
50
Doric Nimrod Air Two Limited (the āCompanyā) Consolidated Annual Financial Report
INDEPENDENT AUDITORāS REPORT TO THE MEMBERS OF
DORIC NIMROD AIR TWO LIMITED (continued)
The key audit matter How the matter was addressed in our audit
Valuation of aircraft
(2023: £273.7m, and 2022: £331.7m)
We identified the valuation of aircraft as one of
the most significant assessed risks of material
misstatement due to error.
As explained in Note 2(m), the Groupās
accounting policy is to measure its aircraft
asset at depreciated historic cost less
impairment. The asset is being depreciated on
a straight-line basis over the term of the lease
to an estimated residual value at the end of
that period.
As stated in Note 3, estimation of the
aircraftās residual value is a significant source
of estimation uncertainty. The Group uses
external appraisers who provide an estimate of
the residual value which is determined based
on significant judgement and assumptions
about current and future market conditions.
Note 3 further describes that the Groupās
future performance is potentially subject to
wider economic uncertainty and disruption
caused in part by the continuing war in
Ukraine. This together with the illiquid market
for the A380, may have an adverse impact on
the future value of the aircraft assets owned by
the Group, as well as on the sale, re-lease, or
other disposition of the relevant aircraft
As disclosed in Note 3, if the assumptions used
in determining the valuation of aircraft prove
to be false, actual results of operations and
the realisation of the Groupās aircraft asset
could differ from estimates set forth in the
Consolidated Financial Statements, and the
difference could be material.
In responding to the key audit matter, we performed the following audit
procedures:
⢠We have assessed that the Groupās accounting policies regarding the
valuation of aircraft is in accordance with International Accounting Standard
(IAS) 16 ā Property, Plant and Equipment;
⢠We held detailed discussions with management, including directors
and obtained an understanding of the processes and controls in place
regarding the valuation of aircraft. We have also obtained understanding
of the supporting documentation or papers prepared and approved by
management;
⢠We have obtained and assessed detailed supporting documentation from
management for key inputs, assumptions and methodology used from which
the valuation of aircraft are derived;
⢠We have assessed and documented the competence, capability and
objectivity of the external valuers that management have engaged in the
process;
⢠We have assessed all information provided including all appraiserās report,
lease agreement, amendment to such agreement, redelivery condition
side letter and valuation report from Asset Manager. We have challenged
management on their method selection and why alternative methods,
assumptions and data that could have been used, were not used;
⢠We have engaged our internal aircraft asset valuation expert to assist
in performing the testing of the valuation of aircraft which included the
following:
⢠⢠Assisted in determining whether the valuation methodologies used to
estimate the residual values of the aircraft are consistent with methods
usually used by similar companies;
⢠⢠Used their knowledge of the market to assess and corroborate valuation
inputs by reference to comparable transactions, and independently
compiled databases/indices;
⢠⢠Assisted in determining whether the appraisers were appropriate,
qualified, and independent;
⢠We performed independent research to check for references of secondary
market options for A380 aircrafts
⢠We performed independent research to assess the reasonableness of discount
and inflation rate changes and to assist in identifying macro-economic
uncertainties (such as the conflict in Ukraine and post-Covid recovery) as
contributing factors to such updates; and
⢠We have assessed the sufficiency of related disclosures in the Consolidated
Financial Statements in accordance with IAS 16 ā Property, Plant and
Equipment and IAS 36 ā Impairment of Assets.
Our results
Based on the audit work performed, we have not identified any indication of
material misstatement in relation to the valuation of aircraft.