The COFR also covers releases of hazardous substances. It is possible,
however, for our liability limits to be broken, which could expose us to unlimited liability. Under OPA 90,
owners or operators of vessels operating in U.S. waters must file Vessel Response Plans with the U.S. Coast
Guard (“USCG”) and must operate and conduct any response action in compliance with these plans. As
OPA 90 expressly allows coastal states to impose liabilities and requirements beyond those imposed under
federal law, many U.S. states have enacted laws more stringent than OPA 90. Some of these state laws impose
unlimited liability for oil spills and contain more stringent financial responsibility and contingency planning
requirements. Most coastal states have also enacted environmental regulations that impose strict liability
for removal costs and damages resulting from a discharge of oil or a release of a hazardous substance, similar
to OPA 90.
The Clean Water Act (“CWA”) provides the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (“EPA”) with the
authority to regulate incidental discharges from commercial vessels, including discharges of ballast water,
bilge water, gray water, anti-fouling paints and other substances during normal operations within the U.S.
three mile territorial sea and inland waters. Pursuant to the CWA authority, the U.S. National Pollutant
Discharge Elimination System was designed to minimize pollution within U.S. territorial waters. For our
affected ships, the incidental discharge requirements are set forth in EPA’s Vessel General Permit (“VGP”) for
discharges incidental to the normal operations of vessels. The VGP establishes effluent limits for specific
discharges incidental to the normal operation of a vessel, many of which apply to our cruise ships. In addition
to the requirements associated with these discharges and more stringent vessel-specific requirements, the
VGP includes requirements for inspections, monitoring, reporting and record-keeping. In 2018, the Vessel
Incidental Discharge Act (“VIDA”) was signed into law and was intended to clarify and streamline discharge
requirements for the incidental discharges covered by the VGP and certain USCG regulations for ballast
water. More specifically, a new section was added to the CWA called “Uniform National Standards for
Discharges Incidental to Normal Operation of Vessels.” Once fully implemented, VIDA will replace the VGP;
however, while the standards and regulations are being developed the 2013 VGP has been administratively
Strategic Report
35
extended and will remain in effect. VIDA requires the standards and regulations to be at least as stringent
as the existing requirements in the 2013 VGP and USCG regulations, unless information becomes available
that was not reasonably available when the initial standard of performance was issued, and that information
would have justified a less stringent standard. In October 2020, the EPA posted its notice of proposed
rulemaking to set standards for 20 types of vessel discharges incidental to normal operations. The discharge
standards are organized into three categories: (1) general operation and maintenance; (2) biofouling
management; and (3) oil management. These standards mandate overall minimization of discharges and
prescribe associated best management practices. No training or education requirements are included, as these
will be set by the USCG in its rulemaking once EPA’s standards are finalized. Notably, EPA incorporated
discharge standards applicable to exhaust gas cleaning system discharges based substantially on applicable
IMO guidelines, which better harmonizes the VGP and IMO requirements. While the proposed rule provides
clarity into the likely structure of VIDA, there is uncertainty over the mechanism through which state-
specific standards may be implemented.
We are subject to the requirements of the U.S. Resource Conservation and Recovery Act for the disposal of
both hazardous and non-hazardous solid wastes that are generated by our ships. In general, vessel owners
are required to determine if their wastes are hazardous and, when landing waste ashore, comply with certain
standards for the proper management of hazardous wastes, including the use of hazardous waste manifests
for shipments to approved disposal facilities.
The U.S. National Invasive Species Act (“NISA”) was enacted in 1996 in response to growing reports of
harmful organisms being released into U.S. waters through ballast water taken on by vessels in foreign waters.
The USCG adopted regulations under NISA that impose mandatory ballast water management practices
for all vessels equipped with ballast water tanks entering U.S. waters. Depending on a vessel’s compliance date
for installation of a USCG type-approved ballast water management system, these requirements may now
be met by performing mid-ocean ballast exchange, by retaining ballast water onboard the vessel or by using
a ballast water management system authorized or approved by the USCG. In the near future, ballast
exchange will no longer be permissible. These USCG regulations, however, will ultimately be replaced with
the new regulatory regime being developed under VIDA, which is expected to contain similar requirements.
The state of Alaska has enacted legislation that prohibits certain discharges in designated Alaskan waters
and sets effluent limits on others, which are applicable to cruise ships. Further, the state of Alaska requires
that certain discharges be reported and monitored to verify compliance with the standards established by the
legislation. Environmental regimes in Alaska are more stringent than the U.S. federal requirements with
regard to discharges from vessels. The legislation also provides that repeat violators of the regulations could
be prohibited from operating in Alaskan waters. The state of California also has environmental
requirements significantly more stringent than federal requirements for water discharges and air emissions.
iii.
EU Regulations
The EU has adopted a broad range of substantial environmental measures aimed at improving the quality
of the environment for European citizens. To support the implementation and enforcement of European
environmental legislation, the EU has adopted directives on environmental liability and enforcement and
a recommendation providing for minimum criteria for environmental inspections.
The European Commission’s (“EC”) strategy is to reduce emissions from ships. The EC strategy seeks to
implement SOx Emission Control Areas set out in MARPOL, as discussed above via their own Sulphur
Directive.
The EC has also implemented regulations aimed at reducing GHG emissions from maritime shipping
through a Monitoring, Reporting and Verification regulation, which involves collecting emissions data from
ships over 5,000 gross tons to monitor and report carbon emissions on all voyages to, from and between
European Union ports.
The EU is in the process of adopting a series of significant carbon reforms as a part of its Fit for 55
package to meet its 2030 emissions reduction goal. The main instruments for reducing emissions are the
Emissions Trading System (“ETS”), Energy Taxation Directive (“ETD”) and the newly proposed FuelEU
Maritime initiative as well as amendments to the alternative fuels infrastructure and renewable energy
directives.
The ETS regulates carbon emissions through a “cap and trade”principle, where a cap is set on the total
amount of certain GHGs that can be emitted. The recently agreed inclusion of the maritime shipping sector
within the scope of ETS will become effective from January 2024 and introduces a mechanism whereby we
36
will be required to procure carbon emission allowances covering 40% of emissions inside EU waters, to be
surrendered in 2025, 70% of 2025 emissions to be surrendered in 2026 and 100% of annual emissions thereafter,
to be surrendered in the following year.
The ETD is a framework for the taxation of energy products and sets minimum rates of excise duty to
encourage a low-carbon economy. Proposed amendments to the ETD will introduce new tax rates based on
the energy content and environmental impact rather than volume. If adopted, these amendments will also
widen the directive to include maritime fuels, which were previously exempt.
The recently proposed FuelEU Maritime initiative is a long-term framework to reduce maritime emissions
by increasing the use of sustainable alternative fuels, and for the cruise industry, the use of shore power. The
proposal also requires compliance with the maximum limits of GHG intensity of energy used on board.
The stringency of these limits increases over time and there are financial penalties for non-compliance. The
initiative also includes requirements for ships to connect to shore power when at EU ports.
The Fit for 55 regulations may individually and collectively result in increased costs and have an impact on
our profitability beginning in 2024, and increasing to have a material impact on our profitability beginning in
2025. The exact impact is uncertain as elements of the proposals have not yet been finalized and enacted
and the costs of ETS allowances will depend on future markets.
5.
Maritime Health Regulations
We are committed to providing a healthy environment for all of our guests and crew. We collaborate with
public health inspection programs throughout the world, such as the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (“CDC”) in the U.S. and the SHIPSAN Project in the EU, to ensure that development of these
programs leads to enhanced health and hygiene onboard our ships. Through our collaborative efforts, we work
with the authorities to develop and revise guidelines, review plans and conduct on-site inspections for all
newbuilds and significant ship renovations. We work closely with governments and health authorities around
the world to ensure that our health and safety protocols comply with the requirements of each location. In
addition, we continue to maintain our ships by meeting, and often exceeding, applicable public health
guidelines and requirements, complying with inspections, reporting communicable illnesses and conducting
regular crew training and guest education programs.
6.
Maritime Labor Regulations
The International Labor Organization develops and oversees international labor standards and includes a
broad range of requirements, such as the definition of a seafarer, minimum age of seafarers, medical
certificates, recruitment practices, training, repatriation, food, recreational facilities, health and welfare,
hours of work and rest, accommodations, wages and entitlements.
The International Convention on Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping for Seafarers, as
amended, establishes additional minimum standards relating to training, including security training,
certification and watchkeeping for our seafarers.
b.
Other Governmental Regulations
Compliance with GHG regulations and the associated potential cost is complicated by the fact that various
countries and regions are following different approaches to climate-related regulations.
In most countries where we source the majority of our guests, we are required to establish financial
responsibility, such as obtaining a guarantee from stable financial institutions and insurance companies, to
satisfy liability in cases of our non-performance of obligations to our guests. The amount of financial
responsibility varies by jurisdiction based on the amount mandated by the applicable local legislation,
regulatory agency or association.
In Australia and most of Europe, we may be obligated to honor our guests’cruise payments made by them
to their travel agents and tour operators regardless of whether we receive these payments.
We are, or may in the future become, subject to other laws and regulations which require our compliance,
including those addressing antitrust, anti-money laundering, bribery, corruption, data privacy, human rights,
securities and sanctions, reporting on sustainability matters, as well as human resources related matters.
Strategic Report
37
XX.
Taxation
A summary of our principal taxes and exemptions in the jurisdictions where our significant operations are
located is as follows:
a.
U.S. Income Tax
We are primarily foreign corporations engaged in the business of operating cruise ships in international
transportation. We also own and operate, among other businesses, the U.S. hotel and transportation business
of Holland America Princess Alaska Tours through U.S. corporations.
Our North American cruise ship businesses and certain ship-owning subsidiaries are engaged in a trade or
business within the U.S. Depending on its itinerary, any particular ship may generate income from sources
within the U.S. We believe that our U.S. source income and the income of our ship-owning subsidiaries,
to the extent derived from, or incidental to, the international operation of a ship or ships, is currently exempt
from U.S. federal income and branch profit taxes.
Our domestic U.S. operations, principally the hotel and transportation business of Holland America
Princess Alaska Tours, are subject to federal and state income taxation in the U.S.
1.
Application of Section 883 of the Internal Revenue Code
In general, under Section 883 of the Internal Revenue Code, certain non-U.S. corporations (such as our
North American cruise ship businesses) are not subject to U.S. federal income tax or branch profits tax on
U.S. source income derived from, or incidental to, the international operation of a ship or ships. Applicable
U.S. Treasury regulations provide in general that a foreign corporation will qualify for the benefits of
Section 883 if, in relevant part, (i) the foreign country in which the foreign corporation is organized grants
an equivalent exemption to corporations organized in the U.S. in respect of each category of shipping income
for which an exemption is being claimed under Section 883 (an “equivalent exemption jurisdiction”) and
(ii) the foreign corporation meets a defined publicly-traded corporation stock ownership test (the “publicly-
traded test”). Subsidiaries of foreign corporations that are organized in an equivalent exemption
jurisdiction and meet the publicly-traded test also benefit from Section 883. We believe that Panama is an
equivalent exemption jurisdiction and that Carnival Corporation currently satisfies the publicly-traded test
under the regulations. Accordingly, substantially all of Carnival Corporation’s income is exempt from
U.S. federal income and branch profit taxes.
Regulations under Section 883 list certain activities that the Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) does not
consider to be incidental to the international operation of ships and, therefore, the income attributable to
such activities, to the extent such income is U.S. source, does not qualify for the Section 883 exemption.
Among the activities identified as not incidental are income from the sale of air transportation, transfers,
shore excursions and pre- and post-cruise land packages to the extent earned from sources within the U.S.
2.
Exemption Under Applicable Income Tax Treaties
We believe that the U.S. source transportation income earned by Carnival plc and its subsidiaries currently
qualifies for exemption from U.S. federal income tax under applicable bilateral U.S. income tax treaties.
3.
U.S. State Income Tax
Carnival Corporation, Carnival plc and certain subsidiaries are subject to various U.S. state income taxes
generally imposed on each state’s portion of the U.S. source income subject to U.S. federal income taxes.
However, the state of Alaska imposes an income tax on its allocated portion of the total income of our
companies doing business in Alaska and certain of their subsidiaries.
b.
UK and Australian Income Tax
Cunard, P&O Cruises (UK) and P&O Cruises (Australia) are divisions of Carnival plc and have elected to
enter UK tonnage tax under a rolling ten-year term and, accordingly, reapply every year. Companies to which
the tonnage tax regime applies pay corporation taxes on profits calculated by reference to the net tonnage
of qualifying ships. UK corporation tax is not chargeable under the normal UK tax rules on these brands’
relevant shipping income. Relevant shipping income includes income from the operation of qualifying ships
and from shipping related activities.
38
For a company to be eligible for the regime, it must be subject to UK corporation tax and, among other
matters, operate qualifying ships that are strategically and commercially managed in the UK. Companies
within UK tonnage tax are also subject to a seafarer training requirement.
Our UK non-shipping activities that do not qualify under the UK tonnage tax regime remain subject to
normal UK corporation tax.
P&O Cruises (Australia) and all of the other cruise ships operated internationally by Carnival plc for the
cruise segment of the Australian vacation region are exempt from Australian corporation tax by virtue of the
UK/Australian income tax treaty.
c.
Italian and German Income Tax
In 2015, Costa and AIDA re-elected to enter the Italian tonnage tax regime through 2024 and can reapply
for an additional ten-year period beginning in early 2025. Companies to which the tonnage tax regime applies
pay corporation taxes on shipping profits calculated by reference to the net tonnage of qualifying ships.
Most of Costa’s and AIDA’s earnings that are not eligible for taxation under the Italian tonnage tax regime
will be taxed at an effective tax rate of 4.8% in 2022 and 2021.
Substantially all of AIDA’s earnings are exempt from German income taxes by virtue of the Germany/Italy
income tax treaty.
d.
Other
In addition to or in place of income taxes, virtually all jurisdictions where our ships call impose taxes, fees
and other charges based on guest counts, ship tonnage, passenger capacity or some other measure.
XXI.
Trademarks and Other Intellectual Property
We own, use and/or have registered or licensed numerous trademarks, patents and patent pending designs
and technology, copyrights and domain names, which have considerable value and some of which are widely
recognized throughout the world. These intangible assets enable us to distinguish our cruise products and
services, ships and programs from those of our competitors. We own or license the trademarks for the trade
names of our cruise brands, each of which we believe is a widely-recognized brand in the cruise industry,
as well as our ship names and a wide variety of cruise products and services.
XXII.
Competition
We compete with land-based vacation alternatives throughout the world, such as hotels, resorts (including
all-inclusive resorts), theme parks, organized tours, casinos, vacation ownership properties, and other
internet-based alternative lodging sites. Based on 2022 Cruise Industry News statistics, as of December 31,
2022, we, along with our principal cruise competitors Royal Caribbean Group, Norwegian Cruise Line
Holdings, Ltd. and MSC Cruises, represented approximately 80% of the cruise industry capacity, including
ships operating with guests onboard and ships in pause status expected to return to guest cruise operations.
D.
Website Access to Carnival Corporation & plc SEC Reports
We use our websites as channels of distribution of company information. Our Form 10-K, Carnival plc
Annual Report, joint Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q, joint Current Reports on Form 8-K, joint Proxy
Statement related to our annual shareholders meeting, Section 16 filings and all amendments to those reports
are available free of charge at www.carnivalcorp.com and www.carnivalplc.com and on the SEC’s website
at www.sec.gov as soon as reasonably practicable after we have electronically filed or furnished these reports
with the SEC. In addition, you may automatically receive email alerts and other information when you
enroll your email address by visiting the Investor Services section of our websites. The content of any website
referred to in this document is not incorporated by reference into this document.
E.
Industry and Market Data
This document includes market share and industry data and forecasts that we obtained from industry
publications, third-party surveys and internal company surveys. Industry publications, including those from
Cruise Industry News, and surveys and forecasts, generally state that the information contained therein
has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. Cruise Industry News is a for profit magazine company
Strategic Report
39
that covers all aspects of cruise operations. Their magazines and annual report cover all cruise lines and
shipyards and report on all aspects of cruise operations including relevant issues, financial results, ship
building, ship reviews, etc. All other references to third party information are publicly available at nominal
or no cost. We use the most currently available industry and market data to support statements as to our
market positions. Although we believe that the industry publications and third-party sources are reliable,
we have not independently verified any of the data. Similarly, while we believe our internal estimates with
respect to our industry are reliable, they have not been verified by any independent sources. While we are not
aware of any misstatements regarding any industry data presented herein, our estimates, in particular as
they relate to market share and our general expectations, involve risks and uncertainties and are subject to
change based on various factors, including those discussed under Item 4. Risk Management and/or Mitigation
of Principal and Emerging Risks within this Strategic Report.
F.
Properties
As of November 30, 2022, the Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc headquarters and our larger shoreside
locations are as follows:
Location
Square Footage
(in thousands)
Own/Lease
Principal Operations
Miami, FL, U.S.A.
463/18
Own/Lease
Carnival Corporation & plc and Carnival
Cruise Line
Genoa, Italy
229/46
Own/Lease
Costa and AIDA
Almere, Netherlands
253
Own
Arison Maritime Center
Rostock, Germany
224
Own
Costa and AIDA
Seattle, WA, U.S.A.
175
Lease
Princess Cruises, Holland America Line and
Seabourn
Southampton, England
150
Lease
Carnival plc, P&O Cruises (UK) and
Cunard
Santa Clarita, CA, U.S.A.
134
Lease
Princess Cruises, Holland America Line and
Seabourn
Hamburg, Germany
108
Lease
Costa and AIDA
Fort Lauderdale, FL,
U.S.A.
61
Lease
Princess Cruises
Sydney, NSW, Australia
37
Lease
Princess Cruises and P&O Cruises
(Australia)
Information about our cruise ships, including the number each of our cruise brands operate, as well as
information regarding our cruise ships under construction may be found under Part I. Item 1. Business. C.
“Our Global Cruise Business.”In addition, we own, lease or have controlling interests in port destinations,
private islands, hotels, and lodges.
G.
Legal Proceedings
The legal proceedings described in Note 7 — “Contingencies”of our DLC Financial Statements, including
those described under “COVID-19 Actions,” are shown in our IFRS Financial Statements in Note 23—
“Contingencies”and are incorporated by reference into this Strategic Report.
On June 20, 2022, Princess Cruises notified the Australian Maritime Safety Authorization (“AMSA”) and
the flag state, Bermuda, regarding approximately six cubic meters of comminuted food waste (liquid
biodigester effluent) inadvertently discharged by
Coral Princess
inside the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park.
On June 23, 2022, the UK P&I Club N.V. provided a letter of undertaking for approximately $1.9 million
(being the estimated maximum combined penalty). We believe the ultimate outcome will not have a material
impact on our consolidated financial statements.
H.
Executive Officers and Corporate Governance
Information About Our Executive Officers
The table below sets forth the name, age, years of service and title of each of our executive officers as of
January 27, 2023. Titles listed relate to positions within Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc unless
otherwise noted.
40
Age
Years of
Service (a)
Title
Micky Arison
73
51
Chair of the Boards of Directors
David Bernstein
65
24
Chief Financial Officer and Chief Accounting Officer
Vice Admiral William R.
Burke (Ret.)
66
9
Chief Maritime Officer
Enrique Miguez
58
25
General Counsel
Michael Thamm
59
29
Group Chief Executive Officer of Costa Group and
Carnival Asia
Josh Weinstein
48
20
President, Chief Executive Officer and Chief Climate
Officer
(a)
Years of service with us or Carnival plc predecessor companies.
Business Experience of Executive Officers
Micky Arison has been Chair of the Boards of Directors since 1990 and a Director since 1987. He was
Chief Executive Officer from 1979 to 2013.
David Bernstein has been Chief Financial Officer since 2007 and Chief Accounting Officer since 2016.
William R. Burke, retired Vice Admiral, has been Chief Maritime Officer since 2013.
Enrique Miguez has been General Counsel since 2021. He was Vice President and Deputy General Counsel
from 2003 to 2021.
Michael Thamm has been Group Chief Executive Officer of Costa Group since 2012 and of Carnival Asia
since 2017.
Josh Weinstein has been President, Chief Executive Officer and Chief Climate Officer since August 2022.
He was Chief Operations Officer from 2020 to July 2022, President of Carnival UK from 2017 to 2022 and
Treasurer from 2007 to 2017.
Corporate Governance
Our Code of Business Conduct and Ethics applies to all our team members and our Boards of Directors
and states our commitment to conduct business ethically, without the influence of bribes or acts of corruption.
We are committed to complying with the laws prohibiting bribery and other corrupt practices that apply
everywhere we operate. Additionally, we provide trainings on anti-corruption laws and regulations and how
to identify bribery to our team members. This Code of Business Conduct and Ethics is posted on our
website, which is located at www.carnivalcorp.com and www.carnivalplc.com. We intend to satisfy the
disclosure requirements regarding any amendments to, or waivers from, provisions of this Code of Business
Conduct and Ethics by posting such information on our website, at the addresses specified above. Refer to
Annex C — Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report of the Proxy Statement on page C-1.
I.
Dividends
On March 30, 2020, we suspended the payment of dividends on Carnival Corporation common stock and
Carnival plc ordinary shares.
J.
Repurchase Authorizations
I.
Stock Swap Program
We have a program that allows us to realize a net cash benefit when Carnival Corporation common stock is
trading at a premium to the price of Carnival plc ordinary shares. Under the Stock Swap Program, we
may elect to offer and sell shares of Carnival Corporation common stock at prevailing market prices in
ordinary brokers’transactions and repurchase an equivalent number of Carnival plc ordinary shares in the
UK market.
II.
Carnival plc Shareholder Approvals
Carnival plc ordinary share repurchases under the Stock Swap Program require annual shareholder
approval. The existing shareholder approval was limited to a maximum of 18.5 million ordinary shares and
is valid until the earlier of the conclusion of the Carnival plc 2023 annual general meeting or October 7, 2023.
Strategic Report
41
2.
Business Review.
The Directors consider that within the DLC arrangement, the most appropriate presentation of Carnival
plc’s Group Business Review is by reference to the DLC Financial Statements. Accordingly, the below presents
the required Business Review for Carnival Corporation & plc in order to satisfy reporting requirements of
the Companies Act 2006. Refer to Note 3 — Segment Information, for a reconciliation of the Carnival
Corporation & plc U.S. GAAP amounts to the corresponding Carnival plc Group IFRS amounts as of and
for the years ended November 30, 2022 and 2021.
Known Trends and Uncertainties
• We believe the increased cost of fuel and other related costs are reasonably likely to continue to
impact our profitability in both the short and long-term.
• We believe inflation and higher interest rates are reasonably likely to continue to impact our
profitability.
• We believe the increasing global focus on climate change, including the reduction of carbon emissions
and new and evolving regulatory requirements, is reasonably likely to have a material negative
impact on our future financial results. The full impact of climate change to our business is not yet
known.
Results of Operations
We have historically earned substantially all of our cruise revenues from the following:
• Sales of passenger cruise tickets and, in some cases, the sale of air and other transportation to and
from airports near our ships’home ports and cancellation fees. We also collect fees, taxes and other
charges from our guests. The cruise ticket price typically includes the following:
• Accommodations
• Most meals, including snacks at numerous venues
• Access to amenities such as swimming pools, water slides, water parks, whirlpools, a health club
and sun decks
• Child care and supervised youth programs
• Entertainment, such as theatrical and comedy shows, live music and nightclubs
• Visits to multiple destinations
• Sales of onboard goods and services not included in the cruise ticket price. This generally includes
the following:
• Beverage sales
• Internet and communication services
• Casino gaming
• Full service spas
• Shore excursions
• Specialty restaurants
• Retail sales
• Art sales
• Photo sales
• Laundry and dry cleaning services
These goods and services are provided either directly by us or by independent concessionaires, from which
we receive either a percentage of their revenues or a fee. Concession revenues do not have direct expenses
because the costs and services incurred for concession revenues are borne by our concessionaires. In 2022,
we earned 42% of our cruise revenues from onboard and other revenue goods and services. In 2019, our most
recent full year of guest cruise operations, we earned 30% of our cruise revenues from onboard and other
revenues.
We earn our tour and other revenues from our hotel and transportation operations and other revenues.
We incur cruise operating costs and expenses for the following:
• The costs of passenger cruise bookings, which include travel agent commissions, cost of air and
other transportation, port fees, taxes, and charges that directly vary with guest head counts and credit
and debit card fees
• Onboard and other cruise costs, which include the costs of beverage sales, costs of shore excursions,
costs of retail sales, internet and communication costs, credit and debit card fees, other onboard costs,
costs of cruise vacation protection programs and pre- and post-cruise land packages
42
• Payroll and related costs, which include the costs of officers and crew in bridge, engineering and
hotel operations. Substantially all costs associated with our shoreside personnel are included in selling
and administrative expenses
• Fuel costs, which include fuel delivery costs
• Food costs, which include both our guest and crew food costs
• Other ship operating expenses, which include port costs that do not vary with guest head counts;
repairs and maintenance, including minor improvements and dry-dock expenses; hotel costs;
entertainment; gains and losses on ship sales; ship impairments; freight and logistics; insurance
premiums and all other ship operating expenses
We incur tour and other costs and expenses for our hotel and transportation operations and other expenses.
Statistical Information
Years Ended
November 30,
2022
2021
PCDs
(in millions)
(a)
..........................................
54.6
8.2
ALBDs
(in millions)
(b)
........................................
72.5
14.6
Occupancy percentage (c)
.......................................
75%
56%
Passengers carried
(in millions)
...................................
7.7
1.2
Fuel consumption in metric tons
(in millions)
.........................
2.6
1.3
Fuel consumption in metric tons per thousand ALBDs
...................
36.1
(d)
Fuel cost per metric ton consumed
.................................
$
830
$
515
Currencies (USD to 1)
AUD
....................................................
$
0.70
$
0.75
CAD
....................................................
$
0.77
$
0.80
EUR
....................................................
$
1.06
$
1.19
GBP
....................................................
$
1.25
$
1.38
The resumption of guest cruise operations has impacted the comparability of all aspects of our business.
Notes to Statistical Information
(a)
PCD represents the number of cruise passengers on a voyage multiplied by the number of revenue-
producing ship operating days for that voyage.
(b)
ALBD is a standard measure of passenger capacity for the period that we use to approximate rate
and capacity variances, based on consistently applied formulas that we use to perform analyses
to determine the main non-capacity driven factors that cause our cruise revenues and expenses to
vary. ALBDs assume that each cabin we offer for sale accommodates two passengers and is computed
by multiplying passenger capacity by revenue-producing ship operating days in the period.
(c)
Occupancy, in accordance with cruise industry practice, is calculated using a numerator of PCDs
and a denominator of ALBDs, which assumes two passengers per cabin even though some cabins
can accommodate three or more passengers. Percentages in excess of 100% indicate that on
average more than two passengers occupied some cabins.
(d)
Fuel consumption in metric tons per thousand ALBDs for 2021 and 2020 are not meaningful.
Strategic Report
43
2022 Compared to 2021
Carnival plc Group IFRS Key Measures
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Revenue
..............................................
$
3,941
$
760
Operating income (loss)
...................................
$
(2,905)
$
(3,215)
Total assets
............................................
$
15,532
$
16,851
The Directors consider that within the DLC arrangement, the most appropriate presentation of Carnival
plc’s Group Business Review is by reference to the DLC Financial Statements. Accordingly, the below presents
the required Business Review for Carnival Corporation & plc in order to satisfy reporting requirements of
the Companies Act 2006.
Consolidated
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Change
Revenues
Passenger ticket
...........................
$
7,022
$
1,000
$
6,022
Onboard and other
........................
5,147
908
4,239
12,168
1,908
10,260
Operating Costs and Expenses
Commissions, transportation and other
..........
1,630
269
1,360
Onboard and other
........................
1,528
272
1,256
Payroll and related
.........................
2,181
1,309
871
Fuel
...................................
2,157
680
1,477
Food
..................................
863
187
676
Ship and other impairments
..................
440
591
(151)
Other operating
...........................
2,958
1,346
1,612
11,757
4,655
7,103
Selling and administrative
....................
2,515
1,885
630
Depreciation and amortization
................
2,275
2,233
43
Goodwill impairment
.......................
—
226
(226)
16,547
8,997
7,550
Operating Income (Loss)
......................
(4,379)
(7,089)
2,710
Nonoperating Income (Expense)
Interest income
...........................
74
12
62
Interest expense, net of capitalized interest
........
(1,609)
(1,601)
(8)
Gains (losses) on debt extinguishment, net
........
(1)
(670)
670
Other income (expense), net
..................
(165)
(173)
8
(1,701)
(2,433)
732
Income (Loss) Before Income Taxes
...............
$
(6,080)
$
(9,522)
$
3,443
44
NAA
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Change
Revenues
Passenger ticket
...........................
$
4,692
$
555
$
4,137
Onboard and other
........................
3,589
553
3,036
8,281
1,108
7,173
Operating Costs and Expenses
..................
7,526
2,730
4,796
Selling and administrative
.....................
1,517
953
564
Depreciation and amortization
..................
1,408
1,352
55
10,451
5,036
5,415
Operating Income (Loss)
......................
$
(2,170)
$
(3,928)
$
1,758
EA
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Change
Revenues
Passenger ticket
...........................
$
2,660
$
491
$
2,169
Onboard and other
........................
872
221
651
3,531
712
2,820
Operating Costs and Expenses
..................
3,925
1,807
2,118
Selling and administrative
.....................
745
568
177
Depreciation and amortization
..................
692
728
(37)
Goodwill impairment
........................
—
226
(226)
5,361
3,329
2,032
Operating Income (Loss)
......................
$
(1,830)
$
(2,617)
$
787
In the face of the global impact of COVID-19, we paused our guest cruise operations in mid-March 2020
and began resuming guest cruise operations in 2021. As of November 30, 2022, 97% of our capacity was
serving guests compared to 61% as of November 30, 2021. Our NAA segment’s full fleet was serving guests as
of November 30, 2022 compared to 60% of its capacity as of November 30, 2021. Our EA segment had
93% of its capacity serving guests as of November 30, 2022, compared to 63% as of November 30, 2021.
The effects of the pause and subsequent resumption of our guest cruise operations, inflation, higher fuel
prices, higher interest rates and fluctuations in foreign currency rates are collectively having a material negative
impact on all aspects of our business, including our results of operations, liquidity and financial position.
We have a substantial debt balance and require a significant amount of cash to service our debt and sustain
our operations, and our ability to generate cash will be affected by our ability to successfully implement
our business strategy, which includes increasing our occupancy levels and pricing of our cruises, as well as
general macroeconomic, financial, geopolitical, competitive, regulatory and other factors beyond our control.
The full extent of these impacts is uncertain and may be amplified by our substantial debt balance.
Revenues
Consolidated
Cruise passenger ticket revenues made up 58% of our total revenues in 2022 while onboard and other
revenues made up 42%. Revenues for the year ended November 30, 2022 increased by $10.3 billion to
$12.2 billion from $1.9 billion in 2021 due to the ongoing resumption of guest cruise operations and the
significant increase of ships in service. ALBDs increased to 72.5 million in 2022 as compared to 14.6 million
in 2021. Occupancy for 2022 was 75.3%, compared to 56% in 2021.
Strategic Report
45
NAA Segment
Cruise passenger ticket revenues made up 57% of our NAA segment’s total revenues in 2022 while onboard
and other cruise revenues made up 43%. NAA segment revenues for 2022 increased by $7.2 billion to
$8.3 billion from $1.1 billion in 2021 due to the ongoing resumption of guest cruise operations and the
significant increase of ships in service. ALBDs increased to 44.3 million in 2022 as compared to 7.2 million
in 2021. Occupancy for 2022 was 82% compared to 63% in 2021.
EA Segment
Cruise passenger ticket revenues made up 75% of our EA segment’s total revenues in 2022 while onboard
and other cruise revenues made up 25%. EA segment revenues for 2022 increased by $2.8 billion to $3.5 billion
from $0.7 billion in 2021 due to the ongoing resumption of guest cruise operations and the significant
increase of ships in service. ALBDs increased to 28.2 million in 2022 as compared to 7.4 million in 2021.
Occupancy for 2022 was 65% compared to 50% in 2021.
Operating Cost and Expenses
Consolidated
Operating costs and expenses increased by $7.1 billion to $11.8 billion in 2022 from $4.7 billion in 2021.
These increases were driven by our resumption of guest cruise operations and restart related expenses,
including the cost of returning ships to guest cruise operations and returning crew members to our ships, the
cost of maintaining enhanced health and safety protocols and inflation.
Fuel costs increased by $1.5 billion to $2.2 billion in 2022 from $0.7 billion in 2021. $0.7 billion of this
increase was driven by higher fuel consumption of 1.3 million metric tons, due to the resumption of guest
cruise operations, and $0.8 billion was driven by an increase in fuel prices and changes in fuel mix of $315 per
metric ton consumed in 2022 compared to 2021.
We recognized ship and other impairment charges of $440 million in 2022 compared to $591 million in
2021.
Selling and administrative expenses increased by $0.6 billion to $2.5 billion in 2022 from $1.9 billion in
2021. This increase was primarily driven by increased advertising and promotional spend to continue to build
demand while the remainder was driven by higher administrative expenses incurred as part of our
resumption of guest cruise operations.
There were no goodwill impairment charges recognized in 2022 and $226 million of goodwill impairment
charges recognized in 2021.
The drivers in changes in costs and expenses for our NAA and EA segments are the same as those described
for our consolidated results.
Nonoperating Income (Expense)
Interest expense, net of capitalized interest, was $1.6 billion in 2022 and 2021.
Losses on debt extinguishment, net decreased to $1 million in 2022 from $670 million in 2021.
Liquidity, Financial Condition and Capital Resources
The Directors consider that within the DLC arrangement, the most appropriate presentation of Carnival
plc’s Group Liquidity, Financial Condition and Capital Resources is by reference to the DLC Financial
Statement. Accordingly, the below presents the required disclosures for Carnival Corporation & plc in order
to satisfy reporting requirements of the Companies Act 2006.
As of November 30, 2022, we had $8.6 billion of liquidity including cash, restricted cash from the 2028
Senior Priority Notes which became unrestricted in December 2022 and borrowings available under our
Revolving Facility (Refer to Note 1 — “Liquidity and Management’s Plans”within the plc Group Financial
Statements on page 80). We will continue to pursue various opportunities to raise additional capital to
fund obligations associated with future debt maturities and/or to extend the maturity dates associated with
our existing indebtedness including our Revolving Facility and obtain relevant financial covenant amendments
46
or waivers, if needed. Actions to raise capital may include issuances of debt, convertible debt or equity in
private or public transactions or entering into new and extended credit facilities.
Since December 2021, we have completed the following:
• In December 2021, we borrowed $1.7 billion under export credit facilities due in semi-annual
installments through 2034.
• In January 2022, we borrowed $637 million under an export credit facility due in semi-annual
installments through 2034.
• In May 2022, we issued an aggregate principal amount of $1.0 billion senior unsecured notes that
mature on June 1, 2030. The 2030 Senior Unsecured Notes bear interest at a rate of 10.5% per year.
• In August 2022, we completed a public offering of 117.5 million shares of Carnival Corporation
common stock at a price per share of $9.95, resulting in net proceeds of $1.2 billion.
• In August 2022, we issued $339 million aggregate principal amount of the 2024 Convertible Notes in
a privately negotiated non-cash exchange for existing convertible notes.
• In October 2022, we issued an aggregate principal amount of $2.0 billion senior priority notes that
mature on May 1, 2028. The 2028 Senior Priority Notes bear interest at a rate of 10.4% per year.
• In November 2022, we issued an additional $87 million aggregate principal amount of the 2024
Convertible Notes in a privately negotiated non-cash exchange for existing convertible notes.
• In November 2022, we issued $1.1 billion aggregate principal amount of the 2027 Convertible Notes.
• In November 2022, we borrowed $799 million under an export credit facility due in semi-annual
installments through 2034.
Refer to Note 5 — “Debt”of the DLC Financial Statements, Note 15 — “Debt and Interest Expense”
within the plc Group Financial Statements and “Funding Sources”below for additional details.
Certain of our debt instruments contain provisions that may limit our ability to incur or guarantee additional
indebtedness.
We had a working capital deficit of $3.1 billion as of November 30, 2022 compared to a working capital
deficit of $0.3 billion as of November 30, 2021. The increase in working capital deficit was caused by a
decrease in cash and cash equivalents, a decrease in short-term investments, an increase in customer deposits
and an increase in current portion of long-term debt, and was partially offset by an increase in restricted
cash and a decrease in short-term borrowings. We operate with a substantial working capital deficit. This
deficit is mainly attributable to the fact that, under our business model, substantially all of our passenger
ticket receipts are collected in advance of the applicable sailing date. These advance passenger receipts generally
remain a current liability until the sailing date. The cash generated from these advance receipts is used
interchangeably with cash on hand from other sources, such as our borrowings and other cash from
operations. The cash received as advanced receipts can be used to fund operating expenses, pay down our
debt, make long-term investments or any other use of cash. Included within our working capital are $4.9 billion
and $3.1 billion of customer deposits as of November 30, 2022 and 2021, respectively. We have agreements
with a number of credit card processors that transact customer deposits related to our cruise vacations. Certain
of these agreements allow the credit card processors to request, under certain circumstances, that we
provide a reserve fund in cash. In addition, we have a relatively low level of accounts receivable and limited
investment in inventories.
Sources and Uses of Cash
Operating Activities
Our business used $1.7 billion of net cash flows in operating activities during 2022, a decrease of $2.4 billion,
compared to $4.1 billion used in 2021. This was due to a decrease in the net loss compared to the same
period in 2021 and other working capital changes.
Investing Activities
During 2022, net cash used in investing activities was $4.8 billion. This was driven by:
• Capital expenditures of $3.9 billion for our ongoing new shipbuilding program
• Capital expenditures of $1.1 billion for ship improvements and replacements, information technology
and buildings and improvements
• Proceeds from sales of ships and other of $70 million
Strategic Report
47
• Purchases of short-term investments of $315 million
• Proceeds from maturity of short-term investments of $515 million
During 2021, net cash used in investing activities was $3.5 billion. This was caused by:
• Capital expenditures of $3.0 billion for our ongoing new shipbuilding program
• Capital expenditures of $602 million for ship improvements and replacements, information technology
and buildings and improvements
• Proceeds from sales of ships and other of $351 million
• Purchases of short-term investments of $2.9 billion
• Proceeds from maturity of short-term investments of $2.7 billion
Financing Activities
During 2022, net cash provided by financing activities of $3.6 billion was caused by:
• Issuances of $7.2 billion of long-term debt
• Repayments of $2.1 billion of long-term debt
• Payments of $153 million related to debt issuance costs
• Net repayments of short-term borrowings of $2.6 billion
• Net proceeds of $1.2 billion from the public offering of Carnival Corporation common stock
• Purchases of $87 million of Carnival plc ordinary shares and issuances of $95 million of Carnival
Corporation common stock under our Stock Swap Program
During 2021, net cash provided by financing activities of $6.9 billion was caused by:
• Issuances of $13.0 billion of long-term debt
• Repayments of $6.0 billion of long-term debt
• Premium payments of $545 million related to the extinguishment of debt
• Net proceeds of $1.0 billion from Carnival Corporation common stock
• Purchases of $188 million of Carnival plc ordinary shares and issuances of $206 million of Carnival
Corporation common stock under our Stock Swap Program
• Payments of $319 million related to debt issuance costs
Material Cash Requirements
The Directors consider that within the DLC arrangement, the most appropriate presentation of Carnival
plc’s Group Material Cash Requirements, Funding Sources and Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures
About Market Risk is by reference to the DLC Financial Statements. Accordingly, the below presents the
required disclosures for Carnival Corporation & plc in order to satisfy reporting requirements of the
Companies Act 2006.
Payments Due by
(in millions)
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
Total
Debt (a)
....................
$
4,344
$
4,564 (c) $
6,082
$
5,875
$
6,755
$ 27,620
Newbuild capital expenditures (b) . .
1,755
2,400
895
—
—
5,050
Total
......................
$
6,099
$
6,964
$
6,977
$
5,875
$
6,755
$ 32,670
(a)
Includes principal as well as estimated interest payments and does not include the impact of any future
possible refinancings. Excludes undrawn export credits.
(b)
As of November 30, 2022, we have committed undrawn export credit facilities of $2.2 billion which
fund a portion of our Newbuild contractual commitments. Subsequent to November 30, 2022, we
obtained additional committed undrawn export credit facilities related to ship deliveries scheduled in
2024 and 2025.
(c)
Includes $0.2 billion of borrowings under the Revolving Facility as of November 30, 2022 which
mature in 2024.
48
Funding Sources
As of November 30, 2022, we had $8.6 billion of liquidity including cash, restricted cash from the 2028
Senior Priority Notes which became unrestricted in December 2022 and borrowings available under our
Revolving Facility. In addition, we had $2.2 billion of undrawn export credit facilities to fund ship deliveries
planned through 2024. Refer to Note 1 — “General”for further details on our liquidity risk and how we
plan to fund our cash requirements, which is assessed for Carnival Corporation & plc combined, given the
DLC arrangement.
(in billions)
2023
2024
Future export credit facilities at November 30, 2022
......................
$
0.8
$
1.4
Subsequent to November 30, 2022, we obtained additional undrawn export credit facilities related to ship
deliveries scheduled in 2024 and 2025.
Our export credit facilities contain various financial covenants as described in Note 5 — “Debt” within the
DLC Financial Statements and Note 15 — “Debt and Interest Expense within the plc Group Financial
Statements. At November 30, 2022, we were in compliance with the applicable covenants under our debt
agreements.
Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk
For a discussion of our hedging strategies and market risks, see the discussion below and the consolidated
financial statements.
Fuel Price Risks
Substantially all our exposure to market risk for changes in fuel prices relates to the consumption of fuel on
our ships. We have installed Advanced Air Quality Systems on most of our ships, which has aided in the
mitigation of the financial impact from the ECAs and global 0.5% sulfur requirements. The blended spot price
included in our selected forecast information within our Business Update from December 2022 was $673
per metric ton, and we expect our total fuel consumption for 2023 to be 2.9 million metric tons. If fuel prices
changed by 10%, our 2023 total expected fuel cost would change by $185 million.
Foreign Currency Exchange Rate Risks
Operational Currency Risks
Our operations primarily utilize the U.S. dollar, Euro, Sterling or the Australian dollar as their functional
currencies. Our operations also have revenue and expenses denominated in non-functional currencies.
Movements in foreign currency exchange rates will affect our financial statements.
Investment Currency Risks
The foreign currency exchange rates were as follows:
November 30,
2022
2021
USD to 1:
AUD
......................................................
$
0.66
$
0.71
CAD
......................................................
$
0.74
$
0.78
EUR
......................................................
$
1.03
$
1.13
GBP
......................................................
$
1.20
$
1.33
If the November 30, 2021 currency exchange rates had been used to translate our November 30, 2022
non-U.S. dollar functional currency operations’assets and liabilities (instead of the November 30, 2022 U.S.
dollar exchange rates), our total assets would have been higher by $1.6 billion and our total liabilities
would have been higher by $1.1 billion.
Newbuild Currency Risks
At November 30, 2022, our remaining newbuild currency exchange rate risk primarily relates to euro-
denominated newbuild contract payments, which represent a total unhedged commitment of $4.4 billion
Strategic Report
49
and relate to newbuilds scheduled to be delivered through 2025 to non-euro functional currency brands. The
functional currency cost of each of these ships will increase or decrease based on changes in the exchange
rates until the unhedged payments are made under the shipbuilding contract. We may enter into additional
foreign currency derivatives to mitigate some of this foreign currency exchange rate risk. Based on a 10%
change in euro to U.S. dollar exchange rates as of November 30, 2022, the remaining unhedged cost of
these ships would have a corresponding change of $445 million.
Interest Rate Risks
The composition of our debt and interest rate swaps was as follows:
November 30, 2022
Fixed rate
.....................................................
54%
EUR fixed rate
..................................................
12%
Floating rate
...................................................
17%
EUR floating rate
................................................
15%
GBP floating rate
................................................
1%
At November 30, 2022, we had interest rate swaps that have effectively changed $89 million of EURIBOR-
based floating rate euro debt to fixed rate euro debt. Based on a 10% change in the November 30, 2022 market
interest rates, our 2022 interest expense on floating rate debt, including the effect of our interest rate swaps,
would have changed by $48 million.
3.
Internal Control and Risk Assessment.
Management
BOARDS OF DIRECTORS
Oversee strategy and risk management.
Boards of Directors Committees
Oversee strategy and risk management.
AUDIT COMMITTEES
Oversee risk management realted to
financial, IT, (including cybersecurity and
data privacy) and non-HESS related
operational risks, as well as monitoring
changes to and compliance with related
legal and regulatory requirements.
EXECUTIVE MANAGEMENT
Responsible for managing the business,
providing the Boards of Directors and
Committees with appropriate information
to enable them to carry out their
responsibilities. Performs remediation
actions resulting from investigations by
RAAS as well as the Global Ethics and
Compliance function.
GLOBAL ETHICS
AND COMPLIANCE
Responsible for supporting a high level of
rthics and integrity and helping
management maintain compliance with
applicable laws, regulations standards.
RISK ADVISORY AND
ASSURANCE SERVICES
Responsible for providing independent
assurance that controls are well designed and
operating effectively.
HESS COMMITTEES
Oversee risk management realted to HESS
and sustainability risks as well as
monitoring changes to and complianes
with related legal and regulatory
requirements.
COMPLIANCE COMMITTEES
Oversee risk management realted to complianes
with applicable laws and regulations, including
our compliance monitoring activities, supporting
a high level of ethics and integrity.
Note: The Boards of Directors Compensation and Nominating & Governance Committees are also responsible
for some strategy and risk management activities.
Our Risk Management Framework
The Boards of Directors have overall responsibility for determining the strategic direction of our business
and have established a framework to manage risk and determine the nature and extent of the principal and
emerging risks acceptable to our business. Our framework is designed to identify and manage, rather than
eliminate, risk to the achievement of our strategic objectives. The Boards of Directors, through their
50
Committees and executive management, have carried out a robust assessment of our principal and emerging
risks, including to ensure that they are effectively managed and/or mitigated.
Risk management is embedded in all areas of our business and is reflected across our policies and procedures.
Our risk management framework includes an organization wide, multi-layered approach and consists of
the Boards of Directors, their Committees, Risk Advisory and Assurance Services (“RAAS”), Global Ethics
and Compliance and executive management.
The diagram above, illustrates the interaction between the Boards of Directors, their Committees and our
executive management to continuously assess, mitigate and manage risks. The Boards of Directors leverage
their Committees, principally the Audit Committees, the HESS Committees and the Compliance
Committees, to oversee our risk management activities. Each area of our business reports via executive
management to these Committees. The Committees of the Boards of Directors and the executive management
of each area of our business are supported by RAAS and Global Ethics and Compliance.
Refer to Annex C — Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report of the Proxy Statement on pages C-5 to
C-9 for additional information on the Committees of the Boards.
How we identify and manage risk
Risk assessment processes are integrated within our business operations at every level. Risks are identified
by individuals across all businesses and functions and at many layers of the organization by considering what
could prevent us from achieving our strategic, operational or compliance objectives or impact the
sustainability of our business model. In deciding which risks are principal and emerging risks, our executive
management considers the potential impact and probability of the related events or circumstances, and
the timescale over which they may occur. In addition, under the supervision of the Boards of Directors and
their Committees, executive management is responsible for ensuring that we have active plans and adequate
resources to manage and/or mitigate the principal and emerging risks, including HESS and compliance related
risks, identified by the business. As new risks arise, executive management seeks to ensure they are properly
reviewed and monitored.
Internal Control
Internal control and risk management is an ongoing process embedded in each of our operations. It is
designed to identify, evaluate and manage the principal and emerging risks faced by the business units. A
system of internal controls designed to be capable of responding quickly to evolving risks in the business has
been established, comprising procedures for the prompt reporting of significant and material internal
control deficiencies together with the appropriate remedial actions. Carnival Corporation & plc has adopted
the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (“COSO”) guidance for
implementing its internal controls as part of its SOX compliance plan. COSO is considered to be the
leading internal control framework and references the same internal control objectives and components as
are used by the UK Corporate Governance Code in assessing the effectiveness of a company’s risk and control
processes.
Our system of internal control was in place throughout 2022 and has continued in place up to the date of
approval of this Strategic Report. The Boards of Directors confirm that they have performed their annual
review of its effectiveness and that it is in compliance with the UK Corporate Governance Code. The Boards
of Directors review of the system of internal controls has not identified any significant failings or
weaknesses, and therefore, no remedial actions are required.
Emerging Risks
We continuously evaluate potential emerging risks that could significantly impact or challenge our strategy
and business model. Emerging risks identified are managed and monitored alongside our existing principal
risks. An example of this in practice are the direct and indirect risks arising from climate change which
continue to evolve. To further address the evolving and emerging risks associated with climate change, we
created a Strategic Risk Evaluation (“SRE”) Committee to assist in identifying, monitoring and reviewing the
management of climate-related risks and opportunities. Refer to subsection “a.”of section XV. Sustainability
and Environmental Impact on page 19 and Operating Risk Factor “e.”on page 55 for additional details
on how we manage risks arising from climate change.
Strategic Report
51
4.
Risk Management and/or Mitigation of Principal and Emerging Risks.
You should carefully consider the following discussion of material factors, events and uncertainties that
make an investment in the company’s securities risky and provide important information for the understanding
of the “forward-looking”statements discussed in this Annual Report and elsewhere. These risk factors
should be read in conjunction with other information in this Annual Report.
The events and consequences discussed in these risk factors could have a material adverse effect on the
company’s business, financial condition, operating results and stock price. These risk factors do not identify
all risks that the company faces; operations could also be affected by factors, events, or uncertainties that
are not presently known to the company or that the company currently does not consider to present material
risks to its operations. In addition to the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic and resulting global disruptions
on our business and operations discussed in this Annual Report and in the risk factors below, additional
or unforeseen effects from our substantial debt balance as a result of the pause of our guest cruise operations
could give rise to or amplify many of the risks discussed below. Some of the statements in this item and
elsewhere in this document are “forward-looking statements.”For a discussion of those statements and of
other factors to consider see the “Cautionary Note Concerning Factors That May Affect Future Results”
section.
The ordering and lettering of the risk factors set forth below is not intended to reflect any company
indication of priority or likelihood.
Operating Risk Factors
a.
Events and conditions around the world, including war and other military actions, such as the invasion of
Ukraine, inflation, higher fuel prices, higher interest rates and other general concerns impacting the ability
or desire of people to travel have led, and may in the future lead, to a decline in demand for cruises,
impacting our operating costs and profitability.
We have been, and may continue to be, impacted by the public’s concerns regarding the health, safety and
security of travel, including government travel advisories and travel restrictions, political instability and civil
unrest, terrorist attacks, war and military action, most recently the invasion of Ukraine, and other general
concerns. The invasion of Ukraine and its resulting impacts, including supply chain disruptions, increased
fuel prices, impact on demand for cruises to neighboring regions and international sanctions and other
measures that have been imposed, have adversely affected, and may continue to adversely affect, our business.
These factors may also have the effect of heightening many other risks to our business, any of which could
materially and adversely affect our business and results of operations. Additionally, we have been, and may
continue to be, impacted by heightened regulations around customs and border control, travel bans to
and from certain geographical areas, voluntary changes to our itineraries in light of geopolitical events,
government policies increasing the difficulty of travel and limitations on issuing international travel visas.
We may be impacted by adverse changes in the perceived or actual economic climate, such as inflation, global
or regional recessions, higher unemployment and underemployment rates and declines in income levels.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We coordinate with law enforcement and intelligence agencies around the globe and endeavor to
identify security-related threats at sea and ashore
• We have communications programs to help mitigate the adverse impacts of publicity
• We have put in place various strategies and initiatives, including increasing our marketing and
advertising programs in efforts to drive incremental demand for cruising
• We have extended our demand planning and are placing purchase orders earlier to compensate for
current extended lead times for supplies
• We optimize itineraries through our itinerary planning reviews and have the ability to change
itineraries to increase demand and/or to reduce fuel consumption
Key stakeholders considered:
• Communities we serve
• Guests and travel agent partners
52
b.
Pandemics have in the past and may in the future have a significant negative impact on our financial
condition and operations..
Pandemics have in the past and may in the future have a significant negative impact on our financial
condition and operations. We could:
• be forced to re-implement a pause of our guest cruise operations
• be negatively impacted by travel advisories, restrictions, recommendations and regulations set by
various governmental authorities, which could impact our occupancy levels
• be subject to enhanced health and hygiene requirements in attempts to counteract future outbreaks,
and these requirements may be costly, take a significant amount of time to implement across our global
cruise operations and may result in disruptions in guest cruise operations, incremental costs and
loss of revenue
• be subject to negative publicity, along with the cruise industry, which could have a long-term impact
on the appeal of our cruises
• be subject to lawsuits, other governmental investigations and other actions
• reassess our ship deployment options and our fleet, which could lead to the removal of additional
ships from our fleet and may result in incremental ship impairment charges and losses on ship sales
• be negatively impacted as a result of the adverse impact on our partners, counterparties and joint
ventures
• be negatively impacted by the inability to attract and retain the loyalty of our guests and hire and
retain our crew
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We have insurance coverage for certain liabilities, costs and expenses related to COVID-19 through
our participation in Protection and Indemnity (“P&I”) clubs
• We report health, environmental, safety and security incidents and take appropriate action to reduce
the risk of recurrence
• We have taken significant operational actions to preserve cash, prioritize capital expenditures, reduce
interest rates and extend maturities to increase liquidity
Key stakeholders considered:
• Communities we serve
• Team members
• Guests and travel agent partners
• Investors
c.
Incidents concerning our ships, guests or the cruise industry have in the past and may, in the future,
negatively impact the satisfaction of our guests and crew and lead to reputational damage.
Our operations involve the risk of incidents and media coverage thereof. Such incidents include, but are not
limited to, the improper operation or maintenance of ships, motorcoaches and trains; guest and crew
illnesses; mechanical failures, fires and collisions; repair delays, groundings and navigational errors; oil spills
and other maritime and environmental issues as well as other incidents at sea, while in port or on land
which may generate negative publicity or cause guest and crew discomfort, injury, or death. Although our
commitment to the safety and comfort of our guests and crew is paramount to the success of our business, our
ships have been involved in outbreaks, accidents and other incidents in the past and we may experience
similar or other incidents in the future. Our ability to attract and retain the loyalty of our guests, our ability
to hire and the amounts we must pay our crew depend, in part, upon the perception and reputation of
our company and our brands and the public’s concerns regarding the health and safety of travel generally,
as well as the cruising industry and our ships specifically. In addition, these and any other events which impact
the travel industry more generally may negatively impact our guests’ and/or crew’s ability or desire to travel
to or from our ships and/or interrupt the supply of critical goods and services.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We provide training to team members related to their job responsibilities to ensure understanding of
and compliance with our policies and procedures
• We report health, environmental, safety and security incidents and take appropriate action to reduce
the risk of recurrence
Strategic Report
53
• We have appropriate policies that govern, encourage and reinforce the right behavior
• We have communications programs to help mitigate the adverse impacts of publicity
• We promote a culture that encourages team members to speak up about concerns and opportunities
which are addressed appropriately
Key stakeholders considered:
• Team members
• Guests and travel agent partners
d.
Changes in and non-compliance with laws and regulations under which we operate, such as those relating
to health, environment, safety and security, data privacy and protection, anti-corruption, economic sanctions,
trade protection, labor and employment, and tax have in the past and may, in the future, lead to litigation,
enforcement actions, fines, penalties and reputational damage.
We are subject to numerous international, national, state and local laws, regulations, treaties and other legal
requirements that govern health, environmental, safety and security matters in relation to our guests, crew
and ships. These requirements change regularly, depending on the itineraries of our ships and the ports and
countries visited. Implementing these and any subsequent requirements may be costly and take time to
implement across our global cruise operations. In addition, the accelerating pace of regulatory changes may
affect our ability to comply in the future. If we violate or fail to comply with any of these laws, regulations,
treaties and other requirements we could be, and have previously been, fined, placed on probation or otherwise
sanctioned by regulators. In addition, there is increased global focus on climate change, which may lead to
additional regulatory requirements. Refer to Operating Risk Factor “e.” below for additional discussion on
climate change regulation risks. We were subject to a court-ordered environmental compliance plan
supervised by the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, which was operative until
April 2022 and subjected our operations to additional review and other obligations.
We are subject to laws and requirements related to the treatment and protection of personal, sensitive
and/or other regulated data in the jurisdictions where we operate. Various governments, agencies and
regulatory organizations have enacted or are considering new rules and regulations and we expect to continue
to incur costs to comply with these rules and regulations. In the course of doing business, we collect guest,
team member, company and other third-party data, including personally identifiable information and other
sensitive data. We have incurred legal and other costs in connection with cyber incidents relating to such
sensitive data. Refer to Operating Risk Factor “g.”below for additional discussion of data security risks.
Our operations subject us to potential liability under anti-corruption laws and regulations. We may also be
affected by economic sanctions, trade protection laws, policies and other regulatory requirements affecting
trade and investment.
We are subject to compliance with tax laws, regulations and treaties in the jurisdictions in which we are
incorporated or operate. These tax laws, regulations and treaties are subject to change at any time, which
may result in substantially higher tax expense. For example, the Organization for Economic Co-operation and
Development (“OECD”) has proposed a multi-jurisdictional inclusive framework to address base erosion
and profit sharing that, if enacted by relevant jurisdictions, may result in increased tax expense.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We monitor for changes in laws and regulations and changes in interpretation of these laws and
regulations relating to our business. Where necessary, we obtain specialist advice to implement
programs to help ensure compliance
• We have appropriate policies and procedures that encourage and reinforce the right behavior
• We provide training to team members related to their job responsibilities to ensure understanding of
and compliance with our policies and procedures
• We have a system of internal controls to prevent and/or detect risks and we perform risk assessments,
audits and other evaluations of our control design and performance
• We monitor our own compliance and where incidents occur, take appropriate action, including
conducting investigations, to prevent recurrence
• We promote a culture that encourages team members to speak up about concerns and opportunities
which are addressed appropriately
54
Key stakeholders considered:
• Communities we serve
e.
Factors associated with climate change, including evolving and increasing regulations, increasing global
concern about climate change and the shift in climate conscious consumerism and stakeholder scrutiny, and
increasing frequency and/or severity of adverse weather conditions could adversely affect our business.
Growing concerns regarding climate change have resulted in increased global regulatory focus on GHG and
other emissions which may have material impacts on our business. For example, the EU’s Fit for 55
package, which includes recently agreed updates to the ETS relating to the need to acquire carbon emission
allowances for maritime shipping related emissions inside EU waters, proposed reforms to the EU’s ETD,
which imposes taxes on fuel purchased in the EU, as well as a new regulatory proposal, the FuelEU Maritime
initiative, which sets out a long-term framework to reduce emissions by increasing the use of sustainable
alternative fuels and shore power. In addition, the IMO is currently considering various other proposals which
aim to reduce emissions within the global shipping industry. If finalized and enacted, these regulations and
reforms may individually or collectively have a material impact on our operating costs and profitability.
Regulatory efforts, both internationally and in the U.S., are evolving, including the international alignment
of such efforts, and we cannot determine what final regulations will be enacted or their ultimate impact on our
business. Climate change-related regulatory activity and developments that require us to reduce our
emissions, which includes both the EU and IMO proposals discussed above, may adversely affect our
business and financial results by requiring us to make capital investments in new equipment or technologies,
pay for carbon emissions, purchase carbon offset credits, or otherwise incur additional costs or take
additional actions related to our emissions. Such activity may also impact us indirectly by increasing our
operating costs, including fuel costs. Regulatory developments may also result in the inability to operate ships
that do not meet certain standards, the acceleration of the removal of less fuel-efficient ships from our fleet
and impact the resale value of our ships in the future. In addition, regulatory developments may restrict or
limit our access to certain destinations and/or countries or curtail our freedom to operate.
Growing recognition among consumers globally of the negative effects of climate change and the impact of
GHG and other emissions may lead to material changes in consumer preferences. For instance, our guests
may choose a vacation option that they perceive as operating in a manner that is more sustainable for the
climate, seek alternative methods of travel, or reduce the amount and frequency of their travel. In addition,
some environmental focused groups have and may continue to generate negative publicity regarding the
environmental impact of the cruise industry and are advocating for more stringent regulation of ship
emissions while the ship is docked and at sea. Growing environmental scrutiny of our operations and the
industry from the investment community, other stakeholders, and the media have impacted and may continue
to impact how we are perceived, which may have a material impact on our operations and financial results.
Certain climate-related actions and investments we make today may not lead us to our intended future
emissions related goals or may not be favorably perceived in future years based on continuing evolving
regulations and perceptions around effective emissions mitigation strategies and technologies.
Our cruise ships, hotels, land tours, port and related commercial facilities and shore excursions have been
and may continue to be impacted by adverse weather patterns or other natural disasters, such as hurricanes,
earthquakes, floods, fires, tornadoes, tsunamis, typhoons and volcanic eruptions. Climate change is
expected to increase the frequency and intensity of certain adverse weather patterns, possibly making
certain destinations less desirable or impacting our business in other ways. We have been forced to, and in
the future may be forced to, alter itineraries or cancel a cruise or a series of cruises or tours due to these or
other types of disruptions. The physical climate-related risks to our business include increased hurricane/
typhoon intensity and frequency, increases in global temperatures and rising sea levels which may adversely
impact our shoreside facilities, our investments in ports or the availability or desirability of ports and
destinations in which we operate. These effects may also disrupt the supply of critical goods and services to
our facilities and ships. Any of these events could have a material impact on our business and profitability.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We continue to investigate alternative lower carbon fuel options and technology and invest in energy
efficiency improvements
• We monitor for changes in laws and regulations and changes in interpretation of these laws and
regulations relating to our business. Where necessary, we obtain specialist advice to implement
programs to help ensure compliance
• We provide training to team members related to their job responsibilities to ensure understanding of
and compliance with our policies and procedures
Strategic Report
55
• We monitor weather conditions and have the ability to change our ship itineraries to avoid adverse
weather or regions impacted by adverse weather or in preparation of or response to significant climate
change impacts to particular regions
• We partner with key organizations and stakeholders on research and development to support carbon
emissions reduction efforts
• We have a CCO who is responsible for the oversight of climate-related matters and an SRE Committee,
which consists of members of executive management and an advisor, that reports to the CEO, who
in turn, reports to the Boards of Directors
Key stakeholders considered:
• Communities we serve
• Guests and travel agent partners
• Investors
f.
Inability to meet or achieve our sustainability related goals, aspirations, initiatives, and our public
statements and disclosures regarding them, may expose us to risks that may adversely impact our business.
We have developed and will continue to establish goals, targets, aspirations, and other objectives
(“sustainability objectives”) related to sustainability matters. These statements reflect our current plans and
do not constitute a guarantee that they will be achieved. Our efforts to research, establish, accomplish,
and accurately report on these sustainability objectives expose us to numerous operational, reputational,
financial, legal, and other risks, any of which could have a negative impact on our business. Our ability to
achieve any of our stated sustainability objectives, particularly with respect to environmental emissions, is
subject to numerous factors and conditions, many of which are outside of our control. Examples of such
factors include the availability and costs of low- or non-carbon-based energy sources, evolving regulatory
requirements affecting sustainability standards or disclosures, the availability of future financing and the
availability of suppliers that can meet our sustainability standards.
Our business may face increased scrutiny from our guests, our team members, the investment community,
governments, regulators, destinations and other stakeholders that we serve related to our sustainability
activities, including the sustainability objectives that we adopt, our methodologies and timelines for pursuing
them and our ability to document and support the achievement of those objectives. If our sustainability
practices do not meet, or are perceived to fall short of, the expectations of our guests, team members, investors
or other stakeholders, demand for cruising, our reputation, our ability to attract or retain team members,
and our attractiveness as an investment could be negatively impacted. Similarly, our failure or perceived
failure to pursue or fulfill our sustainability objectives within the timelines we announce, or at all, could have
the same negative impacts as well as expose us to government enforcement actions and private litigation.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We continue to make investments in technology related to our sustainability initiatives
• We provide training to team members related to their job responsibilities to ensure understanding of
and compliance with our policies and procedures
• We incentivize meeting our sustainability goals through compensation
• We have HESS policies in place that govern our approach to sustainability
• We partner with key organizations and stakeholders on research and development to support carbon
emissions reduction efforts
• We promote a culture that encourages team members to speak up about concerns and opportunities
which are addressed appropriately
Key stakeholders considered:
• Communities we serve
• Guests and travel agent partners
• Investors
56
g.
Breaches in data security and lapses in data privacy as well as disruptions and other damages to our
principal offices, information technology operations and system networks and failure to keep pace with
developments in technology may adversely impact our business operations, the satisfaction of our guests
and crew and may lead to reputational damage.
We have been and may continue to be impacted by breaches in data security and lapses in data privacy,
which occur from time to time. These can vary in scope and intent from motivated driven attacks to malicious
attacks intended to disrupt or compromise our shoreside and shipboard operations by targeting our key
operating systems. Breach or circumvention of our systems or the systems of third parties, including by
ransomware or malware, through vulnerabilities in licensed software or hardware, or as a result of other
attacks, results in disruptions to our business operations; unauthorized access to (or the loss of company
access to) competitively sensitive, confidential or other critical data (including sensitive financial, medical
or other personal or business information) or systems; loss of customers; financial losses; regulatory
investigations, enforcement actions and fines; litigation and misuse or corruption of critical data and
proprietary information, any of which could be material.
We have been subject to past attacks which resulted in unauthorized access to systems and/or data and
regulatory investigations regarding such incidents. We have incurred legal, settlement and other costs in
connection with cyber incidents that have impacted us. While these incidents did not have a material adverse
effect on our business, operations or financial results, no assurances can be given about future incidents,
attacks and related litigation or regulatory investigations that could have such a material adverse effect.
Our principal offices, information technology operations, system networks and various remote work locations
may be impacted by actual or threatened natural disasters (for example, hurricanes, earthquakes, floods,
fires, tornadoes, tsunamis and typhoons) or other disruptive events. Our maritime and/or shoreside operations,
including our ability to manage our inventory of cabins held for sale and set pricing, control costs and
serve our guests, depends on the reliability of our information technology operations and system networks,
as well as our ability to refine and update to more advanced systems and technologies. In addition, we may be
unable to obtain appropriate technology in a timely manner or at all or we may incur significant costs in
doing so. A failure to adopt the appropriate technology, or a failure or obsolescence in the technology that
we do adopt, could have adverse effects on our business.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We have policies and procedures that govern data security, data privacy and disaster recovery
• We provide training to team members related to their job responsibilities to ensure understanding of
and compliance with our policies and procedures related to data security, data privacy and disaster
recovery
• We incorporate security and privacy-by-design in the development of new systems and infrastructure
• We actively, and will continue to, invest in cybersecurity, talent and third party service providers to
enhance our data security
• We monitor and test our own ability to detect and respond to an incident which could cause a
breach in data security, lapse in data privacy or natural disaster and where incidents occur, take
appropriate remedial action
• We continue to align our technology planning, infrastructure, security, data privacy and applications
to maximize the business value of our information technology investments
Key stakeholders considered:
• Team members
• Guests and travel agent partners
h.
The loss of key team members, our inability to recruit or retain qualified shoreside and shipboard team
members and increased labor costs could have an adverse effect on our business and results of operations.
Our success depends, in large part, on the skills and contributions of our team members, and on our ability
to recruit, develop and retain high quality, diverse team members. We may not be successful in recruiting,
developing or retaining key or other highly qualified team members. In addition, carbon-intensive industries
may become a less attractive employment opportunity. As a result of the reduction in our workforce
during our pause in guest cruise operations, general macroeconomic factors and an increasingly competitive
labor market, at times we may experience difficulty in hiring sufficient qualified team members. For
Strategic Report
57
example, there is particularly high competition for recruiting and retaining qualified team members needed
to support our information technology systems and infrastructure which is critical to our successful operations.
In addition, we hire a significant number of qualified shipboard team members each year and, thus, our
ability to adequately recruit, develop and retain these individuals is critical to our success. Incidents involving
cruise ships, including disease outbreaks on our ships and increasing demand as a result of the industry’s
projected growth could negatively impact our ability to recruit, develop and retain sufficient qualified
shipboard team members.
A prolonged shortage of qualified shoreside and shipboard team members and/or increased turnover rates
has in the past inhibited, and in the future could inhibit, our ability to operate our business in an optimal
manner. The competitive labor market is resulting in increased costs from the need to hire temporary
personnel and we are often required to increase wages and/or benefits in order to attract and retain team
members, all of which may negatively impact our results of operations. In connection with our resumption
of guest cruise operations, we have hired and intend to continue hiring a significant number of qualified team
members for the foreseeable future, and we expect to continue to face these challenges.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We have programs to attract, develop and retain top talent and use team member feedback tools to
monitor team members’ perspectives and take appropriate actions
• We provide training to continue the development of our team members related to their job
responsibilities and to ensure understanding of and compliance with our policies and procedures
• We provide total compensation that allows us to be competitive in the labor markets in which we
operate
• We continue to expand the number of countries from which we recruit our team members
• We promote a culture that encourages team members to speak up about concerns and opportunities
which are addressed appropriately
Key stakeholders considered:
• Team members
• Guests and travel agent partners
i.
Increases in fuel prices, changes in the types of fuel consumed and availability of fuel supply may adversely
impact our scheduled itineraries and costs.
We have been and may continue to be impacted, by economic, market and political conditions around the
world, such as fuel demand, regulatory requirements including climate-induced regulations, supply disruptions
and related infrastructure needs, which make it difficult to predict the future price and availability of fuel.
The supply and availability of different fuel types in various markets in which we operate have experienced
increased volatility and have led to increased fuel prices and reduced profitability. Future increases in the
global price of fuel would increase the cost of our cruise ship operations as well as some of our other
expenses, such as crew travel, freight and commodity prices. Increases in airfares, such as those resulting
from increases in the price of fuel, would increase our guests’ overall vacation costs and could reduce demand
for cruises, as many of our guests depend on airlines to transport them to or from the airports near the
ports where our cruises embark and disembark.
Many of our vessels have exhaust gas cleaning systems that allow them to operate on high sulfur fuel oil
that is less expensive than low sulfur fuel; however, the significant drop in demand for higher sulfur fuel
directly related to the pause in guest cruise operations has made it more difficult to source going forward
which may result in higher operating costs. Additionally, certain of our ships are designed to use LNG as their
primary fuel source. The price of LNG in certain markets has been and may continue to be unattractive
compared to other alternatives, and as such, at times we have used and may continue to use conventional fuels
to power our LNG ships. Refer to Operating Risk Factor “e.”for additional discussion on the impact of
climate change and regulation changes on fuel costs.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We manage fuel consumption through ship maintenance practices
• We optimize itineraries through our itinerary planning reviews and have the ability to change
itineraries to reduce fuel consumption
• We research and implement innovative technologies to reduce fuel consumption
58
• We are adding new, more fuel-efficient ships to our fleet and have removed smaller, less fuel-efficient
ships
• We enter into supply agreements to help ensure availability and seek alternative sources if necessary
• We are upgrading our fleet with more energy efficient technologies
• Our LNG ships are all dual fuel and can burn MGO
• We have the ability to purchase fuel in different ports we visit
Key stakeholders considered:
• Communities we serve
• Guests and travel agent partners
j.
We rely on supply chain vendors who are integral to the operations of our businesses. These vendors and
service providers are also affected by COVID-19 and may be unable to deliver on their commitments which
could negatively impact our business.
We rely on supply chain vendors to deliver key products to the operations of our businesses around the
world. Any event impacting a vendor’s ability to deliver quality goods at the location and time needed could
negatively impact our ability to operate our business. Events impacting our supply chain could be caused
by factors beyond the control of our suppliers or us, including labor actions, increased demand, problems in
production or distribution and/or disruptions in third-party logistics, information technology or
transportation systems. In addition, the effects from COVID-19 and other global events have resulted in
widespread global supply chain disruptions to vendors including critical supply chain shortages, labor
shortages, significant material cost inflation and extended lead times for items that are required for our
operations. Any such interruptions to our supply chain could increase our costs and could limit the availability
of products critical to our operations.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We enter into supply agreements to help ensure availability and seek alternative sources if necessary
• We have extended our demand planning and are placing purchase orders earlier to compensate for
current extended lead times
• We utilize substitute products where appropriate
• We leverage corporate contracts and our supplier relationships
• We source locally to mitigate logistics costs and delays
• We utilize short-term or long-term contracts as needed
Key stakeholders considered:
• Team members
• Guests and travel agent partners
k.
Fluctuations in foreign currency exchange rates may adversely impact our financial results.
We earn revenues, pay expenses, purchase and own assets and incur liabilities in currencies other than the
U.S. dollar. Additionally, our shipbuilding contracts are typically denominated in euros. Movements in foreign
currency exchange rates, which have recently been more volatile, will affect our financial results.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We net certain exposures to take advantage of natural offsets with our business and continuously
evaluate the use of financial instruments
• We consider and may hedge certain of our ship commitments and net investments in foreign
operations
• We sell/buy foreign currencies throughout the year to manage the economic impact of foreign
currency exchange volatility
• We adjust our procurement activities
Key stakeholders considered:
• Investors
Strategic Report
59
l.
Overcapacity and competition in the cruise and land-based vacation industry may negatively impact our
cruise sales, pricing and destination options.
We may be impacted by increases in capacity in the cruise and land-based vacation industry, which may
result in capacity growth beyond demand, either globally or for a region, or for a particular itinerary. For
example, Asia, specifically China, remains closed to the cruise industry and it is uncertain when or if we will
resume operations in the region. As a result, we along with other cruise operators, have had to find itineraries
in alternative regions for the ships that were previously serving the Asia market, which could lead to
overcapacity in other regions. We face competition from other cruise brands on the basis of overall experience,
destinations, types and sizes of ships and cabins, travel agent partner preferences and value. We also
compete with land-based vacation alternatives throughout the world on the basis of overall experience,
destinations and value. In addition, certain ports and destinations have faced a surge of both cruise and non-
cruise tourism and in certain destinations, countermeasures to limit the number of tourists have been
contemplated and/or put into effect, including proposed limits on cruise ships and cruise passengers. Potential
restrictions in ports and destinations could limit the itinerary and destination options we can offer our
passengers going forward.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We have the ability to change our itineraries to alternative regions of the world
• We offer a wide variety of brands, itineraries, products and services to our guests
• We work alongside government and local regulators to ensure compliance with limitations placed on
tourism
Key stakeholders considered:
• Communities we serve
• Guests and travel agent partners
m.
Inability to implement our shipbuilding programs and ship repairs, maintenance and refurbishments may
adversely impact our business operations and the satisfaction of our guests.
We may be impacted by unforeseen events, such as work stoppages, supply chain issues, insolvencies, “force
majeure”events or other financial difficulties experienced by shipyards, their subcontractors and our
suppliers. This may result in less shipyard availability resulting in delays or preventing the delivery of our
ships under construction and/or the completion of the repair, maintenance or refurbishment of our existing
ships. This may lead to potential delays or cancellations of cruises. In addition, the prices of various
commodities that are used in the construction of ships and for repair, maintenance and refurbishment of
existing ships, such as steel, are subject to volatility which may increase our costs.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• Our newbuild contracts are fixed price and are not sensitive to cost fluctuations of materials,
including steel
• We ensure access and priority for ship repairs as part owners and part of the governance teams of
two shipyards
• We require shipyards to obtain insurance
• Our shipbuilding contracts include a combination of refund and performance guarantees
• Pricing for ship repair yards, subcontractors and required materials are agreed in advance of
scheduled dry-docks
Key stakeholders considered:
• Guests and travel agent partners
• Investors
Debt Related Risk Factors
a.
Failure to successfully implement our business strategy following our resumption of guest cruise operations
would negatively impact the occupancy levels and pricing of our cruises and could have a material
adverse effect on our business. We require a significant amount of cash to service our debt and sustain our
operations. Our ability to generate cash depends on many factors, including those beyond our control,
and we may not be able to generate cash required to service our debt and sustain our operations.
Our ability to meet our debt service obligations, refinance our debt or sustain our business needs and
operations depends on our future operating and financial performance and our ability to generate cash.
60
This will be affected by our ability to successfully implement our business strategy, which if unsuccessful,
would negatively impact the occupancy levels and pricing of our cruises, as well as general macroeconomic,
financial, geopolitical, competitive, regulatory and other factors beyond our control, such as the disruption
caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, the invasion of Ukraine, inflation, higher fuel prices and higher interest
rates. If we cannot generate sufficient cash to meet our debt service obligations or fund our other business
needs, we may, among other things, need to refinance all or a portion of our debt, obtain additional financing,
delay planned capital expenditures or sell assets. We cannot make assurances that we will be able to
generate sufficient cash through any of the foregoing. If we are not able to refinance any of our debt,
obtain additional financing or sell assets on commercially reasonable terms or at all, we may not be able to
satisfy our obligations with respect to our debt. Refer to “Liquidity, Financial Condition and Capital
Resources”.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We have put in place various strategies and initiatives, including increasing our marketing and
advertising programs in efforts to drive incremental demand for cruising
• We have taken significant operational actions to preserve cash, prioritize capital expenditures, reduce
interest rates and extend maturities to increase liquidity
• We have suspended the payment of dividends on, and the repurchase of, Carnival Corporation
common stock and Carnival plc ordinary shares, except pursuant to the Stock Swap Program
• We have obtained and will continue to request, if necessary, waivers and amendments for certain
covenants for our export credit facilities, loans and the Revolving Facility
Key stakeholders considered:
• Investors
b.
Our substantial debt could adversely affect our financial health and operating flexibility.
We have a substantial amount of debt and significant debt service obligations. Our substantial debt has had
and could continue to have important negative consequences for us. Our substantial debt could:
• require us to dedicate a large portion of our cash flow from operations to service debt and fund
repayments on our debt, thereby reducing the availability of our cash flow to fund working capital,
capital expenditures and other general corporate purposes;
• increase our vulnerability to adverse general economic or industry conditions;
• limit our flexibility in planning for, or reacting to, changes in our business or the industry in which
we operate;
• place us at a disadvantage compared to others that have less debt;
• make us more vulnerable to downturns in our business, the economy or the industry in which we
operate;
• limit our ability to raise additional debt or equity capital in the future to satisfy our requirements
relating to working capital, capital expenditures, development projects, strategic initiatives or other
purposes;
• restrict us from making strategic acquisitions, introducing new technologies or exploiting business
opportunities;
• make it difficult for us to satisfy our obligations with respect to our debt; and
• expose us to the risk of increased interest rates as certain of our borrowings are (and may be in the
future) at a variable rate of interest.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We have taken significant operational actions to preserve cash, prioritize capital expenditures, reduce
interest rates and extend maturities to increase liquidity
• We have obtained additional capital through various equity offerings
Key stakeholders considered:
• Investors
c.
Despite our leverage, we may incur more debt, subject to certain restrictions, which could adversely affect
our business and prevent us from fulfilling our obligations with respect to our debt.
We may incur additional debt in the future. Although the instruments governing our existing indebtedness
contain restrictions on the incurrence of additional debt, including certain additional restrictions which went
Strategic Report
61
into effect in 2023, these restrictions are subject to a number of significant qualifications and exceptions,
and under certain circumstances, the amount of debt that could be incurred in compliance with these
restrictions could be substantial and a portion of such debt currently is, and may in the future be, secured. The
instruments governing our existing indebtedness do not prevent us from incurring liabilities that do not
constitute “Indebtedness”as defined therein. If new debt is added to our existing debt levels, our business
could be adversely affected, which may prevent us from fulfilling our obligations with respect to our debt.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We have taken significant operational actions to preserve cash, prioritize capital expenditures, reduce
interest rates and extend maturities to increase liquidity
• We have obtained additional capital through various equity offerings
Key stakeholders considered:
• Investors
d.
We are subject to maintenance covenants, as well as restrictive debt covenants, that may limit our ability
to finance future operations and capital needs and pursue business opportunities and activities. We are also
subject to financial covenants that could lead to an acceleration of the indebtedness of our debt facilities
if we fail to comply. If we fail to comply with any of these covenants, it could have a material adverse effect
on our business.
Certain of our debt instruments limit our flexibility in operating our business. For example, some of our
debt instruments limit the ability of Carnival Corporation, Carnival plc and certain of their respective
subsidiaries to, among other things:
• incur or guarantee additional indebtedness;
• pay dividends or distributions on or redeem or repurchase capital stock and make other restricted
payments;
• make certain investments;
• consummate certain asset sales;
• engage in certain transactions with affiliates;
• grant or assume certain liens; and
• consolidate, merge or transfer all or substantially all of our assets.
All of these limitations are subject to significant exceptions and qualifications. Despite these exceptions and
qualifications, we cannot provide assurance that the operating and financial restrictions and covenants in
certain of our debt instruments will not adversely affect our ability to finance our future operations or capital
needs or engage in other business activities that may be in our interest. Any future indebtedness may
include similar or other restrictive terms.
In addition, many of our debt agreements contain one or more financial covenants that require us to
maintain a minimum liquidity, interest coverage, and shareholders’equity and/or limit our debt to
capital percentage. Our ability to comply with our debt covenants, including the financial maintenance
covenants described above, and restrictions may be affected by events beyond our control, including global
macroeconomic, financial and industry conditions, such as the continued resumption of our guest cruise
operations and our ability to issue additional equity. If we breach any of these covenants or restrictions
and are not able to receive waivers for these covenants, we could be in default under the terms of certain of
our debt facilities and the relevant lenders would have the right to declare the debt, together with accrued and
unpaid interest and other fees, if any, immediately due and payable (or cancel any unfunded commitments,
if applicable) and proceed against any collateral, if any, securing that debt. If the debt under certain of our
debt instruments that we enter into were to be accelerated, our assets may be insufficient to repay our debt
in full. Borrowings under other debt instruments that contain cross-default provisions may also be accelerated
or become payable on demand. In these circumstances, our assets may not be sufficient to repay our
indebtedness then outstanding in full.
At November 30, 2022, we were in compliance with the applicable covenants under our debt agreements.
However, we cannot provide assurance that we will be able to maintain compliance with such debt facilities
as of future testing dates. Failure to comply with the financial covenants of our debt facilities would have a
material adverse effect as described above. Refer to Note 15 — Debt and Interest Expense for additional
information.
62
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We have taken significant operational actions to preserve cash, prioritize capital expenditures, reduce
interest rates and extend maturities to increase liquidity
• We have suspended the payment of dividends on, and the repurchase of, Carnival Corporation
common stock and Carnival plc ordinary shares, except pursuant to the Stock Swap Program
• We have obtained and will continue to request, if necessary, waivers and amendments for certain
covenants on certain export credit facilities, loans and the Revolving Facility
Key stakeholders considered:
• Investors
e.
Our variable rate indebtedness exposes us to interest rate volatility, which could cause our debt service
obligations to increase significantly.
Borrowings under certain of our facilities are at variable rates of interest and expose us to interest rate
volatility. As interest rates increase, our debt service obligations on certain of our variable rate indebtedness
will increase even though the amount borrowed remains the same, and our net income and cash flows,
including cash available for servicing our indebtedness, will correspondingly decrease.
At the end of 2021, the ICE Benchmark Administration, the administrator for London Interbank Offered
Rate (“LIBOR”), ceased publishing one-week and two-month U.S. dollar LIBOR and will cease publishing
all remaining U.S. dollar LIBOR tenors in mid-2023. Concurrently, the United Kingdom’s Financial
Conduct Authority announced the cessation or loss of representativeness of the U.S. dollar LIBOR tenors
from those dates. The U.S. Federal Reserve, in conjunction with the Alternative Reference Rates Committee,
a steering committee comprised of, among other entities, large U.S. financial institutions, has recommended
replacing U.S. dollar LIBOR with a new index that measures the cost of borrowing cash overnight,
backed by U.S. Treasury securities (“SOFR”). SOFR is observed and backward-looking, which stands in
contrast with LIBOR, which is an estimated forward-looking rate and relies, to some degree, on the expert
judgment of submitting panel members. While we continue to monitor market developments to assess
replacement rate options, the consequences of these developments with respect to LIBOR cannot be entirely
predicted and may result in the level of interest payments on the portion of our indebtedness that bears
interest at variable rates to be affected, which may adversely impact the amount of our interest payments
under such debt.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We have taken significant operational actions to preserve cash, prioritize capital expenditures, reduce
interest rates and extend maturities to increase liquidity
• We have obtained and will continue to request, if necessary, waivers and amendments for certain
covenants for our export credit facilities, loans and the Revolving Facility
• We take advantage of natural offsets with our business and continuously evaluate the use of financial
instruments
Key stakeholders considered:
• Investors
f.
The covenants in certain of our export credit facilities may require us to secure those facilities in the
future.
Our export credit facilities contain provisions which may require that we provide a security interest in
certain assets and in particular the relevant vessels that are the subject matter of those financings (or a
comparable vessel). In certain of our export credit facilities, there is a requirement that if the credit rating of
our senior indebtedness falls below investment grade (which occurred on June 24, 2020 and remained the
case as of November 30, 2022) and at such time we have granted liens or security interests in respect of
indebtedness exceeding 25% of our total assets (excluding for these purposes the value of any intangible
assets) as shown in our most recent Consolidated Balance Sheet, we will be required to provide a first-
priority security interest in the relevant vessel that is the subject matter of that export credit facility (or a
comparable vessel). In addition, under all our export credit facilities, there is also a requirement that if a
security interest or lien is granted in respect of a vessel to secure borrowed money under any other export
credit facility, then a first-priority security interest may be required to be provided over the relevant vessel
which is the subject matter of that export credit facility (or a comparable vessel).
Strategic Report
63
If the events described above were to occur, we may be unable to comply with this requirement and would
expect to seek covenant amendments from the lenders under the relevant facilities. Any such amendment may
lead to increased costs, increased interest rates, additional restrictive covenants and other available lender
protections that would be applicable to us under these debt facilities, and such increased costs, restrictions and
modifications may vary among debt facilities. Our ability to give additional lender protections under these
facilities, including the granting of security interests in collateral, will be limited by the restrictions in our
indebtedness and security interest we have already granted. If we were not able to obtain amendments, the
occurrence of such events may result in an event of default under these facilities and other debt facilities that
contain cross default provisions that would be triggered.
Examples of how we manage and/or mitigate this risk:
• We have obtained and will continue to request, if necessary, waivers and amendments for certain
covenants for our export credit facilities, loans and the Revolving Facility
• We constantly monitor the covenants for compliance
Key stakeholders considered:
• Investors
5.
Going Concern Confirmation and Viability Statement.
The Boards of Directors consider that, within the DLC arrangement, the most appropriate presentation of
Carnival plc’s going concern and viability is by reference to the consolidated liquidity position of Carnival
Corporation & plc. Accordingly, this going concern confirmation and viability statement presents Carnival
Corporation & plc.
Going Concern Assessment
The Boards of Directors have assessed the prospects of Carnival Corporation & plc over an assessment
period of at least the next twelve months from the date of approval of the financial statements as required
by the UK Corporate Governance Code.
Carnival Corporation & plc has a substantial debt balance as a result of the pause in guest cruise operations
and requires a significant amount of liquidity or cash provided by operating activities to service its debt.
In addition, the continued effects of the pandemic, inflation, higher fuel prices, higher interest rates and
fluctuations in foreign currency rates are collectively having a material negative impact on its financial results.
The full extent of the collective impact of these items is uncertain and may be amplified by its substantial
debt balance.
Over the past almost three years, and in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, management and the Directors
have taken appropriate actions to manage Carnival Corporation & plc’s liquidity, including completing various
capital market transactions, obtaining relevant financial covenant amendments or waivers, accelerating the
removal of certain ships from the fleet and during the pause in guest cruise operations, reducing capital
expenditures and operating expenses. In addition, based on the evolving nature of COVID-19 and ongoing
collaboration with local and national public health authorities, Carnival Corporation & plc has responsibly
relaxed its related protocols, including greatly reducing or eliminating testing requirements and vaccination
protocols to more closely align with the broader travel industry and strengthening its competitiveness. As of
November 30, 2022, 97% of Carnival Corporation & plc’s capacity had resumed guest cruise operations
and is serving guests.
In performing their going concern assessment, the Boards of Directors have considered the circumstances
likely to impact Carnival Corporation & plc during the coming year, current liquidity, projected compliance
with financial covenants (refer to Note 15 — Debt and Interest Expense for additional details on covenant
compliance) and estimates of future liquidity. The Directors have considered the following assumptions used
to estimate Carnival Corporation & plc’s future liquidity:
• Its continued cruise operations and expected timing of cash collections for cruise bookings
• Expected increases in revenue in 2023 on a per passenger basis compared to 2019, particularly with
the responsible relaxation of COVID-19 related protocols aligning towards land-based vacation
alternatives
• Expected improvement in occupancy on a year-over-year basis returning to historical levels in the
summer of 2023
64
• Stabilization of fuel prices around November 2022 year-end prices
• Continued stabilization of inflationary pressures on costs, moderated by a larger-more efficient fleet
as compared to 2019.
In addition, the Directors make certain assumptions about new ship deliveries, improvements and removals,
and consider the future export credit financings that are associated with the new ship deliveries.
The Directors do not consider going concern to be a critical accounting judgement for the year ended
November 30, 2022. In determining that going concern is not a critical accounting judgement, the Directors
have considered:
• $8.6 billion of liquidity including cash, restricted cash from the 2028 Senior Priority Notes which
became unrestricted in December 2022 and borrowings available under its $1.7 billion, €1.0 billion and
£0.2 billion multi-currency revolving credit facility (the “Revolving Facility”) at November 30, 2022
• Known financial commitments, debt maturities and other cash requirements and obligations over
the assessment period.
Management has considered a severe but plausible scenario which assessed the effects of lower pricing,
resulting in lower expected revenues and adjusted EBITDA, as compared to the base case. In this downside
case, management modeled a 3% decrease in pricing during the period under review as compared to the
base case. In addition, management has performed further downside scenarios including assuming a scenario
which they have concluded is well beyond severe but plausible of break even adjusted EBITDA for 2023.
Even in these scenarios, the assessment still demonstrated Carnival Corporation & plc’s ability to meet its
obligations over the going concern period and remain in compliance with its financial covenants. As a result
of this assessment, management along with the Boards of Directors have concluded that it remains
appropriate to adopt the going concern basis of accounting in preparing the Carnival plc consolidated
financial statements without any material uncertainty.
Going Concern Statement
In adopting the going concern basis for preparing these financial statements, the Directors have considered
Carnival Corporation & plc’s business activities, together with factors likely to affect its future development
and performance. After reviewing the current liquidity position, financial forecasts, and considering the
results of various downside scenarios, the Boards of Directors have concluded that Carnival Corporation &
plc has sufficient liquidity to satisfy its obligations and are forecasted to be in compliance with its debt
covenants for at least the next twelve months from the approval of the financial statements. Accordingly, the
Directors continue to adopt the going concern basis without any material uncertainty in preparing the
Carnival plc consolidated IFRS financial statements.
Viability Assessment
Whilst the Boards of Directors have no reason to believe Carnival Corporation & plc will not be viable over
a longer period, the period over which they considered viability is three years. The principal reasons why
this period was selected are as follows:
• It aligns with management’s typical strategic planning cycle
• Management typically plans its guest sourcing and ship itinerary strategies over a two-to-three-year
horizon
In performing their viability assessment, the Boards of Directors have considered the circumstances
impacting Carnival Corporation & plc during the year, current liquidity and projected compliance with
financial covenants. In addition, the Directors considered Carnival Corporation & plc’s access to capital
markets and expected ability to obtain financial covenant amendments or waivers (when or if needed) as well
as the continued expected improvement of its financial results.
In performing their assessments, the Boards of Directors highlighted forecast uncertainty during the
viability period. Uncertainty exists over future forecasts caused by the continued effects of the pandemic,
inflation, higher fuel prices, higher interest rates and fluctuations in foreign currency. These items may be
further amplified by Carnival Corporation & plc’s substantial debt balance. Given the significant collective
impacts of these items on the business, management has prepared various planning scenarios using a
range of potential outcomes and assumptions.
Strategic Report
65
Management has identified the following critical assumptions and judgements as part of its viability
assessment (“base case”):
• Ability to obtain additional financial covenant waivers or amendments, when or if needed. We are
currently seeking further letter agreements to waive compliance with the Interest Coverage Covenant
for the May 31, 2024 testing date. Refer to Note 15 — Debt and Interest Expense for additional
details on covenant compliance.
• Ability to pursue various opportunities to raise additional capital. Actions to raise capital may
include issuances of debt, convertible debt or equity in private or public transactions or entering into
new and extended credit facilities
• Continued estimated improvement in its financial results
The base case also includes the following other assumptions used to estimate future liquidity:
• Its continued cruise operations and expected timing of cash collections for cruise bookings
• Expected increases in revenue in 2023 on a per passenger basis compared to 2019, particularly with
the responsible relaxation of COVID-19 related protocols aligning towards land-based vacation
alternatives
• Expected improvement in occupancy on a year-over-year basis returning to historical levels in the
summer of 2023
• Stabilization of fuel prices around November 2022 year-end prices
• Continued stabilization of inflationary pressures on costs, moderated by a larger-more efficient fleet
as compared to 2019
• Anticipated direct and indirect impacts of climate change including costs associated with upcoming
regulations, which management does not expect to have a material impact on liquidity during the
viability assessment period
In addition, the Directors make certain assumptions about new ship deliveries, improvements and removals
and consider the future export credit financings that are associated with the new ship deliveries.
As part of their viability assessment, management along with the Boards of Directors, considered various
scenarios and sensitivity analyses. As a severe but plausible scenario, they considered the effects of lower
pricing, resulting in lower expected revenues and adjusted EBITDA, as compared to the base case. In this
downside case, management modeled a 3% decrease in pricing during the viability period as compared to
the base case. Management also considered various other scenarios, the principal risks identified in Item 4.
Risk Management and/or Mitigation of Principal and Emerging Risks and the impact on liquidity and
covenant headroom. In addition to these scenarios, while making their final conclusion on viability, which
is summarized below, the Boards of Directors considered its $8.6 billion of liquidity including cash, restricted
cash from the 2028 Senior Priority Notes which became unrestricted in December 2022 and borrowings
available under its $1.7 billion, €1.0 billion and £0.2 billion multi-currency Revolving Facility at November 30,
2022.
Viability Statement
Having undertaken their robust assessment as described above, including a review of their principal risks,
risk appetite and how these risks are managed or mitigated, the Boards of Directors have a reasonable
expectation that Carnival Corporation & plc will be able to continue in operation and meet its liabilities as
they fall due over the three-year period of their assessment. In making this statement, the Boards of
Directors highlight forecasting uncertainty concerning the impact of the continued effects of the pandemic,
inflation, higher fuel prices, higher interest rates and fluctuations in foreign currency rates in the three-year
plan. The full extent of the collective impact of these items is uncertain and may be amplified by Carnival
Corporation & plc’s substantial debt balance.
In addition, the Directors have identified the critical accounting assumptions and judgements they have
exercised in performing their assessment. The Boards of Directors have considered that management expects
to obtain additional financial covenant waivers or amendments, if needed, have access to additional capital
to maintain its target level of minimum liquidity through the measurement period ending January 28, 2026
and continued improvement in its financial results.
The Boards of Directors believes they have made reasonable estimates, assumptions and judgements in
determining its liquidity requirements and cannot make assurances that assumptions used may not change
66
in future periods. Refer to “Carnival Corporation & plc’s Liquidity, Financial Condition and Capital
Resources” Section for further discussion.
6.
Non-Financial Information Statement.
Refer to the sections below for more information relating to non-financial matters, as required by
sections 414CA and 414CB of the Companies Act 2006.
Description of Business Model:
• II. Mission (Purpose), Vision, Values and Priorities on page 2
• C. Our Global Cruise Business on page 5
Environmental Matters:
• XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact on page 13 which includes:
• Sustainability goals progress
• Summary of our environmental impact
• Climate-related Financial Disclosures
• Annex A — Carnival plc Directors’ Report of the Proxy Statement: Corporate and Social
Responsibility on page A-7
Team members:
• XII. Human Capital Management and Employees on page 11
• XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact: 2030 Diversity, Equity and Inclusion goals on page 16
• Annex C — Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report of the Proxy Statement: Workforce
Engagement on page C-15
Human Rights:
• II. Mission (Purpose), Vision, Values and Priorities on page 2
• XIV. Ethics and Compliance on page 13
• XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact: 2030 Good Health and Well-Being Goals on page 15
• Annex A — Carnival plc Directors’ Report of the Proxy Statement: Corporate and Social
Responsibility on page A-7
Anti-corruption and Anti-bribery:
• XIX. Governmental Regulations on page 31
• H. Executive Officers and Corporate Governance on page 40
• Item 4. Risk Management and/or Mitigation of Principal and Emerging Risks on page 52
• Annex C — Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report of the Proxy Statement: Hotline for
reporting concerns on page C-19
Social and Community Matters:
• II. Mission (Purpose), Vision, Values and Priorities on page 2
• XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact: 2030 Sustainable Tourism Goals on page 15
• XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact: 2030 Biodiversity and Conservation Goals on page 16
• Annex A — Carnival plc Directors’ Report of the Proxy Statement: Corporate and Social
Responsibility on page A-7
Policy Embedding, Due Diligence and Outcomes:
• Item 3. Internal Controls and Risk Assessment on page 50
• Item 5. Going Concern Confirmation and Viability Statement on page 64
• Annex C — Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report of the Proxy Statement: Committees of the
Board on Page C-5
Principal Risks and Impact of Business Activity:
• Item 4. Risk Management and/or Mitigation of Principal and Emerging Risks on page 52
Strategic Report
67
Non-Financial Key Performance Indicators:
• XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact: Summary of our Environmental Impact on page 19
• Item 2. Business Review Carnival plc Group IFRS Key Measures on page 44
7.
Section 172(1) Statement.
This statement describes how the Directors have performed their duty in the way they consider, in good
faith, would most likely promote the success of the company for the benefit of its members as a whole having
regard to the stakeholders and matters set out in section 172(1)(a)-(f) of the Companies Act 2006. This
statement sets out the Directors’approach to decision-making, its stakeholder engagement and details the
matters considered as part of the decision-making process of some of the key decisions made during 2022. To
provide further insight, we have provided clear cross-referencing to where more detailed information can
be found in this Annual Report.
Discussions between management and the Directors regarding decisions relating to our business strategy,
including the potential impact of those decisions on our financial results, decisions relating to our capital
structure and other business-related activities also include careful consideration of potential risks associated
with those decisions. In addition, as part of our risk assessment framework, our key stakeholders are
considered as part of the evaluation of our principal and emerging risks. Refer to Item 4. Risk Management
and/or Mitigation of Principal and Emerging Risks on page 52 for additional discussion of our risks and
key stakeholder considerations.
During 2022, the Directors’oversight of stakeholder relationships and other matters was informed by
regular briefings by management and its Committees on our liquidity, resumption of guest cruise operations
for each of our nine brands, compliance with laws and regulations, our ESG performance, principal and
emerging risks including those related to climate change and other critical matters.
Key Stakeholders
The Directors and their Committees recognize the strategic importance of building and maintaining strong
relationships with our stakeholders. We have identified the following key stakeholders considering their
impact on the success of our business model and strategy:
• Communities we serve
• Team members
• Guests and travel agent partners
• Investors
When making decisions, the Directors have regard to the interests of our key stakeholders and recognize
that effective engagement with our stakeholders is essential to the long-term success of our business. The
Directors consider many factors and balance competing interests in reaching strategic decisions. Refer to the
Key Decisions Made by the Directors During the Year on page 71 for examples of the Directors
considerations.
While the Directors are able to engage directly with key stakeholders on some issues, the size and distribution
of our stakeholder group means that stakeholder engagement often happens through management. The
Directors regularly receive information and feedback from management to help understand how our
operations and decisions affect our stakeholders’interests and in turn, how those interests should impact
future decisions.
a) the likely consequences of any decision in the long-term
The Directors recognize that the decisions made today will have an effect on both our short- and long-term
success. The Directors seek to balance meeting the more critical short-term objectives while also carefully
ensuring we are on course to achieve our long-term strategic vision. During 2022, the Directors and executive
management had particular regard to our long-term success and remained focused on resuming operations
as quickly as practical for each of our nine brands, while at the same time demonstrating prudent stewardship
of capital. The Directors believe that resuming operations and returning to profitability will help preserve
and grow value for each of our key stakeholders.
The Directors also believe that planning for succession is an important function that will impact our
long-term success. We continually strive to foster the professional development of management and team
68
members in other critical roles. As a result, we have developed a very experienced and strong group of
leaders, with their performance subject to ongoing monitoring and evaluation, as potential successors to all
of our executive positions, including our CEO. In August 2022 the Directors appointed Josh Weinstein,
previously our Chief Operations Officer, to the role of President, CEO and Chief Climate Officer. Josh
Weinstein is a 20-year veteran of our company with a long history of success in critical senior-level roles for
our company.
Refer to:
• 2022 Executive Overview on page 1
• XII. Human Capital Management and Employees on page 11
• XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact on page 13
• Item 5. Going Concern Confirmation and Viability Statement on page 64
• Key Decisions Made by the Directors During the Year on page 71
b) the interests of our team members
We celebrate our diverse team and are committed to providing a welcoming and inclusive environment
where people from different backgrounds, experiences and walks of life can succeed. We care deeply for our
team members and must always cultivate an atmosphere of openness, respect and trust. We continue to
focus on our Culture Essentials, which are the key actions and behaviors we encourage and reinforce to further
strengthen our culture. We have pulse surveys, which we use to track company culture, measure change
over time and obtain team member feedback. The results of the surveys are communicated to management
and the Directors. Further, in 2022 with the full support of the Directors, we continued our initiatives
designed to engage with and care for our workforce. Key areas of focus include Outreach & Wellness, Culture
and Staffing. The Directors consider and assess the implications of their decisions on our people.
Refer to:
• II. Mission (Purpose), Vision, Values and Priorities on page 2
• XII. Human Capital Management and Employees on page 11
• XIV. Ethics and Compliance on page 13
• Workforce Engagement in Annex C — Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report of the Proxy
Statement on page C-15
• Key Decisions Made by the Directors During the Year on page 71
c) the need to foster our business relationships with guests and travel agent partners, suppliers and others
Guests and Travel Agent Partners
Guest feedback and research supports the development of our overall strategies to exceed our guests’
expectations and at the same time, drive demand for cruises and increase the number of first-time cruisers.
We measure and evaluate guest satisfaction with our products and services through our net promoter scores
(“NPS”), which provides valuable insight into our guests’cruise experiences and drivers of guest loyalty.
Our NPS take into account a number of products and services our brands offer including; embarkation and
disembarkation experiences, shipboard team member service, dining options, entertainment and onboard
activities. NPS reflects the likelihood that our guests will recommend our brands’ cruise products and services
to friends and family, including those who have not cruised before. Evaluating our NPS allows our
management to make important strategic business decisions. To reward loyal and repeat guests, substantially
all of our cruise brands offer past recognition programs with various special incentives.
Strong relationships with our travel agent partners are also an integral part of our long-term cruise
distribution network and are critical to our success. We utilize local sales teams to motivate travel agents to
support our products and services with competitive pricing, promotional policies and joint marketing and
advertising programs. All of our brands have internet booking engines to allow travel agents to book our
cruises.
Suppliers
Our relationships with suppliers are key to our business as these critical goods and services are paramount
in our ability to deliver exceptional cruise experiences to our guests. Our suppliers provide a range of goods
from materials to support the refurbishment and enhancements of our ships and to build new and
Strategic Report
69
innovative ships to the reliable and consistent supply of fuel and food and beverage globally. We aim to
engage with suppliers to build mutually beneficial relationships and to create strategic partnerships across
our global organization.
Global supply markets and supply chains have been impacted by certain events, resulting in shortages,
extended lead times and increased inflation impacting our operations and profitability. We have leveraged
our business relationships with our suppliers, where possible, to mitigate the impact of these challenges on our
operations while still fulfilling our mission of creating happiness by delivering unforgettable and much
needed vacations to our guests.
Others
Our ships and operations are subject to numerous international, national, state and local laws, regulations,
treaties and other legal requirements, as well as voluntary agreements, which govern health, environmental,
safety and security matters in relation to our guests, crew and ships. We are committed to complying with
all relevant requirements.
We continue to work closely with governments and regulators, including those of the communities we serve,
as we resume guest cruise operations. We maintain our commitment to seek excellence in compliance,
environmental protection and in looking after the safety, health and well-being of every life we touch.
Refer to:
• II. Mission (Purpose), Vision, Values and Priorities on page 2
• X. Marketing Activities on page 10
• XI. Sales Channels on page 11
• XVII. Supply Chain on page 30
• XIX. Governmental Regulations on page 31
• Key Decisions Made by the Directors During the Year on page 71
(d) the impact of our operations on the community and the environment
Achieving our mission (purpose) depends on being good corporate citizens and stewards of the environment.
Safeguarding the planet we call home, our guests, the communities we serve, and our Carnival family, and
complying with the laws and regulations that govern our business, is vital to our success.
In 2021, with the support of the Directors, we established goals which focused on advancing six critical
sustainability areas — climate action; circular economy; sustainable tourism; good health and well-being;
diversity, equity and inclusion; and biodiversity and conservation. We have made significant progress towards
our 2030 carbon intensity reduction goals of 40% from a 2008 baseline, measured in both grams of CO
2
e
per ALB-km and kilograms of CO
2
e per ALBD. During 2022, the Directors approved an update to the
baseline year for both goals to 2019 from 2008. This new baseline year will help us better communicate recent
progress against our climate goals to our investors and stakeholders as well as modernize our disclosures in
alignment with developing best practice and reporting standards and better engage with stakeholders.
We are committed to continuing our reduction of carbon emissions and have aspirations to achieve net
carbon-neutral ship operations by 2050, well ahead of the current IMO target. While fossil fuels are currently
the only viable option for our industry, we are closely monitoring technology developments and partnering
with key organizations to help identify and scale new technologies not yet ready for the cruise industry. For
example, we are piloting maritime scale battery technology and methanol powered fuel cells and working
with classification societies and other stakeholders to assess lower carbon fuel options for cruise ships, which
includes methanol, bioLNG, eLNG, hydrogen, and biofuels. During 2022, we piloted the use of biofuel as
a replacement for fossil fuel on two of our ships.
AIDAprima
became the first larger-scale cruise ship to be
powered with a blend of marine biofuel, made from 100% sustainable raw materials, and marine gasoil
(“MGO”). Additionally, Holland America Line completed two pilots on
Volendam
, one using a blend of
marine biofuel and another using 100% biofuel, becoming the first larger-scale cruise ship to be powered 100%
by biofuel. The certified biofuels used in these pilots offer environmental benefits compared to using fossil
fuels alone through their lifecycle CO
2
reductions. These biofuels can be used in existing ship engines without
modifications to the engine or fuel infrastructure, including on ships already in service. While alternative
fuels may provide a path to decarbonization for the maritime industry, there are significant supply challenges
that must be resolved before viability is reached. We are working with suppliers to encourage investment in
a reliable supply infrastructure. The Directors continue to believe our scale will support our effort to lead the
industry in climate action.
70
Refer to:
• II. Mission (Purpose), Vision, Values and Priorities on page 2
• XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact on page 13
• Key Decisions Made by the Directors During the Year on page 71
(e) the desirability of maintaining a reputation for high standards of business conduct
The health, safety and well-being of our people and the planet are vital to the reputation of our business.
We choose to take decisive actions to respect and protect every life we touch, the places we sail and the laws
that govern us. Achieving our mission (purpose) depends on being good corporate citizens and stewards
of the environment. Safeguarding the planet we call home, our guests, the communities we serve, and our
Carnival family, and complying with the laws and regulations that govern our business is vital to our success.
The Directors and executive management acknowledge their responsibility for setting and monitoring the
culture, values and reputation of our business. We have a Code of Business Conduct and Ethics that applies
to all of our team members, including our executive management and the Directors. We also have Culture
Essentials, which are the key actions and behaviors we encourage and reinforce to further strengthen our
culture and have initiatives where brand leaders and executive management meet with their direct reports to
discuss these key behaviors.
Refer to:
• II. Mission (Purpose), Vision, Values and Priorities on page 2
• XIV. Ethics and Compliance on page 13
• XV. Sustainability and Environmental Impact on page 13
• H. Executive Officers and Corporate Governance on page 40
• Annex A — Carnival plc Directors' Report of the Proxy Statement: Corporate and Social
Responsibility on page A-7
• Annex C — Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report of the Proxy Statement: Workforce
Engagement on page C-15
(f) the need to act fairly between our members
It is critical that both existing and potential investors understand our strategy especially as we resumed our
guest cruise operations and continued to manage our liquidity. During 2022, the Directors and certain
members of management held various meetings with investors. These meetings gave investors the opportunity
to discuss views on our compensation decisions, our environmental impact, including sustainability and
climate change and other topics of importance to our business and our stakeholders. Our Investor Relations
team maintains open communication with equity, credit and ESG research analysts to understand investors’
views of our business. Our Treasury team has regular interactions with credit analysts, global banks, debt
investors and credit rating agencies. Additionally, presentations are made to representatives of the
investment community periodically in the U.S., the UK and elsewhere.
Refer to:
• II. Mission (Purpose), Vision, Values and Priorities on page 2
• Annex C — Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report of the Proxy Statement: Relations with
Shareholders on page C-14
Key Decisions Made by the Directors During the Year
Climate Impact
During 2022, the Directors appointed our President and CEO to the role of Chief Climate Officer (“CCO”)
to lead the identification of climate-related risks and opportunities and oversee how these are embedded in
our strategic decision-making and risk management processes. The CCO and the Directors are responsible for
the oversight of climate-related risks and opportunities and are directly supported by members of executive
management. The Directors discussed the need for clear targets associated with our climate-related goals
and their outcomes for the business.
Climate-related matters were a recurring discussion item during 2022. To enable the CCO and Directors to
fulfil their responsibility to oversee climate-related risks and opportunities, a Board ESG and TCFD
Education Program has been established, with core education components and optional self-study courses.
Strategic Report
71
To further support our climate-related efforts, we created the SRE Committee to assist the CCO in fulfilling
his responsibility to identify, monitor and review the management of climate-related risks and opportunities.
The SRE Committee consists of members of executive management and advisors and reports directly to the
CCO. The primary responsibilities and recurring activities of the SRE Committee are to recommend
climate strategy, goals and metrics to the CCO, who makes ultimate recommendations to the Directors and
to enable practical implementation of climate goals approved by the Directors. Refer to XV. Sustainability and
Environmental Impact on page 13 for additional information.
Section 172 considerations:
Long-term success, Team members, Community and Environment
Key stakeholders considered:
Communities we serve, Guests and travel agent partners, and Investors
Portfolio Optimization
Portfolio optimization is an important factor in our operating strategy. Executive management routinely
reviews our global fleet, by brand and as a whole, to make strategic decisions to optimize our long-term
success. The strategic deployment of our ships requires careful consideration to ensure we are meeting our
business objectives while also meeting the needs of our various stakeholders. The mobility of cruise ships
enables us to move our vessels between regions in order to meet changing demand across different
geographic areas.
Several key portfolio optimization decisions were made during 2022 relating to some Costa ships. During
2022, the Directors approved Carnival Fun Italian Style™, a new concept for Carnival Cruise Line’s North
American guests which will debut in the spring of 2023. Carnival Cruise Line will operate
Costa Venezia
,
transferring in the spring of 2023, and
Costa Firenze
, transferring in the spring of 2024, which will combine
the great service, food and entertainment that Carnival Cruise Line’s guests enjoy with Costa’s Italian design
features. Additionally during 2022,
Costa Luminosa
was transferred to Carnival Cruise Line and began
guest operations as
Carnival Luminosa
in November 2022. This decision allowed Carnival Cruise Line to
start highly anticipated itineraries from Brisbane and have two ships operating in Australia for its high season.
The Directors considered the impacts these portfolio decisions would have and ultimately determined
these changes were in the best interest of our short and long-term success and would optimize our financial
performance.
Due to the continued uncertainty regarding the full restart of international cruises in Asia, specifically
China, it is uncertain when or if we will resume operations in the region. As a result, the Directors evaluated
deployment options and fleet optimization alternatives for certain Costa ships that were previously serving
the region. The decision was made to remove two additional ships in Costa’s fleet. Management and the
Directors decided it was the appropriate decision for the company’s overall portfolio and its long-term
success.
Section 172 considerations:
Long-term success and Guests
Key stakeholders considered:
Guests and travel agent partners
Annual Bonus Compensation
During 2021, the Compensation Committees of the Boards of Directors temporarily modified the historical
approach of setting quantitative targets for incentive compensation as it was determined it was impractical
to set pre-established quantitative financial goals on either a short- or long-term basis for 2021 compensation.
This decision was considered due to the continuing business disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic,
uncertainty relating to performance during the resumption of guest cruise operations and promoting
retention and leadership stability. The Compensation Committees determined that the 2021 annual bonus
compensation payout would instead temporarily reward performance against four critical qualitative
objectives:
• Managing Liquidity and Cash
• Managing a Successful Restart
• Maintaining a Strong Compliance Culture
• Maintaining and Building on our ESG Goals
During 2022, the Compensation Committees and members of executive management held discussions with
various shareholders and requested feedback on the decision to temporarily modify the historical approach to
incentive compensation to qualitative objectives for 2021. In determining the approach for 2022, the
Compensation Committees considered the continued progress made in the resumption of guest cruise
operations throughout 2022 and the feedback provided by the shareholders, who expressed their desire for
72
the company to return to setting and measuring performance against pre-established quantitative financial
targets as soon as practical. As a result, the Directors determined it was appropriate to return to our historical
approach of establishing and utilizing quantitative performance-based targets for our Executive Officers’
2022 annual bonus and are committed to continuing this approach for a broader population in 2023. The
Compensation Committees believe the decision relating to the 2022 bonus compensation appropriately
responded to shareholder feedback while still providing appropriate award compensation to our Executive
Officers, aligned with our long-term strategy.
Section 172 considerations:
Long-term success and Team members
Key stakeholders considered:
Team members and Investors
This Strategic Report has been approved by the Board.
By order of the Board
Micky Arison
Chair of the Board of Directors
January 27, 2023
Strategic Report
73
INTRODUCTORY NOTE TO THE CARNIVAL PLC IFRS FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
FOR THE YEAR ENDED NOVEMBER 30, 2022
The Carnival plc consolidated Group IFRS Financial Statements on pages 74 to 116 and standalone
parent company Financial Statements on pages 117 to 131 are required to satisfy reporting
requirements of the Companies Act 2006 and incorporate the results of Carnival plc and its subsidiaries
and, accordingly, do not include the IFRS consolidated results and financial position of Carnival
Corporation and its subsidiaries.
The Directors of Carnival plc consider that within the Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc dual
listed company arrangement, the most appropriate presentation of Carnival plc’s results and financial
position is by reference to the Carnival Corporation & plc U.S. GAAP consolidated financial
statements (“DLC Financial Statements”), which are included in the Annual Report, but do not form
part of these Carnival plc financial statements.
74
CARNIVAL PLC
GROUP STATEMENTS OF INCOME (LOSS)
(in millions, except per share data)
Years Ended November 30,
Notes
2022
2021
Revenues
Passenger ticket
...........................
$
2,792
$
491
Onboard and other
........................
1,149
270
3
3,941
760
Operating Costs and Expenses
Commissions, transportation and other
..........
569
104
Onboard and other
........................
277
79
Payroll and related
.........................
913
557
Fuel
...................................
825
257
Food
..................................
246
72
Property and equipment impairments
...........
10
1,161
607
Other operating
...........................
1,216
566
5,208
2,242
Selling and administrative
....................
3
857
658
Depreciation and amortisation
................
3
781
795
Goodwill impairment
.......................
12
—
280
6,846
3,975
Operating Income (Loss)
......................
(2,905)
(3,215)
Nonoperating Income (Expense)
Interest income
...........................
2
—
Income (loss) from investments in associates
.......
(34)
(129)
Interest expense, net of capitalised interest
........
(140)
(96)
Other income (expense), net
..................
4
280
47
108
(178)
Income (Loss) Before Income Taxes
...............
(2,797)
(3,393)
Income Tax Benefit (Expense), Net
...............
5
(15)
(13)
Net Income (Loss)
...........................
$
(2,813)
$
(3,406)
Earnings (Loss) Per Share
Basic
..................................
6
$
(15.14)
$
(18.49)
Diluted
.................................
6
$
(15.14)
$
(18.49)
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements.
These financial statements only present the Carnival plc consolidated Group IFRS Financial
Statements and, accordingly, do not include the consolidated IFRS results of Carnival Corporation.
Within the DLC arrangement the most appropriate presentation of Carnival plc’s results and financial
position is considered to be by reference to the DLC Financial Statements.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
75
CARNIVAL PLC
GROUP STATEMENTS OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME (LOSS)
(in millions)
Years Ended November 30,
2022
2021
Net Income (Loss)
.......................................
$
(2,813)
$
(3,406)
Other Comprehensive Income (Loss)
Items that will not be reclassified through the Statements of Income
(Loss)
Remeasurements of post-employment benefit obligations
........
(19)
55
Items that may be reclassified through the Statements of Income (Loss)
Changes in foreign currency translation adjustment
............
(538)
(332)
Net gains on hedges of net investment in foreign operations and
other
...........................................
73
216
(466)
(116)
Other Comprehensive Income (Loss)
..........................
(485)
(61)
Total Comprehensive Income (Loss)
...........................
$
(3,298)
$
(3,467)
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements.
These financial statements only present the Carnival plc consolidated Group IFRS Financial
Statements and, accordingly, do not include the consolidated IFRS results of Carnival Corporation.
Within the DLC arrangement the most appropriate presentation of Carnival plc’s results and financial
position is considered to be by reference to the DLC Financial Statements.
76
CARNIVAL PLC
GROUP BALANCE SHEETS
(in millions)
November 30,
Notes
2022
2021
ASSETS
Current Assets
Cash and cash equivalents
.............................
7
$
251
$
434
Trade and other receivables, net
.........................
8
202
140
Inventories
........................................
9
193
146
Prepaid expenses and other
............................
215
109
Total current assets
................................
862
829
Property and Equipment, Net
.............................
10
13,469
14,953
Right-of-Use Assets
...................................
11
283
333
Investments in Associates
................................
13
144
220
Other Assets
........................................
14
775
517
$
15,532
$
16,851
LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY
Current Liabilities
Current portion of long-term debt
.......................
15
$
1,329
$
486
Current portion of lease liabilities
........................
11
33
35
Accounts payable
...................................
471
376
Accrued liabilities and other
............................
16
526
487
Customer deposits
..................................
2
1,589
831
Amount owed to the Carnival Corporation group
.............
25
5,624
6,204
Total current liabilities
..............................
9,571
8,419
Long-Term Debt
.....................................
15
6,361
5,484
Long-Term Lease Liabilities
.............................
11
256
298
Contingencies
.......................................
23
84
94
Other Long-Term Liabilities
.............................
17
200
210
Shareholders’ Equity
Share capital
......................................
18
361
361
Share premium
.....................................
143
143
Retained earnings
...................................
1,175
4,092
Other reserves
.....................................
(2,619)
(2,249)
Total shareholders’ (deficit) equity
......................
24
(940)
2,347
$
15,532
$
16,851
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements. These financial statements only
present the Carnival plc consolidated Group IFRS Financial Statements and, accordingly, do not include the
consolidated IFRS results of Carnival Corporation.
The Carnival plc Group financial statements (registered number 04039524) were authorised for issue by the
Boards of Directors on January 27, 2023 and signed on their behalf by
Micky Arison
Josh Weinstein
Chair of the Boards of Directors
President, Chief Executive Officer and Chief
Climate Officer and Director
Within the DLC arrangement the most appropriate presentation of Carnival plc’s results and financial
position is considered to be by reference to the DLC Financial Statements.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
77
CARNIVAL PLC
GROUP STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS
(in millions)
Years Ended
November 30,
2022
2021
OPERATING ACTIVITIES
Income (Loss) before income taxes
...............................
$
(2,797)
$
(3,393)
Adjustments to reconcile income (loss) before income taxes to net cash
provided by (used in) operating activities
Depreciation and amortisation
................................
781
795
Impairments
.............................................
1,191
904
Share-based compensation
...................................
17
30
Interest expense, net
........................................
156
132
(Income) loss from investments in associates
.......................
34
129
Other, net
...............................................
38
51
(580)
(1,352)
Changes in operating assets and liabilities
Receivables
..............................................
(103)
18
Inventories
..............................................
(72)
(50)
Prepaid expenses and other
...................................
(337)
(182)
Accounts payable
..........................................
106
53
Accrued liabilities, other and contingencies
........................
125
273
Customer deposits
.........................................
855
260
Cash provided by (used in) operations before interest and income taxes
......
(4)
(978)
Interest received
..........................................
2
—
Interest paid
.............................................
(131)
(96)
Income tax benefit received (paid), net
...........................
12
—
Net cash provided by (used in) operating activities
.................
(121)
(1,075)
INVESTING ACTIVITIES
Purchases of property and equipment
...........................
(2,293)
(1,687)
Proceeds from sales of ships
..................................
346
255
Investments in associates
....................................
(1)
(90)
Other, net
...............................................
(139)
128
Net cash provided by (used in) investing activities
..................
(2,087)
(1,395)
FINANCING ACTIVITIES
Changes in amounts owed to the Carnival Corporation group, net
........
(368)
207
Principal repayments of long-term debt
..........................
(654)
(792)
Proceeds from issuance of long-term debt
.........................
3,146
2,798
Finance lease principal payments
...............................
(33)
(45)
Debt issuance cost and other, net
...............................
(147)
(174)
Net cash provided by (used in) financing activities
.................
1,943
1,995
Effect of exchange rate changes on cash and cash equivalents
.............
83
(10)
Net increase (decrease) in cash and cash equivalents
................
(183)
(484)
Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of year
......................
434
918
Cash and cash equivalents at end of year
........................
$
251
$
434
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements. These financial statements only
present the Carnival plc consolidated Group IFRS Financial Statements and, accordingly, do not include the
consolidated IFRS results of Carnival Corporation.
Within the DLC arrangement the most appropriate presentation of Carnival plc’s results and financial
position is considered to be by reference to the DLC Financial Statements.
78
CARNIVAL PLC
GROUP STATEMENTS OF CHANGES IN SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY
(in millions)
Reserves
Share
capital
Share
premium
Retained
earnings
Translation
reserve
Cash
flow
hedges
Treasury
shares
Other
reserves
Merger
reserve
Total
Total
shareholders’
(deficit)
equity
At November 30, 2020
....
$
361
$
185
$ 7,568
$
(1,930) $
8
$ (1,945) $
41
$ 1,503
$ (2,323)
$
5,791
Comprehensive income (loss)
Net income (loss)
.....
—
—
(3,406)
—
—
—
—
—
—
(3,406)
Changes in foreign
currency translation
adjustment
.......
—
—
—
(332)
—
—
—
—
(332)
(332)
Net gains on cash flow
derivative hedges
....
—
—
—
—
3
—
—
—
3
3
Net gains on hedges of net
investments in foreign
operations
........
—
—
—
213
—
—
—
—
213
213
Remeasurements of
post-employment
benefit obligations
...
—
—
55
—
—
—
—
—
—
55
Total comprehensive
income (loss)
......
—
—
(3,351)
(119)
3
—
—
—
(116)
(3,467)
Issuance of treasury
shares for vested share
based awards
......
—
—
(126)
—
—
126
—
—
126
—
Other, net
.........
—
(42)
—
—
—
—
64
—
64
22
At November 30, 2021
....
361
143
4,092
(2,049)
11
(1,818)
105
1,503
(2,249)
2,347
Comprehensive income (loss)
Net income (loss)
.....
—
—
(2,813)
—
—
—
—
—
—
(2,813)
Changes in foreign
currency translation
adjustment
.......
—
—
—
(538)
—
—
—
—
(538)
(538)
Net gains on cash flow
derivative hedges
....
—
—
—
—
9
—
—
—
9
9
Net gains on hedges of net
investment in foreign
operations
........
—
—
—
64
—
—
—
—
64
64
Remeasurements of
post-employment
benefit obligations
...
—
—
(19)
—
—
—
—
—
—
(19)
Total comprehensive
income (loss)
......
—
—
(2,832)
(474)
9
—
—
—
(466)
(3,298)
Issuance of treasury
shares for vested
share-based awards . . .
—
—
(85)
—
—
85
—
—
85
—
Other, net
.........
—
—
(1)
(3)
3
—
11
—
11
11
At November 30, 2022
....
$
361
$
143
$ 1,175
$
(2,526) $
22
$ (1,734) $
116
$ 1,503
$ (2,619)
$
(940)
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements. These financial statements only
present the Carnival plc consolidated Group IFRS Financial Statements and, accordingly, do not include the
consolidated IFRS results of Carnival Corporation.
Within the DLC arrangement the most appropriate presentation of Carnival plc’s results and financial
position is considered to be by reference to the DLC Financial Statements.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
79
CARNIVAL PLC
NOTES TO GROUP FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
NOTE 1 — General
Description of Business
Carnival plc and its subsidiaries and associates are referred to collectively in these financial statements as
the “Group,” “our,” “us” and “we.” Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc, together with their consolidated
subsidiaries, are referred to collectively in these financial statements as “Carnival Corporation & plc.”
Carnival Corporation & plc is the largest global cruise company and among the largest leisure travel
companies with a portfolio of world-class cruise lines. With operations in North America, Australia, Europe
and Asia, its portfolio features — AIDA Cruises, Carnival Cruise Line, Costa Cruises, Cunard, Holland
America Line, Princess Cruises, P&O Cruises (Australia), P&O Cruises (UK) and Seabourn.
DLC Arrangement
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc operate a dual listed company (“DLC”) arrangement, whereby the
businesses of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are combined through a number of contracts and
provisions in Carnival Corporation’s Articles of Incorporation and By-Laws and Carnival plc’s Articles
of Association. The two companies operate as a single economic enterprise with a single senior management
team and identical Boards of Directors, but each has retained its separate legal identity. Each company’s
shares are publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange (“NYSE”) for Carnival Corporation and the
London Stock Exchange for Carnival plc. The Carnival plc American Depositary Shares are traded on the
NYSE.
The constitutional documents of each company provide that, on most matters, the holders of the common
equity of both companies effectively vote as a single body. The Equalization and Governance Agreement
between Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc provides for the equalization of dividends and liquidation
distributions based on an equalization ratio and contains provisions relating to the governance of the DLC
arrangement. Because the equalization ratio is 1 to 1, one share of Carnival Corporation common stock
and one Carnival plc ordinary share are generally entitled to the same distributions.
Under deeds of guarantee executed in connection with the DLC arrangement, as well as stand-alone
guarantees executed since that time, each of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc have effectively cross
guaranteed all indebtedness and certain other monetary obligations of each other. Once the written demand
is made, the holders of indebtedness or other obligations may immediately commence an action against
the relevant guarantor.
Under the terms of the DLC arrangement, Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are permitted to transfer
assets between the companies, make loans to or investments in each other and otherwise enter into
intercompany transactions. In addition, the cash flows and assets of one company are required to be used
to pay the obligations of the other company, if necessary.
The Boards of Directors consider that, within the DLC arrangement, the most appropriate presentation of
Carnival plc’s results and financial position is by reference to the U.S. generally accepted accounting principles
(“U.S. GAAP”) DLC Financial Statements because all significant financial and operating decisions
affecting the DLC companies are made on a joint basis to optimize the consolidated performance as a
single economic entity. Accordingly, the DLC Financial Statements are provided to shareholders as
supplementary information, which are included in the Carnival plc Annual Report, but do not form part of
these Carnival plc financial statements.
Liquidity and Management’s Plans
In the face of the global impact of COVID-19, Carnival Corporation & plc paused its guest cruise operations
in March 2020 and began resuming guest cruise operations in 2021.
Based on the evolving nature of COVID-19 and Carnival Corporation & plc’s ongoing collaboration with
local and national public health authorities, it has responsibly relaxed its related protocols, including greatly
reducing or eliminating testing requirements and vaccination protocols to more closely align with the
broader travel industry and strengthening its competitiveness.
80
As part of Carnival Corporation & plc’s liquidity management, it relies on estimates of its future liquidity,
which includes numerous assumptions that are subject to various risks and uncertainties. The principal
assumptions used to estimate its future liquidity consist of:
• Its continued cruise operations and expected timing of cash collections for cruise bookings
• Expected increases in revenue in 2023 on a per passenger basis compared to 2019, particularly with
the responsible relaxation of COVID-19 related protocols aligning towards land-based vacation
alternatives
• Expected improvement in occupancy on a year-over-year basis returning to historical levels in the
summer of 2023
• Stabilization of fuel prices around November 2022 year-end prices
• Continued stabilization of inflationary pressures on costs, moderated by a larger-more efficient fleet
as compared to 2019
In addition, Carnival Corporation & plc makes certain assumptions about new ship deliveries, improvements
and removals, and consider the future export credit financings that are associated with the new ship
deliveries.
Carnival Corporation & plc has a substantial debt balance as a result of the pause in guest cruise operations
and requires a significant amount of liquidity or cash provided by operating activities to service its debt.
In addition, the continued effects of the pandemic, inflation, higher fuel prices, higher interest rates and
fluctuations in foreign currency rates are collectively having a material negative impact on its financial results.
The full extent of the collective impact of these items is uncertain and may be amplified by its substantial
debt balance. Carnival Corporation & plc believes it has made reasonable estimates and judgments of the
impact of these events within its consolidated financial statements and there may be changes to those estimates
in future periods.
For almost three years, Carnival Corporation & plc has taken appropriate actions to manage its liquidity,
including completing various capital market transactions, obtaining relevant financial covenant amendments
or waivers (refer to Note 15 — “Debt and Interest Expense”), accelerating the removal of certain ships
from its fleet and during the pause in guest cruise operations, reducing capital expenditure and operating
expenses. As of November 30, 2022, 97% of its capacity has resumed guest cruise operations and is serving
guests.
Based on these actions and Carnival Corporations & plc’s assumptions, and considering Carnival
Corporation & plc’s $8.6 billion of liquidity including cash, restricted cash which became unrestricted in
December 2022 and borrowings available under its $1.7 billion, €1.0 billion and £0.2 billion multi-currency
revolving credit facility (the “Revolving Facility”) at November 30, 2022, it believes it has sufficient liquidity
to fund its obligations and expects to remain in compliance with its financial covenants for at least the next
twelve months from the issuance of these financial statements.
Carnival Corporation & plc will continue to pursue various opportunities to raise additional capital to fund
obligations associated with future debt maturities and/or to extend the maturity dates associated with its
existing indebtedness including its Revolving Facility and obtain relevant financial covenant amendments or
waivers, if needed. Actions to raise capital may include issuances of debt, convertible debt or equity in
private or public transactions or entering into new and extended credit facilities. In light of these
circumstances, the Boards of Directors of the Group have a reasonable expectation that Carnival
Corporation & plc has adequate resources to continue its operational existence, for at least the next
twelve months from the issuance of these financial statements and continue to adopt the going concern
basis of preparing the Carnival plc annual Financial Statements.
Refer to the Strategic Report — Item 5. “Going Concern Confirmation and Viability Statement”for
additional discussion regarding Carnival Corporation & plc’s liquidity assessment.
NOTE 2 — Significant Accounting Policies
Basis of Preparation
The Carnival plc Group financial statements are presented in U.S. dollars unless otherwise noted. They are
prepared on the historical cost basis, except for certain financial assets and liabilities (including derivative
instruments) that are stated at fair value.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
81
On December 31, 2020, IFRS as adopted by the European Union was brought into UK law and became UK-
adopted International Accounting Standards, with future changes being subject to endorsement by the
UK Endorsement Board.
The Group transitioned to UK-adopted International Accounting Standards in its Group financial
statements on December 1, 2021. This change constitutes a change in accounting framework. However,
there is no impact on recognition, measurement or disclosure in the period reported as a result of the change
in framework. The financial statements of the Group have been prepared in accordance with UK-adopted
International Accounting Standards and with the requirements of the Companies Act 2006 as applicable to
companies reporting under those standards.
Basis of Consolidation
The Group controls an entity when the Group is exposed to, or has rights to, variable returns from its
involvement with the entity and has the ability to affect those returns through its power to direct the activities
of the entity. All significant intra-Group balances and transactions are eliminated in consolidation. These
financial statements are required to satisfy reporting requirements of the Companies Act 2006 and do not
include the IFRS consolidated results and financial position of Carnival Corporation and its subsidiaries.
Significant Accounting Estimates, Assumptions and Judgements
The preparation of these financial statements in conformity with IFRS as adopted in the UK requires
management to make judgements, estimates and assumptions that affect the application of policies and
reported and disclosed amounts in these financial statements. These judgments, estimates and assumptions
are based on management’s best knowledge of the relevant facts and circumstances, having regard to previous
experience, but actual results may differ materially from the amounts included in the financial statements.
Climate change
In preparing these financial statements, management has considered the expected impacts of climate change
and the achievement of the Carnival Corporation & plc 2030 sustainability goals. Management has
considered the expected impacts of climate change on a number of key estimates within the financial
statements, including:
• Estimates related to our future liquidity requirements and viability (refer to Note 1 — “General-
Liquidity and Management’s Plans”and Item 5. “Going Concern Confirmation and Viability
Statement” of the Strategic Report)
• Estimates of future cash flows used in the valuation of ships (refer to Note 10 — “Property and
Equipment”
• Estimates related to the useful life and residual value of ships (refer to Note 10 — “Property and
Equipment”)
The following specific points were considered:
• Carnival Corporation & plc’s ongoing newbuild program, which includes deliveries of larger-more
efficient ships over the coming years, some of which will replace existing ships in its fleet, has been and
will continue to be a factor in management’s expected ability to achieve Carnival Corporation &
plc’s 2030 carbon intensity reduction goals
• Carnival Corporation & plc continues to invest in energy efficiency projects for its existing fleet with
expected future investments consistent with its historical annual level of investment
• The current status of various pending environmental regulations which, if enacted, will materially
impact Carnival Corporation & plc’s future cash flows beginning in 2025
Refer to XIX. Governmental Regulations on page 31 of the Strategic Report.
Significant Judgements and Estimates
Key judgements, estimates and underlying assumptions are reviewed on an ongoing basis. Revisions to
accounting estimates are recognised in the period in which the estimate is revised if the revision affects only
that period or in the period of the revision and future periods if the revision affects both current and
future periods. The significant accounting estimates are those with a significant risk of resulting in a material
adjustment to the carrying amounts of assets and liabilities within the next year. The significant areas of
key sources of estimation uncertainty for the year ended 2022 were as follows:
82
Area (a)
Significant Estimates
Reference (b)
Valuation of Ships
Determination of the recoverable
value of our ships and CGUs
Note 10 — “Property and
Equipment”
Ship Useful Life and Residual Value
Determination of useful life and
residual value
Note 10 — “Property and
Equipment”
(a)
There were no critical accounting judgements as defined under IAS 1 for 2022.
(b)
Further details, together with sensitivities for key sources of estimation uncertainty, where appropriate
and practicable, are included within the references in the table.
Cash and Cash Equivalents
Cash and cash equivalents include investments with maturities of three months or less at acquisition that
are readily convertible to known amounts of cash, which are stated at cost and present insignificant risk of
changes in value.
Trade and Other Receivables
Although we generally require full payment from our customers prior to or concurrently with their cruise,
we grant credit terms to a relatively small portion of our revenue source. We have receivables from credit card
merchants and travel agents for cruise ticket purchases and onboard revenue. These receivables are included
within trade and other receivables, net. We have agreements with a number of credit card processors that
transact customer deposits related to our cruise vacations. Certain of these agreements allow the credit card
processors to request, under certain circumstances, that we provide a reserve fund in cash. These reserve
funds are included in other assets.
Inventories
Inventories consist substantially of food, beverages, hotel supplies, fuel and retail merchandise, which are all
carried at the lower of cost or net realisable value. Cost is determined using the weighted-average or first-
in, first-out methods.
Property and Equipment
Property and equipment are stated at cost less accumulated depreciation and any impairment charges. We
capitalize interest as part of the cost of capital projects incurred during construction. Depreciation is computed
using the straight-line method over our estimated useful lives of the assets to a residual value, as a percentage
of original cost, as follows:
Years
Residual
Values
Ships
..................................
30
15%
Ship improvements
........................
3 – 30
0%
Buildings and improvements
..................
10 – 40
0%
Computer hardware and software
..............
2 – 12
0%
Transportation equipment and other
............
3 – 20
0%
Leasehold improvements, including port facilities . . .
Shorter of the remaining lease term or
related asset life (3 – 30)
0%
The cost of ships under construction includes progress payments for the construction of new ships, as well
as design and engineering fees, capitalised interest, construction oversight costs and various owner supplied
items. Any liquidated damages received from shipyards are recorded as reductions to the cost basis of the
ship.
We have a capital program for the improvement of our ships and for asset replacements to enhance the
effectiveness and efficiency of our operations; to comply with, or exceed, all relevant legal and statutory
requirements related to health, environment, safety, security and sustainability; and to gain strategic benefits
or provide improved product innovations to our guests. We account for ship improvement costs, including
replacements of certain significant components and parts by capitalising those costs we believe add value to
our ships and have a useful life greater than one year and depreciating those improvements over their
estimated remaining useful life.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
83
The costs of repairs and maintenance, including minor improvement costs and expenses incurred during dry-
docks, are charged to expense as incurred and included in other operating expenses. These minor dry-dock
expenses primarily represent maintenance activities that are incurred when a ship is taken out-of-service for
scheduled maintenance.
In addition, specifically identified or estimated cost and accumulated depreciation of previously capitalised
ship components are written-off upon retirement, which may result in a loss on disposal that is also included
in other operating expenses.
Given the large size and complexity of our ships, ship accounting estimates require considerable judgment
and are inherently uncertain. We do not have cost segregation studies performed to specifically componentize
our ships. In addition, since we do not separately componentize our ships, we do not identify and track
depreciation of original ship components. Therefore, we typically have to estimate the net book value of
components that are retired, based primarily upon their replacement cost, their age and their original estimated
useful lives.
We have estimated our ships’useful lives at 30 years and residual values at 15% of our original ship cost.
Our ship useful life and residual value estimates take into consideration the estimated weighted-average useful
lives of the ships’ major component systems, such as hull, superstructure, main electric, engines and
cabins. We also take into consideration the impact of technological changes, historical useful lives of similarly-
built ships, long-term cruise and vacation market conditions and regulatory changes, including those
related to the environment and climate change. We determine the residual value of our ships based on our
long-term estimates of their resale value at the end of their useful life to us but before the end of their physical
and economic lives to others, historical resale values of our and other cruise ships as well as our expectations
of the long-term viability of the secondary cruise ship market. We review estimated useful lives and
residual values for reasonableness at the period end or whenever events or circumstances significantly
change.
Occasionally we transfer ships between Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc. The group’s accounting
policy with regard to such transfers is that they take place at the US GAAP net book value of the ship at
the point of transfer.
We evaluate ship asset impairments either at the individual ship level, when it is considered to be the lowest
level for which identifiable cash flows are largely independent of the cash flows of other assets and liabilities,
for example when we have plans to dispose of a ship, or at the cash generating unit (“CGU”) (or cruise
brand) level, when the cash flows of a given ship are not considered to be largely independent of the cash
flows of other assets and liabilities. We review our ships for impairment whenever events or circumstances
indicate that the carrying value of a ship may not be recoverable. The recoverable amount is considered to be
the higher of value in use or fair value less costs of disposal.
Where an assessment is performed at the individual ship level, the fair value is typically estimated based
either on ship sales price negotiations and/or estimated sales prices from previous ship sales.
Where an assessment is performed at the CGU level, we compare the carrying amount of the net assets
allocated to each CGU (inclusive of ships) with its recoverable amount. The estimated recoverable amount
is the higher of the cruise brands’ fair value less costs of disposal and its value in use. If the recoverable
amount is greater than the cruise brand net asset carrying value, then the value of the assets is deemed
recoverable. A significant amount of judgement is required in estimating the recoverable amounts of our
CGUs. Assessments are made at a CGU level as individual ships cash flows are dependent both upon shore-
based assets that support the operation of the ships and the itineraries each ship operates, which is
determined based upon plans for ships in the CGU and for which we have the ability to change over time.
If estimated discounted future cash flows are less than the carrying value of a ship, an impairment charge is
recognized to the extent its carrying value exceeds its estimated recoverable amount.
If, subsequent to impairment, there has been a change in the estimates used to determine our ships’
recoverable amount, then the carrying amount of the ship may be increased by the reversal of the impairment.
The reversal is limited to the carrying amount that would have been determined had no impairment loss
been recognized for the ship in prior years. Determination of future cash flows and fair values of our cruise
ships involves estimates and assumptions.
Leases
Substantially all of our leases for which we are the lessee are leases of port facilities and real estate and are
included within right-of-use assets, long-term lease liabilities and the current portion of lease liabilities in our
Consolidated Balance Sheets.
84
We have port facilities and real estate lease agreements with lease and non-lease components, and in such
cases, we account for the components as a single lease component.
We do not recognize lease assets and lease liabilities for any leases with an original term of less than one
year. For some of our port facilities and real estate lease agreements, we have the option to extend our current
lease term by 1 to 10 years. Generally, we do not include renewal options as a component of our present
value calculation as we are not reasonably certain that we will exercise the options.
As most of our leases do not have a readily determinable implicit rate, we estimate the incremental borrowing
rate (“IBR”) to determine the present value of lease payments. We apply judgement in estimating the IBR
including considering the term of the lease, the currency in which the lease is denominated, and the impact of
collateral and our credit risk on the rate.
Certain of our agreements stipulate potential future increases in variable lease payments based on an index
or rate, which are not included in the lease liability until they take effect. When adjustments to lease payments
based on an index or rate take effect, the lease liability is reassessed and adjusted against the right-of-use
asset.
We depreciate our lease assets on a straight-line basis over the shorter of the asset’s useful life and the lease
term. Lease payments are allocated between principal and finance cost. The finance cost is charged to profit or
loss over the lease period so as to produce a constant periodic rate of interest on the remaining balance of
the liability for each period.
Goodwill
Our historical goodwill represented the excess of the purchase price over the fair value of identifiable net
assets acquired in a business acquisition. Historically, we reviewed our goodwill for impairment as of July 31
every year, or more frequently if events or circumstances dictated. As of November 30, 2021 we performed
impairment analyses for two of our EA segment CGUs and as a result of this analysis, we determined their
estimated fair values no longer exceeded their carrying values. As a result, we recognized goodwill
impairment charges of $280 million and accordingly have no remaining goodwill for our EA segment
CGUs. Refer to Note 12 — “Goodwill”for additional information.
Contingencies
We are routinely involved in legal proceedings, claims, disputes, regulatory matters and governmental
inspections or investigations arising in the ordinary course of or incidental to our business, including those
noted below. While it is typically very difficult to determine the timing and ultimate outcome of these matters,
we use our best judgement to determine the appropriate amounts to record in our consolidated financial
statements. We accrue a liability and establish a reserve when we believe a loss is probable and the amount
of the loss can be reasonably estimated. In assessing probable losses, we make estimates of the amount of
probable insurance recoveries, if any, which are recorded as assets where appropriate. Such accruals and
reserves and the estimated timing of settlement are typically based on developments to date, historical
claims experience, and actuarially determined estimates of liabilities. Given the inherent uncertainty related
to the eventual outcome of these matters and potential insurance recoveries, it is possible that all or some
of these matters may be resolved for amounts different from any provisions or disclosures that we may have
made. In addition, as new information becomes available, we may need to reassess the amount of asset or
liability that needs to be accrued related to our contingencies. Refer to Note 23 — “Contingencies” for
additional information.
Investments in Associates
Investments in Associates are accounted for using the equity method of accounting and are initially
recognized at cost. Interest in the net assets of such investments is included in investments in associates in
the Consolidated Balance Sheets and our proportionate interest in their results is included in income (loss)
from investments in associates in the Consolidated Statements of Income.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
85
Debt and Debt Issuance Costs
Debt is recorded at initial fair value, which normally reflects the proceeds received by us, net of debt
issuance costs. Debt is subsequently stated at amortized cost. Debt issuance costs are generally amortized to
interest expense using the straight-line method, which approximates the effective interest method, over the
term of the debt. Debt issue discounts and premiums are generally amortized to interest expense using the
effective interest rate method over the term of the debt.
Derivatives and Other Financial Instruments
We have in the past and may in the future utilize derivative and non-derivative financial instruments, such as
foreign currency forwards, options and swaps, foreign currency debt obligations and foreign currency cash
balances, to manage our exposure to fluctuations in certain foreign currency exchange rates. We use interest
rate swaps primarily to manage our interest rate exposure to achieve a desired proportion of fixed and
floating rate debt. Our policy is to not use financial instruments for trading or other speculative purposes.
All derivatives are recorded at fair value. If a derivative is designated as a cash flow hedge, then the change in
the fair value of the derivative is recognized as a component of other comprehensive income (“OCI”) until
the underlying hedged item is recognized in earnings or the forecasted transaction is no longer probable. If a
derivative or a non-derivative financial instrument is designated as a hedge of our net investment in a
foreign operation, then changes in the effective portion of the fair value of the financial instrument are
recognized as a component of OCI to offset the change in the translated value of the designated portion of
net investment being hedged until the investment is sold or substantially liquidated, while the impact
attributable to components excluded from the assessment of hedge effectiveness is recorded in interest
expense, net of capitalised interest, on a systematic and rational basis. For derivatives that do not qualify for
hedge accounting treatment, the change in fair value is recognized in earnings.
We classify the fair value of all our derivative contracts as either current or long-term, depending on the
maturity date of the derivative contract. The cash flows from derivatives treated as cash flow hedges are
classified in our Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows in the same category as the item being hedged.
Derivative valuations are based on observable inputs such as interest rates forward currency exchange rates,
credit spreads, maturity dates, volatilities, and cross currency basis spreads. We use the income approach
to value derivatives for foreign currency options and forwards, interest rate swaps and cross currency swaps
using observable market data for all significant inputs and standard valuation techniques to convert future
amounts to a single present value amount, assuming that participants are motivated but not compelled to
transact.
Foreign Currency Translation and Transactions
The Carnival plc Group financial statements are presented in U.S. dollars. Each foreign entity determines its
functional currency by reference to its primary economic environment. The Group’s most significant
foreign entities utilize the U.S. dollar, Euro, Sterling or the Australian dollar as their functional currencies.
The Group translates the assets and liabilities of its foreign entities that have functional currencies other than
the U.S. dollar at exchange rates in effect at the balance sheet date. Revenues and expenses of these foreign
entities are translated at the average rate for the period. Equity is translated at historical rates and the resulting
foreign currency translation adjustments are included in the translation reserve, which is a separate
component of other reserves within shareholders’equity. Therefore, the U.S. dollar value of the non-equity
translated items in the Group’s consolidated financial statements will fluctuate from period to period,
depending on the changing value of the U.S. dollar versus these currencies.
The Group executes transactions in a number of different currencies. At the date that the transaction is
recognized, each asset, liability, revenue, expense, gain or loss arising from the transaction is measured and
recorded in the functional currency of the recording entity using the exchange rate in effect at that date. At
each balance sheet date, recorded monetary balances denominated in a currency other than the functional
currency are adjusted using the exchange rate at the balance sheet date, with gains or losses recorded in other
income or other expense, unless such monetary balances have been designated as hedges of net investments
in our foreign entities. The unrealised gains or losses on our long-term intercompany receivables and payables
which are denominated in a non-functional currency and are not expected to be repaid in the foreseeable
future are recorded in translation reserves.
86
Revenue and Expense Recognition
Guest cruise deposits and advance onboard purchases are initially included in customer deposits when
received. Customer deposits are subsequently recognized as cruise revenues, together with revenues from
onboard and other activities, and all associated direct costs and expenses of a voyage are recognized as cruise
costs and expenses, upon completion of voyages with durations of ten nights or less and on a pro rata
basis for voyages in excess of ten nights. The impact of recognizing these shorter duration cruise revenues
and costs and expenses on a completed voyage basis versus on a pro rata basis is not material. Certain of our
product offerings are bundled and we allocate the value of the bundled services and goods between
passenger ticket revenues and onboard and other revenues based upon the estimated standalone selling
prices of those goods and services. Guest cancellation fees, when applicable, are recognized in passenger ticket
revenues at the time of cancellation.
Our sales to guests of air and other transportation to and from airports near the home ports of our ships
are included in passenger ticket revenues, and the related costs of purchasing these services are included in
transportation costs. The proceeds that we collect from the sales of third-party shore excursions are included
in onboard and other revenues and the related costs are included in onboard and other costs. The amounts
collected on behalf of our onboard concessionaires, net of the amounts remitted to them, are included in
onboard and other revenues as concession revenues. All of these amounts are recognised on a completed
voyage or pro rata basis as discussed above.
Revenues and expenses from our hotel and transportation operations, which are included in our Tour and
Other segment, are recognized at the time the services are performed.
Customer Deposits
Our payment terms generally require an initial deposit to confirm a reservation, with the balance due prior
to the voyage. Cash received from guests in advance of the cruise is recorded in customer deposits and in other
long-term liabilities on our Consolidated Balance Sheets. These amounts include refundable deposits. In
certain situations, we have provided flexibility to guests by allowing guests to rebook at a future date, receive
future cruise credits (“FCCs”) or elect to receive refunds in cash. We have at times issued enhanced FCCs.
Enhanced FCCs provide the guest with an additional credit value above the original cash deposit received, and
the enhanced value is recognized as a discount applied to the future cruise in the period used. We record a
liability for unexpired FCCs to the extent we have received and not refunded cash from guests for cancelled
bookings. We had total customer deposits of $1.7 billion as of November 30, 2022 and $0.9 billion as of
November 30, 2021, which includes approximately $35 million of unredeemed FCCs as of November 30,
2022. The increase in customer deposits in 2022 is primarily driven by the resumption of guest cruise
operations. Given the uncertainty of travel demand caused by COVID-19 and lack of comparable historical
experience of FCC redemptions, we are unable to estimate the number of FCCs that will not be used in
future periods. Refunds payable to guests who have elected cash refunds are recorded in accounts payable.
During 2022 and 2021, we recognized revenues of $0.6 billion and an immaterial amount related to our
customer deposits as of November 30, 2021 and 2020. Historically, our customer deposits balance changes
due to the seasonal nature of cash collections, the recognition of revenue, refunds of customer deposits
and foreign currency changes.
Contract Costs
We recognize incremental travel agent commissions and credit and debit card fees incurred as a result of
obtaining the ticket contract as assets when paid prior to the start of a voyage. We record these amounts
within prepaid expenses and other and subsequently recognize these amounts as commissions, transportation
and other at the time of revenue recognition or at the time of voyage cancellation. We had incremental
costs of obtaining contracts with customers recognized as assets of $59 million as of November 30, 2022
and $13 million as of November 30, 2021.
Insurance
We maintain insurance under Carnival Corporation & plc’s insurance programs to cover a number of risks
including illness and injury to crew, guest injuries, pollution, other third-party claims in connection with our
cruise activities, damage to hull and machinery for each of our ships, war risks, workers’compensation,
directors’and officers’liability, property damage and general liability for shoreside third-party claims. We
recognize insurance recoverables from third-party insurers for recorded losses at the time the recovery is
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
87
virtually certain or upon settlement for amounts in excess of the recorded losses. All of our insurance
policies are subject to coverage limits, exclusions and deductible levels.
Selling and Administrative Expenses
Selling expenses include a broad range of advertising, marketing and promotional expenses. Advertising is
charged to expense as incurred. Selling expenses totalled $309 million in 2022 and $153 million in 2021.
Administrative expenses represent the costs of our shoreside support, reservations and other administrative
functions, and include salaries and related benefits, professional fees and building occupancy costs, which are
typically expensed as incurred.
Share-Based Compensation
We recognize compensation expense for all, equity settled, share-based compensation awards using the fair
value method. For time-based share awards, we recognize compensation cost ratably using the straight-line
attribution method over the expected vesting period or to the retirement eligibility date, if earlier than the
vesting period. For performance-based share awards, we estimate compensation cost based on the probability
of the performance condition being achieved and recognize expense ratably using the straight-line
attribution method over the expected vesting period. If all or a portion of the performance condition is not
expected to be met, the appropriate amount of previously recognized compensation expense is reversed
and future compensation expense is adjusted accordingly. For market-based share awards, we recognize
compensation cost ratably using the straight-line attribution method over the expected vesting period. If the
target market conditions are not expected to be met, compensation expense will still be recognized.
Earnings Per Share
Basic earnings per share is computed by dividing net income (loss) by the weighted-average number of
shares outstanding during each period. Diluted earnings per share is computed by dividing net income (loss)
by the weighted-average number of shares and common stock equivalents outstanding during each period.
Post-Employment Benefits
The Group operates both defined benefit and defined contribution plans. The net deficit or surplus for each
defined benefit pension plan is calculated based on the present value of the defined benefit obligation at
the balance sheet date less the fair value of the plan assets. The calculation is performed by a qualified external
actuary using the projected unit credit method. The discount rate is the yield at the balance sheet date on
AA credit rated bonds or local equivalents that have maturity dates approximating the terms of the pension
plans’ obligations.
Actuarial gains and losses that arise in calculating the defined benefit pension plans’ obligations are
recognized in the period in which they arise directly in the Group’s comprehensive income (loss).
The operating and financing costs of defined benefit pension plans are recognized in the Statements of
Income (Loss); current service costs are spread systematically over the expected average remaining service
lives of employees and financing costs are recognized in the periods within which they arise. To the extent that
the benefits vest immediately, the expense is recognized immediately.
Defined contribution plan expenses are recognized in the period to which they relate. We contribute to these
plans based on employee contributions, salary levels and length of service. The assets of these plans are
held separately from the Group in independently administered funds.
Income Taxes
Deferred income taxes are provided using the balance sheet liability method. Deferred income tax assets are
recognized to the extent that it is probable that future taxable income will be available against which the
temporary differences can be utilised. Deferred income taxes are measured at the average tax rates that are
expected to apply in the periods in which the timing differences are expected to reverse based on tax rates and
laws that have been enacted or substantially enacted by the balance sheet date. Current income taxes are
the taxes payable on the taxable income for the year, applying current rates and any adjustments in respect
of previous years.
Dividends
When applicable, dividend distributions are recognized in the period in which the dividends are declared
because, under the DLC arrangement, the declaration of a dividend by the Boards of Directors of Carnival
88
Corporation & plc establishes a liability for Carnival plc. If declared, Carnival plc dividends are declared in
U.S. dollars and holders of Carnival plc American Depositary Shares receive a dividend payable in U.S.
dollars.
Transactions with Carnival Corporation
We present the cash flow items “Changes in amounts owed to the Carnival Corporation group, net”on a
net basis as this presentation is most appropriate to reflect the nature of these underlying cash flows between
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc and their respective subsidiaries, being large amounts, with a high
volume of transactions, and which are unsecured and repayable on demand (of a short-term nature).
Accounting Pronouncements
The International Accounting Standards Board (“IASB”) issued amendments to the standards, IFRS 9
Financial Instruments
, IAS 39
Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement
, IFRS 7
Financial
Instruments: Disclosures
, IFRS 4
Insurance Contracts
and IFRS 16
Leases,
that address issues that might
affect financial reporting when an existing interest rate benchmark is replaced with an alternative interest rate.
The changes relate to the modification of financial assets, financial liabilities and lease liabilities, specific
hedge accounting requirements, and disclosure requirements applying IFRS 7
Financial Instruments:
Disclosures
to accompany the amendments regarding modifications and hedge accounting.
The amendments require that, for financial instruments measured using amortised cost measurement (that
is, financial instruments classified as amortised cost), changes to the basis for determining the contractual
cash flows required by interest rate benchmark reform are reflected by adjusting their effective interest
rate. No immediate gain or loss is recognised. These expedients are only applicable to changes that are
required by interest rate benchmark reform, which is the case if, and only if, the change is necessary as a direct
consequence of interest rate benchmark reform and the new basis for determining the contractual cash
flows is economically equivalent to the previous basis (that is, the basis immediately preceding the change).
Where some or all of a change in the basis for determining the contractual cash flows of a financial liability
does not meet the above criteria, the above practical expedient is first applied to the changes required by
interest rate benchmark reform, including updating the instrument’s effective interest rate. Any additional
changes are accounted for in the normal way (that is, assessed for modification or derecognition, with the
resulting modification gain / loss recognised immediately in profit or loss where the instrument is not
derecognised).
In December 2021, we amended our £350 million long-term debt agreement which referenced the British
Pound sterling (“GBP”) LIBOR to the Sterling Overnight Index Average (“SONIA”) and applied the practical
expedient. This amendment did not have a material impact on our consolidated financial statements. As of
November 30, 2022, approximately $46 million of our outstanding indebtedness bears interest at floating
rates referenced to U.S. dollar LIBOR and matures after the transition date and have not yet transitioned
to SOFR or an alternative interest rate benchmark. We are currently evaluating our contract referenced to
U.S. dollar LIBOR and working with our creditors on updating credit agreements as necessary to include
language regarding the successor or alternate rate to LIBOR. We do not expect the adoption of this
standard to have a material impact on our consolidated financial statements during the LIBOR transition
period.
The IASB has issued amendments to the standard, IAS 1,
Presentation of Financial Statements
—
Classification of Liabilities as Current or Non-current
, providing a more general approach to the classification
of liabilities based on the contractual agreements in place at the reporting date. These amendments are
required to be adopted by us for the financial year commencing on January 1, 2024 and must be applied
retrospectively. We do not expect the adoption of this guidance to have a material impact on our consolidated
financial statements.
NOTE 3 — Segment Information
As previously discussed, within the DLC arrangement, the most appropriate presentation of Carnival plc’s
results and financial position is by reference to the DLC Financial Statements, which are included in the
Carnival plc Annual Report, but do not form part of these Carnival plc financial statements. The operating
segments are reported on the same basis as the internally reported information that is provided to the chief
operating decision maker (“CODM”), who is the President, Chief Executive Officer and Chief Climate
Officer of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc. The CODM assesses performance and makes decisions
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
89
to allocate resources for Carnival Corporation & plc based upon review of the results across all of the
segments. Carnival Corporation & plc has four reportable segments comprised of (1) North America and
Australia cruise operations (“NAA”), (2) Europe and Asia cruise operations (“EA”), (3) Cruise Support and
(4) Tour and Other.
The operating segments within each of the NAA and EA reportable segments have been aggregated based
on the similarity of their economic and other characteristics, including geographic guest sourcing. The Cruise
Support segment includes Carnival Corporation & plc’s portfolio of leading port destinations and other
services, all of which are operated for the benefit of its cruise brands. The Tour and Other segment represents
the hotel and transportation operations of Holland America Princess Alaska Tours and other operations.
Selected information for the Carnival Corporation & plc segments and the reconciliation to the corresponding
Carnival plc amounts as of and for the years ended November 30 was as follows:
(in millions)
Revenues
Operating
costs and
expenses
Selling and
administrative
Depreciation
and
amortisation
Operating
income
(loss)
Capital
expenditures
Total
assets
2022
NAA
.............
$ 8,281
$ 7,526
$
1,517
$
1,408
$
(2,170)
$
2,568 $ 27,413
EA
..............
3,531
3,925
745
692
(1,830)
2,213
15,317
Cruise Support
.......
171
120
225
140
(315)
155
8,461
Tour and Other
......
185
187
27
36
(64)
4
512
Carnival Corporation &
plc – U.S. GAAP
....
12,168
11,757
2,515
2,275
(4,379)
4,940
51,703
Carnival
Corporation – U.S.
GAAP (a)
.......
(8,228)
(7,249)
(1,646)
(1,492)
2,159
(2,648)
(34,717)
Carnival plc
Group – U.S.
GAAP vs IFRS
differences (b)
....
—
699
(12)
(2)
(686)
—
(1,454)
Carnival plc – IFRS
...
$ 3,941
$ 5,208
$
857
$
781
$
(2,905)
$
2,293 $ 15,532
2021
NAA
.............
$ 1,108
$ 2,730
$
953
$
1,352
$
(3,928)
$
2,397 $ 25,606
EA
..............
712
1,807
568
728
(2,617) (b)
515
16,088
Cruise Support
.......
42
55
335
129
(477)
660
11,014
Tour and Other
......
46
63
27
23
(67)
35
637
Carnival Corporation &
plc – U.S. GAAP
....
1,908
4,655
1,885
2,233
(7,089)
3,607
53,344
Carnival
Corporation – U.S.
GAAP (a)
.......
(1,148)
(2,566)
(1,213)
(1,435)
4,067
(1,919)
(35,656)
Carnival plc
Group – U.S.
GAAP vs IFRS
differences (b)
....
—
154
(13)
(3)
(192)
—
(837)
Carnival plc – IFRS
...
$
760
$ 2,242
$
658
$
795
$
(3,215)
$
1,687 $ 16,851
(a)
Carnival Corporation consists primarily of cruise brands that do not form part of the Group; however,
these brands are included in Carnival Corporation & plc and thus represent substantially all of the
reconciling items.
(b)
The U.S. GAAP vs IFRS accounting differences primarily relate to differences in the carrying value of
ships, lease accounting, pension accounting and differences in depreciation expense due to differences in
the carrying value of ships.
90
Revenues by geographic areas, which are based on where our guests are sourced, were as follows:
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Europe
..................................................
$
3,357
$
710
North America
............................................
311
27
Australia and Asia
..........................................
232
17
Others
..................................................
41
6
$
3,941
$
760
Substantially all of our long-lived assets consist of our ships and move between geographic areas. Segment
information relating to liabilities is not reported to or used by the CODM in order to assess performance and
allocate resources to a segment.
NOTE 4 — Other Income and Expense
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Foreign exchange remeasurements, net
............................
$
311
$
67
Impairment in associates and other
..............................
(30)
(20)
Other income (expense), net
...................................
$
280
$
47
In addition, fees payable to the Group’s auditor for the audit of the financial statements in 2022 were
$2 million (2021: $2 million). Non-audit service fees paid to our auditors in 2022 were $0.1 million (2021:
$0.3 million), relating to audit-related assurance services.
NOTE 5 — Taxation
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Current taxes
.............................................
$
(20)
$
(36)
Deferred taxes
.............................................
5
24
Income tax benefit (expense), net
................................
$
(15)
$
(13)
Total income tax benefit (expense) is reconciled to income taxes calculated at the UK standard tax rate as
follows:
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Income (loss) before income taxes
...............................
$
(2,797)
$
(3,393)
Notional tax benefit (expense) at UK standard tax rate (19% in 2022 and
2021)
.................................................
532
645
Effect of Italian and UK tonnage tax and other taxes at different rates
.....
(547)
(657)
$
(15)
$
(13)
A summary of our principal taxes and exemptions in the jurisdictions where our significant operations are
located is as follows:
UK and Australian Income Tax
Cunard, P&O Cruises (UK) and P&O Cruises (Australia) are divisions of Carnival plc and have elected to
enter UK tonnage tax under a rolling ten-year term and, accordingly, reapply every year. Companies to which
the tonnage tax regime applies pay corporation taxes on profits calculated by reference to the net tonnage
of qualifying ships. UK corporation tax is not chargeable under the normal UK tax rules on these brands’
relevant shipping income. Relevant shipping income includes income from the operation of qualifying ships
and from shipping related activities.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
91
For a company to be eligible for the regime, it must be subject to UK corporation tax and, among other
matters, operate qualifying ships that are strategically and commercially managed in the UK. Companies
within UK tonnage tax are also subject to a seafarer training requirement.
Our UK non-shipping activities that do not qualify under the UK tonnage tax regime remain subject to
normal UK corporation tax.
P&O Cruises (Australia) and all of the other cruise ships operated internationally by Carnival plc for the
cruise segment of the Australian vacation region are exempt from Australian corporation tax by virtue of the
UK/Australian income tax treaty.
Italian and German Income Tax
In 2015, Costa and AIDA re-elected to enter the Italian tonnage tax regime through 2024 and can reapply
for an additional ten-year period beginning in early 2025. Companies to which the tonnage tax regime applies
pay corporation taxes on shipping profits calculated by reference to the net tonnage of qualifying ships.
Most of Costa’s and AIDA’s earnings that are not eligible for taxation under the Italian tonnage tax regime
will be taxed at an effective tax rate of 4.8% in 2022 and 2021.
Substantially all of AIDA’s earnings are exempt from German income taxes by virtue of the Germany/Italy
income tax treaty.
U.S. Income Tax
Our domestic U.S. operations, principally the hotel and transportation business of Holland America
Princess Alaska Tours, are subject to federal and state income taxation in the U.S.
We believe that the U.S. source transportation income earned by Carnival plc and its subsidiaries currently
qualifies for exemption from U.S. federal income tax under applicable bilateral U.S. income tax treaties.
Other
We recognize income tax provisions for uncertain tax positions, based solely on their technical merits, and
the most likely outcome to be sustained upon examination by the relevant tax authority. Based on all known
facts and circumstances and current tax law, we believe that the total amount of our uncertain income tax
position liabilities and related accrued interest are not material to our financial position. All interest expense
related to income tax liabilities is included in income tax expense.
In addition to or in place of income taxes, virtually all jurisdictions where our ships call impose taxes, fees
and other charges based on guest counts, ship tonnage, passenger capacity or some other measure, and these
taxes, fees and other charges are included in commissions, transportation and other costs and other
operating expenses.
NOTE 6 — Earnings (Loss) Per Share
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions, except per share data)
2022
2021
Net income (loss) for basic and diluted earnings (loss) per share
..........
$
(2,813)
$
(3,406)
Weighted-average shares outstanding
.............................
186
184
Diluted weighted-average shares outstanding
.......................
186
184
Basic earnings (loss) per share
..................................
$
(15.14)
$
(18.49)
Diluted earnings (loss) per share
................................
$
(15.14)
$
(18.49)
Antidilutive shares excluded from our 2022 and 2021 diluted earnings (loss) per share computations were
immaterial.
92
NOTE 7 — Cash and Cash Equivalents
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Cash
........................................................
$
190
$
343
Cash equivalents (money market funds and time deposits) (a)
.................
61
92
$
251
$
434
(a)
Money market funds are carried at their fair value, which approximates its carrying value.
Substantially all material cash balances are held with financial institutions that are investment grade rated.
NOTE 8 — Trade and Other Receivables
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Trade
.........................................................
$
163
$
89
VAT, income taxes and other
........................................
39
51
$
202
$
140
The ageing of trade receivables was as follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Current
.......................................................
$
118
$
59
1 to 30 days
....................................................
24
20
31 days and thereafter
.............................................
42
35
184
114
Allowance for expected credit losses
...................................
(21)
(26)
$
163
$
89
NOTE 9 — Inventories
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Food, beverages and hotel supplies, net
..................................
$
93
$
77
Fuel
..........................................................
76
48
Other
..........................................................
24
21
$
193
$
146
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
93
NOTE 10 — Property and Equipment
(in millions)
Ships
and ship
improvements
Other
property
and
equipment
Total
Cost
At November 30, 2020
...............................
$
19,813
$
1,676
$ 21,489
Exchange movements
..............................
(829)
(40)
(869)
Additions
......................................
1,672
55
1,727
Disposals
......................................
(268)
(51)
(319)
At November 30, 2021
.............................
20,388
1,640
22,028
Exchange movements
..............................
(2,021)
(72)
(2,093)
Additions
......................................
2,225
53
2,278
Disposals
......................................
(734)
(72)
(806)
At November 30, 2022
.............................
$
19,858
$
1,549
$ 21,407
Accumulated depreciation
At November 30, 2020
...............................
$
(5,343)
$
(921)
$
(6,264)
Exchange movements
..............................
229
23
252
Depreciation
....................................
(650)
(97)
(747)
Disposals
......................................
242
49
291
Impairments
....................................
(607)
—
(607)
At November 30, 2021
...............................
(6,129)
(946)
(7,075)
Exchange movements
..............................
529
43
572
Depreciation
....................................
(640)
(101)
(741)
Disposals
......................................
398
69
467
Impairments
....................................
(1,149)
(12)
(1,161)
At November 30, 2022
.............................
$
(6,991)
$
(947)
$
(7,938)
Net book value
At November 30, 2021
.............................
$
14,259
$
694
$ 14,953
At November 30, 2022
.............................
$
12,867
$
602
$ 13,469
At November 30, 2022, the cost of assets under construction, which are included in the above table, totalled
$0.6 billion ($1.1 billion at November 30, 2021).
At November 30, 2022, the net book value of assets is shown after deducting government construction
grants of an immaterial amount ($50 million at November 30, 2021).
Capitalised interest amounted to $18 million in 2022 ($43 million in 2021). The interest capitalisation rate is
based on the weighted-average interest rates applicable to borrowings within the DLC during each period.
During 2022, the average capitalisation rate was 4.7% (2021 5.8%).
The continued effects of the pandemic on our business and certain Asia markets, which remain closed to
cruising (particularly China), and our updated expectations for the removal of two ships from our fleet
resulted in an impairment trigger relating to these two ships. We determined that these two ships each had a
net carrying value which exceeded its respective recoverable value based on estimated sales prices and
recognized ship impairment charges of $0.2 billion during 2022.
In addition, as a result of the continued effects of the pandemic, inflation, higher fuel prices and higher
interest rates on our business, we performed an impairment assessment for our remaining EA segment ships
at the CGU (or cruise brand) level. We determined that for one of the four CGUs assessed, the carrying
value exceeded its recoverable value and we recognized additional ship impairment charges of $0.9 billion in
the current year. The 2022 impairment charge was related to the Costa Cruises (“Costa”) CGU.
In total, we recognized $1.1 billion of ship impairment charges during 2022 compared to $0.6 billion of
charges during 2021.
94
Significant Estimate — Determination of the recoverable value of one of our CGUs
We have identified the determination of the recoverable value of one of our CGUs as a significant estimate
in 2022. The determination of the fair value of our CGUs includes numerous estimates and underlying
assumptions that are subject to various risks and uncertainties. We believe we have made reasonable estimates
and judgements as part of our assessments. The assumptions resulting in key sources of estimation
uncertainty, all of which are considered Level 3 inputs, used in our discounted cash flow analyses consisted
of:
• Short-term continued improvement in net cruise revenue (cruise revenues net of our most variable
costs) per ALBD to pre-pause levels adjusted for deployment changes and inflation
• Weighted-average cost of capital of market participants, adjusted for the risk attributable to the
geographic regions in which the cruise brand operates (“WACC”). For the one CGU with a recognized
impairment, WACC was 14.1% in the most recent analyses from 9.4% in 2021. Had the 2021
WACC been applied to the 2022 expected cash flows, no impairment would have been indicated.
Both the discounted cash flows and the WACC used in our assessments are adjusted for the impact
of inflation.
• Long-term marginal growth in net cruise revenue (cruise revenues net of our most variable costs) per
ALBD beyond inflationary changes based on long-term historical averages
Other assumptions in our cash flow analyses consisted of:
• Fuel price
• Climate change related regulatory costs within a range of current market expectations (starting at
$70 per metric ton of carbon emissions in 2025 and increasing over time)
• Capital expenditures for our ships, including in relation to anticipated newbuilds and ongoing costs
required for us to comply with, or exceed, all relevant legal and statutory requirements related to HESS
and sustainability
• Newbuilds on order
We performed quantitative sensitivity analyses as of November 30, 2022 to determine the effect of changes
in the key sources of estimation uncertainty. For one of the four CGUs assessed, the sensitivities performed
resulted in further impairment. For the other CGUs, the sensitivities performed resulted in no change to
our conclusion that no impairment was indicated. The following table summarizes the sensitivity analysis
performed on the CGU which was most sensitive and its impact on impairment:
Key assumptions
Short-term continued
improvement in net cruise
revenue per ALBD to
pre-pause levels adjusted
for deployment changes and
inflation
WACC
Long-term marginal
growth in net cruise revenue
per ALBD beyond
inflationary changes based
on long-term historical
averages
Revenue
per
ALBD
10%
lower in 2023 and 2024
1% increase
Revenue growth per ALBD
limited to inflation
Impact
Additional impairment of
$191 million
Additional impairment of
$215 million
Additional impairment of
$523 million
In 2021, we performed impairment reviews on certain ships in our fleet, selected utilizing our judgement
through a risk-based approach taking into consideration the remaining life (less than 15 years) of each ship
or an expectation of probable disposal significantly ahead of the end of its useful life. If the net carrying
value of the ship exceeded its estimated recoverable amount, we recognized an impairment charge. The
estimated recoverable amount reflects the higher of the ship’s fair value less cost to sell and its value in use. In
the majority of cases, this resulted in an impairment based on the ships estimated selling value, less cost of
disposal. In total, we recognized ship impairment charges of $0.6 billion during 2021.
Refer to Note 2 — “Significant Accounting Policies, Significant Accounting Estimates, Assumptions and
Judgements” for additional discussion.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
95
Significant Estimate — Determination of ship useful lives and residual values
We have estimated our ships’useful lives at 30 years and residual values at 15% of our original ship cost.
Our ship useful life and residual value estimates take into consideration the estimated weighted-average useful
lives of the ships’ major component systems, such as hull, superstructure, main electric, engines and
cabins. We also take into consideration the impact of technological changes, historical useful lives of similarly-
built ships, long-term cruise and vacation market conditions and regulatory changes, including those
related to the environment and climate change. We determine the residual value of our ships based on our
long-term estimates of their resale value at the end of their useful life to us but before the end of their physical
and economic lives to others, historical resale values of our and other cruise ships as well as our expectations
of the long-term viability of the secondary cruise ship market. We review estimated useful lives and
residual values for reasonableness at period end or whenever events or circumstances significantly change.
Since the pause of our guest cruise operations, we have disposed of ships for amounts significantly below their
book value. Management has estimated that this trend will normalize in the coming years.
The IMO is currently considering various proposals which build on existing regulations and aim to further
reduce GHG emissions within the global shipping industry. In addition, the EU has proposed several
regulations that will likely impact the cost of fossil fuels, including the recently agreed inclusion of maritime
shipping in the EU’s Emission Trading System which is in the process of being adopted. We have established
Climate Action Goals, which include a carbon intensity reduction goal of 20% by 2030 from the 2019 baseline
and aspire to achieve net carbon-neutral ship operations by 2050. Given a 30-year estimated useful life for
our ships, our most recently delivered vessels’ lives will extend beyond this 2050 date. Fossil fuels are currently
the only viable option for our industry and it is not clear when alternative fuels or other technologies will
be commercially viable. While alternative fuels may provide a path to decarbonization for the maritime
industry, there are significant supply challenges that must be resolved before viability is reached. We are
closely monitoring technology developments and partnering with key organizations on research and
development to support our sustainability goals and aspirations. Our fleet’s engines are capable of being
modified for use with certain alternative fuels and we have begun to test the use of marine biofuel blends on
certain ships in our fleet. In addition, and in support of our Climate Action Goals, we invest in technologies,
including the use of LNG powered cruise ships, the installation of Advanced Air Quality Systems on board
our ships to aid in the reduction of sulfur emissions, the use of shore power, enabling ships to use shoreside
electric power where available while in port and various other efficiency related upgrades intended to reduce
our emissions. It is uncertain how proposed and possible regulatory changes related to the environment
and climate change and our 2050 aspirations, may impact our ships’useful lives and residual values and the
impact is dependent on future regulatory actions and technological advances. As of November 30, 2022,
the Directors concluded that there were no changes in our ship useful lives and residual value estimates.
The Directors considered, if materially different conditions existed, or if there was a material change in the
assumption of ship useful lives, then depreciation expense, loss on retirement of ship components and net
book value of ships would be materially different.
Our 2022 ship depreciation expense would have increased by approximately:
• $19 million assuming management reduced its estimated 30-year ship useful life estimate by one year
at the time it took delivery or acquired each of its ships
• $96 million assuming management had estimated its ships to have no residual value
Ship Sales
During 2022, we entered into an agreement to sell one EA segment ship and completed the sale of one EA
segment ship, which collectively represents a passenger-capacity reduction of 4,110 berths. In December 2022,
we entered into an agreement to sell one EA segment ship, which represents a passenger-capacity reduction
of 1,270 berths.
96
NOTE 11 — Leases
The balance sheet shows the following amounts:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Right-of-use assets
Port facilities
..........................................
$
155
$
185
Real estate
............................................
111
132
Other
................................................
16
16
$
283
$
333
Lease liabilities
Current
..............................................
$
33
$
35
Non-current
...........................................
256
298
$
289
$
333
The Statements of Income (Loss) includes the following amounts:
Year Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Depreciation charge for right-of-use assets
Port facilities
..............................................
$
21
$
23
Real estate
...............................................
15
17
Other
...................................................
2
2
$
38
$
42
Interest expense
............................................
$
14
$
14
Variable and short-term costs related to leases were not material to our consolidated financial statements.
The cash outflow for leases was materially consistent with lease expense recognized during 2022 and 2021.
Refer to Note 25 — “Supplemental Cash Flow Information”for more details.
During 2022 and 2021, we obtained $21 million and $61 million of right-of-use assets in exchange for new
lease liabilities.
Refer to Note 24 “Fair Value Measurements, Derivative Instruments and Hedging Activities and Financial
Risk”for Maturities of Lease Liabilities.
NOTE 12 — Goodwill
The changes in the carrying amounts of our goodwill were as follows:
(in millions)
At November 30, 2020
...................................................
$
284
Impairment charges
.....................................................
(280)
Exchange movements
....................................................
(5)
At November 30, 2021
...................................................
$
—
As a result of the continued resumption of guest cruise operations and its effect on our expected future
operating cash flows, we performed interim discounted cash flow analyses for all cash-generating units with
goodwill as of May 31, 2021 and determined there was no impairment. As of July 31, 2021, we performed
our annual goodwill and impairment reviews and determined there was no impairment.
As of November 30, 2021, as a result of the continued resumption of guest cruise operations, ongoing
impacts of COVID-19 and its effect on our expected future operating cash flows and the heightened risk of
future regulatory costs associated with climate change, we performed impairment analyses using discounted
cash flows for two of our EA segment CGUs and accordingly we have determined their estimated fair values
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
97
no longer exceeded their carrying values. As a result, we recognized goodwill impairment charges of
$280 million and accordingly have no remaining goodwill for our EA segment CGUs as of November 30,
2021.
For the impairment reviews, the estimated recoverable amounts were based on the higher of the cruise
brands’fair value less cost of disposal and its value in use. Recoverable amounts for our brands that carried
goodwill were determined using a discounted future cash flow analysis, after which a terminal growth rate
was applied.
NOTE 13 — Investments in Associates
We have a minority interest in the White Pass & Yukon Route (“White Pass”) that includes port, railroad
and retail operations in Skagway, Alaska. White Pass provided an immaterial amount of services to Carnival
Corporation & plc in 2022 and 2021. As a result of the effects of the pause and subsequent resumption of
our guest cruise operations on the 2022 and 2021 Alaska seasons, we evaluated whether our investment in
White Pass was other than temporarily impaired and performed impairment assessments. As a result of our
assessments, we recognized impairment charges for 2022 and 2021 of $30 million and $17 million in other
income (expense), net. As of November 30, 2022, our investment in White Pass was $50 million, consisting of
$18 million in equity and a loan of $32 million. As of November 30, 2021, our investment in White Pass
was $76 million, consisting of $49 million in equity and a loan of $27 million.
We have a minority interest in CSSC Carnival Cruise Shipping Limited (“CSSC-Carnival”), a China-based
cruise company which will operate its own fleet designed to serve the Chinese market. We provided an
immaterial amount of services to CSSC-Carnival during both 2022 and 2021 and we paid CSSC-Carnival a
total of $55 million for the lease of ships during 2021. As of November 30, 2022 and 2021, our investment
in CSSC-Carnival was $70 million and $119 million. During 2022 we did not make any capital contributions
to CSSC-Carnival. During 2021 we made capital contributions to CSSC-Carnival in the amount of
$90 million.
In addition, the Group holds other immaterial investments in associates for a total carrying value of
$24 million and $25 million as of November 30, 2022 and November 30, 2021 for total investment in
associates balance of $144 million and $220 million as of November 30, 2022 and November 30, 2021.
NOTE 14 — Other Assets
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Credit card reserves
..............................................
$
296
$
110
Long-term deposit
...............................................
229
99
VAT receivables
.................................................
98
84
Debt issuance costs
..............................................
38
71
Pension assets
..................................................
19
56
Other long-term assets and other receivables
.............................
95
97
$
775
$
517
We have agreements with a number of credit card processors that transact customer deposits related to our
cruise vacations. Certain of these agreements allow the credit card processors to request, under certain
circumstances, that we provide a reserve fund in cash. Although the agreements vary, these requirements
may generally be satisfied either through a withheld percentage of customer payments or providing cash funds
directly to the credit card processor. As of November 30, 2022 and 2021, we had $296 million and
$110 million, respectively, in reserve funds related to our customer deposits provided to satisfy these
requirements which are included within other assets. We continue to expect to provide reserve funds under
these agreements.
Debt issuance costs included in the table above are for undrawn facilities.
The Group had gross deferred tax assets of $141 million at November 30, 2022 ($132 million at November 30,
2021), which were not recognized.
98
NOTE 15 — Debt and Interest Expense
November 30,
(in millions)
Maturity
Rate (a) (b)
2022
2021
Secured Debt
Loans
EUR fixed rate
...............
Nov 2022
5.5 – 6.2%
$
—$
98
EUR floating rate
.............
Nov 2022
EURIBOR + 2.7%
—
57
Total Secured Debt
.........
—
155
Unsecured Debt
Notes
EUR Notes
.................
Oct 2029
1.0%
620
679
Loans
Floating rate
................
Feb 2023
LIBOR + 4.5%
290
290
GBP floating rate
.............
Feb 2025
SONIA + 0.9% (c)
419
467
EUR floating rate
.............
Dec 2022 – Mar 2026
EURIBOR + 1.8 – 2.4%
827
1,132
Export Credit Facilities
Floating rate
................
Dec 2026
LIBOR + 1.5%
46
26
Fixed rate
..................
Dec 2032
2.7%
569
623
EUR fixed rate
...............
Feb 2031 – Jan 2034
1.1 – 1.6%
2,592
1,551
EUR floating rate
.............
May 2024 – Nov 2034 EURIBOR + 0.2 – 1.6%
2,622
1,200
Total Unsecured Debt
.......
7,985
5,967
Total Debt
................
7,985
6,122
Less: unamortized debt issuance
costs
....................
(310)
(198)
Plus: debt modification loss
......
15
45
Total Debt, net of unamortized
debt issuance costs and debt
modification loss
..........
7,690
5,969
Less: current portion of long-term
debt
.....................
(1,329)
(486)
Long-Term Debt
............
$
6,361 $
5,484
(a)
The reference rates for substantially all of our LIBOR and EURIBOR based variable debt have 0%
floors.
(b)
The above debt tables do not include the impact of our interest rate swaps. The interest rates on some
of our debt, including Carnival Corporation & plc’s Revolving Facility, fluctuate based on the applicable
rating of senior unsecured long-term securities of Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc.
(c)
As of November 30, 2022 the interest rate for the GBP unsecured loan was linked to SONIA and
subject to a credit adjustment spread ranging from 0.03% to 0.28%. The referenced SONIA rate with
the credit adjustment spread is subject to a 0% floor. As of November 30, 2021, the reference rate used
was GBP LIBOR.
The scheduled maturities of our debt are as follows:
(in millions)
Year
Principal
Payments
2023
..............................................................
$
1,322
2024
..............................................................
879
2025
..............................................................
1,085
2026
..............................................................
638
2027
..............................................................
521
Thereafter
.........................................................
3,540
Total
.............................................................
$
7,985
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
99
Export Credit Facility Borrowings
During the year ended November 30, 2022, we borrowed $3.1 billion under export credit facilities due in
semi-annual installments through 2034. As of November 30, 2022, the net book value of the vessels subject
to negative pledges was $6.3 billion.
Revolving Credit Facilities
As of November 30, 2022 and November 30, 2021, Carnival Corporation & plc’s short-term borrowings
consisted of $0.2 billion and $2.8 billion and Carnival plc had no short-term borrowings under the Carnival
Corporation & plc’s $1.7 billion, €1.0 billion and £0.2 billion revolving credit facility (the “Revolving
Facility”). Carnival Corporation & plc may continue to re-borrow or otherwise utilize available amounts
under the Revolving Facility through August 2024, subject to satisfaction of the conditions in the facility. As
of November 30, 2022 and November 30, 2021, Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc had $2.6 billion
and $0.2 billion available for borrowing under the Revolving Facility. The Revolving Facility also includes
an emissions linked margin adjustment whereby, after the initial applicable margin is set per the margin
pricing grid, the margin may be adjusted based on performance in achieving certain agreed annual carbon
emissions goals. Carnival Corporation & plc is required to pay a commitment fee on any unutilized
portion.
Debt Holidays
In 2021, we amended all of our export credit facilities to defer approximately $0.3 billion of principal
payments that would otherwise have been due over a period commencing April 1, 2021 until May 31, 2022,
with repayments to be made over the following five years. The cumulative deferred principal amount of the
debt holiday amendments, inclusive of the amendments entered into in 2020, was approximately $0.3 billion
as of November 30, 2022. In addition, these amendments aligned the financial covenants of all our export
credit facilities with our other facilities.
Collateral Pool
The secured debt of Carnival Corporation & plc is secured on either a first or second-priority basis,
depending on the instrument, by certain collateral of Carnival Corporation & plc, which includes vessels
and certain assets related to those vessels and material intellectual property. The net book value of Carnival
plc’s vessels and certain assets related to those vessels which form part of the Carnival Corporation & plc
collateral pool is $7.4 billion as of November 30, 2022.
Covenant Compliance
As of November 30, 2022, Carnival Corporation & plc’s Revolving Facility, unsecured loans and export
credit facilities contain certain covenants listed below.
• Maintain minimum interest coverage (adjusted EBITDA to consolidated net interest charges, as
defined in the agreements) (the “Interest Coverage Covenant”) at the end of each fiscal quarter from
August 31, 2023, at a ratio of not less than 2.0 to 1.0 for the August 31, 2023 testing date, 2.5 to 1.0
for the November 30, 2023 testing date, and 3.0 to 1.0 for the February 29, 2024 testing date onwards,
or through their respective maturity dates.
• Maintain minimum issued capital and consolidated reserves (as defined in the agreements) of
$5.0 billion
• Limit its debt to capital (as defined in the agreements) percentage from the November 30, 2021
testing date until the May 31, 2023 testing date, to a percentage not to exceed 75%, following which
it will be tested at levels which decline ratably to 65% from the May 31, 2024 testing date onwards
• Maintain minimum liquidity of $1.5 billion through November 30, 2026
• Adhere to certain restrictive covenants through November 30, 2024
• Limit the amounts of our secured assets as well as secured and other indebtedness
During 2022, Carnival Corporation & plc entered into letter agreements to waive compliance with the
Interest Coverage Covenant under its Revolving Facility and $11.8 billion of $12.1 billion of its unsecured
loans and export credit facilities which contain this covenant through the February 29, 2024 testing date.
100
Subsequent to November 30, 2022, Carnival Corporation & plc entered into further letter agreements to
waive compliance with the Interest Coverage Covenant under the remaining $0.3 billion of its unsecured
loans and export credit facilities which contain the covenant through the February 29, 2024 testing date and
its Revolving Facility through the May 31, 2024 testing date. Carnival Corporation & plc will be required
to comply beginning with the next testing date of May 31, 2024 or August 31, 2024, as applicable.
At November 30, 2022, Carnival Corporation & plc was in compliance with the applicable covenants under
its debt agreements. Generally, if an event of default under any debt agreement occurs, then, pursuant to
cross-default and/or cross-acceleration clauses therein, substantially all of its outstanding debt and derivative
contract payables could become due, and our debt and derivative contracts could be terminated. Any
financial covenant amendment may lead to increased costs, increased interest rates, additional restrictive
covenants and other available lender protections that would be applicable.
Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc and certain of our subsidiaries have guaranteed substantially all of
our indebtedness.
Modifications
During the years-ended November 30, 2022 and November 30, 2021, we recognized a gain on modification
of debt of $23 million and $9 million as part of interest expense, net of capitalised interest in the
accompanying Group Statements of Income (Loss). Our interest expense, net of capitalised interest is
primarily related to our debt balance.
NOTE 16 — Accrued Liabilities and Other
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Compensation and benefits
....................................
$
192
$
196
Taxes
....................................................
44
36
Interest
..................................................
32
25
Port fees
..................................................
50
23
Other
....................................................
208
208
$
526
$
487
NOTE 17 — Other Long-Term Liabilities
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Customer deposits
.............................................
$
79
$
98
Income tax uncertainty reserve
.....................................
59
50
Deferred income taxes
..........................................
13
17
Post-employment benefits
........................................
21
32
Other long-term liabilities
........................................
29
13
$
200
$
210
Deferred income taxes are principally related to differences between (1) the book and tax methods of
calculating depreciation expense in our Holland America Princess Alaska Tours business and other North
America operations, (2) the timing of recognizing our Cozumel, Mexico port hurricane insurance settlement,
and (3) the ship depreciation and profit reserve of Costa Crociere S.p.A. and its subsidiaries.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
101
NOTE 18 — Share Capital and Reserves
(in millions)
Number of
Shares
Share
Capital
At November 30, 2020
........................................
217.4
$
361
Ordinary shares issued and fully paid
..............................
—
—
At November 30, 2021
........................................
217.4
361
Ordinary shares issued and fully paid
..............................
—
—
At November 30, 2022
........................................
217.4
$
361
There were 31.2 million shares held as treasury stock at November 30, 2022 (32.4 million shares were held
as treasury stock at November 30, 2021).
At November 30, 2022 there were 13.3 million ordinary shares at $1.66 each of Carnival plc (3.2 million at
November 30, 2021) authorized for future issuance under its employee benefit plans.
The Group merger reserve arose from the difference between the book value and the fair value of certain
businesses sold to Carnival Corporation during 2004 as part of a DLC corporate restructuring, which was
accounted for as a group reconstruction.
NOTE 19 — Post-Employment Benefits
Employee Benefit Plans
The Group is a contributing employer to three defined benefit pension plans: the P&O Princess Cruises
(UK) Pension Scheme (“Company’s UK Plan”), the multiemployer Merchant Navy Officers Pension Fund
(“MNOPF”) and the multiemployer Merchant Navy Ratings Pension Fund (“MNRPF”). The defined benefit
plans are formally valued triennially by external qualified actuaries as required by the applicable UK
regulations.
The Company’s UK Plan’s assets are managed on behalf of the trustee by independent fund managers. The
Company’s UK Plan is closed to new membership and to future benefit accrual and is undergoing its
triennial valuation. Based on the most recent valuation of the Company’s UK Plan at March 31, 2022, it
was determined that this plan was 97% funded which triggered a funding obligation under UK regulations,
and resulted in the creation of an escrow account for risk mitigation. The valuation of the Company’s UK
Plan at March 31, 2022 is currently in process and accordingly, the results are not available at this stage.
The MNOPF is a funded defined benefit multiemployer plan in which British officers employed by companies
within the Group have participated and continue to participate. The MNOPF is divided into two sections,
the “Old Section”and the “New Section”, each of which covers a different group of participants. Both the Old
Section and New Section are closed to new membership and to future benefit accrual.
The Old Section covers predecessor employers’ officers employed prior to 1978 and is fully funded. In
December 2012, the fund’s trustee completed a buy-in of the Old Section liabilities with a third-party insurer,
whereby the insurer will pay the officers’pension liabilities as they become due. Therefore, we have no
further obligation to fund this Section.
The New Section is accounted for as a defined benefit plan. Based on the most recent valuation of the New
Section at March 31, 2021, it was determined that this plan was 102% funded.
The MNRPF is also a defined benefit multiemployer pension plan available to certain of P&O Cruises
(UK)’s shipboard British personnel. This plan is closed to new membership and to future benefit accrual
and based on the most recent valuation at March 31, 2020, it was determined that this plan was 93% funded
and the deficits are to be recovered through funding contributions from participating employers. Following
a review by the new trustee board at the end of 2021, additional liabilities have been identified due to benefit
rectifications that may be required. In addition, a settlement agreement was reached in February 2022 for
rectifications in relation to ill health early retirement benefits. The Group’s share of the additional liabilities
for these items has been estimated at $23 million for which the Group recognized at November 30, 2021.
102
The recorded long-term assets (liabilities) on the Balance Sheets for the Company’s UK Plan, the Group’s
share of the MNOPF New Section and the MNRPF and other post-employment benefit liabilities were as
follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Employee benefit plans’ assets (deficits)
.............................
$
18
$
47
Other post-employment benefits
..................................
(21)
(24)
$
(3)
$
24
The employee benefit plans’information provided below relates to the Company’s UK Plan, the Group’s
share of the MNOPF New Section and the MNRPF.
The pension liabilities for accounting purposes were calculated by the Group’s qualified external actuary.
The principal assumptions used were as follows:
Company’s
UK Plan (%)
MNOPF
New Section (%)
MNRPF (%)
2022
2021
2022
2021
2022
2021
Discount rates
............
4.3
1.6
4.4
1.6
4.4
1.6
Expected rates of salary increases
2.9
2.7
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
Pension increases
Deferment
.............
2.9
2.7
2.9
2.7
2.9
2.7
Payment
...............
2.8
2.6
3.1
3.1
3.1
3.1
Inflation
................
3.3
2.7 – 3.4
3.3
3.4
3.3
3.4
Assumptions regarding future mortality experience are set based on the Self-Administered Pension Schemes
tables for the “base”mortality tables. The weighted-average life expectancy in years of a 65-year old
pensioner on the balance sheet dates was as follows:
November 30,
2022
2021
Male
....................................................
21.4
21.2
Female
...................................................
23.9
23.5
The weighted-average life expectancy in years of a 45-year old future pensioner retiring at age 65 was as
follows:
November 30,
2022
2021
Male
....................................................
22.7
22.6
Female
...................................................
25.4
25.1
The amounts recognized in the Balance Sheets for these plans were determined as follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Present value of obligations
....................................
$
(379)
$
(623)
Fair value of plans’ assets
......................................
412
684
Net assets (liabilities) before restriction on assets
......................
33
61
Restriction on assets
.........................................
(15)
(13)
Net assets (liabilities) recognized in Balance Sheets
....................
$
18
$
47
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
103
The amounts recognized in the Statements of Income (Loss) for these plans were as follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Service cost
..................................................
$
—
$
26
Interest cost on defined benefit obligation
.............................
9
10
Interest income on plans’ assets
....................................
(10)
(10)
Net interest on defined benefit liability
...............................
(1)
—
Administrative expenses
.........................................
4
4
Cost recognized in Statements of Income (Loss)
........................
$
3
$
30
Our estimated contribution to be paid into the Company’s UK Plan during 2023 is immaterial. We do not
expect to make contributions into the MNOPF or MNRPF in 2023.
The weighted average duration of the defined benefit obligation of all employee benefit plans is 14 years.
Estimated future benefit payments to be made during each of the next five fiscal years and in the aggregate
during the succeeding five fiscal years for all employee benefit plans are as follows:
(in millions)
2023
..............................................................
$
21
2024
..............................................................
$
21
2025
..............................................................
$
21
2026
..............................................................
$
22
2027
..............................................................
$
22
2028 – 2032
.........................................................
$
120
Analysis of the movements in the Balance Sheet assets (liabilities) for these plans was as follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Net assets (liabilities) at December 1,
..............................
$
47
$
22
Expenses (see above)
.........................................
(3)
(30)
Amounts recognized in the Group Statements of Comprehensive Income
(Loss)
..................................................
(22)
54
Employer contributions
.......................................
2
1
Exchange movements
........................................
(5)
—
Net assets (liabilities) at November 30,
.............................
$
18
$
47
The cumulative actuarial losses recognized in the Group Statements of Changes in Shareholders’Equity at
November 30, 2022 for these plans were $6 million ($16 million of gains at November 30, 2021).
104
Changes in the present value of defined benefit obligations for these plans were as follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Present value of obligations at December 1,
.........................
$
(623)
$
(629)
Past Service Costs
...........................................
—
(26)
Interest cost
...............................................
(9)
(9)
Benefits paid
..............................................
36
25
Administrative expenses
.......................................
(4)
—
Gain (loss) due to experience
...................................
(15)
15
Gain (loss) due to changes in financial assumptions
...................
173
(2)
Gain (loss) due to changes in demographic assumptions
................
(3)
5
Exchange movements
........................................
66
(2)
Present value of obligations at November 30,
........................
$
(379)
$
(623)
The defined benefit plans expose the Group to actuarial risks, such as longevity risk, interest rate risk,
inflation risk and market (investment) risk, including currency risk.
The sensitivity of the plans’liabilities to reasonable changes in certain key assumptions were as follows:
• 0.5% reduction in the discount rate results in an increase of $26 million
• 0.5% increase in inflation rate results in an increase of $14 million
• 1 year increase in life expectancy would result in an increase of $16 million
Changes in the fair value of these plans’ assets were as follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Fair value of plans’ assets at December 1,
..........................
$
684
$
669
Interest income on plans’ assets
.................................
10
10
Return (loss) on plans’ assets greater than discount rate
.................
(174)
32
Employer contributions
.......................................
2
1
Benefits paid
..............................................
(36)
(25)
Administrative expenses
.......................................
—
(4)
Exchange movements
........................................
(74)
1
Fair value of plans’assets at November 30,
.........................
$
412
$
684
The actual gains (losses) on these plans’ assets in 2022 were $164 million ($42 million in 2021).
These plans’ assets were comprised as follows:
November 30,
(in millions, except percentages)
2022
2021
Equities
..............................
$
44
11%
$
133
19%
Corporate bonds
........................
44
11%
—
—%
Liability matching investments
..............
324
79%
551
81%
$
412
100%
$
684
100%
Restriction on assets (a)
...................
(15)
(13)
$
397
$
671
(a)
These assets are restricted in line with the trustee agreements of the two multiemployer schemes.
Our net pension balance represents substantially all of our funded employee benefit plans.
Defined Contribution Plans
The Group has several defined contribution plans available to its employees. During 2022, the Group
expensed $13 million ($11 million in 2021) for these plans.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
105
NOTE 20 — Employees and Directors
The average number of our employees, which excludes shipboard employees who are on leave, was as
follows:
Years Ended November 30,
2022
2021
Shore employees
..........................................
6,694
5,174
Shipboard employees
.......................................
29,093
13,536
35,787
18,710
The aggregate payroll and related expenses included in both cruise operating expenses and selling and
administrative expenses were as follows:
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Salaries, wages and benefits
...................................
$
1,074
$
713
Social security and payroll taxes
...............................
59
50
Post-Employment Benefits
...................................
20
49
Share-based compensation
...................................
17
29
$
1,170
$
842
Carnival Corporation & Carnival plc operate as if they are a single economic enterprise with a single senior
executive management team and identical Boards of Directors (“Key Management”). These individuals
have the responsibility and authority for controlling, directing and planning Carnival Corporation and
Carnival plc’s activities. Except for some share-based compensation and some fees for UK-based services, the
majority of Key Management’s remuneration was borne by other companies within the DLC. Details of
the Group’s Directors’remuneration and share-based compensation are disclosed in the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Report and any relevant transactions are given in the “Related Person Transactions”
section. Additional disclosures of related party transactions are discussed in Note 1 — “General, DLC
Arrangement” and Note 21 — “Related Party Transactions.” The aggregate compensation for our Key
Management includes amounts paid by both Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc and was as follows:
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021 restated*
Fees
....................................................
$
1
$
1
Non-Equity Incentive Plan Compensation*
........................
9
12
Salaries and benefits
.........................................
7
5
Total short-term employment benefits
............................
17
19
Share-based compensation
....................................
13
16
$
30
$
35
*
The 2021 aggregate compensation has been restated to include $12 million of non-equity incentive plan
compensation, which was omitted in the 2021 presentation of this table. This amount was correctly
included within payroll and related expenses in the 2021 Statements of Income (Loss).
Government Assistance
For the years ended November 30, 2022 and 2021, the Group received government assistance under
schemes provided by various governments. The total amounts recognized by the Group during the years
ended November 30, 2022 and 2021 from these schemes were immaterial and is offset in payroll and related
expenses as well as selling and administrative expenses in the accompanying Statements of Income (Loss).
Equity Plans
We issue our share-based compensation awards, which at November 30, 2022 included time-based share
awards (restricted stock awards and restricted stock units), performance-based share awards and market-based
106
share awards (collectively “equity awards”) under the Carnival plc stock plan. Equity awards are principally
granted to management level employees and members of our Boards of Directors. The plan is administered
by a committee of independent directors (the “Committee”) that determines which employees are eligible to
participate, the monetary value or number of shares for which equity awards are to be granted and the
amounts that may be exercised or sold within a specified term. We had an aggregate of 4.3 million shares
available for future grant at November 30, 2022. We fulfill our equity award obligations using shares purchased
in the open market or with unissued or treasury shares. Our equity awards generally vest over a three-year
period, subject to earlier vesting under certain conditions.
The Group granted 699,010 equity awards at a weighted-average price of £13.03 in 2022 (1,595,820 equity
awards at a weighted-average price of £14.01 in 2021).
NOTE 21 — Related Party Transactions
Transactions with Carnival Corporation and its Subsidiaries
During 2022, Holland America Line and Princess Cruises purchased land tours from us totalling $83 million.
During 2021, Holland America Line and Princess Cruises did not purchase land tours from us. In addition,
during 2022 we sold pre- and post-cruise vacations, shore excursions and transportation services to the
Carnival Corporation group. During 2021 we did not sell pre- and post-cruise vacations, shore excursions or
transportation services to the Carnival Corporation group.
During 2022, the Group had ship charter agreements with Princess Cruises and Carnival Cruise Line for
ships operating in Australia. The total charter expense in 2022 was $88 million which was included in other
operating expenses. The Group did not have ship charter expense in 2021.
During 2022, the Group continued to provide a guarantee to the Merchant Navy Officers Pension Fund for
certain employees who have transferred from Carnival plc to a subsidiary of Carnival Corporation.
Carnival Corporation and its subsidiary, Carnival Investments Limited owned 40.6 million or 18.7% at
November 30, 2022 and 34.6 million or 15.9% at November 30, 2021 of Carnival plc’s ordinary shares, which
are non-voting.
Carnival Corporation & plc has a program that allows it to realize a net cash benefit when Carnival
Corporation common stock is trading at a premium to the price of Carnival plc ordinary shares (the “Stock
Swap Program”). Under the Stock Swap Program, Carnival Corporation & plc may elect to offer and sell
shares of Carnival Corporation common stock at prevailing market prices in ordinary brokers’transactions
and repurchase an equivalent number of Carnival plc ordinary shares in the UK market.
Within the DLC arrangement, there are instances where the Group provides services to Carnival Corporation
and also where Carnival Corporation provide services to the Group. Additional disclosures of related
party transactions are discussed in Note 1 — “General, DLC Arrangement”.
During 2022, we completed the sale of one ship to Carnival Corporation, which represents a passenger-
capacity reduction of 2,260 berths for $301 million. Subsequent to November 30, 2022, we sold two ships to
Carnival Holdings (Bermuda) Limited, a subsidiary of Carnival Corporation, for $1.5 billion. These two
ships will be chartered back to Carnival plc. We plan to sell two ships to Carnival Corporation, one in 2023
and another in 2024, in connection with Carnival Fun Italian Style™. As of the balance sheet date, we
determined that the IFRS 5
Non-current assets Held for Sale and Discontinued operations
criteria had not
been met for these planned ship sales.
NOTE 22 — Commitments
(in millions)
November 30,
November 30, 2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
Thereafter
Total
Newbuild capital
expenditures
...
$
932
$
561
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
1,493
(in millions)
November 30,
November 30, 2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
Thereafter
Total
Newbuild capital
expenditures
...
$
1,947
$
1,030
$
583
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
3,560
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
107
NOTE 23 — Contingencies
Provisions
The Group’s contingencies include estimated liabilities for crew, guest and other third-party claims. The
liabilities associated with crew illnesses and crew and guest injury claims, including all legal costs, are
estimated based on the specific merits of the individual claims or actuarially estimated based on historical
claims experience, loss development factors and other assumptions.
The changes in our contingencies were as follows:
(in millions)
At November 30, 2021
..................................................
$
120
Additional provisions
..................................................
18
Paid losses
..........................................................
(13)
Reversals
...........................................................
(13)
Changes in the discounted amount
.........................................
1
At November 30, 2022
..................................................
$
113
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Provisions
Current
................................................
$
29
$
25
Non-current
.............................................
84
94
$
113
$
120
COVID-19 Actions
As a result of the impact of COVID-19, litigation claims, enforcement actions, regulatory actions and
investigations, including, but not limited to, those arising from personal injury and loss of life, have been
and may, in the future, be asserted against us. We expect many of these claims and actions, or any settlement
of these claims and actions, to be covered by insurance and historically the maximum amount of our
liability, net of any insurance recoverables, has been limited to our self-insurance retention levels.
We have been named in a number of individual actions related to COVID-19. These actions include tort
claims based on a variety of theories, including negligence and failure to warn. The plaintiffs in these actions
allege a variety of injuries: some plaintiffs confined their claim to emotional distress, while others allege
injuries arising from testing positive for COVID-19. A smaller number of actions include wrongful death
claims. Substantially all of these individual actions have now been dismissed or settled for immaterial amounts.
As of November 30, 2022 nine purported class actions have been brought by former guests in several U.S.
federal courts, the Federal Court in Australia, and in Italy. These actions include tort claims based on a variety
of theories, including negligence, gross negligence and failure to warn, physical injuries and severe emotional
distress associated with being exposed to and/or contracting COVID-19 onboard. As of November 30,
2022, seven of these class actions have either been settled individually for immaterial amounts or had their
class allegations dismissed by the courts and only the Australian and Italian matters remain.
All COVID-19 matters seek monetary damages and most seek additional punitive damages in unspecified
amounts.
We continue to take actions to defend against the above claims.
Regulatory or Governmental Inquiries and Investigations
Legal proceedings and government investigations are subject to inherent uncertainties, and unfavorable
rulings or other events could occur. Unfavorable resolutions could involve substantial monetary damages.
In addition, in matters for which conduct remedies are sought, unfavorable resolutions could include an
injunction or other order prohibiting us from selling one or more products at all or in particular ways,
precluding particular business practices or requiring other remedies. An unfavorable outcome might result
in a material adverse impact on our business, results of operations, financial position or liquidity.
108
We have been, and may continue to be, impacted by breaches in data security and lapses in data privacy,
which occur from time to time. These can vary in scope and intent from inadvertent events to malicious
motivated attacks.
We detected ransomware attacks in December 2020 in which an unauthorized third party gained access to
certain of our information security systems, deployed ransomware, and obtained personal information related
to guests, employees and crew for some of our operations. We engaged a major cybersecurity firm to
investigate the matter and notified relevant law enforcement and regulators of the incident. The investigation,
communication and reporting phases are complete.
On June 24, 2022, we finalized a settlement with the New York Department of Financial Services (“NY
DFS”) in connection with previously disclosed cybersecurity events, pursuant to which we have paid an
amount that did not have a material impact on our financial statements. All previously disclosed cyber
incidents have now been resolved.
We have incurred legal and other costs in connection with cyber incidents that have impacted us. The
penalties and settlements paid in connection with cyber incidents over the last three years were not material.
While these incidents did not have a material adverse effect on our business, results of operations, financial
position or liquidity, no assurances can be given about the future and we may be subject to future litigation,
attacks or incidents that could have such a material adverse effect.
On March 14, 2022, the U.S. Department of Justice and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
notified Carnival Corporation & plc of potential civil penalties and injunctive relief for alleged Clean Water
Act violations by owned and operated vessels covered by the 2013 Vessel General Permit. Carnival
Corporation & plc is working with these agencies to reach a resolution of this matter. We believe the
ultimate outcome will not have a material impact on our financial statements.
On June 20, 2022, Princess Cruises notified the Australian Maritime Safety Authorization (“AMSA”) and
the flag state, Bermuda, regarding approximately six cubic meters of comminuted food waste (liquid
biodigester effluent) inadvertently discharged by
Coral Princess
inside the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park.
On June 23, 2022, the UK P&I Club N.V. provided a letter of undertaking for approximately $1.9 million
(being the estimated maximum combined penalty). We believe the ultimate outcome will not have a material
impact on our financial statements.
Other Contingent Obligations
Some of the debt contracts we enter into include indemnification provisions obligating us to make payments
to the counterparty if certain events occur. These contingencies generally relate to changes in taxes or
changes in laws which increase the lender’s costs. There are no stated or notional amounts included in the
indemnification clauses, and we are not able to estimate the maximum potential amount of future payments,
if any, under these indemnification clauses.
Refer to Note 2 — “Significant Accounting Policies”for additional information on contingencies and
insurance.
NOTE 24 — Fair Value Measurements, Derivative Instruments and Hedging Activities and Financial Risk
Fair Value Measurements
Fair value is defined as the amount that would be received for selling an asset or paid to transfer a liability
in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date and is measured using inputs
in one of the following three categories:
• Level 1 measurements are based on unadjusted quoted prices in active markets for identical assets or
liabilities that we have the ability to access. Valuation of these items does not entail a significant
amount of judgement.
• Level 2 measurements are based on quoted prices for similar assets or liabilities in active markets,
quoted prices for identical or similar assets or liabilities in markets that are not active or market data
other than quoted prices that are observable for the assets or liabilities.
• Level 3 measurements are based on unobservable data that are supported by little or no market
activity and are significant to the fair value of the assets or liabilities.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
109
Considerable judgement may be required in interpreting market data used to develop the estimates of fair
value. Accordingly, certain estimates of fair value presented herein are not necessarily indicative of the
amounts that could be realised in a current or future market exchange.
Under deeds of guarantee executed in connection with the DLC arrangement, as well as stand-alone
guarantees executed since that time, each of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc have effectively cross
guaranteed all indebtedness and certain other monetary obligations of each other. The fair value of cross
guarantees within the DLC arrangement were not significant at November 30, 2022 or 2021, and are not
expected to result in any material loss.
Financial Instruments that are not Measured at Fair Value
November 30, 2022
November 30, 2021
(in millions)
Carrying
Value
Fair
Value
Carrying
Value
Fair
Value
Liabilities
Fixed rate debt (a)
...............................
$
3,781
$ 2,020
$
2,951
$ 2,271
Floating rate debt (a)
.............................
4,204
3,087
3,171
2,763
Total
........................................
$
7,985
$ 5,107
$
6,122
$ 5,034
(a)
The debt amounts above do not include the impact of interest rate swaps or debt issuance costs. The
fair values of our other debt were estimated based on current market interest rates being applied to this
debt.
Financial Instruments that are Measured at Fair Value on a Recurring Basis
November 30, 2022
November 30, 2021
(in millions)
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Assets
Derivative financial instruments
.......
$
—
$
1
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
Total
........................
$
—
$
1
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
Liabilities
Derivative financial instruments
.......
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
5
$
—
Total
........................
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
5
$
—
Derivative Instruments and Hedging Activities
November 30,
(in millions)
Balance Sheet Location
2022
2021
Derivative assets
Derivatives designated as hedging instruments
Interest rate swaps (a)
.........................
Prepaid expenses and other
$
1
$
—
Other assets
1
—
Total derivative assets
...........................
$
1
$
—
Derivative liabilities
Derivatives designated as hedging instruments
Interest rate swaps (a)
.........................
Accrued liabilities and other
$—
$
3
Other long-term liabilities
—
2
Total derivative liabilities
.........................
$—
$
5
(a)
The Group has euro interest rate swaps designated as cash flow hedges whereby we receive floating
interest rate payments in exchange for making fixed interest rate payments. These interest rate swap
agreements effectively changed $89 million at November 30, 2022 ($147 million at November 30, 2021)
of EURIBOR-based floating rate euro debt to fixed rate euro debt. At November 30, 2022, these
interest rate swaps settle through 2025.
110
Our derivative contracts generally include rights of offset with our counterparties. We net certain of our
derivative assets and liabilities within counterparties, when applicable.
November 30, 2022
(in millions)
Gross
Amounts
Gross
Amounts
Offset in the
Balance Sheet
Total Net
Amounts
Presented in
the Balance
Sheet
Gross
Amounts not
Offset in the
Balance Sheet
Net
Amounts
Assets
....................
$
1
$
—
$
1
$
—
$
1
Liabilities
..................
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
November 30, 2021
(in millions)
Gross
Amounts
Gross
Amounts
Offset in the
Balance Sheet
Total Net
Amounts
Presented in
the Balance
Sheet
Gross
Amounts not
Offset in the
Balance Sheet
Net
Amounts
Assets
....................
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
Liabilities
.................
$
5
$
—
$
5
$
—
$
5
The effect of our derivatives qualifying and designated as hedging instruments recognized in other
comprehensive income (loss) and in net income (loss) was as follows:
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Gains (losses) recognized in reserves:
Interest rate swaps – cash flow hedges
...........................
$
9
$
4
Gains (losses) reclassified from reserves – cash flow hedges:
Interest rate swaps – Interest expense, net of capitalised interest
.........
$
(1)
$
(4)
Foreign currency zero cost collars – Depreciation and amortisation
......
$
1
$
1
There are no credit risk related contingent features in our derivative agreements. The amount of estimated
cash flow hedges’ unrealised gains and losses that are expected to be reclassified to earnings in the next
twelve months is not material.
Financial Risks
Carnival Corporation & plc manages its financial risks on a consolidated basis. The Group’s activities
expose it to a variety of financial risks such as fuel price risks, foreign currency exchange rate risk, interest
rate risk, credit risk and liquidity risk.
The annual financial statements do not include all financial risk management information and disclosures;
as such, they should be read in conjunction with the DLC Financial Statements, which are included in the
Carnival plc Annual Report, but do not form part of these Carnival plc financial statements.
Fuel Price Risks
We manage our exposure to fuel price risk by managing our consumption of fuel. Substantially all of our
exposure to market risk for changes in fuel prices relates to the consumption of fuel on our ships. We manage
fuel consumption through ship maintenance practices, modifying our itineraries and implementing
innovative technologies.
Foreign Currency Exchange Rate Risks
Overall Strategy
We manage our exposure to fluctuations in foreign currency exchange rates through our normal operating
and financing activities, including netting certain exposures to take advantage of any natural offsets and,
when considered appropriate, through the use of derivative and non-derivative financial instruments. Our
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
111
primary focus is to monitor our exposure to, and manage, the economic foreign currency exchange risks
faced by our operations and realised if we exchange one currency for another. We consider hedging certain
of our ship commitments and net investments in foreign operations. The financial impacts of our hedging
instruments generally offset the changes in the underlying exposures being hedged.
Operational Currency Risks
Our operations primarily utilize the U.S. dollar, Euro, Sterling or the Australian dollar as their functional
currencies. Our operations also have revenue and expenses denominated in non-functional currencies.
Movements in foreign currency exchange rates affect our financial statements.
Investment Currency Risks
We consider our investments in foreign operations to be denominated in stable currencies and of a long-term
nature. We partially mitigate the currency exposure of our investments in foreign operations by designating
a portion of our foreign currency debt and derivatives as hedges of these investments. As of November 30,
2022, we have designated $419 million of our sterling-denominated debt and $139 million of amounts
owed to the Carnival Corporation group as non-derivative hedges of our net investments in foreign
operations. In 2022, we recognized $64 million of gains on these non-derivative net investment hedges in the
cumulative translation adjustment section of other comprehensive income (loss). We also have euro-
denominated debt which provides an economic offset for our operations with euro functional currency.
The exchange rates for each of our major currencies were as follows:
November 30, 2022
2022 average
exchange rate
November 30, 2021
2021 average
exchange rate
USD to 1:
AUD
..................
$
0.66
$
0.70
$
0.71
$
0.75
CAD
..................
$
0.74
$
0.77
$
0.78
$
0.80
EUR
..................
$
1.03
$
1.06
$
1.13
$
1.19
GBP
...................
$
1.20
$
1.25
$
1.33
$
1.38
If the November 30, 2021 currency exchange rates had been used to translate our November 30, 2022
non-U.S. dollar functional currency operations’assets and liabilities (instead of the November 30, 2022 U.S.
dollar exchange rates), our total assets would have been higher by $1.5 billion and our total liabilities
would have been higher by $1.0 billion.
In addition, based on a 10% change in the U.S. dollar to Euro, Sterling and the Australian dollar exchange
rates at November 30, 2022, which are the functional currencies we translate into our U.S. dollar reporting
currency, we estimate our 2022 cumulative translation adjustment would have changed by $260 million.
Newbuild Currency Risks
Our shipbuilding contracts are typically denominated in euros. Our decision to hedge a non-functional
currency ship commitment for our cruise brands is made on a case-by-case basis, considering the amount
and duration of the exposure, market volatility, economic trends, our overall expected net cash flows by
currency and other offsetting risks.
At November 30, 2022, our remaining newbuild currency exchange rate risk primarily relates to euro-
denominated newbuild contract payments for non-euro functional currency brands, which represent a total
unhedged commitment of $1.4 billion for newbuilds scheduled to be delivered through 2024.
The cost of shipbuilding orders that we may place in the future that are denominated in a different currency
than our cruise brands’will be affected by foreign currency exchange rate fluctuations. These foreign
currency exchange rate fluctuations may affect our decision to order new cruise ships.
112
Interest Rate Risks
We manage our exposure to fluctuations in interest rates through our debt portfolio management and
investment strategies. We evaluate our debt portfolio to determine whether to make periodic adjustments to
the mix of fixed and floating rate debt through the use of interest rate swaps and the issuance of new
debt. The composition of our debt, after the effect of interest rate swaps, was as follows:
November 30,
2022
2021
Fixed rate
............................................
7%
10%
EUR fixed rate
.........................................
41%
40%
Floating rate
..........................................
4%
5%
EUR floating rate
.......................................
42%
37%
GBP floating rate
.......................................
5%
8%
The interest rate profiles and maturities of financial assets at November 30, 2022 solely relate to cash and
cash equivalents of $251 million in the year 2023. The interest rate profiles and maturities of financial assets
at November 30, 2021 solely relate to cash and cash equivalents of $434 million in the year 2022.
Refer to Note 15 — “Debt and Interest Expense” for debt interest rate profiles and maturities at
November 30, 2022 and November 30, 2021.
We have fixed and floating rate debt and use interest rate swaps to manage our interest rate exposure in
order to achieve a desired proportion of fixed and floating rate debt. Based upon a 10% change in the
November 30, 2022 market interest rates, our 2022 interest expense on floating rate debt, including the effect
of our interest rate swaps, would have changed by $11 million.
Concentrations of Credit Risks
As part of our ongoing control procedures, we monitor concentrations of credit risk associated with
financial and other institutions with which we conduct significant business. We seek to manage these credit
risk exposures, including counterparty nonperformance primarily associated with our cash equivalents,
investments, notes receivables, reserve funds related to customer deposits, future financing facilities, contingent
obligations, derivative instruments, insurance contracts, long-term ship charters and new ship progress
payment guarantees, by:
• Conducting business with well-established financial institutions, insurance companies and export
credit agencies
• Diversifying our counterparties
• Having guidelines regarding credit ratings and investment maturities that we follow to help safeguard
liquidity and minimise risk
• Generally requiring collateral and/or guarantees to support notes receivable on significant asset sales,
long-term ship charters and new ship progress payments to shipyards
At November 30, 2022, our exposures under derivative instruments were not material. We also monitor the
creditworthiness of travel agencies and tour operators in Australia and Europe and credit and debit card
providers to which we extend credit in the normal course of our business. Concentrations of credit risk
associated with trade receivables and other receivables, charter-hire agreements and contingent obligations
are not considered to be material, principally due to the large number of unrelated accounts, the nature of
these contingent obligations and their short maturities. Normally, we have not required collateral or other
security to support normal credit sales. Historically, we have not experienced significant credit losses, including
counterparty nonperformance; however, because of the continued effects the pandemic is having on
economies, we have experienced, and may continue to experience, an increase in credit losses.
Our credit exposure also includes contingent obligations related to cash payments received directly by travel
agents and tour operators for cash collected by them on cruise sales in Australia and most of Europe
where we are obligated to honour our guests’cruise payments made by them to their travel agents and tour
operators regardless of whether we have received these payments.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
113
Capital Management
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc operate a DLC arrangement. The two companies operate as a single
economic enterprise. Under deeds of guarantee executed in connection with the DLC arrangement, as
well as stand-alone guarantees executed since that time, each of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc have
effectively cross guaranteed all indebtedness and certain other monetary obligations of each other.
Under the terms of the DLC arrangement, Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are permitted to transfer
assets between the companies, make loans to or investments in each other and otherwise enter into
intercompany transactions. In addition, the cash flows and assets of one company are required to be used
to pay the obligations of the other company, if necessary. Accordingly, capital is managed at the Carnival
Corporation & plc level.
As of November 30, 2022, Carnival Corporation & plc had $8.6 billion of liquidity (see Note 1 — “General”
for further details on liquidity). Carnival Corporation & plc will continue to pursue various opportunities
to raise additional capital to fund obligations associated with future debt maturities and/or to extend the
maturity dates associated with its existing indebtedness including its Revolving Facility and obtain relevant
financial covenant amendments or waivers, if needed. Actions to raise capital may include issuances of
debt, convertible debt or equity in private or public transactions or entering into new and extended credit
facilities. Since March 2020, Carnival Corporation & plc has raised $28.5 billion through a series of financing
transactions.
The net debt to capital percentage of the Carnival plc Group was calculated as follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Total debt
.............................................
$
7,690
$
5,969
Cash equivalents
.........................................
(61)
(92)
Net debt
..............................................
7,629
5,878
Shareholders’ (deficit) equity
................................
(940)
2,347
Total capital
............................................
$
6,689
$
8,224
Net debt to capital percentage
...............................
114%
71%
Liquidity Risks
Typically, Carnival Corporation & plc debt financing agreements allow for either Carnival Corporation or
Carnival plc to draw under the facilities, with the non-borrowing entity as guarantor.
As of November 30, 2022, Carnival plc had $2.9 billion of liquidity, including cash and borrowings
available to draw by either Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc under the Revolving Facility. As of
November 30, 2022 and November 30, 2021, Carnival plc had no short-term obligations. In addition, Carnival
Corporation & plc had $8.6 billion of liquidity and has an additional $2.2 billion of undrawn export credit
facilities to fund ship deliveries planned through 2024, of which $1.4 billion were for Carnival plc planned ship
deliveries. See Note 1 — “General”for further details on our liquidity risk and how we plan to fund our
cash requirements, which is assessed for Carnival Corporation & plc combined, given the DLC arrangement.
(in billions)
2023
2024
Future export credit facilities at November 30, 2022
.......................
$
0.8
$
1.4
The unfunded export credit facilities are subject to the same covenants as disclosed in Note 15 — “Debt
and Interest Expense”.
114
The summary of the maturity profiles of the financial liabilities at November 30, 2022 and 2021 were as
follows:
(in millions)
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
Thereafter
Total
November 30, 2022
Debt including future interest . .
$ 1,498
$ 1,045
$ 1,205
$ 730
$ 598
$
3,767
$
8,843
Trade payables, accrued
liabilities and other
.......
997
—
—
—
—
—
997
Lease liabilities
............
44
43
40
37
33
165
363
Contingencies and other
long-term liabilities
.......
—
51
31
15
28
63
188
At November 30, 2022
.......
$ 2,539
$ 1,139
$ 1,276
$ 782
$ 659
$
3,995
$ 10,390
(in millions)
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
Thereafter
Total
November 30, 2021
Debt including future interest . .
$
528
$ 1,324
$
795
$
984
$ 469
$
2,455
$ 6,554
Trade payables, accrued
liabilities and other
.......
863
—
—
—
—
—
863
Lease liabilities
............
50
48
44
39
35
206
423
Contingencies and other
long-term liabilities
.......
—
47
31
24
19
61
183
At November 30, 2021
.......
$ 1,442
$ 1,419
$
870
$ 1,047
$ 524
$
2,722
$ 8,023
Under the terms of the DLC arrangement, Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are permitted to transfer
assets between the companies, make loans to or investments in each other and otherwise enter into
intercompany transactions. In addition, the cash flows and assets of one company are required to be used
to pay the obligations of the other company, if necessary. Amounts owed between Carnival Corporation and
Carnival plc do not have a stated maturity date, as the two companies operate as a single economic enterprise
and are therefore not included in the above table. Substantially all financial liabilities are held at amortized
cost. The fair values of our financial liabilities not included in the table above approximate their book values.
NOTE 25 — Supplemental Cash Flow Information
Reconciliation of Liabilities Arising from Financing Activities
(in millions)
November 30,
2021
Financing
Cash
Flows
Receipts/
(Payments)
Exchange
Movements
Other
Movements
November 30,
2022
Debt
.................
$
6,122
$
2,492 (a)
$
(629) $
—
$
7,985
Unamortized debt issuance
costs
................
$
(198) $
(147)
$
20
$
14 (b)
$
(310)
Amount owed to the Carnival
Corporation group
......
$
6,204
$
(368)
$
(211) $
—
$
5,624
Lease Liabilities
.........
$
333
$
(33)
$
(28) $
18 (c)
$
289
(a)
Issuances and repayments of long-term debt.
(b)
Includes debt issuance cost accruals, amortization and debt issuance costs recorded in other assets.
(c)
Includes additions, terminations and remeasurements of lease liabilities.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
115
(in millions)
November 30,
2020
Financing
Cash
Flows
Receipts/
(Payments)
Exchange
Movements
Other
Movements
November 30,
2021
Debt
.................
$
4,398
$
2,006 (a)
$
(280) $
(2) (b)
$
6,122
Unamortized debt issuance
costs
...............
$
(81) $
(173)
$
8
$
48 (c)
$
(198)
Amount owed to the
Carnival Corporation
group
...............
$
6,183
$
207
$
(188) $
2
$
6,204
Lease Liabilities
.........
$
320
$
(45)
$
(8) $
66 (d)
$
333
(a)
Issuances and repayments of long-term debt.
(b)
Non-cash movements of long-term debt, including a EUR floating rate loan redenominated to a USD
floating rate loan and changes to interest profiles on deferred tranches of our export credit facilities
created as part of debt holiday amendments.
(c)
Includes amortization and debt issuance costs recorded in other assets.
(d)
Includes additions, terminations and remeasurements of lease liabilities.
116
CARNIVAL PLC
PARENT COMPANY BALANCE SHEETS
(in millions)
November 30,
Notes
2022
2021
ASSETS
Current Assets
Cash and cash equivalents
.............................
2
$
68
$
99
Trade and other receivables, net
.........................
3
75
50
Inventories
........................................
72
38
Prepaid expenses and other
............................
116
46
Total current assets
................................
332
232
Property and Equipment, Net
.............................
4
4,047
4,408
Right-of-Use Assets
...................................
5
218
253
Investments in Associates
................................
50
76
Other Assets
........................................
6
635
389
Receivables from Subsidiaries
.............................
116
119
Loans Owed from Subsidiaries
............................
2,795
2,986
Investments in Subsidiaries
...............................
7
7,013
7,141
$
15,206
$
15,605
LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY
Current Liabilities
Current portion of long-term debt
.......................
$
1,238
$
264
Current portion of lease liabilities
........................
5
21
22
Accounts payable
...................................
169
108
Accrued liabilities and other
............................
8
209
203
Customer deposits
..................................
1,012
489
Amount owed to the Carnival Corporation group
.............
5,662
6,255
Total current liabilities
..............................
8,312
7,341
Long-Term Debt
.....................................
5,925
4,738
Long-Term Lease Liabilities
.............................
5
208
241
Contingencies
.......................................
40
47
Other Long-Term Liabilities
.............................
9
84
102
Shareholders’ Equity
...................................
Share capital
......................................
10
361
361
Share premium
.....................................
143
143
Retained earnings
...................................
1,903
4,559
Other reserves
.....................................
(1,769)
(1,926)
Total shareholders’ equity
............................
637
3,136
$
15,206
$
15,605
Net income (loss) for the Carnival plc Parent Company was ($2.6) billion in 2022 and ($3.0) billion in 2021.
The accompanying notes are an integral part of the Carnival plc Parent Company financial statements.
The Carnival plc Parent Company financial statements (registered number 04039524) were authorised for
issue by the Boards of Directors on January 27, 2023 and signed on their behalf by
Micky Arison
Josh Weinstein
Chair of the Boards of Directors
President, Chief Executive Officer and Chief
Climate Officer and Director
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
117
CARNIVAL PLC
PARENT COMPANY STATEMENTS OF CHANGES IN SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY
(in millions)
Reserves
Share
capital
Share
premium
Retained
earnings
Translation
reserve
Cash
flow
hedges
Treasury
shares
Other
reserves
Merger
reserve
Total
Total
shareholders’
equity
At November 30, 2020
...
$
361
$
185
$
7,609
$
(257)
$
8
$ (1,945)
$
36
$
36
$ (2,122)
$
6,032
Comprehensive income
(loss)
Net income (loss)
.....
—
—
(2,980)
—
—
—
—
—
—
(2,980)
Changes in foreign
currency translation
adjustment
.......
—
—
—
(4)
—
—
—
—
(4)
(4)
Net gains on cash flow
derivative hedges
...
—
—
—
—
3
—
—
—
3
3
Remeasurements of
post-employment
benefit obligations . . .
—
—
55
—
—
—
—
—
—
55
Total comprehensive
income (loss)
......
—
—
(2,925)
(4)
3
—
—
—
(2)
(2,926)
Issuance of treasury
shares for vested
share-based awards
..
—
—
(126)
—
—
126
—
—
126
—
Other, net
.........
—
(42)
1
—
—
—
71
—
71
30
At November 30, 2021
...
361
143
4,559
(261)
11
(1,818)
107
36
(1,926)
3,136
Comprehensive income
(loss)
Net income (loss)
.....
—
—
(2,552)
—
—
—
—
—
—
(2,552)
Changes in foreign
currency translation
adjustment
.......
—
—
—
53
—
—
—
—
53
53
Net gains on cash flow
derivative hedges
...
—
—
—
—
9
—
—
—
9
9
Remeasurements of
post-employment
benefit obligations . . .
—
—
(19)
—
—
—
—
—
—
(19)
Total comprehensive
income (loss)
......
—
—
(2,571)
53
9
—
—
—
62
(2,510)
Issuance of treasury
shares for vested
share-based awards
..
—
—
(85)
—
—
85
—
—
85
—
Other, net
.........
—
—
—
(2)
2
—
10
—
10
11
At November 30, 2022
...
$
361
$
143
$
1,903
$
(211)
$
22
$ (1,734)
$ 117
$
36
$ (1,769)
$
637
The accompanying notes are an integral part of the Parent Company financial statements.
118
NOTE 1 — Significant Accounting Policies
Basis of Preparation
Carnival plc was incorporated in England and Wales in 2000 and is domiciled in the UK with its headquarters
located at Carnival House, 100 Harbour Parade, Southampton, Hampshire, SO15 1ST, UK (registration
number 04039524). The Parent Company is a public limited company which is listed on the London Stock
Exchange. In addition, the Parent Company’s shares are traded on the New York Stock Exchange in the form
of American Depository Shares (ADSs). The Parent Company financial statements are presented in U.S.
dollars unless otherwise noted. They are prepared on a going concern basis under the historical cost
convention, except for certain financial assets and liabilities (including derivative instruments) that are
stated at fair value.
These financial statements were prepared in accordance with Financial Reporting Standard 101 Reduced
Disclosure Framework (“FRS 101”). In preparing these financial statements, the Parent Company applies the
recognition, measurement and disclosure requirements of international accounting standards in conformity
with the requirements of the Companies Act 2006 (“UK-adopted IFRSs”), but makes amendments
where necessary in order to comply with Companies Act 2006 and has set out below where FRS 101 disclosure
exemptions have been taken.
Under section 408 of the Companies Act 2006 the Parent Company is exempt from the requirement to
present its own profit and loss account. In the transition to FRS 101 from EU-adopted IFRS pursuant to
Regulation (EC) No 1606/2002, the Parent Company has made no measurement and recognition adjustments.
The Parent Company is included in the consolidated Group financial statements of Carnival plc. In
accordance with FRS 101, the following exemptions from the requirements of IFRS have been applied in
the preparation of these financial statements:
• Cash Flow Statement and related notes
• Certain disclosures regarding leases
• Comparative period reconciliations for share capital, property and equipment and intangible assets
• Disclosures in respect of transactions with wholly owned subsidiaries
• Disclosures in respect of capital management
• The effects of new but not yet effective IFRSs
• Disclosures in respect of the compensation of Key Management Personnel
As the consolidated Group financial statements include the equivalent disclosures, the Parent Company has
also taken the exemptions available under FRS 101 in respect of the following disclosures:
• IFRS 2 Share Based Payments in respect of group settled share-based payments
• Certain disclosures required by IFRS 13 Fair Value Measurement, and the disclosures required by
IFRS 7 Financial Instrument Disclosures
Unless otherwise stated, the accounting policies set out below have been applied consistently to all periods
presented in these financial statements.
Significant Accounting Estimates, Assumptions and Judgements
The preparation of these financial statements requires management to make judgements, estimates and
assumptions that affect the application of policies and reported and disclosed amounts in these financial
statements. These judgments, estimates and assumptions are based on management’s best knowledge of the
relevant facts and circumstances, having regard to previous experience, but actual results may differ
materially from the amounts included in the financial statements.
Significant Judgements and Estimates
Key judgements, estimates and underlying assumptions are reviewed on an ongoing basis. Revisions to
accounting estimates are recognized in the period in which the estimate is revised if the revision affects only
that period or in the period of the revision and future periods if the revision affects both current and
future periods. The significant areas of key sources of estimation uncertainty for the year ended 2022 were
as follows:
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
119
Area (a)
Key Sources of estimation uncertainty
Reference (b)
Impairment review of Investments in
Subsidiaries
Determination of the recoverable value
of our investment
Note 7 —
“Investments in
Subsidiaries”
(a)
There were no critical accounting judgements as defined under IAS 1 for 2022.
(b)
Further details, together with sensitivities for key sources of estimation uncertainty, where appropriate
and practicable, are included within the references in the table.
Cash and Cash Equivalents
Cash and cash equivalents include investments with maturities of three months or less at acquisition that
are readily convertible to known amounts of cash, which are stated at cost and present insignificant risk of
changes in value.
Trade and Other Receivables
Although we generally require full payment from our customers prior to or concurrently with their cruise,
we grant credit terms to a relatively small portion of our revenue source. We have receivables from credit card
merchants and travel agents for cruise ticket purchases and onboard revenue. These receivables are included
within trade and other receivables, net. We have agreements with a number of credit card processors that
transact customer deposits related to our cruise vacations. Certain of these agreements allow the credit card
processors to request, under certain circumstances, that we provide a reserve fund in cash. These reserve
funds are included in other assets.
Property and Equipment
The Parent Company’s Property and Equipment accounting policies are the same as Carnival plc Group’s.
Refer to Note 2 — “Significant Accounting Policies”in the Carnival plc Group financial statements.
Leases
The Parent Company’s Lease accounting policies are the same as Carnival plc Group’s. Refer to Note 2 —
“Significant Accounting Policies”in the Carnival plc Group financial statements.
Debt and Debt Issuance Costs
The Parent Company’s Debt and debt issuance costs accounting policies are the same as Carnival plc
Group’s. Refer to Note 2 — “Significant Accounting Policies” in the Carnival plc Group financial statements.
Investments in Subsidiaries
Investments in subsidiaries are stated at cost, less any provision for impairment. Judgement is required in
assessing whether the Parent Company’s investment carrying values are impaired. We review our long-lived
assets for impairment whenever events or circumstances indicate potential impairment. In determining the
recoverable amount of investments in subsidiaries, we first consider if the investment balance exceeds the
net asset value of the subsidiary and if it does, we determine the recoverable amount by assessing the higher
of the fair value less cost to sell of the investment and its value in use. We perform a fair value assessment
of the subsidiary using discounted cash flows and applying a terminal growth rate. Refer to Note 7 —
“Investments in Subsidiaries”for additional information related to our impairments of investments in
subsidiaries.
Investments in Associates
Investments in Associates are accounted for using the equity method of accounting and are initially
recognized at cost. Interest in the net assets of such investments is included in investments in associates in
the Consolidated Balance Sheets.
Foreign Currency Translation and Transactions
The Parent Company financial statements are presented in U.S. dollars. The Parent Company is comprised
of a number of foreign entities which utilize the U.S. dollar, Euro, Sterling or the Australian dollar as their
functional currencies. Each foreign entity determines its functional currency by reference to its primary
120
economic environment. The Parent Company translates the assets and liabilities of its foreign entities that
have functional currencies other than the U.S. dollar at exchange rates in effect at the balance sheet date.
Revenues and expenses of these foreign entities are translated at the average rate for the period. Equity is
translated at historical rates and the resulting foreign currency translation adjustments are included in the
translation reserve, which is a separate component of other reserves within shareholders’equity. Therefore,
the U.S. dollar value of the non-equity translated items in the Parent Company’ financial statements will
fluctuate from period to period, depending on the changing value of the U.S. dollar versus these currencies.
The Parent Company executes transactions in a number of different currencies. At the date that the transaction
is recognized, each asset, liability, revenue, expense, gain or loss arising from the transaction is measured
and recorded in the functional currency of the recording entity using the exchange rate in effect at that date.
At each balance sheet date, recorded monetary balances denominated in a currency other than the
functional currency are adjusted using the exchange rate at the balance sheet date, with gains or losses
recorded in other income or other expense. The unrealised gains or losses on our long-term intercompany
receivables and payables which are denominated in a non-functional currency and are not expected to be
repaid in the foreseeable future are recorded in translation reserves.
Customer Deposits
Our payment terms generally require an initial deposit to confirm a reservation, with the balance due prior
to the voyage. Cash received from guests in advance of the cruise is recorded in customer deposits. These
amounts include refundable deposits. In certain situations, we have provided flexibility to guests by
allowing guests to rebook at a future date, receive future cruise credits (“FCCs”) or elect to receive refunds
in cash. We have at times issued enhanced FCCs. Enhanced FCCs provide the guest with an additional credit
value above the original cash deposit received, and the enhanced value is recognized as a discount applied
to the future cruise in the period used. We record a liability for unexpired FCCs to the extent we have received
and not refunded cash from guests for cancelled bookings. We had total customer deposits of $1.1 billion
as of November 30, 2022 and $0.6 billion as of November 30, 2021, which includes approximately $30 million
of unredeemed FCCs as of November 30, 2022. Given the uncertainty of travel demand caused by
COVID-19 and lack of comparable historical experience of FCC redemptions, we are unable to estimate
the number of FCCs that will not be used in future periods. Refunds payable to guests who have elected cash
refunds are recorded in accounts payable. During 2022 and 2021, we recognized revenues of $0.3 billion
and an immaterial amount related to our customer deposits as of November 30, 2021 and 2020. Historically,
our customer deposits balance changes due to the seasonal nature of cash collections, the recognition of
revenue, refunds of customer deposits and foreign currency changes.
Contract Costs
We recognize incremental travel agent commissions and credit and debit card fees incurred as a result of
obtaining the ticket contract as assets when paid prior to the start of a voyage. We record these amounts
within prepaid expenses and other and subsequently recognize these amounts as commissions, transportation
and other at the time of revenue recognition or at the time of voyage cancellation. We had incremental
costs of obtaining contracts with customers recognized as assets of $42 million as of November 30, 2022
and $10 million as of November 30, 2021.
2021 Cash Flow Reclassification
Following a review of the Group’s 2020 Annual Report by the Directors, subsequent to the receipt of a
letter from the Financial Reporting Council (“FRC”) (following a review by the FRC as described further
below), the Parent Company has reconsidered the cash flows for 2021 associated with long-term loans between
the Parent Company and certain of its subsidiaries within the Parent Company statement of cash flows
from financing activities to investing activities.
We previously presented these cash flows within the line “changes in amounts owed to the Carnival
Corporation group and from Group companies”within financing activities of the Parent Company statement
of cash flows along with cash flows associated with short-term funding activity between Group companies.
Following the review performed, we reconsidered the treatment of the cash flows associated with loans between
the Parent Company and Group and concluded that these cash flows for 2021 should have been classified
within investing activities in accordance with IAS 7.
For the purposes of the 2022 Annual Report and going forward, the Parent Company has adopted FRS 101
and is not required to include a cash flow statement. Had the Parent Company presented a cash flow
statement, it would have restated these figures for 2021 as displayed in the table below.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
121
(in millions)
As previously
stated
Reclassification
of loan activity
Restated
Net cash provided by (used in) investing activities
.......
$
(2,979)
$
470
$
(2,509)
Net cash provided by (used in) financing activities
.......
$
2,342
$
(470)
$
1,872
The scope of the review performed by the FRC was to consider the Group’s compliance with the UK
reporting requirements, it did not verify all the information provided. The review by the FRC was based
solely on the 2020 and 2021 Annual Report and Accounts and does not benefit from a detailed understanding
of underlying transactions, and provides no assurance that the Annual Report and Accounts are correct in
all material respects.
NOTE 2 — Cash and Cash Equivalents
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Cash
........................................................
$
39
$
20
Cash equivalents (money market funds and time deposits)
...................
29
78
$
68
$
99
Substantially all material cash balances are held with financial institutions that are investment grade rated.
Refer to Note 1 — “General” in the Carnival plc Group financial statements for additional information
regarding the cross guarantees within the DLC arrangement.
NOTE 3 — Trade and Other Receivables
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Trade
........................................................
$
53
$
43
VAT, income taxes and other
........................................
22
7
$
75
$
50
NOTE 4 — Property and Equipment
(in millions)
Ships
and ship
improvements
Other
property
and
equipment
Total
Cost
At November 30, 2021
.............................
$
6,541
$
179
$
6,720
Exchange movements
............................
(659)
(24)
(683)
Additions
....................................
310
24
334
Disposals
....................................
(38)
(11)
(49)
At November 30, 2022
...........................
$
6,154
$
168
$
6,322
Accumulated depreciation
At November 30, 2021
.............................
$
(2,207)
$
(105)
$
(2,312)
Exchange movements
............................
211
17
228
Depreciation
..................................
(211)
(24)
(235)
Disposals
....................................
33
11
44
At November 30, 2022
...........................
$
(2,174)
$
(101)
$
(2,275)
Net book value
At November 30, 2022
...........................
$
3,980
$
67
$
4,047
122
NOTE 5 — Leases
The balance sheet shows the following amounts related to leases:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Right-of-use assets
Port facilities
..............................................
$
150
$
175
Real estate
...............................................
59
72
Other
...................................................
9
6
$
218
$
253
Lease liabilities
Current
.................................................
$
21
$
22
Non-current
..............................................
208
241
$
230
$
263
During 2022 and 2021, we obtained $15 million and $76 million of right-of-use assets in exchange for new
lease liabilities.
As of November 30, 2022, maturities of lease liabilities were as follows:
(in millions)
2023
................................................................
$
31
2024
................................................................
32
2025
................................................................
32
2026
................................................................
29
2027
................................................................
28
Thereafter
............................................................
140
Total lease payments
...................................................
$
293
As of November 30, 2021, maturities of lease liabilities were as follows:
(in millions)
2022
................................................................
$
34
2023
................................................................
34
2024
................................................................
34
2025
................................................................
33
2026
................................................................
30
Thereafter
............................................................
181
Total lease payments
...................................................
$
346
NOTE 6 — Other Assets
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Credit card reserves
...........................................
$
296
$
110
Long-term deposit
...........................................
229
99
Debt issuance costs
...........................................
38
71
Post-employment benefits (a)
....................................
19
56
Other long-term assets and other receivables
.........................
53
53
$
635
$
389
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
123
(a)
All assets and obligations of Carnival plc pension plans are held by the parent company. As a result,
the balances for Group and Parent Company are the same. See Note 19 — “Post-Employment Benefits”
in the Carnival plc Group financial statements for additional information on the UK post-
employment plans and the principal risks and assumptions applicable.
NOTE 7 — Investments in Subsidiaries
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
At December 1
...............................................
$
7,141
$
6,240
Additions
..................................................
2,061
2,647
Impairments
................................................
(2,189)
(1,717)
Exchange movements
..........................................
—
(29)
At November 30
..............................................
$
7,013
$
7,141
At November 30, 2022, the Parent Company’s principal operating subsidiary was Costa Crociere S.p.A.
(“Costa Crociere”), which owns and operates the Costa and AIDA cruise brands. During the year, the
company made contributions of $2.1 billion to its subsidiary Costa Crociere, to provide liquidity, including
for the purchase of two new ships. As a result of the investment balance exceeding the net asset value of
the subsidiary, we performed impairment analyses using discounted cash flows for our investment in Costa
Crociere.
Management performed impairment analyses using discounted cash flows for the two CGUs within Costa
Crociere, Costa and AIDA. For the impairment reviews, the estimated recoverable amounts were based on the
higher of the cruise brands’fair value less cost of disposal and its value in use. As a result, the Parent
Company recorded impairment charges of $2.1 billion.
Significant Estimate — Determination of the recoverable value of our investment
We have identified the determination of the recoverable value of one of our subsidiaries, which consists of
multiple CGUs, as a significant estimate in 2022. The determination of the fair value of our CGUs includes
numerous estimates and underlying assumptions that are subject to various risks and uncertainties. We
perform fair value assessments of the CGUs using discounted cash flows and applying a terminal growth
rate. We believe that we have made reasonable estimates and judgments as part of our assessment. The
assumptions resulting in key sources of estimation uncertainty, all of which are considered Level 3 inputs,
used in our cash flow analyses consisted of:
• Short-term continued improvement in net cruise revenue (cruise revenues net of our most variable
cost) per ALBD to pre-pause levels adjusted for deployment changes and inflation
• WACC ranged from 12% to 14.1% in the most recent analyses from 8.6% to 9.4% in 2021.
• Long-term marginal growth in net cruise revenue (cruise revenues net of our most variable cost) per
ALBD beyond inflationary changes based on long term historical averages
We performed quantitative sensitivity analyses as of November 30, 2022, to determine the effect of changes
in the key sources of estimation uncertainty. The following table summarizes the sensitivity analysis
performed on the CGUs and its impact on the impairment:
Key assumptions
Short-term continued
improvement in net cruise
revenue per ALBD to
pre-pause levels adjusted
for deployment changes and
inflation
WACC
Long-term marginal growth
in net cruise revenue per
ALBD beyond inflationary
changes based on long-term
historical averages
Revenue
per
ALBD
10%
lower in 2023 and 2024
1% increase
Revenue growth per ALBD
limited to inflation
Impact
Additional impairment of
$461 million
Additional impairment of
$590 million
Additional impairment of
$641 million
124
Refer to Note 2 — “Significant Accounting Policies, Significant Accounting Estimates, Assumptions and
Judgements” for additional information.
The Parent Company’s direct and indirect undertakings, whose ownership interest is through ordinary
shares, including the UK subsidiaries exempt from the requirement to prepare individual audited accounts
or individual accounts at November 30, 2022 were as follows:
Companies (Countries of Incorporation)
Ownership
Interest
UK
Companies
House
Registration
Number
Address of Companies’ Registered
Office
United Kingdom
Carnival (UK) Limited
100%
03141044
3rd Floor, 1 Ashley Road,
Altrincham, Cheshire, WA14
2DT
Carnival Port Holdings Limited (a) (b)
100%
11523367
Carnival House, 100 Harbour
Parade, Southampton,
Hampshire, SO15 1ST
Carnival Technical Services (UK)
Limited (b)
100%
10613960
Carnival House, 100 Harbour
Parade, Southampton,
Hampshire, SO15 1ST
Costa Cruise Lines UK Limited (a) (c)
99.9%
02482631
Carnival House, 100 Harbour
Parade, Southampton,
Hampshire, SO15 1ST
P&O Princess American Holdings (a)
100%
01453164
3rd Floor, 1 Ashley Road,
Altrincham, Cheshire, WA14
2DT
P&O Princess Cruises International
Limited (b)
100%
03902746
3rd Floor, 1 Ashley Road,
Altrincham, Cheshire, WA14
2DT
P&O Princess Cruises Pension Trustee
Limited (a)
100%
04069014
3rd Floor, 1 Ashley Road,
Altrincham, Cheshire, WA14
2DT
P&O Travel Limited (a) (b) (c)
100%
00773151
3rd Floor, 1 Ashley Road,
Altrincham, Cheshire, WA14
2DT
SeaVacations Limited (a) (b)
100%
03681272
Carnival House, 100 Harbour
Parade, Southampton,
Hampshire, SO15 1ST
SeaVacations UK Limited (b) (c)
100%
03633566
Carnival House, 100 Harbour
Parade, Southampton,
Hampshire, SO15 1ST
Argentina
Costa Cruceros S.A. (c)
99.9%
Avenida Corrientes, 327, Piso 10º,
Buenos Aires
Australia
A. C. N. 098 290 834 Pty. Ltd.
100%
Level 5, 465 Victoria Avenue
Chatswood NSW 2067
Bermuda
Fleet Maritime Services (Bermuda)
Limited
100%
3rd Floor, Par-La-Ville Place, 14
Par-La-Ville Road, Hamilton
Fleet Maritime Services Holdings
(Bermuda) Limited
100%
3rd Floor, Par-La-Ville Place, 14
Par-La-Ville Road, Hamilton
Fleet Maritime Services International
Limited
100%
3rd Floor, Par-La-Ville Place, 14
Par-La-Ville Road, Hamilton
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
125
Companies (Countries of Incorporation)
Ownership
Interest
UK
Companies
House
Registration
Number
Address of Companies’ Registered
Office
Brazil
Costa Cruzeiros Agencia Maritime e
Turismo Ltda. (c)
99.9%
Av. Paulista, 460, 10º andar, Bela
Vista, São Paulo, SP 01310.100
Ibero Cruzeiros Ltda. (c)
99.9%
Av. Paulista, 460, 10º andar, Bela
Vista, São Paulo, SP 01310.100
Canada
Westmark Hotels of Canada, Ltd. (c)
100%
2900-550 Burrard Street,
Vancouver, British Columbia,
V6C0A3
China
Carnival Corporation Hong Kong
Limited
100%
Unit 1207, The Gateway Tower 1,
Harbour City, Kowloon, Hong
Kong
Costa Cruises Shipping Services
(Shanghai) Company Limited (c)
99.9%
Room 276, No 58 Wu Hua Road,
Hongkou District, Shanghai
Costa Cruises Travel Agency (Shanghai)
Co., Ltd. (c)
99.9%
Room 712, Floor 7, No 710
Siping Road, Hongkou District,
Shanghai
CSSC Carnival Cruise Operations
Limited (c)
40.0%
3806 Central Plaza, 18 Harbour
Road, Wanchai, Hong Kong
CSSC Carnival Cruise Shipping
Limited (c)
40.0%
3806 Central Plaza, 18 Harbour
Road, Wanchai, Hong Kong
CSSC Carnival (Shanghai) Cruise
Shipping Limited (c)
40.0%
Floor 1, Building 2, No. 1328
Yixian Road, Baoshan District,
Shanghai, 200439
Global Shipping Service (Shanghai) Co.,
Ltd.
100%
Room 3601L, No. 9, Lane 360
Feihong Road, Hongkou District,
Shanghai
Shanghai Coast Cruise Consulting Co.
Lda (c)
50.0%
Room 274, No 58 WuHua Road,
Hongkou District, Shanghai
World Leading Cruise Management
(Shanghai) Co., Ltd. (c)
99.5%
Room 1501-36, No. 8, Lane 803,
Shuang Cheng Road, Baoshan
District, Shanghai
Curacao
Cruise Ships Catering & Services
International N.V. (c)
99.9%
Kaya Flamboyan 9, Curaçao,
P.O. Box 812
Milestone N.V. (c)
99.9%
Kaya Flamboyan 9, Curaçao,
P.O. Box 812
Prestige Cruises N.V. (c)
99.9%
Kaya Flamboyan 9, Curaçao,
P.O. Box 812
Spanish Cruise Services N.V. (c)
99.9%
Kaya Flamboyan 9, Curaçao,
P.O. Box 812
Dominican Republic
Operadora Catalina S.r.L. (c)
99.9%
Muelle Turistico Buena Vista Sur
S/n La Romana
Finland
Carnival Technical Services Finland
Limited (c)
100%
Vattuniemenranta 2, 00210
Helsinki, FI-00210
126
Companies (Countries of Incorporation)
Ownership
Interest
UK
Companies
House
Registration
Number
Address of Companies’ Registered
Office
France
Chantier Naval de Marseille SAS (c)
33.3%
Terre Plein de Mourepiane —
Porte 4, 13015 Marseille Cedex 15
Marseille Provence Cruise Terminal
SAS (c)
50.0%
Marseille Provence Cruise
Terminal, Terminal Croisieres,
13316 Marseille Cedex 15
French Polynesia
F.P.M.SAS (c)
100%
C/O Mamao Bureaux, 121
Avenue Georges Clemenceau,
BP 43503 Fare Tony, Papeete
Germany
AIDA Kundencenter GmbH (c)
99.9%
Am Strande 4, 18055 Rostock
Carnival Maritime GmbH (c)
99.9%
Großer Grasbrook 9, 20457
Hamburg
Carnival Technical Services GmbH (c)
100%
Am Strande 4, 18055 Rostock
AIDAradio GmbH (c)
99.9%
Seilerstrasse 41-43, 20359
Hamburg
HSE Hamburg School of Entertainment
GmbH (c)
99.9%
Seilerstraße 41-43, 20359
Hamburg
India
Carnival Support Services India Private
Limited (c)
100%
Kohinoor City, Tower 2, Floor 5,
Kirol Road, Off. LBS. Marg,
Kurla West, Mumbai — 400070
Italy
APVS S.r.L. (c)
12.2%
Fondamenta San Basilio,
Fabbricato 16, 30123 Venezia
Costa Crociere S.p.A.
99.9%
Piazza Piccapietra 48, 16121
Genova
Costamed Ship Services S.r.L. (c)
50.0%
Calata delle Vele, Darsena
Nuova, Palacrociere, 17100
Savona
CSSC Carnival Italy Cruise Investment
S.r.L (c)
40.0%
Piazza Piccapietra, 48 , 16121
Genova
Ecospray Technologies S.r.L. (c)
38.2%
Via Ricotti, 5, 27058, Voghera,
Pavia
Finpax S.r.L. (c)
21.5%
Ses San Marco 2568, 30124
Venezia
Navitrans S.R.L.
100%
Via Alcide de Gaspari 45, 80311
Napoli
Piccapietra Finance S.r.l.
100%
Piazza Piccapietra, 48 , 16121
Genova
Roma Cruise Terminal S.r.L. (c)
33.3%
Via Darsena Romana, 11, 00053
Civitavecchia, Roma
Spezia & Carrara Terminal S.R.L. (c)
33.0%
Largo Michele Fiorillo 19124 La
Spezia
Stazioni Maritime S.p.A. (c)
13.3%
Ponte Dei Mille 1, 16126 Genova
Terminal Napoli S.p.A. (c)
22.5%
Stazione Marittima Molo
Angioino, 80133 Napoli
Trieste Adriatic Maritime
Initiatives S.r.L. (c)
43.4%
Punto Franco Vecchio SNC,
34145, Capannone 1, Trieste
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
127
Companies (Countries of Incorporation)
Ownership
Interest
UK
Companies
House
Registration
Number
Address of Companies’ Registered
Office
Venezia Investimenti S.r.L (c)
25.0%
Via Domenico Fiasella 16/5,
16121, Genova
Venezia Terminal Passeggeri S.p.A. (c)
11.1%
Strada Marittima Sant’Andrea
248 30135 Venezia
Welcome Travel Group S.p.A. (c)
50.0%
Via Ernesto Lugaro 15, 10126
Torino
Welcome Travel Sud S.r.L (c)
50.0%
Via Salvatore Tommasi, 62 CAP,
80135 Napoli
Welcome Travel Store S.r.L (c)
50.0%
Via Lugaro 15 — 10126, Torino
West Sicily Gate S.r.L. (c)
50.0%
Via Trapani 1/D, 90141, Palermo
Zena Cruise Terminal S.R.L (c)
40.0%
Piazza Piccapietra 48, 16121
Genova
Japan
Carnival Corporation Ports Group Japan
KK (c)
99.9%
Sanno Park Tower 12F, 2-11-1
Nagata-cho, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo
Carnival Japan, Inc.
100%
Daiwa Ginza Bldg., 6F., 6-2-1
Ginza Chuo-Ku, Tokyo 104-0061
Mexico
Cozumel Cruise Terminal S.A. de C.V.
100%
Carretera a Chankannab Km 4.5
Interior Puerta Maya Cozumel,
Quintana Roo
Cruise Terminal Services S.A. de C.V. (c)
100%
Carretera a Chankannab Km 4.5
Interior Puerta Maya Cozumel,
Quintana Roo
International Cruise Services, S.A. de C.V.
100%
c/o RVA Abogados, S.C., Rio
Duero 31, Col. Cuauhtemoc, Del.
Cuauhtemoc, Mexico City 06500
International Maritime Recruitment
Agency, S.A. de C.V.
100%
c/o RVA Abogados, S.C., Rio
Duero 31, Col. Cuauhtemoc, Del.
Cuauhtemoc, Mexico City 06500
Monaco
Prestige Cruises Management S.A.M. (c)
96.0%
Siège de la liquidation: 42
Boulevard d’Italie Monte-Carlo
Netherlands
Costa International B.V. (c)
99.9%
Telestone 8 — Teleport,
Naritaweg 165, 1043 BW,
Amsterdam
CSMART Real Estate B.V. (c)
99.9%
Zeeduinweg 9, 1361BG Almere
CSMART Real Estate C.V.
100%
Zeeduinweg 9, 1361BG Almere
Philippines
Cruise Administration Services, Inc.
100%
4th Floor Delrosario Law Centre
21st Dr cor. 20th Dr. Bonifacio
Global City, Taguig City 1645,
Metro Manila
Portugal
Grand Cruise Shipping Unipessoal LdA
100%
Rua Dr. Brito Câmara nº20, 1º —
9000-039 Funchal, Madeira
Singapore
Carnival Corporation & plc Asia Pte. Ltd.
100%
One Raffles Place, Tower 1, 1
Raffles Place, #21-01, Singapore
048616
128
Companies (Countries of Incorporation)
Ownership
Interest
UK
Companies
House
Registration
Number
Address of Companies’ Registered
Office
Costa Crociere PTE Ltd. (c)
99.9%
One Raffles Place, Tower 1, 1
Raffles Place, #21-01, Singapore
048616
South Korea
Carnival Corporation Korea Ltd.
100%
6F (Mugyo-dong), 21 Mugyo-ro,
Jung-gu, Seoul
Spain
Barcelona Cruise Terminal SLU (c)
99.9%
Vial Moll Adossat, 122 Terminal
D&E. Port de Barcelona 08039
Barcelona
Costa Cruises Customer Center SLU (c)
99.9%
Torre Mapfre, Carrer de la
Marina, 16-18, Barcelona
Holding Division Iberocruceros SLU (c)
100%
Calle Pedro Teixeira, 8 Planta 5
28020 Madrid
Iberocruceros SLU (c)
100%
Calle Pedro Teixeira, 8 Planta 5
28020 Madrid
Santa Cruz Terminal, S.L (c)
99.9%
Muelle de Ribera de la Dársena
de Anaga del Puerto de Santa
Cruz de Tenerife — 38001 Santa
Cruz de Tenerife
Switzerland
Air-Sea Holiday GmbH (c)
99.9%
Dornacherplatz 7, 4500
Solothurn
Costa Kreuzfahrten GmbH (c)
99.9%
Stampfenbachstrasse 61, 8006
Zurich
Turkey
Costa Cruises Turkey Turizm Gelisim
A.S. (c)
90.0%
Bestepe Mah, Mertebe Sok.,
Caycay Apt. No 13/3,
Yenimahalle / Ankara
United Arab Emirates
Shamal Venture Cruise Terminal LLC (c)
49.0%
303 Emaar Square Building Bur
Dubai Burj Khalifa, Dubai
United States
1972 Productions, Inc. (c)
100%
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue, Miami,
Florida 33178
A.J. Juneau Dock, LLC (c)
50.0%
1429 Tongass Avenue, Ketchikan,
Alaska 99901
Alaska Hotel Properties LLC (c)
100%
Corporation Trust Center, 1209
Orange Street, Wilmington,
Delaware 19801
CC U.S. Ventures, Inc. (c)
100%
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue, Miami,
Florida 33178
Costa Cruise Lines Inc. (c)
99.9%
880 SW 145th Ave, Suite 102,
Pembroke Pines, Florida 33027
Gibs, Inc. (c)
100%
Corporation Trust Center, 1209
Orange Street, Wilmington,
Delaware, 19801
Global Experience Innovators, Inc. (c)
100%
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue, Miami,
Florida 33178
Global Fine Arts, Inc. (c)
100%
24305 Town Center Drive, Santa
Clarita, California 91355
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
129
Companies (Countries of Incorporation)
Ownership
Interest
UK
Companies
House
Registration
Number
Address of Companies’ Registered
Office
Holland America Line Inc. (c)
100%
450 Third Avenue West, Seattle,
Washington 98119
Holland America Line U.S.A., Inc. (c)
100%
450 Third Avenue West, Seattle,
Washington 98119
Ketchikan Dock Company, LLC (c)
30.0%
55 Schoenbar Ct, Suite 201,
Ketchikan, Alaska 99901
Klondike Holdings, LLC
45.0%
251 Little Falls Drive,
Wilmington, Delaware 19808
Odds On Gaming Corporation
100%
Corporation Trust Center, 1209
Orange Street, Wilmington,
Delaware 19801
P&O Properties (California), Inc. (c)
100%
24305 Town Center Drive, Santa
Clarita, California 91355
Princess Cruises and Tours, Inc. (c)
100%
1201 North Market Street, 18th
Floor, Wilmington, Delaware
19081
Princess U.S. Holdings, Inc. (c)
100%
24305 Town Center Drive, Santa
Clarita, California 91355
Royal Hyway Tours, Inc. (c)
100%
C/O CT Corporation System,
9630 Glacier Highway, Suite 202,
Juneau, Alaska 99801
Skagway Port & Rail, Inc. (c)
45.0%
601 Union Street #3920, Seattle,
Washington 98101
Tour Alaska, LLC (c)
100%
Corporation Trust Center, 1209
Orange Street, Wilmington,
Delaware 19801
Westmark Hotels, Inc. (c)
100%
C/O CT Corporation System,
9630 Glacier Highway, Suite 202,
Juneau, Alaska 99801
Vanuatu
Carnival Vanuatu Limited
100%
Law Partners House, Kumul
Highway, Port Vila, Vanuatu
(a)
Exempt from preparing individual accounts by virtue of Section 394A of the Companies Act 2006 and
from filing individual accounts by virtue of Section 448A of the Companies Act 2006.
(b)
Exempt from preparing individual audited accounts by virtue of Section 479A of the Companies Act
2006.
(c)
Not directly owned by Carnival plc.
In order to obtain the above filing exemptions, the Parent Company will guarantee the outstanding
liabilities to which each of the above companies is subject at November 30, 2022.
130
NOTE 8 — Accrued Liabilities and Other
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Compensation and benefits
.........................................
$
50
$
55
Interest
.......................................................
29
17
Port fees
......................................................
20
5
Other
........................................................
109
126
$
209
$
203
NOTE 9 — Other Long-Term Liabilities
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Customer deposits
...............................................
$
65
$
79
Post-employment benefits
..........................................
6
16
Other long-term liabilities
..........................................
14
6
$
84
$
102
NOTE 10 — Share Capital and Reserves
(in millions)
Number of
Shares
Share
Capital
At November 30, 2021
..........................................
217.4
$
361
Ordinary shares issued and fully paid
...............................
—
—
At November 30, 2022
..........................................
217.4
$
361
There were 31.2 million shares held as treasury stock at November 30, 2022 (32.4 million shares were held
as treasury stock at November 30, 2021).
At November 30, 2022 there were 13.3 million ordinary shares at $1.66 each of Carnival plc (3.2 million at
November 30, 2021) authorized for future issuance under its employee benefit plans.
The Parent Company has two allotted and issued subscriber shares of £1 each, that carry no voting rights
and no right to receive any dividend or any amount paid on return of capital. The Parent Company has one
special voting share of £1 issued to Carnival Corporation in connection with the DLC transaction to
enable Carnival Corporation’s shareholders to vote as a group on Parent Company shareholder matters.
The Parent Company has one Equalization Share of £1 that carry’s no voting rights. At November 30, 2022
and 2021, the Parent Company had 50,000 allotted but unissued redeemable preference shares of £1 each.
The preference shares, which carry no voting rights, rank behind other classes of shares in relation to the
payment of capital on certain types of distributions from the Parent Company.
Carnival plc
Financial Statements
131
Independent auditors’ report to the members of Carnival plc
Report on the audit of the financial statements
Opinion
In our opinion, Carnival plc’s Group financial statements and Company financial statements (the “financial statements”):
•
give a true and fair view of the state of the Group’s and of the Company’s affairs as at 30 November 2022 and
of the Group’s loss and the Group’s cash flows for the year then ended;
•
the Group financial statements have been properly prepared in accordance with UK-adopted international
accounting standards as applied in accordance with the provisions of the Companies Act 2006;
•
the Company financial statements have been properly prepared in accordance with United Kingdom Generally
Accepted Accounting Practice (United Kingdom Accounting Standards, including FRS 101 “Reduced Disclosure
Framework”, and applicable law); and
•
the financial statements have been prepared in accordance with the requirements of the Companies Act 2006.
We have audited the financial statements, included within the Annual Report which comprise: the Group and Parent
Company Balance Sheets as at 30 November 2022; the Group Statements of Income (Loss) and Group Statements of
Comprehensive Income (Loss), the Group Statements of Cash Flows, and the Group and Parent Company Statements
of Changes in Shareholders’ Equity for the year then ended; and the notes to the financial statements, which include a
description of the significant accounting policies.
Our opinion is consistent with our reporting to the Audit Committee.
The Carnival Corporation & plc consolidated financial statements for 2022, prepared under U.S. Generally Accepted
Accounting Principles (referred to as either the “Carnival Corporation & plc U.S. GAAP consolidated financial
statements”or the “DLC Financial Statements”), which are included in the Carnival plc Annual Report, as other information,
do not form part of the Carnival plc Financial Statements. Accordingly, they are not within the scope of this opinion.
Basis for opinion
We conducted our audit in accordance with International Standards on Auditing (UK) (“ISAs (UK)”) and applicable
law. Our responsibilities under ISAs (UK) are further described in the Auditors’ responsibilities for the audit of the
financial statements section of our report. We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate
to provide a basis for our opinion.
Independence
We remained independent of the Group in accordance with the ethical requirements that are relevant to our audit of
the financial statements in the UK, which includes the FRC’s Ethical Standard, as applicable to listed public interest
entities, and we have fulfilled our other ethical responsibilities in accordance with these requirements.
To the best of our knowledge and belief, we declare that non-audit services prohibited by the FRC’s Ethical Standard
were not provided.
Other than those disclosed in the Corporate Governance Report, we have provided no non-audit services to the
Company or its controlled undertakings in the period under audit.
Our audit approach
Context
The prolonged pause in guest operations as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic continued to have a material negative
impact on the Group’s and Company’s financial results and liquidity during 2022. With the easing of travel restrictions,
the Group has resumed guest cruise operations and is focused on driving revenue growth and returning to strong
profitability.
As explained in the Strategic Report, a key focus of the Group is climate action, which includes their commitment to
reduce carbon emissions and their aspiration to achieve net carbon-neutral operations by 2050. More detail of how we
have responded to the impact of climate change can be found in the section entitled ‘The impact of climate risk on our
audit’ below.
132
Overview
Audit scope
•
There are thirteen components in the Carnival plc consolidation.
•
Three consolidation components were subject to an audit of their complete financial information due to their
size, namely AIDA, Costa and Carnival UK.
•
Specific audit procedures were performed by the Group team on certain balances and transactions in respect of
four other components.
•
Certain specific audit procedures were also performed at the Group’s head office in Miami, Florida by the PwC
US Carnival Corporation & plc audit engagement team across balances and transactions in a number of the
consolidation components and over certain disclosures in the Annual Report.
•
For all the component auditors for financially significant components and the members of the PwC US
Carnival Corporation & plc team, we engaged in regular telephone and video calls. In addition, we conducted
site visits to both the AIDA and Costa components in conjunction with senior members of the PwC US Carnival
Corporation & plc audit engagement team.
Key audit matters
•
Impairment review of the carrying value of ships (Group and Company)
•
Investment in subsidiaries impairment assessment (Company)
•
Impact of COVID-19 pandemic (Group and Company)
Materiality
•
Overall Group materiality: US$70 million (2021: US$56 million) based on approximately 4.4% of the absolute
net loss before income taxes and impairment charges. In the prior year this was restricted to the overall materiality
applied in 2019 and 2020. This approach was appropriate whilst the Group was in recovery following the
pandemic, due to the majority of the fleet now back in operation and in the increase in occupancy rates we have
concluded the restriction is no longer necessary.
•
Overall Company materiality: US$65 million (2021: US$ 53 million) based on 1% of total assets. For the
purposes of the audit of the Group financial statements, we determined a component materiality for the Company
of US$65 million on the basis that the Company should not have a higher materiality than the overall Group.
•
Performance materiality: US$53 million (2021: US$42 million) (Group) and US$49 million (2021: US$39 million.)
(Company).
The scope of our audit
As part of designing our audit, we determined materiality and assessed the risks of material misstatement in the
financial statements.
Key audit matters
Key audit matters are those matters that, in the auditors’professional judgement, were of most significance in the audit
of the financial statements of the current period and include the most significant assessed risks of material misstatement
(whether or not due to fraud) identified by the auditors, including those which had the greatest effect on: the overall audit
strategy; the allocation of resources in the audit; and directing the efforts of the engagement team. These matters, and
any comments we make on the results of our procedures thereon, were addressed in the context of our audit of the
financial statements as a whole, and in forming our opinion thereon, and we do not provide a separate opinion on these
matters.
This is not a complete list of all risks identified by our audit.
Impairment review of goodwill (Group and Company), which was a key audit matter last year, is no longer included
because of the goodwill carrying value being written down to nil in the prior year. Otherwise, the key audit matters below
are consistent with last year.
133
Key audit matter
How our audit addressed the key audit matter
Impairment review of the carrying value of ships (Group
and Company)
(see note 2 to the financial statements for the disclosures
of the related accounting policies and note 10 and note 4
in the parent company financial statements)
We have obtained an understanding from management
as to how the models have been constructed and the
rationale for each key assumption. As part of our work,
we also ensured they are mathematically accurate.
We assessed management’s ability to forecast by
reviewing against historical accuracy.
The Group and Company hold significant amounts of
property and equipment in the form of cruise ships, as
detailed in note 10 to the financial statements. There is a
risk that, as a result of a slower than anticipated recovery
in demand post COVID-19, as well as other macro
economic factors, the carrying value of these ships is
overstated and should be impaired.
We considered, and when needed challenged, each core
assumption in order to assess those most significant to
the conclusion reached and hence which assumptions, if
inaccurate, would indicate impairment was not required
or indeed would indicate a further shortfall which may
lead to further impairment. This included:
• forecast ship revenues and costs, by comparing them
against available industry data and expectations,
historical results, as well as current revenue booking
and cost trends;
• the discount rates applied by engaging our valuation
experts to assess their appropriateness;
• the long-term growth rates in the forecasts, by
engaging our valuation experts to assess the
reasonableness of such assumptions; and
• the impact climate change is anticipated to have on
future cash flows and assessed the appropriateness of
how management had considered these in the
construction of the impairment assessments. This
included considering the appropriateness of the value
and timing of climate change related regulatory costs.
Due to the factors above, the Directors considered that
an indication of potential impairment had occurred and
an assessment of the carrying value of ships across each
of the EA segment CGUs (“brands”) was performed.
The ship valuation models, constructed at a CGU level,
are dependent on a number of key assumptions including
forecast ship revenue net of significant variable costs,
discount rate and other assumptions including; fuel
prices and potential future regulatory costs associated
with climate change. In addition, management
considered the impairment of individual ships, planned
for disposal.
We considered the reasonableness of the remaining
assumptions, including tying back to long term trends
and assessing against the wider economic factors and
global economic uncertainty when considering demand
and cost projections.
In total, in 2022, impairment charges on ships of
US$1,149m were recognised by the Group. No ship
impairment charges were recorded in the Company.
We conducted a range of sensitivity analyses to ascertain
what would lead to a materially different outcome and to
challenge management regarding their assumptions.
We held meetings with component management teams to
corroborate that the assumptions made by Group
management align with their views of their respective
brands.
We challenged disclosures made in the financial
statements in relation to ship impairment, including with
regard to the key accounting estimates relevant to the
assessments made.
We considered management’s assessment of the ship’s
economic lives in the context of the risks posed by
climate change.
With regard to impairments recorded against specific
ships, we considered the appropriateness of estimated
sales prices based on sales contracts or comparable recent
sales.
Overall, we are satisfied that the impairments recorded in
the year and associated disclosures are appropriate.
134
Investment in subsidiaries impairment assessment
(Company)
(See note 1 to the parent company financial statements
for the Directors’ disclosures of the related accounting
policies and note 7)
Investments in subsidiaries are accounted for at cost less
provision for impairment in the Company. The Directors
identified the slower than anticipated recovery in demand
post COVID-19 as well as other macro-economic factors
as an indicator of potential impairment, and therefore
assessed whether the investments’ carrying values could
be supported by their recoverable amount.
We obtained management’s impairment assessments for
the investments in subsidiaries held by the Company.
For the investment in Costa Crociere SpA, we tested its
recoverable amount determined with reference to its
discounted future cash flows, prepared utilising the same
methodology as those models used within the CGU
models used to assess ship impairments. We tested the
reasonableness of the key assumptions used, including
revenue and cost growth rates, discount rates and costs
associated with climate change.
As a result of our work, we found the assumptions
applied in management’s analysis to be reasonable and
we are satisfied the impairment recorded in the year is
appropriate.
In developing the cash flow forecasts, the Directors
utilised consistent assumptions with those described for
ship impairments, most significantly forecast ship
revenue net of significant variable costs, discount rate
and other assumptions including; fuel prices and
potential future regulatory costs associated with climate
change.
Impairment charges totalling US$2.2bn were identified
primarily in respect of the Company’s investment in
Costa Crociere SpA
Impact of COVID-19 pandemic (Group and Company)
(See note 1 to the financial statements for the Directors’
disclosures of the related accounting policies, and note 2)
Our procedures in respect of investments and ship
impairments are set out in the respective key audit
matters above.
As described in Note 1 to the consolidated financial
statements, the continued effects of the COVID-19
pandemic, inflation, higher fuel prices, higher interest
rates, fluctuations in foreign currency rates and the
Group’s substantial debt balance have had and may
continue to have a material negative impact on the
Group’s financial results. For almost three years,
management has taken actions to manage the Group’s
liquidity, including completing various capital market
transactions, obtaining relevant financial covenant
amendments or waivers, accelerating the removal of
certain ships from the fleet and during the pause in guest
cruise operations, reducing capital expenditures and
operating expenses.
The principal assumptions used in management’s
estimate of future liquidity requirements consisted of
(i) continued cruise operations and expected timing of
cash collections for cruise bookings; (ii) expected
increases in revenue in 2023 on a per passenger basis
compared with 2019 with the relaxation of COVID-19
related protocols; (iii) expected improvement in
occupancy on a year-over-year basis returning to
historical levels in the summer of 2023; (iv) expected
stabilisation of fuel prices around November 2022
year-end prices; (v) continued stabilisation of
inflationary pressures on costs, moderated by a larger-
more efficient fleet as compared with 2019; and include
other assumptions such as; (vi) new ship deliveries,
improvements and removals.
With respect to the Directors’ going concern assessment,
the procedures we performed, and our findings are set
out in the “Conclusions relating to going concern”
section below
135
Based on these actions and assumptions, and considering
the liquidity including cash and borrowings available
under the multi-currency revolving credit facility at
30 November 2022, the Directors believe that they have
sufficient liquidity to fund obligations and expect to
remain in compliance with the Group’s financial
covenants for at least the next twelve months from the
issuance of the financial statements.
We considered the disclosures in the Going Concern and
Viability statements along with the financial statements
in respect of the impact of COVID-19 regarding
liquidity and concluded that these are appropriate.
How we tailored the audit scope
We tailored the scope of our audit to ensure that we performed enough work to be able to give an opinion on the
financial statements as a whole, taking into account the structure of the group and the company, the accounting processes
and controls, and the industry in which they operate.
Carnival plc has thirteen consolidation components. Three consolidation components, AIDA, Costa and Carnival UK
(Cunard and P&O Cruises (UK)), which are considered financially significant and together contribute over 87% of net
loss before income taxes and impairment charges to the Group results, were subject to an audit of their complete financial
information, due to their size, by local component teams. We met with local management, and we performed file reviews
of the component teams’ work via telephone and video calls for each of the AIDA, Costa and Carnival UK components.
In addition, specific audit procedures over the following FSLIs, onboard and other revenue, onboard and other costs and
Property plant and equipment in HAP Alaska as well as customer deposits in Princess Charters were performed by the
Group engagement team.
We also used a US team, who are primarily responsible for the audit of Carnival Corporation & plc, to perform certain
specified procedures across balances and transactions in a number of the consolidation components and over certain
disclosures in the Annual Report from the Group’s head office in Miami, Florida. Such procedures performed included
contributing to our assessment of the going concern basis of preparation, intercompany balances and transactions,
cash and debt balances held, and equity and reserves. We met with the US team and Group management via regular
telephone and video calls.
These, together with additional procedures performed at the Group level, including auditing the consolidation and
financial statement disclosures, gave us the evidence we needed for our opinion on the financial statements as a whole.
The impact of climate risk on our audit
As part of our audit we made enquiries of management to understand the process management adopted to assess the
extent of the potential impact of climate risk on the Group’s financial statements and support the disclosures made within
note 2 in the financial statements. In addition to enquiries with management, we also read additional reporting made
by the entity on climate including its sustainability report, and it’s Carbon Disclosure Project public submission.
We challenged the completeness of management’s climate risk assessment by challenging the consistency of management’s
climate impact assessment with internal climate plans and board minutes, including whether the time horizons
management have used take account of all relevant aspects of climate change such as transition risks. In addition, we
read the communications for details of climate related impacts.
Management has stated aspirations of achieving net zero carbon emissions by 2050 and is working on how to achieve
this. Given the stage of development of this work and the medium to long term horizon, the future financial impacts are
uncertain. We confirmed with management and the Audit Committee that the estimated financial impacts of climate
change will be reassessed prospectively and our expectation that climate change disclosures will evolve as the understanding
of the actual and potential impacts on the Group’s future operations are established with greater certainty.
In planning and executing our audit, we considered the Group’s climate change risk assessment process and this,
together with involvement of our own sustainability specialists, provided us with an understanding of the potential
impact of climate change on the financial statements. We assessed that the key financial statement line items and estimates
which are more likely to be materially impacted by climate risks are those associated with future cash flows, given the
more notable impacts of climate change on the business are expected to arise in the medium to long term. These include
the carrying value of ships and the carrying value of the Company’s investments in subsidiaries, as well as specific
consideration of the impact of climate change on likely ship ownership periods, residual value estimates for ships, and
the related impact on annual depreciation charges. Our key audit matters further explain how we evaluated the impact of
climate change.
Materiality
The scope of our audit was influenced by our application of materiality. We set certain quantitative thresholds for
materiality. These, together with qualitative considerations, helped us to determine the scope of our audit and the nature,
timing and extent of our audit procedures on the individual financial statement line items and disclosures and in
evaluating the effect of misstatements, both individually and in aggregate on the financial statements as a whole.
136
Based on our professional judgement, we determined materiality for the financial statements as a whole as follows:
Financial statements – Group
Financial statements – Company
Overall materiality
US$70 million
(2021:US$56 million).
US$65 million
(2021:US$53 million).
How we determined it
Approximately 4.4% of the absolute
net loss before income taxes and
impairment charges, in the prior
year this was restricted to the overall
materiality applied in 2019 and 2020.
This approach was appropriate
whilst the Group was in recovery
following the pandemic, due to the
majority of the fleet now back in
operation and in the increase in
occupancy rates we have concluded
the restriction is no longer necessary.
1% of total assets. For the purposes
of the audit of the Group financial
statements, we determined a
component materiality for the
Company of US$65million on the
basis that the Company should not
have a higher materiality than the
overall Group.
Rationale for benchmark applied
The primary measure of the
business performance is loss before
tax and impairment. We have used
the same benchmark as for 2021 but
given the recovery of the operations,
we have not restricted the quantum
to 2019 levels as we did in 2021
We believe that total assets is an
appropriate benchmark for the
Company as this entity is principally
an investment and financing holding
Company with some operational
activity. For the purposes of the
audit of the Group financial
statements, we determined a
component materiality for the
Company of US$65 million on the
basis that the Company should not
have a higher materiality than the
overall Group.
For each component in the scope of our group audit, we allocated a materiality that is less than our overall group
materiality. The range of materiality allocated across components was between $52 million and $65 million.
We use performance materiality to reduce to an appropriately low level the probability that the aggregate of uncorrected
and undetected misstatements exceeds overall materiality. Specifically, we use performance materiality in determining
the scope of our audit and the nature and extent of our testing of account balances, classes of transactions and disclosures,
for example in determining sample sizes. Our performance materiality was 75% (2021: 75%) of overall materiality,
amounting to US$53 million (2021: US$42 million) for the Group financial statements and US$49 million
(2021:US$39 million.) for the Company financial statements.
In determining the performance materiality, we considered a number of factors — the history of misstatements, risk
assessment and aggregation risk and the effectiveness of controls — and concluded that an amount at the upper end of
our normal range was appropriate.
We agreed with the Audit Committee that we would report to them misstatements identified during our audit above
$7 million (Group audit) (2021: $5 million) and $6 million (Company audit) (2021: $5 million) as well as misstatements
below those amounts that, in our view, warranted reporting for qualitative reasons.
Conclusions relating to going concern
Our evaluation of the Directors’assessment of the Group’s and the Company’s ability to continue to adopt the going
concern basis of accounting included:
•
Assessing management’s base case and severe but plausible downside scenario models supporting the Board’s
going concern assessment, evaluating the process by which the assessments have been drawn up, ensuring that the
calculations in the model were mathematically accurate and that the overall methodology used was appropriate;
•
Evaluating management’s base case by ensuring that the forecasts being used were aligned with the Board’s most
recent forecasts. In evaluating the inputs used in the base case scenario, we considered the key assumptions
including, occupancy levels and forecast ticket prices;
•
We considered the likelihood of the severe but plausible downside scenario modelled and whether other
scenarios including a reduced level of occupancy could arise and the associated impact on liquidity and covenant
headroom. We considered management’s ability to forecast by assessing both historical performance, current
levels of forward bookings and the impact of the global economic outlook on pricing.
•
Evaluating the committed financing facilities currently available to the Carnival Corporation & plc group and
ensuring that the models appropriately included all contractual debt repayments and committed capital
expenditures;
137
•
Agreeing to debt agreements and associated amendments secured, the covenants attached to each facility and
considering the Group’s and Company’s forecast compliance at the measurement dates included in the going
concern assessment period;
•
Agreeing the cash on hand and available facilities included in the going concern assessment to our year end
audit work; and
•
Reading the Directors’ basis of preparation note in note 1 and the disclosures provided in the Viability statement
and Going concern statement and evaluating whether they appropriately describe the Board’s consideration of
this matter.
Based on the work we have performed, we have not identified any material uncertainties relating to events or conditions
that, individually or collectively, may cast significant doubt on the Group’s and the Company’s ability to continue as a
going concern for a period of at least twelve months from when the financial statements are authorised for issue.
In auditing the financial statements, we have concluded that the Directors’use of the going concern basis of accounting
in the preparation of the financial statements is appropriate.
As not all future events or conditions can be predicted, this conclusion is not a guarantee as to the group’s and the
company’s ability to continue as a going concern.
In relation to the Directors’reporting on how they have applied the UK Corporate Governance Code, we have nothing
material to add or draw attention to in relation to the directors’statement in the financial statements about whether the
directors considered it appropriate to adopt the going concern basis of accounting.
Our responsibilities and the responsibilities of the Directors with respect to going concern are described in the relevant
sections of this report.
Reporting on other information
The other information comprises all of the information in the Annual Report other than the financial statements and
our auditors’ report thereon. The Directors are responsible for the other information. Our opinion on the financial
statements does not cover the other information and, accordingly, we do not express an audit opinion or, except to the
extent otherwise explicitly stated in this report, any form of assurance thereon.
In connection with our audit of the financial statements, our responsibility is to read the other information and, in
doing so, consider whether the other information is materially inconsistent with the financial statements or our knowledge
obtained in the audit, or otherwise appears to be materially misstated. If we identify an apparent material inconsistency
or material misstatement, we are required to perform procedures to conclude whether there is a material misstatement
of the financial statements or a material misstatement of the other information. If, based on the work we have performed,
we conclude that there is a material misstatement of this other information, we are required to report that fact. We
have nothing to report based on these responsibilities.
With respect to the Strategic report and Directors’Report, we also considered whether the disclosures required by the
UK Companies Act 2006 have been included.
Based on our work undertaken in the course of the audit, the Companies Act 2006 requires us also to report certain
opinions and matters as described below.
Strategic report and Directors’ report
In our opinion, based on the work undertaken in the course of the audit, the information given in the Strategic report
and Directors’ report for the year ended 30 November 2022 is consistent with the financial statements and has been
prepared in accordance with applicable legal requirements.
In light of the knowledge and understanding of the group and company and their environment obtained in the course
of the audit, we did not identify any material misstatements in the Strategic report and Directors’report.
Directors’ Remuneration
In our opinion, the part of the Directors’Remuneration Report to be audited has been properly prepared in accordance
with the Companies Act 2006.
Corporate governance statement
The Listing Rules require us to review the Directors’statements in relation to going concern, longer-term viability and
that part of the corporate governance statement relating to the company’s compliance with the provisions of the UK
Corporate Governance Code specified for our review. Our additional responsibilities with respect to the corporate
governance statement as other information are described in the Reporting on other information section of this report.
Based on the work undertaken as part of our audit, we have concluded that each of the following elements of the
corporate governance statement is materially consistent with the financial statements and our knowledge obtained
during the audit, and we have nothing material to add or draw attention to in relation to:
138
•
The Directors’confirmation that they have carried out a robust assessment of the emerging and principal risks;
•
The disclosures in the Annual Report that describe those principal risks, what procedures are in place to identify
emerging risks and an explanation of how these are being managed or mitigated;
•
The Directors’statement in the financial statements about whether they considered it appropriate to adopt the
going concern basis of accounting in preparing them, and their identification of any material uncertainties to the
Group’s and Company’s ability to continue to do so over a period of at least twelve months from the date of
approval of the financial statements;
•
The Directors’explanation as to their assessment of the Group’s and Company’s prospects, the period this
assessment covers and why the period is appropriate; and
•
The Directors’statement as to whether they have a reasonable expectation that the company will be able to
continue in operation and meet its liabilities as they fall due over the period of its assessment, including any related
disclosures drawing attention to any necessary qualifications or assumptions.
Our review of the Directors’statement regarding the longer-term viability of the Group and Company was substantially
less in scope than an audit and only consisted of making inquiries and considering the Directors’ process supporting
their statement; checking that the statement is in alignment with the relevant provisions of the UK Corporate Governance
Code; and considering whether the statement is consistent with the financial statements and our knowledge and
understanding of the group and company and their environment obtained in the course of the audit.
In addition, based on the work undertaken as part of our audit, we have concluded that each of the following elements
of the corporate governance statement is materially consistent with the financial statements and our knowledge obtained
during the audit:
•
The Directors’statement that they consider the Annual Report, taken as a whole, is fair, balanced and
understandable, and provides the information necessary for the members to assess the group’s and company’s
position, performance, business model and strategy;
•
The section of the Annual Report that describes the review of effectiveness of risk management and internal
control systems; and
•
The section of the Annual Report describing the work of the Audit Committee.
We have nothing to report in respect of our responsibility to report when the directors’statement relating to the
company’s compliance with the Code does not properly disclose a departure from a relevant provision of the Code
specified under the Listing Rules for review by the auditors.
Responsibilities for the financial statements and the audit
Responsibilities of the Directors for the financial statements
As explained more fully in the Statement of Directors’Responsibilities, the Directors are responsible for the preparation
of the financial statements in accordance with the applicable framework and for being satisfied that they give a true
and fair view. The Directors are also responsible for such internal control as they determine is necessary to enable the
preparation of financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.
In preparing the financial statements, the Directors are responsible for assessing the Group’s and the Company’s ability
to continue as a going concern, disclosing, as applicable, matters related to going concern and using the going concern
basis of accounting unless the directors either intend to liquidate the group or the company or to cease operations, or have
no realistic alternative but to do so.
Auditors’ responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements
Our objectives are to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are free from
material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to issue an auditors’report that includes our opinion.
Reasonable assurance is a high level of assurance but is not a guarantee that an audit conducted in accordance with ISAs
(UK) will always detect a material misstatement when it exists. Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and are
considered material if, individually or in the aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the economic
decisions of users taken on the basis of these financial statements.
Irregularities, including fraud, are instances of non-compliance with laws and regulations. We design procedures in line
with our responsibilities, outlined above, to detect material misstatements in respect of irregularities, including fraud. The
extent to which our procedures are capable of detecting irregularities, including fraud, is detailed below.
Based on our understanding of the group and industry, we identified that the principal risks of non-compliance with
laws and regulations related to the requirement of the Group to comply with the complexities of listing and UK and
international tax regulations, as well as a series of environmental regulations and unethical and prohibited business
practices, and we considered the extent to which non-compliance might have a material effect on the financial
statements. We also considered those laws and regulations that have a direct impact on the financial statements such as
the Companies Act 2006. We evaluated management’s incentives and opportunities for fraudulent manipulation of the
financial statements (including the risk of override of controls), and determined that the principal risks were related to
139
posting inappropriate journal entries to increase revenue or reduce expenditure, and management bias in accounting
estimates. The group engagement team shared this risk assessment with the component auditors so that they could include
appropriate audit procedures in response to such risks in their work. Audit procedures performed by the group
engagement team and/or component auditors included:
•
Review of the financial statement disclosures to underlying supporting documentation;.
•
Discussions with management at multiple levels across the business and the Group’s internal legal counsel
throughout the year, as well as at year end. These discussions included consideration of known or suspected
instances of non-compliance with laws and regulations and fraud;
•
Making enquiries of external counsel in order to understand the nature of existing legal cases;
•
Review of significant component auditors’work and review of internal audit reports in so far as they related to
the financial statements;
•
Substantive testing of significant accounting estimates, particularly in relation to the impairment assessments of
ships and the going concern assessments (see related key audit matters above); and
•
Identifying and testing journal entries, in particular any journal entries posted to revenue and expenditure
accounts with unusual account combinations, to identify any unusual or irregular items.
There are inherent limitations in the audit procedures described above. We are less likely to become aware of instances
of non-compliance with laws and regulations that are not closely related to events and transactions reflected in the
financial statements. Also, the risk of not detecting a material misstatement due to fraud is higher than the risk of not
detecting one resulting fromerror, as fraud may involve deliberate concealment by, for example, forgery or intentional
misrepresentations, or through collusion.
Our audit testing might include testing complete populations of certain transactions and balances, possibly using data
auditing techniques. However, it typically involves selecting a limited number of items for testing, rather than testing
complete populations. We will often seek to target particular items for testing based on their size or risk characteristics.
In other cases, we will use audit sampling to enable us to draw a conclusion about the population from which the sample
is selected.
A further description of our responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements is located on the FRC’s website at:
www.frc.org.uk/auditorsresponsibilities. This description forms part of our auditors’report.
Use of this report
This report, including the opinions, has been prepared for and only for the company’s members as a body in accordance
with Chapter 3 of Part 16 of the Companies Act 2006 and for no other purpose. We do not, in giving these opinions,
accept or assume responsibility for any other purpose or to any other person to whom this report is shown or into whose
hands it may come save where expressly agreed by our prior consent in writing.
Other required reporting
Companies Act 2006 exception reporting
Under the Companies Act 2006 we are required to report to you if, in our opinion:
•
we have not obtained all the information and explanations we require for our audit; or
•
adequate accounting records have not been kept by the company, or returns adequate for our audit have not
been received from branches not visited by us; or
•
certain disclosures of Directors’ remuneration specified by law are not made; or
•
the company financial statements and the part of the Directors’Remuneration Report to be audited are not in
agreement with the accounting records and returns.
We have no exceptions to report arising from this responsibility.
Appointment
Following the recommendation of the Audit Committee, we were appointed by the members on 23 June 2003 to audit
the financial statements for the year ended 30 November 2003 and subsequent financial periods. The period of total
uninterrupted engagement is 20 years, covering the years ended 30 November 2003 to 30 November 2022.
140
Other matter
As required by the Financial Conduct Authority Disclosure Guidance and Transparency Rule 4.1.14R, these financial
statements form part of the ESEF-prepared annual financial report filed on the National Storage Mechanism of the
Financial Conduct Authority in accordance with the ESEF Regulatory Technical Standard (‘ESEF RTS’). This
auditors’report provides no assurance over whether the annual financial report has been prepared using the single
electronic format specified in the ESEF RTS.
John Waters (Senior Statutory Auditor)
for and on behalf of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
Chartered Accountants and Statutory Auditors
London
27 January 2023
141
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF INCOME (LOSS)
(in millions, except per share data)
Years Ended November 30,
2022
2021
2020
Revenues
Passenger ticket
...........................
$
7,022
$
1,000
$
3,684
Onboard and other
........................
5,147
908
1,910
12,168
1,908
5,595
Operating Costs and Expenses
Commissions, transportation and other
..........
1,630
269
1,139
Onboard and other
........................
1,528
272
605
Payroll and related
.........................
2,181
1,309
1,780
Fuel
...................................
2,157
680
823
Food
..................................
863
187
413
Ship and other impairments
..................
440
591
1,967
Other operating
...........................
2,958
1,346
1,518
11,757
4,655
8,245
Selling and administrative
....................
2,515
1,885
1,878
Depreciation and amortization
................
2,275
2,233
2,241
Goodwill impairments
......................
—
226
2,096
16,547
8,997
14,460
Operating Income (Loss)
......................
(4,379)
(7,089)
(8,865)
Nonoperating Income (Expense)
Interest income
...........................
74
12
18
Interest expense, net of capitalized interest
........
(1,609)
(1,601)
(895)
Gain (loss) on debt extinguishment, net
..........
(1)
(670)
(459)
Other income (expense), net
..................
(165)
(173)
(52)
(1,701)
(2,433)
(1,388)
Income (Loss) Before Income Taxes
...............
(6,080)
(9,522)
(10,253)
Income Tax Benefit (Expense), Net
...............
(14)
21
17
Net Income (Loss)
...........................
$
(6,093)
$
(9,501)
$
(10,236)
Earnings Per Share
Basic
..................................
$
(5.16)
$
(8.46)
$
(13.20)
Diluted
.................................
$
(5.16)
$
(8.46)
$
(13.20)
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
142
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME (LOSS)
(in millions)
Years Ended November 30,
2022
2021
2020
Net Income (Loss)
....................................
$
(6,093)
$
(9,501)
$ (10,236)
Items Included in Other Comprehensive Income (Loss)
Change in foreign currency translation adjustment
...........
(503)
(118)
578
Other
...........................................
22
53
51
Other Comprehensive Income (Loss)
.......................
(481)
(65)
630
Total Comprehensive Income (Loss)
........................
$
(6,574)
$
(9,567)
$
(9,606)
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
143
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS
(in millions, except par values)
November 30,
2022
2021
ASSETS
Current Assets
Cash and cash equivalents
.....................................
$
4,029
$
8,939
Restricted cash
.............................................
1,988
14
Short-term investments
.......................................
—
200
Trade and other receivables, net
.................................
395
246
Inventories
...............................................
428
356
Prepaid expenses and other
....................................
652
379
Total current assets
........................................
7,492
10,133
Property and Equipment, Net
.....................................
38,687
38,107
Operating Lease Right-of-Use Assets
...............................
1,274
1,333
Goodwill
...................................................
579
579
Other Intangibles
.............................................
1,156
1,181
Other Assets
................................................
2,515
2,011
$
51,703
$
53,344
LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY
Current Liabilities
Short-term borrowings
.......................................
$
200
$
2,790
Current portion of long-term debt
...............................
2,393
1,927
Current portion of operating lease liabilities
........................
146
142
Accounts payable
...........................................
1,050
797
Accrued liabilities and other
...................................
1,942
1,641
Customer deposits
..........................................
4,874
3,112
Total current liabilities
......................................
10,605
10,408
Long-Term Debt
.............................................
31,953
28,509
Long-Term Operating Lease Liabilities
..............................
1,189
1,239
Other Long-Term Liabilities
.....................................
891
1,043
Commitments and Contingencies
Shareholders’ Equity
Carnival Corporation common stock, $0.01 par value; 1,960 shares authorized;
1,244 shares at 2022 and 1,116 shares at 2021 issued
.................
12
11
Carnival plc ordinary shares, $1.66 par value; 217 shares at 2022 and 2021
issued
.................................................
361
361
Additional paid-in capital
.....................................
16,872
15,292
Retained earnings
...........................................
269
6,448
Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss) (“AOCI”)
..............
(1,982)
(1,501)
Treasury stock, 130 shares at 2022 and 2021 of Carnival Corporation and 72
shares at 2022 and 67 shares at 2021 of Carnival plc, at cost
............
(8,468)
(8,466)
Total shareholders’ equity
...................................
7,065
12,144
$
51,703
$
53,344
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
144
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS
(in millions)
Years Ended November 30,
2022
2021
2020
OPERATING ACTIVITIES
Net income (loss)
...................................
$
(6,093)
$
(9,501)
$
(10,236)
Adjustments to reconcile net income (loss) to net cash provided by
(used in) operating activities
Depreciation and amortization
........................
2,275
2,233
2,241
Impairments
.....................................
470
834
4,063
(Gain) loss on debt extinguishment
.....................
1
668
459
(Income) loss from equity-method investments
.............
38
129
20
Share-based compensation
...........................
101
121
105
Amortization of discounts and debt issue costs
.............
171
172
119
Noncash lease expense
..............................
148
140
172
Other, net
.......................................
57
137
(56)
(2,832)
(5,067)
(3,114)
Changes in operating assets and liabilities
Receivables
......................................
(171)
(7)
125
Inventories
......................................
(95)
(63)
77
Prepaid expenses and other
...........................
(874)
(1,070)
(209)
Accounts payable
..................................
283
206
(165)
Accrued liabilities and other
..........................
341
601
(311)
Customer deposits
.................................
1,679
1,291
(2,703)
Net cash provided by (used in) operating activities
.........
(1,670)
(4,109)
(6,301)
INVESTING ACTIVITIES
Purchases of property and equipment
.....................
(4,940)
(3,607)
(3,620)
Proceeds from sales of ships and other
.....................
70
351
334
Purchase of minority interest
...........................
(1)
(90)
(81)
Purchase of short-term investments
.......................
(315)
(2,873)
—
Proceeds from maturity of short-term investments
............
515
2,673
—
Other, net
.........................................
(96)
3
127
Net cash provided by (used in) investing activities
..........
(4,767)
(3,543)
(3,240)
FINANCING ACTIVITIES
Proceeds from (repayments of) short-term borrowings, net
.......
(2,590)
(293)
2,852
Principal repayments of long-term debt
....................
(2,075)
(5,956)
(1,621)
Premium paid on extinguishment of debt
...................
(1)
(545)
—
Proceeds from issuance of long-term debt
..................
7,209
13,042
15,020
Dividends paid
.....................................
—
—
(689)
Purchases of common stock
............................
—
—
(12)
Issuance of common stock, net
..........................
1,180
1,009
3,249
Issuance of common stock under the Stock Swap Program
......
95
206
—
Purchase of treasury stock under the Stock Swap Program
......
(87)
(188)
—
Debt issue costs and other, net
..........................
(154)
(327)
(150)
Net cash provided by (used in) financing activities
.........
3,577
6,949
18,650
Effect of exchange rate changes on cash, cash equivalents and
restricted cash
....................................
(79)
(13)
53
Net increase (decrease) in cash, cash equivalents and restricted
cash
........................................
(2,940)
(715)
9,161
Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash at beginning of year
....
8,976
9,692
530
Cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash at end of year
.....
$
6,037
$
8,976
$
9,692
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
145
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY
(in millions)
Common
stock
Ordinary
shares
Additional
paid-in
capital
Retained
earnings
AOCI
Treasury
stock
Total
shareholders’
equity
At November 30, 2019
............
$
7
$
358
$
8,807
$
26,653
$
(2,066)
$
(8,394)
$
25,365
Net income (loss)
.............
—
—
—
(10,236)
—
—
(10,236)
Other comprehensive income (loss)
...
—
—
—
—
630
—
630
Cash dividends declared
.........
—
—
—
(342)
—
—
(342)
Issuances of common stock, net
.....
2
—
3,247
—
—
—
3,249
Issuance and repurchase of Convertible
Notes (net settled through a registered
direct offering)
.............
2
—
1,798
—
—
—
1,799
Purchases of treasury stock under the
Repurchase Program and other
....
—
2
97
—
—
(10)
89
At November 30, 2020
............
11
361
13,948
16,075
(1,436)
(8,404)
20,555
Net income (loss)
.............
—
—
—
(9,501)
—
—
(9,501)
Other comprehensive income (loss)
...
—
—
—
—
(65)
—
(65)
Issuance of common stock, net
......
—
—
1,009
—
—
—
1,009
Conversion of Convertible Notes
....
—
—
15
—
—
—
15
Purchases and issuances under the Stock
Swap program
..............
—
—
206
—
—
(188)
19
Issuance of treasury shares for vested
share-based awards
...........
—
—
—
(126)
—
126
—
Share-based compensation and other
..
—
—
113
—
—
—
113
At November 30, 2021
............
11
361
15,292
6,448
(1,501)
(8,466)
12,144
Net income (loss)
.............
—
—
—
(6,093)
—
—
(6,093)
Other comprehensive income (loss)
...
—
—
—
—
(481)
—
(481)
Issuances of common stock, net
.....
1
—
1,178
—
—
—
1,180
Issuance of Convertible Notes
......
—
—
229
—
—
—
229
Purchases and issuances under the Stock
Swap program, net
...........
—
—
95
—
—
(87)
8
Issuance of treasury shares for vested
share-based awards
...........
—
—
—
(85)
—
85
—
Share-based compensation and other
..
—
—
79
(1)
—
—
78
At November 30, 2022
............
$
12
$
361
$
16,872
$
269
$
(1,982)
$
(8,468)
$
7,065
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
146
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
NOTE 1 — General
Description of Business
Carnival Corporation was incorporated in Panama in 1974 and Carnival plc was incorporated in England
and Wales in 2000. Together with their consolidated subsidiaries, they are referred to collectively in these
consolidated financial statements and elsewhere in this 2022 Annual Report as “Carnival Corporation & plc,”
“our,” “us” and “we.” The consolidated financial statements include the accounts of Carnival Corporation
and Carnival plc and their respective subsidiaries.
We are the largest global cruise company and among the largest leisure travel companies with a portfolio of
world-class cruise lines. With operations in North America, Australia, Europe and Asia, our portfolio
features — AIDA Cruises, Carnival Cruise Line, Costa Cruises, Cunard, Holland America Line, Princess
Cruises, P&O Cruises (Australia), P&O Cruises (UK) and Seabourn.
DLC Arrangement
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc operate a dual listed company (“DLC”) arrangement, whereby the
businesses of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are combined through a number of contracts and
provisions in Carnival Corporation’s Articles of Incorporation and By-Laws and Carnival plc’s Articles
of Association. The two companies operate as a single economic enterprise with a single senior management
team and identical Boards of Directors, but each has retained its separate legal identity. Each company’s
shares are publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange (“NYSE”) for Carnival Corporation and the
London Stock Exchange for Carnival plc. The Carnival plc American Depositary Shares are traded on the
NYSE.
The constitutional documents of each company provide that, on most matters, the holders of the common
equity of both companies effectively vote as a single body. The Equalization and Governance Agreement
between Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc provides for the equalization of dividends and liquidation
distributions based on an equalization ratio and contains provisions relating to the governance of the DLC
arrangement. Because the equalization ratio is 1 to 1, one share of Carnival Corporation common stock
and one Carnival plc ordinary share are generally entitled to the same distributions.
Under deeds of guarantee executed in connection with the DLC arrangement, as well as stand-alone
guarantees executed since that time, each of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc have effectively cross
guaranteed all indebtedness and certain other monetary obligations of each other. Once the written demand
is made, the holders of indebtedness or other obligations may immediately commence an action against
the relevant guarantor.
Under the terms of the DLC arrangement, Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are permitted to transfer
assets between the companies, make loans to or investments in each other and otherwise enter into
intercompany transactions. In addition, the cash flows and assets of one company are required to be used
to pay the obligations of the other company, if necessary.
Given the DLC arrangement, we believe that providing separate financial statements for each of Carnival
Corporation and Carnival plc would not present a true and fair view of the economic realities of their
operations. Accordingly, separate financial statements for Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc have not
been presented.
Liquidity and Management’s Plans
In the face of the global impact of COVID-19, we paused our guest cruise operations in March 2020 and
began resuming guest cruise operations in 2021.
Based on the evolving nature of COVID-19 and our ongoing collaboration with local and national public
health authorities, we have responsibly relaxed our related protocols, including greatly reducing or eliminating
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
147
testing requirements and vaccination protocols to more closely align with the broader travel industry and
strengthening our competitiveness.
As part of our liquidity management, we rely on estimates of our future liquidity, which includes numerous
assumptions that are subject to various risks and uncertainties. The principal assumptions used to estimate
our future liquidity consist of:
• Our continued cruise operations and expected timing of cash collections for cruise bookings
• Expected increases in revenue in 2023 on a per passenger basis compared to 2019, particularly with
the responsible relaxation of COVID-19 related protocols aligning towards land-based vacation
alternatives and strengthening our competitiveness
• Expected improvement in occupancy on a year-over-year basis returning to historical levels in the
summer of 2023
• Stabilization of fuel prices around November 2022 year-end prices
• Continued stabilization of inflationary pressures on costs, moderated by a larger-more efficient fleet
as compared to 2019
In addition, we make certain assumptions about new ship deliveries, improvements and removals, and
consider the future export credit financings that are associated with the new ship deliveries.
We have a substantial debt balance as a result of the pause in guest cruise operations and require a significant
amount of liquidity or cash provided by operating activities to service our debt. In addition, the continued
effects of the pandemic, inflation, higher fuel prices, higher interest rates and fluctuations in foreign currency
rates are collectively having a material negative impact on our financial results. The full extent of the
collective impact of these items is uncertain and may be amplified by our substantial debt balance. We
believe we have made reasonable estimates and judgments of the impact of these events within our
consolidated financial statements and there may be changes to those estimates in future periods.
For almost three years, we have taken appropriate actions to manage our liquidity, including completing
various capital market transactions, obtaining relevant financial covenant amendments or waivers (see
Note 5 — “Debt”), accelerating the removal of certain ships from the fleet, and during the pause, reducing
capital expenditures and operating expenses. As of November 30, 2022, 97% of our capacity has resumed
guest cruise operations and is serving guests.
Based on these actions and our assumptions, and considering our $8.6 billion of liquidity including cash,
restricted cash from the 2028 Senior Priority Notes which became unrestricted in December 2022 and
borrowings available under our $1.7 billion, €1.0 billion and £0.2 billion multi-currency revolving credit
facility (the “Revolving Facility”) at November 30, 2022, we believe that we have sufficient liquidity to fund
our obligations and expect to remain in compliance with our financial covenants for at least the next
twelve months from the issuance of these financial statements.
We will continue to pursue various opportunities to raise additional capital to fund obligations associated
with future debt maturities and/or to extend the maturity dates associated with our existing indebtedness
including our Revolving Facility and obtain relevant financial covenant amendments or waivers, if needed.
Actions to raise capital may include issuances of debt, convertible debt or equity in private or public
transactions or entering into new and extended credit facilities.
NOTE 2 — Summary of Significant Accounting Policies
Basis of Presentation
We consolidate entities over which we have control, as typically evidenced by a voting control of greater
than 50% or for which we are the primary beneficiary, whereby we have the power to direct the most
significant activities and the obligation to absorb significant losses or receive significant benefits from the
entity. We do not separately present our noncontrolling interests in the consolidated financial statements since
the amounts are immaterial. For affiliates we do not control but where significant influence over financial
and operating policies exists, as typically evidenced by a voting control of 20% to 50%, the investment is
accounted for using the equity method.
148
For 2021, we reclassified $14 million from prepaid expenses and other to restricted cash to conform to the
current year presentation.
Preparation of Financial Statements
The preparation of our consolidated financial statements in conformity with accounting principles generally
accepted in the United States of America (“U.S. GAAP”) requires management to make estimates and
assumptions that affect the amounts reported and disclosed in our consolidated financial statements. The
full extent to which the effects of the pandemic, inflation, higher fuel prices, higher interest rates and
fluctuations in foreign currency rates will directly or indirectly impact our business, operations, results of
operations and financial condition, including our valuation of goodwill and trademarks, impairment of ships
and collectability of trade and notes receivables, will depend on future developments that are uncertain.
We have made reasonable estimates and judgments of such items within our financial statements and there
may be changes to those estimates in future periods. Actual results may differ from the estimates used in
preparing our consolidated financial statements. All material intercompany balances and transactions are
eliminated in consolidation.
Cash and Cash Equivalents
Cash and cash equivalents include investments with maturities of three months or less at acquisition which
are stated at cost and present insignificant risk of changes in value.
Restricted Cash
Restricted cash is classified as short-term or long-term based on the expected timing of our ability to access
or use the amounts. The long-term portion is included within other assets. Substantially all restricted cash
as of November 30, 2022 relates to the net proceeds from the issuance of our 2028 Senior Priority Notes,
which became unrestricted in December 2022.
Short-term Investments
Short-term investments include investments with maturities of three to 12 months which are stated at cost
and present insignificant risk of changes in value.
Trade and Other Receivables
Although we generally require full payment from our customers prior to or concurrently with their cruise,
we grant credit terms to a relatively small portion of our revenue source. We have receivables from credit card
merchants and travel agents for cruise ticket purchases and onboard revenue. These receivables are included
within trade and other receivables, net. We have agreements with a number of credit card processors that
transact customer deposits related to our cruise vacations. Certain of these agreements allow the credit card
processors to request, under certain circumstances, that we provide a reserve fund in cash. These reserve
funds are included in other assets.
Inventories
Inventories consist substantially of food, beverages, hotel supplies, fuel and retail merchandise, which are all
carried at the lower of cost or net realizable value. Cost is determined using the weighted-average or
first-in, first-out methods.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
149
Property and Equipment
Property and equipment are stated at cost less accumulated depreciation and any impairment charges. We
capitalize interest as part of the cost of capital projects incurred during construction. Depreciation is computed
using the straight-line method over our estimated useful lives of the assets to a residual value, as a percentage
of original cost, as follows:
Years
Residual
Values
Ships
..................................
30
15%
Ship improvements
........................
3-30
0%
Buildings and improvements
..................
10-40
0%
Computer hardware and software
..............
2-12
0%
Transportation equipment and other
............
3-20
0%
Leasehold improvements, including port facilities . . .
Shorter of the remaining lease term
or related asset life (3-30)
0%
The cost of ships under construction includes progress payments for the construction of new ships, as well
as design and engineering fees, capitalized interest, construction oversight costs and various owner supplied
items. Any liquidated damages received from shipyards are recorded as reductions to the cost basis of the
ship.
We have a capital program for the improvement of our ships and for asset replacements to enhance the
effectiveness and efficiency of our operations; to comply with, or exceed, all relevant legal and statutory
requirements related to health, environment, safety, security and sustainability; and to gain strategic benefits
or provide improved product innovations to our guests. We account for ship improvement costs, including
replacements of certain significant components and parts, by capitalizing those costs we believe add value to
our ships and have a useful life greater than one year and depreciating those improvements over their
estimated remaining useful life. The costs of repairs and maintenance, including those incurred when a ship
is taken out-of-service for scheduled maintenance, and minor improvement costs and expenses, are charged
to expense as incurred.
In addition, specifically identified or estimated cost and accumulated depreciation of previously capitalized
ship components are written-off upon retirement, which may result in a loss on disposal that is also
included in other operating expenses.
We have estimated our ships’useful lives at 30 years and residual values at 15% of our original ship cost.
Our ship useful life and residual value estimates take into consideration the estimated weighted-average useful
lives of the ships’ major component systems, such as hull, superstructure, main electric, engines and
cabins. We also take into consideration the impact of technological changes, historical useful lives of
similarly-built ships, long-term cruise and vacation market conditions and regulatory changes, including
those related to the environment and climate change. We determine the residual value of our ships based on
our long-term estimates of their resale value at the end of their useful life to us but before the end of their
physical and economic lives to others, historical resale values of our and other cruise ships as well as our
expectations of the long-term viability of the secondary cruise ship market. We review estimated useful lives
and residual values for reasonableness whenever events or circumstances significantly change.
We evaluate ship asset impairments at the individual ship level which is the lowest level for which identifiable
cash flows are largely independent of the cash flows of other assets and liabilities. We review our ships for
impairment whenever events or circumstances indicate that the carrying value of a ship may not be recoverable.
If estimated future cash flows are less than the carrying value of a ship, an impairment charge is recognized
to the extent its carrying value exceeds its estimated fair value.
Leases
Substantially all of our leases for which we are the lessee are operating leases of port facilities and real
estate and are included within operating lease right-of-use assets, long-term operating lease liabilities and
current portion of operating lease liabilities in our Consolidated Balance Sheets.
150
We have port facilities and real estate lease agreements with lease and non-lease components, and in such
cases, we account for the components as a single lease component.
We do not recognize lease assets and lease liabilities for any leases with an original term of less than one
year. For some of our port facilities and real estate lease agreements, we have the option to extend our current
lease term by 1 to 10 years. Generally, we do not include renewal options as a component of our present
value calculation as we are not reasonably certain that we will exercise the options.
As most of our leases do not have a readily determinable implicit rate, we estimate the incremental borrowing
rate (“IBR”) to determine the present value of lease payments. We apply judgment in estimating the IBR
including considering the term of the lease, the currency in which the lease is denominated, and the impact
of collateral and our credit risk on the rate.
We amortize our lease assets on a straight-line basis over the lease term.
Goodwill and Other Intangibles
Goodwill represents the excess of the purchase price over the fair value of identifiable net assets acquired in
a business acquisition. We review our goodwill for impairment as of July 31 every year, or more frequently
if events or circumstances dictate. All of our goodwill has been allocated to our reporting units. The
impairment review for goodwill allows us to first assess qualitative factors to determine whether it is necessary
to perform the more detailed quantitative goodwill impairment test. We would perform the quantitative
test if our qualitative assessment determined it is more-likely-than-not that a reporting unit’s estimated fair
value is less than its carrying amount. We may also elect to bypass the qualitative assessment and proceed
directly to the quantitative test for any reporting unit. When performing the quantitative test, if the
estimated fair value of the reporting unit exceeds its carrying value, no further analysis is required. However,
if the estimated fair value of the reporting unit is less than the carrying value, goodwill is written down
based on the difference between the reporting unit’s carrying amount and its fair value, limited to the amount
of goodwill allocated to the reporting unit. Judgment is required in estimating the fair value of our reporting
unit.
Trademarks represent substantially all of our other intangibles. Trademarks are estimated to have an
indefinite useful life and are not amortizable but are reviewed for impairment at least annually and as events
or circumstances dictate. The impairment review for trademarks also allows us to first assess qualitative
factors to determine whether it is necessary to perform a more detailed quantitative trademark impairment
test. We would perform the quantitative test if our qualitative assessment determined it was more-likely-than-
not that the trademarks are impaired. We may also elect to bypass the qualitative assessment and proceed
directly to the quantitative test. Our trademarks would be considered impaired if their carrying value exceeds
their estimated fair value.
Equity Method Investments
Equity method investments are initially recognized at cost and are included in other assets in the Consolidated
Balance Sheets. Our proportionate interest in their results is included in other income (expense), net in the
Consolidated Statements of Income.
Debt and Debt Issuance Costs
Debt is recorded at initial fair value, which normally reflects the proceeds received by us, net of debt
issuance costs. Debt is subsequently stated at amortized cost. Debt issuance costs are generally amortized to
interest expense using the straight-line method, which approximates the effective interest method, over the
term of the debt. Debt issue discounts and premiums are generally amortized to interest expense using the
effective interest rate method over the term of the debt.
Derivatives and Other Financial Instruments
We have in the past and may in the future utilize derivative and non-derivative financial instruments, such as
foreign currency forwards, options and swaps, foreign currency debt obligations and foreign currency cash
balances, to manage our exposure to fluctuations in certain foreign currency exchange rates. We use interest
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
151
rate swaps primarily to manage our interest rate exposure to achieve a desired proportion of fixed and
floating rate debt. Our policy is to not use financial instruments for trading or other speculative purposes.
All derivatives are recorded at fair value. If a derivative is designated as a cash flow hedge, then the change in
the fair value of the derivative is recognized as a component of AOCI until the underlying hedged item is
recognized in earnings or the forecasted transaction is no longer probable. If a derivative or a non-derivative
financial instrument is designated as a hedge of our net investment in a foreign operation, then changes in
the effective portion of the fair value of the financial instrument are recognized as a component of AOCI to
offset the change in the translated value of the designated portion of net investment being hedged until the
investment is sold or substantially liquidated, while the impact attributable to components excluded from the
assessment of hedge effectiveness is recorded in interest expense, net of capitalized interest, on a systematic
and rational basis. For derivatives that do not qualify for hedge accounting treatment, the change in fair value
is recognized in earnings.
We classify the fair value of all our derivative contracts as either current or long-term, depending on the
maturity date of the derivative contract. The cash flows from derivatives treated as cash flow hedges are
classified in our Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows in the same category as the item being hedged.
Derivative valuations are based on observable inputs such as interest rates and commodity price curves,
forward currency exchange rates, credit spreads, maturity dates, volatilities, and cross currency basis spreads.
We use the income approach to value derivatives for foreign currency options and forwards, interest rate
swaps and cross currency swaps using observable market data for all significant inputs and standard valuation
techniques to convert future amounts to a single present value amount, assuming that participants are
motivated but not compelled to transact.
Foreign Currency Translation and Transactions
These financial statements are presented in U.S. dollars. Each foreign entity determines its functional
currency by reference to its primary economic environment. Our most significant foreign entities utilize the
U.S. dollar, Euro, Sterling or the Australian dollar as their functional currencies. We translate the assets and
liabilities of our foreign entities that have functional currencies other than the U.S. dollar at exchange rates
in effect at the balance sheet date. Revenues and expenses of these foreign entities are translated at the average
rate for the period. Equity is translated at historical rates and the resulting foreign currency translation
adjustments are included as a component of AOCI, which is a separate component of shareholders’equity.
Therefore, the U.S. dollar value of the non-equity translated items in our consolidated financial statements
will fluctuate from period to period, depending on the changing value of the U.S. dollar versus these currencies.
We execute transactions in a number of different currencies. At the date that the transaction is recognized,
each asset, liability, revenue, expense, gain or loss arising from the transaction is measured and recorded in the
functional currency of the recording entity using the exchange rate in effect at that date. At each balance
sheet date, recorded monetary balances denominated in a currency other than the functional currency are
adjusted using the exchange rate at the balance sheet date, with gains or losses recorded in other income or
other expense, unless such monetary balances have been designated as hedges of net investments in our foreign
entities. The net gains or losses resulting from foreign currency transactions were not material in 2022,
2021 and 2020. In addition, the unrealized gains or losses on our long-term intercompany receivables and
payables which are denominated in a non-functional currency and which are not expected to be repaid in the
foreseeable future are recorded as foreign currency translation adjustments included as a component of
AOCI.
Revenue and Expense Recognition
Guest cruise deposits and advance onboard purchases are initially included in customer deposits when
received. Customer deposits are subsequently recognized as cruise revenues, together with revenues from
onboard and other activities, and all associated direct costs and expenses of a voyage are recognized as cruise
costs and expenses, upon completion of voyages with durations of ten nights or less and on a pro rata
basis for voyages in excess of ten nights. The impact of recognizing these shorter duration cruise revenues
and costs and expenses on a completed voyage basis versus on a pro rata basis is not material. Certain of our
product offerings are bundled and we allocate the value of the bundled services and goods between
152
passenger ticket revenues and onboard and other revenues based upon the estimated standalone selling
prices of those goods and services. Guest cancellation fees, when applicable, are recognized in passenger ticket
revenues at the time of cancellation.
Our sales to guests of air and other transportation to and from airports near the home ports of our ships
are included in passenger ticket revenues, and the related costs of purchasing these services are included in
transportation costs. The proceeds that we collect from the sales of third-party shore excursions are included
in onboard and other revenues and the related costs are included in onboard and other costs. The amounts
collected on behalf of our onboard concessionaires, net of the amounts remitted to them, are included in
onboard and other revenues as concession revenues. All of these amounts are recognized on a completed
voyage or pro rata basis as discussed above.
Passenger ticket revenues include fees, taxes and charges collected by us from our guests. The fees, taxes and
charges that vary with guest head counts and are directly imposed on a revenue-producing arrangement
are expensed in commissions, transportation and other costs when the corresponding revenues are recognized.
These fees, taxes and charges included in commissions, transportation and other costs were $438 million in
2022, $73 million in 2021 and $215 million in 2020. The remaining portion of fees, taxes and charges are
expensed in other operating expenses when the corresponding revenues are recognized.
Revenues and expenses from our hotel and transportation operations, which are included in our Tour and
Other segment, are recognized at the time the services are performed.
Customer Deposits
Our payment terms generally require an initial deposit to confirm a reservation, with the balance due prior
to the voyage. Cash received from guests in advance of the cruise is recorded in customer deposits and in other
long-term liabilities on our Consolidated Balance Sheets. These amounts include refundable deposits. In
certain situations, we have provided flexibility to guests by allowing guests to rebook at a future date, receive
future cruise credits (“FCCs”) or elect to receive refunds in cash. We have at times issued enhanced FCCs.
Enhanced FCCs provide the guest with an additional credit value above the original cash deposit received, and
the enhanced value is recognized as a discount applied to the future cruise in the period used. We record a
liability for unexpired FCCs to the extent we have received and not refunded cash from guests for cancelled
bookings. We had total customer deposits of $5.1 billion and $3.5 billion as of November 30, 2022 and 2021,
which includes approximately $210 million of unredeemed FCCs as of November 30, 2022. Given the
uncertainty of travel demand caused by COVID-19 and lack of comparable historical experience of FCC
redemptions, we are unable to estimate the number of FCCs that will not be used in future periods. Refunds
payable to guests who have elected cash refunds are recorded in accounts payable. During 2022 and 2021,
we recognized revenues of $1.9 billion and $0.1 billion related to our customer deposits as of November 30,
2021 and 2020. Historically, our customer deposits balance changes due to the seasonal nature of cash
collections, the recognition of revenue, refunds of customer deposits and foreign currency changes.
Contract Costs
We recognize incremental travel agent commissions and credit and debit card fees incurred as a result of
obtaining the ticket contract as assets when paid prior to the start of a voyage. We record these amounts
within prepaid expenses and other and subsequently recognize these amounts as commissions, transportation
and other at the time of revenue recognition or at the time of voyage cancellation. We had incremental
costs of obtaining contracts with customers recognized as assets of $218 million and $55 million as of
November 30, 2022 and 2021.
Insurance
We use a combination of insurance and self-insurance to cover a number of risks including illness and
injury to crew, guest injuries, pollution, other third-party claims in connection with our cruise activities,
damage to hull and machinery for each of our ships, war risks, workers’ compensation, directors’ and officers’
liability, property damage and general liability for shoreside third-party claims. We recognize insurance
recoverables from third-party insurers up to the amount of recorded losses at the time the recovery is probable
and upon settlement for amounts in excess of the recorded losses. All of our insurance policies are subject
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
153
to coverage limits, exclusions and deductible levels. The liabilities associated with crew illnesses and crew
and guest injury claims, including all legal costs, are estimated based on the specific merits of the individual
claims or actuarially estimated based on historical claims experience, loss development factors and other
assumptions.
Selling and Administrative Expenses
Selling expenses include a broad range of advertising, marketing and promotional expenses. Advertising is
charged to expense as incurred, except for media production costs, which are expensed upon the first airing of
the advertisement. Selling expenses totaled $744 million in 2022, $340 million in 2021 and $348 million in
2020. Administrative expenses represent the costs of our shoreside support, reservations and other
administrative functions, and include salaries and related benefits, professional fees and building occupancy
costs, which are typically expensed as incurred.
Share-Based Compensation
We recognize compensation expense for all share-based compensation awards using the fair value method.
For time-based share awards, we recognize compensation cost ratably using the straight-line attribution
method over the expected vesting period or to the retirement eligibility date, if earlier than the vesting
period. For performance-based share awards, we estimate compensation cost based on the probability of
the performance condition being achieved and recognize expense ratably using the straight-line attribution
method over the expected vesting period. If all or a portion of the performance condition is not expected to
be met, the appropriate amount of previously recognized compensation expense is reversed and future
compensation expense is adjusted accordingly. For market-based share awards, we recognize compensation
cost ratably using the straight-line attribution method over the expected vesting period. If the target market
conditions are not expected to be met, compensation expense will still be recognized. We account for
forfeitures as they occur.
Earnings Per Share
Basic earnings per share is computed by dividing net income (loss) by the weighted-average number of
shares outstanding during each period. Diluted earnings per share is computed by dividing net income (loss)
by the weighted-average number of shares and common stock equivalents outstanding during each period.
For earnings per share purposes, Carnival Corporation common stock and Carnival plc ordinary shares are
considered a single class of shares since they have equivalent rights.
Accounting Pronouncements
In March 2020, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (“FASB”) issued Accounting Standard Update
(“ASU”) No. 2020-04, Reference Rate Reform (Topic 848): Facilitation of the Effects of Reference Rate
Reform on Financial Reporting (“ASU No. 2020-04”), which provides temporary optional expedients and
exceptions to accounting guidance on contract modifications and hedge accounting to ease entities’ financial
reporting burdens as the market transitions from the London Interbank Offered Rate (“LIBOR”) and
other interbank offered rates to alternative reference rates. ASU 2020-04 is effective upon issuance. In
December 2022, the FASB deferred the date for which this guidance can be applied from December 31, 2022
to December 31, 2024. The use of LIBOR was phased out at the end of 2021, although the phase-out of
U.S. dollar LIBOR for existing agreements has been delayed until June 2023. We continue to monitor
developments related to the LIBOR transition and identification of an alternative, market-accepted rate.
In December 2021, we amended our £350 million long-term debt agreement which referenced the British
Pound sterling (“GBP”) LIBOR to the Sterling Overnight Index Average (“SONIA”) and applied the practical
expedient. This amendment did not have a material impact on our consolidated financial statements. As of
November 30, 2022, approximately $5.8 billion of our outstanding indebtedness bears interest at floating
rates referenced to U.S. dollar LIBOR with maturity dates extending beyond June 30, 2023. We are
currently evaluating our contracts referenced to U.S. dollar LIBOR and working with our creditors on
updating credit agreements as necessary to include language regarding the successor or alternate rate to
LIBOR. We do not expect the adoption of this standard to have a material impact on our consolidated
financial statements during the LIBOR transition period.
154
The FASB issued guidance, Debt — Debt with Conversion and Other Options and Derivative and
Hedging — Contracts in Entity’s Own Equity, which simplifies the accounting for convertible instruments.
This guidance eliminates certain models that require separate accounting for embedded conversion features,
in certain cases. Additionally, among other changes, the guidance eliminates certain of the conditions for
equity classification for contracts in an entity’s own equity. The guidance also requires entities to use the
if-converted method for all convertible instruments in the diluted earnings per share calculation and include
the effect of share settlement for instruments that may be settled in cash or shares, except for certain
liability-classified share-based payment awards. We will adopt this guidance in the first quarter of 2023
using the modified retrospective approach. We do not expect the adoption of this guidance to have a material
impact on our consolidated financial statements.
In September 2022, the FASB issued ASU No. 2022-04, Liabilities-Supplier Finance Programs
(Subtopic 405-50) — Disclosure of Supplier Finance Program Obligations. This ASU requires that a buyer
in a supplier finance program disclose sufficient information about the program to allow a user of financial
statements to understand the program’s nature, activity during the period, changes from period to period,
and potential magnitude. This ASU is expected to improve financial reporting by requiring new disclosures
about the programs, thereby allowing financial statement users to better consider the effect of the programs
on an entity’s working capital, liquidity, and cash flows. This ASU is effective for fiscal years beginning
after December 15, 2022, except for the amendment on roll forward information which is effective for
fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2023. We are currently evaluating the impact of the new guidance
on the disclosures to our consolidated financial statements.
NOTE 3 — Property and Equipment
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Ships and ship improvements
.................................
$
52,908
$
50,501
Ships under construction
....................................
785
1,536
Other property and equipment
................................
3,970
3,928
Total property and equipment
.................................
57,663
55,965
Less accumulated depreciation
................................
(18,976)
(17,858)
$
38,687
$
38,107
Capitalized interest amounted to $48 million in 2022, $83 million in 2021 and $66 million in 2020.
Sales of Ships
During 2022, we entered into an agreement to sell one EA segment ship and completed the sales of two
NAA segment ships and one EA segment ship, all of which collectively represents a passenger-capacity
reduction of 4,110 berths for our EA segment and 4,110 berths for our NAA segment. Additionally, in
December 2022, we entered into an agreement to sell one EA segment ship, which represents a
passenger-capacity reduction of 1,270 berths.
Refer to Note 10 — “Fair Value Measurements, Derivative Instruments and Hedging Activities and
Financial Risks, Nonfinancial Instruments that are Measured at Fair Value on a Nonrecurring Basis,
Impairment of Ships” for additional discussion.
NOTE 4 — Equity Method Investments
We have a minority interest in Grand Bahama Shipyard Ltd. (“Grand Bahama”), a ship repair and
maintenance facility. Grand Bahama provided services to us of $12 million in 2022, $11 million in 2021 and
$38 million in 2020. As of November 30, 2022, our investment in Grand Bahama was $43 million, consisting
of $10 million in equity and a loan of $33 million. As of November 30, 2021, our investment in Grand
Bahama was $47 million, consisting of $14 million in equity and a loan of $33 million.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
155
We have a minority interest in the White Pass & Yukon Route (“White Pass”) that includes port, railroad
and retail operations in Skagway, Alaska. White Pass provided an immaterial amount of services to us in
2022, 2021 and 2020. As a result of the effects of the pause and subsequent resumption of our guest cruise
operations on the 2022 and 2021 Alaska seasons, we evaluated whether our investment in White Pass was
other than temporarily impaired and performed impairment assessments. As a result of our assessments, we
recognized impairment charges for 2022 and 2021 of $30 million and $17 million in other income (expense),
net. As of November 30, 2022, our investment in White Pass was $50 million, consisting of $18 million in
equity and a loan of $32 million. As of November 30, 2021, our investment in White Pass was $76 million,
consisting of $49 million in equity and a loan of $27 million.
We have a minority interest in CSSC Carnival Cruise Shipping Limited (“CSSC-Carnival”), a China-based
cruise company which will operate its own fleet designed to serve the Chinese market. We provided an
immaterial amount of services to CSSC-Carnival during both 2022 and 2021 and we paid CSSC-Carnival a
total of $55 million for the lease of ships during 2021. As of November 30, 2022 and 2021, our investment
in CSSC-Carnival was $70 million and $119 million. During 2020, we sold to CSSC-Carnival a controlling
interest in an entity with full ownership of two EA segment ships and recognized a related gain of
$107 million, included in other operating expenses in our Consolidated Statements of Income (Loss).
During 2021, we sold to CSSC-Carnival our remaining $283 million investment in the minority interest of
the same entity. During 2022 we did not make any capital contributions to CSSC-Carnival. During 2021 we
made capital contributions to CSSC-Carnival in the amount of $90 million.
156
NOTE 5 — Debt
November 30,
(in millions)
Maturity
Rate (a) (b)
2022
2021
Secured Debt
Notes
Notes
...................
Feb 2026
10.5%
$
775
$
775
EUR Notes
...............
Feb 2026
10.1%
439
481
Notes
...................
Jun 2027
7.9%
192
192
Notes
...................
Aug 2027
9.9%
900
900
Notes
...................
Aug 2028
4.0%
2,406
2,406
Loans
EUR fixed rate
.............
Nov 2022
5.5% – 6.2%
—
98
EUR floating rate
...........
Nov 2022 – Jun 2025
EURIBOR + 3.8%
808
951
Floating rate
..............
June 2025 – Oct 2028
LIBOR + 3.0 – 3.3%
4,101
4,137
Total Secured Debt
.....
9,621
9,939
Unsecured Debt
Revolver
Facility
..................
(c)
LIBOR + 0.7%
200
2,790
Notes
EUR Notes
...............
Nov 2022
1.9%
—
622
Convertible Notes
...........
Apr 2023
5.8%
96
522
Notes
...................
Oct 2023
7.2%
125
125
Convertible Notes
...........
Oct 2024
5.8%
426
—
Notes
...................
Mar 2026
7.6%
1,450
1,450
EUR Notes
...............
Mar 2026
7.6%
517
566
Notes
...................
Mar 2027
5.8%
3,500
3,500
Convertible Notes
...........
Dec 2027
5.8%
1,131
—
Notes
...................
Jan 2028
6.7%
200
200
Senior Priority Notes
........
May 2028
10.4%
2,030
—
Notes
...................
May 2029
6.0%
2,000
2,000
EUR Notes
...............
Oct 2029
1.0%
620
679
Notes
...................
Jun 2030
10.5%
1,000
—
Loans
Floating rate
..............
Feb 2023 – Sep 2024
LIBOR + 3.8 – 4.5%
590
590
GBP floating rate
...........
Feb 2025
SONIA + 0.9% (d)
419
467
EUR floating rate
...........
Dec 2021 – Mar 2026
EURIBOR + 1.8 – 2.4%
827
1,375
Export Credit Facilities
Floating rate
..............
Feb 2022 – Dec 2031
LIBOR + 0.8 – 1.5%
1,246
1,363
Fixed rate
................
Aug 2027 – Dec 2032
2.4 – 3.4%
3,143
3,488
EUR fixed rate
.............
Feb 2031 – Jan 2034
1.1 – 1.6%
2,592
1,551
EUR floating rate
...........
Feb 2022 – Nov 2034
EURIBOR + 0.2 – 1.6%
3,882
2,742
Total Unsecured
Debt
.............
25,994
24,031
Total Debt
................
35,615
33,970
Less: unamortized debt issuance
costs and discounts
........
(1,069)
(744)
Total Debt, net of unamortized
debt issuance costs and
discounts
...............
34,546
33,226
Less: short-term borrowings
....
(200)
(2,790)
Less: current portion of
long-term debt
...........
(2,393)
(1,927)
Long-Term Debt
............
$
31,953
$
28,509
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
157
(a)
The reference rates for substantially all of our LIBOR and EURIBOR based variable debt have 0.0%
to 0.75% floors.
(b)
The above debt tables do not include the impact of our interest rate swaps and as of November 30,
2021, it also excludes the impact of our foreign currency swaps. As of November 30, 2022, we had no
foreign currency swaps. The interest rates on some of our debt, including our Revolving Facility, fluctuate
based on the applicable rating of senior unsecured long-term securities of Carnival Corporation or
Carnival plc.
(c)
Amounts outstanding under our Revolving Facility were drawn in 2020 for an initial six-month term.
We may continue to re-borrow or otherwise utilize available amounts under the Revolving Facility
through August 2024, subject to satisfaction of the conditions in the facility. We had $2.6 billion available
for borrowing under our Revolving Facility as of November 30, 2022. The Revolving Facility also
includes an emissions linked margin adjustment whereby, after the initial applicable margin is set per
the margin pricing grid, the margin may be adjusted based on performance in achieving certain agreed
annual carbon emissions goals. We are required to pay a commitment fee on any unutilized portion.
(d)
As of November 30, 2022 the interest rate for the GBP unsecured loan was linked to SONIA and
subject to a credit adjustment spread ranging from 0.03% to 0.28%. The referenced SONIA rate with
the credit adjustment spread is subject to a 0% floor. As of November 30, 2021, this loan was referenced
to GBP LIBOR.
Carnival Corporation and/or Carnival plc is the primary obligor of all our outstanding debt excluding
$0.5 billion under a term loan facility of Costa Crociere S.p.A. (“Costa”), a subsidiary of Carnival plc, and
$2.0 billion of 2028 Senior Priority Notes (as defined below), issued by Carnival Holdings (Bermuda)
Limited (“Carnival Holdings”), a subsidiary of Carnival Corporation. All our outstanding debt is issued or
guaranteed by substantially the same entities with the exception of up to $250 million of the Costa term
loan facility, which is guaranteed by certain subsidiaries of Carnival plc and Costa that do not guarantee our
other outstanding debt, and our 2028 Senior Priority Notes, which are issued by Carnival Holdings, which
does not guarantee our other outstanding debt.
The scheduled maturities of our debt are as follows:
(in millions)
Year
Principal Payments
2023
.........................................................
$
2,396
2024 (a)
......................................................
2,645
2025
.........................................................
4,385
2026
.........................................................
4,507
2027
.........................................................
5,662
Thereafter
.....................................................
16,020
Total
.........................................................
$
35,615
(a)
Includes borrowings of $0.2 billion under our Revolving Facility. Amounts outstanding under our
Revolving Facility were drawn in 2020 for an initial six-month term. We may continue to re-borrow or
otherwise utilize available amounts under the Revolving Facility through August 2024, subject to
satisfaction of the conditions in the facility. We had $2.6 billion available for borrowing under our
Revolving Facility as of November 30, 2022.
Short-Term Borrowings
As of November 30, 2022 and November 30, 2021, our short-term borrowings consisted of $0.2 billion and
$2.8 billion under our Revolving Facility.
Secured Debt
Repricing of 2025 Secured Term Loan
In June 2021, we entered into an amendment to reprice our $2.8 billion 2025 Secured Term Loan (the “2025
Secured Term Loan”). The amended U.S. dollar tranche bears interest at a rate per annum equal to LIBOR
158
(with a 0.75% floor) plus 3.0%. The amended euro tranche bears interest at a rate per annum equal to
EURIBOR (with a 0% floor) plus 3.75%.
2028 Senior Secured Notes
In July 2021, we issued $2.4 billion aggregate principal amount of 4.0% first-priority senior secured notes
due in 2028 (the “2028 Senior Secured Notes”). We used the net proceeds from the issuance to purchase
$2.0 billion aggregate principal amount of the 2023 Senior Secured Notes and to pay accrued interest on such
notes and related fees and expenses. The 2028 Senior Secured Notes mature on August 1, 2028.
2028 Senior Secured Term Loan
In October 2021, we borrowed an aggregate principal amount of $2.3 billion under a new term loan. We
used the net proceeds from this borrowing to redeem the $2.0 billion outstanding aggregate principal amount
of the 2023 Senior Secured Notes and to pay accrued interest on such notes and related fees and expenses.
Borrowings under the new term loan bear interest at a rate per annum equal to LIBOR (with a 0.75% floor)
plus 3.25% and mature on October 18, 2028.
Unsecured Debt
2028 Senior Priority Notes
In October 2022, Carnival Holdings issued an aggregate principal amount of $2.0 billion senior priority
notes that mature on May 1, 2028 (the “2028 Senior Priority Notes”). The 2028 Senior Priority Notes bear
interest at a rate of 10.4% per year and are callable beginning May 1, 2025. In connection with the offering of
the 2028 Senior Priority Notes, Carnival Corporation, Carnival plc and their respective subsidiaries
contributed 12 unencumbered vessels (the “Subject Vessels”) to Carnival Holdings, with each of the Subject
Vessels continuing to be operated under one of Carnival Corporation’s, Carnival plc’s or one of their
respective subsidiaries’brands. As of November 30, 2022, the Subject Vessels had an aggregate net book
value of approximately $8.3 billion. As of November 30, 2022, there was no change in the identity of the
Subject Vessels. See “Collateral and Priority Pool”below.
2027 Senior Unsecured Notes
In February 2021, we issued an aggregate principal amount of $3.5 billion senior unsecured notes that
mature on March 1, 2027 (the “2027 Senior Unsecured Notes”). The 2027 Senior Unsecured Notes bear
interest at a rate of 5.8% per year.
2029 Senior Unsecured Notes
In November 2021, we issued an aggregate principal amount of $2.0 billion senior unsecured notes that
mature on May 1, 2029 (the “2029 Senior Unsecured Notes”), intended to refinance various 2022 and other
debt maturities. The 2029 Senior Unsecured Notes bear interest at a rate of 6.0% per year and are callable
beginning November 1, 2024.
2030 Senior Unsecured Notes
In May 2022, we issued an aggregate principal amount of $1.0 billion senior unsecured notes that mature
on June 1, 2030 (the “2030 Senior Unsecured Notes”). The 2030 Senior Unsecured Notes bear interest at a
rate of 10.5% per year and are callable beginning June 1, 2025.
Export Credit Facility Borrowings
During the year ended November 30, 2022, we borrowed $3.1 billion under export credit facilities due in
semi-annual installments through 2034. As of November 30, 2022, the net book value of the vessels subject
to negative pledges was $14.2 billion.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
159
Debt Holidays
In 2021, we amended substantially all of our export credit facilities to defer approximately $1.0 billion of
principal payments that would otherwise have been due over a period commencing April 1, 2021 until May 31,
2022, with repayments to be made over the following five years. The cumulative deferred principal amount
of the debt holiday amendments, inclusive of the amendments entered into in 2020, is approximately
$1.2 billion as of November 30, 2022. In addition, these amendments aligned the financial covenants of all
our export credit facilities with our other facilities.
Convertible Notes
In 2020, we issued $2.0 billion aggregate principal amount of 5.8% convertible senior notes due 2023 (the
“2023 Convertible Notes”). The 2023 Convertible Notes mature on April 1, 2023, unless earlier repurchased
or redeemed by us or earlier converted in accordance with their terms prior to the maturity date. Since
April 2020, we repurchased, exchanged and converted a portion of the 2023 Convertible Notes which resulted
in a decrease of the principal amount of the 2023 Convertible Notes to $0.1 billion.
In August 2022, we issued $339 million aggregate principal amount of 5.8% convertible senior notes due
2024 (the “2024 Convertible Notes”) pursuant to privately-negotiated non-cash exchange agreements with
certain holders of the 2023 Convertible Notes, pursuant to which such holders agreed to exchange their 2023
Convertible Notes for an equal amount of 2024 Convertible Notes. In November 2022, we issued an
additional $87 million aggregate principal amount of the 2024 Convertible Notes pursuant to
privately-negotiated non-cash exchange agreements with certain holders of the 2023 Convertible Notes,
pursuant to which such holders agreed to exchange their 2023 Convertible Notes for an equal amount of
additional 2024 Convertible Notes. The 2024 Convertible Notes mature on October 1, 2024, unless earlier
repurchased or redeemed by us or earlier converted in accordance with their terms prior to the maturity date.
In November 2022, we issued $1.1 billion aggregate principal amount of 5.8% convertible senior notes due
2027 (the “2027 Convertible Notes” and, together with the 2023 Convertible Notes and the 2024 Convertible
Notes, the “Convertible Notes”). The 2027 Convertible Notes mature on December 1, 2027, unless earlier
repurchased or redeemed by us or earlier converted in accordance with their terms prior to the maturity date.
The Convertible Notes are convertible by holders, subject to the conditions described within the respective
indentures that govern the Convertible Notes, into cash, shares of Carnival Corporation common stock, or a
combination thereof, at our election. The 2023 Convertible Notes and the 2024 Convertible Notes each
have an initial conversion rate of 100 shares of Carnival Corporation common stock per $1,000 principal
amount of notes, equivalent to an initial conversion price of $10 per share of common stock. The 2027
Convertible Notes have an initial conversion rate of approximately 75 shares of Carnival Corporation common
stock per $1,000 principal amount of notes, equivalent to an initial conversion price of approximately
$13.39 per share of common stock. The initial conversion price of the Convertible Notes is subject to certain
anti-dilutive adjustments and may also increase if such Convertible Notes are converted in connection
with a tax redemption or certain corporate events as described within the respective indentures that govern
the Convertible Notes. The 2024 Convertible Notes were convertible from the date of issuance of the 2024
Convertible Notes until August 31, 2022, and thereafter may become convertible if certain conditions are
met. As of November 30, 2022, there were no conditions satisfied which would allow the holders of the 2023
Convertible Notes, the 2024 Convertible Notes or the 2027 Convertible Notes to convert and therefore the
Convertible Notes were not convertible as of such date. Refer to Note 15 — “Supplemental Cash Flow
Information”for additional detail on transactions related to the Convertible Notes.
The 2023 Convertible Notes were redeemable, in whole but not in part, at any time on or prior to
December 31, 2022 at a redemption price equal to 100% of the principal amount thereof, plus accrued and
unpaid interest to the redemption date, if we or any guarantor would have to pay any additional amounts on
the 2023 Convertible Notes due to a change in tax laws, regulations or rulings or a change in the official
application, administration or interpretation thereof. We may redeem the 2024 Convertible Notes, in whole
but not in part, at any time on or prior to June 30, 2024 at a redemption price equal to 100% of the principal
amount thereof, plus accrued and unpaid interest to the redemption date, if we or any guarantor would
have to pay any additional amounts on the 2024 Convertible Notes due to a change in tax laws, regulations
or rulings or a change in the official application, administration or interpretation thereof. We may redeem the
160
2027 Convertible Notes, in whole but not in part, at any time on or prior to the 40th scheduled trading day
immediately before the maturity date at a redemption price equal to 100% of the principal amount thereof,
plus accrued and unpaid interest to the redemption date, if we or any guarantor would have to pay any
additional amounts on the 2027 Convertible Notes due to a change in tax laws, regulations or rulings or a
change in the official application, administration or interpretation thereof.
On or after December 5, 2025 and on or before the 40th scheduled trading day immediately before the
maturity date, we may redeem for cash all or part of the 2027 Convertible Notes, at our option, if the last
reported sale price of Carnival Corporation’s common stock exceeds 130% of the conversion price then in
effect for at least 20 trading days (whether or not consecutive), including the trading day immediately preceding
the date on which we provide notice of redemption, during the 30 consecutive trading day period ending
on, and including, the trading day immediately preceding the date on which we provide notice of redemption.
The redemption price will equal 100% of the principal amount of the 2027 Convertible Notes being
redeemed, plus accrued and unpaid interest to, but excluding, the redemption date.
We account for the Convertible Notes as separate liability and equity components. We determine the
carrying amount of the liability component as the present value of its cash flows. The carrying amount of
the equity component representing the conversion option is calculated by deducting the carrying value of the
liability component from the initial proceeds of the Convertible Notes.
The carrying amount of the equity component was $229 million on the date of issuance of the 2027
Convertible Notes and $286 million on the date of issuance of the 2023 Convertible Notes. The carrying
amount of the equity component for the 2023 Convertible Notes was reduced to zero in conjunction with the
partial repurchase in August 2020 because at the time of repurchase, the fair value of the equity component
for the portion of the 2023 Convertible Notes that was repurchased, exceeded the total amount of the
equity component recorded at the time the 2023 Convertible Notes were issued. The fair value of the
conversion option remained unchanged after the exchange of the portion of the 2023 Convertible Notes for
the 2024 Convertible Notes and, as a result, there was no adjustment to the carrying amount of the equity
component.
The debt discount, which represents the excess of the principal amount of the Convertible Notes over the
carrying amount of the liability component on the date of issuance of the Convertible Notes, is capitalized
and amortized to interest expense under the effective interest rate method over the term of the respective
Convertible Notes. Following the exchange of the portion of the 2023 Convertible Notes for the 2024
Convertible Notes, the remaining unamortized discount was allocated between the 2023 Convertible Notes
and the 2024 Convertible Notes and is amortized to interest expense over each respective term using the
effective interest rate method.
The net carrying value of the liability component of the Convertible Notes was as follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Principal
...................................................
$
1,653
$
522
Less: Unamortized debt discount
..................................
(274)
(45)
$
1,380
$
478
As of November 30, 2022, the if-converted value on available shares of 137 million for the Convertible
Notes was below par.
Collateral and Priority Pool
As of November 30, 2022, the net book value of our ships and ship improvements, excluding ships under
construction, is $36.2 billion. Our secured debt is secured on either a first or second-priority basis, depending
on the instrument, by certain collateral, which includes vessels and certain assets related to those vessels
and material intellectual property (combined net book value of approximately $23.6 billion, including
$22.0 billion related to vessels and certain assets related to those vessels) as of November 30, 2022 and certain
other assets.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
161
In addition, as of December 9, 2022, $8.3 billion in net book value of our ships and ship improvements
have been transferred to Carnival Holdings. These vessels are included in the Vessel Priority Pool of Subject
Vessels for our 2028 Senior Priority Notes.
Covenant Compliance
As of November 30, 2022, our Revolving Facility, unsecured loans and export credit facilities contain
certain covenants listed below.
• Maintain minimum interest coverage (adjusted EBITDA to consolidated net interest charges, as
defined in the agreements) (the “Interest Coverage Covenant”) at the end of each fiscal quarter from
August 31, 2023, at a ratio of not less than 2.0 to 1.0 for the August 31, 2023 testing date, 2.5 to 1.0
for the November 30, 2023 testing date, and 3.0 to 1.0 for the February 29, 2024 testing date onwards,
or through their respective maturity dates.
• Maintain minimum issued capital and consolidated reserves (as defined in the agreements) of
$5.0 billion
• Limit our debt to capital (as defined in the agreements) percentage from the November 30, 2021
testing date until the May 31, 2023 testing date, to a percentage not to exceed 75%, following which
it will be tested at levels which decline ratably to 65% from the May 31, 2024 testing date onwards
• Maintain minimum liquidity of $1.5 billion through November 30, 2026
• Adhere to certain restrictive covenants through November 30, 2024
• Limit the amounts of our secured assets as well as secured and other indebtedness
During 2022, we entered into letter agreements to waive compliance with the Interest Coverage Covenant
under our Revolving Facility and $11.8 billion of $12.1 billion of our unsecured loans and export credit
facilities which contain this covenant through the February 29, 2024 testing date.
Subsequent to November 30, 2022 and as of January 12, 2023, we entered into further letter agreements to
waive compliance with the Interest Coverage Covenant under the remaining $0.3 billion of our unsecured
loans and export credit facilities which contain the covenant through the February 29, 2024 testing date
and our Revolving Facility through the May 31, 2024 testing date. We will be required to comply beginning
with the next testing date of May 31, 2024 or August 31, 2024, as applicable.
At November 30, 2022, we were in compliance with the applicable covenants under our debt agreements.
Generally, if an event of default under any debt agreement occurs, then, pursuant to cross-default and/or
cross-acceleration clauses therein, substantially all of our outstanding debt and derivative contract payables
could become due, and our debt and derivative contracts could be terminated. Any financial covenant
amendment may lead to increased costs, increased interest rates, additional restrictive covenants and other
available lender protections that would be applicable.
Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc and certain of our subsidiaries have guaranteed substantially all of
our indebtedness.
NOTE 6 — Commitments
As of November 30, 2022, we expect the timing of our new ship growth capital commitments to be as
follows:
(in millions)
Year
2023
...............................................................
$
1,755
2024
...............................................................
2,400 (a)
2025
...............................................................
895 (a)
Thereafter
...........................................................
—
$
5,050
162
(a)
As of November 30, 2022, includes a ship subject to financing. Subsequent to November 30, 2022, we
obtained financing for the 2024 and 2025 ship deliveries, such that these commitments are no longer
subject to financing.
NOTE 7 — Contingencies
Litigation
We are routinely involved in legal proceedings, claims, disputes, regulatory matters and governmental
inspections or investigations arising in the ordinary course of or incidental to our business, including those
noted below. Additionally, as a result of the impact of COVID-19, litigation claims, enforcement actions,
regulatory actions and investigations, including, but not limited to, those arising from personal injury and
loss of life, have been and may, in the future, be asserted against us. We expect many of these claims and
actions, or any settlement of these claims and actions, to be covered by insurance and historically the maximum
amount of our liability, net of any insurance recoverables, has been limited to our self-insurance retention
levels.
We record provisions in the consolidated financial statements for pending litigation when we determine that
an unfavorable outcome is probable and the amount of the loss can be reasonably estimated.
Legal proceedings and government investigations are subject to inherent uncertainties, and unfavorable
rulings or other events could occur. Unfavorable resolutions could involve substantial monetary damages.
In addition, in matters for which conduct remedies are sought, unfavorable resolutions could include an
injunction or other order prohibiting us from selling one or more products at all or in particular ways,
precluding particular business practices or requiring other remedies. An unfavorable outcome might result
in a material adverse impact on our business, results of operations, financial position or liquidity.
As previously disclosed, on May 2, 2019, two lawsuits were filed against Carnival Corporation in the U.S.
District Court for the Southern District of Florida under Title III of the Cuban Liberty and Democratic
Solidarity Act, also known as the Helms-Burton Act, alleging that Carnival Corporation “trafficked” in
confiscated Cuban property when certain ships docked at certain ports in Cuba, and that this alleged
“trafficking”entitles the plaintiffs to treble damages. In the matter filed by Havana Docks Corporation, the
hearings on motions for summary judgment were concluded on January 18, 2022. On March 21, 2022, the
court granted summary judgment in favor of Havana Docks Corporation as to liability. On August 31, 2022,
the court determined that the trebling provision of the Helms-Burton statute applies to damages and
interest and accordingly, we adjusted our estimated liability for this matter. The court held a status conference
on September 22, 2022, at which time it was determined that a jury trial is no longer necessary. On
December 30, 2022, the court entered judgment against Carnival in the amount of $110 million plus
$4 million in fees and costs. We intend to appeal. In the matter filed by Javier Bengochea on December 20,
2021, the court issued an order inviting an amicus brief from the U.S. government on several issues involved
in the appeal. The U.S. government filed its brief and the court ordered the parties to respond. On May 6,
2022 we filed our response brief. On November 23, 2022, the Eleventh Circuit entered an order affirming the
dismissal of the case in our favor. We believe that any final liability which may arise as a result of these
actions is unlikely to have a material impact on our consolidated financial statements.
As previously disclosed, on April 8, 2020, DeCurtis LLC (“DeCurtis”), a former vendor, filed an action
against Carnival Corporation in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida seeking declaratory
relief that DeCurtis is not infringing on several of Carnival Corporation’s patents in relation to its OCEAN
Medallion systems and technology. The action also raises certain monopolization claims under The
Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890, unfair competition and tortious interference, and seeks declaratory judgment
that certain Carnival Corporation patents are unenforceable. DeCurtis seeks damages, including its fees
and costs, and seeks declarations that it is not infringing and/or that Carnival Corporation’s patents are
unenforceable. On April 10, 2020, Carnival Corporation filed an action against DeCurtis in the U.S. District
Court for the Southern District of Florida for breach of contract, trade secrets violations and patent
infringement. Carnival Corporation seeks damages, including its fees and costs, as well as an order
permanently enjoining DeCurtis from engaging in such activities. These two cases have now been consolidated
in the Southern District of Florida. On April 25, 2022, we moved for summary judgment on our breach of
contract claims and on all of DeCurtis’s claims. DeCurtis also filed a motion for summary judgment on
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
163
certain portions of our claims. Both motions for summary judgment were fully briefed. On July 28, 2022,
the court adopted the Magistrate Judge’s report and recommendation granting our opening claim construction
brief and denying DeCurtis’s motion for summary judgment regarding the invalidity of various patent
claims. On November 11, 2022, the Magistrate Judge entered a Report and Recommendation which
recommended that the Court enter an order denying our motion for summary judgment and granting in part
and denying in part DeCurtis’s motion for summary judgment. Both parties have filed objections to the
Report and Recommendation. The court has set the trial date for February 27, 2023. We believe the ultimate
outcome will not have a material impact on our consolidated financial statements.
COVID-19 Actions
We have been named in a number of individual actions related to COVID-19. These actions include tort
claims based on a variety of theories, including negligence and failure to warn. The plaintiffs in these actions
allege a variety of injuries: some plaintiffs confined their claim to emotional distress, while others allege
injuries arising from testing positive for COVID-19. A smaller number of actions include wrongful death
claims. Substantially all of these individual actions have now been dismissed or settled for immaterial amounts.
As of November 30, 2022, 11 purported class actions have been brought by former guests in several U.S.
federal courts, the Federal Court in Australia, and in Italy. These actions include tort claims based on a variety
of theories, including negligence, gross negligence and failure to warn, physical injuries and severe emotional
distress associated with being exposed to and/or contracting COVID-19 onboard. As of November 30,
2022, nine of these class actions have either been settled individually for immaterial amounts or had their
class allegations dismissed by the courts and only the Australian and Italian matters remain.
All COVID-19 matters seek monetary damages and most seek additional punitive damages in unspecified
amounts.
We continue to take actions to defend against the above claims.
Regulatory or Governmental Inquiries and Investigations
We have been, and may continue to be, impacted by breaches in data security and lapses in data privacy,
which occur from time to time. These can vary in scope and intent from inadvertent events to malicious
motivated attacks.
As previously disclosed, on June 24, 2022, we finalized a settlement with the New York Department of
Financial Services (“NY DFS”) in connection with previously disclosed cybersecurity events, pursuant to
which we have paid an amount that did not have a material impact on our consolidated financial statements.
In addition, as previously disclosed, we finalized a settlement with the State Attorneys General from 46
states in connection with the same cybersecurity events, pursuant to which we have paid an amount that did
not have a material impact on our consolidated financial statements. All previously disclosed cyber incidents
have now been resolved.
We have incurred legal and other costs in connection with cyber incidents that have impacted us. The
penalties and settlements paid in connection with cyber incidents over the last three years were not material.
While these incidents did not have a material adverse effect on our business, results of operations, financial
position or liquidity, no assurances can be given about the future and we may be subject to future litigation,
attacks or incidents that could have such a material adverse effect.
On March 14, 2022, the U.S. Department of Justice and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency notified
us of potential civil penalties and injunctive relief for alleged Clean Water Act violations by owned and
operated vessels covered by the 2013 Vessel General Permit. We are working with these agencies to reach a
resolution of this matter. We believe the ultimate outcome will not have a material impact on our consolidated
financial statements.
Other Contingent Obligations
Some of the debt contracts we enter into include indemnification provisions obligating us to make payments
to the counterparty if certain events occur. These contingencies generally relate to changes in taxes or
164
changes in laws which increase the lender’s costs. There are no stated or notional amounts included in the
indemnification clauses, and we are not able to estimate the maximum potential amount of future payments,
if any, under these indemnification clauses.
We have agreements with a number of credit card processors that transact customer deposits related to our
cruise vacations. Certain of these agreements allow the credit card processors to request, under certain
circumstances, that we provide a reserve fund in cash. Although the agreements vary, these requirements
may generally be satisfied either through a withheld percentage of customer payments or providing cash funds
directly to the credit card processor. As of November 30, 2022 and 2021, we had $1.7 billion and $1.1 billion
in reserve funds related to our customer deposits provided to satisfy these requirements which are included
within other assets. We continue to expect to provide reserve funds under these agreements. Additionally, as
of November 30, 2022 and 2021, we had $30 million of cash collateral in escrow which is included within
other assets.
NOTE 8 — Taxation
A summary of our principal taxes and exemptions in the jurisdictions where our significant operations are
located is as follows:
U.S. Income Tax
We are primarily foreign corporations engaged in the business of operating cruise ships in international
transportation. We also own and operate, among other businesses, the U.S. hotel and transportation business
of Holland America Princess Alaska Tours through U.S. corporations.
Our North American cruise ship businesses and certain ship-owning subsidiaries are engaged in a trade or
business within the U.S. Depending on its itinerary, any particular ship may generate income from sources
within the U.S. We believe that our U.S. source income and the income of our ship-owning subsidiaries,
to the extent derived from, or incidental to, the international operation of a ship or ships, is currently exempt
from U.S. federal income and branch profit taxes.
Our domestic U.S. operations, principally the hotel and transportation business of Holland America
Princess Alaska Tours, are subject to federal and state income taxation in the U.S.
In general, under Section 883 of the Internal Revenue Code, certain non-U.S. corporations (such as our
North American cruise ship businesses) are not subject to U.S. federal income tax or branch profits tax on
U.S. source income derived from, or incidental to, the international operation of a ship or ships. Applicable
U.S. Treasury regulations provide in general that a foreign corporation will qualify for the benefits of
Section 883 if, in relevant part, (i) the foreign country in which the foreign corporation is organized grants
an equivalent exemption to corporations organized in the U.S. in respect of each category of shipping income
for which an exemption is being claimed under Section 883 (an “equivalent exemption jurisdiction”) and
(ii) the foreign corporation meets a defined publicly-traded corporation stock ownership test (the
“publicly-traded test”). Subsidiaries of foreign corporations that are organized in an equivalent exemption
jurisdiction and meet the publicly-traded test also benefit from Section 883. We believe that Panama is an
equivalent exemption jurisdiction and that Carnival Corporation currently satisfies the publicly-traded
test under the regulations. Accordingly, substantially all of Carnival Corporation’s income is exempt from
U.S. federal income and branch profit taxes.
Regulations under Section 883 list certain activities that the IRS does not consider to be incidental to the
international operation of ships and, therefore, the income attributable to such activities, to the extent such
income is U.S. source, does not qualify for the Section 883 exemption. Among the activities identified as not
incidental are income from the sale of air transportation, transfers, shore excursions and pre- and post-
cruise land packages to the extent earned from sources within the U.S.
We believe that the U.S. source transportation income earned by Carnival plc and its subsidiaries currently
qualifies for exemption from U.S. federal income tax under applicable bilateral U.S. income tax treaties.
Carnival Corporation, Carnival plc and certain subsidiaries are subject to various U.S. state income taxes
generally imposed on each state’s portion of the U.S. source income subject to U.S. federal income taxes.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
165
However, the state of Alaska imposes an income tax on its allocated portion of the total income of our
companies doing business in Alaska and certain of their subsidiaries.
UK and Australian Income Tax
Cunard, P&O Cruises (UK) and P&O Cruises (Australia) are divisions of Carnival plc and have elected to
enter UK tonnage tax under a rolling ten-year term and, accordingly, reapply every year. Companies to which
the tonnage tax regime applies pay corporation taxes on profits calculated by reference to the net tonnage
of qualifying ships. UK corporation tax is not chargeable under the normal UK tax rules on these brands’
relevant shipping income. Relevant shipping income includes income from the operation of qualifying ships
and from shipping related activities.
For a company to be eligible for the regime, it must be subject to UK corporation tax and, among other
matters, operate qualifying ships that are strategically and commercially managed in the UK. Companies
within UK tonnage tax are also subject to a seafarer training requirement.
Our UK non-shipping activities that do not qualify under the UK tonnage tax regime remain subject to
normal UK corporation tax.
P&O Cruises (Australia) and all of the other cruise ships operated internationally by Carnival plc for the
cruise segment of the Australian vacation region are exempt from Australian corporation tax by virtue of the
UK/Australian income tax treaty.
Italian and German Income Tax
In 2015, Costa and AIDA re-elected to enter the Italian tonnage tax regime through 2024 and can reapply
for an additional ten-year period beginning in early 2025. Companies to which the tonnage tax regime applies
pay corporation taxes on shipping profits calculated by reference to the net tonnage of qualifying ships.
Most of Costa’s and AIDA’s earnings that are not eligible for taxation under the Italian tonnage tax regime
will be taxed at an effective tax rate of 4.8% in 2022 and 2021.
Substantially all of AIDA’s earnings are exempt from German income taxes by virtue of the Germany/Italy
income tax treaty.
Other
We recognize income tax provisions for uncertain tax positions, based solely on their technical merits, when
it is more likely than not to be sustained upon examination by the relevant tax authority. The tax benefit
to be recognized is measured as the largest amount of benefit that is greater than 50% likely of being realized
upon ultimate resolution. Based on all known facts and circumstances and current tax law, we believe that
the total amount of our uncertain income tax position liabilities and related accrued interest are not material
to our financial position. All interest expense related to income tax liabilities is included in income tax
expense.
In addition to or in place of income taxes, virtually all jurisdictions where our ships call impose taxes, fees
and other charges based on guest counts, ship tonnage, passenger capacity or some other measure, and these
taxes, fees and other charges are included in commissions, transportation and other costs and other
operating expenses.
NOTE 9 — Shareholders’ Equity
Carnival Corporation’s Articles of Incorporation authorize its Boards of Directors, at its discretion, to
issue up to 40 million shares of preferred stock. At November 30, 2022 and 2021, no Carnival Corporation
preferred stock or Carnival plc preference shares had been issued.
166
Share Repurchase Program
Under a share repurchase program effective 2004, we had been authorized to repurchase Carnival
Corporation common stock and Carnival plc ordinary shares (the “Repurchase Program”). On June 15,
2020, to enhance our liquidity and comply with restrictions in our recent financing transactions, the Boards
of Directors terminated the Repurchase Program.
Carnival Corporation
Carnival plc
(in millions)
Number of Shares
Repurchased
Dollar Amount Paid
for Shares
Repurchased
Number of Shares
Repurchased
Dollar Amount Paid
for Shares
Repurchased
2020
...........
—
$
—
0.2
$
10
Stock Swap Program
We have a program that allows us to realize a net cash benefit when Carnival Corporation common stock is
trading at a premium to the price of Carnival plc ordinary shares (the “Stock Swap Program”).
During 2022 and 2021 under the Stock Swap Program, we sold 6.0 million and 8.9 million shares of
Carnival Corporation common stock and repurchased the same amount of Carnival plc ordinary shares
resulting in net proceeds of $8 million and $19 million, which were used for general corporate purposes.
During 2020, there were no sales or repurchases under the Stock Swap Program.
(in millions, except per share data)
Total Number of
Shares of
Carnival plc
Ordinary Shares
Purchased (a)
Average Price Paid
per Share of
Carnival plc
Ordinary Share
Maximum Number of
Carnival plc Ordinary
Shares That May Yet Be
Purchased Under the
Carnival Corporation
Stock Swap Program
2022
......................
6.0
$
14.52
3.6
2021
......................
8.9
$
20.99
9.5
(a)
No ordinary shares of Carnival plc were purchased outside of publicly announced plans or programs.
Public Equity Offerings
In April 2020, we completed a public offering of 71.9 million shares of Carnival Corporation common
stock at a price per share of $8.00, resulting in net proceeds of $556 million.
In October 2020, we completed our $1.0 billion “at-the-market”(“ATM”) equity offering program that was
announced on September 15, 2020, pursuant to which we sold 67.1 million shares of Carnival Corporation
common stock.
In November 2020, we completed our $1.5 billion ATM equity offering program that was announced on
November 10, 2020, pursuant to which we sold 94.5 million shares of Carnival Corporation common stock.
In February 2021, we completed a public offering of 40.5 million shares of Carnival Corporation common
stock at a price per share of $25.10, resulting in net proceeds of $996 million.
In August 2022, we completed a public offering of 117.5 million shares of Carnival Corporation common
stock at a price per share of $9.95, resulting in net proceeds of $1.2 billion.
Other
Outside of the Stock Swap Program and the public equity offerings described above, in 2022 and 2021 we
sold 1.6 million and 0.6 million shares of Carnival Corporation common stock at an average price per share
of $19.27 and $21.32, resulting in net proceeds of $30 million and $13 million.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
167
Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income (Loss)
AOCI
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
2020
Cumulative foreign currency translation adjustments, net . .
$
(2,004)
$
(1,501)
$
(1,382)
Unrecognized pension expenses
....................
(31)
(45)
(95)
Net gains on cash flow derivative hedges and other
......
53
44
41
$
(1,982)
$
(1,501)
$
(1,436)
During 2022, 2021 and 2020, there were $1 million, $7 million and $3 million of unrecognized pension
expenses that were reclassified out of accumulated other comprehensive loss and were included within payroll
and related expenses and selling and administrative expenses.
Dividends
To enhance our liquidity, as well as comply with the dividend restrictions contained in our debt agreements,
in 2020 we suspended the payment of dividends on Carnival Corporation common stock and Carnival plc
ordinary shares. We declared quarterly cash dividends on all of our common stock and ordinary shares as
follows:
Quarters Ended
(in millions, except per share data)
February 29
May 31
August 31
November 30
2020
Dividends declared per share
.....
$
0.50
$
—
$
—
$
—
Dividends declared
............
$
342
$
—
$
—
$
—
NOTE 10 — Fair Value Measurements, Derivative Instruments and Hedging Activities and Financial Risks
Fair Value Measurements
Fair value is defined as the amount that would be received for selling an asset or paid to transfer a liability
in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date and is measured using inputs
in one of the following three categories:
• Level 1 measurements are based on unadjusted quoted prices in active markets for identical assets or
liabilities that we have the ability to access. Valuation of these items does not entail a significant
amount of judgment.
• Level 2 measurements are based on quoted prices for similar assets or liabilities in active markets,
quoted prices for identical or similar assets or liabilities in markets that are not active or market data
other than quoted prices that are observable for the assets or liabilities.
• Level 3 measurements are based on unobservable data that are supported by little or no market
activity and are significant to the fair value of the assets or liabilities.
Considerable judgment may be required in interpreting market data used to develop the estimates of fair
value. Accordingly, certain estimates of fair value presented herein are not necessarily indicative of the
amounts that could be realized in a current or future market exchange.
168
Financial Instruments that are not Measured at Fair Value on a Recurring Basis
November 30, 2022
November 30, 2021
Carrying
Value
Fair Value
Carrying
Value
Fair Value
(in millions)
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Liabilities
Fixed rate debt (a)
..........
$23,542
$
— $18,620 $
—
$19,555
$
— $19,013 $
—
Floating rate debt (a)
........
12,074
—
10,036
—
14,415
—
13,451
—
Total
.................
$35,615
$
— $28,656 $
—
$33,970
$
— $32,463 $
—
(a)
The debt amounts above do not include the impact of interest rate swaps or debt issuance costs. The
fair values of our publicly-traded notes were based on their unadjusted quoted market prices in markets
that are not sufficiently active to be Level 1 and, accordingly, are considered Level 2. The fair values
of our other debt were estimated based on current market interest rates being applied to this debt.
Financial Instruments that are Measured at Fair Value on a Recurring Basis
November 30, 2022
November 30, 2021
(in millions)
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents
.......
$
4,029
$
—
$
—
$
8,939
$
—
$
—
Restricted cash
...............
1,988
—
—
38
—
—
Short-term investments (a)
.......
—
—
—
200
—
—
Derivative financial
instruments
................
—
1
—
—
1
—
Total
....................
$
6,016
$
1
$
—
$
9,177
$
1
$
—
Liabilities
Derivative financial
instruments
................
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
13
$
—
Total
....................
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
13
$
—
(a)
Short-term investments consist of marketable securities with original maturities of between three and
twelve months.
Nonfinancial Instruments that are Measured at Fair Value on a Nonrecurring Basis
Valuation of Goodwill and Trademarks
As of July 31, 2022, we performed our annual goodwill and trademark impairment reviews and determined
there was no impairment for goodwill and trademarks at our annual test date.
During 2021 and as a result of the continued resumption of guest cruise operations, ongoing impacts of
COVID-19 and its effect on our expected future operating cash flows, including changes in estimates related
to the timing of our full return to guest cruise operations and improved profitability, we performed
interim discounted cash flow analyses for our EA segment reporting units and determined their estimated
fair values no longer exceeded their carrying values. As a result, we recognized goodwill impairment charges
of $226 million and accordingly have no remaining goodwill for those reporting units.
During 2020, we performed interim discounted cash flow analyses for certain reporting units with goodwill
as of February 29, 2020 and for all reporting units with goodwill or trademarks as of May 31, 2020 and
recognized goodwill impairment charges of $2.1 billion.
As of July 31, 2020, we performed our annual goodwill and trademark impairment reviews and we
determined there was no incremental impairment for goodwill or trademarks.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
169
The determination of the fair value of our reporting units’goodwill and trademarks includes numerous
estimates and underlying assumptions that are subject to various risks and uncertainties. The effect of the
pause and subsequent resumption of guest cruise operations has created additional uncertainty in forecasting
the operating results and future cash flows used in our impairment analyses. We believe that we have made
reasonable estimates and judgments.
The assumptions, all of which are considered Level 3 inputs, used in our 2021 cash flow analyses and which
resulted in goodwill impairments for all but one reporting unit consisted of:
• The timing and pace of our full return to guest cruise operations
• Weighted-average cost of capital of market participants, adjusted for the risk attributable to the
geographic regions in which these cruise brands operate (“WACC”)
The assumptions, all of which are considered Level 3 inputs, used in our 2020 cash flow analyses consisted
of:
• The timing of our return to service, changes in market conditions and port or other restrictions
• Forecasted revenues net of our most significant variable costs, which are travel agent commissions,
costs of air and other transportation, and certain other costs that are directly associated with onboard
and other revenues including credit and debit card fees
• The allocation of new ships and the timing of the transfer or sale of ships amongst brands, as well as
the estimated proceeds from ship sales
• WACC
The estimated fair value of the reporting unit with remaining goodwill and of our trademarks significantly
exceeded their carrying value as of the date of the most recent impairment test. Refer to Note 2 — “Summary
of Significant Accounting Policies, Preparation of Financial Statements”for additional discussion.
Goodwill
(in millions)
NAA Segment
EA Segment
Total
At November 30, 2020
......................
$
579
$
228
$
807
Impairment charges
........................
—
(226)
(226)
Exchange movements
.......................
—
(2)
(2)
At November 30, 2021
......................
579
—
579
Impairment charges
........................
—
—
—
At November 30, 2022
......................
$
579
$
—
$
579
Trademarks
(in millions)
NAA Segment
EA Segment
Total
At November 30, 2020
......................
$
927
$
253
$
1,180
Exchange movements
.......................
—
(5)
(5)
At November 30, 2021
......................
927
248
1,175
Exchange movements
.......................
—
(24)
(24)
At November 30, 2022
......................
$
927
$
224
$
1,151
Impairment of Ships
We review our long-lived assets for impairment whenever events or circumstances indicate potential
impairment. As a result of the continued effects of COVID-19 on our business and certain Asia markets
which remain closed to cruising (particularly China), and our updated expectations for our deployment, we
determined that two ships had net carrying values that exceeded their respective estimated undiscounted
future cash flows. We then estimated the fair value of these ships, based on their estimated selling values, and
recognized ship impairment charges as summarized in the table below.
170
We performed undiscounted cash flow analyses on certain ships throughout 2021 and 2020 and determined
that certain ships had net carrying values that exceeded their estimated undiscounted future cash flows
and fair values, and, as a result, we recognized ship impairment charges during 2021 and 2020.
We believe we have made reasonable estimates and judgments as part of our assessments. A change in the
principal judgments or estimates may result in a need to perform additional impairment reviews.
In 2022, the principal assumption used in determining the fair value of these ships were the estimated sales
proceeds, which are considered a Level 3 input. In 2021, the principal assumptions used in determining the fair
value of these ships were the timing of the sale of ships and estimated proceeds, which are considered
Level 3 inputs.
In 2020, the principal assumptions used in determining the fair value of these ships consisted of:
• Timing of the respective ship’s return to service, changes in market conditions and port or other
restrictions
• Forecasted ship revenues net of our most significant variable costs, which are travel agent
commissions, costs of air and other transportation and certain other costs that are directly associated
with onboard and other revenues, including credit and debit card fees
• Timing of the sale of ships and estimated proceeds
The impairment charges summarized in the table below are included in ship and other impairments in our
Consolidated Statements of Income (Loss).
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
2020
NAA Segment
.....................................
$
8
$
273
$
1,474
EA Segment
......................................
421
318
319
Total ship impairments
...............................
$
428
$
591
$
1,794
Refer to Note 2 — “Summary of Significant Accounting Policies, Preparation of Financial Statements”for
additional discussion.
Derivative Instruments and Hedging Activities
November 30,
(in millions)
Balance Sheet Location
2022
2021
Derivative assets
Derivatives designated as hedging instruments
Cross currency swaps (a)
................
Prepaid expenses and other
$
—
$
1
Interest rate swaps (b)
..................
Prepaid expenses and other
1
—
Other assets
1
—
Total derivative assets
....................
$
1
$
1
Derivative liabilities
Derivatives designated as hedging instruments
Cross currency swaps (a)
................
Other long-term liabilities
$
—
$
8
Interest rate swaps (b)
..................
Accrued liabilities and other
—
3
Other long-term liabilities
—
2
Total derivative liabilities
..................
$
—
$
13
(a)
At November 30, 2022, we had no cross-currency swaps. At November 30, 2021, we had a cross
currency swap totaling $201 million that was designated as a hedge of our net investment in foreign
operations with a euro-denominated functional currency.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
171
(b)
We have interest rate swaps designated as cash flow hedges whereby we receive floating interest rate
payments in exchange for making fixed interest rate payments. These interest rate swap agreements
effectively changed $89 million at November 30, 2022 and $160 million at November 30, 2021 of
EURIBOR-based floating rate euro debt to fixed rate euro debt. At November 30, 2022, these interest
rate swaps settle through 2025.
Our derivative contracts include rights of offset with our counterparties. We have elected to net certain of
our derivative assets and liabilities within counterparties, when applicable.
November 30, 2022
(in millions)
Gross
Amounts
Gross Amounts
Offset in the
Balance Sheet
Total Net
Amounts
Presented in
the
Balance Sheet
Gross Amounts
not Offset in
the
Balance Sheet
Net Amounts
Assets
.......
$
1
$
—
$
1
$
—
$
1
Liabilities
....
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
—
November 30, 2021
(in millions)
Gross
Amounts
Gross Amounts
Offset in the
Balance Sheet
Total Net
Amounts
Presented in
the
Balance Sheet
Gross Amounts
not Offset in
the
Balance Sheet
Net Amounts
Assets
.......
$
1
$
—
$
1
$
—
$
1
Liabilities
....
$
13
$
—
$
13
$
—
$
13
The effect of our derivatives qualifying and designated as hedging instruments recognized in other
comprehensive income (loss) and in net income (loss) was as follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
2020
Gains (losses) recognized in AOCI:
Cross currency swaps – net investment hedges – included component
.......
$
72
$
(1)
$
131
Cross currency swaps – net investment hedges – excluded component
......
$
(26)
$
(6)
$
(1)
Foreign currency zero cost collars – cash flow hedges
..................
$
—
$
—
$
1
Foreign currency forwards – cash flow hedges
.......................
$
—
$
—
$
53
Interest rate swaps – cash flow hedges
............................
$
11
$
5
$
6
Gains (losses) reclassified from AOCI – cash flow hedges:
Interest rate swaps – Interest expense, net of capitalized interest
..........
$
(2)
$
(5)
$
(6)
Foreign currency zero cost collars – Depreciation and amortization
........
$
2
$
2
$
1
Gains (losses) recognized on derivative instruments (amount excluded from
effectiveness testing – net investment hedges)
Cross currency swaps – Interest expense, net of capitalized interest
........
$
5
$
—
$
12
The amount of estimated cash flow hedges’ unrealized gains and losses that are expected to be reclassified
to earnings in the next twelve months is not material.
172
Financial Risks
Fuel Price Risks
We manage our exposure to fuel price risk by managing our consumption of fuel. Substantially all of our
exposure to market risk for changes in fuel prices relates to the consumption of fuel on our ships. We manage
fuel consumption through ship maintenance practices, modifying our itineraries and implementing
innovative technologies.
Foreign Currency Exchange Rate Risks
Overall Strategy
We manage our exposure to fluctuations in foreign currency exchange rates through our normal operating
and financing activities, including netting certain exposures to take advantage of any natural offsets and,
when considered appropriate, through the use of derivative and non-derivative financial instruments. Our
primary focus is to monitor our exposure to, and manage, the economic foreign currency exchange risks faced
by our operations and realized if we exchange one currency for another. We consider hedging certain of
our ship commitments and net investments in foreign operations. The financial impacts of our hedging
instruments generally offset the changes in the underlying exposures being hedged.
Operational Currency Risks
Our operations primarily utilize the U.S. dollar, Euro, Sterling or the Australian dollar as their functional
currencies. Our operations also have revenue and expenses denominated in non-functional currencies.
Movements in foreign currency exchange rates affect our financial statements.
Investment Currency Risks
We consider our investments in foreign operations to be denominated in stable currencies and of a long-term
nature. We partially mitigate the currency exposure of our investments in foreign operations by designating
a portion of our foreign currency debt and derivatives as hedges of these investments. As of November 30,
2022, we have designated $419 million of our sterling-denominated debt as non-derivative hedges of our
net investments in foreign operations. In 2022, we recognized $48 million of gains on these non-derivative
net investment hedges in the cumulative translation adjustment section of other comprehensive income (loss).
We also have euro-denominated debt which provides an economic offset for our operations with euro
functional currency.
Newbuild Currency Risks
Our shipbuilding contracts are typically denominated in euros. Our decision to hedge a non-functional
currency ship commitment for our cruise brands is made on a case-by-case basis, considering the amount
and duration of the exposure, market volatility, economic trends, our overall expected net cash flows by
currency and other offsetting risks.
At November 30, 2022, our remaining newbuild currency exchange rate risk primarily relates to euro-
denominated newbuild contract payments for non-euro functional currency brands, which represent a total
unhedged commitment of $4.4 billion for newbuilds scheduled to be delivered through 2025.
The cost of shipbuilding orders that we may place in the future that are denominated in a different currency
than our cruise brands’will be affected by foreign currency exchange rate fluctuations. These foreign
currency exchange rate fluctuations may affect our decision to order new cruise ships.
Interest Rate Risks
We manage our exposure to fluctuations in interest rates through our debt portfolio management and
investment strategies. We evaluate our debt portfolio to determine whether to make periodic adjustments to
the mix of fixed and floating rate debt through the use of interest rate swaps and the issuance of new
debt.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
173
Concentrations of Credit Risk
As part of our ongoing control procedures, we monitor concentrations of credit risk associated with
financial and other institutions with which we conduct significant business. We seek to manage these credit
risk exposures, including counterparty nonperformance primarily associated with our cash equivalents,
investments, notes receivables, reserve funds related to customer deposits, future financing facilities, contingent
obligations, derivative instruments, insurance contracts, long-term ship charters and new ship progress
payment guarantees, by:
• Conducting business with well-established financial institutions, insurance companies and export
credit agencies
• Diversifying our counterparties
• Having guidelines regarding credit ratings and investment maturities that we follow to help safeguard
liquidity and minimize risk
• Generally requiring collateral and/or guarantees to support notes receivable on significant asset sales,
long-term ship charters and new ship progress payments to shipyards
At November 30, 2022, our exposures under derivative instruments were not material. We also monitor the
creditworthiness of travel agencies and tour operators in Australia and Europe and credit and debit card
providers to which we extend credit in the normal course of our business. Concentrations of credit risk
associated with trade receivables and other receivables, charter-hire agreements and contingent obligations
are not considered to be material, principally due to the large number of unrelated accounts, the nature of
these contingent obligations and their short maturities. Normally, we have not required collateral or other
security to support normal credit sales. Historically, we have not experienced significant credit losses, including
counterparty nonperformance; however, because of the continued effects the pandemic is having on
economies, we have experienced, and may continue to experience, an increase in credit losses.
Our credit exposure also includes contingent obligations related to cash payments received directly by travel
agents and tour operators for cash collected by them on cruise sales in Australia and most of Europe
where we are obligated to honor our guests’cruise payments made by them to their travel agents and tour
operators regardless of whether we have received these payments.
NOTE 11 — Leases
The components of expense were as follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
2020
Operating lease expense
...............................
$
192
$
203
$
203
Variable lease expense (a) (b)
............................
$
(39)
$
(100)
$
(61)
(a)
Variable lease expense represents increases or reductions to costs associated with our multi-year
preferential berthing agreements which vary based on the number of passengers. These costs are recorded
within Commissions, transportation and other in our Consolidated Statements of Income (Loss).
Variable and short-term lease costs related to operating leases, other than the port facilities, were not
material to our consolidated financial statements.
(b)
Several of our preferential berthing agreements have force majeure provisions which were in effect
during the pause in guest cruise operations due to COVID-19.
The cash outflow for leases was materially consistent with the lease expense recognized during 2022.
During 2022, we obtained $111 million of right-of-use assets in exchange for new operating lease liabilities.
Weighted average of the remaining lease terms and weighted average discount rates are as follows:
November 30,
2022
November 30,
2021
Weighted average remaining lease term – operating leases (in years)
...
13
12
Weighted average discount rate – operating leases
................
5.2%
3.8%
174
As of November 30, 2022, maturities of operating lease liabilities were as follows:
(in millions)
Year
2023
................................................................
$
198
2024
................................................................
199
2025
................................................................
180
2026
................................................................
167
2027
................................................................
144
Thereafter
............................................................
965
Total lease payments
...................................................
1,853
Less: Present value discount
...............................................
(518)
Present value of lease liabilities
.............................................
$
1,335
For time charter arrangements where we are the lessor and for transactions with cruise guests related to the
use of cabins, we do not separate lease and non-lease components. As the non-lease components are the
predominant components in the agreements, we account for these transactions under the Revenue Recognition
guidance.
NOTE 12 — Segment Information
Our operating segments are reported on the same basis as the internally reported information that is
provided to our chief operating decision maker (“CODM”), who is the President, Chief Executive Officer
and Chief Climate Officer of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc. The CODM assesses performance and
makes decisions to allocate resources for Carnival Corporation & plc based upon review of the results
across all of our segments. Our four reportable segments are comprised of (1) NAA cruise operations, (2) EA
cruise operations, (3) Cruise Support and (4) Tour and Other.
The operating segments within each of our NAA and EA reportable segments have been aggregated based
on the similarity of their economic and other characteristics, including geographic guest sourcing. Our Cruise
Support segment includes our portfolio of leading port destinations and other services, all of which are
operated for the benefit of our cruise brands. Our Tour and Other segment represents the hotel and
transportation operations of Holland America Princess Alaska Tours and other operations.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
175
As of and for the years ended November 30,
(in millions)
Revenues
Operating
costs and
expenses
Selling and
administrative
Depreciation
and
amortization
Operating
income
(loss)
Capital
expenditures
Total
assets
2022
NAA
..........
$
8,281
$
7,526
$
1,517
$
1,408
$
(2,170)
$
2,568
$ 27,413
EA
...........
3,531
3,925
745
692
(1,830)
2,213
15,317
Cruise Support
...
171
120
225
140
(315)
155
8,461
Tour and Other . . .
185
187
27
36
(64)
4
512
$
12,168
$
11,757
$
2,515
$
2,275
$
(4,379)
$
4,940
$ 51,703
2021
NAA
..........
$
1,108
$
2,730
$
953
$
1,352
$
(3,928)
$
2,397
$ 25,606
EA
...........
712
1,807
568
728
(2,617) (a)
515
16,088
Cruise Support
...
42
55
335
129
(477)
660
11,014
Tour and Other . . .
46
63
27
23
(67)
35
637
$
1,908
$
4,655
$
1,885
$
2,233
$
(7,089)
$
3,607
$ 53,344
2020
NAA
..........
$
3,627
$
5,623
$
1,066
$
1,413
$
(5,794) (b) $
1,430
$ 25,257
EA
...........
1,790
2,548
523
672
(2,729) (c)
2,036
16,505
Cruise Support
...
68
(10)
262
128
(313)
144
11,135
Tour and Other . . .
110
84
27
28
(29)
11
696
$
5,595
$
8,245
$
1,878
$
2,241
$
(8,865)
$
3,620
$ 53,593
(a)
Includes $226 million of goodwill impairment charges.
(b)
Includes $1.3 billion of goodwill impairment charges.
(c)
Includes $777 million of goodwill impairment charges.
Revenue by geographic areas, which are based on where our guests are sourced, were as follows:
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
2020
North America
..................................
$
7,866
$
1,066
$
3,084
Europe
........................................
3,918
811
1,643
Australia and Asia
................................
312
18
687
Other
.........................................
72
14
180
$
12,168
$
1,908
$
5,595
Substantially all of our long-lived assets consist of our ships and move between geographic areas.
NOTE 13 — Compensation Plans and Post-Employment Benefits
Equity Plans
We issue our share-based compensation awards, which at November 30, 2022 included time-based share
awards (restricted stock awards and restricted stock units), performance-based share awards and market-based
share awards (collectively “equity awards”), under the Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc stock plans.
Equity awards are principally granted to management level employees and members of our Boards of
Directors. The plans are administered by the Compensation Committees which are made up of independent
directors who determine which employees are eligible to participate, the monetary value or number of
shares for which equity awards are to be granted and the amounts that may be exercised or sold within a
176
specified term. We had an aggregate of 16.7 million shares available for future grant at November 30, 2022.
We fulfill our equity award obligations using shares purchased in the open market or with unissued or
treasury shares. Our equity awards generally vest over a three-year period, subject to earlier vesting under
certain conditions.
Shares
Weighted-Average
Grant Date Fair
Value
Outstanding at November 30, 2019
...........................
2,491,376
$
59.97
Granted
..............................................
9,971,331
$
20.72
Vested
...............................................
(1,641,570)
$
30.68
Forfeited
.............................................
(480,361)
$
50.96
Outstanding at November 30, 2020
...........................
10,340,776
$
26.61
Granted
..............................................
4,453,572
$
20.65
Vested
...............................................
(6,618,083)
$
21.31
Forfeited
.............................................
(729,073)
$
35.81
Outstanding at November 30, 2021
...........................
7,447,192
$
26.85
Granted
..............................................
3,117,638
$
17.53
Vested
...............................................
(3,503,118)
$
24.36
Forfeited
.............................................
(681,197)
$
36.20
Outstanding at November 30, 2022
...........................
6,380,515
$
22.67
As of November 30, 2022, there was $52 million of total unrecognized compensation cost related to equity
awards, which is expected to be recognized over a weighted-average period of 1.5 years.
Single-employer Defined Benefit Pension Plans
We maintain several single-employer defined benefit pension plans, which cover certain of our shipboard
and shoreside employees. The U.S. and UK shoreside employee plans are closed to new membership and are
funded at or above the level required by U.S. or UK regulations. The remaining defined benefit plans are
primarily unfunded. These plans provide pension benefits primarily based on employee compensation
and years of service.
UK Plan (a)
All Other Plans
(in millions)
2022
2021
2022
2021
Change in projected benefit obligation:
Projected benefit obligation as of December 1
.....
$
298
$
303
$
263
$
280
Past service cost
.........................
—
—
18
10
Interest cost
...........................
5
4
5
4
Benefits paid
...........................
(12)
(10)
(15)
(5)
Actuarial (gain) loss on plans’ liabilities
........
(88)
(7)
(49)
(8)
Plan curtailments, settlements and other
........
(6)
7
1
(19)
Projected benefit obligation as of November 30
....
198
298
223
263
Change in plan assets:
Fair value of plan assets as of December 1
........
355
325
12
17
Return (loss) on plans’ assets
................
(116)
31
(1)
—
Employer contributions
...................
2
1
12
17
Benefits paid
...........................
(12)
(10)
(12)
(5)
Plan settlements
........................
(5)
—
(1)
(17)
Administrative expenses
...................
(2)
8
—
—
Fair value of plan assets as of November 30
.......
222
355
10
12
Funded status as of November 30
...............
$
24
$
56
$
(213)
$
(250)
(a)
The P&O Princess Cruises (UK) Pension Scheme (“UK Plan”)
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
177
The amounts recognized in the Consolidated Balance Sheets for these plans were as follows:
UK Plan
All Other Plans
November 30,
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
2022
2021
Other assets
.............................
$
24
$
56
$
—
$
—
Accrued liabilities and other
..................
$
—
$
—
$
25
$
23
Other long-term liabilities
...................
$
—
$
—
$
188
$
227
The accumulated benefit obligation for all defined benefit pension plans was $386 million and $553 million
at November 30, 2022 and 2021, respectively.
Amounts for pension plans with accumulated benefit obligations in excess of fair value of plan assets are as
follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Projected benefit obligation
.....................................
$
223
$
263
Accumulated benefit obligation
..................................
$
218
$
254
Fair value of plan assets
........................................
$
10
$
12
The net benefit cost recognized in the Consolidated Statements of Income (Loss) were as follows:
UK Plan
All Other Plans
November 30,
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
2020
2022
2021
2020
Service cost
...................
$
—
$
—
$
—
$
18
$
10
$
20
Interest cost
...................
5
4
5
5
4
6
Expected return on plan assets
......
(6)
(6)
(8)
—
—
(1)
Amortization of prior service cost
....
—
—
—
—
—
—
Amortization of net loss (gain)
......
—
—
—
3
4
4
Settlement loss recognized
.........
—
—
—
1
5
1
Net periodic benefit cost
..........
$
(1) $
(1) $
(3) $
26
$
22
$
32
The components of net periodic benefit cost other than the service cost component are included in other
income (expense), net in the Consolidated Statements of Income (Loss).
Weighted average assumptions used to determine the projected benefit obligation are as follows:
UK Plan
All Other Plans
2022
2021
2022
2021
Discount rate
....................................
4.3%
1.6%
5.4%
2.6%
Rate of compensation increase
........................
2.9%
2.7%
3.0%
3.0%
Weighted average assumptions used to determine net pension income are as follows:
UK Plan
All Other Plans
2022
2021
2020
2022
2021
2020
Discount rate
.......................
1.6%
1.6%
1.9%
3.2%
2.3%
2.9%
Expected return on assets
...............
—%
1.9%
3.0%
2.3%
2.3%
3.0%
Rate of compensation increase
...........
2.7%
2.3%
2.9%
3.0%
3.0%
2.7%
178
The discount rate used to determine the UK Plan’s projected benefit obligation was determined as the single
equivalent rate based on applying a yield curve determined from AA credit rated bonds at the balance
sheet date to the cash flows making up the pension plan’s obligations. The discount rate used to determine
the UK Plan’s future net periodic benefit cost was determined as the equivalent rate based on applying each
individual spot rate from a yield curve determined from AA credit rated bonds at the balance sheet date
for each year’s cash flow. The UK Plan’s expected long-term return on plan assets is consistent with the
long-term investment return target provided to the UK Plan’s fiduciary manager (U.K. government fixed
interest bonds (gilts) plus 1.0% and was 4.3% per annum as of November 30, 2022.
Amounts recognized in AOCI are as follows:
UK Plan
All Other Plans
November 30,
November 30,
2022
2021
2022
2021
Actuarial losses (gains) recognized in the current year . . .
$
35
$
—
$
(48)
$
(7)
Amortization and settlements included in net periodic
benefit cost
..............................
$
—
$
—
$
(1)
$
(12)
We anticipate making contributions of $26 million to the plans during 2023. Estimated future benefit
payments to be made during each of the next five fiscal years and in the aggregate during the succeeding
five fiscal years are as follows:
(in millions)
UK Plan
All Other Plans
2023
..............................................
$
6
$
26
2024
..............................................
6
25
2025
..............................................
7
26
2026
..............................................
7
26
2027
..............................................
7
27
2028 – 2032
.........................................
43
151
$
76
$
280
Our investment strategy for our pension plan assets is to maintain a diversified portfolio of asset classes to
produce a sufficient level of diversification and investment return over the long term. The investment policy
for each plan specifies the type of investment vehicles appropriate for the plan, asset allocation guidelines,
criteria for selection of investment managers and procedures to monitor overall investment performance, as
well as investment manager performance. As of November 30, 2022 and 2021, respectively, the All Other
Plans were unfunded.
The fair values of the plan assets of the UK Plan by investment class are as follows:
November 30,
2022
2021
Equities
....................................................
$
53
$
62
U.K. government fixed interest bonds (gilts)
..........................
$
169
$
283
Multiemployer Defined Benefit Pension Plans
We participate in two multiemployer defined benefit pension plans in the UK, the British Merchant Navy
Officers Pension Fund (registration number 10005645) (“MNOPF”), which is divided into two sections, the
“New Section” and the “Old Section,” and the British Merchant Navy Ratings Pension Fund (registration
number 10005646) (“MNRPF”). Collectively, we refer to these as “the multiemployer plans.” The
multiemployer plans are maintained for the benefit of the employees of the participating employers who
make contributions to the plans. The risks of participating in these multiemployer plans are different from
single-employer plans, including:
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
179
• Contributions made by employers, including us, may be used to provide benefits to employees of
other participating employers
• If any of the participating employers were to withdraw from the multiemployer plans or fail to make
their required contributions, any unfunded obligations would be the responsibility of the remaining
participating employers.
We are contractually obligated to make all required contributions as determined by the plans’trustees. All
of our multiemployer plans are closed to new membership and future benefit accrual. The MNOPF Old
Section is fully funded.
We expense our portion of the MNOPF New Section deficit as amounts are invoiced by, and become due
and payable to, the trustees. We accrue and expense our portion of the MNRPF deficit based on our estimated
probable obligation from the most recent actuarial review. Total expense for the multiemployer plans was
$2 million in 2022, $28 million in 2021 and $2 million in 2020.
Based on the most recent valuation at March 31, 2021 of the MNOPF New Section, it was determined that
this plan was 102% funded. In 2022, 2021 and 2020, our contributions to the MNOPF New Section did
not exceed 5% of total contributions to the fund. Based on the most recent valuation at March 31, 2020 of
the MNRPF, it was determined that this plan was 93% funded. In 2022, 2021 and 2020, our contributions to
the MNRPF did not exceed 5% of total contributions to the fund. It is possible that we will be required to
fund and expense additional amounts for the multiemployer plans in the future; however, such amounts are
not expected to be material to our consolidated financial statements.
Defined Contribution Plans
We have several defined contribution plans available to most of our employees. We contribute to these plans
based on employee contributions, salary levels and length of service. Total expense for these plans was
$40 million in 2022, $35 million in 2021 and $24 million in 2020.
NOTE 14 — Earnings Per Share
Years Ended November 30,
(in millions, except per share data)
2022
2021
2020
Net income (loss) for basic and diluted earnings per share . .
$
(6,093)
$
(9,501)
$
(10,236)
Weighted-average shares outstanding
................
1,180
1,123
775
Dilutive effect of equity plans
.....................
—
—
—
Diluted weighted-average shares outstanding
...........
1,180
1,123
775
Basic earnings per share
.........................
$
(5.16)
$
(8.46)
$
(13.20)
Diluted earnings per share
........................
$
(5.16)
$
(8.46)
$
(13.20)
Antidilutive shares excluded from diluted earnings per share computations were as follows:
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
2020
Equity awards
...................................
1
3
1
Convertible Notes
................................
55
53
103
Total antidilutive securities
..........................
56
56
104
180
NOTE 15 — Supplemental Cash Flow Information
November 30,
(in millions)
2022
2021
Cash and cash equivalents (Consolidated Balance Sheets)
...............
$
4,029
$
8,939
Restricted cash (Consolidated Balance Sheets)
......................
1,988
14
Restricted cash (included in other assets)
..........................
20
24
Total cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash (Consolidated Statements of
Cash Flows)
............................................
$
6,037
$
8,976
Cash paid for interest, net of capitalized interest, was $1.4 billion in 2022, $1.3 billion in 2021 and $0.6 billion
in 2020. Cash benefit received (paid) for income taxes, net was not material in 2022, 2021 and 2020. In
addition, non-cash purchases of property and equipment included in accrued liabilities and other was
$100 million in 2022, $127 million in 2021 and $114 million in 2020.
Substantially all restricted cash as of November 30, 2022 relates to the net proceeds from the issuance of
our 2028 Senior Priority Notes. Under the indenture governing these notes, the net proceeds are contractually
restricted subject to the satisfaction of certain conditions. These conditions were satisfied in December 2022
when we completed the transfer of the Subject Vessels to Carnival Holdings, at which time these amounts
became unrestricted.
In August 2022, we issued $339 million aggregate principal amount of 2024 Convertible Notes pursuant to
privately-negotiated non-cash exchange agreements with certain holders of the 2023 Convertible Notes,
pursuant to which such holders agreed to exchange their 2023 Convertible Notes for an equal amount of
2024 Convertible Notes. In November 2022, we issued an additional $87 million aggregate principal amount
of the 2024 Convertible Notes pursuant to privately-negotiated non-cash exchange agreements with
certain holders of the 2023 Convertible Notes, pursuant to which such holders agreed to exchange their
2023 Convertible Notes for an equal amount of additional 2024 Convertible Notes. In addition, in August
and November 2020, in connection with the repurchase of the 2023 Convertible Notes, as part of registered
direct offerings of Carnival Corporation common stock used to repurchase a portion of the 2023
Convertible Notes, as an administrative convenience, we permitted the purchasers of 151.2 million shares of
Carnival Corporation common stock to offset the purchase price payable to us against our obligation to
pay the purchase price for $1.3 billion aggregate principal amount of the 2023 Convertible Notes held by
them, which is reflected as a non-cash transaction for the year ended November 30, 2020.
Refer to Note 5 — “Debt”for additional detail relating to our 2028 Senior Priority Notes and the 2024
Convertible Notes.
For the years ended November 30, 2022 and 2021, we did not have borrowings or repayments of commercial
paper with original maturities greater than three months. For the year ended November 30, 2020, we had
borrowings of $525 million and repayments of $526 million of commercial paper with original maturities
greater than three months.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
181
MANAGEMENT’S ANNUAL REPORT ON INTERNAL CONTROL OVER FINANCIAL REPORTING
Our management is responsible for establishing and maintaining adequate internal control over financial
reporting, as such term is defined in the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 Rule 13a-15(f). Our management,
with the participation of our President, Chief Executive Officer and Chief Climate Officer and our Chief
Financial Officer and Chief Accounting Officer, conducted an evaluation of the effectiveness of our internal
control over financial reporting based on the 2013 Internal Control — Integrated Framework (the “COSO
Framework”). Based on this evaluation under the COSO Framework, our management concluded that our
internal control over financial reporting was effective as of November 30, 2022.
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, the independent registered certified public accounting firm that audited our
consolidated financial statements, has also audited the effectiveness of our internal control over financial
reporting as of November 30, 2022 as stated in their report, which is included in this 2022 Annual Report.
Josh Weinstein
David Bernstein
President and Chief Executive Officer and
Chief Financial Officer and
Chief Climate Officer
Chief Accounting Officer
January 27, 2023
January 27, 2023
182
Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm
To the Boards of Directors and Shareholders of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc
Opinions on the Financial Statements and Internal Control over Financial Reporting
We have audited the accompanying consolidated balance sheets of Carnival Corporation & plc (comprising
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc and their respective subsidiaries, the “Company”) as of November 30,
2022 and 2021, and the related consolidated statements of income (loss), of comprehensive income (loss), of
shareholders’ equity and of cash flows for each of the three years in the period ended November 30, 2022,
including the related notes (collectively referred to as the “consolidated financial statements”). We also have
audited the Company’s internal control over financial reporting as of November 30, 2022, based on
criteria established in
Internal Control — Integrated Framework
(2013) issued by the Committee of
Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO).
In our opinion, the consolidated financial statements referred to above present fairly, in all material respects,
the financial position of the Company as of November 30, 2022 and 2021, and the results of its operations
and its cash flows for each of the three years in the period ended November 30, 2022 in conformity with
accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of America. Also in our opinion, the Company
maintained, in all material respects, effective internal control over financial reporting as of November 30,
2022, based on criteria established in
Internal Control — Integrated Framework
(2013) issued by the
COSO.
Basis for Opinions
The Company’s management is responsible for these consolidated financial statements, for maintaining
effective internal control over financial reporting, and for its assessment of the effectiveness of internal control
over financial reporting, included in Management’s Annual Report on Internal Control over Financial
Reporting appearing under Item 9A. Our responsibility is to express opinions on the Company’s consolidated
financial statements and on the Company’s internal control over financial reporting based on our audits.
We are a public accounting firm registered with the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United
States) (PCAOB) and are required to be independent with respect to the Company in accordance with the U.S.
federal securities laws and the applicable rules and regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission
and the PCAOB.
We conducted our audits in accordance with the standards of the PCAOB. Those standards require that we
plan and perform the audits to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the consolidated financial
statements are free of material misstatement, whether due to error or fraud, and whether effective internal
control over financial reporting was maintained in all material respects.
Our audits of the consolidated financial statements included performing procedures to assess the risks of
material misstatement of the consolidated financial statements, whether due to error or fraud, and performing
procedures that respond to those risks. Such procedures included examining, on a test basis, evidence
regarding the amounts and disclosures in the consolidated financial statements. Our audits also included
evaluating the accounting principles used and significant estimates made by management, as well as evaluating
the overall presentation of the consolidated financial statements. Our audit of internal control over
financial reporting included obtaining an understanding of internal control over financial reporting,
assessing the risk that a material weakness exists, and testing and evaluating the design and operating
effectiveness of internal control based on the assessed risk. Our audits also included performing such other
procedures as we considered necessary in the circumstances. We believe that our audits provide a reasonable
basis for our opinions.
Emphasis of Matter
As discussed in Note 1 to the consolidated financial statements, the continued effects of the pandemic,
certain economic conditions and Company’s substantial debt balance are having a material negative impact
on the Company’s financial results and have resulted in the Company obtaining relevant financial covenant
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
183
amendments and waivers. Management’s evaluation of these events and conditions and management’s plan
to mitigate these matters are also described in Note 1.
Definition and Limitations of Internal Control over Financial Reporting
A company’s internal control over financial reporting is a process designed to provide reasonable assurance
regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the preparation of financial statements for external
purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. A company’s internal control over
financial reporting includes those policies and procedures that (i) pertain to the maintenance of records that,
in reasonable detail, accurately and fairly reflect the transactions and dispositions of the assets of the
company; (ii) provide reasonable assurance that transactions are recorded as necessary to permit preparation
of financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, and that receipts and
expenditures of the company are being made only in accordance with authorizations of management and
directors of the company; and (iii) provide reasonable assurance regarding prevention or timely detection of
unauthorized acquisition, use, or disposition of the company’s assets that could have a material effect on
the financial statements.
Because of its inherent limitations, internal control over financial reporting may not prevent or detect
misstatements. Also, projections of any evaluation of effectiveness to future periods are subject to the risk
that controls may become inadequate because of changes in conditions, or that the degree of compliance with
the policies or procedures may deteriorate.
Critical Audit Matters
The critical audit matter communicated below is a matter arising from the current period audit of the
consolidated financial statements that was communicated or required to be communicated to the audit
committee and that (i) relates to accounts or disclosures that are material to the consolidated financial
statements and (ii) involved our especially challenging, subjective, or complex judgments. The communication
of critical audit matters does not alter in any way our opinion on the consolidated financial statements,
taken as a whole, and we are not, by communicating the critical audit matter below, providing a separate
opinion on the critical audit matter or on the accounts or disclosures to which it relates.
Liquidity
As described in Note 1 to the consolidated financial statements, the continued effects of the pandemic,
inflation, higher fuel prices, higher interest rates, fluctuations in foreign currency rates and the Company’s
substantial debt balance are collectively having a material negative impact on the Company’s financial results.
Management has taken actions to manage the Company’s liquidity, including completing various capital
market transactions, obtaining relevant financial covenant amendments or waivers, and accelerating the
removal of certain ships from its fleet. The principal assumptions used in management’s estimate of future
liquidity consisted of (i) continued cruise operations and expected timing of cash collections for cruise
bookings; (ii) expected increases in revenue on a per passenger basis with the relaxation of COVID-19 related
protocols aligning towards land-based vacation alternatives; (iii) expected improvement in occupancy
returning to historical levels; (iv) stabilization of fuel prices; (v) continued stabilization of inflationary
pressures on costs; (vi) new ship deliveries, improvements and removals; and (vii) future export credit
financings that are associated with the new ship deliveries. Based on these actions and assumptions, and
considering the liquidity including cash, restricted cash and borrowings available under the multi-currency
revolving credit facility at November 30, 2022, management believes that they have sufficient liquidity to fund
obligations and expects to remain in compliance with the Company’s financial covenants for at least the
next twelve months from the issuance of the financial statements.
The principal considerations for our determination that performing procedures relating to the Company’s
liquidity is a critical audit matter are the significant judgment by management when developing the estimate
of future liquidity; this in turn led to a high degree of auditor judgment, subjectivity, and effort in
performing procedures and evaluating management’s estimate of future liquidity and assumptions related to
(i) expected increases in revenue on a per passenger basis with the relaxation of COVID-19 related protocols
aligning towards land-based vacation alternatives and (ii) expected improvement in occupancy returning to
historical levels.
184
Addressing the matter involved performing procedures and evaluating audit evidence in connection with
forming our overall opinion on the consolidated financial statements. These procedures included testing the
effectiveness of controls relating to management’s estimate of future liquidity. These procedures also
included, among others, (i) understanding and evaluating the appropriateness of management’s liquidity
model; (ii) understanding the Company’s debt agreements and evaluating the related financial covenant
amendments and waivers; (iii) testing management’s process for estimating future liquidity for the
twelve months after the date the financial statements are issued; (iv) testing the completeness and accuracy
of underlying data used in the estimate; (v) evaluating the reasonableness of the significant assumptions used
by management related to expected increases in revenue on a per passenger basis with the relaxation of
COVID-19 related protocols aligning towards land-based vacation alternatives and expected improvement
in occupancy returning to historical levels; and (vi) evaluating management’s estimate of future liquidity and
their disclosure in the consolidated financial statements regarding having sufficient liquidity to satisfy the
Company’s obligations for at least the next twelve months from the issuance of the financial statements.
Evaluating management’s assumptions related to expected increases in revenue on a per passenger basis with
the relaxation of COVID-19 related protocols aligning towards land-based vacation alternatives and
expected improvement in occupancy returning to historical levels involved evaluating whether the assumptions
used by management were reasonable considering (i) the current and past performance of the Company;
(ii) the consistency with external market and industry data; and (iii) whether these assumptions were consistent
with evidence obtained in other areas of the audit.
Hallandale Beach, Florida
January 27, 2023
We have served as the Company’s auditors since 2003. Prior to that, we served as Carnival Corporation’s
auditors since at least 1986. We have not been able to determine the specific year we began serving as auditor
of Carnival Corporation.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
185
COMMON STOCK AND ORDINARY SHARES
Carnival Corporation common stock, together with paired trust shares of beneficial interest in the P&O
Princess Special Voting Trust, which holds a Special Voting Share of Carnival plc, is traded on the NYSE
under the symbol “CCL.” Carnival plc ordinary shares trade on the London Stock Exchange under the
symbol “CCL.”Carnival plc American Depositary Shares (“ADSs”), each one of which represents one
Carnival plc ordinary share, are traded on the NYSE under the symbol “CUK.” The depositary for the ADSs
is JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
As of January 12, 2023, there were 2,956 holders of record of Carnival Corporation common stock and
29,362 holders of record of Carnival plc ordinary shares and 46,628,217 holders of record of Carnival plc
ADSs. The past performance of our share prices cannot be relied on as a guide to their future performance.
On March 30, 2020, we suspended the payment of dividends on Carnival Corporation common stock and
Carnival plc ordinary shares.
186
STOCK PERFORMANCE GRAPHS
Carnival Corporation
The following graph compares the Price Performance of $100 if invested in Carnival Corporation common
stock with the Price Performance of $100 if invested in each of the Dow Jones U.S. Recreational Services
Index (the “Dow Jones Recreational Index”), the FTSE 100 Index and the S&P 500 Index. The Price
Performance, as used in the Performance Graph, is calculated by assuming $100 is invested at the beginning
of the period in Carnival Corporation common stock at a price equal to the market value. At the end of
each year, the total value of the investment is computed by taking the number of shares owned, assuming
Carnival Corporation dividends are reinvested, multiplied by the market price of the shares.
$250
5-Year Cumulative Total Returns
$200
$150
$100
DOLLARS
$50
$0
2017
Carnival Corporation Common Stock
FTSE 100 Index
Dow Jones Recreational Index
S&P 500 Index
2018
2019
2020
2022
2021
Assumes $100 Invested on November 30, 2017
Assumes Dividends Reinvested
Years Ended November 30,
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Carnival Corporation Common Stock
............
$ 100
$
95
$
74
$
33
$
29
$
16
Dow Jones Recreational Index
.................
$ 100
$
99
$
97
$
62
$
63
$
49
FTSE 100 Index
...........................
$ 100
$
94
$ 105
$
92
$ 108
$ 120
S&P 500 Index
............................
$ 100
$ 106
$ 123
$ 145
$ 185
$ 168
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
187
Carnival plc
The following graph compares the Price Performance of $100 invested in Carnival plc ADSs, each
representing one ordinary share of Carnival plc, with the Price Performance of $100 invested in each of the
indexes noted below. The Price Performance is calculated in the same manner as previously discussed.
$250
5-Year Cumulative Total Returns
$200
$150
$100
DOLLARS
$50
$0
2017
Carnival plc ADS
FTSE 100 Index
Dow Jones Recreational Index
S&P 500 Index
2018
2019
2020
2022
2021
Assumes $100 Invested on November 30, 2017
Assumes Dividends Reinvested
Years Ended November 30,
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Carnival plc ADS
..........................
$ 100
$
93
$
69
$
29
$
27
$
15
Dow Jones Recreational Index
.................
$ 100
$
99
$
97
$
62
$
63
$
49
FTSE 100 Index
...........................
$ 100
$
94
$ 105
$
92
$ 108
$ 120
S&P 500 Index
............................
$ 100
$ 106
$ 123
$ 145
$ 185
$ 168
188
SHAREHOLDER BENEFIT
Carnival Corporation & plc is pleased to extend the following benefit to our shareholders:
NORTH AMERICA
BRANDS
CONTINENTAL
EUROPE BRANDS
UNITED KINGDOM
BRANDS
AUSTRALIA
BRANDS
Onboard credit per stateroom on sailings of 14 days or longer
US $250
€200
£150
A$250
Onboard credit per stateroom on sailings of 7 to 13 days
US $100
€ 75
£ 60
A$100
Onboard credit per stateroom on sailings of 6 days or less
US $50
€ 40
£ 30
A$ 50
The benefit is applicable on sailings through July 31, 2024 aboard the brands listed below. Certain restrictions apply. Applications to receive these benefits
should be made at least three weeks prior to cruise departure date.
This benefit is available to shareholders holding a minimum of 100 shares of Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc. Employees, travel agents cruising at
travel agent rates, interline rates, tour conductors or anyone cruising on a reduced-rate or complimentary basis are excluded from this offer. This benefit is
not transferable, cannot be exchanged for cash and, cannot be used for casino credits/charges and gratuities charged to your onboard account. Only one
onboard credit per shareholder-occupied stateroom. Reservations must be made by February 28, 2024.
Please provide by email
1
, fax or by mail your complete legal name, reservation/booking number, ship and sailing date, along with proof of ownership of
Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc shares (for example, photocopy of shareholder proxy card, a dividend tax voucher or a current brokerage or nominee
statement with your current mailing address and your brokerage account number
blacked out
) no later than 4 weeks prior to your sail date to your travel
agent or to the cruise line you have selected below.
1
If you chose to email, you do so at your own risk and with the knowledge that email is inherently an insecure
method of communication.
NORTH AMERICA BRANDS
CONTINENTAL EUROPE BRANDS
UNITED KINGDOM BRANDS
CARNIVAL CRUISE LINE*
Guest Administration
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue
Miami, FL 33178
Tel 800 438 6744 ext. 70450
Fax 305 406 6102
Email: shareholders@carnival.com
PRINCESS CRUISES*
Commercial Compliance Support
24303 Town Center Drive, Suite 200
Santa Clarita, CA 91355
Tel 800 872 6779 ext. 13028
Fax 661 753 0180
Email: sbpcl@princesscruises.com
HOLLAND AMERICA LINE
World Cruise Reservations
450 Third Ave. W.Seattle, WA 98119
Tel 800 522 3399
Fax 206 270 8060
Email:
CCLshareholderHAL@hollandamerica.com
SEABOURN
Seabourn Reservations
450 Third Ave. W.Seattle, WA 98119
Tel 800 929 9391
Fax 206 501 2900
Email: CCLshareholderSBN@seabourn.com
CUNARD*
Customer Solutions
24305 Town Center Drive, Suite 200
Santa Clarita, CA 91355
Tel 800 728 6273
Fax 661 753 0180
Email: sb@cunard.com
COSTA CRUISES*
Guest Services Administration
880 SW 145
th
Avenue, Suite 102
Pembroke Pines, FL 33027
Tel 800 462 6782
Fax 954 266 5868
Email: fax_usabooking@costa.it
COSTA CRUISES*
Despatcher Team
Piazza Piccapietra, 48
16121 Genoa, Italy
Tel 39 0 10 548 31
Fax 39 0 10 999 7019
Email: prizemanagementfax@costa.it
AIDA CRUISES
Shareholder Guest Services
Am Strande 3d
18055 Rostock, Germany
Tel 49(0) 381 20270805
Fax 49(0) 381 2027 0601
Email: kabinengruss@aida.de
P & O CRUISES (UK)
Shareholders Guest Services
Carnival UK
Carnival House
100 Harbour Parade
Southampton SO15 1ST
United Kingdom
Tel 44 0 345 355 5111
Fax 44 0 238 065 7360
Email:
shareholderbenefits@carnivalukgroup.com
CUNARD*
Shareholders Guest Services
Tel 44 0 345 355 0300
Fax 44 0 238 065 7360
Email:
shareholderbenefits@carnivalukgroup.com
PRINCESS CRUISES (UK)*
Princess Cruises Military &
Shareholder Benefits Team
Tel 44 0 344 338 8663
Fax 44 0 238 065 7509
Email: benefits@princesscruises.co.uk
AUSTRALIA BRANDS
P & O CRUISES (AUSTRALIA)
PRINCESS CRUISES*
CARNIVAL CRUISE LINE*
1
Customer Service Manager
PO Box 1429
Chatswood NSW 2057
Tel 61 2 8326 4000
Fax 61 2 8326 4550
Email:
shareholderbenefit@carnivalaustralia.com
Email: benefits@princesscruises.com.au
*The onboard credit for Carnival Cruise Line,
Costa Cruises, Cunard and Princess Cruises is
determined based on the operational currency
onboard the vessel. Please visit our corporation
website at www.carnivalcorp.com for updates.
1
Refer to the Carnival Cruise Line contact
details under North American Brands.
DLC Financial Statements
and Other Information
189
CORPORATE AND OTHER INFORMATION
EXECUTIVE OFFICERS
BOARDS OF DIRECTORS
DIRECTORS EMERITUS AND LIFE
PRESIDENTS
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
Micky Arison
Chair of the Boards of Directors
David Bernstein
Chief Financial Officer and Chief
Accounting Officer
Vice Admiral William R. Burke (Ret.)
Chief Maritime Officer
Enrique Miguez
General Counsel
Josh Weinstein
President, Chief Executive Officer and
Chief Climate Officer
COSTA GROUP and CARNIVAL ASIA
Michael Thamm
Group Chief Executive Officer
Micky Arison
Chair of the Board
Carnival Corporation & plc
Sir Jonathon Band
Former First Sea Lord and
Chief of Naval Staff
British Navy
Jason Glen Cahilly
Chief Executive Officer
Dragon Group LLC
Helen Deeble
Former Chief Executive Officer
P&O Ferries Division Holdings Ltd.
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
Former Executive Vice President, Global
Governance and Corporate Secretary
Walmart, Inc.
Richard J. Glasier
1
Former President and Chief Executive
Officer
Argosy Gaming Company
Katie Lahey
Former Chair
Korn Ferry Australasia
Sara Mathew
Former Chair, President and Chief
Executive Officer
Dun & Bradstreet Corporation
Sir John Parker
1
Non-Executive Chair
Laing O’Rourke
Stuart Subotnick
President and Chief Executive Officer
Metromedia Company
Laura Weil
Founder and Managing Partner
Village Lane Advisory LLC
Josh Weinstein
President, Chief Executive Officer and
Chief Climate Officer
Carnival Corporation & plc
Randall Weisenburger
Managing Member
Mile26 Capital LLC
1 Richard J. Glasier and Sir John Parker
have decided not to seek re-election and
will retire from the Boards with effect
from the conclusion of the 2023 Annual
Meetings of Shareholders, at which time
the size of the Boards of Directors will
be reduced to 11 members.
Ted Arison (1924-1999)
Chair Emeritus, Carnival Corporation
Maks Birnbach (1920-2007)
Director Emeritus, Carnival Corporation
A. Kirk Lanterman (1931-2019)
Chair Emeritus
Holland America Line Inc.
Meshulam Zonis (1933-2009)
Director Emeritus, Carnival Corporation
Uzi Zucker
Director Emeritus, Carnival
Corporation & plc
Horst Rahe
Life President of AIDA Cruises
The Lord Sterling of
Plaistow GCVO, CBE
Life President of P&O Cruises
OTHER INFORMATION
Corporate Headquarters
Carnival Corporation
Carnival Place
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue
Miami, Florida 33178-2428 U.S.A.
305-599-2600
Registered Office
Carnival plc
Carnival House
100 Harbour Parade
Southampton S015 1ST UK
44 (0) 23 8065 5000
Registrars and Stock Transfer Agents
Carnival Corporation
Computershare Investor Services
P.O. Box 43006
Providence, RI 02940-3006 U.S.A.
800-568-3476 (U.S.A, U.S.A Territories
and Canada)
781-575-2879 (Outside U.S.A, U.S.A
Territories and Canada)
Carnival plc
Equiniti Limited
Aspect House, Spencer Road
Lancing, West Sussex BN99 6DA UK
0371 384 2665 (UK)
44 (0) 371 384 2665 (Outside UK)
Other Shareholder Information
Copies of our joint Annual Report on
Form 10-K, joint Quarterly Reports on
Form 10-Q, joint Current Reports on
Form 8-K, Carnival plc Annual Reports
and all amendments to those reports, press
releases and other documents, as well as
information on our cruise brands are
available through our website at
www.carnivalcorp.com or
www.carnivalplc.com.
190
Carnival Place 3665 N.W. 87
th
Avenue Miami Florida 33178-2428 U.S.A. www.carnivalcorp.com
Carnival House 100 Harbour Parade Southampton S015 1ST UK www.carnivalplc.com
2023
NOTICE OF ANNUAL MEETINGS
OF SHAREHOLDERS
AND PROXY STATEMENT
OUR COMPANY
Carnival Corporation & plc (NYSE: CCL and
CUK; LSE: CCL) is the largest global cruise
company and among the largest leisure
travel companies with a portfolio of world-
class cruise lines.
We believe cruising offers a broad range of
products and services to suit vacationing
guests of many ages, backgrounds and
interests. Each brand in our portfolio meets
the needs of a unique set of consumer
psychographics and vacation needs which
allows us to penetrate large addressable
customer segments.
With our global corporate headquarters in
Miami and several regional headquarters
around the world, we are the only company
in the world to be included in both the S&P
500 index in the U.S. and the FTSE 250 index
in the UK.
OUR VISION
As the global leader in the cruise industry,
we will lead the way in innovative and
sustainable cruising to deliver memorable
vacations and build borderless
connections.
OUR MISSION AND
PURPOSE
To deliver unforgettable happiness to our
guests by providing extraordinary cruise
vacations, while honoring the integrity of
every ocean we sail, place we visit and life
we touch.
Carnival Place
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue
Miami, Florida 33178-2428
United States
Carnival House
100 Harbour Parade
Southampton SO15 1ST
United Kingdom
Letter to Shareholders from our Chief
Executive Officer
JOSH WEINSTEIN
President, Chief Executive
Officer and Chief Climate
Officer
Dear Fellow Shareholders,
During 2022, we completed a monumental 18-month journey marking our full
return to guest cruise operations. Over the past 18 months we have:
•
Returned 90 ships to service
•
Re-boarded over 100,000 team members to our ships
•
Restarted our unmatched portfolio of eight private island and port destinations
•
Restarted our unrivaled land-based footprint in Alaska and the Yukon
•
Welcomed back nearly nine million guests
Throughout 2022, we progressed on an upward trajectory as we continued to close
the gap to 2019, our most recent full year of guest cruise operations, and believe we
are gaining momentum on our return to profitability.
•
For our cruise segments, revenue per passenger cruise day (“PCD”) for the fourth
quarter of 2022 increased 0.5% compared to a strong 2019, overcoming the
dilutive impact of future cruise credits (“FCCs”) and fluctuations in foreign currency.
This was better than the third quarter of 2022 which decreased 4.1% compared
to 2019.
•
Occupancy in the fourth quarter of 2022 was 19 percentage points below 2019
levels. This was better than the first quarter of 2022 which was 50 percentage
points below 2019 levels. We achieved this on growing capacity as we returned
another 35% of our fleet to service in 2022, reaching 99% of our 2019 capacity
levels during the fourth quarter.
•
Revenue in the fourth quarter of 2022 was $3.8 billion, which was 80% of 2019
levels. This was better than the third quarter of 2022 which was 66% of 2019 levels,
an improvement of 14 percentage points.
The uneven reopening of cruise travel around the world following the effects of
COVID-19 and the impact the invasion of Ukraine has had on European countries
have had a material impact on our results of operations. While all of our brands are
on an upward trajectory, the pace of the recovery has trailed for those brands
most heavily exposed to these factors as the impacts have weighed on consumer
confidence in those regions resulting in greater uncertainty and closer-in booking
patterns. To mitigate these impacts, we have made strategic deployment decisions to
increase our closer-to-home and shorter duration itineraries to help reduce the
friction of air travel, lower the overall cost of our vacations and facilitate a closer-in
booking environment. We believe these decisions have positioned us well to attract
more new-to-cruise guests and make us even more of a value proposition
compared to land-based alternatives. Additionally, based on the evolving nature of
COVID-19 and our ongoing collaboration with local and national public health
authorities, our brands responsibly relaxed their COVID-19 related protocols
aligning towards land-based vacation alternatives and strengthening our
competitiveness.
To help support our growth, drive overall revenue generation, elevate awareness
and consideration and enhance demand for both the near- and long-term, we have
significantly increased our advertising activities, including a nearly 20% increase in
our investment during the fourth quarter of 2022 compared to the fourth quarter of
2019. Our brands are utilizing pricing philosophies to maximize revenue and are
sharing best practices across brands. Having been in pause status for nearly
two years, we are also rebuilding demand by providing our guests with extraordinary
cruise vacations, which we believe will increase the likelihood of our guests
recommending our cruise vacations. In addition, we have a renewed focus on our
travel agent partner relationships and a growing sales force. While building back
demand and enhancing our revenue management tools and strategies, we are
working to optimize the combination of occupancy levels with ticket and onboard
prices to deliver revenue growth in the near-term while maintaining price integrity for
the long-term. We are also not losing sight of our expense base as we have worked
through our restart and continue to absorb and mitigate the impacts of the high
inflationary environment we have all been living in.
During 2022, we continued to focus on minimizing our environmental impact and
achieved a 2% reduction in carbon intensity compared to 2019 (11% reduction for
ships in guest cruise operations), a 30% reduction in food waste compared to 2019
and used 290 million fewer single use items compared to 2018. We announced
the rollout of Service Power Packages, global fleet upgrades, which will improve
energy and fuel efficiency and support our sustainability goals, and announced the
expansion of Air Lubrication Systems, which are expected to generate savings in fuel
consumption and reductions in carbon emissions. Additionally, AIDA Cruises and
Holland America Line achieved milestones in their decarbonization strategies piloting
the use of a blend of marine biofuel. These investments, along with our fleet
optimization and itinerary reviews, are expected to drive a 15% reduction in fuel
consumption per available lower berth days (“ALBD”) in 2023, along with a 15%
reduction in carbon emissions per ALBD on an annualized basis, both as compared
to 2019.
Our fleet optimization efforts included welcoming stunning new flagships for six of
our brands including
Carnival Celebration
,
AIDAcosma
,
Costa Toscana
,
Discovery Princess
and
Arvia
, as well as our first luxury expedition ship,
Seabourn Venture
. All of these
ships were purpose-built to generate higher returns. In addition, we announced the
removal of additional ships from our fleet, bringing the cumulative number of
smaller-less efficient ships to be removed from our fleet since the pause to 26. Once
completed, these efforts will result in nearly a quarter of our fleet consisting of
newly delivered, larger, more efficient ships. We also announced Carnival Fun Italian
Style™, a new concept for Carnival Cruise Line’s North American guests which will
debut in the spring of 2023 with
Costa Venezia
followed by
Costa Firenze
in the spring
of 2024. Additionally, during 2022,
Costa Luminosa
was transferred to Carnival
Cruise Line and began guest operations as
Carnival Luminosa
.
Letter to Shareholders from our Chief Executive Officer
During 2022, we reduced our capital expenditures by over $500 million as compared
to our previous guidance. We have re-prioritized our expected spend to reflect the
current environment, while maintaining our commitment to seek excellence in
compliance, environmental protection, and in looking after the safety, health and well-
being of every life we touch. In addition, we broke ground on a new exclusive
destination in Grand Bahama Port for our Carnival Cruise Line brand, which will be
an important addition to our current existing private islands and unique port
destinations which had 6 million visits from our guests in 2022.
Going forward, we are committed to using our expected cash provided by operating
activities to strengthen the balance sheet over time and expect to be disciplined
and rigorous in making newbuild decisions. We have just four larger ships on order
through 2025, plus our second Seabourn luxury expedition ship to be delivered in
2023. This is our lowest order book in decades.
Overall, we remain focused on driving revenue growth and accelerating our return
to strong profitability. We believe that over time, this revenue generation and our
more focused capital expenditure profile will support significant free cash flow,
and propel us on the path to deleveraging, investment grade credit ratings and higher
return on invested capital. This has been a truly remarkable year and we have
come a long way in an incredibly short amount of time. We look forward to continuing
to deliver unforgettable happiness to our guests by providing extraordinary cruise
vacations in 2023, while honoring the integrity of every ocean we sail, place we visit
and life we touch.
Sincerely,
JOSH WEINSTEIN
President, Chief Executive Officer and Chief Climate Officer
February 28, 2023
Letter to Shareholders from our Chief Executive Officer
Table of Contents
i
INFORMATION ABOUT ATTENDING THE
ANNUAL MEETINGS
iii
VOTING INFORMATION
iv
NOTICE OF 2023 ANNUAL MEETING OF
CARNIVAL CORPORATION SHAREHOLDERS
vii
NOTICE OF 2023 ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING
OF CARNIVAL PLC SHAREHOLDERS
1
PROXY SUMMARY
7
GOVERNANCE AND BOARD MATTERS
7
Proposals 1-11
―
Election or Re-Election of
Directors
7
Governance
8
Nominations of Directors
10
2023 Nominees for Election or Re-Election to the
Boards
16
Board and Committee Governance
26
Non-Executive Director Compensation
29
Related Person Transactions
31
SHARE OWNERSHIP
31
Share Ownership of Certain Beneficial Owners and
Management
35
COMPENSATION
35
Proposal 12
―
Advisory (Non-Binding) Vote to
Approve Executive Compensation
36
Proposal 13
―
Advisory (Non-Binding) Vote on
How Frequently Shareholders Should Vote to
Approve Compensation of the Named Executive
Officers
37
Proposal 14
―
Advisory (Non-Binding) Vote to
Approve the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report (other than the part containing the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Policy set
out in Section B of Part II of the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Report)
38
Proposal 15
―
To approve the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Policy set out in
Section B of Part II of the Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Report.
39
Compensation Discussion and Analysis and
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part I)
72
Report of the Compensation Committees
72
Compensation Committee Interlocks and Insider
Participation
73
Compensation Tables
80
Potential Payments Upon Termination or Change
of Control
84
U.S. CEO Pay Ratio
85
AUDIT MATTERS
85
Proposal 16
―
Re-Appointment of the
Independent Auditors of Carnival plc and
Ratification of the Selection of Independent
Registered Public Accounting Firm of Carnival
Corporation
85
Proposal 17
―
Authorization to Determine the
Remuneration of the Independent Auditors of
Carnival plc
86
Report of the Audit Committees
88
Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm
89
OTHER PROPOSALS
89
Proposal 18
―
Receipt of Accounts and Reports of
Carnival plc
90
Proposal 19
―
Approval of the Grant of Authority
to Allot New Carnival plc Shares
90
Proposal 20
―
Approval of the Disapplication of
Pre-Emption Rights Applicable to the Allotment
of New Carnival plc Shares and Sale of Treasury
Shares
93
Proposal 21
―
Approval of a General Authority to
Buy Back Carnival plc Ordinary Shares
95
Proposal 22
―
Approval of the Amendment to the
Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan
106
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
106
Questions Applicable to All Shareholders
113
Questions Specific to Shareholders of Carnival
Corporation
117
Questions Specific to Shareholders of Carnival plc
A-1
ANNEX A
―
CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REPORT
B-1
ANNEX B
―
CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’
REMUNERATION REPORT (PART II)
C-1
ANNEX C
―
CARNIVAL PLC CORPORATE
GOVERNANCE REPORT
D-1
ANNEX D
―
AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL
CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
Information about Attending the Annual
Meetings
You are cordially invited to attend our Annual Meetings of Shareholders:
DATE
TIME
LOCATION
Friday, April 21, 2023
8:30 a.m. (EDT)
The Carnival plc Annual General
Meeting will begin first, followed by the
Carnival Corporation Annual Meeting.
Shareholders of each may attend both
meetings.
Carnival Place
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue
Miami, Florida 33178
United States
LIVE VIDEO BROADCAST
Carnival House, 100 Harbour Parade, Southampton SO15 1ST,
United Kingdom, 1:30 p.m. (BST)
Shareholders planning to attend the live video broadcast in
Southampton must submit a proxy in order to vote as they will not
be able to vote in person from Southampton. Shareholders
attending the live video broadcast in Southampton will be able to
submit questions live to the Directors in Florida, but will not be
treated as, or considered to be, “in attendance” at the Annual
Meetings.
Details regarding the matters to be voted on are
contained in the attached Notices of Annual Meetings
of Shareholders and Proxy Statement. Because of
the dual listed company arrangement, all voting will
take place on a poll (or ballot).
We continue to closely monitor the public health
advisors and governmental regulations and guidelines
relating to health and safety, including COVID-19.
Please read the section “Safety and Security Measures”
below for further details on how we plan to conduct
the meetings to prioritize the safety and security of
our employees, shareholders and other stakeholders.
The Boards will continue to monitor the situation
closely and may need to make further adjustments
to the “Safety and Security Measures,” including any
additional restrictions or requirements for
shareholders to attend. Shareholders planning to
attend the meeting should therefore check the
“Investor Relations” section of our website at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
for any updates, which will be posted at least one
week prior to the Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
While we welcome the opportunity to engage with our
shareholders in person at the Annual Meetings of
Shareholders, we strongly encourage shareholders to
follow public health advice before deciding whether
to attend the meeting or not.
Your vote is important.
We encourage you to vote as
soon as possible to ensure your vote is recorded
promptly, even if you plan to attend the Annual
Meetings of Shareholders.
The Boards of Directors recommend that
you vote in favor of Proposals 1 through
12 and 14 through 22 and, in the case of
Proposal 13, that you vote in favor of
holding a non-binding advisory vote
every year to approve the compensation
of our Named Executive Officers.
The Boards of Directors consider the
approval of Proposals 1 through 12 and
14 through 22 (inclusive) and, in the case
of Proposal 13, the approval of holding a
non-binding advisory vote every year to
approve the compensation of our
Named Executive Officers to be in the
best interests of Carnival Corporation
and Carnival plc and their shareholders.
We are furnishing the proxy materials to shareholders on or about February 28, 2023
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
i
DIRECTIONS
MEETING ADMISSION REQUIREMENTS
For directions to the 2023 Annual Meetings of
Shareholders, you may contact Investor Relations at:
Attendance at the Annual Meeting of Carnival
Corporation Shareholders is limited to shareholders
and their duly appointed proxies or corporate
representatives. Each attendee will be asked to
present valid government-issued picture
identification, such as a driver’s license or passport.
Shareholders holding shares in brokerage accounts
(“under a street name”) will need to bring a copy of a
brokerage statement reflecting share ownership as of
the record date (February 21, 2023).
Carnival Corporation & plc
Attention: Investor Relations
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue
Miami, Florida 33178-2428
United States
ir@carnival.com
SAFETY AND SECURITY MEASURES
Attendees will be required to comply with any federal,
state and/or local government guidance in force on
the day of the Annual Meetings of Shareholders
relating to health and safety. You should not attend
the Annual Meetings of Shareholders if you are
experiencing any COVID-19 symptoms, are waiting on
a COVID-19 test result, have tested positive within
10 days preceding the date of the Annual Meetings of
Shareholders or you have come into close contact
with someone who suspects they have COVID-19, is
waiting for a COVID-19 test result, or has tested
positive for COVID-19 within the 10 days preceding
the date of the Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
Due to security measures, all bags will be subject to
search, and all persons who attend the meeting will
be subject to a metal detector and/or a hand wand
search. We will be unable to admit anyone who does
not comply with these safety and security procedures.
The Boards will continue to monitor the situation
closely and may need to make further adjustments to
the “Safety and Security Measures,” including any
additional restrictions or requirements for
shareholders to attend. Shareholders planning to
attend the meeting should therefore check the
“Investor Relations” section of our website at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
for
any updates, which will be posted at least one week
prior to the Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
Information about Attending the Annual Meetings
ii
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Voting Information
YOUR VOTE IS
IMPORTANT.
We encourage you
to vote as soon as
possible, even if
you plan to attend
the Annual
Meetings of
Shareholders.
ELIGIBILITY TO VOTE
All eligible shareholders may vote in person at the 2023 Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
Please refer to details about how to vote in person in the “Question and Answers” section.
Carnival Corporation Shareholders
Carnival plc Shareholders
You are eligible to vote if you were a
shareholder as of
the close of business
(EDT) on February 21, 2023.
You are eligible to vote if you are a
shareholder as of
6:30 p.m. (BST) on
April 19, 2023.
HOW TO VOTE
REGISTERED HOLDERS
To make sure your vote is counted, please cast your vote as soon as possible by one of the following methods:
Voting Method
Carnival Corporation Shareholders
Carnival plc Shareholders
Internet
www.proxyvote.com
, 24/7
www.sharevote.co.uk
, 24/7
Telephone
1-800-690-6903 (toll-free)
N/A
CREST
N/A
Using CREST electronic proxy appointment
service (if you hold your shares through
CREST)
Mobile
Device
Scan the QR code
Scan the QR code
Mail
Complete and mail your signed form
Complete and mail your signed proxy form
At the
Meeting
Attend the annual meeting and cast your
ballot
Attend the annual meeting and cast your
ballot
BENEFICIAL OWNERS (HOLDERS IN STREET NAME): your bank or broker will provide you with instructions on how to vote.
ENROLL FOR ELECTRONIC DELIVERY
We encourage shareholders to sign up to receive future proxy materials electronically. If you have not already enrolled,
please consider doing so as it:
•
is simple and convenient
•
saves time and money
•
is environmentally friendly
Carnival Corporation Shareholders
Carnival plc Shareholders
Internet
www.investordelivery.com
www.shareview.co.uk
Mobile
Device
Scan the QR code
Scan the QR code
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
iii
Carnival Place
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue
Miami, Florida 33178-2428
United States
Notice of 2023 Annual Meeting of Carnival
Corporation Shareholders
We are pleased to invite you to attend Carnival Corporation’s 2023 Annual Meeting of Carnival Corporation Shareholders.
WHEN
WHERE
ELIGIBILITY TO VOTE AND RECORD DATE
Friday, April 21, 2023
8:30 a.m. (EDT)
Carnival Place
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue
Miami, Florida 33178
United States
The Board of Directors set February 21, 2023 as the
record date for the Annual Meeting of Carnival
Corporation Shareholders. This means that our
shareholders as of the close of business on that date
are entitled to receive this notice of the meeting and
vote their shares.
Items of Business
Board
Recommendation
Page
Reference
1-11
To elect or re-elect 11 Directors, each to serve as a Director of Carnival
Corporation and as a Director of Carnival plc
FOR
each
director nominee
8
1
To re-elect Micky Arison as a Director of Carnival Corporation and as a
Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
12
2
To re-elect Sir Jonathon Band as a Director of Carnival Corporation and
as a Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
12
3
To re-elect Jason Glen Cahilly as a Director of Carnival Corporation and
as a Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
13
4
To re-elect Helen Deeble as a Director of Carnival Corporation and as a
Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
13
5
To re-elect Jeffrey J. Gearhart as a Director of Carnival Corporation and
as a Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
14
6
To re-elect Katie Lahey as a Director of Carnival Corporation and as a
Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
14
7
To elect Sara Mathew as a Director of Carnival Corporation and as a
Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
15
8
To re-elect Stuart Subotnick as a Director of Carnival Corporation and
as a Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
16
9
To re-elect Laura Weil as a Director of Carnival Corporation and as a
Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
17
10
To elect Josh Weinstein as a Director of Carnival Corporation and as a
Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
18
11
To re-elect Randall Weisenburger as a Director of Carnival Corporation
and as a Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
19
12
To hold a (non-binding) advisory vote to approve executive compensation.
FOR
40
13
To hold a (non-binding) advisory vote on how frequently shareholders should
vote to approve compensation of the Named Executive Officers.
EVERY YEAR
41
iv
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Items of Business
Board
Recommendation
Page
Reference
14
To hold a (non-binding) advisory vote to approve the Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Report (other than the part containing the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Policy set out in Section B of Part II of the Carnival
plc Directors’ Remuneration Report) (in accordance with legal requirements
applicable to UK companies).
FOR
42
15
To approve the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Policy set out in
Section B of Part II of the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (in
accordance with legal requirements applicable to UK companies).
FOR
43
16
To re-appoint the UK firm of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as independent
auditors of Carnival plc and to ratify the selection of the U.S. firm of
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as the independent registered public
accounting firm of Carnival Corporation.
FOR
92
17
To authorize the Audit Committee of Carnival plc to determine the
remuneration of the independent auditors of Carnival plc (in accordance with
legal requirements applicable to UK companies).
FOR
92
18
To receive the accounts and reports of the Directors and auditors of Carnival
plc for the year ended November 30, 2022 (in accordance with legal
requirements applicable to UK companies).
FOR
96
19
To approve the giving of authority for the allotment of new shares by Carnival
plc (in accordance with customary practice for UK companies).
FOR
97
20
To approve the disapplication of pre-emption rights in relation to the
allotment of new shares and sale of treasury shares by Carnival plc (in
accordance with customary practice for UK companies).
FOR
97
21
To approve a general authority for Carnival plc to buy back Carnival plc
ordinary shares in the open market (in accordance with legal requirements
applicable to UK companies desiring to implement share buyback programs).
FOR
100
22
To approve the Amendment of the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan.
FOR
102
23
To transact such other business as may properly come before the meeting.
How to Vote
Your vote is important.
Please review the proxy materials for the 2023 Annual Meeting of Carnival Corporation
Shareholders and follow the instructions.
INTERNET
TELEPHONE
MOBILE DEVICE
MAIL
AT THE MEETING
Registered
Holders
www.proxyvote.com
24/7
Call
1-800-690-6903
(toll-free)
Scan the QR code
Complete and mail your
signed form in the
postage-paid envelope
Attend the annual
meeting and cast your
ballot
Beneficial
Owners
(Holders
in Street
Name)
Follow the instructions provided by your broker, bank
or other nominee
Return a properly
executed voting
instruction form by mail,
depending upon the
methods your broker,
bank or other nominee
makes available
To attend the annual
meeting, you will need
proof of ownership and
a legal proxy from your
broker, bank or other
nominee
Deadline
11:59 p.m. Eastern Time on April 20, 2023,
if you are a registered holder
If you are a beneficial owner, please refer to the information
provided by your broker, bank or other nominee
Notice of 2023 Annual Meeting of Carnival Corporation Shareholders
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
v
Meeting Admission Requirements
Attendance at the Annual Meeting of Carnival
Corporation Shareholders is limited to shareholders
and their duly appointed proxies or corporate
representatives. Each attendee will be asked to
present valid government-issued picture identification,
such as a driver’s license or passport. Shareholders
holding shares in brokerage accounts (“under a street
name”) will need to bring a copy of a brokerage
statement reflecting share ownership as of the record
date (February 21, 2023). Additional requirements
are included in the “Safety and Security Measures”
section above.
Notice of Internet Availability
Carnival Corporation is continuing to take advantage
of U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”)
rules that allow it to deliver proxy materials over the
Internet. Under these rules, Carnival Corporation is
sending its shareholders a one-page notice regarding
the Internet availability of proxy materials instead
of a full set of proxy materials, unless they previously
requested to receive printed copies. If you receive
this one-page notice, you will not receive printed
copies of the proxy materials unless you specifically
request them. Instead, this notice tells you how to
access and review on the Internet all of the important
information contained in the proxy materials. This
notice also tells you how to submit your proxy card on
the Internet and how to request to receive a printed
copy of the proxy materials. All Carnival Corporation
shareholders are urged to follow the instructions in
the notice and submit their votes using one of the
voting methods described in the proxy materials. If
you receive a printed copy of the proxy materials,
the accompanying envelope for return of the proxy
card requires no postage.
Any shareholder attending the Annual Meeting of
Carnival Corporation Shareholders in Miami, Florida
may personally vote on all matters that are
considered, in which event any previously submitted
proxy will be revoked.
On Behalf of the Board of Directors,
ARNALDO PEREZ
Company Secretary
January 27, 2023
IMPORTANT NOTICE REGARDING THE AVAILABILITY
OF PROXY MATERIALS FOR THE SHAREHOLDER
MEETINGS TO BE HELD ON APRIL 21, 2023
The Notice of Annual Meetings of Shareholders, Proxy
Statement and the Annual Report are available our websites at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
.
Notice of 2023 Annual Meeting of Carnival Corporation Shareholders
vi
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
(incorporated and registered in England
and Wales under number 4039524)
Carnival House
100 Harbour Parade
Southampton SO15 1ST
United Kingdom
Notice of 2023 Annual General Meeting
of Carnival plc Shareholders
THIS NOTICE OF ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING IS IMPORTANT
AND REQUIRES YOUR IMMEDIATE ATTENTION.
If you are in
any doubt as to any aspect of the proposals referred to in this
document or as to the action you should take, you should
immediately consult your stockbroker, bank manager,
solicitor, accountant or other independent financial advisor
authorized under the UK Financial Services and Markets Act
2000.
If you have sold or otherwise transferred all your
shares in Carnival plc, please send this
document and the accompanying documents to
the purchaser or transferee or to the
stockbroker, bank or other agent through whom
the sale or transfer was effected for
transmission to the purchaser or transferee.
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that an ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING of Carnival plc will be held:
WHEN
WHERE
ELIGIBILITY TO VOTE
Friday, April 21, 2023
8:30 a.m. (EDT)
Carnival Place
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue
Miami, Florida 33178
United States
Carnival plc, pursuant to Regulation 41 of the
Uncertificated Securities Regulations 2001, specifies that
only those shareholders registered in the register of
members of Carnival plc at 6:30 p.m. (BST) on April 19,
2023 shall be entitled to attend or vote at the meeting
in respect of the number of shares registered in their
name at that time. Changes to the entries on the
register of members after 6:30 p.m. (BST) on April 19,
2023 shall be disregarded in determining the rights of
any person to attend or vote at the meeting.
LIVE VIDEO BROADCAST
Carnival House, 100 Harbour Parade, Southampton SO15 1ST,
United Kingdom, 1:30 p.m. (BST)
Shareholders planning to attend the live video broadcast in
Southampton must submit a proxy in order to vote as they will not
be able to vote in person from Southampton. Shareholders
attending the live video broadcast in Southampton will be able to
submit questions live to the Directors in Florida, but will not be
treated as, or considered to be, “in attendance” at the Annual
Meetings.
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
vii
The meeting will be held for the purpose of considering and, if thought fit, passing the resolutions described below:
Proposals
Vote Required
•
Proposals 1 through 19 and
Proposal 22 will be proposed as
ordinary resolutions
.
For ordinary resolutions, the
required majority is more than 50% of the
combined votes cast
at this meeting and the Annual Meeting of Carnival
Corporation Shareholders.
•
Proposals 20 and 21 will be
proposed as
special
resolutions
.
For special resolutions, the
required majority is not less than 75% of the
combined votes cast
at this meeting and the Annual Meeting Carnival
Corporation Shareholders.
Proposals
Board
Recommendation
Page
Reference
1-11
ELECTION OR RE-ELECTION OF 11 DIRECTORS NAMED IN THIS PROXY
STATEMENT
To elect or re-elect 11 Directors, each to serve as a Director of Carnival
Corporation and as a Director of Carnival plc
FOR
each
director nominee
8
1
To re-elect Micky Arison as a Director of Carnival Corporation and as a
Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
12
2
To re-elect Sir Jonathon Band as a Director of Carnival Corporation and
as a Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
12
3
To re-elect Jason Glen Cahilly as a Director of Carnival Corporation and
as a Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
13
4
To re-elect Helen Deeble as a Director of Carnival Corporation and as a
Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
13
5
To re-elect Jeffrey J. Gearhart as a Director of Carnival Corporation and
as a Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
14
6
To re-elect Katie Lahey as a Director of Carnival Corporation and as a
Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
14
7
To elect Sara Mathew as a Director of Carnival Corporation and as a
Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
15
8
To re-elect Stuart Subotnick as a Director of Carnival Corporation and
as a Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
16
9
To re-elect Laura Weil as a Director of Carnival Corporation and as a
Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
17
10
To elect Josh Weinstein as a Director of Carnival Corporation and as a
Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
18
11
To re-elect Randall Weisenburger as a Director of Carnival Corporation
and as a Director of Carnival plc.
FOR
19
12-
13
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION
FOR
40
12
To hold a (non-binding) advisory vote to approve executive
compensation (in accordance with legal requirements applicable to U.S.
companies).
FOR
40
13
To hold a (non-binding) advisory vote on how frequently shareholders
should vote to approve compensation of the Named Executive Officers
(in accordance with legal requirements applicable to U.S. companies).
EVERY YEAR
41
14-
15
DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT
FOR
42
14
To hold a (non-binding) advisory vote to approve the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Report (other than the part containing the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Policy set out in Section B of
Part II of the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report) (as set out in
the annual report for the year ended November 30, 2022).
FOR
42
Notice of 2023 Annual General Meeting of Carnival plc Shareholders
viii
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Proposals
Board
Recommendation
Page
Reference
15
To approve the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Policy set out in
Section B of Part II of the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report
(as set out in the annual report for the year ended November 30, 2022).
FOR
43
16-
17
RE-APPOINTMENT AND REMUNERATION OF CARNIVAL PLC AUDITORS AND
RATIFICATION OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION AUDITORS
FOR
92
16
To re-appoint the UK firm of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as
independent auditors of Carnival plc and to ratify the selection of the
U.S. firm of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as the independent registered
public accounting firm of Carnival Corporation.
FOR
92
17
To authorize the Audit Committee of the Board of Directors of Carnival
plc to determine the remuneration of the independent auditors of
Carnival plc.
FOR
92
18
ACCOUNTS AND REPORTS
To receive the accounts and the reports of the Directors and auditors of
Carnival plc for the year ended November 30, 2022.
FOR
96
19
ALLOTMENT OF SHARES
THAT the Directors of Carnival plc be and they are hereby authorized to allot
shares in Carnival plc and to grant rights to subscribe for or convert any
security into shares in Carnival plc:
(a)
up to an aggregate nominal amount of $102,995,305 (such amount to be
reduced by the nominal amount allotted or granted under paragraph
(b) below in excess of such sum); and
(b)
up to an aggregate nominal amount of $205,990,610 (such amount to be
reduced by any allotments or grants made under paragraph (a) above) in
connection with an offer by way of a rights issue:
•
to ordinary shareholders in proportion (as nearly as may be
practicable) to their holdings of ordinary shares on the record date for
such allotment; and
•
to holders of other equity securities as required by the rights of those
securities or as the Directors of Carnival plc otherwise consider
necessary,
and so that the Directors of Carnival plc may impose any limits or
restrictions and make any arrangements which they consider necessary
or appropriate to deal with treasury shares, fractional entitlements,
record dates, legal, regulatory or practical problems in, or under the laws
of, any territory or any other matter, such authorities to apply until the
end of next year’s Carnival plc Annual General Meeting (or, if earlier, until
the close of business on July 20, 2024) but, in each case, during this
period Carnival plc may make offers and enter into agreements which
would, or might, require shares to be allotted or rights to subscribe for
or convert securities into shares to be granted after the authority expires
and the Directors of Carnival plc may allot shares or grant rights to
subscribe for or convert securities into shares under any such offer or
agreement as if the authority had not expired.
FOR
97
20
DISAPPLICATION OF PRE-EMPTION RIGHTS
THAT, subject to Proposal 19 passing, the Directors of Carnival plc be given
power to allot equity securities (as defined in the UK Companies Act 2006 (the
“Companies Act”)) for cash under the authority given by that resolution
and/or to sell ordinary shares held by Carnival plc as treasury shares for cash
as if Section 561 of the Companies Act did not apply to any such allotment or
sale, such power to be limited:
(a)
to the allotment of equity securities and sale of treasury shares for cash
in connection with an offer of, or invitation to apply for, equity securities
(but in the case of the authority granted under paragraph (b) of Proposal
19, by way of a rights issue only):
•
to ordinary shareholders in proportion (as nearly as may be
practicable) to their holdings of ordinary shares on the record date for
such allotment or sale; and
FOR
97
Notice of 2023 Annual General Meeting of Carnival plc Shareholders
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
ix
Proposals
Board
Recommendation
Page
Reference
•
to holders of other equity securities, as required by the rights of those
securities, or as the Directors of Carnival plc otherwise consider
necessary,
and so that the Directors of Carnival plc may impose any limits or
restrictions and make any arrangements which they consider necessary
or appropriate to deal with treasury shares, fractional entitlements,
record dates, legal, regulatory or practical problems in, or under the laws
of, any territory or any other matter;
(b)
in the case of the authority granted under paragraph (a) of Proposal 19
and/or in the case of any sale of treasury shares for cash, to the
allotment (otherwise than under paragraph (a) above) of equity
securities or sale of treasury shares up to a nominal amount of
$30,898,591; and
(c)
in the case of the authority granted under paragraph (a) of Proposal 19
and/or in the case of any sale of treasury shares for cash, to the
allotment of equity securities or sale of treasury shares (otherwise than
under paragraphs (a) or (b) above) up to a nominal amount equal to
2 percent of any allotment of equity securities or sale of treasury shares
from time to time under paragraph (b) above, such authority to be used
only for the purposes of making a follow-on offer which the Directors of
Carnival plc determine to be of a kind contemplated by paragraph 3 of
Section 2B of the Statement of Principles on Disapplying Pre-Emption
Rights most recently published by the Pre-Emption Group prior to the
date of this notice,
such power to apply until the end of next year’s Annual General Meeting (or,
if earlier, until the close of business on July 20, 2024) but, in each case, during
this period Carnival plc may make offers, and enter into agreements, which
would, or might, require equity securities to be allotted (and/or treasury
shares to be sold) after the power expires and the Directors of Carnival plc
may allot equity securities (and sell treasury shares) under any such offer or
agreement as if the power had not expired.
21
GENERAL AUTHORITY TO BUY BACK CARNIVAL PLC ORDINARY SHARES
THAT Carnival plc be and is generally and unconditionally authorized to make
market purchases (within the meaning of Section 693(4) of the Companies
Act) of ordinary shares of $1.66 each in the capital of Carnival plc on such
terms and in such manner as the Directors of Carnival plc may determine,
subject to the following conditions:
(a)
the maximum number of ordinary shares authorized to be acquired is
18,613,610;
(b)
the minimum price (exclusive of expenses) which may be paid for an
ordinary share is $1.66;
FOR
100
(c)
the maximum price which may be paid for an ordinary share is an
amount (exclusive of expenses) equal to the higher of:
•
105% of the average middle market quotation for an ordinary share of
Carnival plc, as derived from the London Stock Exchange Daily Official
List, for the five business days immediately preceding the day on
which such ordinary share is contracted to be purchased; and
•
the higher of the last independent trade and the highest current
independent bid for an ordinary share on the trading service venue
where the purchase is carried out; and
(d)
unless previously revoked or renewed, this authority shall expire at the
end of next year’s Annual General Meeting (or, if earlier, at close of
business on July 20, 2024), but during this period Carnival plc may make
contracts to purchase ordinary shares that would or might be executed
wholly or partly after the authority expires and Carnival plc may make
purchase of ordinary shares under any such contract as if the authority
had not expired.
22
AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
To approve the Amendment of the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan.
FOR
102
Notice of 2023 Annual General Meeting of Carnival plc Shareholders
x
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
There are 22 Proposals that require
shareholder approval at the Annual General
Meeting this year. The Directors
unanimously recommend that you vote in
favor of Proposals 1 through 12 and 14
through 22 (inclusive) and, in the case of
Proposal 13, that you vote in favor of
holding a non-binding advisory vote every
year to approve the compensation of our
Named Executive Officers.
The Directors encourage you to submit your vote
using one of the voting methods described herein.
Submitting your voting instructions by any of these
methods will not affect your right to attend the
meeting in person should you so choose.
Voting Arrangements for Carnival plc Shareholders
Your vote is important.
Carnival plc shareholders
can vote in any of the following three ways:
1.
by attending the Annual General Meeting and
voting in person or, in the case of corporate
shareholders, by corporate representatives;
2.
by appointing a proxy to attend and vote on
their behalf, using the proxy form enclosed with
this Notice of Annual General Meeting; or
3.
by voting electronically as described below.
VOTING IN PERSON
If you come to the Annual General Meeting, please
bring the attendance card (attached to the enclosed
proxy form) with you. This will mean you can register
more quickly.
In order to attend and vote at the Annual General
Meeting, a corporate shareholder may appoint one
or more individuals to act as its representative. The
appointment must comply with the requirements of
Section 323 of the Companies Act. Each representative
should bring evidence of their appointment,
including any authority under which it is signed, to
the meeting. If you are a corporation and are
considering appointing a corporate representative to
represent you and vote your shareholding in
Carnival plc at the Annual General Meeting, you are
strongly encouraged to pre-register your corporate
representative to make registration on the day of the
meeting more efficient. In order to pre-register,
please email your Letter of Representation to Carnival
plc’s registrars, Equiniti Limited, at
proxyvotes@equiniti.com.
Please note that each shareholder or their duly
appointed proxies and corporate representatives will
be required to comply with the “Meeting Admission
Requirements” and “Safety and Security Measures” in
the “Information about Attending the Annual
Meetings” section preceding the Carnival plc Notice
of Annual General Meeting.
VOTING BY PROXY
A shareholder entitled to attend and vote at the
meeting is entitled to appoint a proxy to exercise all
or any of their rights to attend, speak and vote in his or
her stead. A proxy need not be a shareholder of
Carnival plc. A shareholder may appoint more than
one proxy provided that each proxy is appointed to
exercise the rights attached to a different share or
shares held by that shareholder. To appoint more than
one proxy, please follow the notes contained in the
proxy form. A person who is nominated to enjoy
information rights in accordance with Section 146 of
the Companies Act, but who is not a shareholder, is
not entitled to appoint a proxy. Shareholders
planning to attend the live video broadcast in
Southampton must submit a proxy in order to vote
as they will not be able to vote in person from
Southampton.
Notice of 2023 Annual General Meeting of Carnival plc Shareholders
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
xi
If you are a person nominated to enjoy information
rights in accordance with Section 146 of the
Companies Act you may have a right under an
agreement between you and the member by whom
you were nominated to be appointed, or to have
someone else appointed, as a proxy for the meeting.
If you have no such right, or you have such a right
but do not wish to exercise it, you may have a right
under such an agreement to give instructions to the
member as to the exercise of voting rights.
To be effective, a duly completed proxy form and the
authority (if any) under which it is signed, or a
notarially certified copy of such authority, must be
deposited (whether delivered personally or by post)
at the offices of Carnival plc’s registrars as soon as
possible and in any event no later than 1:30 p.m. (BST)
on April 19, 2023.
Equiniti Limited
Aspect House
Spencer Road
Lancing BN99 6DA
United Kingdom
Alternatively, a proxy vote may be submitted via the
Internet in accordance with the instructions set out on
the proxy form.
In the case of joint registered holders, the signature
of one holder on a proxy card will be accepted and the
vote of the senior holder who tenders a vote,
whether in person or by proxy, shall be accepted to
the exclusion of the votes of the other joint holders.
For this purpose, seniority shall be determined by the
order in which names stand on the register of
shareholders of Carnival plc in respect of the relevant
joint holding.
If you are a member of CREST, you may register the
appointment of a proxy by using the CREST electronic
proxy appointment service. In order for a proxy
appointment or instruction made using the CREST
service to be valid, the appropriate CREST message (a
“CREST Proxy Instruction”) must be properly
authenticated in accordance with Euroclear’s
specifications and must contain the information
required for such instructions, as described in the
CREST Manual, which can be viewed at
www.euroclear.com. The message, regardless of
whether it constitutes the appointment of a proxy or
an amendment to the instruction given to a
previously appointed proxy must, in order to be valid,
be transmitted so as to be received by the issuer’s
agent (ID RA19) by the latest time(s) for receipt of
proxy appointments specified in the Notice of Annual
General Meeting. For this purpose, the time of
receipt will be taken to be the time (as determined by
the timestamp applied to the message by the CREST
Applications Host) from which the issuer’s agent is able
to retrieve the message by enquiry to CREST in the
manner prescribed by CREST. After this time any
change of instructions to proxies appointed through
CREST should be communicated to the appointee
through other means.
CREST members and, where applicable, their CREST
sponsors or voting service providers should note that
Euroclear does not make available special procedures
in CREST for any particular messages. Normal system
timings and limitations will therefore apply in
relation to the input of CREST Proxy Instructions. It is
the responsibility of the CREST member concerned
to take (or, if the CREST member is a CREST personal
member or sponsored member or has appointed a
voting service provider(s), to procure that his or her
CREST sponsor or voting service provider(s) take(s))
such action as shall be necessary to ensure that a
message is transmitted by means of the CREST system
by any particular time. In this connection, CREST
members and, where applicable, their CREST sponsors
or voting service providers are referred, in particular,
to those sections of the CREST Manual concerning
practical limitations of the CREST system and timings.
Carnival plc may treat as invalid a CREST Proxy
Instruction in the circumstances set out in
Regulation 35(5)(a) of the Uncertificated Securities
Regulations 2001.
If you are an institutional investor, you may be able
to appoint a proxy electronically via the Proxymity
platform, a process which has been agreed by Carnival
plc and approved by the Registrar. For further
information regarding Proxymity, please go to
www.proxymity.io. Your proxy must be lodged by
1:30 p.m. (BST) on April 19, 2023 in order to be
considered valid. Before you can appoint a proxy via
this process you will need to have agreed to
Proxymity’s associated terms and conditions. It is
important that you read these carefully as you will be
bound by them and they will govern the electronic
appointment of your proxy.
Notice of 2023 Annual General Meeting of Carnival plc Shareholders
xii
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
VOTING ELECTRONICALLY
Shareholders are entitled to vote online at
www.sharevote.co.uk.
Shareholders voting electronically should
vote as soon as possible, and in any event no later than 1:30 p.m. (BST) on April 19, 2023.
SHAREHOLDERS WHO ARE ENTITLED TO ATTEND OR VOTE
Carnival plc, pursuant to Regulation 41 of the
Uncertificated Securities Regulations 2001, specifies
that only those shareholders registered in the register
of members of Carnival plc at 6:30 p.m. (BST) on
April 19, 2023 shall be entitled to attend or vote at
the meeting in respect of the number of shares
registered in their name at that time. Changes to the
entries on the register of members after 6:30 p.m.
(BST) on April 19, 2023 shall be disregarded in
determining the rights of any person to attend or
vote at the meeting.
Asking Questions at the Meeting
Any shareholder attending the meeting has the right
to ask questions. Carnival plc must cause to be
answered any such question relating to the business
being dealt with at the meeting, but no such answer
need be given if:
•
to do so would interfere unduly with the preparation
for the meeting or involve the disclosure of
confidential information;
•
the answer has already been given on a website in
the form of an answer to a question; or
•
it is undesirable in the interests of Carnival plc or
the good order of the meeting that the question be
answered.
Shareholders attending the live video broadcast in
Southampton will be able to submit questions live to
the Directors in Florida, but will not be treated as,
or considered to be, “in attendance” at the Annual
General Meeting.
Documents Available for Inspection
Copies of all service agreements (including letters of
appointment) between each Director and Carnival plc
will be available for inspection during normal
business hours on any weekday (public holidays
excluded) at the registered office of Carnival plc from
the date of this notice until and including the date
of the meeting and at the place of the meeting for at
least 15 minutes prior to and during the meeting.
Rights Under Sections 338 and 338A
Under Sections 338 and 338A of the Companies Act,
shareholders meeting the threshold requirements in
those Sections have the right to require Carnival
plc: (i) to give, to shareholders of Carnival plc entitled
to receive notice of the meeting, notice of a
resolution which may properly be moved and is
intended to be moved at the meeting and/or (ii) to
include in the business to be dealt with at the meeting
any matter (other than a proposed resolution)
which may be properly included in the business
unless (a) (in the case of a resolution only) it would, if
passed, be ineffective, (b) it is defamatory
of any person, or (c) it is frivolous or vexatious. Such
a request may be in hard copy form or in electronic
form, must identify the resolution of which notice is
to be given or the matter to be included in the
business, must be authorized by the person or
persons making it, must be received by Carnival plc
not later than March 10, 2023, being the date six clear
weeks before the meeting, and (in the case of a
matter to be included in the business only) must be
accompanied by a statement setting out the grounds
for the request.
Notice of 2023 Annual General Meeting of Carnival plc Shareholders
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
xiii
Website Materials
This Proxy Statement and other information required
by Section 311A of the Companies Act have been
posted on our websites at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
.
You may not use any electronic address (within the
meaning of Section 333 of the Companies Act)
provided in this Proxy Statement (or in any related
documents including the proxy form) to communicate
with Carnival plc for any purposes other than those
expressly stated.
Under Section 527 of the Companies Act, shareholders
meeting the threshold requirements set out in that
Section have the right to require Carnival plc to publish
on a website a statement setting out any matter
relating to:
•
the audit of Carnival plc’s accounts (including the
auditor’s report and the conduct of the audit) that
are to be laid before the Annual General Meeting; or
•
any circumstance connected with an auditor of
Carnival plc ceasing to hold office since the previous
meeting at which annual accounts and reports
were laid in accordance with Section 437 of the
Companies Act.
Carnival plc may not require the shareholders
requesting any such website publication to pay its
expenses in complying with Sections 527 or 528 of the
Companies Act. Where Carnival plc is required to
place a statement on a website under Section 527 of
the Companies Act, it must forward the statement to
Carnival plc’s auditor not later than the time when it
makes the statement available on the website.
The business which may be dealt with at the Annual
General Meeting includes any statement that Carnival
plc has been required under Section 527 of the
Companies Act to publish on a website.
By Order of the Board of Directors,
ARNALDO PEREZ
Company Secretary
January 27, 2023
REGISTERED OFFICE
Carnival House
|
100 Harbour Parade
|
Southampton SO15 1ST
|
United Kingdom
Notice of 2023 Annual General Meeting of Carnival plc Shareholders
xiv
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Proxy Summary
This summary highlights information contained
elsewhere in this Proxy Statement. This summary does
not contain all of the information you should consider.
You should read the entire Proxy Statement carefully
before voting.
Corporate Governance Highlights
Corporate Governance Best Practices
9 of our 11 Directors
(1)
are independent, including
all members of the Audit, Compensation,
Compliance, Health, Environmental, Safety and
Security (“HESS”) and Nominating & Governance
Committees
Presiding Director and Senior Independent Director,
with defined responsibilities
4 of our 11 Directors
(1)
are female and one is
ethnically diverse
Balance of new and experienced Directors
Majority voting for Directors in uncontested
elections
Stock ownership guidelines for Directors and
executives
Regular shareholder engagement
Annual Director self-evaluation and committee
assessment to ensure Board effectiveness
All Directors attended over 75% of 2022 meetings
Regular executive sessions of independent
Directors
Robust risk oversight
Board review of our financial performance, strategy
and succession planning
Code of Business Conduct and Ethics
Commitment to corporate social responsibility and
sustainability
(1)
Following the 2023 Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
Our governance documents are available at
carnivalcorp.com/governance
and
carnivalplc.com/governance
.
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
1
OUR COMMITMENT TO COMPLIANCE, SUSTAINABILITY AND CORPORATE
SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
PROTECTING THE ENVIRONMENT
We strive to be a company that people want to work for
and to be an exemplary global corporate citizen. Our
commitment and actions to keep our guests and crew
members safe and well, protect the environment,
develop and provide opportunities for our workforce,
strengthen stakeholder relations and enhance both the
communities where we work as well as the port
communities that our ships visit, are reflective of our
brands’ core values and vital to our success.
In 2021, we established goals for 2030 which
incorporate six key focus areas listed below that align
with elements of the United Nation’s Sustainable
Development Goals and build on the momentum of our
successful achievement of our 2020 sustainability goals:
climate action; circular economy; good health and
well-being; sustainable tourism; biodiversity and
conservation; and diversity, equity and inclusion.
A key focus of our sustainability efforts is climate action,
which includes our commitment to reduce carbon
maritime scale battery technology and methanol
powered fuel cells and working with classification
societies and other stakeholders to assess lower carbon
fuel options for cruise ships, which include methanol,
bioLNG, eLNG, hydrogen, and biofuels. While alternative
fuels may provide a path to decarbonization for the
maritime industry, there are significant supply
challenges that must be resolved before viability is
reached. We are working with suppliers to encourage
investment in a reliable supply infrastructure.
During 2022, we also announced the global rollout of
Service Power Packages, a comprehensive set of
technology upgrades, which will be implemented over
the next several years across a portion of our fleet. The
Service Power Package upgrades are part of our
ongoing energy efficiency investment program and are
expected to further improve energy savings and reduce
fuel consumption. Upon completion, these upgrades are
expected to deliver an average of 5-10% fuel savings per
ship.
Proxy Summary
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE HIGHLIGHTS
2
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
PROTECTING THE ENVIRONMENT
emissions and our aspiration to achieve net carbon-
neutral operations. We have made significant progress
towards our 2030 carbon intensity reduction goals of
40% from a 2008 baseline, measured in both grams of
CO2e per ALB-km and kilograms of CO2e per ALBD.
During 2022, we updated the baseline year for both
goals to 2019 from 2008. Both 2030 goals now require a
20% improvement from 2019. With the updated
baseline year, we strengthened our 2030 goal measured
in kilograms of CO2e per ALBD since the initial 2030 goal
would only have required a further 15% reduction from
2019 levels. Our goal measured in grams of CO2e per
ALB-km remains the same. In addition, this new baseline
year helps us better communicate recent progress
against our climate goals to our investors and
stakeholders as well as modernize our disclosures in
alignment with developing best practice and reporting
standards.
In addition to our 2030 sustainability goals, we are
committed to continuing our reduction of carbon
emissions and have aspirations to achieve net carbon-
neutral operations by 2050, well ahead of current
International Maritime Organization (“IMO”) targets.
While fossil fuels are currently the only viable option for
our industry, we are closely monitoring technology
developments and partnering with key organizations to
help identify and scale new technologies not yet ready
for the cruise industry. For example, we are piloting
In addition, we have five Air Lubrication Systems (“ALS”)
currently operating in our fleet, we are currently
installing ALS on six ships, and we are planning at least
eight more installations. ALS cushion the flat bottom of
a ship’s hull with air bubbles, which reduces the ship’s
frictional resistance and the propulsive power required
to drive the ship through the water, which is expected to
generate approximately 5% savings in fuel consumption
and reductions in carbon emissions on ALS equipped
ships.
As part of our plan for carbon footprint reduction, we
have 11 LNG powered cruise ships that are expected to
join the fleet through 2025, including seven ships
already in operation as of November 30, 2022. In total,
these ships are expected to represent 20% of our total
future capacity by summer 2025. All of our LNG ships
also have the capability to run on conventional fuels.
LNG is a fossil fuel and generates carbon emissions. Its
direct CO2 emissions are lower than those of
conventional fuels and it emits effectively zero sulfur
oxides (only the sulfur in the pilot fuel is present),
reducing nitrogen oxides by 85% and particulate matter
by 95%-100%.
We pioneered the use of Advanced Air Quality Systems
on board our ships to aid in the reduction of sulfur and
lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions and are promoting
the use of shore power.
PROMOTING DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION
We believe that diversity and inclusion issues, such as
the attraction, retention, development and promotion of
women and people of color, are not only important
topics in corporations and boardrooms world-wide, but
they are issues critically important to sustaining the
success of our business. For years, we have partnered
with organizations focused on improving the diversity
and inclusiveness of workplaces and by extension,
society in general. We strive to achieve greater
performance through capturing the power of employee
diversity across all elements such as race, ethnicity, age,
gender and sexual orientation and identification.
Accordingly, Josh Weinstein, our President, Chief
Executive Officer (“CEO”) and Chief Climate Officer, has
committed to Catalyst’s “Catalyst CEO Champions for
Change” initiative to support the advancement of
women’s leadership and diversity in the workplace.
We are also a global partner of the International
LGBTQ+ Travel Association (IGLTA), the world’s leading
network of LGBTQ+ welcoming tourism businesses.
Through our partnership, we will help promote equality
and safety for LGBTQ+ tourism worldwide.
It is the policy of Carnival Corporation & plc that
disabled persons should receive full and fair
consideration for all job vacancies and promotions for
which they are qualified applicants. It is the policy of
Carnival Corporation & plc to seek to retain employees
who become disabled while in their service whenever
possible and to provide appropriate training and
accommodations for disabled persons.
Training and career development are provided and
encouraged for all employees, including disabled
persons.
Proxy Summary
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE HIGHLIGHTS
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
3
INVESTING IN OUR COMMUNITIES
Carnival Foundation is dedicated to creating positive
change through empowering youth, enhancing
education and strengthening families in the
communities where we live and work. Carnival
Foundation and the brands of Carnival Corporation &
plc support a broad spectrum of organizations that
positively impact thousands of youth and families each
year through charitable giving, in-kind donations and
volunteerism. Whether it is providing job training to the
homeless, preserving and protecting the environment,
furthering medical research or investing in our future
through education and mentoring, the reach of Carnival
Foundation is all-encompassing.
During times of crisis, Carnival Foundation works closely
with national and international relief organizations,
coordinating corporate and employee donations for
emergencies, such as hurricanes in the U.S. and in the
Caribbean.
Carnival Foundation’s contributions are spread to
communities where the brands operate, but focus on
organizations in South Florida, where Carnival
Corporation is headquartered.
www.carnivalfoundation.com
CORPORATE AWARDS AND RECOGNITION
Carnival Corporation & plc was
awarded a
2022 SABRE Award
, one
of the top public relations industry
awards, for its international
communications and reputation
work tied to restarting guest
cruise operations. The SABRE
Awards—which honor the best
communications campaigns from
the North America, Latin America,
Africa, South-East Asia, Europe,
Middle East and Africa and the
Asia-Pacific regions—attract more
than 5,000 entries from more than
60 countries.
Carnival Corporation & plc was
Recognized on
Forbes
’ annual
listings of
Worlds’ Best Employers
of 2022
and
Worlds’ Top Female-
Friendly Companies of 2022
for
the second consecutive year, and
America’s Best Employers for
Diversity
for the fourth consecutive
year.
Carnival Corporation & plc
was again recognized as one
of the
Best Companies for
Latinos to Work in 2022
by
Latino Leaders Magazine
, the
only national magazine fully
dedicated to showcasing
and promoting leadership in
the Latino community in the
U.S.
Carnival
Corporation & plc
earned a perfect
score for the sixth
consecutive year
on the
Human
Rights Campaign
Foundation’s 2022
Corporate
Equality Index
,
designating us as a
Best Place to Work
for LGBTQ Equality
for the fifth
consecutive year.
Several of our brands
earned top employer
recognitions and
honors for diversity,
equity and inclusion,
including awards for
Best Employers in
Germany
(AIDA
Cruises);
Investment
in People and
Empowering Filipino
Seafarers
(Carnival
Cruise Line); and
Best
Facilities for Guests
with Disabilities
(Holland America
Line).
Several of our brands also
earned recognitions for
responsible and safe
operations and community
support, including awards for
Best Service and Staff
(Princess Cruises),
Overall-
Giving Back Initiative
(Holland America Line) and
Most Trusted Cruise Line
(Carnival Cruise Line), along
with achieving and maintaining
the
ISO 14001 Environmental
Management System
standard
for over
15 consecutive years (Princess
Cruises).
Additionally,
CSMART Arison
Maritime Training
Center received the
2022 SAFETY4SEA
Training Award
for
expanding its
training portfolio to
include an online
and onboard
curriculum and
remote usage of its
simulation
technology.
Proxy Summary
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE HIGHLIGHTS
4
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Executive Compensation Highlights
COMPENSATION POLICIES AND PRACTICES
What We Do
What We Don’t Do
Independent Compensation Committees that review
and approve all compensation for our Named
Executive Officers
Independent compensation consultant
Annual Say-on-Pay vote
Stock ownership guidelines for Directors and
executive officers
Compensation Committees assess compensation
practices to deter excessive risk-taking
Pay-for-performance philosophy
Mix of compensation which includes short-term
cash and long-term equity-based compensation
Robust clawback policy
No guaranteed or unlimited incentive payouts in
our annual bonus plan
No evergreen provisions in our equity plan
No short sales, short-term hedging or margin sales
of our securities
No stock option repricing
No liberal share recycling of stock options or stock
appreciation rights
No pension plans or supplemental deferred
compensation or retirement plans for our Named
Executive Officers
No single-trigger change in control equity vesting
No Section 280G gross-up payments in the event of
change of control
PRINCIPAL COMPENSATION OBJECTIVES
We believe that our executive compensation program
should be appropriately tailored to balance
short-term and long-term compensation
opportunities to enable Carnival Corporation and
Carnival plc to meet short-term objectives while
continuing to produce value for their shareholders
over the long-term and supporting a strong focus on
retention. Our executive compensation program is
designed to:
1
2
3
Reward results and effective strategic
leadership through the use of both
short-term and long-term incentives,
taking into account each executive’s
performance, experience and
responsibilities.
Align executive interests with those
of our shareholders by making a
substantial portion of compensation
at risk and performance-based.
Remain competitive in the
marketplace in order to attract,
motivate and retain our talent that
we believe is necessary to achieve
our financial and strategic goals.
Proxy Summary
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION HIGHLIGHTS
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
5
TOTAL TARGET COMPENSATION MIX
(1)
CEO
Other NEOs
Long-Term
Equity
Incentives
50%
Base Salary
21%
Annual
Incentive Bonus
29%
79%
At-risk
86%
At-risk
Annual
Incentive
Bonus
29%
Long-Term
Equity
Incentives
57%
Base Salary
14%
(1)
At-risk compensation includes the Annual Incentive Bonus that is subject to performance criteria and the Long-Term Equity
Incentives that are subject to change in value based on share price movements during the vesting period.
SHAREHOLDER ENGAGEMENT
•
Carnival Corporation & plc has a long-standing shareholder outreach program and routinely interacts with
shareholders on a number of matters, including executive compensation. The Compensation Committees
consider all feedback received about executive compensation.
•
During the past year, as a supplement to our broader shareholder engagement program, we conducted
extensive shareholder outreach to understand the factors that drove investors’ evaluation of and voting on our
compensation program for Named Executive Officers, and to share and obtain feedback on the expected
evolution of our program, including returning to our historical practice of utilizing quantitative performance
criteria for fiscal 2022. We continue to seek and incorporate shareholder feedback in our compensation
deliberations. See “Shareholder Engagement” in Compensation, Discussion and Analysis section (also Part I of
the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report) for additional detail on our shareholder outreach program,
efforts in fiscal 2022 and outcome.
•
The Compensation Committees have implemented our quantitative and performance-based incentive program
in both 2022 and 2023 in a manner consistent with the feedback received from shareholders as part of our
engagement program and will continue to consider results from the annual shareholder advisory votes,
including the next vote in April 2023, as well as other shareholder input, when reviewing executive
compensation programs and policies.
Proxy Summary
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION HIGHLIGHTS
6
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Governance and Board Matters
PROPOSALS 1-11
Election or Re-Election of Directors
1
Micky Arison
5
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
9
Laura Weil
2
Sir Jonathon Band
6
Katie Lahey
10
Josh Weinstein
3
Jason Glen Cahilly
7
Sara Mathew
11
Randall Weisenburger
4
Helen Deeble
8
Stuart Subotnick
Governance
We are committed to governance policies and
practices so that shareholder and other stakeholder
interests are represented in a thoughtful and
independent manner. Sound principles of corporate
governance are critical to obtaining and retaining the
trust of investors. They are also vital in securing
respect from other key stakeholders and interested
parties, including our workforce, guests and suppliers,
the communities in which we conduct business,
government officials and the public-at-large. We
believe that our governance framework contributes
to the delivery of our corporate strategy in a number
of ways. The Boards and our Board Committees
support our senior management in the development,
refinement and execution of our corporate strategy
by providing independent oversight and valuable input
based on their wealth of knowledge and experience
in their areas of expertise. The Boards also oversee
our risk review and assessment processes, while
our Board Committees provide oversight over risks
within their area of remit, all of which are incorporated
into our strategic planning.
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc operate under
a dual listed company (“DLC”) arrangement with
primary stock listings in the United States (“U.S.”) and
the United Kingdom (“UK”). Accordingly, we
implemented a single corporate governance
framework consistent, to the extent possible, with
the governance practices and requirements of both
countries. While there are customs or practices that
differ between the two countries, we believe our
corporate governance framework effectively
addresses the corporate governance requirements of
both the U.S. and the UK.
Our corporate governance principles are set forth in
our Corporate Governance Guidelines and the
charters of our Board Committees. The actions
described in these documents, which the Boards
have reviewed and approved, implement applicable
requirements, including the New York Stock Exchange
listing requirements and, to the extent practicable,
the UK Corporate Governance Code published by the
UK Financial Reporting Council in July 2018 (the “UK
Corporate Governance Code”), as well our own vision
of good governance.
We will continue to monitor governance developments
in the U.S. and the UK to ensure a vigorous and
effective corporate governance framework of the
highest international standards.
Our Corporate Governance Guidelines, copies of the
charters of our Board Committees and our
organizational documents are available under the
“Governance” section of our website at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
.
The Boards are elected by the shareholders to exercise
business judgment to act in what they reasonably
believe to be in the best interests of Carnival
Corporation & plc and its shareholders. The Boards
select and oversee the members of senior
management, who are charged by the Boards with
conducting the business of Carnival Corporation & plc.
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
7
Nominations of Directors
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are two separate
legal entities and, therefore, each has a separate
Board of Directors, each of which in turn has its own
Nominating & Governance Committee. As the DLC
arrangement requires that there be identical Boards
of Directors, the Nominating & Governance
Committees make one set of determinations in
relation to both companies.
The Nominating & Governance Committees, which
are made up of independent Directors, actively seek
individuals qualified to become Board members and
recommend to the Boards the nominees to stand
for election as Directors at the Annual Meetings of
Shareholders or, if applicable, at a Special Meeting of
Shareholders.
When nominating candidates for the Boards of
Directors, including incumbent Directors eligible for
re-nomination, regardless of the source of the
nomination, the Nominating & Governance
Committees will consider, in accordance with their
charter, such factors as they deem appropriate,
including, but not limited to:
•
the candidate’s judgment;
•
the candidate’s skill;
•
contributions to the Boards of Directors (with
respect to incumbent Directors);
•
diversity considerations;
•
the candidate’s experience with business and
other organizations of comparable size;
•
the interplay of the candidate’s experience with the
experience of other members of the Boards; and
•
the extent to which the candidate would be a
desirable addition to the Boards and any
Committees of the Boards.
All candidates for nomination or re-nomination,
including incumbent Directors, have to disclose their
other significant commitments and provide
confirmation to the Nominating & Governance
Committees that they have sufficient time available
to fulfill the obligations of the office. The Nominating &
Governance Committees provides such disclosure
and confirmation to the Boards for their consideration
prior to the nomination or re-nomination of a
candidate.
Our Corporate Governance Guidelines state our
approach and policy on Director diversity, which is
that diversity should be considered by the
Nominating & Governance Committees in the
Director identification and nomination process. In
practical terms, this means that the Nominating &
Governance Committees seek nominees who bring a
variety of business backgrounds, experiences and
perspectives to the Boards. Consistent with our
strategy and overall policy of promoting diversity and
inclusion, the objective of the Boards’ approach to
diversity is that the backgrounds and qualifications of
the Directors, considered as a group, should provide
a broad diversity of experience, professions, skills,
geographic representations, knowledge and abilities,
as well as race, ethnicity, age, gender and sexual
orientation and identification, that will allow the
Boards to fulfill their responsibilities. The
Nominating & Governance Committees assess the
effectiveness of this approach as part of the annual
evaluations of our Boards of Directors.
The Boards also have a goal of having at least 33%
women on the Boards. This goal will be met following
the Annual Meetings of Shareholders (assuming the
election or re-election of all nominees to the Boards),
after which we will have 36% women on the Boards
(being four of 11 members).
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
NOMINATIONS OF DIRECTORS
8
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
BOARD REFRESHMENT
We have added six new Directors to our Boards since 2016, including three women.
2016
1 new Director joined
•
Helen Deeble
2017
1 new Director joined
Jason Glen Cahilly
•
2019
1 new Director joined
Katie Lahey
•
2020
1 new Director joined
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
•
Sara Mathew
•
2022
2 new Directors joined
Josh Weinstein
•
Assuming the election or re-election of all nominees
to the Boards, following the Annual Meetings of
Shareholders, 36% of the members of the Boards will
be women (being four of 11 members) and one
Director will be ethnically diverse.
The Boards currently meet the Parker Review
recommendation of having at least one ethnic
minority Director.
The Nominating & Governance Committees also use
their best efforts to ensure that the composition of the
Boards adheres to the independence requirements
applicable to companies listed for trading on the New
York Stock Exchange and the London Stock Exchange.
The Nominating & Governance Committees and the
Boards utilize the same criteria for evaluating
candidates regardless of the source of the referral.
Other than the foregoing, there are no stated
minimum criteria for Director nominees.
The Nominating & Governance Committees identify
nominees by first evaluating the current members of
the Boards willing to continue in service. As part of
Director succession planning, current members of the
Boards with skills and experience that are relevant
to our business and who are willing to continue in
service are considered for re-nomination, balancing
the value of continuity of service by existing members
of the Boards with that of obtaining a new perspective.
If any member of the Boards does not wish to
continue in service or if the Nominating & Governance
Committees or the Boards decide not to re-nominate
a member for re-election, the Nominating &
Governance Committees identify the desired skills
and experience of a new nominee in light of the criteria
above. Current members of the Nominating &
Governance Committees and the Boards are polled
for suggestions as to individuals meeting the criteria
of the Nominating & Governance Committees. The
Nominating & Governance Committees may consider
candidates proposed by management but are not
required to do so. The Nominating & Governance
Committees generally use third-party search firms to
identify and attract potential nominees.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
NOMINATIONS OF DIRECTORS
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
9
2023 Nominees for Election or Re-Election to the Boards
The DLC arrangement requires the Boards of Carnival
Corporation and Carnival plc to be identical.
Shareholders are required to approve the election or
re-election of Directors to each Board. There are
11 nominees for election or re-election to each Board
of Directors. Each nominee currently serves as a
Director of both companies, and each nominee is
standing for re-election, except for Ms. Mathew, who
was nominated to serve as a Director by the
Nominating & Governance Committees and appointed
by the Boards of Directors after an extensive
selection process involving a third-party search firm,
and Mr. Weinstein, who is our President, CEO and Chief
Climate Officer. All Board nominees are to be
elected or re-elected to serve until the next Annual
Meetings of Shareholders or until their successors are
elected.
All of the nominees have indicated that they will be
willing and able to serve as Directors.
With respect to each Board nominee set forth below,
the information presented includes such person’s
age, the year in which such person first became a
Director, any other position held with Carnival
Corporation and Carnival plc (including Board
Committee memberships effective February 1, 2023),
such person’s principal occupations during at least
the past five years, any directorships held by such
nominee in public or certain other companies over the
past five years, the nominee’s qualifications,
including particular areas of expertise, to serve as a
Director and the reasons why their contributions are,
and continue to be, important to our long-term
sustainable success.
In fiscal 2022, the Nominating & Governance
Committees and the Boards conducted performance
evaluations of the Boards, the Boards’ Committees
and the members of our Boards of Directors. The
Nominating & Governance Committees engaged a
third-party governance expert to perform an
assessment of the effectiveness of the Boards. The
third-party governance expert interviewed each
Director and members of senior management who
interact substantially with the Boards, reviewed the
results of the assessment with the Senior Independent
Director, and then presented the results of the
assessment as well as recommendations to the full
Boards, including our Chair. In addition to the external
evaluation, the Nominating & Governance Committees
reviewed the individual performance of each
member of the Boards of Directors focusing on his or
her contribution to Carnival Corporation and Carnival
plc and also discussed and reviewed with
Non-Executive Directors any significant time
commitments they have with other companies or
organizations. The Nominating & Governance
Committees reported the results of their review to
the Boards. The Boards determined that each
nominee was an effective and committed member of
the Boards and the Board Committees on which
each serves.
Accordingly, the Boards of Directors unanimously recommend a vote
FOR
the
election or re-election of each of the following Director nominees.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
2023 NOMINEES FOR ELECTION OR RE-ELECTION TO THE BOARDS
10
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
MICKY ARISON
AGE
73
Carnival Corporation Director
since
1987
Chair of the Board of Carnival
Corporation since
1990
Carnival plc Director since
2003
Chair of the Board of Carnival
plc since
2003
COMMITTEES
•
None
KEY EXPERIENCE AND QUALIFICATIONS
Mr. Arison’s qualifications to serve on the Boards include his decades of
leadership experience with Carnival Corporation & plc, as well as in-depth
knowledge of our business, our history and the cruise industry, all gained through
more than 50 years of service with our companies.
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
•
Carnival Corporation & plc
◦
Chair of the Board of Directors, Carnival Corporation (1990 to present)
◦
Chair of the Board of Directors, Carnival plc (2003 to present)
◦
CEO, Carnival Corporation (formerly known as Carnival Cruise Lines) (1979 to
2013)
◦
CEO, Carnival plc (2003 to 2013)
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
None
SIR JONATHON BAND
AGE
73
INDEPENDENT Carnival
Corporation Director since
2010
INDEPENDENT Carnival plc
Director since
2010
COMMITTEES
•
Compliance
•
HESS
•
Nominating & Governance
KEY EXPERIENCE AND QUALIFICATIONS
Sir Jonathon Band’s qualifications to serve on the Boards include his extensive
experience in maritime and security matters gained through his 42 years of
service with the British Navy. He also brings an international perspective of
company and industry matters.
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
•
The British Navy
◦
First Sea Lord and Chief of Naval Staff, the most senior officer position in the
British Navy (2006 to 2009, when he retired)
◦
Admiral and Commander-in-Chief Fleet (2002 to 2006)
◦
Served as a naval officer in increasing positions of authority (1967 to 2002)
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
Harland & Wolff Group Holdings plc (August 2021 to present)
PRIOR COMPANY BOARDS
•
Survitec Group (2015 to 2019)
•
Lockheed Martin UK Limited (2010 to 2015)
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
2023 NOMINEES FOR ELECTION OR RE-ELECTION TO THE BOARDS
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
11
JASON GLEN CAHILLY
AGE
52
INDEPENDENT Carnival
Corporation Director since
2017
INDEPENDENT Carnival plc
Director since
2017
COMMITTEES
•
Audit
•
Compensation
(effective February 1, 2023)
KEY EXPERIENCE AND QUALIFICATIONS
Mr. Cahilly’s qualifications to serve on the Boards include his more than 25 years’
experience in the global media, entertainment, sports, technology, leisure,
communications and finance sectors in a variety of senior leadership roles.
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
•
Dragon Group LLC and its affiliates
, a private firm that provides capital and
business management consulting and advisory services worldwide
◦
Chief Executive Officer (2017 to present)
•
The National Basketball Association
, a North American professional basketball
league
◦
Chief Strategic & Financial Officer (2013 to 2017)
•
Goldman Sachs & Co.
, a global investment banking, securities and investment
management firm
◦
Partner; Global Co-Head of Media and Telecommunications; Head of Principal
Investing for Technology, Media & Telecommunications (TMT); Co-Head of TMT
Americas Financing Group; and other roles of increasing responsibility (2000 to
2012)
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
Corsair Gaming, Inc. (2020 to present)
PRIOR COMPANY BOARDS
•
NBA China (2013-2017)
HELEN DEEBLE
AGE
61
INDEPENDENT Carnival
Corporation Director since
2016
INDEPENDENT Carnival plc
Director since
2016
COMMITTEES
•
Compensation
•
HESS
KEY EXPERIENCE AND QUALIFICATIONS
Ms. Deeble’s qualifications to serve on the Boards include her more than 30 years’
experience in retail, transport, logistics and leisure sectors in finance and general
management roles, including significant maritime operational and commercial
experience gained through her service as the Chief Executive Officer of a
passenger shipping organization. She is also a UK Chartered Accountant.
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
•
P&O Ferries Division Holdings Ltd.
, a pan-European shipping and logistics
business
◦
Chief Executive Officer (2006 to 2017)
◦
Chief Operating Officer (2004 to 2006)
◦
Chief Financial Officer (1998 to 2003)
•
UK Chamber of Shipping
, the UK shipping industry trade association
◦
VP and President (2011 to 2013)
•
Awarded
Commander of the Order of the British Empire
for services to shipping
(2013)
•
Stena Line UK
, a European passenger and freight operator
◦
Senior finance roles including Chief Financial Officer (1993 to 1998)
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
Non-Executive Director, CMO Group PLC (July 2021 to present)
OTHER CURRENT ENGAGEMENTS
•
Member of the Supervisory Board, the UK Chamber of Shipping
PRIOR COMPANY BOARDS
•
Non-Executive Director, the Port of London Authority (2014 to 2020)
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
2023 NOMINEES FOR ELECTION OR RE-ELECTION TO THE BOARDS
12
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
JEFFREY J. GEARHART
AGE
58
INDEPENDENT Carnival
Corporation Director since
2020
INDEPENDENT Carnival plc
Director since
2020
COMMITTEES
•
Compliance
(Chair effective February 1,
2023)
•
HESS
KEY EXPERIENCE AND QUALIFICATIONS
Mr. Gearhart’s qualifications to serve on the Boards include his experience as a
lawyer and his leadership experience as general counsel at a global retail
company, along with his expertise from having responsibility for global legal,
compliance, ethics and security and investigative functions.
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
•
Walmart, Inc.
, a global retailer
◦
Executive Vice President, Global Governance and Corporate Secretary,
responsible for oversight of Walmart Inc.’s global legal, compliance, ethics and
security and investigation functions, among others (2012 to 2018)
◦
Executive Vice President, General Counsel and Corporate Secretary (2010 to
2012)
◦
Executive Vice President, General Counsel (2009 to 2010)
◦
Senior Vice President and Deputy General Counsel (2007 to 2009)
◦
Vice President and General Counsel, Corporate Division (2003 to 2007)
•
Kutak Rock LLP
, a national law firm
◦
Partner, Corporate Securities and Mergers and Acquisitions (1998-2003)
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
Bank OZK (2018 to present)
KATIE LAHEY
AGE
72
INDEPENDENT Carnival
Corporation Director since
2019
INDEPENDENT Carnival plc
Director since
2019
COMMITTEES
•
HESS
•
Nominating & Governance
(effective February 1, 2023)
KEY EXPERIENCE AND QUALIFICATIONS
Ms. Lahey’s qualifications to serve on the Boards include her more than 30 years’
experience in the tourism, talent sourcing, cultural transformation, governmental,
retail and the arts sectors in a variety of leadership roles, including within the
cruise industry.
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
•
Korn Ferry Australasia
, a leadership and talent firm
◦
Non-Executive Chair (February to October 2019)
◦
Executive Chair (2011 to 2019)
•
The Tourism and Transport Forum Australia
, a tourism and transportation
industry group
◦
Chair (2015 to 2018)
•
Carnival Australia
, a division of Carnival plc
◦
Executive Chair (2006 to 2013)
INDUSTRY RECOGNITION
•
Member of the Order of Australia, for her significant services to business and
commerce and the arts (2013)
•
Awarded a Centenary Medal, for her contributions to Australian society in the area
of business leadership (2003)
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
None
PRIOR PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
Non-Executive Director, The Star Entertainment Group Limited (2012 to
December 2022)
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
2023 NOMINEES FOR ELECTION OR RE-ELECTION TO THE BOARDS
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
13
SARA MATHEW
AGE
67
INDEPENDENT Carnival
Corporation Director since
November 2022
INDEPENDENT Carnival plc
Director since
November 2022
COMMITTEES
•
Audit
KEY EXPERIENCE AND QUALIFICATIONS
Ms. Mathew’s qualifications to serve on the Boards include her more than two
decades of leadership experience as a senior executive with significant strategic
and operational expertise to drive transformative growth at large international
companies as well as deep background in finance, accounting, technology and
innovation.
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
•
Dun & Bradstreet Corporation
, a commercial data analytics company
◦
Chair, President and Chief Executive Officer (2010 to 2013)
◦
President and Chief Operating Officer (2007 to 2010)
◦
Chief Financial Officer (2001 to 2007)
•
The Proctor & Gamble Company
, a consumer goods company
◦
Division Chief Financial Officer — Baby Care; Regional Vice President — Finance,
ASEAN; Comptroller; Assistant Treasurer; and other roles of increasing
responsibility (1983 to 2001)
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
Dropbox Inc. (2021 to present)
•
State Street Corporation (2018 to present)
•
Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac) (2013 to present)
PRIOR PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
XOS Inc. (and predecessor NextGen Acquisition Corporation) (2020 to
October 2022)
•
Reckitt Beckiser Group plc (2019 to May 2022)
•
Shire plc (2015 to 2019)
•
Campbell Soup Co. (2005 to 2019)
STUART SUBOTNICK
AGE
81
INDEPENDENT Carnival
Corporation Director since
1987
INDEPENDENT Carnival plc
Director since
2003
COMMITTEES
•
Audit
•
Compliance
•
Nominating & Governance
KEY EXPERIENCE AND QUALIFICATIONS
Mr. Subotnick’s qualifications to serve on the Boards include his significant
experience in financing, investing and general business matters, as well as his
past Board experience with us, which are important to the Boards when reviewing
our investor relations, assessing potential financings and strategies, and
otherwise evaluating our business decisions.
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
•
Metromedia Company
, a privately held diversified Delaware general partnership
◦
President and Chief Executive Officer (2010 to present)
◦
General Partner and Executive Vice President (1986 to 2010)
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
None
PRIOR PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
AboveNet, Inc. (1997 to 2012)
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
2023 NOMINEES FOR ELECTION OR RE-ELECTION TO THE BOARDS
14
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
LAURA WEIL
AGE
66
INDEPENDENT Carnival
Corporation Director since
2007
INDEPENDENT Carnival plc
Director since
2007
COMMITTEES
•
Audit
(Chair effective February 1,
2023)
•
Compensation
•
Compliance
KEY EXPERIENCE AND QUALIFICATIONS
Ms. Weil’s qualifications to serve on the Boards include her extensive financial,
strategic information technology and operating skills developed over many years
as an investment banker and senior financial operating executive. Ms. Weil also
brings significant experience in global digital transformation and consumer
strategies from her leadership experience with multi-billion dollar New York Stock
Exchange-listed retailers.
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
•
Village Lane Advisory LLC
, which specializes in providing executive and strategic
consulting services to retailers as well as private equity firms
◦
Founder and Managing Partner (2015 to present)
•
New York & Company, Inc.
, a women’s apparel and accessories retailer
◦
Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer (2012 to 2014)
•
Ashley Stewart LLC
, a privately held retailer
◦
Chief Executive Officer (2010 to 2011)
•
Urban Brands, Inc.
, a privately held apparel retailer
◦
Chief Executive Officer (2009 to 2010)
•
AnnTaylor Stores Corporation
, a women’s apparel company
◦
Chief Operating Officer and Senior Executive Vice President (2005 to 2006)
•
American Eagle Outfitters, Inc.
, a global apparel retailer
◦
Chief Financial Officer and Executive Vice President (1995 to 2005)
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
Global Fashion Group, S.A. (2019 to present)
•
Pearl Holdings Acquisition Corp. (December 2021 to present)
PRIOR PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
Christopher & Banks Corporation (2016 to 2019)
JOSH WEINSTEIN
AGE
48
Carnival Corporation Director
since
August 2022
Carnival plc Director since
August 2022
COMMITTEES
•
None
KEY EXPERIENCE AND QUALIFICATIONS
Mr. Weinstein’s qualifications to serve on the Boards include his 20-year track
record of management and strategic leadership in several critical senior-level
roles at Carnival Corporation & plc, experience in strategy, operations, finance and
legal and extensive knowledge of our business and the cruise industry.
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
•
Carnival Corporation & plc
◦
President, CEO and Chief Climate Officer (August 2022 to present)
◦
Chief Operations Officer (2020 to July 2022)
◦
President, Carnival UK (2017 to 2020)
◦
Treasurer (2007 to 2017)
◦
Assistant General Counsel (2003 to 2007)
◦
Associate General Counsel (2002 to 2003)
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
None
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
2023 NOMINEES FOR ELECTION OR RE-ELECTION TO THE BOARDS
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
15
RANDALL
WEISENBURGER
AGE
64
INDEPENDENT Carnival
Corporation Director since
2009
INDEPENDENT Carnival plc
Director since
2009
Presiding Director and Senior
Independent Director
COMMITTEES
•
Compensation
•
Compliance
•
HESS
•
Nominating & Governance
KEY EXPERIENCE AND QUALIFICATIONS
Mr. Weisenburger’s qualifications to serve on the Boards include his broad
leadership and operational skills gained as a senior executive of a large
multi-national corporation and his extensive financial and accounting skills
acquired as an investment banker and senior financial operating executive. He
also has broad experience in corporate governance, having served as a director,
past and present, of a number of other publicly-traded companies.
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
•
Mile 26 Capital LLC
, a private investment firm
◦
Managing Member (2014 to present)
•
Omnicom Group Inc.
, a Fortune 250 global advertising, marketing and corporate
communications company
◦
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer (1998 to 2014)
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
•
Corsair Gaming, Inc. (2020 to present)
•
MP Materials Corp (2020 to present)
•
Valero Energy Corporation (2011 to present)
Board and Committee Governance
BOARD MEETINGS
During the year ended November 30, 2022, the
Board of Directors of each of Carnival Corporation
and Carnival plc held a total of 11 meetings. Each
Carnival Corporation Director and each Carnival plc
Director attended either telephonically or in person at
least 75% of all Carnival Corporation & plc Boards of
Directors meetings and applicable Board Committee
meetings held during the period that he or she
served in fiscal 2022. All Directors then serving
attended the 2022 Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
As set forth in our Corporate Governance Guidelines,
the Boards of Directors expect that all Directors will
attend the Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
BOARD AND COMMITTEE GOVERNANCE
16
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
BOARD LEADERSHIP STRUCTURE
MICKY
ARISON
JOSH
WEINSTEIN
RANDALL
WEISENBURGER
Executive Chair of the Boards
President, CEO and Chief Climate Officer
Presiding Director and
Senior Independent Director
Our Boards of Directors are led by our executive
Chair, Mr. Arison. The CEO position is currently
separate from the Chair. The Boards maintain the
flexibility to determine whether the roles of Chair and
CEO should be combined or separated, based on
what they believe is in the best interests of Carnival
Corporation & plc at a given point in time. We believe
that the separation of the Chair and CEO positions
is an appropriate corporate governance practice for
us at this time, and that having Mr. Arison as our
executive Chair enables Carnival Corporation & plc
and the Boards to continue to benefit from Mr. Arison’s
skills and expertise, including his extensive knowledge
of our business.
Our Non-Executive Directors, all of whom are
independent, meet privately in executive session at
least quarterly. The Presiding Director leads those
meetings and also acts as the Senior Independent
Director under the UK Corporate Governance Code. In
addition, the Presiding Director serves as the
principal liaison to the Non-Executive Directors,
reviews and approves meeting agendas for the Boards
and reviews meeting schedules. Our Non-Executive
Directors, acting in executive session, elected Randall
Weisenburger as the Presiding Director and Senior
Independent Director. Mr. Weisenburger brought to
those roles significant board leadership experience,
including as the Chair of our Compensation
Committees, familiarity with our Board processes
and company structures as a seasoned member of
several of our Board committees, and extensive skills
and experience gained as a senior executive of a
large multi-national corporation and a director
(current and former) of other public and private
companies.
The structure of our Boards facilitates the continued
strong communication and coordination between
management and the Boards and enables the Boards
to fulfill their risk oversight responsibilities, as
further described below.
BOARD COMMITTEES
The Boards delegate various responsibilities and
authority to different Board Committees. The Board
Committees regularly report on their activities and
actions to the full Boards. The Board of Directors of
each of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc has
established standing Board Committees, which are
each comprised of the same Directors for each
company, as follows:
Audit
HESS
Compensation
Nominating &
Governance (“N&G”)
Compliance
In July 2022, the Boards dissolved the Executive
Committees as the Executive Committees rarely acted
and therefore were no longer deemed necessary.
Each Board Committee periodically reviews its charter
in light of new developments in applicable regulations
and may make additional recommendations to the
Boards to reflect evolving best practices.
Committee charters are available at:
www.carnivalcorp.com/governance/committee-
charters
and
www.carnivalplc.com/governance/
committee-charters.
Each Board Committee can engage outside experts,
advisors and counsel to assist the Board Committee in
its work.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
BOARD AND COMMITTEE GOVERNANCE
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
17
As of February 1, 2023, the Board Committee members will be as follows:
Carnival Corporation & plc Board Committees
Name
Independent
Audit
Compensation
Compliance
HESS
N&G
Micky Arison
Sir Jonathon Band
Jason Glen Cahilly
Helen Deeble
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
Richard J. Glasier
(1)
Katie Lahey
Sara Mathew
Sir John Parker
(1)
Stuart Subotnick
Laura Weil
Josh Weinstein
Randall Weisenburger
Committee
Chair
Committee
Member
Executive
Chair
Presiding Director and
Senior Independent Director
Audit Committee
financial expert
(1)
Richard J. Glasier and Sir John Parker have decided not to seek re-election and will retire from the Boards and their Committees
with effect from the conclusion of the 2023 Annual Meetings of Shareholders, at which time the size of the Boards of Directors
will be reduced to 11 members.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
BOARD AND COMMITTEE GOVERNANCE
18
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
$
AUDIT COMMITTEES
MEMBERS
•
Laura Weil, Chair
(effective February 1, 2023)
•
Richard J. Glasier, Chair
(until January 31, 2023)
(1)
•
Jason Glen Cahilly
•
Sara Mathew
•
Stuart Subotnick
QUALIFICATIONS
•
The Board of Directors of Carnival Corporation has
determined that each member of the Audit
Committees is both “independent” and an “audit
committee financial expert,” as defined by SEC rules.
•
In addition, the Board of Directors of Carnival plc has
determined that each member of the Audit
Committees is “independent” and had “recent and
relevant financial experience” for the purposes of the
UK Corporate Governance Code.
•
The Boards determined that each member of the
Audit Committees has sufficient knowledge in reading
and understanding our financial statements to serve
on the Audit Committees.
FY2022 MEETINGS:
11
KEY RESPONSIBILITIES
The Audit Committees assist the Boards in their general
oversight of:
•
integrity of our financial statements;
•
our compliance with legal and regulatory requirements (other
than health, environmental, safety and security matters and
compliance matters addressed by the Compliance
Committees);
•
performance of our internal audit functions, including fraud
investigations, internal controls and process efficiencies;
•
independent auditors’ qualifications, independence and
performance; and
•
risk management related to financial, information technology
(including cybersecurity and data privacy) and non-HESS
related operational risks, as well as monitoring changes to and
compliance with related legal and regulatory requirements.
The Audit Committees are also responsible for the appointment,
retention, compensation and oversight of the work of our
independent auditors and our independent registered public
accounting firm.
FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
The responsibilities and activities of the Audit Committees are
described in detail in “Report of the Audit Committees” and the
Audit Committees’ charter.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
BOARD AND COMMITTEE GOVERNANCE
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
19
$
COMPENSATION COMMITTEES
MEMBERS
•
Randall Weisenburger,
Chair
•
Jason Glen Cahilly
(effective February 1, 2023)
•
Helen Deeble
•
Richard J. Glasier
(1)
•
Laura Weil
QUALIFICATIONS
•
The Boards of Directors have determined that
each member of the Compensation Committees is
independent.
FY2022 MEETINGS:
6
KEY RESPONSIBILITIES
The Compensation Committees have authority for:
•
reviewing and determining salaries, performance-based
incentives and other matters related to the compensation of
our executive officers and executive Directors; and
•
overseeing the administration of our stock incentive plans,
including reviewing and granting equity-based grants to our
executive officers and other employees, and our employee
stock purchase plans.
The Compensation Committees also review and determine
various other compensation policies and matters, including:
•
making recommendations to the Boards with respect to the
compensation of the Non-Executive (non-employee) Directors,
incentive compensation and equity-based plans generally; and
•
oversee assessment of whether there are material risks
associated with our executive compensation structure, policies
and programs.
FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
For more information on the responsibilities and activities of the
Compensation Committees, including the Committees’ processes
for determining executive compensation, see “Compensation
Discussion and Analysis” and “Executive Compensation” sections
and the Compensation Committees’ charter.
COMPLIANCE COMMITTEES
MEMBERS
•
Jeffrey J. Gearhart, Chair
(effective February 1, 2023)
•
Randall Weisenburger,
Chair
(until January 31, 2023)
•
Sir Jonathon Band
•
Richard J. Glasier
(1)
•
Stuart Subotnick
•
Laura Weil
QUALIFICATIONS
•
The Boards of Directors have determined that
each member of the Compliance Committees is
independent.
FY2022 MEETINGS:
6
KEY RESPONSIBILITIES
The Compliance Committees assist the Boards with oversight of
activities that are designed to promote ethical conduct, the
highest level of integrity and compliance with all laws,
regulations and policies applicable to us.
They receive regular reports from, and provide direction to, the
Chief Risk and Compliance Officer with respect to the activities of
our Global Ethics and Compliance Department (“GE&C”) and its
implementation of processes to support a high level of ethics,
integrity and compliance with applicable laws and regulations.
The Compliance Committees also:
•
oversee risk management related to compliance with
applicable laws and regulations, including our compliance
monitoring activities supporting a high level of ethics and
integrity;
•
provide functional oversight of our Incident Analysis Group
(“IAG”), review the results of any internal or external audits and
investigations relating to ethics and compliance matters;
•
establish and monitor policies and procedures for confidential
submission, receipt, retention and treatment of complaints
and concerns; and
•
promote accountability of senior management with respect to
ethics and compliance matters.
FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
For more information on the responsibilities and activities of the
Compliance Committees, see the Compliance Committees’
charter.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
BOARD AND COMMITTEE GOVERNANCE
20
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
HESS COMMITTEES
MEMBERS
•
Sir Jonathon Band, Chair
•
Helen Deeble
•
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
•
Katie Lahey
•
Sir John Parker
(1)
•
Randall Weisenburger
QUALIFICATIONS
•
The Boards of Directors have determined that
each member of the HESS Committees is
independent.
FY2022 MEETINGS:
6
KEY RESPONSIBILITIES
The HESS Committees supervise and monitor HESS and
sustainability policies, programs, initiatives at sea and onshore,
and compliance with HESS and sustainability-related legal and
regulatory requirements.
The HESS Committees also:
•
review and recommend HESS and sustainability policies,
procedures, practices and training, and oversee compliance
with such policies, procedures and practices;
•
review and recommend appropriate policies, procedures,
practices and training relative to sustainability reporting; and
•
oversee risk management related to significant HESS and
sustainability risks or exposures as well as monitoring changes
to and compliance with related legal and regulatory
requirements.
FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
For more information on the responsibilities and activities of the
HESS Committees, see the HESS Committees’ charter.
NOMINATING & GOVERNANCE
COMMITTEES
MEMBERS
•
Stuart Subotnick, Chair
•
Sir Jonathon Band
•
Richard J. Glasier
(1)
•
Katie Lahey
(effective February 1,
2023)
•
Sir John Parker
(1)
•
Randall Weisenburger
QUALIFICATIONS
•
The Boards of Directors have determined that
each member of the Nominating & Governance
Committees is independent.
FY2022 MEETINGS:
4
KEY RESPONSIBILITIES
The Nominating & Governance Committees:
•
engage in succession planning for the Boards;
•
assist the Boards by identifying individuals qualified to
become Board members;
•
report to the Boards on a periodic basis with regard to matters
of corporate governance and succession planning;
•
review and assess the effectiveness of our Corporate
Governance Guidelines;
•
recommend to the Boards director nominees for each
committee; and
•
make recommendations to the Boards regarding the size and
composition of the Boards and their Committees.
FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
For more information on the responsibilities and activities of the
Nominating & Governance Committees, see “Nominations of
Directors” and “Procedures Regarding Director Candidates
Recommended by Shareholders” sections and the Nominating &
Governance Committees’ charter.
Additional information with respect to Carnival plc’s corporate
governance practices during fiscal 2022 is included in the
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report attached as Annex C
to this Proxy Statement.
(1)
Richard J. Glasier and Sir John Parker have decided not to seek re-election and will retire from the Boards and their Committees
with effect from the conclusion of the 2023 Annual Meetings of Shareholders, at which time the size of the Boards of Directors
will be reduced to 11 members.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
BOARD AND COMMITTEE GOVERNANCE
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
21
BOARD AND COMMITTEE INDEPENDENCE
Under New York Stock Exchange and UK Corporate
Governance Code standards of independence for
directors, the Boards must determine that a Director
does not have any material relationship with
Carnival Corporation & plc or its subsidiaries (either
directly or as a partner, shareholder or officer of an
organization that has a relationship with Carnival
Corporation & plc) and meets certain bright-line tests.
Following an assessment of the Directors’
independence, including a review of their
independence questionnaires, the Boards of Directors
have determined that each of the following is an
“independent” Director in accordance with the New
York Stock Exchange and the UK Corporate
Governance Code standards of independence for
directors and that all members of the Audit
Committees and Compensation Committees meet
the heightened independence criteria applicable to
Directors serving on those Committees under SEC
rules and New York Stock Exchange listing standards
and the UK Corporate Governance Code:
82%
of the Board are
Independent Directors
(1)
Sir Jonathan Band
Jason Glen Cahilly
Helen Deeble
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
Katie Lahey
Sara Mathew
Stuart Subotnick
Laura Weil
Randall Weisenburger
9
2
(1)
Following the Annual Meetings of Shareholders. The
Boards of Directors have also determined that Richard J.
Glasier and Sir John Parker were independent during
the time they served as Directors.
Accordingly, a majority of the Directors of each
company, all of our Non-Executive Directors and all
of the members of the Audit, Compensation,
Compliance, HESS and Nominating & Governance
Committees of each company are independent (as
defined by the New York Stock Exchange listing
standards, SEC rules and the UK Corporate
Governance Code).
RISK OVERSIGHT
Our Boards have the overall responsibility for
determining the strategic direction of our business
and have established a framework to manage risk and
determine the nature and extent of the principal
and emerging risks acceptable to our business. Our
framework is designed to identify and manage, rather
than eliminate, risk to the achievement of our
strategic objectives. The Boards, through their
Committees and executive management, have carried
out a robust assessment of our principal and
emerging risks, including to ensure that they are
effectively managed and/or mitigated.
Risk management is embedded in all areas of our
business and is reflected across our policies and
procedures. Our risk management framework
includes an organization wide, multi-layered approach
and consists of the Boards of Directors, their
Committees, Risk Advisory and Assurance Services
(“RAAS”), GE&C and executive management.
Our Boards leverage their Committees to oversee our
risk management activities as described in more
detail below. Each area of our business reports via
executive management to these Committees.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
BOARD AND COMMITTEE GOVERNANCE
22
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
AUDIT COMMITTEES
Our Audit Committees are responsible for oversight
of our financial, operational and compliance controls
(other than with respect to HESS-related legal and
regulatory requirements and compliance matters
addressed by the Compliance Committees), including
information systems controls and security. They
oversee management’s risk assessment processes to
identify principal and emerging risks, including
financial, IT (including cybersecurity and data privacy)
and non-HESS operational risks as well as monitoring
changes to and compliance with related legal and
regulatory requirements. They also monitor such risks
and report their findings to the Boards of Directors.
In addition, they are also responsible for overseeing
the adequacy of our system of internal control
policies and procedures for the identification,
assessment and reporting of risk, including identifying
new risks as they arise. They review and make
recommendations arising from management reports
on the effectiveness of internal controls and risk
management systems. In addition, the Audit
Committees review audit coverage, the audit plan for
the upcoming year and results of any testing carried
out by Carnival Corporation & plc’s internal audit
department called RAAS and its independent auditors.
The Audit Committees also review any concerns
about improprieties in our financial reporting and
financial controls or other matters, which employees
may confidentially raise.
COMPENSATION COMMITTEES
Our Compensation Committees are responsible for
oversight of risk associated with our executive
compensation structure, policies and programs.
COMPLIANCE COMMITTEES
Our Compliance Committees are responsible for
providing oversight of risk management related to
compliance with applicable laws and regulations,
including our compliance monitoring activities,
supporting a high level of ethics and integrity.
Specifically, they oversee the risk management
activities of GE&C, review trends and insights coming
from the complaint channels and oversee
management’s plans to address compliance risk
management opportunities. They also oversee
results of compliance with our Code of Business
Conduct and Ethics and the Business Partner Code of
Conduct and Ethics, monitor procedures for
confidential submission, receipt and treatment of
complaints and review all significant allegations of
misconduct involving senior executives or board
members. In addition, they provide functional
oversight of IAG, which performs investigations into
HESS incidents, and also review results from audits
and investigations relating to ethics and compliance
matters.
HESS COMMITTEES
Our HESS Committees oversee our performance in
managing and/or mitigating principal and emerging
risks relating to health, environment, safety, security
and sustainability as well as monitoring change to
and compliance with related legal and regulatory
requirements. The HESS Committees oversee
management’s processes to identify principal and
emerging HESS and sustainability-related risks,
including those related to ship operations and
cybersecurity, HESS audits, IAG and external
investigations into significant ship incidents, and
HESS related hotline complaints and assess the steps
management has taken to minimize such risks. In
addition, the HESS Committees review and
recommend appropriate policies, procedures,
practices and training relative to HESS and
sustainability and oversee our monitoring and
enforcement of HESS policies and procedures. They
also review our objectives and plans for implementing
our policies, procedures and risk management
programs regarding HESS. The HESS Committees
review compliance with laws and regulations regarding
HESS and sustainability and material legal proceedings
relating to HESS.
NOMINATING & GOVERNANCE
COMMITTEES
Our Nominating & Governance Committees are
responsible for oversight of risk associated with Board
processes and corporate governance, including
succession planning.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
BOARD AND COMMITTEE GOVERNANCE
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
23
COMPENSATION RISK ASSESSMENT
Carnival Corporation & plc’s management, in
conjunction with the Compensation Committees’
independent compensation consultant, Frederic W.
Cook & Co., Inc. (“FW Cook”), conducted a thorough
review of our compensation programs, including those
programs in which our Named Executive Officers
participate, to determine if aspects of those programs
contribute to excessive risk-taking. Based on the
findings from this review and the annual
reassessment, the Compensation Committees
concluded that our compensation policies and
practices do not encourage excessive risk-taking and
do not create risks that are reasonably likely to have
a material adverse effect on Carnival Corporation & plc.
To reach this conclusion, key elements of our
compensation programs were assessed to determine
if they exhibited excessive risk. These elements
included:
•
pay mix (cash vs. equity) and pay structure (short
vs. long-term focus);
•
performance metrics;
•
performance goals and ranges;
•
the degree of leverage;
•
incentive maximums;
•
payment timing;
•
incentive adjustments;
•
use of discretion; and
•
stock ownership requirements.
Our assessment reinforced the Compensation
Committees’ belief that our compensation programs
are not contributing to excessive risk-taking, but
instead contain many features and elements that
help to mitigate risk.
For example:
PAY STRUCTURE.
Our compensation programs
for our Named Executive Officers emphasize both
short- and long-term performance through our
annual bonus program (delivered in cash) and
through the delivery of long-term incentives
(equity), which reflects a balanced approach
(approximately 48% through base salary and
bonus and 52% in long-term equity grants). The
mix of our pay program is intended to motivate
management to consider the impact of
decisions on shareholders and other stakeholders
in the short, intermediate and long-term.
INCENTIVE LIMITS.
Bonuses cannot exceed
200% of target levels.
LONG-TERM SHARE INCENTIVE GRANTS.
The
annual long-term share incentive programs for
fiscal 2022 were approved as cash targets to be
granted in fiscal 2023 in the form of restricted
stock units and/or performance restricted
stock units to strengthen alignment with
shareholder interests, to align with business
strategy and promote retention and leadership
stability.
PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT.
For Named
Executive Officers, the performance
measurement used when determining their
annual bonus is based on the performance of
Carnival Corporation & plc with reference to
quantitative metrics, focused on cash
management, return to service, compliance and
culture and ESG.
STOCK OWNERSHIP POLICY.
All senior executives
who are designated as reporting officers under
Section 16 of the Exchange Act are subject to a
stock ownership policy which specifies target
ownership levels of Carnival Corporation and
Carnival plc shares in terms of the value of the
equity holdings as a multiple of each officer’s base
salary.
CLAWBACK POLICY.
The Carnival plc 2014
Employee Share Plan (which was approved by
shareholders in 2014), the Carnival Corporation
2020 Stock Plan (which was approved by
shareholders in 2020) and the incentive plan
used to determine annual bonuses contain
clawback provisions, which authorize us to
recover incentive-based compensation granted
under those plans in the event Carnival
Corporation & plc is required to restate their
financial statements due to fraud or misconduct.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
BOARD AND COMMITTEE GOVERNANCE
24
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE GUIDELINES
Our Corporate Governance Guidelines address
various governance issues and principles, including:
•
Director qualifications and responsibilities;
•
access to management personnel;
•
Director compensation;
•
Director orientation and continuing education; and
•
annual performance evaluations of the Boards,
their Committees and individual Directors.
Our Corporate Governance Guidelines are posted on
our website at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com.
CEO AND EXECUTIVE MANAGEMENT SUCCESSION PLANNING
Our Boards believe that planning for the succession
of our CEO and other executive management positions
is an important function. Our global, multi-brand
structure enhances our succession planning process
and enables us to develop a diverse pipeline of leaders
across brands. At the corporate level, a highly-skilled
management team oversees a collection of cruise
brands. We continually strive to foster the professional
development of executive management and team
members in other critical roles. As a result, Carnival
Corporation & plc has developed a very experienced
and strong group of leaders, with their performance
subject to ongoing monitoring and evaluation, as
potential successors to all of our executive positions,
including our CEO.
The Boards and the Nominating & Governance
Committees are responsible for effective succession
planning, including emergency succession planning,
and overseeing a diverse pipeline for succession.
The independent Non-Executive Directors meet with
our Chair and our CEO (both together and individually)
at least annually to plan for the long-term succession
of our CEO, including plans in the event of an
emergency. During those sessions, each of our Chair
and our CEO discusses his recommendations of
potential successors, along with an evaluation and
review of any development plans for such individuals.
As provided in our Corporate Governance Guidelines,
the Nominating & Governance Committees will,
when appropriate, make recommendations to the
Boards with respect to potential successors to our
CEO. All members of the Boards will work with the
Nominating & Governance Committees to see that
qualified candidates are available and that
development plans are being utilized to strengthen
the skills and qualifications of the internal candidates.
When assessing the qualifications of potential
successors to our CEO, the Boards and the
Nominating & Governance Committees will take into
account our business strategy as well as any other
criteria they believe are relevant.
The Boards, in conjunction with our Chair of the
Boards and our CEO, oversee succession planning
with respect to the executive officers and other
members of senior management as they determine
from time to time. Our Boards discuss plans for the
succession to executive management positions in
executive sessions, with appropriate input from our
executive management.
PROCEDURES REGARDING DIRECTOR CANDIDATES RECOMMENDED BY
SHAREHOLDERS
The Nominating & Governance Committees will
consider shareholder recommendations of qualified
Director nominees when such recommendations are
submitted in accordance with the procedures
below. In order to recommend a candidate for
consideration by the Nominating & Governance
Committees for election at the 2024 Annual Meetings
of Shareholders, a shareholder must provide the
same information as is required for shareholders to
submit Director nominations under the advance
notice provision set forth in Carnival Corporation’s
By-laws. Specifically, any such recommendation must
include, in addition to any other informational
requirements specifically set forth in Carnival
Corporation’s and Carnival plc’s governing documents:
•
the name and address of the candidate;
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
BOARD AND COMMITTEE GOVERNANCE
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
25
•
a brief biographical description, including his or
her occupation and service on Boards of Directors
of any public company or registered investment
company for at least the last five years;
•
a statement of the particular experience,
qualifications, attributes or skills of the candidate,
taking into account the qualification requirements
set forth above; and
•
the candidate’s signed consent to serve as a
Director if elected and to be named in the Proxy
Statement.
Once we receive the recommendation, we may
deliver to the candidate a questionnaire that requests
additional information about the candidate’s
independence, qualifications and other matters that
would assist the Nominating & Governance
Committees in evaluating the candidate, as well as
certain information that must be disclosed about the
candidate in our Proxy Statement or other regulatory
filings, if nominated. Candidates must complete and
return the questionnaire within the time frame
provided to be considered for nomination by the
Nominating & Governance Committees at the Annual
Meetings of Shareholders. For our 2024 Annual
Meetings of Shareholders, the Nominating &
Governance Committees will consider
recommendations received by our Company Secretary
at our headquarters no later than September 1, 2023.
COMMUNICATIONS BETWEEN SHAREHOLDERS OR INTERESTED PARTIES
AND THE BOARDS
Shareholders or interested parties who wish to
communicate with the Boards, the Presiding Director,
the Non-Executive Directors as a group or any
individual Director should address their
communications to:
Carnival Corporation & plc
Attention: Company Secretary
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue
Miami, Florida 33178-2428
United States
The Company Secretary will maintain a log of all such
communications, promptly forward to the Presiding
Director those which the Company Secretary believes
require immediate attention, and also periodically
provide the Presiding Director with a summary of all
such communications and any responsive actions
taken. The Presiding Director will notify the Boards or
our Chairs of the relevant Board Committees as to
those matters that he believes are appropriate for
further action or discussion.
CODE OF BUSINESS CONDUCT AND ETHICS
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc’s Code of
Business Conduct and Ethics applies to all employees
and members of the Boards of Carnival Corporation
and Carnival plc and provides guiding principles
on areas such as identifying and resolving conflicts of
interest. Our Code of Business Conduct and Ethics is
posted on our website at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
.
Non-Executive Director Compensation
Annual Compensation
Equity
Retainer
$175,000
Cash
Retainer
$110,000
Additional Annual Cash Retainers ($)
Presiding Director
25,000
Chair of a Board Committee
30,000
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR COMPENSATION
26
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
During fiscal 2022, our Non-Executive Directors were
entitled to receive an annual cash retainer of
$110,000 per year, equity incentive compensation, as
further described below, and reimbursement for
travel, meals and accommodation expenses attendant
to their Board membership. We do not provide
retirement or other benefits to our Non-Executive
Directors. We reimburse Directors for travel expenses
incurred for spouses or partners when we request
that they attend a special event. Any amount
reimbursed for spousal or partner travel is reported
below in the “Director Compensation for Fiscal 2022”
table. For fiscal 2022, the Presiding Director received
an additional retainer of $25,000 per annum. In
addition, each Non-Executive Director who served as
Chair of a Board Committee received an additional
$30,000 as compensation for such service on each
Board Committee.
Board members who are employed by us do not
receive additional compensation for their services as
a member of the Boards of Directors.
The Boards of Directors are committed to attracting
and retaining a highly diverse, experienced and
capable group of Non-Executive Directors. To that
end, the Compensation Committees review non-
executive director pay levels and compensation
practices of certain other publicly-listed companies
on an annual basis with the assistance of their
Compensation consultant to ensure our Non-Executive
Director compensation program is competitive.
Non-Executive Directors receive payment of their
earned retainer in quarterly installments. Annual
retainers are prorated so that adjustments can be
made during the year. Unearned portions of cash
retainers are forfeited upon termination of service.
Non-Executive Directors receive annual restricted
share grants under the Carnival Corporation
2020 Stock Plan. In April 2022, each Non-Executive
Director received a restricted share grant with a grant
date fair value equal to approximately $175,000. As
a result, a grant of 9,541 Carnival Corporation
restricted shares was made to each Non-Executive
Director re-elected on April 8, 2022 based on the
closing price of a Carnival Corporation share on that
date of $18.34. In November 2022, a restricted share
grant of 7,146 shares was made to Ms. Mathew
who was appointed to the Boards on November 14,
2022, representing a portion of the annual restricted
share grant made to the Directors in April 2022,
prorated from November 2022 to April 2023.
The 2022 annual restricted share grants under the
Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan are released
from restriction on April 8, 2025 (and are not
forfeitable provided the Director has served at least a
full year). Restricted shares granted have the same
rights with respect to dividends and other distributions
as all other outstanding shares of Carnival Corporation
common stock. Generally, Non-Executive Directors
will receive their annual grants initially upon their
appointment or election to the Boards and
subsequently at the time of their election or annual
re-election to the Boards.
DIRECTOR COMPENSATION FOR FISCAL 2022
The following table details the total compensation
earned by our Non-Executive Directors in fiscal 2022,
other than Mr. Weinstein and Mr. Donald, who are
Named Executive Officers. Mr. Weinstein’s and
Mr. Donald’s compensation is reflected in the
“Summary Compensation Table,” which follows the
“Compensation Discussion and Analysis” section.
Board members who are employed by us do not
receive additional compensation for their services as
a member of the Boards of Directors.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR COMPENSATION
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
27
Name
Fees Earned or Paid in Cash
($)
Stock Awards
(1)(2)
($)
All Other Compensation
(3)
($)
Total
($)
Micky Arison
(4)
―
―
93,450
93,450
Sir Jonathon Band
140,000
(5)
174,982
―
314,982
Jason Glen Cahilly
110,000
174,982
―
284,982
Helen Deeble
110,000
174,982
―
284,982
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
110,000
174,982
―
284,982
Richard J. Glasier
140,000
174,982
―
314,982
Katie Lahey
110,000
174,982
―
284,982
Sara Mathew
(6)
5,137
75,748
―
80,885
Sir John Parker
110,000
174,982
―
284,982
Stuart Subotnick
140,000
174,982
―
314,982
Laura Weil
110,000
174,982
―
284,982
Randall Weisenburger
195,000
174,982
―
369,982
(1)
No stock option grants were made in fiscal 2022. Represents the grant date fair value, assuming no risk of forfeiture, of the
grants of Carnival Corporation restricted shares made in fiscal 2022, calculated in accordance with Accounting Standards
Codification Topic 718, “Stock Compensation” (“ASC 718”). In April 2022, each of the Non-Executive Directors (other than
Ms. Mathew) received a grant of 9,541 restricted shares based on the closing price of a share on April 8, 2022, the day they
were re-elected, of $18.34. Ms. Mathew, who was appointed to the Boards on November 14, 2022, received a prorated grant
of 7,146 restricted shares in November 2022 based on the closing price of a share on the day of her appointment, of $10.60. The
restrictions on the shares granted in 2022 lapse on April 8, 2025. The restrictions on the shares granted to Non-Executive
Directors also lapse upon the death or disability of the Director, and are not forfeited if a Director ceases to be a Director for
any other reason after having served as a Director for at least one year. Other than Ms. Mathew, all of the Non-Executive
Directors who received grants served for all of fiscal 2022.
(2)
None of the Directors holds stock options. The aggregate number of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc restricted shares
held at November 30, 2022 were as follows:
Name
Unvested Restricted Shares
(#)
Micky Arison
0
Sir Jonathon Band
30,435
Jason Glen Cahilly
30,435
Helen Deeble
30,435
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
29,108
Richard J. Glasier
30,435
Katie Lahey
30,435
Sara Mathew
7,146
Sir John Parker
30,435
Stuart Subotnick
30,435
Laura Weil
30,435
Randall Weisenburger
30,435
(3)
Benefits provided to Mr. Arison include private medical health insurance costs ($39,125), driver and security ($20,425),
automobile lease or allowance ($17,222), gross up for taxes on certain benefits ($6,661) and the following other benefits
($10,017): accidental death or dismemberment, disability and life insurance premiums and automobile repairs and expenses.
(4)
Represents compensation for Mr. Arison’s service as executive Chair.
(5)
Exclusive of value-added tax.
(6)
Ms. Mathew was appointed to the Boards on November 14, 2022.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR COMPENSATION
28
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR POLICIES
The following policies also apply to our Non-Executive
Directors:
•
STOCK OWNERSHIP POLICY.
The stock ownership
policy for Non-Executive Directors provides that all
Non-Executive Directors are required to own
shares (inclusive of unvested restricted shares,
restricted stock units (“RSUs”) and shares in a trust
beneficially owned by a Director) of either Carnival
Corporation common stock or Carnival plc ordinary
shares with a value equal to five times the cash
retainer. New Directors must achieve this
requirement no later than five years from the date
of their initial appointment or election to the
Boards by the shareholders. The stock ownership
policy for Non-Executive Directors provides that a
Non-Executive Director will be deemed to be in
compliance with the ownership requirements if the
decline in the Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc
share price results in the Non-Executive Director
falling below the applicable ownership level,
provided that they were in compliance prior to the
share price movement and do not sell or transfer
ownership of any such shares until after the
ownership target has again been achieved, unless
otherwise approved by the Boards of Directors. Each
of the Non-Executive Directors serving in fiscal
2022 is in compliance with this Board-mandated
requirement.
•
PRODUCT FAMILIARIZATION.
All Non-Executive
Directors are encouraged to take cruises for
purposes of product familiarization. Non-Executive
Directors pay a fare of $70 per person per day
for the first 14 days per year of any such cruises
(or $150 per day in the case of Seabourn), and pay
a fare of $200 per person per day for the next
30 days per year of any such cruises, plus taxes,
fees and port expenses in each case. Beyond the
first 44 days per year, Non-Executive Directors are
eligible for smaller discounts. All other charges
associated with a cruise (e.g., air, ground transfers,
gratuities, tours and fuel supplements, if any) are
the responsibility of the Non-Executive Director.
CARNIVAL PLC NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR COMPENSATION
Additional information with respect to Carnival plc’s
compensation and reimbursement practices during
fiscal 2022 for Non-Executive Directors is included in
Part II of the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report, which is attached as Annex B to this Proxy
Statement.
Related Person Transactions
REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF TRANSACTIONS WITH RELATED PERSONS
Consistent with our written policies and procedures,
it is our practice to review all relationships and
transactions in which Carnival Corporation or Carnival
plc is a participant and in which our Directors,
nominees and executive officers and their immediate
family members and any five percent beneficial
holders have an interest in order to determine
whether such related persons have a direct or indirect
material interest. Our Legal and Global Accounting
and Reporting Services Departments are primarily
responsible for the development and implementation
of processes and controls to obtain information
from the Directors, nominees and executive officers
with respect to related person transactions and
for then determining, based on the facts and
circumstances, whether a related person has a direct
or indirect material interest in the transaction. As
required under SEC rules, transactions exceeding
$120,000 in which Carnival Corporation & plc was or
is to be a participant and a related person had or will
have a direct or indirect material interest are
disclosed in this Proxy Statement.
In addition, in accordance with our Schedule of
Matters Reserved to the Boards and their Committees
for their Decision, the Boards review and approve or
ratify any related person transaction with an aggregate
value in excess of $100,000 in which a Director, an
executive officer, or any of their immediate family
members, has a direct or indirect material interest.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
RELATED PERSON TRANSACTIONS
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
29
In the course of their review and approval or
ratification of a related person transaction, the
Boards may consider factors as follows:
•
the nature of the related person’s interest in the
transaction;
•
the material terms of the transaction, including,
without limitation, the amount and type of
transaction;
•
the importance of the transaction to the related
person;
•
the importance of the transaction to Carnival
Corporation & plc;
•
whether the transaction would impair the judgment
of a Director or executive officer to act in our best
interest; and
•
any other matters the Boards deem appropriate.
Any member of the Boards who is a related person
with respect to a transaction under review may not
participate in the deliberations or vote respecting
approval or ratification of the transaction, provided,
however, that such Director may be counted in
determining the presence of a quorum at a meeting
of the Board that considers the transaction.
TRANSACTIONS WITH RELATED PERSONS
TRANSACTIONS WITH MICKY ARISON
Micky Arison, our Chair, is also the Chair, President
and the indirect majority shareholder of FBA II, Inc.,
the general partner of Miami Heat Limited Partnership
(“MHLP”), the owner of the Miami Heat, a professional
basketball team. He is also the indirect shareholder
of Basketball Properties, Inc., the general partner of
Basketball Properties, Ltd. (“BPL”), which is the
manager and operator of the Miami-Dade Arena
(formerly known as the FTX Arena). In July 2021,
Carnival Cruise Line entered into an amendment of
the advertising and promotion agreement between
Carnival Cruise Line, MHLP and BPL which extended
the terms of the agreement through 2025. Pursuant
to this agreement, Carnival Cruise Line paid $591,000
during fiscal 2022.
In August 2015, Carnival Corporation entered into a
nonexclusive Aircraft Lease Agreement with an owner
trustee under a trust agreement with Ad Astra I, LLC
(the “Lease Agreement”); and in August 2020, Carnival
Corporation entered into a Services Agreement with
Nickel Cayman Management, LLC (the “Services
Agreement” and together with the Lease Agreement,
the “Aircraft Agreements”). In March 2021, the Lease
Agreement and the Services Agreement were
amended to adjust the rental rate and aircraft
management fee to account for substantially all flight
department overhead being borne by Nickel Cayman
Management, LLC following Carnival Corporation’s
disposal of its own aircraft in December 2020.
Each of Ad Astra I, LLC and Nickel Cayman
Management, LLC are companies directly or indirectly
controlled by a trust of which Mr. Arison is a
beneficiary. He is also an officer of Nickel Cayman
Management, LLC.
Under the terms of the amended Lease Agreement,
Carnival Corporation leases an aircraft beneficially
owned by Ad Astra I, LLC from time-to-time in exchange
for an hourly rent of $7,920 plus applicable taxes,
which is based on market charter rates for similar
aircraft as adjusted for costs of operations borne by
Carnival Corporation (i.e., fuel and line maintenance
during its operation of the aircraft) and hourly
service plan expenses.
Under the terms of the amended Services Agreement,
Carnival Corporation provides aircraft management
services to Nickel Cayman Management, LLC with
respect to the aircraft, including overseeing its
operation, maintenance and staffing, and is paid an
annual fee of $162,000 (which is based on market rates
for similar arrangements) (the “Service Fee”). In
addition, Carnival Corporation is reimbursed for
operating, maintenance and personnel costs and
related third party costs incurred in connection with
the services (“Service Costs”). The terms of the Aircraft
Agreements are one year and renew automatically
for one-year periods, unless terminated sooner by
either party upon 30 days’ written notice.
During fiscal 2022, Carnival Corporation paid Ad
Astra I, LLC $531,345 under the Lease Agreement,
and Nickel Cayman Management, LLC paid Carnival
Corporation $162,000 as the Service Fee and
reimbursed Carnival Corporation $1,784,328 for the
Service Costs.
The Boards have reviewed and approved or ratified
these transactions.
Corporate Governance and Board Matters
RELATED PERSON TRANSACTIONS
30
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Share Ownership
Share Ownership of Certain Beneficial Owners and
Management
DIRECTORS AND EXECUTIVE OFFICERS
Set forth below is information concerning the share
ownership as of January 12, 2023 of:
•
each of our Directors;
•
each individual named in the “Summary
Compensation Table” which appears elsewhere in
this Proxy Statement; and
•
all Directors and executive officers as a group.
The number of shares beneficially owned by each
entity, person, Director or executive officer is
determined under SEC rules, and the information is
not necessarily indicative of beneficial ownership for
any other purpose. Under such rules, beneficial
ownership includes any shares as to which the
individual has the sole or shared voting power or
investment power and also any shares that the
individual would have the right to acquire as of
March 13, 2023 (being 60 days after January 12, 2023)
through the vesting of RSUs.
Name and Address of
Beneficial Owners or
Identity of Group
(1)
Amount and Nature
of Beneficial
Ownership of
Carnival Corporation
Common Stock*
Percentage of
Carnival
Corporation
Common Stock
(%)
Amount and
Nature of
Beneficial
Ownership of
Carnival plc
Ordinary Shares
Percentage of
Carnival plc
Ordinary
Shares
(%)
Percentage of
Combined
Voting
Power**
(%)
Micky Arison
121,136,034
(2)(3)
10.9
0
―
9.6
Sir Jonathon Band
52,492
***
0
―
***
David Bernstein
154,283
(4)
***
0
―
***
William Burke
37,226
***
0
***
Jason Glen Cahilly
38,591
***
0
―
***
Helen Deeble
41,300
***
0
―
***
Arnold W. Donald
1,098,063
(4)(5)
***
0
―
***
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
30,854
***
0
―
***
Richard J. Glasier
70,048
(6)
***
0
―
***
Katie Lahey
35,842
***
0
―
***
Sir John Parker
62,668
***
3,004
***
***
Sara Mathew
7,146
***
0
***
***
Enrique Miguez
41,708
(7)
***
0
***
***
Stuart Subotnick
83,411
***
0
―
***
Michael Thamm
0
―
250,026
(4)
***
***
Laura Weil
82,608
***
0
―
***
Josh Weinstein
62,129
***
0
***
***
Randall Weisenburger
870,950
***
0
―
***
All Directors and executive
officers as a group
(18 persons)
123,836,078
11.1
253,030
***
9.9
*
As part of the establishment of the DLC arrangement, Carnival plc issued a special voting share to Carnival Corporation, which
transferred such share to the trustee of the P&O Princess Special Voting Trust (the “Trust”), a trust established under the laws of
the Cayman Islands. Trust shares of beneficial interest in the Trust were transferred to Carnival Corporation. The trust shares
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
31
represent a beneficial interest in the Carnival plc special voting share. Immediately following the transfer, Carnival Corporation
distributed such trust shares by way of a dividend to holders of shares of Carnival Corporation common stock. Under a pairing
agreement, the trust shares of beneficial interest in the Trust are paired with, and evidenced by, certificates representing
shares of Carnival Corporation common stock on a one-for-one basis. In addition, under the pairing agreement, when a share
of Carnival Corporation common stock is issued to a person after the implementation of the DLC arrangement, a paired trust
share will be issued at the same time to such person. Each share of Carnival Corporation common stock and the paired trust
share may not be transferred separately. The Carnival Corporation common stock and the trust shares (including the beneficial
interest in the Carnival plc special voting share) are listed and trade together on the New York Stock Exchange under the
ticker symbol “CCL.” Accordingly, each holder of Carnival Corporation common stock is also deemed to be the beneficial owner
of an equivalent number of trust shares.
**
As a result of the DLC arrangement, on most matters that affect all of the shareholders of Carnival Corporation and Carnival
plc, the shareholders of both companies effectively vote together as a single decision-making body. Combined voting is
accomplished through the special voting shares that have been issued by each company.
***
Less than one percent.
(1)
The address of each individual is 3655 N.W. 87 Avenue, Miami, Florida 33178.
(2)
Mr. Arison is a member of the Arison Group (defined below), which has filed a joint statement on Schedule 13D with respect to
the shares of Carnival Corporation common stock held by such persons. Each member of the Arison Group may be deemed
to own the shares of common stock held by all other members of the Arison Group. For information on the share ownership of
other members of the Arison Group, see “Principal Owners” table below.
(3)
Includes (i) 4,934,166 shares of common stock held by the various Arison family trusts, (ii) 80,736,445 shares of common stock
held by MA 1994 B Shares, L.P. and (iii) 35,465,423 shares of common stock held by the Artsfare 2005 Trust No. 2 by virtue of the
authority granted to Mr. Arison under the last will of Ted Arison. Mr. Arison does not have an economic interest in the shares
of common stock held by Artsfare 2005 Trust No. 2.
(4)
Includes 2021 time-based share (“TBS”) and performance-based share (“PBS”) grants scheduled to be released on January 19,
2023 (2021 TBS) and February 6, 2023 (PBS). The executive officer will also receive additional shares at the time of vesting to take
into account dividend reinvestment during the period for the PBS granted in February 2020.
(5)
Includes 665,157 shares held by The Arnold W. Donald Revocable Trust UAD 5/26/98.
(6)
Includes 23,792 shares held by The Richard J. Glasier Revocable Living Trust.
(7)
Includes 2020 TBS, 2021 TBS and 2020 PBS grants scheduled to be released on January 17, 2023 (2020 TBS), January 19, 2023
(2021 TBS) and February 6, 2023 (2020 PBS). The executive officer will also receive additional shares at the time of vesting to take
into account dividend reinvestment during the period for the 2020 TBS and 2020 PBS.
PRINCIPAL OWNERS
Set forth below is information concerning the share
ownership of as of January 12, 2023:
•
all persons known by us to be the beneficial
owners of more than 5% of the 1,113,479,515
shares of Carnival Corporation common stock and
trust shares of beneficial interest in the P&O
Princess Special Voting Trust outstanding; and
•
all persons known by us to be the beneficial
owners of more than 5% of the 217,371,552
ordinary shares of Carnival plc outstanding, less
40,555,198 ordinary shares which are directly or
indirectly owned by Carnival Corporation and
31,235,457 ordinary shares held in treasury, both
of which have no voting rights.
Micky Arison, Chair of the Board of each of Carnival
Corporation and Carnival plc, certain other members
of the Arison family and trusts for their benefit
(collectively, the “Arison Group”), beneficially own
shares representing approximately 10.9% of the voting
power of Carnival Corporation and approximately
9.6% of the combined voting power of Carnival
Corporation & plc and have informed us that they
intend to cause all such shares to be voted in favor of
Proposals 1 through 12 and 14 through 22, and in
the case of Proposal 13, in favor of holding the
“say-on-pay” vote every year. The table below begins
with the ownership of the Arison Group.
Share Ownership
SHARE OWNERSHIP OF CERTAIN BENEFICIAL OWNERS AND MANAGEMENT
32
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Name and Address of
Beneficial Owners or
Identity of Group
Amount and Nature
of Beneficial
Ownership of
Carnival Corporation
Common Stock*
Percentage of
Carnival
Corporation
Common Stock
(%)
Amount and Nature
of Beneficial
Ownership of
Carnival plc
Ordinary Shares
Percentage of
Carnival plc
Ordinary
Shares
(%)
Percentage of
Combined
Voting
Power**
(%)
MA 1994 B Shares, L.P.
1201 North Market
Street
Wilmington, DE 19899
80,736,445
(1)(2)
7.3
0
―
6.4
MA 1994 B Shares, Inc.
1201 North Market
Street
Wilmington, DE 19899
80,736,445
(1)(2)
7.3
0
―
6.4
Artsfare 2005 Trust No. 2
c/o SunTrust Delaware
Trust Company
1011 Centre Road
Suite 108
Wilmington, DE 19805
35,465,423
(1)(4)
3.2
0
―
2.8
Verus Protector, LLC
Two Alhambra Plaza
Suite 1040
Coral Gables, FL 33134
35,465,423
(1)(3)
3.2
0
―
2.8
Richard L. Kohan
Two Alhambra Plaza
Suite 1040
Coral Gables, FL 33134
121,138,034
(1)(4)
10.9
0
―
9.6
KLR, LLC
Two Alhambra Plaza
Suite 1040
Coral Gables, FL 33134
82,419,457
(1)(6)
7.4
0
―
6.6
Nickel 2015-94 B Trust
1313 North Market
Street
Suite 5300
Wilmington, DE 19801
80,736,445
(1)(2)
7.3
0
―
6.4
SunTrust Delaware Trust
Company
1011 Centre Road
Suite 108
Wilmington, DE 19805
35,465,423
(1)(5)
3.2
0
―
2.8
Aristeia Capital, L.L.C.
One Greenwich Plaza
Greenwich, CT 06830
0
―
10,140,504
(7)
7.0
***
Norges Bank
Bankplassen 2
PO Box 1179 Sentrum
NO 0107 Oslo, Norway
0
―
11,785,088
(8)
8.1
***
BlackRock, Inc.
55 East 52nd Street
New York, NY 10055
50,009,395
(9)
4.5
7,395,735
(10)
5.1
4.6
Vanguard Group
100 Vanguard Blvd.
Malvern, PA 19355
111,933,967
(11)
10.1
0
―
8.9
*, ** and *** have the same meanings as indicated in the table above.
(1)
The Arison Group has filed a joint statement on Schedule 13D with respect to the shares of Carnival Corporation common
stock held by such persons. Each member of the Arison Group may be deemed to own the shares of common stock held by all
other members of the Arison Group.
Share Ownership
SHARE OWNERSHIP OF CERTAIN BENEFICIAL OWNERS AND MANAGEMENT
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
33
(2)
MA 1994 B Shares, L.P. (“MA 1994, L.P.”) owns 80,736,445 shares of common stock. The general partner of MA 1994, L.P. is
MA 1994 B Shares, Inc. (“MA 1994, Inc.”), which is wholly-owned by the Nickel 2015-94 B Trust, a trust established for the benefit
of Mr. Arison and members of his family (the “B Trust”). The sole limited partner of MA 1994, L.P. is the B Trust. Under the
terms of the instrument governing the B Trust, Mr. Arison has the sole right to vote and direct the sale of the common stock
indirectly held by the B Trust. By virtue of the limited partnership agreement of MA 1994, L.P., MA 1994, Inc. may be deemed
to beneficially own all such 80,736,445 shares of common stock. By virtue of the B Trust being the sole stockholder of
MA 1994, Inc., the B Trust may be deemed to beneficially own all such 80,736,445 shares of common stock. By virtue of
Mr. Arison’s interest in the B Trust and the B Trust’s interest in MA 1994, L.P., Mr. Arison may be deemed to beneficially own all
such 80,736,445 shares of common stock. The administrative trustee of the B Trust is the Northern Trust Company of Delaware.
(3)
Verus Protector, LLC is the protector of Artsfare 2005 Trust No. 2. Verus Protector, LLC has shared voting and dispositive power
with respect to the shares of common stock held by Artsfare 2005 Trust No. 2.
(4)
By virtue of being the sole member of Verus Protector, LLC, the sole member of KLR, LLC and a trustee of various Arison family
trusts, Mr. Kohan may be deemed to own the aggregate of 121,136,034 shares of common stock beneficially owned by such
entities, as to which he disclaims beneficial ownership. Mr. Kohan also owns 1,000 shares of common stock directly and owns
1,000 shares of common stock indirectly by virtue of such shares owned by Mr. Kohan’s wife.
(5)
SunTrust Delaware Trust Company acts as trustee for the Artsfare 2005 Trust No. 2.
(6)
KLR, LLC is a Delaware limited liability company wholly owned by Mr. Kohan. KLR, LLC acts as a distribution advisor for various
Arison family trusts and has shared dispositive power over the shares of common stock held by certain of such trusts.
(7)
As reflected in a Schedule 13G/A, filed on February 14, 2022, with the SEC, Aristeia Capital, L.L.C. and its affiliates reported sole
voting and sole dispositive power over 10,140,504 ordinary shares.
(8)
As reflected in a TR-1 notification received by Carnival plc on December 21, 2022, Norges Bank reported direct voting rights
over 9,829,988 ordinary shares and voting rights over 1,955,100 ordinary shares on loan.
(9)
As reflected in a Schedule 13G filed on March 11, 2022 with the SEC, BlackRock, Inc. reported sole voting power over 43,435,453
shares of common stock and sole dispositive power over 50,009,395 shares of common stock.
(10)
As reflected in a TR-1 notification received by Carnival plc on June 8, 2022, BlackRock, Inc. reported direct voting rights over
3,912,081 ordinary shares, voting rights over 208,358 Carnival plc American Depositary Receipts, voting rights over 2,119,182
ordinary shares through securities lending, and voting rights over 1,156,114 ordinary shares through contracts for difference.
(11)
As reflected in a Schedule 13G/A filed on January 10, 2023 with the SEC, Vanguard Group reported shared voting power over
1,364,262 shares of common stock, sole dispositive power over 107,886,486 shares of common stock, and shared dispositive
power over 4,047,481 shares of common stock.
Share Ownership
SHARE OWNERSHIP OF CERTAIN BENEFICIAL OWNERS AND MANAGEMENT
34
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Compensation
PROPOSAL 12
Advisory (Non-Binding) Vote to Approve
Executive Compensation
As required by the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform
and Consumer Protection Act (the “Dodd-Frank Act”)
and pursuant to Section 14A of the Exchange Act, our
shareholders are being provided with the opportunity
to cast an advisory (non-binding) vote to approve our
executive compensation. We refer to this vote as the
“say-on-pay” vote. Although this vote is advisory and is
not binding on the Boards, the Compensation
Committees will take into account the outcome of the
vote when considering future executive compensation
decisions.
The “say-on-pay” vote is required to be offered to our
shareholders at least once every three years. In
2017, our Boards recommended that we provide
shareholders with the opportunity to cast their
“say-on-pay” vote each year and our shareholders
agreed. We are asking shareholders to vote on the
frequency of the “say-on-pay” vote in Proposal 13. If
we maintain our current frequency, the next
“say-on-pay” vote is expected to occur at the 2024
Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
The Boards are committed to corporate governance
best practices and recognize the significant interest of
shareholders in executive compensation matters.
The Compensation Committees seek to balance
short-term and long-term compensation
opportunities to enable Carnival Corporation and
Carnival plc to meet short-term objectives while
continuing to produce value for their shareholders
over the long-term. They also promote a
compensation program designed to attract, motivate
and retain key executives. As discussed in the
Compensation Discussion and Analysis, the
Compensation Committees believe that our current
executive compensation program directly links
executive compensation to our performance and
aligns the interests of our Named Executive Officers
with those of our shareholders. For example:
Our compensation philosophy places more
emphasis on variable elements of compensation
(such as annual bonuses and equity-based
compensation) than fixed remuneration.
In accordance with the Compensation
Committees’ focus on long-term shareholder
returns, the Compensation Committees approved
performance-based share grants and incentive
programs for our Named Executive Officers which
vest based upon the extent to which certain pre-
grant performance criteria are attained.
To further promote long-term shareholder
alignment, we require our Named Executive
Officers to meet and maintain stock ownership
requirements.
The Compensation Committees review the
position of each element of total direct
compensation relative to the competitive
market, and use the range of total direct
compensation levels in the competitive market
to assess the extent to which the compensation
provided to our Named Executive Officers is
generally consistent with that offered by the
competitive market to their named executive
officers.
Carnival Corporation & plc does not offer U.S.
executives excise tax gross-up protections.
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
35
We encourage you to read our Compensation
Discussion and Analysis contained within this Proxy
Statement for a more detailed discussion of our
compensation policies and procedures.
Our shareholders have the opportunity to vote for or
against, or to abstain from voting on, the following
resolution:
“RESOLVED, that the shareholders approve the
compensation of our Named Executive Officers
as disclosed pursuant to the compensation
disclosure rules of the SEC (which disclosure
includes the Compensation Discussion and
Analysis, the compensation tables and any related
material disclosed in this Proxy Statement).”
The Boards of Directors unanimously recommend a vote
FOR
approval of the
compensation of our Named Executive Officers as disclosed pursuant to the
compensation disclosure rules of the SEC (which disclosure includes the Compensation
Discussion and Analysis, the compensation tables and any related material disclosed in
this Proxy Statement).
PROPOSAL 13
Advisory (Non-Binding) Vote on
How Frequently Shareholders Should
Vote to Approve Compensation of the
Named Executive Officers
As required by the Dodd-Frank Act, our shareholders
are being provided with the opportunity to cast an
advisory (non-binding) vote on how frequently our
shareholders should have an advisory (non-binding)
vote on the compensation of our Named Executive
Officers. We refer to this vote as the “say-on-
frequency” vote. Although this vote is advisory and is
not binding on the Boards, the Compensation
Committees will take into account the outcome of the
vote when considering how frequently to hold
“say-on-pay” votes.
You may choose from the following alternatives:
every year, every two years, every three years or you
may abstain.
The “say-on-frequency” vote is required to be offered
to our shareholders at least once every six years. At
the April 2017 shareholders meeting, the Boards of
Directors recommended, and the shareholders
voted on an advisory, non-binding basis in favor of,
holding the “say-on-pay” vote every year. The Boards
accepted our shareholders’ recommendation and
currently, shareholders are provided with the
opportunity to cast an advisory (non-binding) vote to
approve the compensation of our Named Executive
Officers every year.
The Boards believe that having an annual “say-on-pay”
vote to approve the compensation of our Named
Executive Officers in satisfaction of U.S. disclosure
rules is appropriate. In this regard, we note that our
shareholders are already provided with an annual vote
to approve the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report (see Proposal 14), which covers all Directors
and includes the Compensation Discussion and
Analysis (itself a significant portion of the executive
compensation disclosure that is the subject of
the “say-on-pay” vote). Moreover, the Boards believe
that annual “say-on-pay” votes permit the Boards to
receive current feedback on a timely basis from our
shareholders regarding our compensation program
for our Named Executive Officers, which will enable
us to implement more quickly any modifications that
the Boards determine to be appropriate.
Compensation
PROPOSAL 13—ADVISORY (NON-BINDING) VOTE ON HOW FREQUENTLY SHAREHOLDERS SHOULD VOTE TO APPROVE COMPENSATION
OF THE NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICERS
36
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
The Boards of Directors unanimously recommend a vote in favor of holding a
non-binding advisory vote EVERY YEAR to approve the compensation of our Named
Executive Officers as disclosed pursuant to the compensation disclosure rules of the
SEC.
PROPOSAL 14
Advisory (Non-Binding) Vote to Approve
the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report (other than the part containing the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Policy set out in Section B of Part II of the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report)
In accordance with Section 439 of the Companies Act
and Schedule 8 of the Large and Medium Sized
Companies and Groups (Accounts and Reports)
Regulations 2008, as amended (the “LMCG
Regulations”), shareholders are voting to approve the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report. The
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report is in two
parts. Part I also constitutes the Compensation
Discussion and Analysis as required by regulations
promulgated by the SEC, and includes information
that Carnival plc is required to disclose in accordance
with the LMCG Regulations. Part II of the Carnival
plc Directors’ Remuneration Report is set forth as
Annex B to this Proxy Statement and includes the
additional information that Carnival plc is required to
disclose in accordance with the LMCG Regulations,
including certain information which has been audited
for the purposes of the Carnival plc Annual Report.
Other than the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Policy set out in Section B of Part II of the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Report (as to which, please
see Proposal 15), UK law only requires an advisory vote
on the substance and content of the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Report. Accordingly,
disapproval of this Proposal 14 will not require us to
amend the report or require any Director to repay any
amount. No entitlement of a Director is conditional
on the approval of this Proposal 14. However, the
Boards and Compensation Committees are expected
to take into account both the voting result and the
views of our shareholders in their application,
development and implementation of compensation
policies and plans.
The Boards of Directors unanimously recommend a vote
FOR
the approval of the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report.
Compensation
PROPOSAL 14—ADVISORY (NON-BINDING) VOTE TO APPROVE THE CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (OTHER THAN
THE PART CONTAINING THE CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION POLICY SET OUT IN SECTION B OF PART II OF THE CARNIVAL PLC
DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
37
PROPOSAL 15
Approval of Carnival Plc
Directors’ Remuneration Policy
In accordance with Section 439A of the Companies
Act and Schedule 8 of the LMCG Regulations,
shareholders are voting to approve the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Policy set out in Section B of
Part II of the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report. This is a binding vote and is required to be put
to shareholders at least once every three years. The
policy has consciously been drafted broadly to give
the Compensation Committees sufficient flexibility
to act in the interests of Carnival Corporation and
Carnival plc and their shareholders as, under the UK
legislative requirements, payments may not be made
to Directors outside of an agreed policy. If approved,
the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Policy will
take effect immediately following its approval at the
2023 Annual Meetings and will apply until it is replaced
by a new or amended policy.
Upon the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Policy
becoming effective on the date of shareholder
approval, remuneration payments to Directors of
Carnival plc (including former or proposed Directors)
and payments for loss of office to a Director of
Carnival plc (including a former or a proposed
Director) will need to be consistent with the approved
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Policy unless
our shareholders approve an amendment to the policy
by an ordinary resolution (unless the payment is
required to be made as part of a legal obligation
entered into before June 27, 2012 and such obligation
has not been amended or renewed since). Section B
of Part II of the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report sets out the Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Policy for the next and subsequent
fiscal years and other details required by the LMCG
Regulations and the UK Corporate Governance Code.
The Boards of Directors unanimously recommend a vote
FOR
the approval of the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Policy.
Compensation
PROPOSAL 15—APPROVAL OF CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION POLICY
38
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Compensation Discussion and Analysis and Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part I)
CONTENTS
39
CD&A AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’
REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
39
Letter from the Chair of our Compensation
Committees
41
How We Address UK And U.S. Compensation
Disclosure Requirements
42
Executive Summary
42
Our Compensation Philosophy
42
2022 Business Environment
44
2022 CEO Leadership Change
46
Shareholder Engagement
48
2022 and 2023 Compensation Overview
52
Overview of Compensation Policies and Practices
52
Named Executive Officer Compensation Design,
Elements and Pay Mix
52
2022 Compensation Recommendations and
Rationale
52
Risk Considerations
53
Base Salaries
53
Annual Bonuses
59
Equity-Based Compensation
65
Perquisites and Other Compensation
66
Post-Employment Compensation Obligations
67
Pensions and Deferred Compensation Plans
67
Process for Making Compensation
Determinations
68
Additional Context for 2022 Decisions
68
Impact of Regulatory Requirements on
Compensation
68
Independent Compensation Consultants
69
Peer Group Characteristics
69
Peer Group Companies
69
Competitive Market (Peer Group) Comparison
70
Stock Ownership Policy
71
Hedging Policy
▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪
LETTER FROM THE CHAIR OF OUR COMPENSATION COMMITTEES
Fellow shareholders,
Each year, the Compensation Committees conduct
the important task of evaluating the design of our
executive compensation programs to ensure they
continually drive performance against important
business priorities and align with the interests of our
shareholders. The Compensation Committees are
deeply focused on ensuring our compensation
programs reflect our pay-for-performance philosophy.
Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, all direct executive
compensation other than base salary has historically
been 100% at-risk and based on quantitative
performance measures. However, the onset of the
COVID-19 pandemic, which compelled us to
temporarily pause all guest cruise operations in mid-
March 2020, and its continued impacts on our
return to service, led the Compensation Committees
to take necessary measures to temporarily modify our
compensation approach in 2021 while still maintaining
commitment to our philosophy of performance-
based pay in order to retain and reward executives
during this challenging and unpredictable time for the
exceptional efforts and performance they achieved.
Returning our incentive plans to a highly at-risk,
quantitative performance-based structure has been
a goal of the Compensation Committees as the
operating environment stabilized and we resumed
guest cruise operations throughout 2022.
UNDERSTANDING SHAREHOLDER PERSPECTIVES
The results of last year’s Say-on-Pay and Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Report votes signaled
that some of our shareholders had concerns about
the temporary modifications we had made to our
executive compensation program structure for fiscal
2021. To better understand these perspectives, we
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
39
conducted outreach with a large number of our
institutional shareholders following our Annual
Meetings of Shareholders. We ultimately conducted
19 meetings with 15 of our institutional shareholders
throughout the summer following the 2022 Annual
Meetings of Shareholders, in the fall, and further in
the winter—in some cases meeting with shareholders
multiple times to seek ongoing feedback. As Chair of
the Compensation Committees, I personally led each
of these engagements to gather feedback directly
from shareholders and share insights regarding the
Compensation Committees’ philosophy and rationale
for its decisions. These conversations complemented
the feedback gathered in discussions with
shareholders in the weeks prior to the Annual
Meetings of Shareholders. These dialogues revealed
that shareholders supported our planned return to a
primarily performance-based executive compensation
structure and have provided invaluable input to the
Compensation Committees’ decisions regarding our
fiscal 2022 and 2023 compensation program and
the disclosures you will see in our Compensation
Discussion and Analysis and Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Report below.
RECOMMITTING TO OUR QUANTITATIVE PAY-FOR-PERFORMANCE APPROACH
We are pleased that in 2022 we have emerged into a
more predictable and stable operating outlook and
have continued to make meaningful progress on our
full return to service. Given this and in consideration
of shareholder feedback, in 2022 the Compensation
Committees have returned to our historical practice
of utilizing quantitative performance criteria for all
fiscal 2022 annual bonuses and equity grants to our
executive officers. We have also committed to
continuing quantitative performance-based approach
to incentives in 2023 which we detail below.
CEO TRANSITION
Further, in August 2022, following a deliberative and
thoughtful succession planning process, Josh
Weinstein was appointed as our President, CEO and
Chief Climate Officer to lead us on our journey
forward. Mr. Weinstein’s compensation structure
reflects our commitment to return to a highly
performance-based executive compensation
structure, with meaningful portions of target
compensation at-risk and quantitative performance-
based.
On behalf of the Compensation Committees, we
appreciate the input our shareholders have provided
and look forward to our continued dialogue over
the coming year. Thank you for your investment in
Carnival Corporation & plc.
Sincerely,
RANDY WEISENBURGER
Chair of the Compensation Committees
January 27, 2023
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
40
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
HOW WE ADDRESS UK AND U.S. COMPENSATION DISCLOSURE
REQUIREMENTS
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are separate
legal entities (together referred to in this Report as
“Carnival Corporation & plc”) and each company has
its own Board of Directors and Compensation
Committee. However, as is required by the agreements
governing the DLC arrangement, the Boards of
Directors and members of the Committees of the
Boards, including the Compensation Committees, are
identical and there is a single senior management
team.
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are subject to
disclosure regimes in the U.S. and UK. While some of
the disclosure requirements are the same or similar,
some are very different. As a result, the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Report is in two parts. The
information contained in this Part I constitutes the
Compensation Discussion and Analysis as required by
regulations promulgated by the SEC and includes
information that Carnival plc is required to disclose in
accordance with Schedule 8 of the LMCG Regulations.
Part II of the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report is set forth as Annex B to this Proxy Statement
and includes the additional information that Carnival
plc is required to disclose in accordance with the LMCG
Regulations, including certain information that has
been audited for the purposes of the Carnival plc
Annual Report.
Parts I and II of the Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Report are in compliance with the
LMCG Regulations, the UK Corporate Governance
Code, the Companies Act and the Listing Rules of the
UK Financial Conduct Authority (the “FCA”). Both Parts I
and II form part of the Carnival plc Annual Report
for the year ended November 30, 2022.
Pursuant to rules promulgated by the SEC and the
LMCG Regulations, this Compensation Discussion and
Analysis reviews the compensation of the following
Named Executive Officers of Carnival Corporation &
plc:
DAVID BERNSTEIN
Chief Financial Officer and
Chief Accounting Officer
JOSH WEINSTEIN
President, CEO
and Chief Climate Officer
WILLIAM BURKE
Chief Maritime Officer
ARNOLD W. DONALD
Former President, CEO and
Chief Climate Officer
MICHAEL THAMM
Group Chief Executive
Officer of Costa Group and
Carnival Asia
ENRIQUE MIGUEZ
General Counsel
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
41
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
OUR COMPENSATION PHILOSOPHY
Aligning Compensation with Our Mission
(Purpose) and Values
Our executive compensation program is designed to
reward financial results, successful delivery of our
long-term strategy and effective strategic leadership,
all in a manner consistent with our mission, vision
and values, through use of both short-term rewards
and long-term incentives and to promote alignment of
the financial interests of our executive officers with
our shareholders. We endeavor to align our
compensation program and underlying performance
measures with the interests of our shareholders
and senior executives by linking actual pay to
operating performance, environment, safety and
security, sustainability initiatives and shareholder
interests. We also seek to provide a total direct
compensation package (salary, bonus and equity
grants) that allows us to be competitive in the labor
markets where we compete for executive talent,
adjusted as necessary to take into consideration
factors including the relevant senior executive’s
performance, experience and responsibilities.
Considering U.S. and UK Market
Approaches
Our Named Executive Officers are located in the U.S.,
with the exception of one Named Executive Officer
who is based in Europe. As a global entity, we strive to
implement a consistent set of compensation
principles across geographic and operating
company units that satisfy the requirements of all
jurisdictions and local market demands while also
accounting for local market norms and practices. Since
the largest presence of executive officers is in the
U.S., our compensation policies primarily reflect U.S.
market practices. However, the Compensation
Committees seek to incorporate UK compensation
principles, including those contained in the UK
Corporate Governance Code, to the degree practicable.
Emphasizing At-Risk Pay
Our compensation philosophy has historically been
to emphasize at-risk incentive pay to drive a pay-for-
performance culture. In furtherance of this
philosophy, prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, all
direct compensation for our Named Executive
Officers, other than base salary, was 100% at-risk and
based on quantitative performance measures. This
compensation philosophy also extended beyond our
Named Executive Officers to include other key
executives, reflecting the Compensation Committees’
commitment to aligning compensation with the
success of Carnival Corporation & plc.
As discussed in greater detail in the sections that
follow, in 2021 the Compensation Committees actively
evaluated the structure of our executive compensation
programs in light of the impact of the COVID-19
pandemic on the operating environment and
determined, in our and our shareholders’ best
interests, to make temporary modifications to drive
the specific operating and strategic initiatives needed
during the COVID-19 pause in guest cruise operations.
However, for our 2022 and 2023 programs, we
have returned to a predominantly quantitative
performance-based approach, as described below,
which aligns with our compensation philosophy and
in large part with the structure of our pre-COVID-19
programs as well as responding to the feedback we
received from our investors.
2022 BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT
With 89 of the 91 ships (excluding announced
removals of ships that will not return to service) in
our fleet back in service as of the end of the fiscal
2022, our return to guest cruise operations is
essentially complete. Eight of our nine brands now
have their full fleet back in service. Since the summer
of 2022, we have been relentlessly focused on driving
top line growth and returning to strong profitability.
During 2022, we:
•
returned 38 ships back to service,
•
delivered 5 new ships,
•
sustainably recycled retired ships,
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
42
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
•
announced an additional seven smaller-less
efficient ships will be removed from our fleet,
•
announced our innovative ‘Carnival Fun Italian
Style” initiative, launching in June 2023, and
•
began closing the gap to 2019 and returning to
strong profitability.
Fleet Optimization
With the additional seven ships announced in 2022,
this brings the total to 26 smaller-less efficient ships
being removed from our fleet ships since the
beginning of the pause in guest cruise operations.
Now, nearly a quarter of our 2023 fleet will consist of
new, larger-more efficient ships with the successful
introduction of
Carnival Celebration
in November 2022
and the addition of
Arvia
for P&O Cruises (UK) in
December 2022.
•
This fleet transformation results in an 8 percentage
point increase in balcony cabins to 57%, along
with a tremendous increase in our platform to
deliver onboard experiences and generate
associated revenues contributing to greater
revenue yield growth going forward.
•
This fleet transformation also lowers operating
costs on a unit basis, helping to mitigate inflation,
and deliver more revenue to the bottom line with
6% greater efficiency in non-fuel operating costs
per ALBD vs. 2019, and it is helping to support our
anticipated 15% lower fuel consumption also per
ALBD vs. 2019.
•
Our average berth count per ship has increased
nearly 20%, now the largest amongst our public
peers. In fact, our ship operating costs and fuel
consumption per ALBD are lower than our public
peers setting us up to deliver more revenue to the
bottom line.
Brand Optimization
China has yet to reopen which has had a
disproportionate impact on our Costa brand, given
their significant year-round presence in China prior to
the pause. We are transitioning that capacity to
other markets, with a total of nine ships being
removed from the Costa brand since the pause.
These actions position Costa well with an optimal
fleet of eight ships primarily sourcing year-round in
the Southern European markets and seasonally in
the South American markets.
•
We have taken actions to right-size the Costa brand
to the current environment, with two additional
smaller less-efficient ships recently announced for
removal from the Costa fleet, bringing the total
to four smaller-less efficient ships being removed
from the Costa fleet.
•
A further two Costa ships (
Costa Mediterranea
and
Costa Atlantica
) were sold to the China joint venture
prior to the pause in guest cruise operations and
transferred to the China joint venture during the
pause.
•
In addition, we are transferring three ships from
Costa to our highly successful Carnival Cruise Line
brand including two via our innovative Carnival Fun
Italian Style initiative, launching in June 2023.
As a result of all of our fleet optimization activities,
we have reshaped our portfolio such that, amongst
other smaller shifts, as of 2025, Carnival Cruise Line
will represent 33% of our total capacity (up from 29%
in 2019) and Costa will represent 10% of our total
capacity (down from 15% in 2019).
Return to Strong Profitability
Our business accelerated during 2022 on an upward
trajectory as we continued to close the gap to 2019
and gain momentum on our return to strong
profitability.
Throughout 2022, we have continued to aggressively
build occupancy on higher capacity while preserving
price discipline by using opaque distribution channels
and actively sharpening our revenue yield
management tools.
•
Our capacity in service approached 2019 levels by
the end of 2022, 35% higher than we started the
year.
•
Our occupancy gap to 2019 has closed from 50% in
the first quarter of 2022 to 19% in fourth quarter
of 2022.
•
At the same time, we have driven strong growth in
onboard revenue resulting in cruise revenue per
diems in constant dollar for the fourth quarter of
2022 to be 3.8% higher compared to 2019’s record
levels.
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
43
All of this has enabled us to consistently close the
revenue gap to 2019 from 65% in the first quarter of
2022 to 20% in the fourth quarter of 2022.
•
In addition, we have reduced the differential in
adjusted cruise costs excluding fuel per ALBD to
2019 from over 25% in the first quarter of 2022
down to 11% in the fourth quarter of 2022.
•
At the same time, we increased our investment in
advertising during the back half of 2022 to drive
demand for 2023 and beyond alongside a renewed
focus on our trade relationships and continued
growth for direct sales to also drive demand.
•
This culminated in positive Adjusted EBITDA in the
second half of 2022 of over $200 million, overcoming
a $528 million impact from higher fuel prices
compared to 2019.
We ended 2022 with $8.6 billion of liquidity and
$5.1 billion in customer deposits, which was a record
fourth quarter for customer deposits and an
increase of $1.6 billion from 2021. This was a great
ending considering the turbulence we encountered
but successfully managed through during 2022.
Entering 2022, we did not foresee any financing needs
other than opportunistic moves to refinance a
portion of our 2023 maturities given the expectation
of significantly improved cash flow generation ahead
and the refinancing of our 2022 maturities during
2021.
However, our cash flow generation during 2022 and
potentially the first half of 2023 was or will be
significantly impacted by a variety of factors.
•
Revenue: The Omicron variant’s negative impact
on the normal first quarter booking wave season,
the invasion of Ukraine requiring significant and
relatively last-minute itinerary changes eliminating
our high yielding summer season cruises to Saint
Petersburg, lower consumer confidence, and
the disparate protocol requirements between
cruising and other travel alternatives for the
majority of 2022.
•
Costs: Higher fuel prices, inflation, supply chain
disruptions, the cost of maintaining enhanced
health and safety protocols longer than we had
anticipated and higher interest rates.
As a result, management focused on preserving
liquidity by reevaluating capital expenditures,
managing customer deposits and accelerating
refinancing of 2023 maturities as well as the
outstanding revolver balance.
•
We strategically re-evaluated the projected
$1.6 billion in non-newbuild capital expenditures
for 2022 and reduced it by $0.5 billion for the year.
•
At the same time, based on the actual experience
with non-newbuild capital expenditures for 2022, we
reviewed our outer year capital expenditures and
reshaped investment spending by about
$300 million annually for a cumulative reduction of
$1.2 billion over the next four years.
•
With return to service essentially complete, we
effectively managed booking deposit requirements
and began to increase the amounts and move
back the timeframes to pre-pause levels resulting
in strong growth in customer deposit inflow and a
record fourth quarter balance.
•
We maintained a significant focus on liquidity.
There were extensive conversations about the
forecasted cash flows and our need for liquidity.
Management executed a Treasury Strategy to
accelerate the refinancing of 2023 maturities as
well as the outstanding revolver balance.
•
In addition to drawing on four export credits for
newbuild deliveries, six capital markets transactions
totaling nearly $6 billion were completed to
enhance our financial flexibility. Each transaction
was optimized for execution across a diverse set of
investor bases ($1.0 billion Unsecured Notes,
$1.2 billion equity block trade, $2.0 billion Senior
Priority Guarantee Notes, $1.1 billion Convertible
Notes, and $0.4 billion of Convertible Notes
Exchanges).
2022 CEO LEADERSHIP CHANGE
As further described under “CEO and Executive
Management Succession Planning,” our Boards and
the Nominating & Governance Committees oversee
our succession planning process. Our multi-brand
structure and continuous efforts to foster professional
development have enabled us to develop a strong
group of leaders within the organization. Following a
robust and thoughtful succession planning process,
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
44
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
the Boards of Directors selected Josh Weinstein, who
at the time was serving as our Chief Operations
Officer, to succeed Mr. Donald as our President, CEO
and Chief Climate Officer effective August 1, 2022.
Mr. Weinstein is a 20-year veteran of Carnival
Corporation & plc, with a long history of success in
critical senior-level roles with us, including most
recently as the Chief Operations Officer, President of
Carnival UK and Treasurer.
Compensation Actions In Connection
with CEO Leadership Change
2022 Target Compensation for Josh Weinstein, Our
New CEO
Mr. Weinstein was appointed as our President and
CEO, and assumed the role of Chief Climate Officer,
effective August 1, 2022. In connection with his
appointment to the role, the Compensation
Committees approved the following changes to
Mr. Weinstein’s executive compensation to reflect his
significantly expanded scope of responsibilities
from his prior role as Chief Operations Officer:
Pay Element
New 2022 Amount
Effective Date
Base Salary
$1,250,000
Effective August 1, 2022
Annual Cash Bonus
Target value: $2,500,000
Prorated from May 1, 2022
Long-Term Equity
Target value: $5,000,000
100% performance-based
Prorated from August 1, 2022
The Compensation Committees believe that it was
important to establish a compensation framework for
Mr. Weinstein that would provide a meaningful
equity stake in Carnival Corporation & plc that directly
aligns his interests with those of our long-term
investors by tying a meaningful portion of
Mr. Weinstein’s current compensation and future
wealth creation opportunity to our return to profitable
growth and sustained long-term value creation for
shareholders. As a result, the structure of
Mr. Weinstein’s compensation is highly
performance-linked, with 86% of target pay linked to
quantitative short- and long-term performance
measures and 57% delivered in equity.
The Compensation Committees also determined to
approve an additional one-time long-term
performance-based RSU grant (“LTPBS”) to
Mr. Weinstein under the Carnival Corporation 2020
Stock plan in connection with his promotion. The
Compensation Committees believe this grant
appropriately recognizes Mr. Weinstein’s promotion
while also incentivizing retention and long-term
performance on a comprehensive business metric.
The grant is structured as shown below:
2022 LTPBS Grant for Promotion to CEO
Pay Element
New 2022 Amount
Term Length
LTPBS
Target: 500,000 restricted stock units
(1)
Based
100% on performance-based vesting metrics
Vests in February fiscal 2028, subject to
performance
(1)
Target grant date value is $4,695,000, calculated based on the closing stock price of $9.39 on August 22, 2022. See “2022
LTPBS” under “Fiscal 2022 Annual Incentives” for more detail on the grant’s performance criteria.
2023 Target CEO Compensation
For fiscal 2023, the Compensation Committees
determined to keep Mr. Weinstein’s total target
compensation package substantially the same as his
pro-forma 2022 target compensation, with a target
value of $8,750,000, structured as follows:
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
45
Pay Element
2023 Amount
Base Salary
$1,250,000
Annual Cash Bonus
Target value: $2,500,000
Long-Term Equity
Performance-based RSUs
(target value): $3,500,000
Time-Based RSUs
(target value): $1,500,000
Outgoing CEO Consulting Agreement
Effective August 1, 2022, Arnold W. Donald, our
former President and CEO, transitioned into the role
of Vice Chair and remained a member of the Boards of
Directors. Effective November 30, 2022, Mr. Donald
resigned from his position as our Vice Chair and
member of the Boards of Directors.
We entered into a consulting agreement with
Mr. Donald effective December 1, 2022 under which
he will provide advice to our Chair, the President and
CEO and other officers of Carnival Corporation & plc
from December 1, 2022 through February 28, 2025.
Under the terms of the Consulting Agreement,
Mr. Donald will receive $1 million per year in cash as
compensation for all services provided, along with
continued health care coverage for him and his spouse
for the duration of the consulting relationship.
Consistent with the terms of our equity plans and the
applicable grant agreements, Mr. Donald is also
eligible for continued vesting of his previously
approved equity incentive programs for so long as he
continuously provides services to us under the
consulting agreement, including the fiscal 2023 grant
of RSUs associated with the 2022 MTE and 2022
PBS incentives. Mr. Donald will not be receiving any
other compensation in fiscal 2023 or beyond.
Mr. Donald’s consulting agreement also includes a
noncompete provision. The Boards of Directors
believe that retaining Mr. Donald as a consultant is in
the best interests of Carnival Corporation & plc, and
that Mr. Donald’s long tenure, institutional knowledge,
deep understanding and wide-ranging expertise on
matters of continued importance to our business
success as well as his extensive network of
professional relationships across businesses and
governments are valuable assets, particularly during
a time of continued transformation and recovery from
the COVID-19 pandemic.
SHAREHOLDER ENGAGEMENT
Carnival Corporation & plc has a long-standing
shareholder outreach program. We believe
constructive dialogue with our shareholders is a
fundamental pillar of effective corporate governance.
Conversations with our shareholders cover a variety
of topics relevant to the long-term success of our
business, including, but not limited to:
•
corporate strategy;
•
operating performance;
•
Board and corporate governance matters;
•
environmental sustainability;
•
social and human capital matters;
•
diversity, equity, and inclusion; and
•
executive compensation.
Our engagement program is primarily led by our
investor relations team, members of senior
management, and Directors. Depending on the
situation, meetings might include Chairs of Board
Committees or our Presiding Director and Senior
Independent Director. Directors participate in select
engagements to share their perspective and receive
feedback directly from our shareholders. Feedback
gathered during these engagement meetings is shared
with our full Boards and informs conversations at
the Board and senior management levels regarding
key decisions of our practices, policies, and
disclosures. We believe this shareholder engagement
mechanism allows for shareholder feedback and
concerns to be appropriately considered and
addressed by management and the Boards.
Engagement Following the 2022 Advisory
Votes on Compensation
As a supplement to our broader regular shareholder
engagement program and in response to our 2022
advisory votes to approve executive compensation
(also known as the “say-on-pay” vote) and the Carnival
plc Director’s Remuneration Report, each of which
received support from approximately 64% of the votes
cast, we conducted extensive shareholder outreach
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
46
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
following the 2022 Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
We ultimately conducted 19 meetings with 15 of
our shareholders over three outreach cycles, including
the summer following the 2022 Annual Meetings, in
the fall, and further in the winter. During this program
we met with several of our shareholders more than
once to seek ongoing feedback. This complemented
the feedback gathered in discussions with
shareholders in the weeks prior to the Annual
Meetings of Shareholders, which led in total to 44
meetings with 30 shareholders on compensation
matters as part of our 2022-2023 engagement
program. The objective of this outreach was to
understand the factors that drove investors’ evaluation
of and voting on our compensation program, and to
share and obtain feedback on the expected evolution
of our compensation program, including returning
to our historical practice of utilizing quantitative
performance criteria for fiscal 2022 annual bonuses
and equity-based compensation for our executive
officers. The Chair of our Compensation Committees
(who is also our Presiding Director and Senior
Independent Director) led these meetings to provide
insights into the Compensation Committees’
approach and hear directly from shareholders. The
scope of our shareholder engagement is summarized
below.
Engaged
Retail
and
Insider
Holdings
Contacted
19 meetings with 15
institutional shareholders
following our 2022
Annual Meetings
We engaged with a meaningful proportion of our institutional shareholders
following our 2022 Annual Meetings
Other
Institutional
Shareholders
Our Compensation Committees evaluated the feedback received in conversations following the 2022 Annual
Meetings of Shareholders, along with feedback received during previous engagement conversations, and took
specific actions in response, as outlined below:
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
47
Feedback Received
Actions Taken
A preference to return to quantitative and
performance-based compensation philosophy,
including:
Returned to a quantitative and performance-based
program for all executive officers’ incentive
programs in 2022 by:
•
For the annual incentive program to return to
using pre-determined, quantitative performance
criteria
•
Implementing quantitative performance criteria
for all executive officers’ fiscal 2022 annual
bonuses with a broad range of performance
criteria
•
For equity grants to include performance criteria
beyond continued service
•
Implementing quantitative performance criteria
for all executive officers’ fiscal 2022 equity-based
compensation and broadening the range of
performance criteria for fiscal 2022 and 2023
equity-based compensation
A preference for a mix of time and performance-
based incentives
Added a time-vested equity incentive for fiscal 2023
to focus on retention
A preference for disclosure enhancements,
including:
Enhanced disclosure in the Compensation
Discussion and Analysis and Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Report for fiscal 2022 to include:
•
Greater detail regarding how the Compensation
Committees ensured rigor and evaluated
individual performance against qualitative
performance criteria
•
Greater detail around incentive plan targets and
performance evaluation. See sections “Annual
Bonuses” and “Disclosure and the Timing of
Long-Term Incentive and Equity-Based
Compensation.”
•
Further detail on the Compensation Committees’
decisions for the fiscal year
•
Additional context and relevant information
regarding the Compensation Committees’ actions
and decisions for the fiscal year included in the
Compensation Discussion and Analysis and
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report for
fiscal 2022. See sections “2022 And 2023
Compensation Overview,” “Annual Bonuses,”
“Recent Equity-based Compensation Program
Changes.”
The Compensation Committees have implemented our quantitative and performance-based incentive program
in both 2022 and 2023 and will continue to consider results from the annual shareholder advisory votes, as well as
shareholder input received as part of our ongoing shareholder engagement program, when evaluating the
executive compensation programs, policies and disclosure going forward.
2022 AND 2023 COMPENSATION OVERVIEW
Summary of Fiscal 2022 Named Executive
Officer Compensation
As described above, the Compensation Committees
established an executive compensation structure for
2022 that returns to a substantially quantitative and
performance-based program. The following table
summarizes key elements of the program which are
further detailed in subsequent sections below:
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
48
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Fiscal 2022 Named Executive Officer Compensation Overview
Pay Element
Form of Payment
Description of Pay Element
Detail
Base Salary
Cash
Provides compensation based on level of responsibility,
performance, or other market factors
•
Increases reflecting
change in role and/or
responsibilities
Management
Incentive Plan
(“MIP”) Annual
Cash Bonus
Cash
Performance Metrics and Weighting:
•
Adjusted EBITDA at constant currency and fuel (50%)
•
Average Passenger Occupancy (10%)
•
Greenhouse Gas Intensity Reduction (10%)
•
Food Waste Reduction (5%)
•
Executive Accountabilities (25%)
Additional Detail:
•
Program payout ranged from 0 to 200% of the target
•
Returned to quantitative
performance metrics
based entirely on preset
objectives reflecting key
initiatives for the year
Long-Term
Incentive
PBS (Performance-
Based Share
Grants)
18%
Performance Metrics:
•
Tied to 2022 MIP program performance metrics for
2022
Additional Detail:
•
Three-year vesting period
•
Payout ranged from 0 to 200% of the target
•
Vests annually pro-rata in 2024 and 2025
•
Implemented quantitative,
performance-based
criteria in line with
shareholder feedback
prior to and following the
2022 Annual Meetings
Management
Incentive Plan-tied
Equity (“MTE”)
13%
Performance Metrics:
•
Tied to 2022 MIP program performance metrics for
2022
Additional Detail:
•
Three-year vesting period
•
Payout ranged from 0 to 200% of the target
•
Vests annually pro-rata in 2024 and 2025
•
Component included for
fiscal 2022
Earnings Recovery
Award (“ERA”)
•
Former CEO:
50% ERA cash
and 50% ERA
RSUs
•
Current CEO and
Other Named
Executive
Officers: 100%
ERA cash
69%
Performance Metric:
•
Adjusted EBITDA per available lower berth days
(“ALBD”)
Additional Detail:
•
Payouts can range from 0% to 150% of target
•
ERA Cash and ERA RSUs cliff vest in 2025 following the
end of the performance period based on
performance achieved
•
Incentivizes successful resumption of guest
operations
•
Component added
exclusively for fiscal 2022
to reflect the business
initiatives associated with
the return to guest cruise
operations and the
associated opportunity for
us to return to profitability
•
Recognizes extensive
management effort
required for business
recovery throughout this
unprecedented, volatile
and challenging period.
•
Incentive to promote
long-term retention.
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
49
Summary of Fiscal 2023 Named Executive
Officer Compensation
Based on the investor feedback we received
throughout 2022, the Compensation Committees
decided to provide advance disclosure of our
compensation program for 2023, which we will fully
report on in next year’s Compensation Discussion and
Analysis and Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report.
For fiscal 2023 the Compensation Committees
approved an annual and long-term incentive program
design that returns our senior leadership team,
including each of our Named Executive Officers, to
our pre-pandemic compensation structure based on
pre-established quantitative measures and that is
designed to align with shareholder interests and our
long-term success. Our overall 2023 compensation
program for our Named Executive Officers will be
significantly weighted towards quantitative
performance-based programs, with the MIP annual
bonus and the PBS grant being fully at-risk. The
Compensation Committees strongly believe that this
compensation and incentive structure creates the
proper level of alignment with our performance and
our long-term interests, and that of our shareholders
and other stakeholders while balancing the need to
drive measured, well-informed, and long-term focused
senior leadership decision-making.
•
The 2023 cash bonuses
delivered through our MIP
will return to the primary performance
measurement of
Adjusted Operating Income
(80%) and the balance will focus on health,
environmental, safety, security and sustainability
initiatives with specific goals and metrics established
and approved by the Compensation Committees
at the beginning of this measurement period, as
shown in the table below.
•
The 2023 equity-based compensation program
will consist of PBS RSUs weighted at 70% and TBS
(Time-based RSUs) weighted at 30%. During our
shareholder engagement on compensation
throughout 2022, several investors expressed a
preference to return to multi-year performance
measurement and to decouple the performance
criteria between our MIP annual cash bonus plan
and the equity-based compensation program. In
response to this feedback and in consideration of
competitive market practices, we discontinued the
use of MTE grants for 2023. The PBS grant is
designed to support our return to profitable growth
by measuring adjusted EBITDA, adjusted return
on invested capital (“ROIC”) and carbon intensity
reductions for fiscal years 2023, 2024 and 2025. The
TBS grants will support our retention objectives
by providing for annual vesting over a three-year
period subject to continued employment.
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
50
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Fiscal 2023 Named Executive Officer Compensation Overview
Pay Element
Form of Payment
Performance
Period
Description of Pay Element
Detail
Base Salary
Cash
One year
Provides compensation based on level
of responsibility, performance, or
other market factors
•
No changes to Named
Executive Officer base
salaries for 2023
MIP Annual
Cash Bonus
Cash
One year
Performance Metrics and Weighting:
•
Adjusted Operating Income (80%)
•
Compliance, Health, Environment,
Safety and Security (20%)
•
Safe & Compliant ships
•
Safe and Healthy Passengers &
Crew
•
Protecting the Environment
Additional Detail:
•
Payout will range from 0 to 200% of
target
•
Focuses performance on our critical
priority areas
•
Established a new mix of
metrics for 2023 based on
our primary financial
performance
measurement and critical
ESG-focused initiatives
Long-Term
Incentive
PBS (Performance-
Based Share
Grants)
70%
Three years
Performance Metrics and Weighting:
•
Adjusted EBITDA at constant
currency and fuel (65%)
•
Adjusted ROIC (25%)
•
Carbon Intensity Reduction (10%)
Additional Detail:
•
Subject to a three-year
measurement period of fiscal
2023-2025
•
Cliff vests in 2026 based on
attainment of performance goals
following the end of the 3-year
performance period with a payout
range of 0 to 200% of target
•
NEW FOR 2023
Returned
to a structure based on
multiple pre-established
quantifiable metrics
measured over a
multi-year period that is
designed to align with
shareholder interests and
our long-term success
TBS (Time-Based
Share Grants)
30%
Three years
•
Vests annually on a pro-rata basis
over a three-year period
•
Subject to continued employment
•
Balances the need to retain our
executive team and motivate them
to responsibly drive profitable
growth
•
NEW FOR 2023
Implemented to further
encourage retention and
address investor feedback
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
51
OVERVIEW OF COMPENSATION POLICIES AND PRACTICES
What We Do
What We Don’t Do
Independent Compensation Committees that
review and approve all compensation for our
Named Executive Officers
Independent compensation consultant
Annual Say-on-Pay vote
Stock ownership guidelines for Directors and
executives
Compensation Committees assess
compensation practices to deter excessive
risk-taking
Pay-for-performance philosophy
Mix of compensation which includes
short-term cash and long-term equity-based
compensation
Robust clawback policy
No guaranteed or unlimited incentive payouts
in our annual bonus plan
No evergreen provisions in our equity plan
No short sales, short-term hedging or margin
sales of our securities
No stock option repricing
No liberal share recycling of stock options or
stock appreciation rights
No pension plans or supplemental deferred
compensation or retirement plans for our
Named Executive Officers
No single-trigger change in control equity
vesting
No Section 280G gross-up payments in the
event of change of control
NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICER COMPENSATION DESIGN, ELEMENTS AND
PAY MIX
The compensation elements for our Named Executive
Officers consist of:
•
base salary;
•
annual bonus;
•
equity-based incentive compensation; and
•
perquisites.
In determining the amount of any particular
compensation element, the Compensation
Committees consider the impact of such an element
on total compensation (and thus, each element affects
the amount paid in respect of other elements of
compensation). For example, the Compensation
Committees consider the amount of the base salary
and annual bonus that may be earned by a Named
Executive Officer when making an equity grant.
2022 COMPENSATION RECOMMENDATIONS AND RATIONALE
RISK CONSIDERATIONS
The Compensation Committees evaluate the
compensation program for potential risks. The
Compensation Committees have concluded that the
incentive structure for senior management do not
encourage behaviors that would create material
adverse risk for Carnival Corporation & plc, and that
risks arising from Carnival Corporation & plc’s
compensation policies and practices for their
workforce are not reasonably likely to have a material
adverse effect on Carnival Corporation & plc. Please
refer to the “Compensation Risk Assessment” section
for additional information.
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
52
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
BASE SALARIES
Base salaries are intended to provide a level of fixed
compensation that is reflective of each Named
Executive Officer’s level of responsibility. Base salaries
of our Named Executive Officers for fiscal 2022 are
reported in the “Summary Compensation Table.” The
Compensation Committees annually review each
Named Executive Officer’s performance and may
increase the base salary of a Named Executive Officer
at their discretion if merited by performance,
responsibilities, or other market factors necessary to
attract and retain our executives.
For fiscal 2022, no increases to base salaries for our
Named Executive Officers were approved, other than
the following in connection with changes in roles
and/or responsibilities:
•
Josh Weinstein’s salary was increased to $1,250,000
upon his promotion to President and CEO;
•
David Bernstein’s salary was increased to $850,000
in connection with expanded responsibilities; and
•
William Burke’s salary was increased to $700,000 in
connection with his appointment as an executive
officer and his expanded responsibilities.
ANNUAL BONUSES
Annual cash bonuses for our Named Executive
Officers, are determined in accordance with the
Carnival Corporation & plc MIP. The MIP is designed
to focus the attention of our executives on achieving
strong performance results against key business
priorities and is a core component of our
compensation program that supports our pay for
performance philosophy.
For fiscal 2022, no increases to target bonuses for
Named Executive Officers were approved, other than
the following:
•
Josh Weinstein’s bonus target was increased to
$2,500,000 in connection with his promotion to
President and CEO;
•
David Bernstein’s bonus target was increased to
$1,200,000 in connection with his expanded
responsibilities;
•
William Burke’s bonus target was increased to
$500,000 in connection with his appointment as an
Executive Officer and his expanded responsibilities;
and
•
Enrique Miguez’ bonus target was increased to
$350,000 in connection with his expanded
responsibilities.
The target opportunities for fiscal 2022 for our
Named Executive Officers are shown below. Actual
payouts may range from 0% to 200% of the target
bonus opportunity based on actual performance.
Name
Base Salary
Target Bonus
Josh Weinstein
(1)
$
983,333
$1,858,767
David Bernstein
$
850,000
$1,200,000
William Burke
$
700,000
$
500,000
Enrique Miguez
$
500,000
$
350,000
Michael Thamm
€
860,250
€1,116,000
Arnold W. Donald
$1,500,000
$3,000,000
(1)
Values are prorated to reflect Mr. Weinstein’s target pay in connection with his promotion from Chief Operations Officer to
President and CEO.
2021 Context
Historically, the MIP structure closely linked financial
results to individual and overall company
performance. At the beginning of 2021, the global
COVID-19 pandemic severely impacted our business
and only one of our ships was operating with guests
onboard. To optimize business operations and align
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
53
incentives for senior management in light of the
unique set of strategic priorities we had to navigate
through during the extraordinary uncertainty caused
by COVID-19 the Compensation Committees
designed a bespoke bonus program for 2021 which
differed from the MIP’s historic design. During our
shareholder outreach program, several shareholders
expressed support for a return to a bonus program
that emphasized quantitative performance metrics as
our business began to recover and our operating
priorities returned to normal.
2022 Actions
The improving operating environment, in combination
with our executives’ outstanding efforts in navigating
the challenging COVID-19 pandemic circumstances,
enabled us to turn our strategic focus to returning to
profitability in 2022. To drive performance on this
priority, and in response to shareholder feedback, the
Compensation Committees designed the 2022
performance metrics to follow a structure based on
quantifiable, preset financial, operating,
environmental sustainability and ethics and
compliance goals tied to profitability and sustainable
growth, as described in more detail below.
Summary of Annual Bonus Plan Design Evolution for 2022
2021 Bonus Design
2022 Bonus Design
Period of great uncertainty with guest cruise
operations severely impacted by COVID-19
pandemic.
Impractical to establish a traditional formulaic
structure with preset performance objectives due
to unpredictable starts and stops to guest
operations throughout the year.
Emphasis on qualitative goals aligned with key
business initiatives with performance determined
on a backward-looking basis (no particular
weighting):
•
Liquidity
•
Return to Service
•
Compliance and Transparency
•
ESG Performance
Improved guest cruise operations with strategic focus
on returning to profitability.
The Compensation Committees adopted performance
metrics based entirely on preset objectives
emphasizing the following:
Metric
Weight
Adjusted EBITDA
50%
Average Passenger Occupancy
10%
Greenhouse Gas Intensity Reduction
10%
Food Waste Reduction
5%
Executive Accountabilities
25%
2022 Process for Setting Annual
Plan Targets
For each of the performance objectives, the
Compensation Committees focused on an approach
with quantifiable performance criteria and rigorous
goals that were considered to be challenging but
attainable.
2022 Performance Objectives
The 2022 bonus design includes quantitative
performance metrics addressing our key business
priorities of liquidity, return to service, ESG
performance, and compliance and transparency.
Specifically, the Compensation Committees
determined the following measures best align with
our business strategy:
•
Adjusted EBITDA, normalized for the impact of fuel
and currency to emphasize focus on return to
profitability;
•
Average Passenger Occupancy to focus on our
return to service;
•
Greenhouse Gas Intensity Reductions measuring
fiscal 2022 fleet annual CO2e intensity based on
ship fuel consumption per ALBD for ships
conducting full months guest operations;
•
Food Waste Reductions measuring the average
food waste weight per person-day for ships
conducting guest operations for at least 2 months;
and
•
Executive Accountabilities, a personalized set of
commitments to promote the Culture Essentials
and compliance.
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
54
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Adjusted EBITDA, Average Passenger Occupancy, Greenhouse Gas Intensity Reductions, Food Waste Reductions
The following table is a summary of the uniform performance measures and goals used to determine the level
of achievement associated with the financial and ESG performance measures and the associated results. Executive
Accountabilities are more fully discussed following this table.
Payout Level
Payout
(% of target)
Adjusted EBITDA
($ in millions)
Average Passenger
Occupancy
(%)
Greenhouse
Gas Intensity
Reduction
(kg/ALBD)
Food Waste
Reduction
(kg/person-day)
Maximum
200
0
81.0
102.0
0.589
Target
100
(1,400)
70.0
109.2
0.644
Threshold
50
(2,200)
64.0
115.2
0.736
Results:
FY2022 Actual
$
(913)
75.3
104.3
0.638
Metric Payout %
133.6
144.2
168.0
110.8
Weighting %
50.0
10.0
10.0
5.0
Weighted Payout %
66.8
14.4
16.8
5.5
Executive Accountabilities
In 2022, the Compliance Committees of the Boards of
Directors developed the Executive Accountabilities
Initiative to incentivize leadership in the following six
areas we refer to as our Culture Essentials:
Communicate, Speak Up, Listen & Learn, Improve,
Respect & Protect, and Empower. While the Culture
Essentials are always an important component of
senior leadership’s responsibilities, given the rapid
restart of our guest cruise operations, relaunch of
nearly the entire fleet and the return of more than
100,000 crew and shoreside employees over the
past 18 months, the Compensation and Compliance
Committees determined that promoting our Culture
Essentials was a key priority and to drive that, a
meaningful portion of management’s 2022
compensation needed to reflect the importance of
this “mission critical” imperative The Culture Essentials
make up the foundation of our ethics and compliance
culture and our values and serve as specific
behaviors which help us to deliver on our shared
aspiration to maintain our commitment to excellence
in compliance, environmental protection and the
health, safety and well-being of every life we touch.
The Executive Accountabilities (“EA”) component of the
MIP is weighted at 25% and is comprised of activities
to improve across these six Culture Essentials. The
pre-established performance goals for each of these
categories are customized to each Named Executive
Officer reflecting their unique roles and
responsibilities. Scoring for each component ranges
on a scale from 1 to 5, with 5 being the highest. The
total EA payout is equal to the average payout for
each category. There is no payout if the score for the
metric is below 2. Total EA payout can range from
0% to 200% of the target that is then weighted at 25%.
Performance Scale
Description
Payout Scale
(%)
5
Exceeded Expectations
200
4
Above Expectations
125
3
Met Expectations
100
2
Under Expectations
50
Below 2
Below Expectations
0
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
55
Below are illustrative key objectives and representative performance criteria for each of the Culture Essentials.
The actual performance objectives are unique to each Named Executive Officer based on their role and
responsibilities.
Culture Essentials
Key Objectives
Sample Performance Evaluation Criteria
(actual criteria varies by individual)
Communicate
Emphasize the significance of
achieving compliance,
safeguarding the environment,
protecting the health, safety
and security of our guests and
our teams, and strengthening
are culture are required for our
success
•
Number of shipboard visits prioritizing communication
on the topic of ethics and compliance and Culture
Essentials
•
Engagements with leadership of operating companies,
ship leadership, and senior management to review and
reinforce Culture Essentials priorities
•
Utilization of relevant communication channels (town
halls, videos, quarterly communications, leadership
team meetings) to communicate Culture Essentials
priorities and initiatives
•
Demonstrate leadership by example and modeling of
priority behaviors
•
Impact of measures implemented to encourage the
importance of speaking up across the organization
Speak Up
Encourage team members to
speak up. Instill confidence in
team members through
encouragement, messaging,
measurement and follow up
actions. Prohibit retaliation
•
Demonstrate leadership by example and modeling of
priority behaviors
•
Impact of measures implemented to encourage the
importance of speaking up across the organization
•
Review of harassment and discrimination cases, hotline
reports and engagement survey insights to ensure
appropriate actions and follow up plans are
implemented
•
Utilization of a clearly articulated and broadly accessible
‘open door’ policy to foster a transparent and
collaborative culture
•
Measurement of hotline usage trends
Listen & Learn
Engage in audits,
investigations, ship visits, and
employee surveys to ensure
employee perspectives are
heard. Develop action plans in
response to key findings
•
Comprehensive support for, and participation in, key
audit and compliance meetings and ensure full
cooperation of teams in the preparation, discussion and
follow up activities
•
Engagements with leadership of operating companies,
ship leadership, and senior management to understand
current challenges and receive feedback
•
Regular meetings with leadership to share information
and suggestions to learn and identify trends for
improvement
Improve
Drive performance in safety,
environmental protection and
compliance. Support and
promote diversity, equity and
inclusion (“DEI”)
•
Establishment of a culture focused on improvement,
including encouraging employees to proactively identify
opportunities
•
Implementation of key DEI initiatives to help recruit,
develop and retain diverse team members (both ship
and shore)
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
56
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Culture Essentials
Key Objectives
Sample Performance Evaluation Criteria
(actual criteria varies by individual)
•
ESG and Task Force on Climate-Related Financial
Disclosures (“TCFD”) training and reporting working
across functions to communicate and meet goals/
commitments
•
Key Performance Indicators tracking improvement
across Heath, Environment, Safety and Security
categories
Respect & Protect
Take actions to promote,
monitor, and incentivize health,
environmental, safety and
security compliance and
support employees and the
communities in which we
touch and serve
•
Incorporation of ESG into strategic and financial
reporting process to augment corporate-wide focus and
begin tracking and benchmarking
•
Establishment of, and progress made towards, interim
sustainability goals
•
Incorporation of decarbonization efforts into our
planning process
Empower
Support internal teams by
providing appropriate
resources needed to succeed
(training, tools and time)
•
Support efforts to ensure adequate resources to ensure
continued compliance, value-add of work done, and
engaged employees
•
Focus on monitoring and prioritizing ship operational
and compliance needs
•
Encouragement of employees to feel confident and
empowered when requesting additional resources in
order to produce excellent work
•
Holding annual training in ethics and compliance issues
Individual performance targets or ranges pertaining
to the Culture Essentials are not disclosed because this
information is not otherwise publicly available, and
we believe it would cause competitive harm to disclose
these details, and would reveal highly confidential
and proprietary information about our operations
without adding meaningfully to the understanding of
our executive compensation arrangements. This is
particularly sensitive information given the small
number of publicly-traded cruise ship competitors of
similar size and scale. The Compensation Committees
believe this information is likely to remain
commercially sensitive indefinitely. The Compensation
Committees also believe that the target levels were
reasonable and provided appropriate incentives to
our Named Executive Officers.
At the end of fiscal 2022, the Compensation
Committees and the Compliance Committees of the
Boards of Directors assessed each Named Executive
Officer’s performance relative to that Named
Executive Officer’s individual goals across these six
categories. The actual payout based on performance
achievement are listed in the following table. Key
performance achievements for each Named Executive
Officers are further highlighted in the section below.
Name
Weight
(%)
Average Score
(Culture Essentials)
Payout
(% of target)
Josh Weinstein
25
3.5
112.5
David Bernstein
25
3.7
117.5
William Burke
25
4.0
125.0
Enrique Miguez
25
3.8
120.0
Michael Thamm
25
3.0
100.0
Arnold W. Donald
25
3.3
107.5
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
57
2022 MIP Annual Bonus Performance
The 2022 MIP program design was based on
achievement of pre-established and quantitative
goals. The formula-based MIP annual bonus results
for fiscal 2022 reflected our strong performance driven
by the extraordinary efforts of our executive officers
and global teams around the world. Throughout fiscal
2022, we successfully returned our fleet to service,
significantly increasing occupancy on growing capacity,
while driving revenue per passenger cruise day
higher than fiscal 2019’s record levels. At the same
time, we managed down our costs over the course of
fiscal 2022 while investing to build future demand.
We made significant progress on the historic journey
since the pause of guest cruise operations in early
2020—returning 90 ships to service, re-boarding over
100,000 team members and restarting our portfolio
of eight private island and port destinations plus our
land-based footprint in Alaska and the Yukon. And,
most importantly, we delivered unforgettable
happiness to nearly 9 million guests by providing
them with exceptional cruise vacations. Despite the
hectic pace of change, we maintained our ongoing
commitment to excellence in compliance,
environmental protection and in looking after the
safety, health and wellbeing of every life we touch.
Overall performance against the goals for our
formula-based MIP for the Named Executive Officers
ranged from 128.6% to 134.8%, as shown below.
These goals are important indicators of our financial
and operational success; however, Mr. Weinstein
believed these results did not sufficiently align with
the share price performance for our shareholders.
Therefore, upon Mr. Weinstein’s request, the
Compensation Committees reviewed and determined
that the final annual bonus payouts as well as the
MTE and PBS equity incentive payouts for the Named
Executive Officers for fiscal 2022 be reduced to
110% of target. The 110% payout level still recognizes
that Named Executive Officer performance exceeded
defined targets and expectations. The following table
summarizes the results for each MIP performance
goal, the overall MIP formula-based performance and
the final bonus amounts paid after the reduction
was applied:
Name
Adjusted
EBITDA
(% of Target) +
Average
Passenger
Occupancy
(% of Target) +
Greenhouse
Gas Intensity
Reduction
(% of Target) +
Food
Waste
Reduction
(% of Target) +
Executive
Accountabilities
(% of Target)
=
Formula-
Based
2022
MIP
Results
2022 MIP
Results
After
Reduction
2022
MIP
Bonus
Paid
(50% weight)
(10% weight)
(10% weight)
(5% weight)
(25% weight)
(% of Target) (% of Target)
($)
Josh Weinstein
66.8
14.4
16.8
5.5
28.1
131.7
110
2,044,644
David Bernstein
66.8
14.4
16.8
5.5
29.4
132.9
110
1,320,000
William Burke
66.8
14.4
16.8
5.5
31.3
134.8
110
550,000
Enrique Miguez
66.8
14.4
16.8
5.5
30.0
133.6
110
385,000
Michael Thamm
66.8
14.4
16.8
5.5
25.0
128.6
110
1,301,256
Arnold W. Donald
66.8
14.4
16.8
5.5
26.9
130.4
110
3,300,000
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
58
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
EQUITY-BASED COMPENSATION
Overview
The Compensation Committees grant equity-based
compensation to our Named Executive Officers
to provide long-term incentives and align
management and shareholder interests. The
Compensation Committees believe that a substantial
portion of compensation should be equity-based.
The equity-based compensation program is designed
to:
1
recognize scope of responsibilities
2
reward demonstrated performance and
leadership
3
motivate future superior performance
4
align the interests of the executive with our
shareholders
Our equity-based compensation grants are made
pursuant to the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan
or the Carnival plc 2014 Employee Share Plan and
are consistent with the Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Policy, which have been approved by
Carnival Corporation & plc’s shareholders. Messrs.
Weinstein, Bernstein, Burke, Miguez and Donald
received equity grants under the Carnival Corporation
2020 Stock Plan. Mr. Thamm received equity grants
under the Carnival plc 2014 Employee Share Plan.
Recent Equity-based Compensation
Program Changes
2021 Context
In years leading up to and including fiscal 2020, the
equity-based compensation program was 100%
performance-based for our Named Executive Officers.
However, given the continuing impact of the
COVID-19 pandemic, the unanticipated pause in our
guest cruise operations and uncertainty with respect
to the timing and pace of our full return to guest
cruise operations, in January 2021 the Compensation
Committees acknowledged the significant difficulty
in setting meaningful and realistic long-term financial
goals in the current business environment and
approved TBS grants for fiscal 2021. TBS grants have
no performance condition and vest annually on a
three-year annual pro-rata basis starting on the first
anniversary of the grant date, and were intended to
incentivize continued retention during a highly
challenging and uncertain time.
2022 Actions
In 2022, having observed an improving business
environment, the Compensation Committees elected
to return to a performance-based program design
for our Named Executive Officers. As a result, in fiscal
2022, the Named Executive Officers received the
following performance-based incentive opportunities:
MTE, PBS, and ERA, each of which are described
below in detail. The Compensation Committees
determined that the 2022 MTE and PBS grants would
be measured against the performance criteria
determined for the MIP, given their strategic
importance to us and the ongoing challenges in
setting meaningful long-term goals as we continued
our return to full guest cruise operations in a volatile
operating environment. As described above under
“Summary of Fiscal 2023 Named Executive Officer
Compensation,” for 2023 our equity incentive structure
will continue to evolve and performance-based
incentives will be evaluated against a set of financial
and health, environmental, safety, security and
sustainability metrics.
For fiscal 2022, no increases to equity targets for
Named Executive Officers were approved, other than
the following:
•
Josh Weinstein’s equity target was increased to
$5,000,000 upon his promotion to President, CEO
and Chief Climate Officer;
•
David Bernstein’s equity target was increased to
$2,550,000 in connection with his expanded
responsibilities;
•
William Burke’s equity target was increased to
$400,000 in connection with his appointment as an
executive officer and his expanded responsibilities;
and
•
Enrique Miguez’ equity target was increased to
$350,000 in connection with his expanded
responsibilities.
In addition, in connection with his appointment to
the role of CEO, Mr. Weinstein received a LTPBS grant
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
59
which will vest subject to ROIC performance criteria,
as described below.
In February 2022, the Compensation Committees
considered the intense competition for executive
talent, the scarcity of specialized talent required to
operate a business of our size and complexity in our
niche industry, and the need to retain and motivate
the executive team members deemed integral to
our successful return to profitable growth.
Additionally, the Compensation Committees identified
that members of our executive leadership team
were likely targets for companies in adjacent
industries that recovered more rapidly from, or were
not negatively affected by, the impacts of COVID-19.
In consideration of these factors, the Compensation
Committees approved a special one-time ERA
incentive to select executive officers and key
employees, including all of our Named Executive
Officers, to emphasize retention and incentivize return
to pre-set profitability levels by the end of the
performance period. These incentives are described
below under “Fiscal 2022 Annual Incentives.”
Disclosure and the Timing of Long-Term
Incentive and Equity-Based
Compensation
2022 MTE Annual Performance Incentive
In January 2022, the Compensation Committees
approved an MTE target value for each of our Named
Executive Officers and certain other executives. Each
target value was determined after consideration of
recommendations received from our CEO (other than
in respect of our CEO’s own grant which was
recommended by our Chair of the Compensation
Committees), as well as reviewing the scope of the
Named Executive Officers’ responsibilities,
performance and long-term retention considerations.
Following the end of fiscal 2022, the actual 2022 MIP
payout percentage was applied to the MTE target
values to determine the final MTE grant
recommendation values, which may be from zero to
200% of target. As described in more detail in “2022
MIP Annual Bonus Performance” above, upon
Mr. Weinstein’s request, the Compensation
Committees reviewed and determined that the final
MIP payout as well as the MTE and PBS grant values be
reduced to 110%. The table below shows the final
MTE grant values.
In fiscal 2023, the actual MTE value earned will be
converted into a number of MTE RSUs based on the
grant date closing price of our shares. They will vest
pro-rata on February 15, 2024 and 2025. The MTE
RSUs do not receive dividends or have voting rights.
Each MTE RSU is credited with dividend equivalents
equal to the value of cash and stock dividends paid
on Carnival Corporation common stock or Carnival plc
ordinary shares, if any. The dividend equivalents will
be distributed upon the settlement of the MTE RSUs
only upon vesting.
Name
2022 MTE
Target Value
($)
2022 MIP
Payout
Percentage
(%)
2022 MTE
Grant Value
($)
Josh Weinstein
(1)
1,135,205
x
110
=
1,248,726
David Bernstein
850,000
x
110
=
935,000
William Burke
175,000
x
110
=
192,500
Enrique Miguez
250,000
x
110
=
275,000
Michael Thamm
492,900
x
110
=
542,190
Arnold W. Donald
2,000,000
x
110
=
2,200,000
(1)
The 2022 MTE target value reflects Mr. Weinstein’s fiscal 2022 pro-rated targets of $299,589 for his time as Chief Operations
Officer and $835,616 for his time as President, CEO and Chief Climate Officer , which began on August 1, 2022.
(2)
Mr. Thamm’s MTE target value was payable in euro. These euro amounts have been converted into U.S. dollars at the average
U.S. dollar to euro exchange rate for fiscal 2022 of $1.06:€1.
2022 PBS Annual Performance Incentive
In January 2022, the Compensation Committees
approved a PBS target value for each of our Named
Executive Officers and certain other executives. Each
target value was determined after consideration of
recommendations received from our CEO (other than
in respect of his own grant which was recommended
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
60
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
by our Chair of the Compensation Committees), as
well as reviewing the scope of the Named Executive
Officer’s responsibilities, performance and long-term
retention considerations. Following the end of fiscal
2022, the actual 2022 MIP payout percentage was
applied to the PBS target values to determine the
actual PBS grant recommendation values, which may
be from zero to 200% of target. As described in
more detail in “2022 MIP Annual Bonus Performance”
above, upon Mr. Weinstein’s request, the
Compensation Committees reviewed and determined
that the final MIP payout as well as the MTE and
PBS grant values be reduced to 110%. The table below
shows the final MTE grant values.
In fiscal 2023, the actual PBS values earned will be
converted into a number of PBS RSUs based on the
grant date closing price of our shares. They vest pro-
rata on February 15, 2024 and February 15, 2025. The
PBS RSUs do not receive dividends or have voting
rights. Each PBS RSU is credited with dividend
equivalents equal to the value of cash and stock
dividends paid on Carnival Corporation common stock
or Carnival plc ordinary shares, if any. The dividend
equivalents will be distributed upon the settlement of
the PBS RSUs only upon vesting.
Name
2022 PBS
Target Value
($)
2022 MIP
Payout
Percentage
(%)
2022 PBS
Grant Value
($)
Josh Weinstein
(1)
1,101,918
x
110
=
1,212,110
David Bernstein
1,700,000
x
110
=
1,870,000
William Burke
225,000
x
110
=
247,500
Enrique Miguez
100,000
x
110
=
110,000
Michael Thamm
(2)
1,182,960
x
110
=
1,301,256
Arnold W. Donald
3,500,000
x
110
=
3,850,000
(1)
The 2022 PBS target value reflects Mr. Weinstein’s fiscal 2022 pro-rated targets of $266,301 for his time as Chief Operations
Officer and $835,616 for his time as President, and CEO and Chief Climate Officer, which began on August 1, 2022.
(2)
Mr. Thamm’s MTE target value was payable in euro. These euro amounts have been converted into U.S. dollars at the average
U.S. dollar to euro exchange rate for fiscal 2022 of $1.06:€1.
2022 ERA Performance Incentive
In February 2022, the Compensation Committees
approved an ERA target value for each of our Named
Executive Officers and certain other executives and
key employees. For Mr. Donald, who was CEO at the
time of the Compensation Committees’ decisions and
continues to provide services in his capacity as a
consultant, half of the target value was approved in
the form of a long-term cash incentive (“ERA Cash”)
and the other half was delivered in the form of a
performance-based restricted stock unit grant (“ERA
RSU”). The Compensation Committees concluded that,
in light of his role as CEO at that time, Mr. Donald’s
ERA grant should include a restricted stock unit
component to increase the linkage between the value
of his grant and stock price movement to ensure
alignment with shareholders if earnings growth and
share price were decoupled. All other Named
Executive Officers and ERA recipients were approved
to receive ERA Cash. The percentage of the target
amount of ERA Cash and ERA RSUs that vest will be
based upon the extent to which normalized adjusted
EBITDA per ALBD meets or exceeds a predefined
performance scale that was established in advance.
Payouts can range from 0% to 150% of target, subject
to meeting threshold performance. ERA Cash and
ERA RSUs cliff vest in February 2025, following the end
of the performance period.
Normalized adjusted EBITDA is defined as earnings
before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization
excluding the impact (as compared to 2019) of fuel
price, exchange rate fluctuations, and taxes related to
fuel, carbon, or other climate related items. ALBD is
computed by multiplying passenger capacity (based
on double occupancy) by revenue-producing ship
operating days in the period.
Performance will be measured at the end of fiscal
2024 and ERA Cash or ERA RSUs shall not vest until the
performance results have been certified by the
Compensation Committees.
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
61
Name
2022
ERA
Target Value
($ in millions)
2022
ERA Cash
Target Value
(1)
($ in millions)
2022
ERA RSU
Target Value
(2)
(Applicable only to Mr. Donald)
($ in millions)
Josh Weinstein
5.0
5.0
N/A
David Bernstein
5.0
5.0
N/A
William Burke
5.0
5.0
N/A
Enrique Miguez
2.0
2.0
N/A
Michael Thamm
5.0
5.0
N/A
Arnold W. Donald
12.0
6.0
6.0
(1)
(1)
The maximum cash value that may be earned is 150% of the ERA Cash Target Value.
(2)
Target value represents 300,601 ERA RSUs based on the grant date closing price of our shares of $19.96. The maximum
number of ERA RSUs that may be earned is 450,901.
2022 LTPBS RSU Grant
In August 2022, the Compensation Committees
approved an LTPBS RSU grant for Mr. Weinstein in
connection with his promotion and appointment as
our President, CEO and Chief Climate Officer. The
Compensation Committees concluded it was
important to establish a compensation framework
for Mr. Weinstein that would provide a meaningful
equity stake in our company that directly aligns his
interests with those of our long-term investors by tying
a meaningful portion of the CEO’s current
compensation and future wealth creation opportunity
on our return to profitable growth and sustained
long-term value creation for shareholders.
The LTPBS grant provides for 500,000 performance-
based RSUs at target and is subject to our financial
performance in fiscal 2026 and 2027 to focus
Mr. Weinstein on improving returns for shareholders
over a longer period. Any earned LTPBS will vest in
February 2028 based on the certified performance
results. Performance will be calculated on our average
adjusted ROIC as measured in fiscal years 2026 and
2027 based on predefined goals established in fiscal
2022. The LTPBS may be earned from zero to 200%
of the target number of shares. The LTPBS do not
receive dividends or have voting rights. Each LTPBS is
credited with dividend equivalents equal to the
value of cash and stock dividends paid on Carnival
Corporation common stock or Carnival plc ordinary
shares, if any. The dividend equivalents will be added
on the final number of LTPBS earned and will be
distributed upon the settlement of the LTPBS at
vesting.
2022 LTPBS Grant
Form of Payment
Description of Grant
LTPBS (Performance-
Based RSUs)
Target Grant value:
500,000 performance-based RSUs
Performance Criteria:
•
Extent to which the average of ROIC for fiscal 2026 and fiscal 2027 meets or exceeds pre-
established ROIC goals
Additional Detail:
•
Payout will range from 0 to 200% of the target
•
Vests in February fiscal 2028, subject to achieving threshold or better performance
Disclosure of Prior Years’ Grant Results
2020 Annual PBS Grant
The 2020 Annual PBS and Strategic ESG Goals PBS (as
defined below) grants made to the Named Executive
Officers in February 2020 and August 2020,
respectively reached the end of the performance
period at the end of fiscal 2022 and will vest on
February 6, 2023.
Under the terms of the 2020 Annual PBS grant,
shares vested based upon the extent to which annual
adjusted Operating Income, as further adjusted for
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
62
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
year-over-year fuel price changes and currency
exchange rate impacts for each of the three fiscal years
in the 2020-2022 performance period (“Program
Adjusted Operating Income”), the average of the fiscal
2021 and 2022 ROIC result and ESG reduction goals
reached or exceeded specified performance goals. The
ESG metrics focus on reductions in CO2e intensity,
food waste and single use items for ships operating
guest cruises. Under the terms of the grant, the
Program Adjusted Operating Income result is weighted
50%, ROIC result is weighted 25% and the ESG
metrics results are weighted 25%. The 2020 Annual
PBS metrics were as follows:
Annual Program
Adjusted Operating Income
Growth Goal
Annual Operating Income Goal
Two-
Year
Average
ROIC Goal
(%)
Payout for
Program
Adjusted
Operating
Income and
ROIC Goals
(%)
Goal Level
2020
(% of Goal)
2021
(% of Goal)
2022
(% of Goal)
2020
($ in billions)
2021
($ in billions)
2022
($ in billions)
Threshold
92.0
102.0
102.0
3.042
(4,786)
(6,149)
8.0
50
Target
100.0
105.0
105.0
3.307
(4,640)
(5,961)
9.0
100
Maximum
104.9
108.0
108.0
3.472
(4,493)
(5,773)
10.0
200
The Corporation Operating Income and ROIC results for the 2020 Annual PBS grant were as follows:
Program Adjusted Operating Income and
ROIC Results
2020 Program
Adjusted Operating
Income
2021 Program
Adjusted Operating
Income
2022 Program
Adjusted Operating
Income
Two-Year
Average ROIC
Annual Program Adjusted Operating
Income
($ in billions)
(4.837)
(6.166)
(3,075)
Percent of Target Annual Program Adjusted
Operating Income Growth (%)
(146.26)
(126.24)
49.00
0.0%
Annual Program Adjusted Operating
Income Growth Payout (%)
0.00
0.00
200.00
The ESG metrics include a focus on reductions in CO2e intensity, food waste and single use items for ships
operating guest cruises as follows:
Goal Level
CO2e Intensity
(% Reduction)
(1)
Food Waste
(% Reduction)
(2)
Single Use Items
(% Reduction)
(3)
Payout for
Program
ESG Metrics
(4)
(%)
Threshold
4.0
16.0
60.0
50
Target
6.0
30.0
65.0
100
Maximum
8.0
45.0
70.0
200
(1)
CO2e intensity reduction is as compared to the 2019 baseline of 246 emissions from ship fuel per ALG-KM.
(2)
Food Waste reductions are as compared to the 2019 baseline 0.92 kg per person, per day as determined by the fleet-wide
weighing process.
(3)
Single use items, excluding medical use, plastic gloves and water bottles, as compared to the 2018 baseline of 4.78 items per
person, per day (based on passenger cruise days plus crew payroll days).
(4)
All of the performance metrics were designed and approved in February 2020 prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, in contemplation
of the full fleet operating guest cruises. The Compensation Committees confirmed that the ESG metrics were to be evaluated
for ships operating guest cruises.
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
63
The ESG results for the 2020 Annual PBS grant were as follows:
ESG Metric
Reduction Achievement
(%)
ESG Metric Payout
(%)
Average ESG Payout
(%)
CO2e Intensity Reduction
(%)
11.0
200.00
Food Waste Reduction (%)
32.0
113.33
171.11%
Single Use Items Reduction (%)
82.0
200.00
The fiscal 2020, 2021 and 2022 annual adjusted
Program Adjusted Operating Income growth
payout percentages were averaged, the two-year
average ROIC result was calculated and ESG results
were calculated to determine the respective
payout percentages that were then weighted to
obtain final payout percentages, as follows:
Payout % and TSR Modifier
Unweighted Payout
(%)
Weighting
(%)
Weighted Payout
(%)
Average Annual Program Adjusted Operating Income Payout
66.67
50
33.33
ROIC Payout
0.00
25
0.00
ESG Payout
171.11
25
42.78
Final Payout
76.11
The results reflect the impact of the COVID-19
pandemic on our organization and improvement
resulting from our return to service. Based on these
performance measures and a 76.11% final
payout percentage, the Named Executive Officers will
receive the following on or about February 6, 2023:
Name
2020 Annual PBS
Target Shares
(#)
2020 Annual PBS
Earned Shares
(1)
(#)
Josh Weinstein
3,597
2,737
David Bernstein
20,388
15,517
William Burke
5,396
4,106
Enrique Miguez
479
364
Michael Thamm
31,144
23,703
Arnold W. Donald
71,959
54,767
(1)
Additional shares will be provided to take into account
any dividends paid during the period.
2020 Strategic ESG Goals PBS Grant
In August 2020, a special long-term incentive program
was approved for the Named Executive Officers,
excluding Mr. Miguez. Half of this incentive was
granted in the form of Special Retention RSUs that
vested in 2021 and 2022, and half was granted in the
form of PBS RSUs measuring performance of three
ESG metrics over fiscal 2020-2022 (the “2020 Strategic
ESG Goals PBS”). The ESG metrics include a focus on
CO2e Intensity reduction, food waste reduction and
single use items reductions measured at the end of
the performance period for ships operating guest
cruises. The 2020 Strategic ESG Goals PBS measures
the following:
Goal Level
CO2e Intensity
(% Reduction)
(1)
Food Waste
(% Reduction)
(2)
Single Use Plastics
(% Reduction)
(3)
Payout for
Program
ESG Metrics
(4)
(%)
Threshold
4.0
16.0
60.0
50
Target
6.0
30.0
65.0
100
Maximum
8.0
45.0
70.0
150
(1)
CO2e intensity reduction is as compared to the 2019 baseline of 246 emissions from ship fuel per ALG-KM.
(2)
Food Waste reductions are as compared to the 2019 baseline 0.92 kg per person, per day as determined by the fleet-wide
weighing process.
(3)
Single use items, excluding medical use, plastic gloves and water bottles, as compared to the 2018 baseline of 4.78 items per
person, per day (based on passenger cruise days plus crew payroll days).
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
64
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
(4)
All of the performance metrics were designed and approved in February 2020 prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, in contemplation
of the full fleet operating guest cruises. The Compensation Committees confirmed that the ESG metrics were to be evaluated
for ships operating guest cruises.
The results for the 2020 Strategic ESG Goals PBS grant were as follows:
ESG Metric
Reduction Achievement
(%)
ESG Metric Payout
(%)
Final Payout
(%)
CO2e Intensity Reduction (%)
11.00
150.00
Food Waste Reduction (%)
32.00
106.67
135.56
Single Use Plastics Reduction (%)
82.00
150.00
Based on these performance measures and a final payout percentage, the Named Executive Officers will receive
the following on or about February 6, 2023:
Name
2020 Strategic ESG Goals PBS
Target Shares
(#)
2020 Strategic ESG Goals PBS
Earned Shares
(2)
(#)
Josh Weinstein
31,100
42,159
David Bernstein
46,650
63,238
William Burke
12,800
17,351
Enrique Miguez
(1)
N/A
N/A
Michael Thamm
64,700
87,707
Arnold W. Donald
150,000
203,340
(1)
Mr. Miguez did not receive a 2020 ESG Goals PBS grant.
(2)
No dividends were paid between the grant date and the end of the performance period.
2020 Shareholder Equity Alignment (“SEA”)
Grants
The 2020 SEA grants made to the Named Executive
Officers in January 2020 reached the end of the
performance period at the end of fiscal 2022. Under
the terms of the 2020 SEA grant, shares vest based
upon the extent to which our absolute TSR
compound annual growth rate over the December 1,
2019 to November 30, 2022 performance period and
TSR ranking relative to the 2020 Peer Group for the
same period reached or exceeded certain goals. The
90-day average starting price for the 2020 SEA grant
was $44.55. As a result of the COVID-19 pandemic’s
impact on our share price, the ending 90-day average
price at November 30, 2022 was $9.09, resulting in
no payout for these grants.
Metric
End Price
Growth/Ranking
Payout
%
Absolute TSR
$9.09
-41.12%
0.00
Relative TSR
0
th
percentile
0.00
Final Percentage of Target to Vest
0.00%
0.00
PERQUISITES AND OTHER COMPENSATION
Our Named Executive Officers are provided various
perquisites that the Compensation Committees
believe are representative of common practices for
executives in their respective countries. Some of
Messrs. Donald’s and Thamm’s perquisites and other
benefits are, or were, in case of Mr. Donald, provided
pursuant to terms of their employment agreements.
The Compensation Committees, with the assistance
of FW Cook, review perquisites provided to our
Named Executive Officers on a periodic basis and
take into account each Named Executive Officer’s
particular circumstances and overall level of
compensation, and believe that perquisites provided
by Carnival Corporation & plc continue to be an
appropriate element of the overall compensation
package used to attract and retain such officers.
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
65
The Compensation Committees have approved a
policy to establish procedures and controls as to the
authorized use of aircraft owned, operated or
chartered by Carnival Corporation & plc (the “Aircraft”).
According to the policy, the Aircraft can only be used
for business purposes. Guests may accompany these
executives when traveling. Due to security
considerations, the Compensation Committees have
also agreed to allow our CEO to use the Aircraft for
personal use so long as the incremental cost to
Carnival Corporation & plc does not exceed $200,000
per year. Once that threshold is reached, the CEO
will reimburse us for those costs (subject to applicable
regulatory limitations). The Compensation Committees
determined that the Aircraft usage policy and levels
of usage and costs were consistent with those offered
by large multinational companies like Carnival
Corporation & plc.
In lieu of participation in the Carnival Corporation
Nonqualified Savings Plan under which plans were
discontinued in accordance with Section 457A of the
U.S. Internal Revenue Code, the Compensation
Committees approved a program that provides for
payment of additional annual compensation directly
to these employees in an amount equal to what
would have been deposited on behalf of those
employees into that plan, less, as described below,
any amount Carnival Corporation contributes to the
Carnival Corporation Fun Ship Savings Plan, a 401(k)
plan (the “401(k) Plan”). These payments are taxable
as ordinary income.
Beginning with the 2010 calendar year, the 401(k)
Plan was amended and currently allows Messrs.
Weinstein, Donald (through November 30, 2022)
Bernstein, Burke and Miguez (as well as all other
highly compensated employees) to defer a limited
amount of compensation into the 401(k) Plan subject
to nondiscrimination testing. In fiscal 2022, Carnival
Corporation made matching contributions to the
401(k) Plan under the plan’s formula, subject to
nondiscrimination testing.
The perquisites received by each Named Executive
Officer in fiscal 2022, as well as their incremental cost
to Carnival Corporation & plc, are reported in the
“Summary Compensation Table” and its accompanying
footnotes.
POST-EMPLOYMENT COMPENSATION OBLIGATIONS
Carnival Corporation & plc does not have any change
of control agreements that provide cash severance
to our Named Executive Officers upon a change of
control of Carnival Corporation & plc. Carnival
Corporation & plc does not have employment
agreements with any of our Named Executive Officers
that provide cash severance benefits in connection
with the termination of the executive’s employment,
with the exception of the employment agreement with
Mr. Thamm.
Mr. Burke entered into a Confidentiality Agreement
and Restrictive Covenant that provides he is entitled to
six months base salary as compensation for his
confidentiality and further agreement not to engage
in competition with us for a period of six months. The
Compensation Committees believe that the
consideration provided to Mr. Burke under this
agreement is reasonable.
Mr. Thamm’s employment agreement provides that
he is generally entitled to an amount equal to 50% of
the total remuneration most recently received by
him as compensation for his agreement not to
engage in competition with us for a period of
12 months. The Compensation Committees believe
that the severance benefits provided to Mr. Thamm
under his employment agreement are reasonable and
in accordance with market practice in the European
Union.
Upon termination of employment for certain
circumstances or upon a change of control, our
Named Executive Officers may be entitled to retain
or receive accelerated vesting of equity grants. Under
the terms of the Carnival plc 2014 Employee Share
Plan and the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan,
however, the default provision upon a change in
control would provide only for a “double trigger”
acceleration of equity grants (such that no acceleration
would occur unless the participant’s employment
were subsequently terminated by Carnival
Corporation & plc (or its successor) without cause).
These benefits are provided under the terms of the
plans pursuant to which the equity grants were made,
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
66
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
the grant agreement and the employment agreement
with Mr. Thamm. However, none of our Named
Executive Officers are entitled to receive any tax
gross-up payments in respect of their severance
benefits or accelerated equity grants. The benefits
that our Named Executive Officers may be eligible to
receive in connection with the termination of their
employment or upon a change of control are
described in detail in the “Potential Payments Upon
Termination or Change of Control” section.
The Compensation Committees believe that these
arrangements are reasonable and encourage an
executive to comply with post-termination non-
compete and other restrictive covenants and to
cooperate with us both before and after their
employment is terminated.
PENSIONS AND DEFERRED COMPENSATION PLANS
Carnival Corporation & plc do not operate any defined benefit pension or deferred compensation programs for
the Named Executive Officers.
PROCESS FOR MAKING COMPENSATION DETERMINATIONS
Early Fiscal Year
The Compensation
Committees determine
the compensation policy
and approach for the
fiscal year
Our CEO and the Chair
of the Boards of
Directors recommend
key initiatives and goals
for Carnival Corporation
& plc to the
Compensation
Committees
The Compensation
Committees consult
with the leadership
team and independent
consultants on matters
such as compensation
planning, staffing levels
and retention incentives
with the goals of
supporting employees
and attracting
necessary personnel
The Compensation
Committees meet and
discuss with our CEO,
Chair of the Boards of
Directors and the Chief
Human Resources
Officer
Our CEO, Chair of the
Boards, and the
Compensation
Committees review the
results of progress
towards goals and other
material items relating
to overall Carnival
Corporation & plc
performance
Our CEO reviews: (1)
annual competitive
market analysis
provided by the
independent consultant
(2) individual Named
Executive Officer
performance (3)
performance results of
the group of brands or
company-wide results
and then provides the
Compensation
Committees with
recommended total
target compensation
levels for each Named
Executive Officer,
except for his own
The Compensation
Committees determine
CEO and Named
Executive Officer
compensation by
evaluating their
individual performance
against set performance
objectives in addition to
the overall performance
of Carnival Corporation
& plc
Compensation Approach
Evaluate Program
Final Board Deliberations
Mid-Fiscal Year
Post-Fiscal Year
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
67
ADDITIONAL CONTEXT FOR 2022 DECISIONS
In fiscal 2022, the Compensation Committees
continued to consult with their independent
consultants and executive management on matters
such as compensation planning, staffing levels
and retention incentives with the goals of supporting
employees, attracting necessary personnel and
recognizing the extraordinary efforts of management
and the workforce in navigating the pause and
resumption of guest cruise operations. The
Compensation Committees took into consideration
business needs and the impact of decisions on
employees and shareholders. The Compensation
Committees exercised independent judgment when
consulting with or receiving advice from management,
executive Directors or compensation consultants.
After the fiscal year was completed, our CEO and our
Chair of the Boards of Directors reviewed with the
Compensation Committees the results of those
initiatives, progress towards goals and other material
items relating to overall Carnival Corporation & plc
performance. Our CEO reviewed the annual
competitive market analysis provided by the
independent consultant, as well as individual
performance of each Named Executive Officer and
the results of the group of brands or company-wide
results, as appropriate, and provided the
Compensation Committees with recommended total
target compensation levels for each Named Executive
Officer, except for his own. The compensation for
our Named Executive Officers was then determined
by the Compensation Committees using their
discretion to evaluate the individual performance of
our Named Executive Officers and the overall
performance of Carnival Corporation & plc.
IMPACT OF REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS ON COMPENSATION
In making determinations regarding executive
compensation, the Compensation Committees
consider relevant issues relating to accounting
treatment, tax treatment (both company and
individual) and regulatory requirements. The global
nature of Carnival Corporation & plc’s operations
necessarily means that monitoring these technical
issues and considering their potential impact on the
appropriate design and operation of executive
remuneration programs is an increasingly complex
exercise. Technical issues are evaluated in light of
Carnival Corporation & plc’s philosophy and objectives
for executive compensation and their corporate
governance principles, as described earlier in this
Compensation Discussion and Analysis.
INDEPENDENT COMPENSATION CONSULTANTS
The Compensation Committees have engaged
Frederic W. Cook & Co., Inc. (“FW Cook”) (together
with its UK affiliated firm, FIT Remuneration
Consultants LLP (“FIT”)) to assist in their annual
review of our executive and Director compensation
programs. The Compensation Committees believe that
FW Cook and FIT provided objective advice to the
Compensation Committees. FW Cook and FIT provide
no other services to Carnival Corporation & plc and
have no other connections with Carnival Corporation &
plc or individual Directors.
During fiscal 2022, a consultant from FW Cook
attended meetings of the Compensation Committees
and provided FW Cook’s views on proposed actions
by the Compensation Committees.
In accordance with the New York Stock Exchange
rules relating to compensation consultant
independence, the Compensation Committees have
determined that FW Cook and FIT and their
consultants are independent after taking into
consideration the factors set forth in the New York
Stock Exchange rules. Pursuant to the foregoing
factors, the Compensation Committees have
determined that FW Cook’s and FIT’s work raised no
conflicts of interest.
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
68
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
PEER GROUP CHARACTERISTICS
The Compensation Committees perform an annual
review of the compensation practices of certain other
publicly-listed companies with the assistance of
their consultant. This annual market assessment
consists of an analysis of executive pay at a group of
publicly-listed peer companies.
In April 2019, based on the recommendations of FW
Cook, the Compensation Committees approved a peer
group listed below (the “Peer Group”), which was
used when assessing the fiscal 2022 compensation
for our Named Executive Officers. The Peer Group
consists of 19 publicly-listed companies from diverse
industries that exhibit similar pre-COVID-19
pandemic size and business characteristics with
Carnival Corporation & plc, noting also that not all
members of the Peer Group were impacted by the
COVID-19 pandemic in the same way. At the time the
Peer Group was approved, our revenue ranked at
the 45th percentile and market capitalization ranked
at the 59th percentile of the Peer Group. We operate
in a niche industry with a limited number of other
publicly traded cruise operators. The Peer Group
reflects the market in which we may compete for
business, investor capital and/or executive talent and
is more closely aligned to our business complexity,
breath, scope, median reviews and market
capitalization. The Peer Group reflects a balanced
group of companies in the consumer discretionary
sector, including media, retailing, services and
transportation companies. For these reasons, the
Compensation Committees continue to believe that
this set of companies remains an appropriate
reference group in assessing executive compensation.
Therefore, the Peer Group was not changed in 2022
and was used in assessing fiscal 2023 compensation
for our Named Executive Officers.
PEER GROUP COMPANIES
•
American Airlines Group Inc.
•
Kimberly-Clark Corporation
•
Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings Ltd.
•
Darden Restaurants, Inc.
•
Las Vegas Sands Corp.
•
Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd.
•
Delta Air Lines, Inc.
•
Live Nation Entertainment, Inc.
•
Starbucks Corporation
•
FedEx Corporation
•
Marriott International, Inc.
•
United Continental Holdings, Inc.
•
General Mills, Inc.
•
McDonald’s Corporation
•
United Parcel Service, Inc.
•
Hilton Worldwide Holdings Inc.
•
MGM Resorts International
•
International Consolidated Airlines
Group, S.A.
•
Mondel
ē
z International, Inc.
COMPETITIVE MARKET (PEER GROUP) COMPARISON
Annually, the Compensation Committees’ independent
consultant, FW Cook, conducts a competitive market
review to assist the Compensation Committees in their
assessment of our Named Executive Officers’
competitive positioning of total compensation relative
to the markets in which Carnival Corporation & plc
competes for executive talent. FW Cook conducted a
competitive market assessment on behalf of the
Compensation Committees for fiscal 2022. The
Compensation Committees reviewed our aggregate
Named Executive Officer total compensation in
comparison to the competitive market, which consists
of the Peer Group as well as third-party surveys that
reflect a broad database of hundreds of companies.
The Compensation Committees were not provided
with the identities of the companies in the surveys
generally (or of the subsets of companies which had
data for relevant comparable positions). As applicable,
any utilized survey data was combined with the data
for the Peer Group to produce a consolidated
aggregated competitive market range for total direct
compensation.
These analyses suggest that, in the aggregate, total
direct compensation levels for our Named Executive
Officers are competitively positioned. The
Compensation Committees, as advised by FW Cook,
consider total direct compensation to be generally
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
69
competitive when within a range of 15% above or
below the market median. Actual pay positioning can
vary based on factors including job responsibilities,
experience, impact of role and individual performance.
Consistent with the approach that the Compensation
Committees take in reviewing each element of total
direct compensation, the Compensation Committees
utilize these analyses to assess the extent to which
the compensation provided to our Named Executive
Officers is generally consistent with that offered by
companies with whom Carnival Corporation & plc
competes for executive level talent. The Compensation
Committees do not use these analyses to peg any
particular element of compensation (or total
compensation) to any specific targeted Peer Group
level.
STOCK OWNERSHIP POLICY
Our Boards of Directors and Compensation
Committees believe it is important for Directors and
executive officers to build and maintain a long-term
ownership position in Carnival Corporation or
Carnival plc shares in order to align their financial
interests with those of our shareholders and to
encourage the creation of long-term value. Our
compensation structure provides for a significant
percentage of compensation to be equity-based,
which places a substantial portion of compensation
at risk over a long-term period. Accordingly, our
executive officers, including our Named Executive
Officers who are currently executive officers, are
subject to a stock ownership policy. The policy specifies
target ownership levels of Carnival Corporation or
Carnival plc shares for each executive expressed in
terms of the value of the equity holdings (excluding
unvested performance grants) as a multiple of each
executive officer’s base salary. The target ownership
levels are as follows:
Officers
Ownership Target—Multiple of Base Salary
Compliance Period
Chair and/or CEO
●●●●●●
6x salary
5 years from appointment
or promotion
Vice Chair
●●●●
4x salary
Other Executive Officers
●●●
3x salary
Other than Mr. Miguez, Mr. Burke and Mr. Weinstein
(initially appointed as executive officers in 2021, 2022
and 2022, respectively), all of our executive officers
have achieved this Board-mandated requirement.
Individuals who are newly designated as executive
officers are expected to be in compliance with the
stock ownership policy within five years of the date of
becoming an executive officer. The stock ownership
policy provides that an executive officer will be
deemed to be in compliance with the ownership
requirements if the decline in the Carnival Corporation
or Carnival plc share price results in the executive
officer falling below the applicable ownership level,
provided that they were in compliance prior to the
share price movement and do not sell or transfer
ownership of any such shares until after the ownership
target has again been achieved, unless otherwise
approved by the Boards of Directors.
Carnival Corporation & plc does not make any
commitment to any persons covered by the stock
ownership policy that they will receive any particular
level of equity-based grants. The stock ownership
policy provides that executive officers be required to
retain at least 50% of the shares received upon release
after deducting withholding taxes, until their target
ownership is achieved.
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
70
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
HEDGING POLICY
Because we believe it is improper and inappropriate
for any Board member or employee to engage in
short-term or speculative transactions involving
Carnival Corporation & plc securities, our Securities
Trading Policy provides that they may not engage in
any of the following activities with respect to Carnival
Corporation & plc securities at any time:
•
purchasing of shares of either Carnival Corporation
or Carnival plc on margin;
•
short sales; or
•
buying or selling puts, calls or other derivatives in
respect of Carnival Corporation & plc securities.
Board members and employees may pledge shares,
including as part of a margin account, but they are
warned that sales of such shares could have securities
law implications, including under Section 16 of the
U.S. Securities Act, as well as market disclosure and
other obligations under the UK Market Abuse
Regulation (“MAR”).
Although we discourage speculative hedging
transactions, employees (other than executive
officers) are permitted to engage in long-term
hedging transactions that are designed to protect
their investment in Carnival Corporation and Carnival
plc shares (i.e., the hedge must be for at least one
year and relate to shares or options held by the
individual). Any such transactions must be pre-
cleared by the Legal Department. Because these
activities raise issues under the U.S. federal securities
laws as well as MAR, any person intending to engage
in permitted hedging transactions is strongly urged to
consult his or her own legal counsel.
Our Securities Trading Policy provides additional
restrictions for Directors and executive officers. They
are prohibited from purchasing, selling or writing
any exchange-traded call and put options that have
Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc shares as the
underlying security. In addition, Directors and
executive officers may not engage in any hedging
transaction on Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc
shares that they beneficially own, including, but not
limited to, “forward contracts,” “collars,” “equity swaps”
or “straddles.”
Compensation
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS AND CARNIVAL PLC DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION REPORT (PART I)
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
71
Report of the Compensation Committees
The Compensation Committees have reviewed the
Compensation Discussion and Analysis and discussed
it with the management of Carnival Corporation &
plc. Based on their review and discussions with
management, the Compensation Committees
recommended to our Boards of Directors that the
Compensation Discussion and Analysis be
incorporated by reference into the Carnival
Corporation & plc 2022 joint Annual Report on
Form 10-K and included in the Carnival Corporation &
plc 2023 Proxy Statement. This Report is provided
by the following independent Directors, who comprise
the Compensation Committees:
THE COMPENSATION COMMITTEE OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION
THE COMPENSATION COMMITTEE OF CARNIVAL PLC
LAURA WEIL
RANDALL WEISENBURGER,
Chair
HELEN DEEBLE
RICHARD J.GLASIER
(1)
(1)
Mr. Glasier has decided not to seek re-election and will retire from the Boards with effect from the conclusion of the 2023
Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
Compensation Committee Interlocks and Insider
Participation
During fiscal 2022, the Compensation Committees
were comprised of the four independent Directors
listed above. No member of the Compensation
Committees is a current, or during fiscal 2022 was a
former, officer or employee of Carnival Corporation,
Carnival plc or any of their subsidiaries. During
fiscal 2022, no member of the Compensation
Committees had a relationship that must be described
under the SEC rules relating to disclosure of related
person transactions. In fiscal 2022, none of our
executive officers served on the board of directors or
compensation committee of any entity that had
one or more of its executive officers serving on the
Board or the Compensation Committee of Carnival
Corporation or Carnival plc.
Compensation
REPORT OF THE COMPENSATION COMMITTEES
72
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Compensation Tables
SUMMARY COMPENSATION TABLE
Although Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are
two separate entities, our business is run by a single
senior management team. The following tables,
narrative and footnotes discuss the compensation of
our CEO, our Chief Financial Officer, our three other
most highly compensated executive officers for the
year ended November 30, 2022 and one former
executive officer for whom disclosure would have
been provided pursuant to Item 402 of Regulation S-K
but for the fact that he was not serving as an
executive officer at the end of fiscal 2022, who are
referred to as the Named Executive Officers.
Mr. Thamm’s cash compensation was payable in
euro. These euro amounts have been converted into
U.S. dollars at the average U.S. dollar to euro
exchange rate for fiscal 2022 of $1.06:€1. The value
for Carnival plc ordinary shares has been converted
from sterling into U.S. dollars based on the exchange
rate on the date of grant, being $1.36:£1 on
January 19, 2022.
Name and
Principal Position
Fiscal
Year
Salary
($)
Stock
Awards
(1)
($)
Non-Equity
Incentive Plan
Compensation
($)
All Other
Compensation
(2)
($)
Total
($)
Josh Weinstein
President, CEO and
Chief Climate Officer
(3)
2022
983,333
4,695,000
2,044,644
291,176
8,014,153
David Bernstein
Chief Financial Officer and Chief
Accounting Officer
2022
850,000
0
1,320,000
418,671
2,588,671
2021
750,000
2,129,909
2,000,000
77,298
4,957,207
2020
526,902
3,682,967
0
216,455
4,426,324
William Burke
(3)
Chief Maritime Officer
2022
641,333
0
550,000
93,550
1,284,883
Enrique Miguez
General Counsel
2022
500,000
0
385,000
216,484
1,101,484
2021
437,500
219,991
600,000
106,292
1,363,783
Michael Thamm
Group CEO of Costa Group &
Carnival Asia
2022
911,865
0
1,301,256
109,045
2,322,166
2021
1,023,698
2,981,753
2,656,080
190,238
6,851,769
2020
631,781
4,369,595
0
175,443
5,176,819
Arnold W. Donald
Former President, CEO and
Chief Climate Officer; former
Vice Chair
(4)
2022
1,500,000
5,999,996
3,300,000
344,439
11,144,435
2021
1,500,000
7,449,735
6,000,000
114,053
15,063,788
2020
857,413
12,228,417
0
220,267
13,306,097
(1)
No stock option grants were made in fiscal 2020 through 2022. The amounts included in the “Summary Compensation Table”
reflect the grant date fair value, assuming no risk of forfeiture, of the grants of Carnival Corporation RSUs and Carnival plc RSUs
made to our Named Executive Officers in fiscal 2022, calculated in accordance with ASC 718. The valuation of share-based
grants is discussed in Notes 2 and 13 to the financial statements in the Carnival Corporation & plc joint Annual Report on
Form 10-K for the year ended November 30, 2022. The amounts reflect the grant date fair value of the ERA RSU grant made to
Mr. Donald in February 2022 and the LTPBS grant made to Mr. Weinstein, calculated in accordance with ASC 718. The grant
date fair value of the ERA and PBS grants assuming combined maximum performance (200% of target, respectively) is $8,999,994
for Mr. Donald’s ERA and $9,390,000 for Mr. Weinstein’s LTPBS. For the proceeds received by the Named Executive Officers
upon the vesting of RSUs, see the “Stock Vested for Fiscal 2022” table. No stock awards were granted in fiscal 2022 to Messrs.
Bernstein, Burke, Miguez and Thamm. For earned value of equity grants to be made to our Named Executive Officers in 2023 as
compensation for fiscal 2022 performance, see the “Value of Fiscal 2022 Performance Equity For Our Named Executive
Officers To Be Granted in 2023” table. For the proceeds actually received by the Named Executive Officers upon the vesting of
RSUs, see the “Stock Vested for Fiscal 2022” table.
(2)
See the “All Other Compensation” table for additional information.
(3)
Mr. Weinstein and Mr. Burke are Named Executive Officers for the first time in fiscal 2022.
(4)
Mr. Donald stepped down as our President, CEO and Chief Climate Officer effective August 1, 2022 and as Vice Chair and
member of the Boards of Directors effective November 30, 2022.
Compensation
COMPENSATION TABLES
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
73
VALUE OF FISCAL 2022 PERFORMANCE EQUITY FOR OUR NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICERS
TO BE GRANTED IN 2023
The amounts set forth in the column entitled Stock
Awards in the “Summary Compensation Table” do not
represent the equity-based compensation granted
as compensation for fiscal 2022. As required by SEC
rules and as described in Note 1 to the “Summary
Compensation Table,” the amounts reported in this
column only reflect the grants made during fiscal 2022.
The amounts reported in this column do not include
the values associated with the 2022 MTE and PBS
grants to be made in fiscal 2023 that are described in
the “Disclosure and the Timing of Long-Term
Incentive and Equity-Based Compensation” section of
the Compensation Discussion and Analysis. The
2022 MTE and PBS grants to be made to our Named
Executive Officers in fiscal 2023 as compensation for
fiscal 2022 are as follows:
Name
Fiscal 2022
MTE Value
($)
Fiscal 2022
PBS Value
($)
Josh Weinstein
1,248,726
1,212,110
David Bernstein
935,000
1,870,000
William Burke
192,500
247,500
Enrique Miguez
275,000
110,000
Michael Thamm
542,190
1,301,256
Arnold W. Donald
2,200,000
3,850,000
(1)
The amounts reflect the fiscal 2022 target values multiplied by the final payout percentage of 110% approved by the
Compensation Committees on January 9, 2023. These values will be presented for approval of fiscal 2022 MTE and PBS RSU
grants in fiscal 2023. These values will be converted into a number of MTE and PBS RSUs based on the closing price of our shares
on the date the grants are approved. The grants will vest pro-rata annually in 2024 and 2025. The values for Mr. Thamm have
been converted from euro into U.S. dollars at the average U.S. dollar to euro exchange rate for fiscal 2022 of $1.06: €1.
ALL OTHER COMPENSATION
Each component of the “All Other Compensation” column in the “Summary Compensation Table” for fiscal 2022
is as follows:
Name
Compensation
in lieu of
Savings Plan
Profit Sharing
Contribution
Employer
Contributions
to Defined
Contribution
Plan
($)
Accidental
Death or
Dismemberment
Insurance
Private
Medical/
Health
Insurance
Costs and
Premiums
(1)
($)
Automobile
Lease or
Allowance
($)
Personal Use
of Aircrafts
and Other
Personal Air
Travel
(2)
($)
Driver
and
Security
($)
Tax
Planning
and Return
Preparation
Fees
Other
(3)
($)
Total
($)
Josh Weinstein
192,500
9,305
136
63,203
15,277
—
—
7,525
3,230
291,176
David Bernstein
330,000
10,675
136
57,020
11,400
—
—
7,000
2,440
418,671
William Burke
30,240
10,675
92
39,125
11,400
—
—
0
2,018
93,550
Enrique Miguez
126,231
10,500
136
63,566
10,800
—
—
3,000
2,251
216,484
Michael Thamm
—
—
14,870
14,688
28,409
—
27,777
9,214
14,087
109,045
Arnold W. Donald
150,000
10,675
89
55,224
24,000
70,338
—
32,110
2,003
344,439
(1)
Certain of our Named Executive Officers are eligible to participate in an executive health insurance program, which includes a
fully insured plan and a secondary insured plan. Amounts reported represent the cost of the premiums paid on a Named
Executive Officer’s behalf under these plans plus the additional costs of medical services rendered during the fiscal year.
Named Executive Officers participating in this plan generally have until March 31, 2023 to submit their 2022 claims for
reimbursement, and as a result, these amounts may increase. The maximum amount that may be reimbursed in any year under
the secondary plan is $20,000.
(2)
Represents the aggregate incremental cost to Carnival Corporation & plc for travel on the Aircraft not related to company
business. The aggregate incremental cost for the use of the Aircraft for personal travel is calculated by multiplying the hourly
variable cost rate for the Aircraft used by the hours used. The hourly variable cost rate primarily includes fuel, airport handling
and other fees, Aircraft repairs and maintenance, crew expenses and catering. The hourly variable cost rate is recomputed
Compensation
COMPENSATION TABLES
74
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
annually to reflect changes in costs. Fixed costs which do not change based on usage, such as pilots’ salaries, Aircraft
depreciation and overhead costs, are excluded.
(3)
Includes the total amount of other benefits provided, none of which individually exceeded $25,000 or 10% of the total amount
of benefits for the designated Named Executive Officer. These other benefits include automobile repair and expenses, life
and disability insurance premiums, reimbursement of tax advisor fees and associated gross-up, and personal transportation
and spousal meals.
Additional information with respect to Carnival plc’s
compensation and reimbursement practices during
fiscal 2022 for Non-Executive Directors is included in
Part II of the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report, which is attached as Annex B to this Proxy
Statement.
GRANTS OF PLAN-BASED AWARDS IN FISCAL 2022
Equity grants and non-equity awards made to the Named Executive Officers during fiscal 2022 are as follows:
Grant
Type
Estimated Possible Payouts Under
Non-Equity Incentive Plan Awards
(1)
($)
All Other Stock
Awards: Number of
Shares of Stock or
Units
(2)
(#)
Grant Date Fair
Value of Stock
Awards
(3)
($)
Name
Grant Date
Threshold
Target
Maximum
Josh Weinstein
Annual Bonus
929,384
1,858,767
3,717,534
ERA Cash
2/04/2022
2,500,000
5,000,000
7,500,000
LTPBS
8/22/2022
500,000
4,695,000
David Bernstein
Annual Bonus
600,000
1,200,000
2,400,000
ERA Cash
2/04/2022
2,500,000
5,000,000
7,500,000
William Burke
Annual Bonus
250,000
500,000
1,000,000
ERA Cash
2/04/2022
2,500,000
5,000,000
7,500,000
Enrique Miguez
Annual Bonus
175,000
350,000
700,000
ERA Cash
2/04/2022
1,000,000
2,000,000
3,000,000
Michael Thamm
Annual Bonus
591,480
1,182,960
2,365,920
ERA Cash
2/04/2022
2,500,000
5,000,000
7,500,000
Arnold W. Donald
Annual Bonus
1,500,000
3,000,000
6,000,000
ERA Cash
2/04/2022
3,000,000
6,000,000
9,000,000
ERA RSU
2/4/2022
300,601
5,999,996
(1)
Represents the potential value of the payout of the annual bonuses under the Management Incentive Plan for fiscal 2022
performance and ERA performance cash incentive granted in 2022. The annual bonus awards were made under the MIP and
the ERA performance incentive was granted under the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan for all Named Executive Officers
other than Mr. Thamm, whose ERA performance incentive was granted under the Carnival plc 2014 Employee Share Plan.
The actual amount of a Named Executive Officer’s annual bonus paid in fiscal 2023 for fiscal 2022 performance is shown in the
“Summary Compensation Table” in the “Non-Equity Incentive Plan Compensation” column. For a more detailed description of
the potential payout under each plan, see the description in the “2022 Annual Bonuses” section of the Compensation Discussion
and Analysis.
(2)
Represents the full grant date fair values of the equity grants made in fiscal 2022, which were determined based on the
assumptions set forth in Notes 2 and 13 to the financial statements in the Carnival Corporation & plc joint Annual Report on
Form 10-K for the year ended November 30, 2022 (disregarding estimated forfeitures). The full grant date fair value for a grant
is the amount that Carnival Corporation & plc will expense in their financial statements over the grant’s vesting schedule or
until the retirement eligibility date, if such date is earlier than the vesting date, when vesting is not contingent upon future
performance. The full grant date fair value may not correspond to the actual value that will be realized. The maximum number
of LTPBS units Mr. Weinstein may receive is 1,000,000. The maximum number of ERA units Mr. Donald may receive is 450,901.
Compensation
COMPENSATION TABLES
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
75
NARRATIVE DISCLOSURE TO THE “SUMMARY COMPENSATION TABLE” AND
THE “GRANTS OF PLAN-BASED AWARDS IN FISCAL 2022” TABLE
EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENTS
Only one of our Named Executive Officers,
Mr. Thamm, has an employment agreement.
Mr. Thamm entered into a new agreement in
April 2017 setting forth the contractual and economic
terms of his post as the CEO of Costa Group and
Carnival Asia. Mr. Thamm’s compensation is
determined at the discretion of the Compensation
Committees.
Mr. Donald’s employment agreement is no longer
effective following his resignation.
For more detailed information regarding the
employment agreements, please refer to the
Compensation Discussion and Analysis and the
exhibit index to the Carnival Corporation & plc 2022
joint Annual Report on Form 10-K.
ANNUAL BONUS PLANS
Annual bonuses for our Named Executive Officers
are determined based on the Management Incentive
Plan. For more detailed information regarding this
plan, please refer to the Compensation Discussion
and Analysis and the exhibit index to the Carnival
Corporation & plc 2022 joint Annual Report on
Form 10-K.
EQUITY-BASED COMPENSATION
The Compensation Committees made an ERA RSU
grant to Mr. Donald in February 2022 and a LTPBS
grant to Mr. Weinstein in August 2022.
None of these grants receive dividends or have
voting rights. Each grant is credited with dividend
equivalents equal to the value of cash and stock
dividends, if any, paid on Carnival Corporation
common stock or Carnival plc ordinary shares. The
dividend equivalents, if any, are settled only when
these RSUs are released from restriction.
Please refer to the Compensation Discussion and
Analysis for additional detail on these grants. For
further information regarding forfeiture and
treatment upon termination or change of control,
refer to the “Potential Payments Upon Termination or
Change of Control” section.
Compensation
COMPENSATION TABLES
76
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
OUTSTANDING EQUITY AWARDS AT FISCAL 2022 YEAR-END
Our Named Executive Officers do not hold options
over either Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc shares.
Information with respect to outstanding Carnival
Corporation restricted shares and RSUs granted by
Carnival Corporation & plc to and held by our Named
Executive Officers as of November 30, 2022, except
for Mr. Thamm whose RSUs are related to Carnival plc
ordinary shares, is as follows:
Stock Awards
Name
Number of Shares or
Units of Stock That
Have Not Vested
(#)
Market Value of Shares
or Units of Stock That
Have Not Vested
(1)
($)
Equity Incentive Plan
Awards: Number of
Unearned Shares, Units
or Other Rights That
Have Not Vested
(#)
Equity Incentive Plan
Awards: Market or
Payout Value of
Unearned Shares, Units
or Other Rights That
Have Not Vested
($)
Josh Weinstein
38,954
(2)
386,813
3,597
27,178
(3)
31,100
418,639
(4)
3,000
0
(5)
500,000
4,965,000
(6)
TOTAL
38,954
386,813
537,697
5,410,817
David Bernstein
68,038
(2)
675,617
20,388
154,084
(3)
46,650
627,953
(4)
15,000
0
(5)
TOTAL
68,038
675,617
82,038
782,037
William Burke
18,702
(2)
168,318
5,396
36,954
(3)
12,800
156,159
(4)
4,000
0
(5)
TOTAL
18,702
168,318
22,196
193,113
Enrique Miguez
3,853
(8)
38,260
479
3,615
(3)
7,028
(2)
69,788
TOTAL
10,881
108,048
479
3,615
Michael Thamm
111,364
(2)
956,617
31,144
203,609
(3)
64,700
753,403
(4)
18,000
0
(5)
TOTAL
111,364
113,844
957,012
Arnold W. Donald
237,973
(2)
2,363,072
71,959
543,836
(3)
150,000
2,019,166
(4)
300,601
2,984,968
(7)
50,000
0
(5)
TOTAL
237,973
2,363,072
572,560
5,547,970
(1)
Market value of the stock awards is based on the closing price of Carnival Corporation common stock on November 30, 2022
of$9.93, except for the Carnival plc RSUs granted to Mr. Thamm under the Carnival plc 2014 Employee Share Plan, which are
based on closing price of Carnival plc ordinary shares on November 30, 2022 of £7.16, which has been converted into $8.59 based
on the November 30, 2022 exchange rate of $1.20:£1.
(2)
Restrictions lapse on January 19 in each of 2023 and 2024.
(3)
Market value reflects the final performance payout of 76.11% of target on the February 2020 Annual PBS grant for which the
performance period ended on November 30, 2022. These grants vested based upon the extent to which annual Adjusted
Operating Income, as adjusted for fuel price changes and currency exchange rate impacts for each of the three fiscal years in the
2020-2022 performance cycle, ROIC for 2021-2022 and ESG metrics, exceed specified performance goals. Additional shares
will be provided to take into account dividend reinvestment during the performance period. Restrictions lapse on February 6,
2023.
(4)
Market value reflects the final performance payout of 135.56% of target of the August 2020 Special PBS (“SPBS”) grant for
which the performance period ended on November 30, 2022. These grants vested based upon the extent to which certain ESG
metrics for the three fiscal years in the 2020-2022 performance cycle exceed specified performance goals. Restrictions lapse
on February 6, 2023.
Compensation
COMPENSATION TABLES
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
77
(5)
Market value reflects the final performance payout of 0% of target of the January 2020 SEA grant as at November 30, 2022.
These grants vest based on attaining certain absolute TSR growth goals and may be modified by TSR rank relative to our 2020
Peer Group at the end of a three-year performance period. The maximum relative TSR modification is 150% of the absolute TSR
performance for a combined maximum payout of 4.5 times target. The 2020 SEA grant is also subject to a value cap of 5.5
times the grant date value. Threshold performance was not achieved resulting in no payout.
(6)
Market value is based on target performance assuming 100% payout on the August 2022 LTPBS grant as at November 30,
2022. This grant vests zero to 200% of target based upon the extent to which the LTPBS performance measure exceeds specified
performance goals.
(7)
Market value is based on target performance assuming 100% payout on the February 2022 ERA grant as at November 30,
2022. This grant vests zero to 200% of target based upon the extent to which the ERA performance measures exceeds specified
performance goals.
(8)
Restrictions lapse on January 17, 2023.
STOCK VESTED FOR FISCAL 2022
None of our Named Executive Officers held options
during fiscal 2022. The following table provides
information for our Named Executive Officers on the
number of shares acquired upon the vesting of RSUs
and the value realized, before the payment of any
applicable withholding tax and broker commissions.
Stock Awards
Name
Number of Shares Acquired on Vesting
(#)
Value Realized on Vesting
(1)
($)
Josh Weinstein
38,030
730,681
David Bernstein
62,828
1,221,723
William Burke
18,272
358,283
Enrique Miguez
14,642
282,696
Michael Thamm
96,049
1,739,238
Arnold W. Donald
214,001
3,683,889
(1)
The fair market value of Carnival Corporation common stock realized on vesting has been determined using the average of the
highest and lowest sale prices reported as having occurred on the New York Stock Exchange on the date of vesting. The fair
market value of Carnival plc ordinary shares realized on vesting has been determined using the average of the highest and lowest
sale prices reported as having occurred on the London Stock Exchange on the date of vesting. The value for Carnival plc
ordinary shares has been converted from sterling into U.S. dollars based on the exchange rate on the date of vesting.
PENSION BENEFIT IN FISCAL 2022
None of the Named Executive Officers participate in any defined benefit pension plans sponsored by Carnival
Corporation or Carnival plc.
Compensation
COMPENSATION TABLES
78
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
NONQUALIFIED DEFERRED COMPENSATION IN FISCAL 2022
None of the Named Executive Officers participate in
any non-qualified deferred compensation plans
sponsored by Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc.
Messrs. Weinstein, Donald, Bernstein, Burke and
Miguez and other Carnival Corporation employees
who are deemed highly compensated employees
under IRS regulations are generally eligible to receive
a matching contribution under the 401(k) Plan and
are paid a profit-sharing contribution as additional
cash compensation. The matching contribution is
contributed to the 401(k) Plan by Carnival Corporation
on behalf of these individuals, whereas the profit-
sharing contribution is paid directly to these
individuals as a cash bonus. Employees hired after
January 1, 2020 are not eligible to participate in profit-
sharing.
From January 1, 2021, Carnival Corporation matched
100% of employee deferrals up to 1% of eligible pay
plus 50% of employee deferrals that exceed 1% of
eligible pay but do not exceed 6% of eligible pay.
“Eligible pay” includes regular pay (before any pre-tax
contributions from pay and taxes) and bonus. For
matching and profit-sharing contributions, eligible
pay does not include amounts in excess of the
maximum compensation rate under Internal Revenue
Code Section 401(a)(17).
The profit-sharing contributions are based upon
eligible pay and years of service according to the
following schedule:
Years of Service at
December 31, 2021
Award (% of Eligible Pay)
<2
0%
2-5
1%
6-9
2%
10-13
3%
14-16
5%
17-19
7%
20-22
9%
23-25
12%
≥
26
15%
As of November 30, 2022, Weinstein, Messrs. Donald,
Bernstein, Burke, Miguez had 21, 10, 25, 9, 26 years
of service, respectively. No additional years of service
are counted for purposes of the profit-sharing
contributions after December 31, 2021.
Compensation
COMPENSATION TABLES
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
79
Potential Payments Upon Termination or Change of
Control
Each of our Named Executive Officers may be eligible
to receive certain payments and benefits in
connection with termination of employment under
various circumstances. The potential benefits payable
to our Named Executive Officers in the event of
termination of employment under various scenarios
on November 30, 2022 are described below.
In addition to benefits described below, our Named
Executive Officers will be eligible to receive any
benefits accrued under Carnival Corporation & plc
broad-based employee benefit plans, such as
distributions under life insurance and disability
benefits and accrued vacation pay, in accordance
with those plans and policies. These benefits are
generally available to all employees.
CASH SEVERANCE BENEFITS
It is the policy of the Compensation Committees for
executive officers to have notice periods of not more
than 12 months in duration. The Compensation
Committees may make an exception to this practice
where they believe doing so would be in the best
interests of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc and
their shareholders. The Compensation Committees
will continue to consider the individual circumstances
of each case taking account of best practice in the
UK and the U.S. and the expected cost to Carnival
Corporation & plc of any termination of an executive’s
employment arrangements.
Accordingly, Messrs. Weinstein, Bernstein and Miguez
have no employment agreements and no entitlement
to severance except for possible retention of unvested
restricted share grants depending on the
circumstances of their separation of employment
discussed below.
Mr. Thamm is our only Named Executive Officer with
an employment agreement providing cash severance
and other benefits. Mr. Thamm is eligible to receive
50% of the total remuneration most recently
received by him if his employment is terminated, as
consideration for his non-competition and non-
solicitation obligations. In addition, Mr. Burke is
eligible to receive six months base salary upon
separation from employment for any reason other
than for cause as consideration for his non-
competition and non-solicitation obligations pursuant
to a Confidentiality Agreement and Restrictive
Covenant.
Compensation
POTENTIAL PAYMENTS UPON TERMINATION OR CHANGE OF CONTROL
80
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
ESTIMATED CASH AND BENEFITS PAYMENTS UPON TERMINATION OF
EMPLOYMENT
The following table quantifies the cash compensation
or value of benefits that Messrs. Thamm and Burke
would receive upon termination of employment. None
of the other Named Executive Officers are eligible to
receive cash compensation or benefits upon
termination of employment, other than broad-based
benefits described above. The amounts shown
assume the event that triggered the treatment
occurred on November 30, 2022. The table does not
include amounts they would be entitled to without
regard to the circumstances of termination, such as
earned or accrued compensation.
Name
Benefit
Termination
without
Cause
($)
Voluntary
Termination
(without Good
Reason)
($)
Voluntary
Termination
(with Good
Reason)
($)
Death or
Disability
($)
Change of
Control
($)
William Burke
Non-Competition Compensation
350,000
350,000
350,000
350,000
350,000
TOTAL
350,000
350,000
350,000
350,000
350,000
Michael Thamm
Non-Competition Compensation
(1)
3,770,685
1,885,343
1,885,343
1,885,343
1,885,343
TOTAL
3,770,685
1,885,343
1,885,343
1,885,343
1,885,343
(1)
These amounts would be payable in euro. Mr. Thamm’s potential non-competition compensation has been converted into U.S.
dollars using the average U.S. dollar to euro exchange rate for fiscal 2022 of$1.06:€1.
EQUITY-BASED COMPENSATION
Vesting of RSUs upon termination of a Named
Executive Officer’s employment is dependent upon
the reasons his employment is terminated, the terms
of the respective equity plan and the associated
equity grant agreement. Equity grants made to our
Named Executive Officers are subject to the same
terms as all other participants generally.
CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2011 STOCK PLAN AND CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020
STOCK PLAN
All our Named Executive Officers, except Mr. Thamm,
have received annual equity grants under both the
Carnival Corporation 2011 Stock Plan (“CC 2011”) and
the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan (“CC
2020”). Mr. Thamm has received grants under both
the CC 2011 and Carnival plc 2014 Employee Share
Plan (“Plc 2014”). The following table summarizes the
types of equity grants that are issued to our Named
Executive Officers under each of CC 2011, CC 2020 and
Plc 2014:
Name
LTPBS
PBS
SEA
ERA
SPBS
TBS
Josh Weinstein
CC 2020
CC 2011
CC 2011
CC 2020
CC 2020
David Bernstein
CC 2011
CC 2011
CC 2020
CC 2020
William Burke
CC 2011
CC 2011
CC 2020
CC 2020
Enrique Miguez
CC 2011
CC 2011
CC 2020
Michael Thamm
Plc 2014
CC 2011
Plc 2014
Plc 2014
Arnold W. Donald
CC 2011
CC 2011
CC 2020
CC 2020
CC 2020
The terms of the Carnival Corporation 2011 Stock
Plan and Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan and
the equity grant agreements applicable to participants
generally provide that upon termination for death or
disability, all unvested equity grants will immediately
vest. The SEA grants will also be retained if
Compensation
POTENTIAL PAYMENTS UPON TERMINATION OR CHANGE OF CONTROL
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
81
employment is terminated without cause. The SPBS
grants are forfeited upon termination for any reasons
other than after a change of control. If the Named
Executive Officers’ employment is terminated for any
reason, the TBS and ERA grants will be forfeited.
For the purposes of the agreement, “cause” is defined
as any action or inaction which constitutes fraud,
embezzlement, misappropriation, dishonesty, breach
of trust, a felony or moral turpitude, as determined
by the Boards of Directors.
Upon involuntary termination within 12 months after
a change of control, the restricted period on all
RSUs immediately expires.
Change of control means the occurrence of any of
the following:
•
the acquisition by any individual, entity or group of
beneficial ownership of 50% or more of either:
(A)
the then outstanding shares of common stock
of Carnival Corporation; or
(B)
the combined voting power of the then
outstanding voting securities of Carnival
Corporation and Carnival plc entitled to vote
generally in the election of Directors, except
that this provision does not apply to affiliated
companies or the Arison family;
•
the incumbent Directors cease to constitute at
least a majority of the Boards of Directors;
•
the dissolution or liquidation of Carnival
Corporation;
•
the sale, transfer or other disposition of all or
substantially all of the business or assets of Carnival
Corporation; or
•
the consummation of a reorganization,
recapitalization, merger, consolidation, statutory
share exchange or similar form of corporate
transaction involving Carnival Corporation that
requires the approval of the shareholders, whether
for such transaction or the issuance of securities
in the transaction.
Upon involuntary termination within 12 months after
a change of control, the restricted period on all
RSUs immediately expires. All of the equity grants
made to participants, including our Named Executive
Officers, contain clawback and forfeiture provisions
in the event of a violation of confidentiality or non-
compete provisions (which restrict them from
competing with Carnival Corporation & plc for the
remainder of the grant’s vesting period) or fraud or
conduct contributing to any financial restatements or
irregularities.
CARNIVAL PLC 2014 EMPLOYEE SHARE PLAN
Mr. Thamm is the only Named Executive Officer who
received grants under the Carnival plc 2014
Employee Share Plan. He received PBS, SPBS and TBS
grants under the Carnival plc 2014 Employee Share
Plan. Mr. Thamm receives the same treatment under
the plans as other participants generally. All grants
vest upon termination of employment for death or
disability. Upon retirement, the TBS grant will continue
to vest according to its terms as if the employment
had not been terminated. Retirement is defined as
voluntary termination of an employee being at least
60 years of age with 15 years of service or at least
65 years of age with five years of service. Upon
involuntary termination within 12 months after a
change of control, the restricted period on all RSUs
immediately expires.
Change of control
is defined to mean the occurrence
of any of the following:
•
a person (either alone or together with any person
acting in concert with him) obtaining control of
Carnival plc as a result of a general offer or
otherwise for the whole of the share capital of
Carnival plc (other than those shares which are
already owned by him and/or any person acting in
concert with him);
•
the acquisition by any individual, entity or group of
beneficial ownership of 50% or more of either:
(A)
the then outstanding shares of Carnival plc, or
(B)
the combined voting power of the then
outstanding voting securities of Carnival
plcentitled to vote generally in the election of
Directors, except that this provision does not
apply to affiliated companies or members of
the Arison family;
•
the incumbent Directors cease to constitute at
least a majority of the Boards of Directors;
•
a person becoming bound or entitled to give
notice under Sections 428 to 430F of the Companies
Act to acquire shares;
Compensation
POTENTIAL PAYMENTS UPON TERMINATION OR CHANGE OF CONTROL
82
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
•
a court directing that a meeting of the holders of
shares be convened pursuant to Section 425 of the
Companies Act for the purposes of considering a
scheme of arrangement of Carnival plc or its
amalgamation with any other company or
companies and the scheme of arrangement being
approved by the shareholders’ meeting or
sanctioned by the court;
•
notice being duly given of a resolution for the
voluntary winding-up of Carnival plc;
•
the sale, transfer or other disposition of all or
substantially all of the business or assets of Carnival
plc; or
•
the completion of a reorganization, recapitalization,
merger, consolidation, share exchange or similar
form of corporate transaction involving Carnival plc
that requires the approval of the shareholders,
whether for such transaction or the issuance of
securities in the transaction.
All of the equity grants made to our Named Executive
Officers contain confidentiality and non-compete
provisions that restrict them from competing with
Carnival plc. If they breach either of these provisions,
they will forfeit the right to receive all unvested and
unreleased equity grants.
POTENTIAL VALUE OF EQUITY GRANTS UPON TERMINATION OF
EMPLOYMENT OR CHANGE OF CONTROL
The following table details the value of all outstanding
RSU grants that would have become vested, or that
could have continued to vest, subject to any non-
compete and confidentiality requirement, for
termination of employment or upon a change of
control as of November 30, 2022. The true value of
these equity grants for future vesting periods is subject
to market fluctuations occurring over time.
ESTIMATED POTENTIAL VALUE OF EQUITY GRANTS
(1)(2)
Name
Termination
without Cause
($)
Death or Disability
($)
Retirement
($)
Change of
Control
(3)
($)
Josh Weinstein
29,790
5,417,321
0
5,726,144
David Bernstein
148,950
1,027,020
0
1,490,255
William Burke
39,720
279,013
0
406,117
Enrique Miguez
—
112,805
—
112,805
Michael Thamm
178,740
1,349,800
0
1,941,295
Arnold W. Donald
496,500
3,574,125
0
5,063,625
TOTAL
893,700
11,760,085
0
14,740,241
(1)
The value for RSUs is based on the closing price of Carnival Corporation common stock on November 30, 2022 of $9.93, except
for the Carnival plc RSUs held by Mr. Thamm, which is based on the closing price of Carnival plc ordinary shares on
November 30, 2021 of £7.16, which has been converted into $8.59 based on the November 30, 2022 exchange rate of $1.20:£1.
(2)
The value of the RSUs are reflected using the target number of RSUs granted.
(3)
Termination of employment is required to trigger acceleration upon a change of control.
Compensation
POTENTIAL PAYMENTS UPON TERMINATION OR CHANGE OF CONTROL
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
83
U.S. CEO Pay Ratio
In accordance with SEC rules, we are providing the
ratio of the annual total compensation of our CEO to
the annual total compensation of our median
employee. The 2022 annual total compensation of
our CEO as set forth in the Summary Compensation
Table is $8,014,153, the 2022 annual total
compensation of our median compensated employee
is $14,496, and the ratio of these amounts is 553 to
1. Our median compensated employee population
consists primarily of ship-based employees who work
fewer than twelve months of the year.
Employee
2022 Annual Total
Compensation
($)
Pay Ratio
CEO
8,014,153
553:1
Median employee,
other than our CEO
14,496
This pay ratio is a reasonable estimate calculated in a
manner consistent with SEC rules based on our
global human resources and payroll systems of record
and the methodology described below. Because the
SEC rules for identifying the median compensated
employee and calculating the pay ratio based on that
employee’s annual total compensation allow
companies to adopt a variety of methodologies, to
apply certain exclusions, and to make reasonable
estimates and assumptions that reflect their
compensation practices, the pay ratio reported by
other companies may not be comparable to the pay
ratio reported above, as other companies may have
different employment and compensation practices
and may utilize different methodologies, exclusions,
estimates, and assumptions in calculating their own
pay ratios.
To identify our median employee, we used total cash
compensation for our estimated employee
population of 82,096 as of September 30, 2022. Our
workforce includes a large number of ship-based
employees who typically work six to eleven months
of the year and we did not annualize the pay for our
employees when identifying our median. The number
of employees relative to the prior year is higher
because of an increase in the workforce for both our
shore and ship-based employees as part of our
continued resumption of guest cruise operations.
Also, a larger number of ship-based employees that
returned to service at the end of 2021 were able to
work for a greater portion of 2022 and more
employees returned to service or joined for the first
time in 2022. This resulted in higher median
compensation for fiscal 2022 and a lower ratio as
compared to prior years. Of the employees returning
to service in 2022, we again saw a fair number of
ship-based employees that returned to service shortly
before or during the month of September 2022 for
whom the pay actually received in 2022 is lower than
what is ordinarily seen in a full year.
We then applied a valid statistical sampling
methodology to identify employees who were paid
within a 1% range of the median. From these
employees, we then identified a representative
median employee from this group and calculated
that employee’s annual total compensation in fiscal
2022 consistent with Item 402(c) of Regulation S-K. This
figure includes gratuities directly billed to our guests
but excludes any cash gratuities paid directly to the
employee by guests. It also excludes room and
meals, transportation to and from the ship, and
medical care, which are provided to our ship-based
employees without charge.
Compensation
U.S. CEO PAY RATIO
84
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Audit Matters
PROPOSAL 16
Re-Appointment of Auditors of Carnival
plc and Ratification of Selection of
Auditors of Carnival Corporation
PROPOSAL 17
Authorization to Determine the
Remuneration of Independent
Auditors of Carnival plc
The Audit Committee of the Board of Directors of
Carnival plc has selected the UK firm of
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as Carnival plc’s
independent auditors for the year ending
November 30, 2023. The Audit Committee of the
Board of Directors of Carnival Corporation has selected
the U.S. firm of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as
Carnival Corporation’s independent registered public
accounting firm for the year ending November 30,
2023. In doing so, the Audit Committees confirm that
the selection is free from third party influence and
no restrictive contractual clauses have been imposed
on them. At this time, we are unable to anticipate if
representatives of both the U.S. and UK firms of
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP will be present at the
Annual Meetings of Shareholders. If they attend, they
will have an opportunity to make a statement if
they desire to do so and would be expected to be
available to respond to appropriate questions from
shareholders.
Proposal 16 would re-appoint the UK firm of
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as the independent
auditors of Carnival plc for the fiscal 2023 audit. It is a
requirement of Section 489(2) of the Companies Act
that Carnival plc appoint its independent auditors
before the end of a general meeting at which its
annual accounts and reports are laid (which, in the
case of Carnival plc, occurs this year at its Annual
General Meeting). Proposal 16 would also ratify the
selection of the U.S. firm of PricewaterhouseCoopers
LLP as the independent registered public accounting
firm of Carnival Corporation.
Although ratification by our shareholders of the
appointment of an independent public accounting
firm of Carnival Corporation is not legally required, our
Boards of Directors believe that such action is
desirable. If our shareholders do not approve
Proposal 16, the Audit Committees will consider the
selection of another accounting firm for 2023 .
In accordance with the UK auditor rotation
requirements, PwC will not be eligible to continue as
our auditor after the conclusion of their fiscal 2023
audit. As a result, during fiscal 2022, the Audit
Committees oversaw a competitive tender process to
select a new audit firm for the fiscal 2024 audit.
Following a rigorous selection process, the Boards of
Directors selected Deloitte & Touche LLP as the
independent registered public accounting firm of
Carnival Corporation and Deloitte LLP as the
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
85
independent auditors of Carnival plc for the fiscal
2024 audit, subject to shareholder approval and
ratification at the 2024 Annual Meetings of
Shareholders. Refer to the Carnival plc Corporate
Governance Report (attached as Annex C to this Proxy
Statement) for additional information on the audit
tender, selection and auditor transition for the 2024
audit.
Under Proposal 17, you are being asked to authorize
the Audit Committee of Carnival plc to determine the
remuneration of the UK firm of
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as independent
auditors of Carnival plc.
The Boards of Directors unanimously recommend a vote
FOR
the re-appointment of
the UK firm of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as Carnival plc’s independent auditors for
the 2023 fiscal year, the ratification of the selection of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as
Carnival Corporation’s independent registered public accounting firm for the 2023
fiscal year and the authorization of the Audit Committee of Carnival plc to determine
the remuneration of the UK firm of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP.
Report of the Audit Committees
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc are two separate
legal entities and, therefore, each has a separate
Board of Directors, each of which in turn has its own
Audit Committee. In accordance with their charter,
each Audit Committee assists the relevant Board of
Directors in carrying out its oversight of:
•
the integrity of the relevant financial statements;
•
our compliance with legal and regulatory
requirements (other than health, environmental,
safety and security matters and compliance matters
addressed by the Compliance Committees);
•
the independent auditors’ qualifications and
independence;
•
the performance of Carnival Corporation & plc’s
internal audit functions and independent auditors;
•
risk management related to financial, information
technology (including cybersecurity and data
privacy) and non-HESS related operational risks, as
well as monitoring changes to and compliance
with related legal and regulatory requirements.
Both Audit Committees are subject to the audit
committee independence requirements under the
corporate governance standards of the New York Stock
Exchange and relevant SEC rules, and the Audit
Committee of Carnival plc is also subject to the
requirements of the UK Corporate Governance Code.
The two Audit Committees have identical members
and each currently consists of five independent (as
defined by the listing standards of the New York
Stock Exchange, SEC rules and the UK Corporate
Governance Code) Non-Executive Directors. The
Carnival Corporation Board of Directors has
determined that each member of the Audit
Committees is both “independent” and an “audit
committee financial expert,” as defined by SEC rules
and New York Stock Exchange listing standards. In
addition, the Carnival plc Board of Directors has
determined that each member of the Audit
Committees has “recent and relevant financial
experience” for purposes of the UK Corporate
Governance Code and that the Audit Committees as a
whole have competence relevant to the sector in
which Carnival Corporation & plc operate.
Management has primary responsibility for Carnival
Corporation & plc’s financial reporting process,
including their system of internal control and risk
management, and for the preparation of consolidated
financial statements. Carnival Corporation & plc’s
independent auditor is responsible for performing an
independent audit of those financial statements
and expressing an opinion on the conformity of those
financial statements with U.S. generally accepted
accounting principles. The Audit Committees are
responsible for monitoring and overseeing the
financial reporting process and the preparation of
consolidated financial statements and for supervising
the relationship between Carnival Corporation & plc
Audit Matters
REPORT OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEES
86
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
and its independent auditor, as well as reviewing the
group’s systems of internal controls and compliance
with the group Code of Business Conduct and Ethics.
The Audit Committees have met and held discussions
with management of Carnival Corporation & plc and
the independent auditor. In this context, management
represented to the Audit Committees that Carnival
Corporation & plc’s consolidated financial statements
were prepared in accordance with U.S. generally
accepted accounting principles and that Carnival plc’s
financial statements were prepared in accordance
with UK-adopted international accounting standards
and the company financial statements in accordance
with United Kingdom Generally Accepted Accounting
Practice (United Kingdom Accounting Standards,
comprising FRS 101 “Reduced Disclosure Framework,”
and applicable law). Where necessary, amendments
are made in the Carnival plc financial statements to
take advantage of the exemptions available under
FRS 101 Reduced Disclosure Framework.
The Audit Committees:
•
reviewed and discussed Carnival Corporation &
plc’s audited consolidated financial statements for
the year ended November 30, 2022 with Carnival
Corporation & plc’s management and with Carnival
Corporation & plc’s independent auditor;
•
reviewed and discussed Carnival plc’s audited
consolidated financial statements for the year
ended November 30, 2022 with Carnival plc’s
management and with Carnival plc’s independent
auditor;
•
discussed with Carnival Corporation & plc’s
independent auditor the matters required to be
discussed by the applicable requirements of the
Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, the
SEC and the UK Financial Reporting Council; and
•
received the written disclosures and the letter
from Carnival Corporation & plc’s independent
accountants required by applicable requirements
of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board
regarding the independent accountants’
communications with the Audit Committees
concerning independence and discussed with
Carnival Corporation & plc’s independent auditor
the independent auditors’ independence.
The Audit Committees also considered whether the
provision to the relevant entity by the independent
auditor of non-audit services was compatible with
maintaining the independence of the independent
auditor. Based on the reviews and discussions
described above, the Audit Committees recommended
to the Boards of Directors that the audited
consolidated financial statements of Carnival
Corporation & plc be included in Carnival
Corporation & plc’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for
the year ended November 30, 2022 for filing with the
SEC. In addition, the Audit Committees recommended
that the audited Carnival plc financial statements be
included in the Carnival plc Annual Report for the
year ended November 30, 2022.
THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION
THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF CARNIVAL PLC
(1)
Mr. Glasier has decided not to seek re-election and will retire from the Boards with effect from the conclusion of the 2023 Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
LAURA WEIL
RICHARD J.
GLASIER
(1)
JASON GLEN
CAHILLY
SARA
MATHEW
STUART
SUBOTNICK
Chair
Chair
(until
January 31, 2023)
(effective
February 1, 2023)
Audit Matters
REPORT OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEES
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
87
Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm
AUDIT AND NON-AUDIT FEES
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP were the auditors of
Carnival Corporation & plc during fiscal 2022 and fiscal
2021. Aggregate fees billed by
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP for professional
services rendered to Carnival Corporation & plc for
the years ended November 30, 2022 and 2021 were
as follows (in millions):
Fiscal Year Ended
Type of Fee
2022
($ in millions)
2021
($ in millions)
Audit fees
6.3
6.0
Audit-related fees
0.1
0.3
Tax fees
0.0
0.0
All other fees
0.0
(1)
0.0
(1)
Total
6.4
6.3
(1)
Less than $50,000.
•
AUDIT FEES
for 2022 and 2021 were for professional
services rendered for the integrated audits of the
Carnival Corporation & plc consolidated financial
statements and systems of internal control over
financial reporting, quarterly reviews of our
joint Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q, the audits of
the Carnival plc financial statements, consents,
registration statements, statutory audits of various
international subsidiaries and the issuance of
comfort letters.
•
AUDIT-RELATED FEES
for 2022 were principally for
services rendered for the audit of one of our
sustainability reports. Audit-related fees for 2021
were principally for audit work related to
government grants received.
•
ALL OTHER FEES
for 2022 were principally for
services rendered for UK regulatory reporting. All
other fees for 2021 were principally for agreed upon
procedures related to customs and border
protection data.
All of the services described above were approved by
the Audit Committees (including pre-approval of
services relating to registration statements and
issuance of comfort letters up to a cap), and in doing
so, the Audit Committees did not rely on the
de
minimis
exception set forth in Rule 2-01(c)(7)(i)(C)
under Regulation S-X.
POLICY ON AUDIT COMMITTEE PRE-APPROVAL OF AUDIT AND PERMISSIBLE
NON-AUDIT SERVICES OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING
FIRM
The Audit Committees have adopted Key Policies and
Procedures which address, among other matters,
pre-approval of audit and permissible non-audit
services provided by the independent registered
public accounting firm. The Key Policies and
Procedures require that all services to be provided by
the independent registered public accounting firm
must be approved by the Audit Committees prior to
the performance of such services. The Audit
Committees consider whether the services requested
are consistent with the rules of the SEC and UK
Financial Reporting Council on auditor independence.
Audit Matters
INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM
88
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 18
Receipt of Accounts and Reports of
Carnival plc
The Directors of Carnival plc are required by the
Companies Act to present Carnival plc’s financial
statements, the UK statutory Directors’ Report, the
UK statutory Strategic Report and the auditors’ report
relating to those accounts to the Carnival plc
shareholders. Accordingly, the Directors of Carnival
plc lay before the Annual Meetings of Shareholders
the Carnival plc accounts and the reports of the
Directors and auditors for the year ended
November 30, 2022, which have been approved by
and signed on behalf of Carnival plc’s Board of
Directors and will be delivered to the Registrar of
Companies in the UK following the Annual Meetings
of Shareholders. Shareholders are voting to approve
receipt of these documents, as UK law does not
require shareholder approval of the substance and
content of these documents. The UK statutory
Directors’ Report is attached as Annex A to this Proxy
Statement and the UK statutory Strategic Report
accompanies the Carnival plc financial statements.
The full accounts and reports of Carnival plc will be
available for inspection prior to and during the Annual
Meetings of Shareholders.
The Boards of Directors unanimously recommend a vote
FOR
the receipt of the
accounts and reports of Carnival plc for the year ended November 30, 2022.
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
89
PROPOSAL 19
Approval of the Grant of Authority to
Allot New Carnival plc Shares
PROPOSAL 20
Approval of the Disapplication of
Pre-Emption Rights Applicable to
Carnival plc
SUMMARY
Proposal 19 authorizes the Directors of Carnival plc
to allot, until the end of the next Annual General
Meeting of Carnival plc (or, if earlier, until the close of
business on July 20, 2024), a maximum number of
Carnival plc ordinary shares (or to grant rights to
subscribe for or convert any securities into ordinary
shares up to a maximum aggregate amount) without
further shareholder approval. Proposal 20 empowers
the Directors of Carnival plc to allot (or sell any
ordinary shares which Carnival plc elects to hold in
treasury) a maximum number of Carnival plc ordinary
shares for cash without first offering them to existing
shareholders in accordance with the pre-emption
rights that would otherwise be applicable. If given, this
power will expire at the end of the next Annual
General Meeting of Carnival plc (or, if earlier, the
close of business on July 20, 2024). The authorizations
given at the last Annual General Meeting of Carnival
plc are due to expire at the end of this year’s Annual
General Meeting of Carnival plc. As is the case with
many UK companies, these resolutions are proposed
each year as the Directors believe occasions may
arise from time to time when it would be beneficial
for shares to be allotted without further shareholder
approval and for shares to be allotted for cash
without making a pre-emptive offer. The Carnival plc
Directors have no current commitments or plans to
allot additional shares of Carnival plc using these
authorities.
DISCUSSION
Under Article 30 of the Articles of Association of
Carnival plc, the Directors have, for a “prescribed
period,” unconditional authority to allot ordinary
shares in Carnival plc up to an aggregate nominal
amount known as the “allotment amount.”
The power to implement the authority provided by
Article 30 is sought each year by the proposal of an
ordinary resolution to establish the prescribed period
and the allotment amount. By passing this ordinary
resolution, shareholders are authorizing the Board of
Carnival plc to issue, during the prescribed period, a
maximum number of shares having an aggregate
nominal value equal to the allotment amount, without
further shareholder approval. In the absence of
such approval, the issuance of any additional shares
would require shareholder approval.
Other Proposals
PROPOSALS 19
―
APPROVAL OF THE GRANT OF AUTHORITY TO ALLOT NEW CARNIVAL PLC SHARES
90
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Under Article 31 of the Articles of Association of
Carnival plc, the Directors have, for the same
“prescribed period” referred to above, power to allot
a small number of ordinary shares for cash without
making a pre-emptive offer to existing shareholders,
up to an aggregate nominal amount known as the
“disapplication amount.”
The power to implement the authority provided by
Article 31 is sought each year by the proposal of a
special resolution to establish the disapplication
amount. By passing this special resolution,
shareholders are authorizing the Board of Carnival
plc to issue, during the prescribed period, an amount
of shares having an aggregate nominal value equal
to the disapplication amount, for cash without first
offering them to existing shareholders of Carnival plc.
The Third Amended and Restated Articles of
Incorporation of Carnival Corporation do not contain
equivalent provisions and holders of Carnival
Corporation common stock do not have pre-emption
rights. Accordingly, no action is required in respect
of the ability of Carnival Corporation to allot shares or
to disapply pre-emption rights.
In common with many UK companies, resolutions to
renew the prescribed period and re-establish the
allotment amount and the disapplication amount are
normally proposed each year as the Directors
believe occasions may arise from time to time when
it would be beneficial for shares to be allotted and for
shares to be allotted for cash without making a pre-
emptive offer. This is the purpose of Proposal 19 (an
ordinary resolution) and Proposal 20 (a special
resolution). As usual, the prescribed period is the
period from the passing of the resolutions until the
end of the next Annual General Meeting (or, if earlier,
until the close of business on July 20, 2024).
Guidelines issued by the Investment Association,
whose members are some of the largest institutional
investors in UK listed companies, require the
allotment amount to be limited to one-third of the
issued ordinary share capital (except in the case of a
rights issue). By reference to Carnival plc’s issued
ordinary share capital on January 12, 2023, the
maximum allotment amount in paragraph (a) of
Proposal 19 is $102,995,305, which is equal to
62,045,365 new Carnival plc ordinary shares, being
one-third of the amount of the issued ordinary share
capital (excluding treasury shares).
In line with guidance issued by the Investment
Association, paragraph (b) of Proposal 19 would give
the Directors of Carnival plc authority to allot ordinary
shares or grant rights to subscribe for or convert
any securities into ordinary shares in connection with
a rights issue in favor of ordinary shareholders up
to an aggregate nominal amount equal to
$205,990,610 (representing 124,090,729 ordinary
shares), as reduced by the nominal amount of any
shares issued under paragraph (a) of Proposal 19. This
amount (before any reduction) represents
approximately two-thirds of the issued ordinary
share capital (excluding treasury shares) of Carnival
plc as at January 12, 2023. However, if they do exercise
the authorities given to them if Proposals 19 and 20
are passed, the Directors intend to follow the
Investment Association’s recommendations
concerning their use (including as regards the
Directors standing for election or re-election in certain
cases).
The Pre-Emption Group, a group comprising
representatives of UK listed companies, investment
institutions and corporate finance practitioners and
formed under the support of the London Stock
Exchange, issued a revised Statement of Principles
on Disapplying Pre-Emption Rights in November 2022
(the “Statement of Principles”) to align with the
recommendations made in the UK Secondary Capital
Raising Review. The revised Statement of Principles
recommends that a resolution to disapply the
statutory pre-emption rights provided by UK company
law should be limited to an amount of equity
securities not exceeding 10% of the nominal value of
a company’s issued ordinary share capital (with a
further authority of no more than 2% to be used only
for the purposes of making a follow-on offer to
retail investors and existing shareholders). The
expected features of such follow-on offers are set out
in paragraph 3 of Section 2B of the revised Statement
of Principles.
The powers requested under Proposal 20 reflect the
revised Statement of Principles. Proposal 20, if
approved, will give the Directors of Carnival plc
authority to allot Carnival plc shares and to sell
treasury shares for cash otherwise than to existing
shareholders in proportion to their holdings (i) up to
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 20—APPROVAL OF THE DISAPPLICATION OF PRE-EMPTION RIGHTS APPLICABLE TO CARNIVAL PLC
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
91
a maximum nominal value of $30,898,591,
representing 10% of Carnival plc’s issued ordinary
share capital (excluding treasury shares) on January 12,
2023 and (ii) up to a further 2% to be used for
follow-on offers of a kind contemplated by paragraph
3 of Section 2B of the revised Statement of Principles.
This is equal to 22,336,331 new Carnival plc ordinary
shares. The Directors of Carnival plc will have due
regard to the revised Statement of Principles in
relation to any exercise of this power.
In summary, if Proposals 19 and 20 were passed, the
extent of the authority of the Directors to allot new
Carnival plc ordinary shares for cash (other than
pursuant to an employee share scheme) on terms
which would be dilutive to the existing shareholdings
of Carnival plc shareholders, without shareholder
approval, would be limited to 22,336,331 new Carnival
plc ordinary shares. The Directors have no current
commitments or plans to allot additional shares of
Carnival plc under these authorities. Furthermore, the
adoption of Proposals 19 and 20 would have no
material effect on the ability of Carnival plc to
undertake or defend against a takeover attempt.
We have a program that allows us to obtain an
economic benefit when Carnival Corporation common
stock is trading at a premium to the price of Carnival
plc ordinary shares (the “Stock Swap Program”). In the
event Carnival Corporation common stock trades at
a premium to Carnival plc ordinary shares, we may
elect to sell shares of Carnival Corporation common
stock, at prevailing market prices in ordinary brokers’
transactions and repurchase an equivalent number of
Carnival plc ordinary shares in the UK market. In the
future, we may also re-introduce a program that allows
us to obtain an economic benefit when Carnival plc
ordinary shares are trading at a premium to Carnival
Corporation common shares.
Any realized economic benefit under the Stock Swap
Program is used for general corporate purposes.
In June 2021 the Boards of Directors have authorized
us to sell up to $500 million of Carnival Corporation
common stock in the U.S. market and repurchase up
to $500 million of Carnival plc ordinary shares in the
UK market as part of the Stock Swap Program.
As of January 12, 2023, 31,235,457 Carnival plc
ordinary shares are held by Carnival plc in treasury.
The Boards of Directors unanimously recommend a vote
FOR
the approval of limits on
the authority to allot Carnival plc shares and the disapplication of pre-emption rights
for Carnival plc.
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 20—APPROVAL OF THE DISAPPLICATION OF PRE-EMPTION RIGHTS APPLICABLE TO CARNIVAL PLC
92
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
PROPOSAL 21
Approval of a General Authority to Buy
Back Carnival plc Ordinary Shares
Shareholder approval is not required for us to buy
back shares of Carnival Corporation, but is required
under the Companies Act for us to buy back shares of
Carnival plc. Accordingly, last year Carnival Corporation
and Carnival plc sought and obtained shareholder
approval to effect market purchases of up to
18,500,792 ordinary shares of Carnival plc (being
approximately 10% of Carnival plc’s ordinary shares
in issue (excluding treasury shares)). That approval
expires on the earlier of:
(i)
the conclusion of Carnival plc’s 2023 Annual
General Meeting; or
(ii)
October 7, 2023.
Shareholder approval to effect market purchases
(within the meaning of Section 693(4) of the
Companies Act), once the current authorization
expires, of up to 18,613,610 ordinary shares of
Carnival plc (being 10% of Carnival plc’s ordinary
shares in issue as of January 12, 2023 (excluding
treasury shares)) is being sought at this year’s Annual
Meetings of Shareholders. Since last year’s Annual
Meetings of Shareholders and through January 12,
2023, no Carnival plc ordinary shares have been
purchased under that authority and 8,930,004 Carnival
plc ordinary shares were purchased under the Stock
Swap Program. Carnival Corporation & plc will treat any
such purchases made by Carnival Corporation or
Carnival Investments Limited under the Stock Swap
Programs as if they were made by Carnival plc under
the Carnival plc share buyback authority.
The Boards of Directors confirm that the authority to
purchase Carnival plc’s shares under the Stock
Swap Program will only be exercised after careful
consideration of prevailing market conditions and the
position of Carnival plc. In particular, the program
will only proceed if we believe that it is in the best
interests of Carnival Corporation, Carnival plc and their
shareholders generally. The Boards of Directors are
making no recommendation as to whether
shareholders should sell any shares in Carnival plc
and/or Carnival Corporation.
If the Boards of Directors exercise the authority
conferred by Proposal 21, we would have the option
of holding the shares in treasury, or cancelling them.
Shares held in treasury can be re-sold for cash, used
for employee share plans or later cancelled. The
Boards of Directors think it prudent to maintain
discretion as to dealing with the purchased shares.
The Boards of Directors will assess at the time of any
and each actual purchase whether to hold the
shares in treasury or cancel them, provided it is
permitted to do so. As of January 12, 2023, 31,235,457
Carnival plc ordinary shares are held by Carnival plc
in treasury.
The Boards of Directors consider that any buyback of
Carnival plc ordinary shares may include the
purchase of its American Depositary Shares (“ADSs”),
each representing one Carnival plc ordinary share, with
a subsequent cancellation of the underlying ADSs. If
the underlying ADSs are so cancelled, Carnival plc will
either cancel or hold in treasury the ordinary share
represented by such ADSs. The Boards of Directors
will assess at the time of any and each actual
cancellation whether to hold the ordinary shares
represented by such cancelled ADSs in treasury or
cancel them, provided it is permitted to do so.
The minimum price (exclusive of expenses) which
may be paid for each Carnival plc ordinary share is
$1.66, and the maximum price which may be paid is
an amount (exclusive of expenses) equal to the higher
of:
•
105% of the average middle market quotations for
an ordinary share of Carnival plc, as derived from
the London Stock Exchange Daily Official List, for
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 21—APPROVAL OF A GENERAL AUTHORITY TO BUY BACK CARNIVAL PLC ORDINARY SHARES
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
93
the five business days immediately preceding the
day on which such ordinary share is contracted to
be purchased; and
•
the higher of the price of the last independent
trade and the highest current independent bid on
the London Stock Exchange at the time the purchase
is carried out.
As of January 12, 2023, there are no options
outstanding to subscribe for Carnival plc ordinary
shares and Carnival plc has issued 1,258,013 RSUs,
which represent in the aggregate 0.7% of Carnival plc’s
issued share capital (excluding treasury shares). If
the existing authority and the authority sought under
Proposal 21 were exercised in full and those ordinary
shares of Carnival plc were purchased by Carnival plc
and cancelled, these RSUs would represent in the
aggregate 0.8% of Carnival plc’s issued share capital
(excluding treasury shares).
The authority to purchase Carnival plc ordinary
shares will expire at the conclusion of the Carnival plc
Annual General Meeting in 2024 or on July 20, 2024,
whichever is earlier (except in relation to any
purchases of shares the contract for which was
entered before the expiry of such authority).
The Boards of Directors unanimously recommend a vote
FOR
the approval of a general
authority to buy back Carnival plc ordinary shares.
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 21—APPROVAL OF A GENERAL AUTHORITY TO BUY BACK CARNIVAL PLC ORDINARY SHARES
94
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
PROPOSAL 22
Approval of the Amendment of the
Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan
In order to ensure that Carnival Corporation & plc
may continue to issue equity-based grants with
respect to Carnival Corporation common stock to its
management and Directors, the Boards of Directors
have adopted an amendment of the Carnival
Corporation 2020 Stock Plan (the “Amendment”),
which is attached as Annex D to this Proxy Statement,
subject to shareholder approval at the Annual
Meetings of Shareholders.
Why We are Requesting Approval of the Amendment
In January 2020, our Boards of Directors adopted the
Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan, which was
approved by shareholders in April 2020. Upon
shareholder approval of the Carnival Corporation
2020 Stock Plan, we ceased making equity grants
under the Carnival Corporation 2011 Stock Plan, which
was adopted by shareholders in April 2011. On
January 19, 2021, the Boards of Directors approved
the Amendment to increase the number of shares of
Carnival Corporation available for grants under the
Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan by 10,000,000
shares, which amendment was approved by the
shareholders at the April 2021 Annual Meetings of
the Shareholders.
On January 19, 2023, the Boards of Directors approved
the Amendment, subject to the approval by
shareholders at the 2023 Annual Meetings of
Shareholders, to increase the number of shares of
Carnival Corporation available for grants under the
Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan by 21,650,000
shares.
The following highlights and summary of the material
features of the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan
are qualified in their entirety by reference to the
complete text of the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock
Plan, which was attached as Annex D to the 2020
Notice of Annual Meetings and Proxy Statement and
the Amendment attached as Annex D hereto. The
Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan, as amended in
2021 and as proposed to be amended by the
Amendment, is referred to as the “Amended 2020
Plan.”
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc operate a DLC
arrangement. Each company’s shares are publicly
traded on the New York Stock Exchange for Carnival
Corporation and the London Stock Exchange for
Carnival plc. In April 2014, shareholders approved the
Carnival plc 2014 Employee Share Plan. Proposed
amendments to the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock
Plan will have no impact on the Carnival plc 2014
Employee Share Plan.
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 22—APPROVAL OF THE AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
95
Highlights
What is the Amended
2020 Plan?
•
The Amended 2020 Plan is the primary vehicle used to issue equity-based grants with
respect to Carnival Corporation common stock to the majority of our eligible employees
worldwide and our Directors.
•
Carnival plc 2014 Employee Share Plan is separate and apart from the Carnival
Corporation 2020 Stock Plan. No changes to the Carnival plc 2014 Employee Share Plan
are being requested. We will continue to grant limited equity-based awards out of the
Carnival plc 2014 Employee Share Plan to certain eligible employees of Carnival plc and
its subsidiaries. Most of the Carnival plc 2014 Employee Share Plan participants are
non-U.S. based employees.
Who participates in
the Carnival
Corporation 2020
Stock Plan?
•
The Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan is not limited to executives. It is a broad-
based plan with over 2,000 eligible employees, located in the U.S. and abroad.
•
Incentive compensation delivered through the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan is
an essential tool used by the Compensation Committees to drive our pay-for-
performance philosophy.
•
These incentives influence our ability to attract, retain, reward and motivate our
employees. They also drive the alignment between our employees’ interests and those
of our shareholders.
How many shares
remain in the reserve
in the Carnival
Corporation 2020
Stock Plan?
•
At the time of approval of the first amendment to Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan
by our Boards in January 2021, 10,000,000 shares were proposed for shareholder
approval, which was granted in April 2021. At that time, we expected that the number of
shares would be sufficient to last over four years based on our historical share usage
and other information, such as our stock price.
•
We could not anticipate the continued material negative impact that the global
COVID-19 pandemic would have on our operations, financial results and liquidity well
into fiscal 2021 and the ongoing impact that global economic events would have on our
share price.
•
Equity grants are approved as values that are converted to units based on then current
share price. Continued share price volatility has an impact on the number of shares
needed to make annual grants to our employees.
•
As of November 30, 2022, there are 12,363,312 shares that remain available for future
grants under the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan.
How many shares are
being requested to be
added to the Carnival
Corporation 2020
Stock Plan?
•
We are seeking shareholder approval for an additional 21,650,000 shares, which
increase represents approximately 1.94% of Carnival Corporation’s outstanding
common stock as of November 30, 2022.
•
We estimate this will allow us to continue to make responsible and market competitive
equity-based grants over the next four years.
•
The estimated reserve life is based on a number of factors that are subject to change.
We cannot make assurances that our estimates may not change because of the
extended impact of COVID-19, economic impacts, market price volatility or other factors
beyond management’s control, and as a consequence, our ability to be predictive is
uncertain.
•
We have a history of responsible share usage. We thoughtfully manage share dilution
and closely monitor our annual run rate and overhang to ensure we only make an
appropriate number of equity-based grants we believe are necessary to attract, reward,
motivate and retain employees and Non-Executive Directors.
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 22—APPROVAL OF THE AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
96
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
What other material
changes are being
proposed?
•
Other than the authorization of an additional 21,650,000 shares, there are no other
changes being proposed to the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan.
What key features are
being retained in the
Amended 2020 Plan?
•
The Amended 2020 Plan will continue to retain key governance features and market
best practices that serve to protect shareholder interests, such as:
◦
No Evergreen Provision.
There is no automatic increase in the shares available for
grant in the Amended 2020 Plan.
◦
No Stock Option Repricing.
The Amended 2020 Plan prohibits stock option repricing,
and the cash buyout of underwater stock options, in the absence of shareholder
approval, except in connection with certain corporate transactions involving Carnival
Corporation &plc.
◦
No liberal share recycling of stock options or stock appreciation rights.
◦
No Excise Tax Gross-Up.
The Amended 2020 Plan does not provide for any tax
gross-ups.
◦
No Single-Trigger Equity Vesting.
The Amended 2020 Plan does not provide for an
automatic vesting of equity grants upon a change in control.
◦
Clawback.
The Amended 2020 Plan provides that participants may be required to
surrender shares received, and/or repay any profits or any economic value made or
realized by the participant if the participant violates certain agreements or engages in
detrimental activity as defined under Amended 2020 Plan.
What happens if
shareholders do not
approve the
Amendment?
•
If shareholders do not approve the Amendment, we will continue to make equity-based
grants from the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan as it is critical to our
compensation philosophy and to incentivize the achievement of our strategic business
objectives.
•
In the event there are insufficient shares available remaining under the Carnival
Corporation 2020 Stock Plan to provide equity-based compensation, we may be
required to consider using alternative forms of compensation such as cash. The use of
cash in place of compensation that would typically be delivered in the form of equity-
based grants could have an adverse impact on our recruitment and retention efforts.
The Boards of Directors recommend a vote for the
approval of the Amendment because they believe the
plan is in the best interests of Carnival Corporation &
plc and their shareholders.
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 22—APPROVAL OF THE AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
97
Securities Authorized for Issuance under Equity Compensation Plans
Set forth below is a table that summarizes
compensation plans, including individual
compensation arrangements under which Carnival
Corporation equity securities are authorized for
issuance as of November 30, 2022.
Plan Category
Number of securities to be
issued upon exercise of
warrants and rights
(in millions)
(a)
Weighted-average exercise
price of outstanding
warrants and rights
Number of securities
remaining available for future
issuance under equity
compensation plans
(excluding securities
reflected in column (a))
(in millions)
Equity compensation plans
approved by security holders
4.9
(1)
0
13.7
(2)
Equity compensation plans not
approved by security holders
0
N/A
N/A
4.9
0
13.7
(1)
Represents 4.9 million of restricted share units outstanding under the Carnival Corporation 2011 Stock Plan and 2020 Stock Plan.
(2)
Includes Carnival Corporation common stock available for issuance as of November 30, 2022 as follows: 1.3 million under the
Carnival Corporation Employee Stock Purchase Plan, which includes 255,546 shares subject to purchase during the current
purchase period and the shares noted in footnote (1) above and 12.4 million under the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan.
Summary of the Features of the Amended 2020 Plan
Administration.
Our Compensation Committees will
administer the Amended 2020 Plan. The
Compensation Committees will have the authority to
determine the terms and conditions of any
agreements evidencing any grants made under the
Amended 2020 Plan and to adopt, alter and repeal
rules, guidelines and practices relating to the Amended
2020 Plan. The Compensation Committees will have
full discretion to administer and interpret Amended
the 2020 Plan and to adopt such rules, regulations
and procedures as it deems necessary or advisable
and to determine, among other things, the time or
times at which the grants may be exercised and
whether and under what circumstances a grant may
be exercised.
Eligibility.
Any employees, Directors, officers or
consultants (and prospective employees, Directors,
officers or consultants) of Carnival Corporation & plc
or of its subsidiaries or their respective affiliates will
be eligible for grants under the Amended 2020 Plan.
The Compensation Committees have the sole and
complete authority to determine who will be issued
an equity grant under the Amended 2020 Plan. As of
November 30, 2022, approximately 2,000 employees
and eleven Non-Executive Directors were eligible to
participate in the Amended 2020 Plan.
Number of shares authorized.
The Amended 2020 Plan
provides for an aggregate of 46,650,000 shares of
Carnival Corporation common stock to be available
for grants under the Amended 2020 Plan and the Sub
Plans. No more than 1,000,000 shares of Carnival
Corporation common stock may be issued to any
participant during any single year with respect to
incentive stock options under the Amended 2020
Plan. No participant may be issued grants of options
and SARs with respect to more than 3,000,000 shares
of Carnival Corporation common stock in any one
year. No more than 1,000,000 shares of Carnival
Corporation common stock may be delivered under
the Amended 2020 Plan to any participant in respect
of each performance year in a performance
compensation grant. Shares of Carnival Corporation
common stock subject to grants are generally
unavailable for future grant. If there is any change in
our corporate capitalization, the Compensation
Committees in their sole discretion may make
substitutions or adjustments to the number of shares
reserved for issuance under the Amended 2020
Plan, the number of shares covered by grants then
outstanding under the Carnival Corporation 2020
Stock Plan, the limitations on grants under the
Amended 2020 Plan, the exercise price of outstanding
options and such other equitable substitution or
adjustments as it may determine appropriate.
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 22—APPROVAL OF THE AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
98
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Change in capitalization.
If there is a change in
Carnival Corporation & plc’s corporate capitalization
in the event of a stock or extraordinary cash dividend,
recapitalization, stock split, reverse stock split,
reorganization, merger, consolidation, split up, split-
off, spin-off, consolidation or other relevant change in
capitalization or applicable law or circumstances,
including an unpairing of Carnival Corporation and
Carnival plc (that is, an unpairing of the share of
common stock from the trust share of beneficial
interest in the P&O Princess Special Voting Trust that
is currently paired with a share of Carnival
Corporation common stock), such that the
Compensation Committees determine that an
adjustment is necessary or appropriate, then the
Compensation Committees can make adjustments in
a manner that they deem equitable, including,
without limitation,
•
adjusting the number of shares or other securities
of Carnival Corporation (or number and kind of
other securities or other property) which may be
delivered in respect of grants or with respect to
which grants may be made under the Amended
2020 Plan, or the terms of any outstanding grant
(including the number of shares or other securities
of Carnival Corporation (or number and kind of
other securities or other property) subject to
outstanding grants or to which outstanding grants
relate, the exercise price with respect to any
grant or any applicable performance measures;
•
providing for a substitution or assumption of
grants (or grants of an acquiring company),
accelerating the exercisability of, lapse of
restrictions on, or termination of, grants or
providing for a period of time (which shall not be
required to be more than ten (10) days) for
participants to exercise outstanding grants prior to
the occurrence of such event (and any such grant
not so exercised shall terminate upon the
occurrence of such event); and
•
cancelling any one or more outstanding grants and
causing to be paid to the holders thereof, in cash,
shares, other securities or other property, or any
combination thereof, the value of such grants, if
any, as determined by the Compensation
Committees (which if applicable may be based
upon the price per share received or to be received
by other shareholders of Carnival Corporation in
such event), including without limitation, in the case
of an outstanding option or SAR, a cash payment
in an amount equal to the excess, if any, of the fair
market value (as of a date specified by the
Compensation Committees) of the shares subject
to such option or SAR over the aggregate exercise
price of such option or SAR, respectively (it being
understood that, in such event, any option or SAR
having a per share exercise price equal to, or in
excess of, the fair market value of a share subject
thereto may be canceled and terminated without
any payment or consideration therefor).
Grants available for issuance.
The Compensation
Committees may issue grants of non-qualified stock
options, incentive (qualified) stock options, SARs,
restricted stock grants, restricted stock units, stock
bonus grants, performance compensation grants
(including cash bonus grants) or any combination of
the foregoing. Grants may be made under the
Amended 2020 Plan in assumption of, or in
substitution for, outstanding grants previously made
by an entity acquired by Carnival Corporation & plc
or with which Carnival Corporation & plc combines
(“Substitute Grants”).
Stock options.
The Compensation Committees will be
authorized to grant options to purchase shares of
Carnival Corporation common stock that are either
“qualified,” meaning they are intended to satisfy the
requirements of Section 422 of the Code for incentive
stock options, or “non-qualified,” meaning they are
not intended to satisfy the requirements of Section 422
of the Code. All options granted under the Amended
2020 Plan shall be non-qualified unless the applicable
grant agreement expressly states that the option is
intended to be an “incentive stock option.” Options
granted under the Amended 2020 Plan will be subject
to the terms and conditions established by the
Compensation Committees. Under the terms of the
Amended 2020 Plan, the exercise price of the options
will not be less than the fair market value of Carnival
Corporation common stock at the time of grant (except
with respect to Substitute Grants). Options granted
under the Amended 2020 Plan will be subject to such
terms, including the exercise price and the conditions
and timing of exercise, as may be determined by the
Compensation Committees and specified in the
applicable grant agreement. The maximum term of
an option granted under the Amended 2020 Plan will
be ten years from the date of grant (or five years in
the case of a qualified option granted to a 10%
shareholder); provided, that, if the term of a
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 22—APPROVAL OF THE AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
99
non-qualified option would expire at a time when
trading in the shares of Carnival Corporation common
stock is prohibited by Carnival Corporation & plc’s
insider trading policy, the option’s term shall be
automatically extended until the 30th day following
the expiration of such prohibition. Payment in respect
of the exercise of an option may be made in cash,
by check, by cash equivalent and/or shares of Carnival
Corporation common stock valued at the fair market
value at the time the option is exercised (provided that
such shares are not subject to any pledge or other
security interest) or by such other method as the
Compensation Committees may permit in their sole
discretion, including:
•
by withholding or surrender of the minimum
number of shares of Carnival Corporation common
stock otherwise deliverable in respect of an
option that are needed to pay the exercise price
and all applicable required withholding taxes;
if there is a public market for the shares of Carnival
Corporation common stock at such time, by
means of a broker-assisted cashless exercise
mechanism; or
•
by means of a “net exercise” procedure effected by
withholding the minimum number of shares
otherwise deliverable in respect of an option that
are needed to pay the exercise price and all
applicable required withholding taxes.
Stock appreciation rights (“SARs”).
The Compensation
Committees will be authorized to grant SARs under the
Amended 2020 Plan. SARs will be subject to the
terms and conditions established by the
Compensation Committees. A SAR is a contractual
right that allows a participant to receive, either in the
form of cash, shares or any combination of cash
and shares, the appreciation, if any, in the value of a
share over a certain period of time. An option granted
under the Amended 2020 Plan may include SARs
and SARs may also be granted to a participant
independent of the grant of an option. SARs granted
in connection with an option shall be subject to terms
similar to the option corresponding to such SARs.
Except as otherwise provided by the Compensation
Committees (in the case of Substitute Grants or SARs
granted in tandem with previously granted options),
the strike price per share of Carnival Corporation
common stock for each SAR shall not be less than
100% of the fair market value of such share,
determined as of the date of grant. The remaining
terms of the SARs shall be subject to terms established
by the Compensation Committees and reflected in
the grant agreement.
Effect of termination of employment or service on
options and SARs.
Unless otherwise provided by the
Compensation Committees, in the event:
•
the participant’s employment or service with
Carnival Corporation & plc is terminated without
“cause” or by the participant for any reason other
than “retirement,” each option and SAR to the extent
then vested shall remain exercisable for up to
three months after the date of such termination;
provided, however, that any such participant who is
subsequently rehired or reengaged by Carnival
Corporation & plc within three months following
such termination and prior to the expiration of the
option or SAR shall not be considered to have
undergone a termination;
•
the participant’s employment or service with
Carnival Corporation is terminated on account of
death or “disability,” or the participant dies following
a termination described in the bullet point above
but prior to the expiration of an option or SAR, the
option or SAR shall to the extent then vested shall
remain exercisable for up to one year after the
date of death or termination on account of
Disability, as applicable;
•
the participant’s employment or service with
Carnival Corporation & plc is terminated for “cause,”
the option or SAR shall expire immediately upon
such cessation of employment or service;
•
the participant retires, the option and SAR will
continue to vest and remain exercisable through
the expiration of its original full term; and
•
a participant who is a member of the Boards
ceases to be a member of the Boards due to death
or Disability, all unvested options and SARs shall
immediately vest and become exercisable and all
vested options and SARs (including after giving effect
to such accelerated vesting) shall continue to be
exercisable for up to one year from such cessation,
provided, however, that upon a participant’s
ceasing to be a member of the Boards for any
reason other than death or Disability, all unvested
options and SARs shall continue to vest in
accordance with their initial terms, and all vested
options and SARs shall continue to be exercisable
until the original expiration date of such option or
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 22—APPROVAL OF THE AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
100
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
SAR; and provided, further, that if the participant
ceases to be a member of the Boards prior to
serving in such capacity for one year, all of such
participant’s options shall immediately expire upon
such termination.
In addition, if a participant’s employment is terminated
due to disability at a time when he or she also
meets the requirements for retirement, the participant
will receive the better of the disability or retirement
treatment for the participant’s options and SARs.
Restricted stock.
The Compensation Committees will
be authorized to grant restricted stock under the
Amended 2020 Plan. Grants of restricted stock will be
subject to the terms and conditions established by
the Compensation Committees. Restricted stock
is Carnival Corporation common stock that generally
is non-transferable and is subject to other restrictions
determined by the Compensation Committees for a
specified period. A holder of restricted stock will
generally have the rights of a shareholder, including
without limitation, the right to vote the shares. At the
discretion of the Compensation Committees,
dividends paid on restricted stock may be either
currently paid or accumulated (and interest may be
credited on cash dividends at a rate determined by the
Compensation Committees), and any accumulated
dividends will be distributable to the participant at the
same time as the original underlying shares of
restricted stock are delivered. A member of the
Boards of Directors who ceases to be a member of
the Boards of Directors prior to the first anniversary
of his or her initial election to the Boards will forfeit
any shares of restricted stock that were granted
upon such initial election to the Boards.
Restricted stock units.
The Compensation Committees
will be authorized to grant restricted stock units under
the Amended 2020 Plan. Restricted stock units will
be subject to the terms and conditions established by
the Compensation Committees. Unless the
Compensation Committees determine otherwise, or
specify otherwise in a grant agreement, if the
participant terminates employment or services
during the period of time over which all or a portion
of the units are to be earned, then any unvested units
will be forfeited. At the election of the Compensation
Committees, the participant will receive a number
of shares of Carnival Corporation common stock equal
to the number of units earned or an amount in cash
equal to the fair market value of that number of shares
at the expiration of the period over which the units
are to be earned or at a later date selected by the
Compensation Committees. To the extent provided in
a grant agreement, the holder of outstanding
restricted stock units shall be entitled to be credited
with dividend equivalent payments upon the payment
by Carnival Corporation & plc of dividends on shares
of Carnival Corporation common stock, either in cash
or (at the sole discretion of the Compensation
Committees) in shares of Carnival Corporation
common stock having a fair market value equal to
the amount of such dividends, and interest may, at the
sole discretion of the Compensation Committees, be
credited on the amount of cash dividend equivalents
at a rate and subject to such terms as determined
by the Compensation Committees, which accumulated
dividend equivalents (and interest thereon, if
applicable) shall be payable at the same time as the
underlying restricted stock units are settled. A member
of the Boards of Directors who ceases to be a
member of the Boards of Directors prior to the first
anniversary of his or her initial election to the Boards
will forfeit any restricted stock units that were
granted upon such initial election to the Boards.
Other stock-based grants.
The Compensation
Committees will be authorized to make grants of
unrestricted shares of Carnival Corporation common
stock, rights to receive grants at a future date, the
grant of securities convertible into shares of Carnival
Corporation common stock, or other grants
denominated in shares of Carnival Corporation
common stock under such terms and conditions as
the Compensation Committees may determine and as
set forth in the applicable grant agreement.
Performance compensation grants.
The Performance
Criteria (as defined in the Amended 2020 Plan) that
will be used to establish the Performance Goal(s) (as
defined in the Amended 2020 Plan) may be based
on the attainment of specific levels of performance
of Carnival Corporation & plc (and/or in respect of
Carnival Corporation, Carnival plc or one or more
cruise brands or reporting units, administrative
departments, or any combination of the foregoing)
and may include any of the following (including any
combination thereof):
•
income before taxes or net income (calculated with
or without asset impairments and/or gains or
losses on sale of ships or other assets);
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 22—APPROVAL OF THE AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
101
•
basic or fully diluted earnings per share (calculated
with or without asset impairments and/or gains
or losses on sale of ships or other assets);
•
net revenue, net revenue yield or the growth of
either in current or constant dollars;
•
net passenger revenue, net passenger revenue
yield or the growth of either in current or constant
dollars;
•
net ticket revenue, net ticket revenue yield or the
growth of either in current or constant dollars;
•
net onboard revenue, net onboard revenue yield
or the growth of either in current or constant dollars;
•
net other revenue, net other revenue yield or the
growth of either in current or constant dollars;
•
net cruise costs excluding fuel, net cruise costs
excluding fuel per ALBD, or the change of either in
current or constant dollars (calculated with or
without asset impairments and/or gains or losses
on sale of ships or other assets);
•
operating income, operating income per ALBD or
the growth of either in current or constant dollars
and/or at constant fuel prices (calculated with or
without asset impairments and/or gains or losses
on sale of ships or other assets);
•
fuel consumption, fuel consumption in tons per
ALBD (x 1,000) or the change of either or any other
metric of fuel efficiency;
•
occupancy percentage;
•
return measures (including, but not limited to,
returns on investment, assets, or equity) calculated
with or without asset impairments, gains and/or
losses on sale of ships or other assets, construction-
in-progress, goodwill and/or intangibles;
•
cash flow measures (including, but not limited to,
cash provided by operating activities, free cash flow,
and cash flow return on capital), which may, but
are not required to be, measured on a per share or
per ALBD basis, in current or constant dollars
and/or at constant fuel prices (calculated with or
without asset impairments and/or gains or losses
on sale of ships or other assets);
•
earnings before or after taxes, interest, depreciation
and/or amortization (including EBIT and EBITDA)
which may, but are not required to be, measured on
a per share or per ALBD basis, in current or
constant dollars and/or at constant fuel prices
(calculated with or without asset impairments
and/or gains or losses on sale of ships or other
assets);
•
share price (including, but not limited to, growth
measures and total shareholder return);
•
expense targets or cost reduction goals and
general and administrative expense savings;
•
measures of economic value added or other ‘value
creation’ metrics;
•
inventory control;
•
enterprise value;
•
employee recruitment and retention;
•
timely introduction of new ships or facilities;
•
objective measures of personal targets, goals or
completion of projects (including, but not limited to,
succession and hiring projects, completion of
specific acquisitions, reorganizations or other
corporate transactions or capital-raising
transactions, expansions of specific business
operations and meeting cruise brand, reporting
unit or project budgets);
•
cost of capital, debt leverage, cash and liquidity
positions or book value;
•
health, environmental, safety, security or other
enterprise risk management initiatives;
•
strategic objectives; or
•
such other performance criteria selected by the
Compensation Committees.
Any of the above Performance Goal elements can be
stated as a percentage of another Performance
Goal or used on a relative or absolute basis to measure
the performance of Carnival Corporation & plc
and/or its affiliates or any divisions, operation, or
business units, brands, business segment,
administrative departments or combination thereof,
as the Compensation Committees deem appropriate.
Performance Goals may be compared to the
performance of a group of comparable companies or
a published or special index that the Compensation
Committees deem appropriate or, stock market
indices. The Compensation Committees also may
provide for accelerated vesting of any grant based on
the achievement of Performance Goals.
Change in control.
Except to the extent a particular
grant agreement otherwise provides:
•
in the event a participant’s employment or service
is terminated by Carnival Corporation & plc without
“cause” (and other than due to death or disability)
on or within 12 months following a change in
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 22—APPROVAL OF THE AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
102
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
control, then notwithstanding any provision of the
Amended 2020 Plan to the contrary, all options and
SARs shall become immediately exercisable, and
the restrictions on restricted stock and restricted
stock units and any other grants will immediately
lapse (including a waiver of any applicable
performance goals); and
•
in the event of a change in control, the
Compensation Committees may in their discretion
and upon at least 10 days’ advance notice to the
affected persons, cancel any outstanding grants
and pay to the holders thereof, in cash or stock, or
any combination thereof, the value of such
grants based upon the price per share received or
to be received by other shareholders of Carnival
Corporation in the event.
Transferability.
Each grant may be exercised during
the participant’s lifetime only by the participant or, if
permissible under applicable law, by the participant’s
guardian or legal representative and may not be
otherwise transferred or encumbered by a participant
other than by will or by the laws of descent and
distribution, unless otherwise permitted by the
Compensation Committees in the case of grants
other than incentive stock options.
Amendment.
The Amended 2020 Plan will have a term
of ten years. The Boards of Directors may amend,
suspend or terminate the Amended 2020 Plan at any
time; however, shareholder approval to amend the
Amended 2020 Plan may be necessary if the law or
New York Stock Exchange rules so require. Under the
UK Listing Rules, the prior approval of Carnival plc’s
shareholders in general meeting must be obtained in
the case of any amendment to the advantage of
participants which is made to the provisions of the
Amended 2020 Plan relating to eligibility, limits,
variations of capital and the basis for determining
participants’ entitlement to shares. However, minor
amendments to benefit the administration of the
Amended 2020 Plan or to take account of a change in
legislation or to obtain or maintain favorable tax,
exchange control or regulatory treatment for
participants or for any member of the Carnival
Corporation & plc group of companies, may be made
without the prior approval of Carnival plc in general
meeting. No amendment, suspension or termination
will impair the rights of any participant or recipient
of any grant without the consent of the participant or
recipient.
The Compensation Committees may, to the extent
consistent with the terms of any applicable grant
agreement, waive any conditions or rights under,
amend any terms of, or alter, suspend, discontinue,
cancel or terminate, any grant theretofore made or
the associated grant agreement, prospectively or
retroactively; provided that any such waiver,
amendment, alteration, suspension, discontinuance,
cancellation or termination that would materially and
adversely affect the rights of any participant or any
holder or beneficiary of any option theretofore
granted shall not to that extent be effective without
the consent of the affected participant, holder or
beneficiary; and provided further that, without
shareholder approval:
•
no amendment or modification may reduce the
option price of any option or the strike price of any
SAR;
•
the Compensation Committees may not cancel any
outstanding option and replace it with a new
option (with a lower option price) or cancel any SAR
and replace it with a new SAR (with a lower strike
price); and
•
no option or SAR may be exchanged for cash or
another grant.
However, shareholder approval is not required with
respect to the bullet points above for any action
specifically permitted as described in “Changes in
Capital Structure and Similar Events” above. In
addition, none of the requirements described in the
preceding bullets points can be amended without
shareholder approval.
U.S. Federal Income Tax Consequences
The following is a general summary of the material
U.S. federal income tax consequences of the grant and
exercise and vesting of grants under the Amended
2020 Plan and the disposition of shares acquired
pursuant to the exercise or settlement of such grants
and is intended to reflect the current provisions of
the Code and the regulations thereunder. This
summary is not intended to be a complete statement
of applicable law, nor does it address foreign, state,
local and payroll tax considerations. Moreover, the U.S.
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 22—APPROVAL OF THE AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
103
federal income tax consequences to any particular
participant may differ from those described herein by
reason of, among other things, the particular
circumstances of such participant. References below
to the effect of certain provisions of the Code on
Carnival Corporation & plc’s ability to deduct
compensation would be applicable only to the extent
that Carnival Corporation & plc were otherwise
subject to U.S. federal income tax and any such
deductions were relevant.
Stock options.
The Code requires that, for treatment
of an option as an incentive stock option, shares of
Carnival Corporation common stock acquired through
the exercise of an incentive stock option cannot be
disposed of before the later of:
•
two years from the date of grant of the option; or
•
one year from the date of exercise.
Holders of incentive stock options will generally incur
no federal income tax liability at the time of grant or
upon exercise of those options. However, the spread
at exercise will be an “item of tax preference,” which
may give rise to “alternative minimum tax” liability for
the taxable year in which the exercise occurs. If the
holder does not dispose of the shares before two years
following the date of grant and one year following
the date of exercise, the difference between the
exercise price and the amount realized upon
disposition of the shares will constitute long-term
capital gain or loss, as the case may be. Assuming both
holding periods are satisfied, no deduction will be
allowed to us for federal income tax purposes in
connection with the grant or exercise of the incentive
stock option. If, within two years following the date
of grant or within one year following the date of
exercise, the holder of shares acquired through the
exercise of an incentive stock option disposes of those
shares, the participant will generally realize taxable
compensation at the time of such disposition equal to
the difference between the exercise price and the
lesser of the fair market value of the share on the date
of exercise or the amount realized on the subsequent
disposition of the shares, and that amount will
generally be deductible by us for federal income tax
purposes, subject to the possible limitations on
deductibility under Sections 280G and 162(m) of the
Code for compensation paid to executives designated
in those Sections. Finally, if an incentive stock option
becomes first exercisable in any one year for shares
having an aggregate value in excess of $100,000
(based on the grant date value), the portion of the
incentive stock option in respect of those excess
shares will be treated as a non-qualified stock option
for federal income tax purposes. No income will be
realized by a participant upon grant of an option that
does not qualify as an incentive stock option (“a
non-qualified stock option”). Upon the exercise of a
non-qualified stock option, the participant will
recognize ordinary compensation income in an
amount equal to the excess, if any, of the fair market
value of the underlying exercised shares over the
option exercise price paid at the time of exercise.
Carnival Corporation & plc will be able to deduct this
same amount for U.S. federal income tax purposes, but
such deduction may be limited under Sections 280G
and 162(m) of the Code for compensation paid to
certain executives designated in those Sections.
SARs.
No income will be realized by a participant upon
grant of a SAR. Upon the exercise of a SAR, the
participant will recognize ordinary compensation
income in an amount equal to the fair market value
of the payment received in respect of the SAR. Carnival
Corporation & plc will be able to deduct this same
amount for U.S. federal income tax purposes, but such
deduction may be limited under Sections 280G and
162(m) of the Code for compensation paid to certain
executives designated in those Sections.
Restricted stock.
A participant will not be subject to tax
upon the issuance of a grant of restricted stock
unless the participant otherwise elects to be taxed at
the time of grant pursuant to Section 83(b) of the
Code. On the date a grant of restricted stock becomes
transferable or is no longer subject to a substantial
risk of forfeiture, the participant will have taxable
compensation equal to the difference between the
fair market value of the shares on that date over the
amount the participant paid for such shares, if any,
unless the participant made an election under
Section 83(b) of the Code to be taxed at the time of
grant. If the participant made an election under
Section 83(b), the participant will have taxable
compensation at the time of grant equal to the
difference between the fair market value of the shares
on the date of grant over the amount the participant
paid for such shares, if any. (Special rules apply to
the receipt and disposition of restricted shares
received by officers and Directors who are subject to
Section 16(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of
1934, as amended). Carnival Corporation & plc will be
able to deduct, at the same time as it is recognized
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 22—APPROVAL OF THE AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
104
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
by the participant, the amount of taxable
compensation to the participant for U.S. federal
income tax purposes, but such deduction may be
limited under Sections 280G and 162(m) of the Code
for compensation paid to certain executives
designated in those Sections.
Restricted stock units.
A participant will not be subject
to tax upon the grant of a restricted stock unit. Rather,
upon the delivery of shares or cash pursuant to a
restricted stock unit, the participant will have taxable
compensation equal to the fair market value of the
number of shares (or the amount of cash) the
participant actually receives with respect to the grant.
Carnival Corporation & plc will be able to deduct the
amount of taxable compensation to the participant for
U.S. federal income tax purposes, but the deduction
may be limited under Sections 280G and 162(m) of the
Code for compensation paid to certain executives
designated in those Sections.
Section 162(m).
In general, Section 162(m) of the Code
denies a publicly held corporation a deduction for
U.S. federal income tax purposes for compensation in
excess of $1,000,000 per year per person to any
“covered employees” (in general, the CEO, the Chief
Financial Officer, and three other most highly-
compensated executive officers for the year at issue
and any person who was part of that group for any
other year beginning after December 31, 2016). To
the extent that Section 162(m) were to become
applicable to Carnival Corporation & plc, certain
compensation attributable to grants may be
nondeductible due to the application of Section 162(m)
of the Code.
Continuing Plan Benefits
No stock options have been granted under the
Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan. The following
table sets forth summary information as of
November 30, 2022 concerning the number of
unvested restricted stock and restricted stock unit
grants previously made under the Carnival Corporation
2020 Stock Plan to each of our Named Executive
Officers, all executive officers as a group, all non-
employee Directors as a group and all employees
other than executive officers as a group.
Group
Unvested Stock
Awards (#)
Named Executive Officers
1,607,518
All executive officers, as a group
1,607,518
All Non-Executive Directors, as a group
310,169
All employees other than executive officers, as a group
3,203,900
On January 12, 2023, the last reported price of Carnival Corporation common stock on the New York Stock
Exchange was $10.28.
The Boards of Directors unanimously recommend a vote
FOR
the approval of the
Amendment of the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan.
Other Proposals
PROPOSAL 22—APPROVAL OF THE AMENDMENT OF THE CARNIVAL CORPORATION 2020 STOCK PLAN
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
105
Questions and Answers
Questions Applicable to All Shareholders
WHAT INFORMATION IS CONTAINED IN THESE MATERIALS?
The information included in this Proxy Statement
relates to the proposals to be voted on at the Annual
Meetings of Shareholders, the voting process, the
compensation of Directors and certain executive
officers and certain other information required by
rules promulgated by the SEC and the New York Stock
Exchange applicable to both companies. We have
attached as Annexes A, B and C to this Proxy Statement
information that Carnival plc is required to provide
to its shareholders under applicable UK rules. The
Amendment of the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock
Plan is attached as Annex D.
WHAT PROPOSALS WILL BE VOTED ON AT EACH OF THE ANNUAL MEETINGS OF
SHAREHOLDERS?
PROPOSAL 1–11
PROPOSAL 17
To elect or re-elect 11 Directors, each to serve as a
Director of Carnival Corporation and as a Director of
Carnival plc
To authorize the Audit Committee of Carnival plc to
determine the remuneration of the independent
auditors of Carnival plc
PROPOSAL 12
PROPOSAL 18
To hold a (non-binding) advisory vote to approve
executive compensation
To receive the accounts and reports of the Directors
and auditors of Carnival plc for the fiscal year ending
November 30, 2022
PROPOSAL 13
PROPOSAL 19
To hold a (non-binding) advisory vote on how
frequently shareholders should vote to approve
compensation of the Named Executive Officers
To approve the giving of authority for the allotment
of new shares by Carnival plc
PROPOSAL 14
PROPOSAL 20
To hold a (non-binding) advisory vote to approve the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (other
than the part containing the Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Policy set out in Section B of Part II of
the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report)
To approve the disapplication of pre-emption rights
in relation to the allotment of new shares and sale of
treasury shares by Carnival plc
PROPOSAL 15
PROPOSAL 21
To approve the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Policy set out in Section B of Part II of the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Report.
To approve a general authority for Carnival plc to
buy back Carnival plc ordinary shares in the open
market
PROPOSAL 16
PROPOSAL 22
To re-appoint the UK firm of PricewaterhouseCoopers
LLP as independent auditors of Carnival plc and to
ratify the selection of the U.S. firm of
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as the independent
auditors of Carnival Corporation
To approve the Amendment of the Carnival
Corporation 2020 Stock Plan
106
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
WHAT IS THE VOTING RECOMMENDATION OF THE BOARDS OF DIRECTORS?
Your Boards of Directors recommend that you vote your shares
FOR
Proposals 1 through 12
and 14 through 22 and that you vote your shares for “1
YEAR
” on Proposal 13.
HOW DOES THE DLC ARRANGEMENT AFFECT MY VOTING RIGHTS?
On most matters that affect all of the shareholders of
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc, the
shareholders of both companies effectively vote
together as a single decision-making body. These
matters are called “joint electorate actions.” Combined
voting is accomplished through the special voting
shares that have been issued by each company.
Certain matters specified in the organizational
documents of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc
where the interests of the two shareholder bodies
may diverge are called “class rights actions.” The class
rights actions are voted on separately by the
shareholders of each company. If either group of
shareholders does not approve a class rights action,
that action generally cannot be taken by either
company. All of the proposals to be voted on at the
Annual Meetings of Shareholders are joint electorate
actions, and there are no class rights actions.
GENERALLY, WHAT ACTIONS ARE JOINT ELECTORATE ACTIONS?
Any resolution to approve an action other than a
class rights action or a procedural resolution
(described below) is designated as a joint electorate
action. The actions designated as joint electorate
actions include:
•
the appointment, removal, election or re-election
of any Director of either or both companies;
•
if required by law, the receipt or adoption of the
annual accounts of both companies;
•
the appointment or removal of the independent
auditors of either company;
•
a change of name by either or both companies;
and
•
the implementation of a mandatory exchange of
Carnival plc ordinary shares for Carnival Corporation
common stock based on a change in tax laws,
rules or regulations.
The relative voting rights of Carnival plc ordinary
shares and Carnival Corporation common stock are
equalized based on a ratio which we refer to as the
“equalization ratio.” Based on the current equalization
ratio of 1:1, each share of Carnival Corporation
common stock has the same voting rights as one
Carnival plc ordinary share on joint electorate actions.
HOW ARE JOINT ELECTORATE ACTIONS VOTED ON?
Joint electorate actions are voted on as follows:
•
Carnival plc shareholders vote at the Annual
General Meeting of Carnival plc (whether in person
or by proxy). Voting is on a poll (or ballot), which
remains open for sufficient time to allow the vote
at the Carnival Corporation Annual Meeting of
Shareholders to be held and reflected in the Carnival
plc Annual General Meeting through the mechanism
of the special voting share. An equivalent vote is
cast at the subsequent Carnival Corporation Annual
Meeting of Shareholders on each of the
corresponding resolutions through a special voting
share issued by Carnival Corporation; and
•
Carnival Corporation shareholders vote at the
Carnival Corporation Annual Meeting of
Shareholders (whether in person or by proxy).
Voting is by ballot (or on a poll), which remains open
for sufficient time to allow the vote at the Annual
General Meeting of Carnival plc Shareholders to be
reflected in the Annual Meeting of Carnival
Questions and Answers
QUESTIONS APPLICABLE TO ALL SHAREHOLDERS
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
107
Corporation Shareholders through the mechanism
of the special voting share. An equivalent vote is
cast on the corresponding resolutions at the
Carnival plc Annual General Meeting through a
special voting share issued by Carnival plc.
A joint electorate action is approved if it is approved
by:
•
a simple majority of the votes cast in the case of an
ordinary resolution (or not less than 75% of the
votes cast in the case of a special resolution, if
required by applicable law and regulations or
Carnival plc’s Articles of Association) by the holders
of Carnival plc’s ordinary shares and the holder
of the Carnival plc special voting share voting as a
single class at a meeting at which a quorum was
present and acting;
•
a simple majority of the votes cast (or other
majority if required by applicable law and
regulations or the Carnival Corporation Articles of
Incorporation and By-laws) by the holders of
Carnival Corporation common stock and the holder
of the Carnival Corporation special voting share,
voting as a single class at a meeting which a quorum
was present and acting; and
•
a minimum of one-third of the total votes available
to be voted by the combined shareholders must
be cast on each resolution for it to be effective.
Formal abstentions (or votes withheld) by a
shareholder on a resolution will be counted as
having been “cast” for this purpose.
HOW ARE THE DIRECTORS OF EACH COMPANY ELECTED OR RE-ELECTED?
Resolutions relating to the election or re-election of
Directors are considered as joint electorate actions.
No person may be a member of the Board of Directors
of Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc without also
being a member of the Board of Directors of the other
company. There are 11 nominees for re-election to
the Board of Directors of each company this year.
Each nominee currently serves as a Director of Carnival
Corporation and Carnival plc. All nominees for
Director are to be re-elected to serve until the next
Annual Meetings of Shareholders or until their
successors are elected.
Carnival plc’s Articles of Association currently require
Directors to submit themselves for election by
shareholders at the first Annual General Meeting
following their initial appointment to the Board of
Directors and for re-election thereafter at subsequent
Annual General Meetings at intervals of no more
than three years. The Boards of Directors have
decided, in accordance with the UK Corporate
Governance Code, to submit all Directors for re-
election on an annual basis.
WHAT VOTES ARE REQUIRED TO APPROVE THE PROPOSALS?
Proposals
Vote Required
•
Proposals 1 through 19 and
Proposal 22 will be proposed as
ordinary resolutions
.
For ordinary resolutions, the
required majority is more than 50% of the
combined votes cast
at this meeting and the Annual Meeting of Carnival
Corporation Shareholders.
•
Proposals 20 and 21 will be
proposed as
special resolutions
.
For special resolutions, the
required majority is not less than 75% of the
combined votes cast
at this meeting and the Annual Meeting Carnival
Corporation Shareholders.
Proposals 20 and 21 are required to be approved by
not less than 75% of the combined votes cast at both
Annual Meetings of Shareholders. With respect to
Proposal 13 (the “say-on-frequency” vote),
shareholders will be deemed to have approved the
alternative that receives the most votes, even if that
alternative receives less than a majority of the votes
cast at both Annual Meetings of Shareholders. Each of
the other proposals, including the re-election of
Directors, requires the approval of a majority of the
combined votes cast at both Annual Meetings of
Shareholders. Abstentions and broker non-votes are
Questions and Answers
QUESTIONS APPLICABLE TO ALL SHAREHOLDERS
108
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
not deemed votes cast for purposes of calculating
the vote. Abstentions and broker non-votes do count
for the purpose of determining whether a quorum
is present.
If you are a beneficial owner of Carnival Corporation
common stock and do not provide the shareholder of
record with voting instructions, your shares may
constitute broker non-votes.
Generally, broker non-votes occur when shares held
by a broker for a beneficial owner are not voted with
respect to a particular proposal because:
•
the broker has not received voting instructions
from the beneficial owner; and
•
the broker lacks discretionary voting power to vote
such shares.
Accordingly, if you are a beneficial owner of shares
held through intermediaries such as brokers, banks
and other nominees, such intermediaries are not
permitted to vote without specific instructions from
you unless the matter to be voted on is considered
“routine.” The determination of whether a proposal
is “routine” or “non-routine” will be made by the NYSE
or by Broadridge Financial Solutions, our independent
agent to receive and tabulate stockholder votes,
based on NYSE rules that regulate member brokerage
firms. If a proposal is deemed “routine” and you do
not give instructions to your broker or nominee, they
may, but are not required to, vote your shares with
respect to the proposal. If the proposal is deemed
“non-routine” and you do not give instructions to your
broker or nominee, they may not vote your shares
with respect to the proposal and the shares will be
treated as broker non-votes.
GENERALLY, WHAT ARE PROCEDURAL RESOLUTIONS?
Procedural resolutions are resolutions of a procedural
or technical nature that do not adversely affect the
shareholders of the other company in any material
respect and are put to the shareholders at a meeting.
The special voting shares do not represent any
votes on “procedural resolutions.” Our Chair of each
of the meetings will determine whether a resolution is
a procedural resolution.
To the extent that such matters require the approval
of the shareholders of either company, any of the
following will be procedural resolutions:
•
that certain people be allowed to attend or be
excluded from attending the meeting;
•
that discussion be closed and the question put to
the vote (provided no amendments have been
raised);
•
that the question under discussion not be put to
the vote (where a shareholder feels the original
motion should not be put to the meeting at all, if
such original motion was brought during the course
of that meeting);
•
to proceed with matters in an order other than
that set out in the notice of the meeting;
•
to adjourn the debate (for example, to a subsequent
meeting); and
•
to adjourn the meeting.
WHERE CAN I FIND THE VOTING RESULTS OF THE ANNUAL MEETINGS OF
SHAREHOLDERS?
The voting results will be announced to the media
and the relevant stock exchanges and posted on our
website at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
, after both Annual Meetings of
Shareholders have closed. The results will also be
published in a joint current report on Form 8-K within
four business days after the date the Annual
Meetings of Shareholders have closed.
Questions and Answers
QUESTIONS APPLICABLE TO ALL SHAREHOLDERS
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
109
WHAT IS THE QUORUM REQUIREMENT FOR THE ANNUAL MEETINGS OF
SHAREHOLDERS?
The quorum requirement for holding the Annual
Meetings of Shareholders and transacting business
as joint electorate actions at the meetings is one-third
of the total votes capable of being cast by all
shareholders of both companies. Shareholders may
be present in person or represented by proxy or
corporate representative at the meetings.
HOW IS THE QUORUM DETERMINED?
For the purposes of determining a quorum with
respect to joint electorate actions, the special voting
shares have the maximum number of votes attached
to them as were cast on such joint electorate actions,
either for, against or abstained, at the parallel
shareholder meeting of the other company, and such
maximum number of votes (including abstentions)
constitutes shares entitled to vote and present for the
purposes of determining whether a quorum exists
at such a meeting.
In order for a quorum to be validly constituted with
respect to meetings of shareholders convened to
consider a joint electorate action or class rights action,
the special voting entities must be present.
Abstentions (including votes withheld) and broker
non-votes are counted as present for the purpose of
determining the presence of a quorum.
IS MY VOTE CONFIDENTIAL?
Proxy instructions, ballots and voting tabulations that
identify individual shareholders are handled in a
manner that protects your voting privacy. Your vote
will not be disclosed to third parties except:
•
as necessary to meet applicable legal requirements;
•
to allow for the tabulation of votes and certification
of the vote; or
•
to facilitate a successful proxy solicitation by our
Boards of Directors.
Occasionally, shareholders provide written comments
on their proxy card which are then forwarded to
management.
WHO WILL BEAR THE COST OF SOLICITING VOTES FOR THE ANNUAL MEETINGS
OF SHAREHOLDERS?
We are providing these proxy materials in connection
with the solicitation by the Boards of Directors of
proxies to be voted at the Annual Meetings of
Shareholders. We will pay the entire cost of preparing,
assembling, printing, mailing and distributing these
proxy materials and soliciting votes for the Annual
Meetings of Shareholders. We will also reimburse
brokerage houses and other custodians, nominees
and fiduciaries for their reasonable out-of-pocket
expenses for forwarding proxy materials to
shareholders.
Questions and Answers
QUESTIONS APPLICABLE TO ALL SHAREHOLDERS
110
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
CAN I VIEW THE PROXY MATERIALS ELECTRONICALLY?
Yes. This Proxy Statement and any other proxy
materials have been posted on our website at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
.
Carnival Corporation shareholders can also access
proxy-related materials at
www.proxyvote.com
as
described under “Questions Specific to Shareholders
of Carnival Corporation.”
WHAT REPORTS ARE FILED BY CARNIVAL CORPORATION AND CARNIVAL PLC
WITH THE SEC AND THE FCA AND HOW CAN I OBTAIN COPIES?
We file this Proxy Statement, joint Annual Reports on
Form 10-K, joint Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q
and joint Current Reports on Form 8-K with the SEC.
Copies of this Proxy Statement, the Carnival
Corporation & plc joint Annual Report on Form
10-K for the year ended November 30, 2022, as well
as any joint Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q or
joint Current Reports on Form 8-K, as filed with the
SEC, can be viewed or obtained without charge
through the SEC’s website at
www.sec.gov
(under
Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc) or at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
.
We also file the Carnival plc Annual Report as
well as the Carnival plc Group Half-Yearly Financial
Report on the National Storage Mechanism
maintained by the FCA in the UK. They can also be
viewed or obtained without charge on our
website at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
.
COPIES WILL ALSO BE PROVIDED TO SHAREHOLDERS WITHOUT CHARGE UPON WRITTEN REQUEST TO
INVESTOR RELATIONS:
Carnival Corporation
Carnival Place
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue
Miami, Florida 33178-2428
United States
or
Carnival plc
Carnival House
100 Harbour Parade
Southampton SO15 1ST
United Kingdom
We encourage you to take advantage of the convenience of accessing these materials through the internet as it:
•
is simple and fast to use
•
saves time and money
•
is environmentally friendly
MAY I PROPOSE ACTIONS FOR CONSIDERATION AT NEXT YEAR’S ANNUAL
MEETINGS OF SHAREHOLDERS?
Carnival Corporation shareholders and Carnival plc
shareholders (to the extent permitted under Carnival
Corporation’s and Carnival plc’s governing documents
and U.S. and UK law, as applicable) may submit
proposals for consideration at future shareholder
meetings.
In order for shareholder proposals to be considered
for inclusion in our Proxy Statement in accordance
with SEC Rule 14a-8 for next year’s Annual Meetings
of Shareholders, the written proposals must be
received by our Company Secretary no later than the
close of business October 31, 2023. Such proposals
will need to comply with applicable SEC regulations
regarding the inclusion of shareholder proposals in
proxy materials. Carnival Corporation’s By-laws
establish advance notice procedures with regard to
shareholder proposals that are not submitted for
inclusion in the Proxy Statement, but that
shareholders instead wish to present directly at an
Annual Meeting of Shareholders. To be properly
brought before the Annual Meetings of Shareholders,
a notice of the proposal must be submitted to our
Company Secretary at our headquarters no later than
six weeks prior to the Annual Meetings of
Shareholders or, if later, the time at which the notice
of such meeting is publicly disclosed. For shareholders
of Carnival plc, the same requirements apply under
UK law requirements to submit a notice of a proposal.
Questions and Answers
QUESTIONS APPLICABLE TO ALL SHAREHOLDERS
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
111
MAY I NOMINATE INDIVIDUALS TO SERVE AS DIRECTORS?
In order to submit a nominee for election at the
Annual Meetings of Shareholders you must provide
the information required for Director nominations set
forth in Carnival Corporation’s and Carnival plc’s
governing documents in a timely manner. Specifically,
under the governing documents, you must submit
your notice of nomination in writing to the attention
of our Company Secretary at our headquarters not
later than seven days nor earlier than 42 days prior to
the 2023 Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
Any such notice must include, in addition to any
other requirements specifically set forth in Carnival
Corporation’s and Carnival plc’s governing documents:
•
the name and address of the candidate;
•
a brief biographical description, including his or
her occupation and service on boards of any public
company or registered investment company for
at least the last five years;
•
a statement of the particular experience,
qualifications, attributes or skills of the candidate,
taking into account the factors referred to in the
“Nominations of Directors” section; and
•
the candidate’s signed consent to serve as a
Director if elected, and to be named in our Proxy
Statement.
In addition to satisfying the deadlines in the advance
notice provisions of our governing documents, a
shareholder who intends to solicit proxies in support
of nominees submitted under these advance notice
provisions must provide the notice required under
Rule 14a-19 to the Company Secretary no later than
February 21, 2024.
Shareholders may also recommend candidates for
consideration by our Boards’ Nominating &
Governance Committees in accordance with the
procedures set forth in the “Procedures Regarding
Director Candidates Recommended by Shareholders”
section.
Questions and Answers
QUESTIONS APPLICABLE TO ALL SHAREHOLDERS
112
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Questions Specific to Shareholders of Carnival Corporation
WHAT CARNIVAL CORPORATION SHARES OWNED BY ME CAN BE VOTED?
All Carnival Corporation shares owned by you as of
February 21, 2023, the record date, may be voted by
you. These shares include those:
•
held directly in your name as the shareholder of
record, including shares purchased through Carnival
Corporation’s Dividend Reinvestment Plan and its
Employee Stock Purchase Plan; and
•
held for you as the beneficial owner through a
stockbroker, bank or other nominee.
WILL I BE ASKED TO VOTE AT THE CARNIVAL PLC ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING?
No. Your vote at the Annual Meeting of Carnival
Corporation Shareholders, for the purposes of
determining the outcome of combined voting, is
automatically reflected as appropriate at the parallel
Annual General Meeting of Carnival plc Shareholders
through the mechanism of the special voting share
issued by Carnival plc.
WHY DID I RECEIVE A ONE-PAGE NOTICE IN THE MAIL REGARDING THE
INTERNET AVAILABILITY OF PROXY MATERIALS INSTEAD OF A FULL SET OF
PROXY MATERIALS?
Carnival Corporation is taking advantage of SEC rules
that allow it to deliver proxy materials over the
Internet. Under these rules, Carnival Corporation is
sending its shareholders a one-page notice regarding
the Internet availability of proxy materials (the
“Notice of Internet Availability of Proxy Materials”)
instead of a full set of proxy materials, unless they
previously requested to receive printed copies. You
will not receive printed copies of the proxy materials
unless you specifically request them. Instead, this
notice tells you how to access and review on the
Internet all the important information contained in
the proxy materials. This notice also tells you how to
submit your proxy card on the Internet and how to
request to receive a printed copy of the proxy
materials.
WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN HOLDING SHARES AS A SHAREHOLDER OF
RECORD AND AS A BENEFICIAL OWNER?
Most of the shareholders of Carnival Corporation
hold their shares through a stockbroker, bank or other
nominee rather than directly in their own name. As
summarized below, there are some distinctions
between shares held of record and those owned
beneficially.
Questions and Answers
QUESTIONS SPECIFIC TO SHAREHOLDERS OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
113
SHAREHOLDER OF RECORD
BENEFICIAL OWNER
•
If your shares are registered directly in your
name with Carnival Corporation’s transfer
agent, Computershare Investor Services LLC,
you are considered, with respect to those
shares, the shareholder of record, and the
Notice of Internet Availability of Proxy
Materials or set of printed proxy materials, as
applicable, is being sent directly to you by us.
•
As the shareholder of record, you have the
right to grant your voting proxy directly to the
persons named in the proxy or to vote in
person at the Annual Meeting of Carnival
Corporation Shareholders.
•
If you request a paper copy of the proxy
materials as indicated in the notice, Carnival
Corporation will provide a proxy card for you
to use.
•
If your shares are held in a stock brokerage account or by a
bank or other nominee, you are considered the beneficial
owner of shares held under street name, and the Notice of
Internet Availability of Proxy Materials or set of printed proxy
materials, as applicable, is being forwarded to you by your
broker or nominee who is considered, with respect to those
shares, the shareholder of record.
•
As the beneficial owner, you have the right to direct your
broker on how to vote and are also invited to attend the
Annual Meeting of Carnival Corporation Shareholders.
•
However, since you are not the shareholder of record, you
may not vote these shares in person at the meeting unless
you obtain a signed proxy from the record holder giving you
the right to vote the shares.
•
If you request a paper copy of the proxy materials as
indicated in the notice, your broker or nominee will provide a
voting instruction card for you to use.
HOW CAN I VOTE MY CARNIVAL CORPORATION SHARES IN PERSON AT THE
MEETING?
Shares held directly in your name as the shareholder
of record may be voted in person at the Annual
Meeting of Carnival Corporation Shareholders in the
U.S. If you choose to do so, please bring your proxy
card and proof of identification.
Even if you plan to attend the Annual Meeting of
Carnival Corporation Shareholders, we recommend
that you also submit your proxy as described below so
that your vote will be counted if you later decide not
to attend the meeting. Shares held under street name
may be voted in person by you only if you obtain a
signed proxy from the record holder giving you the
right to vote the shares. Please refer to the voting
instructions provided by your broker or nominee.
Please also refer to the sections entitled “Meeting
Admission Requirements” and “Safety and Security
Measures” included in the “Information about
Attending the Annual Meetings” section preceding
the Notice of Annual Meeting for additional
information.
HOW CAN I VOTE MY CARNIVAL CORPORATION SHARES WITHOUT ATTENDING
THE ANNUAL MEETING OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION SHAREHOLDERS?
Whether you hold shares directly as the shareholder
of record or beneficially under street name, you may
direct your vote without attending the Annual
Meeting of Carnival Corporation Shareholders. You
may vote by granting a proxy or, for shares held under
street name, by submitting voting instructions to
your broker or nominee. For shareholders of record,
you may do this by voting on the Internet or by
telephone by following the instructions in the notice
you received in the mail. Where your shares are held
under street name, in most instances you will be
able to do this over the Internet or by telephone by
following the instructions in the notice you received in
the mail, or if you received a full printed set of proxy
materials in the mail, by mail. Please refer to the voting
instruction card included by your broker or nominee.
Questions and Answers
QUESTIONS SPECIFIC TO SHAREHOLDERS OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION
114
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
If you received a full printed set of proxy materials in
the mail, you can also vote by signing your proxy
card and mailing it in the enclosed envelope. If you
provided specific voting instructions, your shares will
be voted as you instruct.
If you are a record holder and submit a proxy but do
not provide instructions, your shares will be voted as
described below in “
How are votes counted?
”
CAN I CHANGE MY VOTE?
Yes. You may change your proxy instruction at any
time prior to the vote at the Annual Meeting of Carnival
Corporation Shareholders. For shares held directly
in your name, you may accomplish this by granting a
new proxy bearing a later date (which automatically
revokes the earlier proxy) or by attending the Annual
Meeting of Carnival Corporation Shareholders and
voting in person. Attendance at the meeting will not
cause your previously granted proxy to be revoked
unless you specifically so request. For shares owned
beneficially by you, you may accomplish this by
submitting new voting instructions to your broker or
nominee.
WHAT DOES IT MEAN IF I RECEIVE MORE THAN ONE NOTICE OF INTERNET
AVAILABILITY OF PROXY MATERIALS OR SET OF PRINTED PROXY MATERIALS, AS
APPLICABLE?
It means your shares are registered differently or are
in more than one account. Please follow the
instructions in each notice to ensure all of your
shares are voted.
HOW DO I REQUEST ADDITIONAL COPIES OF THE PROXY MATERIALS?
You may have received only one Notice of Internet
Availability of Proxy Materials or set of printed proxy
materials, even though there are two or more
shareholders at the same address.
Broadridge Financial Solutions, Inc., the entity we
retained to mail the Notice of Internet Availability of
Proxy Materials or printed proxy materials to Carnival
Corporation’s registered owners and the entity
retained by the brokerage community to mail the
Notice of Internet Availability of Proxy Materials or
printed proxy materials to Carnival Corporation’s
beneficial owners, has been instructed to deliver only
one notice or set of printed proxy materials to
multiple security holders sharing an address unless
we have received contrary instructions from you or
one of the other shareholders. We will promptly
deliver a separate copy of the notice or set of printed
proxy materials for this year’s Annual Meeting of
Carnival Corporation Shareholders or for any future
meetings to any shareholder upon written or oral
request. To make such request, please contact
Broadridge Financial Solutions at:
866-540-7095
Broadridge Financial Solutions
Attention: Householding Department
51 Mercedes Way
Edgewood, New York 11717
Similarly, you may contact us through any of these
methods if you receive multiple notices or sets of
printed proxy materials and would prefer to receive a
single copy in the future.
WHO CAN ATTEND THE ANNUAL MEETING OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION
SHAREHOLDERS?
All Carnival Corporation shareholders of record as of
February 21, 2023, or their duly appointed proxies,
may attend and vote at the Annual Meeting of
Carnival Corporation Shareholders. Please note that
Questions and Answers
QUESTIONS SPECIFIC TO SHAREHOLDERS OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
115
each shareholder or their duly appointed proxies will
be required to comply with the “Meeting Admission
Requirements” and “Safety and Security Measures”
included in the “Information about Attending the
Annual Meetings” section preceding the Carnival
Corporation Notice of Annual Meeting. Each
shareholder may appoint only one proxy holder or
representative to attend the meeting on his or her
behalf.
In addition, if you hold your shares through a
stockbroker or other nominee, you will need to
provide proof of ownership by bringing either a copy
of the voting instruction card provided by your
broker or a copy of a brokerage statement showing
your share ownership as of February 21, 2023,
together with proof of identification. Cameras, audio
and video recording devices and other electronic
devices will not be permitted at the meeting.
WHAT CLASS OF SHARES ARE ENTITLED TO BE VOTED AT THE ANNUAL MEETING
OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION SHAREHOLDERS?
Carnival Corporation has only one class of common
stock outstanding. Each share of Carnival Corporation
common stock outstanding as of the close of
business on February 21, 2023, the record date, is
entitled to one vote at the Annual Meeting of
Shareholders. As of January 12, 2023 Carnival
Corporation had 1,113,479,515 shares of common
stock issued and outstanding. The trust shares
of beneficial interest in the P&O Princess Special
Voting Trust that are paired with your shares of
common stock do not give you separate voting rights.
HOW ARE VOTES COUNTED?
You may vote “FOR,” “AGAINST” or “ABSTAIN” for each
of the proposals, except that in the case of
Proposal 13, you may vote for "1 YEAR," "2 YEARS,"
"3 YEARS" or "ABSTAIN". If you “ABSTAIN,” it has no
effect on the outcome of the votes, although
abstentions will be counted for the purposes of
determining if a quorum is present for joint electorate
actions. If you submit a proxy with no further
instructions, your shares will be voted in accordance
with the recommendations of the Boards of Directors.
WHAT HAPPENS IF ADDITIONAL PROPOSALS ARE PRESENTED AT THE ANNUAL
MEETING OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION SHAREHOLDERS?
Other than the proposals described in this Proxy
Statement, Carnival Corporation does not expect any
matters to be presented for a vote at the 2023
Annual Meeting of Carnival Corporation Shareholders.
If you grant a proxy, the persons named as proxy
holders, our Chair and Secretary of the 2023 Annual
Meeting of Carnival Corporation Shareholders, will
have the discretion to vote your shares on any
additional matters properly presented for a vote at
the meeting. If for any unforeseen reason any of our
nominees is unable to accept nomination or election
(which is not anticipated), the persons named as
proxy holders will vote your proxy for such other
candidate or candidates as may be nominated by the
Boards of Directors.
WHO WILL COUNT THE VOTE?
Broadridge Financial Solutions will tabulate the votes and act as the inspector of elections.
Questions and Answers
QUESTIONS SPECIFIC TO SHAREHOLDERS OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION
116
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Questions Specific to Shareholders of Carnival plc
WHO IS ENTITLED TO ATTEND AND VOTE AT THE CARNIVAL PLC ANNUAL
GENERAL MEETING?
If you are a Carnival plc shareholder registered in the
register of members of Carnival plc at 6:30 p.m.
(BST) on April 19, 2023, you will be entitled to attend
in person and vote at the Annual General Meeting in
respect of the number of Carnival plc ordinary
shares registered in your name at that time.
You may also appoint a proxy to attend, speak and
vote instead of you. If you are a corporation you may
appoint a corporate representative to represent
you and vote your shareholding in Carnival plc at the
Annual General Meeting. For further details regarding
appointing a proxy or corporate representative,
please see below.
Please note that each shareholder or their duly
appointed proxies and corporate representatives will
be required to comply with the “Meeting Admission
Requirements” and “Safety and Security Measures” in
the “Information about Attending the Annual
Meetings” section preceding the Carnival plc Notice
of Annual General Meeting.
WILL I BE ASKED TO VOTE AT THE ANNUAL MEETING OF CARNIVAL
CORPORATION SHAREHOLDERS?
No. Your vote at the Annual General Meeting of
Carnival plc Shareholders, for the purposes of
determining the outcome of combined voting, will
automatically be reflected as appropriate at the
parallel Annual Meeting of Carnival Corporation
Shareholders through the mechanism of a special
voting share issued by Carnival Corporation.
HOW DO I VOTE MY CARNIVAL PLC SHARES WITHOUT ATTENDING THE ANNUAL
GENERAL MEETING OF CARNIVAL PLC SHAREHOLDERS?
You may vote your Carnival plc shares at the Annual
General Meeting of Carnival plc Shareholders by
completing and signing the enclosed form of proxy in
accordance with the instructions set out on the
form and returning it as soon as possible, but in any
event so as to be received by Carnival plc’s registrars,
Equiniti Limited, Aspect House, Spencer Road,
Lancing BN99 6DA, by not later than 1:30 p.m. (BST)
on April 19, 2023. Alternatively, a proxy vote may be
submitted via the internet in accordance with the
instructions set out in the proxy form. If you are a
member of CREST, it is also possible to appoint a proxy
via the CREST system (please see the Carnival plc
Notice of Annual General Meeting for further details).
If you are an institutional investor, you may also be
able to appoint a proxy electronically via the Proxymity
platform. Please see the Carnival plc Notice of
Annual General Meeting for further details. Voting by
proxy does not preclude you from attending the
Annual General Meeting and voting in person should
you wish to do so. If you are a corporation, you can
vote your Carnival plc shares at the Annual General
Meeting by appointing one or more corporate
representatives. You are strongly encouraged to pre-
register your corporate representative to make
registration on the day of the Annual General Meeting
more efficient. In order to pre-register you would
need to email your Letter of Representation to Carnival
plc’s registrars, Equiniti Limited, at
proxyvotes@equiniti.com.
Corporate representatives themselves are urged to
arrive at least two hours before commencement of
the Annual General Meeting to assist Carnival plc’s
registrars with the appropriate registration formalities.
Whether or not you intend to appoint a corporate
representative, you are strongly encouraged to return
the enclosed form of proxy to Carnival plc’s registrars.
Questions and Answers
QUESTIONS SPECIFIC TO SHAREHOLDERS OF CARNIVAL PLC
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
|
117
CAN I CHANGE MY VOTE GIVEN BY PROXY OR BY MY CORPORATE
REPRESENTATIVE?
Yes. You may change your proxy vote by either:
•
completing, signing and dating a new form of
proxy in accordance with its instructions and
returning it to Carnival plc’s registrars by no later
than 1:30 p.m. (BST) on April 19, 2023; or
•
attending and voting in person at the Annual
General Meeting.
If you do not attend and vote in person at the Annual
General Meeting and wish to revoke the appointment
of your proxy or corporate representative, you must
do so by delivering a notice of such revocation to
Carnival plc’s registrars at least three hours before
the start of the Annual General Meeting.
WHAT CLASS OF SHARES ARE ENTITLED TO BE VOTED AT THE CARNIVAL PLC
ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING?
Carnival plc has only one class of ordinary shares in
issue. Each Carnival plc ordinary share in issue as of
the close of business on April 19, 2023, is entitled to
one vote at the Annual General Meeting. As of
January 12, 2023, Carnival plc had 217,371,552
ordinary shares in issue. However, the 40,555,198
Carnival plc ordinary shares directly or indirectly held
by Carnival Corporation have no voting rights (in
accordance with the Articles of Association of Carnival
plc). As of January 12, 2023, 31,235,457 Carnival plc
ordinary shares are held in treasury. As a result, as of
January 12, 2023, the total voting rights in Carnival
plc were 145,580,897 ordinary shares.
HOW ARE VOTES COUNTED?
You may vote “FOR,” “AGAINST” or “ABSTAIN” for each
of the resolutions, except that in the case of
Proposal 13, you may vote for "1 YEAR," "2 YEARS,"
"3 YEARS" or "ABSTAIN". If you “ABSTAIN,” it has no
effect on the outcome of the votes, although
abstentions will be counted for the purposes of
determining if a quorum is present for joint electorate
actions.
Questions and Answers
QUESTIONS SPECIFIC TO SHAREHOLDERS OF CARNIVAL PLC
118
|
CARNIVAL CORPORATION & PLC
2023 PROXY STATEMENT
Annex A
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
Carnival plc and Carnival Corporation are separate
legal entities (together referred to as “Carnival
Corporation & plc”) and each company has its own
Board of Directors and Committees of the Board.
However, as is required by the agreements governing
the dual listed company (“DLC”) arrangement, there
is a single executive management team and the
Boards of Directors and members of the Committees
of the Boards are identical. This Directors’ Report
has been prepared and presented in accordance with
and in reliance upon UK company law and,
accordingly, the liabilities of the Directors in
connection with this Directors’ Report shall be subject
to the limitations and restrictions provided by such
law.
Information regarding future developments of the
business and business model of Carnival
Corporation & plc can be found in following sections
of the Carnival plc Strategic Report that accompanies
the Carnival plc financial statements (the “Strategic
Report”): 1.A.II Mission (Purpose), Vision, Values and
Priorities and 1.C. Our Global Cruise Business. The
financial risk management objectives and policies and
exposure to fuel price risk, foreign currency exchange
rate risk, fair value risk, interest rate risk, credit risk,
and liquidity risk can be found in Note 24 to the
Carnival plc financial statements. This Directors’
Report and the Strategic Report constitute Carnival
plc’s Management Report for the year ended
30 November 2022, in accordance with DTR 4.1.8R.
In accordance with the UK Financial Conduct
Authority’s Listing Rules, the information required to
be disclosed under Listing Rule 9.8.4R, to the extent
applicable to Carnival plc, can be found at the
references set out in the following table:
Required Information
Cross-Reference
Interest capitalized by the
Carnival plc group
Note 10 to Carnival plc
group financial
statements
Details of long-term
incentive schedules
Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Report
under “Long-Term
Incentive Compensation.”
LR 9.2.18 disclosure
“Profit Forecasts”
Other disclosure requirements in Listing Rule 9.8.4R
are not applicable to Carnival Corporation & plc.
DIVIDENDS
During the years ended November 30, 2022 and
November 30, 2021, Carnival plc did not pay any
dividends. On March 30, 2020, the Boards suspended
future dividends. Accordingly, no dividends have
been paid in fiscal 2022 or are proposed in respect of
fiscal 2023.
SHARE CAPITAL AND CONTROL
Changes in the share capital of Carnival plc during
fiscal 2022 are given in Note 18 to the Carnival plc
group financial statements.
The share capital of Carnival plc at January 12, 2023 is
constituted by two allotted and issued subscriber
shares of £1 each, 50,000 allotted but unissued
redeemable preference shares of £1 each, one
allotted and issued special voting share of £1, one
equalization share of £1 and 217,371,552 allotted and
issued ordinary shares of $1.66 each. The subscriber
shares carry no voting rights and no right to receive
any dividend or any amount paid on a return of capital.
The equalization share carries no voting rights. The
redeemable preference shares carry no voting rights,
but are entitled to payment of a cumulative
preferential fixed dividend of eight per cent per
annum on the amount paid up on each such share
that is in issue. On a return of capital on a winding up
or otherwise, the redeemable preference shares
rank behind the ordinary shares but ahead of any
other class of shares, and are entitled to receive
payment of the amount paid up or credited as paid
up on each such share. Redeemable preference shares
which are fully paid may be redeemed at any time at
the election of the holder or of Carnival plc, in which
Carnival plc Directors' Report
|
A-1
case the amount payable on redemption is the
amount credited as paid up on each share which is
redeemed, together with all arrears and accruals of
the preferential dividend.
Details of restricted stock units granted to employees
are given in Note 20 to the Carnival plc group
financial statements.
The Articles of Association of Carnival plc contain
provisions which, in certain circumstances, would
have the effect of preventing a shareholder (or a group
of shareholders acting in concert) from holding or
exercising the voting rights attributable to shares in
Carnival plc which are acquired by them. These
provisions would have effect if a shareholder (or a
group of shareholders acting in concert) were to
acquire ordinary shares in Carnival plc with the result
that the total voting rights exercisable by that
shareholder or group of shareholders on matters put
to a vote as joint electorate actions under the DLC
arrangement would exceed 30 percent of the total
voting rights exercisable in respect of any joint
electorate action. They would also have effect if a
shareholder (or group of shareholders acting in
concert) already holding between 30 percent and
50 percent of the total voting rights exercisable in
respect of any joint electorate action were to acquire
shares in Carnival plc and thereby increase
the percentage of voting rights so held. In each such
case, the percentage of voting rights held is
determined after taking into account voting rights
attributable to shares of Carnival Corporation common
stock held by such shareholder (or group of
shareholders) and also taking into account the effect
of the equalization ratio which gives effect to
common voting by the shareholders of Carnival plc
and Carnival Corporation on joint electorate actions
under the DLC arrangement.
Under the relevant provisions of the Articles of
Association of Carnival plc (articles 277 to 287) shares
which are acquired by a person and which trigger
the thresholds referred to in the foregoing paragraph
may be sold at the direction of the Board, and the
proceeds remitted to the acquiring shareholder, net
of any costs incurred by Carnival plc. Pending such sale
any dividends paid in respect of such shares would
be paid to a charitable trust, and the trustee of such
trust would be entitled to exercise the voting rights
attaching to the shares. The restrictions summarized
in the preceding paragraphs would not apply in the
case of an acquisition of shares that is made in
conjunction with a takeover offer for Carnival plc,
which is announced in accordance with the City Code
on Takeovers and Mergers, for so long as that offer
has not lapsed or been withdrawn. However, if such a
takeover offer is not made, or lapses or is withdrawn,
the restrictions will apply in respect of any acquired
shares.
The foregoing is a summary only of the relevant
provisions of the Articles of Association of Carnival
plc, and for a complete understanding of their effect,
shareholders are recommended to refer to the
Articles of Association themselves. A copy of the
Articles of Association of Carnival plc is available at
Carnival plc’s website at www.carnivalplc.com or upon
request from the Company Secretary, 3655 N.W.
87th Avenue, Miami, Florida 33178, United States.
There are twelve significant agreements to which
Carnival plc is a party, which may be altered or
terminated in the event of a change of control as
follows:
•
Under the
Facilities Agreement
originally dated
May 18, 2011, as amended and restated on August 6,
2019, as further amended on December 31, 2020,
May 11, 2021, September 30, 2021 and February 11,
2022, and as may be further amended and
extended from time to time, by and among Carnival
Corporation, Carnival plc, Bank of America Merrill
Lynch International Designated Activity Company (as
facilities agent), and a syndicate of financial
institutions, which provides for approximately
$1.7 billion, €1.0 billion and £150 million in revolving
credit facilities, the revolving credit facilities may,
under certain circumstances, be cancelled upon a
change of control of Carnival plc (other than a
change which results in control of Carnival plc being
vested in Carnival Corporation or in certain
members of the Arison family or trusts related to
them).
•
Under the
Term Loan Agreement
dated as of
June 30, 2020, as amended on December 3, 2020
and as further amended on June 30, 2021,
October 5, 2021 and October 18, 2021, among
Carnival Corporation, as lead borrower, Carnival
Finance, LLC, as co-borrower, Carnival plc, as a
guarantor, the subsidiary guarantors party thereto,
JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., as administrative
Annex A
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
SHARE CAPITAL AND CONTROL
A-2
|
Carnival plc Directors' Report
agent, and the other financial institutions party
thereto from time to time (the “Term Loan
Agreement”), Carnival Corporation and Carnival
Finance, LLC incurred two tranches of term loans
in the initial aggregate principal amounts of
$1.86 billion and €0.8 billion, respectively, as well
as an incremental tranche of $2.3 billion. Under
certain circumstances, a change of control of
Carnival plc (other than a change which results in
control of Carnival plc being vested in Carnival
Corporation or in certain members of the Arison
family or trusts related to them) could constitute an
event of default under the Term Loan Agreement,
which would permit the lenders thereunder to
accelerate the term loans.
•
Under:
(i)
the
Indenture dated as of July 20, 2020
among Carnival Corporation as issuer, Carnival
plc, the other Guarantors party thereto and
U.S. Bank, National Association, as trustee,
security agent, principal paying agent, transfer
agent and registrar, as supplemented by the
First Supplemental Indenture, dated as of
November 18, 2020, relating to the U.S. dollar-
denominated 10.500% Second-Priority
Senior Secured Notes due 2026 in an aggregate
principal amount of $775 million and the
Euro-denominated 10.125% Second-Priority
Senior Secured Notes due 2026 in an aggregate
principal amount of €425 million;
(ii)
the
Indenture dated as of August 18, 2020
among Carnival Corporation as issuer, Carnival
plc, the other Guarantors party thereto and
U.S. Bank, National Association, as trustee,
security agent, principal paying agent, transfer
agent and registrar, as supplemented by the
First Supplemental Indenture, dated as of
November 18, 2020, relating to the 9.875%
Second-Priority Senior Secured Notes due 2027
in an aggregate principal amount of
$900 million;
(iii)
the
Indenture dated as of November 25,
2020
among Carnival Corporation as issuer,
Carnival plc, the other Guarantors party thereto
and U.S. Bank, National Association, as trustee,
principal paying agent, transfer agent and
registrar, relating to the U.S. dollar-
denominated 7.625% Senior Unsecured Notes
due 2026 in an aggregate principal amount
of $1.45 billion and the Euro-denominated
7.625% Senior Unsecured Notes due 2026 in
an aggregate principal amount of €500 million;
(iv)
the
Indenture dated as of February 16, 2021
among Carnival Corporation as issuer,
Carnival plc, the other Guarantors party
thereto and U.S. Bank, National Association, as
trustee, principal paying agent, transfer
agent and registrar, relating to the 5.75%
Senior Unsecured Notes due 2027 in an
aggregate principal amount of $3.5 billion;
(v)
the
Indenture dated as of July 26, 2021
,
among Carnival Corporation, as issuer, Carnival
plc, the other Guarantors party hereto and
U.S. Bank National Association, as trustee,
principal paying agent, transfer agent, registrar
and security agent, relating to the 4.00% First-
Priority Senior Secured Notes due 2028 in
the aggregate principal amount of $2.4 billion;
and
(vi)
the
Indenture dated as of November 2,
2021
, among Carnival Corporation, as issuer,
Carnival plc, the other Guarantors party hereto
and U.S. Bank National Association, as trustee,
principal paying agent, transfer agent,
registrar and security agent, relating to the
6.000% Senior Unsecured Notes due 2029 in
an aggregate principal amount of $2 billion,
(vii) the
Indenture dated as of May 25, 2022
,
among Carnival Corporation, as issuer, Carnival
plc, the other Guarantors party hereto and
U.S. Bank Trust Company, National Association,
as trustee, principal paying agent, transfer
agent, registrar and security agent, relating to
the 10.500% Senior Unsecured Notes due 2030
in an aggregate principal amount of $1 billion,
Carnival Corporation may be required to make an
offer to repurchase the notes issued under the
relevant indenture at a redemption price of 101%
of the principal amount of the notes upon the
occurrence of certain change of control triggering
events that are accompanied by a specified ratings
downgrade with respect to the notes issued
under the relevant indenture.
•
Under the
Indenture dated as of October 25,
2022
among Carnival Holdings (Bermuda) Limited,
as issuer, Carnival Corporation, Carnival plc, the
other Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank Trust
Company, National Association, as trustee,
Annex A
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
SHARE CAPITAL AND CONTROL
Carnival plc Directors' Report
|
A-3
principal paying agent, transfer agent and registrar,
relating to the 10.375% Senior Unsecured Notes
due 2028 in an aggregate principal amount of
$2.03 billion, Carnival Holdings (Bermuda) Limited
may be required to make an offer to repurchase the
notes issued under the Indenture at a redemption
price of 101% of the principal amount of the notes
upon the occurrence of certain change of control
triggering events that are accompanied by a
specified ratings downgrade with respect to the
notes issued under the Indenture.
•
Under the
Indenture dated as of April 6, 2020
among Carnival Corporation, Carnival plc, the
subsidiary guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank
National Association, as trustee, as supplemented
by the First Supplemental Indenture dated as of
June 30, 2020 and the Second Supplemental
Indenture dated as of Jul 8, 2020, relating to the
5.75% Convertible Senior Notes due 2023 in an
aggregate principal amount of $2 billion (of which
$96 million is outstanding as of November 30, 2022),
if Carnival Corporation undergoes certain corporate
events (each, a “fundamental change”), subject to
certain conditions, holders may:
(a)
convert their convertible notes into, at the
election of Carnival Corporation, common stock
of Carnival Corporation or cash or both, at a
conversion rate specified in the indenture; or
(b)
require Carnival Corporation to repurchase for
cash all or any portion of their convertible
notes at par.
•
Under:
(i)
the
Indenture dated as of August 22, 2022
among Carnival Corporation, Carnival plc, the
subsidiary guarantors party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee, as
supplemented by the First Supplemental
Indenture dated as of November 1, 2022,
relating to the 5.75% Convertible Senior Notes
due 2024 in an aggregate principal amount
of $426 million, and
(ii)
the
Indenture dated as of November 18,
2022
among Carnival Corporation, Carnival plc,
the subsidiary guarantors party thereto and
U.S. Bank National Association, as trustee,
relating to the 5.75% Convertible Senior Notes
due 2027 in an aggregate principal amount
of $1.13 billion, if Carnival Corporation
undergoes certain corporate events (each, a
“fundamental change”), subject to certain
conditions, holders may require Carnival
Corporation to repurchase for cash all or any
portion of their convertible notes at par.
Subject to certain exceptions, a fundamental
change would occur upon, among others:
(1)
a merger transaction pursuant to which
Carnival Corporation’s common stock is
converted into other securities or assets;
(2)
the sale of all or substantially all of the assets
of Carnival Corporation to a third party; or
(3)
a person or group (other than certain members
of the Arison family or trusts related to them)
becoming the beneficial owners of more than
50% of the rights to vote to elect the members
of the Boards of Directors of Carnival
Corporation and Carnival plc.
ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION
The Articles of Association of Carnival plc may be
amended by the passing of a special resolution of the
shareholders. In common with many other corporate
actions that might be undertaken by Carnival plc, such
a resolution would be proposed as a joint electorate
action on which the shareholders of Carnival plc and
of Carnival Corporation effectively vote as a single
unified body, as contemplated by the DLC
arrangement.
PURCHASE OF OWN SHARES
In June 2021, the Boards of Directors authorized us
to sell up to $500 million of Carnival Corporation
common stock in the U.S. market and repurchase up
to $500 million of Carnival plc ordinary shares in the
UK as part of the Stock Swap Program. The Stock Swap
Program allows us to realize a net cash benefit
Annex A
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION
A-4
|
Carnival plc Directors' Report
when Carnival Corporation common stock is trading
at a premium to the price of Carnival plc ordinary
shares. Under the Stock Swap Program, we may elect
to offer and sell shares of Carnival Corporation
common stock, at prevailing market prices in ordinary
brokers’ transactions and repurchase an equivalent
number of Carnival plc ordinary shares in the UK
market. During fiscal 2022, Carnival Corporation
repurchased 5,958,558 Carnival plc ordinary shares
with a nominal value of $9,891,206, representing 4.1%
of the called-up share capital of Carnival plc (which
does not include the disenfranchised shares held by
Carnival Corporation) as of November 30, 2022, for
aggregate consideration of $86,112,061 under the
Stock Swap Program. The Stock Swap program does
not have an expiration date and may be discontinued
by us at any time or upon achieving the authorized
repurchase amount. Other than pursuant to the
Stock Swap Program, there were no purchases of
Carnival plc shares by Carnival Corporation or Carnival
plc during fiscal 2022. As of January 12, 2022, the
latest practicable date prior to the publication of this
document, and taking into account purchases by
Carnival Corporation of Carnival plc’s shares in
prior years, Carnival Corporation holds, directly or
indirectly, 40,555,198 Carnival plc ordinary shares with
a nominal value of $67,321,628, representing 27.9%
of called-up share capital of Carnival plc. Carnival plc
shares held by Carnival Corporation, including
those repurchased under the Stock Swap Program,
do not have any voting rights (in accordance with the
Articles of Association of Carnival plc).
Shareholder approval is not required to buy back
shares of Carnival Corporation, but is required under
the UK Companies Act 2006 to buy back shares of
Carnival plc. At the Annual General Meeting held on
April 8, 2022, the authority for Carnival plc to buy back
its own shares was approved. This authority enabled
Carnival plc to buy back up to 18,500,792 ordinary
shares of Carnival plc (being approximately 10 percent
of Carnival plc’s ordinary shares in issue). Under that
authority, 4,010,965 Carnival plc ordinary shares have
been purchased through January 12, 2023. That
approval expires on the earlier of:
•
the conclusion of Carnival plc’s 2023 Annual
General Meeting; or
•
October 7, 2023.
Carnival Corporation & plc treats any such purchases
made by Carnival Corporation under the Stock
Swap Program as if they were made by Carnival plc
under the Carnival plc buyback authority.
PROFIT FORECASTS
In our fourth quarter Business Update during 2021,
as well as the first, second and third quarter Business
Updates during 2022, we included the following
guidance which represented a profit forecast for
purposes of LR 9.2.18R.
In the fourth quarter of 2021 (“Q4 2021 Update”), we
reported that we expected (a) a net loss for the first
half of 2022 and (b) a profit for the second half of
2022 on both a U.S. GAAP and adjusted basis
In the first quarter of 2022 (“Q1 2022 Update”), we
reported that we expected (a) monthly adjusted
EBITDA to turn positive at the beginning of our
summer season, (b) a net loss on U.S. GAAP and
adjusted basis for the second quarter, (c) a profit for
the third quarter, and (d) a net loss for the full year
2022.
In the second quarter of 2022, we reported that we
expected (a) positive adjusted EBITDA for the third
quarter, (b) a net loss for the third quarter, and (c) a
net loss for full year 2022.
In the third quarter of 2022, we reported that we
expected (a) a net loss for the fourth quarter,
(b) breakeven to slightly negative adjusted EBITDA for
the fourth quarter, (c) positive adjusted EBITDA for
second half of 2022, and (d) on a year-over-year basis,
improvement in adjusted EBITDA.
Our actual results were in line with the guidance
above (to the extent the relevant periods ended), with
the exception of the following:
•
The guidance reported in our Q4 2021 Update
related to the expected profit for the second half
of 2022 compares to second half of 2022 result of a
net loss of $2.4 billion (U.S. GAAP) and $1.8 billion
(adjusted basis).
•
The guidance reported in our Q1 2022 Update
related to the expected profit for the third quarter
Annex A
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
PROFIT FORECASTS
Carnival plc Directors' Report
|
A-5
compares to the third quarter result of a net loss
of $0.8 billion (U.S. GAAP) and $0.7 billion (adjusted
basis).
These differences were primarily a result of the
impact of and uncertainties from COVID-19 and the
Omicron variant, the invasion of Ukraine and the
sustained increase of the price of fuel.
DIRECTORS
The names of all persons who served as Directors of
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc during fiscal 2022
are as follows: Micky Arison; Sir Jonathon Band;
Jason Glen Cahilly; Helen Deeble; Arnold W. Donald
(resigned from the Boards of Directors effective
November 30, 2022); Jeffrey J. Gearhart; Richard J.
Glasier; Katie Lahey; Sara Mathew (appointed to the
Boards of Directors effective November 14, 2022); Sir
John Parker; Stuart Subotnick; Laura Weil; Josh
Weinstein (appointed to the Boards of Directors
effective August 1, 2022); and Randall Weisenburger.
Biographical notes about each of the Directors
nominated for election or re-election are contained
in the Proxy Statement.
Details of the Directors’ membership on Board
Committees are set out in the Carnival plc Corporate
Governance Report attached as Annex C to the Proxy
Statement.
Upon becoming a member of the Board of Directors
of Carnival plc, each new Director participates in an
induction process, which includes:
•
a meeting with all of the current Directors;
•
provision of an induction pack;
•
site visits (some of which were delayed given the
impact of the COVID-19 pandemic); and
•
meetings with senior and operational management
teams.
The Directors update their skills, knowledge and
familiarity with Carnival plc by meeting with senior
management, visiting regional and divisional operating
offices and receiving updates and training coordinated
by management. The appointment and replacement
of Directors of Carnival plc is governed by the
provisions of the Articles of Association of Carnival plc
and also by the provisions of the Equalization and
Governance Agreement entered into on April 17, 2003
on the establishment of the DLC arrangement. The
Articles of Association and the Equalization and
Governance Agreement require that the Boards of
Directors of Carnival plc and Carnival Corporation be
comprised of exactly the same individuals.
The business of Carnival plc is managed by the Board
of Directors, which may exercise all the powers of
Carnival plc, including, without limitation, the power
to:
•
dispose of all or any part of our assets;
•
borrow money;
•
mortgage or pledge any of its assets;
•
purchase Carnival plc’s shares; and
•
issue debentures, shares or other securities.
Details of the Directors’ remuneration and their
interests in the shares of Carnival Corporation and
Carnival plc are set out in Part II of the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Report attached as Annex B
to the Proxy Statement.
Annex A
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
DIRECTORS
A-6
|
Carnival plc Directors' Report
SUBSTANTIAL SHAREHOLDINGS
As of November 30, 2022, Carnival plc has been
notified of material interests of three percent or more
in Carnival plc’s total voting rights as follows:
Shareholder
Number of
Voting Rights
(#)
Percentage of
Voting Rights
as of
January 12,
2023
(%)
Aristeia Capital, L.L.C.
(1)
10,140,504
7.0
Barclays Bank Plc
7,155,308
4.9
BlackRock, Inc.
7,395,735
5.1
Norges Bank (The
Central Bank of Norway)
11,785,088
8.1
UBS Group AG
6,184,921
4.3
(1)
Affiliates of Aristeia Capital, L.L.C. have an interest in
these shares.
Carnival plc has not been notified of any changes in
the number of voting rights held between December 1,
2022 and January 12, 2023, the latest practicable
date.
Carnival Corporation and Carnival Investments
Limited are the holders of an aggregate of 40,555,198
Carnival plc ordinary shares as of January 12, 2023.
These shares carry no voting rights or rights on
liquidation unless Carnival Corporation owns over
90 percent of all the Carnival plc ordinary shares.
Accordingly, the details of voting rights given in the
preceding table take account of the absence of voting
rights carried by these shares.
Except for the above, no person has disclosed
relevant information to Carnival plc pursuant to
Chapter 5 of the Disclosure Guidance and
Transparency Rules.
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE AND DIRECTORS’
REMUNERATION
A report on corporate governance and compliance
with the UK Corporate Governance Code is contained
in the Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
attached as Annex C to the Proxy Statement. Part I of
the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report is
included in the Proxy Statement and Part II of the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report is
attached as Annex B to the Proxy Statement.
CORPORATE AND SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
HEALTH, ENVIRONMENTAL, SAFETY, SECURITY AND SUSTAINABILITY
CORPORATE POLICY
At Carnival Corporation & plc, our mission and
purpose is to deliver unforgettable happiness to our
guests by providing extraordinary cruise vacations,
while honoring the integrity of every ocean we sail,
place we visit and life we touch. We strive to be a
company that people want to work for and to be an
exemplary global corporate citizen. Our commitment
and actions to keep our guests and crew members
safe and comfortable, protect the environment,
develop and provide opportunities for our workforce,
strengthen stakeholder relations and enhance both
the communities where we work as well as the port
communities that our ships visit, are reflective of our
brands’ core values and vital to our success as a
business enterprise.
The Boards of Directors of Carnival Corporation & plc
established Board-level Health, Environmental,
Safety & Security (“HESS”) Committees comprised of
six independent Directors. The principal function of
the HESS Committees is described in our Corporate
Governance Report under “Committees of the
Boards.”
Annex A
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
SUBSTANTIAL SHAREHOLDINGS
Carnival plc Directors' Report
|
A-7
In addition, Carnival Corporation & plc’s Health,
Environmental, Safety, Security and Sustainability
Corporate Policy describes our commitments to:
•
Complying with or exceeding all legal and statutory
requirements related to HESS and sustainability
throughout our business activities;
•
Protecting the environment, including the marine
ecosystems in which our vessels sail and the
communities in which we operate, striving to
prevent adverse consequences and using resources
sustainably;
•
Protecting the health, safety and security of our
guests, employees and all others working on our
behalf, thereby promoting an organization that
promotes well-being and always strives to be free
of injuries, illness, and loss;
•
Reducing our greenhouse gas and other airborne
emissions with an aspiration to achieve net carbon-
neutral ship operations;
•
Supporting sustainable tourism practices by
respecting the culture, history, natural resources,
and people of the communities we visit;
•
Supporting a circular economy by engaging
employees and working with our supply chain to
source responsibly, reduce packaging, reuse
materials, increase recycling and reduce waste;
and
•
Recruiting, growing, and maintaining a diverse and
inclusive workforce that promotes equity.
The Health, Environmental, Safety, Security and
Sustainability Corporate Policy is published on the
Carnival Corporation & plc website at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
.
The Boards recognize that Carnival Corporation & plc
needs to ensure that there is a consistent standard
of operation throughout their fleet in keeping with
their leading position in the cruise industry. In this
regard, the Carnival Corporation & plc Maritime
Operations Department is headed by a Chief Maritime
Officer, with a full-time professional and
administrative staff, and is responsible for providing
a common, integrated approach to management of
HESS matters and for reporting to the HESS
Committees on such matters. The Chief Maritime
Officer reports to our CEO and to our Chair of the
HESS Committees.
The Boards of Directors of Carnival Corporation & plc
have also established Board-level Compliance
Committees comprised of six independent Directors.
The principal function of the Compliance Committees
is to assist with the Boards’ oversight of our ethics and
compliance activities, as further described in our
Corporate Governance Report under “Committees of
the Boards.”
Carnival Corporation & plc recognizes our
responsibility to provide industry leadership and to
conduct our business as a responsible global citizen.
Our corporate leadership is manifested in our Code of
Business Conduct and Ethics, which requires that
every employee and member of the Boards use sound
judgment, maintain high ethical standards and
demonstrate honesty in all business dealings. As a
responsible global citizen, Carnival Corporation & plc
is committed to achieving and maintaining the highest
standards of professional and ethical conduct.
Risk Advisory & Assurance Services (“RAAS”) is Carnival
Corporation & plc’s internal audit department and is
headed by the Chief Audit Officer, who reports directly
to our Chairs of the Audit and HESS Committees.
Our Chief Audit Officer also has a “dotted” reporting
line to the Chief Risk and Compliance Officer. RAAS
conducts annual HESS audits of each brand’s head
office and of each ship in our fleet. These audits are in
addition to the audits performed by third-party
certification and regulatory auditors.
Each RAAS HESS audit is organized and planned to:
•
verify compliance with applicable rules, corporate
standards, brand policies and procedures,
regulations, codes and guidance directly involved
in the safe conduct of ship operations;
•
verify the effectiveness and efficiency of the
shipboard and shore-side HESS management
systems; and
•
identify opportunities for continuous improvement.
Further details of matters related to health,
environmental, safety, security and sustainability
reporting and community relations at Carnival
Corporation & plc are available in our Strategic Report
and in the “Sustainability” section of the Carnival
Corporation & plc website at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
and our sustainability
website at
www.carnivalsustainability.com
.
Annex A
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
CORPORATE AND SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
A-8
|
Carnival plc Directors' Report
EMPLOYEES
Carnival Corporation & plc own and operate a portfolio of brands in North America, Europe, Australia and Asia
comprised of nine cruise lines:
CARNIVAL
CRUISE
LINE
SEABOURN
CUNARD
HOLLAND
AMERICA
LINE
AIDA
CRUISES
P&O
CRUISES
(AUSTRALIA)
PRINCESS
CRUISES
COSTA
CRUISES
P&O
CRUISES (UK)
Our corporate office and individual brands employ a
variety of methods, such as intranet sites,
management briefings, newsletters and reward
programs to encourage employee involvement and
to keep employees informed of the performance,
development and progress of Carnival Corporation &
plc.
Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
We believe that diversity, equity and inclusion issues, such as the attraction, retention, development and
promotion of underrepresented groups, such as women and people of color, are not only important topics
in corporations and boardrooms world-wide, but they are also critically important to sustaining and
increasing the success of our business. We recognize that maintaining a diverse and inclusive workforce
promotes an open, tolerant and positive work environment where everyone’s different talents and
strengths can be utilized. We work to attract, motivate, develop and retain the best talent from the diversity
the world offers. We believe that our ability to be competitive and to thrive globally depends on it. For a
number of years, we have partnered with organizations focused on improving the diversity and
inclusiveness of workplaces and by extension, society in general. We strive to achieve greater performance
through capturing the power of employee diversity across all elements such as race, ethnicity, age, gender
and sexual orientation and identification.
Josh Weinstein, our President, CEO and Chief Climate Officer, has committed to Catalyst’s “Catalyst CEO
Champions for Change” initiative to support the advancement of women’s leadership and diversity in the
workplace. We are also a global partner of the International LGBTQ+ Travel Association (IGLTA), the world’s
leading network of LGBTQ+ welcoming tourism businesses. Through our partnership, we will help promote
equality and safety for LGBTQ+ tourism worldwide.
Annex A
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
CORPORATE AND SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
Carnival plc Directors' Report
|
A-9
Senior employees within Carnival Corporation & plc
are eligible to participate in either the Carnival plc 2014
Employee Share Plan or the Carnival Corporation
2020 Stock Plan, further details of which are provided
in Carnival plc’s Directors’ Remuneration Report
attached as Annex B to the Proxy Statement. These
plans reinforce the philosophy of encouraging senior
employees to contribute directly to the achievement
of Carnival Corporation & plc’s goals and of rewarding
individual and collective success.
It is the policy of Carnival Corporation & plc that
disabled persons should receive full and fair
consideration for all job vacancies and promotions
for which they are qualified applicants. It is the policy
of Carnival Corporation & plc to seek to retain
employees who become disabled while in their
service whenever possible and to provide appropriate
training and accommodations for disabled persons.
Training and career development are provided
and encouraged for all employees, including disabled
persons.
Information on the gender diversity of senior
management and their direct reports is included in
the Strategic Report in section 1.C.XII. Human Capital
Management and Employees.
OTHER STAKEHOLDERS
Information regarding our business relationships
with clients, end customers, suppliers and regulators
can be found in the following sections of the
Strategic Report: 1.A.II. Mission (Purpose), Vision,
Values and Priorities, 1.C.III.
Ships Under Contracts for Construction, 1.C.VII. Cruise
Pricing and Payment Terms, 1.C.IX. Onboard and
Other Revenues, 1.C.XI. Sales Channels, 1.C.XV. Supply
Chain, 1.C.XIX. Governmental Regulations and 7.
Section 172(1) Statement.
Political Contributions
Carnival plc did not make any political contributions
to any political organization during the year ended
November 30, 2022 (2021—nil). Carnival plc’s
subsidiaries made political contributions to
organizations outside the European Union of
$0.1 million (2021—$0.075 million).
Corporate Governance Statement
The corporate governance statement, prepared in
accordance with rule 7.2 of the FCA’s Disclosure
Guidance and Transparency Rules sourcebook, can
be found in the Carnival plc Corporate Governance
Report attached as Annex C to the Proxy Statement.
The Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report forms
part of this Carnival plc Directors’ Report and is
incorporated into it by this reference.
Independent Auditors
The independent auditors, PricewaterhouseCoopers
LLP, have indicated their willingness to continue in
office and a resolution that they be re-appointed will
be proposed at the 2023 Annual General Meeting.
Statement of Directors’ Responsibilities
The Directors are responsible for preparing the
Carnival plc Annual Report in accordance with
applicable law and regulations for each financial
year.
Under company law, the Directors have prepared the
group financial statements in accordance with UK-
adopted international accounting standards and the
company financial statements in accordance with
United Kingdom Generally Accepted Accounting
Practice (United Kingdom Accounting Standards,
comprising the FRS 101 “Reduced Disclosure
Framework” and applicable law).
Annex A
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
POLITICAL CONTRIBUTIONS
A-10
|
Carnival plc Directors' Report
Under company law, the Directors must not approve
the financial statements unless they are satisfied that
they give a true and fair view of the state of affairs
of Carnival plc and the Carnival plc group and of the
net income of the Carnival plc group for that period.
In preparing the financial statements the Directors are
required to:
•
select suitable accounting policies and then apply
them consistently;
•
make judgments and estimates that are reasonable
and prudent;
•
state whether applicable UK-adopted international
accounting standards have been followed for the
group financial statements and United Kingdom
Accounting Standards, comprising FRC 101 and
applicable law have been followed for the company
financial statements, subject to any material
departures disclosed and explained in the financial
statements; and
•
prepare the group and parent company financial
statements on the going concern basis unless it is
inappropriate to presume that the group and
company will continue in business.
The Directors are responsible for keeping adequate
accounting records that are sufficient to show and
explain Carnival plc’s and Carnival plc group’s
transactions and disclose with reasonable accuracy
at any time the financial position of Carnival plc and
the Carnival plc group and to enable them to ensure
that the Carnival plc Annual Report complies with
the UK Companies Act 2006.
The Directors are also responsible for safeguarding
the assets of Carnival plc and the Carnival plc group
and hence for taking reasonable steps for the
prevention and detection of fraud and other
irregularities.
The Directors are responsible for the maintenance
and integrity of the corporate and financial
information included on its website. Legislation in
the UK governing the preparation and dissemination
of financial statements may differ from legislation
in other jurisdictions.
Each of the Directors, whose names and functions
are listed in the Proxy Statement, confirms that, to the
best of his or her knowledge:
(a)
the Carnival plc group financial statements,
which have been prepared in accordance with
UK-adopted international accounting standards,
give a true and fair view of the assets, liabilities,
financial position and loss of the Carnival plc
group;
(b)
the Carnival plc company financial statements,
which have been prepared in accordance with
United Kingdom Accounting Standards,
comprising FRS 101 and applicable law, give a
true and fair view of the assets, liabilities and
financial position of Carnival plc;
(c)
the Directors’ Report attached as Annex A to the
Proxy Statement and the Strategic Report
include a fair view of the development and
performance of the business and the position of
the Carnival plc group and Carnival plc, together
with a description of the principal risks and
uncertainties that they face; and
(d)
the Carnival plc Annual Report taken as a whole,
is fair, balanced and understandable and provide
the information necessary for the shareholders
of Carnival plc to assess the position and
performance, business model and strategy of
the Carnival plc group and Carnival plc.
As part of the process to reach the conclusion in
(d) above as well as the overall annual report review
process, the Audit Committees received and reviewed
drafts of the components of the annual report and
provided feedback at a meeting with management to
discuss the disclosures in advance of our fiscal year
end. Feedback received was appropriately addressed
ahead of the January meeting of the Audit Committees
where the updated draft Annual Report was
reviewed and the January meeting of the Boards
where the final Annual Report was reviewed and
approved.
In the case of each Director in office at the date the
Directors’ Report is approved:
•
so far as the Director is aware, there is no relevant
audit information of which the Carnival plc
group’s and Carnival plc’s auditors are unaware;
and
•
they have taken all the steps that they ought to
have taken as a Director in order to make
themselves aware of any relevant audit information
and to establish that Carnival plc group’s and
Carnival plc’s auditors are aware of that information.
Annex A
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
STATEMENT OF DIRECTORS’ RESPONSIBILITIES
Carnival plc Directors' Report
|
A-11
This Directors’ Report was approved by the Board of Directors and
is signed by order of the Board of Directors by
ARNALDO PEREZ
Company Secretary
January 27, 2023
Carnival plc
Incorporated and registered in England and Wales under number 4039524
Annex A
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Report
STATEMENT OF DIRECTORS’ RESPONSIBILITIES
A-12
|
Carnival plc Directors' Report
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Report (Part II)
Certain information required to be included in the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report is set
forth in Part I (which is also known as the
Compensation Discussion and Analysis) and in the
“Non-Executive Director Compensation” and
“Compensation Tables” sections of the Notice of
Annual Meetings and Proxy Statement to which this
Report is annexed (the “Proxy Statement”). The
Compensation Discussion and Analysis and the
relevant parts of the Proxy Statement should be read
in conjunction with this Part II.
As explained in Part I, Parts I and II of the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Report form part of the
Carnival plc Annual Report for the year ended
November 30, 2022. Carnival plc and Carnival
Corporation are separate legal entities (together
referred to as “Carnival Corporation & plc”) and each
company has its own Board of Directors and
Compensation Committee. However, as required by
the agreements governing the dual listed company
(“DLC”) arrangement, there is a single management
team and the Boards of Directors and members of the
Committees of the Boards are identical. Accordingly,
consistent with prior years, we have included
remuneration paid by Carnival Corporation and
Carnival plc in the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report. The Directors are primarily paid by Carnival
Corporation as part of the DLC arrangement.
Both Parts I and II of the Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Report are in compliance with
Schedule 8 of the LMCG Regulations and the UK
Corporate Governance Code, the UK Companies Act
2006 and the Listing Rules of the FCA. In particular, our
executive compensation program takes into account
the principles outlined in Provision 40 of the UK
Corporate Governance Code, as set forth in Parts I
and Part II of the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report.
The Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report
(other than the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Policy which is set out in Section B of this Part II) is
subject to an advisory (non-binding) vote at the
2023 Annual General Meeting. Section A of this Part II
is the Implementation Section, which contains the
disclosures in respect of the actual pay outcomes for
fiscal 2022. Section B contains the Directors’
Remuneration Policy, which is subject to a binding
vote at the 2023 Annual General Meeting and will, if
approved, take effect from April 21, 2023.
1.
Statement by Randall Weisenburger, Chair of the
Compensation Committees
The major decisions on Directors’ remuneration and
the changes on Directors’ remuneration during the
year (and the context for these decisions and changes)
are summarized in the “Executive Summary” section
in Part I of the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report as well as my other letter as Chair of the
Compensation Committees set out in Part I of the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report.
Our pay practices are consistent with best and
established market practice provisions in the U.S.
where, for example it is not common to defer the
release of long-term incentive grants following their
vesting or to require executives to maintain a
shareholding following their departure from the
group. The Compensation Committees have
considered the potential implications of adopting
such developments in UK practice since the last policy
review and concluded that it would both unnecessarily
place Carnival Corporation & plc at a competitive
disadvantage to other large U.S. headquartered
companies and that the corresponding increase in
the overall quantum of pay required to offset the
diminution in the packages arising from such
provisions would not be in the interests of
shareholders. The Compensation Committees will
keep such matters and, in particular, whether they
become more prevalent in the U.S. under review.
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-1
The performance results for fiscal 2022 short and
long-term incentives are detailed in Part I. The
Compensation Committees considered the outcome
under the terms of the various variable pay
arrangements and approved the results applying the
discretion described in “2022 MIP Annual Bonus
Performance” and “Disclosure and the Timing of
Long-Term Incentive and Equity-Based Compensation.”
A new Directors' Remuneration Policy is being
resubmitted to shareholders for approval at the 2023
Annual Meetings of Shareholders, as required. The
new Directors' Remuneration Policy sets the
framework under which the Compensation
Committees make pay decisions affecting our
Executive and Non-Executive Directors. No substantive
changes to the Directors' Remuneration Policy are
proposed, although:
•
The caps under the long-term incentive
compensation have been updated to better reflect
the position under the shareholder approved
long-term incentive plans;
•
The summary of how the long-term incentive
compensation will operate has been updated to
reflect the current approach to operating them; and
•
A minor change has been to the policy for Non-
Executive Directors to permit the limits to be
doubled if a Non-Executive chair is ever appointed.
These are intended to provide clarity and appropriate
flexibility. There are no current plans to change our
practices as a result of these changes.
The Compensation Committees continue to consider
the Directors' Remuneration Policy to be appropriate,
including the overall pay levels, having regard to the
Executive Directors’ positioning relative to the Peer
Group set out in Part I.
2.
Implementation Section
2.1
IMPLEMENTATION OF APPROVED POLICY
The Directors’ Remuneration Policy that is currently
in effect (the “2020 Policy”) was approved by the
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc shareholders at
the Annual General Meeting held on April 6, 2020.
The 2020 Policy will be operated by Carnival
Corporation & plc until a new Directors’ Remuneration
Policy is approved. The new Directors’ Remuneration
Policy is being proposed for shareholder approval
at the 2023 Annual General Meeting (the “2023 Policy”).
The 2020 Policy is included within Annex B of the
2020 Notice of Annual Meetings of Shareholders and
Proxy Statement, which is available on our website
at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
.
The Compensation Committees have regard to the
UK Corporate Governance Code and are satisfied that
the 2020 Policy supports the long-term success of
Carnival Corporation & plc and includes due regard to
corporate and social responsibility issues and to
managing risk within the group. The 2023 Policy will
be implemented for fiscal 2023 consistent with
the descriptions of the 2023 compensation described
in the tables below and in accordance with the
approach to implementation set out in the
compensation philosophy overview and disclosures
found in Part I.
During the year, the following actions were taken for
2022 or anticipated for fiscal 2023 when implementing
the 2020 Policy:
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-2
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS
Compensation
Element
Actions Taken
BASE SALARY
Annual Salaries (not audited)
Annual salary levels as at December 1, 2022 were:
•
Mr. Weinstein
$1,250,000
•
Mr. Arison
$1,000,000, however, effective April 1, 2020, at Mr. Arison’s request, in
order to preserve cash, the Compensation Committees authorized the
suspension of his salary which remains effective through fiscal 2023.
Mr. Weinstein’s salary was increased to $1,250,000 in August 2022 upon assuming the role of
President, CEO and Chief Climate Officer. No further change in salary is being made for fiscal
2023. No increase was made to Mr. Donald’s salary for fiscal 2022. Mr. Donald retired from
employment and the Boards of Directors effective November 30, 2022 and will not receive a
salary for fiscal 2023 (although he will serve as a consultant as explained under “Outgoing CEO
Consulting Agreement” in Part I of the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report). At
Mr. Arison’s request, in order to preserve cash, the Compensation Committees authorized the
continued suspension of Mr. Arison’s salary for fiscal 2023.
Details of the companies considered as comparators for the market competitive reviews
described above are set out in the “Process for Making Compensation Determinations” section
in Part I.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-3
Compensation
Element
Actions Taken
ANNUAL
BONUS
Fiscal 2022 Annual Bonus (audited)
The annual bonus program is referred to as the Management Incentive Plan. Details of the
performance measures and targets for Mr. Weinstein’s and Mr. Donald’s annual bonus in
respect of fiscal 2022 are included in the “Annual Bonuses” section in Part I under “2022
Performance Objectives” and “2022 MIP Annual Bonus Performance.” The quantitative
performance measures included adjusted EBITDA, average passenger occupancy, greenhouse
gas intensity reduction, food waste reduction, and executive accountabilities. Please see Part I
for additional information on the performance measures.
Mr. Arison does not participate in our performance-based annual bonus program.
Annual bonus for Executive Directors who served in fiscal 2022 were as follows:
•
Mr. Weinstein
919,178
(1)
•
Mr. Donald
$3,300,000
•
Mr. Arison
Nil
(1)
Represents Mr. Weinstein’s bonus for the time he served as an Executive Director.
Fiscal 2023 Annual Bonus
―
Performance measures and targets (not audited)
We will continue using a predominantly quantitative performance-based incentive program in
2023, with pre-defined metrics and goal levels consistent with the process set out in the “Annual
Bonuses” and “Summary of Fiscal 2023 Named Executive Officer Compensation” sections in
Part I. The performance measures for fiscal 2023 will be disclosed at the end of the performance
period in the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report for fiscal 2023, as the Boards consider
them strategic and commercially sensitive to disclose at this time.
For fiscal 2023, Mr. Weinstein’s target bonus remained unchanged at $2,500,000 (with the
maximum possible bonus being 200% of this level).
As of November 30, 2022, Mr. Donald no longer participates in our performance-based annual
bonus program, except with respect to payment of the fiscal 2022 bonus to be paid in early
2023.
Mr. Arison does not participate in our performance-based annual bonus program.
As reported in the “Annual Bonuses” section in Part I, the annual bonus program includes
clawback features that will require participants to reimburse us for all or a portion of payments
received under the program in the case of a participant’s wrongdoing that results in a material
restatement of our financial statements.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-4
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
Compensation
Element
Actions Taken
LONG-TERM
INCENTIVE
COMPENSATION
Long-Term Incentive Compensation in Fiscal 2022 (audited)
Descriptions of the ERA incentive and the share grants made to Mr. Weinstein and Mr. Donald
during fiscal 2022 and their vesting conditions are set out in the “Disclosure and the Timing of
Long-Term Incentive and Equity-Based Compensation” section in Part I. The ERA cash incentives
and share grants made to Mr. Weinstein and Mr. Donald during fiscal 2022 are disclosed in
“Grants of Plan-Based Awards in Fiscal 2022” table in “Compensation Tables” section of the Proxy
Statement. No long-term incentive compensation was made to Mr. Arison in fiscal 2022.
The 2020 annual performance-based share (“PBS”) grant made to Mr. Weinstein and Mr. Donald
in February 2020 and a grant of PBS RSUs measuring performance of three ESG metrics over
fiscal 2020-2022 (the “2020 Strategic ESG Goals PBS”) made in August 2020 each reached the end
of the performance period at the end of fiscal 2022. The PBS and the 2020 Strategic ESG Goals
PBS grants will vest and restrictions will lapse on February 6, 2023. Details of the 2020 PBS and
Special PBS grant performance targets and results are set out in the “Disclosure of Prior Years’
Grant Results” section in Part I.
Long-Term Incentive Compensation in Fiscal 2023 (not audited)
The long-term incentive compensation for fiscal 2023 for Mr. Weinstein will include a PBS target
grant with a value of $3.5 million and a time-based share ("TBS") long-term incentive grant with
a value of $1.5 million.
The monetary amounts referred to for the PBS grant are subject to quantitative performance
conditions that will be applied to the target number of PBS RSUs at the end of the three-year
performance period. The performance measures for the PBS grant will be disclosed in the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report for fiscal 2023 as the Boards consider them
strategic and commercially sensitive to disclose at this time. The amount referred to for the TBS
has three-year annual pro-rata vesting and is subject to continued employment. As explained in
the “Equity-Based Compensation” section in Part I, grants are calculated by reference to the
value of shares to facilitate external comparisons and also comparison to other forms of
compensation.
No long-term incentive compensation will be made to Mr. Arison in fiscal 2022.
BENEFITS
Benefits in Fiscal 2022 (audited)
The detailed benefits provided to Mr. Arison are described in the footnotes to the “Single Figure
Table” below. The detail of benefits provided to Mr. Weinstein and Mr. Donald is set out in the
“All Other Compensation” table in the “Executive Compensation” section of the Proxy Statement.
Benefits in Fiscal 2023 (not audited)
Benefits provided to Mr. Arison and Mr. Weinstein in fiscal 2023 are expected to be similar to
those provided in fiscal 2022.
PENSIONS
Pensions in Fiscal 2022 (audited)
Details of the pension plan that Mr. Arison participated in fiscal 2022 are set out in “Total
Pension Entitlements” section. Mr. Arison does not have any accrued benefits under his pension
plan as of November 30, 2022. Mr. Weinstein and Mr. Donald do not have any pension
entitlements other than employer contributions to Mr. Weinstein and Mr. Donald under the
Carnival Corporation Fun Ship Savings Plan, a 401(k) plan. Mr. Donald will no longer participate
in this plan except with respect contributions made prior to November 30, 2022.
Pensions in Fiscal 2022 (not audited)
No material changes to the arrangements are anticipated for 2023.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-5
Compensation
Policy
Actions Taken
STOCK
OWNERSHIP
POLICY
Stock Ownership Policy (audited)
A description of the stock ownership policy applicable to Executive Directors is set out in the
“Stock Ownership Policy” section in Part I. New Executive Directors are expected to be in
compliance with the stock ownership policy within five years of the date of becoming an
executive officer. Messrs. Arison, Weinstein and Donald were in compliance with the stock
ownership policy as of November 30, 2022.
NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS
Compensation
Element
Actions Taken
FEES
Fees in Fiscal 2022 (not audited)
As described in last year’s Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report, during fiscal 2022,
Non-Executive Directors received a $110,000 annual retainer. For fiscal 2022, the Senior
Independent Director received an additional retainer of $25,000 per annum. In addition,
Non-Executive Directors received an additional $30,000 compensation for serving as Chair of a
Board Committee.
Restricted Share Grants in Fiscal 2022 (audited)
Each Non-Executive Director elected or re-elected in April 2022 received share grants worth
approximately $175,000 on April 8, 2022. Each of these grants was based on the closing price of
a share on that date of $18.34.
Ms. Mathew, who was appointed to the Boards on November 14, 2022, received a prorated
grant of 7,146 restricted shares on November 14, 2022 based on the closing share price on that
date of $10.60.
The restricted shares vest on April 8, 2025 and are not forfeited if a Director ceases to be a
Director after having served as a Director for at least one year.
Fees in Fiscal 2023 (not audited)
No material changes to the arrangements are anticipated for 2023.
Compensation
Policy
Actions Taken
STOCK
OWNERSHIP
POLICY
Stock Ownership Policy (audited)
A description of the stock ownership policy applicable to Non-Executive Directors is set out in
Section 2.11 Directors’ Shareholding and Share Interests below. New Non-Executive Directors
must achieve this requirement no later than five years from the date of their initial election to
the Boards by the shareholders. Each of the Non-Executive Directors serving in fiscal 2022 is in
compliance with this Board-mandated requirement.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-6
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
2.2
SERVICE CONTRACTS (NOT AUDITED)
Because Directors do not have formal agreements, it
is not feasible to include a table with the unexpired
terms.
Non-Executive Directors are appointed under terms
set out in a letter of appointment. They do not have
service contracts and their appointments can be
terminated (by the Boards) without any compensation
on termination. However, they may retain their
share grants (if they have already served for at least
one year) and may receive a departing gift of up to
$25,000 in value.
2.3
COMPENSATION COMMITTEES (NOT AUDITED)
The membership of the Compensation Committees
during the year consisted of four members who are
deemed independent by the Boards of Directors:
•
Randall Weisenburger (Chair);
•
Helen Deeble;
•
Richard J. Glasier; and
•
Laura Weil.
The members of the Compensation Committees are
appointed by the Boards based on the
recommendations of the Nominating & Governance
Committees. Further details regarding the
Compensation Committees (including the number of
meetings of the Compensation Committees held in
fiscal 2022 and the attendance of the members at
such meetings) can be found in the Carnival plc
Corporate Governance Report attached as Annex C to
the Proxy Statement.
Details of the Compensation Committees’ process for
making compensation determinations, including
the advice provided by internal colleagues and
external advisors are set out in the “Process for
Making Compensation Determinations” section in
Part I. As stated in Part I, Frederic W. Cook & Co., Inc.
(together with its UK affiliated firm, FIT Remuneration
Consultants LLP, which is a member of the
Remuneration Consultants Group, the UK professional
body, and complies with its code of conduct) were
appointed by the Compensation Committees as their
external advisors. The advisors were appointed
following a tender process and are subject to an
ongoing periodic review by the Compensation
Committees of their independence and quality. They
provide no other services to Carnival Corporation & plc
and, accordingly, are considered independent by the
Compensation Committees and to provide objective
advice.
Frederic W. Cook & Co., Inc. and FIT Remuneration
Consultants LLP have each provided their written
consent to the form and content of their references
in the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report and
the Proxy Statement.
Fees paid to the Compensation Committees’ external
advisors in fiscal 2022 were $543,937 to Frederic W.
Cook & Co., Inc. and $31,697 to FIT Remuneration
Consultants LLP, such fees being charged on these
firms’ standard terms of business for advice provided.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-7
2.4
SHAREHOLDER VOTING ON REMUNERATION MATTERS (NOT AUDITED)
The Annual Meetings of Shareholders of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc were held on April 8, 2022. The
results of the shareholder vote on remuneration matters were as follows:
FOR
AGAINST
ABSTAIN
BROKER
NON-VOTES
Proposal
Number of
Votes
%
Number of
Votes
%
Number of
Votes
Number of
Votes
To approve the fiscal 2021
compensation of the Named
Executive Officers of Carnival
Corporation & plc
339,182,673
63.9%
191,681,061
36.1%
1,942,848
205,415,170
To approve the Directors’
Remuneration Report (as set
out in the annual report for
the year ended November 30,
2021)
340,527,875
64.2%
190,231,874
35.8%
2,046,833
205,415,170
The last shareholder vote on the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Policy was held during the April 6, 2020
Annual Meetings of Shareholders of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc, and the results of that vote were as
follows:
FOR
AGAINST
ABSTAIN
BROKER
NON-VOTES
Proposal
Number of
Votes
%
Number of
Votes
%
Number of
Votes
Number of
Votes
To approve the Carnival plc
Directors’ Remuneration Policy
set out in Section B of Part II of
the Directors’ Remuneration
Report as set out in the annual
report for the year ended
November 30, 2019)
448,739,964
85.3%
77,347,793
14.7%
931,552
36,573,968
Carnival Corporation & plc has a long-standing
shareholder outreach program and routinely interacts
with shareholders on a number of matters, including
executive compensation. The Compensation
Committees consider all constructive feedback
received about executive compensation.
During 2022, as a supplement to our broader
shareholder engagement program and in response
to our 2022 advisory votes to approve executive
compensation (also known as the “say-on-pay” vote)
and the Carnival plc Director’s Remuneration Report,
we conducted extensive shareholder outreach
following the 2022 Annual Meetings of Shareholders.
The objective of this outreach was to understand
the factors that drove investors’ evaluation of and
voting on our compensation program, and to share
and obtain feedback on the expected evolution of our
program, including returning to our historical
practice of utilizing quantitative performance criteria
for fiscal 2022 annual bonuses and equity-based
compensation for our executive officers. As required
under UK rules, we issued an update in October 2022
on our response to the 2022 advisory votes to
approve executive compensation and the Carnival plc
Director’s Remuneration Report. We continue to
seek and incorporate shareholder feedback in our
compensation deliberations. The Compensation
Committees have implemented our quantitative and
performance-based incentive program in both 2022
and 2023 and will continue to consider results from
the annual shareholder advisory votes, including the
next vote in April 2023, as well as other shareholder
input, when evaluating executive compensation
programs and policies. See “Shareholder Engagement”
in Part I of the Directors’ Remuneration Report for
additional detail on our shareholder outreach
program, efforts in fiscal 2022 and outcome.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-8
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
2.5
PERFORMANCE GRAPH AND TABLE (NOT AUDITED)
The tables below show a comparison to the S&P 500 index of which Carnival Corporation is a constituent (as a
broad index) for a period from December 1, 2012 to November 30, 2022 and have been calculated on a U.S. dollar
basis.
0.00
50.00
100.00
150.00
200.00
250.00
300.00
350.00
400.00
450.00
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Carnival Corporation
S&P 500 Index
Comparison of 10 Year Cumulative Total Return
Assumes Initial Investment of $100
November 2022
0.00
50.00
100.00
150.00
200.00
250.00
300.00
350.00
400.00
450.00
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Comparison of 10 Year Cumulative Total Return
Assumes Initial Investment of $100
November 2022
Carnival plc
S&P 500 Index
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-9
The following table sets out, for our CEO, the total
remuneration as seen in the Single Figure Table, the
bonus paid as a percentage of the maximum
opportunity and the number of shares
that have vested against the maximum number of
shares that could have been received over a 10-year
period.
Year
Name
Single Figure
of Total
Remuneration
($000)
Annual Bonus
as a %
of Maximum
PBS Vesting
as a %
of Maximum
ESG PBS Vesting
as a %
of Maximum
SEA Vesting
as a %
of Maximum
2022
Mr. Weinstein
(1)
1,770
55
38
90
0
2022
Mr. Donald
(1)
5,842
55
38
90
0
2021
Mr. Donald
15,266
(2)
100
8
N/A
0
2020
Mr. Donald
4,587
0
16
N/A
0
2019
Mr. Donald
8,713
38
56
N/A
0
2018
Mr. Donald
12,704
78
72
N/A
N/A
2017
Mr. Donald
11,711
73
81
N/A
N/A
2016
Mr. Donald
32,132
76
94
N/A
N/A
2015
Mr. Donald
10,621
87
80
N/A
N/A
2014
Mr. Donald
7,241
74
N/A
N/A
N/A
2013
Mr. Donald
(3)
1,919
N/A
(5)
N/A
N/A
N/A
2013
Mr. Arison
(3)
2,213
0
0
N/A
N/A
(1)
The fiscal 2022 figures have been prorated for each individual to reflect the period in office as a CEO.
(2)
The 2020 single figure has been updated to reflect the actual share price on the vesting date of the 2019 PBS grant.
(3)
The fiscal 2013 figures have been prorated for each individual to reflect the period in office as a CEO.
(4)
The annual performance bonus for Mr. Donald is not applicable because for fiscal 2013, he received a fixed bonus amount as
provided for in his employment agreement.
2.6
PERCENTAGE CHANGE IN PAY OF EACH DIRECTOR
―
FISCAL 2020 TO
FISCAL 2022 (NOT AUDITED)
The prescribed pay elements are: salaries, retainers,
taxable benefits and annual bonus outcomes.
Information in respect of global employees of Carnival
plc is used for the purposes of this comparison, as
required by the LMCG Regulations. The percentages
have been calculated using a full-time equivalent
weighted-average number of global employees of
Carnival plc. The disclosure will build up over time to
cover a rolling five-year period.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-10
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
Year-on-year percentage change in pay of each Director compared to employee average
2022
2021
2020
Name
Salary/
Retainer
(%)
Benefits
(%)
Bonus
(%)
Salary/
Retainer
(%)
Benefits
(%)
Bonus
(%)
Salary/
Retainer
(%)
Benefits
(%)
Bonus
(%)
Micky Arison
0
(22.3)
N/A
(100)
28.7
N/A
(69.1)
(7.8)
N/A
Sir Jonathon Band
0
0
N/A
59.1
0
N/A
(37.1)
(100.0)
N/A
Jason Glen Cahilly
0
0
N/A
59.4
0
N/A
(37.3)
(100.0)
N/A
Helen Deeble
0
0
N/A
59.4
0
N/A
(37.3)
0
N/A
Arnold W. Donald
(1)
0
192.6
(45.0)
74.9
(48.2)
N/A
(2)
(42.9)
(23.6)
(100.0)
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
0
0
N/A
168.3
0
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Richard J. Glasier
0
0
N/A
59.1
0
N/A
(37.1)
(100.0)
N/A
Katie Lahey
0
0
N/A
59.4
0
N/A
(37.3)
(100.0)
N/A
Sara Mathew
(3)
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Sir John Parker
0
0
N/A
59.4
0
N/A
(37.3)
0
N/A
Stuart Subotnick
0
0
N/A
59.1
0
N/A
(33.8)
(100.0)
N/A
Laura Weil
0
0
N/A
59.4
0
N/A
(37.3)
0
N/A
Josh Weinstein
(4)
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Randall Weisenburger
0
0
N/A
59.8
0
N/A
(29.5)
0
N/A
Employee Average
4.9
28.1
(53.1)
10.6
13.0
232.9
(2.0)
54.3
(11.1)
(1)
Mr. Donald resigned from the Boards of Directors effective November 30, 2022.
(2)
Mr. Donald did not receive an annual bonus for fiscal 2020 and received an annual bonus of $6,000,000 for fiscal 2021.
(3)
Ms. Mathew was appointed to the Boards effective November 14, 2022.
(4)
Mr. Weinstein was appointed to the Boards effective August 1, 2022.
2.7
UK CEO PAY RATIO (NOT AUDITED)
In line with UK reporting requirements to which
Carnival plc became subject in fiscal 2020, set out
below are ratios which compare the total
remuneration of the person(s) who served as our
CEO(s), as included in Section 2.9 Single Figure Table,
adjusted in the case of fiscal 2022 for the period each
person was serving as our CEO, to the remuneration
of the 25th, 50th and 75th percentile of UK employees
of Carnival plc and its subsidiaries. The disclosure
will build up over time to cover a rolling 10-year period.
PAY RATIO
Year
Method
25th Percentile
50th Percentile (median)
75th Percentile
Fiscal 2022
Option A
753:1
440:1
202:1
Fiscal 2021
Option A
2,083:1
1,359:1
424:1
Fiscal 2020
Option A
184:1
106:1
58:1
The pay ratios have been calculated using Option A
as we consider this the most straight-forward
approach from the options available in the LMCG
Regulations and is consistent with the information
and methodology used in determining the U.S. CEO
Pay Ratio disclosed in the Proxy Statement. Option A
requires the calculation and ranking, from lowest
to highest, of the pay and benefits of UK employees
for the relevant fiscal year, to identify those at the 25th,
50th and 75th percentiles. The total CEO pay for
fiscal 2022 is $7,611,963 which is the total of
$5,842,383 and $1,769,580, the pro-rated portion of
pay associated with each of Messrs. Donald’s and
Weinstein’s respective time in the CEO role.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-11
The base salary and total remuneration received during the fiscal 2022 year by the indicative employees as of
September 30, 2022 on a full-time equivalent basis used in the above analysis are set out below:
25th Percentile
($)
50th Percentile (median)
($)
75th Percentile
($)
Base Salary
10,105
17,306
37,592
Total Remuneration
10,105
17,306
37,592
The figures above include gratuities directly billed to
our guests, if applicable, but excludes any cash
gratuities that may be paid directly to an employee
by guests. It also excludes room and meals,
transportation to and from the ship, and medical
care, which are provided to our crew members without
charge.
Factors influencing this year’s result include the
continued return to service of a large number of ship-
board personnel and shoreside personnel, the hire
of replacement employees and both the change in
CEO and the 2022 pay outcome for the CEO
The UK CEO Pay Ratio is likely to vary, potentially
significantly, over time since it will be driven largely
by variable pay outcomes for our CEO and changes in
our employee population over time. As a result, and
depending on our performance and employee
population, the UK CEO Pay Ratio could increase or
decrease significantly in future fiscal years. For the
reasons described above, the median ratio may not be
representative of our pay and progression policies.
2.8
RELATIVE IMPORTANCE OF SPEND ON PAY (NOT AUDITED)
$0
$1,954
$0
$2,679
$0
$500
$1,000
$1,500
$2,000
$2,500
$3,000
Profit distributed by way of dividend and share
buybacks(1)
Overall expenditure on pay(2)
$'millions
2021
2022
% change: 37.1%
Relative importance of spend on pay
% change: 0%
(1)
No profits were distributed by way of dividend or by way of share buyback during fiscal 2022 and fiscal 2021. The Stock Swap
Program is not treated as constituting a share buyback for the purposes of this graph.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-12
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
(2)
Overall expenditure on pay has been calculated on a broadly consistent approach to the standard UK approach to calculating
this amount and includes all global staff using normal accounting conventions for benefits and includes expected value
assumptions in respect of share grants and so is not consistent with methodologies used elsewhere in this Part II.
2.9
SINGLE FIGURE TABLE (AUDITED)
EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS
The compensation of the Executive Directors of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc for fiscal 2022 and 2021 is
as follows:
Executive Director
Josh Weinstein
(1)
Arnold W. Donald
Micky Arison
$000
2022
2022
2021
2022
2021
Salary
417
1,500
1,500
0
(7)
0
(7)
Benefits
(2)
26
334
104
94
121
Pension
(3)
3
11
10
0
0
Total – Fixed
446
1,845
1,614
94
121
Annual Bonus
(4)
919
3,300
6,000
―
―
Equity Grants
Multi-Year Incentives
(performance-based)
(4)
405
(5)
2,347
(6)
204
―
―
Other Equity Grants
(time-based)
0
0
7,450
(8)
―
―
Total – Variable
1,324
5,647
13,654
0
0
Total
1,770
7,492
15,268
94
121
(1)
Mr. Weinstein became an Executive Director on August 1, 2022. Values reflect prorated compensation for the period from
August 1, 2022 through November 30, 2022, except for equity grants that are included at full estimated value.
(2)
Details of the matters for Mr. Donald provided within “Benefits” are disclosed in (and taken from) the “All Other Compensation”
table in the “Compensation Tables” section of the Proxy Statement (other than employer contributions to Mr. Donald under
the Carnival Corporation Fun Ship Savings Plan, a 401(k) plan which are included in “Pension”). Benefits provided to Mr. Weinstein
include ($000): private medical health insurance costs ($19), automobile lease or allowance ($5), and the following other
benefits: accidental death or dismemberment and disability and life insurance premiums ($0.8), personal air travel ($0.6),
spousal meals ($0.3) and gross ups for taxes on certain benefits ($0.08). Benefits provided to Mr. Arison include ($000): private
medical health insurance costs ($39), driver and security ($20), automobile lease or allowance ($17) and the following other
benefits: accidental death or dismemberment and disability and life insurance premiums ($2), automobile repairs and expenses
($8) and gross ups for taxes on certain benefits ($7). Consistent with past practice, benefits reflect the position under U.S.
rules as no UK tax is payable.
(3)
Represents employer contributions under the Carnival Corporation Fun Ship Savings Plan, a 401(k) plan.
(4)
Details of the performance measures and targets applicable to the annual bonus for fiscal 2022 are set out in “Implementation
of Approved Policy” section above and in the “Annual Bonuses” section in Part I of the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report. No element of the annual bonus is subject to deferral.
(5)
The 2022 amount includes $25,969 and $378,962 the estimated values of the 2020 Annual PBS and 2020 Special PBS grants for
which the performance period ended on November 30, 2022, including estimated additional shares to be provided to the
2020 PBS grant to take into account any dividends paid during the period. These grants were made to Mr. Weinstein prior to
his promotion to the CEO role and vest in February 2023. The estimated annual and special PBS values were calculated using the
$8.99 average share price (rounded to the nearest cent) over the last three months of the fiscal year. There was no share
price appreciation with respect to either PBS grant. Please refer to “Disclosure of Prior Years’ Grant Results” in Part I for details
of the performance conditions met and the number of shares vesting. The estimated value of dividend equivalents to be
delivered in additional shares at vesting is $1,369.
(6)
The 2022 amount includes $519,673 and $1,827,797, the estimated values of the 2020 Annual PBS and 2020 Special PBS grants
for which the performance period ended on November 30, 2022, including estimated additional shares to be provided to the
2020 PBS grant to take into account any dividends paid during the period. These grants vest in February 2023. The estimated
annual and special PBS values were calculated using the $8.99 average share price (rounded to the nearest cent) over the last
three months of the fiscal year. There was no share price appreciation with respect to either PBS grant. Please refer to
“Disclosure of Prior Years’ Grant Results” in Part I for details of the performance conditions met and the number of shares
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-13
vesting. The estimated value of dividend equivalents to be delivered in additional shares at vesting is $27,384. The amount for
2021 has been updated to include the release date values and dividend reinvestment in respect of the 2019 PBS grant.
(7)
Effective April 1, 2020, at Mr. Arison’s request in order to preserve cash, Carnival Corporation suspended his salary. The
suspension remained in effect through November 30, 2022.
(8)
There has been no share price appreciation with respect to the 2021 TBS grant.
NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS
Compensation of our Non-Executive Directors is set
by the Boards, upon recommendation of the
Compensation Committees following the
Compensation Committees’ annual review of Director
compensation. No non-Executive Director is involved
in approving their own compensation.
The compensation of the Non-Executive Directors of
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc for fiscal 2022 is
as follows. The format is different from the preceding
table for Executive Directors as certain aspects (such
as bonus and pension) do not apply to Non-
Executive Directors.
Fees
Restricted
Stock
(1)
Total
2022
2021
2022
2021
2022
2021
Non-Executive Director
($000)
Sir Jonathon Band
140
140
175
175
315
315
Jason Glen Cahilly
110
110
175
175
285
285
Helen Deeble
110
110
175
175
285
285
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
110
110
175
175
285
285
Richard J. Glasier
140
140
175
175
315
315
Katie Lahey
110
110
175
175
285
285
Sara Mathew
(2)
5
N/A
76
N/A
81
N/A
Sir John Parker
110
110
175
175
285
285
Stuart Subotnick
140
140
175
175
315
315
Laura Weil
110
110
175
175
285
285
Randall Weisenburger
195
195
175
175
370
370
(1)
Restricted stock grants are structured as restricted stock (with dividends paid as they arise) at the election of the Director. The
reported figures are the value of the grants made during the year using April 8, 2022 closing price of Carnival Corporation shares,
other than for Ms. Mathew which is based on the value of the grant made to her on November 14, 2022, which uses the
November 14, 2022 closing price of Carnival Corporation shares.
(2)
Ms. Mathew was appointed to the Boards on November 14, 2022.
The Non-Executive Directors did not receive any benefits in fiscal 2022 and 2021. The aggregate emoluments
(being salary, bonuses, fees and benefits, and excluding long-term incentives and pensions) of all Directors during
fiscal 2022 were approximately $9.7 million.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-14
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
2.10
SCHEME INTERESTS MADE TO DIRECTORS IN FISCAL 2022
(AUDITED)
The LMCG Regulations require disclosure of grants
made in the year plus a table of aggregate outstanding
awards, separately detailing grants that vest in the
year. The latter information is included in Section 2.11
Directors’ Shareholding and Share Interests below.
Director
Grant
Date
Plan
(1)
Number
of Shares
Face
Value
(2)
($)
Threshold
Vesting
Level
(3)
(%)
Vesting Level
at Maximum
Performance
(3)(4)
(%)
Anticipated
Vesting Date
Micky Arison
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Arnold W. Donald
2/4/2022
ERA RSU
300,601
5,999,996
50
150
2/15/2025
2/4/2022
ERA Cash
N/A
6,000,000
50
150
2/15/2025
Josh Weinstein
8/22/2022
LTPBS
500,000
4,695,000
50
200
2/15/2028
2/4/2022
ERA Cash
N/A
5,000,000
50
150
2/15/2025
Sir Jonathon Band
4/8/2022
Restricted
Stock
9,541
174,982
N/A
100
4/8/2025
Jason Glen Cahilly
4/8/2022
Restricted
Stock
9,541
174,982
N/A
100
4/8/2025
Helen Deeble
4/8/2022
Restricted
Stock
9,541
174,982
N/A
100
4/8/2025
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
(3)
4/8/2022
Restricted
Stock
9,541
174,982
N/A
100
4/8/2025
Richard J. Glasier
4/8/2022
Restricted
Stock
9,541
174,982
N/A
100
4/8/2025
Katie Lahey
4/8/2022
Restricted
Stock
9,541
174,982
N/A
100
4/8/2025
Sara Mathew
11/14/2022
Restricted
Stock
7,146
75,748
N/A
100
4/8/2025
Sir John Parker
4/8/2022
Restricted
Stock
9,541
174,982
N/A
100
4/8/2025
Stuart Subotnick
4/8/2022
Restricted
Stock
9,541
174,982
N/A
100
4/8/2025
Laura Weil
4/8/2022
Restricted
Stock
9,541
174,982
N/A
100
4/8/2025
Randall Weisenburger
4/8/2022
Restricted
Stock
9,541
174,982
N/A
100
4/8/2025
(1)
The terms of ERA and LTPBS incentive programs to the respective Executive Directors and the terms of restricted stock grants
to Non-Executive Directors and the basis on which these grants are made are summarized in the table above are described in the
“Non-Executive Director Compensation” and “Compensation Tables” sections of the Proxy Statement. Although subject to a
future vesting date, a Non-Executive Director restricted stock grant becomes non-forfeitable one year after their first election
to the Boards.
(2)
Face values for all grants are calculated using the closing share prices at the relevant grant dates, being $19.96 at February 4,
2022 for Mr. Donald, $9.39 at August 22, 2022 for Mr. Weinstein, $10.60 for Ms. Mathew at November 14, 2022 and $18.34 at
April 8, 2022 for all other Non-Executive Directors.
(3)
The restricted stock grants to Non-Executive Directors do not include performance conditions.
(4)
The face value of awards reflects the target value. If the performance conditions are fully met, vesting may be at up to 200% of
the percentage indicated of the target number of shares.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-15
2.11
DIRECTORS’ SHAREHOLDING AND SHARE INTERESTS (AUDITED)
The stock ownership policies for Executive and
Non-Executive Directors provide that all Executive
and Non-Executive Directors are required to own
shares (inclusive of unvested restricted shares, RSU
and shares in a trust beneficially owned by a Director)
of either Carnival Corporation common stock or
Carnival plc ordinary shares with a value equal to
six times base salary for the CEO Executive Director
and five times the cash retainer for Non-Executive
Directors while they are employed or serving. All new
Directors must achieve this requirement no later
than five years from the date of their initial
appointment or election to the Boards by the
shareholders. The stock ownership policies for
Executive and Non-Executive Directors provide that a
Director will be deemed to be in compliance with the
ownership requirements if the decline in the
Carnival Corporation or Carnival plc share price
results in the Director falling below the applicable
ownership level, provided that they were in
compliance prior to the share price movement and
do not sell or transfer ownership of any such shares
until after the ownership target has again been
achieved, unless otherwise approved by the Boards
of Directors. Each of the Directors serving in fiscal 2022
is in compliance with this Board-mandated
requirement.
The following table shows the total outstanding
shares as at November 30, 2022 under any incentive
plans, as well as shares that vested during fiscal 2022:
Shares (including Restricted Shares and RSUs)
Director
Grants Without
Performance
Conditions That Have
Not Vested
(1)
Grants With
Performance Conditions
That Have Not Vested
Number of Shares
Acquired on Vesting
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Micky Arison
—
—
—
Josh Weinstein
38,954
537,697
(2)
38,030
Arnold W. Donald
237,973
572,560
(2)
214,001
NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Sir Jonathon Band
30,435
N/A
3,193
Jason Glen Cahilly
30,435
N/A
3,193
Helen Deeble
30,435
N/A
3,193
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
29,108
N/A
0
Richard J. Glasier
30,435
N/A
3,193
Katie Lahey
30,435
N/A
3,193
Sara Mathew
7,146
N/A
—
Sir John Parker
30,435
N/A
3,193
Stuart Subotnick
30,435
N/A
3,193
Laura Weil
30,435
N/A
3,193
Randall Weisenburger
30,435
N/A
3,193
(1)
Restricted shares granted to the Non-Executive Directors are subject to service conditions prior to the anniversary of their first
election to the Boards and are forfeitable until that time.
(2)
Dividend equivalent shares will be added for the 2020 PBS grant to take into account dividends paid during the period.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-16
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
All Directors receive Carnival Corporation common stock, which are denominated in U.S. dollars.
Details of the Directors’ interests and their connected persons are as follows*:
Carnival plc
Carnival Corporation
Director
November 30,
2021
November 30,
2022
November 30,
2021**
November 30,
2022**
Micky Arison
―
―
121,136,034
121,136,034
(1)
Sir Jonathon Band
―
―
42,951
52,492
Jason Glen Cahilly
―
―
29,050
38,591
Helen Deeble
―
―
31,759
41,300
Arnold W. Donald
―
―
607,160
707,118
(2)
Jeffrey J. Gearhart
―
―
21,313
30,854
Richard J. Glasier
―
―
60,507
70,048
(3)
Katie Lahey
―
―
26,301
35,842
Sara Mathew
(4)
―
―
N/A
7,146
Sir John Parker
10,052
3,004
53,127
62,668
Stuart Subotnick
―
―
73,870
83,411
Laura Weil
―
―
73,067
82,608
Josh Weinstein
(5)
N/A
―
N/A
4,955
Randall Weisenburger
―
―
761,409
870,950
*
For consistency with the “Share Ownership of Certain Beneficial Owners and Management” section of the Proxy Statement, the
above table includes restricted stock (but not RSUs) held. For RSUs held by Josh Weinstein and Arnold W. Donald, the only two
Directors who hold RSUs, see the first and second columns in the prior table.
**
As part of the establishment of the DLC arrangement, Carnival plc issued a special voting share to Carnival Corporation, which
transferred such share to the trustee of the P&O Princess Special Voting Trust (the “Trust”), a trust established under the laws of
the Cayman Islands. Shares of beneficial interest in the Trust were transferred to Carnival Corporation. The trust shares
represent a beneficial interest in the Carnival plc special voting share. Immediately following the transfer, Carnival Corporation
distributed such trust shares by way of a dividend to holders of shares of common stock of Carnival Corporation. Under a pairing
agreement, the trust shares are paired with, and evidenced by, certificates representing shares of Carnival Corporation common
stock on a one-for-one basis. In addition, under the pairing agreement, when a share of Carnival Corporation common stock
is issued to a person after the implementation of the DLC arrangement, a paired trust share will be issued at the same time to
such person. Each share of Carnival Corporation common stock and the paired trust share may not be transferred separately.
Each share of Carnival Corporation common stock and the paired plc special voting share are listed and trade together on the
New York Stock Exchange under the ticker symbol “CCL.” Accordingly, each holder of Carnival Corporation common stock is
also deemed to be the beneficial owner of an equivalent number of trust shares.
(1)
Includes (i) 1,625,577 shares of common stock held by the Nickel KA 2022 Annuity Trust No. 1, (ii) 1,625,577 shares of common
stock held by the Nickel KA 2022 Annuity Trust No. 2, (iii) 80,736,445 shares of common stock held by MA 1994 B Shares, L.P.,
(iv) 35,465,423 shares of common stock held by the Artsfare 2005 Trust No. 2 by virtue of the authority granted to Mr. Arison
under the last will of Ted Arison, (v) 841,506 shares of common stock held by the NA 2017-08 Trust and (vi) 841,506 shares held
by the KA 2017-08 Trust.
(2)
Includes 665,157 shares held by The Arnold W. Donald Revocable Trust UAD 5/26/98.
(3)
Includes 23,792 shares held by The Richard J. Glasier Revocable Living Trust.
(4)
Ms. Mathew was appointed to the Boards effective November 14, 2022.
(5)
Mr. Weinstein was appointed to the Boards effective August 1, 2022.
There were no changes in the above share interests between December 1, 2022 and January 12, 2023, the latest
practicable date.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-17
2.12
TOTAL PENSION ENTITLEMENTS (AUDITED)
Mr. Arison continues to be eligible for a benefit under
the Carnival Corporation Nonqualified Retirement
Plan for Highly Compensated Employees (the
“Retirement Plan”). Mr. Arison’s benefits under the
Retirement Plan were calculated based on age, length
of service with Carnival Corporation and the average
of his five highest consecutive years of compensation
out of the last 10 years of service. The benefit
formula provides an annual benefit accrual equal to
1% of his earnings for the year up to “covered
compensation” plus 1.6% of earnings for the year in
excess of covered compensation then multiplied by
his years of service up to a maximum of 30 years of
credited service. The elements of compensation to
determine his benefits were his base salary and annual
bonus up to the U.S. statutory limitations under
Section 401(a)(17) of the U.S. Internal Revenue Code.
Mr. Arison’s accrued benefit was fully paid out in
March 2020. It is not expected that Mr. Arison will
accrue any additional benefits under the Retirement
Plan under the terms of the program. Mr. Donald is
not eligible to participate in the Retirement Plan.
Details of the retirement benefits of current Directors
arising from their participation in defined benefit
pension arrangements are as follows:
Executive Director
Accrued Benefit
(1)
at
Nov. 30, 2022
($000)
Increase in Accrued
Benefits including
Inflation
($000)
Value of Increase in Accrued
Benefits Net of Inflation and
Directors’ Contributions
($000)
Micky Arison
0
0
0
Josh Weinstein
―
―
―
Arnold W. Donald
―
―
―
(1)
The accrued benefit is that pension which would be paid annually on retirement at the normal retirement age of 65 under the
Retirement Plan based on service to November 30, 2022. Current Directors are not entitled to any early retirement benefits.
2.13
PAYMENTS FOR LOSS OF OFFICE (AUDITED)
No payments for loss of office (as that term is defined in the LMCG Regulations) were made during the year.
2.14
PAYMENTS TO PAST DIRECTORS (AUDITED)
Upon completion of the DLC transaction, Lord
Sterling was appointed as Life President of P&O
Cruises and Special Adviser to Micky Arison, Chair of
Carnival Corporation & plc. As Special Adviser, Lord
Sterling is entitled to receive fees for his services at the
rate of £25,000 per year payable in quarterly
installments in arrears.
See “Outgoing CEO Consulting Agreement” in Part I of
the Directors’ Remuneration Report for a description
of the terms of the consulting agreement with
Arnold W. Donald. Mr. Donald will also receive the
2022 MTE ($2,200,000 grant value) and 2022 PBS
($3,850,000 grant value) grants to be issued in
fiscal 2023 because of his transition from employment
to consulting without a break in service as more
fully described in Part I under “Disclosure and the
Timing of Long-Term Incentive and Equity-Based
Compensation.”
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-18
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
Section B: Directors’ Remuneration Policy (not audited)
PROVISION 40 DISCLOSURES
The Compensation Committees believe that Executive Director remuneration policy and practices address all of
the factors listed in Provision 40 of the UK Corporate Governance Code, as outlined below:
Clarity
Our compensation structure for Executive Directors is clearly and transparently explained and
disclosed. We provide detailed disclosures on the performance measurements and vesting
schedules used in annual and long term incentives. We also conduct shareholder outreach to
ensure shareholders understand our executive compensation program.
Simplicity
Our compensation program for our Executive Directors includes elements that are disclosed
and explained in detail and that links compensation for our CEO, the only Executive Director
that received salary, annual incentive and long-term incentives in fiscal 2022, to our long-term
success and interests of our shareholders.
Predictability
Target values, performance metric ranges and formulas for all performance-based
compensation elements and payout ranges for bonuses are disclosed and explained. Use of
discretion if any, is also disclosed and explained. The scenario chart illustrates potential
payout scenarios under the new policy.
Proportionality
The annual and long-term incentives for our CEO in fiscal 2022 are linked to the fulfilment of
quantitative performance measures and align the CEO’s compensation with our long-term
performance and long-term value creation for our shareholders. The Compensation
Committees retain discretion to ensure that rewards under the incentives reflect
performance.
Risk
Our Compensation Committees conduct an annual assessment, with support from
management and the Compensation Committees’ independent consultants, to ensure our
executive compensation program does not encourage excessive risk taking. Our executive
compensation program is based on a pay-for-performance philosophy and provides a mix of
long-term and short term cash and equity awards that is intended to motivate management
to drive performance in short and long term and align interests with our shareholders. Bonus
payout is limited to 200% and performance ranges for all long term incentives are disclosed
and limited. Our policy limits the risk of unfair or excessive remuneration through the
following measures:
•
Clearly defined limits on the maximum opportunities of incentive awards
•
Powers of discretion for our Compensation Committees to adjust formulaic outcomes
of incentive awards to ensure payouts are aligned to performance
•
Malus and clawback provisions on all incentives
Alignment with
Culture
Our CEO’s compensation in fiscal 2022 is designed to drive behavior aligned with our culture,
values and strategy, for example by tying annual and long term incentives to achievement of
health, environment, safety and security, and sustainability measures and our Culture
Essentials, in addition to operating performance metrics. We also have a stock ownership
policy which sets minimum shareholding requirements for our executive officers and all
Directors.
The following section contains the material required to be set out in the 2023 Policy for the purposes of Part 4 of
the LMCG Regulations. If approved by shareholders, the 2023 Policy is to take effect from April 21, 2023 (being
the date of the Annual General Meeting).
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-19
1.
FUTURE POLICY TABLES
GENERAL STATEMENT ON POLICY
The future policy tables set forth below apply in
respect of the Directors. Once approved by the
shareholders at the 2023 Annual Meetings, they have
mandatory force, which means that payments may
not be made outside the scope of the 2023 Policy
without prior shareholder approval of an amendment
to the 2023 Policy. The 2023 Policy is in a similar
format to the 2020 Policy and all key changes are
summarized in an additional column to the tables.
For a description of the Boards’ processes to identify
and mitigate conflicts of interests, please refer to
“Board Balance and Independence” in the Carnival
plc Corporate Governance Report.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-20
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS
Element
Purpose and
Link to Strategy
Operation
Maximum
Performance Conditions
Changes to the
Policy
Context of
Policy
As a U.S. headquartered business with most senior executives based in the U.S., the Compensation Committees’ overall
approach to total compensation is to set pay by reference to U.S. market practice. Similarly, the design of bonus and long-term
incentives is largely driven from a U.S. context.
All Executive Directors serving in fiscal 2022 or anticipated to serve in fiscal 2023 were located in the U.S.
Carnival plc has been advised that, to comply with the regulations, each element of pay needs to be subject to a monetary
limit. Those limits are to ensure such compliance and are not reflective of any form of aspiration and are unlikely to have any
practical impact on setting appropriate compensation levels.
Base Salary
Provide a baseline level of
fixed compensation that
reflects level of responsibility.
Salaries are reviewed after
results for the prior fiscal year
are available.
Salaries may be increased if
merited by performance or
other market factors in order
to attract or retain our
executives.
Each year a competitive
market review is undertaken
to assist the Compensation
Committees in their
assessments. This
assessment is undertaken
against companies that the
Compensation Committees
consider to be appropriate.
This data is used to inform
considerations rather than to
benchmark to any particular
peer group level and the
Compensation Committees
apply appropriate judgment
in consideration of the data.
As a consequence of the
LMCG Regulations, the
Compensation Committees
need flexibility to consider
appropriate increases so will
operate to an individual cap
of $2.5 million per annum
with this level increasing from
the date of approval by the
increase from the date of
approval in U.S. Consumer
Price Index or (a similar
measure of inflation if this
ceases to be readily available).
It will apply the factors set out
in the previous column in
considering salary
adjustments and will not
automatically gravitate to the
maximum.
None
None
Annual Bonus
To focus executives’ attention
on achieving outstanding
Carnival Corporation & plc
performance against pre-
determined financial targets
as well as other relevant
measures.
Provides flexibility in
rewarding favorable individual
and overall company
The annual bonus plan is
referred to as the Carnival
Corporation & plc
Management Incentive Plan
(“MIP”).
Performance measures are
chosen for each performance
period to focus participants
on achieving appropriate
financial performance results
200% of target bonus. The
Compensation Committees
reserve the right to reduce
(but not increase)
this percentage.
Target bonuses may be set on
such basis as the
Compensation Committees
consider to be appropriate
and, in particular, may be
The Compensation
Committees may set such
performance measures and
targets for the annual bonus
as they consider appropriate.
These performance measures
may be financial or non-
financial and corporate,
divisional or individual and in
such proportions as the
None
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-21
Element
Purpose and
Link to Strategy
Operation
Maximum
Performance Conditions
Changes to the
Policy
performance.
as well as other relevant
measures.
At or following the
commencement of each fiscal
year, the Compensation
Committees determine the
target bonus for each
participant by reference to
such metrics they consider to
be appropriate.
Following the end of each
fiscal year, the Compensation
Committees confirm the
performance condition
outcomes and the preliminary
bonus for each participant.
This preliminary bonus is then
moderated, which may
increase or decrease the final
bonus amount – see
performance conditions.
Bonuses are all currently paid
in cash although the
Compensation Committees
reserve discretion to build in
the ability to defer part of the
bonus (whether into cash or
shares).
It is currently anticipated that
the bonus will continue to be
cash settled.
Carnival Corporation & plc has
a clawback provision
applicable to the annual
bonus. The clawback
provisions may be modified
from time to time but
currently apply in the case of
fraud, negligence, intentional
or gross misconduct or other
wrongdoing on the part of an
individual that results in a
adjusted each year to reflect
changes in the performance
metrics for the year.
The target levels are set for
each fiscal year as described
in the preceding column. The
LMCG Regulations refer to the
need to set a maximum which
will apply for up to a three-
year period. The
Compensation Committees
will not set a target level in
excess of $5 million per
Director.
Compensation Committees
consider appropriate.
The starting point for
assessment of any financial
targets will normally be to
review the reported figures in
the Annual Report although
the Compensation
Committees may make
adjustments to the reported
figures to determine a
position which, in their view,
better reflects the underlying
performance.
No payout is earned unless
the threshold level of
performance is met. At
threshold, target and
maximum, such level as the
Compensation Committees
determine for that year
(currently: 50%, 100% and
200% of target respectively)
will be provisionally granted.
However, this amount is not
thereby guaranteed as such
provisional figure is subject to
the Compensation
Committees considering
wider performance under the
moderation described below.
Moderation
The Compensation
Committees may moderate
(up or down but in all cases
subject to the over- riding
bonus cap for that year) the
preliminary bonus outcomes
in relation to financial
outcomes taking account of
both technical factors (such
as the impact of changes in
accounting principles),
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-22
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
Element
Purpose and
Link to Strategy
Operation
Maximum
Performance Conditions
Changes to the
Policy
material restatement of the
issued financial statements.
Clawback would also apply for
any other event or
circumstance set forth in any
claw- back policy actually
implemented, including,
without limitation, any
clawback policy adopted to
comply with the requirements
of the U.S. Dodd- Frank Wall
Street Reform Act and any
applicable rules or
regulations.
unusual gains and losses and
other events outside the
control of management and
individual performance (such
as successful implementation
of strategic initiatives) as
more fully detailed in Part I.
Such moderation is a
judgmental assessment by
the Compensation
Committees and not subject
to formulae.
Long-Term
Incentive
Compensation
•
To recognize scope of
r
esponsibilities
•
To reward demonstrated
performance and
leadership
•
To motivate future superior
performance
•
To align the interests of the
executive with our
shareholders’ long-term
interests
•
To encourage the retention
of key executives
Each of Carnival Corporation
& plc has adopted broad
omnibus plans—the Carnival
Corporation 2020 Stock Plan
and the Carnival plc 2014
Employee Share Plan.
Each of these plans permit
equity grants to be made in a
wide variety of forms
including market value
options, stock-appreciation
rights (“SARs”) and restricted
stock or restricted stock unit
grants and cash-based
awards, each of which may or
may not be subject to vesting
performance measures as the
Compensation Committees
consider appropriate.
The Compensation
Committees reserve the right
to use all aspects of the
omnibus plans as approved
by the shareholders.
Current practice (but without
limiting the powers within the
plan rules) is to operate a
program under which one or
more forms of grants are
The Carnival Corporation 2020
Stock Plan and Carnival plc
2014 Employee Share Plan
rules have individual
maximum limits and the
Committees operate to these
limits.
As those rules were drafted
without regard to the UK
regulations, the Committees
have set a separate limit that
grants, under all aspects of
the plans, will not exceed
$25 million in the year of
grant. This figure looks at
levels before the application
of any performance multiplier
and looks at the cash value
used to determine awards
whether cash or equity
denominated (if equity
denominated, the cash
amount will be converted to
shares using a share price at
or near to the date of grant or
as a fixed number of shares).
Under the rules, if options are
granted, they are valued at
one-third of the grant date
value. It should be noted that
The balance and mix of equity
grants will be set at the
discretion of the
Compensation Committees
and the Compensation
Committees may set such
performance conditions on
the performance grants as
they consider appropriate
(whether financial, which may
include, but not be limited to,
earnings per share (“EPS”),
earnings before interest and
taxes (“EBIT”), operating
income (“OI”), return on
invested capital (“ROIC”) or
total shareholder return
(“TSR”) and/or non- financial
and whether corporate,
divisional or individual).
The plans allow the
Compensation Committees to
exercise negative discretion,
to reduce or eliminate the
formulaic results of a
performance grant.
Performance grants may not
be subject to additional
performance conditions after
No change to
the approach
to limits is
anticipated
which has
always been
to comply
with the rules
of the various
shareholder
approved
plans. To
ensure
compliance
with the UK
regulations,
an inner limit
has been
introduced
which is a
limit and not
an aspiration.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-23
Element
Purpose and
Link to Strategy
Operation
Maximum
Performance Conditions
Changes to the
Policy
made each year. These may
include, but are not limited to:
•
Performance-Based Share
(“PBS”) Grants:
—
subject to a three year
performance-based
vesting;
—
allocations determined by
taking account of
aggregate market
positioning of total direct
compensation;
—
allow a maximum vesting
of up to 200% of the
number of shares granted
as the target grant with
50% (although different
percentages may apply to
future grants) of target
payable for achieving the
threshold; and
—
no entrenched vesting
regardless of
performance on
retirement included.
•
Time-Based Share (“TBS”)
Grants:
—
subject to a three-year
annual pro-rata vesting;
—
allocations determined by
taking account of
aggregate market
positioning of total direct
compensation.
Each form of performance or
time-vested grant may be
structured as restricted
stock units with dividend
equivalents accrued to
vesting. In practice, PBS and
TBS grants have been
this inner limit has been
drafted to comply with the UK
regulations and does not
reflect an intent or aspiration
(the CEO’s fiscal 2023 target
value is $5 million).
In practice, awards will be
made having regard to
competitive compensation
data in the U.S. (and
elsewhere as the
Compensation Committees
consider relevant) and to the
Compensation Committees’
assessment as to what is
appropriate in light of
business strategy, competitive
data and the experience and
caliber of the individuals.
the initial performance
condition used to determine
grant value is completed as
the size of the initial grant
may be determined by
reference to pre- grant
performance assessment.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-24
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
Element
Purpose and
Link to Strategy
Operation
Maximum
Performance Conditions
Changes to the
Policy
structured as restricted
stock units and dividend
equivalents have accrued to
vesting. Consistent with US
practice, once vested, the
recipient may hold or sell the
shares, subject to our Stock
Ownership Policy.
Clawback and forfeiture
provisions can apply to
performance or time-vested
grants in the event of material
restatement of the Carnival
Corporation & plc’s issued
financial statements or in the
event of an individual
breaching continuing
obligations following the
termination of his or her
employment. These
provisions may be varied
from time to time.
While not currently utilized
for Executive Directors, the
share plans described above
permit the operation of share
options and SARs and the
grant of fully vested
unrestricted stock. Both
options and SARs operate
similarly, with a market value
“strike price” and vesting
schedules to be determined
at the time of grant in
accordance with prevailing
practice. The difference
between share options and
SARs relates only to the
settlement process, with the
exercise of SARs being
satisfied by the issue or
transfer of shares equal to the
holder’s gain net of exercise
prices and all relevant payroll
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-25
Element
Purpose and
Link to Strategy
Operation
Maximum
Performance Conditions
Changes to the
Policy
taxes.
Carnival Corporation & plc will
honor the vesting of all grants
made under previous policies
in accordance with the terms
of such grants.
Benefits
To provide perquisites
representative of common
practice for Executive
Directors and to enable the
Executive Director to give
maximum attention to their
role.
The Compensation
Committees review
perquisites provided
periodically.
Details are set out in the All
Other Compensation table in
the Executive Compensation
section of the Proxy
Statement and may include,
but are not limited to:
•
various insurance policies
•
automobile lease or
allowance
•
personal use of aircraft
•
other personal air travel
•
tax planning and return
preparation fees
•
driver and security
•
the ability to take cruises
under the cruise policy
•
living accommodations and
maintenance (where
considered appropriate)
•
relocation expenses
The Compensation
Committees reserve
discretion to introduce new
benefits where they conclude
that it is in the interests of the
Carnival Corporation & plc to
do so, having regard to the
particular circumstances and
to market practice. The LMCG
Regulations require that a
maximum is prescribed for
each element of
compensation. It is not
possible to prescribe the likely
change in the cost of insured
benefits or the cost of some
of the other reported benefits
so a monetary limit of
$1 million per executive has
been set although, the
Compensation Committees
will monitor the costs in
practice and ensure that the
overall costs do not increase
by more than what the
Compensation Committees
consider to be appropriate in
all the circumstances.
N/A
None
While the Compensation
Committees do not consider it
to form part of benefits in the
normal usage of that term,
they have been advised that
travel and/or corporate
hospitality (whether paid for
Consistent with prior years,
the benefits have been valued
in this Part II on a consistent
basis to the Executive
Compensation section of the
Proxy Statement and the
above limit will be assessed
on this basis.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-26
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
Element
Purpose and
Link to Strategy
Operation
Maximum
Performance Conditions
Changes to the
Policy
by Carnival Corporation & plc
or another and whether
provided to the Director or a
family member) may
technically come within the
UK definition so the
Compensation Committees
expressly reserve the right for
Carnival Corporation & plc to
authorize attendance at such
activities within its agreed
policies.
Executive Directors are also
eligible to participate in the
employee stock purchase
plans (or if applicable to
them, equivalent non-U.S.
plans) operated by
Carnival Corporation & plc, in
line with U.S. Internal Revenue
Service or UK His Majesty’s
Revenue and Customs
guidelines, on the same basis
as for other eligible
employees.
Pensions
To attract and retain our
Executive Directors.
Defined benefit pension
provision was fixed due to U.S.
tax changes in 2009.
For the CEO and new
employees, the current
approach is for them to join
the all- employee pension
arrangements (a qualified
401(k) savings plan together
with a profit sharing
arrangement) on the same
basis as all U.S. employees of
Carnival Corporation.
While no change to the policy
on pension provision is
currently anticipated, the
Compensation Committees
Details are set out in the table
of “Total Pension
Entitlements” in the Part I
above.
As indicated in the previous
section, the LMCG Regulations
require the Compensation
Committees to operate with
an overall cap for each
element of remuneration and
so a figure of $1 million per
year of annual accrued value
per Executive Director has
been selected although the
Compensation Committees
will also ensure that the costs
operate within an inner limit
of being aligned to the
N/A
None
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-27
Element
Purpose and
Link to Strategy
Operation
Maximum
Performance Conditions
Changes to the
Policy
reserve the right to consider
the appropriate policy having
regard to the needs of the
companies and to relevant
market data.
Carnival Corporation & plc will
honor the pensions
obligations entered into
under all previous policies in
accordance with the terms of
such obligations.
pension arrangements
available to all or most U.S,
employees of Carnival
Corporation.
Stock
Ownership
Guidelines
For Executive Directors to
build and maintain a long-
term ownership position.
The guidelines are not
contractual and no penalty
arises if the Executive Director
does not comply.
Under the guidelines, shares
owned outright by the
executive and their
immediate family (and related
trusts) together (and
consistent with U.S. practice)
with any outstanding MTE
grants count towards the
guidelines. The Compensation
Committees reserve the right
to amend these guidelines as
they consider appropriate.
The Committees note that the
headline level of these
guidelines is higher than is
typical in for UK companies
which is appropriate given
our approach of following U.S.
practices. Consistent with
practice in the U.S., such
guidelines do not continue
following an executive’s
departure (although such an
executive may continue to be
at risk of recoupment under
our clawback policies for a
period).
Mr. Weinstein—six times base
salary
Mr. Arison—six times base
salary
Other senior executives have
guideline levels of three or
four times base salary.
The Compensation
Committees reserve the right
to increase (but not reduce)
these stock ownership
guidelines.
N/A
None.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-28
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
Notes:
1.
The rationale for all performance measures and the process for setting performance targets are explained in the relevant sections of the table.
2.
The general principle of the 2023 Policy is to remunerate people for their personal responsibility and contribution. In order to deliver this, different reward mechanisms are
used for different populations. Where the reward mechanisms differ, they reflect the appropriate market rate position for the relevant roles.
3.
The Companies’ approach to clawback is set out in the sections in the above table relating to bonus and long-term incentives.
NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS
Element
Purpose and
link to strategy
Operation
Maximum
Performance Conditions
Changes to the
Policy
Non-Executive
Directors’ Cash
Retainer
To appropriately compensate
Non- Executive Directors of
the highest caliber.
Fee levels are periodically
reviewed by the Boards
(without the Non-Executive
Directors voting on such
matters, although, to ensure
coherence of approach, the
Compensation Committees
may make recommendations
to the Boards) having regard
to external comparators. The
Boards exercise judgment as
to what they consider to be
reasonable in all the
circumstances both as
regards quantum and the mix
of pay and do not apply a
strict mathematical approach
to assessing such levels (i.e.
they do not automatically
apply a median level).
Within the stated maximum,
the Boards reserve the right
to consider how to structure
the Non-Executive Directors’
fees and whether to utilize a
general retainer, committee
membership, chairmanship,
attendance fees, or board
attendance or time-based or
travel allowances.
Currently, the Non-Executive
Directors receive an annual
cash retainer fee. Fees are
currently paid quarterly (but
this may be varied).
Under the LMCG Regulations,
Non- Executive Directors are
equally subject to policy caps
as their executive colleagues.
Accordingly, the Boards will
operate within a cash cap per
individual of $250,000 (which
may be doubled in the case of
a non-executive chair).
However, should the Boards
cease to make restricted
share grants as detailed
below, the cap for Directors’
cash retainer stated above
may be increased by the
maximum value of the
cap relating to restricted
share grants.
None
Provides for
increased cap
in the case
of a non-
executive
chair.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-29
Element
Purpose and
link to strategy
Operation
Maximum
Performance Conditions
Changes to the
Policy
Non-Executive Directors also
receive reimbursement of
travel related expenses.
Restricted
Stock Grants
To appropriately compensate
Non- Executive Directors of
the highest caliber.
To align Non- Executive
Directors’ interests with those
of shareholders.
Non-Executive Directors
receive annual restricted
share grants at such level as
the Boards consider to be
appropriate.
Grants vest after three years
and are not forfeitable after
one year of service from initial
election to the Boards.
Non-Executive Directors must
own shares with a value of at
least five times the annual
cash retainer. New non-
Executive Directors must
achieve this requirement
within the time frame
selected by the Boards
(currently five years from the
date of their initial election).
The Boards may increase (but
not reduce) this guidance. As
with the stock ownership
guidelines for executives, the
guidelines are not contractual
and no penalty arises if the
Director does not comply;
however, the Boards may
require some or all of the
Director’s cash retainer to be
delivered as fully vested stock
as they consider appropriate.
Under the guidelines, shares
owned outright by the
Non-Executive Director and
their immediate family (and
related trusts) together with
any outstanding restricted
stock grants count towards
the guidelines. The Boards
reserve the right to amend
these guidelines as they
The formal cap is $250,000
per individual (which may be
doubled in the case of a
non-executive chair).
However, should the Boards
cease to pay Non-Executive
Directors a cash retainer as
detailed above, the cap for
restricted share grants may
be increased by the maximum
value of the cap relating to
Non-Executive Directors’ cash
retainer.
No performance conditions
apply to ensure the Non-
Executive Directors maintain
their independence.
Provides for
increased cap
in the case of
a non-
executive
chair.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-30
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
Element
Purpose and
link to strategy
Operation
Maximum
Performance Conditions
Changes to the
Policy
consider appropriate.
Benefits
To encourage product
familiarization.
Non-Executive Directors are
encouraged to take cruises
for purposes of product
familiarization and pay a fare
of such rate as is determined
from time-to-time. Currently,
for the first 14 days per year,
Non-Executive Directors pay a
fare of $70 per person per
day for such cruises (or $150
per day in the case of
Seabourn), and for the next
30 days per year, pay a fare
of $200 per person per day
for such cruises, plus taxes,
fees and port expenses in
each case. All other charges
associated with the cruise
(e.g., air fares, fuel
supplements, fees, taxes and
port expenses, gratuities,
ground transfers, etc.) are the
responsibility of the Non-
Executive Director.
While the Boards do not
consider it to form part of
benefits in the normal usage
of that term, the Boards have
been advised that travel
and/or corporate hospitality
(whether paid for by the
Carnival Corporation & plc or
another and whether
provided to the Non-
Executive Director or a family
member) may technically
come within the UK definition
so the Boards expressly
reserve the right for Carnival
Corporation & plc to authorize
attendance at such activities
within its agreed policies.
The formal cap is $100,000
per individual although the
likely level is somewhat lower
and the benefit each year is
reflected in the table of
Non-Employee Director
compensation. Any benefits
under the cruise policy will be
valued for this purpose on an
incremental cost basis.
In addition, a departing gift
may be provided up to a value
of $25,000 per Non-Executive
Director on termination of
office.
None
None.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-31
2.
RECRUITMENT REMUNERATION POLICY
The following represents guidelines considered reasonable by the Compensation Committees, but they may
need to change in relation to securing an appropriate candidate whose appointment would, in their view, be in
shareholders’ best interests.
•
In terms of the principles for setting a package for
a new Executive Director, the starting point for the
Compensation Committees will be to look to the
general policy for Executive Directors as set out
above and structure a package in accordance with
that policy. However, as provided for in the relevant
regulations, the Compensation Committees
reserve the right to make payments of base salary
and make benefit or pension provisions outside of
the scope of the general policy (and its caps) for
Executive Directors to meet individual
circumstances of the recruitment (recognizing that
such events are inherently exceptional and
unplanned and that it would be disproportionate
to seek shareholder approval).
•
Ignoring any special recruitment arrangements
which may prove to be necessary, the annual bonus
and long-term incentive compensation
arrangements will operate (including the maximum
grant levels) as detailed in the general policies in
relation to any newly appointed Director.
•
For an internal appointment, any variable pay
element provided in respect of the prior role may
either continue on its original terms or be adjusted
to reflect the new appointment as appropriate.
•
For external and internal appointments, the
Compensation Committees may agree that Carnival
Corporation & plc will meet certain relocation
expenses as Compensation Committees consider
appropriate and/or to make a contribution towards
legal fees in connection with agreeing employment
terms.
•
Whether to enter into an employment agreement
and the terms of such agreement will be determined
at the time having regard to norms in the U.S.
and/ or where the executive will be based.
•
Where it is necessary to make a recruitment
related equity grant to an external candidate,
Carnival Corporation & plc will not pay more than
is, in the view of the Compensation Committees,
necessary and will in all cases seek, in the first
instance, to deliver any such grants under the terms
of the existing incentive pay structure. It may,
however, be necessary in some cases to make such
grants on terms that are more bespoke than the
existing annual and equity-based pay structures in
Carnival Corporation & plc in order to secure a
candidate. Details of any such grants will be
appropriately disclosed.
•
All such grants for external appointments (whether
to buy-out forfeited grants or negotiated as a
sign-on grant), whether under the annual bonus
plan, PBS, TBS or otherwise, will take account of the
nature, time-horizons and performance
requirements for any remuneration relinquished
by the individual when leaving a previous employer
and will only include guaranteed sums where the
Compensation Committees consider that it is
necessary to secure the recruitment.
•
For the avoidance of doubt, where recruitment
related grants are intended to replace existing
grants held by a candidate in an existing employer,
the maximum amounts for incentive pay as
stated in the general policies will not apply to such
grants. The Compensation Committees have not
placed a maximum limit on any such grants which
it may be necessary to make as it is not considered
to be in shareholders’ interests to set any
expectations for prospective candidates regarding
such grants. Any recruitment- related grants which
do not replace grants with a previous employer
will be subject to the limits as detailed in the general
policy.
A new Non-Executive Director would be recruited on
the terms explained above in respect of the main
policy for Non-Executive Directors.
A new Executive Director’s terms would be subject to
agreement on joining. The Compensation Committees
will not automatically replicate a predecessor’s
agreement and will have due regard to internal
provisions for other senior executives, developments
in market and best practice globally and to the
commercial circumstances at the time.
Mr. Weinstein.
Mr. Weinstein does not have an
employment agreement.
All elements of his compensation are subject to the
discretion of the Compensation Committees.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-32
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
3.
POLICY ON PAYMENTS FOR LOSS OF OFFICE
ALL EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS
For the avoidance of doubt, the LMCG Regulations do
not require the inclusion of a cap or limit in relation
to payments for loss of office. The Compensation
Committees will take all relevant factors into account
in deciding whether any discretion should be
exercised in an individual’s favor in these
circumstances, and the Compensation Committees
will aim to ensure that any payments made are, in
their view, appropriate in the context of where the
executive resides and are fair and reasonable.
In addition to any such payment, the Compensation
Committees reserve discretion to:
•
retain perquisites which they currently receive for
a period;
•
pay an annual bonus for the year of departure
(pro-rated to the period actually worked);
•
retain or accelerate vesting of any outstanding
equity grants; and
•
pay for other items, such as outplacement services,
legal fees, settlement payments and such other
payments as our legal advisors advise may be
necessary or expedient.
Further detail on the terms of the potential payments
upon termination or change of control are contained
in the Executive Compensation section of the Proxy
Statement.
Any amounts already accrued under non-qualified
deferred compensation arrangements or any pension-
related arrangements, which have already accrued
to the executive, will be retained and will not be a
termination payment.
Acceleration of share grants may occur following a
change of control if an executive’s position was
terminated or may occur following the termination of
their employment as disclosed in detail in the
Potential Payments upon Termination or Change of
Control part of the Executive Compensation section of
the Proxy Statement.
Mr. Arison.
The Compensation Committees have
adopted a policy not to enter into employment
contracts with longer-serving U.S. executives.
Accordingly, Carnival Corporation & plc do not have
an employment agreement with Mr. Arison that would
pay any cash severance benefits in connection with
termination of employment.
Mr. Weinstein
. Carnival Corporation & plc do not have
an employment agreement with Mr. Weinstein that
would pay any cash severance benefits in connection
with termination of employment.
NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS
The Non-Executive Directors are not entitled to any
compensation on termination but, once they have
served for at least one year, they will retain all
outstanding equity grants. Entitlement may be
accelerated in certain compassionate circumstances
or following a change of control. However, a departing
gift may be provided up to a value of $25,000 per
Non-Executive Director.
4.
PERFORMANCE SCENARIOS
The LMCG Regulations require the inclusion of
scenario charts for each Executive Director showing
the levels of compensation which an individual could
expect to earn under the 2023 Policy for fiscal 2023
in certain circumstances. To assist the reader, the
tables distinguish between MTE, PBS, TBS and SEA and
the other elements of fixed pay.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-33
Salary
Amounts in ($000s)
Bonus
PBS
TBS
$25,000
$20,000
$15,000
$10,000
$5,000
$0
Salary, $1,534
Salary, $1,534
TBS, $1,500
TBS, $1,500
PBS, $3,500
Bonus, $2,500
Salary, $1,534
PBS, $7,000
Bonus, $5,000
TBS, $2,250
Salary, $1,534
PBS, $10,500
$0
$0
$0
Bonus, $5,000
Minimum
On-target
Maximum
President, CEO and Chief Climate Officer - Josh Weinstein
Chair - Micky Arison
50% Share Price
Appreciation on
Maximum
Minimum
On-target
Maximum
Performance Charts
The assumptions used in the table are summarized below:
Minimum
•
“Salary” consists of base salary, benefits and pension.
•
Base salary is the salary to be paid in fiscal 2023.
•
Benefits measured as reported benefits received in fiscal 2022.
$000
Base
Salary
Benefits
Pension
Total
Fixed
Mr. Weinstein
1,250
284
—
1,534
Mr. Arison
0
94
0
94
On-target
Based on what the Executive Director would receive if performance was on-target:
•
Short term incentive consists of the target bonus ($2.5 million) set by the Compensation
Committees for fiscal 2023 for Mr. Weinstein and nil for Mr. Arison.
•
Long-term incentives for Mr. Weinstein include the expected target values of his PBS
($3.5 million) and TBS ($1.5 million) grants and nil for Mr. Arison. While the precise grant
levels are set each year, the Compensation Committees believe this is indicative of ongoing
policy.
Maximum
Based on the maximum compensation receivable (excluding share price appreciation and
dividends):
•
Short-term incentive consists of the maximum bonus (200% of target bonus).
•
Long-term incentive consists of the grant date value of the maximum number of PBS RSUs at
200% of target number and 100% of the TBS number of units.
Maximum plus
50% Share Price
Reflects the same position as the preceding Maximum except that share price appreciation of
50% has been assumed.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-34
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
Appreciation
5.
CONSIDERATION OF EMPLOYMENT CONDITIONS ELSEWHERE IN THE
GROUP
In determining the compensation policy and the
compensation payable to the Executive Directors, the
Compensation Committees took the pay and
employment conditions of employees of the Carnival
Corporation & plc group (“Carnival group”) into
account. The Carnival group’s pay policy ensures a
clear and direct link between the performance of the
Carnival group or relevant operating company and
compensation. Substantial use of performance-based
compensation not only ensures the continued
alignment of the interests of shareholders and senior
executives within the Carnival group, but also
enables the Carnival group to attract, retain and
motivate the talented people upon whom our success
depends. Carnival Corporation & plc is committed to
encouraging strong performance through a reward
system that aligns management’s interests with those
of its shareholders.
Across the workforce more broadly, many employees
participate in bonus and commission plans based
on the performance of their employing company.
Where locally competitive, employees are also
provided savings plans such as 401(k) plans, company-
sponsored pension plans, life insurance plans and a
range of other employment benefits. In addition
to these elements, the Carnival Corporation & plc also
issues share-based compensation to management
to incentivize, retain and recruit talent which
encourages an ownership culture among employees.
We do not operate any compensation or incentive
plans in which only Executive Directors participate.
In accordance with prevailing commercial practice, the
Compensation Committees did not consult with
employees in preparing the Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Policy. The Compensation Committees
take into account information provided by the
human resources function and external advisors.
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
|
B-35
6.
CONSIDERATION OF SHAREHOLDERS’ VIEWS
As described further in Part I, the Compensation
Committees took into account the approval levels of
compensation-related matters at our Annual General
Meetings in determining that the current
compensation philosophy and objectives remain
appropriate for use in determining the compensation
of Directors through analysis of proxy reports and
direct engagement with major investors, as
appropriate.
Carnival Corporation & plc has a long-standing
shareholder outreach program and interacts with
shareholders and proxy advisors on executive
compensation. The Compensation Committees
consider all constructive feedback received about
executive compensation. We continue to seek and
incorporate shareholder feedback in our
compensation deliberations, as appropriate. The
Compensation Committees have and will continue to
consider results from the annual shareholder
advisory votes, as well as other shareholder input,
when reviewing executive compensation programs
and policies.
On Behalf of the Board,
RANDALL WEISENBURGER
Chair of the Compensation Committees
January 27, 2023
Annex B
―
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II)
2.
IMPLEMENTATION SECTION
B-36
|
Carnival plc Directors' Remuneration Report
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate
Governance Report
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc (together
referred to as “Carnival Corporation & plc”) operate
under a dual listed company (“DLC”) arrangement with
primary listings in the U.S. and the UK. Accordingly,
Carnival Corporation & plc has implemented a single
corporate governance framework consistent, to
the extent possible, with the governance practices
and requirements of both countries. Where there are
customs or practices that differ between the two
countries, Carnival Corporation & plc has nonetheless
sought to be compliant with UK best practices
whenever possible. Carnival Corporation & plc
believes that their resulting corporate governance
framework effectively addresses the corporate
governance requirements of both the U.S. and the
UK.
Corporate Governance Guidelines
Carnival Corporation & plc has adopted corporate
governance guidelines (the “Guidelines”) that set forth
the general governance principles approved by the
Boards of Directors. The Guidelines are available on
Carnival Corporation & plc’s website and are
summarized as follows:
•
A majority of the members of each of the Boards
must be independent in accordance with the
corporate governance rules applicable to
companies listed on the New York Stock Exchange
and the London Stock Exchange.
•
The Boards will each have at all times the following:
Audit Committee, Compensation Committee,
Compliance Committee, Health, Environmental,
Safety & Security (“HESS”) Committee and
Nominating & Governance Committee (collectively,
the “Committees”). All the members of our
Committees will be independent Directors under
the criteria applicable to companies listed on the
New York Stock Exchange, the London Stock
Exchange and any other applicable regulatory
requirements. Each of these Committees has its
own written charter, which principally sets forth the
purposes, goals and responsibilities of the
Committees.
•
The Nominating & Governance Committees will
review with the Boards, on an annual basis, the
requisite skills and characteristics of new and
incumbent Board members, as well as the
composition of the Boards as a whole. The
Nominating & Governance Committees will assess
and recommend Board candidates for appointment
as Directors.
•
The responsibilities of the Directors are laid out in
the Guidelines and cover matters such as the
Directors’ duties to Carnival Corporation & plc and
its shareholders, attendance at meetings and the
annual review of Carnival Corporation & plc’s
long-term strategic plans and the principal issues
that Carnival Corporation & plc may face in the
future.
•
The Non-Executive Directors shall appoint a Senior
Independent Director to preside at meetings of
the Non-Executive Directors and at Board meetings
in the absence of our Chair, and to serve as the
principal liaison for Non-Executive Directors.
•
Directors have free and full access to officers and
employees of Carnival Corporation & plc, to the
advice and services of our Company Secretary to
the Boards and to independent professional advice
at the expense of Carnival Corporation & plc.
•
The Compensation Committees will recommend
the form and amount of Director and senior
executive compensation in accordance with the
policies and principles set forth in their charter and
conduct an annual review thereof. In particular,
the Compensation Committees will annually review
the compensation of our CEO and his performance
to enable our CEO to provide strong leadership for
Carnival Corporation & plc in the short and
long-term.
•
The Boards and the Nominating & Governance
Committees are responsible for CEO and board
succession planning. The Boards, in conjunction
with our Chair of the Boards and our CEO, oversee
succession planning with respect to executive
officers and senior management.
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
|
C-1
•
The Nominating & Governance Committees will
maintain orientation programs for new Directors
and continuing education programs for all Directors.
•
The Boards will conduct an annual performance
evaluation to determine whether they, their
Committees and individual Directors are functioning
effectively.
•
The Non-Executive Directors will meet at least
annually under the direction of the Senior
Independent Director to conduct an appraisal of
our Chair’s performance.
•
The Boards will determine the appointment and
removal of the Company Secretary.
•
All shareholders may communicate with the
Boards by addressing all communications to the
Company Secretary, who must forward any item
requiring immediate attention to the Senior
Independent Director, who must in turn notify the
Boards of any matters for discussion or action as
appropriate.
Carnival Corporation & plc monitors governance
developments in the U.S. and the UK to support a
vigorous and effective corporate governance
framework.
Board Composition
Each of the Boards of Directors is currently comprised
of 13 members, of which two are Executive Directors
and 11 are Non-Executive Directors. Richard J.
Glasier and Sir John Parker have decided not to seek
re-election and to retire from the Boards with effect
from the conclusion of the 2023 Annual Meetings of
Shareholder, at which time the size of the Boards of
Directors will be reduced to 11 members. Other
than Ms. Mathew and Mr. Weinstein, each nominee
for re-election to the Boards has served for the full
year. All Directors are required to submit themselves
for annual re-election. The biographical details of
the members of the Boards standing for election or
re-election and their qualifications to serve as Board
and Committee members are contained in the
Proxy Statement. For a description of our procedures
for selecting and appointing nominees, please refer
to “Nominations of Directors” in the Proxy Statement.
All Directors elected in 2022 have been subject to a
formal performance evaluation during the year, as
described below.
As part of the commitment to increase the
representation of women on our Boards, in fiscal
2022 the Nominating & Governance Committees
engaged an independent search firm Ridgeway
Partners to identify a Board candidate with significant
executive experience and giving consideration to
diversity, in accordance with our Corporate
Governance Guidelines. Ridgeway Partners has no
other connection with Carnival plc or any individual
Directors. Following a rigorous selection process, the
Nominating & Governance Committees recommended
the appointment of Ms. Mathew to the Boards and
the Boards approved Ms. Mathew’s appointment in
November 2022. Assuming the election or re-election
of all nominees to the Boards, following the Annual
Meetings of Shareholders, 36% of the members of the
Boards are women (being four of 11 members) and
one Director is ethnically diverse.
The Boards currently meet the Parker Review
recommendation of having at least one ethnic
minority Director.
Board Balance and Independence
We believe it is important to have a balanced board
with a majority of Directors being independent such
that no individual or group dominates the Boards’
decision making. The Boards believe that the balance
between Non-Executive Directors and Executive
Directors is appropriate.
We have a number of measures in place to assess
and safeguard independence of our independent
Directors. As part of the Boards’ annual independence
assessment, each Director is required to complete
an independence questionnaire. All questionnaires
are reviewed and assessed by the full Board. Following
this review for fiscal 2022, the Boards determined
that all of the eleven nominees for election or
re-election as Non-Executive Directors are considered
independent in accordance with the corporate
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
BOARD COMPOSITION
C-2
|
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
governance rules of the New York Stock Exchange
and the UK Corporate Governance Code. Sir Jonathon
Band, Richard J. Glasier, Stuart Subotnick, Laura Weil
and Randall Weisenburger have been Non-Executive
Directors for more than nine years from the date of
their first election to the Boards. However,
notwithstanding this fact, the Boards have determined
that each of those Directors is independent for the
reasons set forth below.
Consistent with U.S. practice, the Boards believe that
length of tenure should be only one of the factors
considered with respect to the independence of
Directors and, accordingly, that tenure alone should
not result in the loss of independence. The Boards
believe that automatic loss of independence status for
Directors due to tenure would effectively operate as
a term limit for independent Directors and result in
the loss of the valuable contributions of Directors
who have been able to develop, over time, increasing
insight into Carnival Corporation & plc and its
operations. The Boards prefer to rely on rigorous
annual evaluations of individual Directors, as well as
external evaluations by an independent third-party
governance expert every three years, to review their
objectivity and independence, as well as their overall
effectiveness as Directors. All Directors are also
subject to annual re-election by shareholders following
individual evaluations and recommendations by the
Nominating & Governance Committees. Mr. Arison has
been Chair of the Board of Directors of Carnival plc
since 2003 and previously served as the CEO of
Carnival plc from 2003 to 2013. His unique experience
and in-depth knowledge of our business, our history
and the cruise industry continue to be invaluable.
Mr. Arison has made and continues to make
substantial contributions to our success and to
demonstrate objective judgement throughout his
tenure. As a result, the Boards have concluded that
his continued service as our Chair is in our best
interests and that of our shareholders. Mr. Arison’s
performance is subject to annual evaluation by the
Non-Executive Directors. We also have separate CEO
and Chair roles.
As further discussed under “Board Procedures and
Responsibilities,” we also require Non-Executive
Directors to obtain our consent before they can serve
on additional boards.
The Boards, with support from the Global Legal
Services Department and the Global Ethics &
Compliance Department ("GE&C"), have procedures
to identify and manage any conflicts of interest that
may arise in relation to any Director (including
those resulting from significant shareholdings), and
assess Directors’ independence, including by reviewing
on an annual basis questionnaires completed by
Directors which are designed to identify potential
conflicts of interest and also by requiring Directors to
report any potential conflicts of interest.
Directors’ Indemnities
Carnival Corporation has provided an indemnity for
the Directors of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc.
This was in place at all times during fiscal 2022 and
up to the date of the approval of the financial
statements. To the extent Carnival Corporation is
unable to indemnify the Directors, we also maintain
Directors’ and Officers’ liability insurance which covers
Directors for legal actions brought against them in
their capacity as Directors, subject to certain
limitations.
Board Procedures and Responsibilities
Meetings of the Boards are held on a regular basis to
enable the Boards to properly discharge their
responsibilities. During the year ended November 30,
2022, the Board of Directors of Carnival plc held a
total of 11 meetings. All Board meetings during the
year were attended by the full Boards except for
Mr. Gearhart who attended 10 of 11 meetings and Sir
John Parker who attended 9 of 11 meetings.
Ms. Mathew, who joined the Boards of Directors on
November 14, 2022, attended the only meeting held
after her appointment date. In addition, the Non-
Executive Directors meet periodically during the year
with our Chair of the Boards with no other Executive
Directors present. The agenda for each Board meeting
and meeting schedules are prepared by our Chair
and reviewed and approved by the Senior
Independent Director, to enable the flow of relevant
information to the Boards. Each Board member is
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
DIRECTORS’ INDEMNITIES
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
|
C-3
entitled to suggest the inclusion of items on the
agenda and to raise at any Board meetings subjects
that are not on the agenda for that meeting.
Non-Executive Directors are required to allocate
sufficient time to meet the expectations of their role.
The consent of our Chair and Senior Independent
Director must be sought before accepting additional
directorships that might affect the time a Non-
Executive Director of Carnival Corporation & plc is
able to devote to that role. No additional directorships
or significant commitments were undertaken by Non-
Executive Directors during fiscal 2022.
The Boards have resolved that Executive Directors
may not serve as a Non-Executive Board member on
more than one FTSE 100 or Fortune 100 company
nor as the Chair of such a company.
All Directors are expected to act with integrity, lead
by example, promote the desired culture, provide
constructive challenge, strategic guidance and
specialist advice and hold management accountable.
Board Structures and Delegation to Management
The basic responsibility of the Directors is to exercise
their business judgment in the way they consider,
in good faith, would be most likely to promote the
long-term sustainable success of Carnival
Corporation & plc, for the benefit of the shareholders
as a whole and also contributing to the wider
society. Further details of the responsibilities of the
Directors are set out in the Guidelines. The Boards and
their Committees have a formal schedule of matters
specifically reserved to the Boards or their Committees
for decision, which includes, but is not limited to,
the approval of the following matters:
•
quarterly, half-yearly and annual reports, notices of
annual meetings and Proxy Statements;
•
dividends, issuance of shares or share buybacks;
•
changes to structure, size, membership and
composition of the Boards and their Committees;
•
significant changes to our corporate structure;
•
material changes in accounting policies;
•
selection, appointment or removal of auditors,
auditor independence, approval of all audit and
non-audit services and remuneration of auditors;
•
risk management framework;
•
investment policy;
•
material agreements, transactions or borrowings;
•
material transactions in which a Director or an
executive officer, or any of their immediate family
members, has a direct or indirect material interest;
•
appointment and removal of executive officers and
Company Secretary, executive officer compensation
as well as agreements with executive officers;
and
•
adoption of, or any changes to, equity incentive
plans as well as equity grants and other share-
related benefits.
Details of the Committees of the Boards are set out
in the section below.
The strategic management and direction of, and
significant commercial decisions in relation to, global
operations of Carnival Corporation & plc, except to
the extent reserved to the full Boards under their
schedule of reserved matters, is delegated by the
Boards to the Boards of subsidiary companies within
the group and to management committees of the
Boards, which in turn delegate to local management
as appropriate.
Our Chair of the Boards leads the Boards and is
responsible for its overall effectiveness. He promotes
a culture of openness and dialogue at the board
level, including by encouraging effective contribution
and participation of all Directors and supporting
management and the Company Secretary in ensuring
that Directors receive accurate, timely and clear
information.
The Boards of Directors, with support from the
Committees and management, have in place a
framework of prudent and effective controls which
enable risks to be assessed and managed. The Boards
of Directors, through executive management and
the Committees, have carried out a robust assessment
of Carnival Corporation & plc’s principal and
emerging risks, including those that would threaten
its business model, future performance, solvency or
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
DIRECTORS’ INDEMNITIES
C-4
|
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
liquidity, to ensure that these risks are effectively
managed and/or mitigated to help ensure Carnival
Corporation & plc is viable. As a result of this
assessment, the Boards of Directors have identified
principal and emerging risks and their management
and/or mitigation which are listed in Item 4 Risk
Management and/or Mitigation of Principal and
Emerging Risks in the Carnival plc Strategic Report
that accompanies the Carnival plc financial statements
(the “Strategic Report”).
Committees of the Boards
The following Committees have operated throughout
the year. Each Committee has a written charter,
copies of which can be found on Carnival
Corporation & plc’s website at
www.carnivalcorp.com
and
www.carnivalplc.com
. The Board Committees
regularly report on their activities and actions to the
full Boards.
AUDIT COMMITTEES
The Audit Committees are comprised of the following
five independent Non-Executive Directors:
•
Laura Weil (Chair effective February 1, 2023);
•
Richard J. Glasier (Chair until January 31, 2023);
•
Jason Glenn Cahilly;
•
Sara Mathew (who joined on November 14, 2022);
and
•
Stuart Subotnick.
Mr. Glasier has decided not to seek re-election and
will retire from the Boards and their Committees with
effect from the conclusion of the 2023 Annual
Meetings of Shareholders.
The Board of Carnival plc has determined that each
member of the Audit Committees has “recent and
relevant financial experience” for the purposes of the
UK Corporate Governance Code and that the Audit
Committees as a whole have competence relevant to
the sector in which Carnival Corporation & plc
operate. The qualifications of each member of the
Audit Committees are contained in the Proxy
Statement.
During the year, 11 meetings of the Carnival plc Audit
Committee were held, which were attended by all
members except for Ms. Mathew who attended the
only meeting held after her appointment to the Boards
of Directors and the Audit Committees on
November 14, 2022. The Chief Financial Officer and
Chief Accounting Officer, the Chief Audit Officer, who
is responsible for the internal audit function and
risk advisory and assurance services within Carnival
Corporation & plc, representatives from the external
auditors, the General Counsel, Chief Information
Officer, Chief Privacy Officer and Chief Risk and
Compliance Officer attend meetings at the invitation
of the Audit Committees.
The main role and responsibilities of the Audit
Committees are to review:
•
the integrity of the relevant financial statements;
•
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc’s compliance
with legal and regulatory requirements, other
than requirements related to HESS and compliance
matters addressed by the Compliance Committees;
•
performance of Carnival Corporation & plc’s
internal audit functions and the adequacy of
internal controls; and
•
risk management related to financial, information
technology (including cybersecurity and privacy) and
non-HESS related operational risks, as well as
monitoring changes to and compliance with related
legal and regulatory requirements.
In addition, our Audit Committees:
•
liaise with, appoint and assess the qualifications,
effectiveness and independence of, the external
auditors;
•
assist the Boards, if so requested, in ensuring that
the annual report and accounts of Carnival plc, taken
as a whole, is fair and balanced and understandable
and provides the information necessary for
shareholders of Carnival plc to assess Carnival plc’s
position and performance, business model and
strategy;
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
COMMITTEES OF THE BOARDS
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
|
C-5
•
review compliance with the Carnival Corporation &
plc Code of Business Conduct and Ethics; and
•
establish and monitor the procedures for receipt
of complaints or concerns regarding accounting,
internal accounting controls and audit matters.
In fulfilling their responsibilities during the year, the
Audit Committees have, among other things:
•
reviewed the quarterly and annual financial results
of Carnival Corporation & plc, including accounting
matters and key factors affecting financial results
and future forecasts;
•
reviewed financial statements and related
disclosures, and other proposed filings with the
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and the
applicable UK authorities and draft earnings press
releases of Carnival Corporation & plc;
•
reviewed the form and content of the annual
reports and accounts, including the Strategic Report
(including the going concern confirmation, the
viability statement, the assessment of internal
controls and principal risks, and the annual risk
management and/or mitigation of principal risks),
financial statements and Directors’ Report, to be
presented to shareholders of Carnival plc at the
year-end;
•
reviewed the form and content of the half year
reports (including the going concern confirmation);
•
approved, together with the Boards of Directors,
the viability and going concern statements, which
are included in the Strategic Report;
•
reviewed reporting from management on
impairment analyses over tangible and intangible
assets;
•
confirmed receipt of certification letters, disclosure
controls and procedure checklists and loss
contingency memos from all reporting units;
•
received briefings on Carnival Corporation & plc’s
Sarbanes-Oxley 404 compliance program;
•
reviewed reporting from the independent auditors
concerning the audit work performed, identified
internal control deficiencies and accounting issues,
and all relationships between the independent
auditors and Carnival Corporation & plc;
•
reviewed and approved fees for audit and non-audit
related services provided by Carnival Corporation &
plc’s independent auditors;
•
received and reviewed various reports from the
independent auditors regarding the planning,
status, execution and conclusions of their work;
•
received reporting, as well as quarterly briefings,
from the Carnival Corporation & plc internal audit
department called Risk Advisory & Assurance
Services (“RAAS”) concerning results from their
internal audit work, including significant findings,
any identified internal control deficiencies and
management plans for remedial action;
•
reviewed reports of RAAS regarding the results of
its independent internal investigations of alleged or
actual impropriety as assigned by the General
Counsel and in coordination with the Chief Risk
and Compliance Officer on the status and results
of those investigations;
•
reviewed RAAS’s historical audit coverage and
assessment of risk for the purpose of developing
an audit plan for the upcoming year;
•
reviewed reports of RAAS concerning progress
against their audit plan, department staffing and
professional qualifications, and the status of
management action plans for previously identified
action steps;
•
reviewed reports regarding information technology
security, including cybersecurity and privacy and
responses to and investigations of breaches; and
•
reviewed the status of complaints received through
Carnival Corporation & plc’s third-party
administered hotline and other channels.
COMPENSATION COMMITTEES
The Compensation Committees of the Boards are
comprised of the following five independent Non-
Executive Directors:
•
Randall Weisenburger (Chair);
•
Jason Glenn Cahilly (who joins on February 1,
2023);
•
Helen Deeble;
•
Richard J. Glasier; and
•
Laura Weil.
Mr. Glasier has decided not to seek re-election and
will retire from the Boards and their Committees with
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
COMMITTEES OF THE BOARDS
C-6
|
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
effect from the conclusion of the 2023 Annual
Meetings of Shareholders.
During the year, six meetings of the Carnival plc
Compensation Committees were held, which were
attended by all members, except for Mr. Cahilly who
was appointed to the Compensation Committees
effective February 1, 2023. Executive Directors are
invited to attend for appropriate items, but are
excluded when their own performance and
remuneration are being discussed and determined.
The Compensation Committees are responsible
for the:
•
evaluation and approval of the Director and officer
compensation plans, policies and programs;
•
annual review and approval of the corporate goals
and objectives relevant to our CEO’s compensation;
•
determination and approval of the compensation
of our CEO, the other Executive Directors and other
senior officers; and
•
recommendations to the Boards with respect to
the compensation of the Non-Executive Directors.
When selecting or appointing candidates to the
position of our Chair of the Compensation
Committees, the Nominating & Governance
Committees and the Boards shall give particular
consideration to candidates who have previously
served on a compensation committee for at least
12 months.
The Compensation Committees are empowered to
retain compensation consultants of their choice to be
used to assist in the evaluation of compensation
issues.
COMPLIANCE COMMITTEES
The Compliance Committees of the Boards are
comprised of the following six independent Non-
Executive Directors:
•
Jeffrey J. Gearhart (Chair effective February 1,
2023);
•
Randall Weisenburger (Chair until January 31,
2023);
•
Sir Jonathon Band;
•
Richard J. Glasier;
•
Stuart Subotnick; and
•
Laura Weil.
Mr. Glasier has decided not to seek re-election and
will retire from the Boards and their Committees with
effect from the conclusion of the 2023 Annual
Meetings of Shareholders.
During the year, six meetings of the Carnival plc
Compliance Committees were held, which were
attended by all members.
The principal function of the Compliance Committees
is to assist the Boards with oversight of activities
that are designed to promote ethical conduct, a high
level of integrity, and compliance with all laws,
regulations and policies applicable to us, including
by:
•
receiving regular reports from, and providing
direction to the Chief Risk and Compliance Officer
(“CRCO”) with respect to the activities of GE&C,
including trends and insights coming from our
complaint channels, GE&C’s compliance monitoring
activities, management’s mitigation plans to
address compliance risk management
opportunities, changes in laws and regulations that
could have a significant impact on us, the
adequacy of staffing and resources and any
difficulties encountered by GE&C;
•
oversee risk management related to compliance
with applicable laws and regulations, including our
compliance monitoring activities supporting a
high level of ethics and integrity;
•
reviewing the results of compliance with our Code
of Business Conduct and Ethics and our Business
Partner Code of Conduct and Ethics and conflicts
of interest disclosures;
•
providing functional oversight of our Incident
Analysis Group (“IAG”) and GE&C with respect to its
review of effectiveness of IAG recommendations;
•
reviewing the results from any internal or external
audits and investigations that have relevance for
significant business ethics or compliance matters;
•
meeting independently with the CRCO to review
any significant changes to or challenges with ethics
and compliance activities;
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
COMMITTEES OF THE BOARDS
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
|
C-7
•
Establish and monitor policies and procedures for
confidential submission, receipt, retention and
treatment of complaints or concerns;
•
oversee and review all significant allegations of
misconduct by the Board, CEO, Leadership Team
or Section 16 executive officers; and
•
promoting accountability of senior management
with respect to ethics compliance matters.
HESS COMMITTEES
The HESS Committees of the Boards are comprised
of the following six independent Non-Executive
Directors:
•
Sir Jonathon Band (Chair);
•
Helen Deeble;
•
Jeffrey J. Gearhart;
•
Katie Lahey;
•
Sir John Parker; and
•
Randall Weisenburger.
Sir John Parker has decided not to seek re-election
and will retire from the Boards and their Committees
with effect from the conclusion of the 2023 Annual
Meetings of Shareholders.
During the year, six meetings of the Carnival plc HESS
Committee were held, which were attended by all
members except for Sir John Parker who attended five
of six meetings, having missed one meeting. Our
CEO and the CEOs of our cruise brands also attend
meetings of the HESS Committees.
The principal function of the HESS Committees is to
assist the Boards in fulfilling their responsibility to:
•
supervise, monitor and oversee compliance with
Carnival Corporation & plc’s HESS and sustainability
policies, programs and initiatives at sea and
ashore;
•
review and recommend appropriate policies,
procedures, practices and training relative to
sustainability reporting;
•
oversee risk management related to significant
HESS and sustainability-related risks and exposures
as well as monitor changes to and compliance
with related legal and regulatory requirements;
•
review and discuss with management pending or
threatened administrative, regulatory, or judicial
proceedings relating to HESS that are material to
the Companies and management’s response; and
•
Review our objectives and plans (including means
for measuring performance) for implementing the
Companies’ policies, procedures, practices,
compliance measures and risk management
programs regarding HESS; and
NOMINATING & GOVERNANCE COMMITTEES
The Nominating & Governance Committees of the
Boards are comprised of the following six independent
Non-Executive Directors:
•
Stuart Subotnick (Chair);
•
Sir Jonathon Band;
•
Richard J. Glasier
•
Katie Lahey (who joins on February 1, 2023);
•
Sir John Parker; and
•
Randall Weisenburger.
Sir John Parker has decided not to seek re-election
and will retire from the Boards and their Committees
with effect from the conclusion of the 2023 Annual
Meetings of Shareholders.
During the year, four meetings of the Carnival plc
Nominating & Governance Committee were held,
which were attended by all members, except for
Ms. Lahey who was appointed to the Nominating &
Governance Committees effective February 1, 2023.
The principal function of the Nominating &
Governance Committees is to:
•
assess and recommend to the Boards candidates
for appointment as Directors and members of the
Committees;
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
COMMITTEES OF THE BOARDS
C-8
|
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
•
assist the Boards with our CEO and Board
succession planning;
•
establish procedures to exercise oversight of the
evaluation of the Boards and management;
•
maintain orientation programs for new Directors
and continuing education programs for all Directors;
and
•
annually review and reassess the adequacy of the
Guidelines and recommend proposed changes to
the Boards for approval.
Further details on the succession planning process
and the Nominating & Governance Committees’
approach to diversity are contained in the
“Nominations of Directors” of the Proxy Statement
and diversity generally are contained in the
“Employees” section of the Carnival plc Directors’
Report, which is attached as Annex A, are incorporated
by reference into this Carnival plc Corporate
Governance Report.
Carnival plc Supplement to the Report of the Audit
Committees
Certain information required to be included in the
Carnival plc Report of the Audit Committee is set forth
in the Report of the Audit Committees included in
the Proxy Statement, and which is incorporated by
reference into this Carnival plc Corporate Governance
Report. The principal purpose of this Carnival plc
Supplement to the Report of the Audit Committees is
to comply with the UK Corporate Governance Code
requirements, which are only applicable to Carnival
plc.
In fiscal 2022 the Carnival plc Audit Committee
developed an understanding of the significant
accounting matters which were comprised of the
significant areas of accounting judgments and the
related estimates by reviewing, discussing with
management and, where appropriate, challenging
the approach and key assumptions adopted by
management. The Carnival plc Audit Committee was
satisfied with the assessments considered and
conclusions reached with respect to the significant
accounting matters. The significant accounting
matters considered by the Carnival plc Audit
Committee and discussed with the Carnival plc
external auditors, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
(“PwC”), for fiscal 2022 are included in the Carnival
Annual Report for fiscal 2022 in “Item 5. Going Concern
Confirmation and Viability Statement,” “Note 1—
General—Liquidity and Management’s plans” and
“Note 2—Significant Accounting Policies” under
“Significant Judgements and Estimates.”
In addition, risks of fraud in relation to revenue
recognition was an area of focus for the Carnival plc
Audit Committee and discussed with PwC in 2022. The
Audit Committee considered the presumed risks of
fraud as defined by auditing standards and was
satisfied that there were no significant issues.
EXTERNAL AUDITORS AND AUDIT TENDERING
The Audit Committees have the responsibility for
making a recommendation on the appointment,
reappointment and removal of the external auditors.
PwC was recommended by the Audit Committees
for reappointment as auditors of Carnival plc at the
Annual General Meeting held in April 2022, and
reappointment was approved by the shareholders.
The Audit Committees also reappointed PwC as
Carnival Corporation’s independent registered public
accounting firm, as ratified by the shareholders at
the April 2022 Annual General Meeting. In addition,
the policy of the Audit Committees is to undertake a
formal assessment of the auditor’s objectivity and
independence each year, which includes:
•
a review of non-audit services provided and related
fees;
•
discussion with the auditors pertaining to a written
report detailing all relationships with Carnival
Corporation & plc and any other party that could
affect the independence or the objectivity of the
auditors; and
•
evaluation with the Boards and management of
the effectiveness of the external audit process.
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
CARNIVAL PLC SUPPLEMENT TO THE REPORT OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEES
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
|
C-9
PwC has served as Carnival Corporation’s independent
auditor from at least 1986 to 2002. In 2003, following
formation of the DLC arrangement between
Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc, the independent
audits for the consolidated entity, Carnival Corporation
& plc, and Carnival plc were tendered. Upon
completion of this tender process, the Audit
Committees decided to recommend to the
shareholders that PwC be appointed as the Carnival
Corporation and Carnival plc independent auditors for
fiscal 2003. The Audit Committees annually evaluate
PwC’s performance and have each year recommended
that the shareholders vote for the reappointment of
PwC as Carnival plc’s independent auditors.
Our reasons for recommending that PwC be
appointed Carnival plc’s auditor for 2023 are as
follows:
•
PwC is one of the largest independent audit firms
in the world. In addition, PwC is uniquely qualified
because they are the auditors of the three largest
public cruise companies in the world. As such, it has
an exceptional level of understanding of the
cruise industry, the significant accounting principles
used by it and the economic environment in
which it operates.
•
Carnival Corporation & plc has periodically
undertaken internal surveys to confirm PwC’s
qualifications and performance, the quality and
candor of their communication with the Audit
Committees and management and their
independence, objectivity and professional
skepticism. The results of these surveys have
supported the Audit Committees’ and
management’s recommendations to appoint
PwC as the independent auditors of Carnival
Corporation & plc and Carnival plc.
•
PwC’s lead audit engagement partner for Carnival
Corporation & plc and the engagement partner for
Carnival plc are rotated from the engagement at
least every five years. PwC’s lead audit engagement
partner for Carnival plc is John Waters. The PwC
engagement partners working on subsidiaries are
rotated from these engagements at least every
seven years or in the case of significant EU
subsidiaries, the engagement partners have been
rotated at least every five years. The Audit
Committees actively participate in the selection of
the lead audit engagement partners. The Audit
Committees and management believe the partner
rotations support an independent auditor view of
our operations and provide fresh insights into the
audit processes.
•
The Audit Committees meet regularly with PwC in
executive sessions, where management is not
present. These executive sessions, which are not
required under UK or U.S. regulations, further
support PwC’s independence from management.
•
The Audit Committees’ Key Policies and Procedures
establish a framework to monitor and maintain
PwC’s independence. These Key Policies and
Procedures require, among other things,
pre-approval from the Audit Committees for audit
and permissible non-audit services prior to the
performance of any such services in accordance
with UK and U.S. regulations. The Audit Committees
only approve services to be provided by PwC that
are consistent with these regulations, which helps
to support auditor independence.
•
The communication between the Audit Committees
and PwC has been timely and informative, which
has assisted the Audit Committees in the
performance of their oversight responsibilities.
•
The Audit Committees and management believe
that PwC has performed the audits of Carnival
Corporation & plc and Carnival plc with proper
professional skepticism and demonstrated the
necessary knowledge, experience and skills to meet
their audit requirements.
•
Based on the review and analysis of audit fees of
comparable public companies, the Audit
Committees and management believe the PwC
audit fees are appropriate.
The Audit Committees continue to be confident that
the effectiveness and independence of the external
auditors is not impaired in any way. There are no
contractual restrictions on the choice of external
auditor and, therefore, a resolution proposing the
reappointment of PwC as external auditors will be put
to the Carnival plc shareholders at the 2023 Annual
General Meeting.
The policy on Audit Committee pre-approval and
permissible non-audit work of the independent
auditors, are set out in the “Independent Registered
Public Accounting Firm,” section of the Proxy
Statement, which is incorporated by reference into
this Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report. Refer
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
CARNIVAL PLC SUPPLEMENT TO THE REPORT OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEES
C-10
|
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
to Note 4 (Other Income and Expense) to the Carnival
plc financial statements for information on the fees
payable to PwC for audit and non-audit services in
fiscal 2022.
During the year, the Financial Reporting Committee’s
(“FRC”) Audit Quality Review (“AQR”) team selected
for review PwC’s audit of Carnival plc’s 2021 financial
statements as part of its annual inspection of audit
firms. On completion of the review, the AQR team
wrote to the Audit Committee Chair and provided a
copy of its final report. The Audit Committee was
pleased to note that the FRC did not identify any key
findings and only one limited improvement was
required. Work performed over going concern was
identified as an area of good practice.
Carnival plc is also subject to UK regulations regarding
external auditor appointment and rotation. The
relevant UK legislation (the Statutory Auditors and
Third Country Auditors Regulations 2016) requires
statutory auditors to rotate after a period of 20 years
and include a mandatory competitive tender of
audit firms at the 10-year midpoint. The Competition
and Market Authority’s (“CMA”) Statutory Audit
Services for Large Companies Market Investigation
(Mandatory Use of Competitive Tender Processes and
Audit Committee Responsibilities) Order 2014 (the
“CMA Order”) also set out transitional rules that
determine the latest date for the initial auditor
rotation or tender process. The CMA Order applies to
FTSE 350 companies. Carnival plc confirms that it
complied with the provisions of the CMA Order in
fiscal 2022.
PwC has been Carnival plc’s auditor since fiscal 2003,
so the transitional rules state that they may not be
reappointed more than nine years after June 2014,
effectively meaning that the audit firm must be
changed for the fiscal 2024 audit at the latest. As a
result, during fiscal 2022, the Audit Committees
oversaw a competitive tender process to select an
audit firm to replace PwC for the fiscal 2024 audit in
accordance with statutory and regulatory
requirements set out by the CMA, the Financial
Conduct Authority (“FCA”) and the FRC. The selected
firm will audit the consolidated entity, Carnival
Corporation & plc, and Carnival plc.
We invited three qualified public accounting firms to
participate in the tender process during the first half
of 2022 to ensure an orderly transition and the
independence of the selected firm well ahead of the
start of the fiscal 2024 audit. PwC, as the incumbent
audit firm that has audited Carnival plc for
19 consecutive years from 2003 to 2022, was not
invited to participate in the process.
Under the supervision of the Audit Committees, a
selection committee, comprised of senior members
of management (the “Selection Committee”), was
established to manage the audit tender process. A
set of selection criteria was developed by the Selection
Committee to enable its members to evaluate each
firm, taking into account meetings with each firm and
their review of each firm’s written proposal. The key
selection criteria included audit quality and inspection
results, public reports and comments from regulators,
audit approach, relevant industry experience, a
strong global network with significant experience in
managing large multi-national audits in the U.S. and
the UK, a presence in the key jurisdictions in which
the business operates, quality of the proposed
engagement team and the use of technology and
innovation.
The Selection Committee provided input and made
recommendations to the Audit Committees. Key steps
in the tender process took place from February to
May 2022 and included:
•
In February 2022, the request for proposal (“RFP”)
was issued to a shortlist of firms meeting our
selection criteria.
•
A comprehensive data room was established to
provide the firms with sufficient information
to familiarize themselves with Carnival
Corporation & plc and appropriately scope and
design the audit.
•
The three participating audit firms participated in a
series of meetings with management from across
our organization. This provided an opportunity for
the firms to ask questions arising from their
review of the data room, as well as enabling
management to interact directly with each proposed
audit team.
•
The Chair of the Audit Committees interviewed
each firm’s proposed audit leads or partners.
•
Each firm provided a demonstration of its audit
related technology and analytics capabilities.
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
CARNIVAL PLC SUPPLEMENT TO THE REPORT OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEES
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
|
C-11
•
Written proposals were received from all three
participating firms in April 2022
•
Each firm provided an independence assessment
detailing services currently provided to us and
confirmation of their ability to achieve
independence within the required timeframe.
These responses were reviewed to assess
consistency with our own assessment.
•
Reference checks were performed by our Global
Controller and the Chair of the Audit Committees
with comparable companies, seeking insights into
matters such as the firms’ ability to challenge
management effectively, use of technology and
tools, and confidence in the team’s expertise, and
experience. This included discussions with the
references whom firms provided and reviewing
each firm’s quality inspection results issued
by regulators.
•
All three firms presented their proposals to the
Selection Committee and Audit Committees in
May 2022.
•
During the oral presentations, the Audit Committees
probed the firms on their commitment to diversity
in the workforce, quality records, technical
expertise, and planned audit approach, among
other things.
Following a detailed review of the performance of
each firm during the audit tender process and an
evaluation against all criteria, the Audit Committees,
with input from the Selection Committee,
recommended Deloitte & Touche LLP as proposed
auditor of Carnival Corporation and Deloitte LLP as
proposed auditor of Carnival plc (together “Deloitte”)
as its preferred candidate to the Boards of Directors.
The factors contributing to the selection of Deloitte
as the preferred candidate included a high-quality and
experienced proposed audit team, a record of
delivering quality audits in both the U.S. and the UK,
solid inspection results as well as its technology and
innovation capabilities.
On June 23, 2022, the Boards of Directors selected
Deloitte as the independent registered public
accounting firm of Carnival Corporation and the
independent auditors of Carnival plc for fiscal 2024 to
be effective upon the execution of an engagement
letter and related completion of Deloitte’s standard
client acceptance procedures to ensure their
independence. The Boards of Directors will propose
this appointment of Deloitte for fiscal 2024 at our
Annual Meetings Shareholders in April 2024.
PwC will continue as the independent registered
public accounting firm of Carnival Corporation and
the independent auditors of Carnival plc for fiscal
2023, subject to their approval at the 2023 Annual
Meetings of Shareholders. It is expected that during
February 2023, Deloitte will begin the transition
process, after confirming their independence. The
transition process which will include shadowing PwC
to familiarize themselves with our processes. To
facilitate the transition, we will establish a working
group led by the Global Controller.
FRC REVIEW
In November 2021, Carnival plc received a letter from
the FRC informing Carnival plc that it had carried
out a review of Carnival plc’s Annual Report and
Financial Statements for the period ending
November 30, 2020 and that it had a number of
questions to assist the FRC in understanding how
Carnival plc had satisfied its reporting requirements.
Carnival plc has provided responses to the FRC’s
enquiries which they have acknowledged are now
closed. In light of the FRC’s enquiries, we have taken
steps to enhance our disclosures in our 2022 Carnival
plc Annual Report, most notably regarding climate
change risk disclosures, the impact of our business on
the environment, providing balanced information in
our disclosure regarding the usage of LNG and the
presentation of alternative performance measures
and accounting for foreign exchange. In addition, we
have reconsidered the cash flows for 2021 associated
with long-term loans between Carnival plc and certain
of its subsidiaries within the Carnival plc parent
company statement of cash flows between financing
and investing activities and concluded that these
cash flows should have been classified within investing
activities. Refer to Note 1 (Significant Accounting
Policies) of the Carnival plc parent company financial
statements for additional information.
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
CARNIVAL PLC SUPPLEMENT TO THE REPORT OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEES
C-12
|
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
On Behalf of the Audit Committee,
RICHARD J. GLASIER
Chair of the Audit Committees
January 27, 2023
Information and Professional Development
The Company Secretary is required to provide
members of the Boards with appropriate information
in advance of each meeting and Directors are
required to devote adequate preparation time
reviewing this information in advance of each meeting.
Our Company Secretary is also responsible for
advising the Boards through our Chair on all corporate
governance matters.
All Directors have access to the advice and services of
our Company Secretary and are permitted to obtain
independent professional advice, at Carnival
Corporation & plc’s expense, as he or she may deem
necessary to discharge his or her responsibilities as a
Director. A Director is required to inform the Senior
Independent Director of his or her intention to do so.
All Directors are offered the opportunity to attend
training programs of their choice. The subject matter
and content of such programs are reviewed
periodically during the year. In addition, the Directors
participated in multiple compliance and culture
training sessions from experts in the field.
Board Performance Evaluations
During fiscal 2022, the Nominating & Governance
Committees and the Boards conducted performance
evaluations of the Boards, the Boards’ Committees
and the members of our Boards of Directors with
assistance from an independent third-party
governance expert. The UK Corporate Governance
Code requires that an externally facilitated evaluation
on the Boards’ effectiveness be undertaken at least
once every third year. During fiscal 2022, the
Nominating & Governance Committees engaged The
Governance Solutions Group, an independent
third-party governance expert which has no other
connection to Carnival Corporation & plc or any
individual Director, to perform an assessment of the
effectiveness of the Boards. The third-party
governance expert interviewed each Director elected
in 2021 and members of senior management who
interact substantially with the Boards. Some of the
main focus areas for the assessment were boards
dynamics and rapport, board interaction and
relationship with management, meeting structure
and format, board balance and refreshment, board
meeting logistics, meeting discussion topics and
committee division of responsibilities. Following the
completion of the assessment, the third-party
governance expert reviewed the results of the
assessment with the incumbent Senior Independent
Director and then presented the results as well as
recommendations to the full Boards, including our
Chair, for discussion. The Boards will consider the third
party governance expert’s report and
recommendations to further enhance the
performance of the Boards and when reviewing the
composition of the Boards and future board
appointments.
In addition to the external evaluation, the
Nominating & Governance Committees reviewed the
individual performance of each Director focusing
on his or her contribution to Carnival Corporation &
plc, and specifically focusing on areas of potential
improvement. In making their assessment, the
Nominating & Governance Committees reviewed
considerations of age, diversity, experience and skills
in the context of the needs of the Boards, and with
the aim of achieving an appropriate balance on the
Boards. The performance review of Micky Arison, in
his role as Chair, was conducted separately by the
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
INFORMATION AND PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
|
C-13
Non-Executive Directors, led by the Senior
Independent Director, Randall Weisenburger, taking
into account the view of the other Executive Director.
The Nominating & Governance Committees also
discussed and reviewed with Non-Executive Directors
any significant time commitments they have with
other companies or organizations. In addition, the
number of directorships held by Non-Executive
Directors was taken into account, in line with Carnival
Corporation & plc’s policy on limiting multiple
appointments.
In October 2022, the Nominating & Governance
Committees reported the results of their review to
the Boards. The Boards concluded that each Director
was an effective member of the Boards and had
sufficient time to carry out properly their respective
commitments to the Boards, their Committees and all
other such duties as were required of them. It is the
view of the Nominating & Governance Committees
and the Boards that the Boards continued to operate
effectively during fiscal 2022.
During fiscal 2022, the Audit Committees, the
Compensation Committees, the Compliance
Committees, the HESS Committees and the
Nominating & Governance Committees also reviewed
their own performance against their respective
charters by completing questionnaires that were
provided to the Chair of the Nominating & Governance
Committees. The results of such reviews were
discussed among the members and reported to the
Boards. The Boards concluded that the Audit
Committees, the Compensation Committees, the
Compliance Committees, the HESS Committees and
the Nominating & Governance Committees continued
to function effectively and continued to meet the
requirements of their respective charters.
Directors’ Remuneration
The Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report is
presented in two parts, with Part I forming part of the
Proxy Statement and Part II being attached as
Annex B to the Proxy Statement. A resolution to
approve the Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration
Report will be proposed at the 2023 Annual General
Meeting.
Relations with Shareholders
The formal channels of communication by which the
Boards communicate to shareholders the overall
performance of Carnival Corporation & plc are the
Annual Reports, Carnival plc half yearly financial
report, joint Annual Report on Form 10-K, joint
Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q, joint Current Reports
on Form 8-K, Proxy Statement and press releases.
Senior management and Non-Executive Directors of
Carnival Corporation & plc meet periodically with
representatives of institutional shareholders to
discuss their views and to enable the strategies and
objectives of Carnival Corporation & plc to be well
understood. Issues discussed with institutional
shareholders include executive compensation,
performance, business strategies and corporate
governance. For additional information on our
shareholder engagement efforts in fiscal 2022, refer
to section “Shareholder Engagement” in Part I of the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report.
Presentations are made to representatives of the
investment community periodically in the U.S., the UK
and elsewhere. Results of each fiscal quarter are
reviewed with the investment community and others
following each quarter on conference calls that are
broadcast live over the Internet.
The Boards receive periodic briefings from
management regarding feedback and information
obtained from Carnival Corporation & plc’s
shareholders and brokers. During fiscal 2022,
Carnival Corporation & plc’s management presented
to the Boards regarding shareholder matters.
Shareholders will have the opportunity at the 2023
Annual General Meeting, notice of which is contained
in the Proxy Statement, to ask questions of a
representative of the Board and senior management.
The Boards have implemented procedures to
facilitate communications between shareholders or
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION
C-14
|
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
interested parties and the Boards. Shareholders or
interested parties who wish to communicate with the
boards or the Senior Independent Director should
address their communications to the attention of the
Company Secretary of Carnival Corporation & plc at
3655 N.W. 87th Avenue, Miami, Florida 33178-2428,
United States. The Company Secretary promptly
forwards to the Senior Independent Director those
communications which the Company Secretary
believes require immediate attention. The Senior
Independent Director notifies the Boards or the Chair
of the relevant Committees of the Boards of those
matters that he believes are appropriate for further
action or discussion.
Annual Meetings of Shareholders
This year the Annual Meetings of Shareholders will
be held at Carnival Place, 3655 NW 87th Avenue,
Miami, Florida, United States on Friday, April 21, 2023.
The meetings will commence at 8:30 a.m. (EDT), and
although technically two separate meetings (the
Carnival plc meeting will begin first), shareholders of
Carnival Corporation may attend the Carnival plc
meeting and vice-versa.
We are also pleased to host a live video broadcast of
the Annual Meetings of Shareholders at our Carnival
plc headquarters located at Carnival House, 100
Harbour Parade, Southampton SO15 1ST, United
Kingdom at 1:30 p.m. (BST). Shareholder’s planning to
attend the live video broadcast in Southampton
must submit a proxy in order to vote as they will not
be able to vote in person from Southampton.
Shareholders attending the live video broadcast in
Southampton will be able to submit questions live to
the Directors in Florida, but will not be treated as,
or considered to be, “in attendance” at the Annual
Meetings.
Workforce Engagement
In line with the UK Corporate Governance Code,
Randall Weisenburger was appointed in 2020 as the
designated Non-Executive Director for workforce
engagement.
The main responsibilities of this role are the
governance and oversight of the following matters:
•
to directly engage with the workforce (which we
also refer to as team members) in order to ensure
their feedback and concerns are appropriately
relayed to the Boards, and that strategic direction
and priorities of the Boards are communicated
throughout the workforce;
•
to coordinate direct engagement between other
Non-Executive Directors, management and the
workforce, as appropriate;
•
to support the Boards’ discussion of employee
engagement efforts and structure the contents of
such discussions;
•
to monitor and evaluate policies and practices
relating to workforce engagement to ensure that
the efforts on workforce engagement are effective,
consistent with our values and support our
long-term sustainable success and that employee
feedback is shared and collected in a balanced and
transparent way; and
•
to report on the results of workforce engagement
efforts, including any feedback and concerns from
the workforce to the Boards periodically, and
make any recommendations arising from those
reports to the Boards.
We believe that having a designated Non-Executive
Director who reports to the Boards with support from
senior management, the global human resources
department and the subsidiary management teams,
is and continues to be an appropriate and effective
workforce engagement method.
In this role, Mr. Weisenburger is also supported by
senior management who are responsible for the
day-to-day implementation of the efforts on workforce
engagement. Given the global nature of our business
with various operating companies, most workforce
engagement activity is conducted at the subsidiary
level under the leadership of the respective operating
company management. During fiscal 2022, our
workforce engagement program involved a
continuation of a number of initiatives, led by various
leaders throughout our organization, such as live
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
ANNUAL MEETINGS OF SHAREHOLDERS
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
|
C-15
virtual townhall meetings as well as a variety of
virtual and live ship visits. In-person events and visits
were not feasible at the start of the year because of
continuing travel and health-related restrictions
around the globe associated with the COVID-19
Omicron variant. Despite these challenges, we
adapted as the year progressed to respond to the
needs of our organization and our workforce. The
Boards received regular reports from management
regarding the status of the return to service, as well as
updating the health and safety protocols and other
critical matters as they relate to the workforce. The
Boards continued to work closely with management
to sustain the business while balancing the needs
of the business with that of its workforce, shareholders
and other stakeholders.
During fiscal 2022, with the full support of the
Boards, we continued our initiatives designed to
engage with and care for our workforce as protocol
updates were implemented. Key areas of focus include
Outreach & Wellness, Culture and Staffing. The
Boards and their Committees received periodic
reports from senior management on key issues and
developments. Mr. Weisenburger reported to the full
Boards on the workforce engagement efforts.
Our pay practices are established to attract and
retain talented individuals at all levels of the
organization and to reward performance, as described
in the “Staffing” section below.
For addition information on how the interests of
employees have been considered by the Boards in
their discussions and decision-making, refer to the
following section of the Strategic Report: 1.A.II. Mission
(Purpose), Vision, Values and Priorities, 1.C.XII.
Human Capital Management and Employees, 1.C.XIV.
Ethics and Compliance and 7.Section 172(1)
Statement. A statement describing how the Directors
have performed their duty to act in the way they
consider, in good faith, would most likely promote
the success of Carnival Corporation & plc for the
benefit of its members as a whole having regard to
the stakeholders and matters set out in Section 172(1)
(a) to (f) of the Companies Act, is included in the
Strategic Report.
OUTREACH AND WELLNESS
Management, with support of the Boards of Directors,
continued focus on shore and ship employee
outreach and wellness with focus on the unique
needs of shore and shipboard employees.
We remained focused on maintaining and improving
ongoing communication with and from employees.
The operating companies focused on communications
channels including regular town halls, newsletters,
email updates and video messages. Questions and
comments from the workforce were requested in
advance of the town hall meetings, and in some cases
could be submitted electronically during those
meetings. Town halls, in addition to other existing
communication channels, such as the hotline referred
to in the Hotline for Reporting Concerns section
below, also allowed our workforce to provide
comments and ask questions.
Brand leaders also increased shipboard outreach
with live and virtual visits to ships. In addition, Non-
Executive Directors were able to resume cruise visits
in 2022.
Other examples of shoreside outreach and wellness
efforts include:
•
frequent updates from management to improve
transparency on business developments;
•
newsletters, emails and video updates for both
active and furloughed employees to share news,
recommendations, helpful resources and tips for
wellness;
•
encouraging leaders to conduct engagement check-
ins with their teams as a group and individually in
order to hear their concerns and take questions; and
•
leveraging social media to engage with shore and
shipboard workforce.
Other examples of shipboard efforts, in addition to
expanding the use of our social media channels,
include:
•
video updates from brand leads;
•
special recognition of achievements; and
•
COVID-19 awareness, health and wellbeing related
training materials.
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
WORKFORCE ENGAGEMENT
C-16
|
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
In addition, the shipboard workforce continued to
have access to resources and support to ensure
physical and mental wellbeing. Brands instituted
robust shipboard mental health and wellness plans,
including the following:
•
access to medical professionals, including mental
health professionals, Care Team and peer support;
•
seminars on dealing with stress, mindfulness and
cognitive restructuring;
•
on-demand physical and mental fitness video
library;
•
additional Wi-Fi, internet and telephone services;
•
multi-faith spiritual services; and
•
mental health awareness training.
The feedback obtained from the townhall meetings,
surveys and other channels described above touched
on themes such as communications, transparency,
remote work solutions and engagement needs. With
the support of the Boards, management actioned
the feedback received through an assortment of
communication, health and wellness and enrichment
and recognition efforts.
As the understanding of COVID-19 and its variants
continued to evolve, we worked with a number of
leading public health, epidemiological and policy
experts to support our ongoing efforts to develop
appropriate protocols and procedures as restrictions
on our cruise operations eased. These advisors will
continue to provide guidance based on the latest
scientific evidence and best practices for protection
and mitigation, as well as regulatory requirements for
the safety of our guests and employees.
We also continued our efforts to implement
significant changes in the way we work, pivoting our
shoreside operations to allow for remote working
where possible including, for our US Headquarters
office, creation of a Remote Work Policy. We leveraged
information from experts in developing protocols
and procedures for use in our shoreside offices for
those employees whose duties require them to work
at the office. In addition, we made available vaccines
and boosters for our crew members, many of whom
otherwise may not have had access to vaccinations.
We believe these measures are critical to helping keep
our workforce, their families and the communities
in which we work, safe and healthy.
CULTURE
Our Culture Essentials
Speak Up
Respect and
Protect
Improve
Communicate
Listen and
Learn
Empower
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
WORKFORCE ENGAGEMENT
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
|
C-17
During fiscal 2022, we developed and launched a
Cross Brand Culture Survey program featuring a
common survey focused on our Culture Essentials
across ship and shore operations for all of our
employees. This comprehensive semi-annual survey
is now a key management tool for tracking our cultural
health and putting in place initiatives, setting targets
and action plans to improve our culture where
appropriate. In connection with this, our operating
companies will develop and implement specific
initiatives
―
many of which will build upon our initial
Culture Action Plan whereby brand leaders and senior
management met with their direct reports to discuss
these key behaviors. These initiatives are expected
to include a series of extensive and consistent
communications about the Culture Essentials to
increase awareness; new and innovative training
sessions to promote further understanding; and new
expectations that would be measured and
incorporated into performance evaluations. More
specifically, through these steps, each brand would
drive and incentivize the key behaviors that will
strengthen our corporate culture.
To further elevate the importance of strengthening
our corporate culture, management, under the
supervision of the Boards, also developed a new
culture governance process in which our leadership
team is responsible and accountable for developing
the strategy for culture improvements. Given the
relative expertise of our human resource
professionals, the human resource leaders within
each operating company are responsible for
implementing the strategy throughout the brands, as
well as providing periodic reports that summarize
such efforts and activities. We are focused on
supporting a ‘Culture of Compliance’ through various
compliance monitoring, communication, and
continuous improvement processes. The Boards of
Directors, together with their Committees, also play an
important role in monitoring and assessing our
culture to ensure that it is aligned with our strategy,
values, mission and vision. As part of that role, in 2022
the Boards received and reviewed reports on the
progress of our Culture Essentials.
The Boards of Directors also monitor alignment
between our policies, practices and behaviors and
our culture, mission, vision, values and strategy and
review management’s actions to improve this
alignment. For example, a culture project began in
mid-2021 that addressed the need to promote more
accountability of our senior leaders within our
organization. On behalf of the Boards of Directors, a
nationally-recognized expert in ethics, compliance and
integrity was engaged to lead this effort. This
executive accountabilities project has been developed
and was implemented in 2022. It provided the
Boards with a practical tool for assessing the
contributions that each leader made to further
promote and embed our various culture-related
priorities and values and this information was used
as a meaningful part of the annual review of executive
performance and compensation. Please refer to the
“Executive Accountabilities” discussion of the “Annual
Bonuses” section of Part I of the Carnival plc
Remuneration Report for additional details.
Our goals also continue to be fostering a positive and
just culture that involves supporting recruiting,
developing and retaining the finest workforce. A
highly motivated and engaged workforce is key to
providing extraordinary cruise vacations. We believe
in building trust-based relationships and listening to
and acting upon our workforces’ perspectives and
ideas and use feedback tools to monitor and improve
our progress in this area. We remain focused on
becoming the travel & leisure’s employer of choice.
We celebrate our diverse team of over 160,000 team
members representing approximately 150 countries
and are committed to providing a welcoming and
inclusive environment where people from different
backgrounds, experiences, and walks of life can
succeed. We care deeply for our team members and
work hard to always cultivate an atmosphere of
openness, respect, and trust. We know our team
members are at the heart of inspiring unforgettable
happiness, so we strive to be the world’s number-one
choice for hospitality, travel and leisure careers.f
STAFFING
In 2022, we completed a monumental 18-month
journey marking our full return to guest cruise
operations. As part of this endeavor, over the past
18 months we have returned over 100,000 crew
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
WORKFORCE ENGAGEMENT
C-18
|
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
members to our ships and employees to our shore
side ranks. We also brought back the last of our
furloughed employees.
Returning ship employees attend a “Welcome Back”
session as each ship returns to service to review the
Culture Essentials, new training curriculum and to
encourage commitment to our Vision Statement,
shared values and Culture Essentials. Our pay
practices are established to attract and retain talented
individuals at all levels of the organization and to
reward performance. Engagement with the workforce
on common pay programs with the support of the
Boards were coordinated across the organization and
shared locally via townhalls, communications from
senior leadership and from their team leaders. Use
of local engagement channels allowed each brand to
tailor conversations to their specific programs. Our
common programs for 2022 included merit increases,
common forms of annual equity incentives for
eligible employees, announcement of planned
inflation and merit pay increases for 2023 as well as a
new broad-based performance incentive program,
all of which apply to executives and key personnel.
These programs, established with the support of the
Boards of Directors, reinforce our focus on retaining,
rewarding and investing in our workforce as well as
the alignment of our pay for performance philosophy
for executives and the workforce.
Hotline for Reporting Concerns
We have policies and procedures in place for
employees and other stakeholders to report any
concerns or complaints regarding actual or suspected
violations of our Code of Business Conduct and
Ethics, our other policies, or the laws, and for
appropriate investigations into and treatment of any
such reports. We also provide an independent,
third-party-hosted hotline where reports can be
made in a secure, confidential and, where desired
and permitted by applicable laws, anonymous
manner. Our Compliance Committees are responsible
for monitoring policies and procedures relating to
submission, retention and treatment of reports
described above. The Compliance Committees review
and discuss on a quarterly basis reports regarding
the status of hotline activity, trends and the results of
any significant investigations. The reports are also
shared with the full Boards. The Compliance
Committees also review on a regular basis the policies
and procedures relating to hotline complaints to
ensure that they remain appropriate and effective.
Internal Control and Risk Management
A description of the Carnival Corporation & plc
internal controls and risk management systems in
relation to the financial reporting process can be found
in the Strategic Report under Section 3. “Internal
Control and Risk Assessment” and in the Proxy
Statement under “Risk Oversight.”
Directors’ Responsibility for Financial Statements
The Statement of Directors’ Responsibilities in
relation to the Carnival plc financial statements is
included in the Carnival plc Directors’ Report attached
as Annex A to the Proxy Statement.
Statement of Compliance with the UK Corporate
Governance Code
The UK Corporate Governance Code 2018 applied to
Carnival plc during the course of the financial year. Set
out below is a chart that illustrates how Carnival
Corporation & plc has applied the principles of the
UK Corporate Governance Code during the year ended
November 30, 2022. A copy of the UK Corporate
Governance Code is available on the website of the
UK Financial Reporting Council (“FRC”) at
www.frc.org.uk.
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
HOTLINE FOR REPORTING CONCERNS
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
|
C-19
1. Board leadership and company purpose
A.
Effective Board
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Governance
and Board Matters”; “Board Performance Evaluations”;
“Board Structures and Delegation to Management.”
B.
Purpose, values and culture
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Workforce
engagement”—“Culture”; “Workforce Engagement”;
“Board Performance Evaluations.”
C.
Governance framework and Board resources
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Board
Performance Evaluations”; “Board Structures and
Delegation to Management.”
D.
Stakeholder engagement
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Workforce
Engagement. “
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part I):
“Executive Summary”—“Shareholder Engagement.”
Carnival plc Directors’ Report: “Other Stakeholders.”
E.
Workforce policies and practices
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Workforce
engagement”; “Hotline for Reporting Concerns.”
Carnival plc Directors’ Report: “Corporate and Social
Responsibility”—“Employees.”
2. Division of responsibilities
F.
Board roles
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Board
Balance and Independence”; “Board Procedures and
Responsibilities”; “Board Structures and Delegation to
Management.”
G.
Independence
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Board
Balance and Independence.”
H.
Time commitment and external appointments
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Board
Procedures and Responsibilities”; “Board Performance
Evaluations.”
I.
Resources, information and Company Secretary
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Information
and Professional Development.”
3. Composition, succession and evaluation
J.
Appointments to the Board
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Board
Composition.”
Proxy Statement: “Nominations of Directors.”
K.
Boards skills, experience and knowledge
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Board
Refreshment”; “Board Composition”; “Corporate
Governance Guidelines”;
Proxy Statement: “2023 Nominees for Election or
Re-Election to the Boards.”
L.
Annual Board evaluation
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Board
Performance Evaluation.”
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE WITH THE UK CORPORATE GOVERNANCE CODE
C-20
|
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
4. Audit, risk and internal control
M.
External and internal audit, integrity of financial
statements
Proxy Statement: “Report of the Audit Committees.”
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Carnival plc
Supplement to the Report of the Audit Committees”;
“Corporate and Social Responsibility.”
N.
Assessment of company’s position and prospects
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report: “Statement of
Directors’ Responsibilities”; “Board Structures and
Delegation to Management.”
O.
Internal financial controls and risk management
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report:
“Internal Control and Risk Management.”
Proxy Statement: “Risk Oversight.”
5. Remuneration
P.
Linking remuneration with purpose and strategy
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part I):
“Executive Summary”—“Our Compensation Philosophy”;
“Process for Making Compensation Determinations”;
“Named Executive Officer Compensation Design,
Elements and Pay Mix.”
Q.
Procedure for developing remuneration policy
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part I):
“Executive Summary”; “Process for Making
Compensation Determinations”; “Named Executive
Officer Compensation Design, Elements and Pay Mix.”
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part II): “2.
Implementation Section”— “2.1 Implementation of
Approved Policy,” “2.9 Non-Executive Directors.”
R.
Remuneration outcomes
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report (Part I):
“Executive Summary”; “Process for Making
Compensation Determinations”; “Named Executive
Officer Compensation Design”; “Elements and Pay Mix.”
Carnival Corporation & plc has applied all principles
of the UK Corporate Governance Code and complied
with its provisions throughout the year ended
November 30, 2022, with the following exceptions:
•
Provision 3 provides that the Chair should seek
regular engagement with major shareholders. In
order to facilitate shareholder engagement
and achieve what we believe to be a better
corporate governance outcome, our Chair, as an
Executive Director and a significant shareholder, is
not involved in regular shareholder engagement,
and instead our Senior Independent Director,
together with other Non-Executive Directors and/or
Committee chairs, as appropriate, participate in
our regular shareholder engagement efforts, as
explained in this Corporate Governance Report
under “Shareholder Engagement”;
•
Provision 19 provides that the Chair should not
remain in post beyond nine years from the date of
their first appointment to the Board. In addition,
Provision 9 provides that the Chair should be
independent on appointment. Our Chair of the
Board of Directors of Carnival plc has been in his
post for longer than nine years and was not
considered independent on appointment. The
Boards believe that due to Mr. Arison’s unique
experience and skills, his continued service as Chair
is in the best interests of the Companies and their
shareholders, as explained in this Corporate
Governance Report under “Board Balance and
Independence.”
•
Provision 36 provides that share awards granted to
Executive Directors should be subject to a total
vesting and holding period of five years or more
and that a formal policy for post-employment
shareholding requirements should be developed.
Our share awards to our U.S.-based President, CEO
and Chief Climate Officer are subject to vesting
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE WITH THE UK CORPORATE GOVERNANCE CODE
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
|
C-21
periods that are less than five years, consistent
with standard U.S. compensation practices, as
explained in Part I of the Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Report (included in our Proxy
Statement) under “Equity-based Compensation.” In
addition, we do not have a formal policy for a
Director’s post-employment shareholding,
consistent with standard U.S. compensation
practices, as explained in the
Carnival plc Directors’ Remuneration Report
attached as Annex B to the Proxy Statement under
“Statement by Randall Weisenburger, Chair of
the Compensation Committees”; and
•
Provision 38 provides that only basic salary should
be pensionable. The annual bonuses of our U.S.
Executive Directors, consistent with U.S. pay
practices, form part of their pensionable salary, as
explained in the Carnival plc Directors’
Remuneration Report attached as Annex B to the
Proxy Statement under “Total Pension Entitlements.”
This Corporate Governance Report was approved by
the Board of Directors and is signed by order of the
Board of Directors by:
ARNALDO PEREZ
Company Secretary
January 27, 2023
Annex C
―
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE WITH THE UK CORPORATE GOVERNANCE CODE
C-22
|
Carnival plc Corporate Governance Report
Annex D
―
Amendment of the Carnival
Corporation 2020 Stock Plan
Section 5(b)(i) of the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan (the “Plan”) is hereby amended in its entirely to read as
follows:
(i) subject to Section 12 of the Plan, no more than 46,650,000 Shares (the “Absolute Share Limit”) shall be
available for Awards under the Plan;
This amendment has been approved by the Boards of Directors of Carnival Corporation and Carnival plc and will
become effective only if approved by their shareholders.
Amendment of the Carnival Corporation 2020 Stock Plan
|
D-1